Karnataka High Court
North East Karnataka Road Transport ... vs Sri Touqeer Ahmed S/O Sri Ziauddin ... on 12 January, 2011
Bench: N.K.Patil, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
§&1%§;HK%§£QU§?<x?xARNA?gKgixaswrfggwfiggwf BHiAR'€v"AD. ~ "
§A?E§§%§s?HE22ww1@£@P&AN§A§$é0;§5"7'"
PRESENT ""=4' _ mg £~t§43N'BLE MR, .j§}S?E:§E ;?;$:§{£DP§'§fv¥¥T§;' = TfiEs%mwELEa@3JmS?§§gkf%§§g§@%ALA:§fiM§A MFA Ns,flsQs%§_%:
BETWEEN:
Transperz CQ;j;;:}o'1=33€'i;:a5:13:,_ V _ Central Qfffcs, Saxige S-9jVaC2'r_:a;::';Afa.§ Guibargag '€252 its E\5Ea'::afi:g§n_g; £';":§*.3£_r?€~:<:i;@':;*, ?;'Jof;*':E": East Kar';é4at:_;:§:;' "
. . _ , mfippefiant {By Sr': S?:1.:'va%é:«;;:r;a:* Egdafiifadagé, Aévzé _:%§;'}:
8:: TG{i€§€&fV§§hIZT::é'éL§,_ S; 9' gr: _j;Z::¢:;:V<;=§.§iér:"Si%:*:rn:,z§E;:? figsé aha-at 24 jsfiaigs} <3 Raiéfifizzrga _'§::£::q, §€T*§g:a.um E3*;}Si€'§:féC'i:.
{ Jgsggadisfii Paééég Eafivg} ... Re$§m':é€:::
I -y 'f'hi3 gfiéaceéfinsazga First é§pp€:~3J:. £3 flied Ejfidfif Ssctiezz §'?'3{1} sf §'»éZ§J, act against {E26 j'udg:n€2":'§, awa:'é._ éaieé 2®'Q-4%=2GG6 jaasseé fir: ?v'§'\z"C- NG,2é22;'20G«$ an the ffi{5_ 7:35 Eha cm Judge gagamq, Member, Adda MACT, S31i:_%":.fi§é1.Eti, awaréimg a cempenaaiian 9%" R34§,éS§{}@{Ii;"-- 'ax:it.Ef;*'*'i-r2_f2",a:>:jT6$';__at 8"/is pa, {mm the éata 0%' petitien tifi reaiizatiom '§'hi3 appaai <:0mi_ng 0:3 for §§'1":£,t3éhé81'i1f§g .':E'§iS. ]dé+.;i¥',' N.§<.i3a§:'§ 3.? dsiiverérd the fséiawingz Thig Ap§&aE by {he Cfifpgéiéféyfiisifg 915%: 9:" the impugneé judgment ar';.dvé:--;§£L~1:"A<:I"--V: gassed in MVC Nat 2622/Qeagzgzg t?:;s_~,-'2"fiéfifixfv":37%._$;;ie§:$§'%v*£§¢;*g€T: Saandatié; {"E'r§bu.r23l' fer = "
:3' 'E'he: €*:~:su;»;a1 5333; : jV'i*:;SV"~27¢_1%:fpi:;:.g:1eé jzzégment ané awam, awaréed .su.m2;§ %:*3;5@,@@{:,r1 with ézzieresi at 8% fmrzi {he '<§.até"a§V§;é§i%.i>nVVM'iii} '£§:§'5ai:& 0:' reaiézatéazz on aCCC%§5:EE?Z 95 this' i.Y:j¥.fi":"§€:"é[' 'aha p€§fi€}1'Z53'FfF€S§G3€%5,;€§Ei £2": the maé :3f&r: a5:/;2<<:éd§:3i's:;, :""E"%2§;* appssiiani/Serperaiien Céaémmg {fiat the "?2j;§;«~?;:%;é:L'::'%:; £3? c:.:::n§e3:':sa.€§@n 3?-,%,:~'*3.:"<.*;'§é:r::§ is 6;-,:<::€ss§2;€ fiflé 'Mp..) zgispmperiiemafass is $116 f{"';€':EE,;£'i'§3 Qf §f1j;Li'§'§@:§ arm': is §?:€:"°€f@:*§ fiabia {:3 'as raducrad, has presented this appeafi.
