Mrs Arathi Narayan D/O Late ... vs Mr M D Balakrishna on 26 August, 2009

[Cites 5, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Mrs Arathi Narayan D/O Late ... vs Mr M D Balakrishna on 26 August, 2009

Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar, Aravind Kumar

. ...é~,B_§.
,2", 'I .\ as.
5 ' £51
5 7 g

3' !

1 KEV

 

9%/'

IN THE HIGH COURT' OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

Eetweenz

And:

 m:;:~::t> .§:E%{E}§.J'E'A.'T£j'(} 'r'§«:;a:£:s::9
 »:§;:~;:f E\{£'}; 55,' «E§A;;,ga<: E12 ra<:};a_:;>.
* L.133;ra:q<:;a:,.§:a§g§:  

, 2%/'<3 m;I'§:._ SR? 5::112.;;;:;a.:x;§.:%{1:2--:gaN13§;:?
 ";:%{;;»§:1:} .sx::_%.<31J"§' $2 Y§::A§2s3:.
»§~€,.-Cé-'{:7'_;a 5,: M §%Z§?£'i'§a'E'E§;_
- ' :f;::g%::,g%;g:-;a:ga:.,§,: E3{}EE'E.',
--  via E%z%§',EﬁfE€1'E%Z-'§', 5§'%z"7§.?':f1.§4E§$§"§i(§3§4§§{f§?2§_QE,,§§§.

" "'Kz%§'%3'§fi'§'iE§<:§2 §?:% 2.24;;

DATED was THE 26%: DAY 92* AIEGUST, 2009  
FRE-SERVE' " '

THE 3%i()N'BLE MRGJIESTICE 9 V SHYLENTBLRA    -

ANB _ .. _ .. _ A
THE HGPFBLE EVIREJIFSTICE Aagévmix .f{§§'?l3'Isf§,§3..Ri._'' « _   '
©R1G1E\E"AI, 3:133» 2'-'sPI?'Ii';AI. N0§'3_oé%*2%:3G8'~  ..

1'%:'IRS5 ARA'.I.'.'£:II NAf€?vJ:'2X?€
:3/5} :,mf£:: M12 M :3 ?€2\E%J«'xY.%5;E\E

W/O 1")§%.AL{';}K =:tr~1c>:;J:m;;:.R'2<.

AGEZI3 AB()U'I' 46 ypzgxrzs, " "
PE:RMANE£NT1,YR/;¢'{E" :1<><> _
F'£.§.4A}i£*3SE"1{}R§1 132~zm~:,   « *

AP'? ZFA <::H:<:A<:c:u._::.;I.,:N§>:5s ..

:1, 686% :,Lts.;>y._  _ _   _ 
RE? E3? HE;F<';;' E>z3'wiI«:z{v-<?:z:s* xx'-:f:ifg}Rx?&:Y   '
2-;ci>mE:R é:xs1':"z.*?s..-»'*I§:i_:_%;:,,1\«I 1;§;*:*;ss§;is_§3=E'%;+'s,A_  * 
gage :2s<:_. 2 1.9 {:13ENEN'§3$§_f}E»i;i._M.f€{}£%§?3.., ,  
E3.saN<:;A;4,<>;§e:'wag} 032 ' .

£%i§"E3 EELLE-'\§\E'E'

 ' £3'; fzéfézségzzxfi¥§~;T's;ﬁé.:~€:3£TT::'. ;s;§}v.,§

MR 2:2: E} F3.AE.£é§§.§3:E.S'§'1iE'€;% V'
$;<ij.: 'm:::: 3322, M.53*;z:>§«%sa1:v:a<>::;sx>v:3;x

:x:::c2;:§;":%::§ :3 _s§;é§;%;':V=§TT£§Q;¢:MEy':£:a
Ejégagzfm :~':gmzsa;i2"g:<:;{:2w£>ga

E'§.z%%f'§$z'%.?€ Ei}§$'§"'E%:i{_',1'Ii'1



 s;z:_£':: €$._€:'§> __saeééié'"_~;}:'<:=;'§§2i%:€ <3? 2: WEE <§2';E.e{E E§.{'§3;.2€}i}:E s_:sa.i{§ £25;
 {' 1§"}_2T£§.»".~':? %:;€:@.::'i2" <;%>;€;f:<?:?;;éfé:§ E3}? :;'«.:':e  E} E'£2::'21§:z::§. W%1{> ii'  2;;a;€;'.:'r:*{§

_ _{§i':%€:§ 8:':  §_{}§:»?;{}{3£§ azsi: 'iifzgé £.E.§('? <35 75? jg<i%gi:.:°:%a 21$": §r~E<:§::.s9;§.::r:§ 

3

"I'E~I}.;'EE§ EX§"I{'Ei§'1i. C-{}MI:\§{T} {E33 i*"{.}R HE3..<'-"iRI'E'€{}, "i"E--RS 1{}:"«.'3", D V
Sf:¥YLEN.l3RA KU§Lﬁ.J,' i fI%ZI,EVE§§{¥§I) "I"§"iE':"3 I3{i}I,I,Cf)\¥"EN{i§:

JUDGMENT

This is an zzipfﬁﬁffécﬂ 1.::'2e:i<:é3: i'3€?(_Tf'['.i{)2'1 of €126 Hi§§}'1 C<§L;r"£, §';<é't', 1&8} [far fi-31"1(}1'.'ii e:i€éf€:1da:'2i_ m. :9: §I€:?'5:E'EI2?{.ETt'T1é?i'}"{.é:¥.1':._; 0r§;g.E1_'1a1 V 's:I":é3 file «inf this €:«:>ur¥:. is; iiitsr £i}':T}E3€;'f1}hE?t.I"'i'if:"'%.§fihiﬁh « ' 2* '_§'he appeal E3 €ii§'E*.{.'fi4('.£§::4_%ig;{£1i£'.§V§%%;.?::fi..€.;%< péiésvf:-§Af;'EV€A¥; by me Eitatfneii Singie Jmdgtt :31' a::_;r.1:§i. ""'&%Xé:i:--i;%i:1g§ <}rig.iI122§ §m"isd1?<:*'£:iaI: ami E:.:'§,i%j§.r.zg;:;"*'i::;;, tiiéswtﬁiii<;>;:':_§az:'jgé' é::::t2*€J' zmd 21ge1inst ihé {}I'd€3§" pasgezi {>11 -EA'::.!;\?;:§;Vx3 %>§'«.;2'¥G€3? LEI': igffse SUEJE. wE':§<7h wag am a§:>;}i;1<:22Eii<}.n t.:§'1:ii_s>§°T C:,i:'?:c3ie%j_:9 2; and 5 1":-:21{i wiih E:§f3CU€}E"1 1:3} 9? the: .<:>:f: §';§*'<>_{%4:éf§iz;zra%, £908 {far Si'1(}I"'€'. "she:

caéeﬁ.

:%.L, fE"§:t:f; Stzii .eEf}j,54'§§«7é_f;? férsai: mi:-'~:p<>:':{%£."rf§éi Ezssrem ~-- pi2;2,.§:':§;§€f H2 'ihéf T .. ,§--Ef-éézéiiéssiéa mi" ;"%.::2€2*§z:".%2::.' "§.'§'f::=t= :T:a%:"€.§§'§_a:=.aii? €35 {"§€,'.§Ii'§i.§'1 .§§é§§§E,§%;"fi§ E3»? §* 'VT:pa»%t:Vi«€..:€:>:3§:%:"( 5% Eégéaar :":':<;}:n%. §°z2:::€s=.:. {§.§z7:aé.é?::§ E323 §3:"<;>'§;;2:§;a% §>é:%%',§%;.;£s.>:'3 4 i:,hé3 211,1i:.hm:iI:ié:és.§ ix}. mtg: (T§.1f.}" 4:31" H<)z:1s3t::>n is-5 :'°_"-§{_}'L.§§__§I'"1§ ii} bfjf ;'3ia1<:€<i in illflﬁﬁ pm5::321t:£r~ §::<i%t.i%:i{f;.n £x.n.:1.ex1.1:*<2~C £10 Eiim p:€:"ét:§.t:i<3'r":, 32$ aiséo pieadetgi t:E12é:i. 81:? {i{3(,T.€'§£?iS€('i g:z€.~.;'e;<::1 had 21 r€s:;f§_s€§:':1{ii::{';2J::"~ E.'~J<::,6Q§ 9?" §'xz'Ez-11:1 Résazzi ﬁt" <ffm:.'~;.:-is, REX? Exit-::n.ssi<>n,"'~B21:*;g::1§c:;§*<;%J ~ 5630 G80? and wag perma:1€;3f4Iy r{%:§idi171g::%'ii." fhi;-5:'-§}A§21.(f€, alga'; 1'€v:;%a£ed f::'0m {£16 f'a€:i.&s é15?}»--§§,fk§('3*ET';_f,é1IiI"§if§<C§__ pefﬁiom that': £1316 cie::?:e21s,;:'-:d p.§.-::°s;<:;*gV--§?--3VV:;1A.if§.?5z:':.e.:1 %7'};1"E?..E'Ff,€d:§3I.£) {me Smi, Rukmini Szissappziz tI"u1ﬂ;1i: iégiiweeri. them wag diascﬂvtsrd 218 pemged in M62 336,19 er 1.92% §;:::e§:.;g§"~::,%%:;<;% 'i_:§%i»eg§i";,_3ucige at E3anggj_a;I<:)ri:~ zmci out sf 'E":=c1;§ (me iizzzxgihitéz" ~»~ the first, f€Sp{}E1€:if?'E}'f,.!_i{i V...%«1::1ci firssé. €§{E?f€'§}d£'£I'E§ in the auit, V I ' g§_§fc;?}_21é.aé Z pf-%.2?'.ii%,'§<>z': aisé} :"eW-;z13s Ethai; é;h§>; §::§:%:ééi.'%€3:*:§;":fg5§E';:;i€'x%;é£*3§:'Ezzazﬁ 33%;": zz'p§3'>i:1'€:.a:c§ &*>«;<3<::':'z.<>1:' {Eff the ' '-..E7'?i§§EE ${}'§.zf5§.§;§:i. ia "i'}*e%'j__§:3i"z>E322.%<;?{i 3133:? éiimt. Em :£_$ i,E:.€: E'}r{>?;:§'2£3: Qf §:h::=. _ _(4"€.§.,%'f§"if:-égsééfii ;:=<;éf:e;?{'}:2. 'E'E"2.<:: §"m~t.h<31:* 2z2;€:r.:.21€::1i;s are 'i.h5i.t ézhe:

2 its 2«2;"<% {Eff §..%":_€: {§e%:;_::%2?:§5£;*r€§ 21$ '%'&»'€:'.*£§ fzihs-:

.2 ,4§v élféff t:I=1aE', Sélid R1.:k1ni:':.i I[}as,;2;ppz1 Emzi 5-:s*:.1':3s«:=:c;u<;%:1i; m {.116 c?§§s§s::>h.2€,ic>:': 0%" '€;h<»é me::rr£agg;'€: rr:21§*:'ied {}I'1€ Sri. 1% G V §'%.g%§:%,«:1},;' and :'hr:> fii'f~;§'Ei 1"'43E¥i~p€)§"1{'§{i'£'1EL gg;:"m>a»* up wit.1'1 them.

5. It is .21_Eso f:h.@ av<3:'1:11:-?:a'1*:'. f:h.:1'£. in ';jE1e': Cii'C§i.'i41T:'i;'§§'{1E'kIT:(Ti'tLf.gE:i.__Afh§_7A' first re%s3p{}11::§e:1':; did not r€sa'idt: w:§Ji:,I:3f' "E2::t;éi E} the dis-;ssx:)iut.i0:1 of his r11.arI'iage 6' Fm"t'he;.:f facts pieadcdv p'£A;%1fﬁss<3:r1 haci £:xecui;ed 21 WE on 0f {.116 at:?:€s«3"€:1?::§_§ vsizi€.z1es;§§cs3§~.:.é}ﬁ«§': u':\%'ik':iV§E emd t:e$ta.me:1f sf iii:-3 aiettezzfsjegig X-viii Eihi-3 deéteaésa-rd gezrscm haxzi in Eifgdia anii abrazzé zmlmigssfi. {:hs5 éhe p€'Li§;i(3IHf1' and {he <;*,:§;€_:*,;t%;,z*€,::3:*V,.ca_¥:§: 9§§':~{-% WEE? fin" grezrit, af §>r<:bat.:;% {sf the §ﬁ:'§§§__é3:}:f.i<;;;t. tibia:;};2fi.%:f§{>.r1<;%r cam §};i'§-*6 <;=,fi'{%ct '£10 the §?%,="iSh€3§% ef {he §i%S§iEi§L(}}'Ai.§'"I:«é7§{3iTf{}E3§§«E£§}if{? with {the €£.€.rr§':€~%; sf 'E.§*':£E 'éfafiié V""§'nh=j:~. p€:?i.é;i:é<:::2 8.§${'3 €fX§}ff55:'§S§_'§,-' 2=g:i:é3:.r *z.E*:2':z€. 131%:-=, éigzrszéezsstéii ._ .§>£:%:':s<3:§Vwziasé ism: {}3":§j£ 2.: §}:%:'m;2:§'1:;:3:':'E. :**@s=_>;;ie:%e:':'§: 22:? .E3::m§g;';2E:}r<?: E:m'i.

2:a.E:%:,> <'§:'2§.m7{T:§§:% 223:; E-E:-m;§_--,.;;2«:E:.::a:"£;: "§""E':s.=:: ssé::§'_:_:%s:§:§§e'::ss :":::::a §f§"§{§' §§{}iI£S;i::{3§% <E}}"§A emd $;:h;s;:%: ﬁzz? }}E§E)§§.§(3E'}.€.§" Eiatui i:'1f<::r;:2"1{3d "%.hvé:~~§';';:"-sgé, .2:*'::t$§3*§::3'Vﬁ":%:i'{;:":§. gr": m$§>{>.::*:"é',:£2n :3? SEQ": 2=:;§321riZ.§3<1%:::ii :*<;%.1€§°:;%

-'§.:E?"Vs49::f'i§§%:{Ee:2z'%§\civ"'u2'a&; 3%:-ring Iii"; E~§«:>:..::~»;§:{;z:, he hascé ;§.<:sit. iixzizzi 215:}:

E::?;§i2:;":2€1':%; a;:2{'E €i.§":&."£ii. Em-%~. .E':§is:;% éﬁfiéigé zamé. E{%_f'§i. Egmi, EFVEEE V'*._2E§'i{E.€,€S'§;é§E"E§{f'E"§§. ;::'2.{E £2: é?:"2§$ 'v"13€f'iﬁJ si:;a§' %;.E'":§% 22:'2{E€;%§*:--a:é.z:§";z§é::g {>5 §.'§".§€;'? 5 p<:£:i'i,;Z£}:1 ggz-zwr deiaiis af ihe pr0per"§.ies. m{}v2?:b1e:s; and im_r:10v21.b1s3. azxzi Wgill was ss:>:.zg;§E2t: Eli} bi'. pr<3§321i'.t-éci xx.»-*it:i:""'*i}1e 1::1d:?:"t.2:}§i.z'1g§ fiihai: 'she p:*<>pc%rf.i»3s3 Wm 136:

a<:<:<:=:"da.:'2_<:<-3 with {he X-".7iE3h<3$ <:f£',E1.<-'5: f,a=%s;i4.:_m}r( ' '

8. On ESSLZE {}f:1Uii£'.E;'t ix: 'ilhéf pa:at;.it:i<3::1: §V'1:§":f--§'é:

W110 haéi amtti-rretzi .21pp<:~am..n¢::e onv;ra:§rea1{"a1§%§é{>A. fi1€3{%..i'T)b§vE{';T1:'d::ié; irzfer aiiay pieziciirzg t..hat the first r(;%S;.;f<f3:3.ci:3:1'i{"€sg ithé sixie irérgai E'E€'j.§.I'" to ihe €'S'E€fE.€ 0%" the de><j{-:as,~§e.;i dau.ghi;:<':r of the deiteased; E;h;1i?._: was ii} and had been fﬁst; regpéyxagierzt wha wa;s=. iizrérzcf .i;5':; :%s':.:>:fz zzréd ziﬁﬂczsdeé. ii} her f21%.i":m" {iE1§'.§.}T",l§4._{".£f'i--L';-'5 her feaﬁlar s1.:C;<t'urI2be<i; "E0 §§£;};es§-2:, GI} $9.1")-L<'..§;:2V.8Q;':*".s 21%": E§(:u§a'£:<>n; ihaféi 'i:3;1<;>; p€r"E'.iii®£':€i° had ai'&:;-3, v§.§§:::e<i. 'i'.}f:{»3 deztezzs-;€:€E perszm at "£319 h{>sep§€:2:§ 13::

ME "*-.E;5?:a§' EEK':._%;.:"1:s3.$§g'§=g.;:'i::.2.2*e%: cf éhe {'E€;"i§3€?E1-S€';'ifi Mitzi daess 2':.«;>i: :*&~éfE€<7't ~ 'w.EsE2e&; if _?.E::': <E<;%<':::?as_s€<§ ii': 'E:§":_<3 .§":";2:2i',?{.:;-':2' Qf Eyziégzieaéizaé 95 §§i€;'f = .?§'_§f:'a: §"i:f§§":. ::"a%:%§}<}::<§§::'3§. E': 21:? §,I%':r<:2»;.:§;;§3 Ex-':.:* $e:;:41:"::€ "<;§E}--i..:T;'§_;f:_$%;i <3;%:'§3e:?r%." {T§§}§E'Ei{}i'"i :55»; '£9 {mi ga-._§a»'=%1.":'z,.:E:::€;',* mzsgsg azzef Eihi-:;= 7 first: :"€:$p<>:1de:':t:, the €it3€?€E-3.S€{i E':2;1:'1<ien1: far the 'i"irs:et'. '{2§I"3i1'§3. §-S £ip§'}1"i.S€-3C1 £13121? :3 Wiii Ezexé been exeeéalieci 135; §:'_if;":'£" fz1{«:1g};.,

-She haii {'..*€)}fE1€f to Emdia in <7<:s:1rT1«:3<:t;.i:3 :1 with i.}1"u;% me vczikzzma :_s;ama1'adfT1c:n.a amii sazhe Wit} sf {ht} <i<;rc::%21s€€i mg be: reiad, QL_1t: <)fi'O5;..i "é;'r':21*;.E§§:'1 'V O5s1E.2:0®5, £1116: Cit)-::u._rn<§:1'vi,;?1,:rp;}r€:%;§ﬁi'L_:':16' i.1iE Q1" thﬁ decszzsaed amci ailleggediy n121dé 4:1' fifélﬁi {mt by the AciV0{:*a:t;e §3r21::i:i.:t§;§§g;v:.;it ";;§é%s§2'n::c of letrge mxmber of iézmigfj} ixtzcthiding the pe€it_i<>ner am her m1<:1e5:; and u.ne1ii;4eSt<--:. A523-fC;_«:7z:'§,¢ v'i7J}1(} had rsad (3113:. max? 30 aitzzﬁeii %§;':Vi'§.«.V_"§f'h:%__'§':1r§;I'_ §°G_§;§}{}§1{f€rE'ii:'{}'Q§€i%C1:,€{§ is the g€I1'iT1§§}(3§}€E'§S of the {"i0<::é;::gz:<>,:';%fp:*§:;*:§{ég>{?é:«:3§i"as €116 'i?i?'i§E {sf $19 daizézeiss-id $1}/121?. dig} rxgﬁz. WEE, agL:>§;':e;c-aéé:;°£»; {iii}: a::icEi.'i:i<§.na§ :°:%_;':}i:i:{§€=:' wzgg §i]a::%{£ an t%.{§';:2.{%G'éEEi aviziz 's7%'Ef1i{"?§{1 'i225: 9222:? E15}? 2=%:r§; <":<:2'§"a:;:é':';":\';@{§ the: ":3%:V'a:§e::" ;§;3§3£%si.§.:%<§ ibis <;:r:'€E%r:r ::§;;:§,€&<§ Ti" :2{}{%? §}E?:f:Ef=Z*-€55} 9 "[1? Wi'1eii'2.er §l}"£.é?' pEaé:'z:,g'['jf" proaées: {hat fhe Will. da::z.Z:{-zd 25.04.2004 pmduce:>c:i aiong z,:.2i:':i2. £h.i.:'~.; pe{z'.zz'<::~rz and. marlaced as ;*'n'1r'2;s<.£) is zihe East Will s:;m.ci I.es:.{1;:r'z::?:'zz. cgfSz"z'. M l}_Narag;m1 and the game has S';r:3::>,;'24 d':.z.E;; exeCzz.i£3<:i by hz';r7'z? j [2/' Wf1ez:'§'zez* {he marlcei v.:.:lu.x:% qf z'}'zT£3 esz"c_;::é3 Qj"'< T: Sri, M I} Naz'c:;;ar': }"aa,s,; been a,%aiw2d"'.a:1df"~ COi.H'E_]'%':'*€3' paid. is szg[}"ic::'er1I','?"_ b' ,.

12: The firszt d<3fe.:'1ciar1E: 2vva1--:~: . §)€¥I'3"{1-'§€""g'&:1'n(':};.ff}-»;}I1'iéIiCi'§'1f§1T*' évritteza $tai:c~:mei'1t in iE:e:*ms of the and 0:1 ﬁling 0f the {:"g:1vi%sCq1zeI1t1y this court permitmdj __ r'e._§@i_z1€i<?r ':9 the aamarnded "sJ€:.!'£;""}:'{.'?L.£:T'}"!'V§;U pEa§:2§:iff {ﬂed i:w»::s rejainderi-st '}';§"1§: 'lfirsét, aﬁfter {E19 x..x.-*";:'§3:'.i',en :'«3%atem£-rm. vgas aIn<:'r3:¥ed aaﬁasi add:-f.i€}:_1;éE~~*'issue ha\;'§:";g b€'3€£'§'i f'ra.med; an 2_2'V.'i«-E_A.2G§"? {:gf1{.hv{5 f:*J;I1'§.e'}f3i{'§;€:'L? W-"z*i'i:*::z~::»z1 séteitenwrit, as tinder: __'"fL§Qé;:i:. é:z:':§7e:'é:§.s:;z*':*: N9, 3 §:3§"(}Z3€ gm: {he 5;z:,z'.E £5; bam3d E32;":¢'§5T:;J§'é.g:s'£§:?§;§:;z'fé""

/"' //j 4;?

by the iezarzmd ssirzggic J'u{igc sf izhis cm.:r1:. on 11136: app§i<3a!;ic>I1 zine; r@f7e1'1'e:d to 21'i)()§-9'8'

14. In the 21pp1.i{:21'é:i<31'1, iihieé firsst. detfcI1{i21:i1E: pf'.EiyE3§i._'f{§V§;'*:1fI{ﬁ."--.

Only 'fmmi:1g éiiie qu.:3rssi:i<>r2 {Ff U16 E§L,Ei'z', 'b€i11g 7£i}fc1'1""3'ff';',C,jI '£.¥..E% ' :5i::._f E33119 buig. 335$} i4h;:-1%. ii: sheuld "be £;ri€:d asé 3, c/.'i_1'15:1'in21':"j;:f i..5_~,s<;f{1'e:;' 15: In the affidavit. 5;upporiir:g---~--i;.E§:3 "'2:pp1icé:t.ic:sn..v»'iii. was §)I.€";'E1df3*{i, inter aifa, mzazt. '£1915:I'péi:iiic§I1€:f=. 'r1at§,inséﬁuted 21 pet.i'{.i.«:m for grant §:f- §>r:_:}b2:;;_{:e .'E:':s€:f:,sx:eA"~.;§3f§:§>¥£:'z3.i;:3I C*:{}E.1I'i, No.3 ('If Harriss C{:«1,:m:y if; {E32135 Urlmzd 8ta2:.e;<-3 of Aznsrica, Sgesiiinggiﬂx \;s;§gjg\~";E{)<t::.:m<5r1i: {:Ea.£§:n.ed as last: WEE ::1zﬁ'*_'g.é's};.:1§:§§§:;{'igﬁgﬁééézxsaéisd p::%rs;0:"}. {3X_{3Cui:e{i cm. §5,Q4.2SG<§} g:*1;?'i"'§4;<.1 ;§.21 i¢j_ :ps;";"»tL'V'.i1£::i<::::: b«:-éfore "she £'<);*eig_§r"; <.:0ur§,, E1236 *g3EA2:i11i._§}E*f ..;}:E<:;aA§:V§':%':}\_.£.':§~ maﬁa:

_ 'fa; _§.?':--:>_ é:,E%é€::?._>a5;e?e:é', dies? in §tf@::$i'ia3': an E E} Q{i'i"G§9€3§'° " ._ ,25'59;_"~;~%.:% - " "

I53} £,E';:;§ :;'3:?§€ €1C'a:,:r:. aér E-f0:.§.5§'a§': fT1:cz5ijz.§.;"£5§<:§f:?i.ierTz :0 ;'-:;2g';:- amzi E23; 2:339 pm§2az:'{_2 ;3eiz'.§.:1:2r': :;~:z':'::'re {E-2:': deégreaﬁed Ezaci €i:2m:'s;riEe:% in azzd ciieesi arzér §~is:1r:°:'s z;L'@'a.a;2E§.; in s£:§":§{;'§'z ajazm £31,; éfze iféégg Q!' §:§{}§,.;,;<.;éor': A .€:':; $:'§.uaE;e5i:

V'A.&%:§<%':1{i2§,;'§_i:"MWag;'igéiﬁ:2:: "%f2'Z:§E{i azid Z;21ﬁ;:%,:1 'JJ"éi§_: Efgaé: ii". E";23_€§ .m:;§:

-. ..sig§:":e{%j' 'E333 zE":9 <i§%::::;=::&&;{?€§.

1?; j " §'§'"i,S ?;£§${i% %§E.Z:El{E{i in :'.E3*:': a§§."§{i22ﬁJi€: €:E':2'3,'§': EEK: p:~s';b;z:§.{=%. :"r{>:.:r'i: '::§"s;;::::',,,_§%%§E:}:s:§r2g; '§zm:.ha=;%:* :"::%{_%£*§éa-31"}? ;;>;"<:><_:é2%{§I;.2z*:;:se; figs 1 1 {cf} Em; 0rig::'::a.§ cf {Em éiispufed Wail was dep0sz'.iies:z'. by {he pZai:':€.;'[f be3f'2>re3 this Horz'}:rh3 Cfeurzl in Pz'0Z:>£2{.e OP. N0. 1 ?' QITCBOOS;

{(1.} :'.ha2f in :'.';"2e e::er'z:j me d9c7sgasé?::i dieai E!'Zi£?$'{(£,i.g3?.VV':"

I w0u.I..«:i. 298 the orzly heir e:":€'zfz'Zed. to ifjzfterié.

izize esiciié-' Q1' ' fihe? airs-3::?ease>d¢ " V 16% It is 21330 further &3t.at.e<:i {E12111 Vt:E'_:'eé {.ft"1§;:»._ piziimiff, thift pI'{)b21tE% rnaititer bei'<>;fe_ 1319 i'oré3:.g,§§12 {37£)L'§[iT'{A.'*+.>E?At.1EI71!f". Ezéz'; €ria.E be:--:.f:::sre at 31.11?' amd on ::{;;'1<:I1.:&§e-tag" <3f"the .t,'ri:1Ev.}3ef£3':~e the jury as 011 GE¥.G?',2®G?, t..h§' Juzj; having exexmined the {;'4'\,?i.€1.€;3.§1'{.7:§:f'§ Zgét. wit}: the first é€ffi§'}dEi_I1'L' aisa €'?X£i§I1iE1i1'1§--Zf; {W0 i1e};:1d*=.,>:.,-*r§i'.i;"i§§..;:a%i§3.£:§f%/5; 0? America as-5 aga.i;:1si: 01163 :§:;:::'21;.:'1(1:';:1«:%<,§ by iims: pEai21'i:§ffa.né whvz: had '{:<>2'z1;3L.Vf:°<§r1VV".§:V the jury ha.e:§ éieéivereé an a1§_;;"ia::?;_i:':1<:s§_:z"§i; a§:§1°1i§_<:§: {>1:§GE§-;-$7.208? i:1d§<:;s:i:§r;g_§ iheaé; ?ih~f;'% zziieged W k'pS;:,'§.¥§:}€:},§'-%EV,V£::E§i£E..Ej;;f}: behixizd by the f?aJ£,§1i:::' <3?' '£:E:a firm', 1 2% :/,. 4 £7' 12 E)I'd€E'" <ia'£:e2:i 2€§,G"?.2U{)'? zs1ii<;w§:":g; m<}'£.i<>:": <3? {Ears re:sp<>3'1cie3'1t, for Ju{i'g;m€.z1§ in f.é3.m1s's ef i:}';<;? v€:_r(£i::£, {sf i:.h:3. j:,:ry £iI1C3:"'f.£1€? ;'€je<:€:ir1g ﬁle? 1"I"i{}§§~f}I'}. of the p3a.i:'1f:i§f' zfur z'§?<i§'<-M-':5.~"s::I~;2;._.1_ 'J{f1?'di€.?"{. Gf Eifles jury.

18.' it is t,§.1.£_éreai"t.er that the f€)} '.€ftig§}" ' ;.j:<:>"z,_.n"%é"' -fégzgiefégi Jzxdgmczzni: an 26,07,289? in <:<:r:§§:€5'é:f;f1::<:§; {if em-3:1 dam: and the modiﬁ€:é1 rétrardaéd, it 13 Si:a§;<id shat'. thc_p§a1i:1t:;ﬁ7_ }f;2;<r.i V._§%iiL1&3ﬁ~vVV?fjé§Vfg}fé the fC;:z'r3_ign_ cmsrft. 05 <:€)mpe€:e'n%§; is pro'.-'<3 the very Wiﬁ s<}L:gh£i ; j'::*'<i;'v€-§:iVV"b<:~f"()1"<3 iihiss scum; in {he presem. WESLE was ge1";2,2.§_:":er 'f0i'gé:c§; {ms '2i:1"V*§;v%1i<%E1 'g:e.ra_s3 dire{:€.E;; zmci SL:_bs::2ir1::§;§§_§y L.fw2z.:~_:;V in iS:E%LE.E'. in pr{:='{)2«:*m pe'u?ii€>n 62€3--4G 1. bc%:€<2re Ehe g::;:*z}bzz:'e <:<}:.,2;°i E\':>,i in E1§;3«r%:':%;'"§i7_<}2;:§z'%§, 'f{:r2<;a5:«§ E;?*:":ii,:"::§ $*£,a_i':a*,::2 if}1fé':.§I}€ZE"§.{E€§. zméi in EEK: wéiiazeé "-égf '::.??§@§.;€ §ia::i',s=; zazngi {§evei<3pn§:%:'2§.s, :'1s'>E; mzigy mg , ,;§T€E:'§"j:i:m§V(3!'g":a..E4_ §§;S'é,z€: w2*::&~; r€'}&1="z1m': Em" ﬁzéé pu:*'p<}:e:€: 5;?' tryirzg é:he 4'V..gar:s:::.i2:z§*::2ri'§3:"§;' s;:.1:§€: E':;'uE. fa", s:;E'3<:::.2i.:'f; 33$ %:.z"ée{§ as; gag ;;>r€:Z§§:':§z';a:'}; V ' ~._ iééésiziigf: am as 2; p:*:;:E§mi;€::nfy §$;<.=;:.:@ in €:§3<-:% :fa{:E:$ zmié <§:§:"'<:z_;zms-;;f;8s"1<':€;é.s.=,:

~ "_;':' {:21 }:.:j.%%;i §2:§é;i:::,;:E21§"i}; 2155 'ahziir 2::":s3w€:::° Est} €::E:<:r iséssi:-me ':.>%.2*2r:.se»:

"--2«:§s2:i: §:§.§%'§2.§:i'3};£€;?::i:i, {>21 i3:§'m .i.§':§§i=iL£€?.°;":'=; (ts? £2:-2£::>t.s--%s §1J{':ﬁ, 1 3

19. In the: wake of s::»u<:h an £-"i§}p1i{Tf€11".i{3}"1. {this C,'€3i.1I"'{ being ef 1:h<3- vimv i;:h21£'. .E .if"§ a.<iciit'i<)3:1a1. is:-253219 e:i«:3€:-3 21;'i.é;€, If}t'é'}..II3ti'f£i§' "'--i.1£f:::3 a€idi'£',i{}."I"}.&?iI .i5ss:;:,:e as pear c}1'£i<3r aimed 22;, E L209'? thig qLze.--:~st:ic>:1 as-:~ {ii} w1';e:t,hs:é1' ﬁiiﬁf a<:id.it.i<3.r1ai '§',E"i€tCi as 21 gum:-1i:z1iz'121ry i:'--:~;s:~;u€: er <;i.11er\x=::1;.é; c:<:»masei far $116: pzxrtias 03:1 i:§'f1£: q1,::=.;e31:ic):3A'----:;1s'Vim Thf3 5.&d'di.f.i(§3*1Ei§~ £38136 :»'sho2:1ici be t::*i.eci as V }}rs:}fV:V;1":i'§_V;;t~$;--..VTjlsssxgg'£3: .:7:i:>t. anii pE;1SS£Z':d csrdem am this; ()}'fd€Ef daEe~_>d 06.12.2007 h<3i£ii:1g i;§z1.§:_ _§'§:'2V;'£ussd§(:t;ir>}:"; '£10 i:.:'y iggzze I\§(>.3 as 21 2132130113 memtiarzed in the a2fA:*r""':":'~,rw{;.;~ £10 iS$L:€ Ntiﬁ being aiéspe:-%r1dé3I1t (§":':A qu.¢::--3?i:i<>.r:S of f;a;<;:¥;.s 3.150 and if $0 §,§_1e pL:E'a:.;vifsaE;<:;:i-S A~:3s_'i""{-_}V§"£ier KEV §%:_,:ie 2 anci i'Ls.r§:,hs;' «::§'eﬁ.';s3'g-3:5; é%;--._§?p--§. cf sii'i3=1"?;1'iE€ {BE 2:}? Rule 2 Q? Qrciéér KEV 21$ w':"}{*=:T:2:,;i.:':4»;;?{_§;' éviigaﬁiga. {E0 n<>'é: em:-2§::i9 the :;::§::1:"i: 'E10 i;F§; issue 14 28» In <:<;>rn£1'1g H"; i',I_*1i:-'5 <'.:<>r1<%2:,2si<:>::":§ the Eerzxmaozi J:1:i;ge \'*£2}S of t'.hL:% viesw éhaéi iihét? 21:"as'xx»-'er Ur: £;E*;e addi1;:i«.:)21aE i$:~§m:>. being c§ir@{:1:'.Iy deptzrzciéjrm. {H1 i;h€- '.2';-:'£i<;i§i'.y G17' ?1Tf€T%I1{.','}%1E3§.Vé"f£'1€?E%E~3 <:>§.__t:_hf;':

JLZ€E§§II'i€iI".£'E. of :::'m-:» i'{}1"&*:§gz'1 {i{)?.i§""{ in terms 0f the p:'::>V'i§:;'i£§1=::§"--;:§i7 .' S6-:<:t,i<):T1 £3 {}fi1h€3 Code zmci 'i',}"}.£;"f q11est:i<).r1 gas; to 25.-=i§f1é:%i41';.£:;*"L-f"'f':«2: "* V' Judgme'I'1i:. i$ c<>11<::11:31'vrs. 0*: <}t:}1erwji~s;'é' "3113 'i;€:rz_.";1,:%'-7.::;f "£"E;e"--:

€';'2<.C€j?p'i',i()1'1S eanumermed in §t3;3:1:s:>§y-§2:.u§V:.. 'E'i'§__0;f" .§,é(7:"c.i--5:tn. §E 3 and in answerirlgg as 33,0 x>v*hr3t:h<:%r <.*:§{¥:¢;;§§:i.;1nd in (me of the exqzeptions the v'§"ei§%§x{Jgir£éd ta gm mm Eh:-3 q:2<:2Si,2;_0ns <2'? a<:i<:ii{:i0;:'aa§ E35-sue?

nanaeiy, 21$ :f*:3.}':<,> A':*';".és:s..;*"i* jt1fiSdi£3i,i{)ﬂ ':10 try the 551.2%: in fin: of 0;? resjudicraza beirzg maée depe~:nd€:n'{:V {gm ééiii§1'7ES%'{{~£?£'S:._:f{}':;E§§l£TE1 d.i.s3pu.te:a:i faacts zxiseu é:}:1<-2 p:*é:j§v§.3i<>I;'§§}":*<>§fA..f{:'1am;$a"§ §é:'i""gxi:1d £231 of sszzbwrtsiﬂﬁi sf ruie: 2 H} ﬁriiéif 3'*<iE§?'a:>{"i3{:%;»v 4€iZ'.=:;:€i§:> ziiéi mi}? aafgazbie i:§1<:= {:<}1..:rt. is try ii: 215; a .Vx"-p.:<'e;:§:im.i:i;1Q>" §.§?=:.:~=:§z,:Lé:-;~.V. in 1-'%f§E§(?h €iE:"é;?§}§;. it as iihzéagggh '§I§3€i*. C<';m"€, "--«.:§:»zi~€3_V:'E{> }a::'§'é:s.s::§_>3.A%;:i",:i<:>':'3; '£557: 212:3? €:E'§<-9 §.E%3E=§i§:';:'. 2:53 22 §}i"€§i§Z':i"£'1&}':s-"" E-S-3:%::;%:

"--;22.r:.:§ "'*':;:?:ws2=,::':f::1E};::'€: $37; ¥;E:"1i:a§ €iX"§i€?E'§§l i:E";.::: E,-E.p§}§§€2&1?1§§}ET£ E1225; EX} E33 ':w:~f§:§«;;%é:%§;:;;§:;f'é§. M

21. ft i8 {ms <31"€_i:%1:" of 'éiize? 1:'-3.e:m'1<»3£i s;i:3;g1cé J"L.:€i;gz3.~ Whiéfh in 2'-xppeal E§e£}::~§t3 2155.

