Karnataka High Court
The Chairman Cum Managing Director Iti ... vs Sri Venugopalan (Late) S/O Late K ... on 22 March, 2010
Author: B.S.Patil
Bench: B.S.Patil
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANG4L§R,g
DATED THIS THE 221") DAY 01? MARCH, :20 1c A' %
PRESENT
THE I-ION-BLE MRJUSTICE G_m2':v'DA..,; '_
Am'
THE I-ION'BLE MR.JUS'I'ICE B.E':..;V_i'A.'--V.17'IL ;:
*_;§r__._.g!.;._1_,_sI_o.6_s"1'2g' 2()o 3-._
C/W wr,_4a;.1\:o.ggaj24/'2()o4T
INW.A.No.6312g29_Q§_ '
BETWEEN: " ' i
THE CHAIRMANéCUM_~
MANAGING DIRECTOR, V: ;; ,
ITI LIMITEZD,' AV :3 ' _ ~.
No.45/1. NLAGRATH RDAD.W '
i'3ANGALORE_- 550 025.' ..
(By Sri KastuTi;.. _$evni2r- _Cd1,1»i3s{%I and
Smt K.S»I1uba Ananthi, Adv }
1.' .__sI<;z2.VI::1\I:J'c;oP.:\_mN..(LATE) {MAJOR}.
S/O.__LAT'E3 K,'i\IA"i';?;'.SHAN.
53 YEARS, S'1'A%.§'i*'NO.I3692. DEPT. 262,
N0.'-4482. .F_3OL}TI'~I III ROAD,
V '3' AREA. 'm' TOWNSHIP.
' ~».DOORA\?¢§'iINAGAR.
" BMJGAIDRE - 550 016.
. ' sRr:~:...MUN1swAMY {MAJOR}.
S;{O.A.KUPPAN. 56 YEARS,
STAFF NC). 15755. DEPT. 542.
~ " "No.4, 42-: MAIN.
v MALLIGE THOTA.
V.R.NAGAR.
BANGALORE A 560 023.
APPELLANT
SR1 RAJARAO KSHEERASAGAR (MAJOR).
S] O LATE SREENIVASA RAO.
56 YEARS. STAFF NO.8439, DEPT. 808.
NO.127/10, MUNISVVAMAPPA BLOCK.
157' MAIN. 157' CROSS.
GANGANAGAR.
BANGALORE -- 560 032. I _
SRI.M.GUNASHEKARAN[MAJOR},
S/O M. MADHURAI MUTHU.
56 YEARS, STAFF NO17557. DEI?T._762,
NO.316. 4TH CROSS. '
3RD BLOCK, H.R.B.R.LAYOUT.
BANGALJORE -- 550043. V
SR1.M.HANUMAmHAPPA (MAJOR). _
S/0 MUNISHANUMAIAH. .0 -- I '
55 YEARS. STAFF NO1417, DEPT' 1\:0f8:57,__._'--
NO.E~302. NORTH gs? LANE; =
IT] TOWNSHIP. '
D0oRVAN1NAQ_AR;;. '
BANGADORE: 5500515.;
SRI.H.RANG1?s.SWAMY {MAJOR}; ..
52 YEARS. S'1'AFF_ M02012. DEF'? 592,
NO.28S-3. SARASWA'f'flJN1*kGA.R. ._ ' -
WJAYNAGAR. ' .
BANGADORE4_560O_4O';«. * _
SR1.K,BA1.ARAMAN V {MAJOR}; 0.
S/Q ;K.C.KU'ITAN,-.
49._'Yr§.AR$. STAFF N();8--£3--£32. DEPT,/493.
N030. Vii CROSS,
; 5 15?. 51005; AKSEEAYNAGAR,
f3ANGAI_,£).REv 4 5.50015.
A;)Ii3I'I"fOI\ISAI;"S:1)fI5{l?,C'I"C)R (P &A.
M/Sm 1151:1520.
CORPORATE 055105;
. ' No.45; MAGRATH ROAD.
23AN_GA;,x3RE »» 550025.
. 0' --.TE-I.'37IJ'1\3'ION OF INDIA,
MINISTRY OF INDUSTRY,
DEPT OF PUBLIC ENTERPRISES.
S " "PUBLIC ENTERPRISE BHAVAN,
BLOCK NO.14.
C.G.O.COMPLEX. DOD} ROAD.
NEW DELHI --- 110001,
REP BY ITS DERECTOR.
10. THE UNION OF INDIA.
11.
12.
13.
-L4.
MINISTRY OF TELECOMMUNICATION
SANCHAR BHAVAN.
NEW DELHI -- 110001.
REP BY ITS SECRETARY.
SRI.H.N.SATHYA,NARAYANA GUPTA
S/O H.N.NARAYANA SHETT'Y,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
5/ 1, SRINIVASA NILAYA,
OPP.RA'FIONSHOP,
KALAPPA BLOCK.
BASAVANAG UDI .
BANGALORE -- 560004.
DMUNIYAPPA [MAJOR], V '
s/0 DASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, _
S'I'.NO.8904 R. V =
R/O SRLVINAYAKANILAYA,
III CROSS. BEI":IiND;.{3gYYA¥*PA 'i'E1'JiPLE,'°' Q ..
V1J1NAPURA,_ 3. ._
BANGALOR'f:~ 5550o'1v5;'..__ »
KASHAiAH,(M}8J_ORj';1:;;._ _
s/0 c:4IENNAiA1i{LA'ff1a:}, _ ' n
AGED 'ABOUT 58'-KEARS. '
ST NO.I8672M'R/O~NO,D'128.,'
NORTH 39?? LANE,
I.T.I.COI201\";Y_, ' _ _ I
BANGALORE »: 5500.16.
H.161; fV.AR$§Y'1kNASWAM¥.{§.£AJOR}.
s/0 H.R.K.ARIYAPPA.
V AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
ST_NO.. 1'41_39 R, '
R/-Q D 2'2.AswAfrHivAGAR.
15'.
BEHIANED ANJANEYA TEMPLE.
R M_V E;cr3.Ns10N.
:1 STAGE, 3RD CROSS.
BANGAIQRE -- 560094.
-,D.S.KGOTI-IANDARAMAN [MAJOR],
Se/O LATE P.V.SAM'PANGI NAIDU,
GED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
G " "STAFF NOJ2431.
R/O D 196. NORTH 57"" LANE.
I.T.I.COLONY.
BANGALORE »~ 560016.
15. GURU CHANNABASAPPA [MAJOR].
S/O LATE MALLIKARJUNALAH.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.l1580.
No.85, CHINNAPPA LAYOUT.
RAMAMURTHY NAGAR,
BANGALORE A 560016.
17. K.S.MUNI REJDDY (MAJOR),
S/O SIDDA REIDDY.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.610,
MUNNE KODALA.
MARAT I-IALLE (POST),
BANGALORE A 560037.
18. A.SIVALINGAlVE (MAJOR),
S/O 1:00 ANJUNAN.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.7400 R,' '
R/ONO.11, , g
NANDAVANAM F _
ULSOOR, 5 "
BANGALORE 356.0008. '
19. RM. A?{UMUGAM {MAJOR}.
S/O L1'iMUPIISW,Fs1ȤTY.. ' ' ._ ._ '
AGED ABOUT 58 _ ,0
STAFFNCU15333. "
R/O NO_1o5A,..4"i5_cRQss,.. . ..
NAGAPPA BLOCK, 5R1RAM1=U'RAM,
BANGALORE A 560021..
20; MUr>:r'K1T'M'PANNA (MAJOR).
A 5/0 u»,TEP1L.L,A~--;:«pA.
A _ AG,E'DA..ABQUT 59 YEARS,
" R/"'O_ NOE; 397. RING ROAD,
ITI COLONK
BArJ,GA1nF@: 5550015.
.. . , , 21 BYLAIAHQIAJORJ.
" " '8ANGALOR1i1- 550040.
A -22. B.S.P A RAO {MAJOR},
_ S/O LATE JAVARAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
' STAFF 150.5440 R.
'R/O NO.4l6, 145'! MAIN,
N10 LAYOUT, VIJAYANAGAR,
59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 10939,
8/0 P SRINIVASA MURTHY {LATE},
23.
24.
25.
26.
NOJ535. 281" CROSS.
BSK 2N9 STAGE,
BANGALORE -- 560070.
PEERUMAL C{M_AJOR).
S / O CHXNNAPPA REDEDIYAR.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 1 7978.
R/O NO.31/1.4"?" CROSS,
SAIBABA NAGAR.
SRIRAMPURAM.
BANGAIJORE -- 560021.
SKRISHANPPA REDDY (MAJOR),
S/O LATE S REDDY.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, V ' '_
STAFF 190.5404, .9 _ --.
R/O DODDA NEKKUNDI POST,
BANGALORE -- 560037. =
SYED AEDUL '*':Ai%_~ [MA;JO¥i}.'
S/0 LATE SY"E3.D--.AB.-.";JUL REDHAwIAN,.O9 if; E 0
AGED ABOUT 59
STAFF No.1554 __ '
R/O NO, 19.10 . _ 5'v:L_cRc-SS,
RAHAMATHNAGzs.R,
RTNAGAR_POST,'-0'.'--~.._ H V
BANGALORE 4- 560032."
KRISHNASWAMY P {MAJOR} . V .
S/O mm PERU»/LA1..&V = '
AGED ABOUT 59 "rams.
R/Ci 135" BLOCK, HI CRO-SS;
0 "A,KSH"AY)%NAGAR,
9 DDDRVANINAGAR POST.
_ 1~3A.1\:GALc3«EE 5500.16.
2 27.
"s_T'AF__I«f. NO. 11492.1" ' ~ "
K.RA._,_IU. _ _ ..
S/O I..ATE KANNAPPAN.
K_AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
~ "NOR'i"H STREET. NALLASANDRA.
' BA1\lGALORE -- 560047.
B.N.KRISHNA RAO (MAJOR).
0' "S/O LATE B NARAYANA RAD.
0' AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 13893,
R/O NO.57'5, 16'1"" CROSS,
16?" PHASE, J P NAGAR.
BANGALORE ~ 560078.
. V STMTF NOJ8817, R/O NO. 6/1, c CROSS.
29.
30.
31.
32.
B.R.SESHADRI {MAJOR}.
S/O LATE B RANGASWAMY IYENGAR.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NOJ2614.
R/O NO.258. 1! STAGE.
117'" MAIN, E BLOCK.
SUB A NAGAR.
BANGALORE ~-- 560010.
N.VENKA'I'ESAN {MAJOR}.
S/O NARASIMMALU NAIDU.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.8596 R.
R/O No.22, RIGHT SIDE.
em CROSS. MAGAD1 ROAD. "
BANGALORE M 560023.
T.LMUNiYAPPA{MAJOR},
S/O IJNGAIAH, '
AGED ABOUT 69 YEARS.
STAFF NO.l71_91_. , ~.
R/O NO.171.;'11Tfi=MA1'N;.__
MANJUNATHA NAOARA. '
BANGALOR§:_4':'3(_5001'1-3.,
VADIVEL IOA}. " ' -~ ._ *
S/OVAIIHVEL. ' _ . .
AGED ABOUT59 _
STAFF NO.6:;20G
R/O No.10/54; V
ASHOKNAGAR, '
KAUUGONDANA HALLIv--{P«OS'£'}.
. "BANGALORE "~5_eso045.
