Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs M/S Kurlon Ltd on 20 July, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
EN ";{'iiE HIGEE C033'? GI?' ATfiE% fig? EAN E')21E€<:i t'h§s~3 §.'E':€?. 28"" {fizzy <1}? J 'digs, .
ymggflgfy TEE HONBLIEE zs»I1i,'.;:::$':*:5Ee°a7 :32: Ki§§§*L§XE.. THE fi0N=BL§:V rs«1ié;; 1.3"::Sf§*:¢?¥::'._1L'azé§;v:»» MAL1MA'rI--§ M n?s';%%'Ass%9 .:§£"72@@{$ BE1W£z:E:N} --:i_ 1 The CGVfi'$EZ1iS_S.iQfl'€.§' '€';§f__I:1<%;3I1'1e "fax C_§3.' B1iiI_51:1'3;."i§._§--.. ' "
Qt}-2fi:e:1$s R<>ad"~ _ '"
E%21mg§a1<>:7§z -_ 2 '.§'_Efi€: Q0111: V§:€}E13_§}1'£SS§{}I'i{'3§' GE Z'£:1.{:<)m€3: "fax _ ;$§é<3<::§z:E_ Ra;3g€:--5 R B:,z.E.Ed_E;§g 1 " bv -?;¥®21:§ ..JXpp<3EEm1'és's {E3}? Sr: Es? 'J S»:=:ss%1a:":haEa. ;'%<i'v:><:z1§.@} ' ~. 'A12;-:13; H /' i"*';u:*E<;::': E.,i.miE.<?{§ .. ,V___E-Sm E~?'E{>e:::2", ET'\3'::;r£'.'z; Eifiisiféa =.w,/ .,««w: W"
M an igmi Cészm re N€.3.<§7.E3?Z{i§<;€fi'E$;1{)i'1§?;{}&§.{i _ .V Ef>".:.1:1§;§22§<>:°e: ....§{e§ea;3<§';3<§<;;.:j:f{' _._ €_3i?3y 83% ;'1i-E: rihy. Aa:;i*a-'s}e::21i.€>. f{u.'i, §\£E;"s:a E\fE'm'§.hy 311:1.Kzimart».._E'%.dV£.%<?i2?:E,€*:E?§§--L' V '§'}":.i.:«s ETA fiéed :s.:'1.c1e:' Se{:':é<):': 22§5€}i:€¥ {if §'§."£X<f"i.§. i95'3 "':Zi'i;§'3iE}§§ am as? {}rc§.«s::° (3:-jximi i€§~{}9«C»3;€}{}:3 py2"s,vsi%--%:;.{-3d ' 'ii:
§'~é<>e:»ui%4("§g'E:%AT€(};'2€3§2 a1'1.::E C_{§'~v. ET\i<}m3;?a[ i§31:z:":g,/ 2%;3i._5U';'.;~,... £63" @122' :a4:;ss€.s;s:ez'1:en1 y<éz.u° 19§§E3«9'"", f;::;;z§7§.:}gg ii.2~._ {'1} if<3:*::1L1I2iie Eihs': subsi'.an.I5,ia1 q_s.2es;;f;i0n:s {:35 Ezmr EE§'i,?i?ijfi-?{lh.€:E'€£ifl {i§§--.ai1(}:£»" iéiiz &§§}3f:'.&1§ and 93.6: affiidéf the 0:'dE'.}_' '§}é1SE€C§ ..:.§"e..€"~E"FA'f I-Bzirigzxiare in ETA Ekx3%O/8angf2002 & {f3E&:33/Bamgj2G02 daMx§i6£%2G05 {'.EJ}'1fiE'§Z1 the «:}2:'dez" passe3d"b§; é.h<;* ;,Ec-->i;;1'i.~-- jC1s:::_é.:11:":i.s;s9»i<'211<:%1' of §."E'.r, $:3§3€{*.i€,iI E{a:'1.§3;»5¥_3f3a;'1g;§a-1E.{ii'é'; * " VV ' 2 Thiss;_.£*§'é'3,«:é<i;::,i.:*:g§§ an *§g):" E;~e;§g;~.iz1g{:EiEs dzay. N8 KUMAR J"
df_".§i\-7€;','k7"£';"'.d the fl€>1'.iQwi;':-g; .
