Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Customs vs M/S Symphony Services Corporation ... on 3 August, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
IN THE HIGH COURT ma' Eifi.1%?A'1'AE§2§ air E}a'i<'rr:'§ Ehise; {Exit 3"" day <}§'z%zT:_g1,:s§.¢ ;"3;E}3§§. "
?R§$§N@~~-
THE }{C}N'BLE Ii-1RM}'I.;1*S»":i*I_Cf'*.:i*T; i\2; z:tm A' R, ~. " A T 1l<~«,;:**-?ff3*'~.
'ma HONBLE M31; JUs'r:i:_E Ivnmaxmésrfi c:s*:'::; V;:%:' :&'}=:%. _ B£'~:'§'Vv'EEEZN:
"1'h:=:: Com:}'1i§'sS§.<>_;-$23.3' .(}L§: "€324: éli.-§3"fi:1S:: . if R §31Ji§€§f1§§E3., §1.:at':%;~::1s,--VR0_;;;§L ' " V __ a __ -- .
§;32r;.r1§;f;zI0;%:E /._56{F.Q§EA,f,, mA;.)§:é:E.EE::m €E)3{~.,._=* §%':13€:, ;f£é:s;§é<3<?E21. 5%: Eéri N E%?; E?-3'§1;;:::~:§:2:::".
" ;'%{§v<}<*.;zE.=333} ?v'i 523;'w':'§:fi"§'i_§}.}3fé§'}§'§ 3; §§»5:'?E"E-'§{'E€'ffS> C{):";jj;<>.z":%.'s'.i<:=:1; Ezdizi E-"xi."
;%§}.-?':'1';§}E'::3':'2§* "E 'c{7?::':<3§«:s;§§ €'fi{~,;':§ at? V ' ~.i\f<_':x E . " ?a;E_9:;;r;3;%;£': §{<:}2::<% 7-'?";§é:.;:7§i5t§{§ E%s)a{:§ . V' ' -- §~é'¢:2;<.:~<§: 'éfliézza _ §§.2T:.r:§_§zTa§<'}§'s§. ~ f?§€?§{} €}i§:3 .i.Rii3f€§§{}§'E{E{f§TL. n-r4'€<W \ {B}!-' Sr: £,,;;1Ee«:s;E1:':z:' .E{:.::'1';a:"2"::': ééz 'J. $i"ii:i_11éé':'2-:«%.:' --- " ;. fa<"lz=<:(::z'1§.:e:+s} ' "
'E'1:1.1.::s C3;'E3".£'£'a f1Zic:":*d uzzdez' S:%3€{?{*E<}E'.'5 §§§{}{i}H€:'f"--:EL' E'u'?I,, 1. §%€52 a1:"i3§:1_g; <;m'{ £2? azrrdtkz" {I§2?L'i"€.;d Bi}? --~;i3C'=.{}E} 3);' "£:?:§._LL.§:z":§Eé2?s.E cszrczer gm as: ?4;:;:{>09 in ;'%;;';~.;3c>é2_E T £i,5E§:w;2*aQ';z..& {Z;'2'£§é~§,f'2{}O8 p:'a1yi:'1;,I3; {.0 ii} f<>'s"':1:2,2i2.:.£€,'--AE.Ei:*s ::;L.:bs.~:--i-j:,2.'xf:1ii2;2§1. q}.z€$%;:e:§§:7 of .}3;w :;~r.i2=1'i<?