, S3E_O'AE~:':«1AN {MAJOR}.
"3/O._sYED.M.A_s-THAN.
AGED ABOUT. 58
R/C2-.NO.93L2._ OPPOSITE MOHAMMAD.
ALL LiNE"~./mi CROSS.
' x_PERlYA}'?. NAOAR.
.331.
O 3ANOAI,ORE ~ 560005.
i.;JOs.EPH ROZARIO {MAJOR},
S/O G LIGOURE.
" "'AGE]Z} ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.l1800.
R/O NO.5/ I06. JOSEPH CO'ITE}GE.
NEW POST OFFICE ROAD.
LINGARAJAPURAM, '
BANGALORE -» 560084.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39,
RONSID LEWIS (MAJOR),
S/O BERNARD LEWIS {LATE},
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.11546,
R/O N092, 4'"? MAIN ROAD.
AUSTIN LAYOUT,
BANGALORE «~ 560047.
ANDREWS P.J.{I\/IAJOR},
S/O P.V.JOSEPH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 12971,
R/O NO.35, LYITLE FLOVVER,
ITiLAYOUT.BNARAYANAPURA, '
BANGALORE -- 560016.
GANGAIAH T {MAJOR},
S/O THIMMAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
STAFF NO.3964;R;
R/O No.60. 11T'='_CR;'OSS, ~. «
V1SHWESWAgRA1A_f-i ._ VL
KALKERE ROAD,5,__ __
RAIVIAML NAGAB, .._
BANGALORE '~55 5g;Qo16';V
M.BSHvi?ARAI4CHARi A ' O"
S/O MALIC-ACl~:LAR1.=._ '-
AGED ABOUT.__59 YEARS}
STAFENO. 1975 R, A .
POST, A -. ..... ..
R/O VARMAU AGABA' MAIN ROAD.
-BANGALORE 9.560043.
via»; KATABBA [SE/EAJOQ R].
"S/O._GIDVDAPP_A,V.V""
AGED ABOUT. 59 'YEARS.
STAFF NC!:1?°_167,
R/O CHALLAGAITA,
A n_YAl\/IALUR POST,
-410.
' BAMOAIORB --- 560037.
3; VICTOR {MAJOR},
S/O A JACOB.
.. " "AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
STAFF NO.}.3930,
R/O N044, CHAITHANYA.
127"" CROSS,
JAGADEIZJSH NAGAR.
BANGALORE M 560075.
47.
-'-£8.
49.
50.
51."
C.R.STANLEY [MAJOR].
S/O D.R.CHAI\/IBERPAIN.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 1 1505.
R/O N088, 80 FT ROAD.
MICHAEL PALYA.
NEW THIPPASANDRA POST,
BANGALORE -- 560075.
TRAMACHANDRA (MAJOR),
S/O LATE G THIMMAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF' NO. 1494 R.
R/O NO.180, am CROSS.
5'!" PHASE, 15? STAGE.
WEST OF' CHORD ROAD, A ' '~
RAJAJINAGAR, "
BANGALORE -- 560044.
T.J.THULAs1NATHAN _t?1LLAI"ti\}:A.;O12}_;' -.
AGED ABOUT456,VYL:A;Rs. ~.
STAFF NO.6373 R;-.
S/O T.R.JAGANriATHA'N PELLAL; [1;A'rE}; A ' V»
R/O NO.9O/1._VCi{A1?iLES'C}LMPI;E ROAD. V
COXTOWN,_ .,
BANGALORE '~--560005v';V
VENKAT}%\CHALAPATfiEY"-SETIY'(.MAJOR],
S/O B.V.sAfIHYANARA\;_A'sE'i*2fY [LATE],
AGED ABOUT._58 yEARs,1 " .
STAFFNO.12727, _ .
R/O Ij)EW\.SANDRA. MAIN ROAD.
VIN_AYAI{A NAGAR, 4'Tr+G:2_Gss.
. 'ADEvp.sA1\sDRA,A. _
»BAi'J(}ALQRE 560036.
'z-AAGA REDmt_(xv;AJOR).
s/O NARAs1MA1A1AH.
AG ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO..13109.
HR/O 1309. 15'=TMAiN, VIMANAPURA.
' DOORAVANI NAGAR POST.
~._'I3ANG;ALORE W 560016.
.. SUNDAR SENGH (MAJOR).
S/f'O LAKSI-IMAN SINGH,
" -AGED ABOU 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.l4023.
R/O OLD PUMP HOUSE ROAD,
KADUGODE.
BANGALORE -- 560067.
53.
54.
55.
56.
V57.»
M.VENKATASWAMY {MAJOR},
S / O LATE MUNISWAMAPPA.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.12353,
R/O KHAJK1 SONNENALLI,
KANNAIVLANGALA POSTY.
VIA KADUGUDU.
BANGALORE M 560067.
MSHIVARAMAIAI-I (MAJOR),
S/0 C.MA.'HADEVAI,AH {LATE},
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS,
STAFF NQ11964 R,
R/O N02862, 131"" MAIN,
1: BLOCK, SUBRAMANYA NAGAR,
BANGADORE M 560031. ' ' *
VENKATMAH (MAJOR),
S /0 VENKATESH (LATE).
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
STAFF No.1514:r,'
R/O No.24, 10km-_MA1N,._» . - _
13%: cRoSS,;'n/1AI_<*L1THr NAGAR-, _ --
NEW THIPPASANDRA {POS"f3_, -
BANGA1,0RE_~'560011-5, A
R.KALY;aNA__SU1\iD;apg\gA~{MAJ0R1_, *
S/O LATE S.RAMAswAMY»:21.L:A1,V._.
AGED ABo'u'I'59 S --
r:E;M_I>A.\:;\1A %(MA;i0_R).
_ S 10 NH ¥N'1'¥Af'PA. (LATE).
