Indian Kanoon - Search engine for Indian Law

Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai

Deepak Niranjan Nath Pandit vs M/O Finance on 5 November, 2019

am & 3 nt Bb Gi ~ i od . :

ta Fe ta a ad £2 @ Z j . es af tS ort m D o fb ao oUmelUM > rj ia G & bs it 44 é oS Os uy oof arf we $4 " OM 6h i t re 4 ed : Bog a moO 'a 3 . Mm 43 oy ved cm ° se wae Eo orf 6 4 . a Bo 6 a a 4 7 ka cad o edi Cr i 3 * 3 & yp rt GW b> Eis) LP oCe w rl #4 9 & & OG 1 foe set ies 43 ay ei o es « $4 a

- BE 8 y 38 Bo ld ~ i | og Ho Ei xs fone a aw ct g a mM OO a , URN OR ad Ee OG. g Bs 8 % os > a y SY nos rd eat & 3 wa ao a oe en & 3 S| 3 oO 8 Be a 68 f@ ggg ~ 4 He og s 89 Ue gu RU Ge & 8 HOS gl og fe de : 4 Sh gab 8 8 a & S| a ~ 9 i) ot a Z a 5 ts 1 . arf .

* i 3 w A o oy Res sot oy we ms e 3 Pd ets aid oo ig A m 7 " oO R 634 . & go fu a a Es rw Met % ' 8 ify * a ® a * . y 4 co ~ i 4 me ar gv - " q 25 v mH orf & $ 4 og . uz os 0 > 4 S¢c i. Fi ehh i wn ae e X M4 8 pr 5 C o ef, 4 : 5 ¢ oa wf ke 8 . ef fe zo ay ome . a 44 g » é % o a & eo Be j Qe 8 & iy "

* ee OS ED ied So OY ay GD q oy Pa ¥ d Eh Oe eR BE Ooef LF om ot Cb te i 2 ny g " 3 : ae UB Poo et "a 8 8 oe 2 e 6 8 . aS og 7 OTR ao a wet woe 4 " ws é & # 4 Ba 7" -- : ws feed a.

AA.

on oy Q a) ord at Sa Sing et od ny hy y Es 3 Wy ut co oS AS wD 3 nS BS re © w rf 4 a & & q i 2 ed PrP GC @ 4 Bo odo om ¢ 68 mm @ & & O ro 44 a es a sed re 6) ® ae) ts vi cf 3 el oan nt vet it > © Oo oe ce & eS be « Py on & oy oa ot ard a 43 4 Ww "rd . a a D wy $y wD 4 Pian i cA si} Ct 4.4 xt 3 iy Ls Oh, gt $4 * Oo Bley 8 om w " «4d G MM eo MM go 4 tt a AR Th el ae wh Mi © ord o> . ced . @ & 44 > 4 "A e @ e wy KG 4 4 ct go wy tt a . w 6 ' " ns te "

At gs vt SQ <i OY gy By Is Bd » B 2 'J @ mo Wook 3 , fi cS fa) ea Bn Os c oM OG 4 eet &4 ke aged . wn in as E 4 an 4 ge aot yD a is oe s a ' 6 a) ia B B4 : "4 sy me 2 Od ce 9 ® M ss " re) Ld rs ed % a wo 6 4 re eG "e 'ae 4 s , ~ 34 "ct i " i a an 4 "rt . we : = ! £3. g wh 44 g peed a a be "A Ry rd cd od O 4 a mg Of 9) Fr bs % go eS ws 3 : . 4 ce @ Big o ie be 6 w 3 srl e re o wt kh poh ry <4 ogg 18 e GS Aig 1 4 2 cs = a 14 3 1 Phy 4 3 G wed 4 @ wy , ws Fi oD ; cs) i) ' ae wh og 3 Beek gg a G whos gk tH og Go ec a ey ww ad mn "ot oO w OM . ae 2 ct & 13 5 es Q Q us 4 C AG ser} 43 03 a tee wD a a 3 m3 eG & ' «ed 43 a 2 a @ 3 ad 3 OB * a & Bo ge ep a Be 6 S BP % ames ho wy cn a C4 ge 6 G u he 4a yy ons my Ct " as O} eo ee Che 43 mam fe D bs 44 3 ia oy QB 7s wy "ad o cy oo art $24 oF rai a & WS Gg ed i 3 ws oe 8 wD Mes bie og 6 tt oO {3 wd ee D us 3 0 oy hee tte go Od ae 3 i the « a @ si wp « 4 wy mm 4 a Bey w AC ae aS oe 44 "a o i ze ved ) 43 Bag 8 i 8 fe gO ys rey ba, EE hy 2 ie ved hy + 3 A wt es q ae a +4 vr 4 nh A f Se gee * 4, Bol : ka "rt 3 a eo v oe A + cM yy bas B gy OS é 6s £2, " at on « ey 'BD ' 5 4 SS c es "4M 'rp oS ag 3 13. B #0 ege ae KS 43 gNf Pe) wh £3 g gt e oo a 3 oO + ah Es ng '3 . n D sie) nt et 5 v Be wt bE OO om Bard EE eed ee, a D $4 44 GS on 3 4 AG co OO Oo ® Bet mow & 3 @ n i ba Ae <4 S " Pe 4b o se: ce t eo GM UT oO et ae wb oO ot x Bb re are o a o Wht OG a GB tt Ob OO wn EE Ae KD oad ts a 3 ad * ~ : + a fe ; » i, 2 OM MO OM OO OD BU Em ty Bo Gio 4 i Re rte " Y H QD . Ey og i 4 q a a Pd ved co) a Ja @ as Sa 4 @ 4 3 wv SA ay a x x a my Hi OH oS +t 8 o "3 "<4 rd Oy co 'a @ ty rd hoo a} & Sve rs a 1G w go to @ es a 8 #4 3 Oo @ 2, 2 4S ng s : tf} 3 5 : a ea 44 m a) 4 i x3 "4 He Q & 3) ort aw ' ea $4 13 reat s es: 43 i 1G Bt] x & 5 44 Fas w 43 «3 ip 4 @ oO PO 4 % "3 C ey uy * a 3 a #4 set my a i $4 & se 4 : 4 i wm oO + : ay ut a a Sef et Oh £6 6 3B A&B @ | wo g Mo Com + 4 a3 % 3 & : Ho 8 yo HO o * 5 Bg ea MM "4 4 u wv eal ct yn oO a te ad by a $4 @ & ug cm PW 8 4 ao SO e @ «4 & H i ne ct cf mG & 3 r ot x wt rt Py 4a 4 4 wy wl & zi at . "44 ro bo od Mi a iQ u © 4a 1s " nh Oy 4 se ' w w ay i oh, 4 b < Oh a ay re Cs QB ha od ok = 2 ps at OO eB UO Oe im > @ 3 © CY 8 a '6 -¢ FY i v c ; , 6G Bo a gy Mo es 2 fy : a 3 © v8 dj ..8 4% #8 Bom & -- BB dj : Gooy BP "pt 3 oe} ub rt it 03 4 eo, G (G £3 ry . a3 o 4 wy j 4 ree a 3 - ; 0 td OG i 4 i G 8 ce fe 6 , 5 By og . 9 Ro © ° wo oO } ° a c 6 om : " 33 ie @ a Das « weed 4. 3 wy *e ca 3 Be * Me kd ee! 4 4 ct ig

3) O 3 Q, i. Ma a ~ 8 mS * "4 es x» A a rm . ft pe Does 4 5.8 6 8 & ir / oy Wy ay 4 'st "ay Ct Od Bo + wv Lt a 4 zi i oo

13) iD my 5 an % Bw om. in th oy C3 cs 4s G ; Go fy ° 4 3 ced + 3 9 "rd Ww) C4 a 5 a i mh rs] s : cs he Oy "rd o oO ch B ; wa ad ' z : f a I> 4 a % +4 [2 4M te Eg @ in rr wo . ft 3 ut vf 4 ' a a , ig 2 x wd et A ort } 2 ¥ or WS ag @ 84 i} ot <A " o | ag a "73 4 w 3 A at Slog a3 hy ® rt ia vet set . " in « oS rf ' ra a Me G & eG eS a4 y Tr cl mn ™ bd Gd « rm 3. BF w O O Bo Aye $2, og ON ~ we Bo mB se Re oa mF ' Be a ws mg ge | a) » & MO Goa OF wi & fm O 9 GS B | e fF Oo ® o 8 8 A £ PF w» 2B 2 @ 8 _ a © £3 3 UG 4 : es 3 & a a9 a te Fa : eG a 2 % RW 44 ot Oo A at i BR Ap ed i a - 3 Good ay aU 5 ¥ w os 44 5 : 5 o> o ' ra C . iS ee Gt @ A oe u a3 ca . iB - & H o ff 8 g 2 fo oa oe # OC Bom YY 8 Bf a os vet "A & % cd ae to 3 4 a ord Shed «3 a 6 A ' % fe 4 4 wre .. * ie oe » ~~ 4 pS ¥ a Bo, eo 8B a 2 2 og 6G UB OR Boo @ #& bi Eo 28 22 6 3 (2 4 Bg oe Gm RO OR 8 a ae "4 4 Bo © 3 o t mo ad 4 . tS * uo me BB ws $§ 6 8 8 BY Ord . #8 | oo 8 &g 6 ew PF 8 6 oO B O, Ot @ Boos Boos ty in ' i . "8 ; PB a BO 5B 3g 0 a 4 " Cy 4 ard $4 0 4 vr 3 ~ rs) =e 6 @ > ho G @ & # » B fg @ gg 8 8 o 8 ss § 8 oo 8 6 8 Sop FF moO anes 6 « fof iB wo ti 4 " " or 2 a a 4 3 gt 2 - j » i s Dp @ &§ @ > £ & *Y ge 2 & fe wed a FR 8 gw | ® BE @ @ G . 5 od © 5 fe ro

a) 3] @ oD u 3 4 ao ord © ig or Q g 3 j ot G oe ROS GB UF UB OG eon lume Be £ 2 2 & Mee 6m rd wed et e ra & fs 8 a oy is Oe oD Um a e vB vO ia he 4 Qo @ 34 a} 5 3 a4 ow rs 4 » "

Se x ~ e hs $3 2 rh Uk ; St fx} txt "

penadvnenananenag tne ts a aa i rg a CY i % ty £4 in Co uw us od icf "tS : Rd sh a4 "tt & cS a ed ' o 43 nor aS G a ced wy Soy ws 3 3 @ Sug 4 ont te e ga ny vel ba iy 4d Kor Ye a "4 a & Qo o se 3 ved & Oy o © i ah aa oH bb ord DO ved . i C xn 0g 3 Ss a a pe wD m a ay 0 HM Ch a 05] fa ve a 4 ord OQ 3 wt it 2 on a Ra 43 3 Ry 2, Pat 4 a # ro} ae es yo ty ae wy . 4 ; hy ih oO @ ee 4 ; @ yo} ; Cs ty 44

-) my tt one ved @ aed ~ EE 4 Cy 4 Aa Sy «© cH . a Gs os 4 4 "a Gd 4 tet 40 "3 a w . SA va 3s Shy a on Go D + ol i @ @ Bey Ww Sh wn "3 a "A ep a Oo ff, . Fe mo ee Be DR 2 o woo "<4 . sf Fa, ae 4 be it 6 OC. ct Wd 3 . v 'SF 4 x a ew @ GC 8 & OG wo 'Gg . my od ™ rE me ran) 6 54 gD ad wet Gi wo a gu ra if 4) J gi % "

By 3 i cs my oed a e 4 oO '4 me a oO a 4 in SS GO fe o 68 )6hU OD ord es 4 4 gg & o

4 @ g rot ug s $4 & ts As $4 @ Pa co 3 "yy St xh $23 "3 GO cae @ - es a ae aed iw 4 Wk ad , 43 eee go a , v4 o 3 o Aa wy a4 134 @ # $3 4 de fe Oo Ba Ps a Cc Oy, cs oo ay ot a ks Se, +4 03 . ed a bey hoa ' ree % "oy ~. . . CG " vt 3 ard qh 5 : a 2° 44 q Q ae Oo ty &% @G SS . 4 mus of QO wo w Mt gp » oo % Poa he Oo 5 me OW 4 Ff " - oy et a ~ ty = ogo} t 3 ay cea ved w Cn SY Ba m s - rm i ) > % mf ay) wi ad 43 ca eed ca 4 4 bee 6 Oo ye Bo fh a 1g Ba os G : i - a wed be ti bss 1 "e 43 gt '* "cy a es Aa * @ os 4 w in os M4 a a cg a8 wv ai 44 Ao 49 ty we 8 Be Go F Db 2 D & Og 6 a Cs G . x 4D ai a fa wy * 4 OG 3 Ca bs * " a od . & AA G a K3 4 4 , 3 oH a es ea mK a a et ea 4 tht 2B i ® ved oY bs 2 43 oS . 4 es "rf ag $4 & , \ o v4 13 5 rs i a ts i % G re - ad 43 4 4 Le 6 oO ; i Q 4 | i hs ed Ba H g " ss ny 13 r4 $3 a i bE Es & ke a Gort Bod 2 gD m8 44 i w ri rt sa G o ' Os « © ead sor fA gS a UM cs ro Ol lm GHB ~ it Ge & mw @G HB 2 eM Bt reat OD $4 D ha c "rd '4 : + 4 si 4 ed "3 i 5 gt % @ & 8 bp OF a a eo oP vw © @ 2B @ # pw "4 aq} oy ° 6 ee WG z 5 hg a 4 i ? ce s BS oO 4 rs o ht o es £3 gO o B A % a yh a "ej yd Sa @ - @ ha oO cg ry 's a O "4 e a or a3 org nod = - Cs ps wf o fea os R ce Bee Bog rho wr eh Qe "8 eo fn of ff @ ne th © ood ge DM Eng "ho pt gt G Go, fs os) ii Be ; ® ir Om hh G@ 2 CG es . O a4 6 as yo Oo @ 8 m go BS HF Bb Be wt wy od & @ Te 4 ee M «© " os ch © * eh ed eo & Oo mt * ot od fh 2 oe ke oh Sh RS " ay Oo rd @ 4 a rf mM by G A ad u 2 SG 3a Sh vel i b4 % "ed o 3 o red v 44 ~ 'a AS a # Q wo aan % a a nm 8 & 6 9 4 BoB om Of BH RB RH OH URL UD PLE:

a & 4 a o at G o rh 7 oh te wy w Mi oS @ wt be 4 1 a n 3 my , o we a2 Ky G B9 oD x } a e H+ "4 a rf G tr) 8 ae) a x4 a 'a rt i ot a £3 G 3 G 42 Bs GE 4 iG & £5 ae of a 4d Sn ¢ Q Q 5 e Bs Sk nm 2 i iB be wo 8 eh ® f ed $4 pet Fi Sa ay WG wD hd -; as uy 4 '3 a a 2 Do b 0 P -« po 2 £ & @ Ss wo SG Bo .~ 8 8 3 a a o vs t wa m3 Ls a Ct rhe a . Ky 33 a ts 7 a (3 ns ' ey 2 4 aa "4 44 En ond C2 / 2 ad me wy 3 g % wt 3 ° Gy o XS MM cs a, 4 . "pf s Dh ty aa sa w ty oO oy 4 $33 ty a * 2 re cy are$ O 4 ¥ @ oC . caf 4 : Te a rs ~ es 3 wad fs re] wo 2 tet "14 3 ; Fz 4 2B E G Pai % 4d @ 4 os r4 a a G od ef 4 $4 ge 4 5 oO rd oo § oo @ et 8 Ds a DH a ot OB ROD 4-4 $4 mn vt 5 7 * + " tin ord % Se w oe ~ OF vet oo hed e ra . " a a a 4 a # bed i Oo 5 us 3 Pp 3 oO Ge ded ® bet rot mm cs ard 3 G i. : 43 a ri ing % "rd 3 oy wD aa . fh, a & QB ? | 4 o3 tw 4 a o . a od G a wt > QO wed red 4 % a 1: ' g e F Sk Og 8 o b 2 # e & & q3 oad et wy Q tS hy OF Oy 4 @ ee v tr hy Bee wo & Os 6 8 oe 8 F @ e@ Boe 8 - 8 oe 8 8 SB vw a 8 bp GB 43 vet ot A + 7 "4 wr i? oe i un r a pa | ts '5 6 5 @ eS w '3 63 Rs i & @ $3 os 8 m 4 & G & © 4 , ha Sa i fy ms o " rood ° ¥ iG x mt w , $4 i 5 44 3 a 9) wt OF ~ i 4d ka « "

fe, , We i * 3 ' "4 w Med 5 c A ce oe hy o a} ao a4 bef * Bt YD iy 4A a - ws & Oo - 3 ME * a + ord r4 oa nm ru ® 35 S ao} ce ° cae vr 15 c & ; past Be & By 2 o 3 eb &t a * - in . a 4 6, cs a wd Buy S . ~} 923. o a - cet D if ~ fen Ch fo 6 8 & 43 Bo o@ ~ ag 8 mo BH Bg P 2 yg a 4 mo Cs} u3 4 ay ur Ah XS " i + rot cs ca et a c rs : a ts Y 43 cS bt G bo my co v 8 43 af 64 5 G ts fos oe & », Cm Bo De® SC @ BN GF 4 Y Bo, ooo 2 on & q - mt 5 : ; Rh, a 1 . ep Fe oe ORO i ge 5 aw Rm og "ed ry { : i oO 4 ~e4 0 wy + : n 4 4 wi we

8) veg & 34 @ weed in uy ha : wy wed 44 | @ @ Hoong Bs Go eh gt ~o 8 we Bo og rt BB ow MH a PE Be Be Boy eho 8 mm OB ( @G& & "2 SB oo ao 8 Sf G& 4s @ £3 a nt 4 a ee) be 4 e ; ct my ra _ Be oa] Aa ms 4 Se H et uo % oS <3 3 123 rf & ws 5 4 c ey ci Bo BS WO Dl st Go *% wu 2 Bo cs GC gt aq & iy rs) 44 C a G yd id @ ky 3 wy $4 5s oS Oo Dy & Ky ty4 el Uy es G4 a cs ~ es Sy oO vv vet t~ tr G} « Q at i a C nerd 44 rf fy Cy & 43 ay 3 , 4 td ci @ ee ww ei is a4 or @ wy x2 a iG ha Fe a ® e oO B A BG . a Q © 8 eo a a oO 2 pw @

3 td a 3 ' "el iJ @ 4 a 3 4 wo ted o 42 43 { a sr] ak ta zs od 43 . rs) 3 ar we i a - a bo ved 4 0 & 4 Pal @ ee a ir ved ay = C4 54 oS te ba a G 44 44 Oo a 3 i & oS 3 a) BE Be "ct uF wD " 3 43 £ ort Th «rt a en QO € is, 3 ee) © id . oy cs a {ort B "ch oi ot $4 G ce) bed Sh, Ma ee O 3 G e 7 tO tt o ® ty oth he eo ©. @ a we 4 0 rd i Q G g Ga 8 8 tS og £ xy. a $3 nt ae he ee 42 os O $4 (2 eh, a! eG ved st ae svt t 3 ha f2O18 62h! OA 43 chek CORCGEED o te ef Gt sod on} 3 ope ch a} 3 43 faa ed B uy oN S$} yet eG vom ot ty re RS 3 Peete al egeccdecceeneerebedtenttpnp ede nt ntia bined deicibetilie s $34 tw a .

Sthact 2B & 43 ord 5 f8 Nae ME t ea 5 eek « he ws fay U3 Gy ae cet 2019 Ee t f 627 ¥ 3 we.