{i i;,I'1er<;:i1'1; {ii} sci 'é___<i;§"a:1;is :'.h:;*="a:>1fc:«;>.:f »:§;1i4€i£i_ '3V{}V--€2E«Q0933 §32?a$s:;>:e:§ 2:"; .E*'i:';a.I ardesr N(}973"""£'iI'i(»§ ?'4f§.4?.f3.99 in 2?'fx§31:3e:2:} f'~€:3:~;;¢ C,/5.18/_i2.G{}7 & €If2QE}%,f2G{F8 E-?::?~:1.&:»:,+.%3:<3,'=¥::J}f CE§S7§Z%f.E",AV.'S0u;E.§'3 Z:):'1.@ B%';'f1'1(l'"fh, E3323u'1§;21Ic}2fi:%. " " A V "E"°E3.i5::: (ESTA <é<}_1zéi:1g'. V<>:": f'<§:' _.£T£_;é3;:~. Ef:_':;%21:'ir;g;§ th.i.s <§:_~1:.,--'-'.; N. KUMAR J3, {if;.=:E§v<%::{:e;i"£»E:«§%' f{:='iE§§w.ig':§_€: .. '?f'§';&,= :*a=%:?-*»:;%{e:j;11§é Ef§V£?i3.-S"'§§'17i?§.1i'§'fI'€'t{§ €:h:':+ a7g.:%§3»{;%z7:.E <':§12z.E.¥&:2'":s.r_{§:2{._% 33$ IR :};'{Es3:' p21':3::a§r3i:i E33? .EAE'%f:3 '§7':°:€§:=..;i*:::{E" u»'1'1i(?§: §"i£?§£§§ §,E;:2€z:" 'E.§1é% <7:21$e (3? '$35 2z$s;es.<_r.$e §a§§E=;=.'r; 1,:':'1<Iit33." S{:<é:.;€%>3': 23 {X figs? {i'z.x5==;im'z"e;s:-a z7%.r:%:, §.9iEi<f»i §E'<_2:"
.:=s§'2G-:fi£ 'ha?-::é;%i.:v2;::f2;.é:=r':' r€%§'é:%':%"é"::<E 'En as"; "E..¥.":::% A:;:£_'} .::;:n.:% §'I?E%£?§°€?§.;Zf}3"f;?,_ ':..E":{:r V"-§%<:*E':e:'éfi;'.:;: 'T%'§é;t:j:; é.:::':;'3<';;'§.<:::§ {..?{:':§'§Ié.ZiE2 :;r§:;::i.;;}:1:z'":=:1i.'s=; .f'<";:* z:5:;<:= 52:: é.E":s:%i.r 3'E'E'1<: 2};:rjé:"-3E.'.S§:'r}§5;Tf€* .22. ;'T%3'E"}'}'-E2 iméi <;;a::::'§§.i:':g; 2,2:'*;.:%s;%r EEQEE E E? <;?:::.$ifi:<.:2§s§ j i.%":€: i.<>w:;é:" 221.z£.':m:"i%'.i<=7s; 25:116. i"%':c:%1'i?i'1=:>I":;?, ii s.~;t*rE 2:1E:':$§.(."§§€?. ~iii.-é? '-«<j2:*r:§e:'5:; §}a:$%s:&~;€:a:i. "£33; £232? Es:;2w<-:%:* z::z€E1{22"iE',é€'.::§ .21;<':{i g;_§1"2::z'1£"fici§ :"::::j:'%:*;%+3:;§;§';".:'vxi)? 2.1%: agrom 8:11p}:-1§,f;.*,{i u.z':{i::é:' S&%<"Ié<,:1'1 23 %1iC:;}:1_e Rafi. E'; _:
§§£3.ET§€i'.., f:§:<;: 3'<*m3z':':.:c% in ;1;};.3t:2-ii.
