Mallanna vs The State Of Karnataka on 3 March, 2011

[Cites 3, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Mallanna vs The State Of Karnataka on 3 March, 2011

{By gzgigﬁ,§;éx.;:mrad§:;=z.__:4§ai,I;>es§.a:, ;i'»§::i{i1. 31?; EN ':'2-as: E-»H'G§«-§ $202323 (>1: i{ARNA'£'A.§§A Cmczm' Eszzmci-«E M QEULBARGA Zi}E§'E'§',-E) "E'Eé§E% 'E"E~{E%I. 633% EBAY G}? EVEESEFECE--E"; gm :3;z1:3:;:a:'*§' 'T '§'}--:9: %~§GN""1~3§,Ei MR JUS'F§C,EE'. M0}.--i§§.N Sir-iAN?'A?§¥%.1ﬁ--{;§?:E:;i:3§?;;'«_ AN!) _ ' '§"HEj; E~-£0N'E3L§=; 1V£R.JL?S'FECE§':' '£':.i:€;s%.._£,;i CRE,.,J&,NO' $84 Between:

Evizxiéazzzzaa SXG Shzarzmappia £T50£§§; "

;'»%.g6:28 §,--*:3:ars§ G€£',Z;-f§§.;3;;i"§.(?{ii,'f€i'§i£~;Yf€f R/30 Saiiiaizaaiihhaﬂi, zmw 2i"i: * ' E§a{iiSar1g21"v'§ '- V V 'E'q:J'€w9;rgL Di${4:G:1;--§ba1rgg;a."' --

{By Sri ESE}§Q§}=£7_.§°§%.§.V::CZ:£§;5}T{£Ei§:'§:é§";.

'E"'h<--:: 3*i,£ii,é' ai.' E§a::'n;?a;E.é; ._ " _ Rz:%p{c:§, E33' J7€'~A§2::*§;% RS. ; = ' " , . ' §€€sp<)n{§€:1i:

'i'?1i$, :%g5}§.;~:*é:;»>:..E is ifiksd L§g's;.3?4}{2} C;:?3.C. 2g;,§.21.§m:{ 'éhsiz "tjgmiéggjﬁ§:'z:%'ﬁ".:.»i_ {iii ._2V%E:§;{§5.2G{38 §::21;:5s€;%{'i ?3=:; ihe P2'? S€$53i<>:":é~: ;}'ti{§§;{éi: {§;';E?;'2;.§§;:2é'; §i:V,S.%'§_;;§€<}. E??? E 2$Q?m{'i{3*'E1'§7'§€':"§.§1'3_§,§ 31$ £i§)§.}%3*H&:E1tf&1{Eif'L1.E%€3{§ §.2::~r '%.E::;% {}§{€' " ' E¥'fE§;'SZ§€}2 {>5 WC 2-2_:'1.{i :~:~:.:3:"s'E.€:m'it§:%{§ 2:} ';:z1{§:-3:g<_§<: in:;3'§"§.s;::t:.22:r::2em;*"£32" Eii?'=::: gzmd 2:.i&;<> 'E5; gay 21 firms: 3? E%;S~S.O§{1%f~ LE}. {.9 _ .L_;:::ie:é:"g§;;2 SEE C3:-*2}-':?>; RE, €133' Ems: zziﬁézasée ?;"E}/3:392, {>5 EEK'. <'.f§fi";é$ :a§,:g3€f:2.§ {::<}2:m§.'::;§ <31": i°z;>:" E'.2:::=.22:°§2:;;; ::i2'.2;31-", Eriéiiﬁﬁ " _ §§§é§:§f?;Ei&gQ§§§a3" J, <§a=r3i'§..~*€:'<3{:i §.§2€= §;E:}EE<:w;§:':g;:;: Em) J L5 if} G M E N T 'E'h1Zs:»; :5:pp{:;aa§ by 'am-:* «::::):1'»-*i{ti:es<i §2_<7:€t:,2.s::~:%%§:i;. "a_Tfze 2i1pp€:I§21;;:_%:' hsereirz was-3 t:;*.E.€%d far {he <;f£1i%::{t:=5:~:¥§ ' p:..z:i'iL:%§?1_a3..VEj?Ec:§* 1,me:2:';%:* Se<:*iii::ms:; 362, 201 0? EPC 3;;1:ciws;2§s-'_4e::s:>_rf1*§%i<€1:::2{i«:53? {i<1§:% 9 ::§ffe:'1<?:3 lgzuzxishabie Lzndez' S<»3:«::t;ioz1 53132;'-.:>f" IPC; }*I{,}'~J%E€'v'i.--'}{:';'};'~, Vim' was 2*:(é{;::1it,?£.€«;%; 0%" the C}ff€}"}{?€E pnxvgiishabvkis._:.2::::iTé:? S:;:<§i:i{>n 281' <§f.EPCi.

