Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Rajesh Bhikari Pardhe vs M/O Defence on 7 November, 2019
i OA No. 764/2018, 2435/2019 to
Z50/2019, 3235/2019, 8326/2019,
* 366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
4497/2019 to 4354/2019,
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAI
ORIGINAL APPLICATION Nos.
7164/2018, 2485/2019
246/2019, 247/2019, 248/2019, 249/2019,
250/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 366/2019,
436/2019, 437/2019, 438/2019, 439/2019,
449/2019, 450/2019, 451/2019, 452/2019,
453/2019, 454/2019
Bate of decision: O7,11.20183
CORAM:~ R. VIGAYRUMAR, MEMBER (A).
R.N. SINGH, MEMBER (0).
Mes. Punam Kumari
Ex-MTS, PA No. oS? 71-6,
widow of Late Rai Koshore
Singh, age-32 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at SMO P-134/3,
Air Force Station, Devlali Camp,
Nashik 422401, Mahareéshtra.
, Applicant in OA No.764/2018,
Pandhari neath Sukdev Gawande
EX-MTS, PA No. 63767
Son of Shri Gawands
Suxdeo Kalu,
Age-44 years, Occ, Service, presently >
hirctwe
residing at H.No, 305 ZL
Bahula, Deviali Camp, Nash
Maharasntra. .
Applicant in OA No.245/2019.
Santosh Digambar Kshirsagar
Eu-MTS, PA No. 6S7S8-A,
Son of Shri Digambar Kshirsagar,
Age-28 years, Occ.Service, presently
residing at A/6é, NE, Panchjyoti Society,
Deviali Gane Nashik-422401,
Maharashtr
3 OA No. 7864/2018, 2459/2019 to 7
2350/2019, 323/2019, 326/2019, '
366/2019, 436/2019 to 439/2019,
449/201 to 4584/2019,
.. Applicant in OA No.246/2019.
GQ)
gp
its
wy IG
rs
t4
ry
ie te
aa
583)
"wo
rey
a
cfr
Go
f--5
dD
£4
"
it
Sq
tH
iy
ie
oe ry
Oo
oy
fas
mad
es
oy
}
}
iwi Trambak Patole,
<
rm
wise 4
sha 4,
Age~ sears, Occ, Service
Presently residing at Village
Shingawe Bahula, Deviali Camp,
Nashil-422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.247/2019.
Shankar Bhagwan Pale
EX~MTD, PA No.45825-8, Son of
Shri Bhagwan K. Palde,
Age~40 vear Occ. Service,
resen a
Ambad Ganvathan, Village-
PO-Lahavit, Na asnik-422502,
Maharashtra,
-» Applicant in OA No.248/2019.
Pravin Shivaii Gsawali
EX-MYs, PA No.63760-S, _
Son of Shir Shivaji Sawali,
Age 29 years, Occ. service,
Presently residing at jaily
Market, Shivaji Chowk, Lahavit,
Dist. Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No. 249/2019.
¥Vined Kumar,
EX~-MTS (PH}, PA No. 63770-5,
eon of Shri Late Hazgari Lal,
Age~39 vears, Gcc.Service,
Resident of 145, Idra Colony,
Ratnada, AF Area, PO-Residency
Defence Lab, Dist-dJodhpur,
Rajasthan-34ecil.
.. Applicant in OA No.250/2019.
Sachin Govind Adka
RAY Ow oy Fane, ad " "
Ex-NTs, PA No, 63759-P,
OA No. 764/201 8, 2435/2019 to
-- £80/2019, 323/2019, 3262019,
366/2019, 436/2019 to 4539/2019,
44/2019 to 4354/2019.
Son of Shri Gavind Adke,
Age-28 years, Occ, Service,
Presently residing at H. No.703,
Rarkhana Road, Post-Nanegaon,
Nashik-422502,
Maharashtra.
.» Applicant in OA No.323/2019.
Namdev Bhausaheb Jaras
Ex-Cook, PA No. 45824-N,
Son of Shri Bhausaheb Jaras,
Age028 years, Occ. Service,
Presentiy residing at H. N.1054
Lahavit, Malwadi, District-Nashik
422502, Maharashtra.
Yogesh Pand
... Applicant in OA No.326/2019.,
hurang Ch
o me
EX-MTS, PA No. 63764-L,
S/o Pandurang Chavanke,
Age-24 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at Village & BO
Shivade, Taluka-Sinnar, Mandir
Gali Nashik, Dist.Nashik-4225902,
Maharashtra
*
.. Applicant in GA No.366/2019.
Rajesh Bhikari Pardhe
Ex-MTS, PA No. o3761-A,
Son of Shri Bhikari FPardhe,
Age~3l years, Occ. Service,
Presently residing at NP-95/01
Six Chawal, 25 ED AF Station,
Devieali {8S}, Nashik-422501,
Maharasntra.
.. Applicant in OA No.436/2013.