OLA x we yer, are we 2s ce wy G4 < wy ee af EE KO mn aged be ge Es $4 a £5 4 and ther Year % again ~ Aa iQ he a 4d ord "v4 rf $4 2, 6 @ to) Pg Oo A on ey Fa "tS rd @ red & D al AS ° a oy xt rd "D (a7 inf Fy ue 44 .

tes ~ aor oe ce 8 wed apd red ea e vf ® 3 WE ro t "

m . 4 43 © * rt Os G vet y aie) Ja NS 4 ' nH SPEEA ALE LOL EE 49 "4 @ i o 4 a XS 43 * Oy Mumbai at OA. b27/2019 ® w eA x a [ wn ts u Ld a L> ord om ee Se we a 3 a E33) ds x hi ioe Os # @ & * a ° te fa M 6 44 oH ~ ce) "th xg er) $ ' CPx ' A cw 4 a «3 @ ~ fa wet ot 4 Go cd me jt 4 ony Es es re 43 "3 eo ct 4 a ws O o Gel wed ee a 43 a M . @ ™ Oy o Q 6 5 % «6 Ae ws g as ae . eh ; + ° cd werd we ths si iD ~ i} 7 £3 Be as @ fs ie ars a i 43 , n o o o i hg wf Ww a3 Bo ® fod a wo by, co peas sj rs) ed '% 6) 4 ty ee Md ® ri ae DS i Os , ee 4 oe a Go oS ne . « eed od A 4, s \ ri * oy "ri « 68 BR 8 Tada ee HSS 5 GF S oe a E Com eo 8 Be od e Hg 4 2 iA ' % -h oo . HY . . i . * 4 a oy as a 6 "7 ved i 7B v w os a ad £3 5 34 "3 he ca od = a mn 4 ry of es ®D j i 5 et o -" a4 im a ' a ig ce a Die So vd "- @ " Bs 4 ret ay eee Tt as ri Ms ot a ub beg CG 4s D 2 tH ry 3 G o a ~ oO @ & A a i oon a b t GS fo '2 1) GQ ic ved & * . gee Mg Boog 8 ef BS UuelUwlCU 1 toa, 8 3 im oy & B 8 oe a g Oe ce! ~ ode $4 A @ Pe a eC 7 t or 8 "4 a Le $3 as Ct ra er rn ey it 43 ved tS 4 gee a) me e @ 5 ms & wd rip) 'i vend <3 44 by a os 4 a wd @ fs 4) 3 i et "é 0 5 Me Oo nO 8g ne OD 3 OD o 1 @ @ o « "4 ay am e 4 @ . Q * soe $ a 4 . a i @ 4.3 "4 4 ws oe 4 4 te "we a 4 ef uy is veg it E Se 5 Seb A c @ wo G Go oa & & 4s . io 8 i , 4 44 * oe ict gs re Oy wed iy us a a vo Go at um x? od : £3 G 4 & ye 2 B Gu ff Sa a 2 » RG m & & ge 4 @ & arf a ¢ . a a Go ae ci ob i 4 43 e Ry sa 'z @ a be eed Q oy $24 33 ay at 4 i 'y ) 2 & 3 iw 3 aw » aed a @ ot fis] ved a3 $4 DB ty, ' t& ved @ Boe, o co wy + 44 od ved '; ty < ; a 4 = od 31 3 4 5 4 4 ee ro , % wm : mc i o xe "a 43 oO "oie © wo 3 rd 3 G ox 4 & 4 Go . m GO oh a ea w ao & cay Qo £4 a 8 $3 gh ed Fed ts 3 o 4 & 4 B 3 > 4 wl at * 3 M4 4 he * {3 Py ©} i ys : v 4 at * ae D ev 4 reed [e) a Oo a " Yes eS w . rt We ct ot cs 4a Co gerd ig $2 De 4 33 wea . bd > ze 'tt % sen ' ' r4 44 i Gy 4 oe 4 45 bi O ct a © "a 4 28 4 w ase ee # a 2 «3 gS 6 "4 = 4 ts "3 : OR ® Ea 4) a " 9 ™ ie) a 6 '1 @ ~ ® 0 oe ms 2 % 5 ts sal H are + rf as a rs Oe wn Z sf ed Oo ed 3 g 4 d & & & ® S Boo eo OG @ « £8 5 «eo» § & me oo ou on of , a mB a ee OQ ft Bd & "3 o oy am) es "3 3 hy OD, oh, i) BS orl 3 SX ved a 3 Ke x3 4 o 6 Ch, c @ 42 Y are rf oo a 3 4 3 sad nei th beg o Qo % M4 : oy c 44 a 3 Ww ord & Et Ch rf eS » @ 8. °& 3 © iG * 44 " wt iG hs hy 3 ry a a % $2, 8 oy 3 ; 4 : vet ) oy, g¢ g st ° go BD mE oy 239 3 2 8 3 6 BO oe, 7 ve 4 wy i im red 4 @ «a i a Q, 5 m b4 @) 4 rey i ond aged as Cs cot Ct = fz hy wh Mo By « be, eo Cz ie ' ard ao i * t a ns q ts a ot cS a " HA rf} ' wt oe ; @ ay ;

"ff be a i oh a $4 OMe ~4 ies Pa 8 B x es ' "Ce 4 oS 44 oO Ez a) a mn, B ae iO . reed rs rhea $i a 9 o En a go « ord wy . at zt to bg) 43 va _ peek SF ci 3 p uy we yp ay 1A 0% O @ £4 re oh fn 4 a a a Go is io a L mo Hog @ 2 ° mn g 8 Boop a G g v4 a te @ a O88 OU Be > yp 62 8 o @g oD ge 2 Gt * re rel co ord se wn ' 5. iA w My e wD Be aa 44 wD o * ood # 3 CE o i. av cs 4 a 5 cd a ce Oo re gg & & op © 2 mo » oH 8 OS ° ~ = rl Gg C3 42 ag ¢ 4 ie be rd ab Or eA ¢ 4 4 ey Oy Ma af 3 "

4d af F we yp ¢ w uh . et Y ua iy 4 We ved a © 4 % * 4 g ' 2 % gt 4 : "3 o sk teed by o & 8 me fC m «a "& - @ Gg 8 . pet we a o 4 4 Ae om a mS 4 G wy Gs A M o g a ms iB <a ey, CG y "cy 3 us Ss sn 5 4 3 5 . re) 4 40 rd Drs ot © Hs vt os a UH wi nt oO Ch Lond oO * eat a or a Q Os Os ge ee 43 ws be, zs wt 4 is oF = 6 4 wD 4 mH G i ig a " wed = red 4 a ord rt 3 oy es wn : w a ned in a & x gq OG & nm a | OR @ wo ID ' Mo i o x 5 CU a iG nd > "O 2 G s a wm FO oa Gg oA & Go e % . a 30% 4% eS -- a #8 g od eo a og BS > = Oo @ 8 v is } 3 ot ; SS B 6 ~ oO O a 4 ba Ss a a 4 Hel 42 #2 a 4 $a at mn ym & bt rd 62s ea cs) @ ca 3 ed "G @ +" a . Do ot a yO 4a o we ip % 5 Goo GB 3 mw Ol > oe) 6 OG ne! 5 ~ B 9 5 OH % g $4 Be j 4 4 ia ' 6) 0 mS © @ wi © nm og Cy, Oy O oS pu 2, G 4 a ard we ie a pee @ ao 45 So fs w , m® uo om. 4 oe in OO i nn pO oS t | (O o & @ Oo fF eS re @ Fr © 4 iB e 5 ®B a oO we HH 3 * 4 o . rt w a5 q oO M - i ny { , id "4 $4 re j ~o a3 a 0 sed wd j . @ ar $4 a3 we @ i sed 4 uw G ad 44 a $4 5 a '4 a 6 " oO 4 me A sy OU® Ne ft a 2 3 2 4 3 O, "tt Pog ne @ Gb od a 5 oe & s g ¢ i 2 © 3 5 i es 4) a | a aa oq ci oe 5 SX a we Be ' or . " by a rt 2 nD Gh ( xm ct ues 4 E83 al ie hs tet read 4 0 Ly @ £4 wh 4 . 4 5 44 3 © ved 5 Ea 4 ea ee a «a a4 bd weed $4 mH ged 5 8 & 6 mn = 2s 4 ow & oS oe g 8 8 8 Sf aoa . e by Fe Ud ari td w o oo , Oy & 3 " ay by @ i r4 o 4 ord a an ab &o G D oe OF 0 PS 5 4.5 q 3 D GB og 5 * uw 2 8 2 OD 6 6 $ a ag & » - * cod r o wt i ie 3 st ro ans wD ra ° +4 o os UR . m i Y as M6 eed es 3 n it wa GD ; ni o 7 es o y a ts eed g 5 e MoO @ 54 4 ; pS a ZI 6 we a Os a Ha 2 BP BS , da & Mi iv fe % eood "og 0 t eae or et - wt 4 - ~ chee i ' a bee yy ¢ 42692 ag 8 woo of 5 86 « & 8 Ob g pF Het pb = oe ry 3 44 ved Ds gy v 2 : o . ne; w ui wg o G oO ir a ord * XS G i Se fag a a * C {h od | wD 3 * tO 1 @ wooed 3 A 8 8 8 Bk a of 8 Mi 4 a 5 RES soengeeoense dy ALLE PONE CORE ETE eer 8 mH do oe F oe ef Bs @ pu a 7] : 1 f?3 = A wm oa SG B® i ® eS i i " oo wt ie £ py eo a fs & BR # 2 & «ft ht oy oy (e KS by wh % veo CB i S o ue ® oy Oo 7 3 4 ; Co "3 on co 4 9) ad @ Fae a BG "4 od im 4 o) f Ce 0 Fy a ua oy os 43 43 ad PS G 8 SG 4 ba q % ad 1% sh a: 3 o "6 © BD i " " od @ % uy © @ es Boal x uw Ae ¥ wy 3 oa ie 33 cd 4) a @ #4 +3 es, 3 ra Q eed ne 44 nS Baan ui OD ~ 4 rs B.S py 3 a3 Com °° ne nS Bg Ps Be e foo Boo § a Gf wS fy . wD a r ; ! £ ° + e ° 3 re) co 3 Cy oO Bg 4 A ; DS a 2 'bed red bt eS s fo Me aS eo © bes 4 Ad % 4 , " Q xs we a ire 23 5 4 rye on id a mj $2, ha 43 > a a4 ¢ ' "5 Ht & 33 % © te Ae tp oa 3 c} anf Co ! * es) ped DY "" wy 6 ao ha oi hy rt ba beg par) 43 teed re j ot et B : ka +e ref es 2 Cy "s oO rod w ray $2 ' cs . & geek is : S 2 "5 * bey x i i hs rat rd ved 4 v4 ce « rie] oF a, 4 he wa @ 40 sigs 3 4 & si & rl Foy G 4 by p hs P G Go 43 bn 3 oD 3 . be $22 of " s rs 43 b G @ a { , a Bom = & A py we BO OM Oo moO a cf gs vet 43 : vet vet 1d rd iS orf oy © if @ sea a ao ow oor pS yOOM eM pg eo 4 ch u Gg a + cf GS To . a3 a ye gS *" a oe oO 5 4 Ga BF a on Oe Oe 4g pp db oy P O 45 ; "

et Ct at 5g On ~ ox on rf ay He oC oo 44 ce fs to . o se] a ef & cs Co Oe & oe g @ », be a ot 2 Dox i ok co 4 é @ o cs ra tu tn mt ee ; O bf y a . ve Sa Q os es a i ¥ © te ri % © Ci 2 @ 4 s 4 4 a 4 te * a Ae "4 43 "3 * 5 ri SG Gy es 43 hs 3 . a et ai ty Oy, n OQ "A MM 44 Ord 3 a My Mid tes ao Q 4 "3 2 43 cs a © os Pg © 6 © a D, ty a ; oi ct ra 42 ay + ¥ % ; QO : oO 43 in $2 4 o gg " & GS gi x m8 & OG y eo & So wo 8, Food Si $3 My np '$ ° fc 4 cy ved "3 i a ¥ iD aS ve 4 2 43 or i 3 il a} Oy hom g oo 8 FB Ho og @ 6 § a @ 3 2a "

& & . . tard os fa OY a "4 5 Sa a "

13 oO ot wa iz mo rn ref in o Dy ' i i 4 $3 hs 03 : - ; a Dy ed ye we 6 "4 m §& 4 "e ' ; Bor og @ OM go" Ss 8 G ye 8 on % o 4S a BE 1 by Bom RB aq of & 5 @ eo 3 5g B68 Ze se BoB g © 3S gee eS 5 % i ; 4 ) i , mg: aH 4 . - a eC " OD oer 3 (Oo OG Ho oY vo & wt 5D Q @ 8 eo »5 F 8 8 & Bo BF A 8 a § 8 & i 68 Un SD a #8 a ee ac & v i 8 Sd ne % i a sae Bw esd 6 ft os ie Oo ww + ra hy " mo & Cd, , % ae OG a 6) _ co 5 03 {6 . . om 43 $4 mw Ho Ss - 6 § 8 8 SE wo 8 £3 ot 4 bs 6 oo ' 2, te & oy a c mn a ES 2 ng ms a co 09 , 2 od f @ 3 3 OS Gg @ ot go Bos | ® in oo bo ~ # be wy & i 0 O, cA By Lf "rd Pa me N w i w ef cy ' aM A $24 ot toe noe a 3 cf on M % Sow BS 8 BL OR oF 4 Rod OM oO @ oS fe oF gH oa 68 i oh a @ ps o iw Ak a w esd Be os Wee a 4 ga C a 1 ' G , xy ' + Le. £ > aS » 5 43 a ved a 4g 4 af a f @ "~ 4 a M4 3 wea 42 4 Lo 3 fe] £3 i> we @ a 4 a = Ef eo @ x "G4 & Db & DD mm wo f 4 i 3 & # be we @ a ab iy it ved " M a s ' a ms ey a 9 - ? MM be © a 43 Pe ® 4, 4 4 Sa iy ei w if.3 weet 42 iy " ip ao Gg ww GO » moos 6 Oo : j $4 yp Fe i + 433 Me a ty ' '3 S - } i } , wy a Ch: QD as « ~ w 5 3 ved "ery 4 a gy a , a D oe oe: § S&S . % a Qo ts

6 8 mq G GC B « a 080 U8 eo Pu Ye a: eon bt Kd 3 re ra a 4 my ba \ e iD sd @ me so é end O; a ( i fe 4 i Bt 43 3 4 we wo "t 4 @ 4 Ss a @ oun g hi 1 '£3 4 Wh : gc ® a » 8 @ eo ~ § B py S&S wf ma o , g e+ a 2 bes bp ms Q Hi 43 on Fe © & ; a Ae B (> = 5 # es - &§ ; 3 Ba . 44 Q @ * e se @ or ith im ti 2 fs 8 8 @ '3 5 ** s4 9 4 M / ci) 4 ty, ont 5 ra wn wy ce) ie is gt 1G ; S63 ay Say att @ qi ~~ »o ® Gg «a F Sk & me 4 N Zp On 8 fe " sf + B 8S v Woo Go s gloat ato 3 G 5 Og 43 dog dG * oe Set yy et "4 te] "4 0 w a ~ wD ty C ig Fa te a 4 "g 1S ved D i . 3) . & 8 85 w Qo room =| GO aa, a »

a) t « cs & 44 wy D mo RS . zg Go ws S 4 oF He » &§ GF D2 BD 0 ® 6 ame cs:

vel $3 eooD i - Oo os ch o - ai © 4 a © " « 5 | bo ot HO OBO OG '2 rs oe aK ep & oo 8 Com od OG GO a 2 BS mo , uy { '3 45 3 £ mo G8 8 2g © e ft dtp 6 fA a 3 t ' G nS "4 oy os Cog 4 3 wag be wd 4 Fi 4 fs ms ra a a, Oe og 4) ~ re) CO bo wo &§ G To hk 2 wm F 3 OM v t mo '2 So GD ao G 8 & e fg Oo ® "iG > 9 re a 3 mf ai GR Go fx oe OF os aw 2 6 @ Hi Go 9 -- » ¢« % 8 F 8 OB or Oe & ef @ wy ® mG w 2 ny 5 a a @ B a wt a 4 a ba "js Mw ref i 4a - ie 0 a "g ie B "s "| :

vs as aa , c 3 i 4 4d Bea ne m SE OS uy th te eS 3 oH o eo 33 Fi " ze ON ved ort oy 3 oa or Pr ff , ' rt 42 cG ved 4 ' an xy * & Sct ; i , rt Oo 3 Mb nh ; Q = rt & @ o si 43 @ Ly 3 o @ ob ot & £ O i ws nh iH Te e ao o€ 8@ a2 8 . § 8 8 2 S EF 3 4 4 o wD wn ret a ea el a tp a es cA Ss Rs "A % 43 sy * 2 a "4 " go oy-4 $2 4 3 eg vt R ot mM 6 fos 68 he OB on ® & a whee Mi * gy Ra w a 4 iv ad oh my "Ty 3S i a 4 8 = oy | ' od 423 ra) rs) by @ "a ; ; vd hed wert oo Sa 2 " us at oy cs 4.3 a oH eed mh Go ry wy < ' é r o G «8 ty ng et ss t inact gy it fore, oN Pan oe TS ke he + Jae @ 44 vf sed 43 a , iD State of Bihar & Ors.

VS.

& Ors.

Boge (Mrs.) oy OH ry aed net M 3.3 i Q nee AF A. 3 ¢ y a} ' ane h oF Gt " a AF eget rf es cs 2 vod red age ed od ed «i St m on} Aa Yt ory aed Nandlal daiswal VS.

PB.

State of M, cy i fA mH i 3 4S uw WO oy od uy g ape tod oped as wf ef aod ay ot © records ™ aS out made :

EManR $4 re hw 43 i of State Mustafa vs. Ghulam in and Ajit Kumax Jog wv Maharashtra x, et J hod fe te Od orgs Oil Corporation Indian ng

4 + 2h provid wy wy at 43 G 5 "

ma 3 i aS ved x3 1 vet ja et «a ou ved aed "<y &H t nieres tame 2 public i :

RY ahh Lbtee aL.

ro Na w es ord a y 123] a et ed "ed 3 "ct & ert toed fiat es g yRaM thas Conca the we "ot "rd > +4 as 3 Y vt "4 ha © ved + oS be, mt wt cs os} Rene ee RNA Amann nd ne ws ; om -

' A cf Be e 8 © 6 8 4 re i 43 eed a 4 ww O .

i co ceoe a ne oy 5.4 * wt 6 : og go Ff a eC ne nr : a 6 ® a m 1 oH a 1S m 4 ad oO 4 o 8 oO Mm A oS os o © oo et a » oe ¢ 2 a co a . " » a os th 4d ig nig 7 .) A G es wel ' ~ 6 8 B Bp 2 ih re mK a UU e eG ea ™ oop G§ Soe HOG me ~ eo" ai § oe oon 6 4 mo a fh ey a oO o gt ® a D wh oe) s » Z ; es © 4 rs) a5 ed Oo A 43 w "4 ee got OM oy G Bog wh GQ 3S Oo ew a 8) a es & cl Q 4 i ng 4 . a 9 5 mA 'i w Os xs Aa M . 43 Shy Shed i} res i 4 . 4 ee «f ® 2 4 . "i 6.4 - rt Gg 4 fy Y oO 5 BR G 6 dd BR Bo Ms 3 ed ci et ww ort 44 ve] nb 42 Aa of fn ond a - itd ' ot "f "yk ao oe o Pp 3 BF 43 5S & gw B® ~ £m & o 4 i 4 td . % ' 4 ee fy 4 OF 4 4 "sy a 4 +7 i oH & Od ae) a i wt inf 4 a oi ct OU ) "4 € : a i " i ' "Ss oh gy cs u 3 6 a ; q ' ® 3 cs Shey roan bey oO ' £3 t a wy i c bd 4 : a t c " , a 43 im wy U f a bed oO x oO a) 3 gi ay A £ Be & ved wn, xf ef vga, aA Pe ay 4 esd G Chy s tt te OF { ha i 13 ae Zi o 'a "cd we w et 43 s, 43 @ 4 rq a O ym mt 33 ra) 4 sed % c 7 e as @ f we - 4 re 3 Set 4 ; ys 4. "4 ' m ei eB ww . He Ck . % v 1 eA a oy a G mS w w 3 s Nog 8 eS o PP 8 8 1 mB . 8 en yO & @ 4 4 4 #4 NY wo ~ ys ' a > ht fea "Eg ved 4 , zi 13 £ @ 4 red bas, 4 os ng ts 4 ' oe 4 sed ny em tr 4 im wD KY 4 G 4 rend ri . 'Q hea $8 wD ts e c is tn 44 +t BD 42 apd « % ae Qa a us i a ~ 8 » - "rt 3 Me A 3 ! a 5 8 4 © op 2 1 oo og OR oe B goa 8 « BB og BOS a2 Gg $ "| BT 2 oO tat Oo ol a wee ge a > op 68 ee QO ws wy ® na tS 4 i 3 "Fy At Fr Cy '4 rca bi 4 Bo ob 2 Boom OD w © G & Som GS Gg oe 57 gd Be 2 og & ya 4s v ° av ch oF) G m4 43 B 2 @ ry © 5 & a + er x iS Aa . wy a a {3 ca a , a2 c es A i @ 3 ip " 4) ef o * 3 "3 $) a o @ Fa) kG @ i reef Be "4 aS «a rd $4 a rt w as . G e rf ' r a ct o "ng, : a is 43 a a @ $4 4 o i th 45 ip Gy " Et = # 4 13 uu 4 s o Ry a 4 m gy ey "rh ts 4 3 by Ms 4 w i b+ oO 4g ~ 2 a3 mn @ 2 @ Wo og om 8 B® #8 6 GS &§ eo mF ao 3S » 8 & a 4 ri GO a ay nn Oo Pp, "rf a rt i $ bi o a . ia 5 @ rs) 0 ds } "sg 8 4 G g 3. Oy % wn 4 a * A 4 oe " Y a § i" £24 sh . S "ts a 43 Oy ore Gt ; @ / i 4 3 { ind o os ord uy * ites £3 @ rs Oy a mt Ch rt vot " a ds a i & BO OB BG gf f ghd Pp ry ao 8 & 'oO oom 6 s § & Be wt 44 Fi wo ty "oo ce nS a x - o es 1g i a 4 4 uv 4 id x og a Q Wy a) & a a g , yd a o tng 'a ws ° f '4 i : a @ we $4 "A 4.4 : 4 wo 3 ts. - 3 GG } Q ; " 43 O A oe © wo a @ o © g @ a 4 $4 © rom G ' $4 ; y / S i S Cg r- 44 H & & a @ j $4 Ww ° Ch ve 43 ea 3 aged 43 het Ly " t » r ' bo "ef 4 raed gy ry a ¢ € 8 & vant Ae i 4 sa cs * j ;

= fs 3 i a 'i '4 ee us % w a3 ro a 8) a am 94 @ 9) w i) =o; $4 be ct x fart aD 7 5 6U6BlUSU G 6 em: Poort wh "ood UH eo 4 we Wd i - - 4 KS - fe a "a 4.3 ma a R i m hs a gC ord eat us a a) 0 G ai 4 £3 & o uy © © g A "rf =z aa a4 ns Soe ns 4 va o oe 4 ga "4 Ww i i ord a a {3 ». ni 'S << 2 & o 5 om SO ov Oo fy Bo me Det ok BD OU .

