Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Vikram Uppal vs Manish Desai Pr Director General & Anr ... on 16 January, 2024
1
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench, New Delhi
C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
This the 16th day of January, 2024
Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A)
Hon'ble Mr. Manish Garg, Member (J)
1. Vikram Uppal
Field Publicity Assistant,
CBC, Field Office, Doda
R/o H.No. -01, Ward No. 10,
Near Bus Stand Akhnoor,
Tehsil Akhnoor, District- Jammu (J&K) - 181201
2. Jashubhai D. Chaudhari
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Palanpur
R/o Moto Madh, At & Po: - Machhava,
Taluko:-Kheralu, District: Mehasana,
North Gujarat - 384130.
3. Kamlesh R. Maheshwari
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Bhuj
R/o 3, Nootan Society,
Behind Santoshimaa Temple, Bhuj,
Kutch, Gujarat - 370001.
4. Sanjay Shah
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Godhra
R/o H-6/31, Akruti Apartment,
Near Vardan Tower, Pragtinagar, Naranpura,
Ahmedabad-380013 Gujarat.
5. G. J. Shreekạnth
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Bengaluru
R/o Gowdaihnadoddi Village,
Maddur Taluk, Mandya, Karnataka- 571422
2
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
6. C. K. Suresh
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Vijayapura
R/o 85/A, 3rd Cross, G.K. W. Layout,
Vijayanagar, Bengaluru, - 560040.
7. Lakshmikantha C.V.
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Shivamogga
R/o Chikkanahalli, Post- Chikkanahalli
Tq- Koratagere,
Distt. - Tumkur, Karnatka-572121.
8. Nagappa B. Ambagol
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kalabugri
R/o H. No. 19, KHB Colony,
Kalaburagi, Karnataka-585102
9. Muralidhar Karabhari
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Dharwad
R/o At-Suvarnagiri, P.O.-Suranagi,
Tq-Laxmeswar, Ditt. Gadag-582116
Karnataka.
10. N. Ramakrishnappa,
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Bellary
R/o C/O CBC, Field Office,
No. 20, KHB Colony,
Gandhi Nagar, Bellari,
Karnatka-103.
11. Dharshan P
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Mysuru
R/o BSNL Biulding, , besides Siddharatha Hotel,
Mysuru, Karnataka -570010
12. Dilip Singh Parmar
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Indore
R/o CBC, CGO, Bhawan, A wing, B. Road, Indore.
13. Dinesh Kumar Gaur
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Sagar
R/o HIG-10, Rajeev Nagar, Tili, Sagar (M.P.)
3
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
14.Shravan Kumar Sahu
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Chhatarpur
R/o CBC, Field Office,
Near Nehru Smarak, Jawahar Ward,
Mandla, M.P. - 481661
15. Ram Sahay Prajapati
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Chindwara
R/o CBC, Field Office,
321, Mundikachehari, Gulabara,
In front of Jail Bagicha,
Chhindwara, M.P. - 480001
16.Sandeep Kumar Choukesy
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Jabalpur
R/o 1347/5, Sudama Villa, Ward No.35,
Vijay Nagar, Jabalpur (M.P)
。
17. Ajay Singh Bais
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Mandla
R/o Ward No, 32, Moti Nagar,
Balaghat (M.P
18. Hemant Kumar Markwade
Field Públicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Shahdol
R/o Near of old RTO Office,.
New Bus Stand Road,
Ward No. 23, Jain Colloy Shahdol (M.P.)