Mano? Prabhakar Shinde
Ex-MTS, BA No.63763-H,
son of Prabhakar Shinde,
Age-25 years, Gcc. Labourer,
presently residing at 124,
Maruti Gali Lahvit, Nashik,
Bistrict-Nashik-42250¢2,
2019,
tt
;
~
45/2019 to
23/2019, 3526/2019,
2019 to 4390/2019,
z
4
a0
4992019 to 454)
OA No. 437/2019,
2019.3
(2019, 43
e
OA No. 764/2018,
S0F
6
2n
2
36
4
.« Applicant
a a ot
vot rt mt
Lo) o oS
st mM Ol
aes nm wn
cea oO Py
~ oy sf
"<i "ft xt
o Oo 0
ws a wa
et ef a
»
G 13 oO 6 o
Oy w Me
& ™ * & % ih oo §
4.3 "ot OG
43 a) Be (Fost 9 43
~ 3 te G BO th a
aS) i @ ty reed a) a = bd
ay } ear i he oO Wo ed t * bef org
~ & "rf ved art ag rf ~ Oo fog ol ~"S oo 4
GD ~ % wd we Red LOE By rt eG rs rf eP oa ke og
hd nyt O, OOO NW -d id Dy fj j 2, , 2 ES ky
Sw AY Cy MOM EG f wo ei CO 1 Dy pow em OAM Oy
» 8 + a3 et 47 0 Dp yet pH MN Chet on ay ee tS -rf .O
PQ SL ed 4 Gy, ' Mo 42 U4 ty be veg oD * SF MS 4d Oped * Ow gs 4s
@ i Orwoam mH. a 20 O rt $4 <f a a cl tu cy . Mu £5 ad ie
bh DD (oa . oe om OD ' "so ox an . sf {
SO So» me oS 44 Soe ow "DB ny ma St thE
Gm Hh o Pa 2440 @ pb wey Do ed a ced gp we OO M OF og
Op Eb ved yp OST UD SE OT ed EF vey od Fe i Se dt OG WD oad
OO HOH ty as ~s WD 44 9 Sh m4 6 B41 Dy ah £3 EO g
» Ms rt 4G wp OS - G 8 O se tox ort ed eg "rt
sty CY x My ty MH CM wn a Mord O Of oy 6 a uct A308 Oh «ow
Th mM MO a + oO m4 Moog ahs } @ SF i + wy A De
Hort bd be og 43 ot 43 0, Be by ay ~ G8 OF wow Goward bq Sy
Hel he @ mo Wo cpt 9 © Mo ah ky Wo hed eed eG ot bag
@ fa OG fay eed och aa Kor CO WG a ST mre yD Coa te te OP gy Goi st ah mp,
Q Hb Pa eed 1 9 ct BP Mb uy ae ee Ut og a OW Ea kp a5 oe YE BQ ed
= 43 a Ow Dorf OB rH WH a a) we ow ay fe
GWU oo Oo om A og SS Oy + 8a oe mts MeN 0 ER ne} 8 MME ed cs
MH ON GD sd 4y 4 OS OD SM a he <0 sy hy wird OO GH
a Bo f 4 mf br ag AGU) fh 4 be med at «Tey ered bd gy AD fey town
et Se Oe et Wf WO fF ry te let OP De omy Tb sop @
oO Or a wg OM OO Get ay ied OM OO 4 4 Gg MA OA by
9 Tel 2 eG On 0 i st Wh OOF O BS Ao 2 Gh 09 >. be i et Qu te 1 et 9,
.. Applicant in OA No.450/2019.
3 OA No. 764/2018, 2458/2019 to
SoO/20TS, 3823/2079, 3236/2019
| 366/2019, 4936/2019 to 430/2019
, 4490/2019 to 4354/2019.
Dinkar Ashok Patole
Ex-MTS, mA No. 63765
Son of Ashek KR PB
ve y
Ag
"
fa-Z6 years, Occ. Service,
esently residing at
oashingve, Post Shenit,
strict Nashik 422502,
Maharashtra.
mo SS rg et
foe
.. Applicant in OA No.451/2019.
Shubham Laxman Waghchaure
Ex-MTS, PA No.¢38S7-F,
Son of Shri Laxman Waghchure,
Age 22 years, Occ. Service,
presently residing at Qtr. No.
94/05, Driver Otr. 25 ED,
AF Station Devlali {(Seuth},
Nashik 422 501,
Maharashtra.
Bhausa heb Kacharu Jdundre
&5
mw
}
rx]
fa
Se ota po po
Oo
ry
O ul
bes ™
ge-38 years, Occ Farmer,
% : * en tac ¥ FY
resentiy residing at Shraddha
Ci 1a
Behing Suman Hospital,
me
partment, r
Jai Bhavani Read, Nashik,
District-Nashik 422401,
Maharashtra.
.. Applicant in OA No.453/2019.
ayur Subhash
Sonawane
Bx-MTS, PA No. 63757-S8,
Son of Shri Subhash Sonawane,
Age-24 years, Occ. Service,
Presently residign at 96,
Subhash Road, Bhagur,
Nashik 422502,
Maharashtra.
...Applicant in OA Ne. 454/2019.
(By Advocate Shri Yogendra Pratap Singh)
.. Applicant in OA No. 452/2019.
3
x
(201 9 to
2019, 3826/2019,
S6/2D19, 436/2019 to 4390/2019,
wy
xt
ra
8,
--
0
oy
ke
64
250/2019, 32:
ms
QANo,
20] 9.
za
en
as
x
sf
¢
S tod
cal
ma
e
449/201
RL
4.