z;§9GMENw "§.'hi§;_;>q.;;:§%z1§_ wafs'. §§:11i.'€,'E;;a%c§ £0 ::%m1sai.{i€;' éhe f(>§i<>w.m.g}§ s1§'E3§e§§,2:§é%;i::i e:§wiss:i.éQ__1_.}._é:g & mi" km: :«
-£3 ".._':7€»'§g.e€§zg-2:" she "E'r§E3:::25zZ 1.52525 :?:;2m:%::*z'. in §z.oEd:'n.§; éfmi. ' .. Eiééé-33a,E,e€i _§';3C,{§;'¥TI'Ef;?I'E?. Q?' £?2'¥I_§3§{>§,g€3ci%S e.:?{m.é"r§.%,>z.:E.ia:'": {:9 ESE"
a.2':;<§ {SPF :3 am. (;i§<5z,;.%{zE3is3 €f&?€i££.{f'Zf(}§"'§ in 3.33:3? E:'§;§'2: of 5,329 ;3m::€3§:3:*z5: sf" :§§::3<:'{,:".{m 5353533 Q?" 552$ A55; Egg; i§;z'::2:'in§; §"E2e mm3,.{f<1z.e:.}z"g ; :*e:;:.:§:'emg:':.i. z.g=;""E§2:;2E:m€:.z'§{}z': 5.5;: {f§.(,£X,i.:%'8 5:22? Q?":s::.:E§~sec£:'i§}:'z. I E? gj" Sc><:':".z3:>:': 36 %'£?:",£.€i sari';;E'§:3'%p£~;:;§;ea?5é:
.f°§§("/1:19 f:':::;°z.:.z"{.:m:£»> I-icz' ami. E£7:$2g3E.{3;;e>,e%5; .-}~'§?:'<§zf§e?e;=*sr1;7 .%-?'?.__z":'":{§ A{:§':' and the pmz;:is.:iar'2s_-§ <;;"}S<a<:€:f{)z2."2§'2~/E45,:
ii} E-¥iiei,§'3é>r {he 'z"mT§:;>z.:jV2"'2{z£ i,L.L"i£",?£r"=_§ ;f<'}§;§g?a7:4'§§;;' 3.518 pz.:.2'p<;§;e <gf {5{§:§;Ij'駧{£{C££..i;)?'é. é:;fi z.zz':::'i§(-32';
s~::ecI'.:'.(3n. 5§€).§':?f-{C {,3,f}":'iEi:.¢ €;)4'%a€%.f£.é;V£.E"gf,£4£V§,.(£34§} and saies :"a2< c::2::'?g'J<}n;%z§iT_'ésffiggzggféiiv Li%'.:§:j*§:;.;'€i~si>{i 5:': £§'z<-3 §'z}€.:2zE §,:m':. 0L><;*r? .
_i_i.31} ..V.iV,¥?.:»r5;'{;}:1.er'i§ieuLApg';é'i£Vt:;{€';Az1ii'z0ri:.ies z;.z;:ere COI"f€£'I. in ?ité.E--;§1g;;Q. ;i§':«:§; §~?':_s_2 :'r_:i:;>re;;£' receivecé by the 5z.sses:~;ee on; ' $2.6 =9:V2::»:2?°'-- d'2):-:3 "E2633 is 6559:3359 jbr d€(l{,£Cif€}?'E :.mz?£.s2r V-.E~;§Ve=;g;':£Iz'0%'2 8€Z?§z§. of E.}"1:{," Am. :.z.>§*z.erz the ssame was moi; .,ga,;*'z':8c§ fmm :,?':s;.> Ef;:,:si.§'2e3:ss £?tj£?"1"'ie'3{"§ 0:? E335 alfzé-3 éiséassaése?
z in SC: fat' 21$ {ha §'§z°a-iii. &::.:E3:s§',m'1E.i2¥i.1 q::e3:=3é£.{>:2 8? faamr is x«;7:§>1%1,'<:€:z:°:':m=:£L iii s5::;z::a.:'é%E§;' (,':{>¥"?;'.£"€€§ b3; 'sh€: §:,:d;}§:'m;%':1i, of file }s§}e2-g:
A" <":;;v;;~;:~z;. in i".E'1:'% <:2::.<§§% 95 C$.§§@M§fSS§Q§§'E§ $3 §£¥C@f$€E tax 12$ 2%./« 3 24;? fine ;§_<%z'=:i? » Azmiaf EXTREESIGNS LIMETEE [(293%) 329 gm 396;T"~;x»he;~a~ ii.