19.Mukesh Kumar Mandal
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Rewa
R/o. Vill- Bakuri, PO-Dulha, PS- Bisfi,
District- Madhubani (Bihar) -847121
20. Damodar Narayan Agnihotri
Field Publicity Assistant, Retired
R/o E-57, Teachers Colony Khajri Road,
Chhindwara (M.P) - 480001
21. Bishnu Charan Sahu
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Bhawanipatna
R/o Wno-7, Thikadarpada, At/Po-Titilagarh
Dist-Balangir, Odisha-767033
4
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
22. Khagesh Baipai
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Balasore
R/o At-Sandalima, PO-Bhagabandi, PS- Tiring,
Distt-Mayurbhanj, Odisha - 757053
23. Jiban Kr. Samata Singher
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Koenjhar
R/o Babusahi, W. No. 05
Post Baripada, Dist. Mayurbhandj,
Odisha - 757001
24. Jyoti Ranjan Patnaik
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Jeypore
R/o Quarter no: D/3 All India radio Old: Colony,
PO:-Jayanagar, Koraput, Odisha - 764005
25. Satyanarayan Nanda
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Phulbani
R/o Brahman Pokhari Balighat, Puri, Odisha
26. Manoj Kumar Patro
Technical Assistant, CBC, RO, Bhubaneswar
R/o Plot No. 4072/73, Gadakana Talasahi
In front of Space Town Apartment,
Bhubaneswar-751017
27. Raj Kumar Gautam
Sr. Technical Assistant, CBC-HQ, New Delhi
R/o A-92, Street No. 2, Harijan Basti,
Patel Vihar, Karawal Nagar,
Delhi - 110094.
28. Manoj Kumar Sharma
Technical Assistant, CBC-HQ, New Delhi
R/o E-3, Type-3, Tower-17,
East Kidwai Nagar,
New Delhi-110023
29. Surbir. Singh Negi
Technical Assistant, CBC- HQ, New Delhi
R/o 1347, Laxmibai Nagar,
New Delhi-110023
5
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
30. Rajesh Arora
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Narnaul
R/o 1452/5, Mansa Ram Gheir,
Near Apina Opticals,
Railway Road, Rohtak (Haryana)-124001
31. Rajbir Singh
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Mandi
R/o Vill. Dhaikola Post Off. Tigaon
Distt. Faridabad-121101 (HR)
32. Surjit Singh
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Hamaipur
R/o VPO Ghaloon, Nadaun,
Hamirpur (HP) Pin-177042
33. Daulat Ram
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Hisar
R/o Daulat Ram House No.8
Geeta Colony, Near Bhader Ki Dairy,
Azad Nagar Nagar, Hisar (Haryana)- 125007
34. Deepak
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Amritsar
R/o V.P.O.- Kanwali, Kharkhoda,
Sonipat, Haryana - 131403
35. M. Murali
Technical Assistant, CBC, RO, Chennai
R/o No. 715, Thulukkanam Street,
Varadarajapuram, Pudupet,
Chennai- 600002.
36. S. R. Chandrashekaran
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Coimbatore
R/o 78/22 Uppiliar Street, Singanallur,
Combatore - 641005.
37. J. Bosewell Asir
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Madurai
R/o No. 17/118, Kanni Mariyamman Kovil 2 Street,
K. Pudur, Madurai-625007.
6
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
38. P. Velmurugan
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Tirunelveli
R/o No.9 Roja Nagar, Uthaya Nagar East NGO 'B'
Colony,
Tirunelveli -627007.
39. K. Ravindran
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Thanjavur
R/o No. 72, Azhagammal Nagar, Near Yagappa
School,
Thanjavur- 613005.
40. S. Veeramani
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Puducherry
R/o No. 15, Zion Street, Kamarajar Nagar,.
Gorimedu, Puducherry - 605006.
41.M. Thiyagarajan
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Dharmapuri
R/o No. 5/1301, NSCB Street,
TAMS Colony Back Side,
Elakkiyampatti, Dharmapuri- 636705.
42. M. Jaya Ganesh
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Vellore
R/o No. 3/5, Subramanaiaya Swamy Koil Street,
Thorapadi, Vellore- 632002.
43. S. Arun Kumar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Tiruchirapalli, R/o 110/1, First Floor,
Kalyanasundaram Nagar Extension,
National Nagar, Karumandapam,
Tiruchirapalli-620001.