"AGED .A1%3o UT 58
S"i:AF'I+* NO. r0511 R,
R/ O-..GARUDAC~'I~£AR PALYA,
BANGALORE) M 560088.
' [SKQNDAIAH [MAJOR],
"S/O LATE SUBBAILAH.
59.
_ ' AGAEDAABOUE' 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO3156 R,
REO N03, 89.
5 2 "'NORTH 4'"? LANE,
ITI COLONY.
BANGALORE W 56001.1,
DHANAMAIAJ-E {MAJOR}.
S/O LATE ROSAEAPI.
STAFF NO.l"3.326,_ . .
R/O D_.NO. 10, }{ANU1\AA{AI~'i REDDY ROAD.
ULSQOR, "
BANG:ALQRE,,_-- 560008. .....
60.
61.
62.
63.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.3817,
R/O NO.867. A/I.S.ROAD.
MU'I'i"I1YAI,.AMMA NAGAR.
MATHIGERE POST.
BANGALORE --- 560054».
CHIKKANNA .T.T (MAJOR),
S / O LATE THEMMAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.19363.
R/O NO.189, 12""*1\/IAIN ROAD,
MANJUNATTLA NAGAR.
BANGALORE - 560010.
TLAKSHMAII-\.H (MAJOR), . '
S/O LATE THIMMAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS. ._
STAFF NO. 13849, V
R/O NO564. 17m $0335. "
11 STAGE,END1R.RNI}AR, '
BANGAUORE 70500038.
B.SRINIVASANA1iK_ (3/1A,_3"OII+':},_V ._
S/O LATE TB[.VEi\TKO}i*3'.:'\,_ NAT'-K.
AGED ABOUT 5.'.~:r5Y1«:AEs. '
STAFF T'JO.1._1669', =
12/0 D.NO.3"3"7, EAST 511-: U' 0'
1T1cOLONY,"A _ ..
BANGALORE._--560016_. "
V.CP1.--;XI\Tl)RfAN {MAJOR},
s/O' V*§€&D1_VELU, « ..... .. e
A 'AGED ABOUT' 59 YEARS.
»SfI'AF§F 1'~fO.'487', SOUTH 3% ROAD.
_ 'B' AR£2A,"1._T 1- COLONY.
._ 6
4.
"3A}'«3_(;£LL(3RE."v.¢ 550016.
S.$RINIV£.S2E_i?3£DDY (MAJOR),
S/O LATE; SUBBA REDDY.
QAGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
' 4' ' = STI'A.F_'F NO; 1066.
~ . _ ~12'/O SJNGAIYANA PALYA.
Nh1AR_.GANESHA TEMPLE}.
MAHADEVAPURA.
BANGALORE M 560048.
.D.RAMAN (MAJOR),
S/O LATE DURAI SVVAMY,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NOI3095,
R/O NO.36/I,
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
R.MAN'I'I"iA NILAYAM,
VIJINAPURA.
BANGALAORE -- 560016.
R. ALAVANDAR [1\/LAJOR}.
S/O SHNAN [LATE].
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAF F N048. RAMASWAMY LAYOUT.
BYRAPPANAHALLY EXTENSION.
BANGALORE -- 560038.
M.D.YASIM [MAJOR].
S/O MD BASHA.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
STAFF NO. 13594,
R/O No.68. M.S.PALYA,
VIDYARANYAPURA.
BANGAIDRE -- 560097.
A KASI {MAJOR}, _
S/O ARUMUGAM '(L.A1f*3}, .
AGED A13OUT_59_ ~. '
STAFF NO.1S?L'16;2._'=, "
R/O NOJ81. BEHIND TIN FA 6
DOORAVANI NAGAR'P.OsI,--»._
BANGALORE 465500161; '
sH1VAs1~>IANKARAN {MJXJOR}, ,'
S/O L.A'rE1sJAGAPPA._ '- '
AGED A1300?-T_59 "
STAFF N0.12231V. , *
R/043006.36/1. HI 'GROSS.
NAGAPPALBLOOK, " ..... .. =
= SRIRAMPURA" POST.
. 3AArGA:.ORE:*.«,5eO__021.
"RAr£#A.KtJ":?i'1a._P {MAJOR}.
s'/O K RAMArJ'j_NA1R,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF N0.122'/'2,
' R/O NO_9Ii;'5.cH1NNAPpA LAYOUT.
' KAMMANAHALLY.
BANGALORE - 560084.
--.'":%'_1.
G--O\}1NDAPPA [MAJOR],
sjo MUNIVENKATAPPA {LATE}.
6 6' '''A'GED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.5883 R.
R/O NO293, TANK ROAD,
KRESHNARAJAPURAM.
BANGALORE -- 560036.
72.
73.
74.
75.
O76.'
JANAKAN P {MAJOR},
S/O P.KANDU [LATE],
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. I 2673,
R/O N020, 4?" CROSS.
RAGHAVENDRA EXTENSION.
R.M.NAGAR.
BANGAIJORE -~ 560016.
JJOHN 'NESLEY {MAJOR},
S/O JAQULES {LATE},
STAFF NO.10250.
R/O NIRMALA NILAYA.
OLD EXTENSiON.
KRISHNARAJAPURAM,
BANGALORE -- 560036.
D.K.RiSHNA MURTHY {MAJOR}.
S/O LATE DURGOJI RAO.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, ' '
STAFF NO. 13700,' __
R/O SAN'£'OSH.N.IVA;S,
SHARAVATHY -'
R.M.NAGAR,
BANGAEJJRE _-- '55oo1'1€:... ..
SEY"E'im§U'1\/I.R.[I.£AJ(}R;;.._V ._ '
S/O LATE? M.R.M[IRUG;/%PPAN."'---
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS. * " '
STAFF NO. 19493,.' '
R/O No.19/1 1v:A_R;u?1:?._A Rom SROSS,
ULSC-50R, - ..