ham ?:3<3€§3. Etaerid {Rafi if E_E:1.e €z§'1§.}'m}-féfm' iicsiszi2fi.bu§:é::....§j§gs;ESE V:-zzfaii ESE}? i""'v"&';'£': '-.¥h€£"1. ;'n2:.5i.<3 aEE.e:" Q19 daze <:§2;»*;i"a% :.:mE{3';'._ £.E::é.;%T=ai'<';:v'<E:;z;:icE' 5~':c'i15-3 hm'. %3e:<f{:re;;? fiiizzg of the £'€"3'é.'i,iZTfE$ S'i%::«%'§c,i:13 " if»; ,£fiv'E:E:i"E1{'.V1'.'fE(§ T 2-2215i the? 5:;-agiéi ::r3:':.':..1'iE'>u1£032 is; §§a?}2_é%'._é:<) '§:s5:;v_~ '€.§'€?€§.ZIE{_i1,if'Ei e';'.Xp€'.E'§{fi.EZ,3_3T€:2. Eric. a§1:u" view at' '£TF3€."sEi'i.(EI";-- .i E1's: §isu"bs5s':';1§:§;,§21VE {;'z.1:?s%,3;r:m sf ism? is £:3J'TVE:-j§iE{'f3}'§3':(§~'"iii "§:$Z'1'§="€)'i.'li-{i_°. of ':.h{%" a;<é;s;&§ss:;ee a-mzi 2%g;{:»:§nsi: éhe re:z2'<;%§'::.1eh
3. in $0 <15 ':,E§1'éf3 E§€?L?*C:»1"3{i'E:¥Eii1E}£S'[.§-i.I'}:§.i.é1§ q:.2e353Ei0r1 of Eaw iss {?Q{}{?€?I':'{i€€§_¢ giiigsv-;:)~.+c7.(:r*€.;%;c::"I":::§i by 21 jxzdgxnezii: <3!" 3216 Apex C<)m"E. in me ztésgtt ':3! cG;§smi£z§széza:r§R 99 INCOME mg; as mxsam E!/£A.€.E:fI1\7ELi9§?GRIV{.S?._{{;;§Qi§.?E*;} EQQ 13% 36?} W§"E€E'€i iii: E1a.:; '::see§1 heE;c§.{i£.!12§T&. Eixéfif-1'€'~.€§1iE.}:' zfmzié ::s2s.§e:é:'.--3 321,1»: 21:2": :£::{ii:*'c<::; fgezxees anesi do , §':«:::1, §1:vz3Ex;:;%_;i:<T§.§;' %1:z,zr:3<:eve:' and i.IE.1@:":3f<}:'a=% §E":e§;' <:am1:}i §."a:'§:t": par": 0%"
'{li1'<i:.5."E.;é.E"§7E{5§i€§E"..fl§:§7'§~"'5?;%Ji{t§1 1.z:2:€:§s E12?»-':;:* to be: ax{':.E:.zd:3.ci {mm 'ihst ie:3§.a§ 'V E':s':.~§{i '£22. EE.:z.="<>:::' {if '£'.%"::;% 2-?:.::"::§ z:m::i':'1;<~:5L E151:-3. .:':*,=:!::%:'1=u;e':-':. ~ Effie 'i;:§z;':{3v:%::i .2.z:'1::i<:%;" S€:e::é'E<3§'1 §i'8E'i§'-iii: "§."Z:<;;*.:'s:».'§':f>:'<°:;E iihaé saééi <;z.:<5:€=s1.i<>:; E59 3 E2 "E '(M1 35 Ea"; $56 3":-at as *e..E'1a'-2 :"E"s.i:'{"£ s;a:'§3§;E'.z1*z'2:.izs,E' <:§2..2<ts:~g'z.i:}:":f<§£7i2::w LS :'ts,>:3<é<:r':1<;=:{i, §I.§"i€;§ §€:'.£:i'E"1f;"C§ <:m.=..:'1s;ss:%§ Em' £322? §'€?V€iE'E{§{"?i.~~§7€Tf'.§i€:f§ %-<";»;s1; '*;,E1e3 j11<:§§§:1'§€:§¥i, <>§"1:he Apex iimlrt. in Ehéi <:22.s~3€% {if gxé CQMMISSIGNER 0? IN€OM'E T >ff§io!'69}"431-:?.J::»'ar§V .2 1:81 'am: I {T{}Z}i,f;'.f.'1E§S £.Erf:a.¥§. {he :1,z':>:'.e::*s:e;;«E. :';3{:s%i'a-'e€§:.. E}5':,-r_ éhtt ;1'::::=:él<2':,~::~:é*e@'=.'€31=1A iifgéit <3ve1'::is,:e biiis :5; inefiiggibie for ('jE<£1'L1{'i.i{311 :Lmc§s:a,r7_.S~:%<%fbE.<:vf9§ SQHA GE"