44. P.T. Palaniappan
Field Publicity Assistant, Retired
R/o C-1, Vijayashri Apartments,
Dr. Thangaraj Road, K.K. Nagar,
Madurai-625020.
7
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
45. Nathi Singh Nayal,
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Dehradun
R/o H. NO-64, Pocket. 16,
Adarash apartment. Dwarka.
New Delhi - 110075.
46. Bhupendra Singh
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Nainital
R/o Nilanchal Colony, Radha Bihar, Dahariya,
Mukhani,
Haldwani (Nainital) Uttarakhand- 263139.
47. Leela Dhar Pandey
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Pauri
R/o Field office, CBC, Kandoliya Road,
Pauri Garhwal, (Uttarakhand) -246001
48. Mahavir Singh Chauhan
Field Publicity Assistant, Retired
R/o 27G, B-6, Mayur Vihar, Phase-Ill,
New Delhi -110096
49. Bikash Rajbangshi
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Barpeta
R/o CBC, Field Office,
L.C. Nayak Road, Barpeta, Pin: 781301
50.Sujit Kumar Deori
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Dibrugarh
R/o CBC Field Office, Milan Nagar,
G-Lane, Gate-10,
Dibrugarh-7860039 Assam
51. Sarangapani Borah
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Tezpur
R/o Monaimazi Gaon,
P.O. Dhekorgorha, Jorhat,
Assam - 785015.
52. Angshuman Malakar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Guwahati
R/o Pub Sarumotoria, Dr. Zakir Hussain Road,
9th Byelane, Suruj Path, Guwahati- 781036
8
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
53. Ganajit Medhi,
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Barpeta
R/o CBC, Field Office,
L.C. Nayak Road, Barpeta, Pin: 781301
54. Jayanta Kalita
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Diphu
R/o Bardadhi, Anursery Chowk,
Near Damdama College PO- Gerua,
Dist: Kamrup (R) Assam.
55. Bidyasagar Talukdar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC Field Office, Silchar
R/o Village Pipalibari, P.O. Haribhanga,
Distt. Nalbari- Assam-781378.
56. G. Srinivas
Technical Assistant, CBC, RO, Hyderabad
R/o H. No. 2294, Near Pochamma Temple,
Lingampally, Dist. Rangareddy
Telangana-500019
57. M. A. Rasheed
Field publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Nizamabad
R/o H. NO.6-170, Shabunagar,
Miryalaguda, Dist. Nalgonda
Telangana -508207
58. Thokchom Anthony
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Imphal
R/o H-37, D-Sector, Officers Hill,
Near Sema Church,
Kohima- 797001 (Nagaland)
59. Shangreiyo Rimai
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
R/O, Imphal Ro T. Hundung village,
B.P.O. Tangkhul Hundung village
P.O: Lamlong Pin 795010 Manipur
60. Dirai Pame
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Tamenlong R/o Chingkhiuluang Ward No-5,
Tamenglong District, Manipur-795141
9
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
61. Lhouzotuo Casavi
Field Püblicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Kohima
R/o H-37, D-Sector, Officers Hill,
Near Sema. Church,
Kohima- 797001 (Nagaland)
62. Lalginlen Lhouvum
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Aizaw
R/o Chong Inn, House no. A-12,
Ground floor, Zonuam,
Aizawl, Mizoram - 796009.
63. Angthoi Sankhil George
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Senapati
R/o Keithelmanbi village, B.P.O Walkhong,
P.O Kakching Chandel District, Manipur- 795103
64. Mathew S.K Bengam
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Chandel
R/o Kreithelmanbi village,
Po. Kakching BPO, Waikhong,
Chandel - 795103
65. Robin Kashungngo
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Senapati
R/o Village Shingkap, P.O. Litan,
Kamjong Distt. Manipur, Assam.