2., it E5 the <.*a:3€ <}i; ﬂ'1.s:%'V the éecreaséitd azgecé 21160911 deaih was éhe b:"<>E:h€=::' :2? ~Sir;{:€ the Wifﬁ 0f the EE{§C¥.1£%i3'Ci aftw {he meirréagag {mm 'ta be fﬁiquerifi Cmarre} ?::>s3?;:&2v<:e:i1'_f;h€. .¥.:""ii:':1vi'V"i'§:wF;?f€E- <?::i;2:,1;§§'i'.:: Being em:ag._§ed, f:h:~3: accusé-,*-d f1:'>;: <2:n;}ji_,>* 2:f:..s"se*:a::%;z €39 qi::é;':"2f':';=:§ v;i§.h his w;?:'E:, but 2:339 E,§ft'=€f{",§ is :g'1:;;;::*:':3§§'%s:Vi:i:;?:_Vt:E9i<::._§j;<}E:E:§:§fS <25 hia axzifaz At {me piéimt 9? Eims, ' éhéi 2?:.;.3:3:hé.?~1'. E§;.?<§i:}:e:>::" <3? 11%}. wii% 0? 22{:<:§_:S@{% vizzﬂ Sh2mEs:'::3..z' < E}-$$ETizL§E_EZE*{§ 3:2}? i;:}"::'fr {§€;'f{ft;',£?.$€';°€§; zmé ::h::rs%a_f€{+r V€£:"iE§ éaiazgzzz :5 ":'-:§:::' ._s%:"z.1i§§f::;e* w;::'é.::::* E§::;i:r':}; ;::"2:::§ ségrag _§:r::sa§*:{é<?5; ii: é"E1<:é ::e;>:.:§d '§':m3~:

{}§'3§'ff {"33" '{'§i»%3'€T3 ;2'2";<'::":E,.E'::'--:-:3 §;:r§<_",z;° 2:; iiézié §§"E€i'§zf§{'.'.§§§', E213; i:§'é§{','f:=2§",§£i}E'L Ea;

Wi'1{;=,n. ~::;u2;.:':'e:§ fiflﬁ-}'L.?;s'3€:§. {}§"ICf3' aggairl, i:§1€: dszfeziaazti V:s%m.I*zaz12H:h i::{,€:ri?::re<i. Ai; %"}1.:*:f;. gxzsini; séf tirriszf, 'the ac::*:u$@{i E,E1zf€:21i;en<:<i V§S§m:21z:saE_E§. €,lf::«:;v7t Em arxmzici be €§G§1€ €12: :§e:%a€,E1. A::{:{§T::<;i:';r;giy, i:hi:% a{:<%u:se£i, 0:1 I3()..€I%§,2GO8 'i.o<::k £1116 éeiteézxsééki'"22é?£;-~--._.2§;"f_f:=f:;_v;:"<:'_ 5.80 pm. on {$13 pr€t:<=:x't', sf eati1'1g ggzsz i'37:;:'i'é:*;=.=f:'zr;%?;:':? Bhizlzélh river, 'The ac:<7'L:$ed {'.c;<}I~: 1:313 <:111b'»._1_yi:'1g;..52621;" 't,E3E;- é§g§'€:: "mid 2:sS21uE¥;:€& 0:1 the head {)5 '{'.11'&9 d_:;%{:€;1s-zad, gc«:>}iis,s9ev:i;;L2-si%:.:f;'{--w1upzzrx' whicllg the der::eaS€d fiséii z1;T2c<>n_$_:§i::s1:5;, The '2:{:{:u:~;_é}d flzimibiy €§§{'GV«f§1€:"fC1 the iii":C{}f1S{i§€){i£§% {i!ﬁ3?€.:f3:a':§';§:£§ iﬁﬁ. '§?'v'E},"{)€3E'S of Bhima :'1?v<--:1'°, <:<3;.'1:~3;€:=::;L2é-::";:é::"upaxz-"'ii?i3i3i;h," é;1*2.c éieijéased Vishwezneziih 305% 11is;VEIi'f{?§' V:":€:§<f1_":iz1j«r'._'i§i*ib<:iz1g; qL1e$t§e;mé:d by the fa'ﬁ1er <}§ é:h:;~.{£6932:E;;¢«ti_ a.'z:§{:E.Qihzér eiaiers-s in iihfi' Viiiage, this €é{Z'{_'3E3§:'>€:V'Ci_V€,'i{}§E 'u~':'iv's£§ §'f§..§53€f€i:I"€ ﬁ1ﬁH1 thaé: }'1E€;' has 9231155652 mayday <;ﬁ'_ E1319. éiegtij-6213535 by 'EV'§'E"'i'5{'i'§.{':§?", Ezim and drm5e"§:§.ng him in 8hi.ma '£:V'§'TS,-'ii'V':,"VIV".--. :'5E':{;%§.f,t§22a;§:'é,§:':°;_j.i,E':s: dead Eyeaiiy wem §"€3i"§i{1'='V€i'Ci ﬁ"(m*_a ﬁzé-:: 2"iv{::** 23-"éi:%1A »%:§'_::3; }1.a:§p5 j:?s§" P'i£-'JEQ 212:} {E fmf'i;h{;-.:" pr:><>e€--:£%£::g$ E:{><:~k §3§£TzC€-3,