22; '£258 E1211.»-w hé?aI'{i Sm A:iii:yz1 S<3:':d.I";i, iséarned cQ.i.3_1_j1:»;s:§'£' €119 .21p'peI£a:1i:, Sm. Reaghzzvara, E«3.=.1'r11::*.ci ss<21f1;{j':~._ <:'f.§ti£'?:-Eréf-.'f'I'-- Eipfﬁﬁéififlg; fez' %.}"1<:a i'i_z":<:'~;§: 1*es;p<>.1'1dent., IVE-Eri. ';:;1i§21s'~?sk1;.__V,%'cg:':f':;:é§;i_ cmmsel appea.rm.g fen' resp<):1ci{::'2t,<=: 2 tie

23. Szzbmissitmss on 'be3r1a'Ii:"k_.:rf '{'i:<.1_r:.%7 ;'"<~3s_;j<:§r;dé%:1i.s are ail in C{}1'H H1611 .

24¢ App€€:11"i}"1§;_'{: aiéiigagﬁeiiaazziz. Sri. Aditya 8€_>z2riE':r.i. §.£2éE;§V'i?..€:?§§ "{i*ir1_;EES%?§ a2e.?<'§«:..;{'§«:E {T{EEéé'.E?!1{§ %:.ha:: E:E':e: E€:.21:"°m:d Sizzgle ﬁxidgﬁ in <;%::i:f<5gi':;.:2"*%:;£§=;i;:ig,§ ihss; Viéiw' theii: éhe: c<>:,::*€', kzétkeii ju:ii:;:ﬁ<:Ei<>é1V.§,<>'é,:§*y €;}"3;_€ .§s§ss3u€: ass 21 ;):"€§i:nir1:-zry isssgtie:

i;E'i'é§E,.~.€;§13i&§.L__{§{:s:;;2:%£: 5§:;~es;'-3: Eaéim-:$';;z,;rEsdi:i%E;§0n E0 t4'§':._; ihﬁ .§:-:;5:::.:€ as; :5: §3r€§£';z_f:i'§';2:fy. ~i':_afQ'n age; s5é:*:;«€:3§e{.§ :.:§1{ia=.z°' 'ihsﬁs p E°€)'i----"§SiOE§S <3? ' éiikéifr;"§:>;a:_:'E_i<,:Vi.§_E;sa%§y§ ans u:*:e:§€:r éiaes §}E'i)'~f§.fé$s§.{}I':E3 <31? €_§:*é€:r XE? _ _fE§?;_:,;i€%._2{2;![b§~ e:>§;'%:h€ éiéxiis: emd 21$ i',EZ.f;¥ 2::.:2s=:;2>2,m:r "€15; éihaé adéi§.iG:":aE ':'%ei';::.:'§::§. §':2:ys.r'é;% S521?'i:'i§§'£*i{fiIi'§E"i§.}' €2.25-3§_><:'>s;:;%{;¥ :.::»§' ?;§'z.i-3 ;%';E.:§"E1, {Erie iEi%§%1.'éi¥ V" "_'~:T:'3§:'::s;--':: E5a'_;»:r:'a,«-"£3 Egczién :':a:%:ﬁ$;«;;s2»:§"§E}? §:f:%_:?:;'i 21$ 3:. ;>§':%'2:§_m§:§':;;z§°}«* i:--=.;s3s:.:€2 EE§"::€ii§ .:f£3:e:ga:a;ési: A air} §:h:'::-- ":E2 'j:2§;h<::'Ed an 21:': a-':=:*:"<}:':€<}us u3'2{i&rSi.2::':{§§'z1g iiiazzai: %;%:£+ ."'<*::'}2.:.éf°E.. "§7e'}é<':E<£<E _;§::z@S<E§<:7:§<::s1:'é_ Eat: 5:12'? 32:1? §§:%§S';,3{i' 215+; 2: _ §;:$Vz'a:éEE::::%'2':e:;fj,:-' £s;éI:~:="s:,:::* Egg §.E'2€: 'av2;:E<:::-% {}§2}?'1<%: is5:<5:,1:i% 3::::r:;i::':;;;;i EE'E'§i'i':§' E§_z':.E§<-xi 16 should 2101:: haw: Ezxeerz .r<-:1:%gz:.i.e<1 its be ['I°'i€fi'i 2_é:§«:mg; wi'{:h e:3t.he:' iS§:§£§{':8 f1'E.iZ'ﬂ€:'(i in £1118 suit

25. it is; 5:-;uE}1111?i.i.<3{i in miss; reg;;a_r{i Eimti {ha d;eveE{}pn1€:r1t:S of 'ihe 5:21:59 a,::1{i '£.§m c<>:1{iue::E'. (>5 ;)E21i'ni:i;ff E-iftd @v«3:\:1 {>31 {$1.6 aqlmiittzed 1=*é;%rs:'i€§%:"{;£7 on Ezhezé Ju«:igm<;::r:t in the f1>r£;:ig;"I1 {?'§f}{3:"i; i'iE:.é":3_=.1iE, f<:§:i ;§':!<:sE)21ti;i§.;"% V the so {teziied W11} of {he dc_>.'ct%¢%_?iM;-',<,r::ée:¥'_ EVE, '§1_'E13f;Ei}?&1E} is b(c1I'I"€{i by éihe §}£'E£1{E§p}.€tS {Ff resjz2.d€;c:*c:€g;',_§:::3--.VE{::1.:§§(i"{1} S€.3e;:--f,i"{>n ii 0f the cadet; 'i:ha.%; the agzzéfséiiw' "was-:;_ 23$ 35;: xn*Ir1¥i*;é}f_1.€::f suit is barz'€d by' {he ;3F£11(?ip«E€;*:$ hf" zfeie.jéi;d'z.:;«:¢;:'¢;».i,Ir1':»i€:'-9:3;;I:;e11 £1113 pr<>x.s"is31c>}::3 in ihﬁ C{}{§§f€? i€g}€?<_t§_§i{f£'%;§.§:§"f5§.§';1§f.':§.€':;;'§' ;:{i;_;L;:":..5't:; £':'.22;ms:: 'ilhfii is.-:s:;u€: 223 a preiimimiify -.i:es;:§_i€.% .'iz:; *?;h£%,_ '<:ér<;::.1mss?E,2m<?:es; r::<3:ﬁ.i::m.eci in e":§:;m:~3::7;<5; E21} zs.z1d'*{'§_}§*:>f é'::b§?f1.;--}.§5%'§'i%E of r:.:E€--2 of {}§"€i€:£' KEV <>f'i:i'1e:

{3:}{:§<:u ii: vjmss :i.:'1:t%.,:::.1béé:;':%;. E-mém the <_:<>m°€: iii} €X&H"}'.2.§f1é3 {M15 :;:::.'l&a;es.§:',_:'_{"2:2._' €;§*;é;t:z; {::§s;:::*a i':':g;§---~é'§:2:%, ii; is in '§§1:;": ::iis3<::"<@§:i<}':": sf 'lihié <%<}:1z:fé.»%.{::5'%':f_j.;' :;:;§'2'«.§§:s«.<:3 aT1--~2?r_';=;.s+; 23. pE'€§§§§EE1'}.':?.i'"}" isssmz? Emi: :§":'~:§&3<:::§r:g 'i:§'1&*:

5X':-,1 As: §%;:i§§'§'1;.:'§v::E3, kézixfmitii ss;::22'3;i{:;:' <::::_:s:..3_n${'=:E_ ii-2§}§}€?»Z%§T'iE"E§;' ﬁg? '«. .1i.;§<r;§% ":<%;7s;g}€:}:";i:Z.{%_%éi; NTQPE §"'EEE$-38:1? 21 ;_>r£é§_§m.E.m2:f§: <3'{::je{:§:£<§:'1 '--ff,"§;:23_.§€_§§E"i§§ :"z'2;.2,§:1':':;:.§.:1_23:b§§_i_:_§; <1}? E..§'§.é':T*. a-»*':.=-:~;§.:r ;::;§>§>€:%aE é"1"%.='§;'.'.i'}i ii} "Té.%:%2":>§::§ {#25 $€j?%{.i€'i{.';£'": =2; <3? §l§"3a'..'. :'%{:::g. am? it 211% §.'::=%:%.:*{'E Sri. E€:2;;?E';2r2af22:'1, 1 7 with ¢:;u.<3s;€,i<>1'1ss of E'a<'ri:s 22.1%} t}1e;ére:f'{i>m reject4ir1;;; €316:

21pp1iC3f€,i+:>.1'1 ifkégariy 21 findérzgig :11"11'c,n21E:;vk*. in law: i1h;i'£:. ii' trirmaiiy def 2211.5; the 2-121'}? §3{II}."p{.'&E?:éT'-- of Elhfﬁ amzzbiizagg that 9%-:2'; an arm ;.2.{irnit;,t.sé~:1 £'a<t€.$ am} oz": s1.:<*.h of $210596 E'a{:t.s3 w11iC§r1 arts: :i:n-:

whisk: <:21;n.r}.<>t: be {iii-3pu£:<-jed by i;,h§:3 _p12.1iri':i{f=.<3:1 §1is¥:I1 .Q\:v':': gﬁieéx mke_:1 b¢Eff{}i"€ §§'1€ fe:m::ig;1':: {:<),x.1 1fi, "q;;cszf.iA'(31':v.:wia;z 218 118 {ha i-331:9 0f law which in v;}:;2:\;9'5:::»vV:jEj;'%7;:ia>§1"5 s8.tis£'21{:i{1+ri'Iy dee::ici<id e*~;Ie3~.1.3 on 0:': the Eegai p0sit.i<::n zmd §'.§"£('?f'.'¥4":{'i':'§;-'%':_)"'-,'.T';€*§'AA"'%"§%)fZ..:€:$;:£§$§'%ii=Y}'iVi;{§{:".f§.i"1§?'§°{;?q'{}iI'f3I§fl€£"}.{, to 'try £11539 isssue 'i':""é:':w~r;":"§ ihés b21a::kg§:'<}'L,1:§d but: r'e;?c={:'i:3E.:1g Eh§:VE3'§é .%::=:%§g:;aé{}1.::4; 'c"iSSE?§H1§}'{ii€}H f:hai: the: iiimri. Eezckeé 3?u:*i:.=:;ci'i<:';t.i{3._r:: 5;'-:<:>"i;:rfj; t:E1e:3. s_~3a:':'1€ as 21 p}*ei_iminary §s;:1é§éis%_'§$ £;__:*£~ =:?z;i§_§.&:f rzzﬁ: i',:3:'22?£:';'i€ in iaw. ratqziims 50 hi: set. aaaida araé '='€:_h 63. g_1lp;>E'Vi<%_g':i§{}':3_ V2:--§E<>wa:£§.

/€ \?'<%§ 18 I<:a.1"ned seni¢:>1' <%<>t.::'1.<:e;<:é1 on the pre1i111iI121;'y <,:bjs:ctie:m:~; and t:.h<3r€r21ff:€:..r "A-'Ei' .ha.'x~*e £':e:a1..:'"{i 1€:21.r11::é:1 s::°<:~1m$eE 0:1 i,1"1.€ 1z1<;?r"3;{i':;»-*s 5.3%' $143' 111E1"§.ii€;?E' 213590.

2?» In $0 £211' :15 {he p1'eiimi12z1ry object.ie:::1 is; "<:{>11.{:e;°%3<¥:iT, -- $z1E;W<:3isSi<:}:1 {sf $1~~}. RE1§§§ﬁ.&iX.='é1I}, E~€€13'I"1fif€i '§éIi'i{)§"'_ the wiry appeai is; not }'}:'1:rSAi.i1':'itr:'}.}'.1".'E'v2§:§.:'Vv:.1_V't?'«> ﬁg": 0% the p1"f}ViS§OI1S5 Qf se3:{:i;'.i{:>3f1 5:: of 21:1#:;i'AAx%.;};;e{1. Eih<3 enabiingg e1ppt'-33.1 pmvi§3§0r1 Higix Court Aifi is axamimﬁ {;«'§"i& fzhe <*:0r1'{:r0i1§.:1g provigions of the Code, ii is s:,ab§::.i¥;.i:ed af kw; zzézmi E9:-Hzzeai eztaungei E121vi3igV._§i;1cé:€i~--%éL§.iV§1_::i§%e3':LV»{§fg §:.h.e ibilowingg d<;'{',iSi(}¥1S: CQM{3«iISSf§NER CZESTGMS ALNB SENTRAL .._E.:ar:ic_iI*s.g§:_ 22$. Hézva-9 zrmm gp) LTI), {(2039} 5 sac 291; % "'z_f39:A_ mggmw :23.

V _ V_ gggmmg 5: gm 3:??? Sgt? «gag;

3 333A; $3. BEPIN' 'mam E, mgrg ggmagg gc 33$;

3.33;, F g? §§I;§L@Z"¥ fﬁfﬁ iﬁﬁé $8 éégiz'?

3 /"

'?}/ iii, iiiiat L. :0 $39 f§T}i42E1{§."§'§:;§. '§--.§:s:%<.:Ei€_2:':. Z%{§{} 0%' °£,§":e:s §--§.{':'§ 2:a.m:§ ;=~:::.%:::2':_£:,§:': 19

T NA 8.2, ORS. US MISS RENUKA 82, ORS. [ILR 2009 KAR 1209]"

s;;:::.§:>mi1?.§; iihai. i.m7: p:*<)x,-'i:~:;ir:>n&.=; 0? &s'€c.{.i{>r'; 1% (if 'aha: }£i§§§§;...C<:s;i.:i:: Act; by itsézli' €§{>€:'§5 mu: :=%:'1.z1%;=I<:< 22:13; p::%2"ss<}r1 tr: ::12%{_1':'i:é1:V§:' 2:1§::pc:*e1§ 'L::11.i::7sss:s amps:-ral under se<:ii<3:'1 4 :15 $319 }~:':g%n'--:f:m:':~: 2'°/act"

bélifkéfd by .21 €T{}§'f€Sp()§'1€ﬁI"E§._{ z1'pp<3i1z1i::e §);f{w"?;s'i<§;?; tazidezé'. :;;1f§rV.A aiiher siiaftiwsee out (if wharf; 3. pr:?:»cc>.éé}§_f1g;j_n1::1y':nffsé. in other worciss, sv.bmi5ssi0'r: is i,E"a21ii..f{,E1«é3 21--'pp§:§_1Lé1rt;§~*:V.jmiisscii.(:ti.{):1 muier S€t'3f;.§O§1 4 of the §~I1'g.f1 Quart £§€T3[, 3-'c'.h33(iE3';§i'Vpf'é§§3*3'd1.EI'é1§ aspest, s~:~e{:'E.ior"; 5:: sf the ¥;'§é§:§3? -.'$<>1.%fE: is_"; §:.<§"u§:>€;%_.f$3U.i>E30.:"t'.€:d by a subs3€;.21:1i.ix,--'6 1°igh'i'_ e'3f;:éi;;>péé11» a3;Ti'.%1m;:g: ii'; E1313' <§i.§1c::' e:':::mi:1:1<~:r:t gram? 5:411:71': »:»é;§':s§1?2:§'_§""i:'}:%}. 'IE}23;i.I"£§',€1fEf:Ef}{?€ {Ef em 3;§3p€;'.'Ei§. _ V _ ' 28, ii: is»; S1:5brj:1i'itc:d' $5 2120: in dispzgte, that the ;:«§'<>§"):.1"{:€ g3:'<}£?<:r<a:€E%:t:;g;&%; git:-2 A;::V:;z§§<2é{":{§%2':gf;§s:e <,:sr'§g_;;iz'::.:>:-:aé:.ir:g,__g '1.2n<:i<3:1" ihés M 3 §;2:§ gm';

.E'%';v1f€':§""'<V':1'.'é:','.§{;'fV.Riﬁé} E'::§%g-::il'i:>§1:% 255% 'Ea 3%} {)f Ehzs Aatig 'E:.E1§~3 :'::':2:_':}.Ein_g E:*1s':iia:3 $2,..%{:<i:<%§32$§{3§':I' "_.;%.<;:'§; ifs): .:%;%:z>1"i: '£.i':€ ancé pr:,:€i'is;§§:é;;_ '!i;§x;:;% fi.:§"§€;*,'. 2,-=%?:~§r k§u:°is;<.iie;':€§{>:'§ E3;-* éhss: E~'§§g,§E": {3:3m"€:

r::

J) Qii?

'f_'%'1h,:% i2.:§::pé%:a,i m":E;3;£:2:2:.i.<:=.s§ i7m':":': €i§'::::

<tc}1'1f'<;%r:°i:':g the wry }'1.sr'is~:;r:ii_<:*£:i_(_::':a of i:E1e> {:}iS'{1i"iCi {fc>1.1r*£; on 'the Higgh Court: 221-530 iiiziz jur'i:s';<:1i<3i'iam f[i'121.'z. iseirzg e::=:::%r'c:i:~se:1i'-..fi3}; the Higfh Cc>m:': in pr{>b:;a.i:e pr:)<tee:dit':g--$ iﬁg '€'}:1<>1:§,?;i'i§....E§:«;E{§:"' L.'{;.:1"~ <:o:1t.esi is '%:}eiz'1g {'.{}£"1Vf;?I"tfj?d i§Tl'E',{} 22 t.c%$t.a1n1é%121.ar§; m*igj:;1'2%{i'V.sLi2ii; is 21 pczwew :~'::>~;:e.r*cis.':;c-aci by the Eiig_§}1 C<)1.:rf xvifh' :a"é;';'>'"_€:?*ié=,m;f<;*=-- .tu.<::_f:h§::

pI"{}ViSi{)I"1S cf sec£';i{>r1s 254» to 380 _<:»f i:i.ia3 évrtt: a:1c3;"I.a;:?:'i.£E 2i:1«ii u1'1§<:ss%«: an a.[:s§3é:a2;1_ a%:1'12:':3Ie2€i;..;.;.z1dt3;jV.E;E:%;;é'AL':I:':t:Eig;z1 :$ia1<év::g;%.sss:i<3r: Azéﬁ; against. an {}I°d€I" appeaileti .pr&*.s«;€:n'E; cases;

se<:E.i(3:1 4 £)f't;§1é-3 :u":<}%. ssu.si'ai:1 an 21;) pea} cf the? praéés £39; ._ 29' 9 ' "':«é:i"--ss€%n.1Eé:>2*"(%;':»'a,::"2ss::%i éipiﬂéféifiiliif {<3}? iihﬁ' responcienfs. VE:€:é~s_ i;h<;?r:'€:;%.f"e":3L3i*e'*.g§i}_:ﬁ'.§:.nde:i ﬁiaéi 311$: appeaé £13 §§:°ess3,:f:¥;'.e€i §}':,Zfp€§i"iiI1§__'§ VEi,=:>'._E";§i*,z,z'::.--:3e:" S€{:%::§_{>';"; 4} Sf E12163 Eiazrzizziagkai §}%f7:§.,v.};§3§} '§'i'<::** ':3.h{>r1:;. 1;.%1<:= Higgiz €'j'<}%;.:rii; Acfii is; I381". §}'.1é1E:§'i§IEE§§TE&i§3§€"»giiéii .__'{'§":;.(i*:'€f{31°€ ma'; §'°:,:r"§'.'E3<=?:* gm:-s§':;:i<3:15s :*;:;%€:s:§ has V V:::v;21:"':2§z:@:_§[ E,Z§a%>:.}:22'£_:3i.;':.g.§ "::E';a3 s:;:.:§3'::1_§5s:-s§{:>:'2;%§ 5°-3:? Ra:;,gE3;2m-'gain §,2:'g§s={§ éémi: <.}r{.*7i<=:%:" 'g}a;:§.e:;s--:'=;é>:<i ii": 2:

'$1, // '=3 21 fesai.21:11e:1.t:z1.ry ;=::a.1§t. which i'['S€:3§f is 2?: aim-':=:1<3§3:11<;é:%;'t; ii) the i:?()I"IF5s€?C;§3;.£Ef1'1£7fE*, of 21 pmba.i:a=? pF{}{?t2f{3diE"1gS {er ;'3r0':}a€'.ing a W1?-1'1-pr} <:{}z:t.€E;i, g;ei;iT.i1':;;; <::>m:::%:*f:.ec1 irztrza 11ir3:é;i:2:.111e:1i:a.ry . th€'r€:f<§:'e.3 $§:1E}1::i?,£:a%d i,h,a'£_ mes: _p:'z>(?:e£i1,:re far £',:*:;ii:§;;; 't:;'::V'_é;e.éé1,%.ii:-..T bei.I1g g;§:)w.-'rrzaed E33,.-* {he p1'()'éfiSi()I7iS {}f CpC E1J"i'€i_ }'I}:'I£3'Ef_;'V;';".i:54T}V"é}?;VI'i £:PI31icat.i<Jr1 ﬁi<i"'.€.i zmdez' Order X.IV5~Rz,11cé£§A':5 émci 'aviiiﬁifxw 'V is gaverried by {E18 c+:)rrespo,:1di11gg:;:*<:rx3:i$;ié;~:1$ (sf 'CR2? .i{,':=3£:1f fm' the purp0s~;u:3 3:" fi.Ii:1g; of 211? ;i.p;5}.iv<§¢13t.ie:i'V _ag:a;i>:1£-»s't. 2111 order pé1SS(-Xi undéir this p~2"(2visia}h"" {>15 1é1x§§>.._21Ii:i.,AV§'£§r éaizzéh othéér purpese. If is-2. p<:{§r1t:£§*ri {2ui;§i.§1aﬁ. §.I5;e;:V_2i;#pZi<%:a§i<}:': is {me no': {mi}; for £%e1.mi:1g{ 211:3?'.§ia€§';1fi{§.i'§,§§E_ .iE%§é:L:ié bait: 3.15%: :0 try 'iihéfi

23.dd.if;i.{m.2':.§ .i§:;é%v;€% §3Eif§iin_f:i2ﬁar§g' iséiiéz gmrci 'E'.h€1f"€fOE'§;'. 'f<)r the purpese ésf f§E1i--ng«<>f 27:2'; ?&::_ip¢21i__ £1;,gga.;if:1-53%;. 2113 <3:'§%m' <3? tihté §335"€*S€t§1E', r1at'::r€<., ass aapgaigikcd E:1"._*5g,E1:2I;4:7" app<:=:aL zméé :;E2a'¥;. 'éihe ::»=;ui'i ;)rg3:<7e<3{§irV3g§;s§uimizzg £é'%1:£.'EE iii;<:<}v';';i?§;1,:$i1!<3, am 0:*{£<;*.r p21.E§s%s€3:d 21%;, {big §i;<§'L€2§"s§3';?'% VV:';.i;.sz"<': <,>:'<:'k%r mist: §'é3s;u§E:§;'1_§_.§ 'Z1': 22:33; €i§é{_::*<3.é3,:, am 2:pg3ea-3 -:_'«1L::;;:ii:14$é:.v n s'{f{,:<;'§'1 am {:»r<ia>:* Es; @:z'z.:a'i}§:%s:£ :m{i:=2:' iéze "'--§;A::f<§z-*ii:%§:::¥::_:}§ sf ifT.§'.2r;§:L'a"-.;.Z€;e:§s3 €j}"1":§§,»-" 2;.:;:'%;z§&:*z:° {E2 E}E'{:}§ef§§§§{}.§A§5'57§ {:s§7 {}:_*§§€::* 22 XLEH §{E,11E-7 E CFC Eiﬁii if am appeal is :'m'£' '£:€:':;21':3k: in Ei@'£"fI1$ ("If this p.mvissim:": (sf Eztmz, rm zsppziai (#2111 be filed.

31' L~'3E1I".I"£f;':€§ s3am'2ie:);" c:<1uz1sr5:E 's,x-*{3:.:1id draw 0211* z1t:t'.s:~:1Ei_i:£?s.'rf£' if:-C; "

"i:i1.e pr<>visis:ms«; af (}:'£it%r XLIH R'LE}€'.'- E CPC and £_i%£f%i;f:' ' "

:10 éhsié pr<>vi5sii31":s3 «:3? Sa;*,£:t.i:>§1 304» CFC A_;fe;%e:§.<i'i:1g§ Qf._Sccii§:§{:_T f 184 of the C036 wouid 123.}; s;>.:I1p}1.:%;~_=;£s;s an V1;..E*_1<m34".§.as'i:péixfﬁﬁgwf sigh?' &;e<:t,i01_";. {E} of Seﬂizzsn N34'..{§'PC,7:§:'1gi.i§*:a:.{.£*:j§g«.aha? an appea} shaié :l()ii he :agz:§:':::aé. 2:11}: »:>r,de:::'$;.11111535553"e::5:f2z§;:~§_ef%{i i.2iI"1€{i'3'I' the p2'<wisi{;§:ss sf 'ihsa '§ﬁ£':*ET§1'i~'f:'?:.:*1'?;€.:;i mf'E:.r>"2:%:y""§z12ar fix' that iémést iaemg if}. f(}E"{E€*,, ailéi S-:.1§i}_;f11§tr§ t;-Eijaﬁf £«..7r1é pr<j§sx;i.§5i(2'r"2.ss 0%" 0'rd@;: XLEEI Rzgie E CFC:E":;1$.ri::'1A:;'L :';.<>~i;, '%:;:§12é"«;v§§.asE+:i gm ;'1§3p<;:2.é}; ;':g§22.;:2s%. an Qré 2' pzzsgcsd an 21%}'=.a;p§'}§i:€é3E1i€3§f§ air-§.{E{é:° Urziar KEV R1135: 2 €?C; Lgggvéar arzyi O:1<::~ of iiée.__;3m:amemiiétcé. {:Egm:-335+; {:1} K} {W} of Oriiger X_§.;£.E_§ .§?:1;;§,<;é E'v3€.3§fiI'.,} ;;a:::1 gippeai 15:':dr::§* QTPC &.§_§&7iiI1Sii am (31:68? 0'? the :1::f.'2:':*€::3§ :'?.E%:.._ é:§{é§§£:22§2?{§: 2i;§21§;1ssa§: in fziiéiig ;-2g.>g:::22;.§, <§:;*:finii;s3E}g ' _§Z§{}%L"T':i-if iimi: E53, . ;'?;>:°.'§: 7§?;&;;§§fé:2aa~'a.:1 waizazécé -;<:;»;:::§,::mEi; 3223232: =.:«:§2i'§:% f;,E':£Es_e ﬁg $2153: gmri:

V..:_::{ é_EE.:;: mz:r.:.'":§'; é.E':£.=?, €."}'E§2é'f§' ;3;=z.r:'. is; ';.:: has §<}:_.:::"$ of th:-Er Ac? ii.e3:%Ii: the }mIr3a.i:e; £1') pr<>:::e€;d:iz1g$, wE1i.{.:h 331;: ''m1*:; has be';*.('.6Z',}ETl€ 2: I?:<;%§;i".z_zr1";e.z1'i,;1rjg;"gait. :32': {t{3nt',<3:at., is :1 pr<}<3§:edi;'1g 1..::'1d«:>.:" iize Am: zemd §.:':_..t:1i1 i$ :';'g:;i_.,K a'é.i:.e1':£;i0':': is {iI"2*i".--'i?'IT£. to ;'§S€;?e::'£:§(:s1": 299 cf 1111:? Am. .;1;f;ré'::§:u s.;i){Tr3:':'1ifs£§*-«T that an a21p;:>:=:2=3_1 21:3 c:3:1t,en1pi2,1'i:e:{i :;1r1ci9rV.Ses<:f:i(;«:1 '?,9i+i'~} -s::sf E~If:;::gf3gi:t. is only an appcéai :e:gai:1s{. 2.1 final {fFII"_d€I' by{fie'{iise;E.'i'?ie:é'i.~ :t<)L:ri. azlii wh1'ie 21:1 éxplagjzai "~-gm '{:?r<;i--:3r..~V§a.t; an §I1ie3ri0Cut'.or_\; sE.21§__§€ of a du:"::15,_z; the pencierzéry of the s»3:.1jt. is not.

expregssiy prm:*iciL%:j' u:%§zé1éjj_af the ACE; arid an the mhey fiisti agai1'3_ss"i:: an t:>I'§er pe1sssses: i"'~{}:4: gm Order XXV Rule 2 CFC, iazwirigg 31:23 bee;1"'«..a%xpr<-3:5:-;sE§f 'i)%a::"ra>.{§ under S€2:{;i{>1";. 194 read w:i%:_E':«--._{)re§::§f'§= .§<Z§,.;3EE E{§E§""'i**"C?C, ma zipptzégd is {:<>:'1:;<:r:1pE21{€d r 21§;.:>:iis:_s€i' .2351' 4 §}:?_i.'e3tf;%€£§ aim an :E§§3pIi{?21%.§{)I1 1I§§{.'"§.{§€i"£" iﬁfdﬁi" KER:

"=.§€:»:.zE€ 3 tziiighsi' v:..':.:'"£{E:§3:'V iiim Caégiie: <31" :,me:i;er iiézéjr Aiit, 'vii. i";*: 1%i:h§s; b:;1c?Eggr<}z,:::1<%§ aha E532-wzaeai sa:2::§{;=:* {1'i}'L§ﬂf§£E§ V-:;;:::é:.sf*{{§'_ fi:<> a%;;%:2§z"s:i.z2::: iiae §}E"i}'§:'iS5TE{}Y'E;'ié {sf E§5<:§:is>:T; ii sf §',§E{i"': "E1*§'Eg;§};: {:§':;:.:r'%;. 2'-34:2,; '£%f§f:iE'": §"'é_':'1§%*,§."{,".'fEE{'I'.€f? ii"? S{:s£::%::%z3:': :7}? §:Z'"::% éiigéé 24 C€:»L:rt: Act; Sri Ragklawaizzi w<>:.1Ed sxzbrnii. iihat Sec:i;i<>n 1; 1)}? .i'E.sseE{ does; not p1"<>vi:i€: for fiiingg sf ax: appezai btrii it {>t3.£j;«--.;111 ea-?:mb£i1'":g pr<3v§$ir:§H. e:'1.z-xblizlg an appeaeii {:1} 23. £}i1risi§3:2_ <:::f 'i.i"1i:-9; {?C.i{1i'§', zzgzxizassi an mféier p29.z4s.s;<::r:§ by :1 $i:i{g_.-§.§e €:X€'E"(?iE§i'I}.g cxrigirmi juris;dic"[i011 zmd £;£1<:%'r:%f't3;*§:: "«sL::E3:z1Vi£:3,{.i*::ég:_ Lzralesss 2111 er1:gib1i:'1g pmvis_i<:3z'1. fox: _:f'i1i.:';g'--- f¢1z91~ z1.ppe?:§;.§. is 'm°1b7e §':3z.:11ci €3i1I.I'1E%§' in 1,3119 Code 21:53':-3i'f or e1.s'V§s§V'p<>ssibie. 1Tb: 'é:jE:1€r ;>resse:1t :~3i'£uatic:11, u;r1d::-3:" £1116 AC1; .'.C<)urt Act by itself does not: #1 bezfore 21 Sivisiera Eiemth <23?' an mrdazg' passeé E35;

