Karnataka High Court
Arjun Halappa Naikwadi vs Vasantharao on 25 June, 2010
Author: H.N.Nagamohan Das
Bench: H.N.Nagamohan Das
'€33? N{>.4(}E4--E%j2€}{}E
was T§€;F3 E~§1'<.': 3: <::;:x:.J"'_¥::*§* <3? E€AFEE\§5%3.'A§§;E
{EERCUET BENQH gr BH.AE<?;'WA§Z> _ V
ETEATEIEE Ti£--.§.£S Tag. 2% my <5? JEENE, ";v- .L: if r.- A'
BEFGRE _ _ A I
THE Ei{}1"€'BLE Ef1RJ"U$'E'.EC€ ,
wgrg' PE'£"'ETf{T)N r~e'q4a1<:5%;<2:;§'<;V_: ggggggag - *
BETWEEN :
L
IN}
'VJ
ARJUN §iALAPPA E'€'A§.§<;'»?E!'ADE ---"-- , "
§a{3E:4_>17 VRS 5 --.
AG§i£CU§;TfUE1?;§1
R/O ?BYAKUD -- V
RA§BA{} -':'AL:J.:{
BELGAEEM 1
PU'NDAL;§K :-T'~i«&.z.g:'_;;¢:':*'é;i«_>,»a E*i$§.§{'%?.?AE>_£ '
A£§E::E">4 '~:_Rs:fi__ , ' ' ' 2
AG-§§.r.::L3 L': "'L3_'RE'* :;,_ , _
R/{J B'r"z3;.és:iE.1fD
R§1I73;%C-E '?ALU;§{'*- .» ' ' %
BET'.LGz%UI'wf '
§;A:\;zAc';§AN§.*:m-H,é:,}fi,,P~:?ié r€A:§<xz.rAa§
;a.;;ga'-::">2 "{R:§ " '
';3~§:il'zRVI_<';:'€.I';{~,*E'Ui'€','EL;' A ..... .. «
' J' 2')?»-. §:i-'.'Y;'»¥;,Z<f{;?;¥;'2
. 1 = RAEBA{3 <rj;%''£;,LfK
" V _B§§{{§_.§«:U'VE'¢§
:5"
.' A é§;ér::2A.sH'é:4% ;:¥.£ALA?§a.s; NA'£§<"£:§A;E'>§
E.:__4;'§
A{;.REi;;:§}L.'§'UREt
E€;'{>§3"':';%EéUE?
" ' E?';_»%§Bfi:.{} T;3:§,¥JE<;
H v .>'§jfifi3;EJ{:.T§f§§{,E?\:§-
§'v'EE§L?€A%;"E§Hi W;'{f} $EDR:%§:v§ I\3s%§E{'i§z';%i3§
5'%,GE:3?; YRS
aw :%;:;.4<>:4s;;2::e:
;'%.€CI}§{§CUL'§E5RE
R/ {L3 B':5}1E{UiL>
RAIEBACE Tfixiifiii
BEEAIE-AUII\!Ia €79 .?Ej.T§T§{}E'xEE:'7iS
(S? E:">'RZ.8R7{§.%_';§RE§§_r¥A ,-%.f'€EZEL{}PAI\E'E1 ADE? FQEEQ m. '.§'{f) 3; 7 "
$].°'€D:
E ,
5%.)
'%%'AE§ANTE-E.:%RA{}
:~:-;<:> .LA§{KA(}{}UDA '?A'."£"Ei,
?xrI14'§&{}R3 AGRECEJLTUREL ~ t --.
EX/EEZEJEBER OF' LE<}ESLA".§EE--"E AS$§;:~gig:,§zT ..
Rfi} BEKKERE I
SABASHIVNACEAR
BANGALCERE
ARUNABEVZ _
W/<1: v.L.PA':'1:,. . '
Ev'EA§}(}R§AG}EECUL?UE£ET~' __ . g n
ME'£*v:fEBER OF LEa:2:Sm?§'-ma A$;sE;§x»£;B.:.%?. j
R;*'<}BE1E«;fi§{ER§.