332.. € E":g3 .:*::z;%21.:2w§':§E:%, <':{_>§*:":.pE2::.§:':§4 was; E:}c.§;§€{§ 'fgsy Eﬁﬁiffé 22$ _ ?E}:E§'{>m': 331%? Eéaf ?§E€§ E3'E%§ 'a:;%f:<3 :*<':g_;i$§:.a;:§2%{§ éihési EFC. "

<;:{:m;3E21.i':1i:. ami 3921?; HE12 €10 t:E:€: C<>L::'t:. C<3mp§aint wax:-; E<)dg€2£i at abaui; }2.§5 pm. cm. 0I.,}G.2C}G6¢ §}m"i:1g iihﬁi {:m,::"s2€: :>f i21v€s;':%,;g;e:f.i§:;:z1., iijhizr si.z1"£:em@m;s3 sf :'1:;v,:ur:'3?;;é:;j {sf wiéi:":€:ss;:=:~s i;1€r_Eu»:ii:1g eye w§i::'2&:&;%€;%; '£3.-'€f'§': zf::?l§§€§"rciéé'§§. e:;:'é_§_ itharggge Shﬁéii. vms £'i.E.€:::i.

3. {During thét €f€}uI'E%€3 :3? tria'E., "IE2:-:A.'pr€;S€'e::::'i.i:§1":""--..iﬁ'1.21.1} examined 3:?' w'§%.:2e5sss;3s,s 21$ pa':-ér"'--~E?.W1 is .marR;e:_"§, '£1611 exhibitig 2:53 ;";s£:.:' E:>~:s.PE {<3 P_1iGV:EiI'1€}v.f.hF€€"i":T££§i1€;Zff§£3;§ abjectsa as per N§Q-S. 1 13:} 3: Si: '7i3;«3.E221_§f'f.f:ff' ..;:?e€<::1{:é: one exhibit was markeei, zz§'<:»:*£€::1'G._{:'f.i€:s:i::£3.{§, '"I"':"§.:e1} Ceuri: an §'1€?é:11'i¥}§.§ V'g:;§;:1¢:E p§:§§':V€;i:3gV*§Ei'€ :1*:a'i.«:?ri2ii an r'<--:*+$m:'+CL (fem-*i{:i',eci ihi-3 &1{3CL§f:~'s€3d; £0i~--__§;§':%% {}f%'"_<:i';:3e~: p;:.1:'1is.ha1bie umiatr S$e:::ti<:::: 302 of

4. 'f":1<: --'§,}A.:*v::ss::3<i*%.;:.i.£<>¢:§ §."@ii.e{i apes': 'é'.h£--: 'i!&'E'S§{}ﬁE;% cf Ehzé 63}-'€? 2:s§i;:'2é:3§;€é§' i;~;;i:éf§§ 215:; éizszz "xx-'é."'i:§";;'-'~:«».§é.";'atE",2E~}<;~ <2? E:1*1<;*: w§f.::a%s;s§s;tss %.z,=-ﬂfm

--s;3<}§<:é';i:.E3é::_ﬁ:':§£3§"fsaa;i:': {3i?{3%.iEHSi.€iZ1C€S 21§._-;>;;1§:2-:z~3i, §:h::*: a.<:{:::s€:{§, AA "-§fE?'z§'s»;;.;§ zzmtii E3 Eégféi ?:'_E_3.&*. €;'"f:;»'%:'." E¥§'iii.":€T-fi°?3Sé;€S "€153 'ihé? i:'2_{:§{E§%:":'::. '-«.'§""éJ'fg;,Z§, 5%: é?i;§'l{§ §§ {§£*i§}{"}E§§f{'§ 2g§::s<> 21% £329 €:«.:€,:ra hf§'E,éé;"§§ijE}ZEZ!.?E. €fZ.}§'1§éf$$§{j§§'E 'E42;

E 'Ey,x/

- v.:,t§.c~::{:e2_ ix:

macie by the 2.:<':c:;::1s:;~;:?{§ bef<::*&% mxsem. L2Ta;:+;:: E:~'s€3€E'1 €:i1*<:?1.:.r:'1s£:a;'1{:<3 w'2~"z$ {i€p<}5t3{:i by i--""'»-Vii-:«.Ef.%, E} arlci 1 E, PW':-§,i E azfzci E3 d:Z';}§)(}$€Ci 2:2b<>:.x£. i:%1_:% zzimizrsé ami (}'€'§1€f famiiy :z":2z%:1'::@:"s~';. 3'£>}V2%.*-'Z:.:§1iT1.g in zgnarrel saiiit.