£139 fixczi. 2:55 the same '§.21::1!éd ifije b'*.,«>:'.s:§Vi':'"1e;=::<_i;S:_»; <:a:'§'i.eci {FEE by the E1E§S€SSf:'..€';'. The HOE Lay down any iaw to §;.Ej1.§% }1,ad§3;'n'1€;:3:'{. has no app1I:C21{'i0:z'§%. far' c§e::111.c1i()n of i,h<:- i1'1<:0me t'a11:1z/aaifi i"rg>1%.:; 91': by {he 21ssaess;€e as ii, is 3 :1:-"sw i:ia§:;.s:1.:fi21i' ami tin: .§:,;=2.i.c§ incmne éiamaéci wi£,h.i_:1 'fine t§3v'¥"€ES{§,§"}§;;€?{i'~.'§1}{§'1*§{){f1. A11}? §:'1?.ere$'i. gazryaijle 0:": <>xr{«::°--=.:i'ue E{322:Z?€'\i:3f3;?.'é§ £455; £*1ES('} 'ex-;:3....3lE3<:<}%:m% E'.£i'£"'I'i€d from the 'iaasizaczéssssu TEIS =22 SS'€::} we "§f:2::sf{§--":(3:. §'e:;%€:$i$e{§ the zm<:<>1.1;":'é'. an 'SE16: «time (E2136: 33.16 €?:€::*c:>. is 2%}: =<i%7i'3:e13.r in pa_yn";e%n'i'. of %;:he s~32;i.§:§ e:u':":{3:.m":, Uzfieiiez' '£'h€ 21gflz_z":3(::::i»:im: i§'1'z.{;'t§'€f'fS§E'l is §}£'ijy'€i§}§f;? zzzzzm '1 he sseaid §:'1%.a>':'e,,<s'%';. is; ipaid E33; v;=':";;y.j <3? <:<3'::":pe:':ss:.z'£.iam anti 'Eh::%§"€§§}:'€% 0:'; i.§'2£:? {'.§EZ§_{'. Egg: E'§?{'.'.i'f.'ii-"E§fé% éirziz g:'2a.§;i*:"::>.:':é, wiih §;':%"¢:ms.asi:« iéii? €.'fiE.iiE'€ 2::.m<';u:3 "s>::}z1.E{§ b<2= §,h.€? %:'2;7.::>:1'1:*:
;§_}"¥.»/"' {2 ea 'mztgi §:'<;3m E':§":<: '%.:»:::=5i2'z<-';s5;:'-3. A55 s'su{th "Em E3 6é:':"€iE.'Ec%s:i Ea {.i€:{:§a.1<t%..§<}:'; u:;:{is;;*.2* S€:<'?é'i§3:'2 é'30«1';'L in ¥_..E":2;1§. véfiw of the? m2'1E"£.s:*:'r, __t.f2':e f€~':2;':E{§ s.au_E}:e;§'.2émt'Ea1E {§%..zs;%ss§.i<}:'1 05 iaw aésscf; 2:1:':s;w¢::3°e{'§ E3": iii-:w::_Vi.:«z7 'e:.§" the gzzmji a§.j§a.§:1:iai. iim :°s:;'=x-*e1n.::2 1{';§jf€f{f)EfCf§§}§§'§'f§?;.flit r:'--auE}$§;2mi.%2zE g:.:€$¥;.§c3r1s9 E1§'§;": 2::3:1§5w€*.:'&%{§,m§'£(3 :1':t%.;ifE'T.' " 'E-3EEg:f¥,1'§ii§~SSt?'Ci. in .
m :m €§&;=..., kg?-=' jsaég