4 i g wp it 4 o Ot a } 4 3 My rt rot ea e o , by oO , A & a" ie b F 4» G 8 @m@ fw 7 od @ 2 ® x rd € sa ws & 9 Jf 4d ¢ @ 4 o ie 3 ? c < "t t 43 Qn ty ot oy ord es wo a & 4 ut ® "¢5 fa » ri a i c w i a 3 Bi wh re) a 3 um 4 wi te ~ os Ry 3 2 go 3 o by 4 ' C m om Gos 3 oot os v4 wo ved a ny fi "i 43 ry > is oe ; "4 Cs #3 oO ae oP Be ted oO cy ht go # e 2 ts ® 4 i e a me % 4 a bil age a - ren me vee xt boa { a eg Wg gs 3 can ht my o 4 n ' © « Q ed a Ds ved 13 fa w@ 3 ba ah « i} uy © i ua tit Ea ct 4 ¢ + 43 B c 15 ; QB Wd rs u @} Go Ci Oo a Q ca G as uA 43 a & od G et @ 24 S oy o . S4 M4 & om £4 SS bt ee et oo at nS 4 @ a a - 43 ' if a wy nt ry al ge Bg Las oB 3 5 >. Sh ae OQ 3 i $4 CG $4 i) rf 64 <4 a ® ad a oa od Go I o wg i a Hand # wt ao 7 g e wt ; rd G D "4 " ua + @ "ct 4 2) 4 Xe ct cy 3 S&S gs 4 OR . So o § ~ 5 68 RS o 5 oa ¢ 0 vf "35 ' o ri is ra % Oo 4 a ' w ® 33 is wo od * wo iG 0 ve cS 4 4 > 64 a od a 4 4 as Cha b> a ot ts ref w in ve +3 wm a 44 & wo s £2, 'a @ Py 3 we oa Aa . ui 4 e a B th «3 @ i "4d 2 Qo ze Ro aS a o #4 w) 5 bs 5 OU os cM cs) ra 3 @ i Ma ms a a B a oy a i ay 44 zi 6 . ¢ me a - 733 a é mo OC ty ft 0D « "74 be re sg 3 o wrt ts i ) CO $4 Dy Me a a $4 D ® ES 2 wt ap 44 a ord '3 - a a "ed fe <3 @ a : vet 3 f 43 : 4) 1 4 oy y i » 3 rd o tu Sas ons 3 it Aas ce MM rr} r3 - Fil & cs ort en 3s xi a a 3 2 em fa 2 4 @ & 8 @ § & G & BP OP 6 Fs oo Bog & . ge HM Gm & Og gb © RB D Jj a % * 4. crt 3 apd B® 3 & sl wi WD va ' 1 & . o = & " 4 ws « o ' o Sys 43 © @ i os Wi 2 @ pt tr A a : 4 a "Gg Wo ky @ , . | " 4 co za " a i £3 "a a * a '| vet it ea a ; ~ $4 = is) s hy o St x3 3 ve & 4 og > as) oe uel SOUR " }@ Bi 8 5 G8 o 8 & i . * ' . we } : : iy 4 ~ , ' a o « wd cs c 13 $4 & " i ie " th a vt rf Ci g Fy} ; $4 3 CD ' a bet eS a3 " fa 4

4) ® 3 " Q #3 a mM OS a 43 OU Gg tog a oo e ve "6S OU fs Uo @ an 3 0" G ou " « ® @ OB Hr & So» oa o 8 a '6 es i tet Ci $4 ; 1 3 Ww } ro 4 3 bed iy m4 ,_ Boo fi uo FC yo™ " OY ord x oS @ ook 2 : t Ei w oi : OQ @ * w S ay R bop € ad » oo 'hB Be ; § § 8 Se A A BF 8 8 po ow og ; og a a me . ! 4 ce red f ed Ut : . i" 'eo Co ved 4 , i , i rf a b x = od : & val iv B 2 Ba 4D 4 B® be a ty & & a sj Shed Ps . a ! : + 5 5. Gg $2 3 G3 UF on 44 a 034 433 13 "ry a3 Oo "3 a 3 o M4 - Ww :

a @ a a ne dng nae 5 SO a i wn = i & % } ;

o 3 ne het od a 3 red xed id im 4 .

Ct cd wed a 4 i Be @ a a iv 0

- ved ees - ¢ £ j -

® b. 4 he Uk SS SG + ost oD 4 «3 Om 0 4 ved % rt 5 5 & a ; ed Dp chet ook eed 4 xy Ge tht wt a3 é y rf dt mn ver} 5a "y ma 6 et ed TE" 4 eB B oy " 2 0 98 ge ; / © eG 49 ba £8 eee SS € & ia mr om ' my ay Bo 6 OF gee De n Oo 6 ba = , : os " ma is o ww. 6 oe Go ® Obs eo oe Od a 6 & a Sr > © a '4 Q od oO oO 8 wh wb eo oD x G Oo 6 ™ a wo oh ard at uy in & 1 Ow Sy ie nF ec gt 6 4 be ts ort ot od G4 Bo BP Be aa ae pang mF ve ho og ge © ss % "3 Ei wr} gg 5 O vk eo ted 2 ay cS wt mS oO BG va w fx aXs m o rf top oe a be rot o ay o a 3 " oy ae G ® 6 y 4 a au "i ed wo % we <4 Ya $4 2 SS <3 p 4. » oO 43 t $ Oy 3 i . ot ced = se xed a g BO ae se g Mo 4 i 8 $3 So %@ Gy os f 8 we oe 3 4 -" ' 4 .

5 od a we bee i ab th io vel @ u © B wi w ane AkGw® 8 Bon bp oy om i 5 6 2B Bs .

ay OS i oR ® mo fa re el ra O v4 is B an ts c rs a om ao BG Mont s o ened w ho Sad 2 % t. ye Sa git eg i. "ef & . 43 = o @ & @ Btn af fcc i Ag 8 © ~- £§ & A aS ML : t ro? g - on a] . : o on e ey t rd cs fe Ge a vt # 4 4 i b 4D re 3 i} mG ort a Q aD 0 2583 "Gee & em yg 8 & gs Bog oa EF o vy es ced 9 oh Bs Sh w w B Ks fe tt 4 ns is et pp Vo a ME hE = z 4 YB od ' {Gi ap ago Dy os ae a Og «a ww 4 w ct i wy £3 » g) } tO : as ; ' 4 vo ms oy Q ae yt wed * ag S o om : a oo we tl B " i" Oe Ge NS Go fe gf Sy» 8 2 ¢ sr t 6 "4. 6 E Be! a eG Rt A OF ao og po om a ia a) Bg fe A rh et . & 7 Go 9 my a 2 he Gs Oe eh Eg a 8 aU 4 e e Gant OO Eh am B a ed v GOR ct BG wd oh gh Seay 3 fg v o © vi wa i ad o a Rg. 23 a , ' ch 4 gh £4 Sf ot GY Le Se tg re 4 vi ct ve a Q ot & 'e) rt vged 43 44 43 aa) 1p g 4 OB 5S 4 uh art th om

- 5 £ 3 mA oe G3 oe 4 Gu we ss OE & od 5 £ ' ya arf ay ® sg ¢ i oe M ay XI ft te o £ 2 ma + an 33 w rs ed went : '. yy 43 " "

So of o a kg . GH et NS af ie 5 6 @ GS Hw 9 m @ & 4 o£ B @ Rm OG , a 8 GD SB go 2 PB mw a 6 os g f 8 4H 2 BD BR pe e4 % gre " & "x ' z et 45 ti ; z "A 3 £2 2S s © A o 2 8 @ 8 Be * 5 A w 6 8 B ES a om Gi ue vl Mt ed oe cb MT ' e 3 @ BOS by 4 54 <3 Q ba 4 a 4 3 OQ 4 Ps 4 o im g¢ G © go 2 Q ty * oo » : . @ (2s oH i o Go Eats a i wD _ re so oO 6 0 2 p @ o 8 8 , a 3 2 8G ord 5 g '3 Dp 3 = e Bo ced 4 4 or Oo a e + 4 raed " 3 GS . 3 . i * & i Hi et ee ee re 3) g ro BO Se 3 is oS on pad a Q wy ia rod , o 4 ord =f 2 , ia oO we "4 =~ o 4 ri @ os 3d Q 43 cs ia a . 43 Pa rd q} eas ot w i vp 8 B ww MN BB o So 2. @ % wp

- 44 * 5 orf a 4 - O QB vd Ut G og | OM m Bo 6 © GY wm | ar ' 4 Go @ 4 ao 2 «6 woo# > § « & a w Oo 9 8 2 & - 8 ap FO } bs 5 © ¢ Mg ved o9 §£ @ & moot @ oS ~ rs) mS O ® Oh @ c n Gr ag a & 44 3 = ty 0 el "~ G A a a <a R% mm rt To mo 6 © wy 4 3G aed Ww goood © oe a, gs @ 8 ef Se 3 8 po ig oO fy OO GS coo ns A im ord S aed Y r Foot a 073 es - cy hat y OF a CY rh } G MO 5 # & G@ ; & © & 28 © 38 J Se * Sg © 8 a a oc bt a m4 o © "A ° uwo6UCOB > eh 4 o yy - 3 oa 8 OF vy M4 "4 tS . , yf & Hr s a Aye ia * BP eo 4 & §$ & «- BS Oo wt ord gs "6 dw ° g 8 ¢ B , po ke Be eoow eB & go eee ee a © $4 ' A Te Os tp 4 ' et 5 ee 6 0 ° HO OB eg Be G9 - 5B Sf =e © Jo mm OR ars So ye BOR 8 Sy B48 oh @ 8 8 6 t 4 os d 2 § ww FB GR ay & So mw @ a ot Bg Pop & e » 8 &® &§ % BB o fg @ Be eB Som b we Gg eg a eo ® ns Sh a ¢ p 8 3 A oH o 8 fos "x 9 8 | ; ia x B ved 4/ : a re Sef - ay 3 ay w a fy a er re we 8 "3 6 ° % 2 4 & 4 an GC at ss uw ne EO v ? Boor 5 ce " o Sgt DN "om @ «@ & o « C ¢€ e ; & . o «ed a od £4 ; @ Ch ie - D ht $5 ay a 5 wo in 6 oe g@ oO B + & g wm & a ee nn yg whe oh a A ot o c fc oy ® @ Q 3 o : " th % eG "

. Hi 4 . * 4 Es! 3 ; py aang $4 $0 is 3 a o . vB a e seed 4 Pe 9 Or oO wc cn 5 3 |C® yo a ay BP et a of ek Sf Be we BB $a. BBG 8 8 Be BE ry ' i ot wget ' 4 7" . uo Dy 3 @ $3 9] Th as Fon' fe ti & wg i », 3 We ™ ' a eo o£ : * 2 3 : rH wy vet » & Soot a iS ba ioe a 3 a ny « io Hed sl .- E v wD wt 3 G 45 $4 a <3 Me O t aa ua "rd 4 a . } +4 oy wy 43 . 4 : m © An x ccd 38 OLA. 627509 Semesh Eumar Fiwerk (supra) helding that the o x 3 5 < haoame Faw se oe os a"

UTaGNS rear OFaEYs Vere Porc OSaSea on amy fLaccar ore eee be ved wei s 4 4 ay a, AN em be he i va Germane fo SUCH OYMSersS and tnerefore, attracted <4 ~ : * .

oe ws = toes "

BAe PORLACIAPLSe OF Mallee im LAW aS OSsaerveag &n "16. While striking dewn the order of transfer by invoking the erinciple of "Wednesbury Unrsasonablaness', Lt was directed :~ "35, AvTHs stage, His to be noted that the petitianer in spite of being transferred fram Bhopal to Almedabad has not gone and joined his place of posting Hl date and that there is an interim order of this Court preventing the respondents rom taking any disciplinary action agatnet the petitioner for not joining his place of posting at Ahmedabad. Under the circumstances while we quash the order of transfer of the petitioner from Bhopal to Ahmedabad we feel constrained to direst that the petitioner shall not be entitied to salary for the period commencing fifteen devs after the modified order of transfer to Ahmedabad fe. the order dated 28, 12.2005 nif the date he again jains duties at Bhopal."

OR 3 * ton omy te ho, 3 Ra. wan ay grt, ome ed 10, While reiterating pleadings, learned 3 Pas 3 he mati ker aro oRM Se woos A ot counsel for epplicant submitted that he had nct Filed any Apex Court in State Of Madhya Pradesh & Ors vs Shei §.8. yequLres

- >? . Qo wn reoresentations only where thie is & statutory am » ') cq ecg +. wa o ot a ory Lt i ' os Cs 44 4 esd a yt -- i Q By ee $4 3 uy 4 4 . a x * " i 3 6 M4 i G6 ts te i g Q a ui o ows w tet us pe 2 eT oP BE a Sf oe 8 8 UU i 4. = . hed 4, : a ¢ ; Be a 43 4 w Hes c ey o 4 43 ot Dy @ ih mt ra a "

A 4 3] 0 fe bd ont ws a Pa . the ts Me) Ly % whe tS o s a, © " : Bi 4 to 4S he 8 : fi ¢ w z 3 3 7) 7 ~ oe BY Q el abo | Oo 4 Bo fo 5 rr ne oD 33 hg 2 . a3 ws ty £5 fa " fh, %% rs! rs " s © 13 4 Ex @ " @ AS @ a es a oka Gh bs 43 @ red ' 4 veel v Fan D {5 i 4 Bi wet wy on ae $3 4 rd G B am , gS e 3 ao 43 i wy bg © a wt i wd Q 5 i ' ny : D ba ay sy ty eed bo et a ig G5 @ On a me "4 a cs w 4 < Ba aS 0 ad us oy wet Do 2s 4 2 a eh & og BOO 5 6 BO om GG en Be 8 6 PS UR OM p ag o ns ey a 4 ws t. 4 2 oy Oo ~ Hd

4 TOM i "oO eS c i ae ; hp i Db a @ ts Po #8 2 2 8 & 4 8 po op BS ® a gf PS "ug + % tO ; of 6U6lUlUw UB o 8 6 St "

~ ¢ © 2 & £ 6 7 op & HG om eo» 8 wt wh ge oo o 8 g @ 8 t B : > a | 2 eM OB "dh Goo 2 m 8 gg of O GG Sb Boe BG anes Ad Gi > ¢ Bee re "O i ne @ £ - eed w . os Boo Q 3 " G oo Bf B BB © x ; i v ' a3 o edi - ay be ad od bt & ip @ t S$ ey Q #4 rf 4 U a a o < oD ts % a as w a BS s A . ; ye 4 we 4 iy Aa A. mo 3) + of oan . * y 8s & fT 2 8 Soom 6 6B 8 & 2 2 mm g 6 es o ie) & io 3 a po 0D e es) & in ved 4 1 Pel " a ed tH ty "od 3 m 2 a a on o ce ~ j i i Fs] q "aS 43 $2 ¥ ke re . tb " 44 ' S Bd. t " 2 0 bes om i 3) ri oa 4. - 3 & hy ah i ord id z ae "rh G UW oY C3 "a a * % ved wy a oa 4 o 3 ioe eI if wi oh a) oD sed gy @ w €f, rf AS a 43 o a rial Shut Ais 4 we v2 bk Ess a 4 wr - my a ss) + a QD Sg rs) gt aod yet ho * Ae 4 oF ce Cr a bo f ® oa at uO ad & "ch . & fy aw i Sy oO a o art th Cd ard 4 ey 4g i a ord wh bas 4 gy Ms 7 ky 43 a wef SS GB " mS B i x i G 43 3 A "D «© oe % if % ot it me F&F Oo %& BS @ * BK Me Dy wo gp RD i ih o ve} 4 roy te aed ~ ow 3 MY G u . . t @ $4 ' a My ' r3 bey Qo AG wy apd \ taf hd wD wy wy ° 43 x df ti od " 4 a 9 ~ 22 ° - o BD ht iQ Fs Ss Q 4, eg @ gg OF 6 HO it mG G " ASD a) er vt fo " a QD in 2 a 43 a wet Gi oO 43 of s e ; @ Be ™ a : ed in nay is ~ fe Se a @ @ G €& % 2 2 yy | @ Bb Bod TB gt oP OG Cy Bed Us "y a oe ris $ 4 @ @ @ i is eZ «3 j o i a © ord 0D a tA eed a si Db . 4 + we B.4 uy {hy it phe © ay @o "4 ord ee ee ee O M & @ 8 8B wo" 6 28 8 gg @ Pe dd a ei Cr ® 2 2 OQ ® Goo @ ef oc ts 8 u " cd "d & a4 3 * M4 ia) os Dy st 4 3 a "3 oO fa rf $4 4 a A uy ot Pa . : fh My cs 2 6h ¥ 44 4 3 % - : - 5 S an ot 3 ci o @ € 5 a oe © 8 6 8 S&S a 8 & & # w@ a SB : beeen net npn nner ne nee EERIE EERE OPRC LEED ELTON DAE BOE Cohen eet 28 OLA. G27/2019 ee . . 3 = i: .

submissions at pare g OF his rejoinder sugplemented by details of the critical medical ot ee cw £4 ao : th . eondition of his wife and mother annexed with Ris : : a :

weetAtindar { Reaayw Be wath Bie 4 hg tm ¥ FETOLNder Af AMNENX Are! COLLY. SILLS Stating that : * oy Som re Soar PN Y Pe ned he 28 Presents mosted cone Central SBEACLSS on = , 4 ~ - <2 a 5 et - (Appeals) Lf OMesrqe Of RALGaAd, x WAS WLLLLng co . hee od ~ ' * _ mat mA ove . nt acum lainee Ya real me Gaa mo xKnowleade OF my COMPLAINTS. NE Yel ags ef MP in Ripudaman Singh Yadav vs The State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors. W.A. No. 1141/2019 dated O7 218 8 = as a La which states the fol a ~ % o e "a, For a public servant to strive towards excellence, it is of utmost importance that fiir and equitable opportunities are made available by the State. One of the menns te achieve this goal of providing equitable opportunities by the Stgte is to make available healthy and stress-free working environment a a public servant. A stress-free working envirorument is inter alla possible when the State, functioning as an. employer, while effecting transfers takes into account not only the administrative exigencies/public interest but also the gemulme personal orsbleme of the public servant lishie to be transferred. A halance has to be struck by the employer which is though dFeult but net impossible to achieve. Every government in it's capacity a8 ax employer ewes it te its employees. If this balance between the administrative exigency and personal inconvenience is kept in mind before every event of transfer, the cause of heart buming amongst public servants ander transfer would reduce to the minimum thereby cresting a healthy and congenial atmosphere between the anipiover and em ployees which in torn contributes greatly fo the over all deve eloporent of the particular institution and as well as the nation."

mn this context, he also submits for reference, 4 bork A = ay RolAwwere f we se aie fe _-- ot csooy of ths applicant's scapresentation dated Py E PODUEAY MOP AMD AAP AP ARPA DL ADIN Ce 14 000 Bids COLE ME ODDO A ADMD De pd Cbd DEDDEDEDLEP EEL OE TED eel en entice es eetelnede ig 627/204 OA A 2 ce Mei ti oy i 44 oo v GS se O th i a ky od ce) et. ' i = .

bee o wn 'eg En > ed od rv} GB a a iG 2 fs i O wD i 4 fi 3 ny 4 pt i o 4d o Ww 4 ' be am rei vit (i t tS ed B 3 $4 aed & i .

a et Da wd $4 rd Me 43 vad uf} st ra 4 that argues ad eed w gt pet $2 2 hed ay G orf 4 ek rhe a4 ey, G 13 w %, or ch 43 is 5S 4s G3 GS ct o o a 20 oad & n oh 3 srt "rd Le, in to as o & ect MM 44 ths 2s Qs 1% a x A ot 4d + ns a ie "e hs ate Sea se 3 oy wrt Ba Be «a 'et Pe Oo fd os a ooo by he eo F © Gel ° w@ st Mo eg oaed <j a fe a3 3 : a *r3 a" {4 % * ae fi of a vd ont ae g 2 & aa 4 cS u 5 end . a " 44 rs) oD a} vot oy <4 "4 rp 4 LS insist He et um @ 4 ag Bs od cog rd a deg ol og whey w fo 0 i whey 44 3 F Cy 43 iss) sew Sew. oe Ce reyes Prov Se @ sf $4.4 "4 ty chs Uy Gi ard (54 @ a bes ord > CONS fuk ih M Q?

43

spel Non hea ha +.

es he fear, fh ver} 54 Rs wp nt wed Ese 3 wd Cy ort wef Act vert "pt as rl o orf 4.3 kt Bay «ea cram o 4 "a hf 3 $a i rs oO 4 O pl Go Janardhan £ India we in Union o woe Ra tn \ rad ere

-

a abe wee <7 ect (4) MH ag Keo?

"Ss rod oF ce bd gry

a) uy

4) ied ey

33) wet 4p id ANG ary uUNNEcess oged >t £4 a be Q <3 rt ard ts 3 43 om a o bef :

ord i. w, w g yD oe ~sd 44 y #2 a ih G re} ues a @ o S4 2g , uy w «rf od oe ch GO 4 3 ot a Me bg % a » & vy a ' 3 3 he 4 @ 8 9 M :

: a a} 4+ we "ct «a tes 4 o 4A y 2] 3 ba a MM ct M4 o Q ud Gt a of Oo @ wy od 4d 3 g? o G G e 43 cael sb a} bed 4 wy Hd we nd ba > a $2 6 A 1@ amploy bh e g ci Bs) B ee we Rama Rao vs Lokayukta & so held in ¢.8..

x a Court a 1996 SCALE ore.