PW": iihéz-t §.'}s:::?;é<3:" vshc} <:iQ;:1{3mf:tz:€§""§*3'7é?}§;é€:.*;. "=f%;§far£,::::i'» ex2?:rr1i'nai:i<m. EZXPE is; the pos~;'i: ;:r1<'>rt.e;;*r:T ;*e;}€::f{i"~::;f1£i ma': (}p'iI1iOI} <){E';E'1«:_= E)0<:ti:or. '§'i€'£;é"~F}<)<ét<§':'* Ejazs <}pir:¢:'¢:E--V.¥:,?::éf:. this ' deziiﬁg is-ea €§{i{:'. is brim} .in}:__.::'j,-¥ E€2iV{ii:'§'ggE_:.{} .._ur1c:<>:'::sr,:§;::s'§; :§:<:1esS zmzi pa1:.*ma_.§iy dr<;WI1ing of 221%': vé-:%<:€t_21:%§:.éi=:§,'"<.§%§sf: E12155 aisx) {£epe:}seéi that ths: in} m°'i<:S z_1i"e_.2:11't<§€¥r:§{>if:.<2::1-.i::V :'::,i¥;z;%f'e, "i'h£:r-, Ps:::S'€'x {'\.§'£l:&::'3f%'§a=.s;':_V1':;. Vé;»:;ii':1:1'ia*£:i_c)n mp<>'r'*€, 2159 we}? as Ilka':

2"-:vic§e:'z<:s3 'E3§@{:%;:<}:*A -7'PWE ciazgzﬂy FQFJQQEES 'iheii ézhe *5=5d__}§:&",E§§ ::~su$é§'.g?;i.zf§.:~>s:1 :2 :2; 2 ::t;<:h iéué; inciigsaﬁéi 2,-mjzlzzzi (m. i:€r::r;;:s+:;.f:-:3"zzéiﬁi. Es.-'-rfi s;:?&:;%. it: iha {?F{}SS-ﬁixéiﬂiifiEifi§{}§"i ii is; ';>r:}:.gg;:{E':Mi: (mi; f'jE.%:§;:E: E'fh:=: a'§ea:=a§:E': 2?: hs:;m:i:;:§{i2:z.§ gyms amci 13:}? 2,?:.;:<f:.§:§e:%:w;:::::E;';. 's£§:"€::.;.:;a;E2y§ E:i§::€>:r:*-: §$ 33:3 <::?:21§§één§;'s;': E53 €,%1é*: €"«-'§{i¢E5§Ti{f{if <t;§'€,%.j:z';% E",'Z'3<:>:<%£T{2:a.' 2:': $3143? s:,**;f§::-?;:::'-1;«--zé:>;2?s:"::§:1_3;"§:.:Za:z:'L em :";:2:E'.%:':ria% 2:z§3§_}€:<:ri:se;. 'ljx

3. / W.» '2 PE¥§ hag depased that whiée ha had inﬁzzigeé in a,gri.c*a.1§'x::::*a} eperatiarzsg at about 5.38 p.;":L he a}4i:»3é§g._ wi.:§':