?
ine-c
x
2
a
a
OUcer
Lg
ryt
ee
gos
4
x
¢
x
OnMa ne
ix
x
¢
Deviali
tA.
e
e
mh
Versus
Ly
2
7
OMMan
o
Newt
ou
we
Xe
R. VIJAYKUMAR, MEMBER (a)
in-e¢)
&
-&
"
ae
os
oan
*
*
5
3
ORDER (OR AL)
fA we Naw she nmbenan tric O .
Pex = Lpmant Depo _ SAL 7 > 373 station, Qo ~ is ir fai ® HO Ber (By Advocate Shri R. R. Shetty} x6) a sod ot ay Ba 63 sed SS td cs me is) sed end f;
kg Q oA $5 oS red ned the 6 "4 he fr bet cs act % sy}
19. } O19, os i fo 9 A 2 2019 to 4 y 2 y 6 019, 323/2019, 326/2019, 43 '2079, f y 25 366 63 3 mr 4 WHR Ox. Gos i Mo Thy SE GR wh BG Ea a ® a Beate So PO bod ko Bw BO crf oy Of Oy fa 2 mG OO ey Bo OG am 4 Rory 4) GQ wt eg eae Go Yo M ts, Sp ey tee ae es ted bd 3 vid ASO) ed Cp ee 4 3 Me GO OO OG ep a oe os Yo OG BN 5 ta Oy MO ® ap . uk am wm 4 ra fa ay SP ty Meg font Port 0, ry tq 2 WO, a 5 os iG a: rn rr ; re sey GO, ry ots 6,64 Uber, oa ty & fh) EEN pe 43 i HE try . O Of ry Gc OW Gg aoe OB Ss cet Og - wo op bo bg Bae % HO Co 6 & my Bw Bm ON we @ & aa: oS & FE my BB CM oy ae RE on x oP Eo Cs i 43% p Hog Bm 6 7 EF Q vey wo ye SS SO 8s 3 o ~ " . 3G we "4 5 wh ey By gs $e EE org 6 0 o + 2.4 8 ct ba ed og EW Sg os, ge és vd Owe Eo og ® g . 49 m © 62 BO os gy fal 3a a ' oC Ci my PM og Ba BB hy gy go moo, 3% & 4p BI GS 5 4 we BG 2 ao, 2 Say Ba OH RR gp BOD OS » 4 Nor 1 © a; mS et og EO Seo Go 8 fF BG tao gw uu he a we cu may BEDE YS BOM ES GO Bea f ie St Oo 8 BL cep en Ge BU Pam ae DHS t~ Bs 6, oD Wy Sy xs boN, fet OB a gs Mel iho & ot o PDRA t peed oa, pee Be oy OG oo m :
uh DA Gs Sty wy WoO cH oe fe a oy ® oO G hm @ a O e . ag any HH "4 4 SOG g@ | a NE "MP NS ye cs i . on © Red & ay mn Ne ey 4 TB ; ih Ew De Ub tg vet & se} El EN gy OG & o ty Uy Be ey 5 Tt By Eg SoU th a er Ao pe gy (8 ot ot " c @ Ry Rey £3 cs <4 43 Se wa hi ogy & <4 ~s, & Sy 4.3 i ° i a 4.3 SS paid & a bm Bm ay gio wg a os "tm, Bre mh OO py BO Bet we "el " aS the mt, By Gy ka me gh Ba ae Ry Eka ey ets bb Shey Big, Sy Cy i ic Ge Sy in B ri P BP ROM OR WOR gg Sm em gL f-4 Hs oy ty MG dd a Sa 4 Lp uy oS sr) G AE ed ON wt Sy OM OM mt ad ty YY yy © Na db wy O € th ap BO B, ® wed ed om Gop kp DN Yy or «by . tA @ 4 C4 mg ooy a Mk gh cp 4 ro am Moo Ry ste of tp Rg, EE Gt { a o "4 & BP oo om G oy, dom fy SS = ri ni a @ OW O oo mG a BY ae ay te bs yt rl - ba 9 ed ord Re ce yt ey ve + 9 a Oe sony Oa os Oe ' rt =P QOH BN Eg BY 2, 0 UN 2 42 TS Oy ord TY Oy OB bP EY oe 53 4 x 2M 8 ob G WOO BP aS OY QE mh ort TW my oy rete Hg eS SHO yb) at by © iy ee we OG 'HO OREN Soo & set Ge ge OO Ba Cy Ca co Gs wg @ wy M by 2 TR Bs ony To 0) Cb seg eee Ma ms & Om So CO OF wy Be bo te ey op % WT O GN TO tH hy oO wy «rf "4B S ie "4 4 f2019 ta 245;
§ O18, 9 & OA No. 764 Z2S0/2019, 3232019, 326 i f 2019, 2019, O19 to 439/ fe Ne 3 4 2019, i $49/2019 to 454, oh tf my r| xed a ies 44 4 ay hy g ih 43 o} 3 wo ¥ vet tf tt by hes fet 1s bf ie GS red renef oof "rd fo OM proba y UMNGEer wer G
i) @ Oo nd, ed G "4 5A > id oh, wo Ct a +f 3-3 "sd ot ea.
oO an eq net s term Ne ae ee fe @ £ § cy ita) ir .
wef a 43 O19, O19.
