Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission

Samir Shroff vs Hasmukh on 25 October, 2007

;1£J/K mugs cum Ftcuzuzt sfimvt, =g;°mct mm, aamalcue.

wflet rixuea (2993 2»u£1c4L-ixtoozllgu wilet -1231 is 51911.

iiiflét-2 : wfll a'1c{'lmi2§3ii£s Iwitvsra :

ma, zit cam, ilzilsra 1c«1L'J£L, 2»u2.é1.2»£1. 2-Etéla mil, flan its, gm [Egtu '1. ¢u.gMc=u5 .sLezm>Lt<S °52'1cuc+:
21m.g.2i15--.vtL sca.i§,2{1em§t«t euzgmmzz? cdlcuaz bill/2-4:"L.t(:,3:ié3.,~:1é3,;i3l1, amscu GtL$5*Q{, "§,?.rI..

2. 1'-'L-W131 flisaa 2'Ic~uuva¢ £1§Lc«£l2.L»L e0;

Xe, aha-3-3, 22:21 "L'1,'>iD5l?.L é1€:Q{,3.§L€~LLi..

3. 33¢ srmearail an.

(231) 8. C-LL€:t@{L\'5 élvgtsaz §§nM@t£:t, 4'i'12£'L mm, umfl aiutizl utik, rttdgzn, gzct.

(oil) sci éL(3.'i4., xx, ,:§1c¢--3_--x, $121 4.1, c»i.-am aleu, lgtwu.-2.. an =1é't<a?1:>L£1isa1 321 sra4.ea-24."! an.

(231) 3. c-uc-Lona? Qmvgtsaz émétat, zileim mm, u.m~fL citqciifl U.I§t, vttrtgu, aged.

(oil) 5% -mm, xx, , aim-3-X, £121 -L1, bizstu «£1621, §.§LfrtLE..

uma -i.1oo2 (gu.

zltilétva : 1. flamraa flétafiuu cfl.

XE, aim-3-3, 2'L2"t rm, ¢>i.:>$L2L élrzqt, v3§|.1'».£I.E..

2. i'+-'Mot {Lisa flétli-L-'24. il§Lc--{1u>L en.

3. svi sraaarw. :41.

(zit) 1:. euaomi Qt-@381 §'L1ué4.a<., =I'L2i'L 3-LL01, umfl c+1u<§L2'1 mil, v1Lvtg2t,g2ct.

(oil) 581. éL(3E{, 7:5, ,211cL-3-K, 5121 vi.'1,tvia+L2L élau, 2.§Lo1Ls.4 ac it-'N1aL£13_sa2 351 3-we-u en.

(:91) Is. cue-tnutS §tv;Lsa2 §l'»1«l.~':-L&1.,€.{l%1"t mm, umfl c-tL=4¢§£L2'l unit, vu«tg2L, gm.

(oil) 53} mm, xx, , itq-gar, $312'! -12%, oimm eilc~a,§,g'1¢us.

[F1364 Elzzilnsra : =L. é.ugMmLsS;sLau1omS °KflCiléLL 2'£121.g.=§1a.rLLsrt'L§2fleLLt31vt e-.2J.gn>t<=1L5 rxilqtcit 1rtl2,'3~4:£.£C:, Lbigz, iwg'-1.913., zmscu. aufirra, gm.

2.w{1z §Lrfl0tLE5 241$ 30%, >31 ct1oL,1312{1,s--a 'L-LLML, 2~tL2.éL=»i'L. 2»i'Ls'muL$L, flat its, gm .r§L2H : sfl ws'L=1L2»LLg°n, E12mS§1oL ilwa afl dlrucltrn 1Il.'2.2+tsS, 91*-2:12 aitsciniisazt : -wflci ri.ue<:/on-1La3u1éLra dzé ailscifsa : sfl 25m..2l'm.BLé1s.'i wllca. *{.'iOO?./OU.~'tL Iiuléra «R3 3-:{$<J:t_!x2' : ail u"l.°E'r.o1§ maimrsra cnfi =?1sq'L}a : ail 2>a4.<$:.ass2 \j__.