21 Singie J::r;§¥;g§e%L"' fu:"i:h€r ssubmission is i'.ha§. an e1§;3é2§_E of 2-': Suit, <:»11iy if it is sac} p}'OE-"iiiﬁii 23;:f;.f:§i ezxééibléwi. GE' {heir :s3i',a::ut,<;::"y pmx--'i5ion.s, mi?'Vi.i'€,i;§2i.r§.£:'<7ésgé =::{§m<:>. i.2§§""i';'§:i apps-322} 21$; 2;: m2:i;£;e'r <3? "right Eiéfid th€r%::f{)'é33_9&2:-;:i.:;§ :s%;.§*;}::;§i. in ibis-3 "ﬁ21<:'kg_§:zf0L::1:1 4 of §'§ig§':»._C{f%'L.3~:'.?.L L;»=§:i*T£: b€§:'1g§ zmf, in zihcgz E'éEi{§.§I"E <3? éjguz' §€3z':e:i§s "~§§:'«m;§:é;E:>:': aé:;i__ §&i§*2£$i§ii.(Tf 9:1 2:22 f3,§'i£ib§iE'§;§ §}'E'{}E?'§§§i{}'E'1 ':.::"2<:i@§' CW3' "§_é::"" "éhzié ';i+"s.<:?if 2312:} ':3::%E:":g§ £2 sn:,:§3;;:=<:>_rt ":.}:; £1-"=.§*:',%:::%:° 52%" ihe:sé:: E'::m} "wzasnﬁ E3223 11> :'2<:.<':<»ES:g;2s;i"'%1:3" 215 E60}: Ems} '€243 s£~:..:,1;}p:::ri;i1':§g §}E"{}'%"iE$§€}E§. 1;.fi:€:_:"f {';§3{",' :15: if 1E3¥E€I.§§3*-2" gm: §'}3;"{}'%..-'§E%;§£'f::'1$ 0%" gm {f':;2a:§:';: é;:h:;:;"e,% 2:

5."_'§§;<'?a;._;%' f:? E§3"sg§ gm 2.-:§}§}:'::;-2} ;::.;;je2i£:§$%: 32:2? {}§'{§€:?E" of é..E'2e:i~ E';-»§':=T%;<~;::*-:':i; 25 e1'121<:i:n'1:-311.3, an appeai is; ::m'£:. at all tezxaizsle and £.31§%FE?§tT)£'€ {hiss appe21i_ ssh0L1id be z'e3:j:'=:(:t:<::{i at ihe §i1res.~:E1oia:§. 34' En 5;'L.1pp<}1'i': sf '[l?:€? ${41fJEI1£$$i{§E'i( S1711 plzzcte st:r{3:1g reéiiamzie W': £4113 jz1dgme.11t. sf thczé in thrss ztasge Qf COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE vs HONGO INDIA PgnrA:z:E--1}TD I{2%é':3*.Q)A 5 scéc: V 791], by dr21wi:1g :~'1i'.t€'.E1f1E€}V1'}.._:55) p};-1r3;.s.s §.._ '»1'€T}a1'1€i 1.8 of this §Tudgmem",, vmuici ur;_;f.Q £;E;21{,,...é;%xfe;:1 'asse3gL;1ﬁ'i11g;f'--I§:)é" arggi,::m:ar;{'.'s Seike, an appeai {f§I;§"1 '§:>*<11:*_3;f;ai.£z'1f.g1it3e{§ 1Hi§€ﬁ'iE'";S€€?ﬁ'{i()}f3; ii :35 the High C€')1,E}.'§ A<t%:3e:ggf:;;L1'i':»s§; 51:': by 21 Singla Judge ésxi-:1'c§si::g {}Z'§L§..§i.}"§.2iﬂ,#;fL§.}Z'iE:§§§§i{T'i.§'{3}".§"ii": 2:"'si:u2:i.i<}:1 ':2;-*"?sc1"<: ma cﬁizzsr ;"-3i',&-'if,',L'a°F;'.{}i"}«" p£'{3??i$§{§Ii.S-Eifégft"'£%,:f3f;3§_iV{j:;7£,}Z}E€3, but in Elhﬁf presmii. {:aS£;: She ;3:"{}<ttea%jc§i:1gsL ""1:mf<:§V1f:gg z::§éé;'€."n :.1;:1{i€:':' §:.E":é=: Aiii. zmd E10 thee f.i':§€;"{'.€Fi'§', <:§»%§€::::g_; §g;;}v€:::*:3.::3c_i_ﬁg; thgi prm»"és»3i{}11--$ {)5 t':§::=é Airi, 2-vhiie a:';:, :%:f:2:%>_}:.§:;§;§ §§::=:::%*£s§::}:': fez}? E'iE§:§2g 2221:': é?1§}§'}€f£{§ ?.4E§é{i€':3' Efme: ﬁéfii :;ﬁ:a:;:y--s§ bfi' E1}:~;':]§v,4€§.€:;'f'{3S«:"i %;T%f emzzi if i.E:<=::'<% is ﬁé} €:3_1a§:3§§:':§§ _p:*«:}v§si:;}:1 26 11a.mre., 215:; E53 {'0 'i::~<e% f'€>a.1r1d in the p;"<>\r-'is.-;i:;2r:3 <3? S:;«:<:ti«:>:': E04 ffﬁéid wit.}": Gfiiﬁéf" XLHI RLEIQ 3; CFC 21.53 in E:_E:ee iigghi. GE' ihfj 1"£i§Vf1..{';" €)f }':,zdgm<:%n'{. Qf that S{.1§}I"fi§I1E€.' {'1<3m"£ in the HOAIGQ LTD ::.:1s{: {&mp'ra1}. smztiiz 2:: pr::;v1f::;i01"; in E'E'1€ Cibdi'. }A>'é.':A4i'.,%...1.{§.V;}é}1'&Z"fv'$;?;i}"' <32-'ix Eihff p:'<>vi_sio:'1:<s sf Hie }Iig_.gj}'1 C0312': Acttg a-_V:1'*i;}-':;:1€;:s'e;%2j}.1"mjidkzgjj A' S€€'?:.:i_c:.n 5% of {he §~1'igI"1 Cmxrt. AC1: _<::3.xm0fi_. 'be: §n}:i Cg1<§1'1€§.€%r:};t'._13;:~ ma11nt'.z1in<3ci by g,_2;iv.i.ng :5-2, ggofey to i;he"L"p-_fO*Ji§séc>:'§s.<}fTS€;:<:tV§§on 104 mad with O§'ci€%}:" XLHE GE Sn Raghewezn, Eezxr-g1ea§:.Sé%j1i§)1' £3-;;;vi€3:1ci€t:1t,.

35. Sré E'€21g_§§12n?:;iH:'1":s;x<{%.iiE§. ﬁjﬁiaeziiiie am {.319 d£:=c:isi<::::':

ea? .2: §,€:rge3:    :i_:";'  G5 ';?'I"{}'g.'$£'Z%ﬁ'A£'J1'J;'%;
vs MISS   120?} '£10 szxbmiéi tihai ihé:

prejvésizm pf Acéf'; §f§:"2:e:% Fiiggh C0:.3§*§: A€:'£': 1:13.53 '£9 §,2:,§1'::'::E»::"'~§:.;;= Eiﬁéé'§§":*{§vis;'£{;:"§5s sf S:'~':%<:"i'..i<:»z1 "N4 maeci with {}1*'a'§~.?§7;s:j I§'é;§,,§:E'§- w'h:i<':§:1 {':2E..§"§. be (:%<}:n;};::re:§ éa} S€;3{'f§.'E{}§'1 8 'SE26: EE.§_gE': .{Ts}i§..:€, ..»:5%<*E:. L<"::1:"m3{§ é='é€iI"i§€Z}§' <.t«:}v;:_'2:-ise=r§ w<3u.E<i " ":é§.::'E?%_z:2.»ié} §:.E':a€ Exgz" E316 E§g_;{h1:: Sf iiéze-.6 §Ez'1{Ei:2g:~s an :'a:§a';w;g':I:1i; {§L1€S§'..§€§EE ._ €;?§§é;.§f§'§.§*.§*:?i&3{i £933}: ﬁg': Lzrafgeéz" §§i"?§'}{"':§'; £2: "é:E':§:<§ m':{,§ s.=s':.2b:';:1i'é,$ §A.I§:--€:: _;:>:*<_}:-*.§:§::.:>:':s-3 57:" §€fé1"€§{§3'"i Eﬁeéé :fe:t;::::'§ 2a*§§'.E'2 {}.z*z'§:=-.3? Eiiﬁé §€z;.:§<~': . "{'§;e} 2:11:53 {.13} are _;43;4_€:.$;.:"*:;:<:*é:e<i znzgi if €326 <':<:«'L,::°i: ﬁg fuiiy $a'£:is§E&3{1§ 'ii ::e§z:}:.'{i:fi__ {be iiffféﬁii 21:3; 3 }'}§"€'E1i§i1§E'}£i.§"j{ is;-s;=:«::%;~: 'E3€:§.}'1g em _ﬁssS'L:é% 4_ "'ss§""§s_;:ﬁé;-.A2§;::§_<ifi.he E-iEEf%§'Ji£'{?E" 23:2 1%-'E3_i{%§': §:=e;s=;:m ES {'.£?a§'}é};7£}§c';?f ii} ?3:'i;;gg ﬁes é:;éfé.'§i:V. i;<j:s.:é2.:é2 <=:~._:":s§ zmii <=§:*%;*€::*: W§'&::h<f;:.2%,. 'gm :':<3€<'§, $22" €;>;":g«:::';2::zi:.i1'}g;f ijhéé 27 E CFC yi»:31z:ie:%(i E'1€?£T{?SSE'13"iE_',F it; the pI"{)Vi$i{}£'} zzver S€:m';ic>r1 4 of the High C(3I.f£§'§, Azrii, :.~i1r1'v:i€s»i'<>};f:s3; {Jf See::t_i<m I04 rzst-éad wii;h Ordsr XLIEI Rz.11.e 1 CFC;

no xvzzy for' the': appta->.a.1 b€:'%.i£'1g z1zainia1i1';ed ' i.Z1e::3.'ei'<>::&% m'g;,§;<-?r:i éihai' 5:116 appeal} UZ1E"E;'.f31'1(}}.€1, ' ' V

38. Sri Raiglrmvzm wcmid join is:;s§i:2v:;?; 'a:ft1_1 £1153 fi"i€:.i"it;s--§; 0f the appr;=a.I ti) submit, that the iss§i,iV<§.'21$' ﬁes:-.ra1is;eci by the dsfendarﬁs ::::a;r1m:f. 'Vb.-.:€ _ma«::1e; ssu.':jgj";:(é:,fr2é1:i.§3f 11:3? d€t:é:rm§.11ati0:1 as a preiinzinairji'"i§§::5;z1%¥' pmvisions of Ordeer X3; Ewiaé 2 aE&19ii%"';;i3';{>V§si<3r1 of $ub~i?:1:/.1us€:

{2} Gf Ruie 2: ;>§ j€*.%1:;.ﬁ:>1es§; an isszzm {.0 be 'ffiﬁfi as 2: pre1§§11§1'121:§' £1 §3iE;'L:ai:i(>:'1 v2J§1z:*::'€;3 may ssuii: §x.'3§*\;z£:'§'ga;fi:1§§.?.§ém:,,j-%S&~s:1§%-5: z1z1'{:;"'§a{V:i.$ 2,1115% €,E":<;*, 21z1$w::r to the issue sf Eaw ':1';.("_:'ElVC¥"1.v'£L1;'}';'v1V5i;K-,:_5E'{Z?'_:!fZ.§"§V€'fai,i§7%§4'T{} Ef~}i?;".1.Eé}i'§iaf,'éI1-:'~.% m§%:1ﬁ:i<f~»m2<:§ in s;:2b~c'::E2'.mses ""---':§«:éi2";§§§ 'r<;%{§_;z.i:°€e;i .'i,:§=_..<;:'>%;2'm3i:1e €326: §:,:r§':}1é"::* §:';:,z€:5:;"€',§::>:'": ass {IQ :;a:.1y am? .e2;i*é.;;,::a7¥;,3i§_::":$ <::"mm=:%r2?:E,x€:{i in <:§z1:.1se;e=3: {a} :6; {E} 9%" S&'.€_f'E,§{1*.!2 2;é:':*.:'-&'w :;;_z%:._?;3--:.";£{':i:{;%<a:§ zm<E ﬁzkr :2;31€~;2>v'€:r£;;'_:;;; ss;:,::%h {§i.3:{:?S§§'..§{}§'}S E,E*:§::*§: ':'%.%€5a:*::é:e;V:;;:§:"§E}; §::i:;Z_:':g §"1€;',€.'f€T§ 3'21}: €j'f2<;?&.ET§§§":§§'E E;.§2:;:=, £§i:%a§3:,2.§':é:%{E {,§§,,Efl',;'{S"5i'L§.:'.i%§'E.:".=i<'; 28 iSSLIf;"".E3 cf f-;:':£,(::.E4.Ig '£.h:3:':2 aE«:>:m'3: ii; :9;1"1=:mId ':33 'e:1'ic'-2:1 as .21 ;;}re§in1ir:91;°}; ESS-3118 and S1.EbZ'£1iEZ:'-;.§ "£11 "{..h_ar3: p;re:'=:~;e2'1E. c0z1£;€:;<:t t}1:»1§; {he q1.£ess{iis:>:1 as to £1Jh.€3'{'h€}:" i'h._e:: ssuii: is; E::;2:m°ed by p'ri11::ipE<:.s_3 of n3s'jz.zd§§rai.a in éxsrms Qf Secii:):'1 3 1 <.>f1'3:'1<? Act, d<><;=r:+; mot. €fVf3:i1 the Cass: sf 2?: fizrcéigzl jL;cig:ne:1€;. wherrsas {he * Sactign 3 2 am i'1€:»f'. max': &1'{.i'.{'27£C{",é'CL it Es'-;_;.:3Ai*:_.1.y Sections 23 3,1115% 14 'Which. are a':.%ra%:.i:{%:i éiilﬁi -. wi£',E:_i§Lsj;"*. €EOI1(Z€diI1g, bu? asguming that Secttiarz E1 is also 2:tt,r;1ctt::;j;i.§.-itﬁyszrz 'as; 1:} whether {ha Suﬁ: is barmii' vf%¢$';:fa:.di:?ai.a being in {lE.3E'§TE déiﬁrzzzadigig '€'1§i1:'s:iéit'i:)11 aa {:0 whether 21 fareign jz1&g;:f:2c:£ij. 3:3: by ':he defzzmdam in this gtaseé, C0n.<:tE_usi1-='€Lfr;::1'Eia::'je _s'}f'a;IJh~it:E2 E2; disp11t§:*.d and. is required H22' ci+.:€{i§{i§;{§ 53:15? ;§i:*:s:>;2-*é:'£%d b3: {his <2<>z;2r'i; sand {er}? iiile pz1r'§3{:_:s'€;: _<T>€T.é::1$sz?%E::é:é:g Ehia {;2.1€:$%.1?m:, £12113 4:<:»2.:rt né3<:es:t~;a:'1ZEy /"A 2*' <:»'ffa<?:1': a.r:e:i tE'2<::r<3{T0re: in 22.113; evexxt. €.i.1'1SWt:?§' to %?.he issue 2153 :10 whether suit: is 'raarreci by iiiléis ;;}.1f_i.t1::§pE€::=.: of res_j:..:dz2.:~.:;£c2 being in mm. a:'£<:épe;'1daTn;__§ {.211 {he furi,h.:.:?::* £§{,1{:§S{.iQ;1 ﬁgwf"V C'f}I1(.'i1L§$§V€I}{?Sf% <7»? the fzsrssrign j1,:cigmé%z1:: reiiai H2._._1;;'";'~:-.33' 4i',Ezé_%'--« {1efe::':u:i2t:'1t: amd thai: in fgurzz E)eing dep<3:'1':c1_:e§'e::_':'«_i:}'ie .:;ii:~'.-:~p:_V._1i.'éV<V;ij_ qL.1.esi'.ic>:1s of £".:>1<7i;, which in fac::i: mgzcleé g;f'<:c)€i'-- in a.vf:;E.E}f3'ed§geé:i~ iriai and the isstmr regardizig a1;)p1i{fz2.1§E3i§,y e::f;-'f*§<;4V(iLti'¥:>:1V':§1.3 and bar unde-*:.1" Sec:f:.i<}11 E 3 cteiiaratifii prcliminsiry issue: it is in =§§EV3ﬁg§; ;V)§§:ri: é:':{331t4€11ti{}11, Sr:

R21;g.>;hav;1.:1 Wm,.;Ec%j Qwizzg ju<igms3§1'§.:ss sf tbs S11;>'r€:m§:' 1' ' é vv ' ' S S {AIR 1964 SC 49?} R5dMESfIuV:B"ﬂES;§§VAA~::;$"~:--§IPIN VABILAL [(2906) 5 sec 638;' " L. A. %a3p:z; L23 PRéS6£'§?'Y BA! {AIR mm 88 _ 1:32. 51 K ' -

E21}a'Z;*:_<3§":331:§.;':;g}' £1336: :§1.:§3m§s;:i%§<;::_":, E§r:£ §{a1g_};§":;.-:1-:';1:1 1%.-*@:,:E§§; "":e§.:'v,é:E:.2*i*:';é; €gha§ 23;" £'€;7::'m::s {Ef Se-':::§i{>:': 2%} <3? 231$: ACE, em. 21§_3;3::%2:2_E is;

4.V"§EE7{§=Z?§é:§€E{§~§E;}'§" iﬁmz 'EE':£;% i.§§§*-3§'£,§"§{I'3 ::z.::.1:"é: fie": é_:.E"2:*: %'1%§g;%": <;%m3;:"z. 8.E'E§.'§ 215:. :55 §.'§E-f;'3"§*.'§§.EK..E.§§"¥;i.' 53%' em': '§:"§'{.:';?§'~€ii'}¥..2:"'i. ;42.§§g_}:3:::%. E'~%s':{;fé:§{s_:': 2%} i"}.:";§j§_,r /~ am?» 7* we 30 6211211316255 an eiippmi from <iis;*:;z"§<:f: <;*()1m: Err: thee higggh <:C>Lm. (311 the c.1.:1mir121t..io:'1 <31' i:.h1;% pr(}b21{< : p;*:3<::@e3{ii.:1gs and W-*%1€:re:' i<.,If:{: prz}{:ee£i.i:1§gss 27-Lfﬁf b{?f€,'}E'i;'f CIi$E:ri<:t' :%<)u:'*{. or Eziggil {'{}'lEE'°E'....~«~§T7£: f:§§Z§'"fEi{'; as tbs-: €:3':ab1i:1g.j{ pmx--'isi(>r: of p23,ss-s~si.:'3_g i:1=:,c-".~:'I<?;z:*;¥;.1t,V<<3;j,:'~--..g>:ﬁ§;%:~$ ié'~ {:0 be fcmnd in terms cf S€'f.{.'i'.;i(3E'1 269 0fji.}1€: éiI_1{i i§'-ékét'.~a13"éi:j;_j order passed Larxdetr S<:r<:i:i<:sn 269 $2211: 's:<)L1gh*§7-A%,<)V be A3211': m:*d<3:* pF3¥.S?:'§(i'fCi in zexercists of 3'1,:.:"i:-7;cii<§':,i.(_:¥1%L;, _cc)nfEi:~:<1jé:i' u.}::V:;ier iihs pmvi:~;2I.ons of 1;h€ Anti. r3ubmiss£{>11 is that. the: dis~:.tric:'£: :t<;;,3.:i;;c§{ {41',§;;£éw "€:x21mi:1i:1g 8.111 Eippliifailiﬂﬁ sf tftigi-3%' Se/::*£;i(::r: 289 {}f the Ac:tf:, is "£.§9i :::"}3.}:<>x»j§si<;-;;_s5 of the C(>cie pa.rt4i::u1'a.;°Ey "*f<3f cm {Liza courts for p.':}£~SE~3i§'i§§; -s9:.'zV{_:If1 if; Se;%<:'£.it:;sr: 95% of ihe Cadiz. ii $37; 21.5' :i'p;3§§<?21€.§{>{: mldésr O:§'oE<§::r XIV' Ruie 2 CFC' V211}: T. .é;_p: p5§§£{E%;;:;Tfé:i'%{:;.:': wiaiciz iss s;L:pg}<>r€:rc:d 'by S§'L}bEEé5£,éEII1£'.i¥-*6 "g';r01:§s;i<}%:._¢s:}£' :?§<2:::.*§.:.s::: '£34 CPQ }:2r{>vEd§_E':g far' s--3z.:§3p.%s:>§:;é;%:1i.:33"y " -« "@:_:fé:»e?i{iin§;S' §;j__§3~ é:E:%:: <ééviE <:c}:.1r£:.

._ "3535; _ '"*5§'i§.1':.=:":%§%:%r§%':'2a:e::% '*L::t: é:::3;:E?:r<:.is~=:s<?': {:15 j :4::°§s;é§<j:i:E<>1": E.EE'i{'§2'f:§° §§€:{E§',§{'.}.E3 ""§;"§.:v:1_I1 ':41§}§._{f%V§' ﬁrizé (23 it} (w) av? {lrréier Eéhiﬁ §3:.:k>; E CFC» 33>' he: :§'2f::.;.z2%:§«:_ £3': -:%%:::<T:i:§.:>:'1 Eéiéi {fsf E.E:<-5 {.\j{,j?{'.§.€:.$-.2 wE:§.r:E: :"é::a{§s; 221$ i§v:?:%;'§--a*;t=.:i, .. T " * 31 pasased by C(j}L11"£",EE§ in :L=%x<-3:'Cis;r3 of 1:3 «:>rigi112-3.1 j1,£I'iSC1i£ff,i{}1L '£119: asnablitag-_§ pr<?;vis;i<;:'1 'for fiIi:'1g; an app<~;%a1 is to 'we: f<:):.2m"i~ m Se<:tioz1 104 <}3f'"i11c:% Cocie and Se<ti.ion H34» af Eihff with {)rcie:~3.r XLHE R:s;i<3 I €f§'1"£-'iSé1§§£?S {hit against, 316' {}I"d€i'ES p2.1ss:3r:i on different, pmvisions e11'L.:r11erat;a>d in (:)F:aE?§% §5:LIH E iihe pr0vi&;af<;:'1s; ef (}rcE€:_r .XLHi Ruie i'*%1;é1:; spe%{f£~fi<:i'1E--}';§J dE:jbe11"red ﬁiingg or m21int.21i'r1iI1g of an 'ai}7;'3<;%é1}.v.'i'1j: r§5s~;~;.;;3'é:V(.tf;-.{>i' 211.3}: éythzszz' type ef orders 1101: f1'a;:?eab§'é"*£.<:$f :-1:1.}:pp]i.c2}i.i{}:1 Lifldﬁi" any other <:§aL1s;e$ {)f~C}rdéI§_',._§{LE§I__ E«1uIe.." if 'CFC .re_-adding (mi. ihe 0miss5~;ic:>z1s and dé;2§,et'i<);--f}_s. ' b 39, it is p<2Vi'::f,§(--}c_i «i::'*.».a£ ':r.TE1:«1f§:'T'at;*-.;7;§:g;3£i<:21t;§on um:§r:3: Qfiiﬂi' XLEH §€t.1E<? 2 CPS e1r:c§'~.21E§:.Q3':{§{%': Vpézs-3:=_:::%e:,E cm E:3Ef£{Eh a,ppii<:a':'.i<m is; whikf: 31$}? 521:1 v<_3i%§"<i€r €:.:ié;:§*3,E:§_g§;; zmdéér Grder XLEZE R'z:§;§3: 1 CFC to Eém-13:: ,«:>§'V.rz3s:§._f:{:§ ,€§:..=:: w{}:°r:':§3 fag.' ;;>:"€:v€:§{.i:':g em ap§3€:a§ bsiilg EEEGCE ;;*.ga§i;f::i"s9E:'v~.2i;2.<3_ pazssswai am an :Iz;§j3§}i§{:23i'.i<?;:§ ::»i',Ef:erwiSe: ,§ '5%§¥""/ 32

104. Ordersfrom which appeal lies (1) 53:1 appeai ssfmiz lie _]"rc;>m {he jbifezeing V er*der.:s, anti save as eiherzzxse e;~:p:'es5£yVV. T previeied in the 13003;; of i"I1é3 Code er 13;; agzy 4;

Eczw jbr {he mile being in .,]E:"m:re, _}'}*ez"z1_Ink:¥--~~-.

other erders: -

{ff} an order Lmcier section' 35%;. '_ 5: 3-21; an order ?,£f'1d€I° seei'ior"'a.__91}.V_or see_et:iC::V7_. 2 92 refusing leave iéz:-V..«£r'1.5::'i£u!;'e'~:f.: Szi:iI"

{he I'lCl{1.i?"'(? ﬁe 'erred~fO"€:'1"see:ion 53.} 02* seeiien 92'; __es:. the ease --«{na_L;-- be;

{$31 an order u:n,eZe}* s:;eci_i.o§": §f:3;

{E1} azrii e?§dle;' ;:%r2;a'e:' }:Lr1§; .Qf' {?1~e~wprez::'siez'zs ;C"§E}"" ~§}"%;':7;*s;--':*_V Cede" "~~iET'€f30f-$_i§7.g' .51 fine or €{i:'e_e;s"irzg 'me '€£?_"'!"€3SZ"iC)?" 'eie:er1i'iez1 in {he

-------- .{;ie.i.£ '-of 5122;;-"'4 person except.

_:;3}'£ere Vs:;Lc?1 'a§rc>_s£ or ::iez"emi'ier1 is in " éexceeigiiari ::}f€;:._sf.j£Te__,?ree;

52"} '-smgg Verder' 'made zmder mies ﬂare ' * ;:.eE=e'eE':':2z2 {;ig:>gee::z.i £3 expressﬁy eﬂezeed E35,; m'£e:~:...f.... < 'V eF5§Z{}E%5f§?EE} £.§'za£' :30 appeal :;izaZ.E. {ﬁe againsz;

"e,z'2§§§__ e:'acie:i.VV_sg§¢:~:f'§fEeeI in e§au,se {ff} :§€ZE}€3' on {he 3j;f'e;e':ei §.?'2.é:zi[i_:'%e erdeéz er cm OI'"d.{3§'j§i}!" {he pagsmen: ej'€s§"§e::s'e::'3e«:.:r2:, eugfﬁ ze ﬁéiiﬁéj' Eeeee specie.

. , §2} ﬁfe' eippeel. :::~;i':efE §.€ej$*"::3:'r'2 5122;; erder pezeeeei in , ""_«€zp;,:eaE é,iE"E{f§€"§' E.E'3is :;e«::£,2'ez'2, €23"

33

40. It is ¥:.E1<-:.r°ef'c,m;% .:'s1,1brmH.<3d that whiie Sec:i:i:m 2239 of the Act; w}1.icE: is an €':E}E:1CI1"E"if3Iﬁ, under wE'1i{:h the: p1'c:»vi$i(>::s3"'5;re §:121ini;ai:1<:ci, While d<.3&:3 z'1.r:3i', e:>s::;'}r€:sss1.3; gsrqévideé zfaz." g1;1.__a},};: ::é&;%:s51,V' pza..rt.i<:u1ar1y an m1E:'2:1~cm.:rt: appm} ag_;.a1in_ssi'. 21::':H_{3?{*<:§V<::* ';:~t.' at': -- i111€er1(>(:ut.()ry sstagrs: :;>i'prob:«.1te prc3c:<:éedi:r1g;s zaflei the"p:f_Qv.:g.i:§ifi§3 of S€C':'{iO'ﬂ 94: cal' tzfie Ccyde, w'hic:h e.:1_21bIe~.s'--paia:s£.r1g2;,c:ii".x:):*<_i?::"e§ at the i;1¥:,<3ri()(:L1m1'y stage sf i'.Ir;<: pr{>fi2:i.'{r: pr<3{:s2é'<E§i1gsg :)'t.ht::r ihaxz u.r1<:i<3r the p1'(}ViSi()I1S of VS£:'cifio:'§ .(§'f._t.i:e :'\ci:, is only :10 be: f()13.§1d in S@ct_:i<>f} 94 {:PC'€'§:1d'AFI§"§§.Q, '";:?':£::' (?f{):"§'€',Spf_)HdiI1g appeliaie pr{;Vis§;d:t1 i;'3--'cV'1.1€.'1"l:C3f1;_"_1£j§f'-.i§';'§¢:ff: "'§7€}_;j;:"z4.iiv. :r1. 'S~e<:t.i{m E84 0f the Cadéz alnci the:"":*e5§?ii.;fi»::iiEE:":S '"_;;a}'a(:e€1 "l:1g:';i§n$t iiliixg {sf apspezaiss ermbied Llliﬁiéiif S§::<:i'4§<1£é:§:ri'£hE1 Qrdez' XIJEII Ruie ii CFC iazguaziiy zmpéieéz ':€3~.:».m appe%23_E;'i~§" has {.0 hi? me1ir1t.2.:inec§ against 31:?"e32f;§e;»ri__gizzigssésd an é1:".n:'~.i;;:E,€ric::<::.1t<>ry :'-s'a.a.ge, sf tbs? p:'(:fb21'é.€ §_}emdi.:1§_3; be::E'<:;2t*::*: gm: E:_ig;'§."; a?:<mr€, and ;;§ 9? ilhiif :"322i:1.::*<:% £31" an 2:p§}ii<t2?:£::%<3:.'; {3i',E':€3:° _.. §:§*;':?z%é'~».§:§i1:.::1<1%i<:';;§é.¢:%:.;3§}s::2e1% ﬁg :itx§m;%s;s§}; §3r<3E3EbiE.e£§. it ";~:i~;V2aTE§_:§éiziﬁié i:.§'::,?:§; €;§':{% ;?:;:3§§<5.22:§ %;.%':<;7::*:::§'<):"&: Es}; E"§;é§E§i I§'§.E%§E'."§§,£Ei'§§"2é?£§}§%Z?.

"--@';,:2" g1'{:'z:§;ii;E..§<.::2ii: "§§":.é:% 2.u,2i:.§::3:'i%:.§€:5ss @1221 Ezaéagvér éée;-t:*<a:*%§§>g:€-iii in éhisa *- E§a:f?7%§§§:"{>1:.:i3<§'.. __3 GE': <:{:z11§32ar'i:3:}2z §:vc:i:':g 1§"i«E1{.§€ E3}; i:E::£~. Apeix '"--€:f<?:'--:.;%;'"'§:.a "§3ei_§;a,r £71': 329 :":2:m.::°::: 2:'i§E{§. §'}€}W{%}"f%§ 5}? the 2i;3§}{:E§a'{:e ';;*:§;:"s;":s;%§_i§_i_af'?4:,§<'}:sé %é:i'1&:;'1 é%:m§<'%i:=3£:<:E :..:§':::£s::§' T§4.,£;=é*?:.<::?r:' §3:2:.314'£-7-gzé. é.'?aE'E{§ 34 :11. Sr}: Ra;gi1z2w23.:'1 E1215 21159:: 1332165 E'1.:m',h€rI' ss1.:1:3tI1is;ssi<}n:~; 'x%r;i,*;4}1 réégzxrd 3:3 i:§:1€: s{:<::p::-"2 of Sc'%<f:t:ie:H1 4 :.}:i'' the E%i_;;§I1 {f3;f:'t°'§:'*'v.A' <:::2:1t,e11cii:1gf the:-11: S<=,<:':i:i<2n 4 is E'}{',}{'. 2-: s:.1§3e;t.21:1t;ix:-'9 Qniy a p:'0<;ttedura§ pmvissafcpn. An appeai in i:e:fm--s?{_:<f:f'_ "

4. <3i'"'{,E1sF3 iwiigfz C{)?;I.IfT. A<:i'., w}1i<:11 is-2 ;3r<)<:§%€.{ﬁf2:i in._:'-1;:-:4-:.:[;f;e.,::;:'%§<:

mack: a<::t§*~.s€: 01' €f1"€scE;iv<3 has; to bf: r1e(is3;§§:s;1;9§A=AE:};? é3t1:;j;3_§§§:*?f¢::1 :)m;.:side by 3:113-r s11b$t:2x.11i:i*ac=: 2:ppei1_e1t.§2 p:'m=:is'm;1,*ég.::§fE=ss:;;§:?i a §){'{)ViSi()I'1 having :20: '0<3:3::..g3;:"i>.§;:c:3;_ec;i 'i',.i'I1C§EE~f_'- ?:;ih<3 Am: and haxsmg b€3fiI'; é:xpr{:».g~?1_S1y:;1ig::':oE1i4t;i§i:§dV.a;3ﬁ«%:%~éE29"i§1a"C<)de, é:h<: appeal CE11'§I1{ﬁ be n123i11tf.;2i*m;;"}3Ec% 'git. é15}_"§ «.éi':'1(£ 'ff::'E1ez'e_ﬁ:3'1'e the apptiaé $}'1<3:,:.§§. be dis:n§s?sa€;3:':Ev.";3f,_E,1*::% E:Ej;%*<:é;és".é:£z:}; 3.5,»: :1-52%: ﬁléfiiiléﬂifléiuiﬁ. $2, Eva: Wii.1:1..§fe'g',§21:'<?; 1i:.i3"é~.--3;'"ze s.+;c:{;;>e and e:%X£:e:1€', €32? Ehe a;;"3J;i»'s3E§je>:i:e;: _§::_:§.§;<;§§v<':i:i:>r:H €?;5'~:é;':i'{Tfi§5*s';?C§ by' 3312:? 'E~§:i;gi§3 Czmrt 'L1E}§§3E' S5-r<:E"€j;%{_)§':" 4i+"'<;s§"°="€._}f;:%:=;. Eggi: C€}?_1I""i'. Aim Sri Rzgghexvzxrz hzis cirawzz s.:v1'1<31'1. eXc3.r<':is~;ed :.:mcie}' t:}";x:* sﬁ{:2?:i':.1i,<>ry p1':)vi:-ieiozzs gm-*:%r';':i:1g 21 high cauri. €}§}"1f3I' t:hz:«m Liildfftl' the Ixsiier' Patent.

