Karnataka High Court
Murali S S/O Subramani vs Sathisha C V S/O Venkatesh A on 17 August, 2010
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
_éf-;.-
Hi TE-E I-§GH saga? G? mmsfmm arr Baflaargiég mmm ms 'I*,E§ 1% my Q? xaugusr, 2;e:=.%%:;~ "
BE FQRE 'rm HQEELE :sm.ms*:':cE B.sR:}EE;§:2:as's£' A V 221.33.. 33.9353; :2 _m3* % i % 1 BET'% 33:
mm: 8 any 3flE AGEE 1'§BGU"};' 9 RM _ % , % __ sgmmygm T.a.L§}.g-- ;
mmm fiI$'I'EI§:_::.::If'=. a ~ « it .;
{BY 35;' s 23 Lg' s Ps_...H.fl*
2. 3fi,'I'KI3fifi grzfsz . .' A am VEHKATEBH A» _ gem awry? 2:5 R} a~cH22=m;a§;mI xazrimz 3 1%%PA*rN2z*£aLzIK 6.13 '\\%:é;i§:;I:J . 31$ mam "®~<::>'%?EA vsxam fi:B€;}U? 5: Yzam ' _Ri<3_CE§I<¥}1>AfimI KGPPQ'. xi': 3 LI £93133, 8R§RF§.§3"GfisP£T% TELUX ammm
3. f -. ..*1':iE mw mam assumamca as I}I"£)'13IQHfis;'£; G§fiCE £39.}, J L E RQAIJ A v cmm31::m.IRgm,&5&'smE REPR%E§I7'E§ E'? FIE E§fiLI§&GER RES?§2*I£3EN'm &» {BY SR1: D S gamma Ffifi R13, R1fiER§§°E§ HGTIQE Ti} 12:. I3 B$?EB§3E{3 WITH} WA man figs 1?3(;§ 0? mt Aa'r;~:-*u::;§;m's*i? mnamm Am gwmfi EATER: I9.3.2*@§S'?A$i3E3§ ;1§*'3:.;£t;(;?2m;. 341; 2%'? ms: Tim ms 91? 'rim Pxmmirsgs c?1mcm',.j"z«:e;2§if TRACK cmmmv, gamma, Anni... §A$"I';--._ 2.t¥3;:::1;s?,?$; PA.'-a?r3:¥'«..L mmwme THE: mam PE'2"fI'iG¥3_ "ma Qamysxsariag -'Ann SEEIEVG E EEE£fiF C}? --
mm appgm crgsmm ':22; mfigfiégsfszcfl mam»-, TI-IE:
coma"? uswmms THE m;;r_:§1a¥G:%9 ; " 1. 11% spfifii "£';..';*§:f;*;__ ' uiv'fi§' ' whanaement <9?
2. Hga;a.,%k 3» aamma and with me mnsent sf ffiwf V#:::u nae' appnmi' ii): the palm 3., it Ea u§%:$:~ *§;1afE..§is W3;
af mnxgm. §ge_n:ce. the Wtm' are 5: as are ressgm 1:3 in the claim peiiztisn hefm "1'3_'Z"'§.A;§"V£.$':II"Ie.*".3.,E,,V! '§%hzrieffacm$ft1wema«e:
'4 5 Cm 2l.f33.2%'?§ when the cgaflzzt wag on his bicyelsa an :21: 133?: sifia $1' Sriran@§a'ma-Parxiava§u.rs. %' 3 ,: . 9. Tata Irxaifiaa gar bmfl ragiggfafiqn HG. HA-$2-~A§1356 mm in a, 3:25.31": and am mam agazmz has 'faicyck. as a hr: 'ieii ' L sustmmr-:' d . Hanna, he fi§e::i a a§sum:',4' MACT, Mysam melting at;
Tribunal awarfim him a with mmrwt at 6% pa, 5* As mafia" smzufwm af aeclfi ant, ixwurar nf rim
afiaxxdm wag: ma: 3.213% far my cansideraficxfi}: 37:1" 2113' :3 :; fig ' ' * §:'«§§pe1ma'?mZ@r1 awardaci by the V' éfi-firmsozxabie er deem it sail fer &, ' {ha Emma caumei a 5501* pfimairg me judit arid award caf the am as? the vim tlfwt the zzammnsatiexz awardnfi W ' . V _ is mi jug: mg mwaraahla, it $3 an the lewes' side E13123 it is raqufiefi m ha ezzxhamed. '2'. Tm siaimzzz Ems sugtairzed the farilawing ir1;!ur£%:-
$5,.