" v _ BAt;ic;;a1.QRE.,_-- 560008." ----- --« *
KRI'SHNAP'F*A' {MA.IoR}.
s.¢o_ [ATE .MUN1S_H}::ApAP.
'A_c;'::-._1) «AEEOUT. 59_m;2ARS.
STAFF NO. 13220;"
R/0-..No.486,. NEAR POST OFFICE,
K.R.PURAM, BANGAJDRE -- 560036.
VSSIJRYANARAYANAN {MAJOR},
~ . _ "s /0 'LATE V.K.RANGASWAMYNAiDU,
AGEDABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 12871.
78.
REO NO.25A. CHICK BAZAR STREET.
" '"2%® CROSS TASKER TOWN.
SHIVAJINAGAR.
BANGALORE - 560051.
MUNTYAPPA KV {MAJOR}.
S / O LATE VEN KATARAYAPPA.
'79.
80.
81.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.l01/1.
KADUGODI EXTENSION.
WHITE FIELD RAILWAY STATION.
BANGALORE M 560067.
MRAMAIAH {MAJOR}.
S/O LATE MUNISVVAMY,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.9183 R.
R/O GARUDACHAR PALYA.
MICO RAMAIAI-I HOUSE.
MAHACEVAPURA POST,
BANGALORE » 560048.
G. JAYARAM {MAJOR}.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 10894,
R/O NO.18. 3RD CROSS,
IMEUTCI-HN'S ROAD,' ' __ * '
STTHOMAS '£'O'_.VN .' _ '
BANGALORE e_.5500sjs_4.
MNARAYANA .(MA-JCIR}, '
S /O LATE AMUNi¥APPA,,_
AGED ABOUT 5sjY_EAF«;,s.
STAFFrJO.1._1s2V(g},~-._V '
R/O DODDA DUNNASANDRA,
DEVANAGUDI POS'1';._ ' '
HOsAKO'rE.*._ _ .
BANGALORE A "5§0oe7.;~
V . flV£A.JOR],
"S/VOO'LA'm~3 SONNAPPA,
AGED Ar3Om'~ 59'
A G__S'l}'X.FF'AAE\IO..1768t3. _R.'_.
'R./O.GNO.'288;..HOD'D1 ROAD,
MAHADEVAPUEBA POST.
lE3ANwGAL(_}RE.¢----.--~560048.
.T.SRIRAMA1\I {MAJOR}.
" 5/O __LATE'T1RUMALA1swAMY NAEDU.
" . ' "AGED=ABOU'I' 59 YEARS,
STAFF" NO. 1 1926.
R',{O NO.1027. £VIARANA'I'HA.
84.
BEHIND R.R.STEEI, CENTRE,
0 '"RAMAMUR'1'HYNAGAR MAIN ROAD,
BANGALORE --- 560043.
G.\/ENAYAGAM [MAJOR].
S / O LATE GOPAL,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARSD.
85.
86.
87.
88.
STAFF NO. E2230.
R/O NO. 12. CHINNAPPA LAYOUT,
DINNUR 2"" MAIN.
R.T.NAGAR POST.
BANGADORE ~ 560032.
KRISHNA REDDY (MAJOR).
STAFF NO. 17064,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
R/O 123, K.H.NIIAYA,
2"" CROSS, NET}-IRAVATHY STREE1',
UDAYANAGAR. -
BANGALORE -- 560016.
R.D.JOSEPH (MAJOR),
STAFF NO.16451. =
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS. '
R/O MADHURA NILAYAM.
B, NARAYANA PURAM. _
ANDHRA COLONY, . *
BANGALORE -- 58¢-9:8-._ '
P. CHANDRAN {MAJoR};'..__
AGED ABOU'l'_58'YEARS. '
STAFF NOk'},5B5V8f ._
"SINDHU SADAN£sM".
181" CROSS, NE1AR'M.L'R
VIJINAPURA.4 ' _ _
BANGAIDRE --' 560Gl_6.'». '--
MUNIYAPPA {1§1'A.,fD§2).,
s/0 ;;..AT1«;Mtm1APPA.
" v ._ AGa.f.'D<.ABDU1j 58 *
"STAFF N0;4258 R,
'0 ADI}R'BIDP;R#3HAJ.LY HOBLI (PO).
_.BA:\rG'Ang::«;gE 550849.
'" ». 89.
V;GG'pALA RAG (MAJOR),
S /o~-.8831: 'V1-SWANA'I'}~LA RAO.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
HSTAFF NQ.104.~8 {Q}.
R,/0_NO.3'0, G.N0.8m STREET.
~ . _ "JOGU£?AL.AYAM. ULSOOR.
--9:0.
--- 560008.
BNARAYANAPPA (MAJOR),
V "S8/O LATE BUCHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.13818.
R/O NO230. LAKSHMI NILAYA.
KRISHNARAJAPURAM.
BANGADORE -- 560036.
' ' P128,
91. BKARIYAPPA {MAJOR}.
92.
93.
94.
S / O LATE BORAEAH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF N'O.4564 R.
R/O N022, 4'1" CROSS.
51"" MAIN ROAD,
MAGADI ROAD, DASARAHALLY.
BANGALORE ~« 560079.
G.RAMESH CHANDER (MAJOR),
S /O LATE GOWNDJEE MORARJEE, _V
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO12612.
R/O 1\IO.J.1.J CROSS,
PiPE LINE, MALLESI~IWARAM:g_
BANGALORE ~ 560003.
