Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Samsung Electronics Co Ltd on 2 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
Vs WVM WM W.u.w.v\vz\xu«n¢ax>e<»as\a>«».':\3 Qij'E*EE'gé$v._§;£§;%v%I3%;' SQ:--%s;.:a;g?;§§g:§:a:; §J_:=v§C.:sf€E;:
" fi§§fi: j x V 5%; ., 2%;
$2;
/V1 N.fl...,..w_.uu»H.~/M.;>,..»,»;/.=mc..~..1<;,,:«xv»»»w»'»'>'/» fEi\§ mg 5-§§s;-: igaém" <3? §<AmA?;':a@<A AT Bmgaggegg----.%_ msyga EMS mg 2"? was 0%" F:§G':,.?EMfiE§ 2C§E_§.," "- :'--_:. ~.. PRESENT mg §~»~§@:\;"§s_5 Mas" 3u$"s";:€:%A1:x2,;<:j§;%:;2éé2, 4' M43: é ' ' "mg HGi'=é"3LE r4R%3usT:cé'i'R$a;3%Vgvéfiij-gvgfiéé BETWEEM:
zj THECQ®Wfi$Sfifi%a?§$EN£QME?%X C§agufi§%%fig "%g«'.w ""~"
QUEEN§RQ§@gVW\ BANG&&QRE,' "
ma Qgpzma§:.":»;x«:;*»I'§.i:Sé:?_:£:§s£-~32 9? :ra;::@§e:E "?.%><_ " " % , §§'&§"§E§;fs§A°E'§<§€'éz3:L '"§Z§:}{;.51Ts."§"E{L5?'§, "'::*.§R::':% E~lf§{ 1 j: ,,~ _ 5:») §A§:s_=£:A4f'§,€',::5:-:t';::.s:,~f"; M;»'4's;¢?E§_LA§x§'"E"S %é;'.,§;:s;:>~e%;%3:3:2:g §§,EC"'E"§;§E'éECS 5%, 53:3,? «'rZ3§A§S§§~"T%'¥'£§E aggamzegxgsf :" ya; §A€I:'*§'~«'Efi§'afE éfi_§<E%§EE¥%;Z fu-
x gzacxwgg §'7'Sfia§"§$E"~§;>'g, §'§'~j.fiQ.ff&f"f§.§§§"x§ ?'~éAGfi~;R_, §£x§'x§£AE_%39;,E: .=.RE§?P$%$§EE\§"'s'"
xx$*$ Yhis Zélé féieé under Séfiiiéfi 253% e?
arising gut 0? Qréer éatézi 1?.®5a2§:9 __'9T'fa?'s5.§_«:§.___"
ET£,.§\i9;3'325g'Bang/2fl$§, 50:' the A$sesS':'s'%'36é"':€-.V."-;»*éa:?_' 2GQ2~2€.'I83,, may/éng ta formmate the 5:;§sta~::--:£.a':¥'~g:,£as§.E§:2g' Q5 Eaw giaied Eheréin, afiaw {ha avgzsgea-§.éa:'zd $ei ":;$%de~.i%;~he-~é arder pagged by the §}"AT:?,.._f} §?T3§"%ga3EOFE€ *-.__ Z?A.?€0,122§/Bang/288% éatad §.?',Gi?..2Q1§" <:9;r;iF'§:fi?:fé§~:3g'._ we asfier 0? the fizpgeiéaie VC@mmis§%_Grser &"'<::,m§;;rm_;:h7e §%'§&§" ;§a$$ed by :%:e fiemzty C<3_;rfir;":E5s§énger' "i;"2<j~o§r:'25ie1' Tax; {Ezster:':atEe:3aE "?axa%§0n_f:g, C§:*cEe-EExf_;:£'},_§ang'a!.§re¢ This félés caming' F0:-{VA@:<!;§é?';:.__"éi,§§'i:?:%_fia§;*, KQMAR 3., fiefivereé the f§¥EQwE§":§:«» " " * = " -.
Tfie 'é:;;se':':f:_§1@'s"i%V"'-Li:§'2'a2.t_LV'a;{§§%s far Qémsiéeraiéan in Ems agwm E3 s4-*xV§?:a.'§z§"2§rV"€~§j':ée'§:*§'£:'éma£ wa$ esyrect En Ewéémg ihat
-'W.y::%2e._:§"<r:<:;r;é;:s,;%;%:2g %£~%§v§§§«'a:me§' Seaiézm ESMA af {€39 izéiteme &X§€E'E駧ii.§E"€ Engurrea? éy €319 aggegsm $§"é{;a;§':§A mi gar: sf ism ism? iuyrzzgxsar ag gasah éi: gimzséé fjbe ex<;§s,s":Eéé fmm iéze %:G%:&§ '?:%j!"§'E§'==§€E' if the gama are '~é%"s::fi;:§:'l§3;§ fmm exgazz iE,§?§'E{}'*£§E".