a} Iaefiaiw. wmmzi om: thg lafc uppar syc awsEi% ' ta} mefarmy m*er1:}2eifit1f3¥& 'me austainaé by that elaigt ya' ~ the wauzfi c w Exg?~3,E almt Ex?-1%, X-ragga E33,?-9 ofa}-
evidezme ef the alaimnt as Wis-1 aua 2 [email protected] $3 itzpatient imm 2133.9'? 23 19,as4fg::m irilfillg z»:ysm-e far the fracture 02' mt mh:¢:mg. PW-2, firm dczcmr wba in héfi evidmice that he 21.03am ami xmtieeei that Im fiamxgiwas it was mm, M; mm was tifmt was fincture af right ::Iavia:':}:s.: harm mm' the: Qhi $533 at" 'Ehfi saalp aw %""--~Vwa2.=hras1;é::1§:a5verV V. irgasmk sf {E15 @131 imrmd mad he Wm 3,31% ta _ ifiaifie-».fQBeW£r£.a%m1t. PW-2, the émiar stated that he had ' an 1§.§42€}C8 iastly' and r2:_2&e§. that limping, zmabla ma git crass bgad. Has hag stated that Em dimahszity 554.9% :5 the ieft 1% and me. m the czmm % 5
8. Ciamiéarm the: n&.:1,3:a;-: af §;t§'i11"i%$, Es._2xjC:;§)£<.;"'Qi~ awazréfi by the Tfibufi tczwarda 'pain 33$ the iasamr sifig anci it is ciassazvad to " » Rs.2$,mQ}- azfi x award Rafi»G,@GC5i-- "-u' %
9. As Ra?3;4,52t3;'- tgwards V 'medical mpmsaa' 23 by the cmsmmz and is uncier
13. ané éuratizrzzz cf zmazncmz, E3 % gs the zzamsxaal tawards 'mnvwaxmzszf, attenfiant :2:-hargaa' is: an {km fit '""-***ez"u-aeéf in be enhai by axwtlrwr Rs;§;fi ,_@Q:¢rf'-. xgwm Ra.m,<m;« mm this mad.
c3a§m$ ta ha an Efi amfimt at the €:f,_;aac7i§e:3;t and queatian raf awardm mmgematisn af 1.:'sm' zm fixing iaid up gezmtfl cl' ésas not arias, 'T T that rim c%a1man' t wag as smdant at tbs t1.m¢' 'mum. ' mfg: mid {ha mm hw afimtfi him eéucatign, it 2'3 juat %.
5 and prepay to awaxfi. a sum af R3.,1§,GCv§[- tnwarda mmn musefi in ufiuzzatian zsazm. IQ. the nature rsf the ciaiznmzt, the: stataci fig; aha doctm_'_.--s§§. 1fij:'b amunt sf fiismmfart ané ux2happi.z2@.;zs; " 'V mxfiwga in his mm m, it gm just sum af R$.43§{§@f- mwaréa 'ioséfi. marfage pmamcztua' and iii; awargiad T£se'15A_agi s:.irm¥:. R.:;..$,GVGQ,«'- awarcm by the mhum g£km§g2:ifim*.
13. <mna§darir§;,:::a;:;u~%a of injurxc' 3 sustaitmd by the that he has m unéerga future ymper m awazré a sum sf Rs.%:¢;§Qs3;-%%L§¢:va§aa fszmm mam apcmera' and it 'as
14.-._.A fixua, tiw $ t 1'3 enfitlad far tha fsllawing a} Pain and sufifcfiw - Rsfifl-£010 B) mam axpanaaa - Ra,};4,52€} <3} Cmrrvganm, nnurizahfit mfi attxerfiam. aha:-gm - Rs§it3,{@ cl) L%$ asfmizaaaltifia « R$,lG,0flG 45/.
6:} Less af a § fiisafiiliiy _T amfi marriaga firaaemms -- Rs.=§Q_,${)i'.'*. "~
g) Future magma -
....._._.._....._v....'.._...,............._ Ema}. _-"Rs;§.'_g24;52.Q * A ' ' ii-'¢&$:fl$-#fizm$nImuIVuCflBBI-'
15. Aamrciixuwg the is; 'a.i};::w'& judit 511$. awmfi §ass& ~ .. tn' the when: stamd hwein afififzc, is for 'at natal mmmxmamlerz gaff Rs,4~3,52{§}-
awariiafi by é% 9.9.. cm the enhanceé --v &z3m the date of claim patiiisn anthg :2. %
16. _ ia éirmfifi in dapnsit 'the with intmwt within twc:
ctf rmfpt sf a was :31' this arder, Q" the & s:::3mpv5rzs&1:3m1,, I-1's..S€3,G@[ - pxvgeféifinam i1:3.$$$'i: ifi sréerad. is he izxwmstad in fmed tlzaa mama af +:::}a.*2.mr1' 2: in any Kafianailsfi Bank;'P:rst Qfm far an pcriad. :31' 19 yaam a is %?}:§i.z*a'a:r the i1f}.tfi2"fit Ramai axmum; with grrsagartiarnate irxte-rat 32$ ardem-d to
3)/' be releagseé fizz famur ef the ¢ £ -- -.2 dgfiit.
18, {R39 w&r as mmsm.