ANTHONI AMMAL (MAJOR),
W/O LATE C.SHAl\?MUGAM; '
AGED ABOUT 59 YISARS, '
STAFF NO.12s.n6_. __ « _V
R/O NO.14,8,::'NEi1U. P'U'-AM."-.,j?--~--._VL
TFHMMA1AH RQAD CROSS; ' '
BANGALOF&:_+ 550001,,
H.S.SRIDHA_RA (1v£A~JOR};~ _
S/O HVLASRINIVASA RAG,
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS; *
STAFF NO.14.32¢i_ ' . A
R/() E.NO.434," zajm 1':/I.A._i'N.
RADMANABHA NAGAR.
B ..... .. V
" 4560070.
95*."
G_.CE:1ELI;APPAN'{1\/EAJORJ,
S /O '£'.K.GAN EiSFiA IYER.
AGED A1E_5OU'.IV'.-59 YEARS.
STAFF NOJ3141,
' R/O NO..236, VINAYAKANAGAR.
1:F;*JASAN'b1C2A. K.R.PURA.
BANG~ALOR1«: M 560036.
. (MAJOR).
S,-*0 LATE SUNDARA VINAYAKAM
" "AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
STAFF' No.9, 18'? CROSS,
A STREET. N.K.PALYA.
SHIVAJINAGAR.
BANGALOR1: » 560051.
97.
98.
99.
100.
A. KARUNAKARAN {MAJOR},
S/O LATE ANJANEYAN.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.1292.'2.
R/O NO.520.
I MAEN. 47" CROSS.
NEW EXTENSION.
KRISHNARAJAPURAM,
BANGALORE -- 560036.
PARAMESWARI A (MAJOR),
S/O LATE JGADEESAN,
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF No.9005.
R/O No.322, 8"??? CROSS.
RAMACHANDRA MUDAHAR ROAD;
MURPHY TOWN, _
BANGALORE M 560008.
A MUNIREDDY {MAJOR}, .
S/O LATE Ag~BA3Ar;I;RE0_DY; ~~
AGED AB()UT_ 585frEAR~S. «
STAFF I\§C?J'.784_::'3" . _
R/O No.20:/2_._ \;'1JT1NA1>U.RAv.A_' ._
BRINDAVAN' £,.AYC}E;.}fT.\ 7%? CROSS; . A
BANGALORE+ 560€{l6._ *
R. K0'iHANDA:°ANi. v(f\4IAJO_R'j;. ,'
S/0 LATE A,RA'1'£:iINAIVI, ' ._ " '
AGED AB'QU'r .58 YEARS; .
STAFF NO.80'7, B .BwCK,
1$3'MA1.N. 3RD CROSS.
BEHIND INMBEDKAEEEGH SCHOOL,
D'.J.1-IALI.I,
» L ' ' BA1w*<}AL0iv.:+:":~ 560045.
10i'. ._ 'ASWA I*:«3L¢~L1A£'%'.v'(MAJoR).
A S /*0 LATE NARASIMMALAH.
AGE1Z)_ABQUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF' .N0.72:61 R.
R/0" :~1o3~.51, RAJAMAHAL GUTAHALL1.
* A .03? CROSS. MALLESWARAM,
" _ BANGAL0RE_ 550003.
'-1002.00}
RSEENAPPA {MAJOR}.
S/O LATE PERIANNA.
A AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO5982 Q.
R/O VARMAU POST,
BANGALORE -- 550043.
103.
104.
105.
106.
JB. NAGARAJA (MAJOR).
S/O LATE J BHIMA RAO.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. E0875,
R/O I-L26. L.N.PURAM,
SRIRAMPURAM.
BANGALORE -- 56002 1.
RKRISHNAPPA (MAJOR),
S/O LATE HLLAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.18270.
R/O KAKKADASAPURA.
C.V.RAMAN NAGAR.
BANGALORE -- 560093.
CHIKKA MUN1swAMY(Ivm:;'oR}';.L g D'
s/0 LATE YALAGAPPA, ._
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, .. _
STAFF NO.1692_'3', _ ' -
R/O NEAR 'IE~iI'RU,1V.'ALA:3C2HO'Ui,:TRY, 5 ' u
MALUR TOWN 5£§j3'1A:so,~. F _V
KOLARD1'STRJ'CF§"""'--... O '
B.N.G_oXzIN}§A_ ~ .. . .
S /Q LATE NADUPP33NA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT '
STAFF N0,15933,~. ._
R/O DEVARA B1'S_INA1;LI.
BILL.AND£}_RPOS'I',. ' . "
BANGAIJORE SOU'.1'.:~I.
._C.'}aNNAMA1,1 {M}\JO--R}«; *
3,10 C.{jiINNASWAMY.
' "AGED ABOU'I"5__9 YEARS,
" STAFfFNO*. 1"537€;.
._ "R__/r..) N'O.}3)_I4Q,"NOR'I'H 31%: LANE,
. 1 TI COLCl\)fY.'
- 560016.
,. % A TI?fi(AGARAJU {MAJOR}.
A. ,5/0 LATE YAJAMAN ADAVIYAPPA.
" V AC3-«ED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
109.
"STAFF N01 1431.
R/O NO.3141. HALIE STAGE.
ESI HOSPITAL ROAD.
INDIRANAGAR.
BANGALORE --- 560008.
KARIYAPPA (MAJOR).
S/O LATE PUTTE GOWDA.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
I10.
112.
13f
4__1'~1O_4. V
115.
STAFF NO.18469.
R/O NO.4l. 3RD BUOCK.
57" LANE, DASAPPA LAYOUT.
RAMAMUR.'TH3."NAGAR.
BANGALORE ---- 560016.
VENKATAEAH (MAJOR).
S/O LATE SANJEEVAIAH, _
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.384-Ii,
R/O NO.l8, 87'" CROSS.
SIR M V NAGARA.
KALKERE ROAD,
RAMAMURTHY NAGAR,
BANGALAORE n 5360016.
V.JAGA1\¥NATHAN[I\/iAJQR},_ _ _ ..