-4,}

43. Reiyimg; on the ci<;%:cis-:si0:1 cf t,E1e SLip§"€IYié? C{}l.'i,1'.'.i'." c. _LC ' cage of UMAJI KESHAO MESHRAM (supra). -s:,_1E§'sz1is-é§_E'e>:9'1 2:: ~ E;'I":a'i'. ~e..>s;'hi':e e>,:2m1.i:1i11g the €t3C(3*p€'Z nizsf ax: i.z1'::';a."a4':::<::11'1ri. éa.;;;)é.éi£_., enabled ulldetr 21. L»ei:T'e:' Péiiléiilil, th<>:_ 'teat is we': to x,vh.6:t{i'1<'31' ijhé aippeiiate jT.1I'iS{ii{i'ii()E"i <:<>'11fc%r.1_'£§id tzaf Ixztter Patsrat pmvisiarz, has been Aaixprsisi-2Q;§._é3x(:1u<:Eed"*:.1V:fﬂ::;f5 21 Siiatzzmry mvisien anci am 32319 §§{i§1'iif&§?fV1§"£'h€1?V @x'::iﬁi1'i.in<5 the s;£:<> <3 9%"

ihf-3 exercise 0f°:1p;§é.EEa1té' j::i"i'$dAi<;:%.-ii)1:}iii the itomexii of 21 s»;t:22.tu.'{0.:'v e.:"s:;1{%if.VrI;:'{=::'::i§;.§ 2:s?i::=: 11721353 High £31231 Act '{§'l€i tesi, 215;. £10 Wh{~{f:.%:éé::'*..;%:1}g..0'£,her §$'§CEiiLI_L3'§'.{}1'}' ;31"'{3ViSi£}11 1:10 aﬁahkzh $3 a..§.f?;:rib§,ii:%:{§. V{:_E'::e pr€j'étee£ii::§;;&2, xwsherzi an apgxstai £3 €T;ﬁé£i'3§€£§ ._§,_é'éi2{i;i3§' {.319 1'%5ss§3és%«é:'£ii1r:% Si:aE:2,1'£.<::ry pr<:evisi{m¢ H is s;uEb2.i:1;§;:.{%'<§.V é.E<2;;2;';€M 'a;z7s.?€~::?;:_ 'é'h:?.-;::, 'Lihe-"r E'.€f~f-Q'. ésg '$1.0 E96 ;';§;3;'3§_§:¢%{§:§ "SE16: £;2,:€-:ss?;§'§;?s:":" .;_:§ ":1§E9:t_2.::::.§sva::é'§'§ 2i,%'3<:*»..=*€: Eif§f%E-§?€.§"S §§Sé'i'§f in {E26 m%§;21i.:x:é3 éiifze §E{."fE'. _mi;§.V.iE'121vi11g €:13bE€fsZi am 23.§}pti'£i§ in Eihér gzregeni, " ~%"':,;?;t:.:_T.";':'*:»>: ;'2z::*:{?:" :.;:j%;%i%:': :.::1{§<é=g' 'ihii?' {:€..§{§€;'f, .ss;u_{§E': 22:2': 22._:;::p£:=21..'£ E2;-":¥i:':g;f "._{%i>~:.3:"a:%éé;:,§§'2.s* 1§'"}€'Tt€;'.§'".§ §i::?~E:§z?:z':°%:%cr§§ éém %'>:"':}v§:§is;:2:':$ 4;? S~:::{.?§:i_:';2': 21% :3? i:§":z=s

-. -- _ ~_ . I .3 (5% 38 laéing in farm. zmd eve1'1 in 3; sii'.uatic>*:'1 w%1_e.re i.E1e high. (:<3§,1r':: €?X€£"€.TiS€8 an a;>peIEat:e jur§;scii::i:i<.::'1 Le. an apps"-ra.I «af_"1:}.1.e .r:ai;:1:'e ;*ef€:_:'rr:%{i ii} in St3(?fi(}I'I 1;, 21:11 aappmzl f:'{>;z1 E:he"--E::%;;r_;'1é§§ ' ssiiigle j1.zdg;<?: 1'0 I.h%3 {}iviesi{>n Bemih, it is; to E36 '«::>jr*; .p:aa5"

wiith the: exerciaacs of a>2'ig§i1121i }111'isd.ic:{,,ior1 b"};}thgf' 1j:i';:;,f,i1 vvé':v.=:2é.11:i; .' itself.

46. it is 21139 submitiieci "éihafi, wihViuL§{=%.V:S<%§:t.i€)%i'vi '£.1*i}e. High Court Act; does not make 3 *-<'ﬁ.*_;'§_,:i1";«_::iT.i:,;_;:?1 'i:34:i:x>x}é3:£:r: a final order 0:' an csrdar passvzsﬁ an 3115} does not expressiy debarf ' béririg ma1'ni.21i1":ed ageiirzsi: an §§:'{i'é~g* i'1:§§'é3:'§::;<iMary st,::1g<:x Se«::i'i0n 299 0f {ha ,}~":{:'§§ .'_&1ESf:}VVV§;%X;g}f{fSS1}' dstbar 21.2": appeai againgi. 3:; §.fd%;§§"~~ iI":t€:'i}'§{feCi'i..E"f,{)I":gf sﬁage, in the .€~:e;_:f'1?is£;":, c:xpreé§'$'§3:s;3'%1_ibi£:i<)§1 is to be: 'f0Lm(i 1:11 Sezttion 299'§:1'm$§:,s{%:{:%'€.,_«i§i?ii}":s:%'<}.r{}<t:"s; an iE1{',€f§'§{}{fU'§j.(}§"§7 app§.ica.£ic~ns' Ii, :?$~..__f1,:rjéth:*::{~V's§z:%:::2"z§£:ie&{§ €:§3;a.i: ﬁ>§2;_n12?'s':;?y::ia:"":_ «:3? ihﬁf right: 917 ""z::§5;§;2s:;éé;i AA 21$ §}:r'e;'x3'i<ie?<i zmiier S€<%i;§£3':': 29?} (3% izhs ACE: £5; ms? 2:

"._ E:a:?z{i:}§«;§;§,:*z;}i;:;'::jE <12"? ﬁzz': §}0s;s;§§:s§§1?i4;; ii}? §.:':E:€:§'---{':m.:rE: 22:§::§3£=.ai 0:"

~ I :'T';V;.?.:':_'2;:~~{:re.;%:.:2"§' :2;§§3::>2:2.E. 332.2%. ii"; ééé 2:2. §3:"*<'::v:?;~3;':3:': ikzéz' {fi'}§"Efi:?F§'"%E'":§ 3": .§'§.;§§2¥1:

wjucigc sf {E1155 <:c>1.:;:"E: pa:-i-;.,9i;'1g z}r<ie:'ss in f3X£i'.'f'£'?iEi%{3 cf <>rigi1"121.E ji.1}.'i§F3{ii('ii(}§"1 2111:} 313:5: agjzzsin no €§;i&':3'{..iE'§C.'{§{}I"i rr1a<:ic:. "%}eéi5gé:;ée11 an {}:'d:;>.z* §_321e;sed at: i'.h:»3: fi £1211. 5:1' {}i'€§t1';':i' ;3£?tE§§f%'<if's;§_'§:ff__ 'ii}£§3"

iI'1'i:€rr§<><:a.ztm'3;* 5;'t.21§;§c cf Ejfiaié p:"::)::r<;%é:€i§1'1gg:~;e be,=f1);.:tz3__:E,V§:;ér"..§;i:1g3<i?"

}a.1dge.

50' \-Vhiie the st,2'c3I1g rcfriiarzite ;§12.1c:f§&,_VVch':'::'r:% 'hf the:-3. Fuil Bemih, in suppart sf ﬁeialg directly can ihéi paint, £6zirziégﬁ"';*<)11--i%§%s<§'§Af'<,§2i__i;i;i&§.g3%p;}téﬁa1%;§. w{}u1d pami. {mi {he {§;§§§*1£i§11 rericitzréid by 2:

E,-argez' " ()5 THAMMé.NNA Es~3::_?g;:1:;:§s is Ehrai whiie in the 9.3.3::

a:}{::§1é3 Fm} §§{%I1:{T%"if}f; KRISHNAPPA's; came' this i?{?_i§¥i1 "e-*~'«':%<'i'>'§;:'€§K21mEI2§3f1g;§V..V§§ §;.%::$§:%(>:'1 di:'€r:£:*:',E§.-=* in igsue viz", fhﬁif sa<:'<}jg}<3 ;1§;:pe'E2;::?,:=%"j:_1r§sdiitimii a,1m.%€:° S£;3("t'i,§€}i".1 4 5)? $12? High. ifimré: 'é'%;{::'§r'.%'aim?7_"i§"2tiziétzzsijeai ii': if% 2%-*z?:E§::2;_i*::E«::= v«.rh<,%:'1.€:v£:r 2: Simgsgiﬁ '7 §1;<i§;;<% G? §§"%js§' .§:t:.:'ri:. am": e:;:'cE€:%:" 3:": €;=%>;'s;%r::§:§s:% <3? :>:"igi:1a..iE. 2 ;§V:.%::.":s§;£%{:i:'§:32:.

44

by the 111$': c:;>m"t. in <:xe3r:7.ise':? sf fits:-<; S'L1§}€°I'ViS(}I'}7 j:.:.ris:;&i<:1:.ic>n 'u11cI§;<r Ari..i<?Ic 22'? 0%' 1.11:5: C<3z'1ssi:it.12{::i<>:2 of Eiaciia.

52. It also subn1it:i',<%{i i:h.ai:. whi1<:ér in ii.ht% ;:f>f' T NA {é::L':pfé1L the I,,;1z"ge3f' Bemth of I'h}:Et'> "-i'::{}Lf3 I:"'{1. seizeci Sf ea. €;1.:£,=:':;ti<2;1 in 151m: {?€)I"ﬂ'€}eZf. of e;3§i<:1°c?iés::c:<§ iiigss «'£'.§*V,'K':"'}'.--:V'~3E'._(V}'Z§'",t':ir§3..E ju._risdi:tf.i{H1, ths:)ug?h the r'e:11edy wa.g; s(31.1g.E1_f, {(31%»i;'if:.If<)'1.:.§§h'iaii appeai under Se(:i:.i0:1 4- of the High"€c3L11't 'ACi:§? bL1i;: in H16 }3Z"'{",S€I'1i1 situ::1t1*oz"1q 'i.1'1{;",_C€iS€ b€%:1.g.;§=(>:1«5:&':}fé1 3"<;ff::,vé:dy* sozzghfc, far in the a.pp<:}};21t€ }4u3§fisct:i{€f;i<;+.zi'«.3;$:. _ag23..i:i:3,'{,' Ufﬁiffi' passed in {.216 exermlssz-: of <1-_r1?_gji':':;2£§_;j:;1:'isLé?;ié:%'£i<>::;_fogzf£21 :-singie judge of this <:<>:.:r*;:g Eh:-3 <>;;:1:1i§;;: 346:';-.:§=::fc:~sj§."by?/E[3_:t -Leirgtér .Z%§m§<:h in iihé'. Ce':1S€f5 9? L 4_fS::';319z;} E215; iii; bezzrimg <32" ap§}ii(3Eii.i()EE in the present. '{f:(:_%_:§',;'L;.",:v:€:-:sx' §3:,:.i,' §%1'e=: s§,i.L221:§on 728 {mi}? zmzi sq1323..z'€-3%; gigs;-"e3r':.? 5:1 ..'::_}y £'§1<::m}§§%'s__'i:ai«;e:::: by §.§"1€£* Fzsﬂ Eﬁfzmth af {:E1i:~; ('i{}EH""§. in » . ihe '"§§5s;2__ 'E6 is; in... "i:%1e ba.<:E<§§':*<>:,2:':d {sf E?~}'i.E{ifh {Tii}E"§.E1€E"iE§{>)i'§.53 zzyzsj _ §s~%..:§§::2i;;~;S'£.<>m%; E:}21<:%E«:sé<§ E35; 2?:i:§I}Ti{}§':"{i€:?:?%; :'@f€r':°e:<'§ it'; Z":§§}§}§/'E33 :.E1{~*: 47

5'? ReE%z»:::.1<3e pEaz::<?{.'; by Sri E'€.21g§E:21*»*21rL §€~a.rned s_«;t"::2i:::r <:":<m:3&i»:.€:E fer f',f'."i€ f§z":':sé: 2"e5ap<;m{§€:3.f:, {:2}: Iiihe "§'i.1(}L§§E'E1€:?E'E§ of $16 Sxzprcrne C£:n_.:r€. iii: i::21s-? ::i%2::~5<% ::i:»i' ARA'?! L}U'1"I"A EASTERN mg ES'Z€°'A'1'E PVT LTE {AIR 19s3 _ *s¢ -

"i§..r}j}i{Tf1 in '{1'LEE"I1 rsiérs to 3. §,')§\;is§<m Berarrh :";1'i_i§1.fg High Caurt in SGKULCELQNB 3 MoR§:,K1%:3A" 2:5.

LAW BGARB [(1973) cam CA3 1}»,2?;:1€i i§::j;§;'i.:V§Aéj,f,; :%g;:{»a;%gy the Eixrisiam ﬂeas}; 0? Sh:-:gE}.§=iIhi &;viéis3'v~§':1;v:i§:I":er in ?;'1,z1"'x1 reﬁitrmd :0 by {E152 VA of EELHI E..?'NI'$@RS§'T1' §ELH§ :92}, wherain f.he: s:;aéc3€§:)§r Sécf.i0:1 }G{ 3} {if Ehe Semi Higiz {3€§ §13:'%. {:E.:f'i.::.r€':iV.:VE;iLi.:E.£'£'E.&,:'{'£.g whicth.» a<:{:0:'d.in.g £10 Sm R21gE:_a:§';z_:%,'. E51 ..3i;:EE'{i(§EE 3; af 'aha Eéigh Cauré. A,<*::L &{)€S: .310}: Léé{§;x.{;;-mzééé of ihéé :=z5s:«;§3or:d€~:1f.§ far p'§'"'7T-'{§"§-§1'§.V%. .;{}; E,Vi':i;j?'§}7Q§€{'f"iZi{)§'3 ta i.E::a>. m2,zm?;.a;in21b.iE§E:y Qf %;:E":é=: 'E7;-§§V§:~€ij?E'£§; ";..§€@._§:§?as;0n '{.%m.%: in i:E':.2% <:a:=:-;€: 6%" E Eef SME '{$1.?;>3°z:§ E: 2§%:;%-: . %~=':{}%,. {§i&;;3:.:'é::;3{i §.§z1_:e;.i: ihéé appeai we:-5-3 ariiéz "'29%3%A§Ee::§é*i~;7::5i:=: ii} 'E-E%}.=::§.i<>z': EQZE 5:?" *:.E::é;: {":<>::E{>. emd if s5£;:a "ii": m§*:': %2%;ii:§": «.V"*§"é:§'€:§*e'zf;{::::; 35:3 {Er:E{=:2" X.E_;EE§; E_€;a2§=::é 3 €§3{ff, Ehéf §.§:r":":Ei.2'.%,§.§:T:r:": §:;;faév:i:;i<;:{'§; ;. /./ W5

4. . %&Wmx%m®4mWm wm .$9§4R\ ' V' '--.§€T:?'2"3;§"Z'E€£?'{§ A <>b}'<:%<:£'i{}I2 he <';v:%§2*':.:Ie;%'pt:21i fbr GX;1H1inaé".§r;)Ii1 .

5}' E179 éift? aka «sf the a-'iew 'fhéiii xx;h%::'r": €X8;}"I1iI1'§};'1§._§ ijhér ,S%;::§§.§x:é'=. 9:" fhe £ipp€3§L'i1?;'.fif §3r<>v:1$'i<>t1., t:E1:;:? 5.-%xa.mi1'1z1%;§<}:': €:27:.:1:':€::«f:,' §}€?*vf§;£?f1i the angiz-it of makégfxg Eiiifie §:s:'::)vi$:2,:>:1 ins%f§":%<::%T.ive Ta:-%%:é¥:¢é:1':'f{>é*~ }§§}'1i§ZiI"}.§_.{ 'izhé :--3c<3p<3t cef the £?t§}p€'H213l".€€ ;§%'§TV<«>_;i:;15:;i<>;':,"b:.;{sh<>i:§£{i 01113;"

be {min tihez 21.:1g§€ Q? :';:4a7i:inig}; i;%1é-«._v;;;3;}';;;«:3iE21t.€ §3I'GViS1:{}Z1 Hlﬁkliliflgfléig $0 igihaii the §.e:;~.§;;;is;§-2zV€.i~:?f;e';»:".ii*:'é,e3;:i.C;;§_g;}r<>vid§:1g{ far fﬁizigg; if an appez-xi _;:g?;;;§i:*3,s3é. *§5§1<;%:<§_§::}:3.:j"'bfgf..;f;:é faggriﬁved p::rs<:::"a £55 géveza iéffééti. E0. 2-"uftarii _ "_?'€*"§.;i)_§'€f3 ix-=.;%§1€.n ézﬁeinzirziizg €316 $<?0pe:=. of

-S'3{f§1§{?é§E 4% <3? ihé V;i:"§ i;§éi~i3 V§)a{:t}§g§'<):;;:nz§ sf t§i"zé$ zzppeai amé 7'€;he_ <ii3{V:;é%Ss§i>:2s'«,:ﬁ2s.dc é>.b{;>v<:? ave £i'£'€;'.. {}f the View E:ha.:: a;3§3@e:A:'-.€E'§_:;%:r.i z::<zgi'é3;%f' 4 0f iihéi'. High Cmjri; Am. is me:§:*:i'2?ai312i?:sE:% a:":{i ..,%i;:_h'€;:*v"?:Ij:E'a':"E;:-"e 't:§::a=% p':"e£§_n3{;1r:.;*::'§; €'§§3_j§€€3?Z.§{"}i'.'i <}:§€:':'"g~«:z.A: E €:::§_ .

E32, i:%':s5{"'«:;":s:%'§é;:§"};f>§ ':.%:a:é 2s:§:p€:2&:i ;§§_.§a,i2':s;%;. %;,§":<3: 0§°d€::* <2?" éht':

:eé'£V1'1;",.§§.€:j::;.:::§§§<;=:§ :§s:.2E3:z";§s§;i::m <3»? 3:': :"a{§§1::.:gz: S<:::f:<iE:%§ " .E_§;n:»:::w:"::'.*:<:§ {_?*.s:év...:":V";*:4;§:;.=§ V:§%:2:' "E'..§"§?E 2-"§§2§}if§§%§§"iE'. 3% %E1z';:i, '§:%§{.-% .§a=:;.':§m?i§ §=;i:'sg§E:a% 2' %;

y K 53 Sé:<1*;i<>:': E}; {sf the Code zmzi 2zsss5aL.::n.E:::g§ EE32" a.1*gL;:11er1'E:'s; E:h:?:.%. S€rE{?'§,i{')I'E 2.} 312'": é?:,u;r§'1 is Einkarqi to Si-5<f:':im'f: £3 £2": 2: <::1s;§é:~.'<2f the pI'€'ff:3€:'.§1'§, §':27:tu:*<:=z it .1'1i;T"«'{ffI'*£.§":€;';§E?§%&3§ E2223»-*i:1g H1ﬁ?_..é?.§:§L'";§i* 2 pr%3v:¢?::f.i::.g; £.§'1£: '§§"f§Ei§ :3"? %':§1{% :»:;'ué§. ix: §Z§1€f_3;7.E*Zﬁ:g' §e:;:5_:%g é%""<f>.éf; »§«:§:* '§:h€ x.«*e§*y' ::::2.msis<: in :,.@.:°'m_s af $119 p:*i:1c:.ipic%i% 'e}§° __'§2,£§E£E?ix{£i¥.:

im:{>;*p:>rz1E;<-xi in Secizmrz E E of 'i1§1€§: "'f_f§;}€§e."' ?'h&'.~ '.:té;.%;1r*:'._j':sVE%3.<>e;iifAVE:«1'<1€';2%"s§"§1: §3£"é3HE'E":§.};f1.£1,A1f'i;-' ESSEEQ Lmies-Es 3; clésar finding had 'i3r¥:%:%:7;' 'gi':?_e;{t'1 v%.hi1€V:A_izhcét» a:1swez* ti: thﬁ ESSUQ 0%" ism; wag <§€:;§¢:;§_d.::1;§§ <i:3;"?;.i1c'*:é;:1,§:5\,>¢e:t in me i.s3s1,:@ ef $4-. ":%1:3;i%'.'}g21 Sa>zz.::§i§z:Z§ awqsséizi Submiﬁ th_22i1f"A_;§:': {Sr a££miE',E",e-ii £"a<':i.:~; in 1:}/:6: pE'€i*S€I'}.'{ sii._z.2a:.§;}:*:§.r;%a:€V%f:' _ Of '§i3*"'i€ p<:f;iié<>§1 a2Iem2er1'::$§ :.af %éi{:E§ ..f':;ff€:aE<A3:§é1'&:v---gﬁiziim. {F18-i'i{§§YEgS, ziméi t:h@:r€: 'i':.s:°:i£":::§g 11:1} {§ié§§i.§:"é;.<*: jé;:jE:e:3:.s?;_ ":'i,§4.fz%:%.__{i:<j§.:€»;*:i:;":§."§.e::s: {sf 2: gzxigggnzésm: :"e:m"§.:5:.:"é:<§ by 2: '-.<i;:3::::": {:6 §i:>:2:;:géa:ii:€:::T'_ai§z1:*;§.$:'ii::i:,§0'::,, é,%1:3:.sg;§1 Q'; .2: §<}.:*£:%§g;:1 {:€32z;'1§;:°§:',

-...{'_;§:,:*a.{_§"§:1 '%i:é3m'i2f':Vs§'i-{>15 i:i':e §}:"§%s;~;m:zp*:;.%{}z": :.m{§i:%r S€%<t:i::i_0:": E4» 9%' iihzz' V.{3::»:iEV1<?s,_ ;§1,::£g§.::::=a;:1§. {sf :.%;:e §":3mi;_;j§: {%{}a..::*é;: w"§_E§_ E'32::»%: Eat} $39 3 <;_:%.:"§.Ej; :"s:<:?i%:§:':Ez:;%:{§ 21315:? 5-=%§f"§E.'.=<'%'€.:4sa§é?r~{§ 2I:"z§'}{i§ ~f5§%Eé1.'§§€§§'E 3 E Eirsezsriz 56 936$ the piainiiff camraat fesciie {mm gush j'E.i§§§i'I1EI1t £2": the wake sf pire-sgumptien uaéér S:::~e::i.%.0n 13; reaci xisith S€{3€'.iG?fé -I3 sf {ha Cade and ever: in Eiarms GE' Sﬁfiiiﬂfi 1:3?

présumptian can bﬁ rebuiteé under any HQ3%"};a:?§V viii". {E36 enumerated c£a'uS€$ :::«f Sectien E3 »CE;m;'se$' {a;.:}'-??;;:>; "{'£},. Submissiar: :3 ihaii there is I10 see;-péat 3}? for Vf4h1<:v-Vpkainiiffj in the prwarzi. Suit ta €39Z1'5£€1'§d;..5.[.hE:'Lf :}<:A:>vvV:Af§"§:si'$'§~.(;_:.:j§: j;Li§gn1en:£ is hit by any {me cf the gituationé'L§.13tém§§§ia$§§V:_ §%iV:1i:':'%_;er éitiauses {a} :3 (f) 0f Sectian E3 Sf :ijh€_C0;ifé: V ' . . ' 86' in Qthia CG:1f:<~§;1;"i.34'_1£§%,ﬁ§2€sf_:_Q§'u..:§Se§ appaﬁant wouiﬁ Submit €h.i-}€--?:§'1$ﬂ '}é?;i:':%iE'iE;:{§I,M§ " was m1»: right £3"; recezﬁing 9;: fi::€1i:n§V {cf {ha foreign muff} was ism; Qﬂncﬁ-1i:§E§{€§V'a:%§ AE%*ga§.§:_'--~£: 0%: bﬁgn Supparteﬁ by gmpgr r$,a_§§:1§.1"1,g';«€:§;f;i33.:"1€§"'§;s3..._:h& judgmﬁni: and zzethmg i3 ts $36 famzé .-Er':-v.f;§':.é"§::égm$ﬁ{ d3§@§:z:a$$ir:§ the aaécésgiabiiiigg 92° ' =.._§>:vhe§'1if§:tgé":§fti/§:::¥'"%:§:2€{"%$::ce E5: in by @216 ﬁariésa E': is 3:: such _ _T '§;*:$ﬁ:':_§s€, the §€;:»1:"m€-d Sirigia jziégﬁ has Cams :0 EEK: {':Qn:.::§uS;i5n '¥._§iE:«e;J:«.'i_f§:.:€_ éi:7:$%§§€:* ii; the §§S"E.,1;§5 3%" Eazzz 2s':¥.2r;$, a5; ':a :%;h&i;§z€r ﬁgs *§:§?%§$}%:§:§;§ $35. is; 32%;: if: 33$' Sffﬁgé. {Z'»f:¥;3'};EE€}€ gig} far iriaé an €333 prizzcipiess of ?"€;'.S~f§ji£.€;Z.i£?{i.E"€/2. in 'iemngsa 9? S§.'(fiiET3I'1 ii réfacﬁ wiéh Se%<?i'é;<3:3 13 of i',E1s3; €L0d&:._ {'f:£1.§1§"§<}'§ be S£:i'€.i.§Bf21{?{.€}fi.i}=' ;:_§:s3w<::"1*-égd

1.:.'r:§:'3.:;~3::; Em: 'i§;s;;u<t=s»; <3? f;aa<:i:$ are :::1,sa:<3 .a1§":ssx>;rem>;g§AV....in "i.ir*;;:% bextiigrcmrzzi sf z:§;"za:s:';e {he} of S:3s;:Ei<.m 13 9%." £;E:<% C{}rCf.§%;"'._V 6?, Sri S{}I"£{§hi w<:.>:.1}:i s.~:u.E>mi'%: §'.EE23;'{:=__'»7'v'}fE.i}{j::v .' {axpresssiy re<i:§':.<2S t'.h;'iE, 'aihrs: pf€){I€d.E1%"€«.__§.§"1E£{ 'iv><:mv':1% is as <:mri;empEe1E:€:d by {E362 fgimzrt. :;1::f-.__§ke §" 'E§:£¢ ;;:sr%§Ce<imr€ 211:6. thii pE'()"s,-'§S3i{§I'1S§ g{}V'€3F§1V§§'E§E?£~" as; p:-_-*::f whmb.

i;.1";Z8i 'i:~:.: jurgz" Syﬁqkgrm i:sj~A'.:%_;{h1 23.<t3z:1<'«*§)::*h;.--e5::€:f; zmci in 3:

trial by {heat jLE§"§? :.1«:_::'V or E~}{?C}p€ far :°eg:<}r(ii31§§ ?:.%:;%:...f:f<:§é*;:5;*}:*;;éi;,:_E'§ f§E}{i§:E§§§ of §:a.::E?. 21..1;*§r_§ :,h€r'€f::>rc far 33$? s'L§§}p<}r'{éI1g ﬁnéigig :3?" Fastt: bezafkgfezzxzgi axmi em E33126 <3?

fgzgsiz §§€>es:: .:Vi1A:"2%::3<%____i:_3¢E7v 21$$:;:;§1'i:3§;; ii:hé:*:;:e>; arzgz <}'§.§1e3:° isasznmag <3?" :§'§;,«:€i.,w. '2'iL:"E.S§ﬁ';'¥{EVE5"*i::€'§=. é'.§:.¢_:=. {sf Eaw baéiztzg' nag: {§€:'f§}~f;T'ﬂ'{§{?§1§fj $31.23:

_ .[,,__j,;*f:e:§e:ep::%§:iiéiéfaét. ;:m§:§j_ %i:f§1<:: i":>:°<7a§§3§:': ja,:€E§§::1§%:':E: if}:-?§::':g;z; as': <:{§m':Ea:$'§ar:: .. '3::s<';s:a;._é:h&% i_§=%~%:i<;3* s:si*:.{?>:.';2:"§ E':z2:;e ':3<%e:': :'1<é<:€::$s;22§'ﬁ:; '§.E"§{'E?{i 'by' SE22? 4' ~._é}:;:azi;':°i;:"_ £5 a:"_§}':'€:§f§n'2§:':2?s_.:'j§: é§;«5s:;'1_.§ é Ei;z""

¥$&W£ .

7. "~r;::€$§:1g§; géiezga .cs§'j_--@:{t:9p%,%<:§*: 2:": %;:<:::*ms:-a 5}? {'.§E§;'é,i.&f~;€E3 3:23} aim? {b}§ :25; $f§_{f§}}€f fin" §'.m:E::ii:::;g i:§':z:;?.4 {Em §"i::{i§:';;:{ Q5' 'SE39 E83116 <2?

"*E2:%;':a'»1 ._i:<_.:2? w_%'*s.a~>:%..Eze3.r Eihﬁ §§:"s;¢s::;:t::':':. s§§é:'e_.:&%£i<'i:;': 2%; Eéii 1'33? 3&9 '§}é*§:2:.€..§§."é§_{?§e; <5}? §"é?:§"_§§,é{§iif°€i§€Z '§::::>:'n;:T_ me::é:§e:§ <.%<%§'3€::3§:::{.§ 9:3 Eigié 59 ;>2?z1°i,:; Who 3153 pr€s_;m':E: wi"€:E"aE:'1 GE' 'WHEE had sz.1':):1:ii.{4ed to j:2:"i$<ii{:i.i:::1': <7f2::3'm=:}i' 22§'i:e%3*wm°{i:3 :;1,m=:s;i:.i{}:': ii: 2:-ind i:h€::"€;éf<>:"<s;--."'mt:

péaérgiff in {hiss Cffaiééi?' is; €?E5iﬁ{)§3§}€{'} §'}:*<3::1 z";;ai.$i;':g;; ihéf <f;':2:ms;:>:s.; 3;_v23.i§:2a_E3§e in S<;>.<%:".§<i;:'1 "£3 0f the C066. £§i:T~;c:.3ssi<}:T: wig: r@:fer<:m:(:': 13:0 t'E":€ .r€z3s5s<::1£=; :'2_§V311,--.ug:f\}%ic%:VV1_ c<>w?.:"s fZ?§E11;§S€*:wb of ihe <3:><<:ep§i::).r1 amid £':hA1e :3§_is:;pL:i,€:rs§I. :sA{3i:§ghf'. ti)» be? :~2:i$€e:i by the pEz>;i:1f:iff 2.%;%'sssa1.1m:E.>ti;;g:;--.i'::. €13'-2:9 c{:>i,i:*i;--..::.<:»ii, g<>iz2_g; beyazzéi the E-§(',{}_p§3 cxf zélmises' {a} 2é;;1:'i' :{b)_'aé_'1"d 'ihare E3€ing H0 ssczxpe far .imr0k£ng i;§:€: :;:;;<ée§§i.i:;1*i.§g: 21$ 'f@°::.:f:{i' iii; {*;E2;z.:1ss€S {ax} ::1}f}.d {b} 0:" 8E3C3E,E0:"3: 13:'éf"';;i2éé"-iiggde;-_e:yé:1_ é?_ssSs.:.3n1Eng that a s:i1§§;:mie:<:E faérf, °'JV()1ﬁ{i vhjzéwsi ;§uf§f§ 6,j%Z'i' in W:"E1<:: A "'::s<}*ﬁie:xé, <)§ eirkmverigzg 3; qmis$€§<>n i:}1a'E,.A£:{m.:sT§'{E 'Ia.€;is:if,;%:*mi::i:1§; 23$ {(3 whether 'she: 'i%m3ig§:1 "_§Li{i§,§*;ﬂ"§{€?I'1f."-;:E§VCf}1f§.Vcif§'G(f$i"i?€f:£3? <}%,%1e2"Wé$:3 in ':ih<3 zt<}§1'i:e:x1. sf '§.?;*:'€2' '{:':;72<;C€§§f{.'f{}i'?; --Lgfmtzzssss '{2:'j"";:2;'*:d {E3} . 1*.

19%. __.E§: _:E'::::"'g:;;*::;:v§$%3::i[.. {ff:>;'§.f5(f. "if.§'".i@'£'§i',' ?:::":.i:":.g,:; Hi} :s»;<':z:>;2<-3% ex.-="'s:%:": E92? 9' 7 _ ""'-s,%:':':<> ha::i».,§:b§:aV§:?z€':E.-- 2%: §:3<§g,:3':{;':n':: 9:: 'ﬁgs: E'§:;13'}€§S <25 23, §<::"s§g:: atzmriz N§:1§{.i§§}§;T§';i.€;?I'E'i1 ézféar ggairag '?a;h:*m,:g§§'1 ii}; :::.{:»m123;§. §}i'€":={2€'3':T§3.§;E'=Ef 4_ "'£?:.§i:'{§ '§"E__.§V§'"E-..E:%._}'}"'§{"§ 3:? ;:::':;§ .:"2%:.€':§'-:: :.:.<':»§: rZ}§)e';"f§'}. ':':{:; i',§':<: _;3'§a-:_i::mff E4'; {:{}':2*;.€;=,::£§ ...1§'.E':§: §z.:{§§,_§2';:i-é:'2§: .ais&; 2;§§:§::s§:<;%{"E §:::';" Z%:'§2'?w%:':;,.%; §:%::'é,zra.§m-::.§ :2": 2': 50

0:" fé?L{TfI;1, ~=.,r=§.:-'§':2*<:"ra. 1&3 :"€::;ui:"e(§ £0 'i::w3 éiI'§Si¥'f;'I°é?{i far 'i.h<-3 pm"p<;sse <3? p1"e:-;<::';f; :~;euiL in fm*':;he:' s;upp<>ri: {}f {bias iséggai p€3ssi:%<}'r: "'i',if1.€:

ie2a_:':':e{.i (?{)El'£ESe':3§ far EiE':€: 2,1ppé,=.i13..r:*i: E12255 2€:E::;{r; 28 <3? €326 }2..2dg2;3":1€::':E: in tzhssr {.'.3;S-E6 <3?

