Ciber Sites India Private Limited vs Nil on 29 March, 2011

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Ciber Sites India Private Limited vs Nil on 29 March, 2011

Bench: Aravind Kumar

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, BAN

namn THIS THE 29%! DAY 02' MARsCH ii»?.{) iii.   A-

BEFaRg»_

THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE 

coP.No.263f;zo1<j' V
8:   %
co.P'.:s§o.2As41+2;01a_%_

COP.NO.263/2010:

BETWEEN:

CfBERsites5 E11c_E-i'a_ pfi'a?Tcifé ,';;;i1&}.i.té.,d "   V
Re;gisi:e1fedWO'f'£:iéc13:: V Eﬁ-VF 10:31", __ __ 

Tower 2)., IBCA. ,'n:'§1_1(>xiéV1Vétdge._F'ark,  V

4! L B£4213.n--:::1'gh2it,i;2z"£{:;at;i, ---__ ' ~

Bangemm >560 _o'2j9._ A  ..PE'm'10NER

an?SRLsaJ§?;KHﬁﬁ3:SRLSRHmvAs<1s,;u3v0CAIm$}

 V'    z   ..... .. N

   x     .REZSP{)N§)EE\T'E'

  ':i%:m1p22:;'1y ;;>e'E;i_€::i<:>:'*; C2<:;.RN{),2£§3,1'2§}ES  filed

 .__ ~m':<k~*:1" S§r:'é'i{t>'ri 39'} '$0 394- <31" {he C(}I}"1pE1'1'3iE?.$3 Act. E9565.
' ..'L»..;>:ai:;.§:'1g 323%': far ihezt reas«:>r1$ :st.at,e(i £:E1<%r»:%in this Pi<m'b.'1:::
' €3'e:;:;._: :11 I3} 213; E56 g}§.<:%2?:.sc{i ':19:

E%a:1<::i.i{::;"1 %'i'2:'.:?-, S<:'E2a%:1a&: =:.::f .53;§:'*:ze.§5,;§2?z:r§:21£é:>:'1§ _A:'1m;*xz,m:=w

.4  in '{'§.':€%. g3e§i*;'..i.<.}:'1,. 5-K} €%;S if} béé E.'>§:z':d§2'2gf :}§.'} ﬁzz;-,*; 'g:sa:é*:.i:;i:;:sm<%:f

 



ct()m}_321n}-2 ifs; s;11a'1"eE1:>Eci<31'S. c:'r<:c:ii£:.{::*:e: zmci ah:-:»<::: on {"1119
'I"'ra.'ns:sfe1'€:e C{}fI1}T)8.'I}§?' and its s11a.:*e11<:}1(ie:'s zmci <:reciii:01's~'.:
and €;.'§'.{7.,

C()P.N0.264/2010:

BETWEEN:

I{:<:~a.mi{: Private Lirni£.e:c:i   -

Regi:+;1::c%1*<.:d Oﬁice 211;: Eiifh Fimr.

TO':-V61' 1), BBC KTm2w1<m:c:ige Park,

4/1, Bzannerghaiztei R_{)21d,  .4  "  ' A. ;
B21:r1ge1.I<)r€ W 560 029.  ..¥»'E;'i'i'1fI®:N'f:§R"' "

(ray smsagz PJDHN 8; s:z_:'srz:3;%E's.2vi's--G15,K A1')V'oCAf;§«:s2

ANS:

NIL     % :7; 1% -.f}_,.f-épsgéiiomibam'
"H113  jc:;gA;1:).:\;§:";s%,254/2010 E53 ﬁled
Lmder Se(:1;i01_1"3_9 .1 "*i1Q.._3E3!_4-:)f" i:h<2...C€>mpa1nies: Act, 1956,

praying {hat f"€3'rJg:.h§;2  1T€321SﬁO1Z*_-$5 s_t21t,e+d f,'h€',1'€'.i11 {big Horrbiéz
C<}ur°i; r11é1;y be pIeaE;.€:'~.j 'i;'€::'  "