%?§°§awz' ' 2' The saéé gzgegiéen waa aagvageyegi 51:' ifizég Cami is': 55% saga is? She Cemmésgiaagr" of fmsamewfax 5:25' 5:,m:::fi?€: V3, M;'s,"?"ai§ Efzsi aid", 5:; 33% :'V:3.:<;;?G,f'2§$'£'?_§;§§ $558? cnnweated ma2;'€e:'s!, afisgmsea' :35'? an 33; éméémg 55 amdarz ~ "Fair: fhe af@re53;'&J }'\i1»{/'?§?f??:«3:?f;'?f='; emergas is 2,1235, were shazfid ":§}r2§é3":s,r_§fik:£f;i;y..i{; the irzgrefiémés 3:' §9i':": £=;'t§e §?L;'§?7?€;fa:¥§f'G?V' :§§;f;§~3:faf"§ff?f¢f3 €f€f?O;"?'§f2"f§fO!' sf ifze forr%§';:§é; ssgskégé '3{§§3:eEyv§.§:§% :2' wcggfa' prafiasce , '§~:3Qm5!§é§' V-:('.,Z:1i;" §'c3T'.é'f2f'.3"Uf'€}'z' V%*£eS':}iZ"$, .§£ci;'sn §§-«,<*-is :'5 Ta' .i}€*?'i--€%Zé?7fi:f§§ 3:" :3 Eaéefided {fa ,ar§;v:'afé:" i:'z'e:§:2_§"§:»5€:5éV""ifé' promafe &;<;3£~.:f£f$*;, igvfie-{$532/le*"~55,fv":éa wcemgi ;9:'0f:'§5 ,?<gfa2f§bfé""::;s'V-$:<;i;é;<'§é'.'v---._ .5"n" ihe C358 32*' camémea' fsassgaesg' é:;§@§s€e, having §XQ€3f°§ V _§£i§S§'§'€:?:3;é_§ §!?VQ1'-d£3:f'f'Eé$'§f€ bzsgifiegsf {fie ségfgfatgxrs i'=:"'E'?__:§E'::f.:1,"?§'f@8 §"s:.3*v..§.'.I;§'?.«'='€ 5 firmufs is agcerégiré 3&5 ;3;2:=-.§;'§.§f"'*f;";%:3? exmri §;;s,::1r:$3s by 3§§§F§"f£.',"'*§"E§}"§§ :*;%sfv--.§f:@:§§.§';"a§$3 52? SE28 éasgmegg es: 552$ fiaség as? V z:'a;rs?§"§is;»%5, .£§p@r:?"§s'§men€ Q? ;::;v.::>2'If£"5 $5'; 5&9 ..%;eé3§§§ 9:' éazrsgmxgr wag accggéas' 53 3 me§i3§Q' sf " &§*é"§ixi;?§ £5 axgari gmféézzsg 3:2 z'f3<«:=; erase af f§§{f§."§{}:'? §é:?i-§f~§£", {fie §}'%';':}é'}i"§ gmsféé' 51$ {"5} ba €§§f"iZf€§ fmm 5325 may &;;§:}*:e§.§ Efimme ca? 539 ' :'£TCiis*?T?;'2<€%{"?@::§'V""::;:%" E953; £"£:r;§{3z/Ker 5;':
«:":§;:~"§é_,§»sxf_e:*,' ' ' 52:: Ci;;::?$$ §XQG§"§" f::r;2@mz:
A' Aaféffarésfié, ' §afErs§§'§as? {sf 552$ farm 15:3; sis:-';_2§zx§:" 5:2 §§{:5£§:2 ; §3§€:3':~:$e, gvheraas is? Ssséim §§~»,%, 31% @;<,4:29r:' Qfefié is' 53 £35 fieréwfi fmm £1533 méai §:::$:':':3ss;: _ = ef Effie ufideriafzéngg bassinegg af 5:? uaéeréakifig, 5% may «5§§}::i:£'::?é H Evéz? fr; we C3S.§__ :::§*'f'k.