#2 "
?
2019, 2019 to 439/ fe :
O19 to 454, 2 , z ;
23/2019, 326 23 & 449, B4/207T8, 245/2019 to *~ 3 Of W2019 & \ OAN 2 66/2019, 4 _% 2 W184 ® Wy a © ey 3 "A ay DWP 4 oO BO OU ae mm "4G G1 0 @ mm & @ & tn SPO & w ® 4p "rt 3 AE @Bl4 OD DO Cf OG tb UU ft Moet oy Gh O OG ch OS) to & 3 4 m4 ay "ef rH & Wor 4s Ror a RY 4) ots S228 Qo Bd tg ors 4 of ny e $3 4H a 43, Bi ty ce = Q, 4 4S no G go 8 ae 1 8 ae geot es. eeu 8 me a wy J | # OM OS Doo Ho ib ge 2, 4305 i. a a : o 424 % we wy "ey ne G i a Minny GS : o Sh, f rf ¢ oo ts ate "tke ns a | hg ty EE gee oo g ea lg pad "el Tf | Se 86 yo Gy, BBY A res « @ ce) uy by we 3 Gy BE 4 Bia, Bal oI me ee % BS ag ge Oo 6a Te wou he o esp S hc ot Fe i ° wm Et UE rE 2 83 bp "GH x eo Ty ba wet by ome, EE 4 wm oy Uy aa Ay Pe i i ty HIG a a a a a 8 oH oN at Gc a fe be "ef "4 al, aww Ss ky om 2 a NM Ke ek RE, "Edy ae Ey, KD ey {oe % f " a} aad % 4 an o "eh Se 46 By HE ty 2 +3 i gS a 8 Be; $4 i i mo ms Sah ae UG @ ce Be ate ty, TS DE 4 O ve ae "CS mt Os ot Ew wm BH OF Me OG eae bes tHe a fe @ BO Buy yy ni " a Stk CH bays Se 3 - ae j is + oo § a3 ote t a0 B28 By fh ae ® ni vis 6m RS . x hd a ty ® td "4 ll iG ----- i By oO ved dah oil EE iG) A tet mhag, * 4H Sct "4 E Do A Gl | O] ta Al ah og (8 81 gS dio a EB OS Oc) a Bs AS Be mY E Bp Bad 2 mn | Ope e Ps Od WS dig & 44 hoo ™ Sap sal © OP, 3 = es o ts SMG Ops we Pe 4 BS g Ae ow FE AY TES acl ofS 2 i ee Bl ort ey ' 2 yy © ay bd Map Wy "5 5 ad ty £ OF & tt Gy tt OE em OS ES a ay % bot Ho' See Css sts sss se PhO ekg wal So ® HE .. rah hah ac} fs rel CS 2 EE a. og C ay i oe ef Sp a Pd tal Dl ey 3 4 HG Oo hy mort OS Ag p i & san 4 th hal CH dh OE * *) Gah EIS a "CH Oi ri by oe ew, m wy fel vy A EO ort SO Gece La oe ro 0 Gi didn yO UG 4b by ~ ox w Raped ret Sa se EE i Cy UH CH vet O gw OF, i & Ge Wb OG - g es ks 2 + i . t o™ PS OU kp Ep Mp kab Oh tal sor ee ty gy ky ~~ OF OD GD ow Ge G& BH OD a DO Pps 2) Gc ap al OF mh @i ce by CH Ag Gy Oy GPG kp ay O £2 wm ep mG a eG OG a Sp kp OM te Ag Mee I ky Me he, 4 we . . : M6 ga 4 " > . ' : _ eg po o Rb 8G OP Gh tap Of = je af + fy EQ "- Ty HO, mo eG HO Re we fe Oe fap yt EP GS Cds a & @ od rv Q 4 2019, i i 4 3 O18, 2435/2019 to 2019 to 4 oe 4 wn {Se é 2
449. OA No. 764 19
79) Ut C by .