Sz«.1:1c::i.i1O:1_V V1Ehe;:*: Sch'.::1'sr1s:~~n(}f Amaiga1n21t:ic>rT1, Ar1r1e:>:ur<3~
3% in I'1§}t:"§)A€§iiTl.i0£3 SO as§'t:::> be bindzing on the: p:3'{:if,i0ner

"w€t«;)m;}_21f3.)_;-mi i€'.s_ s3hz1fe12ni.§ie:'5s. <f:'&>,dii:o1"s5 and also 011 t._h::%
"g_'§'r;1.:1;a:E'*::':'e:é;> V'{3<>m.;32m32" Eiilii  s;h2?:.:"<§:h<}Ed«:%1"$ 2'3.1'1{§ c::r<:~;d§t,<3r$
;;.m:1.  " " ~-

"'}'_§1t;3:i~;é%' (3-§:'3;rnpa':":}; Pei.i'z:i<,ms <é£>ming am; ii}? {ZZ>n:"ie';:*s%:,

 ' i*..Ei1§;='s ::.ie:}=-x. fE';._<? C{}E.EI"E'. zzmdér 'iihsé f":>E§mx.-*§.r1§g:



1))

ORDER

'I'hes<;% {we }::<:%t':i":H)1':s«3 are f«;:>1* :3:a;m<:i:ior'1 Of s:;<f:§r_1c=V,~.{:'1<;:*_.."<:é._f"

a.11:a12gg;21r112zt.ic3:1 by 'E'ra:'1s;fz--31"(>1" sand T1'E3.1'E:'é§f€;%1"€f('E (:_'/%i'4_3:1V'§."..'a'{;§'c'§.._f"'£'§-§.:"?=_.',-V':.:_._' H.en{:e both {hie pei.it.i::):'1s 211%: «;111,:bb<;?:d _'.'()'§§§?.ﬁ1.(jI;"~,Eliiléif finaiiy heard and disposeaci of by i'j1'1i._S C{3~m;,i13€:»a::1_ c::*€i'<=r;'

2. P€t':.itic}:1er in C{)p"TV§\}£9.§.26<iLr'Q.i'Z)1O_ T'{7§f'1'€§:z?;:ti-2.2:a.ffer raiérred to as "'f'1"a:"1:3{_e3r<>r "«a'_A<:Qvr:§r1p21ny i:.1<:0:'p(>;ra,ted zlnder Companies Act, 1956 witih. Karr121t".aka at of "I"£'EZA1\«'IIC V : registered office at the 1:,it'lTe. 'I'7ir1r: main <>bj<~:c;t', of "i'rans9;fe:;'(}r ?:;:<3_;i1}:>;;1_:1§; '$5 {f£5£.II."II"}' on fxhssi b1E."?3iI'iE;'S-E3 Of

--.{A_ic::v€}_:j§i?ai:1:g;§' <*§>r11piii.<:@f.p;;0g1'2a..n15, 5:s0i¥;f,w.2"i.re zmszi Ego éiessigza '~:.:s;-*1s:<'§:*r:é1;'i E;zéa:5a"2;,rr:r;§é':é.g_§;est1 {>'{:h€:rs; as 5:-sé%i.w::::1£: in the M::?mor22:1<ium . "::€E:ii._i_<m_.~.

2mdX 53{:'t:i<:E<;éSa's j_:">.f As;s<_';r::%;21'é:.im': 2:id<:': ;»":.:'*:.:3t3x:u:°<:~'E3' £10 the 5 _C€}I"I1p,é"i_§:1fiiV€ff5; 2155 *u'1§1'é..€:Ar: V 8 heme: be:e2'1 <:<}1':c:i1.1_{7:t:<;écfi in 2':.h_e n3a'1':'nc:%;:* pr&j1,:::iic.:iaI to the iE'1.'€I€31."€Si' <:»f1't::~;s n1e"~r1":1'ber:~3 or ﬁzz I'T:.he pu'i::1iC, R¢:%;')(31"t Inay k€:'1<;i1y 10%;: p<3r:.1_5:g'é€i;CT---- '1':'a11s.;fez'm' con'1p21n}>" may ki:;'1{i_1y Em o1*ci§:_:fé{~£..1;'(;.A * ha ciissmived by a.;3;3r<);3r.i;1t:.é%" '"<'>.r{ii.:;1*s;, V ' cieemeci ﬁt in tlie fzicréis ami Q£':ic:1:i:%fn5§*i:21.1ﬁ:é$és..<){ £1316 rnay ki1'1(i'I_y be p:a'§-;a=..sed." ' V ' Said r€:p(:>rt: {sf Official .[_;_£q:1i{1::1U:u"_A' 'a:_1()';f;g wiiih ..Ch;;£rE.er£:d A<:C<)1,mf,am. repart dated' '1 If'--.i_s,+,u:2}_s:) placad on rscord.