SA9AS§--EEVE§J.f%-£35':-E
BAN{}AL{)}?_iE }:;=
<L"}£§E1P.P_siz' V . _»
3;' <3' £AL>*.f.fvEA§'~J r'3fi;2:;§J:si.._ ' é
REAKJEER; s:>{:<::;:z<:=1ie.?:4'e::>}"';3*;«'As<'a;§
RA£§A::3"ETAL'UE{ ' ' ~'
E;e:L«i;~AUM _ " '
§ %g%:_:<;<;:;:r;~;%:4
" -» Wff) ms%;«!§?:;J--'§"§ NAEKEEVZIEDI
" &§é%.,j%<}R,'v§~{:Ef::_E_J_§3EH{)LD W{f}E%E{ (2%? §<UDA.e::*sm::
. ' .§{A1B;;:;_.. .'§A~LU§<
' _BEL{1:§':U'I'--{_E '
3§<?:;=m' ?v'EF£RU'"§§ E\E;5;I§{ii-"§a§.I
.. _E:£;i..;i£-->R, R,f{:: §<.Ejwf§a£E§¢E--E§
~ ' ':?.sJBA<: *m:;,:31?«:
* B$Le::g:,:'éfv§
? M R/%TI§J
Pa? EPQSER
WE} ]'."le:4G E 45%-"2{}€}i
ERNIE }TE£E3§iZ\?;-'3;§_,
REUIBACE,
EEIEXEALIM
7. L D {}H{i}U{§-ULA
I'$'zE¢/é.*~l.j{:}E5 MEEVEIBER
LAND TREBLTNAL
Rf%.§BA€L} _
8EL<';A2;M :
8. 3"?-{ES E3 R EEFFECER
{EHEKGEEE
ax TEE STAT.EZ GE' K;%RNA'§£KA3 ' '
BY yrs SECRETARY,
DEPT. <53? REE-'EZNUE,[_ * '_ _ _ ,
MQSBUELDENG, BAN{§}3.fi&{,}.RE+ 2 ;
2:1 THE SECRE3T§.EE":' ;%ND'"'fl%H'E§ELD§§».R '
LANE TRIBEg:rJ$.L--;_ j
RAISE-EGH, :g3§;:,sA_:;:\;: '§i}£:i'~f_'I'R§CTL ' ;.;RES?Gf'<Uf}ENTS
{BY SR§,ASH{}K R3.,_§<;fi;LY;§N'SHE3§"fY'5"ADV FUR RE,
SR1B;--S--;§<;2M_e%f§E;1,::;Az:>vE03 1:26 --;zr:r.E; 2?,
R3, ':51!' AND ':"§f%?:_D, --
srv:?;.SA2;';';:%A'1u';j§%,é;§':1,,"H§:'<:3P §'(}R R9 AND 10,
?*a'r:2*;:>ru<.:3:sr»«::s5~s:_E:3 'AS ';~aG~::a1NST R2}
33:5; P§*§*:':§::>:*»:. is §*:LE7B UNDER A§?;'§'ECLEiS 225 AND 22'? {>9
~ . 3';-EE"-2 §;:€';r>.;m;:$f1%;T;;T§:'>i~£:"<:»§%..::a:mA 'i?'fl'E'H A gggyggge: 72:; {'.'i<>N$l'DER HE;
;:;.'}p*;P;:<:;::f:'<}A:§; 3331:: 'mg ;*%P?E,:3;L l\3(>,:L-RA E'€{},E{L-RA 3?; 1&8? FELED
=._'j:;.;%..r«::: REFVCERMS .fiP§?'EL§;A'E"E- fi.U'E'E{}RE'§"{,
<§HEE{§§T£§D§, 'ggIé;;:,<:éA:.Jr«i $ES'f'R§C'f}.
T}"§iv5:;§A';E3'E?2'E'§7§'.E{'}E'€ {§{."}?:/§i?€{} {"}E'«é" ;?3{}¥3 PRE§£E'xfE§E"~§2%'§'{ E'~§.EI2'§§§f'*§{.1§r EN
'A i::;:::;;U§{?H§$ ma: 'F§r§EL <:<>UR"§ 2:;-mzég; mg: ;:'<3;.;{}':;;:N{;:
WE' N{3.52{'§ZE48ji2(E{}§
{T}E'{E}E*-ER
L ?e%;1iEi(}r:e§s§ are i'>5f<22"z3 this wuré; baizsg ezggrievad by the
Qréfizz" {sf 'aha Lziné Tribungzi gieaiaécé 2:3,{3@,E§8? in Cfifiéfi .§*§I7a:s».j'§'i£'€{3
SR;1Z?'"°"+E.'?'€>.