4 42 m 3 44 ord ae $2 BS 4 44 @ ty hd O & 2 Qo 5 Q we 8 o Sy ae Se ty w g 43 Cs & 4 fo 8 a & ES eo oY as ei oS "4 o q} oh:

a Sed bee od Oo a OU a , o 3 a Se vged i a} PE be 6S bo oo < . CE e 'A aa ort x4 3 4B $.4 ea i] ved 3 = aS Oo 4s 4.4 4 yet 43 « w & 8 & 7 & 8 a Q a on a a wy Q 5 Ad 54 "3 3 ao £32) ' et ml 43 A Cc "

qa ort q 4d cee ee ee tg NE LEM MOOOL CA COON ROPE LDAL ID DED LFEEED ACO MEE EE Es -

TY 2 3 x 4 involve ike eament « A e on rs a ol * y 1 ed 4 3 od uy xy 23) o iy \ , a> ft or 5 i 5 : + a wu is os ; : 2 8 wd si) tn « CG sh $4 eo « ic md B a oS wy 4 Mi aH i 4) 44 ca od e 4 g $4 Ea he ty ty a "vd @ ©. a Oa xt 6 ca oe mo = & ° " a Ze a : fos a cH 3 gs to Bom rs) ae Q a oO -t wv « 43 % . ® i) C ip Ra ct "3 o i Gi ao 4a 4 4 x3 @ oe g yw , rs G "cd ord My en ty ad "red ro) tt 5 i Q eC K Cs 03 © ot i i 7; Gg a 4 he 6 4a A Pee aw ' G t ae $ of 3 Par z . hon, vA a o g et & u De ue vA 3 sn % a Q 4 e rf 4 M "Go o GS ve g ry © 0G "3 i : 43 43 % ibs @ G + Os Ms is y 63 nek ca g , be 3 no: Bo : ae 5 & Oy Oe et gy a aes Z 24 ot ve - t > . it. - 4 ea 5° & o 6 & 3S & Bog ® uO wo ge FO we a3 4 % Seg 3 et 3 2 © "4 -- "

B o 3 ce ie + n g a * 4d 44 3 *y rt uy Dw xt 9 $a ws @ ha Oo 8 1 e bes 2 BS . ae ny f, £5 > r4 03 Rul rd $. 4 sg 4 in tt a oe ia " 2 } 0 5 " > e i o = na fe B 4 Aa a Ba cy ved md 44 om ie t " . 4 "rt An cist aa ay ae 8 am we fe oo am | fe Bd oe G&G" A ; as $I hy + YY M9 a > B® » 8 Go g # Mg My on eh gs , A 2 6 tO wo 4 13 p Ss "3 4 @ n . by u an a a ff 4 wed @ G : el ba fos A Wd @ & % e a a * G BS ww 4d at Du ret i oO wy ee Bp wm HH og 4 RF Bow @ » § @&§ o@ © BB Be gy BO . & & SB BP yg # & FG " 3 9 @ 3 * gg wu io oO mM 3 we ae iw $4 & ts 5 @ SY by a eo re) My a3 $4 hy a Ee 2, 6 e Oy 4 af A 44 Cs aed mo ' 3 ay 8 fet % om * - 2 BS i gf 4 GS gy OS OQ fC wig» ke He Wa % ae fF o a oS Bg MM a 4 o ¢ ¢ uy v go th & n - ty ie - re g f od " uh aoa Oo ry fey 8 « G&G Rs a 4 Hrd BD wh 3 F @ & 8 4 , G g@ uw Gg 4s Ho OM oO OD BE $4 a "ed j ee en £5 {2 is i oa {beg A 3 3 e ® w 3 45 "ed o3 @ a o " i M ue "3 o 8 w 4 w BO eG 3 13 . Wi a : a i 4 an a wa . S 6 i " aS Cs & } a M4 % oe La by $ ; 4 i} 4 dat £ , 33 44 5 B ¥ a wo s . # at wD Mo @ a Al % . } os ' a £3 o % 62 3 ot v it O 3 bet os yw OU o 5 @ 4) oe 2 eo 8 8 Fo aw g g » Sg 5 B gy fed ws ee G uy as uo tn good 44 0 'G 3B ce) 4 # ad ' 6 4 "3 ky cs M4 i i #3 fi. od 0 " fog j 44 : i Bo & 8 6 oOo © t "4 ~ © o ~ 43 us St 4 oe a 5 re) 4 4 S ay @ % AG tb a) in ¢ at Re 33 A "ee w3 3 a is 3 os bos Ly Choe ed a cm us a3 a) oD oA v4 B 5 D 5 Wo» oh a wt io we eo rs Be red an! $4 y mm oF Be Go @ vet * 4 a4 f ey < ret $4 44 a $3 "e3 re rt 7 at . ed £4 e bn 8 vo € «» & 2 & @ B B&B 8 & ps eo OG BA Pe a Oo & Go : Bai 4 ro) wm oY tr a g reo a > CG bad bt ty uy 4 4 4 2 ved xb 43 a red $4 at <4 4 st bls «i ® me 1 6 © oo 6 DBD @ 8 8 G 8 OG DH 4 A Bo gd & 8S

- 4 crt wt wy @ % «£ od 3B os 4 w a x Fas C pone A 1 # Ui > Ae er j es @ AS a oD 6 $3 a % id 3 u & 3 % be Se sot Bs) "4 ") o us 4d o ff ks Be se 8 yh md 8 8 "- & HB EF ¢ CG a a 4a ce n "ts Oo 43 "3 = os 5 i" v1 uD re C wh WO 5 @ pa g Bb wo co "3 a 3 i & 3 a cr) oy wD QO or _ a oe a % Md aged tS ef 3 @ @ 4 a 6 cl 4 "tS G seg " ws "4 $f 43 ae bs ig? w 44 a 4 Y Hy, a od QD cd OG GS ¢ a a é; s Q & QB Lo OB cs oo £ ed a Ad es 43 $3 @ '3 1 "a ed D Os oy Sa ' "os = ya a e 3 wt ® ed ny a { + we ae a4 ad ao 8 Bay i fs mo a oO iy Qa "rd $4 4 ts M4 c Gy fd a oD a} a Qi 4 or C <3 ® as 4: a3 r Fe] hg "4 a Gs; ose 44 a OG mg S @ G P a @ 3b fF «@ G OO 46 & ae 4 ; 6 a Foe :

ce hos fh ct g we . eB as a 3 i ~ rn a rai oi nt Ml nt @ Ee Aa a "rl 5 rt is oo Gy é i 44 w @ Q> 5 e 3 2 5 3 ated Bed 3 t } 3 ¢ rego TH . Bo woo B® a om goog 8 * g 8 a Pom Db G ¢ € % oe 8 Dp ¢ 2, 3 om S 4s a A gt Phy $3 vet 3 4 o a O iy Pe) , 4 Q og a3 5 34 2B & 6 »~ ff B a a a Qu BG 9 B fF 4 weg te be mH of 'd ry a D " toe EM 0 G is & Ned

2. So 2 @ eo oy» 8 " «2 eo mm cd » os eo re pop 8 Bo ge ws Bt Ad - ef Hom Be os a 4 ad iB DB 6 o a CQ + cs) 4h '6 ws a a a gh Oh Mo go 8 od ee 3 ~ Be 25 3 cn '4 ab vel "3h . G ~ GQ <4 ° a} a ae e) @ a i "eh is 2s 43 qT. fe og te 4 % ad fe a 42 ub a 44 re aa af $4 4 > : ee / mt or rt " . . * ie) $4. Bo Og Do me Re ; eq 8 GP Ge 6 @ 2 Bed "4 o 4 : 4 at v4 ic) We eS ont xt he £4 c é s ' C 8) "3 A is Pe a Ca eh cob Mi eg SQ » GF cs o a a 3 % 4 3 "

4 e ; a OO" " 5 ort vo - 4 > "

oy we oe & 6 So ° oS @ 8 @ ¢ Bong 8 mn % , @ @ * as wa wef 8 QB 4 iy oO $4 i " 43 fe , tC 4 hey a isd $22 £ % 2 oY ved fhe te "ef 83 4 a ; Freed a 45 i a) 'i Q e «md § ve ' , CQ ; 4A iD es ° rn o @ 4 th wy Cy 4 i 43 ® g Ei v Ad ry 3 * ie - "2 - - o 4 y ; oe . - a ? ve a os a oO ov aed e 43 i" * ; aS a a ct a ed "s fa re mG MD 8 o GB 8 BH n «3o ob 2 8 88 By 6 Be go 8 Bow wm @ - 9 " g B 3 4 ag 0 as) 4 @ aod ca : - 44 g + wy o oS 4 fs a Het a v rs cy D at 4 MM a Yok he th 4 id o Sha a Ss ep OG OF 8 8 os "fe o «» 82 ££ & ° po 8 4 4d eo BS Rp - 60 Um aS we , as he Lc G 2 o fe ort ord Ct a Get 3 hd w @ Ha ea "Dp SS 5 h : « i "sd sa my wm ort a n esd 43 = Q Qi " ie GQ. Bes oD a © os ye 4 fo 4 @ 43 C x ed rd e boned Qo 4d eo8 $$ @ 8 8 Bo Bo 8 8 Be Bg S 6g fb BoP ie 8 ¢ 2g 2b 28 8 eee Be PE ee ew gE . 3 3 a Ld L ie mt HoH G & A ws wer "1 a '6 & OA. 627/201 a3 yor} ie.

"

w Gt 3 $2 2 Bed Boge Shilpi ot founeil of Indian Director General, Parveen vs. Forestry Research & Education 2 rd mst C4 4.3 a "4 ii Gobardhan Lal (2004) i Bose Shilp Ps a i 5 te g.

and &.

scc 402 8} 19 yh a peed

7) ard 4 eo $ Ad t.

a he $i 5 RE should S oy "< et B:

wy i we Qe vgeh Ned Cs q3 44 Pe he srt W i} D A must ¥ o iB Ki 44 5 " 4 -t iD wy GO @ "3 ws 4d 3 . j & " a 0 Gs - of te a 4 ny An G oD 44 $4 GC 44 det Ee wt s | z & a & 42 « o 2 a oa ow oh i @ uM gs es 6 Dm , mm 28 & << B a 8 g® 8 ».2 § » ~ 2 © 'gi GQ OU Bg of rf ° = tS of i 3 id sj ' % Oo gs 3 a te mn OB f ® & & a 8 § go ® bos & Gy " ct ma Fog ¢ os nm 8 ae fa e § § g # ra + uf 4 eo os 2 2 &é « & ge ® @ BS " we @ 8 5 8 & a who 4 o Boot mH ' eat Ee eg rd er es as 4 e a ra Ka 5 'a go tr 4 B 3S yooUnlUG 8 Hho Tom ™ 3 m os BR AO mt Bw 6

5 a ' . G a £4 "5 @ Dp Ps) i ref et o he fe rs v a ww U3, & a a o b by a ey i me 33 " 3 gy ot a 6 o $4 i 44 uO . 3 & 4 bs ° @ ' Q oO Q 'ei 4 NA ht seed * . @ * a 3 4 G § Ba ® 42 Q Per} ct {3 D Oo = Sa re 4 od « oO i v 4A a » " : mS u a Yo te ai o 4 @ cy g Q 44 rf 6 w Sa ea ef ui | ; me ' a4 3 4 ; o 4 A a e od p & 6 4 2 Df B & B% 6 ® e 4 7 OB at 4A vod Ess gy ~ "ed ard Ba a - 2 aS, oe ee g i 2 Ho U8 , 2 9 FF x mB ot By Gm BP eG Qo * ~ # ry th y do Oo G tn B 8 ow aan BR og Bw é og gg & Bo ow 8 o 8 9 8 § B bh % oR 6 om 8 8 om og 4 ® a a & ® 8 4 B @ pom S | ® ° 3 o 4 ee $. 3 "4 nd 6 a "ed ject nt we o 4 3 4s 2 D Q 5 a £4 rf © & 4 im LA Pf 4 « it it 6 a tt Cy re % By Os a Q a5 ed o 6 o ie th oC tet w os as Be 4 ' > & FF @ & o og? og +4 4 06C€<«de a Md .

" noo i Si g ® 4 6 «a Os « / a ay we $3 42 & 43 1% wn $

4 ed a 13 S > i as is I " 9 Q macs) 5 te ) $4 : ip 430 f aos D 43 ee ¢ oo - 5 3 ® s . i iS B 7 a it a4 hy @ oy Py yD 3 cre oe go eget wy td 44 Q G 3 wy wo Go vy oO ah 7g ak An » hy oy 4 weg e BR Fw og OG ce of MEF 43 a oo Oe r wh by i arf A re 4 CG 4 a . & Y "rf 4 3 ee w m3 c 3 G a 4 3 ' i het wi 28 o) hee 4 44 'oS ern 4 e ; ve 42 "a © 6 v y; ee ° 5 £ , i :

3 $e sed 45 we zs y. a MG a e mn 3 ® who ht (Ae 4 ae bd us oo 3 m6 pom «6 + 1 4 'a : # - / 5 es rs ; se Rs Oo + . & t Me d t ' a ® Hl « oad eg i poet 4 . 5 : mt SB og 3S #8 OQ, Get Me Soo 5 ro 6 Bod p ot Dd 5 © a Md & Ri ' n GS % we Oo ¢ 2 @ Oe nf oe re 206 2 ri Bow SG oH om @ mf B B & ee os 8 B Be SS © € F GB 2 SE x 1 rt 44 py Re bs] ry wD pe od 4 5 4 ie ® ko x ad £4 ne ei nq 4 6 aa ot 4d BD) & % ha Bs 2B eee eee e eee cing cnet eae RATER ERA RU ER EEOC TES ee eine oN S u "

em " : ve t it @ Sey 3 wn . 4 at 3 - aw a a ° @ 3 ng 43 x rs 2 as cf; 4 i. 3 gt 4 * Oy I red 43 4 6 » go 2 3 2 8 a & ed oz gy ah * BA 4 (s 3 7 a "5 S "oo . ne C cS 6 a i te * w uP % ae % rs ay cs $5 re ae " yy "4 ; a Cs 7 ct a "

bet oo at "ye Bd ss "4 a 1 } Qo 9) res ig oO, od a Zi a 3 t a3 ~ . @ 4p wth oe Cc Ww mis Es oo ti 4 re) Oy 5 Res " wkd - "cs 4 % he 1 ui re uy & 4 6% y 33 4 ri al 3 $j 1] ref a4 st BB a .4 * in cc Cy ah aa y eK : QD cee oO Go AG " we 1s ot "oS G A rs B a $2: he xo ¢ i 4 sf aed & O ; Goi @ , in 6 i " ed 43 * me 4 es) cs i" mn re 4 OU 4 , 8 y G CF eo "a 5 m4 "A 443 tes ne 3 # i oog g i 5 8 GC & a fe " = = ot) wy a G svt bed 3 4.3 ' 4b sg 33 a Gy a . o e 7 "3 y mB 4 i ts a mG 3 @ e rs o D Q fa She oe + G oe Ep) eG 4 a a : a a ce Ms B i @ ka as a4 Me - 0 wey 63 . sed & a "4 oS é 4 a BA go B Q 5 3 5 ; G4 s 3 I wa 43 i i e "¢ mi 4 "od wi $4 Hi Bs we v is ts uA B red G By ee ct Wg an 43 2 m a th o hm Oo H 8g Oo Boy # a a eM ey by "ed & C3 "4 ba ch $4 3 ) a ; % o B a ce g ft he 4 (U8 UM sve @ a og B * ew s, ay my 6m 4 p > So ayy a3 Ey i at ¢ i) 3 ot 4 vd Py +4 a2 © a" m 2 A o ® Ht gy) *s D eo » 3 oh a a af mB BR @ c MO <4 » @ o 3 ti} oO G a fA Oo oat * - --S o u @ @ wo } vt @ oe 8B OB GO ef gO a # MG oo 4a owe 2 4 a a @ . dg too y "

ane we 4 -- ® vt rp sy ke 3 a ny Qo "S oy C . rf m4 io ii & ha 44 we. o ar} tos Hay het 6 werd pee} ' ' AG ord to bed " &s ua 4 o . 4 43 % i 2D 2 $e Pe , C ny on "4 ! 44 oA wn the :

oO %i "¢ "A wt . at he i c w % nies 5 Uy i to 6 Mi 3 4 a 2 fA 7, oye 5 aa a $3 oY 44 Ch 3 w w ' 3 48 i xi # $a 3 od « o w ¢ a wd a $4 B ey a ved a, es 4 io od 2 8 6 G8 a ¢ o YD y a f pot ww n Fs 4 $4 a3 ; wy tn tn x 5 5 HOS ay i 5 @ mo & bod " 6 § os aa % oo weed 0D a ov 'g a os, el WS a vA a my wn 43 om os 43 oa 4 cs vee Cc 13 e "a w nA # a i 5 '5 em * a es a F 8 ' ia 4 a rs C wy 33 a ER 8 Oo So * oe 4 aaa 4 a Cf 4% t a 4 a} o df a3 4a GS ved «a et eS KG 7% 5 a i vs B 0 33 wa 5 Dy OD ws in OCU td "ed ® Pe | OS i Si ti 1 og

5 g i> QB 4 44 7s t 44 hy t3 s ee us 1 a "

go g 8 o & B 8 oD po £3 a og 4 ao 6 4 a oo a oD BOD it DF © s ah OS gS 44 & a Oy @ od 43 a 4) ae Q ' ci te '5 & ved 43 5 i) ky 4 ref ba ry w Sd rs 4 $4 o od 4 & 4.3 :

M4 Ba re ord o AQ & c aged G 'ef ° ad 6 oy ; " we i ve i . Hl by i _ & 3 r ch Aa . 5 $ g os » o 8 4 ad 6 ; 4 Bs in thd 6 OG ; ig "4 4 "4 A oC # @ f y Ci tr ast ® & . : . i ved + a " 2 8 OB a 0 Gog 4 » ' uo 4 DOU , G " G "

o " 2 bs % od wy "

v4 a Be o g @ 2 xy Bd G8 RP Ss 6 73 nm & G a # 8 8 @ ra 23 iward es Somesh T:

yiigk WLaH a Me ous camplain ym a anon the * w% v4 ip rs BX By AY nad te Sou Nandlal State of MP & Ors we.

tt YS £Ors.

et 6 & wy f a Py G3 mn Gard ords su 4 ze ye eit

-

Ne use of the ard he 44 re AA ay O legations ~ { x Such & "i whom <b "

ee have an ur ¥ = ma sant probe appli:

os '3 AE @ i oH av @ m4 ry ie) od a tees i eG ms me "<3 ws mf 4 rm) G Ut @G beg 4 ® S33, Oy $53 ho O @ $3 Fs $y whe a (3 oF f} D $4 Sa Qo S .

5

tS rok 6 Th .

Mh 3 a 4 geod * oh :

we 4 o & Maneenbenecemeeceradetedete ds ie:

hy ny wt cs 4 Ghulam Mustafa am rea aw th geod ws Fe wy 3 vet ey QA. GST2019 Parveen o cs ad oy ha vted @ 44 no OH fy th 0 Om 8 Ub ef ced Grd ch Ce. a 43 ip wef kt srt £38 Ea "rt.

gE 3 nu 4 4 Sil one me ord sh ord w wel . et ued ey 14, stnweentceael cette apetp tt ah tt theron tatty tats eis ty Board & Anr ves.