3

g§rt:-- all w§L=Dt.a»ttggt, [it2ttsS$1att'tust1 mzaa 'L Czuitawt cotr-3t 2»u£1c~Et aflctta Eat vt'.¢ta.:t/c><t éscrt Et. gm firmt -'lttéé «mt:

titcttrttet !§'t2='t rtl.3.c:f'tO/0'o'vtl 331°; siet gsttafl rLL2L°5 2:29 (3u.i'ts<t ¢2"t2.tte-tt 2{lH.l<U.Uu r£..=t ztlmt-tit =>tuflct '{.'{OO3I_/01%. art-R ztuttctttrtt v{.Lt+tt5>'t arttflet --'t.=t2e 4/ottrfl. ztutct sia étet t-tv4't 2-tuT1eT.trt't F-Lisl<':L Sta °J .§tH.vi °tr°tr3tva2£1 §s2Cl.tHi aattét Q. Et. till"-t*£:l'1tlLE.Hi sict gszt rflit gmt Qt.
" (1) azlztteflvft silctts. lviitdi flag: szcttuqt 2»tt3t £9, (2) 2ttH.tcttutt ~{."L ztlx-1 gal: azcttut and £9 3!: Etmét aflzttét-1 ztgtsct st-"t (3) Etotsvt:t'Lét gtxc: ,ooo/-t'1_ lsvt gtscil lvw-t.€-0..

atttttcttutt -{ft afl tr-Vt zitcit gm §:3.<U.'{[ 2»tt3t 23 3; Et»t@t silcttét-1 zigsct 2~tr't Etotseilét d.L.2X}'B'/I-.'é2fl 3_:,.9.ctt;t'l-t'1 rttiflut gttfl 'U-L 2&1. cttErTt.¢.= G-|.|.'!s'+1.lE.9.%fl C?«tl°6 14.91 gtsctg. czttwr-«Ct 22 all vttrtvt 9«tl"lHL ztbflét =»ttvt=tt=ti 2-tt'c't 279 § aeeaeil C-U5 moo agttl ctstntat '14 aatefl 12: eat czttosrft 22 -ttctt. r*«tLZf!{LE. etactt-it sztg eteit Etafl 2»tit zltcti-tr c-tottcfiit 2»tt c2tt°srt't 22 etottétct £9 ctett az'l2tts.'14't s?ttS Qfllrtl 1btLU.CJ.L3-Li utctgt -12:51, cLtt°ar Clfllrtlvtl ylt 9-vt1{L<J.<1.t"-'Ii 2»ttEt €9.

¥tl1HL¢|.Lf-'ll.v1'..'t all 391. zitcit wet gait éslfilmi bttét E9 3: €tHt§'t 6.s2'lztt€1?t étgact zttét [Etot.sct:t"L$t 3,t.3,ooo/-- 5 flute-tt btitrtt 3341 3:{t1l.CLL.

a~tt=ttcttutt -t'.<t an 71-1 =3'tcE't u.-at gsvt sszctmi anti €93: &=tg5't Gttarft gsctgtl [%rt--3o=tt 3241 Q&,L*£l<1lU'tL vttt-1 zitcit U.L2L gm szcttwl 2»tt€t £3: } E't=tL§t gt.*to,ooo{-- Cl0'Lc't2"Ll gmtt .=;2'1att€l3t [E-t-3o=t't gtacfl. '-'rtl't-Lt'-11.. 53* aitgt rt 3'2' E1 «:4 cut":

0-3.3.0.1. wit."
2. Rt. £?t21tv€t got wétttt szlettzvtt Qtmlcllflll -i.1t-tt aéicttzil azfiettélvlt gt,2re,o2o/--:tt -él.:»i't.2{L£1. t>t2'la"t t-tt.22/tr/eavtt i'l°J' Iftcttrtt vtt="t glvflél &2lCtCll ztmtcttutt -Lu 3-ltléd. 2{LHLd.ltI1L -{.3-7t uftaetctt 2t"ii'tc~t, uig, (3u:t'Lat-t éL2»it.2iL_£1. §I.=-2&3'-'.

=zt*S3t &1'lztt~a'1-1 ttzt-t =~t¢?t<--t -hi]. était ¥LlH.L<U.¢fl.L rt.-3 at-1 HLHLQLML -Lit-{'t ztué £s9.rLl ctt.'t2j°to/<:<:vtt its ttuttcttutt vt'..3rtt2?t 'xIettr":tc«t3x Cavnftact él.-2»t1.2{L.s'L 3519?-L.g.?;X5.~1L'1l'"{ gtvretaz 2tsS at}, Etvt rt étv-t Itzct uitsacttzti mttétct 2'9, ut=.'g,_t <1 a2'1=.tt€t-7t 'U.2rt rtétct r1. titctt-*1 '/ 4 anti s2"1.u.L2,"L=S1 [EL $122+ wax zmucuuuaait iagtttui zsmue. mute-L sicfl. aw-ucuvu ri.u.~u2}t Iizuitsct éI.==$L.::fl.$L s>.'1uL€.1=3l hailarfl cmél £x2°LuL2'13L °.mLL3la viél 3: 5 :L"lu.Lz'1-LL 2?ta.g.2$Ls.~1L~1L5'+ gtraaz 8&5 wit rtél élzfl .=.s1'1u.:.€123t é1.2>{1.2{L§L «C1 25% 331.32 ,o=.o,'-- 3.3'%*i_L cm; 24.-élct imqcu M-1 gL.:mooo{~ szLn'L[is auuru M31 $2'1zus,vi'L wit i>mqc:.L =u}'a ailuuz ama am.

