Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Hemant R Purandare vs M/O External Affairs on 30 December, 2019
nig B94 eo Be Naské Od MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBAT a 5 im fet fs Et > Es of fot :
wn 4 a Fan a s| e} 4 Be G ORIGINAL APPLICATION No, 802/2019 OR. VIJAYKUMAR, MEMBER {A) "
a Date of Decision: 30° December, 2018 ' CORAM fe « uy RypSaes, > es ween Z CS oO ut ae Ot ce! ayo ge Be aa AL : a + ig thy 43 C * GH $3.
mG Geo ALE ne «dy Applicant enue tae cg ie CP cel I, 2 Yl ea ae x SESE 2 JOS he de VERSUS Seige aM 2 s 3 lake ms, & Toe inh te de) ey Ne # TR 2 (By Advocate Ms. Annie Nadar} on 4 ot MOIETIES LEAT ELE ee Respondents < Ps AS Bose be mk ty x (By Advocate Shri V.S. Masurkar) os #9 a os 43 $3: h4 4 SF oe : ;
= a © poe "| o cS Q @ Q a & rl em ke a @ mw BH 8 ee, " od C Me, tee teh a i uO We oe a me dee as eS BE © 8 8 oo A we ow. a : ; u gs Se i bp Loos Oy Fy bed a S Pe a : x £5 Us: a Ty 0; a ce oO ~ 3 Af: ne yay aed wy oe o € 5 rae oh oe 6 ie S a3 on fe QO Go £2) € fa . a a ct 5 TD Ss Ps, ~ co a $4 a xe) oy oH np i weg Soot Zs fy oS oe Oy Cy ped et ss pod ab fot C3 te gh Cy oa teks nee ee, 3 fed @ i ory . ve "ed ng re "A BO OD Be a ® oe ba ee a Pd a tee a fg 4 @ js a3 eo GO ) fs us 5 i we Nee Ae se é es ites 6 reel 4 $34 of c oa ~ Mao ' "eA = eat: 5 oy 43 1 ied * : O nn 44 ee be Bae AD & x hg oe £43 3 £ sp-d ing nn wa Be cee ce et be iB 1 mea ift et 2 & wR . To ey ep: 3 fry F ee nh wed fed ey oe By rib Sy 1) 3 ae $3 : £4 : 7D 2 8 a feos BY ae as a a et c a a i oe SS So ie uw 4 fe bay o o ae oe gee a ty Sa. = i beg ft one Af @ ged rey i eee: cd mn ee oes, te TS BS a H £4 a fy eed a Ss ae fe > e @ 5 ey os a S we & a & Z 3 ae th : ni a ey. Hog ee} By ae - a Seo on" De pre Bay vt oy ied ct ty So eo. a Pang Pee i rh ns ) "ye & he 8 gos 3S = "ho ge : ; iy "
- oT} r ; oe we iy sot g3 : ayy 4d & - oe 52 gas Ne eae 4 Ya creh ee Be a ieee e Co 43 4 : ie 4 eye BO Of FE Sn Ss. 3 o 3 a ee a) ny te Sor Sag OS op "ed A aoe toe 4:3 hey oa Cf as S ot Bes : 2 oo a oS " ao "08 : te FE: CM ON WO & PRM SSE SE a ha ay g O | * 9 sen, ed te 2 OS Sg 2 oy i) ao "ed ge nel M in 4 Be uot i tee eo re oO SG S) cee ae iy CH, Ss Bh 3 ee a rae ay m BAD oan " : "A C3 z C Ce ee Be ee Se As fe * 3 , 4 st ce a oS PMR RS S 4 BO, sa ah 5 5 44 2 in fh oe pe Pe the pm ape ONG Te fe % rm yo © ; vt we CG. 5 as O 2 aS wo 8 my 8 Bo B ei ® wre eft oe GS 5 cj Sr as wy el 4 s 4 iB ise £4 3 43 ° vb " Oo ay oS fh ie) : : SF 43 me EG Be Rao = i i ae 3 ons ne ie be a on @ ig 3 a be Box om oa " cs cf 2 i ' wp } 3S Dao pe, CH es he ts ge ct cH nt ae:
el oa Se aa wf OO EFS = reel et i & cM ind ' Y cod a8 ke es fe faa bo ee ey ES ¢ pee oo eo "3 @ aA ws AAS & os s i Sy oe rES G a $ ' a G5 es u Sr poe Po. Ren AN a CS f Me Ss 4 BF es me & ES Bs Og My 0 Ho Mee es B Bo Qo EO ' : oy ' ts © H a vA a "4 aa : o, 0 O Sf a vt 'o * foe hea C oS | 23 @ ' wh S a fo : Lf f8 O & 6 ww & a Oo 3 "8 ba $4 Oy Oe % uf A, :
a heed 7 ee O ¢ %, op os fot ug @ yoke ( rae race.
nS ged S Mey peo feo jut A at teed fod ated gt G io wet tt ie5) ced ia oy ueee Oo op pth abcd oF xebwd, sed Les e oset Me:
Ba tet re .