athsr agr£cu§tm'i$5t$ 3853: £116 aasused takirsg Vislrmranath near t.§1:=: zrivﬁr. Aftsr a§:>G:._1fi *£<i:f:"'i::ié:a1i€:$'_'A:ha:fA heard 336 Cries {sf tha dséjeasseé 1?ii4:hai}£é;5nﬁt}fi'x*. _ PW5 xxgmat with PW13 to t1r:ev'@E;;ﬁi'a:aijA ariﬁ f0x::1%:i.:€14:§:5""a;£éus€d'V beating the &e<:&a,$s36;.v ;---...fﬁ;§"":e;:*-"'"i:§§::- 'Q-s$32ﬁ§:;'~1:h,.€'§ accugeﬁ started ﬁrawning the déa<ﬁfe .3,lse;--é:;':.. --'i;§}€ river 'water. Gr; 'aging a$i§€§';f§;':;§:_: am Why' he was assaulting geceaaaé, the accusad hurriadijg-?"'ixé"e%.§%,v5. scena. In the crass» examinaﬁiafi that he ciid net :6}: ahaui tbs §n§%=T€_1;e:1i"i::V_fr£s::i eéf aﬁiher viﬁagera as ha was afraid sf £315 ass:-'£'::,:Sf*:::d."%~ is 'a%j§S:';» eia.riﬁed by him that thﬁre was Eess iarafar in ..§};f:§;§;i:'aT~_:4i'2;@:* 3: that point 3? time» §'\?':? '§§'3 hag aése §6§{1*S§§ in tha Same iriries ag ?W§a. Ea V' E"-333 _a§%;~:G dagmgﬁé ihai an hﬁaﬁng ii:h.@ wigs, ha went rzaar :§:§:$%: giazzg %.%5§*4:E': ?%%?% 323$ $31? $1? assugaé asaaziiiééig 5} E",//5:) «N3 the, c:k:»s;*:<:é:?as€:r<§ 21I"i{§ {i:*{>w::§z1§; him ss2i,:bé§€%qL1_e%:1t:Ey. '}f'1'1e rividenctvzs 0%' these {wt} <%:»;€;% wii,:1<:%s;-::~:<;%:s: is <:<}r:s;:isst.ez1£' 211153 <:{:\;_-__'§€::2€" zmd 1:236 §:':23;I'I'i€*. :25; f:"i.1$€} I'{i*.§iEib1iE*. '§'h€5:'e is ::;>ﬁ_1i:{;'g;;.V_<3:1 :"e{:{3:*d £10 ghaw thai; 816}; are UK? <:h2mc§~:-- '»'%:*4'1'T'i':f1"féiS§'E§:i2'.§§..' .Admit.ted1ye .PWs;,5 anci 13 'be10:":_gA"I g:} "

havizlggg iands §1€:e11°§:>y the §5€:€:'1€3: :"s::>f 1'§i>}TfEr:iE£>_. _ §€' E,i§1C;{}I1'iII1{H} in the. Viligage {.0 '§§1€§"'"{?$1'Li":if:3:};3€EEi}f'"{*;§Tff3":"E'i'JEE§"v. ' {hiring evsniizg f.§f}f}£'Sx E'v'I__<:»;'6<}&:'e:r...:1§§§":.h§':1g is si'u-ggegﬁed in {.116 >::r<3$$»«e:xamin21£.i0n €10 th%:.s€'- €;">';'.'-57 €163 Ciimbii E1136 xriarziciiy sf iari.€::1t%Ss<i.t~:, Iii") :m:as<>n as {.0 :,a:'§1y t3€1é;é:;:%;9..§£ii.1r:é?';§s;¢3,%§'~.§;§:<}z21d"'{§c:p0s€: falsehead Ei§§8.iI'1S§i Eihes a.<?::3ussé--r§ if ':}1{:'§.f E':é§iéi %*<;%a__"{:'E},: .:~:0i 866:1 éhe inciﬁa/1i;. fi. if, .iVS__:'1<:*.i§.v<:3*.VVé:3_1':1'Z,'. E:=.::s_ §;f;<>mz ms {2b$€'rvaE':i{>':§$ ma€E.é3 in .;&f5{?.€ii§E€ i3ffaz1{:<:: §§'2:.--:":{§_E"2a3.":2;:m21. 'E§':€ ;3a1.:1cha:1&ma as»; am}? as féjfzsa ;sl§§é3§.<.'Zr*; 2::35:;é:~.::jé{E {G E: :"s;%1?s3;2:}$ éhzzé, f::;%:<3 ':§0<:E§z wags; Eyi::g_}; an %;§"1:3'§:7;2::*zf§{&2. «:'>§5".'§f3i%: ':;::2§2§ §"§'i/'€;"f§'. g_~':---mw.«:> \ \'»J PW '%3 has de;:><:s$e€i flhéiii x>:;:21?;,€%r was; jlifsf. 2-35?: §<ne:i=€: Eevei. The éiiéad b{}("§§-' wzm: :*r3.n10'<..-yeci {man} i,}"2<--3 révsr wiiiilin 21 da}; iaf'£:<3r §<:s{i_g;;'.r°;§g the {::<}mp1a.mi.