3. ?a.lHL¢Li<!l.L -131 sf} xvual zlql mutt eflfitt-EL 3;, Qwilfltflll rm 2"Lc+m-ra érsafilmnt rLL.°Lf?!;'?.OO'1%fl us} 9123 mil:-L £9. s2'tqLz~'~t gm-{L bun ~13 1-}. s2'1zwe.'1 :emucu.cru-u was wail. Fax. gm [5m41s§'m+-3. avu a2'1uL2. atlmumqt-1'1 gym -120.. ¢2'lqLeuL C--t1»lL¢?«lL*__)l%'6-I.'iL cuctgstit tiuuflu cLLcu;Lii"t Lt-3. szilzmfl-3. btulsct éL.2»i'L.2{1.$I. um =i.'Lseta.mt aauéu:-L £9 A20 azluts 9.2 szcfl °2'L2S2?l.

X. 231\1c+reru C{§Ia8U. 11.95. 01; 243: V-L§1.C'L ail 2?m.23'm.Bt¢"vz."H a'Lm<suL. zimtqwuarft 2'»L2é~1 3, gm ailzuél rug ailea. ail 23L2L.°3r.ass:z-1 24.i0+.tR«lL.

1;. zmuquru via 3:91 -i.:3 vélzei 3-Lu-1'1 sh 2~L5't zumcuuu v{.3vfl uunu §2c1.'*l.i £9 M31 Ex zwucucru -mm Qlfliisl i-'wva Q9, 2u=uqwu vim Hxzasd szlqtaflil é1.2>it.:~€1.£1. gure,ozo[~u.i m.'l%::{1 2:61 gmr-24.52 szcu ufé zmucuuu r{.a HLQ.--$d. nlseil wiiex. £1 eaflan Ffriqvz. £9 'a, fzuium él.3=$t.e{l.$L i¢L2L.g5,.:I3.$.vt'I ctistemi av-21$: 212$ 228: Pm rt étcuét stzét :s2'1uLLz'1~1L vu.="t A §l~='H.$2 @175 $136 rtafl, zmucuuu «Lu Ham (3u2'Lssct éL2»I1.2fl;.$L a2'12m.'12'~1 caoxmzmizfl m.'1%c+ «M1 8: qua zmucusru r{.u:31 a21uve.'13L mm zzcfl °8LsS23t3; ailzuélvu «L91 9. annual am? aLs:i1---Lél. 2muqLuu «Lu alnrra «€13; gm 3:':

$3 91 é.§l.a<t vimi 0&1 zimra «L213 c'12»i'w3L s1*1z4L2'1v'1 arena; em 3; =k2L.g.2?ts.-{L rui gxraaz M -4.41 ct». s-.:_'1uLsI1=11 éL2-fl.%fl.£L gL.7rc:,o2o/--u.'L 5t".5't?.Hl9fl u2'1€1 vi. élct Ml \i 5
-'2{LHLC4.!.¢ItL rturfl t§maL9.'l «£1, wig flcurfl umfl glam sun :8: M31 Em szmqqtni [$1. §L2i'1 §uS rgez ail ».{1.u Pm artmg vufl.
zmucuuu «Lug ailgi 89H 3 (Ba. .=£12v.-{I zmva Stu-3. r=+°'A'et «L20 3:211 AIM'! Edgtrmi uilet gsu 3.2 szcil 02123231, uig 24.u+LcLLtnL ~+Z.uru2?¢ £?L1H zmu 23 alumni urwia rem-2+-{I c-{°arcu2t'l 2»i5trtL gztqwfl milztlssmqtufl «set ctéli $43 2<gg sic-L rnIL 24.L=ucucru ring 212-1L5. 1rL'«[Lf:tHL GLW-LL =;_w<>¢ «£13 éitu am 91 mmti 2313', 3&1 am:-L «£1 § zmuctttnt -{mi R1. {~12 H-1'1 vi'Lé'L:a wire. '1 gcfl Pwfl Qmrit bu eazuq Ht-lQl1lL'>l *1.%fl. e. s2'l2.ua'"l2lt cvmzuiafl Malia él.2»iL2{l.£1. 2ll2L.g.=3>.s;.w+.L -nil. _;tru.=.s2 vi EH5 ifs z»L$'L Fteflvx $2'luLz't~u~w"1 EL ;L-:a§s2 valet «tail 812:1 Pt gtrrasz rl. atcurl swim umtcuutt -{J1 zfl 7:-1'1 $125 i'+ctL§lu Wat'-U. 3&1 sustu. vtél
9. wuqtuu r{.3-ml £:2'1uLs,'151 rLl.'1?./".0/f.¢(¢*tl in; us»: r:-tr~{1¥'t arlgttétca 2;, =?m.g.23L.=.=.-11 vuii §Lr2{$?. 2&3 at}. an -tzfl M41 91 um =s§'L<tL .£s2'1uLs.'13i él.2>iL.2fl.§L uzct vhscwqxui zsuétet 23» Mr} 'L(:(:(:Hi s'1m'1=}1 flea Z mmcucru -mail 2vu=31 u.-at em °6QL04.