66. Puheswar Sonowal
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Tezu
R/o Field Bureau, Ministry of l&B,
Govt of India, P.O. Tezu,
Dist. Lohit, Arunachal Pradesh- 792001
67. Rama Kamsha
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Bomdila
R/o Village, Kamsha, PO/PS- Seppa,
District- East Kameng, Arunachal Pradesh-790102
68. Mibom Basar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Along
R/o CBC, Field Office, Along,
Yoji - Yora, West Siang District,
P.O. / P.S -Along, Arunachal Pradesh - 791001
10
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
69. Lopsang Dawa
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Itangar
R/o Village: - Sera, 0.0 / P.S Bomdila,
District- West Kameng (Arunachal Pradesh)-790104
70. Pem Tsering
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Tawang
R/o QTR No- Cent/PUB/Ill_1, Old Bajar,
PO- Tawang, PS-Tawang, Pin-790104.
71. Ramesh Das Swami
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Kota
R/o CBC; Field Office,
B-20, Civil Lines Nayapura,
Raj Bhawan Road, Kota,
Rajasthan - 324001
72. Ravi Kumar Yogi
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Sawaimachopur
R/o A-11, Guru Colony, Goner Road,
Jaipur, Rajasthan - 302031
73. Bharat Bhushan Bhargava
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Ajmer
R/o 317/10, Lane No. 1, Sundar Villas,
Near Shiv Mandir, Ajmer (Rajasthan)
74. Prem Singh Yadav
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Kota
R/o B-20, Civil Lines, Nayapura,
Rajbhawan Road, Kota, Rajsthan - 324001
75. Sanjay Boolchandani
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Jaipur
R/o B-177, Hari Marg, Malviya Nagar,
Jaipur, Rajsthan - 302017
76. Naresh Kumậr
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Dungarpur
R/o CBC, Field Office,
Old RTO Building, New Colony,
Head Post Office Road,
Behind LIC, Dungarpur, Rajasthan- 314001.
11
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
77. Parvesh Kumar
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Udaipur
R/o 3, F39, Hiran Magri,
Sector-5, Udaipur, Rajasthan-313002.
78. Phool Chand Gehlot
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Sirohi
R/o VPO- Shri Sela, Theshil-Balli, Mallyo Ka Vas,
Distt. Pali- Rajasthan-306701.\
79. Kheem Raj Soni
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Jodhpur
R/o Megawalo ka vase,
Thani Bazar, Barmer, (Rajasthan)
80. Nemi Chand Meena
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
Sawaimadhopur
R/o Village & Post -Gagwana, Mahuwa,
Distt. Dausa (Rajasthan) Pin - 32608
81. Shambhu Lal Salvi
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o House No. 12 Shive Nagar,
Bhomiya Colony,
Street 2; North Sundarwas
Udaipur (Rajasthan) - 313001
82. Thana Ram Royal
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o VPO. Kharwaliya,
Via -Toshina Tehsil- Deedwana,
Dist. Nagour, State Rajasthan-341001
83. Purnmal Verma
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o 3K-292, shivagi Park,
Alwar (Rajasthan) - 301001
84. Narendra Kumar
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o Station Road, Gaytri Mandir ke samne,
Barmer, Rajasthan.
85. Devendra Trivedi
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC Field Ottice, Junagadh
12
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
R/o Block No-115
Samarpan, Shrinathji Nagar-3
Near Mangalamhall, Bhavnagar, Gujarat- 364002.
86. Rajesh Sharma
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Kathua
R/o House No: 169, Lane 20E,
Swaran Vihar, Police colony Muthi,
Jammu (J&K) - 181205
87. Sikander
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Srinagar
R/o Friends Colony,
K.P. Bagh, Srinagar - 190008
88. Vijay Mattoo
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Poonch
R/o H. No. 587, Christian Colony,
Near Gurudwara Bakshi Nagar,
Jammu: District - Jammu(J&K) 180001
89. Mohd. Iqbal Khan
Field. Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Anantnag
R/o Ranbirpora Mattan,
Anantnag (J&K) - 192125.