S/O LATE RVENKATACHALAM.'-L 2, j.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS. A
STAFF No_3245,, _
R/O NO.U9/9,4.' _ 3
ROAD SIDE am $22055,
MAGADI 3,091), if '-
BANGALORE g*560'023_ , *
TE, VVERGHESE {MAJOR}; «., .
S/O':LA'I.'_E3-- GEE;'.Ir.RG£.§Es.I:: EA_SO'W,
AGEDABOUT 59 Y,E:ARs.,_.
sTAFF'N._o.1S3673.__ . ' _
R/O 310.130. SHAJI VILLA."
8?". CROSS.' s_T.AN.1x:--1«:'s"r3oLLr::Gr:: ROAD.
RAMAMURTHXNAGAR.
.,§3_A.NGAIx3,RE ~ 5600.1-5.«'
V "--B_.NA..NJ=UNQAswA1\aY (MAJOR),
" V S/0 LA.'rEv.I0.QY..sIDDA1AH.
._ 'A_C.ED'AB0uT_58 YEARS.
A STA.F'F' N0;1é=.449 R.
R,/O No'.39.,~' EAST zrm LANE.
1 T I. COLONY.
~ 560016.
SA'YINA'I'I-IA T.C {MAJOR},
-A A "S,/.O LATE CHINNASWAMY.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF N052 I 0 R.
R/O NO. 1030, 67"" CROSS.
SREERAMPURAM.
BANGALORE W 56002}.
KLSUBRAMANI {MAJOR},
S/O LATE KNNI,
116.
117.
118.
119.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NOJ54.-12 R,
R/O NO.E3~793,
EAST 47*'? RIDAL ROAD.
1 TI COLONY.
BANGALORE -- 560016.
RAMASWAMY (MAJOR).
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 18293.
R/O KADUNABISANAHALLI.
PANATHAR POST. VARTHUR I-IOIELT.
BANGALORE ---- 560087.
M. GOWRAMMA {MAJOR}.
W/O S/O LATE N MAREYAPP.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS; _ -_
STAFF NQ19014, 12/0 7/9; '
9TH CROSS. 3RD MAIN, A.
ADARSHANAGAR. _
cHAMARAJA;>ET,. . g ~~~
BANGAI.ORE__~ 5501__3. . U
R.NARAsiMm.xJfi; (MA;:oRj;5f T_
s/0 LATE J'QT1L1'rs:(3An«i;._ ._
AGED ABOUT.58 YT1.;Ai2S. '
STAFF No.0 19436-R. __ *
R/O 'N033-15; EAsr:f"'.r.NLA..1N;.._' _.
ITI COLONY, V v "
BNGALORE 4 560016;.' "
MLINK-3.wAMY"(MAJoR).
ROSAIAH (LA"i'E)_,_. s
AGE) ABOUT 59 YEARS.
. ' v STAFF NO.,16E337;
* R'/0 192...TRAJESWARE LANE.
. "V_¥'f.EKANA_NDA'
' . 'A"TNARAvA:-uA"PURA.
BANG_A;{;QRE -- 5600 I6.
T1~:E'~.AD":)1T"xoNAL DIRECTOR (P 3: A).
.. M/s IT1 LIMITED.
CGRPORATE OFFICE:
" N045/1. MAGRATPI ROAD,
BANGALORE «« 560025.
7 V.M.VERGHESE {MAJOR},
59 YEARS.
S/O KURIAN MATHLAL
EX STAFF NO. I70 (Q).
EX CHIEF PERSONNEL MANAGER.
R/O NO.-412, 7"" MAIN ROAD.
122.
123.
124.
125.
I-I.R.}3.R.I,.AYOUT.
BANGALORE -- 560043.
QKARUNAKAR REDDY 59 YEARS (MAJOR),
S/O CLRAMACI-IANDRA REDDY.
EX STAFF NO.728.
EX GENERAL MANAGER I.T.I..
R/O NO. 316A, 47" CROSS.
KAGGADASAPURA ROAD.
C.V.RAMAN NAGAR.
BANGALORE -- 560093.
A.C.KADIR VELU 59 YEARS [MAJ(5R}, 0'
s/0 s.A.cHANDRA sEKARA5I,Ex's3fA£rE_ No.53sR,I ' '0
EX CHIEF MANAGER I.'_I'.I,
R/O NO.l5, III CROSS.,;
GUPTHA LAYOUT ULSOQR P_.O,
BANGALORE - 560008. A '
K.K.VARGHEsE'iMAJo.R}, '
s/0 LATE K,P.'KI_}R1AN,¢:_ __ --.
58 YEARS._£'-X S'§AFI*" N0.15540, _, =
EX DEPUTY I'-EANAGERI'.-if;-I.,. .
NO 10. WHEELE;R RO;s;D4_EX3'ENsIoN,"g
BANGA1pRE~'56QQs4..._ ' '
'I'HANGAMON'x'-" GzJNALA:\I (MAJOR).
58 YEARS. ' ' __
D/O LATE SANTHGSI'-}AM;.__ "
EX STAFF No,193:_29,; ' _
EX CHIEF NURSING supm I.']'.I,
R;/O' NO. 192,"R.R.L.AYOUT.
A CROSS ROAIIVIJINAPURA.
'GooR"AvA;x:1 NAGAR POST.
. G V 560016.
1265.
{MAJOR},
' . 59 YEARELS/'O S.B.KI-IARE3,
Ex STAFF No. 19662.
DEPU'1Y GENERAL MANAGER I.T.I..
R/G B 2:. ITI COLONY.
.. VEDOORAVANI NAGAR.
.1j2%'.'-
BANGALORE M 560016.
GAEMOTWANI 59 YEARS {MAJOR},
s/0 BRIJAL MOTWANI.
wx STAFF N0.00'?9l F.
