North Karnataka School Of Nursing vs The Karnataka Nursing Council on 29 July, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

North Karnataka School Of Nursing vs The Karnataka Nursing Council on 29 July, 2010

Bench: A.N.Venugopala Gowda

 » '}~u\s1i€?iA 1§A1_RwA D/O TOT/\ RAM

V ISREJV MORAN 5/0 HAE\1E.:'M/\1\?

IN THE HIGH COURT 0;? }<;x;2NAT.z\I<A,
(:1R('L.:H' B1'~3Nc.'H AT G1;1-BA_RGA
DATED was THE 29"' DAY JLJLY. 2.010

BEEFORE

HON' 131,13 MR. 3LESTiCE A.N.vE.NUGoPA1.-_A.€§_0w1§g%g~ L"

WP NO 324 £2~a2::52 oi::§k)1()'§':::i).gAp)-I' --  '

BETWEEN

2. NORTH KARNATAKA sc::{o(>1. 01%'  
AKKAMA}~fAE)I'.EVIC()LON'Y '  '  L 
BEEHIND SAMSKAR BLII!._l)I'N('3'- V
B11)/\R    _ 
R_EPR1+;sENTL:1>.a--3y mi 1>R1§NC1pA1:.,: < Z
sMT1AYA1_.AiXMi;:;.L.-  =   ' _ 

my srg./srién ; 1w,A'1V}gEa;'MII<"::;§-'A/"1T'r:1{.fvIi)   '

 

ASHA' Nri':£aN2x. 1)xc>"1</\R"m5E':;"\:A
Age,:26 Y1£AREJ .,  .4  .
N()RZI'H :<.AIzNA*r.xs;1<A'r;CHc;3Q1;--or NURSING
AKKE» M/u~1A1)12s:v1'c'(3m1--~:y   
BE{HIND._-SAMSKAVR B"U'I'I..l_)11"\?_(} '

BIDAR  . .  
!?IfiT1T1()NIE3RS._'2 TO .221 AE%£.!E3STUI)Y1N(} IN 1

, .x;:j:a:A:{'m_I>1_.oMmsq EN NU]?1SIN(i

{Q

_  .Agc:v33"'{.I7i'A_RSV ._
 NORfI'H_K}\ !T<'§\ Aj:A:<A SC.'H()()L 01'? NURSING
' .._A;<r<A«;\«1_n.__L:'A;s';;::V: C(')I..,(I)NY
V 131=~:HIN13 's;A:-v;;.s*1</\R 13u11__1'>1:\:<.;
"~I3I1)z}.'R' . 

AA : Age: 18 YEARS
. ':*€0R"E"1~i K:\R.NA'I'AKA SCH()()I... 01-= NURSING
'  ;?;'§<§<:\MAH'A1)1"iV! (:01 ONY
BE}-{IND SAEVISKAR I3{.F1i..,I,)EN(i
!-3![):'\R



6.

9.

('J

8H,.-AV I3,»'\H{WA I)/0 SR1 BRIJU] AL I3;=\EI{\-'Wk
:'\ge:-27 YEARS

NORTH K:'\Rs\§:'\T.-'\K;'7\ SCfH()OI.... O1" a'\'{.7RSIf\E(}
x\KK;\E\--*IAHAI)l3VI CIOLONY

13I'i}'£I'E\5I) SAEX-1SKAI{ Bl..7ILI)l.=\3€}

BIDAR

I)L'RI{A§\5I 1\;1Ls1:)Ass112 KHAN sxo 15;:vr.;x11.. I<.HAN
.1\g.;<::23 Y}?/\RS .:   .
NORTH KA1{NATAKASCI-I0()I.(I)I-9§\E1,ER§~)II\é(} ' ., "
Axmzx-1AL1A£)1=:\-'1 CO1 .ONY  T . 
BEHIND SAMSKAR BL§ILDIN(} 5

BIDAR

DIEEVRAJ G()JEiR. S/O RAM 9001.. c}(_)J":-L13 .

,-'\g:::2() YEARS  
NORTH KARNAMKA S(','HO()I._ ()I::=~N'U}2.S1N(1}"-» _
AKKA§\'iAi~{A£)EVI C.()1..,(')NY" .. ' " . . 
BI-;Iw1IN'1) SAMSKAR 13U11T41j1?~:(';..

BIDAR 

GHAN SHYAM {NAN IYALS/(3 13 A1; 1,)I;v'.s>;1z«A  INANIYA
Agc:33 YEARS  2 1%  ' AV  
NORTH 1<_;/x';a!\'AT'A_K.;i. s'(?H0_()'1.._()I'i= r_eL2R:;1N(;.
AKKA.M,-".HAI;}1., /,1 c0mN'Y.j'-- *  

BEHIN1) sAMs'KA_1§ BU3LD1N'G.