9» P111's1;aLnt; __.é:i':.er"«r1iﬁ:_.ic:e_..is§:3L:i<::ci"Iiy* this Court. to '£1133 R€g.i~:)1'1e3.i'=1)i'1'<;é'§:i::.<)r, _é:r1"'-f1f£'§.§1a1vi,ﬁ. has; E36611 ﬂied by _Regi:stra§?__ <3._f-- C:)'i=1'p;iI1ijé's~v_T 'on' behalf {if t:.h<~:~r Regi(>'r:a} Dir€:€:::c:>r x>:.z1'z<T;re1.;':§tZe:'AAii; aébserved by Registzrar of _ '«'f::z,s";-"ggayrds {he Accozmf:'mg T:'e:iz:r?'zez'2E, *-"_a'_i'?;é"=f%:i:v;_'2§;fez"¥é:3 C::>mpa:':§; propased :0 foélew A ».'§f:e _;3«::u:§€fs':§; of I:'2:e3I"es£ Me£E'1od of ar:<?0z;zr'z::'ir1g {2s;;~~ n'::;;?:':::'0n:e:i in <:?£:"m5;€ E 6%.} Q?" E:'h<2 .;<;;{:?'t:errz@, , A $§§ff%'i. £5255? {£§,f}'?e;n>,;'2<>ez gj' :';:;'z§;.. ?3€§,z..z..2e2e=%;'z §..?'l{'." :35/aim? {;jf" §::~;s;ei5§ Oifiéf E[.?'2{~*; {?{;{§.§,.£.{? agf §§{£?)i.§i.i§{f.".%§ aszgf 9 reser've>5; ITEAEVIIC {ihe }"'raz'15§_/%?:'5Jr' CIor'z'1pc2:'zg;} z.:e:;:ed in CIBBER [the TI'(ZfL',§f£?7"€i':Z? (Tfc;vmp(m;;} sfmfl. C{fi"eE?I' azijusimg {he e::a:~z~yi:'zg am«:')u.ni" q;"7_ :;ha:"e:; in. ITESEEXFIC bg; CIBISER, in {"}"£(.' V QfCIBBER, sfzoulci be ar:?{je>sied {.0 i:'i'm "C(i'p%'i:'aiVA_T". ' Reserve" as prezscribecl -{'31 '~.;':X(.'§:%{){{v1;ﬁAi?V}£Q 'V S£.andard~14 cmci 110% in the x as slaieczi in clause 10,1. :§}v'7__i' f'"'ce3 W19 TI"(i;'1fgfE";'¥"€(3 C0r72pa}'i'g:"%i1as ﬁigll qﬂidavii of {.L!Id€?':ﬂ} Ci.I'lg .;*.{V7_::'71'gVii'E'ia:.1z'1c?eﬁ }:'g}"A8 ~ 14 Zaejfore this I-I0z1"I9i.=;fCf0:;ri§--T' j.