i mG oo f« 2B 4 a «3 cS 4) ct a t "ig = eZ ye 2 i O OM a. ag ct ty yg » ' . s y os "tt i yp "Seeagmwy 68oae ai plhehe Rew Geo ay a gy yy, GO Bo tt ord Loy 4b da wk a by "ei we rd ed ey OP eh ed be ed ed hE Oho ~ + @ 43 3 a O hog a a UE 43 Oke rd tts hy a 43 o coat $4 6 wg $y th ws 4 o é & Si red 2 ee 8 Pty pe 03 a Q ot Ww cpl oO Cea g Gu Og Se DBO Be a ys Bs wy eed hw o age DUE Sy oy : ke Qe ' 2 "rt | a 4 th 3 # eq hd e £ > z. a < toy oo wef of oa 3g tied &., es , We Pan Rot. gn apy Ob 83 Sa w i 8) a Ou "ey mr Our bbl 4 & G rue ae Te & BA EG fn cel oa PO Ss 6m" + Ge hg EF eg Tg ® watt rl cy og OG ¢ @ n sq HO 2 2, 2 ° Oe i 3 8 HS c3 G Me rs iB Pi = ioe % Ss & a a bye sm Ou BRA MOON faa SO Gy yi Ge g 8 PD OB e 5 9 "YAS BD gy G Oe & of Bet od DO he By 4d * th M4 @ % cS OD % Mj BI ve 43 Ty Gy uy AS ty od uy Yt fy oN gt iw "Ft it eri gg fo Fath wy ; ay & Bd ty as x, 4 a ak ads 5 is © cs eo BP Be SN Ow ol a ote OL om yw me og & eG 'i , « 2 4 * ' f ¢ 1 Me . oe js o ms one 2 " . ape Bese Sou" BR w Yao Boge GY eet a, © SB 8 & yO "Rg © 2 toe g a OF RY We Bs pe Sed OU se 3 ae A SS a ot ij ko Bi ny _ i 0 4 Ad ge 43 i ® 3 Aa & a é bu eg aso GU | HAG oT, 6G RE Re BS tha ow 3 G6 « 8 G EG AS "| pay 3 yD my OO g 3 ' mt * tao. » : * & > > 7 i SP aS sO we BB & EG gia <p me Ok G Boom OP io Zp og G ® " 2 wg Fa gy ie byt a ret if sot ¥ $3 gs 1H SS x my Gs rg CO BY AQ , @ ap g O ha G AS N@ eg yt Poop Be Mls Gag 8 Hg Sw YO Be th a ee i or ae wm ® + yw Gal GS care 4 OO Bo Ss a "4 a } a tS w
- ¥. , kt ae 4g . ie eet ray 7 i Me. ss oe red Og eB Bos Beri ig I OD GG "e te ab fy RD 1 a "rd i mE Ks 43 aan EE $a gy OY 25 oO w ' 3 2 w my ty Ba OY Q of SS gg ROE Bw oy Se a a ed W % CS ep ty mH ow nd me 6 re oe AO oy a if oo Gt i yy ¢ 9 44 B wt ie whore ay a) ee $ + a "ty oe 3 8 43 tr qs nm , fh C3 $4 a ord i ° er Gy eat ag OR Wo OO ty a 48 t eee @ OB & Rl 6 sq oen ge v om Rory Ff ev an a ee . By ed eg cpg hy a Uy $2 Sp ome ep og Ebr, tae tb OMS by ass x is Pe _ ip re eM Crh ng Os te ts og gy i a do w fos » OP ced 4 Sort ty C3 a na a od ny AS ht $4 uy i) $3 Oo U O7°O & neg ty B try; ay a on fs a 4 Qa ky 43 "3 ing $4 5) ve e Aas os i cm F te, 4 : ' "y iP oS LE 4d re u3. 4p spd re wet et 44 i Soe Wo a ha 6 mp t B Ged f 2 e @ @ hy Boe FY @ EF Pw +g. aA ' . , rhea Set RMR Ord mee RR kp day 4 re ont ve oe 4 © GO Ge ts OO "Oe Gea ko og Gey e iy oS ts he? o 7 =<) ae . it ct m v4 et ba Ge ; DB > ord me q rel i = . ny J .
S 8 5 2 § = « , 3 o ip € eB £ 8 Hog OB 4 k hy * ka a it a iS mt G we a wv wd Qo © Mm G « 4" og og «ow axsex2 g F 8 § 2 G 8 & mG 6 BH ~ @ i S 2 et uM ocd G sy 3 ed ¢ 2 @ Ss md Ci 8 ah wy x3 ce ts D aor ui 3 "¥ 4 is "ef a4 '4d " 2 isi S + " vl Lm 43 5 i SORA TS oO w iO im © xs s £ @ 43 "a vt he a 5 TA ep @ G 4 Rs a . Db 43 mh gy i r3 fa ay w ace 8 8 Fog g o B88 #& © * 39 B 6 fo A BS BB 1 ne we a 3 , a 6 % ne ' i a Bs rt c a a oon OH wo 6mlCU OO Do 8 ay go GO 6 cs - @ me Sy oe os Ch, @ G é nm 4s ved 7 Pol 4 a «4 ay 53 pa & sy ES ey SP Need ont % - it 4 kA a 4 iggy oe us haa ao eS O be By @ "4 ed 5 © ri ro) o oo 4 a) 4 "S {0 Q es EOSD om a ye ts i mop Ul SU BR OG