:'.E1a'z: even 21 s;§i',L122,"i.ie:::": «:>'f fihéf pm-?&§<;¥I:1ii :12;t:1:r€: éwhi-5:731':1'":__Vi%:.g«.i:_Eris p£:1m'é'£ff haéi i:";ssi;i"£zW.:£:<;%::i 21 p:'<>C:3<:édi1':;g§"'éz; {.§'1€'§"§3:{I'€i.g}f} ;ii§§é3f'§,élfiiéi' '§::st:§E:z:€:§ng;f the prc3<;:<§e::ii:,1g3 §f>e:-§7':7:*e. °--~.3;_.§":_§s e:§*f}U.}T§.:, but :i1e"::€1"t.he1€ss:a sufferg an ad2?'€:fs;e: :,n:5:¢; 21*:-: €;}j;::*-: fareigga a:*:9ur'::

befere iihe §3res.s<-:_n.'é': '<:;u'§I}1i2E21i€Ci, {ha C{','eZ':(.?.E'ii:'§i'€.»-*3 {:=f Eiixé f::a':*é.;g_;:;.__ V §.1;.::i§g.?::é;1t._: iss_'m:- whétm <:§iEu'::e{§, heérzmsse £3? ~iEr:ii§-S§'%;;_:;:i§§::~£"L £§:§:§:i':>.;$sVe{£ in par.22»~28 of 'ihri:

j§E§.dig}"£'}€§1'£ {§§_'' @316 _ Viz?-i1«}f}E'€:.:j::é;:_"_..C0u:*'é: in the {33;Sé': Qf VISWﬁNAT'EA3? E.'§iz'p::f;j;VEg_ :-:5; 'iaisgs-5} s;:.;:i"3:nE%.':;i;%:3"ﬁzezé. 'ihﬁ-.'E°€ ES ahss<3§1,:?£:€:§_j;,? 11:} ;<.~3<:{}§>€:

ii}? z*';s;__i;§é:;7:,{>:;' TiE::':a7r_V<i3:::{:%:;§'§é£}z: <::_E2:_1,:s~_'~;<~3 isié éﬁéééi}, 2155 "ii; is; £1316: péaéméff

-55% ff' -

61 11:2:::'1:1a.r <3p>;>(>s,;s.:?:i {E} i'h<:% ;'::r'i:'1<7ip2<~;->.:; of :3;-1'£',2~:1"a:1i_ _§L.1S'iI.i¢i",{'f zmci E'.E"z:;>. siszuid {?E.2?:a.;s:2:€ is 215?; €3v€::'2 z2é:"é,r;-z.<":»::t:d,,; t:h:=> j1.:{iggfmi::r:i:, E€:$::%E§ §aa';1s at: 'ihzri hamds «:1? i:.h<:e §)Eamt;?.f£I TE";z:? f0i'E:m;?'i:1g " pz1:°a~:3€} abf{hissju::igz12.:%:1§:, ass Lmciez': ' "'H1e Eang séazzciimg praciicfef of _E§§'1'i:: C'oi:Az"'i.'V._}i:é:--;,, ' E,?m:" ans? sf {he Jzzciges; rnaf+:e:; a'gre;j}?§:eT:"z;3z':{:'é~.E,ég;.. gig' i"I1:?E'€f recard in {he or'de.r'_ sfzeei €g:f'"I,er.V--l 331:9 judgrnerzis an? separaidy pf*::>;'§'G:;rT1{:s2:£. ' V Ii: apggaears §;I':.zfi?fg§}'%>r*e £.?§.ai""..::'E1=g->5? mag 51 seiiied. prae::ziiC(3 in {Em J'éiy_;~e:<;~:"e=>.V,;§¥?1'z.'3;;:i'a_ €30f';::'i. {"0 refer gases :mz:i.e2' S.__ 35(3) 'd€£ivéf:'r2gw--§;:E§}f7$a2rir"zg opirtions £r:C£z,;<ii:1::;._£f2(;j fE:2ci§soiirsitafzsa :0" he passed {:2 {he appeaé 5;}; 'E,£e;?;§I"%'}*§i?°§VE:0I'l.§:1;,'~.§?"é ;i(§fiz.dgé;'2g {he £'jO§'?1p€f€IZC{3'ﬂéffﬁ-{E26 gf;:r<:>'ig«:t; "C.Qi.;_ri'?;:. .£££}0?;i,EC{ :10: be open as us in t}gz1'37:'e '$1:-'3 <"?'::%u:--:°5'é af§pra.<?:'::?£3 in ihai Couré ebéia-gj{'"i:i§. "s?07:'*.s':-riczgj":;:;.:ar:'anied by Em»: g:r:"9<?ea:sra;_?j. Za:--;a: Q57 __ S{:;::1<:>. 'L-%f'§'2s;?z?'i€:" 5,526 preceoiizrfe' Qf :'::.?'2e'«;fbré2igi'?,---.,£3:::;gz": :v!1z'c§": @995; moi Q_,:}'Z2?2.d F1{1?'}1:£¥'G§_j§;£S£E.:f€» iéixvbgiéd £3 ﬁx {he fb?'€;'§gZ}';F'E C§z,g:"{_ :19 deéédé -<3g;2.'{:i r2:3£ 'ﬁg; the Cam: in z.:;i'2ici': :-32¢» _ f0:'gf:'_g{g:'i A';'.r,:.&3:;iI'2E:5~3.:j§. 1;3§.eac£e5£ 52:5: £;.'OI'ECE£.£S{L3€T, En " ~._Z3r'_:Zf!.a7§ ;%~?{ZFi'§jAi&{L.9 3;"':f§oz}ir':d22::;.:'rz $ord}'z.cm;cEa,.§, 'F4 gnai g;;:pv,2%9:3;% {fﬂfé 294? PC :92; gm». L/FiéC£.f§:?§:{§.§.

__;€;':;n_éz'szi,5i'§.:3;é~€%:»._s:i§9aEir":g a::€§"f'"£. £'§z»;> €}{£§?"E.G?ifl§} Qf" Size §E~'zd@.::::>. }£"f_%;:_ '{jfa::;"E; {'0 §"m:'"zsa.j_i'2;:2r ;3:'<3{rzz;?ec§i:"ag5:s j%°:'>m zfzé €.;<:§':°.f:*E_. am", egg" f:':.d.0;r'e:>? ab5:erans3<:§ :

é '§?Z(3? {,§.z.£€%§;ri"£<::n; wf':.<2*é:'E'z::>.:" 5: _f&}:'eég:z C-::2a::"§:' is Efze V""p:jQg3€:"~{f0u;*E." Sc» gzfgsai :T:.:€f:'§2 52. g3>:m'.z":?zz,§a;" s'm:zZ'E'er "Q{ra?é2=5;f§§'zg :9 351:'? 552:3; ezgg" {"326 M§'%2:"e:i§;z'*: <;><:2am€:'z';g 52 _ _ i;;V;,££%'s;--§'§<s:'s_f%3:' :'§%a> €fs:;2zg:'§s ::;f §i':s:.E_ €.?{}E,£F'2fjz"§;4 '?"'§2s;ér"e 55; {K} __ " {f<i'::.:§:::' §'f'3.:::_§. ;<;<m::;.> {E{;:mi' in §:'::£{>:2:,> 235253 'E: €Iff:;:,::*§T 2:}? " "::r:§;'s':g}s:-?§"a?:'::_§as;'i:::;::§§:?:.%:3;':« E5; a.g.,%<"s:§ K5593" zifaa? E'-§ég;§':4 {ff:}zzs*§ "9?

S2 Q!' frzdazz? in z'.n£.e>;r'pra?€ {:5 Oi.L-'Fl faaz: 552:2. rules; sf ;3r0:?z2ciu:'e. and :25; dezrisism. Ehai, ::'!':e E-{igh Cfauri was {he °"pmpe.>r" C:';su.:'E mam: be mgardezi as zrarzzif ;:55z'.va>:, ?§K Réfiiziilifﬁi if-Ts a§s<> pi2?:.<?:€c§ am: iihe ;f'L2sr;ig;§1'3:;%':isi!f""{;£ ' SupI°€:rn€ €>:>u:"t': in {he Céifﬁff 05 KAMZALA gs K '35' '4 SA [AIR 2093 SC 31 '$4,? zmci s11§>::_i§' $.55 é.hai1, itjhif.p1*i§>*é':1§§i'<:e3<;s: 0f S€f(?'{Zi()1"i ii C?C ix: the a1;)§;}.i<:e:b§1%-:23',6?ifhégt p;'§i1k::v:1g::sici:é§ Uf res; jazdz"caE:0,§ Whicéia if Z1§'€' EippE§(":§;ib§_;{3'. "Q:«:¥5'£°'§211gj ifréai of $216 suit, whcssgz i:ri€e:i as an i.<:s:=3«ams;% ggf" ea1';; bye imiia :3:

p';feIim_im_a_:j; is.'-:«s':1_s:x ? ev "*;£ ;";'§S:£-}i,I§"Qii1§:§ééfhéif:"EEE"QEIESXEVEE" ta {his £88116: af Eawz §2xiémi_.:ie:tf§<§'n .<>4f'C§'E.:{%' qu:"2st_i<>m§ af faci: amé law ar{:3:'Vi:1VVc§§:u?§:§"? VV.P};:'<;:i§é§ §'i'§§Vé'i;EC€? 9:: 'She: 0bs<*:r*vai.éon ail: pz;1m--E5 Eiﬁéi 16 9f §_::{ig%:;;(-;:§;§ s:ub;:1is$i<>:"2 £32; ihat: mare faziii. that in a::s:1=a.f.@»r'i:1;§'a;'§~,is.:g£,.ée of Eew.-2 the: <;%;s:.:_am1§.;"221':%§{3:"2 af <:;§:..¢?:§3%.§s}:1&:'.3--{ <35 facé; "':3y__ '£;23a';é:1¥:::?,;<;=.§*«.»-*s;%$ gang? zméi :'°eE€vaI":%. Q?' {?€§:7E{El:,.:E~;4iE;*{f %'.<}E<2:;'§£§'iifE321§: t:_h<a=% is;;ss=sz::+::% 0? Rams' {:.a:mn<:»'£, $3': 23%} he %.;"i€::Ti ass -§T'giT:i:;§:::;}i.=?:_:E'::1.'.§.'I:?E.V§:i:,*.%-;'§'f?>'ié%E.5.E,.ig:§ E132" :%;;;z:"ai; {;f3?s;2r§:+;<.i§<t"i.i<sn. A §:Z.z1<%i:2§§ £32: é:EiSp5"w_i,{:<§ §.::-:.£és:;j:§,3A{:§ faitfi. a;a%:,:§*:3.§.z':g i'E'*aa«>:E, it ES E§€{.'f€$f5}E?.§°'}! __Té::}.":":::*§:::§:"::§ ~§§:":§€;.§:3gf sm *::.E"2§?§:;§:: {§;Z,$§}§,:é',::::{7§; <i;:.':_€;?:eséL.i:fm--:%e {:5 §::i{?%; 2-.mT;:;é:: 'V.__A€;::v:€j@§':-3'{:zz::;dE::;;~ ﬁ'}i? :'a~s<':{}_g>e;% (:2? 3:5: §}E'{.§i=".§E§1§{}§JE {sf Griier KEV "'§':;7i§§= "?;n;§zf;. "E122g::...aT:<>;'2i,e:x%: af {§§E;zL§S€f~E)n 11.='§"E§{fE"1i haés :"e:saz£.§:.€:€i in §E":=:3 ._ .§f3§§';",§'E'é;f--£'§ =:'~.;§.;{2.g.Ee jE,i{i§g§£ﬁ <:i:%{7Eé:"2i;':g €11} 2§:$$1.:.:m:: "Ei.E.IE"IiE§€I§i{f§l§{}3'} 63 1-'€{§E..EI{i zmt: in 22:33»-* way ;):"s%v::*:1t. ear: .i:-3:=su<;=: 3;?' ism: being; €<x21n':i2'1e{§ a p:'c:E'ir:'1:1'1a.ry :s:es.'--;ue:'=: far "aha: I'€TE§S()N: i:h:«;3;§: ﬁéiigii; @2123 c€)m{? £2": tzfrlér 'iFJE?i§,f €}3'1§j_£' 'v%.»'h€fﬁ for: 233':$w:éri_r1g iaaxr, it bézjztamerga ~:is%p::%z':c¥§3:1§: (1:21 iihe answer COH§€X'E. of an if-."a'1S.%I_§€:"? 0f i:a.:~.:; zxzhiciiiz and in *£:%1<-3 <:0:1i':>:x£: Of ézkae pEc%21{ii:1g$ 0f Efizs 'pzu*ti§:S ~:::jd' fdf :5: s21§'.§sfae:i;{}ry ci_isp5)&*.a£ sf $1.»:-2: srazii,-*"-- . E3*':;'{3r13;is;éé:'i<3::VEss i:.h21i: asmmlizngf thaéi {hares are i8s'U;é::€;_":>f' _':k2;2f1v'?:./=1.3";;2.:':d uniess an azngmsr to the is-3$'L,:i;%.«:1§ §7;1t,:%;;:be§r:§'§.: :.%:%%§%'_':1Ve:?:%s;s21_:f§,-F {HT ii' being the $ii:.uaEior1', WE:ér{t"----€:h'<-3 §§$§§L1€ff"..{}§7«§_E};*:§¢' {§€:1EZf1{}fj. be 2mssWe:'ed at :;:}_E ".=£-"i'i'hG%_}?;"'"2iﬁ&§§.?fg;{3§'iI}§fJ'P15:~.'VV'§SS1.§*.é "'{}f' fad.' {hare is £16 impedimﬁnt. §'§:>;§*'exzimi:*x.2ij*{4i:i:'z,.3;:%1e.s::..~§'€{;:.1es§: zfby i'.Z'};"i§1§.§ ihﬁ issue: 3% Raw 21$; 2: _p_reEi:éﬁr:.é'1:juii5s$2;:;_€¢.A"

?-f'§3;. ' "-E": 'i"z;3f'i:.%":a:%~:f. s:;1,z%;2::§Vi"£i'i'{%d by tihe §e21:":":m:i {;:{;:,fa::s;€§ ;€'0:r Eihgs :ag3p:'§%E:3i_;2::1_*é... €:r:"<3:1&€=:<'3:..:s5; ;=1sess--;z,::";':pi.%::n:1 &1ii"E€i {::":"<>E3;<i*:m.:~s .4 E'.'{} §:§%';_:;:% {§§4'E.§%35:3%'§Z§{'}§'E 222% iiézae 'ﬁféfi'§§"EE.§.E'E£Zi.E.":=£ §5:§:':?EiEéj',':§ 2}§§E';{"3E.2;§'f§.§i§.EE.§§ 3'5} .=., / /'/ 35, :1' €Xé117I.1i§'1§;?{i in {has §)3"es:3:3*'s: sgzﬁé. E}&:i1i1g; :15; '£155 w1";:'>:%,§"1e§' {he sauit is hit. 'E}y p§"'ii'£{7E§>§€ES af f'{;'?S'j2,£€i.i{.':£:E"'€€ zmd %,i1_a1: izm} E.£§"}&§'i?if{:',£' %:<3;i1¥:>;1?s:: q:.:e:¥~:f£';'<m E3e%11§:; {iepe-.é:.'}.<"ié:::':t: {kn '§§"1€:' }z.1€,i§r:1€:;:"1£: 0? " <i:<mr"{. azzd '{}}€',E'"€'. beizlg :10 §:;:<}p»:>;. :,'";<>r §"f,'%fi;",.I"E {.is;%:r1{>;';_:s'€,::g%.t:€§C:"~ifnaéf. tbs jzxciggzraexxéi is-5 rwé; C:<>:1<:7:§:.::+;'i_ve in i.<%:rr§1§; e::s_i'i}:3T€é«_;3t°é;%a2.:,§::1§2§:i'{3ij1_ msicier Se:<:t:ic>n 14 of the C'fc:3de:; _bec.21'%a;$€:= GE ?s::¥t9.a::% "(if théf €:x::epE.i<>n:<3 enL:me:rrat.e€i in a:i;1z1$e$~-----§--:3.§"€a:~{'--{i§ wf é§e::;£';i{3;:'§. 13 {If the C::»:ir3, the iS':§'Lis'3 E-_'-;h{}{,1iCiJ _7r:a:»"{*23e7" f:»)€é:i': *i;*':i"::.=.«:'3 oniy as 31 preEim§:1a:°y issue _ .:éq1«~§_ zims-::*«,xz<::r €10 th§.$ p:"e}i:11§1121ry issiwé $0 ':39: i;ri<3(i aizmg wﬁh 0:31:31' i:s=;$3:i<:§;' %::g' éixﬁféfiﬁﬁ? aim §:i.1e1*€f{>re:% tbs «:}rz;'§€r §1$;.id€ and Ehﬁ appE§{é3:?t.i<>m EiH€§'«ﬁJ€€}. 631;; _v V % "

Agxzcfﬁ"é:$:1"?,«:=::'2ﬁ<3:"::+; zzrggsci am b§é7E2a§'E' of {he app€:*i_£;2:'z§ ,"§i:*:v.,§%§;34g;»:E;:z'¥a:":§ E€z::":"':€%£i :%;£::':iz:';vz* <i%z.m.m.;e%E Ear fihéi §'§°'S§L V'AA..r:;3s5p{:s:'f:<§'&::i'é. ax-"§;:::'iLai§é_ §.%{%§1€fEEEi?§} iiijg ?;£.E"§§;€f $122.3: ﬁkéf z>:°{i¢/2" p.'«;iS._"§;:'i%€§ Esjg

-- _'fi¥;.~E"'.;€;'f_ '§.$z§..:*:1%:%¢:§' _S'1i.§:g:;E£»: z}'¥_."E.i:§§;€".' an éihés ;3:p§3EE<:2:€.§{::': {E}:-tci '%_:~}; €',E:e= '*«.j§é§a§éf§--%:.;i§:5°_ :.ééi_:<£<::* 2&9: ;:;:":>:zi%§~:>:':s; Q'? {}2'{£:;>,-.1' }i'E"'«%é' Eéziié BEE} ii??? "%%:2§§':;'::i;e?;. ha: i27:':"i'.<'n"°*é:;:éniésli :32" ;-.§..E§{>'w§:%ci :..'::':'£::Z} zimii 1Ef1§{T*,f§f-E éiﬁési 87 21§3;3Ei<.*.a:1i. ES ezbk"-2 ';",{} c'ié5:11'1_<3:"3ssE,z'ai'<:% thzat. E'.§"1:3 appIi(.?.at.§{}1'1 is fuﬂy £<:?:'12.1bI€:% W'ii'.hi\:1 {he f3€ff{}§3{'? af E §'iiS §}Z"{}'~.»-'§Si{}I'i; {E12-":.t. fihé.' s<:'?<}p:s:§'----f€3:' i:_ry'i;1;g an §.£*I§Sif1§i'. af E2325 as 2: gisrﬁiirzéézzzujg isgséua. i:=e;;....<_:::i:._Ij%§'.;::r1* s3xc€pt:§{m Ea {E19 m>rr:12>:E mie sf tr}/'E:'1g,;>; aﬂ Es;:%;u€:§§é-~..};.GgE:t'Eé&%:"; whether (:72? 12123: er' if facég 2111233'. Eifzzg? E{}.gg;is3iéii4ix:c%«_?;:§'tV.<:r:ii.--.§}§i'i";g vésrry ztiear ti} keep to iihté :tr1i§1i:z:1,;'ii1. si£.i;at.:<3.:;é:~._v€Jiif§éi:'&: "em issue: sf iaw {ism be fiE'§€£f 21$ fa. 33:31-i1:}§:';:«'1fyLA é$:%L:és'::v:.: .t';.«;%;i';':1,<.~3 (1? E216: zamerzdmezii, ii} §;h1's p:"<}if:Sf;_:j:i" -of 1Q'.?5 with €ff(i'(E'i, {mm i--2--T~Q??'}' .;s,r}1€,§:*ééi'ii.éé§r _'§:.E":§f%-_v:€;:;uj%'€r.:z3@§.1i. is that. m<:*:.w§t,hst:az1{i§.n§g 3:. :€.7i£iEi: '.V1';i2i:J1}3€§f?-§iiS'§}€L}S*??§ i35fbr1 21 p§'€:'l§;ET§iiE"i'c1'{"}' ésssue, ézhe <:{}Liri,::sh<--;i;_2£§d :iV€;:::é_§5;§';;.gr§E§..,.m{5.Q§.,;:§S mi ﬁnding an Em issmets e1z:d1.s:,:b--_f::'ié;-V €_2(§:'.V§3§ff§..4vI">1i'§§§H::¥.E_i.'€X€€p§i§€}£} ':6 iihé: zmrmai {me {if £?{§L§E' EI {>15 '§7ir-5%"§1f§Si;;i:";§r:é rec<3rd§ng fi:1di:<1g on 3%} §s3$u€$ £i3:'"iS§i_"i§._:__§ §:'é;"~%;§::é.Vs::§i.;_ wiiiigé 'Lhsé :s::<t{>;:<;=. {>5 ;<--3ub~:°u§e {2} {ja::x'?;<>i: 'E33_iZ5'3'€?:§1§_€3L3"§\;.5;f:3{§ :'§:*"e;r'.a:%_€::1:.vunc§€r$ﬁ:<}<}€E 23.2; a mwnrzai :r'e.2.§£€e éhs: {%>§%iff»:;%p»?f§{}£--E_V E*§§V":{i:«§..§§f"§"'~--bf? §s1':2*i<t*{.§}»* <?<>z1§5;%.1°L2g?:{i &1§'.'§{§ :;z::"s.§<-33$ this: $i.':,::21é,§<§:': '-ES §:4§;'é1{*E--..*;*;;EV':.i£7§'1 $<;;L:;11_':::iy gimli ;--:§}§;§§; e:,?e:w:*.:°<*:{§ bjgz '77_<:§a.:--s.:5{%»'fr:; if, éfﬁéfii' {as 'ghzé §§§Ei§1'E?..Eii§'1£%§)§:§§§':«gE €33" €::":_?§:'2;;; <2}? %:.§:.€: "és'::':.§§2 _§.:§§'§:?2V3E§'.é'f{T§ zgmg»-' Ezgaae' E13? §E'E{'E éémss 'ai3<;t-33;; 23:2 §E:';<:"::::a~': :53 fagiéjg . "'--~S§<3:EE;§{;:'§ Q5. "é;E;;i:" Avg; ami as}; €?'%,--="éZ;?3:'E aésiziaég' E'§€?*(?§§i}§.'§ E39 2;: " ~ §fj:,;2;:*.§§_:%;2?T:<\;{*::1¢§{'. <24?" i§_:é:<;é §<>":°a":i§;;'2'2 {f{}'E.11."3§. %;&%:§:':g :'2e::vf{. {"feZ}}71.{f§'LiE-§;i'i-'€L i{ if; is; hi: "--E"::§** 2.j;§*.;§:*"<}::";_;:%T ai 1236:: €'X{.'%;%'§}'§.§_0E"§E*§3§ <:E21'zJ:5e.~:€:s G? S{ff_"2§Z§{}§'} éii Ehsa 2352:" 88 d::7rr::>r:si;r2:i:e{i in :>zbs»s0iL.z'g.e:% iern1§su_ I:.h::ém:-"r is; no 5-.3<:*:{>p:-": at. 3.3} {Ear éiryizfxg ex-':33.1 am i.:=3s3v;€: {XE Eaws 21:3 2: §.3r:3Ef§.mi.,:"122.:°§; i&:«ss:sm3. ?6. E1': thisss b21{:kg,.§r:}L::3d§ Sri R2:.g%121_*<:a..z1 w<:mid A' in $0 §'e9=:;:' 21$ 't:.E1e _§ud§;§£'E1Erz'1'{i8 of f{}.r«c:ig§:'1 «:t{}1.;.r":.$ ihe przyvisaiarzss {>5 Se«::i:i<)n 1: mi iihé: sagas; '€1'*1.7.7E"€;*t E1§};€,-.V€;?ifV;é'{}__' 21tiE.:'23.<:%:€:i buiq. it {mi}; £1216: pma.ris_~iie:;1i ﬁf S€"3'i'ii£i"§§ﬁ" 33} which ifiifiléfé imézei"; play and ~:.§H::rei7:)_f€;s-- £:'n--€: §}'§if}'$V§p}€%E§' <3? resjudzicaia am: rmi; per 38 a€';.i;ra<;:§'.{:<:§ a;.':f:_<§ =%;:<c:~' ._be;: :'1é'a.:i£;¥ I,v--:1'}ppEi<:abEe far haiciing {hat 2?: §;3;_.;i%. _ %3.é£r:*i.:c§ $13' sf gr: $*é,5.:1'£.:,:tm"y pr<>&riS£{>z§s~L '2?' EE21bor§%?';i:ig.;: Vi:E}§5. '~.{%<:»:i£';e,:é';:§<>:":, SLibi'}1iESS3§£"§}"3. {if Sr}: R21§;§'1.:warfs., E£_>22,:§':1€d Vf€~;~E'iZ}?'iv{}E'A"Cf€§§;1%.:f1S€§, 3.5% that. whim S€:s::{i:m E1 {§P{j'--em:2:2./gﬁrizg-£:i;;§e$ cf f1é5';j:;di{:c2€"(z are net; EiEfE.f&'i{T3iI€r(,§. 5%?!" 36 if at .é:E§1__. if 3.i";g: "e:§;:;= 4V?<,:;:'é . béi 5»;?1{m»-*t1§ ii: iiélﬂ aénﬁy he in ':',e3'§:2&§ {Bf iéssa 5-i»sm%I'.%;'"gmiiv'::f€§:§_§{i;"§E":.e:"&%:f<}:*eé :~s~;L:fE3::';1ii: i:h2af:, §,3'"}.€;f §}3f'{}'E;'§.Si{}§1f-3 sf '7]E§€::*~§:£:§:1 1 E CFC é::°€;% sssmrii xmi: 2zi:i;m«:;tE',<:<§, .1 -22%. .7E'"§;:<=:-.._:"i§s::'§':§;'3.§:f§::i:>:1 sé;{}':.:g_%3§: 31%;} 326 ;"Z"ié;?:2'j§£';'f §3::é;:":-ws::%:'*: 2;: <:£}1:2"§: "_'~'w5£'§'§«ié?§'1 ;;;;<}2:s;?:':':€{,E %}§,.s' SE63. {Tf{:s<.'§€: 2:£'§':£§ 3, §%,>'r:%i§§z': c1?{3:3¥;'E; '-éséziéiiz £53 69 atarxzzazi; be 2?:1.:t.<>:};'1zﬁizrzzligr re-%21ci Era %:<> p:"€:*<..»*<3:n'é', %"}1€% :ssué'£: bei_mg;;f '§',Fi€3'd 01:1 21%} is:e$z,1es:; 272%' f1e1<.*':.$ zmzii E:-ma

178. In 5-3'L:p§3<):*:. {if {he SL:'b:11i&;s2:i.<3:'z iihé-i'é'. S*:":(7Eii€3'I":

§3§'i:";<?i;}Ité:':; :3? r€3_fu.dir:ra{'a gm: xmi: 21t,t:*a<:"i'.c:%d§ Szifi Eaikezz "L38 {:0 %;..':1e defini't.i{3:.1 ;s3e<7:§.§0n judgfmerat. as fe:m:'1'f""§?3éé:._ii0n 2;; «:i'e:'f§":1it'E<>':1% V {Ef EE::'r£:igr:: :::3u_:"§ in 811%sa::3:':;é'.}i_{3f:*1_A{;§V} :2: "2,-v{>u2«:§ azbmit that the jud§§1:1e11i....=9:£{;_'Eeingg East 23.

";;u<:i§;m€m rerziieifgési-_.:va1:rf%: by 'she Satie and in éijifizrg. waist) :10: cazztaining i'<3*2iS81":S§ ii": é:§:'$<?:n5,*s:~;§§0:: far ggrzizzting 21 dam':-:>e. gr <>rd<§i*; %é.<t;§;z§:*:%§i: E><%§*;~§;§5:%§.r:2eé as eiiher 21 jaxdgnaeni Grjeis 21 w§:,.;§(§§g::1e§"§5:. fﬁzldééfégi by .21 e::0?;.::°L wilich haii %;1r§€2:§ 21 §{§?:"§}::k§. lsszziii, ::::"2.e:§; %-;f;i§.{~§., £"€Z'{3{}Z'€f§€;?{§ §'Emi:§:§ggs; 2&5E§§<.:h '@J€3F€;? in §E:'aE§i,§C 3:"; ''§ '/4 §'*~£,2 mm: g:;>x,-»'e:';:%:e<i by Iahe };'}F{){3€%d¥.1I"€? %f'E'11?iS21§§i;?{i zmzrim' {ha Cutie; zgmd ii, i4E1::%r€::f"<)z*€ -E§L1b3'i}§.'fE'.i3{§ fax.' 21t,§§'21{:i:::1§; iihe ;3~:'<:a2:%s:;i<:::_';'iés----»<§f S€<:1:i<m IL 1.::':£<3.s+;5; ihe §EIzdiz1gs .21'§*e 1%'<3£::<}:f:ie{§ i§.~.§...'§':Si;,:.fi§3;.3::ﬁ:.V 'V ir2si.ii.u%.€d in a <:cmr'é: in thia ::<3'LmE;:'g.a bmdizlg _:1a}f;:{§_;i<: <3f"s;{1a,:?i f'i3*1<;i:iz1g$ betwe::*.:1 'aha same: pa.rt.1?ess§ as p;"{w;d"&:d'1':z'":.__:$e§.::§i'ei§§j:_ E1» is mat 21va.iE22.E3i::é.

SQ. E~§0wev€r, Sri Rag-§haE'f.£1:<},..%*..*{§'L;'§.(§ gjgciéér..gié$p§:_'a.e:: 1',_hat, Sﬁtfffiéélé 33 CPQ wlriich. ;3r<}v§<j%;er:2; f<1~r_.:?a..ﬁeitxrsgzéusivéhég, V' {be narmai emzrse but far thgs %;.i::e'mi:L wcmid n_€:ve,r':,.heEess €a:%.:}{:- S €é{:i§¢>n E} and if 21 §'m*<:ig':3 §:.:z{ .~£.:<f; 3% s:7<::z1c§:1ss'x-2:1 perhaps-L ':'.hzit Wauid §:1'«?€;:.,1n§rr; of 8<--:{:i:i<m H CFC €:.I%:¢:;",:1§A;f":i£:"<':. *i.;%ﬁ::§" heaiiérnei :1<_2{; Z£"'£TE§£§§3{.21§i1&ib§€. Argzm1%::::: £3 "aE1.:a=i, Af1£:::* h€:§_{%:£;'1gg 2: --S:":'E2;i'i:'l ass .rmi: m:£i:1i:z«2_i:m'01eg 'izhe :'e{§1.:i2;:,*:§é3si-1:3_:;"%: xi-mT;::E1.$255'ér>;2§Tn:E:':2i'EJis>;:: 3:5; ms: an {M2 ":;{}1E{':§ES5iZ{}E'i€3 af 7 E1§';£€:'.- §}§'{}V§§§i{}.E§'$ 2:3'? S:':%£:€:§<}:2 E E has? €31": "iiize '{.{2:,:<?i';1s;"£:{>n€: {)5 the ; -;;:';::é§i}=%i{}:[::'§:3? §€3{if§,§i§I§. E3 of Eéyg: C{}{§;€.', 8}. in s3upp<>:*§. sf i:.E*:r.-=: 5:1I:}mis$.i0:': ithait. E11319 g:>:'<3a:issi§>:_1.$ $3"

se<:t..i<):1 1. '3 Of i:E1<=;=. C;<}{i:':--: £5; not per" se a'€,'£,m:::€:d in 21 s3i;m.2::i£.:>:1 {if §{>:'€:ig;1 Judgmﬁzni ijeing rééiiééd élpéfiii, Sri. E{:22.r;'1<?{§ $€?I1§€,%'Y' {_';(}"L§.E§..S%3f'}. a_pp€2:r'img far i;%":€: §'E1"$§'.__ i*:::§:pé:¥_:':~::i£:nf;' E1215 pieiceci £"€}i€1£"i('?€ an *é'h&3 J£§{§§_'.{EI1€f§1?ﬁ;{")f i'.E_1'<-:=': «.fE«i«1p.:"1e5:1:9'--.C:}i:%'jj£ in Iihtit eiasa of VISWANA.TI:£AlV --..[§é'eei_pr2i}' zmféii.u"~--%fE'i'2a;'w'§z1g pa§*t;.ie:tu.Ear r€:§er<-znce in p£i§E1gFz'i§3§'££3. _"35"-a_and .-ii'; this Judgmﬁsmi. ii: is; s'L;bmit':.ted i.h'a§._{_'i':':'§:}:§;'<:.2;_$§. bf a.Judgme:1t 9f the foreigia izsauri. Com',-ELxsixg./*§:iéi%s--:§ <:E"ﬂféa fzéreigﬁg Jmdgmem, is ,g:':i_}?{.;§ia:21§'.é@V " au;§L§':': and "ah €1'I°€3f{§E'€i' 032%}; E13 :"£124.f£,%;:';"%:'s:: 2' 6V€°E":~,-' issuer: §:e21:9LE_31:f;§i;.V_fir:é1§E}:_ ':§é:«:'.i;c':§'s:'=.-d ?:;i7:':f€$re tihaié f:;::reigm c0::.§é;. is mm' ::~:};":<f;}'=;,*£éi'«;»*"s.iiii§:>eif{i-?é:'9:§'~.f:i%3€3 g3'é1:":'i£%$. The: CR'-3i,i21€:U::>:':

§}{}§.E1i6{i Gui: ivés-'*E"i'121tV2.:1 Emit, in we-'his:.*h §3I"iEEf3i§E€S sf r€é:j::d£cai:%a jgim-_j %;:} is E.%€fi(3§',§:y' e:">:'*: 311%? E:<}§.1<:§'3;&§§:<):1<;"--r of _ih<: E§E?;"i'3g§:E.3:{.Vi¥;}7?€-ii Ezziér-'~A§;§:V_2i: <:<>m§;e:%§',<«3:1<7e {)5 fasréiigéjrz 'E'r§bu::21E sEV%.:§.%;.,iI§'<§. ;«;i§L:é;€} é;:'é';sé%'a:§r' ?é:E";2%V"{5.i'5§.«:«z1i '{.<::se;%:, {ES {':<311*:;:re:t£>m:z1% E33; ¥:,§:a.€ Eazaw GE' €{3z?':§é -*§*é?§:§§:::*E:_ '£:§:1€: {.*:{}ur'i. fm":{:'é:%<}§":=$% zmd f:l3;E%{E in an L» i:":?%,€:§*:':;2.i;é<::;3'222i 5e:%'z;'2:;~:i': ;;é2i:'ze:V§ ifhéz :;uesi:i<:;§: E:::€:§:'1g; esﬁsesa Eézzkaéti iii: Eihifi ::';:§::1i<:%§E§: %i'E%§ é;.§_:€% ';j"}'§:',§"5%§{f§§'"§ {%>=:z:%<i::§%,:§':§;§ i::E§£;% ¥»Jé.§E 212:2; §:E'.:<: g:>m§}€r2*€;'§«:r5e; S SS V§;%§:é§:§z:r.'§§.;f:2?::'3; 3:2: 223%.