§. Sr: Es;hwz1.i*e7sj Ch<3W:%2.>:§311z"k ie::;u:*:1ed .»:5§.mit:'us3 {i"':;xj:'ia3;<;2 sa,:bm.ﬁ:$ fé:E::;it iihe "J€I'SE§i{}£": traf {the eye; wi?:.n€s5;e:-*5_.<:.:1j:':1ii::€j~ z2;e:3c~<3,;3s€.'.£:(i% A{:C.<>:"d.i:1g E10 him, {he eviéerzsgﬁj 'eaf 'tii§;£>"£) _A wi*:n€ss5§€*:<3 £3 :*:<}m:':ra2'y {<3 {:18 r:1e<E§c2ﬂ;&xr£d_f§:r;£€:*,i ' '3 955-3 afQrem<3m.:1?<}z1t:é E115?» 'D.;_}cE;<;1f 31.21;; de§x:.3i§§éA:%:4_vEh::§1'; dizaéih is due is herad i:"2j'::z"y §e:%z1c¥i:'ig;:'<; .;3m:<ie:':s§§§§::1s§€3_€SS and piifiiélﬁéf j§?'I.;i*V''~«*»>'':£"£§1'iT1§a 473 "Sé§;'a3}:': :S""tI'i*':€~: §':'%J"i§€':}'.}{E€ Q? the eye 1ﬁ.?ii::1&:55$&€:s;'-. '§"'?E1»:%jy. 'TcE.;¢fp:;:ss3:i 'iihﬁi. éhiff aitcused cizms-3:253 haéad i.:a§a,§:f3% i'}j§5'?1Vi §1§Zi}T§ig;§ {:21 {lie %:ea.d Qf £11363 é~s';»::<3a.:§€d with {ha <§i'e.,:"E3, "7§'§:€:i:':>21I'€;<:r '£::he :1i{?;'i.€::$e<i f%}r(:1§b§}? iirezmissd the cisiiéezzsésti i:'i._.i,§2gA:. iég-<;*a'{:'%:.:M 9%" AV:F'3§1.§;1:a ri*;<3:*. §}:Zf}C{i' neiiheg" aha §§_§i.§".§§§;'E5 gm? ' éézéi ;<3::<:;snf:2"i<?~i'§. .{f'}{}§A";i§i&§§§}iEi{§ %ss;=:%;a::: €215 ;:=@:r ?<>Si: Eviarism E"{'3§}€}§""[',},, ' '"§;"§ Ef%h1%,?';(3;v?."ff{,§}§ Ch<;'we:ie:pL::", §s::.2m':z3;d Fzﬁiiiiiiﬁ C1§E"§3.é? $i.§bf'£'}§§'.S ""€._E'2';::,'E:" --é;?'.2.é%:"e::«:: a%:;:1$ 32:3 a::§V:a§"::':€ 3:? §§f;"?€iE'fE§;;*f~;z';":{"§ :§rs>2¥:':i:1§§ 3:2 311%: '_§'}::ttr:°z';~".= is; :':::€: :'-:%;a=22%'": 2-: S§.i§§;g§é?i--%§i.§£i}§'} §§"L%.E§{§€f 'ihif iL',§"{§Eé§§- <5xz:n:i11zit:§<:2':2 Gf the E)0c'§<>:' iii} find 02.11:, as {.0 w%1{:€.h£2:r "i..E:e §U.EE§§S or s*£:<):r:a:_f:h :25er<:: {nil {H5 xxsatezf or };'1{}f',. '"§'h£: de§e3:':<":e :~tsh::}uECE Ezavﬁ §§{)il§_'_§h{ §zxp}a'r2a1ti<3;:1 f:'::>r:1 thaé E}{3<:"£:{;r in that. re§;;ar£i. E11 the aibsééiizte {Ef 5-3'L:C:%1 a su§_§g,e$i:i(>:1., t;hi-s;vC€>'urE: €:a:m«:>i, ziccézpf. Eihiff s;~:«:2_1§:i $:::b:1:is;s5i::m {if the Ie211":1§f::§ ,§iiai:g::é;:.S Curiasa.

A3 2:f0rEI::enti<3m3d_ i",h§: ;)r{>s;%;é::?1::§:i9§: f7;';§'ﬂ'E€'§ :?§iEis:zd'-.V mpsn €?€E'€.é3iEE (T§f(?§lfi}S€)EiI1{)€S 'V"2:§1;:;»€:i'1 "'@xi:réj, jttdiciezi ::c;nfe$&;§;.{s1r1, E218: 538:1 the:§f3é_, m_'€}t.§V€:°-:%f£;C7'~S9me'ii§":1é 2¥.f"£,%::" {tbs 21cci€is::z'1t., V f}'9i<:' 1 .. %¢:<é(:a;;'§§€§'::1% "~.:§:':;2€i<: . £é:s%;i:1'a judicia} €??{>I"£f€fSS§.011 agzzirisi. P';%,3's;;.& a;§;.i_i~.§;«._ '§?W3 is 'iihﬁ: :%'aEh€:'~ir1--~Eax.%J af the Ei{?{i'i,iS€€§. i:E*;e:_V'f;*:f§15:§;3i"*.<:§.;"%h.s: {i€t{."Z€3aS€€§;., PW;e:;,8 amé § gm: .§..1"§;é'jiE§§'tf*E'§ C{€?.E§.§; "~:;.ri'z.::€5§S§{§éé{. 'i"h:'}ugh ihésiae wiinegses 'néwéi {§€;:-§:a§<§.%.;;ge{i' jilﬁiiiiéﬂ c{3:1§€sssi=:>n, ihﬁfﬁ £5; n{;i:%a§:zg b§<}z,:g§§z_E :>;:.'?:: é;hé:e iii'E'{}$E:§~i3X:E§§7§'i§E1Ei§li{}E"3 <3? ﬂT1€;'i§§*f %:v%§::1<%.ss2e€:$ is " : "f§.§3?}€3:.§€¥6"§.hf3$€if 1--V§.'é".§"E€fS%%§§€fS, I'€<>i war: 21 :~:ug>;gg<3&ei',i<>:_'2 is zmzds: :";:f2'..'i{é;.»=:'3..:%.:§pﬁ:7:%. £2?' €'3.}<L'i'.}"é':§. §2;.;{§:Z<t§z:E ::<;}§':€€$$i<}:izg E1x<"rs%§;§; §i§3¥'§:j,?§§'§§§; ,1 Lb.» 'é'="%<*--é:":{:i{E:i%:§é:E Zffiilé si::E,E"::as?::' s;1.:§;§;_g<%5gE:§{>:'2 £53: §:':22:é:%s::. E..