BR 4 ome 8 O o gm ocd 3rd nn wy oo od "A 4 sy cy wm ONT rt yO OB 4 @ wD " G ua Q BONY a @ G é ® 1 8 , Me et 3 - od C Q a3 ¢ oy ' - eS) i . bas 9 ry 4 by Mi oe Cy OS 4 sy S 4 py Je arf | Gh {3 ¥ wt a 4a geod re a a «ed ta 43 @ ry $4 3 ES > we 4 i, gy ut os eS 3 in a am $ 4 & 14 ry @ £2 O ¢3 i O 5 St 5 a 93 < B mr OW ny 3 B PS OM eA Ce wy 3 ~ 5 y @ 44 4 am = ih } ad rl si w om 7 4 "bef os Ch, " 3 5S 4 a n ey % red Sf tb. wi) Te "et . a x ery © ot Sf tS a z G i a 8 B Set eI O ie 4 5 _ G . ° re ae A O Q oO te, & © 2 "4 ms M eo OM UO co Pe uv oh, a Sy 4 <t is $3 9 a4 ¥ "4 ws ss 4 py y 6 # @ GS 32 @ & 3 ~C rad Soo Bg USO (i : ee ap M4 6 a & 4 ty in a ve aed ay ry 4 cs Oe by Q ee ork w ; mm Md 2 3 ' 5 is:
= 2 rn w gc og 3 Gg mg sai ec we $f} + is $a ' s , 23 re} " a ort ies 3 a , @ el ts 7 a gs a 3 ' sy « i w te 5 i _ : os ae tng Ds ns ot r§ ae ; ¢ 4a ra = XS 4 t : a As ) os An , ES - ue) y 8 a uw A ¢ ee o mn wi tS 43 <3 i] fa o a } a * g Y x3 Red wD Sa red F} Sa « bE ry , . i ved , gs 44 a" " ns 4 4 od 43 D « wo OS ba fs 43 & O " is uw i Q % mn «cd @ i \ 4 © ra . oO ot by eed @ ; : Q a MM 4 "a4 4 bes u3 th oy oa wn 44 3 ose aS v © . o Ch, a) "a v 0 a B ae ort id fea © 5 1 M foe mm wv Qo + - ' 4 0 a ' Q ite) CQ Q os 6 a ref w 4) ra Cc be bey tS ® wid cy we " w D $4 cea th 43 a | vs ey « i ord re M4 '3 % ag wn ort rg uy ee w is Aa a ie : 3 a @ a i > & & tO a a 8% no fo 5S 9 " v +4 toy a DR : ® Oo + n oO : ro ns) © gs 5 " hd ot 4 io 44 ob An Z . 4 aS Dy 65 oa . i a bs @ of ea m ¢ hy re + 4 ¢) rt m4 ad oh DE CY w O ded wet Sq Ta es] ry ay Roni Ww vt AS ort gn ba @ > oy a in cn Q % mr eG bs "4 cs a $4 bet * 3 AX 4d | fF) A ie ys "rd ™ :
£ i ; Oo ny e ht pa rf GQ Boog 8 © 3 " a a u 3 oO PDP » uy 9 D fs : D ies ng aw &¢ 1) i ved 0 03 @ or4 4.3 eed , @ 43 ed es e wd 44 eS et 3 $4 sd ha ved Ba as o 4 A y nS whe q3 5 ved bys 6 apt Q ay & 43 my ne
- f 3 an Be 3 "e4 "Ch ; se @ , « Ww ts " a a of i & = ne ni 4 o 4 oa ce a oo fi oO ved 3 c i v2 bs, ord 62 @ 43 vet os . es xy ct ) ; @ 0 GO & ug 3 2 SG fe , ro a oO @ $4 '4 '4 th ; ie rt Ad @ i 4 Be v4 ; es D Ss ie Ch, gy Yel a G a 43 D ret a . ed ea 3 o @ ay € keg ah Se, a a4 " + ' hed ay ns a3 ES 9 4 : bs 5b a2 ea) Q, Hed AG eg c x pee ing ay ' + i) Shs t tes} g Be a a 3 4 QO ort 43 a ai iG £0 M2019, 2 f2019, 326 019 to 439/2019.
3/2019, O19 to 4 io ae >
449) Bei aly fi cs "
3h:3
2019, 4 2019, 3 3 B 23 66 » x 12 aw AS be id ¥ COU 0 £ s G g asd B a pray nee SA RAL way te BU y nat ar ion :
wpe SSS : ie "dd " Be Wow . 4 , ng in o ie a ry a @ Ly eg fg 4 A GS « 9 @ f > ". 3) @ 3 et w iN ; £ a a, ba o we 42 7 a3 BK AM FH 4 eo gt gs OO fe et a © ae 430 vet o " 3 tH ws Q S285 2 io» 6 OY 8 e a chet SB $4 = ° 4 7 Lt i a a mt = = ot 4 eS A on 1 * oe 4 on Q 6 i) ih ie & 44 c AS on xf @ bt bel Ms 43 Met my rn & 43 aS CG 43 © G wom | a ce & o vd w 3 a a vd um G ved 0 ty ne iy 7 % o fp OE . mod a od "0 G mg a me & QO 4 Ag 9 & ® 0 13 @ 1 th fa wed red & a * 4 ' 3 S D ra ved "