Ptzrsuaxati to $a.ici":;ffid2**;%*i't"crif E'5{<::§»iS1.r:§1£*»:«:E&i" Companiess, T:":»:1z";:?3f'(~::r£:<:: __r:,x3ﬂ1,péi13y "E1;«;_§_§' _fi1s*3ci{ v an afi"_i_d.21vii. daied O~i1~,G3.2Q,1. "s.:g§:1'e::::,;. I-:>y<.__"C;5c);*1<1.p_>:;'i1y Sc:c;:e.~ta1*y and Aui4}101*_i.zeci '-- '§"'Eipf'€§§;%.TEj§é3:.i.'§V§;§V"'" Gi" 'E'r21:1sf<3.r<;-':6 C(::11p21ny x.><.Ih€:1'<;é~um<:i<'3.19if 5re1:1.$3""£_31"€:é S '<:£3:11p21z'1y E12153 m';e:.1::r%:aken to

-'V.c§<>r:1;;§i;§é::. "°&J'_'I'.A€}':""€VV Ag:{:A{i'a1n_E_¥:"t.g_§ St;az1dar<i »» 14 :;_mn2@<:§.iai'.€:Ey an

--:-}.;3p;:*<;n.f21£'v.§§f'*%$a::§i<::z:':€ af a.n1a1Eg2:n:a1E.i<s:':. Saki zxffidzxvit. is 21§ssé.g:€E';1{>r:~:ci r~i:3c<)rd_ % W»~w

10. 'F'r21'2':asi'e1'c>r anti '}'m.x':sferee c<:n113:3.2'-11'1ie:+.; }'}é1V€ {ﬂed auditcsci b::11a,:'1ce sht::=ei: as on 3LO3.2,0EO in 1'<«3s3.;3e.{%t, of 013je<:i:_im'1ss wE1i(:tI"z 21'I"<_>: at §XI'}1"1{3X[11"€'.~C: which I:;.z:_.:_~.3' "

zmdiiieéci anti} dtziy c:e:*iif'i{;*€i by C1La1'i:'.e%1'<3ci }'ié;.:::<)t;ifIii2?i::f:3 which a<:<:m1m:s i'13.x»-*6 bczen 21u:iitedg L.1pfQ'§;.he:_yt%::1:i €:-:1VCi§iég__ on 31.0320 E0. Said ba.1an::e 5+he&%i: 'c?!Ai.S'(:.3<)ses;3»'sf7i1e"aEe3séi.s"~ and 'iizzbiliities sf both (7()mp2mie§%;;.._ _ 1}. Board of DiI'F£'§E'{.()fSV.£J'f r~.§{}'F'"c1,3{i;'7",-.f4f:?'IF'E'.{f'? ﬁﬁmpéiny in t;he.ir 3"m:*<:t;i:):1g kielti 011 and adopteci the Az1:1ex:4m:~A wherexmder pmposszed to be mergfeci wifi;'~ Th «:7: <>bjt:n::t:~: of T.I°&1E]Sf(,¥I'($17' ::§:)ri1 to i:1r_z<3r obj E3C'CS Gf Tr21I1s3fe:'es;> (§C»§T1f3é1f1§I, ';i'*E.'é:;% e:2xt.r'a<:'£. of Z'(':;'S{}}lE1'£ii{}E'1 95 'E11 :,_§>.f '~.§":3oa2*c§ '"":;i§'E" I')in*:i<:E:<::"s; mi' '7£'z*:»:1:.1s+;f«:*:':"<>:" ;1..n<i '§'2i;;1:'1.§3_fEé§'é€:«._e;:{}:%:p_ei§::jg are pr<3{iu<':c:<i 2:2.1<>:11§.§ w:'i?;1'1 pet:_it,i{;m as § ;3 3:" A:;::'3:?:s<";..,; :"€4'--j'}?[ ' E2' Ci£:{tAE§€'. (B} ~ 10 of IX/I<'3.11}<)I'a11(?ium and A:1:"{.i<:1€s of Assoc;t:iat,iot1 of'I'ra..1.'1s;fbree C:C)I1'}pE:1I'1y 21:'1<.i Cia;u.$e {.B}w~32 Gf M€nf1<3rami1,1m and Az"E:i.c.1é3s of As:s;<:>c2§e1i;jc:>1'1 pr<:vi<?I.é.~::.sV3T~~.f'<52f_ z1.nm1gan1at:.i(m '