4

he Gujarat Electric n < a 43 "= ee x Court 2019 8 627 A 2 rs Q para Atmaram Sungomal FPoshani (1889) 2 SCC 602 at BoA Ch a hy goo we 4 a a Mg @ YS a uy ed th, Qo ved ba oo 4 a a z "4 G ¢ © ent * wy & COR ne x + Weak ms wats o ed. the .celk Aa va if bt he O "3 eed ct i $8 ry ety @ An 4s G o v ~ be oy i se] ed i @ coh EG be gy @ 44 ey Us & 1% £4 42

15. 2 3

to tt

-

rs « refe:

a4 Cou cned Lea € hed $4 5 Susheel Kumar 43 @ w 44 £3 D re w ved c3 ba A Le wef d 4 ms Jd:

te b4 3 4 mw id 4 4b ae a 4 «4 aw a 'e BS 53 ved u m3 2 wy a r J aa rh 3 ~% o on reed ord 44 C3 wet um uw "rj uy $4 & Ors 2011 scc Onkine Unien of India Singh we.

od para CAT 3742, a as pts » ana uthority a oa G3 y 3 1 é CS A. B27 627/20 wetotines.

eee epion ered eters ns % uy , ' x4 H % 2 © 4 on v3 a ah ed vf ka 3a wo vel ce ih 3 "

iH " se a : 3 ee v w sa g 3 $4 ous wd O a i tA Hi at c 4 Oo @ a a WS 4a a BD a AG 45 i 34 w% oe " "rf ba o uw 8 g 3 a , a 8 & Ho uo i) i fog Se ved OE Q "4 tn © a os < be 43 Q ry Cr + 4 % @ a Bees eg 3 oy Be 4 mo BS a ee ~ ft fe s Sa " \ oh tad en a G woos Bt be 3 Gi G e a " a of , "4 sok +4 f ri OE zr i 3 43 ty a Q 5 ip re ed on ESB a 3 4? @ ii 2 od oe 4 aa # oy eet G3 Q Py 4 " : oD 5 4 ; 6,8 bet 4 3 7 i. 8 i a3 fe 3 i "ts Fya KS 3 and 6 te Pa wy i) . was «2 a 3 Bg og a © a gy g 4 eh e 2 a athe) KG ord ot wb we a 44 + @ a ot Be 5 2 OF a" Bd Soom oS % es rhe » " a i 2 ei es @ 4 wt werd SS . ed a w% a Pe Re 3 43 au" os es 4 oS 3 © By oO yp ¢ i 3 sg wo ra Pies wy © cet a ao 4 Bet ot '4 3 a od aed is @ © 3 4g es 6 3 7 we Ct rat co be ved rm my my, gs 3] Y Es rn ae: @ Aa bag *s Si Bt " » Ff OC a) Ba a a Go % 4s 9 a 4 ® rt on ty P a a 3 Ps ; « I On gd i % 4 . tt € 3 :

5 a ' pa 2 e 4 bs uy 3 4B A ei & ¥ tA B ¢3 2 * foes er : co . 4 5 , i . 8 o BS , w eG oF! oO ob po 4 as Ho a § a a . Gog FR Do : O Oo UU oo od es td wd et a se} 2 ns "rj ie co vd ue + i GS Og © 4 rg in ra Bo " " g Re % Gog 8 8 «. ' - ah h 4 ' 24

- f 4 4 os G Oy a 4 ® i » aed a i a, 4 Q a Q 3 "5 iD ae a y " fs ty @ a we " 5 Os 43 wu re 1 g " a of ons w a , a iH a o 4 @ £3 } oj "" a sy 14 3 43 hd 4 3 "3 3 ved rd ty 8 4 a " Ke at G ° 3 md Be b S + o "ot ke . go ne:

o 43 ae Ae % of « BM 8 44 8 » & " i ' an B so = ce A vt eA GQ G « 3 3 Ad * 4 os ° ing 3 Q ied + tos fs AY ins hd oo g a a a g ¢ eo 4 is BO i a: om " . ne . $ oy rd ws o y 5 a a % eG a y & 2 i in i '. 6 2 8 ij veh "4 i * : sy cs 2 ved + - j gt + _ Bd e pe @ = D 53 Go f shoe a eg o 'ss ao a oo BoB @ 6 Qo oa § s See ag ef *® gs o § BS ° oe & @ 3 4a Do a oe a & 3 4 me 3 bo . O w @ G ed a GQ a 9 Bo 3 CoG 6 Soom on o 2 fou 6 . ¢ 6 8 2 BG 4 6G ao & o of CG 5 ws bet ie t 23 & Be fs i ved - ga ks 3 ; a Ss 4 q by 43 a ae 6 43 u © 4 o G oS 4 @ a 8 DB a 8 2 & Aa @ Ms 3 Ba Be) ma 42 shy p wy vet we a ay yd % oe 3 ® oO ' ; @ & O ua x & ' km ~ = cof RS KE OR 4 rr hy ay q@ a at a " cy ww @ ss vt a} $3 0 ea ' : Dy a rt ok a i i t rt o @ ogy reer eo So oy es a 4 & na ' . wed a @ Beet A At 0 a > po. & ™ i Hi ty w a OG wy Ad rd 'a cc "es 5 @ Le) @ ov c @ ss & ed ip a a 6 8 5 7 2 RB & a « $f B 4S % a Ho G £§ « 28 Sg es em 73 $4 a 6 : + " uy nS BM o @ og wg 5 ~ @ a G , ee 5 vt oH $B} | re a yp 8 "f, tA, @ Qs i a4 4 a i % ay $4 rn) ts 0 1S ~ sy . 0, +. x Oy # ¢ 4 ' ' 4 a Sg y € Be 6 E 9 8 © & g BP» FA gg a GQ qe wy @ 5 oY ba o oY $3 th "ch i 3 w Ci 4 GS oy $4 @ a %y "8 Boo = 8 e 8 8B fe ge P g & br bag o pg 2 gy % ew hg & a ; BB ng a 4 " rf 9g G By Mm wm Ho a Ooo BH GG ot ge 2h ay € E27 RB SRL ge yp Rw ge a ES x by } . k "4 * "4 ae ;

oy em * 9 HY @ cd a wo Oo Fm $35 Boys Cn a an o o a $ Gt ty vet Ee eh Q a ) orf ty a yt & G U5 > ct a oO q Se ' q? { j oY 4 G i o3 $d oO ee od * ot ee Ww a va wg ; hy a t Qo a 3h sod D kG q [on o # & ¢g ee Bi ; & & 4 tm OH ed og MOOT 7 Ul Ue eX GC @ 3 o % i ay fa @ ad v o os fe es te wo. mt & 6 B "A @ C Bai id oe 82 tn as, 4 4 6 3 0g & G at 4 Q is C £9 Pe 5 i a gf ao "3 L é vd 0 oY wo td o 5 it © Bog gg @ Bf SC = 6 a 6S 6 B® Sa : cA wD ng re) ZS Ee a a st te fd % ty oF ' 3 OD om som OY 4 5 UB we 4 ' oO @ & Bo a wo 4 Gy Bo a es Se ee by. Be ge S BSR Bye Be GREE ERO : wD at OQ @ ong ai ie) oO ' i i AS a ee 3s f a Q 4 w Ho Rood 4 ; « G4 yy @ OM 4 Se eto gi wd re Mt os 3 3 BS * 3 . oO ca) a \ tr ih 4 we g 8 oo '4 & a) oO 4 ~-- ' rt 4 a 4 $e M oy Bd ow GAS 5) G York aS How og OUR sf >» 2 ® & 82 8 B pw , , oe i oon ag Dy by cs ce Oot 28 ® % ag fe OO % @ 5 i es 3 a od G 3 : a " . aD e 6 : - 9 ri wy BE 0 »p » |. 8 ®B & Goa 22 ¢ "i ® bo 4 Gt Ya ot o Be A * fs ig oe ey " "4 ce 2 i 3 ad 2 @ "uy ~ BS A " a A 3 a o G Fy 44 tr i 2 a ie } Se > OU vt a 4 hy Add yd Dy a x oe} gy a G a 4 3 ped hey wm oy vB gy So @& oo & £ 2 5 & - & fF Oo i 3 SG 8 oy Ha bi ie Body GP & eH SU uP wm UG OS it @ a we " nt ocd ae o o @ wf rf MH v3 Q vA Mg ah uw "3 | gt =~ Gr ed ed GG , "A 42 wy i be a vet o A 'a e wG us Ed & 5 i r Ey S ee ag pp g © 8 »« &8 €© S&S & @€@ & moot! Ho oF & 3% & ee : rt ed is ws = 5) RP ' a a B it Aa § "4 0D w ei $2 33 Ona i 5 c ws a wy » @ ag va 5 ot 8 a a * O.A. G27/2019 uy 3.3 i] "> ed wy oyd ened ch ' ot and {supra} Nandlali t2 ot BE Abed yd a 44 a 2 wy eed & a "$b a re} & r Ke y 4s AD oe AES oo transp L7.

3

oe A} ot cs so , sed 4 nk we fon ay od 3 it) or § 43 43 3

33) red 4d 44

a) oy wy arf 43 fed ed 3 a cid aed oged a f2O48 } OLA! 627, in wo nn * 2 ' - a . .

8 bb ob 'D gm : :

"o § G HH 8 i ° OM YS 6U68lUlUUUe eR G 3 43d gs a ao % i a Bp md 6 M rf wy a w a v 3 3 os a me a + w oy "et a # ic Be a RE ord i g 2 43 ry . D>, iS ; ne i od rd a ¢ 5 gag pb w 9 © 8 & pO FS i 5 og G8 yO 2 9 9% "

6G % 4 BB BS oo o # , ES og BE goa eo * os ts ts o eh 3 ee Q id a -e4 £4, me me ued Mi i & rm) © ® a me ° 4 f SE asd * a & ad Ct % 12 LS r ad 4 Ls 4 4 | moO ' " + 42 a o % 8 g@ Bb 8 S 2 2 & Bo «» ag & eo o O 5 @ he @ Go oe ree OG ' 2 PB & 4 EE '5 we end a mi) 45 Me ct a mA Ch wm . 44 wD ; 4B oh, & 4 G Wow Ba 45 43 e 5 D4 " - s t 6g 3 a 43 a o 42 " + os het he o a ge BL 6 OURO Bo a 2 p> & 8 6 cag my wD 4 $4 & # AA the a 6 a vy o i "3 ey , i a a3 a BA Ba 3 : Ma 8 ag 3 : Sb ot 8 G 44 "ch fd a G if ce ie ~ 44 © 3 : y @ @ 1 i ci wy - eS _ % 3 a » " ; Q g a cs ihe 4 he "S i 2 Hed w eo A ~ Bo ee 23 bi ms a in a ° ae " c vet Go ha wy _ 4 ' eo @ a & & £3 6 My u & © "4 go so Os % i ne » ma ow FO a ns mG af : 4 i a , Or cs a ac! i £45 os " } 42 Cg 2 "e wyy a vee KS 5 > - Bo & BBs 8 Be gs a ° ob @ 8 a 8 2 8 3 8 ms 3 @ oo a 4 @ re i g : 9 3 «s Se 43 * -_ a a o s Oo GF os Sf 8G oe #2 we &@ Bg a YS © O a oO & Bp Bf mh orf @ : a # oe 4 o & Pm a i ed oO aw i y is fed oe 5 4 ' » ® ; a Oy ved as a i a in : 33 a n os o Sa a B SH a " 3 4 Wag @ Ap " » 9 os 4 ® 8 & 8B ps 4 pm & Pw ) & u Ho Gow OR we ° a gop o& 6 G mA gOS ; od " ry od a ref "3 on tH Fel vet a a a Q G ® ® a Ee he 73 god a ag fat q co apd 4 oo Ry v4 " rs ree g

a) QO wl © a Ma " Q ® Wa o . 1 o rd - 8 3 : "a i ' ig * ss + ay - i « a a a ri a 4 44 @ i) 5 m4 co wee} ec wf 4 y Ad

- qt roel i 1 vB we O 5 a 2 A e Gg £4 ¥ a ob 8 wy ce a Gy wt " 8 cy 4 2 a § By A, . es e oO 5 Go 2 it Oo oy 42 a «= oR Ou @ Do 8 BF SE a 0 8 POE 5 oa "7 me

3) Do 64 a nD a w Oo pf G5 i tg a 63 we u ma 4 § 4 me 4 a > ted CG o i © "ed "

fe Ch ce, SS a gow os i o © Q nm @ @ oe 4) ™ i om . BD 44 ba { 5 . 1p wy a th 5 it Hi e re 4 oy ta a de @ "§ ro » o 4 2 to « AR Ot 4 > 2 uy & is D a a ty ay) aH ' o ed wy ord @ 4 a 7 + "x gB "8 G G} fy wd 'a oD 3 $4 oi Gh © e at "Hs wh ra 3 os wy & e 3 G as a O 43 D a @ i a) i as & a @ o "§ uw * v # oD cd eed My 43 Pe i "i a a eg g Ch, rn . 4 am ay 7 CO 4} (2 fog Act $5 § € 2 § &8 8 8 8 8B BS o a § lad os weed st Lo % Pcs seein fe ledtete Deditetdmenwner ares stentenatnne ttt etante, :

a ay tet t ' & a & 5 ty a a4 ' wo 4 -£4 ' 7 . ny = * 8 oo 3 be 3 DP 6 a : :

o os * i - @ * & 4 3 " a 6 S oy at ve 4 wD x mm "3 "¢ af wy ord 43 good $4 "4 é 10 Sy oe * "i mB © Q cs ¥ ; a i 3 ia a a ' s ih ae A ~{ Oo FF a B ne rs at 5 ca sl & Ula OE wt | | ww 43 m 5 ; ; f wed apd ca eo rs ; 44 i ip ts bs oh £ tes - a a ee ay wy 3 , . re: ret a Sef ra Pa Wy xf us 43 3 a bd : a Ay ed "rf iS asa 4 4 wged Cy 43 od Cs Py oe fh xd go " &§ ap Mg a * ao ©& "A u go Bh BP oy @ @ ts "3 a ie we i sad set Ad Lt C 6 @ 4 3 ced sed a os "a "4 84 w 5 kA 4 m - * ses ow 4 z Bed oy p wD on © 2 OS @ wv é of a Oo i, Bret G G ay rp 2 UY 8) hf a cca dol ia) bd we ( 2 sf a $4 b4 im & w Ae] bt «9 6g G a bet a wn oD 2 ua 4 & S as iiss he x5 L i on a "ct ot Boe ici 0 ve by $4 om 0 & oa 1G ce id tt 4 3 Bg "4 ee a 3 3 ee 6 8 gw gm fb a Bp wD ot % 3G BO BS we 9 G§ Bo Oo MS a Beh eB . mY BB, og a 0 & ee pn. 2 eo % ae fh ig oe & Gg eh 2 a M xt o Yd s ' uy 35 D tM by 43 yd we 'cs ~ ° od - at ". 4 * s ° 4 ws tf we ao a @ 3 0 a 'cs 7 | 4 1 oe i mH 6 Q ha tt Gal 4 a a as he ves uy 5 4 vA wv Si 3 hy ee @ u 43 wv Fes o uy i od a ved Sy me &S A oe) iy a La Cy en 3 od i Pa 5 rf is] a sp got vec} rf wd m yO . f 5 Ck So mA nn ee if ad z Ay '1 $2. O y c 5 ec vat 43 @ @ 8 2 » 8 fm 8 x gs 8 a § & YY 2 ts on '4 ws ee A "S 4 3 os is 4 E co 3 Ch, i t vm ie) 'J au x B f a ; Bs G3 m 0 2 si '4 4 43 +. 1 nb a 4 q . : saad "a go = 4 gi seed a $4 rt a ® ft mM a h wo 'is o pod @ ral ts ot a be st BS 1 " ct ay ms fet SS peed "4 . a 3 ade a a oe at & i ; "eh 4S $4 3 , 4 a 3 " et B a "el 4 4) 4 ' t} + 44 a ay "

@ 5 ia eh ba a ' A i 3 43 £2 in " % & a & & i ora 6 syed $3 £4 at Ha & iS C 4 2 uo ' a ¥ th a ct "4 iS c -t Sef un rt s @ bef a Og 6 8 yp o 6 GO 8 Jw OG Le ' a o ay "eS arf A a ~ cg R sg Ly 3 69 4d th 5 ch 3 Mt vB a Sy @ g} uy ba a a at m ty "4 au Kp a Ks ua Ra mo e w 3 ) * § a gy PY 6 oo» oo § &- bs fa 4 fo rw ty by oS . a) OO 6 © if @ 7) 6 . . oH 4. 4 ord 4 ' "4 Gh ad a O o s4 "4 " ss @ 3 2 D 4 9 8 4 } BG o <4 Os ot a ; + ee £3 3 4s "et, ' ri Ri ¥ 43 it ee 'A Ser f "i 8 4 x - UO iy 0 > "y td % Oh SG at "ed UE ; u " @ % C C of a o ct 4 j ie 43 4 o3, 24 es 4 gt ea oS $2, gt 4 @ = 3 4 Ch xy ard ret a "O m on pha 6 a o aed fe 3 $4 it 3 ry Se ' a . , : tg tye Dp Ai Y ot 45 @ a 33 4 4 ~ @ 4 ' é as a on A 6 @ S a yo o 4 be 4 cy a be BY an ig i Bo EE oe 4 4 re wD ord "rd 3 o ee © 43 § "4 © a wp g ha ' A 4 Q re . xt oy t G i 4 ; x tw Bn . . A c st te © 2 KS . a cn ss thea . re 4s th et 4 44 53 *q 'oO & " ' ga a ord "t "<3 os wy C C W cea Oy cd 3 H Sy Ka 4 Aa aD ~ ~ 8 3 3 Beet Rg gH me SH 44 te $4 ; gw qi eed BP gs TO i y B ne er o B Q ~ rn My a) Fi g 4 a "oh QD - is es aa 2 oe g "3 po OG 8 OD a 8 » & 4 BB gy rn ao aS Shag qi 43 _ a eged uw go a a 4 rs ow v e) beg o a ga as) vy ot oO 2 DB ef ost gc @ & qs Sy 5 a tog Oo We oo ee a » YY @ 1S BF Ht wm Ud om og #8 B® es e a @ eo} tb baby od ert * ; -- cA S oa c ot n hd rt i Ve et a Need b o "% wD ' 3 } c . ks > $i Oo i rd aS A es - 5s eh Gg @ =~ y B Gk GW om My Poet a nh epg HoH GBH om 4 ° ard a) mf i a os a = red " "3 3 a as 4 4 ne) u mo 4 Shut "4 go 4 j ' 7 a a) w 4 ~ g3 oc Fa 33 «Eh 4 a @ Oo * ' te os * w i i a) in G Wo gry on Bo 4 Ed Oe y OR ~~ OS : rt FOG = ne 4 ae if a sot & 43 at da 4 a 2 co ; 3 8 'sf tha ns ood iG beet 7 % ree 7 < tr ct 5 "2 C eo Oo @ is © "Dp QD SA 3 ' os er Ae w ay 'y 7 : $2 £3 3 WB md bt ba ay 43 $4 $4 hed bs C4 2 o 4a itt € ed - , o Qe x 4h 4 ro-$ wee} Cy tb} =e @ 3 - @ % a 9 ra @ 5 ' a a i 3 G uy hey ® i» oe ed i ss hs "<4 'i vf a we * Q " " he : hs be i 4 us cy ! ; , <a 4 i bf m3 ea ha ed C i eS C © 83 B a A 3) @ a a B £4 Es «3 "sd @ a S$. ey ey 3 a s a i m ns x w Be ng u 2 SE gh gat a © FF ufo @ ow ae 3 go FO Bg G @ OG HB cB Se OB, i i ° & 4 tf ® 3 Be MH ns _ : £1 eo ° te ay o ed a Ae 5) yO "a & Bh is) ca a " ro) 5S s @ hey ve 42 4 he Seg a Bd e xo n a 2 cy > 7 a Ls 4 ' ao coi . vA - aed = te 4 . 43 + Soa Fg eb at gy FE, 2 & o 4 mM me OD . Oya cg nS @ " ao 8S 8 BF og . oO ew 4 hs ag Se "4 Gi wn ra ' be "¢3 eS) as ui io w co) > ti uy srk ar ed he on 4 a oa +3 ta ay ed wot a jt a ' £5 : ord rot OQ 0% 3 gS i as 44 ry as we iM tbe r ' if tt cp : : 3S y Oo S$ od ; oe oS 6 SG 4 es DOU 8 gy Ge 4 eH Ge G oO @ 6 ay ed . he . 3. ed ; . oped ~ : o Soom: BOE a Os OE Gr Woog G yo OG oo a Go Bs . 5 Y 5 veg : Bo PF mW K @ 4 t a eI a wt 3 tS G3 te ved oy 4. wy ; 3 a x Gb rt eed eet ws bp rh eed D Ow 2 i 4 wt 3 @ . o Z G Oo ad wed wp i" Gxt i wy <4 Gd ay ra ¥ v z Son n a i 3 4 wy i) uy "A 2 3, i ay CH eo & iy a) 2 4} $5 ®@ 4 ' ps ¥ bet ! ne * a ¢ ~ % ha ey ' aed ry a c a3 bar 4 a ved w < a3 qs xt hes dt aa is Oy o ied @ 4 4 7 . f ri Go a "hee hs es ® res "ed Qi -r4 b) % ba 43 Os as - , 1 GB fa ts i c ' 2 Meo WS {Fy OLA. 8272019 K . a pee As wt ms $i € My td "

. vt $4 5 g etn' Gh cha 42 od co t~ wd 43 oy vg $4 $4 i$, wet "ae Cd thd ork or} a Se ert 44 f he $3 tS Re ay we oe 18] oy weeny i ey OS Wor CSM wc re 3 vw ' tee RAR ND Ga % O.A. G2T/2019 rg md wo i hd 44 s mot Me ar wt Cl a no Lo Kad f- a i o Do od mA es oO z © ay wt Ry © Q 4 ee mt $4 . x3 Ch vod wed hd wy a + 4 B49 im m 2 he wb ee fet a us & * oO gp ~ ra Ad i & Y 4 At a ty at +3 ne a xb KS 4 mt 43.3 ha tt 3 wart ed bed oe wt a3 WB i 43 a re) ort ot of & St / i?