73 §"6S§}<)E"1€iE%E'1'§. §'123..s; piacréi-(ti §'e?ii_e;1..m%:.::% :31'; éhe J'1,:{§g,?;:";1m1i: ii:«£_ {ha Szipxvarzze: C<m'rI:; in thee, aitaser of 'RAMLESH 3 BESAE ctzzrmzzs 35. BMW VAEILAL MEHTA AND_. ' ~ m3p<>§i:ed in 2§68 {5} SCC 638, ._

83. §;}r21wé:'2g gut' $_pe<E_ifi<': a1"ii.éer:£'i<>r: 'i{.<_§*p:;§:;::é2gfr:1gj<h_Vé'E..3V JLi{i§_§HE€I§f,; 'aha-3 escape sf 5-3z;:b~«:"L::£<:: rulé 2 <:%fvA(;¥:;"(i*e--.%:'§'<i:'§'x;7 sf {he Cmrie Eazwing {::c>z:s§{§e:,r;;1§@}y , 22<.2'};":=i.'a_'1'é';.ié<'i__ <i<}2afr1"~AA21»§7:is*::' E:h€--:

Ziﬁléfidméizii. ef Ehéi yezxr "E§"?€$' 2:i:f:=§;:":'1<)i%;r. beirag f¥,'1§'"i,hfiI" ﬁ3}.;ff{_§%*€d dizaargz 2»:a._;;§._§§ ;.T:<:zé'.£::t€%;§. €i3£'iZ'I°}§€:£'v'_._" E'V.E1?%€I"'§ss;uc Ca.11;:3az_é€: be Eriéeti as 3; §L:§"€Eiii.EI1iif3g1%"§~'1:§_&$S"ti=:f_ '§',}Ei€§§A1§§1f'§ "f1'1;1:;r havgg: EEIE gggug gf gaw if" it ::1v{>Ev<2s%;v::';§;;€:e:£V'<§>:.;--:::§€.iA=i;:1«§a_ {;>f__§.z:w zmai; fé.,<:'::€~; *£'.h.:;"i'{: W0z.:Ec§ :'<35«_=;:;E'£: £1": 21 E<§;:2s;'éries:E i:'£;;:.E bf ?;;§':%;é* »$1 13';'L '=fE"E1€ﬁ._ "§E;.:%i 'vV£'§'1;1_E" %Ei'%§i"'VSLzpr<é::2€ Cam: :%*€;>§"{.m"2?:ii;€::4; {he §}E'"EI"iiii:§,§Z3:§?;f..§é1'i€§;"'{§A{>E¥§§'1._{$3. éihisaz a9;§3::s{:i. sf éhaé ::121.E:'£:<;?:z' in 'éhﬁ: :.:a;<5:: %§'_§%:--¢;§ Eszagérzﬂ is; é'i§EE§}§'"§éi$Ii.}:{€_";{i gmii %.§1e3"e:§%:>:*s;% ""é€.E:;%;%§i'§3%i'E.€a:§ E;'E';v£:T%.€i if £1316: é:%;s~s::2€ <3? Egms" i:':%;"£}Ex..ra::§§ {§€;i.:?::f':z*:§.:':aiém": zéf _ ":?§:i};;:;"::"§-., é:'1é--a::é:%§§;é1.é{;ms~.»; <3? :§';z{':E:s; :9;i§'1{iE Ezm-' ii; {";&'i'¥:E'1§'T£{':%'{'. Efm. %:;:"§<;:{'E_ as 2:: V E%_ug §f:i%§2:<? {f<>:.':.:f%: is:

74- Fbr 52.1.96}: §3E,'§.i"§3{}Ei-Eff, MI'. Ragghavzeiri, §e21r~:":eci s_~;;e;..":;1;:~:" <?()2.J;:1§-sci hziss 318:1: i.ake;.'1 11.53 ':..h:"=s:fn.:g}: 326:: «,fL4:€£g§::1":e.:<:~'::. g:>¥"'_ " Sup1'€*.H"1€: Cmzrt. ix: KIQNNA3 itas.-=;e> {s".4,L1pr;.:,E ii} .Vf_._Ef:.}::~--.. .§%§EI§j{>z>;_i:1g.._;""' <}b:;é:;'vat:i<):i2s 2-Ls: {'?(}E'"§f,E1i;E'1f§'.€f in pax.r2:grap21_:i8; é:a.j£: €3.I'1{,i Msygf f giage 592 as; LiI1.dE%_f':

",..Undc3r Grder £4 féuie 2 Co€ié:_Oj' Civif fﬁjaitfédzzije where issues E:>0:E'i. Qf {aw £1:vzVcE'*:gE"f?fE:i€>i arésé' {:12 {fie same suit, a.;'u::i Zhtié g?9:.;_f£~ is ff zfué t.>,:>i;'i"i«:>;z'z {Thai the 55:59, or par: £'f1e:'eQf'c7Q:£2';ﬁf be .E.:l:£sp<§::;ec§ L3,?" or: {he issues of {am Qrfgiy, ii' s.?1a E.£.V£;'°g_: ;§"zo'.é§'e €,;<;s+;;és firsi. an.c£,for :,im p_L:;"po-Se. zfgnczgg, ii AE'??:.Li';-'2;.)3cs"f'ie£, Vpogipane s;e:>i':€ieme:2'E Qf if; ' _i$s:§..€5::;_ Cf i:.'x':"i'::'E ajiw the issues sf} '":e,*%._w "-"E*£.:;z:;»e-,j-._§3é.»g%_r5;_ L"gé'if3FITEiF"é€Cl, The }L:résdfC:.'io?'z -v..Za':»-Egg; i:;.43u;£3SeQ,ff fawifv apari? fmm {he §SSE£€S ~70}: ;'1:i{:VEfi;;2'2.cig}i-: be'3s;:?>ée*:zrisétiﬁrzigg znfzere in {he apirzioiiz Qf'. £.§?,c>'a C%;}::r'i' "Vi'§2_£-_* «z,::f10Ee Sui: may 39¢ disposazéri 'q;'' 5:': ::Ei5e.Vi:svs.:ie>,s .Qf' {aw aioriae, buz {he {Jade Of 'vifivﬁi Pr0{i<.<.>TgE::.%1£a._ é::ozgjérss 2'20 ju.résdzic:,'ion upon {the <?Ch:~:r"f 55;; {';i;z; A-2:; Stiii an rmbcfsé issueg of {am V {z:'3.d ; ;'}:z;::.i, as-5 p_gféE£rz'2.i:z5:r'§; és;&:a.g.e:;9 Nomzaiiggk aié «-._A:'s:3v-:;é;3;*~; sjéa $516' su.ié'é;'§"a:-::::E5i be izéeaf; by {E26 Cami; rim': . ,§:;ag€.5« s§o,.e;?:§g353{?£aE§;; :.:2§z{é:'z i'h.53 {3;€c::;z'0r': rim {sages L_€':';{3_:':' Q;"«§{::,»::"gisgzéerzds 5:302': {E26 deatisziarz sf issmass ":§,i°V';Tf;;::?::'§" «:.;i_;3::__:.z§a:§z".' [email protected]§. in :2 §<3p~:§z1;:i.e{£ mzzé Q5" sifze $mE2?," " ' ,E%;; {§r2m;'i::':§:§ 2::.E:£'.::3:':E',iv;3:': 'E10 g}a¥2:a;g:"2::§:~h~ E 4 aizf {E163 :§:.z:§ggn;:%§2E; T ES}? 3 .;§.§§Sﬁ§""§ :':7;'.:ss& §$:.:p:"z.z§§ éiz-2T};j,s;§:;3§2..-*2':::':. w€T3:.:E<,§. s%;:.z.Ef}::"::§'é: i§':;.:§ 'i§<':,<% §3E;;:.§2'"s._€:i§"§? in ﬁx? :%z,:;§i $1/' z=-' "~%.§":§% Ea=é§;?:2.§£€.y {fs.'§' "ij:E'2f::i {}E"€§€EE" ﬁg': €;*:}~;fé3i"{fii§%§€3 9%" %.he:-*% a;;p§5:'E§.a:€ §:;£f%§séé_ii<::i.i<}.:'§'yzzagézi egg ii: ésg a. *4,-aT='z=rEE :ae%i:€:§a:;~%z°{.i<%:" in 2-:p§::e3.3;E s;;%'é'Z§; _;§?§52E::': §'%:z=:-? :'%<';:..:§"i ::':§z';s:;=a. 22:233. 2%,.{§§':'"2§§. 512:? i,E':.§=.= €i§§'§?€?§},§E?:'.E§i. '%»'T§£%":,%»'$ E12~:vi1":g :'2':ai:-_3<'3d 21 g:>E@z2 <7»:§'T £.'as;7:m.1_:"mr ﬁr: t..EN3 g;>Ee%a{i%1'1g$ 3.12:1 the w:'i%:t.e3.:1 e§i:.;1"£'.{-,*:111e-?.:T1i./<7>E>g§e«:t"iizéms <35 the first €i€?'f€;?I'1dE§.E'l.E. 2m::E;'-gb3,I W213; c>f'fi1§:1§g 21 §'€'§{}iE'£d€f'i" 2:m::i in {$19 wzxke af é;h§s:~:.§ E".E3§§1_fi;i mteéi fez' Eihcf <'r<m:'¥i '£10 ezsgamérzcz-.% t:E:§'-3 £§iS'§}1i?f.E.',{§ {;:.:<;ési,i.<§'n:% e:é§°=§°ei<::,f'$ aild umicstsess E".E"z.e::+;:: €;1.1€s§E:i01'1$ Qf fa=:?.E:s-: a :'<;;é z1.'E$'<:§ :?::'15+::»;é:7E'§:§CE;;féjiég reiiminaz I issue sf lam-= béi:i14_°f>~V.. im.?ém21"§:iEe:i'§T'_""*bc:i:1 3" Es ._ 1.. . _ . .

s2ati$i?ac:i:«::rE.i§g E:"i};'1§§°:'J»:-*€f'£'*fi"t{§, 'ih€3:;..iSS1.i.€,* E§'E7 .E...;{m4-*"i*:£.;*;A 'i:.h€?g3;*éés{%»2.é;:: ziasés: atannoi; be {mad as 2-1 pr:%ii:11i':iigi':}.> ffE'2§'<reE'(>r<2 1.:rged E.E12?:t {ha :?e::>u1"t, cizkesg §)E'(?§%§I1i}f121X'y' iSS%_iE;'. in terms; KEV "Raﬁ: 2§2EE%:>E {if {he Coda; xraés a.-wax}? £.%ar*r'&<:% in CEE5:§§"E1iS€:§ii"£§§ ifiiéf' {he gfrzyuxld if wguzt, czf ;§mri;€sdi<:*€.§<:~:2 ami i,E?e<:%'v<:ssj'{E€.:1i* %.~%j<3£:5€; n0i: {@2131 for" §E1Ef',{:"?.I"f§§"€3}T£{f.'€;?' «$5.3; :7:-.L§.At:s*~r:<t:::a€iv:*:'"s§a;:'%jm§$s:;é:>:T:3 SQ; E%;1;g;%1;3ra-?2::"a, Se.-%ar:1ﬁd $::%£':.£%i':'_1%f €':;7si.::';<%€:E._§1;:VS§a;a:2?:£:;;{:3 'urgsiééi Eihazéi 22$ iihésaz €i{".'2E,§;§"§Zi is-3; £%:>;:a:::i:':§'2":§,§ >2 /"' W'? .

'~:

ff'.

'\V <»»/ ea 76 'mi? G;";._}jg' <}:";.<:: "«:'§i?.°€.£-"' is; me C€3E'§'€{f?Ei Vim.»-* 2:'i:'§(i wazsid §}{}Eii'{. mat: in i..%"2ie3 :*e3:g;:1.3*{.€ 'i:h;1'é: Wiiih i.E':e': e';':21bEi:":g; }3I'{}'v'i$§{}I'3f:'§ of C§:r{§e:i*'Z*fEV Ruic 2 ef §;.§1{:'f Cixie whi<:h 2:33.63 as; ::.nd€ér,

2.

{E} {:3} Caurt tg pmrnsunce judgment §?'_'i '€T;«l.EE '~.

issues _ §\?o::'z,:::£.?':§:{mdmy :.i'za:': .51 case' ma:,_,; 5 be.

c£.ispo:«;e>oi of on :52 preél§fmi:zarg;V' Z?':é""

crzmrfj sfzaii, Séiféjéci :0 iE'1€*provés£0ri5: aGAj¥}SLL?ZI j mée (2% _§Ft3:'z0ur'2cs'-3_; udg r:1€;r2i' -53% Q3 is-;s:£a3s...V W?":e3re issues bog}: rggf" E&;§.,=:f' {;;:10,f'T'a§,%7jE:):?i.' arise in {he saingz sgéii", (:1. ?i1 ':;':*.Z3"i€-?_ C-0L:%='£'v,§s;'3I_{iépinéan z'i2,a.£' E"h.s3j 2:358 or: {lI:§(§}f; .?F}£I1?;:'.,('{'.g:§€53§;€CE{'??3.{1y be diSpG$€%_i. (fog; (:2? ié::_5;:5€ j§gf:_E£éi{}":31":£§j' {E mag; {Egg mi': €3.31:-zzfjirsf.-.v§{fvE.f~:.g:"isss:/:63.teéaties {:0 # {crgf .,£f§ji2;1§a£%é§5;2:i.:3:'f'£'fQ;f: qj"£"'§'2::'--:i0urz9 9:"

(2% ' .o:'§3;C£r*.é.é;% i§":e"';::<:ii: created by any irczuj ' ﬁar £.'%w,9 ""€.:f:2:é"--.Eéémg in forére, and far "2f.E1¢:::; p2;:rp;Q5:¢="' mag}, {F £31' Ehirzﬁcsx fig p9'5;fp{jsf1e $326 3eé€Eerz1{32*1i' 0f Ehe e3z'?':.er .¢V_§ss:4:.€5s;'1-:--:=:§:i£ £§.}'E;er {Eu}: a's§:ge> Ems; been A _5§«:%i":'--3:°m€ne7ci, arid 3252;; ﬁes}! :,:2§E,§'z {E36 " ..;s:;.iz"'-- in a;c::<3r{éar':.<:e :.s;:§ﬁ.§'2 me £5€{f'§S§8%"E _ _ & .¢., _ €}::€_' §§'§{,::' :'s;«;:.:.<2.

'77_§.:1{ii;%21i,§_;1g;{' §.E3§';;é:.: E11": 2: s§':2.221i;:?:;:'§ w§2{21"€3 azsshiie? fiiing .21 gaéé: é";§1%:> .1 *V§s:;:é::é.é::s==; ":}?<}'%:§Ez {sf §é:'£{?1§ﬁE§ 2:-s:":& £222.23? E-"i£"if.='§€ff in 312%? s§a2a.;=:'m% smié. 212335} %.:§:<;% {i%a:3%;.:.«é--"§; 9:? 2.112;: {}:§)§§'i§{§§'§ :':.E':2?Li: z'::;2zs§;s% :35" mg}; g::s.2:%.§"é:. §.%":€::f£%<,"s§ 3222}? E33 {.ii:.sp<):'~sa:-xi sf {>12 i§':~:5€s:,1€ «:>fiz;1w <:»zT:E§; if majg try the iSES'L.1.€';E firs«:s€, if than is-5:'sL1@ r€:§21t.€:S to 819 bar £10 {.218 Emit: ::?.:'€at€:d by 2'1§1}=f'..¥£r;1w fer '€:§::e>. 'é,;'.2:m;"~: Easting E1": §"qt;:°<;.:é? mad if 3:': me: {".}«'.Z&';§'"{",fi$&?.."{i%1: éI:§}'ff '. §fE§s{7:*e§.i<>nar"3r jur'§3<ii<:Ei<>n E.'i:it;=: E€:a.:"z1<3d Sirzgiﬁ «(,¥;1_.:;:_fg§: i.hié'~ <:<):;1§°t has dé:<:::§imse::§ {<3 izry {.1252 £33139: 21:3 9: _p:*::3i'::1ii':21.ry"§;4:s~§::£:{,_ ihCI"€*. is no E:§(3Gpt"; for i11i.c31"f€:r(%n(:e iI._1 'E:~§_1{*: €X€:3f_('.i:~,\.::§ Véi;i9';V:§€:%ii'é1?;.€i j:,:§'i_s&i€€:i<m anti i:I:1ere:'f{)r<:*. in-'{:;e§%rfs2z*e::2'<_:<;: "$5,: :*1'.::s;;t. w21r:'2:;:;€"s3.€§i 88, 3.'v'£1*, R21g§1.21va:";_, %%%.g:;{:1ci :e3;'Es5<:;~ draw Sus€e.ma_:"2«:%<3 Es} §":Es§j 3--*_=:-:f;ﬁ.:§A";%:':':V'.1'_A%."~;«:.ss{5:":a.:":::;f.§:e1§;:_'i'E'f;:é .§i:'é:§n1ir321ry isesue of law é1SSLiEI1§E";.§:§'V F93 judicam 0:"

c:c>.:':_$i.:"u<:%£..i'v<;%:__res__;@/st, be %.:"i<::{§ ass 2-: préaiimineziy issue {mi}: é§Spué.<:% emai if i.he'::ra=: are any di'§_;§y§:%.<3{%', i::1:2*GhrEd far' {E19 s:§%sp{;>s:;iE sf §',E'§;§'.t $1.3; §'E'i.€é*."§Ss$i,2€'€?§$;E§Efé{Z1fiZ bﬁ i',ri<-id ass as p:°<;*:§.i§z11?:1:£ry" i::.s:§:.w;% and if} §;u'§}§3a:'"sf;,A ' '::;§.f if§';éé'_'*-..S:§.Eami$si{m E'za$ ;:%i2::{:£::{§ rsééazlzia GEE {E29 '7 §;§€':t%;5s§<;:": £5'? "é:7§j:<§ ;';*':1:.:p:"<ém.ét €m..2r°"a'. E32 "i',§'§€% <::2:$€: <3? Aﬁﬁiffg C §}Z{"E%_} %.m§::E': €§.'§§§§§"§£1§_-§§;5?§ an §::21mg:j:°2a*;§3h_»2E {>5 ihis; 1;§%;.:'{§«§:§:"§E:::3':E.:

78

8Q. On the: E-'E3§":§ <;::<:%:€;%.i<m, Sri, Aciii:.§-'a§ §earz':::t<*i <?<>z.zms:1%E far €216: appﬁzilaixi. Elm; 21155:) p§a€:s;'%:i :*'9Ei.21.';'1{":e and an the p21z*agr;::pZr'; ':0 smbmiit E.}mE: V»»'hi;"fI"E '£"a::i'.s% 221% z:dmii;t':'3d "

Emi; giwi {ESQ ii} an isa-Em: in me; S€3ns3€ that .i§3S?.§€":S Qf f21<:'é:s_§ Whi¢.:iéi_1 are ::*€;%c;1:£r<?..§MA»V':E.§}"

§I1Cir::pc:ncier:£:iy, t:hs3;":a mt: i'.I*:.e r:a.:i:.': _«:>'f %.§1+<:: '5:.:,1§i3"1g,5;.-§'.:i: V WAJIEE <:21s<:=. {:'~3u_p:"a_} 21${:<)§2f,a§-;":x3-€i"-if:-»_§z1rag:*:1;:2E*£--21 sf PRASONY BAPS ciase {3:,1pr21j' *;:§I'":':<7'"s?3.V ii":;';adf;é'v.:*1s.V1.i:?:der":

"QE . Far {he gmpage {j;j"d;zi;§poéa;4(i'Z.f{;,§'f£.iie1:;:zi: an {$16 ﬂd§?'E§ii€d _"iTa;:f.s§ ;a::;§::c;;--sa;1~§&z; a:s}jz5.r1":Eie'"$z::£{ can be dispoged {:=jf'"Céjz.pr'€'€§mi'z::€£r§;. _£Ss;:ié3é=:,V. no §ar€'£C:;Ear° pracedzzre {,1-:a$»..:2'§q::ired. :T'?c:zL_'i:£{fVbif)o:§m2d by {he .E*{i,gh C0:..ar£. ~f';?,"?i:;:.>:%%j;.s: Q}:'fi.~;$'--.rde:f'XIV E€'z;;'Ea E ofZ"E1e Code Qf Civii Pm<:ed::z'£*;g<z_ €*ii)§§'..§75'<'¢,£?'E.{7;iir"E dispase smi: an preiirzziézary .£':Z-§SZx.é<?S;'}i'1;<?ii1§"i€*?" in deubi :10?' in d;£spu,E.9 '~..fiE25::. '*?'.'E1:"-3 ,.i§::,;z€3 af reg jI;i€Z{C€1ZQ and?z:0z'z5£:":a::"£i;;§3 res; "~;}u,di::aia as aEs;::} the mai:':--;j£'a?z":z.abéiiégg.. ihé Sui: (ram be a;z:ijud:'{:a§'.e& ~._A:.:g3e%;f~a;f;L_p;2Q£§I2':éziar"§g*«issues. Suﬁ}: issuésﬁ érzifmtig . ;.£2Ei:en j'2;:a:::,s:;"'<_2z'e. adméiéeci, grciéraariﬁgg :_<.;§2;o:.:;E5§ be ' _ ci'£3{:i£€§.>§%-{::s.;2r:_-5§"£--52'z{z':;a:*§; iSf§££€3$e 7?'_'é:E':s;=.. issauéf' €25 Eéaiéz $"E"::31;:'E{i i3:"{ii1'E&.%:"ﬁ}=-' E36 :'2::,>'z; {§€f{,":§(§§f€§ as , .§3§:'::§':::g:i';':w2:..zfj.; i.%9S:.:€:

./ /« .k\¥'_$-'gé ='t its dii-:»;<"::f<3~.i:E.0:§ in <>E'."i€i% W21}? 2m{.i :21'":E.§%s;:-5 t:ha;i: i$ _p:":>x.-*e.{i it: 35-23 imp0S:sib};e is "e;aE«:e the 'i="i€,'.££«3 f;;h:3 a::p;:>€:Eiat.€: C/(){,EE"JE. wiE§":<1:3{. in E1€ér'f7€::'e.

98. 0;: H113 asp€:{:'L of the qus:*>s:~;{ir:3n as zzris-:;iI1g.g in '?i}h_:"~t pf:"€S'€fn'. . éfélﬁt?' if p€:'E:;21;}ss:« E1136. Eeazrzzed Sizzggief J:}:{ig.§,e>. 7«As%?g<:2;.;:E'::E._ ijéwe exierctised 'the ciE:s::::*ef;i:::>:': as»; {G wheihex" ii:-..1::.i*:,!' éihe §S.;?2i:'<: Sf ji=.-f21w V as a preiirgzigsayy isesue is zmd fix"

any yreaswrz it is being E"2s;3§{}....£:?;( _i;:% to try éhaéi gggue pgfhapg g;-ﬁg Eiidﬁé Wm":

£:ha1i,. .B1;2€:,, :':§1;é§i::g nezfz. Chaser: is €;"3x;f:".§'C§§3i:E ?:'.;";_e:'- g._:§i;°:s_§cf: g:%:«;.;§'r;v:.§_::-->1*:.' 331 sf €h<;% i:e;:~:m¢3 «Sf 955 23; pE"§:'§§I}'§i§';Ei4i"§,f'§S--?§ﬁ#i<;?. E£':%. '€§§..ke:': {ha 1-riezw 'Q2211: {here is; 23 '$22.: :3? §;:._§z"§és§§§<:>1f,i<}z"§ 0:1 i:I*1;3 {§{}L£'§"i1 iii) irgr 316: §s:;s-ésue as; .3:

§}¥€.§i_::3i:}a§fy" Et.E":::'=. *:z:;:.Ew:€:* <3? '§,§1£: }"}'I.'{}'E;'§;'*3}:€§Y'E-E3 <3? :::E::m§sé3 Eb} {:2}? 5»a*:.2}'L'9;>=-.::*'::.»'{r:,A 2 5}? {'}:r{ia*::" KEV as? %;E";€ {f<>{§@ zmzé an ' ;=-32:33??? {§e3{.":Ei.:§::%:§ £1: s3:x2:_:azé:1€: §';%1<§: §.§:a§;:.:e anii *é;§:";€ a;};>éi<t:2.%,é:§<}:'2 ithsé :;:.ws;%:.i<t;:': éézaé; 21:'§:e;€-:::=; is; as EEEE §?i§'}§'Sv§.§€i£:1;AEi.§{Z§£'"; if s;%:'>::.:§§i; §'2a2z.:z€:;% Z:";e;"-rim €%}:'am_'1:Zm*:z§; V V "~--..:s;*§4§_§?;_§:"§ 3219: §:s{:%<;g:3§_-% s::::'i:" {f}:"<.§;:%:" iii"? §€a.:£é:% 2§:L2:§E':3§ €35 3:333 {is-;;*:::.%s:.a Q «'§ 81 §ié. GE <%<>1.:r"sse, 021 this; axspctaﬁ, Ee9:r;'":é3<:§ <:<:m:'1si:.:zf:éE cm b{3'::.h E5id€';'.E:':> héﬁ-7i?= .21<£c.%rs:se;se{i ;n'gLm"1z;>.:"1'£:'s'.~3 amd wéﬁltzé ii is; {:<>r'2t9§i:i¢<i :13"; be%1.:;.:if af the rcs»_;p<3z";.£§9z.1'§,ss ihgu", iiiw iSE§E§€ ::éa:'::";<::*~.I.~~.Ef§«;t,§r:£v%3:§; ' 23$ 22; §3'rs:%§£m.i:1e1rj; issue i:'I:1<3 §s+;;<_=sL:e: <3'? §£1VJ_HE_1'1_ 'if£.Ef'§i§'EEiE§;(5" 31.112-"€}iv€;=.s exan1in21'::§(>':3 <}f mizsiezegi q1,:es+;i.:?(:-{ms-; {}_§ﬂ1'f3.(.':ii(§5 ':::1_:1w:;£4E£3.vs;, i;1_ f the: serzstx an 2s.:":s3We,r 'z:~::« the isT--:s~;1,:g:r<§'f f1:1<:t:"i._s.-§a=*e1"3,7 :?;é;%:.::-=:vS:3a;r*3,}; £16 arrive 21%, 21 sat.isfa{t£1<)3fj; a1:f1ssWe:* ':'.%:'>~.._i:%2:'3. 1381;,-:e_ {§f 323%; the <;u€si:i:m £:::em:1::3'£: be 't.:'ie;td 2:55; _ ;': ';g::t:;Te'§»'irI:_i':i;::f:t;3r"' ~;¥5-35:u§: on {ha .2mi'.'h{>:°i.§y 0:" the cie.;c:§s§~{>;15;; 1f&:§i§:ai ..;.:}:§{)':ﬁ:V i:°éé?'<2i*:'e{§ to ab<_>v€:, sgubrrzisﬁian an ba*.§':;9_Zf5E{}§'.§;E?;=2'_::tfg3pq;2E.§:1':1é sis; ihzgi; ihe; £1§}p§i€f'cﬁi{}E.'E {iid {,';GEE'}€';'? w§.%.;h.i.:1 1:}; E9--a<;€i§%.<;p9 if i{i1¥;;r«-<s€§::i;z;1f§.<3ry" g3r<}¥§$§{;;':£~3 has--'mg {weird ':iz:> 31$ 2:1&f:%';;§"€,iic€§ £'T;-'2.{.*:i':.ss 21:':-{E isavézfa i re: -faré "Ea {he :7: 1 _ .V .' _ _ __ pea-:'i€;é::n:1 {Elf 121":ix_9:':'1;<§ {:=».%<;%:~2. ;a"z_ss_."';3,;&%f;l' '{,E§_e=: iSSu€S as {E'"€£E§}€3'»i t:i1€=.;r<~3 w'z;:s~; :19 iZ"i{;J;€§§3€jI.1{§€':I33:' is%s:=--;::.:€~: :3? '£°a;<:E. va,rh§<:h wag ;f:a>,<:a>::5s:-3a£°§Ej; its his :1-.%'1Sv;>-*§:%z*e€§g--. §'?@:3:\:%0zn§:«§e*:.i:1g§IE; 212'1.%%.:§:*c:%r H} iihszé igsaw {)5 Eziw and

6.-':2.-="€é:"»z %.:2:<i2i.i?":e:>:;'£1-_éf::;§§'i_=:";§ %'ea:._p§3<>:'€, §'§*z;:'2'1 £22': z~::':::sv;€:' 5):"; 21:1 iégszm 0?

L9 fa€;?:é <ié1.:=is:é§€i£:2 ':j£"';:¥*%'_'*--$a'}'::§é<:': :3? iégszm <3? Eermr, 2iE":<% '£s«~:.s:sa::€: 3:' 121?»? '=5é:%;°y :.:;€§ﬁ§ ;ms:§""--s§ai:V§:s§Z§1{:%::<3z§§j; :?%;2§.:T: be §°€f:i%'-{I?§.§~"€.'.€§ 3:'; iii}? {?E}§.S€:?'. zmd __:é§'. ss2E*':{_';:.;E{'§ '§":a:w:. 'zészié-%;': 'E.ria':<.§ g-':.;<g 23; §3:":;%§iz:':§:'§.;2.:*§' §:?%}E$"LE€ff. 3 '<3 {}r<i<:%:* §{AEi5.+R:.§E'c7_'ZZ§QZ{E}? sf '(fiat {":<>{§e, ii" *:.§":{é $i€::,ze1€:%{>:'2 ES gjmii 21::

' .;j:§f1 '§§a:>v€:':';_':s:§§§;§::":{§a:é:' '§§13l$ g>m%.:'§s_i«;§<}':'13 E1': ifizat Si?'i'§§i? é:§w;:?:% {he s 's%%.%.u:::'§i.é52*;L" mi: :3? Eéze §}:*a:z§$i<ms§ <12? {fig-u,:.%a=%EE3§ £1}? :=s;'u%3~ §.é:E:,3.':§ ;;:>§' m§.2": 21 {if {_§:"{§<::'" XE"? zgjﬁ" €§i:,><i%::, %;:§':e <:;:4:<*-:;%:?:%:>:": iizaé" 82

95. It is: 'Li-"E'.'H s:sé;r':i':Iezes1i.i<m am0m'1E:.;<:~; H'; {i€<i£.iz1§_:'3§g; iii) €;TiX€:'..£'{'?EE§€'? t:1r":€~ j:.z1f§s.~3€iic?§':i.<>:': V:c1'§"1€;?I'<1"T2??V75Ii::'§"'{§'"E'i €Xa:z1i:322ti<.>:2 {i::é<t§iz1§1':gg "§:<> €%:>s:€:§':'_:;1&"e::? ihé? £ii5§<::'é3:Ei{):1 i121§<.ing 2: vieéw (BER? way 01" $316 £33161" is§ Hi}? {3I'E€: giié €f}<Z€:'.}"'€?§S3€'3j"L11"'i${§i€T{.§;(3E1. r'¥i${"} 2:2. q:.:<:%s3i.i<:»§'1 i:0L:chsE:.{§rze of 21 e;iatm':.:)ry prébviésigzi = m}i_ amimniiss $9 2.: iieztiszizm re:m{iere::1 wif:.§i'<;_1.:':i,j2.1.z*iséi2ic;4§.::::i":.

98. in te'r'ms*s {Ff '£1/:i3.$i'.a'§u':.«:§«:?§;_ps'<)v'§s%.§(§i§'§; i.:"zé_€}é;" Order XIV Rule ZEEEFBE of 't,h¢§--._€{::;T'V"%<'-3__,. if §?21<:ii. _5it,t:$§'i.i{3':§*.{ {TOfI"i€;".'S squzzreiy w;;t§§m mg; 5-;::,-ope "a;f":.,'s*é;§§s .ss,:";3;1§i";'r,§f;'s32*;'._:_§é1'c3'§%'is5i;"::3§ {hen {he itgmré' .--. A -3- /N L ':3 'i:}:c:%----{§§s+;<::"€:§i.<;:'1 far i{.'.{':§{§iI1g 21% L} ; L83 $1'; :";€:Cs::é;%_5;<a3f;§W V %a:'E§.c=E':h:%r iihe 31$ss§u_@*<::1.::i"§3éf§,z:'§s::€i;.21:=; .21 _p'mi§z:1i2'223.2"j: éssgaze £31' 230:. E:ii_:§'21=:::::g '::,h_3§:: dﬁ-::<:r€3'§i£}.:'1_.xvii}. be e%Xé2::'<":%s~;:e£§ {)E'§.E}' wE":<3.:'z"3 €316 isgsue is: {Ema $§'€§»?.;a:°:%E},«',::T:{V:%i;»"'i::f€:i wiiE'12;§'; iihﬁ EEsi3€}§3€ Q? §';E:@ §}§°{}V§S§{}E'iE3 sf /_,.