?<3%:§€:.;%<>:mrs fiiéé. Fazrm Nay'? b<:f<}.re the T_':i%,_b}:::3.a§_fg;;é_g3,:'°;§.:1§V b'
of OSC'-J.§é3,f1CfJ rights;. The '§'r{§ur1aE igngis: "L3::é*«_ir:":;:sL;._g§f1*;¢V<i§ '€Vif§§:€j,€V§'
rejcstsd ihés Claim 0f the petiiiansrs Qcm '€116; ;g;r{;».::;:.éd ihat €f:':#3y'V.
geagess Eazzd 3:1 EXCESS Sf -::{':{§§:1§gV"L3§»%V::?*:§é:¢ §'&;§3j4,g;3T';<$'i2!e.~?,-E. by 'Size Gfdfii"
0% the '1' ribunaig pe:§{;i{J~:";er$_«"fi}€{i1~-9:12éiggpzéaé ':)éf<}%<: 3;§'1€'3 {hen
Disiréct Land Reforms Ap13=eA11z3?::~3 Chikkodé, in
Appeal Nv:;;--§@j'ifiuriégg':Eie*:*---;na:r:fi_e:1cy of the appeaé. bazafmsés
{ha fixp§:t3l"E3.'Eé Land Refermss Ac: eame :0 $6
amendeé a;:iz:§_ rig: Ag.3;;:w3}}3;.:::}*:u:h:::riE}; came 2:0 bi: 2:b<3Eished anti
3/'.
it »%_$"~:35«:--;fi'v:€:<>r:: $155 <:»:"d:3r aheei. thai, {E19 295 resgonéfint
fiééiféh '€§;"%;.%§'§v§'izé;;.V.V"::§Eé,3'§8r}é%:'§'E{i}f {:25 tézés gz;-%:3'%;.%.<}:: 0:: 2?'{}3,2@8€>. 'E'h&
j §€U..?;§iI'l?§€%SV :20: <:£z1{>:'--;6;;": Ea bring the Eegzsé Z{'€f§}§'éiS€EfiEi':i%'€S :2?
Vj»:,§<§<;%:£%._:.a.:5€i 23* :€,:«;§<3:r2=3i€*:::E ané. 3.3 Such {E5 petéiisén zzgeamési €335
-- 235- :'€~:'§:«:p<:;:':dez:.': is abazisd.
'$3? i'~Eo.¢%{}T§~"3;8;'f£{}{}E
i S} I
5%' §"§é'§&':':'d :c1§":;_.§'L'§.§"31'1<'::':'['E§ an baéih ssédrs z/:1m:i p&J:":_:&;{:{i ibis s«:n:§:"€
writ gapfir:-3'
3 it ES mi}: in dispute éhai §'0:*m No.7 W:a:&~; film}. b;€§<>r€3..f%:€
Tfibumai am 'bshaif of the _}oi.m famtiiy 05" {he p€:%;é%::§{:;r§Z'€:1<:~§l;~..§€§§;>r€:
0A1 i
1136 "§';"ibU,f;aL §§E?1i"E'i£}.1'E{")E"S3 $555; deezéiareci i'he_..ié>:§&V§";§.".;} _§2m:%_::_ '
Gwrzeci Eihem.' '?1"ébun23§ by ¢:2ns§:;«:%;<:fifi'g§T {E16§_':§§::':._f:§1:j;:i1j;
as a unit ané the namber af m:=,_m.b€:z~;§~in"~th€ §::t\»f-£1151 fa:é::fi§5' 1?1::Ec.:"'L
{bait iiéay p0SS{fSS Land £3": eXc&s§€s.._éif the {,;tZ§'hf'Aig':§§'E':§§ '£. Em the
Memorémduzirz af Appfiaé "E;cf0§«é. Pi§§:§;s;§§at€ §'{Auih.orit"<-3 the
peti'{§0;1er:<; {:{)H'£é'3I1{i{3d as uniisr: b
"6, ~~~~ :;§?'?7{'?S£?L.VTfl'f-_v'C%§f.§€?;~~~-k;iCg??1it€E?C}f§y {the Jain:
V ._E;?:'2vj:V§?é,:*~..E;am€'§y 'Qf * Z'§f'ai§<:wa,di consists Sf 4
' éfgéhegfi :,j'}«5§.#»J*v)_i?tE3:::!'Z£Z<"i'éfS E E0 4} and She Legai
E€;:'e;r}?¢;>s§:%i£®éi*,§»vé;§'bLV sf deceased Maméhi :15',
;%ppféiEE::3_:rf;_€s is i?' ané as such Share are 5?': :33?