3., Ths undisputed facts 8?" the Case are; the e:c'::_:f:f¢:_I2'::§'z:§ accident and $1126 mguitarzt é:1ju:°§es in ._::'.éffi<: ""
accidant. Furiheiir, 31': is :10': éisp:;,:i:eé, t'§.';é;€, ':i};f::i_4{:.E;:7.;::}f:*fig;;2m:'é;--
rsspozzéam has u::de:"gor:e tremrygsnéEr::'*'ab@'::;~z" $99 éa§:"js 'L'zf§§€FW€fiE éwe surgeries' Thfi .BG':C{".§I' 313,3 3.::.s eéseG:; dégabfiiij; at 48% is the Eeft eye a::é:i._.§?®f'%€«;_ tE}f"'§'}.'§'f?._'i%;'§;§G_i€ 'body it is 'she C386 0f the Claimant ;¢a3::$:iA;<:$r:a'b.§e:""isgéhgunt is spent tawazdg rr1€&i::..a§.,,e}:fpe;1s,é:§$ v._TE":@r}efo11"é;""'V--%1e {fled the siaim petition under 'sf she zvw, Act, claiming €0mpensai£a:£'aga,.i.:":-is: fie" 3§jj:peE1a.m. Thfi Saéé ciaim petitiem _£:-fame "a':§i-._'{2€éi1:'2§*e §E1§'&-~.'§'_:ff§_¥Q:;;r:a,§ and the: Tribunafi irgiazyn, afier §:::~:a=g:f::g._mg» §:%.;§:~f,£ss3 arzfi 35:61" 3.s$ss$§r:g fins arai ané. V§a"}é3EJ:}fI3_€':'i§aE"jQ"V~V€j%!i.si§.€§1C€ a*2;a.i§e.fit:E& an fflfig afigwed 333$ ciaém §;::é,%':i£};%:§. aafisafaiirzg ?fi§,%3G3€}Q{}j-- mafia? éi.ff&2'€z"2'é: hfiadg with. 3-.
f§_:1'€:$";§$€"~«aé 8??/=22 imam this d.;=:E€- $5 petiiian 35%}? $226 dafzfi :3? mairézatian, Being aggrifived with éihfi qaantum 0:?
camper: saggy: aixsardsd by E}: E T:%§.E:L:na.i3 §ip§eRan:;1C0rpezaE1?@n has fiiaci {big fisppeai $e:€:}§.§;j:g.':f§;i__§§;'2'€:€§!:;.r:
sf quantum of cgmpengatign awazded by the "_§%fé,';:>1_:::;f:;a:;§:.§" 4» '$553 have iiéayd the §ea:*:1sd__ c{::{§_ ré._§eE ap";<:€:~::Aét::g fair' appeEEa3":tfCerpGrai:%@:r: and $36 §<=,é:*V:f§éd_VVCo'z,::fg--S.,é}}'épygearing fez' Q15 rafiiwrzéerzi,-"CiaT';mar:*:.V
5. After sarefzzi perusa}....é:{{_'éihe.;1m§§%;:gfi'é1gi".JuégmeméE and aw Ed, we are 2r;i§:%xJ<.5 ..i'}J1a t_<V jE.?fi1€'VV*£"i'§bz:r:a§ h&$ ;r%.ghtEy awaréed %<':'__l,2if;,Q{}'{j:V;~, 't§<;2;é§*&_$' -'meéicaj expenses 3.3 per meémai bsliigg.32€},Q{1'@f'§ *:Q€%;=:35i'<Ei'$ C@17§V€};'aT£EC€, zszauréshing and at§5n€§;a:1§.ghargf€:s_.Vanr3;* i€'»:_*§,0'3€s :10: caéi far 2§:1;i€?fer€;::::e. Bu';