13. These twc) p£3t.it,3'c3:n$ .. --'ad§ir:i'i2€.fé'd. u ;i':~:.dV"'T1./.A r1,<)t.i::<:s had been <)rder<3ci asbb--:sc:rved»h<:reiI1'ﬁg1b~:§vx£:..aﬂci 'I'ra1":s.-2-f<3:'e<-3 Campemy has u11d§::fifiake;;3_v {;0'€rc1n1'p1y§ with e1<:<:(>11nti.z1g si'.2md.2:rds3 ¥"3=4 .3;ss £33.; Regmnal Direcmtur iihrough _:E--{£fgist:;:'éii*"cf': €3'{:a:j'1pe11:~ie§.VV" Material on r .rec<:>3*ci 'F1T.E_1VI";.S§3E't§t'f"()'If:' pany and T1"EiI1Sf€I"f;f€'. Boarci of I3i.r<-3.,(:t()1'$"~.:fn<:*<§i,i:%.§% 10 as per AI111€X'z,1re«~ E' have 0pir1§%€3--..?111dV'Vf67gt;éf'§ L'iE1{TI€31":

A VP1.2r5§u'e1.:Ts_1i._.'L<> Sc2<:ti{>ns3 393 and 3944 21:1{§ Qi' IE§€;:' 'Lia;§:;p=~E.i&_c:a1'::s.ié:: p:'<>visi«:>12&; :35', if azzxy of the ' {i':'>:11§*a,V.:itéf:f:§;. }'1';::L E958 {i;h_e "AcI"} arid. Cfauaié H} m.1.:i'i¢é}r~-, :1".-Eigve .A'?;1':'%. {H {B} of i1}"1«:z M:-smcrrarnium <3.f E'=,¢3é§:><:i21ti:§:: 4:)? t:};1e C<>1::r1;'>any ami s:.2bje<::'t: to {hrs 2:ppr<)2:f;51_E-01" the s§1a1*:5:.h£>i{ic:r::-3 31.1%? <:1fe<Ii17;{}'rse; aifzd V s:san<?:é..:i::>:g <)fi':%_1£;t* E¢§<:wn§b}::% §-iigh €i<}:.1:°:, 0%' E{2.1r:12:*E.;2k.a. at B§;m.g2:.E::3z"sz §'.E§%;°? p:"»:>p<>s;aE {:5 ;'?§<::E':eme;:% <3? An'12&g21_:1':e1.i:io:1 ::;;n€:'"~A:°:'2:::3.§;:5n3aé:1E: {"E$::.E::=*:§*:':%:-'-f"} e2.m<>:':§g §€'e2,:;m.:'<% E3ri2:;1£:&% 5??

h€:ré3ir1 Elbiﬁkfé? 1':<)n€ sf '£116: t-érazpiayeszs (sf iziie '1'r2;:.1::~;s.£}3z'<3r ctckmpany fzax-'6 3.ppe21red i:}€f<)1*<:'. iihiss Court and ihiit sscthemeé ifaf€1r'I1a1§5§E?iFI1E1?,fi€)£'1.

20. As shardiculdizrs ilave Vv.r_i11i-r1g.1y 2i;>p.I'm-*€ﬁi-; i:h:€'~ Sttkaeme of amafgjamatitzm. §§'i€*ev 'that res01u£':i:;}I1 of b<);11**:§ﬂ 01" réVL:3c)111€:i011 acctepted by equity best. :i2:1t'.eree3t ::)f rescaivezd to appmve have e%xs:r::ised their the resolution whicli SiI1€.'.f;'. the said 1'es0Iut;:io:1 has Ah:-:*a:é:: p;1s$Vs3:i a.ft:vc:" exercisixzg 1;.Ir1:3i:r* bus;iI1<:ss °prLi<:¥_c€né:::"e. "In iihe 'i:';éi§:2fsa azlci crimu1:11s':.a';1{:<::S of (hm: case

--<:Iisss:2§()Ess:::'t;i*;:£% 2fib¢;$~ve pef;it,i{):1€r*s haw: maeiie out; a; {vase for '"3-ﬁirizteé Ei_'i<;:5=: f'0§§owi:1g <i21"<:i<':r:

Sa§"££?__iiGI_'§1:}f.:'~"S{7h€:IT§€ sf 21:nz1igfan121i:i:>r1 222%: A:'2:':£~:xa,:2*ewA. ééjﬂ.

7

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court