5. L. %au":2é::{§. z".~0L.1:1:+;e§ f°§}'_£_"VV"»vi;.v}.1€.'."~._V'£"é3':Vé?'I'£"é;.E{§ ;31s$a1iIi:'1g 'ihfi?
i.§1:2pL1;_;1:1c>(i mrdrstg' £3€)f'l'i,€?ETi'1Z§.t'3;j§' AiE'_t21E,{_ ' §'Ei{';{.:gf1"~i1§/:3 :"§12;i3(}:°'i;e«:1. gaésds-3 "€,-K---"Q'*:1"':':*. a;i21I1'1:agg;&%d (.3152. 2:;{:::<3:,1';';:;. .5? SE§€'3f§.E§§.g§';?.Vv€§§w. '1'§ii!I]; \.x.:a'E'.€ér, ii: is 2-'LSSf;ES;'3,=fi':€:T uéiiagy :~.}1.E-3.f§3:7 i.{} 33:15-'r. §L3:1--.fr':E§?f}€':3C.i Em" 5:--:§r;E.{%'f": :2é::;;§E%g%3:'*:'£. anti. The:
:1s;s3&%:;5s€<% éiiezi 'E-1:';:'%§' EI.'i1'=i£';<_ j§3:f'<;;'> €{':" pie: *.2'-u41'£,iv;ms £10 ;'3m{.es::i_. {he i;":;§>0§:'é_i;:t§ __:s.:$<:ai:?: EfE1%c3a:.:g%;A 'Es'; ihfi bmsmi €X{"f¢1"?E.1.?:l€{i me £:?.&3E%3€;',E:3S{'.{ff :,2:1{.i=2;%2"E,{;>{§1;_ ti; £2-a }az=:_ é1§§ p{>$~. __ E33363 ('E-ii'? E0 p:"<i<$<:m.fe 21:34:? p:"{:€,.@{:E E":.§":{:
z?:.'3':§::,)A;"2<$r'E :g:{<'1<_::»<.Es5;. "'3;f3ndE~=.r' §h€,'éft=§i'* {',§§°€".§.i'{¥}f§§§'i1'§{"i€"f4§. "Em" {':;'-;s=;<'*é '§';'=;§§s% "'iI_'3.E.L€'.§\i'jf£' $}"?'é~:'€..iVé::.:s'1. 22 G5 the 2-'~X{&é. amci méé. -%e{j:%.i0:1 23 9.? the': faéfi. 2:239
--..?'i::>.E_€% 'i;3,a*_"'i'lf:€t< 'E'7i'vf§'E_i:'a.::':;2:1 arivzji £':§':%:%:'e£'%,>:'<%, :é;E'm :;::§3:":':i';':.:%; 2;; {:zrz:~5{: féféz' " 3:¢«f'z,.2{g;.§.';s>z"'ié%€'§ I:'E':<% §3'i1§}i.§§£:'1€:'f€§% <';:*:i§<~t::: gi é":2i':%;:f:"'§'€¢:~<::'1§'': " f:~s 3'E1&3.(.i:'.-E E;-.-§E.}_E:x €:3f" §5?':::<:' {_'i}E'}§§§"2'i; 'fizz: §tf;iE"E'}€?{'§ {f?{f}%'zE'Ef-Sfiii §'<..':s§* 'ihté a,:¥=;:%<?é5s:ae:? "'{%\:{".' :1 _' by 'L-?._§1{-5 ' "$25 Abatement af duty an damag£,?d§_ z:V*r§_;:fL"V.L' deferiorated goods.» 5' Z;
'ifix'f'2@ré.> {E ';<=;§'?:i:Q.;€:'2 'M ii} {me s;c:£z'.:,j}b:z:{.ic):'z. 53;" :'?h.e As:s§s.tr:zz'2:__{§<>1'2';i7i§é;§é5%:f29z"::5f' . {fz:z;:-3:213 er I;3e,=pz.zzg4; (7:12:'2'::7'z:5»;5:£é2':'z<;ezj z:g__;" €iifzz;<+:£z;¥:rzs:~. {(2} 5'???