;_'vi;'f':'é"i«.._A'§':"i'§§j?§:§$i~1".:%.L':V: €::°:€'€di 1?:v*--------.2ward:%mg §SO,QG§,,---'F Eewardg §:'1jU;rj;, §a¥--i_fi' 3333.$"z2.f§'::»:%§:t:g'$._a::é %'§%,G@@__;'-- mwards Eggs 9*? a:':;:m':§_?.1?.&s, :iés:c§1<zi:"2:§.:fi3VV":;é%f:ha§;§§in6:$-S a;z:.{:% ?3324%,€}{7§§g'-- E:§:<:a§*d$ 3333 sf §'a:%'::.,:_:5 ;I'z"::.:a;;is__*;:$ aféé iihfijgi 3:55: 3:: Ezéghar sééa a3 réghfijg pairsziéé Quf: by $115 ééarnafi €:eu:r:se§ apgs-a¢§2'*:g far the appeiiant. Tzibzmai has e:"re§ in aasegsézzg pezmananf: d%;§a$3:'E§?i:j_: §éE:--»T5§{>/E} witE*:€§1,§i: agségnimg vaiid reasengu ,_,E'%?v.€E'°€l¥'fi1"€'g §2as:ir:«<r.1f2:;?g?c:;:€:'§';.§3 the nature af injuries szxgtaérzeé, we can safe£}§%:'é:.sa3.s}::3$_$ 't%::%_ ' ermanem éisafiiiiév' at 3 % izzgéieazjé sf _5€E53/§f--;;. ':}"§'a.w-96225?' .fi.hA%3 T:*ibur:aE hag righfigi 3.3363865}; :h<~:_£r2c91121e'*::»f %;?::é~e§{air:2s£;:1fi';s§:"'L, ?3;GGG;'»~ par month am ii is jug? ;3vr0p--é'r'- aéié {B353 SE3:i"}:1€ is accgpfgefi. :F'Lz2:':}::er the 'E':*-§.3.§f;'-':§:a?; %}--z2é"€f:'%TédiA_i:: 320: awarfiing C€}E'B§€1'}S8;i3iO1'1 iG'Wa?.';&S E::>s;s._%3f '-§:1<:eif;r€<»3 1é TE;}1':¥.'i3(§«g treatment psriad. W6 pres%.;m§é;' _.§:.:<~t:~ " mI;ghE§"I%1v%é i3;:*:fiergr:3z":6 fafiaw uga treaftmfint §0 :;?§V'f§1<3z1t§"18. Congiéaréng the nature ar:s<V§_éu?ati{§1é "':_%«§§§v._%ié*e§§;:.:~;:15:1': undergone, éi3a":::fl§t}»g fliscemfor: aétfifi~g:132a;'p§§::.é$$u~7=:'::e be Suffereé ihmugh 0:2: his Eéfs 'az:{§v..:§§$:§ "$23 fa:§r::'?:--VéT:Ef:___a_§:_E25 Cafififii d.és<:hargs big day is éaj; : ?£§;%§:§?£Z§aEE'?.'§§§S§ arm 3:0: $::>::é;%:":"a:;<3 Eés m€s.ha:":§c prGf€~§s;§.«{:_«:2 W6 §€€"§fl 'E: {ii E6 aaarayfi ?%Q§€}C%Qf«« """'%:'a:%:a7a;:=dS»..§_:/3;z,::<5;:,_§%~z%é:*: arm'? suffering, $2-'%§?G{f%{}/W '*;m-2,-'3._7:°&$ E933 sf ._:'E%.._?f§}€?,f§}:§"i€$3"?§iA§%;C{3*EE5Ef(}§"'E am? E.,l.§E§'Zé3.§_'§32§f'i€SE5§ ?EQ;'}G"'°;'-- E{}'€fi=.«"EL}""§$ X'
2."
«:
§a§p83£.a::§;'Cm'p@:"at§on £3 fiirézatfid is fiepeséé remaénizzg cempézxgaiian 'ax-';Zt.E1 6% "§E'§'£f;"'£"€i°S?C £r2stead; "<»:sf 8% 832%-'aZ"§€& by '?:r°§b1;ma.L iaiiihin f:h:'€€ 3%/'fi€§*:S f:'gm..~«~tE:.¢,§'£3,fE:é'0f receipt 0? cepy 52%" '£216 jzzdgmeat anfi award,"__;§;g;:;3Qé5.%§§a::;3i5";:.AiV'"
352$ the manner of éisbursememé ::i;a<:§e_Ab:;g£73364T:*i_'SL:;1>__a§.Vge%;3 yeéucad aCCa3:'dingiy, Amcsunt in d_€§:>o$é€ shaii be %fr~a,::s§er:i'e§-- :5 'the Vémncerneé 'E'r1*.b'un3§ farthwithk Qffice U3 d.z*av<: the a1a2g;f<i a..cfiiéVr§i::gif}*,--».I'V_':v .. av: . ' {"2-