oF on TH 4 me orp x by ns > or f% * n 8 c 5 Is OB ; 3 ce Ne! 7s " whe et ye . Sans co 8 @ & " @ ¢ wi BGM eG hon 3 8 SA Gye, 440 OO ke s oO ¢ te mY ; Hg SE Go, oe 2) il Cy oe et "4 my o a 8 m i poi we fn R wf a) seg Dy a mS ris) Sher MO sp ord Pa 4 v ey, fw wD ry = S Meg By 6 OO . me ¢ o Oo Fo. OG 5 , a) ut cs ~ ae v us 3 Q @ in ta D g a wn 5-4 ow BS oe ® GR OC 6b lg » »® Boot GO BH HY i OS ed aS te 3, (3 a3 a $4 . #3 eed _ 3 e ja " ot @ x 7G + eke no s is By rg cd 4 CG es 5 i foe St ry "4 bi on be 43 om " as C & o - "iO ' ct ® 43 LOS " 5 «dH ng : aaa $i kd - 5 :
; rm tL 4 1+ Qy os as GS e ¢ i sed hy im hg 4 3 is OAS tf) vt Y od a et . 4 43 " 43 ha fs &y wv a 3} S a bo fs ie vee} £ Set be 64 iy my ' ny , "4 B ~et i 6 wn fs 3 } 4 ny ' by © cs Q Oo 3 e C : of rs a Q @ % . "4 hg @ Ra G wy hed o cd - 3 aS Oy, qs B . w M4 ® a oe es 4 Ta) i % a nh in i = i2 Ueeg , Pay HS WS a Sh} a) 5 a ved 4 43 5 Ct gt 8 os [ip a @ @ rot 44 ay 3 @ (3 £3 a 4 'D od mo 4) a Fe ey f ad Le Sa iy rg he iB " Oo uy A ny yy a i rt a <4 $f faa iw, A fo © i ty ed oa 3} a % Ba 6 St «3 went 2 os wy TS a o ved i Ut a oO ; rt o os et Q is ° o $2. ip 3 Wd V % : 9) v 2 ~ : Ci he 4 ; oO "my Dy 63 3 w mt o O i G " % ord aa a oD a 44 hed @ raat re MI ay i re @ oe o 4 v : a v) e " ey {5 a he " Med ra ref 4 Qe wo # th Vv C ® «a q3 er G3 &, fe ed bg tt ® . G gs ves a ord red aot 4 44 a a + ae "i a % Mo EP a ow OF ti 3 « @ ve 2D - et is ~ 6 ref Ed or at ow , G oS ' ~ oD ~ sd 4g o 6 # 8 py 8 2 vst ~ Re - 5 ew Go» 4 G8 Db @ 8 g ££ #6 ted a ; 44 th Root OM m ooo g Ms bd 3 m4 oD BO + A a Hoe @ © € » & 8 & Ly 2 uw a ra 4 "4 ny i - z ry " he tt ved i g at '6 Oo @ y Hoo 8 Do a rh So B S fu a by nn mg le " + Oo 8 a} Tae 44 Ms 3 ia is 43 bm a $4 © iw
4 , & a £8 4 @ 8 yo oO 'i 2 D wo D ay o o a + 2D ce ci iG vd @ gE a 4 ee vs & re Pe 3 id ay vm Fe 3 ad x 3 Gi a3 Ww in a Us eo MS mt 2 5 2 3 4 @ 8 A e . CG @ He w @ ~ @ u oH mh a wv ¢ oe 5» £ & * ho oo oe £ wa & @€ 8 8 8 a th " > hy WS uy ip be f i Fas hy nf {ha @ 3 a3 ' wo a cs $-§ @ - fees ad oO Q 43 3 i '4 % 4 apd orf rt CG a 3 $3 Oost eh Hh UO Oe 45/2019 to > , f2018, 0.763 ¥ :
a OA so et OK we i th i tt bd a : vp a Ree me ah se Gg " cs te ao & w ne: a 4 og " ~~ gh gs eg oo a ref oe uy O " 4 ow yo i) 3 At G cd oie y ot ma ao 0 Oo a an sey we os " @ & go CG Cae a See SS a aed :
os ot n $4 4 iA os bd & © $4 a ey * xed aS a oye, 7 a ra 4 H ve) sa q 1% i O oF 43 ce uy te xp iy , as ta G a 2 vod @ 4 ' gs %
-o : 7 Reve me pe » 0 USO ce 43 con os o% & ee : aa a hy goof ned rot ™ 2 ; g) : rr] es 7 4 3 fe nny, 43 g Q Bs 54 wg a ey 4 ws Son a veed + ay 44 as & oa wed $3 @ ts al 44 : a és i co "+ oe L 1 hd 4 4 th "& a © we ved 3 43 ot . Hl 4 Se @ wed 8 tc A a ¢ ' '4 ic S 4. 0 ame fo a a3 ef os o a be e te m8 od a ws es Se, Ex Ld ed vc age "ee a me iw whee wy a po "st ¢ A bt t as . rn : 2 { % rt : ie a % . ie C "4 Hd od OO 8 Bo Bog 8 BF we re 4 8 HS wy i on . ot ot cred rs in . ; te 4 . Ch oe fee ef "3 ny : fi nai a pia or "hon eg 46 © » ® @ x oy yO ym rs 4 ye a) x oe a ef aed a yD KO 3 ot Sg hd W O gy 4 "A gee 2 Sy if r . 44 « 4 7 5 . vied 4 i bd Wa Gord vA 3 vt . * 4 ec tard a nt * . we | 8 ee + :
S v o & 8 8 ow g es is T PG 9 B Bg @ D> oO Hod " a im 3 he a) } ' 43 ra is C3 o m 9 & @ 8 S$ 8 HB yg Boos 2 » 9 # eo g # :