14.!-\7I\.ES12;:\E\-i v(){;+ "S-10 VS*£EEV'vAR'A.M" YOCiI
Age:§:()YE£A]{S--    
N()RTH..KA~RNA?.AK'A ;~;<;i;»«EL*>_(>1;()Er 1\E'URSING
AKKAM}'\--HADI:'VI -f__?()'1i._{):\"Y._ 

A311:-HI'N1) sA;A.sKA.R'BLI1';.1)1:x:G

.. 4311)/\'}??

A m'1:«:':~z1';R_A* MH/XVAR 5.;/0 RAVI KISHAN KILI
" -V Age-">;§~Y1'-L<\I2E~: ..

 N(:».1_{':*1..+_1 1'<AR.w;.mKA S(.'.H()()L 01: NURSI.N(}
--.V:xKK.»a_w\2ivAH;x;51év1 C()1._O;\'Y

B1-31-{IND L:~;;3 ;'\7ESKAR BL'IIL,1.")1N(}

 13113,__;x"R -. 

Ki<.:$I%NA KUMAR R S;/0 SHs\MBU 13mm, 12

s  ;xge;"1<) YEARS
"~N()R'1"E~1 KARNACFAKA SC,'.H()(')I. (:31: NURs:;1N(;
~;i\KK/\3\/1.»'\ H.-m1::::v1 (n'(4)1..n(.):\€\"

B15iE"~IINI.'.} S:'\3\'§SK.-*\R B UH DI NE":
1311.)'-'\R



I6.

V1 7. 

MISS. KA§\"§I3AE-'A'I"I §\'A(§ARA.§I'ESV'v'AI{} E)/'0 N-'E1TEE{.-=\I .E
Agezlﬁ YPEARS

NORTH KAE{:\EA'l'.=\K.r\ .'SCHO01,.()I" RSE\'(i
AKKz\MH.-*xI)}?i\z'1 ('(Z)L(')?\'=Y

B}~Z!~fE;\§D S.r\MSK;'\R B£§11...DET\:'(3

BIDAR

MISS. IAKSHIMI B;\11zw;\ E')/() Hz\RH.A1..,. BAERWA
 YEARS   
N(i)RTH KARNATAKA sCH0()1, 01? N'URs:{;\*(; '
AKKAM./\1«E'AD}'ZVI ('()I_ONY  
BIEHENI) SA§\-"{SKz'\R BE,EII..1f)EN(3

BIDAR

MUKESH KB. S/O BAS{jE..A1., B.

Age:f.',3 YEARS  
NORTH KARNATAKA SCTHLKDL ()E.AN'UR'S1N(} ""
AKKAMAHADE\«"I (ﬁ7()i..OI\'-.Y V 2. '
BEHIND SAMSKAR BU£L.1)iNG ' A

BIDAR '- V

MANESH KEJMA 2-1 as/(1 JACAEDISH 'ERAS/'\D' -- .. '
Age:2.z1 Y17i/\RS~2 7' '  1%  ' _ 
N'()RTH' K,e~.«:<r<2*;xTA..1g.eg.s;CH(:«Q1.;;.()1-= 1~-:_m2_s:;\:c} ,
AKKA;\/IA"!-IAi)_.iji"V1   
BEHIND SAMSK,'=£R.VI3UIE.I)'§N(3'. 3
I3EDAR""'~. " "51;  

NIOHED ';/\'f>'/-'..[}[H';i':}*,, {C-) UH h/'JD 'ULL/\ S
Age:2@'.YE€:AI{S - ' ~ A ~V   
NORTH"K:5\RN}\TL'\K/'X' $CljI.CIQL OF NURSING
AKKAMAHAIJVEEVI COLONY'  

BIEHTND S/\1'\/'.$'K}-XR BUH.;-DING

, BIDAR

A MA1;}:}:2:H §\ﬂ31£NA S/O HANUM/\;\' MEZENA
" Age.=i_8 "~{En__RSv .,

_ . Noamgj_éK;'=,Rr;Af:.:AKA SC1--I0O1., 01'-2' NURSING
' =x_\KKAM_A H.z\1;>1:v£' (.'()1,()NY

Eli-ZHEND SAMSKAEQ BU11.1)1N(Ii

"'««1.31:j_).A,_i2' . 

av;/7\:.x11s;3H K.A. 55/0 ASE-{OK K.'-\.

' :  Age:2?1 Yli/'\RS

NORTH KA 1{E.\§A'E'z'\KA SC.H()C)L O1' NURSING

"  A-;}<.K:\%\r'§z\I~1A£)E.£\2'I <:om:\:\:

BE'iH'I§\$D SAMSKAR B€E.I...-E)E'E'<'U
BIIDA R



!9.