?'»?'£'ss,8 and 9 E222'~:.»*:3 EEIE-SE} degjziséd &'ibG"L1.'{ tfzeza last 8831} (Tf§¥'€?E1§7§1;§§§'££I3(?€f. .PW8 §i:.2::::; €.i€p::)S€d t;Ezz1:i: E363 szzw i:h{:: aiéfgiiésad gmd {he :§ec:€21é3<;2c:i gc:>'i:1g§ '§,{}§§;€'il}.'1€*F £i:::>w2m:is; tbs 'rivf:<x*--.é1i;.;§.béf;;iieA 5,38 pm: 89 the: <;*,a-=*i(i::m<:::t:% of PW9x The zfnazdé by the d€fm1Cé3 t.ha'é. '€i11t';'*§.:' hat: not S;§:er:..A:h§~3 'éck:t3;f.€%e1Sés:'§'~.g;:ﬁ>i.{1.g§ zxlagzg wiE.%1 the &'£{Tf{?1,£S{-Ed £3 ,prfQ1np'i11y"'d€:1§:3::§ w'§.§n&ss€s:=;, Tha p§'&':S€3I:{3:f3 cf §"%?\g'"$_€;% a.§:fé*;._ 9' n{;:ar that. par::i.<:'uE21r piace €1(:1;I}I}{}?; b€ §§{}i1E:?i1€§3v,.. "

P17'v'}.§ is ihtit .":.$.~""§f€;'-': £}'f7--i.--;:c§"Va{:*:é;:.sé<§E';v_ .ha$.~; 31¢}: onﬁy d€;3<)$if--3«;:E é;;b<>ui: 'i'h<s;~; §".§_1€3'E'i"if€E., "i§.;:£..22'Es<) dsrpaused abauféi ihe 33$':

Séééﬁfi «:::?z*::':«.:2"*::ss;taz":<:s;%._ .§E1{%:~'._A_€i'<:*.§:as€;si'§.§on ssha has s:»;i:..21%:,é:tc§ eﬁsaut :'é1:'.:*: §':":=:£§:..1a=3m'. :§*:,:zi:°':*%:Eé':1g§=,bjg2'~--'She ?:{?{.'?;IiS€{§ wiih {E29 {iec<--:&:sed _;>s,:3d h€:':*.ﬂp22§*:%:3€;§ 21:11:? V:_:»Eh.«:.?rr E3mi:h2t:°, Us ;3:°e&;su:*:1?$@ her fzzmﬁy §}f1€;",§ZE'§i3€j3*§."ES i,:;e.%m;:i§%:--;;;; mags: ﬂiiﬁiiéfy ;€':"«:3m §"i€':I' pezrerﬁzzé E":<):.:$sx E5:

§E":::%---w€:"aing§4:::;f€3"£§2:.£f;zi§.e:é {>5 51315:: §:':<?i:ie::z; £335 2:<:::'L::;<_;€:{§ €:{::<§;<: €.E:€: V ' e,{§§5<i:e;::::a;€'{% mi; 31%;: §;:°<:::é%x€' 0? {:g:i:_m;§' gazziarzi §'§*uE"§s;; Afi:€3,'z:' s:;;::f:$§é'z. 313:3? a;<7(t:.2 grzizizzzaa :"<*:i:2.2r:':%::{% 'Sis; :"E":s:t: E':{3:,.::<-;;::~?, ':%i"f::=:=§3 2:--ss}s;{3:{f% E35; I E PW} §;. égiher 21ce;?u.$e:t:i iﬁﬁki her €:hai, E}."i.{;% dezzzﬁasezi 11211:} 113$, a.<:c<m1p;;a:1iec§ him. 'i'E1<:: €'iVid.E?§1{§€'f {sf PW 1 1 Es»; xzeify mucth vital 1mde;%:* tihe f.21=::iss gmd €:.i.E'{:§,.:f:'EE;t:E}_.I}{jﬁﬁﬁ ifiélfﬁfiiiiéfh ass me: wiffté 91'" '£:.I'1e &i€:{'.'.EiS€*,(§. SE16 has; {iep<;se:{§ in .23. i'13f.'L1_:*§§l €9'21§gj'---i.i1é;.f;_?' . baiﬁzl £2516 {§E{'i€3é1S€{i and iih=t';i' 21¢:-c::.:ss€;><_Vi....'..>a.;'_£:~:":¥': j:,{ig»é:"t-Efiigri" 'i::'.£ih=si: €Vt'3E1§I'E§__§ and the 3.£:<:L:s€d aicyne czzinicé bigiciivk wife {1¥§?;'.h€3* a<:::*::.:$€<:i {iii} 119%: <:1'£»:3:§':~::';: €10 A§prQt5:ci' 313?§':f§;"'--»wTi;?'€"é de * my: find any art.if§CiaEii;y in her ci€:;:'rQ's;§.t,i{:2::, Q, in View of i:hi<é_ isf<}r.%3_:13;ézi:;--é.<;g:r1véé.% m1i::':§3eg:c:§1a¥3Ee é:':s.ri&€:7e<:*:3 :}f§";" ":'ss:€;';.~.oz*ci§'iffV ?}1;s:a_ "i'3"i21£WC<}:u;§"*( £3 jus«3£:ifi@d in C<3;":c:§':1<:£i_:":g_;'Rfﬁzai --%".h€"r A:_}j';ff:1*€;,=§;«éis:?';:7t~i:i:::»:1 has ;33"{}*-;<:<'§ the casgf: bey<>:1<:§.,:{:;1s{§§;:;bEe .'--d{::.:fé%.. Tifazis €m1'rf:,§ <:.=:"a-Yen an ' E"€é£§Zr§}}T'4iii{'ﬁV§i:7:%€Zi~Zf>§"i""Gff iihés Vi%3'éi€,e:r§a§ an §"{iC{}§"C§ fuéljggz <:{:n{?urs; :.v§'£,h. ihé-:2...:*{%;:S:;:§§§=..;a.$séi§:::%5{§ %:Eﬁ€§. the €a:§{:£_::;:3§<}z1$ reachgsd by ihzfi ' {ﬁ{m:°':. =..§f;:::E.{}.w A'§"%1e:=. §:2»'§{§e:2£':::*. =32" iihaé €?;"t;-£6": '§i7i§ZE1.i;T§§.ES€fE§ is " If'{t<:r:f:»2:§$§;{3:3€,;v... "g::>§,T€§'2.£'. and 1"s3§iecSi:;£€:§ E9-'§{i{3:1<":é:% sf the 6376 %;*;§E:'2:s%;$$%aé; §z:riiZ?1_<--:':" a3::>r2°{>E::<>;'2.:.i?;mi E3}; €:E:e.::*. {::'r:::;§:':&;?i;.zi,::i;"§8;§ €1»'i€i€:'Z(';€': srrmrh as r;':'.'X'E.§"2?z _ju<i§<'ria.E éiE{}I1f%3SS§{)I'§q 13.3%. fv§€i{EE".l 'i.%1<;%ory anzii Izzcﬁiwa.

18, E~§'aviI1gg reg§;;1:*d ':30 the meﬁerial 0:": 1"€'(?(JE'{i, 1:E1§5 imiy <::(3m:E1.::e;§()r: 'E.hz1'i' cram be '1*@21<:I1ed is 81211: the p':*c:3$5é:a(::1.:;i'§;;§';**1_hag §r::3v€<:§ its czzsssfi bejz<m::i I"€:'€if5{}E§£ibE'€:' aiotxbii _. ;5;g21§f:i*:3:§i:" ~ ;:1€i{f"iiS{:*.d 'far the Gifﬁilix-': punifshabifsr.;':;;:"1.<*i§~2r E§e(":i§i'(}:i»f3Q2 {PCV. VV Hengts, the eippezﬁ fé1.ﬁS3 211/1d this $z1m7r': $i:2m;é:i$ a'§$fni»s3§e@:;_,,._.A' . The Cami; piaézeszs {>11 1*e<:cQj'ti~~..éi:h€ "assis3§;z1:a2€é*:; i*%::'::ii{:~:"*e3n:§" ':35; Sr}: Eaixwaraij ChGwda§=',=:;a°, Ecgxfigegi-A1n§<3:1s C'm'ies;:3 Eiiid hi»:

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court