"4 i ME wf * ye ee the, oN = cent AAS eA ESCvea a Rade nae Ch tt dA Fe & Ee i a ae 'a 2 o & pea a4 u ns 4 a3 hf 4 f ¢ t fa oy So 4 as So og 8 S 8 6 8 = 8 8 a oo a ted a cS s send 6 mS g a : GW O a feo co fs j Oo + 8 i a 2 8 5 Bo 4d. 4 @ -- @ 2 Sgt gd oe rt 9 gh os OD . ee AB 4 5 Z ve . B @ Q : gh os i rs a Fs Ry a g ee 4 7 go Oo oF "y 3 "4 3 wed ei ky g oO 9 =. ff oi oe Ke Ml Z oe Qa Gg ® a ho Z 4d bs oo 3 4 mo Og 8
4 ie ee et a ey po fa gg qi f 5 Pe ue uh ss . a 3 a3 AY ues : ae Z we ' bel bes 3 4} @ aes a : bas gy a s . ey ms 4 ol G G a va : &g x By wo, o Se ae "04 g em : 5 Ss es O 3 a 0 : Y ei at 5 te : 1G £3, 2 cj : 2 pt * : ved y Z L ey i Be ca cs aed o ie © a a yk a be g HI 5 iu c 8 ws @ C3 " 3 e : ey 3 w fe oa Bf 8 8 Bos 4 8 8 YZ oe a Sy u "4 Pe 2 hg aS ¢ 6 : g | a << 8 & ep Bo G8 ® 6 ie y { a 4 as SAR So : CF 3 (s SEE: g A cn i O af as '4 LA ry --@ a oa it iy Ch OQ, i: Se BD 3 it aS } Wy oe ou ec & 2 8 6 oA ig is . "4 y 2 = @ c g 'e : ae 3 ~ . as :
OU 4 ws 3 Mao Fg, of y eG 6 o oD Ms mp oS gg AG ty 43 So re S ay fa abe ee Fy 42 a) 4 y we a fA & ae ") Z A ce a y a M9 zs - » 8 - 4 ® 0 Go} gy yO DD ¢ 2 Of Bw : Yoo og y fg ne B eh 8 Uf} os gy a i 4 wo 2) fe rc . :
oor > G ivy ng Ye op as a wt ; : ron hes S yy ee Fie} "ch Ky Go ® : wD is oO wt Yt i $3 3 yy 2 au 3 a a Sy is bed os a J 'wpe ef ¢ 2 ed a $ 44 NS L fd A ha 4) a i el M os y e f a 6 De FR ee ee _ wD +e Yat : ra f 2 % :
ka act iy cS i by : ane S) ie) ay @ ry C73 gy ron A3 the 3 ae AGS ve: hee :
a a Er O gt os 8 o og oS Ae o ; _ oh cd $3 ® 2 Gj oe @ ' oa bs oe te na Pe a o «€ t& Oo ¢ Se > PF 8 Poe we eG / afoot tank, : * ees Z @ Q n i o g bes w Mm Mom ot & Bw oo Oe OE asl 44 OG red Bu fi i CO a i} es ap CR, @ me ie) (44 © : Be ga : : hy 4 Chi on "ES A 3 feb $4 : te
4) a a v OQ a a) $e a ed es rea ead etna on ii §3 yo sg ha os o ie © Moved, © 8 G . 8 5 abe 4 rei eeed AD we se te O @ ie oe 3 cs 6 a © #3 "5 u uD ed "A as) od 2 43 a 4 Ae e : @ a as G0 ' ay , eb sy Poe gy Dg oe ee 8 2 gw og 8 2 8 go OD MM ve ¢ Q wy fay G 4 fe sed wy aa t me a a ai : > . ip wy i $y ard , 3 ie) MD 4 ra " 5 ted DG Dy ay Do gg 8 oy ada 8 6 a g 43 Di ee xs mS S Gy. oF Py So © O $4 ne Va, ht is} " w Fad 6 "cs acd 'p a (i oe ie a 4 ef og G cf OW Gh fee me om 8 oa . , @ ; Q M A ed 4 ' 44 = sl bed ee i . et we ; ba C3 Sa 5 Be gc ag ee ago egy cbc hese gape go 6 & ao 8 & 8 ope G DB 5 oe Q 4 4 ( ; s ed ee 3 TS é : © a a o wn cs iB ie 3 ; tel yy £3 ' 3 2 mao ms 7 oe an .
B & 8 BB Fe 8 tg mb a She gq OQ, wed ri a 6 G C 'is C3 AD a En 3 ry. : @ ay wy : 3 ty 9) Log sy a Gy ae Qo hed Goo : "aed fea : : gy ES ae) ac se of oO a ¢ 6 4 ie) ca oh; A Co Soe : a bed a 8) O bp t he : : > C ; i me) kt oy Ba Shot aero) Oo Oo x ts wed as . a BO Shad on ved Yer pe Wd 3] a) 43 By i. 2 fe Ne. Cae OE.
4ry