°'s?efE';.EgE& 2&2? .:';s,},*si% {:<}:'.:seac§:ms:3 iiimi 'é'}*:e §i--:2'-:1*'r':{%€§ {:::3'z::':$@E fan"

'4"3£§'vE€:?'_§'iE?S§}€}'§'3;.§§ii"*Eff;;§l h22$ 2:<i{§ré;%>i-:s$<%<§ 22:°;g:.2::":<»:':'1E.$ ta {',{}I"i5£'.€§E{i ihafi: in §}::_.;<A _:§1:.-7% §%;>'r€;i§__:§a'3 ;?:.:§§gg:":::%:'1%£. is {f?{T}§'§{'.i§?E*§"E€ff{§$ E: E3; {7%§'.'£E:J 331E153:

§n:éf:,>2:§.%+;i.t:;':s§ <3? $aé§;%§;§:;:*: E3 6;? '::i"::3% {:{'}{.§i".' <22" E"_:2'x.> :.':;%§:;%%;:§§:":§;. 83 €X€I'{TiSi1":§§ {§i.:i-;c:rei;.i§3:"; xfzever 21..ri:s::%5e; amci ihé? m21t:E:-:=:r emis; wiiih *:'§121£..

9?. '§'h::é £;1,:es;i:i.<>:': mat: 2?i.I.'i$€:%E=T»' it: E:%":_i$ appsiai {i'XI:31"1'}'i§'E€fC§ E31 ih€:': bacikgrmxzxzi 0f smazrh. st:ai'.L:t,€f:ry . in E:h_e Eight, {if '£316 b§m§%:'1g mviaicm anti 3 )iVi.:';<.y {.333 ')rin<::i. ﬁes; {(3 "1he f:1§::t::'-2s éf *£«}1_éM presssm'. (T2186? and this: ssEi'.ua£",i0:'1, 98' in the pr<3$s:_a.t« %""c1?4i§€, £1316 §s§:.:;@..thé:j$..§sé E§{)L§§§hil 1:9 be §.r§<;*;c§ ass 21 preiimineiry N9 I proves iifaaf the Sléiii is §;3e:*;:*:54'e::i: }'%§;<;i';j;a&é.ca€:1. as ?'€C?O§}1E§§€d uzizaier E315 Cévﬁag £2 cf we Coda is 'E}{}'{', in d§:~3«§=.,:'{.€; '_ji'E":§:=.1"L*£€§"x::;:'{:,V..i{.?:1§§'*is§é;§:;% E55 vi2*E,z:ezE§y as £153» %7€§'}€ih€f $V«::f{a:é.§:"1:a:f:V <3???"Q:3§é:"E%3'"é%%:€r2:ci:{3ai in the §:>r€:8€:ni. f3;<t?;.sg and {TiK7?;i;§Ti"i;$3.§i{:7&i'E'sL?.£f:V§?s'~ii) éiiti 2: E3213' iii} {hi} irisii of {Em -5a:_,:it"? i%/ ;31'c»visi<>r1$ ':z:E'2i::E1 Ezifﬁ' z2:*E,i::2'2.1.<::£'e(E 3.115% ::'::{>%:, f..E'm S€3{3'E.i(}I'7z I E. of ihﬂf Csda'-.3 E3": i<3r.n2$ of {ha diE~§('?1.IS:E§i{3E'}E3 iii') £3253 E"»;)Lz2.':{i_ in [:}&1.fEi~T§5..E§ {}I{ fht': §1.:1€i;;'m£-:;'1€. <32?" 'é:ET:+3 S;.:g3re:%;:':e =:f«:'}z::'Ii. in 'the:

f?ISH7ANATIiAN £311 pra} .

SL1 prcsme: Ccmri. h.avim;}§ <>':3$<::rve<::?; Ehziésv S'¥';'?:{i"H_C}'iT1VVx__§ 'E. £:1<t<:rp<:rai:::s; {Ema b§*a:'1:%I'1 {}f p1'iz':s:,i_pi<:a2: :::€ "res &jT:.:.€:;Fir:;"i§;c1 é§3n€?i% £:X%:e:3:":{i{?:cE it xariiziiixz €e:::*E.air1 iimii:~i; "'a:«i;% ju{ig1%1e.:1%.5:;'i:r§' :§§<:::'<2§g§:'1 ::::m1"::s, if <:<}:11p<;%'t.<:m". in an i;i'{;£$:_r':123;i;i.i§:j:aE__AS'€:':3é:1:0 desixtiiie z;:i"1i3 dis;p:_:E.e, be':t.w<:e:z:z i:§1e-._;;>2a;1'{:;§~:%§$. I i.:§'zIi;:3_;:;_Q '<:b*::;¥:§%:'ve:.i that; the mée <3? resfadi.:75z'i:'::;;_23§:;p,:;;Vé:;;5% %::.§§i<::£i.i<:z1$ in a '%'<}r<3§gI_1 Stlif which £10 S<:*:<7:t§_o1:".§ £1 :>1?"éhe::

C066 Q1' CEEQEE.' n :1 E-i%E,1ﬁ. '¥'iFhi{f§§ have beg:-3:1 §iec::id£;*d p:j§.{>_:f €'<;4Ef1E'w;:':;«:~2<:,iVéi st;iibx€:§s£;i<>:1§ whé>:f.h<::1* GE' 2393: it Xi-721$ i§:::}ééi::i£,'e_;?.:ee:EL.. ':'§)L'i'»f3'§' f£.hs;é:"€§[{}';'"" '"%'E1:'s <3xp?;2:_:1a§im2 is mereiy {i{%a:'E'é:_:£1i:;;}§j; T.,_§,AI::zv:5é' '5:E:?{;§§?; ihzzr. €§€*€E§f§ii)E':$ cf i':h€=, ezftzmris £3": mm "'§3'rv?e:§;' 3:32.44 3:54;. '}::i:é..2:;{.ri..§":2631%. §,a'~s;i:e1E}§.E:e;E': iihgiii g.3:'<§p<ss~:;ii:ie;"; ' ' -»:§%%;3:.°:.§:§ :5 z~:;i'2:'e:;%ij.;", . 1' "_'~§{§{Z%: ' Ef'§§%;. {'}::<':e: <"={:;::':<%§=:{_E::%<:§ éizzﬁ: <.*{}:':§t%§a.:ss;é:;€;%:':é:%ssgs§ <3? §2:::*:3§g;j§'2_ V'*-;§:.'3sf§g§;:':z:"%:'2é'. is §}.2:§:°% <32? §:§':z.<?: §::::"é:'2:r:E§}§<';%;~e; £3? f'€{?$_§£.£{i§(?£Zé§I€: zizzzzé /1% wt. /4 ~ 2 In éézer v<:%r;y ;:2:;';:.§§;r;§p§i.;'~ i,E":é'~ T',_ %;%;?§'3.2:"£'. :.1Jz=::?,{§£%:3~§{§;::§§§ Wzié; iihaé qm::sssE'..£am as :9 issue iiéﬁiﬁﬁ %1;«;w{-3 "'%i:é;%a:%;':"'%':'i§r{§ E}1"€E§§"§"E§E"§£i.§'":Z %;:-;5e;:.:t?: :2? gm: 2'.-335:3 ﬁgs? Sa:§3:"<:::'1e;'-: §f§,_2}:13'}%'.§':z;;;' <:rg>§::a:=:<:§ §;.E2a-H ii; s<:_%<>':2§«:'§ §.'"E.2i'%-'i;?' '::}<:§%<::': iiiaéijé 223; 22 85 'Hm §}E'°iI'Ei'T§}_3E€fE:§ 9'? reg; _jz.:{£z}:7:iz:{i: E":e1vir1g bﬁfﬁii re(ti<>;',§§1i2it:<:i by f:':31i21.'§',1,E'5['.€? in t:'~%r:n:€~ <3? Setéfiajm E I 0:" {he Cade, {ﬁe i.{}i.£{7E'1f%§%.{}1'}Ef £15.31" ex;1::.n:1:221t:§{'m {}f€1§"'1€E {;%1€3:"-:?i5ii(E§': E55; 3.52.; {:0 wE":e§ $133 Eziw viz.,,. 313% isssuxié 2-3.53 i'r21zm::<f§ in ééiiza stzii: 22$ " gzgii, is hit. 13}; {E363 prixzatipiséa of mg 'E11167 é§{.',{}p€i of <?E.2m.&:»:£é¥%} mi' s:~:ub~s:eec3i&<3;.1 {2}V":;%' i{%'.1;2}<«%TV XIV' is aniy wziiih I'€;":f€i"€3§1{'f§3 :0 =.:.sv:'~,jVi:;g2'i;;:j:.4z*£:<:£»"£'37-- "_u}:3_:':«i:>\';"iﬂ§; a§<:;1s; Of S5-3c;?:'?{:i::>:': IE <)f?:.'Ef1€ Cade aa'1<§--.._£f:E%:-3:'?-'f%)1j:%.}év.e';t;"_i:?3._<:'ass€ of ibrwzigfrz j1:::igm1é%:1t,, the pz"§:?:--<::p»§_E%5 of, §fe.:sf-.4jti<;iw.£::c:.{"éz* Vzmcessairiiy is :ra:%E<eV.:3.:2i: and if E;::E'i€ at---.jg::>.:f{§p_g==:if_ is.3z::_:% €31? Eaw and cam be éiricd £3.55 21:. §,fI.*.'?£31~}:'i}';'E:V.i'1'~TP_2iI°§r':i:;:§ffs§_S¥.1'1{:§,'-._€§_§?=1' :3-E:ss§.%:£*w-3.d by {he Su_p';fen1§:% C<>u:*t in §}€§'3,"&iS EL in the am:-:;<-3: <;-E' ABDUL [si.:p§*e:§, vwrfz-s:*.§é:.._v "fas:'E¥;.s; are :~:;im'iEa:° ix} Tlhﬁ? f&1{i'{. $i%,:32:_i'.§<>n :18' ;:.:°@v;1iE::r:.gg; in @1229 presezzé: {sass}. 21:15? 22: '}"L£{'§§n§§'£3;&T!1iI, b€',§'.}?1§_;§»312...$1,:iE}€}§'§§.:§?""-€)§'}§}f far W§".B.&1'il ii': {i€.'{7i{§{*,S ami 233:1 far w'E:.3;;: Esaxggrai, E: <i;§:sé:'f°% §'§:§3f,,/A {§.i'l\?:§%.?:§\\§i;T1AV.T~§1'35ihéf {'.3f§3{f'. <2? ﬁﬁﬁifﬁ I " ». g§:*:éEim§~:ié.2-:T}«-* E-i'?'5, _g)E'1i'fHH1§I'"iE'1'i":s,--' i%:ur;? zzmi ﬁ'E{,'. 2-:p'pr3.21..£ a;:jz;1§.r":s~'sE. 1316:? {}r:i&.>.f:' for '{'..I"j._,-'§I'I§;f the issue of re2:<;j:.zr:fi(:ai.(1 gr (j%(1iE'}.E%§i'1"1,§(i:€,iE?'€ res jz.azi:'.<fczz:2 :2'5i:'~--; £3; p:'e1§z11mz1r),.-* isssi.2<;=:=. is: an i&;:=,s:.1z:=, Ehéii, s*,2?:..:1 7:39 t:zi1i.e<r.:'i;' » .::;s?'V;~ p1"<:*§imi§:a:'y i§.€«3§_%:.1€3r., it is; <.m§j.;' an ;:m£.E1<3:"ii;j; fan" EI§'33€_":_§}:i§}§€§S§ii{?=f§* éifld 21$ €f{):'1'i)€;"tE1(T1f3{i by Sri A.<ii{.}-*2: S<):'1{iZ-fix; E_e{3;;<;':é5:§i '1é§<:»2,_u*;:=;y;;a§_j f€>;;f €316: appelizmt. éhaﬁ, £1119: :53:-sue: csf re$ j:1a:i.icta--:'c:even of; -E7;L?:.V,1".',.1'}L("}i:"1fE'.:.}V-3" {if this ci€:«::1?,€a;'<7:.1te @121 be t.:"iz::-iii 2:1-"';:r§*':i--in?*:-Exjgziirjgz zmd £3 {i€éI'i:1i%z:?i3;' rm': an a'uE:h€3z*i{:jg' f<iVr_ 1h'e3..§:i:snt:g;%_t1.tj'i<§:i--.u:"g<:d by Sri Ragilavazi, Ie3.m,ed_ .r';;~:i_e::>r §:<?<};::§s:;c%E.4vAéI:§i§§':§%2i:*%£:1':g for the fi}:S~5t r€:sp€§nd@m;. £;.h.a£::' 'ii; .2.u::;.<_:.a ;:i'?L,«EE:§;§<j§§'.if2}~*..£03' ttzoﬁi ET.:"y§:';g§; 21$ .5: pre.Eim:i:121 ;'-s;is:':;.: :3: _ §Z§if1§§? 'é=§;iE';'s3:;€3.,'f%2<:i.&; 'é£?§%':1d1ni§:§:ed e":;<:.. 21:15? net: iéiih e,a"v5i;<§e;:* ca:£*2.':f";;{jf;_ be .&}.{?{,{{":';'}fé;%{§ Q ':Q_fL '£15772 3 pi'i;':;<:§pi8 sf £2239;-' the (3215:-xi :*i3Ei:*::{§ :;.:§}{;m and :"s;éfe:*:'%=:<i'«., £1'; _V £'€$§'}:3X{f£€f';-, is an a'ut§'z<>:'E%.y 'E0? E':0Ea:§;i§'";§;; timi: 22 ':1-=;t.'::':E: 213:: {f§'£,§€E%§l§{}§'15§ §'§',§Ei§1iI7:§§ 'i'I{} éim guiii; 7l_b<~;>:i§--';;;T §'3.2iz5:":a%£§"'-- £35?' '£63 jz,:.<'£i::z1:€.€: 532:": $35: i':*§{;*r.e:i as 2: §}:*:%i§nzi:'2a§*}-* ; Aé.,i*ié*:_ ?;':.:3."E.i'2-:35' q::€s§i:§{;1'1 as ta xi-*E:§<%£:h:'%:' iI§1i"T* f;;3.::"is éiféf "~:2f§{}3i§7:"§'i?:4""i1{'§€§ $2" ?.'.'§.{}'€', .355 gm ;::%,;g}::;.=:.:%§ 53:" iii§E.3€:':$E:§{'}§'1 25:55 ﬁx} W:§'7:éiffl.§"é€3f§' ii: V"-...§:'z€y?z5,2h:§%s; €;}%:§'":a::" s:.§§s; mzié §z:s:""€:§~;.; :5:E'§§{:_%';'::; i?€}f.'E-:'*§'§i'§.§.§§€'.? :§&:;s:::..:{: zzzzéii p;::*'E,§:;::§:-,~ §i'<.>:r .§§Ti{ii-- ;2:.mfi:;:e':E <1}? ':.E':<: '=Ji',E"€§§{3§'. by §:h%;: §z,;:.:"}* 2<;.:'1{§ Siiiifh " .r:<;>é: §é:a.:r.;3 22<%<.::;:§:;:.ea§ §'?;{'3E"§"£".1. fig? :'€§2{iz'é§°i§1§g §z;:dg§.:'13¢'::2i:', by €r;:r3:s:°%:::§ " --§T§": ? §.r;':<:ié2:s 9:': ;a:p§}§}?é:_':g § §'Ei?: E:<.§E:{:.%1:=e:i:{:}:n<: {sf aizﬁiiii ';;:§:%;§g%::é:?%':é$. }"{,'i1".'E{.§f;T'§°{?'d 'irgjg e:'%{::m"%:<5; in Ezéiéiza E.'§"::€: §.%_::":::r§;§:': A§2,.z{§;:;.§2':e;':§: 88 {ZEEYIEES of Se3<t'{.i0n "£4 <2? '§§"1E"i Ce:3ds:. i:§1.<3r€ '{3é:2i:1;,§ 23 :n2:tx1daie:--r {EEK}. thiié <:<>z.::'§.s ii} {irzm-I 21 pre$a.11.1':;}i..i{):'1 in f€:1\!{)¥;.Ef' Sf iihazfj1.1<ig;'i1*z::1T; E}:-*:im;;_§ rzm §'.§3§"f 5.-3's{.I;¥E'. §'1e1_§r§mg bﬁﬁﬁ ;>r<;;':1:}1.12'"z.<é<;2€i E33; aézgmpetemg. juri--s:dé<:i;i{>m., L£§'}§€:':'f.=',~'i-f:'% %;'.he a:{>:':i.r2«::°y ¥:')L:~":VV §'€(f{}i"C§ emdi iilim e_:a:issi,e=n<:«:% sf the ever} 32:": 15,:-3:.rrns af '£119 plezzciirzggss éiapgfr t.E;§é*-- $1921 £'"c):V1.':9V:.:\:§ " '? :3? the r::=:§0i11d€33 it: is; {:0:1E.s:-mzieci'u{"%;.;§t4 31¢? not CO1".L{3h,ESi"\.»'f;':., <;~nE3; for th&:;«. 1"e.;.'1-s3»::a:'::':i._E"a.1Es; w;i.th§:'1 131:3 €;'X{f€'pi'.i0E]S as $§.at.:§n§ §::§..§€3te:§€,i{}:"§_"VE;?s._i§f ':h€' (Swizz? and also in E.h:~.* walks? of 'zhe pg-irzis 4%? § zméi 6 ft} (tc;=11*£.:::1zji *;I:12;'i'."§:'E":<:7 é:'";§:g{ig,»§3':1e%z;i: in 'éhgr eye of iauz 21$ it §.;;'S xE'£'{3"?.§7'€?€Ti(}§§}'}iZ€i{i by i;hé=: Q<3z::3"{:s in Endiaa 21$ L];i:§t§§.3%f{1€?:§"i'§I A€=:._%iS;" ':3':-:r1£i€:°e{i am. ?;:he: basis of 3; ffi_§§{i.§«:";§.<_{ ai53;i'i.t.:g::3 by 21 ;?:3':'"y '*:»"{"«::'€ii<:t: am qa.:::%:+;§;§<>11:~§ <3?' §:'£i€:t', am} '§'£7'§'&§V{}'§t,i'V§: Va:%'=::§"§'=:'§i:s::iM:.::3$éi.:1gf E;?:_&:*: {i€~:1;:ai§.$ (sf ﬂag:-*: €'3.'§----'i{i:1':§'}{§€f 36%: in E3}?

e§.<:<:2a§ig:%{i:;--_§":§é :és:'*§is'§:§.i:épi.£:'::1 in §"2w{::z;,zr {if "Kim? %k>:°{:::;1§§:": §1.E{§§.§§'i"§€;?§'1§, ﬂ_;;=.:§*§.:;:~';Vi::'z§j.§j ; : ':'§§j£§:"§':V:;' ;"§§é€;?:%:§<:>:"; 34 {}.f %:}':::% {3<>€:§€:: gm? sssiaezag :i}§1{Z€' Eha-3 'T§;";';§£§.fé;:1a%:§_i: is; gin' :§v::*:~d, ii; 2mE::>r::2ii:i<:2:.EEy E3e:?<}m§:3g %;'3'i«"i"?.'ii'E in ?§.%;'.'I§".§"§"§-57?; :12? E;E':_§;: g:3a:"§;%::e;::§:';;>%.§<:;§': e::'"::f§§;;§g§e{§ a.:__:*:§:§<%.:f $€i?f{';§",§{}E'E E 4% :2? éiiéés {ffs:;>{:E<% 2-z:";::§ &;a:.:<':iE2 §}E'é;';*E~;¥;4é.ETEE§}§li{}§"§: €;@§_:': 89 next: 3. vaiaigi j1.::lg;'r:1ez?;_i. :~;mr:1 %,§':e1*é:fk>re§ ﬁ.2rt:h:3:'r guess?-:.t..im:r; ass ix: w'E1€:ﬁ'1€:r it 1:; Vﬁﬂid <33' <;>i:E.":e:'s,x.r§sgz;% in i_'hs~ wazké? <1? "i:-hjis; Cf}I"§?,ff'E7£§i{}I1 b{'iiE1§; <§e§}em'§e{i 23:': €;ha=> q_z.2es-:i.i<?:z'; of f21<:E':.. ~ {sf 221.1%? ::"&§22_'i..'£Z:?1g;:' Eli} 'ﬁle s;z::§1i 'b<3:;.:3§§ E3z.z1"r€=€§ by res; hjudicaza is, in f£{{?f;, {i€?§3t';'fI'E{i€?d 23:21"; '::§e:,§;ii'<::eAr§1.: aissa, i.%1<:s i--:-353315 <:arm:)E' be tried 213;: preiL::1'i:1:1.ry j§s.~*.':".--::,-get', 1i":<3':; 21 szzbnxiss-si(>:: whkrh {merits E1{?{?€}'"3ﬁIE1{i€§Ffxii)? :11<$r¢-..€:h;§m Oiléif F'E3E1S0§."l .

1&8" E'irs<s':,§:«;; ;1s«3:2;1;V:i§:'*si:/::fV'°ijE;a£;.f€:::*'VV{}e§%€§i§':g§"axe: is v;'§*1£>i.E2<3;:" ihe Suit. :3 emci Whigth E8 the:

a._::m2:?; 2ar;.}é%§§§' L?51:%$_ fEzsajiiﬁ'f§:fm/::j,(§ in ﬁns: {fE3:.E§€, it": 'is: *1':

depeizéixégg zmzi t.h_2;u': 'i>«::§;:1_g_>;

c;§_:1i:t§'L2_:<§§xzg€-9émd ii; at this: aéiairza E3<::f(::re {E19 zéeurig, rziiaé ?3€%;%.«1t?:g§ 2.%;E';_.é;:'z'"-3 {>€E{f§? £:xi:§t&:':<:€% {>5 "the fééfﬁigifi j;1<ig;§§11€s:2't: 51$ 4- :*ebut:t.aE3Ie 531.113,.-* cm 21:13' {".)E'1€';? sf '€:?1€: c%,>;.<:<:-pt:i<_">r:21§ <:}aus€:$ e:*::1:m:érz-:Ii.<-Ezi in {?iE£i13.€:§€E§ {ea} {.0 {f} of Se<:i".i<:>:1 ':3 (if SE1:-3 C<.)£1éi;"f}1c=: €:xis:a§<--éz:<7:% <3? fi}E'E§i§_§j§"1 }u<ig_g_§I1"1<;*ni: beirzgg 'ﬂiiﬁii at 221% in {3;is5;}'1.:1::'s:.g;:1"' the 33:13:-.;em»:, <*::'»;:s<:a and in §"2?z.<ét. 3.<iznii§.§.edEy *é.'§"§;:.'§ vf:::é:'€§_ig;1": _}v.dgm€§':i. b€§ng.,§ at ilfze: iz'1ée;%,2mc?e <3? %:Z::': é pEéii:';i.i'£ff ii:61--.£1;.V¥:'<: :3;:é§iiV1;:V, the pre$1.zmpt§{>:': under SeC.t.im'1 14$ fa1:i.<>mAati.:2a113:,zi.:"i:;3éS} E31 {he wake af this posimm, La: ,~E;E:s:"-£3:§<é::;t;e:m:é' '-:?:f..vv'4f%;reig_;::: jizdgmezﬁ, bé-:=<é.w£3e:=.n the gauze ;'3é;*tie3:;-3., §::':d 5:1. vihé:-very qL:es:«:ii.i012 of 1-«-'aI;iciity sf E',If}.€ WEE-E&"$~<>1,:g§§:€: _i:€:1f;be:._Ap§*'§;pcé::z:_ieie€£ b<3€<:z'r<3 31:3 CKEEIEE in 32238 :3_2:::?.'€" a.r1ﬂ:%'»'bi5:§.;'1g §"§.{}t', in éiisspzﬁsz and being; .1153.

"wi'§_}1§n 331:3 ;é§;x,c:E£*:.'_ of <';+:x:<:'<-?.pt:i{>ns; in {7§au.S@:*s {a} "LG if} in S§%§j{,i{}I"£ "E3 ':>f:Vi~_§1é=.§i:5z3 and {EVE}? f:1.::--:1'<: the piaiméff i%§%'i_é:g:3.;_ §}:'e:%_é:n1:;Q§_'3<,% f:"®m '_i':w€3E<:i§3;;; <:Ee"»:;1ss@«a zmci. i:n§:E:€:1* ';:*€:*iat{3d {:Ea..:1i':2:_x;:%s's V1'i_zi'*é.'?§é:%._&§$.2:?§V§:;i%: "gsf €319: piezi i:ha;t: 'i'E.':£»: pEa.E:1'£.:r§E":f hi1':ES€§f haii "'g:r:;r%: f<2:°§:,AE'2__u.i:3 hiss ;:':;;;;§3E§<:é?a§':§{31': Ea §:ar<>b225::{:"r ':'."'é1§-3 WEE :':{fsf£; §}§'<:>c§u_<:::§::§ ~e:§f<m;:*§i &?;£"i{§;v.V_§i'i;}"£' E32'-:;'z.;2m<i:z-* {}f k~>.'§:%:€:"s.=; i;,sési:21m£;%2':%,a.r5; '§3::§<>i"e ihﬁ "'§"{7;éf£%§g;':i;'s::z>;.:':"i.. arJ%.':e:%§"s: ifhzsr :L:;:s§;:%§§::a'::§<}n :z1€:z2E4§<}z§a:§ :E'::::§.: V. {:"{}:.:.§'§' Ems j:§:'§$::§.:{i*§.£.:3z';: {E%""£{§ aéerégzage ?3€*<:€:a.:.$§? {'fé?{?fé£j?£T,§£?§'§.El z.s:§'::;é §"2<2,::,§ iT§£.£.{§§ <.?z'.:'z'.za¢r':.s;§'::',g:2, :,.:2§:;2: 91 ::i.0r'z'::'§.?iZ:3d in and i'z.a€i cz.fz1>c€e:i pigzrre of r'e5;i::fe:'2{:e in, {his <?0:.:.z2E"z'g; an fizz? dzrzze q_f"hzL<; de;i2£.f'L $851. if: is; 333:: 110:'. in e:i§si~:;mi:t? than E:2€:f2::sre:% {:h::% f<3;*e:§;;':':"€%.:}z.1;'ii.,_ i%1€ v€er::iéa:%_ afihcgf jury on <;m:s:.:::m Ni} 1 *2-*:£;>:t, il.£.3£%'f§?"iiij}'T§?'i':.1 * p?'"t';'§3{}I'1d€i"€£Z'I(T'E? af€vz'd€:'tc::? ihai 5228 :,:.1§iZ;:;::?cz.5 »€1",*<é';'£?i:i i.:c";',"£L§:'Li}iE}I.. €ZH ., {he j7G:"maE££.z'e>:-; is n'2C:k'(3 ii" ialqfizi v a§i;7E ' zgfiéi' ;r;2'.;itiVV':.i2Gs anszsjered in 5216 m*3ga§,£z;e' zmd {ﬁzz} 'Eh:-i?'§:*:.s§f.§i.:<:€.i:}:}$ §_.f§;'i:'€§1 by the jucigge in the jtxzgx,.wh;;t§12.j_a:*é:'::f ; ;§:;n_€ie:": Z, T316 wiéﬁ m:;:.s_-3:" be:.ér:";::if':ii%:g;'=,_

2. 'H16 €e:~:E':cz,':é§:r*' rn:£3£. ?Z:%¥é §}8._ ;;m:«~:«;= of age or aides:

3. 4§zf1E'\.=':¥"5 *m:Vs.s':. .§e;"soé*'z'::z§§g s»::"g,}:'2. {he z.a,*é§7;

43, TEX: "z,;.:z'E£ 'z?'::.':V'3.é '§:?é"'~:3{'i.«:?§E'€d 33;; {we 0:' ;2*2:3r'e <:rz3:i,:'E9E.5? zz:>£:.:1s?'ssé's:»Lkébave Em'; age 53;" E4 ggéazrss';-«.V:.:>'§'z0 Qacfflfs s:.;:§3sz;:r£b(3 {has-35:" 3'*:{;m"z€ is 532513 'mg; in i.%2*:éi;°"Gs;.:,:§':.'§1arzéwr£:£:":g z';":z E3352 pr'€5::ez'?.c5 ' '%5j_".,T£E2.:%%_ §es§:::£'{>vsz---«"'}?:{5:"e is no rea:gu£3"e:3'2€3'2é {$25.3 §'§:€: :,z?i§ir2;g%.s:sé3;<; Sigrz in §2a:,CE"z 9i"f1er's; pz'e5£2:2::e, ii; :Es;'VA:::=§: f£;,_%";.é%' §<f;§'.§;};";::: ;;1z'"3ssi.£-*@:' €13 {;:.:€:§E.£::§;': Ni} 3% '¥'«.«"EZ.i{7§"i§ an '».::*:{>€:;i{:3;': 'Egg p;;._;4€..;£ £6? §}i"{}"£'}i}E.EEE{Tf€;'fE1'1€?£Ti§i :3? h§ucEgg:m*::'":§5 '::§1:*:~. _ ;.§;1{i§,§:f2:{:=:;':%[ 1:»-*.:j:;<§éA§}§'<3':':<::,:;'1{:_:@:§ :.1§1<§a=>::': 92

55253;: Na :3:§9.§2§m4a2 ESTEE TE ff)?' £5.

8:;

MA§§Gf*J§~E;%iZ-£4} D. N1§§13:%§"}L?iE, gi EECEASEE3 FINAL Jimézimwzt' £22; THE §~'§EGBAT§"E C€}{§§%'.f' s*s§UM8E;€ O2'%J'E{£§ Q5?'-'V V"

& gggmgza {fO{,?Z's£'I"%', % 3313*' REMEMBERES :--;+:,ja=:2..%on§ :21; 25%a%«a%&a,g Qf Jwza 123$}? qfier the casé"»:;}::g3V mag ._$é£ fag';

trial with due and pmpras" rzoéizﬁe -Ezé'-aié-»;2ar£i€5%,i'*-éfaés case was caiied jbf-..__f:*§a£.--'_ "~._:_2'*»€,:::Ea feiﬁaizged amsmd MB. BaZakri3%;f:€:':s7' ;"appE-fcagiian far' pmbate af {fag purpﬁrzed' . "§9§;%'}E£'£' and "I"es§arnem'; eff :";f'asja;;z,;';:1::.,._"aimed Vziiprii E5;

29%" ["Pu%f;30:3z'ié;(,£ _ "W2T§.£"}, E?rfo7p¢«'mé:1:, zzxm.

Baiaﬁcrisfzniig {»T'Bo"zE::;§;:a1§E1;f[§:;";?-- §,§."%p7e.ar€d pergaraaiiy and by and -Vfjfw-'m:';:gE1 his.aE'§:,s«r:f:ég recsrﬁ, Rag; U1.

Biartii, a,g'é;:f:,az,éf'§-258d.' h})'""7e:ir':"i%*£a£, Canieg €£fi!?.§_. ArC£Z§1i:'.fV£if€§§;£{E':'V<%.E§:is.?€z;:?§é3"€:é,f'-;3&'5 persanaiig and ﬁg; and zzegsmgsa '§1:a€,'?"«§:3;E',12fOi'é*f;§é*§}ff$ _.Qf recard, James H, Siiéweii am. Ge';3z"g"::i7; .A§dg?r2.$, ma {ff Andrews Kz:rz';h_LLP§ 1:;-nﬁ G.§'fE§--TiO:':;_'I$ei'd ready jbr irzai' .--,,¢"f:§;EE€E AFf'E?E%;""Q; paneé 95 six §,::,£g,; quaégifieei ,_a?er;§a::$ §,::}=;.?§°é.*..VS€§€C§€& ané swam in as the Jury 3*: €:3_":€',.§ Crzgis-5%', 'A '?Ef§§"{,§;{.;i§E"§§R, {he p<::2"E'ie§ Efzraugh é'§'z€€:"

a::'9:*'r2e§,3 "Stacie ffzeir opening Siaéememis, a,n&

-.??"Gp0?':z:82'_'"i£ ﬁaiafcrisfzna §%'"€S€?'§f€E'§ his ez3zZ<:2§€r:Ce. ,§;"£er 5B€:€a§:?i3§'m::: :'*e$ied5 hiﬁ sage; Caniiesiani ;::2;é;?:: fxfaragan E3233: §§"&*$e2;:é'€é fag?' €::§"§€§"%€€, éixzsiaﬁing an Sasig 53, 2Q§?. §V?'?.€§"€%,£§G3'E, éhe _.§_z§.z*"£.:LeS ihmzagéz §'§f::£§ir £E,§'§"G§'?E€§,jS a:':;=":$wzz:€:£ in 95 C0z.z:':.:<;c3Z. {Ezra e>z,2i§Ze;'zc?£= }C3?"€<'§§8I'Ef€?d air Eriai, and iii:-3 zJe<3m3.ic'>Z Eff Kim Ja.n"_:; n':%r"z5£er'ed. 0:": Juig 5, 200?, {:15 0}' z.::i':i:;:}': am z':2.co:'paz"azaz,€ E':.::3rei2°1 I/3;; rQf'ere?r2c:cz gm::'z:"€a:i e.=c;a<:iz m0{i.::;>:'z in gsari and €§(3r':ir2d. €.*C£{f?_?_v " _4 moiiozz in pvczrz: Wig? Cami. up%2;.efd ::'§':g%* J:.z.rg.Jz.'_.§s' » .Respmzs<<: £0 Ques§'ior2. E: ap.«3r:u.mec§ ffzga Jurg_;'s "' 1': V Regpmzse :29 QE4i€Si"§{2I'i 2; C£!"£.1'3§ g>.n:.ere:i £2"j%:'2diri§;fb:{_T". Qu.gsii.o;'z 3 in ihe ar';2Q::r:{ Qf $3 '84; M 'M--zggamgzag {he cam ':s:;:>u;_'_' T ;2féErif:3§:.:§s and €n£"<2r:; ::'f1{-2 jE:2ZZaz,L:ing j1;d§;':7_1er::." €25; j2;L¥i:*r C<3m"e5;:a:z A mihi. I'\§czI'ayaz'2:

I5, is GRIJEREIB, 1z2::;mI3%£:;§::3$ AN?) BECREEI} Eihai' zlhe p'zirp'0r'E:e3s5:Z L<_::s%f v"».V'.§x'1£k-':'2'.E. and '3'"esz.an1e2*t§' Q;'i§r:{,I;},, ;\r'arcs.§.,;rd;'a;..Ci'c:£'e;0£ ;}5§pri£"= ;€'f}°, 2804 is :20: Q Eazigfézi :.::'iZE-.an<:;f i5.:':§}.£ a._:35éE ir_i} z.::i:"E.' FEJ'REfI{;§E,?.R11»:?jfQE£E3», _ 5: A GREFEREI}, AEJJLFIJGEB ,7i::;;~:d*= A .:§_,:e:<::a:gEé2+;;9g ilhaé 1%/Ii}. f:?aEa§cri3§;_1_;:a'.b%2:5:;g_Ej:i' ..§.?2r.--3_"pfzaciefgriizzg E0 pmbaiie :"E'2.e 'E/1;»'ifg" in f'C;§§:}é; :;,".3..3"%%i,§,£)i{f'%_._§¥,£S'§ {"f:'}.i£S£i". FUR'? 1'---.7 Eﬁfisf €3f%:E:, ' ' ~~ .__ " " :7" is OEEEJEREEE, z%E}JUE)GEIf}i_4 " .<m:a §>z«:::'i:}£EE:3 mag. Pmp0ﬁ.ez'2::' f3a;Ec:§<Tifs?'1:':€z"riecijaixér "5253 a.£.§0me§;':=; ﬂags in {$26 ar71Q€{§"ai' 753;" $5 ifﬁ',-'55_ mZ__.g§§4 j":'0m {he Esiaie Of Axflf), 1Z'%7af:';§,;a.}5;;.; E3{:»:j(5zL€ecZ.