'20.

Ix.)
Tx.)

Ix)
-327.

ix}
.» '--_J-E

I\.?IR;'\-1A},  SEO IT'R.»'\B}*lLE 

Agc:;ES YEARS

NOEQTPI KARNA'TAK.~'\ SCHO(.)I .. OI' NE.'a'RSIN('i
AKKs\MAl--i.M7)EVl C,'.(')I UN Y

IE1-'~i¥~!i.?'~.'1T) S;-\;\=1SKAE2 BEfE1.I)I}\E(}

I'3E1)AR

OM E?RAK.ASH SHs\R.E\-'E,«*\ Sm R.:xM 131z__-A._s' SHARMA
Age:24 'r'EARS   
NORT}--I KARNAT./\KA SCH()OL 01--' NL3RE:.iN(? '
I-'\.KKA1V1.%\}L=ﬁ..I)I?-i.VI (:0: ,()NY  w
BEHIND SAMSKAR :'sU1iT,1>1N<:;

BIDAR

PRAKASH CHANDRA M. 5/0 N;(m1';;.-.;. 
Age:28 YEARS  
N(')R"1"}~i KARNATAKA S(,Ti'-EOOE, cu-2:'VN'L.s12s'1N<;"-»_
AK§<AMAHADEVI c0L(i);\_1y' «. ' "  V '
BEHIND SAMSKAR 1sU:1_1)':r:<c3-.

BIDAR ~.

3PA\?VA1\E C}-lO.U{)AH'AR_Y 31:01>1;'AE«1z../'xi;'R0\ri_(i 7
Age:2&YIEZAR_S   =.  * _ 
NORTH K._=\PN{\".E':'.xK._21 s'c'.H0_(>%:',.__<)}'-' §_¢L;1_<;:'~:1N(;

AKKAM25 H;\1_.>1¢w1 'C'(_}i...()N"':7._':"- , _ V.
1313; IN) SA.1v£s%<;!3Iz 13U¥1n.D1N(;_' ..
    

RAW P1~.'.AK_-{\SH.S)-S/(FE3/EA~}:i{§S«1_:-I §'~CUMAR 
Ageﬂi-55 YEARS.    
N()R"m_KA1a.:\=M=AK;.« 's:t_H<>_o1; Cw NURSING
AKK./\§\/1/3} .HA1)I€\z'i c<>I;()N»\f_ 

BE3HI'NI) sAM_s1<;xR'--BLm.1)1Nc;

,, ._31E)m2

1>AMI~;EsH 1<I;M_AR M. 3/0 BAI)R.E.1.AI, KOLE
' " ..;\ge:,_22' ~YI'1AI{E3 __
 Ni?-R'i§}a_1 K!\RE$IA TAKA S€'H0O1_ ()9 NLJRSINU
' ._;xKK.A.MAI+m,1')I5VI (i(I)1..,(')NY

'13:=-.H1:\:1')' IVESKAR BU'11,I)IN('.i

'*-4.._13}i)_;xR , 

1<AMi~;R.1} S}«I/\R§\/EA Sm 13.1. SHARMA
Ag'c:"I' H 'r'If_iARS

V  '*N(.')RT}-I KARNATA KA S(.THO(_)1,. 01' RSINU
.AKKANL-\H.ADI*5iVE (_'()1.()NY

B}.iE--IE';\'I) S:'\'i\---'ESK/\R 13 UI1.I.)IN(.'i
131 DAR



36,

29.

30.

31:.

RAMI3":SH ('E--IAE\EE) S/O KAELAS H (.'ITi.~'\Ni)
;\ge:2S YI:'.AI'{S

N'-(')RTI~1 KARN:\T:'\KA S( 21-1001. 01"' NURSI§\EC.i
:\E<K.r\Z\.-1;-\TT£AI)I1VE (_..'(.)I ,.();\'Y

BI33ZHINi.) S./\?v§SK1\R I3L§iI.I)IN('.}

BEIDAR

i{A.IE§.ZSPi K{.MAE< S/() MAIf)AI\ELAIN K{.?':\-'IAR
Agc:2E YIiAI{S 

;\'ORTH K.=XI{NA"£1»~\KA S(_'}£()()L 0:: .\IU'Rs{1'N(;  ' «

AK.KAE\-'§:\I"'IAI')E€\fE (7()I__O§\3Y
BIEHiNE) SAEVESKAR BUI§.._I',)IN(i
BTIDAR

SUNITA !<;UIvIAR M. E)/0 12A<}r1L:\'}§i::«R}::':NGH '-

/\ge:24 Y1€ARS  
NORTH KARNATA KA sCH.(_)()1 .. (>Is.\'€I2$':N( ;*-» _
AKKAMAHAi3If:"Vi c1(:>a,m__1<\5"~.. '  .. . '
B1i~1HIND SAMSKAR I-3U11T.1)i:<:(;-- A