90. Prem Sherpa
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Jalpaiguri
R/o CBC, Field Office,
Vivekananda Para PO. Jalpaiguri, West Bengal
91. Deepak Chakravorty
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Siliguri,
R/o CBC, Regional Office,
Ashutosh Mukherjee Road,
Subashpally, Siliguri Dist. Darjeeling
West Bengal. Pin. 734001
92. Loden Lepcha
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Siliguri,
R/o CBC;' Regional Office,
Ashutosh Mukherjee Road,
Subashpally, Siliguri
Dist. Darjeeling Pin. 734001-West Bengal
13
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
93. Navin Tamang
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Malda
R/o CBC, Field Office, Malda,
Sarbhamangallapally PO. Malda,
West Bengal
94. Goutam Biswakarma
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Raiganj
R/o 9th Mile, Below Govt. High School Ground,
Upper Cart Road, P.O.& Dist. Kalimpong- 734301
(West Bengal)
95. Joy Prosad Ganguly
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Bardhaman
R/o Dum Dum Motijheel Govt. Quarter,
Block-D, Room No-9
Kolkata- 700074, West Bengal
96. Arpan Saha
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Mednipur
R/o FA-28, Narayantala (West),
Sayan Apartment, Deshbandhunagar,
Kolkata-700059, West Bengal
97. Pintu Rajak
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Chuchura
R/o Old Kapas Danga Kazir Bangan,
PO+ Dist. Hooghly - 712103, West Bengal
98. Ashok Kumar Vishwakarma
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Varanasi
R/o Village panchyat Bewarya
Behind Murdaha Police Chouki
Distt. Varansi (UP) 221005
99. Becha Lal Pal
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Gorakhpur
R/o H. No. 582, Panlam Vihar Colony,
PO Manas Nagar Badli Kera,
14
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
Kanpur Road Lucknow (UP) 226023
100. Ram Khelawan
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Azamgarh
RIo 73, East. Narauli, Azamgarh (UP)
101. Vishnu Dutt. Sharma
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Jhansi
R/o 478-CP, Mission Compound,
Gawalior Road, Jhansi (UP) - 284003
102. Dharmendra Kumar
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Aligarh
R/o G-46, Krishna Colony,
Ramganga vihar-2,
(Behind C. L. Gupta World School)
Moradabad, (UP)
103. Deepak Sharma
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Moradabad
R/o B 74, Jigar Colony,
Moradabad 244001(UP)
104. Shri Gopal Shrivastava
Field Publicity.Assistant, Retired
R/o 441/80 Bhelupura Colony,
Balaganj, Lucknow (U.P)
105. Sunil Kumar Chaudhary
Field Publicity Assistant, Retired
R/o Krishna Nagar, New Abhanda,
Laheriyasarai (Darbhanga)
106. Amarendra Mohan
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Patna
R/o C/o CBC, Regional Office,
Karpuri sadan, 4th floor,
G. Block, Ashiyana-Digha Road,
Patna-800025.
107. Mihir Kumar Jha
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Darbhanga
R/o CBC, Field Office,
15
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
Pustak Bhandar, Laheriasarai
Darbhanga-846001.
108. Ambadas Irappa Yadav
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Amrawati
R/o C/o Anjali Collection,
Near Regal Tyre Servicing Center,
Old bypass Road,
Amravati - 444606 (Maharashtra)
109. Sanjay Madhukarrao Tiwari
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Nagpur
R/o C/o CBC, Field Office Nagpur,
New Secretariat Building,
Opp. VCA stadium,
Civil Lines, Nagpur, Maharashtra - 440001.