§;.:~§;jI_'v1::»~;:'a;-?..<:: :9 E36 wrmked cu: in me eniire holaiiizg
jfizlm', fmnéigg. 3:' is ssufiiniifezf fihfif. 5315
' 7,'; __s;i;§9;2;s;Padi Jflifii Famiigg awns in QEE 245 acres: §
gégzntas éncizgzfifng pm' kharerisfi Sf 26 acreg 27
gzmfas and {he Simzres :5?' each sf 392.3
€£j3>f:}€3§§€é?"i§8 wifi war}: Gui 55> 4? aares eazéh and
E316 gizare af appéifanég 5 {5} Z7 wgeifzer' wéii E28
499 a:'3Z"€2$. 3:' is sufsmiifecf ?§§2.af: as the
M_3{""'
xi
/3}'
,,,/
'Ev'? :'*3€3,%{}Ti_4%8;'2{}{}§
pregcnfiefi Eiméi is :34 gzzcresj €328 f3?"€S8?jE§
3/zo§dz'?'zg; sf W218 appeffams E :0 4 §?2@§ividuaZVEyV[.f§;§'T._
49 acres mid Eézat Gf appefianis 5:17 50 E7
153 459 acres, There 53 as gaesiiarz a';'f:"exc;e:'S§§§
Edclfiing and heizce the ?':r°é &A:,:;1aZ 3,z,>:x;~39ii:--
§':9Z&z';r:g {hat {here is anj <s2;cc§$s;i%s:__.V
{he appe§Zam;'s. V __ b V. _ . V'
'3"Pz.a:t the '§"'r:7£2mz:::§ z',é;T=Q s~..;'z"a e.r%*<::rV 2'31
as per' {ha fiat, 5: j:;i%z«E'V ;Zfz{néE§,j' :.':(;uI':'i ,:}'i{)Z:Cv7:£ag fhe
§¥:1r7..:r33 E0 ihe of 2S'iz%:ii.V§ zCe._,
268 acres 52f §:E0:S:3_.V i.'5.:'$5?¥izE";'.?%?E'§§f€CE7. ihat éhis
fin.a'ir:g~.of €he.A3'"s'--:'§2:;na§E-i$'»L§f':?§55fzé5:2S'§y based 0:1;
by miiy if/z.ii'Jtz";2;f::zg%';'5'iVé3zi:vs::..:;.J?' Seciian 63 {2}
i:'rz'éi§§_::sva€"'~<>f'.._Sécfiarf:"*553"'4{>4}; {ifs sumizzed flag:
""" '*f'?:§£X'i?'?Z1»V£'}';§'13. =§:'rri:z'i '::gf 20":m--iz's is in ?'6f€Z'"8?'ZC8 $9 a
.=;'2;:rrj££E§.:§e}E;@.¢tE~.;i%a«ier -Secééafz 21%;'? 2} of She Ac:
" u 'ff3is fl3;m:§;j'-rfée-g?::;""a parses: or individuai, his
is/*:;fe":;2'2;ۤ ifizefs' miner gems and unznarried
§au§?ai€;f$. _Fm"€hez~' Seciian 63 {2} pmvidég
zvfien Efaefe are mere éfmn five meméers
famifgg 2/side Section 21% {iifj me eeéféng
V' E96 .25 zgriéi + an aédéiiaizaf exfenf §f 2
p;:?i'z7?:s far every fizeznéer in 62:06.33 sf five
1 szsbjeeé {Q ?r25§.}:2Er<?zm'n gglggregaée 3f 20 ééfliffi.
1I"'§'ae czppeffaarzés gabméi :"§<2e::2: 2%: a; given came $3" a
fami§§,; cafiségiing sf an iz's.dz'a!::'£ua§, his 2';:;:§'"e and
4?? :"m7?:.-:3r 5€{'}??E:' 5:23.53 2 :g?m'zs:2r:'€e3c§ daagfiiers €329
.
:23," W / 2 If E3»??? E'§a.4%-{}E48;'2{E{}E Zsiaé mamézser sf members wiii E36 eégkii am?