-%1'lv-LL€15i. d.l.'l3./'4.0](:£:vil iw 2-mlet c} MA cum-mil -file-LLa'1a3x Q4. IILSCLHL &3.'!.uLa amca siet Q. 2uH.LcLLuLL;,g saw 3;, s2'1zuer'L 3;acxr11r>tm rfs {b A MH1 'it*Ld.l-1913. M91 [EL $1251 ma: than ilét a:u?1c«L :29 E a2'1e.us.~'i gLs.ctr{'1nuu -mil rczfl. e. mmqL<nLr_,g éillrt 3 P1241231 afliuilfi a'1.2-EL.2{1.$L 2u.Lc--L mzsa tits:-I1 a»w?2.<-L Q $1 xii zwucuuuaiuli xi'a.ctLvu 2=J12a2nLrL'L (wait cm/=1ai<:¢-fl 2g am 4} ma am 23141 «Morgan ztg siez :3 A fauzefl zmucutruvu sax-1-1 Mai-1 nah £5. 3.'9s"Re2-E1 M uzqrfl E vhze 2~I1§«'12tvi'L §Ls'>" 'swtcit 2=§ szqmi 2»u?+eI1 vtzfl, uig Csuflad 211»-£1 2+.mLqLu1Lru ?.°d'l?tal*{L vilél iléi cmtila ém an Htrtcuvi 316 amt '19-[1, flag; '*5 -1421 (11~LiiLsct 6 é1.2»i't.:tfl.£L attzbttz cmrtaaitrtt rttit dfitfirktl 265% gt-14.52 M5 otitct £3» 2»t5't 2»t2~tc«t H1603: E1. 2»t5t 5'12? afinttz ail tint Em mat 'KQLl.§ vtail E W1 5&1 5tL%L?--L .3; mwttcttvttzritzit a2'l=.ttfl zttit 21:3 2Hr|. nit t§te.t, 212:3; 0: -ttfl §x2'lctts.'12?t §1trt'tr't zilarl E Q4.i.HlGI.L€fl.l ~{.=t2fl 35% $16 2»t.¥:'t°a 2»ttvi't étzt €tci't 1»££3sQL*t%n art-1 wt ya §tz§1tt2t itctt ittrtctqt rttli: w:tr1°x ?2ttU.<ttHi rt M31 cut zgtfl Pt C?-{Ext Q»lL!é._'$ etvtcit «tail 2»t3t °é't Qt cztllct 3-Llé5' rt at-+.ri't -étzt cit Gtcft cLt[3:ctv't svzrtgtuz Iitésssttrt 21123 Saascrt 3J.Lé3 stsfl 5lL3L?J. Put -tail 2»t~"t Elait Cauitsrt 3l?4.'E.L éatrtvt'1 ¢1"tetts,. attc-[1 atlc Stu vtvfl étcit litttttet am"-tvazt g3 '1(:(:X(3) §'|-fl'-L §té 11:23-Ema. Esaut 2»t2ct'1a {_pd.|. Pct. aflsgzlébt nltrs =23'tat-'clr°a' cvtti s§-itatt 2>L:t wtzirtt Qatnjt szrtutt mttétct 2'9 Etafl afl=.tt2.'1 étt-flvtt attea ~t état Etztrft sitztts °J.LGU. 2!}: Put rt éjtat szlqtzla attwttcttuttrbitvfl i~'ta.tvt'i Ht'-[1 2>'t5't .=.x9."tLtt2. étzt cit mat =>tt séflattz Rt. £?t2H. E a»t3t sfitsttvt Q4.'-tat attcsfl QL3: Eta vtail E120. wet £r2'tzttt'.1-fl Erflilti. %I.LH.l<tlU1|. rm 2R 7: my-ht=ti 2?. HQH um :33. ailzttét-; satrt uitgl 2} 3,, tauttcttuttait Azzatlit é1.=»t't.z[L.§L Ltzct vttfl Iitacit itctt-{L vttwfl eaftfitct £9. "it E ?{L*-LtCLlU1.L ctrté ?.°&l%e?.-{L (3d.l9;_'L vg alctmt 2-ttitct 235, Pm Urti WQL 2315; Ht-t'1 c«t~2S23t S9 2ttHtcttUtt=»t't=3t cvfleit Qua? gtztcit ttzct iitacztt nftit-{'t 23 aft vi titq cit um $2'1r.tte'l 3lié£:rt'1 czttx-2.tt1t't 'U.$cll vt titat %llH.tcLLU1.L -{Ii tail 3' [itgttt £193 8&2. itutqctt éaztz otrtctt -121}.