Cl ped «rd nt m od ory g -

OG x4 ba a B 6 ch AS uty e uw "ot ih ga td bf w qt ih kA 43 . rf thy

7. ded a A " Si Qt Ad ed wd a au Fe 43 58) cf ved 7 a4 se) . re "e3 at B 1B wy Ww et $24 &

22. Q red Aa Ad the La nal Sibu T ir as.

ocd 4s rd i ve} xo} 4 esd eoprding iB 52 Ww a cod en Aes Shed O tht AMTst aN Ses Mab ae AAD 4 Ne ne ae "et the a mf esed Oo 3 3 a iQ 0 aw w st ad sf c cy geod "cs 3 mr uj fed sre ord "3 be RR Rost id OY 3 ar os CG un xs 3 "

"

is » i ws 4d os . a it vers " i $4 -

6 3 4 C3 a3 bee rd Ci gab : od Ly 3 st C} By , a 4 o "

xe ot Het 6 s 4 £ a & ° un ved "4 no Og 6 a 4 <9 b3 ae 4 $4 4 wa oy "

iy Ly y wed wt G3 a . oe cs gs & vt @ 42 aw 64 a » & Wy 3 4s i uy o $f a4 a vert g ood Bt hh t2, 44 w Ds iB 3 is @ Os #3 * nf eS GE sy &3 's 2 3 ow DS ea G4 ren #55 ?

f FEES OP + 2 ho Reve three y i.3 Officers w wi " ¥ é af 2gion aR f é Shah ih, "

ite B ah Gy

43. ead < Ar OAMis car baad qed Cn CH 1h UES ths wef thd oy Pe Hy £3 i pd erted > Vv YON oe % ei » ELL x :

Sak lay AS a ae * gt hy ae ne) An BPA Bake TEE he y sof CLA, 627/2019 ay sy re who ad Udy oO oy vd rt o wed gi is vet G tp at Fay cia) "ri eA w Ad i Cc re Q o yD AY 964 8 w a G At asd <a rv # wy ved G 5 ps $4 i Q BAR by a RS 4 Ag ra * it) Sa 4

-) or 0 ® a £4 } a @ @ oH en Y ot ed we 3 % "

fea eo 8 O ne; a ae 43 <5 44 ) "ed Es gi pro 52 sed %) AG Ae x Say o #3 oo a a wee} ce tes G n m4 a 4 C ct reed

24. 4 wy sr sed $4 Ww Q oF or 44 3 ws + wi bey esd "fd 54 44 re Od ee} arty Sat ea way dt 3 mma dh

g) O tana eannaiinneninin, 0b tee ONE CCEE Enea eee Rae heen d eee OEE EE ees a on * e) 2 qe wy $3 3 oh i ' ; e = C : "A v4 3. no i 4.3 my ht M4 * ' es at y y 2 &S Me Ae a) 4 iS i 43 Pp i i Be) ovd rot 4 oh e Lo & 5 3 we Oo 5 a @ 2, a nb c 6 Gk gd i fos pr ; LJ gb tye. ' , " 1 . oe 4 ea @ w . we wy tS 6G "es nae a a) 4 $3 <ef 3S ba My hi wy i tt we at 43 42 & ha ve oy "| wn @ 5 2 Mo fy 5 wi "to PGR mH A OR Os ul Oe on : a wD a oe o° w ga yg uw © mo 2 i " vad % bs ei vB x ' ' vend e o a a hy ay a "4 i G " + ts 5 3 et bs ra ce rc ee w ie &, t ' . oe a é ne "

Ci 7 « bys "ed u Ma ty iy a a ' 43 oka 4 *

3 Med 4 ca Mt 4 a 6 t os Bo ig iB b $i D 5 og 8 a) e Bo oC e Tog si Os ong : LA ce Oo 4 a " S43 a ~ 4 2 0) 4 G BS esd & Ra ad 3 ad o gs - tH wy 4 , 4 4 a QV 0 oe wh eed yes Bo ge a 4 as + 44 a Ly ig af i wo oO oe 5 oe e a f : : & an i 4 : i m4 ": Bo F 'S Sto Og OS oy ocd aM « ; ¢ wa LB a ; et 4 hd 3 4 Ba ky nat : o ov o > ' t A £3 i oe ot ~ oD fee bs e 2 43 up _ wd wt ct op oO "a m3 od % G a 3 if Le fe 3 os 43 "e R 9 we he m4 " £3 ba F " © x4 '7 a 4 BS s " a % he oa - ag gE «3 y 4 a @ Boy RS or * 3 , x J Lb hs re is a ; a ' "

og, eo 8 ee ie be w "a OS t i C3 co OG 7 Ee 3 a 4 $i B a i : Pe c be) an a Oy G ra) 3 G Ay 3) as a pod -y4 bet 7 C35 a g) ne v4 , 4 4 a re a m% : ia) £ pk a i 4 a z 3 +3 wn Ae is 42 hi a 4 £ "f at 45 oI oe "

4 f #3 2) hg & ww CS ht co Eh 4 oxy '3 . ed D SS ad he a3 o 43 at xo @ C 4 ved 6 £ 4 us od 4B "} Vs ni 8 rs gb , & rd ' Ct 4 oD o 5 @ D : te ub sn is s by Ky o a th ws a + 4 on ns a a? '. Q CO Le te ri rd 4 ie ty bf 15 weg © We hed Oe] Ad , ; « 4 : Q t a & 4 ie '4 D ws @ Ft ms wb Gg Ls os & n " ~ w o « - oo hg gC fo @ vf G ' 8 oo BUM ge 2 8 m 4 2 So #4 ha bd od @ we * @ Pa v4 2 x 0 wed eg a " ry £ 4. : : : ag ny, 5 r - is si 2 oy - m$ a4 5 O ay ry a 5 os oO ft a 6 3 a a eS Bat 2 3 zm G4 ge OG < 5 Oy, € 3 G8 » § rt Ae & n Bose & FY ah oyy po" 'rt A. * 3 © ; w eee G a vet 3 a io "et 3 "ee ti aN 5 4 ad g a ' G : % % iy ; Ewes 4 a & fy ¥ 4 by ot 6 C a a : + % TH Se a Q @ "4 3 nd a a ved aH G Md i Qt ot $4 vf i ort y "43 Be * ed m3 au wy ved $4 < ce) % 44 ag Go 8 Oh, Pay e@ga & mS a hy ban g s on co & = ~y he = Eas wy ¥ x 2 $-§ mes a zs ord OQ a %, Qo -r 4 cs & i ise) i] o QQ &% fi, ia e ww rad = e a A a 2 ' 5 43 %, oF gi 43 wg Ho 2 g@ g@ 29 @ g he € § § & nn O % C qt 4 am @ & i G & a "a a 4 g ia oo Go eo Gf Pp Gg # 5 kk es bs t - oe & $2 Hp oss "4 uy ® - oO My a wD , a wt at As oD 15 os § A 0 "4 5 a ber Sh m4 wy oa G mn s vi US oe go Bg @ * 6 8B WB geo - 3 " Os u " Shek 5 4 be ea " 4 h Oo oe orf M4 a ug we es So ne a mE my Sy oo a OS Ot peck % rho ® Com 4 og nn o e ee Sad om eg gy wn oc eH @ oe OO . om % © Mm Mo gy 'SB > 9 G o nn ; t. ' 4 "¢ | 2 ' 4 r 2 Hog 9 8 & z BL 8 we *" fed 4 a orf ay - B re wv "es :

moog D 43 na 2 43 3 G 2 oO . 2 6 ° e 3 a 4 *% 0 a By Bove 0) * ard ey wef 43 ss DO Mel Oo 44 An 7S Ms . fs j 42 tg wD 4d 0 By "e a 3 ts 4 tn ~ a dS mee werd o QO rd + > - o ms ; w © tt orf La "iD C 43 a4 43 ad @ " 4 og '4 oo « Ga ord vt ® O LS eS . ve be G 3 Ci a $3 . ot os v4 a 3 cr 5 vd ; % ro oi 44 Mm & a 2 ay ~ ae) vee i CG 4 + w & Fst , Ct wi & " at a , G4 ; . 6 os a | -

oy Le Etsy Ww o rod rd th t3 we sot x ~

6. & wD DB Go oF oy " - tt be th ve " 44. a i 4 ty ¢ :

AG i io @ gy a hy w yay o o a Ly B a risf ¢ } ts @ BG a "4 oe ett a = . Oo 3 BOD ¥ 2 oo © »D 5 2 PP @ BO * se 2» F us UO w 4 1 ay: o > n 4 4 a i L G fa Q i 4 ke & fe u rey a ce) 2 3 os ie ts 5 ot wo vA ' ' , 4 " ro % o eS GB Hg Bt om 6 ~ Ge OH G i C ; "sy ved : 6 43 toy se 3 ned Gh Sony if G eo hy a Os e 9 ed eet 1 wg 4g EG oe 4 m4 ts eo cn. i Wo? o ei z ' y BB w & '4 fa 4 B 44 w ou a w Q uy ch wa " ip 3 G 5 ag ( b> 2 a * ts PO owt M bt y a8] ab ey Ds iy g 9 & ey 4 ig Cn eC a a © 3 bo « Q o a cd 3 ro wm '3 ' a 6 a Let 4 vert @ a a) 4 vel 'A rs 4.4 g ~ od ay OS ; ' wy 3 a @ 4 O ws 3 @ O aa} us @ n wi bo * BB " od i 4 vt | G ¢ a i aa { 4 4 rd tp. be x 5 ¥ 4 Ct '¢ a t ha 43 43 ad 6 og 4 re tH 4 i gs eo OG 6% UE Hg Be Gwe a % -

g raed A gre . '£ B "th $5 oO e g u 2 7 a a 6 : * e he red 2 qi h4 i P a 1 vl s ; wit i re a a ® M4 e a "« % CG Go Br ye 2 Oo. Sas oo gM ct SD TS Gert on BO ' ao onl OM ey S) rh a BE sed & § Oo od 6 a & a 2 tt wy @ veh w $4 4 is " gs a Be a @ A os a Bs A & Rat wD Med tA ® e s } " % ' 2 : : " Cs , %y CoM a a N ort 6 6 GO & 8 6 ww DB G WM Hw G O° Ss £ uns ignore O19 ¢ fe crim oie GLA. 6 @ by QB 45 ted sed M4 a SS ted 4 o 4 2 w amr ae A ww 3 3 us 3 ot og det G D @ Vets VASE e had he qt ht POUR nt od a* y ie a "3 oot 4 2 cz] 24 Dp , @ + d., ft 3 oA w G t : j a a 4 g Ae "rf 3 ved B D x 5 as o ™ a ty od . as . . La S i. 4 ot aS cy + oO ra3) 43 4 a ree "2 = 4-4 gc ra . *: hd ~ 4 ? a } ft a - 4 @ w , 8 & PF & a & 8&8 2 # 2 & B&B BB Sf Ss & eon = & Hom OB wo " ~ 6B 3 @ O Bo wp 7% af os wet w fe oc oe ved ced ys ~ ct Ws "hed c £ & XS " i a a 4 ft R mo gS #8 re A 8 Bb FB Go is oS oe NB oo 8 omy OO . 3 6 Bo rt Ba BS ™ ¢ AD _ seed isd 4 t + 3 a $4 ot * + 45 ct 3 = EA el mT rt Os Sot th FE a ow 6B Gf 8 5s on % ® nes 5, » " e @ od a cs oe i * Oy S ch BF % 4 hy ct wet 2 GS ov wn et 4 £3 thy or} GH © at Ky whee Pape sh Ct Es wend j ? w ei i 3A ot a « as - or oy & 4 - 5 wd $4 se] s (o '. © £2, os th ¢ , 8 a ae 5 8 bs a mgm & @ toe m 8 abe. * . " . ' 3 af , st A neal os tH re 2 @ e 8 cH we @ aw wu g $4 us *S i Q 4 ee eee en en oe 8 © S$ G. wn i 4 a 6 7 rs} A o> o : 4 uy ee . hed i we - D 4 4 w a G Q ° z ' L ° sa ' Ho Ks > Qs v C a RS 8 9 8 fo fs B 8. FB BaF g 9 g " @ § BB Qg * we ooo yO 0 POM & o U

- bf G AS rae) a 4 @ NM " ed wn nt wn W) @ oy "3 ft ceed ved @ % ran 32 5 bo el " cy wa Te a ry 3 a - G4 an

-t 3 8) e a e) Ss wt oS r ¢ ' 33 Ky 4 & x ° a o (i 3 a cs wet Sed bf a4 aE a 2 o CH ¥ cog Ra a tke o S te Ge « o || ¥ Goo ba @ B 74 6 @ G ett © OG 4 ol o @ cm Oo a ' 44 4 a B oO ot BB td * a 4a 64 orf oy @ . a boy yd 44 i é 3 ad a wd ee fe cs + Meo $4 us KG wy . ete n 5 e © : ' e a 4 wa me od a | 7 ie ed a 2. Bod B4 ay 5 Oy " ho tS Dp ow CO rh GS Sg & mw 8 YG 4 fee si 4 ae .. 5 a Qo B $3 wt » t 3 5 ot . w ry a « Qt S aa 3a 8 & ey 4 rog tf ho @ Mw 4 tH GO 8 ct 1G rea 43 W Fay hea $4 i F 5 wm aS. a sf a 33 A as et nn eS 2S DP og % oooUdeU SO wt 4 & 4 - G & (5 ° ref ws yt @ o "2 re - 54 Ri, a a a a ae Cry a oss rr uy ed ip * vot 05 on B a |. - rh 1 a tt a i? a ad e $4 rs v4 we ' & cy 3 Ch, Lg @ Y me sk OM GG wp» DB a tw : " sare my o 5 oy, cf be 5 4d 4a "rf us fs om fe x be 0] <4 w & Be by, C3 4 G end ved a 43 @ 4 a re 13 yD Bs oo apd ce ha we Ar O43 Grd th G by tp @ " & ° 2 rho gD , '4 Oo ns Bo ; 1° oo aS wn Pom 8 8 eg s a 9 % e +4 e * - a 3 fds 5 $3 os ~ Y « e " Ra 2D ® 2 @ @ ce ye e Bod ual -- foo $4 » 3 8 5 8 S # £4 % _ G oo u v3 ce # H £4 '. Soh Gi B ; oe et 4 6 $n ny ws ¥ i . cs8) cms Ei ix t a) £ i 6 tr , Br ore Eg » OO fe pp 8 -- & 6 a Bo 6 4 4a «i 6 } a G 4 oy y 0D Fie) a3 iy i 4 za a 9 Ba vt Qo ed o ee ee D , 2» #8 ho Hf GR & of DB "4 Bw eo & 2d * #8 sg ym 8 rhe 4 3, : che z x ie ~ at oe os r oo Q w MM 44 f. 2 oe re & ae Q, CG G e ae a fe 4 ist ve 43 s we GS ra" bi te ® Oy & a a4 : = ¢ fat at di Ms o se 5 gS ms 8 ved ss eA om aed cotnenae teen & '3 wy at ot eeeremenienenes ree) A Bn GS a wt reetntaninincn *h, a ro oie 7 O wef wn a we Go 5 a & & a a @ 3b Fs v3 pa " an & t 4 ; 7 & o a D 43 4 5 hg a 5 g . 4 % O w ny " ' g cs t eed el ra Lx fot % vt - ues % rei q 4 Oo " o in 4 ae) i be a wre f2 oe a 4 OG "5 -, 6 3 QO cs "3 My . 6 " 5 we 5 4 2 be re cs 3 3 c ' 4 o a 3 6 LY ved agg "4 / 4 co 4 2 3B Hl « wy " , at B be OU + Gj @ u O i ee ; CO wi f wt 4 t iy Qa isi ie b. # \ a @ Lg at ng ke wa 44 4 u $a te "¢ i k ; xt a ts ' i 8 ot ns Mo A G fM " 2 ; A 4rd f fag : 4 a ' a * wy 13 & a % e S u 4 a a oy £ Se os we i 4 . " a i a 3 - & : a 3 3 8 , ~ 4 % gon $4 ® si H mS O @ i a e # 4 ti e B in pa 2 og fF a 2 gf 4 OS moog 6 A gs mood 6S oe RB ® &3 oa i a © 's " moO gel B 4 a i Ki 3 i Os wy 8 6 a ri : u 83 « 4 ny g a OU B 4 4 oo: 8 @ oU Bo ys 1 OG 3 Be & wo z a 8 8 GF ane ub a a t. ao a8 a a "d re P a3 es i ier . 5 £ 1 ¢ os aS 3 cy > @ os ¢ "i 4 8 Ct wo G a ra 43 a Oh w a ei ot OR 5 - mond yoo 5 O vd Gwe 6 ge ce a * bs ) of a a i & B os ; w % G tii Md e 2 in a cal '3 i ca a 4s "$ ao +t oF ee » 9 2 a 2 0 GS Hop BES n o Bg 5 8 wo 3 Bg et Ht a) aos ia ae oO 5 ay i * wd Bg PF "rd re) GoM '4 rm jo ia - are . raed ' ae ' 5 %) } ~ 3 So we 4 we 2 4 i 3 4 Ref 4 $4 4 ce ere fom go oF a OF Goa ¢g o3 3 Gt ea Bo Ut a Oo P cd nr at 3 Pe ( - Bg e go oH & o ea i4 . $4 bef arf 4 t 4.2 4 yt igg a Cy @ . * wy ted a 4 y wu fa iS ty Pa 4 {5 iB nt CG 4 AG As Ly £3 , sod . m4 @ co cj wef ved fat ee 4 a w ae Pat ¢ j fe cd "

i ed oO 4 se a) © "3 > a in s I 44 i i) Q is & bt as aes $3 but ard qi ved "4 ua a C a n e nd a a sg + 3 "yD qs OB '4.4 w Ms a Co A id an? ete + on ns os ots 4 i gk G a got ° eo cs ut ms a} 3 fed GQ aa iB % "a eS cS vy 3 W o a ' , 4 ryt ea 3 £ ; z ro © v4 " o f ™ G 3 5 i. * iy be a iB Bg @ @ my CO tan ped oe O ws hf t a 3 "g rt a t i ° Mi ¥ oy 44 e rs a be) 3 i : by 3 ee CY it Q ug (0, 5 " uy 6 rt us ia gC oh s a4 : oy ved 43 " "ef 43 * a B a 4 4 Y "Sik iy o aU gs rf yo » bi ® im ONG @ w a di + a >» 2 o rc 8 oe oo "3 as a M4 é a . a : rs 2 £y, ba # wef 3 cy ni ta * bef hb ow i iD i a wy 4 aU eed @ "cd ot a sy ih ' bd bs ve wy 43 Es n a é cy q BOS if @ es 4 s ed " # ss f 4 ain 3 * 6 j ve ¢ { 42. hs as { as wD uy o "et x ye} . he 4 k hs £ fe n at x -r4 3 © rd D Mi 4 AY & "4 "4 M a vend vl « a ' 4 42 ( ed m4 D0 4 5 ° by. at nyed A ;

mo ooG) & a a yo OM cK 4 th HH Lt @ wed a oO or $4 bet oi 0 43 a @ ° a 7 eued C LS a 43 Dp i a xi "ad £ zg zg z g hy, wrt Ci "

3 $ Go od - y i 1 4 o I fe oe eo @ co o me 8 @ 4 wy w aa « 43 x 4 a "4 "~4 4 & MM ot g§ Boo 42 id : SE SO & o OQ WG ca wy yn & me 43 @ (3 7 es eo 7; 4 @ 1 Re a t-4 be Get 4 wn . vd led ord = a) @B O ed od "4 % vad 4 ox a - v t- ibs "ct a 3) i AG aed c 4 A : p hod 8S » « G SRR - Mo ® Oe y o » 4 be 3 5 9 & fo Fy 8 «a ws nt o dd on (9 MS y 64 ae 4 ; 0 i 3 * 44 vad ns yd ya ver woof tn ot yD z @ ; 4 645 Ae é 42 et wt . tA us 4: uy : wy Qs ort y Q & at at ay wy 4 i at «i U3 ve} i "4 1 " O 6 Pa 4 . wr "3 3 is 3 i . 8 & 1 GON oo, ° { 6 no 5 8 2 yO ie a a oo rf Egg i se <d & £§ 8 moo CBU yd RB $4 * sel 4a ts set re 4 za " i * Wb & $i A gt @ a0 m4 i ° Qo v cs ved . By wed * cs) ut e es 9 rend ty G wed w o % us #) - A C3 e a 3 4 rs 4 . ef Hg Sy ed o " ® ' Oo 5 pep we yg og BEG #} Y Ad et @ a we oy wm hb ny Oe By ~4 at i me Gg id # 6 a om) 0 vet ws * G oe B 5 @ 2 & n a "tS , 2 rea a oy Fees a im wed re ms ef 7 r~f +4 7 ky to vee" a os | a wy te a hy ; ty > it x eo eo ihe Bee m4 bea { cS oy 4 arf Lt $4 i he. wy Le i 3 whet at a" tr a 1% went ° a Co 9 Ts 4-4 4 nt 42 oe 2 ot ah i oO ® 4 i3 wt Pt ty wD 3 4a 5 3 a w Ks wn a ved ined G a aS » 4 @ " cs 10 i re) wD 43 th "5 oe hd bt ut wt 3: 4 a i 4 ct f : ~ "y 2 42 a wh w Dm - og a s) "4 "ey ba be ; 6 Bd ? o oo ay tod sh Q "ed oD B a rs) ; D sd a Gs y C i ha 4 e hs oa co od PA 4 $4 A £4 o y S G a 4s 43 43 G Bt ted e re ig 3 fa a eh fh + o bo a #8 3 OM yO a » # OE og Se a 4 'S , ref" @ % a} we 4 t be wt ore ca . t > 4 s ty ay a a a ne 6 2 = S$ ¢ 8 Ss yD S nn, hd * wer eed ok i G o 2 fu et 43 a et ct w 1 42 2 @ ~ rt ty B 8 gm dt Gg , Ss of 9 "2 B@ Go - ee a ' Ch vr " @ Oo i wD oh & ria ht ac = a © 0 uw 6 Qa wh vel & ay a "4 a a a a cn XS aot net a "eh Ad Og % A Bo 3 Tag ow 4 » aS wy " C8 6 & oy : z . ¢ 7 i ; 4 ve . > oy 3 & 4) ') 42 oe nM Q @ a o 0 OS a Gh B " Go fs "ed ia x 3 PB : Eo 4 ved * " bt : t, _ eh ped 4) : ord a G4 es fs @ i Q ft eg ® " + @ rt @ vet GB cS ed a a red ws rr ee o ww oj» fo « Go @ 4 a § B + Bd re bh vg mS hy 2 ri a ih o r3 aw bs . es O fg eo 33 3 D o G fs - a we ao % BO e iS a 4 ogg 6 Bo o <c 2 0 « ork ed oH O 5 w oO FY © 4 UM » G Bo gm ead we op 8 ® oe #3 sped o wt oO " " 4 ta ved rie ty ; ® e ce tr a nm Oo a * 4 bs os a Py od ' pe a ced a 4 a ord ' & ox bt uy " gH +t * Fray 5 m. " ts n eo x ~ " - iG eg hs = at uy 4 i e > cs oe 8 «oe § 38 3 ae 5 &§ gf & we @ ae , mm 4H 5 « :

ne fe ort ap --t ' "| By ' "8 +3 y rt ~ & ® om 44 @ Q tg @ ha tek mn a iB oa fa ie co oY ed 5 ad 'S oe a G @ oy Mh y fy Py AS a ' ed ah "a a a Hw #8 i a i a: G 3 3 G3 vert ng on B $a cg c By by ort C a 2 wy v ts " f " ca wo 3 . 3 4 od a 3 oe 44 yb $3 text a os o ra a : 43 G orf a mh $3) te Be 5 oA 3 $3 by % 43 aR Qe "