" ai Os 4 phe oe a WS gD my Erp Q 4 @ & Ths & a ie Ch oy 43 A el Oh, by a re 5) ey "4 " ce fh m 3 i hte o " oy - "a 8 % 4 ww 2# na a Mg He ® 4 " ® £3 it] an} wo r~t w M4 5 se] mS hoy. Beg gS wy OD wy my 4 BD ? 4 4 Ba, 5 $2 rg % a ay y 3 3 no as , rf uO ai 1 4 ; iA " ay 4 5 hd @ { Zi ' y * 2B vo gt rg a £3 Po oof oe i a o ¢ aa , + : oo ty a3 4 Oo oe ep rho Gk 4 Ob ms Goo OF 4S P G hd us . 6 03 . : an a g ° a 4 e Gg 2 + cs a 3 tt 3 "1 ie bs Pe 4 ' ed a '\ . e = . + . 3 - ( ( 4 6 of é) ' BP Bs oD Som 8 RG Ow : * - : kt : my C Ly OQ r ' Bm Ae Bg o 4 H & 6 G@ a * 4 3G i "rd ve 'ed @ o g) rs rg af mf 3 th rt in n g eo "13 ent ral fa oe 4 ae 44 G by 4 rs 2 a f aS cd 4 : 3 B QD g 43 AY 4 @ . } $4 4 w rr rd " 5 ce 43 , ss ub "f ch 2 o t o a w 43 ' @ fg oS wed a] oa : " * t 3. . . 3 . Cy bd de z or £4 co in @ a "eed 3 Bs y bef @ @ '6 oh, a) o pat OG S4 BY yet oert aged sd ared v} 3) if ont i ¥? na A Dem a ce . 7 hd D tend c . we tc w et "4 hg 3 v ¢ a £3 KE : Mon Ci o 4 .. a oy © . 4 : ' : : "4 oe. iB rt G 4 i bss np as si e od oe G G 44 @ % m3 xz a3 eS cs 4 ¢ a ey * @ a G b : " A "* ' cs) G sy! eed a oy 1 re) j 2 ' ° KS Sa ' $4 f "t © d oh es r D a a SB nt " 43 ci O Fs iS yO a Gg UB ae o # C cs bd % CO 5 aed 4 ng hoy m4 wyped *: A ' oh 43 ren wy 4} 7 + a @ 'eat io a C3 m 6 ' 7 , oo te fi ek Mo TS gy ta, A a a ge ee ws 0 2 y 4 8 8 6 RY Bf os 8 » ow & FA H gs BG ved D Sa ; ; we ef "4 ce 2 j Ad oy 6 ti % 43 t pa o* . ha os Aa - ted w @ a) a @ ts ( rs - in O o @ a o cy f \ M4 i 3 wgek Q bs 4p al ta . iB +4 i Ge 04 ut a Os, Ch ne, td 3 a ey a 7 q 5 / : © a] 4.8 iB n nee ' oan) & a 3 rat rai a ei ® Se 2 4
2) fe 3 % % ans : 4 ow Q aod uy re i 7 wy bg > z KG cs 4 im we 2 "3 Gs $4 tz Ch, 4 = e i a us oft whet a cy hed $4 rd 26/2019, S/2019 to
5 ae 3 9, 436/2019 ta 439/2019, O19 to 4542019, Z. m~ ee i ' 449 2019, 3235/2019 1 i é 9 Q OA No. 764/201 8, 24 2 "y ij :
"366.
aed a4 At @ a %3 v i * Q o @ ew G 4 a a C 5 --~ Ee * © 8 ae a he at cy .
oS ct 5 ba @ od cs iy & Gs ~~ ot bs G 3 a fs x Ad ef Ct o ort 2 Ss wd 3 mi t& zc 44 ord na 3 bt ot 3 \e iy g ay fay a tr a "% a . rg wef @ wD MH wy 3 ot us .
So @ F & oO fr . 8 ® 2 A (i oO : @ & aa ny th, . a 44 ' ea Ba ha ' 4 G . ist S48 Q Cos a in o ra mt @ © 6 n a ey - 4 y "i me ' Q QO Tt ' 3 a O tM Oy . e : a vcd @ wn } cS " ao 2 My ' ty ord a 5 ES i red mG tea o Pe oS OU 43 &i a ® Soo OG OM Re % coed o $B : 4 ft 4 Oo So oH fF 9 6 © .
oo 3 w . wed i ES 4 "A r a oj « ah c wy 4 w 5 G . it v4 "4 w a oe a g i 9 y 8 a G 23 55 5 0 1 oO AS @ Be ond ws 43 as ct & 2 Oy, on z 3 ar a Oo "Y - & 43 44 # a ed G} ny a} cf " a8] eG ct on ay on $a , fa eo oC - 4 bo OG O ty rt 5 Fs re t Js i © Bt omt TY ee wp x ~ 3 uj 1 week A FoR, BB 8 5 be & -
4 © #2 gy 8 g Es eg a6 e 8 8 SF SOS Go B 2 SS 9 Bb a2 ei a ord 5 a ed id Qo a od % : mp gos 8 BS a BB om " 9 mn "4 'a eed «© ve Bey sed i . nm ob @ 2» #9 # tp 2 vf od 4 $4 a tc © i a aE Ss "3 vod a 4 hed @ q CQ @) a OO 8 «@ GG oo RB Xx Mw Oo . :
3 cs st 3 tt a2 re fend GO $4 re mG * oy mr is) "4 1G 43 4a a ee G 4 "et oe SSS SATB BIBI IH HW gga dene dada weneee eee .