110. Alim Salar Khan.
Technical Assistant, CBC, RO, Pune
R/o CBC. Mahadji Shinde Bhavan,
Near of Poona Club, Camp,
Pune- 411001 (Maharashtra)
111. Sadashiv Banappa Malkhedkar
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Nasik
R/o Flat No. 9, Dharmi Housing Society
A-WING, Shivaji Nagar, Jail Road Nashik Road,
Nashik-422101 (Maharashtra)
112. Pramod Samuel Khandagale
Technical Asistant, CBC, Field Office, Kolhapur
R/o 411, Indraprasha Prestige,
Nana Patil chouk, Phulewad Ring Road,
Kolhapur-416012 - Maharashtra
113. Pradeep Vijay Pawar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Aurangabad
R/o H/104, Kasliwal Marval Nest (East),
Beed Bypass, Aurangabad - 431005
(Maharashtra)
16
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
114. Vikas Chandrakant Tapkir
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, RO, Pune
R/o Wadmukhwadi, Charholi BK.
Near Vitthal Rukhmini Temple,
Block- Haveli; Dist-Pune- 412105.
(Maharashtra)
115. Phani Kumar Pemmaraju
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Ahmednagar
R/o 20, Hemant Smruti,
Savedi Naka,
Ahmednagar- 4140058
116. Sumeet Kesharchand Dodal
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Nanded
R/o 'Shrikeshar Plot No. 149,
Vaibhav Nagar, Near Ratan Nagar Jain Mandir,
Malegaon Road; Taroda Kh.
Nanded -431605 (Maharashtra)
117. Ramchandra M. Sonsal
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o C/o CBC, Field Office,
Secretariat Building, Opp. VCA stadium,
Civil Lines, Nagpur, Maharashtra -440001
118. Ulhas Totaram Kohle
Field Publicity Assistant, Retired
R/o 10-B, Devidas Colony,
Nearby Seema Park,
Jalgaon - 425001 (Maharashtra)
119. A. R. Mulay
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o 206/2/3, Rasta Peth,
Near Shanti Hotel, Jedhe Park,
Pune, Maharashtra - 411011
120. Satish Kamalakar Ghodake
Technical Assistant, Retired
R/o 92/1, Mashal Nagar, Vijapur Road
Solapur - 413008 (Maharashtra)