AIEEE POE ACRE PPP ta banned ER Om ms = . 627/2 A o ay 4 oo a ref we r4 sd r INS o> on {3 ced red et ef a3 ce em * a ii 25 oy ot Pe, x3 issued a = © .

at A * + tice to MIs tee > x a ribe ~~ tae des "ed cc bee oa ery hey GO @Q 42 4d ist cs I 6S 4 ba G ok aS rot om rg Sed Bo oe, ae Bo 4 B 2 eu 9 g@ @ go @€ Ge £€ $$ & 8B BH BF A Be 5S § fog 28 8 3 8 8 8B A 8 8 4 Ss ge 8 Re Ho GS B BS ES os a o oh " rm) 8 $3 ort o iL Pel 3 49 as G Fe o Poa Pm . wv St AB at tt ' Bo OG : fe . + . @ O & fed . co 5a) Dp on oO Oo 8g 3 G Ho Dad Ut ioe woo od 6B ® Oo. 6g 4 6) + 4 us i cS 4 gy ont a e ons Gy @ od By mo Si aS @ GC @ 4g, % be G6 oF 2 Yb a s @ CoG wy Os 3 , * oe iW . oo $2 aged & . ica ie 4 ee > 3 A we oj vot a ot 2 & 2 n tc i ow 7 & '¢ Ls "3 # Be vet 4 a a v3 Mel 64 © xy 1 3 y 0 ge n G " a a ay a sy mS 3 fed a ch $4 4 cm "4 ae ! ag "nt Oo Ue iD AD a 4 i *. "rd q v } + ney i 4 ec a 5 , B ve Qo o @ Dy ? a & 4 a in Bg G4 ° 43 ws "3 es rs 5-4 44 5 wea wn ou , r n Oo «4 od 4 ® 4 e 2 GC rp om Oe my MB OT Ke @ G si a ce uy: a - 4 ao g ov Oo "RG @ vt a a nee orf od et 7 3 i ey od XG "ct a ue $4 e HG a 8 rho Sy : i vy m O rt 8 8 gy ° & Jn cg ed ve 4 se) ms @ a 4 od ti wo = © 3 a C w on rs wet $i, . a ao wre} Gaal a s. ie wD ~ o es , a rvf ts Pont ch 4 'a 3 tng : ® i Gi EA 3 a) ord 43 weed os ea $4 read a 2 ad & a4 Gh os 2, 4 "4 ing C 43 G ° 6 °° by q ; ti eS 43 A f & £ tg 4 t * ha 44 s ( 3 a > O 3 > 4 > te G G 44 oot i ae O 4 43 o o & 74 : ub es oO + rea 93 cS wy 9 1 ged OG ret g} od a % " o ° Gh wD a hg ae Q " ne on ® & ad 4y o es rsa} " oa . Dy oes 4 Ci ' . w® » . i we oe ay uw & : ts 2 4 oO ae 42 . 2 oO } wert a y m4 4 ~ i a ub ris a ig wp a mo a ie; or 4 ot ot O. 2 og Boot Ge a e 8 @ 2 » to Bt sed cE 6 Oo A oom § 8 8 Fw 5 # BO A a op 8 & «a . Go pp @ aw OF sy R « a ae & ; co fh 44 4 Ct a ww Lf Bo O ie rf ¢ 4 ar oS wd ig ¥ mH wD ca i ri "e ad "ai vet @) : % <4 @ ha at a Hg C 3 Pa ta t fe og es a +s , @ fg " "t 4 0 o 4" o - 8 4 re a ne) x o ig G MS @ us Oo o 64 a » "a @ 3 a ' 6 oo" " Gd vel ee a o 44 & $3 Fo ord ye a 4 8 & e G Oy a . & Pb SE b {9 3 oD al 4a 4 he ay Gy a " oO i tS @ wo Qo Gy A 6 w wed mi 6 3 ; Gh gS % w 2 wo a e x oy ted o iy 2 " ua 4 3 8 cy CG ot a . 5 Md. : 42 ved h, © : 4 bn i Ay rd aaa eo aS oO aa OY ME wt 43 ut ' ot Le i 4 on Q as a Q wi a Oe e ea ed 4 a ® v a in a '3 a a ff foo o ' ce oo & iA vd ne) aS oe io é 4S a 4 43 w orf % 5 a c Q 4 we v4 i 3 #2 4) ea a} oe , 4-4 go ee ra "re i by ue ; vel wrt w <y a o set # ea B o a 8 u 4 os) ie) ad a i rt e Db eg OB ao 'O & 4 fork Bee a "a a ba a a ee gt fe if Gi + ze 3 ond 43 $3 Y oj : Gy F Bs a vee$ @ 43 iw ge & Q) rn A ved iy oS S 3 Q AG $a re G wo %: a '

- .. xR { : y 4 fy wn Ky C3 Oo a i ha A ponednenarnsaneesenecneatetensed cs nm ¢ ocd 3 m . , ms Z ® am ao 8 & woe OQ rf 4

-- r3 ha be AD e a m go 9 & 8 nA 4k 7 8 OR Bo 8 o + Om "q+ st ig Do SB oe BR 8 mw BY & 5 oa cy 3 4 x 4 . 4 ms wy i oy, ° eo ¢£ a Et ne) yw + gy «« ~ @ Os gt x ma a @} 5 ; 4 weg $4 '. ea Oe 44 U3 oy $4 BD ; ce a oe fey , gt 6 C3 Py oO | © a3 a «3 1g ci ; OQ fa a 4 Ire ey £ Gy e w arf fief o a a 3 43 rd & a oe ay a ao a t 7 * wee! 3 4. oh fre: oe a 4 co ey h ' 6 ® 'a if & ot io i ved o 4 e e ua 6 wt a ged a 6 " 43 a vow fb Go 6 GG B® 'é OS ooo oe ao OB D mn & 4 Ms oS £ «a 8 Q f o 8 Bi] 2 wb 3 ° "a4 ds C3 3 "s . #3, a aw 4 haa ; ? 4. 5 wn . & 45 7 4 e > o on pn» & © 8 5 e 8 & a mB Bg eA hy @ Qo. # ot cad © ' 3 2 res ty a tog ® reo Fa Se 5 B xy v " 5 od a 'es fe Qe veh 4 ref % het won "3 me $4 e a 4 e 6 8 oe ge mg o Oo rs a GQ & wD Gg £2 v 3 2 we "ug ed uy 3 43 : 4 ut ; ea obo & " : ba wo OW a o W wd ad bea fe 43 a ve 4 £3 fs ch t ~ ot tt 4d a a ad oes wt £2, G @ nD or <4 He 2 Pa Ei ip oe & 5 v 4 "4 & S$ Db mB gg et ne re BO rr oO ay ab Oo : i, oe ow @ : 4 e Be of a gf . 3 x o 4 my ih, fd : wed gh ed . 4 a te ¥ ' 0 3 3 Sow § GQ tH , gw ao A a & DG 4 a ee Woo 8 fog 8 e g 8 8 » OS eu rn G he Q Sa 4 <6) Ds a i 45 a uy ie Sa 4 We ri @ ip . " 4s es a a & en 43 # $4 a 4 a > o * 5 vet as ~ 22 2 We wy iy «es a a vee @ "4 wef Ss ted © a $f Gog oD o & | ty 4 A a wD yt ae ~ » 33 & a 2 B® om i @ oot + wy ao re) "A 4 43 wv "3 M4 on] w & 3 4 iy od 4 i # uw cs a) 2 » eR 8 oO fF & 5 4 mh ed GH gg hy hE va ' eg Bf e «2 © @ 6 Om % po oh, G eed # ar by . ao ® wes it nf 4' a oO . th 4 us ret C te xy < 24 2 ts oy ~ wa 3 wt w i w ' re - 3 Q a it a 3 Hi ay u 2 bs 7 3 i A SM ep § % Boa # @ & 5 SSE 3 '4 » 2 5G » 7 £& He a8 8 OR pO we , & mf mG

- 43 t ak @ G ant oS i $4 a ' , "4A t kt m aed o 44 week © iG un " ot i be 4 4 "4 cs) 43 oh ~ 8 if} mn Sef 3 x ord ws eS © Ee i $5 ty a th 5 a CQ o sed : 65 ed rf @ ard Pe 8) oa Pr) Qh i 2 0 wd PY KS e 'a a ct o fs g 6 S et ea ge i Q a) ow 0 rs) es mt Gj " OG f+ " / 43 0 ie ° " ti : . " n 4 :

a ort a Fs a a 3 a 4 a 5] Sh, 4 ee 4 G . rc) $3 ° cok A + Ww he B zr 5 WwW G s add - @ 6 & mM OG an) Om Fo gj . on F a GT fed t 3 sg . G 4 - g as . my mm bs «4 beg ce G Ct thy "ed ei @ re5 3 : Sy 4 a a 7 ret af Uw % 3 gh £ 4 5 8 e eg ea gees 8 ¢ B 4 zp aw ; p Ds i : A oS a @ LS vp : a a rf oe 4 i 42 i gs 9 a rm oo ts 5% G oes 3) aoe ; rs Q 4 ® Go 44 ws hy ' red i BE o x oF . 43 Sa * M i Py sod we J £3 a w a : a 4 4 Es wm gE s 2s 8 4 oO 4 OLA, 622019 ad o wo Ea 43 a @ ® id 0 u) oy m4 oS uw i 4 ts oO 3 ees a wy a we mt & ved mo a Y i} nS ved i AG rt % rf ss 44 G 4) £4 Qo Me £4 Le Ae wed 3 @ 3 ed g AS a) o a3 G ag G Be Cn fe 43 Bod 4 ws a a fs G 43 42 ws 0 o a wD ' 43 w @ a $4 wy as € a a) uM «A em e re x 43

43 He a ce uy & $4 B 42 a 44 wy wy S o a & in uy re icf ot uM a @ @ 6 2 sg MW GH ng e of a n>, cs a MO oO G6 @ GC wor G #8 YB Bw» ce | Mo Ew KS 4 4 ee * c fhe i) vet te vat ey gy 4d ort 43 bet oh Go end $3 5 S ns Ch ae i rs & 3 we $2 e i ® ef @ gt 4 ; on at wa 3 fa lu ed ue Z @ 4 , "ef aD G aa . w xc CC 4 "ee a GS s w wy B 2 an 8 a is a ' & ord ay aa ms AB w a Le TS reid rg ayy io iA 3 "rt 4 . wa " te bee! os @ "a ox re) "5 is wet a $4 a e ed ev Q 42 . & i by © ; Hog G& 6 © 2B Fe Am eG ay 3a 4 $ rs) co a B+ om gE oy + ci 42 a a ad 5 "A eH noo SUB Ulm UD po © SOD Pa A + w $ © Go gS os 4 gn fu wr G mG a "4A 2 GS Bag ie a" w o ss 0 $3 iG ay ef 43 w 4 @ a 4 sh ot 44 gn ted 44 4d 4) e 4 i 44 a % a . ci 4 8 C3 "rd 2 % ' a we 8 + oe "ch set qa 44 - Dy Zz : ved wet kn gy 4 6; Se a oO G € & a) M4 - , OU eG 8 ¢£ 3 3. lg 3 Bo Mod et MM © tt s, OG SC i Me ro) 4 wt 3 ws w ms Do « a @ 43 a MD ci gy S$} 1 by Q oy i A ud ny tnd eed Ch AS a & mo FF 2 ed Gg thd Go nu o 6 8 ® ZO 1 og BG Gm fe 2 3 OG Bg 4 ord Be 44 Ls) G Ch vd ad " ct a rf wd t 43 . $2, 5 i 4 G MS fs] ay a art re a 1 +. 4 ph re 3 He " ae ai " < Bed : 4 Dy ct C} ie om Z wy i it ih % e ik a a in ge . 3 (G % i a WD sod QD " BS O ae 4 m ra f vad Wa o ced ve] of 6 us o at 44 orf ~ ° tri 4 ad tb ad "ag $4 i. '.., bea wf ef rf an " te r Ao md a @ ? a) hy 3 4 ch oo hee ip " o @ Q ; 4 choy on A ooo rt tt 44 . ES : 4 a rs see "d , m4 i) (2 ood & a wu} 3 [7 uy wp Ag + « 4.3 « nee a} $a rat ~ = 5 ; i wn iG or . 4 5 ct wo a i rd et ig % i ee GG me 8 6 3 Gd #8 & s Pe @ ni ' ; oO rc 4 a oH a ret Fn z ve a o 3 i a Boe ts 6 gg oF Hg gy ww @ 7 Bog og YG a 5 oe Boga oe My Bw A re - n ae 5 ¥ 8 t vs 4 f.. . oe f ye ' i y 4 wo G 4 % SS ord nai ce] th o o a 124 Mes 8 3 "4 is AG x vel oe Pe 3 ee SG % a G B nS 6 "rf 3 wd ut bea 44 8 3 wo oa oO ved 3 a ¥ Seg 4 ws 4 Bs $A 1) a i im G a > OG g ® ob us $4 n S Oy a3 ad Ht ch 44 ria} m rd Us i 4 "CG 53 M4 2B @ a i © uh , SS "i tn 3 o gy ae 4 rs on e a wf w i O @ & ce, "rt @ uy & "4 3 $4 w D at 3 rt od th ' foot 4 rd 3] ht E ort i ag & 13 $t Hed C <3 o ay rt % ra} 4 w nH on a Yd ri a oO ba bi Bf 3 O ag o qi ai we me iz o St ted % os react 43 Q 4 z i 4 0) & = xy 3 rd wa ct wt by Tae! $3 4 4 3] Sha to on og er et oc 3% & & »® "

re by " 4 to 6 a ee ee MO eS & } # B 8 -

OB o ov O ao og § Bg Go m @¢ 8 go Go ox se 8 & ri OD B Oe x a3 7s) 3 4d b> my heal 43 x nas hens a} ad 4 ¥ $5 ed re wy ved sid ty 63 iyg ee ref w} £0 44 cd g mf vod a ot a re o > 43 A "3 iS i 4 xg $4 'aA Q H " o is) , 44 @ in " a 4 c i ¢ oe. ay rs eal is . 2 ro * g 8 ws g © "tg OG a Boa » § 2 G& G6 2 4% oxt a _ w we a C as 2 SA i Q se oa wl 0 & ' My on cS aed ° 4 uw ey $3 * ay « } by na "r4 . a 2 $4 a eel hy ; < c uC a 44 . 5 we : A OY : Cs AS @ + t a as rd + £2, ty. "4 ed 4g ee ¢ a he ra £3 ; 3 3 oF a 3 2 Ci i bed Z gs SR Ree 6 5 2 ow HFG Bi a og & Bog 8 ¥ a Cobar gs 'a Boe Hoo & Bi as 6 wood 7S tier. e "4 " nn 2 By OG t » G ms # 'a aa 2 Bon" = a a an ut r ved - 5 : _ $3 f sy we e o ee ad QB @ S a a go « '4 Goda g © iG gE, a BS 22 8 os g a : 4 te " 3 Ci "3 wre ¢ Dy ay OH ey F e 8 C ip a Wi « 3? set e a o © uw « i a f ta we Ba Th on 33 Gy 2 as es 3 ~ oe & i Gg vA Bon" s mo 2? ress y CQ bel > rea wher ° a $3 Bt el Thoin gh arms 4 ' +3 g "74 4 a ey 3 2 * @ A amu S my age S 4 - e aed ah 4 Ch + 44 «8 red iy i B me "SS wt gy m, 4 t 8 "4 UH ee 4 $4 ; + « ay "ee Bn ee Py ms 43 ks a th @ % 4 us ot ~ w BEBE Bh 09 e D wo 5 © «4 » 8 #8 Sw mm ae a i . Se Bees a. a wy. $ coo a a ne Woo Oe ee wh - 88S S Ses ws @ ced ws o ¢ fi 8 ad ts a mE Ea! 253 & a oO M4 G <3 B © ib io 43 44 wd oY i vy 4 H co v "eB & ig oe Q HO 4 g 8 & eae gO oS an ge G3 BE e@ we a 6 O i 4 pon 4 5 at a @ ed & } ae BS, SB es Go a . ef Oo, as w +t ; 8 x a3 23 £t 4 om BB ob Es wo ay "4 " wn pe ri ¢ i ti os} fj : gts a a4. 3 tate a os og 8 oS -« & ri & GS oe os & re 2228 2 Blt wy 8 Bs i ud A G @ fe B ed rt wo & + C Ba a Ww i BD BS wep be rn Os Book fae COU 42 » Oo 5 & S SAB & oo a & G eM a GY Gg * ao GF @ m 2 sD no uw eRe BO"

. o . ay eo st ao g m : -- * 43 i 26 8 m BEB in mt a a iff Oo weg beg S, 43 "4 ui a a © ce "EEG qk ee Fae g o S Ne '. at ae y Uh ; a Us m4 wy a sel q mt oO rt % «ef "Be EY wa & a G aed od &) a a 13 i.) $ 2 o ra 44 bd aA wt Re ie ha + ae sy @ © & 5 OR Bog " GF 4 oe Com BA BO BE a ee S$ & o % 8 ® 8 g # 8 & o PS "4 Go 8 y BY PGB op Ks 4 a3 ¢ ath Go * ret i uw ts BOE op. st ty a "i n ee] # boy "ed C A se sok Me 2 FG fn is 4d ti wi wo i Ke ' Rd wm 3 aa "tg Oo 4 Gis ay 4 vas A 4 7 OM of qi 2 on wm HS She & 2 eo eG a . 2 Hod gS F 2 & 4d » Oo BBE BEBRERES Ss oe 8 & 8 uD / | a &§ OS Ge ss w Bog Benge e oe "

oA ¥ - * 4. i ji bee " | Le . re a ee 43 ge 4 BS 4 8 & 4 GES oe ghee iG c bee ved w ord re ng G et te Et wo ao 6&6 6 & §& ¢ oO & go: g F 6a Zhe es ts A OU! OP ' oa 2 8 Es " B86 2 oon @ 6 eo o A oi ct eget a ne rt co A C : ee fA at O 4 me z 1D 4 5 Pood w te ¢ m er weed O43 S cs % ti a 3 3 3 i :

i i 3 directed that mo action should be ta y ey 3 4 - 'w:

her words, the DBOPT Aas wt 43 heard, the said complaim may be filed as pseudonymous by the he Ministry'Department."

t ete cane 3 . oe ee ot Se tt OA Further, in a letter dated 26.11.2014 an . ANY } dated 08.2 "OFFICE MEMORANDUM Subject: Guidelines regarding handling of complaints in Ministries' Departments. The undersigned is directed to say that instructions regarding dealing with anonymous and pseudonymous complaints were issued vide this Department's Office Memorandum of even mumber dated TR.1G,2013 preseribing that no action. is required to be taken on anonymous complaints, irrespective of the nature of the allegations and that sack complaints need to be simply filed. Subsequently, the said Office Memorandim has been clarified vide Office Memorandums of even mumber dated 18.06.2014 anc 34.03.2014. In this regard, the Central Vigilance Commission's Cirealar No.0? Utd dated 25.11, 2014 may alse | be referred to. A copy eack af the DOP&T's aforesaid Office Memorandums and CVC's Circular are enclosed hevowith 3, The instructions contained there are reterated and all Ministries/Departments are requested to follow the same while handling complaints received in their respective Ministry/Depariment. Enel as above. (EO Raw) Under Secretary to the Government of India Tele. No. 204799 * O.4. 627/201 , omy 179 ¢ ' ' r ar No. O7/11/2014 dated 26.21.2014, the CV matte « OLs, gat 9 a ae dated reaffirmed oS %S ct 553] oO © es ct 2019 és ?

g OLA. 827.

wt a rt 3 arf @ S 4 40 44 a 22 8 8 8 & op 9 @ 9 @

4) n \ f ort wha wD te Ds an Ke xr 5 G Shed hh co "

mp GRE ce se GO ee ' * s o 2 &§ mm & * & 8 8 4 4 G > 5 ° " 2D pd 3 . : 3 Blawg Ho G 2 yo i fa ~~ © gy 2 @ g BE 2 4 & og & Bf HO HB 3 8 2 o © 8 FA & a ® B + wo 43 ih GO x3 4 iy a tet . a) , a ra} G 1) ee go wi 8 G fh a ¢ %& 8 & we $f WB ' we 4 Xi ag "4 '$1 i} a 3 a3 i ha , ° et CO ay a 3 ' oO 4 be a ea re Q é Ss 3 3 * . i Hf a % "ch gs wo @ na Bs wv a4 1 » 6 Ls td Ma eA M he os m 3 & itt "

SB a © 8 G OB " m8 oo & : 4 oye] m4 & 4 wee et ¢ oo 4 y o , 2 # a" © g Gm a 8 & @ 2 § 8 4 a PS 6B UM «OO va 4 98 § BB © oy B S pot i? aes " ag oS mt cs) wi 4 "4 © Q oy Ss io mS wo @ 8 9 & "4 p i Be ® fad fo UG 5 1 w , od :