exgaré Qugirzess $530? fiamegsziic §a:.<5;';*?iz»:s:;;5§;", Es: aifzer warais, €X§?€}f'§f £'a;rrza>5sge;fl_Aa§??j;§ :"a:r;";ar2z€:', The @;<',9aré _t¢zrna:é.=*,@,=f".V_sxvQ:.;£§a:3fie as {1'Of??p3i?:3":'!'%i' gr gar: 2;}? 3 giérwméyéséarg .5523 é;ff'?5'§«;*';'* {§0!.?"§§G!"?@!'§?;° 5@mg the QQfi?.€Si{€ :;;;«;<:s:;:e;~gT ;;~: $2;"f2e:' wards, £3 @X;f@nf, éf._:e:>{§*@r§ iggrnoverf {flare yvaruid be 3 C§§i?"}§f}'?'éf}af5f}?'vx§?$b€?¥ea!? 3&6 s"E£,3!?"?€§"8E':€}§?: Q%5€???;é3'f?f?§£V7£§':5;'}VV?' 02' $576 fQ;~;;g§;jg:--._ ' _.;;iev§r _ j':;»Jf 5525 j ééffééféanafity, 5&8 un§e§£:a;é_§§'_;2g'".e*'i:.é':;;%}i:j,§ éfsa ;¢;'3é7 me sameg In c§'£*}*:Me r" "E5 ezgfiéféy mrnavgr is? She :21:-,s:?2=a:*3"a$r'3§""§;%s» ..£;c°s=.v5I<:*T.__7é;*vffz:;efi §z': gaffer exciyfiing £a;*i"a*§§'2* efxfi-'=;;§5:';es--,V."'éfE:fe same shcazfd aise be ; :@~><§;°iz,zai§e:5;;€.§;é 'cémginuéfng the gxgart €é£f$"§Gii$§' as a 55:8
--..a';:~é;"::}:f;:~§::§'a-zfar. ffw reasfaz? §2a?:?g figs 33:23! "§'"f'2€= z::3_;2*:;;*;'%§:'?e;§§A:: Q?' 5% exmrz' éagraawer in 5323 s*';.;§'?-;52r5£"$;" gag' mg $'er20;?"'s;':':a€§r cagwfsaf be "E"§§e:*ef@r§, §f.2@:;§!*2 ffierg 35 as _ :"Q:s*r'?§lé~':9 fa 3:3, §S~,%; éiéere 2'5 §?G€"§?é}"?§ 3:? 51% 533? $555303? 59 maafiaée 523$; whgi" 51$ §;<€§:;z2'@a frem i*f"z;;2 I mzmeraésr 5&3: 55 §}€,§:'}f"E" éagrnaver nevsrthefegs fsrm par: m' {fig s:2'ez";$;2i:§43!':ar:é;;};.if ' "f"f?Gz,;gh whgn 5 garfficsjzar §*€ O5A§ffi 5'5 r:.:;z"£§é=§j:i?:7é?$? éy the iegfgfaéazre arm' 3;'?
{G be atérfbufed is éfzrg 5ame;'§h}s_:é?§£s' é ;=f{f§::3;*3Q V meafiing 59 $6 a:*ir;?§a,:€'eQ_"":i*::_ 35,25}; :gv:,>r_Q";-i§ Er: grcanfarmiiy wiih She ;§fi%'r3fe,v§ 5;? :u,=!?§§:9f2 Es asseai §f'Vi€?€'f? zi7é: §~:ata'%é :§r'駧::§b:e$ a fbrsfiéézsfa aim' in $128 Sam' fo ;';§fi::f§; ':éxY,:7:g?:%2'-'f?_ ffizsfftmver' E3 dgflned, V a_e%§a*;z~'.__ whgffé '£"¢:';».«=5§:'§'-- .zjz:r}"§:';§3'xV£«;§r"" incfudes s,><pe.:>:£f.. }%*:':7earz;':7g giver;
Ea €!7:§e__a,;%«;f:7p@_3;?i.€a1r;§§§'i%e§f ":'.7}é' é'}';§éfegisi3:*a:r«se is it} £79' é'c;ri<:%};:}%i?:€a' ' :%§2?'§':if'§£:* ~ . §§:?a'a€?.§7€3?é§ing €525 megzxng if éfire? £0355'2f:,;.%;*;2§%;«'s%:f:fj;*-- when we foéaf éuzrrsaver Encisgdgzs e.:;%',§a}':i" :a;%'s*3;e'a2er, If whaf is exgfzsdea' §§?1C£'*:'?;?;3v£,§E"§!'?§§ 3!?-g é;<pQrf fasrzzfiver is i3'?€!u{;?€€f V *z»v,f3£:%a.§;;=*::r2?,r§g'"§Z* E319 faiaf ézgrrmwr, wsfies": the s--;>{;:;';§:'iiVv""§:«_gr;?Qver 51$ 5 {Z"Q!??§C§F?i3;'?€ 532' 25933.5 "V. §:,:;*%§';:%:fa:§;"""g:::§: 5;'? éaéergreiaiéarn wasgfa' ms; {fie §}',?§"€!'3€ 35$' :;%;3;:er;m'ss;§§ie. ff 52232;' were 5% §;2§@;"§§7:'o:: 3:' 5% 3§g§s*§3£"§ve AA ' "4.,.'ie§:'§i§§:,:re&, éfgsy wazsfé fzazré &r;<g;'a§5§3.r §'§"§§§'€f if §'5'}fi}«' 523% M36 $323385? 55 S}=:§§"§S§§}*' ggw/__.\ , ,,.,,......,..n;,.,¢,.-m»N=..(w,:/,w.z.r..zn:«r¢,w:»r»v-4*!'/>¢ R éégmégsed. "§"%2@ §u§i:':$ia:'zi:*aE Q§}&'SE§§f2 Q? Ea;-as fra:*:2&§F_.._§_n this aggaaé E5 arigwamé in jfavezgg' 9? the aggesage ggejé' --~;:3§'1;z.;*.$é':i<'2;45€ the r§\.r='e:'me*