BHJAR '-

SHIVKU'MAR_C~.:   I3I}fAI§.:E
Agc:18Y1-EARS  - 

NORTH K..xR:k:AT;:V_1< A s'L't.L.:ii)__c_)L..g>11?m,::is;IN<:, 

AKKA_1v1:>3 HA1;;1i;\z: (:01. .()NYf -- V~ A
ms-.H1NI) smyas-Iz./1\;_1<» i3Ufi.1)1I\EC§. ~
BEDAR"    
S./-\I.LMA 'SB;/\NU  'I>£{)'ABI3%{_§1
Age;:>;<)Y1I€.ARs--    
N()RTHv._KAR;\§A'F;AK'2'-. AS(.'_PIOOI.; 011: NURSING
AKKAM/\--HAl)EIZVI c:()i:_:)N\.{_ 

I,3EHiND SAMSKAR 'BUILEDENG

. "1~1.AMI'{;ii'jI) K.

, BI DAR

A S£\R1K;'~. 1v1;=1_>/c) BABUAE, B M.
" --.Agc:.1V9'¥I=-amés .,

 N(',R_"i H 1<A:<N.A_jmKA S('H()(')E.., or NURSING
' -.AKKA.VI'AH}'d.')i€VE. C'()i.().\EY

BIiHIN'D ;:;;«_*;=~«:"s1<,»\1z 13 [Hi DINC3

"~«..13I1');;f;R' . 

sH::.e1=a:?%: (TI-{AND S/(T) J/\(i§3\x§AL RAM

' I  Ag:::2'E YEARS
";°'»EORTH K./\R:\'A".FAK/\ SCHOOL OF NURSING

V' -- . .;g1<I<.A.Max:-1A1)1:_;v1 C()i,()a\}Y

BI.{I'{INEZ) SAMSKAR E3 {III .E)E;\!G
BIDAR



9

petitioners 2 to 41 for the first: year GNM course and to
direct. the  Jondent not to insist: t:he eti'ti_'o1i"e1*."vv,to

produce the siiitjability eerti.ﬁcate.  e'

2. Sri. Shivarudra. the learned st*andii1g"~VcouI1seiit

appearing for the respondent would subimitpthat siri-Q6

first petitioner institutiori has not complied the and conditions prescribedin the :no.tificat.io_n {annexure~B], the responder1_;t"1':«as' taker: t:~1~ie't:]e'ci_i'=~i.o1_f_i_fr1ot to approve the list of st.uderits;.:"_,. V" ' 3f eeee ""O.riifcon'§}i'deration ohfthe material on record, the first petitior1er----ir1stittiti.oi'i...éhas made admission of the students baesedv 0.-:1".'--the. provisional permission accorded by ""the"-Creovfernment of";K;arr1ataka as per ar1nexure--A and as per'_e.?:ahc_Iiiotification of the responderit. as at am1eXure--B. A Vexpiamiriation. ,4'.

/fhAe»..4_'sttider_it:sAie [petitioners 2 to 41) hive to take the R approve the list of students visa, petitioners 2 to 41 of the first petitioner's nursing school for the first year G.N.M. course without insisting upon the first petitioner to obtairig*'.Vg:"'the suitability certificate under the Council Act 1947.

that, when the petitio;rie'i*s'_d:2..vt'o_ 411 -- the GNM course frofii first 'petiti-or~i.er'su institution gtfter'co'n1p1eti'ng their the' respondent shall an eiitiorsement to the effect that ,_p€titiQners 41 areentitled to be registered 'nurse, midwife, au>tili:ary~ntirs--e--'rijidvvifexg only in the State of __i:i~1:th._eV certificate to be issued to uncertainty with regard to the approval of the list of "student_sf 15*" petitioner's nursing school for first year GNM course by the f respondent and the same is recurring year "~.:_;'ialfterfgyear, the first petitioner may not be if A the feasibility/suitability certificate or . provisional. approval for admissions to the first " year GNM course for the next academic year 2010-2011 onwards, unless the 15>' petitioner ./T x However. . clear.

fulfils the relevant terms and eor1dit.ion_s_ and the required infrastructure.

Sri. Shivarudra, Advocate for re:--;':;5onde11"'t."r permitted to file his memo of appe'éi'ranee*'_' ff)? respondent within two weeks from Ordered accordingly.

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court