hence 023 per Secéian 53 5'2}; the maxifmzm §':.9§ding c;f"fhefz:m:z'§y wiéé fie? 2%} urziag + 6 2;ami:.__s fer {fér five members} {:2 zmiis eaeE<a}VV.fE§§' 'T.. addiiiamaf 3 m,emE::e§*3 and heszce pervnissibie unizs in ihazi case: is .35 2;?" if: (.2 gisxeza. ease i'§'3.e.:ffiéffiiig_ Efb'f'i:"§S§$"'wO¥?7.V Ezusfiand, wife and § {§3'ifi§;§?"€?j;_A:(§"s'§{3'§i:§3f"
unmarried daughters} in me rj';*;§ér:g;-«. per the p2'e:3:,:z's0 of;--_S'éc_§ianA.V'é3 eniifiied '50 a maxérrzuufn-,v:?:aVZz:€ir:Q"z:f'i28 Vizrzitg insfead sf ":.:?r:_§:;y'V €fe:a.§Ci»:Za2f:vE,r1€53 net appiécabfie E0 faméfy as CEefin§;fCE ;§:nd€'?V'3€';;?i0z;:' i?§'§.._(E ?) A55. 5702"
f}L§§.;;Gi?':t::'iffiiiiigéy S_z2}f.1:io;§ {§3'{4}*p'fe3C:€bed mode __;;:-;-F <§'a:f:.:;;.:;;":':m:'q,**§<a_gzdz:s2g as fgzzows.-~ VV 2%? cf {and hefa'. by a membszr 'bf. a' far::f§:§_»§'a=.i;f§e Secéémzt EA {E2} mad 9:230 mefiéber afjgmzfarniiy Seciéera 2A {I 1?'; share of 524:5}: meméer in the Eanda hefé by Q jam:
;&m_,::g§. 3??;s.:飧 $8 iaf%:en £31250 acaaunf a$ if Ehere is V' gééréizioiz ami €529: wéif fie éha exfieni of . '§'::§E§£r"z§ af Such :°2':em£}er of me jam: famiige 3%; E316 presenf sage gs ézeicf 5;; me? E"r€EH,zr:aZ, {E16 @3555 gxierzi {if 3529 ;*€55駥»:Lvad§ Jairzi §'a;'/rzéég is 2455 gems; amt? Pzence 392.9 share {if inéivfduaé z:?3€m&e2' tisffizse {?§~§9€Z?'{?€?'£€?"£«: 10552 58 49 acres 5%! //3;» ;' fl W? N0.¢§{}E=%8;"" {}{3'T, e<:§,s::?z. .52? is sub::fz.z':'§e:>.d {E55115 S§?'ZCEf zmder .E>'er:::k:>r2 63 {2} {Z persofi 2'3 ezztiffecé :5: hafd 534 ac?'e.<3 af 'B' <?Ea;$$ Zandg, the preserafi §':oE£:f?3gS Qf gwpeéfanis irzdiyiéuaiiy wilf E26 damned §{;{ *z3z_r% ._ 49 asres which is admiftsadégg fess Ceéfimg grescznfbeof tinder fhe Act He:--:$:é, :§¢s,:éf%$' was me reason "for {he '_3'zi§9p;na§ _-§:é"'§*gf}3;:t'V"§'?':5é.V céaim sf me appeiiamfg.
LC} i?"'hm: the tr'ib:,£rraaE oughé ?:§;z--z)e $eéb%;r_2,_ zhat' per $3315 preyésions é;;'.S§.¢t€onA.§?_§f ffiibzgnaf finfis ihaé a §9-e§I"5Q2f1 iS ?aQéC_§Z'%'i§ fafids in excess Gf':;'.é°~iEi?1QfVA?i3"§fL§€; :.E.'§?,5.?§*;~--';'f 50 give GppOF€&f?%§fy :9' éffgé {;y:*::€:§"_»:§"'<:§fz0ice has :0 be gizzenh to zgfisy' €3'£"?'é'd he:/ice the im§:2ug,§f::3'd 9%'-rieif §§asée<:Z'"%.§)'é:--}*~:?)u§ aarzsidering ._ E§':.e '4;ir:";::.2:;'i;<;:.r7c>f:;:<:=:¢ §?s.?:a Act is Eéabie 50 be set ' VV +§:'a3€(:Z?€=,'' ' '§'h::m; is é;:~a:>:m:~ E-°{'}J§:4'é:VfiV'§§"£ ifm: &§'}{}X7€ <:<s:1i@::%;§a:1 {sf the geigiéamersi °?h:3 Vg;%z"<:e{;~5EL's'sé<:s"'::~s;« £3? éhe Lam}; Rafarms Ac? rziiaiing 'ES 'ihé ceééézzg "i%_3:§:ii §'§§..';f€'?":L:'i.i.q:i>'::;,§-f?7':VA '§:;Ef'v?'c};~{. in 'aha same {if 21 ;;CsfinE .§"ar§1fij;, 2: rioiimrzaé @313":-§.f_£§{}§} "i:%_ 'fa: be :aé<_{-:2"; 37111:; aa::<:m,::1%; ansi an thai 'E:sas~;i$ %:.%;e "'aa':x%;€1*:%'a e-22:5 "iaifiizgiizzg £22? {each Shgarfiheidar fizz 3 ngiiagaé garziiigzg " §;f§§:E%§ %':3§i" éihj bgeisés :5} Emicé Wiéeéfise? éhsja {min Eami in sxcesas of .V _h<%_:i3:'§:§n;g(: Eiméé. Théaa a:«;p€;:{:.% <22? i§"E{": 3:/:2:%;',':s:*r %$ EH}? <:::>n$§£§€:'{3<E E3}; 23%