that any' ziIz'1§;2:>r°I.a;>:T;3._ $i:i:;;_:)ds ?'é;:_1:ff' *?35;>er'§:_' " darr'z.a§;:n:Z Gr {§é'f%f?§{}?':i§é¥€§_ é1..i'_ ":;,:*:g;' mime I'}£jf7(3§":';? er »éf:;rz';'?g 2':-fie 'z.:s:Z%25zd.€.;f%1g Qf {:'f'z:=,> ggijcizfis f?"£ §?i.(§,§A0'; ,{}."' ma! ari§;_T ':z71I;3::2§'i4§;%€i _gi}€;«_{}5§:§; -.<>?:f'z.er {ham .V.1:;a.re>§::;§:1:.s:»%efi " ..€"<3c>5f:§:'.. .V V" had 5399?: ';:;:%a:':'za§§;;e5§ "}~::£ 4' c,g.;15.';; " -327mg ::gj":,er gm Vféifiigffifgiéfifffl' §.'§?_(;§§ft*'(éf: 2%; Indfa. §}:.:s'. £7)éff;f}.?'€*3' :>.f3° é-3-,:aje:2~:'2'1z':Eé:'z,fzs:-2'"zmcizar s;eCILz'0n E .7, an. '"€3?_;.'€?<T}§.£f"é'vI_V(§f..{}£f'Ey a.::r<:i(;Zenf. 2'20: aim-;= z"'<:: mtg; V {Er} ' v.._z4i::£.;';'5}z.E'5:§ff';' %::.£a§;Z2')gs3:'?<r¢? <2?' degfzzzzii Qf £326 . Vzf:.%2p<:w_'£§%:*'." E':.:':':;' £-.Wz;r3Z<>§;ee3 0:' a.gc%2'z.§.; or Z "'5.-§'1_{§'§."€.iF'i§; £.i.?C§i"€}'E(,>E.,£.Sé'{§ §;{}(:v€E.§,; had. §}€3€;-iii. €£.ar§'z::::g;e'::§ 52!: 5:32;; £iz'zne E}§,f?,:>';°a* <:Ze§:2;*°::2m:z3 jar izrzsmfs <7:'m.:;z4::'r2p§4'zf{}r2 an a::::::3:.m.z" 515;' az":g.,: :::.<':{:f{§e::E:' ms? e:2§'z:,e :5} 51:32,: z.:.%f§Ef"zz§ ascrzz m.:?§;Ef§;s?;':<7s;e 53:' {2':§j'{::.zZ:, 53;" 532:? z>z,:,=-s':e?:: his €??';"i;j)§{_}'§_j€?{%' <2?' {,zg;e*:'2E} ,.,,,',§§'z,i{."'§'2 g::i{}€}{ff$ $E'2z,z.£'£. Ex? {L'§"i€fE?'_§';€:?CE.f"}§£' 235.: (32,235; 5:'; {Z{T{i'E}§"{§{.£.?'E€T€? :::§§"E': {Ema ; mz:i;--.;z":;>:"z;<; {.3} $5:5?}«s;a:*;:::'.:':I2:'E. "NE {:2} '3':"'zg,> 51222;,' :10 Eggs «:,?}2{2;*:;';s:{,'§ :95: I'31¢'"§;'a{::3$:§:' 5 ;__ r°$;'¥:er"r:%d. SC} in $21}:--sa>{,éi.i{)z'I 5'3} sfsczii btifffif' : ,+"':~g §{;;"z'2é? _g3m;:3<}rZz'<:er'2 is} fizz: cizgzgg r:??'2.(2?§g;é?'<?£§_R3cf? <32': {.516 -§;'o<}:?E3_:'«. ?}<:%,?'3;'}m z';f'za«? :f1cz.z2zr:z.( Gr e:ie?i.erzfz:)r'a_z£2':;:z3.~:g.:s?2i<7'%% i}2.e5"a,%ci£g:'z;:__ A 53;" {fie d.(z:rzage>a' Q?' {IL-'?{.£?;"i(;§I'€zE"(?C5{}€}{}£"§S ijesfaii-':A{éf) f.F1é3 z.:aZu.e3 Qf Iizé? §;;(>:>d.:=7 V.-...» re? the V€Z.7.§f.7£2'V"}'_';'i£"2§{':'.' EH"
:'.1£'i&%rI'.£}3'"':Té Ho? 2, {3} }'<-'<.>r Z1"!-'£l£'.:.'J§3'II£?':C1*f'i}f§:C?§§$ .f:§uj5:?'" ".:3E3(§E'.'i(_>?'L éi'1.e> zsaizza (if d{z.r'I'z(2ge?d;"'<;;*. :€ I."£?E'v'E:'."Ti'()'.'?""{£af"f-;"'V.f_.17 g{;:ré)g€s 17352;; 33%? asce%:"{,ai2_é<;?c,§.j;E:§; a<3:':§;i':c:=.éf {ff E522:'jE§{éU:;:--:§'r2§; :m=%z.Pz(2(,Z3 at {Em qg§§£.z'<>r':"Qf°'?3:'.é%_ <3z:1>:fz'¢>:i"--'-- " V. """ "!:<::,§;' _v :,}€z*5.§f§e. (;_,+'.': ::'§*§.:{t.3z. gmziis maggg be VV fhxi' p:*::'3;)g?r <:g[}fE<?c:', <33"