17
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
121. B.S. Dhruw
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Jagdalpur
R/o C/o Raja Ram Baghael,
Near KVS School, Shiv Mandir Gali,
Hatkachora, Jagdalpur (C.G)-494001
122. K.S. Diwan
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Jagdalpur
R/o Block E-33, Vardhman Nagar,
Devpuri, Raipur, Chattisgarh - 492015
123. Kamal Vas Giri
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Bilaspur
R/o Plot No. - 17, Phase-1, Sector-B
Raj Kishore Nagar, Bilaspur (CG) - 495006
124. Himanshu Soni
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Ambikapur
R/o Vikas Vihar Colony, Mahdev Ghat Road,
Patwari Gali, Raipura, Raipur (C.G.)-492013
125. Ms. Shweta Sharma
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kanker
R/o A-1, Rishabh Nagar,
Pavan Vihar Colony,
New. Rajendra Nagar Raipur (C.G.) - 492001
126. Anjani Kumar,
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office; Gumla
R/o Mandir Path, Bhatiya Basti,
Kadma, Jamshedpur, Jharkhand - 831005
127. Khursid Alam
Technical Assistant, CBC, Field Office, Dumka
R/o Mani Tola, Dumka
Ranchi-834002
128. Raj Kishor Paswan
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Dhanbad
18
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
R/o R.K. Paswan, New Bank Colony,
Steel Gate, PO. - CCWO, PS-Saraidhela,
Dhanbad, Jharkhand-828127
129. Manoj Kumar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Daltonganj
R/o 12/165 Near, Tiwari petrol pump,
Azad Nagar, PO Maner, PS Maner,
Dist Patna, Bihar - 801108
130. H. K. Chang
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Agartala
R/o Type C-3, Air Staff Quarter (New),
79 Tilla, Agartala-799006, West Tripura.
131. M. Suresh Kumar
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Palakkad
R/o "Sooryagvayathri", Ambalappuram,
West Yakkara, Palakkad-678001, Kerala
132. K.S. Baburajan
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kannur
R/o 'Thiruvonam', Chirakkal PO,
Kannur-670011, Kerala
133. Amjith Sher P. P
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Trichur
R/o "Anjaneyam" West Street, Vallanoghy,
Nenmara (PO), Palakkad (DT)
Pin : - 678508, Kerala Stat
134. K. S. Jayaram
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Ernakulam
R/o Kochuveedu, Punnamoodu,
Mavelikkara, Alappuzha-690101, Kerala
135. M. A. Jaleel
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kavarati
R/o Dr. Zakir Hussain Road,
19
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
Kavaratti- 682555 Lakshadweep
136. T. Sarinlal
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kottayam
R/o Thiruvonam, Muttathuparambu Lane,
Near Palamthanam,
Arattukulangara Vaikom,
P.O, Kottayam, Kerala-686141.
137. Ibrahim Shariff
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Visakhapatnam
R/o 8-29, SCBC Colony,
Chinamushidivada,
Visakhapatnam-530016
138. K. Gopala Krishna
Technical Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kakinada
R/o Near Sai Tample Revenu Colony,
Samba Murthy Nagar, Kakinada-I, Pin. 533001
139. D. Satya Siva Prasadad
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Nellore
R/o Dr. No: 134-6-136,
2nd line Hanuman Nagar,
Guntur-522002
140. V. S. Phanikumar Kadali
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC, Field Office,
R/o H.No. 1-93/1, Viswesuruni Agraharam,
Amalapuram-533201, Andhra Pradesh
141. Hari Krishna P
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Kavarati
R/o West Street, Naidupd, Tirupati
142. T. Prabhakara: Rao:
Field Publicity Assistant, CBC,
Field Office, Guntur
R/o DR. No. 21-9-535,
Back Side Koritepadu Park, Guntur 522007
20
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
143. B. Ramesh Babu
Technical Asstatnat, Retired R/o H. No. 87/1109-A-13-
E,
4th class Employees Colony,
ADJ Ganesh Nagar-2,
Kurnool - 518002, Andhra Pradesh.
.....Petitioners
(Advocates: Mr. Irshad Ahmad)
Versus
1. Sh. MANISH DESAI
Union of India
Through its Principal Director General,
Central Bureau of Communication
(Ministry of I & B), Govt. of India,
Room No. 274, Soochna Bhawan,
Phase - V, CGO Complex
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110003.
2. Sh. APURVA CHANDRA
Secretary,
Ministry of Information & Broadcasting,
Government of India, Room No. 655-A,
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
..... Respondents/Contemnors
(Advocates: Mr. Sanjay Kumar with
Mr. Argh Bhushan Sharma)
21
Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023
In
O.A. No. 3500/2022
O R D E R (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mr. Tarun Shridhar, Member (A) A limited direction was given by this Tribunal while disposing of the captioned OA, i.e., O.A. No. 3430/2022. In terms of this direction, the respondents/competent authority was to dispose of the representation of the applicants/petitioners by passing a reasoned and speaking order within the time limit prescribed for the same.
2. Sh. Sanjay Kumar, learned counsel for the respondents draws attention towards the affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents and the order dated 19.06.2023 annexed thereto. He submits that in view of the said order, the present Contempt Petition may be closed as the directions of the Tribunal stand complied with. On the other hand, learned counsel for the petitioners while confirming that the respondents have passed an order pursuant to the directions of the Tribunal submits that the said order does not address the issue raised by the petitioner/applicants in their representations and hence it cannot be termed as a reasoned and speaking order.
3. While recording the respective submissions of the learned counsel, we note that the OA was disposed of 22 Item No. 25 (C-4) C.P. No. 338/2023 In O.A. No. 3500/2022 without going into the merits of the subject. Therefore, in our view, the limited direction given therein stands complied with. However, taking into account the submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioners, while closing the Contempt Petition, we offer liberty to the petitioners to seek an appropriate remedy, in accordance with law, should any grievance still survive.
(Manish Garg) (Tarun Shridhar)
Member (J) Member(A)
/aks/