e. ailctta-tt attatqtuttbftgt ivht mat sétgi 23 3, 2»tt atqétit Ei'¢LLe's'[?-L12-t€1.aél3:'L $3 rot-'t €t tvtrttqflt Hté 2oo1t(2) zilttla-tt2--u:et(21'tvt:»f1) sfl lvtrtv-31!. ~'u.l1-{1|9l citvs [EL til 2S+s2si1%tct fit?-l"tI:'Q4. mitts Qttftiatd wits sfirilztt-tt gstst (am. 1-ttbttz 2I.1;'|.el 93!. St =g.st<-.t»ti 2'-tct't lit?-ttict cttlctcttiti 2»ttE'tct 2'9 3; :3.-% :~»tt2'>".:3'tfa.'«~fLz>tt2S".rt't cm: ctiti £sH.L.Ct.CLl Hté "it QKLELQL 335, étet cit «lit titttélu. €?«1C8.éL3. aiscttzt, twig; tzltitsrt Iittttlct 2~t=tt2."t %t1-I-'¢£rtI.}.Qt*£l c-ttgt utfl Qlsl?-l rlefl, stztgt 3: $2'lattz.'1 53 itsttat szctt Hiatctt érll. $1 Iitcttvtl =»tt°a'lf€t3t Hté szctt Itiatctt «értl, -tél 3 *iHl§l'~£ £55; Hta. Etefl m¢ttcttUtt1t8t zilgi 3&3; % httttslq dtqetit 3§.¢lt°«L Rt =tt~tcttLttvt vtetl 7 fzufafxsrx aura uni °&'mL 2uH.Lcum,L ri.uru=i$L :f»'xaé{ E wflci ri.°n.ec]ou--tL ikftaré $3fBJ.t$.'l35t i1.2»{L2{L$L wflscirfl qua aA=¢.3,.33L£v.«tLvtt¥:%;1«re1£.v-1 2123 afs «£1 31% '?b"%iL3tél '-1 ém. "é1c{LrL'1 Hmfl zaticla ém ?tH.-'1". Etgtttui azqmi ~2»u31c-L gamu ewim such rim '1.

£94. aawzlet rmzeciou 22. mull um 6131 £9.

'10. 5 114191 2'¢Lw.L<u..u1L ~{.a an 3'11 auésvfl rmwuu U.--Sd.\. *1. éliv-L Emil-1'! mil:-t wivgz 91.4'-L|..'*«Ll.'>t ém -'fl§L g=-get gen sraqmi zsuél £9.

§é.'.'~ 'L wila vi.&_2e 5 you 22. .32. qmi 1~D.3L

3... mile. rmooz/on ivgz szqmi MEL £9. E. '§;1.--'J..H.~"L"L zurucucru via til 7: R334. szqtui. muéza gsm man 12 s'zcu»1"L2»u&i

-3. 2>m'Lei'i.rLL mi =bi'5'L §Lé§ gsu aicuui 2»ucL<-EL «mil.

wam iw <1t.2u.i1o[o~e~tL M 331231 xgceil 2»1am<;1Hi°sL-25.1541.

( "a'1.%?L=»tL§°dL) ' (_e{l"r'£Li»?m u'l.%;iLL2§) fiR4.LE§flDL. $11143. iwstz