__{f;;r} V f:Y2{i.;; be ;se:)§(£ Egg; éfw pr<;s;;>er 5;; ;CéJ.?2§:'.~:? {Z2.5.e:."'§§£:=§"£ <23" 32;; §::':.{/52%;: {>'r"a.:,:z'i?2 {fizzy <:e::2;':.:~i;<3z'2{' 9}" {E16 azmzssr is": mtg; 5:35:92" mczyzm-,>r: afzmfi §"?2.e g;;*e:}s3 3:256 §'}f"{_}{,'€?¢1?{."§::? i*S'§'?.{Z.§§ 513%? ::z'.a>m'n£-?{z'. is 32:5 {E28 23::',E§.i.£.é'? 53:?" S: siih _§f}'€3€.}(ZYE>Z ' ~ _z":"§='§ge'
23. Remissian cf duty destmyeci fir abandaned goods:
{.5} se>«:?{z'{m. 13, w-;'"2.er'e if is E»'f'I{}l.1.f?'? £12.. {lief S{1f"i.$jbf{;'fZ:i'i.{,}f' Qf? . Kite .»€:-fE:i5§!1'{Z:'?fI Cf<3I'3'2:'z':i.€5$i{>r'?¢}"~~Q?' {?z.i:e:£;:_.>r'¥:%j 0': Z}-:L>f§i.gig;V C<>:'21.rm's;siamzer cgj" Cf:§.s°{"{;«m5~: __2f?é's:3:'_ any i:1dg93z:2r'€{3(/2' gfigofisf f'zr:z,:,.=e Exgeerz E03: 'g'§§i'}1.a>ra1i>éis::%_ V f?:«{_1i'i, Ears {Ti resulf: Qf pzfiercgggej ctr €]7.tg>5;£.I;{>f&2#1'&'iT§4;'., :{;:'.'f £z__'m;>. E;q;"ore <:rZé:?z:;raz'z:,?:;% __;'£;>:f_ ?2a:¢'i:5" 1C?:::'V>;:!'E.'.'~3'?Z{?fEE§;?{El()§V?::. ;'7§S5§i:§I.CU1Z. €35;mmigfs§i.c:=r{§%2:* '_:3__;"'.v:iE:1zs}.§)}'}1.«; {:j§:*A._£f'é:=f§:::;;' C.'/<;r7'2rm'.ssf(mer (;j'€,f:[§.i§:£:>r§§§§' :.::fj3;; (3%. s;::.z.cE': go0€2'.s. ( {2} _f,%"hs,> fiéifzgff g3;'";'::'zy 2'm_;3<}:':.e=:t§ §;5){3d$ r'§1.a.§;;, czz.'-izngg :la'r;'2g> E;s1.:f::>_fe ..{JV£'f'2»..c4f);..'~"(}§.<;'?'fi j'?::=r {?§.£%{Z,r°€é{i"£€,"€;? qf g<;ad.s; j'3:i;r" §'i:}r::s3-'16 :?(m5;:.:.:?'§g}"E:f:;_§:%' :,::':{€e>r Seczivn 4? or an <.>ra'.er fizwi_;3em1§E'.:.A§;f;§ §.§7£{:I' €2',z:?g3<;>si.§:' ggf ;jg(;5;cf.5; in {I E,.z§{iF€ff'E.{}§.E8&% .z:%=é';c:§g2:r*" ..s;e;?::?izf€):'1V""§§(} E'35z.%:: E}e?e;en madsza :'8§2'r'z{g:.éfs§':. $35.3 {fig ;f;»:3€:>€§$ smgré §.§':ea;°§?:.Lp{:2:':. E259 ;<;?'1€3.E§ !'Etf}{" be f§§{i§}§i§"'5.'E} 'i}§ZE f"f'2;.:% {z'1£.2"':' i"?z,er2"e;3c>:'z; _ A: .. .3' §3r{.}:,%2'{/Eeii §§'2{£§. §.f'2.g? ::>z..r;:"i.€r :35?' zxzzgj 5%;z:.{f'§'2 r £_?:'"2§2<>;°§<3af§ §f;(}{f>(T§5§ 5;f':5:§E F'Esf'}{f P}:-3? 5zEEz:}:,;:{;.>d E0 §"e3§.z';'zq:.:§s§":. E35; f'§f',§.5;% :4} ;=:ss.z.:,?§'2 ;t;:.}<>:i1€.s; 2*°a:*§;a§;':i:iz'2§; §,§,?§"if{I."§E :iEf.§'2. {g§;:§"é:~s:2<.*: 3 _ -1- V.«"z'.:.f'2o:.:z' {)I'é§fI,.1df(.':f:'.__ {.0 ,!'r3"é:%? p%<r>z,%§:s§i{;z'2S * éiigf » T A 594'