S @ 4 § GS HB « 6 © & @ 9 § Bom 9 B 8 2 § 38 Hed ont ry on os ~ ve Wa eh sx 43 fet "y bs 44 « 4 * ha gy Lo w 3 ha we aa o eg a ay ee as a G @ hg aS it det aol k4 gs * ¢ MM o 43 3 2 t} 2 ; 3 fa | ao pn oo BR i - gg AR Bow om rt BOF AG ® > in M4 44 uy a o 2 6 8 "4 $4 "<3 o mj we 5 iS fi, a tH 6 ai S OY te i 3 a G v _ oe a ck OS Gg BMT 3 e © 8 o@ fs e D3 6 bp 8 MB BY Ae ha i St - hd we at Ea ved ' * ved 4 a ob & FB S$ 8 yb a eB fo 8 8 Bom Mn of BO"

o 8 % eo Bn »o 6 a B 4 o 6 | Se a OG § re) a vr a 4 4 G ne sy i a 44 " iB ® a 4D tO " + ® C PB GR 3 8 gp eH Ew ; wB a a i © 6 wd & iD 4 a re 3 Ea a 9 7) > a i @ Zs 4 fet Cy 4-4 i 'ef D 43 $4 2 wd ze 54 i 41 oS Pa © "ed 4 4 a Q oa a a u , a aa 5 r ie - vB ws is G o 8 G Ww 8 6 e 8 § 2» FP a @ 6 o a oP os wo OG 4 a i & . Go go Ff . OB i Oe v4 1 ne 5 . "€ ; a & © w t ; E . 4 ; a 3 G o> Mm oi 3 a w ; 43 3 6 BOO 4, BO a, BO Ow CU A a Bo 6 "g Go 3 St wo rg So op gq B a ge BB oO GY np-e G 8 "GO 3 i ed i wh ™ we al i r--} iA 43 t © is) i 5 Si @ Ft) 4 4) ey * 2, rts) oO. wo ie wh £3 » red Pi o 33 mS E s c Wa g wD ced $5 gree} raed , ed a4 "5 " 4 ' Li ge ved - (} ees 4 Aa m vet a 4 Goma BR wow aE te om BU ° » 8 & 8 6G Boom dM bef C iS g 3 ° ia @ * , ; 43 ci es . x o 3 3 -) ( Ss ts i Gt vcd G oO a @ a ns @ : ay "fA ng on , $ mo " Co ort ok gS Bg Bb Boom Bay we Pw og ti $3 7 Oe bey a Ff Fs SB ee mot Gi G a v 3 0 5 5 i te : us a fd O 2 Q 2) 3 & "a ba fa om oC a 6 i mw ot oy} ; 2 % Os sd r yd 1 OB o 4 ES) G i @ a ig uy st ' 4 ao oO o . eg ch Cs ; 2 ay a hy re a Send - a 4 x gt a 2 4 oy fe 3 oe ' 423 ret C sa oO "he rr Ad 4 oy 6 a Oo ia) P2049 UF Maint OA. 8 at that ge @ Sa 4 M4 a Gs be YY 2s Se 4 hac x

4. MMOUS BN » x.

bat Ak ano is alse x aa Sle Hon' syed Fened "

t ro AQtLe @ admi > Sion acti tt ie MW ord @ Q Be Ht cg Ad G ay "ry 39 np oo & x bed YD 4a oO ea oo B * 68 2 og G e

- a rs) 4 4.

+ , ac + Bo ® G &«£ & at ay i a} i Ut ved wh 3 ot 4 hos ths ek es «5 42 4 at iw 4 a Q G 43 Q ied & ie, Ho x» Sa a veg a a + my y $e ri on.

» "4 iG ws a @ t » Ho.

G od @ D a 4d . e $4 it "ed Me rm oO BS wo ROUc x WLt < ' an a a @ a { 4 Ki, be &S ord o QO $2 -et A a o od 44 De 4a ond ug cy * i B82 9 Gg «@ & eo cs S 6 Po iQ kG a 4 ct ; : o 3 wo 44 s "nd 4 nr nS) be o D 43 fed Go gf 8 8 red ay @ 4 Os e Ey a o ce ay od LS hd rf ia w "4 4 4 a id Ww O sed Qa 4 O} 1% oy @ et wt @ [on {3 cs) A Sa wy @ i 3 43 u 0] KS & oo a o eh mn a * to. 8 vr v4 . ~ %. .

o ® e Oo eH ved s c "4 b> G baa "3 @ at ong 2 5 rs Ets 4 ft @ hy a ud ry , 3 S # m - S a wor GS @ YD 6 8 ow 8 £ O wh GR 2 4 fa} 4 fe 6s fa ce) 3 af b> gtd q a Ei or GO te] & 0 43 be sed 4a weed as 43 ret 3) n ot g 6 Dy fh 3 to Q 1) fy ord wD « i> Oy ca 4g m bee Yt vd Lang a one Nae hom & Te the details, able avd $4 ved ear Bray "ye Lew ; £4 inistra a < ot wear an

3) re Ae ws 5 4 ot t at CRS ar Wt ee Teasons Gh tLe 4.3 3 a} acy oy 1 Wg 4 sref Aamir PN ee ee MM ence ved te, age eee whe ta ae e 2 ae ved red i ay $5 oe not wp ee pent Rad gi 43 i

30. © 13 a3 a J its} a At on a ee Bf Q Be « ® : ;

S 0 @ 44 % wD pot Oy G . 7 ® 3 u 5 a a nn qo. 3 :

4 . : :

' é 0 3 w E33 ay tr} @B iad eged : 3 m2 od <4 03 St at b, 43 63 us od wy a $4 on 2 Y : 4 re Md G & ca} res 8 F ' " : :

o 94 4 ka . : ! .

ti * Uw {3 fog, . wy 8 cs Q 5 ? : ' ; *s i $ 3 at veg id " a wd uss ; o ke Ors i a an @ & ne i | § : ; : : | : 3 a a 4 oped c my ord a uy , ns 4 OG Oh 2D ad a4 oy « 3 " ° é 3 Q . fo : «a bee a a wn OD 6D 13 ed a "3 wed 44 bo os 5 en m4 Q qv at cS ° @ | i :

re @ % 3 we £h ; ae rv "3 5 " : : : : : | | , 3 y 7 ¢ ws gi » & @ ug hd an tt AG fy 44 2 ord Go AS ved L 3 t s c ic} bs ie ra . Be nea ch ord ny bs : CG a 2) ) | | | ' ae r B red 58) . Gt 4 ¢ 44 cq hd 3 Mo O (i $4 © " :

oy et ' rch Pas an cis] we a4 c aed . 7 , BD a as a cet Kf 4g 42 re > 9 D i} tn c 3 : ; ; : : 2 ni i @ % 4 e ao i ha ce) 44 os : . omy oA Q we g es iy "4 yy gt 2 a $2 m ° : , . 2 :

BG 'i a | OD 4 o <4 2 . : | | : Co ao Ou a oo RO tod 42 , a es : : a ta Ww oy kG 3 a n mt "rf ey wd Sa wt ced in G * uy 4 D iS ' 44 ne vt it a ~ i of a > ey Bed 4 $4 6 © ~ ' nS ot 3 © wD i oe 3 wn tC oS «4 1 s o i) a us 4 . Sa oO i a oi J ag : 2 H a : 3 i eS gE & D oO god rh o . , : i : ' ot ' ph 43 Gg a "A fp! iw mt 5 Os a , , | i . 4) red «a AS uy i i 44 a ? si 3 4 G Ch 3 ee 6S x3 o i ° : | 3 : : ' o a tr i a4 a mh 4 he ay 43 wu 4 : : : g ty orf B 43 be 3 oH cn ve od 44 % a : , : é 4 cs £ nie "a * wy cd ' 5 s. tnd se > » 6 ag a et j "a Ke we 'ot bd rd o f 3 :

mn * 3 ty . Fe} @ @ ad 4 ie GF C3 % -f uz rf e 8 " a) 4 om By (a 53 ka oY ss a] 4d eee ot Fe ab ) 4 wt 3 3 :

Qo hy Ned er Ed 44 a a Gi xi | 2 od "03 3 % . 3 $3 @ ved 0 8 4 oO a Hh 4 r nD wet ah os "el '4 wt E : ; : 8 ts 43 wed 4 v4 4 Os 2 'ss QD yy o tp 3 uy us cs "3 nA 4 ae b4 S * ip me eh 3 cn is " z :

| : , . «rd , a Bi 3 ed u @ MM 5 , a Med o q ad w : F 7 4 i ot @ 4 ty "yt "S $4 3} , G 4 , ved 44 w Gi a oA U4 a w 44 a a = ct od $4 ort " < i ee 4 f 8 nd & my o US BR od ar s) ; -

os ig s % 4 "rf cS 5 ot 3 3 % : | i :

| . : . iS oO BB $4 4 2 43 4 cc] « e os . : ' : 3 a yy es as 84 "rj Se ot by ist a 6 AG =r} 43 ae th WW f.- : a arf Gs : ; : : :

44 : we 4 if 33] "3 4 44 5 7 ' | (3 o a oy Wy ao -el o i d . :

wD wel 4 @ ts we @ on i . 3 ; : : xu ao w a) » "4 e iy oy 4 4 C w a bg Md et : ard ey 5 8 : 5 3 : : » rd Ww a 43 ov bd 4-3 7 ¢ ! 'cS ne} g SG a : ; 2 , "+ 3 ta ay bed : : | : ; w GS ca ot "7 = B 3 Qi oy ca hi vod o 2 ;

Go ~8 of od ; fg 4 uy 4.4 i WB 4 mt hed a 2 : :

: : : 4 em tts G fs .

a wo cee ; ard a * : 5 WE tt < : , wm = ° :

£25 7 :

44 B 3 : :

43 8 % : 2 :

8 S 3 3 3 & 3 8 | <3 : $23 a eegeeecap nadie: eneee nein con oe fi con ' ;

mS a a o o 4 a 4 @ et wR . eo « 6 6 « © & & & & & ~~ < Cs i 4 EA Ga a & a wed f ? @ 4 @ mR os a ° J8 ; oO 44 ii} 5 o tes © $4 % ee o e ® wt 4 wD og 33 vB @ 8 eo Bo @ 4) ow e Bf . 3 . * 4 t . Pes a 7 oS s 43 od 3 e Ct ' iw ued G he a mn 1 "3 kK! Ee wet Q a cs orf . a 6 4 2 Ci a yf 3 CG gf y * 5) ' z p Moy RG fee a te a x 3 mS a & 6 xt cy tf ay o 43 a o a uy $4 . 3 Ky se} rs 4d wy $4 hed ved £2 2 on fies oj ag ed ° fo no i os ~ 2 " ; i a oS oD as g¢ @ ® gi a & # 43 4 ay Oo @ sal & od c} a 9 4 uy Sf & b GC " oe cf gM ma 4g 3B et Gomme OGG iS 4a i © $4 a 0 ce eo @ G 4 @ i ° rod 4d 3 * o an co 4 '2 44 ry Fos a 3 ce G n 3 , ga o 4 gf #2 © e . 2 oa BD @ £3 a pe gs B Bh ad $4 eg Pe bs rs) ra ea @ " $4 ub a 8 a YP iy f 1 ref fh y AS " j ¥ "£4 : , % mu ra 6 2 oy ved Y B - , ard ca % a ct u 4 « * Rea) ys re » " a. ut y 73 3 ; ; 5 . a 24 a yt 43 7 We 4d a od 6 OS a ) 8 (3 c 44 o 5 od "r4 " mb ig i ol Os a x Q wy oF o '3 a o a ' Sng Bs ae B i el Ra) 4 a sed nef , wo OD oY 33 @ Oo 4 iw Ay op »o 6 & Bf "4 r 4 5 cc % mr é a a ~ Oe 4 be § £4, ua dg rt PS ee ee ym 8 Oo oo @ G 4 o 8 , D « 3 4 3 4a oh 4 wD ay ded ty iD [e7 - a 4} 4 45 as} ES wos veh or} ® a i Q, Be ved a) C3 oO ed or ae Q it in i as A 43 nf rh bey Ma a Ms a) RY i a os Fb 8 & & 1 QB @ Go $A 8 8 5 wv . mG ot - wo - . n has 55 * ? y fy a & 5) Ws a Bs) Sud ahs '3 ret '4 43 5 i ee w ver} a od & aged oh, £ i uy ou ws a 3 "a As rt A ® © " a 9 ; sg ® ca coo (SUP RE qh a : a SS 9 ag rf # BE w.. $y w D og Al + fs 4 5 53 *% % Ch 5 &S @ af O cca} u , wt § "$ ; ed ms % aS " / a3 a y . nef it Oy a 3} . ; et a wb 1 @ ~ 4 ed 44 Aa G a i) G4 g 3} Wy "x a oa 4 32 ; "C4 4 "7 on t 4h ia 5 2 G4 < a fs > 6 4 e a 4 w eo F eo oboe) 6 OB 4 a S o » § 8 4 3 %§ 8 B Db op & . we 3 HS i a : . 4 ; : £ - z 4 he gy GO © o o ts xf Yi aa 2 $l o ue is 4 wd ge pO N wg ort 4 BDO be O Foy Fw OD o BB " sa ce ie 9 rs Ww . nd O 4 a od G " w m a © @ hg z a 4 wy D o 4 " 6 a Got oS Oo Bo m@ Bo Hom OO Bw ao ® ord ~ " a eed bey oe 3 } A % orf ve fn f hs d] . ss 3 5 & SS * > a oa 4 D 3 a Ss 5 @ & wt 4 a 3 &t ' ? - ord . " i ms aS i "ig 5 : ot og ® dg x ~ © 6 8 % & Hog 8 § oe 2 8 2B w 8 8 8 eo 2 8 & 3 ce hm 8 Db fp OS o¢ QQ x i : 4.1 oH a] Li te "i ; vied Se 5 Oo a Pls $2, f Vy 2 oe : 4 e PB G8 S & 3 8 6 & 6 8 8 f& "

ne QQ uy 7 ay 4% 4 3 a t> ea im ches Ef nf Le phe At 4.4 o 4 \, 627/219 a +a 0 of FY Ad Mt tg 3 uy 4.5 im ff Py @ ot od rd MeaSure crt het 33 ra cs "rd ret Ds a a

3) yy wd mr and aicris a Gs 43 4 QO vet cok "ry UOIr L8si SCR Swadeshi Cotten Mills ve.

oo ae vet 43 Cour ° a Ww ele 2h % (2) 333 1 ae O.A, 62 4 wy a or 5 o 6 a we 4 4 Poo ob . . , @ Fi Oo We OG CU n 4b abe oN Oo a mh ok 4 . if , ob th we be eM edo oe Se ee te SEO dt ard Or Ge UG Gs « ced a "Oe Bags Cm RE a Bee GB fos § $4 we as 5h O O FP. 1) wm ty a Ge yee Bas BOM Oo oe BO Boe wD Ro B GF Oa OH goat GB wD Se BF, BES PeSe eee a? BR Ee ay Pogo HE eg Owl fo ee g Go OBE OD wel OBB gy CE ee Be Be ey Be wo bag Or Gat OG mB @ $2, A © BY Age eH ATEN gee eo RB 2d ge | h BoB By ee BB ' ¢ @ ss SER ZEUREvEL BEB S et oo fs BS Boe OM BO Bs 8 ° 06D OM yO eh ROOK SRC EBB SE AR ci » ed E: eed BS "3 org nh ' ao w ® Oo BR eae Se Se 6 2 9 wo ha 4 ey . ort Ye ' 4 £3 LF Oo 4 8 Moe Te oe ee Dg OS ay Os "4 bo @ cp gt 3 af fa * mt " on OM TE ee ow Ge m 02 7B a SME og (ey ee Be ot oH BaP 3 Mo BEE YR Beat RVR ABT @ 2 w ogy Pg gk AA ge gy oO ey "cf e 0 8 gy 3 @ vd 3, oA % ae wa On Ok aE BE Ge 8 a g aod a og ramet ud "Trg HOS % * wt oo 4 of BO Be ey * QS th & BG me _ ha +] oF A a 3 ae aw _ rey. fo Tet oe © tO, BR oa "4B re kp Tork ao bd ty 0 Be gy rh A wt "og a2 5680 (She 8 go FB 7 ms BH 8 OL hf aia ow PY we Boe + . ve BE a Bop a oe ee BE SO o sa A GM ae de 8 ee Os ag eg 8 ' ~ DB poe eon Se Pe Bt Bee Be mg TG "1 33 OO Mord ns e gi yp ae © He % a % 2d BRE EOL EER eke Be we Boe is Bd Ob eg Aas vg & , we f Srp Gy 2 OY We Bag yD o : od toa by SE Os eS it Skew; PRO ee pw KS bad 6 ge * % 2 fev Na ry of a My. Sw & 0 ay a we hg Fe 1 OB pe as me | digg a 3 6G Eg " 2 4 " 5 aw Ga Beg "a Bos & 2.43 8 eh 3 wy 't 4 c 4 Sia EP i 3B ms OM go gk B Bom OG 4 Bo © a Moog, Bake Se Ras. See EWES o 8 o0g@ane @ 8 Be BoM LO ge BB Gl lO Be Bee OBB AR EB fo OG ME ® "i TE 4 ony ad re ; es ft og, Gh no "et oe & Bee Oo OM Bs OO nt 3 ry UG fa 9} 00 cc oo 44 C3 UY ae B a es ge 9 Ba 2 % a ke 5 % Oa Oy a iP pO DN a ga @ 4 SS ERC ee SB eG yer SkSBa Sas r 5 aed opt ted E. : a 5 a7 4.0 mM os Ot 7 Oe OP Pet wt Om oe on ee eto Bm 8 a «we RQ PES es keh ek eas yw kaw SC f : "p4 4 ae bed pee! . 5 gh a ae) bo et , Sg ta GS x oh Sek ega kh Gt ao ac "a & 8 og 6 oo EBe Ay, BBt e eSShEr es " OME 8 GEL OR aa Yo Son rho oy ROBE ER SRS ey APO gee ee,"

4 . neo + is - m 2 ee ON ay eg te BO yng ES RF + row ng, Qed' poet fhe! eB so B® GABr eRe RE LER EE ee y BE Hh 44 et po 8 Oo pug OG OM 2 gw or 3 : . egeugh ey wpe Sy ne OB Be Gio a aor a Ow go ol Os P CO 8 gs Bm Bay Be on BT ah a RO aoa te aa AS "ef CF 44 gD $3 ryt 4 GS g3 wd '4 3 ny O PP we eg ee oe BOG gr B Gs 23 arf ohn eed tts iM Oo wm rel 4.3 Q QO @ i Ceo n 3 oo 2 8 te, G é go gO s 6 8 & GO wt MD MD by DD GO Ch KL ed a $4 a 2 wR ag OR g Be pu # eM wy GH Op UO 20 Oe by oe TS te 6p Gee woud "3 st ow 2% 2S a mies wy. Be yp Se 2 OB Get OO Pert Gem Oo Gk OW Meet ed fe YG & fe en Oe eS Dn HSBE SE Gee oa ' BR SGP AHS Ga Sa Hoos h ef India

32. closure would 3 j 5, is it Gf such = character that tis d 3 wer Word *:

#h at { 6 Gna OLA: G27/2019 be against the interest of the State or the public service and if so, whether the public interest in Rs non-disclosure is so sirong that Ro must prevail over the piblic interest in the administration of justice andi on that account, its disclosure should not be allowed. By aperation of Section {62 of Evidence Act the final decision in regard te the validity of an objection against disclosure raised under section 123 would always be with the court. The Court would allow the objection to disclosure if it finds that the documents relates to affairs of State and dts disclosure would be injurious to the public interest, but on the other hand, if it reaches the conchision that the ducument does not relate to affairs of state that the public interest does not comipe! its non-disclosure or that the public interest in the administration of justice in particular case before it overrides all other aspects of public interest, it will overrule ihe objection and allow disclosure of the document."

" + 2 . L le a) mn 2 >. sealed cover and its contents by the Tribunal. fn fides urged by the Applicant, ana we have tourna 3 . ~~ " weak} ste wo that there is just and reasonable cause for the "

orecautionary measures adopted by the Respondents of the view that the larger pub

-

Saal m iw £ cr $3) i.

te ty re eet 1 £ served by not permitting disclosure at the p rs o a a 3 CF ' : wie Bd aes ' an +e tp esos t Pos moment on the consideration that if any Gevaris + .

+ We -- toa are codisclicsed at trae Pp resent SCAGS> Whicnm A258 meirels xy neEey the enquiry itself may bes env rel.y PLSLAMANG LY s eras STE a Dy LUGS RaAL ¥ on owe oS =a i i 627 OA.

ry "£2.

44

iD "3 a rome & LO ~ ta MOwn © A send } 3 # a4 uy € OQ "vd Es ad ey hd Ye ved At Ye at AES x x 4.3 44 Wa dlalen sacar eden oor een es ww Ud 3 ort rd iy @ AN ht G4 o> Ms M g $4 Qo cs) ok Aue ys ues ues «pd on} 'qe $.

i 3 wrt a 4 dectirneinags, FOLD O.A: 62 ree "4 bg a sit At weet sta tty 4s CG wr © aay bs ot heh Cy os & ud At eceis

-

she pan x t G @ ;

v4 bet :

34 iy 44 AS "rd £3 & 6 At $53 Cy a G iy wo oS «ed * ee 43 Oo 2 oh, 4 wW .

i bet @ we be ao .

AF wy @ 43 OG a 43 ad QO o ws G ' $4 he * a ' 44 mand & {Ravinder Kaur) Mamber (d}