- T " V ,p§:I?§€)E?f;§:f{";§='f{}:QE§g is is amzgﬁgzz 1}iE}é;§.é}§§}i§§3E}:__'~§j:'.i'%;d 9:Ers::R5Ez:: z'.§'z:z:" C0nE'.e$§"s:g:':§. 3-"§;*'a__§'fz;i. fgaffgggzzrz ra>»:?av€r 5:52:53': ztasgis _}"mm E'.?:.a% V . E,'s§&1si'£ Naraggarz, ?'}'z..£.:fé j:.§{€§;£'§zg%::§' is jE.;'i;::azE s:"m5§ g§z':«.~;§}<2s:;€s 55,?" 5,525. _ 'C: 52;; ::z.§.§ g}{z.:':i'§e$ §':=%5{;E,:':§g% 22¢: £'§':a;? §7*z.:r;)::>:'€a%s:£ 1%/£55, ' ' . {:;;''z.:;§ 2}»; :::g:2;:g':*{zE§a§2§.a 35.53%?' ;§T.§E3fi1€€f}§€E; 5.: is V" {}£3.§}§§f€;E?i}, z'§i§}:}§.:?E:}{}§§§:i .g*§f*~§§} §L?§§{3E€§§E§£} 5.525;: 62:35 §a**w; *§;?E*?..§i:Ef1'::i&>¥V?_"»§.:;'~{':,3%'z': iéggébi $3 ﬁnéiza " $25: the dig ziieii A . J T. § Ev § éi § §:2$;%f;.§:§:t}.$!"<..{}f §;E:3a3§ hm; per 38,, {Em §GE%$3§§3§§§§§«" €533' $326 96 reifef ma: €..2:§2"<2s3£g; grarzteai in this judgmxzné £3 denieda SlG?z?'E£C} {his {he 42$?-1'? {fag <i§fJ2,£Zy SQQK JUSGE PRESII}.f§E?é} ff '

165. when thig is iha ad:311?iie&V.g3:}sit§0if:.4_V'if at Caulﬁ SE;EI"'Ji"J€ for a dispuie being ijgi 'f£}'§:;¢3--<;:Vt€}r1':3:&§<,v:%; 0f the fareigm jzzdgmeris is mil}; tr:'3.2}.;:~g€ a_«"¢ <§:é'i$é::;i§t:sm in iéfiﬁé Gf one af the a'vai?;ab1e exceptianaf %:}.a2ise}:}; ::'§n: 13 0f the -

Csde. Thai: E11€3ﬁS i_%:'e,__queSiiiG1:;1ef_ ':A}j{'::~%_Vs:.ﬁ:i'i«.:.}§;%i':':g barred by res jadéeaia even €':_1;§v:1*r1_}§§a'};$'€':?*:{i'S' an the answérs is ihige it has $53 aié q'ifi€S'{i0§iS under zziausag {a} {£9 {f}.;~ njggjg p0s§§:ﬁj;? &I"}:S€ in {his gage, haying 313$ §s:e':f2_ e;;::$%§i&,-%'I;*%é*;d?;.'}ﬁ§'§;):}€;"gwsguming the wma am Eﬁfi far" e:ia;mi::aii@:i~L<_®:i'{1?i:% ::Q::t§é';*.atiG:2$ Eaiaeé but 123?: an the fa€':3 p§€E8.§f3%'3., 32': ES _::&:::3rtE°:e§éS$ an}? a quﬁgﬁezz af Eats; and mszié'q:_;eg%:i{;g;_ ._g§'.__ f3;::'{, "' ***** it $31139? 'Q6 ﬁiggufzéd ma': $16

e)X$5é::;;3:i;:§ﬁ.3;E @E:3;L1;S<:~'r.§'3:€ 333 canstiiuieé; 8'E3.§':§' for quﬁgticns :3? 98 {S3} W'f':e?i'%':er {Ema mar'i<':e?{':' vctzfazer sf ZE'i..:<3 é%sZ"a:':€ Qf Sn' 3%/{.3}, Naray{zr: has; Eyemz vgzizxgsd {Ind {?O{£§°?.&_/ikti' pziuffi sa,§,f}?a£:ie;'z£.?

and i:.h:%ref::m;2 it is <}1";.1.y iihé? is9:«su,«:-é 9!' ihés ;312;1:%_::.i',iﬂ' pr<31r:'z'1g;{"«€~hav Vail} dziteii i£.§--4--2C)0«f1_ as; (".1323 12152:. xvii} a::1<:§ *£'.«:%:};'i{f3.r;2 A:':§:':'.:5E9;:"' ~ d€¥€.'é:T'.é:3,S€di Ev? E") E'§21:z'21},-*22:.::1§ '{.1'1{'.' q:.'1es3i:§_.e:3;;;1 .__*s:',>;-*fzi.=;::*,E"2 V' E"iE1SVe.7€':E'€{§ if ii is fezmxld. t':h2>.1f Q16; Ligigibiﬁ ta prave the V€;':i"}-' W113 b«::for€% §f .<A> £::;rf{:'»u.;:A7;1"';;:fi_» é>%'2,-reﬁé £11": {arms «:2? the: '{.es%. as ir1di<:a1t,e:L §.:1s§ﬁf;.:*:.2::(_::i{;ﬁ;i.;':";' the judge {<3 the j'L::°§; §:};.}T1d §'h€3 VV§i'{3?ﬁr:_pa1;'i_s<}:": Ea EEK?

municipai i,:V.Vﬁ'1«:§ mam rig<):"0u.$ in 1:15: the mzzxziigéipagi§%'{;;:.m€:2?y zemd §213§ing; the 3:3: of :»2¢;:<t€p£:ab§E3§£iy €E?'a$*:§}*§}'i i.'E':e::"".<:';2.;-'»;-:;é."'~:i§§' WSWANATEAN Esuprgziﬁ :2":

$€}_i§721.r 21ssf:§<3§:t.i:3:: E53 '§J§'€?SLiE}1pfZi{}§} i3 {Tfi}Z1(.?€'3I"E'1€i{§. in Ei€::":::$ cf §'.}}§€ {}§3$€.Z°§7€Ef.i{i'.§j§S5'v €335 €325: S'L1§}§"€*l'§'l€ Ca'u2"E; in éhisa £22139: 21$ 5:012izzéizéii-.VVi2f:'Vp%:;:m%'2'5 and 32%-ax; ":12": ?:E";£:% iE'§i.€'f§"'I'EEiii{}I':&i§ 5§f3fTi1S€':, '7 ,2a::{?; i'§' 22?. 2:E§§[§:s§3 féfsgi, fast' §)§"{§%-"'§§':§.;? €E"2€ £5»-*'§_§."i LE§E{§ff'E'" "the mz:§fa§{:i§>a._E .1 "';a;"2&-= gzfszi %f§1€:'-..§t<}:m€;r'y axsssra": p:*a*$é%.:1%:.§ émii is E3:;%i_:1_g '€§§s=:<:E. zmcé '::>ei:':g "_'~:3:£§*:'%;': §*%;-;§<}r{3:.:s; arzd if izééégzt §:;Ez;.§:'*:.i:§.f§' E} 212:3 §°&;'%;%:§ 2:52 ;3m:r'é% €.E*:é»:< zariiég 83'} ﬁ"§'zs3: ?..:::a.§::;%§s%z'i:{:;z"::;% Q? %i:%:::?: :r§;§:;r{>z,,:s; Lem? §j}E'éE{?€L.§{Tf§.E§§§ "*'~"§i~'~'«EE'>»~ V' ~.{;} ~ V':,::e.§~":V::*§'a zfé" s&:z£;§'E.1z';>:§£f'2:»; 5:; C§.:fiif'FZjV;i1'i£E"1Cg€'& an 5; 106 {E4} S€(7{'f8f'E 33 Q/V {hag Cede QIVV Ciufi f3I'O(?€d{£.I'£?§ fV--V§{?'l" V QEV K938. proL:i::ies:

"[33, Ajéarreign',f:.:d§;n"ae>:1i. sihaii be z:'t::s:'::::Ez.:.:e::°>:;e as; {'9 am; :n:2.z£s3;r E}"E£f%"'€b§; 52firez::i:'!g;

:1x:§j:zdi<?a.z'ed upon }3€?iI£)€tE'i"i Z'i':.e:« .:'§'{",i.?'?1€?_§3CIiF'fi£€'S T 9:" §3e£:.z.:e,>€r: pariies z.u'2cier :.::§'z@m z:§2e;; or any " ._ _ Cgf {hem Claim l£!':igai"i:'tg wide?' Z326: sozme i.§:Z€«s3V L' excrepi, -- " V VV {<2} wi'zere ii Ems; moi bg-,=é:'7:_vVVV'p;"on0Vi;::;g:g2:iV V Cami' OfCompe:enE:'j:zrisd.i::::icﬁg: V ' V {E3} g,vf1ez'e it". has moi .bVé:&s:?:'z37iv§3:2VVc:j}:'$215:ztrzeriig of {he €.'iT£S€3._' V V " , _ -

{C} where it a.appeQ;**sv. . ﬁn. --. We L]'V{3£';'€V3'3VV c:3jV {E19 gorocezécéfiriggfs Via be j.F::~z.:..2*2oi€&* «:35: V asji in<:om2c::. vz'ez,::2 ggf. :1 Vz";*_za,f:fcs:'zVa§ Z{z,a,::f:3r {V:VVVVrej[Vz,z5;czZ {G z'e{?og%z£s¢»?V"EE':VéVViazafgg-'.}{éVz.;f§ E:':,c:ase3 in z,z.:}1ic!": su ;?__Eja Ef::'::,;§"'§31.;{§pp§é§:?af§E€:

{CE} :;e;3E1e--:'e: p§fd{?€éVLZ5iiVé§;'S in :,é??E{(ff? {he j£éC§_Qi?3'*E€F'1iI' _:.:,»:1j:~'»;_ '<:«i3f.*:2£r:ed are Gppeszed :0 z'zaz"LV§;*§aEjasiiigreg.. " V {{3} ; ':::§:a{éz'<»3 ii'-E';aVsSV§?eer'1 0E9i'a;i€?"aeaE b§;_,f'%"a:sd: 5i?_§'é'f£L?§jiVV€}-_f'V{3EVE4§.j 5.95:: £:ejE3z"<:€ £5': 1TF"§é'§EV{;z;"

:V"~V«?EVE§3;V§,'.CVIVE{£5Cf'§??VE€2'V3§ :5: _f§3rs5r§,§gr'2 jzz5€g:'3':e:'fa5. is :na.5ééjj_s::;$mtE::s€:}e 52:; £0 GEE. m&:€:'§:€:°3 c§ér{;>;@E"E§; 515$; zﬁuff £€?aE"'s3€£ 3353032 §::€Ez4;2e.:%r: EEK? pa::;':€§-3.;*s.; {.{}<"{"§f?g3§ 523 5:0 {:%{zsg%;; ﬁg: 522:5. in $35, {{2} 350 ff}.

_ 2*"§'ge.L§z,z{£§;m§%;z: égj" €:'§'2:e z'%'fggs{;r§% E"-§§§gE'2 {k;:.::": is. V VV"~.§:: £5; :rE§;:i:2:s:%:'E ﬁg; E'V.§'Ea'3 g9§a§:'::§;f?V.}s; :'2,{:=§. <:a:':<f§z;sE:,.:~e*:

._ " 'VE')g?{:t::a,5.5a»2 ~--

/'V %>/ , 22323: Eé:::::'{é.__a§"VV ..

107 5 3} :"f:' Ems moi. §.3€.'8fE _[)§"GI'1C}E.i?'Ti{1'é?€i E35; {ii <.':o:.zr§ 55,1' (.'0F?'?10E?fI€?I'1 if z.ari:«;d :'.c7f:'i.0:'2, ' {:2} max" a:>:'2. zhe dI%:1{?e Qf' z':'E':e pr0::>e?€ciiz:§m'it:'* ;;,>a3'_jé3:.Lr'zdecf on ii"éc:3'€3?"!""€*{'?Z z;{(3z.:.: qf__§f::»'>.f-.. "

z':1z.g>rr'zai.'£.0%2.aE iam amt! -- b " V {3} élzctsi' {he pro::eeding :32 wI':é:r?': §.;_'2:.§? j:;£dg1fnez::* ' ULFCZS §mna;:>uz'zced waszr sapptgrseégi T 50 I'Z'r1'..f.i'i'.£Ef€Z:' jzasiike. T V V' ' 35:: 2: {:{sn1g::i::%te §1§'1E%'£¥'f3§° is size {:{>:1'{.t%r:;i;f'§.;;;1:% ;ré£..IZ.;<3ri%€§._ gjzjiz Eacvhéiif' Q? the first: resgponderit: that in 23' Qé-23:3. 3;. 3§§§:.':es::;_f£.i'§:s::.. its Whsﬁizer 23 foreign jtxdgmcrzt. 3:3 €:{§f1{T_Ei,ES§§7€V{§§f.'¢€}§1Ij1A€i3;§£'f§Sé§(7 V

108. '§'heré3f<>:'{=., éﬁxit being barred by the prir:<:§_§>£v%§$ _;:::"':«3€:s £;1SS':,Eﬁ";§§1§§ '§,':1:;ﬁ: it '£55 ;::1t€~:rcEe:%pa%1:Td<3f.§::w._$33 being? £:<:23<:§L2S§ve eirgé iiV€;".I1" it {ia£'":a be £}%:h<:%mr§sfse; in i€:rmS af 21:13; 0:13: of 'iiha gaafaiiazbig «::Ea12s5s::<-; (:5 ex<:s:§:z§':§:':»:: i'.ha"£: dizsisrs mat: 21:33:-': __:":~%;§':9 c:§z:£%$i',E<>:':$ i:'::§@p<:%:2::ie::":§: {}f 'the §:"~;s%;3<;% af 7?'_Ea:.aa=2 Exagi. g§i'§.s2-issgféég C:§ea;rEj; §'m_.§:'::% §}§"3;§§7 em E:E":::% qz:es_:s1i'.E.<f>::3..e's ("Ff E2-mar .1 aés' :--i:'§'-,s§;':g.§.._§n %:§":£=, <;.,-*a>:k§3 {sf Eh 2% <-3x::€:;3E.'£{)z'.2;;:1.§ {E123 :.:s;<a:?e %§s%E:":§g ma.:§<-3 g;§£:{:ssi%.- :1 E2: §}E2::;§:.'é;%?:.§'§E"., {Q %m "%,">.~3i*?'§§§:.

S¥.§§3E'iiEi'i'.5*'§ i.~1i1'§:i€ 'Ei};i_{3', .é:=:;:;;<;#:%§,2::>: sf E2113; %J;',;e:M 'ihaszt $t.,3§t heéizzg 31:1: E5: 'the: §}E°i§1EV{3§§}§EE$" {$5 ?'s2~s.~; jz,£s:,ii:ra:.5; Ezsééigfagg {§é:3;::£::§'2<§£:r{i an iitaéi ;E,3'-Q? ?;;}":;:% {Maia amé '€,"%1;::?:: {'§§.i€f€€»?f.§{}E'E is; £22 Ewe: {?i@§'}s%:"::§i.§':g§ -an 'a'.:'E:::;=. 108 "£09., "{'E::e*:_"ef<:>:"€., it abvicmsa that; wE:.e1T2 £}I"E(?{¥ t:E:e: is:;ss:.2<::= €313' éaw 215%; 'E0 wI*:6i:}3€tz' i,hs:»:: E5-iiilifl is; 'z321.rr«:*:c§ by pminctiples Sf !'":1"f.'$'f:Lf£{;73.i>¥f.;C{$i.:.é"§. is; a..I2s:;2=:-*@r:;é<?§. £,he:'»s;=: «:i<2<--:s'-; mu: §'é';?f§'§"E2i§}"£ 3:13..-* i%1<?t'i:, whicth are s°ea:;'z,:é1:*::%{i {<3 bi? 2:z;<":s;*w@:*<-,*:c:§ E;'?'x?€3;'1 "

zmci {his sauii: ::,onz€:.s; ta an enii wi_t,E1 f:E1é;:Ajz1;1%§§é?§3:" u:;:

Eaw, %"'hi{.'fh W215; :*s3QL2est.ed by Eh:-:':' ﬁrsi, ;;Vi*z:>_}%€E'23cE21zW:V'g;"iiiggf. 5555:; .21 p:*<;=.E.imi.I2ary §s5sL.:.€r, HQ' in this; E"E'g'EifCie _f§'l'1{)1.£g§}.".3. .R.e;gE12$i*:1::;" l_'§E:'é1.r:1€2i Sezziar C<m:1se§ appawzirigzgggg {§:s!L;:9_.::E*V1€: first. __i*s~:>€;p<§::1:ié%ni:, has péaceﬂ :'€~:.i§.2i21C:€ 0:: {he jtsdg"-r:1§;::21i fgi'-.t}i:~sA=.§««S1,A:pr§§'§1€ C{m:"£; in thcf: cage <3?' AB§L?LZ.5r P';,_.é_.'"+£1?2/E;*},?'Z_ aEsi2g§m_§- -'§»:::e {:::;':'é,€,:1£§ ':1 22-'? 637611 €iet&1":'ni:1a'{:i{::r': "€,Tif ~*::'%'3e""E:<:;§t;'é::»-- izazar if is; one Which. in mm':

d€.jg3e3.§:{§:§»; "i;€j.:":'é.i%.1:: i:~3s:%'u{-3 ef f23<tts, 21:5»; :a1?§s3i:'1g" in the sui"£;, "é£::h_:3m i.§i?a§: §sés:;;::.€: {t:a.:'§.§}<:s§ b.€ :§z3%:§2:*mi§:c{E as :1 ;}:':=:E§n3i:1a.:'y issaue zmcé. ; *£i§§i'£{fE§'§§£:§£%3ﬁii§}é1':$S (sf fiﬁif i%3:."a'%§g:'2 jz':::ig:1":&*.mI £1': ::<?;rm§3 05 8e>,::é;é{}1": {iii-?s§3Z3'E.~';'.'{§ q1.:<%s;i;i<:>::$ Sf fz»:::*:.'E: zmii f;he:'<:£%.1:*€;é ii: :;éa.:'111»:'3t Em *§;..ry 2253 2?: p:*eEir:1i:122:'3.»' i:=ss--.:ue.

E11 011 the str<:&:3g_§%:.h of iizis-2 j:.:,ci§_g;m<:?:'1i',, were fmezi irxsmglite ihai. E':§1er<.:3 is no iz1<fE€:pe1'1d€:m'. 2:'-331:3: <3§_E':£1::i;;3&¢<E3:i§:}/3' has eii:her b€€'I"i fmmezd 'far dééE,<5rm.'iI1a£.i«:33?-03: E'121S1;%§:*;:z;€1z'=-'iﬁé V the wzzke cf thzzr pktazdixkgsa <3? '£,h.e 2;1:';ﬁ_ 'E';,'IZ1-i=§'E't'.:f§}f(;3 t;h£a argzxmem. §>e<:::3m:=:$ a<::z1{Es;%r:1vi{:;~~..'_ M2. Even here., u.r«.:§_ 'fi,;'1ii :':iE*:i:-1;' gaxrza is 9211:;

faﬁevaing 'ﬁle in the €363.86' if S S i ?ci,§}.;€§ paragr21'p'h5; 0?' ithéss judgmem f{3:::'°~,§:he" ;:§g:§§?§;m in muggy .3 333% issupraé, which c:§1;Vé;"-,§_f;.":§:?~.s"._vi't5<é«:§§.*g*:'€x'{.:"2:<:i.e{i and ii: £?§f;',3;I"§:§f iays ﬂ;{'::?.~.*.if£ _'t}1;::{E:"i£7._____;3.:1$W<ir° ts'; ihe :Z$s';::,2<': sf Eaxv Es; §§1*s'_§i*;<:d&.§:s£:*:':;1:':i{»;:f;:V'a'i'~{xix 2s;--2} ;m$v.:e;:* :3 "E1?:{:' Esasusz: 0? f'a{:£f: aiaé}, am ' {Elf fzijiti, W§r."':.';'5§:':j_?:z.5éz;:f'§:é;a:%§3 fa}? {§éi1;c;"n:'i:2a?,i<>:"; in iithzé {T23;$€'. zmé _. ':x:3"}i<:§': £3523 b<%:;%;'2 -SQ §:°zs.m<:ts:i EEHCE :";€2:'si:'§:§';<3:§es;$ iiryingg iihéf i$s3a3.é:a ;3}<:z:§'§: 22$ 2;: §3z*s:%Ein21?n:1r§; isggszmx z":';és-sz1§'i;.im§3; $3': E<::g:»s§:%€:{i iiﬁzaé '€35---é.Eé£: 5%;u§f:4 zmgi EE'::,=:§: 5E'z<:%_.:Es::§ Em ::?a.*«.;-*a?:;Z§'§e::r§:§ :»1.f§";.<§ 5.2'; §%T;€:: £::2:=.+s§',a:'1€'. ,4sé"

110 {'f£.iSC. whiie {The iaasxm 3%" iaw £115: ssuii: is hit by the prim:ip1e:e; {"2f :95 &_j:.:.d}i{:aia E::e::':iz':;g r:::si: iz:€::3.r{E»::%§3<3:':{i€::1t' <}:':f '2:31:;' {}i',§"£{:f_'I' iss:mt;? sf fa<:.*3;':, but. ::"r2,m be 2-*:::s,:\2;<:*:§':%{i E3}; iiﬁﬁﬁﬁ ;1>:1£§ §::£i:§ ' ':'h::::*<2= h£:::§;;:":g,§ no iSS1.E€:'§ Sf fézai; fm112r:=:{i for asm::::::§_':--;;z:aigm_ £2': " {ﬁrms of Ehéi judgzjiezli, in RAJHESH B :;;':}'s.'L',1§:§f)§';E'3.'E'g-I§§3VE:1'Tf§éfV «i.§»=; 21bsoiL:teI3r my bar GE" in1pe:ii::<1<&:1i:T'§f{}r ﬁ":e,»§':%;ag;:1:::% as'; 1:0' 'Wh€f;§'}("3'I" the Silii; kjeizigg hit by Exhe p19£m§?.:p§:%$ at' --r°§é$'juafi.g:>o::'a 21:; 21 pr<:iimi:1z1'ry .i:-3s;m;:; <~3v<:%11 W1V€.E':£:1*.i:E;eI i'.€f1f'I.'Ef}ES. "e::=;f <iE21L::a:€:»b GE $ub«:'z,zi€: E2} {}§'R:;le.V2 ﬁ,'c:--. V' H3. E31 this v.::£:f10%;her aspaxit, ihzxi:

ewzé E-'».?"h.§.§€ 'E.:,"'§:,*z.§:,-'«"""y"?:.'%f:§v:v£::*a": ms13.r bat nccﬁ far:

€;'X2£.:}'.}§I"§iIE§.§ quesstimzss <3? Eawv 215;

zxreﬁ 21.5 d.i_2f:7;3j:u;*é'.<3V{i ""a;;;;€5sE.Vi{}ﬁ§g._%'zé§';f"z:£3E:$ aise, imi: i:%:21'i; dams :30: n1éééi::., %i.%;:«1f.' :§j;§.1:.& §$§;:.1€ "'c}5j§'" .i.21w ggas Emeif' {3i§E":VvE;':§'E'.{:'€§ ink; :.<:;:}:§3'é:.%f_..%?;'2ig2gi%%§§§§;::g ~ E3 u:f -f;?E§Eé1§i'ES 2:2": iszasme <35 ism»: 'i'§'aé:: i-'é§E*i§L'£Ei' <2? in ﬁiszeéé ;}:mé=-::e>:_éé§;..«zéézii, £2'-3: bczéizzg '£.>¥E'2€j'f3§i?{i1€?'i.' i:E";;<: 323253 is; hié; by ihﬁt " ~§§:jéz1;_éiipEs;%§; :',1szE' ___?'58S j:.:,:§:':?a:a, '§'h€: §>2?zr E62' §,:"§fi:1§,gf {his}, 2255 21 .§Z3'2'"{5'*;§_§:E"E'.1-_§§§;5ii_E"}»*' E5; <'m§§r w§':.{%::'z ?::%":s.-%:°s~. ans? isssggmzé; géf i":=;<*:§;:% Eli} %:w:~: %:;*§§::gtE ..i2'T:[V€:22::% $2325': ;2.§":€:E §:::.:a §_1*"_;:a-"2 G? 5233:: %}§-=:§:2;;; 2&3: iz"§1;§::A;;:§;:_<;%2:."%;__V.{;§'§'%%_;L__ 23:? Km? finsgiiiag 32.5; '?{"€{',{}§'€§€-iii $323; ihst $215: €.§.1.§ffS?:§}:.€T%i'"i <2§"_§::r§:~2:{§§{:=Eé<}§"z iﬁéingg ETEEZ":{%€ 3E>V;:'' : :§_e<:Ei:3§§":zg.§j U; a:x:1§:3i_:";@ t:§":.a;:% c;u€.=s;i.i::2:1 f:3;i'1{§§ 2%. I» 2'::*'§:-:1-;dﬁ<f:E:.i:.>:': ;?z.E§A.»-*2;'§,,-':%; g{,>§.'s'§;;: iii} '§'§'E£'*. §"<;<§E', :2? {E29 §"§'i€iUi€;'fE" ~._ ;{i.§Ti{':'3 £2': :::z":'<::§"::%<}2;:s:e; Ei§'}$'%?€{?§' iii} ifzége ::_;'a.s::%:s:§'.§_<:;§':_ .m"é:%::%§s-;;z:*§.E}? I 1 1 nezxesgsgzzrjgg E02' 3 s,%z-*:E.is-;£'a<:'£;mj,--' &1.1F."ii:"~:-'WE.-",::' to the isssam? £3'? Eaw. 31.15%": 23. :+::iE:z.:z.»2i'.i<>z1 dams; :1<>'£. 2u*'is:'s€: in 'iim ;;}:'at&;::*:1":t. €fi£%.SE':

b€(§&1i.I.E§{? i:h€=,:'£3 is :10 issgzm G? :f;3..ci, €:iihe:':r i"r211:':€:c§ ew:.n as 1:59 £3..:;~2.vc:é e%:>;3..1'z1iz':e:{i an €.h.@ z1dm.i%,i.ed mat:€:'i27:} Iiiiéidfif avaiizxbie as; p211": eifJf v.'{l3."1€',"}fCfvC{3_1"{i§ '2{fi{}'.VVf5i?.'};i;fVEfi. disputed iSS3;,I€'i sf E2101: a:°.1Z:4;r:s in the.;:5§;=<é;%ae;9::1i:"<ﬁ::?zs:;%,V V £145 In ihig xzieizar af the §;%:;é'§;<;%VAvvz>»'21s no impe€ii'm€2.n':: at 2513 far §;ryi.r:_§.;; preE.imiI1a:°y i$5'u<3.. §~ti<)*;-vevezxﬂ§%1'{%&:}%;§;§:'::;§3d A:;§3i?§g§':"i:}%1E?§I1g deitiined ta examine this €<;§.V1e::;:¥f;::§!%:}. can iaéé €:.:*§ed as a §3:'r:§i:21i112:s-.;v AV _' §E':_2:t ihe <:<>:.::"{.

iasitke-:& j'u:*isd:iri:i.._§.0§:1 €.0'=.€::fy IhéA--..i;és§."u.::% 22$ 2:: preéizninzzry is-sssufrg Eihé? saici 4f§'§7E{'}§}§§.§ ::.";;'a:;*.§.7j_=&':1s;$a:"i'.§fj,x' héiﬁ M3 bi? €3=Z3}'.'1£'€i'{T?'f,€-id in this ap¥;}sa E,' é?:§"'é'._ ai:~3<> <t<>:';1;:>é=:E§.é3{i E10 §§1f{'i§"f€fI"€;? "~ﬁ!'E'§.§"'i §:§1{-.=:

2.xrarra::t.iI1gj <:<,>rrecti<m §:>ef1:'3:*e3 21:1 ezzpgyé.-2.':i2:a'z',:<;>r €:e:)m"::, aw EiE'€;':

c<3r:%1pe*:};i.@€i E::::» <%3<s%:*eti§3{% :i§'::% ;«;-:;:»;>e:1Eai;<2 _jz.::'§s:;{ii:%i.i<>§1 am} t:;:«"'-.5;ss:?'£:

'c7iSi{§{"'Ef Ehzzé z;}:'<i€:' :,.1:'1(£€%r z1pp€:2:U§ 3E5. '§'E1§:* appii<?:e1€,ioz3 was (mi? £15333" f:°a.::1£ng; of 21(igIii:it;ma:§_['i:s;s:se.::«é*- and wiézh 2?: reiéqm:-::%;i. it; try it 215; 2:1 p.r£;%Ei11;:1_i:{12:;.:4y g§:e§$:2;';<§':.* ®;':..V_€}'{iur_ finciing '{:.ha§: *:':h.€: .i$s_~:u;e cam '£39 1£.::"§<;"*:<iV..2,_?:A:4:; ex p'1;€3.i:%1:':i21:j;; £33126; flifihﬁf {;us:2si:,i<>:1 uscmici be ';1;si"'?,<} Wh§:>f'Eimfé.::"}:3 ?.:<} be made T:-3:) an the ¢?.:>§f3;£"€3§S€f gf fhéf'§ﬁS€f1'€§,l'Ef}§f;:' b3r':t<>z»;r£ é§'? i;:i.<}:1.3 .. i',_§.."iv'r"Ef'--V1'€'-.,2{i'*i""3"§{'"':{l Smggie Jutige H6. Vﬁfhijiti', on $h{)1.1E{i ihayés gr ihss cﬁhea', iﬁzere weuid 210% §:__;1ve:.§:3r the 2:ppe_E§21te <t<>11;"éi {<3 E::f,er£'e1*<-3 0:' "i:%_;§§<:;§if§r ;Z}V§L'.}'}é"i'° "v'i{ff\,>'v" W'8;S p{>SSibi€, in i,§ff;€:j &g;%:"a%s:;v£.:«%_§§":,'vv(%'a:28c:, beigigg :10? at 21%} £3><,:er<?:£;<;e:%, 'm:'€_ '§:E'i§'»tf€Z?{§.;1.iET€;3Z?2f§é'Z;"§_fiZ {sf &%:s;'2::nz§:§.3A'iz:z1 ef iihif Q},:es3'i;ia:1 2:3 3; pr€i§n1':na:<**;é£ iégs-:--é.:f&z V§fi;=%;a:i§;':§f§ 7£"3::=:*.:'1 2:.v<_3i<ia:{i§ if ES iii: agmg is éihe "e._;2§}p;€%EEa%;_s:% '<:{>:i:ii: in €X{°f':"{3§S€ '€Zh23§fE, ciisa<::"<-3"€.i<3:"§ 91$ :15} wiga"-ﬁber ii: ;..f_%3:7 "i:i:*f.§;::e:§ £2 g}§'%?§§E'E1i1'}E'i§":;? is3$:..:§3 0:' ii}?,?1€£'i%'iE?;é: "€ﬁ£'I'1€3"E Eifhe '£3%.._§_":§E§'§i?§:'f§'; iii} §:.1":.<:* q:.:&s5'€:.i<:.>':': é.E':ai: §l§'":.{i ésaégmgi 2§;E':<i%%E::2=.2" a;':m.:§{;% 'ix: ma'-éai

118. in She «:7i:'<:umss€..a:T1<:&?. 1;':§'1§s :z:;3g3€:2§E is e:I1<::a!'::*{i. i',§1:% r€r.q1.:s::s:--;i.

far £:2"yi1'1g the: i§:;.e3m% <3? Eaw vim. £7063 degj'Te:':d.(mz. No I prove imvzil the 5:=;;:z'£ :':»:~: E3az'r"::?::§. by f'€?SjiiCi§{7C£i{l 2: pr:;%§ir:1£z1211j5::'i:5.{f1.;é, is-3 g1"2mf.e€}. it :35; 1'1m..a.»* ft)?' fghss Eazzrrxzaci :-:-;i.11gE€ j:.:{§ge'1.§:<'3 H W§i.§'; £316 triai and to éjezke up the isssxzg: sf 1e;i*»--.s; iv 21 '

g)ze£i.H1in21':"§3 iss5_~;:.':e. 'E'h€% :'3r::i€r pzxssed :i_:'1 this; 2;;t;:;}i:.;§§ aa2.f1v<.'::V:_21}E_V (>bs:ers;21i.i:>:1s; <?{'}:":t.21%.m3d he:"s*:§1: Eifﬁ'. fog. E3515? éiisposssai (}f£.E1is:s ézppeal a§<);"z<:% and ih<':1"€~:§"<):'e;'%"

bezzrmg; on me d<:*£;em:i:"12;-:i,i{:sn of i:%1£.: i%::?~_$L.aei'i%i"fig gawg- 333;;

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Mrs Arathi Narayan D/O Late ... vs Mr M D Balakrishna on 26 August, 2009

Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar, Aravind Kumar