EX EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR I.T.I.
R/0 NO A1/2, SOUTH AVENUE.
ITI TOWNSHIP DOORAVANI NAGAR,
BANGALORE ~ 560016.
H22",
128. R.K.VENGAR3 {MAJOR},
59 YEARS, S/O LATE K.R VENGARI.
EX STAFF NODO78.
EX DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER I.T.I.,
R/O B-27, SOUTH AVENUE.
IT! TOWNSHIP.
DOORAVANINAGAR.
BANGALORE - 560016.
129. K.U.S.NAIDU {MAJOR}.
59 YEARS, S/O LATE K.V.RANQA RAO,
EX STAFF NO.IM~4011, =
EX ADEDLQENERAL MANAGER
R/O N~2, THEATRE ROAD. ' _
ITI COLONY, DOORAVANINAGAR... _ 'V
BANGALORE - 560016..' "
130. CSUBRAMANLAN {MAJOR}, _S '
59 YEARS, H ' .
s/0 LATE CI-ilN1'\FAV KU1ANJ:)A1~.
EX STAFF Nc.2.1'=:1.1<£;?. R, __ .» ' V.
EX ASS'? PUT3L1<;5*RELAT'10N. OFFICER.
R/O 13-9 N'0r2'EH Av1~;NUE_Vi<:f1 TOWN SHIP,'
BANGALORE 5.60016; ._ " 2
131. R.c.RAWAT.{r;z;AJoT:;}.' _
58 YEARS. S /0" MA1G.~iAN4.SSI'1~JG1--3, .
EX STAFF No,401.T5, * _ ' __
EX cHLEF"ENGIN_EE-R' I T 1;, " = "
R/O C-99, NORTH 151* .ROAD';
I.T.I TOWNSHIP. . _ '~
DQORAVANINAQAR.
,_BANc;51pREw56oe-1.e;«' RESPONDENTS
M.C_,NaTa.Simhan, Senior Counsei for R-1 to 7, 13 to 121 Sri»S..;Ka3y2it:.tvfiafizwaraj, ASG and SH' Rajararn, CGSC for R9. 10, i'?,,"?:23, ifl34,AT1'I36 and 137, Sri M.R.Sha:iIeI1dra, Adv. for R T' 11, Sr:._L.Qov~:n¢;raj. Adv for R-125 to :30, Sri 13.1,. Jagadeesh ~ :;-yR_S--, :22 and 136) " ma \iv5A;1ito.2o24/2004 "1". NVENUGOPALAN S/0 LATE jK.NATES}{AN. for imply-;d'ing applicants, Service heid Sufficient in respect of 58 YEARS, STAFF NO.I3692. DEPT. 262, NO482. SOUTH 11] ROAD, B AREA,
-23..
ITE TOWNSHIP, DOORAVANINAGAR, BANGALORE -- 560 016.
K. MUNISVVAMY S/O AKUPPAN, 56 YEARS, STAFF' NO. 15755, DEPT642. N04, 47" MAIN.
MALLIGE THOTA. V.R.NAGAR. BANGAIJORE « 560 023.
RAJARAO KSHEERASAGAR. S / O LATE SREENIVASA RAO. , 56 YEARS. STAFF NO.8439, DEPTf808.._ NO.127/£0, MUNISWAMAPPA BLOCK, :51" MAIN, £9T.CROSS. GANGANAGAI~"{,7~.. ' _ BANGALORE ~ 560 032. --
IVLGUNASHEKARAN.
S/O A MADURAI MUTHU, 56 YEARS. STAFF No.17557,V_Dj:I2T.'iS2,:_ QT" CROSS, 3R9 H.R.B.R.IAYOUT, ' ' BANGALORE -'H550 ~ M. _ '.
S/O MUN.ISHANUMAEA_H, 55 YEARS. STAFF.' NO. 3141 '7, 'I3}f;','I--'}'.86'?V,VVVV' A NO.EO3V-.02,DI0RTi*I'.35T1;ANE,_ ~ LTI TOWNSHIP,' _ DOORAVAL'\JINAGAR,,_ . BANGALORE: ssooxs. W H.RA;;xrGASwAMY'; -. ._ H A S/Q IZATE .... .. v ' - 52 STAFF No.20 :2, DE3P'I'.692. V_ . No.--2_89,..SARASwATH1NAG,AR. _ V£JAY;\.NA3m'z,' "BA1~I<.3ALOR:;.,_- 550040. i:.BA;.AR,e.1vLza,i\§~w'S/0 K.C.KUTi'AN. 49 YE/KRSQASTAFF NO8222, DEPT493. . ' No.30, 'V11 CROSS, :51" BLOCK. = AKSHAYANAGAR, =._'BANG~.AL€)RE « 560 016. MUNIYAPPA S/O DASAPPA. AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
A " NO.8904 R. R/O SRLVTNAYAKA NILAYA, III CROSS, BEHIND AYYAPPA TEMPLE. VLHNAPURA.
BANGALORE ~ 560016.
10. IE.
12. . S/Q SIDDAREDDY.
AGED AI%50_U'T 5:3 YEARS, KESHAIAH, S/O CHENNAIAH (LATE).
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STREET NO. E8672, R/O NO.[) 128, NORTH 3"" LANE, I_'E'.I COLONY.
BANGAIJORE - 560 016.
H.K.N"ARAYANASWA1\/EY. S/O H.R.KARIYAPPA.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STREET NO. 14319 R 12/0 22 ASWATHNAGAR, BEHIND AALEENAYA V' TEMPLE RMV EXTENSION, 11 STAGE; ' 3RD CROSS, ' BANGALORE ~ 560 094.
D.S.KOTI-£ANDARAMAN, * S/O LATE P.V.SAMI~"'ANGI NAIDU, AGED ABOUT 58 YEr1\.RS, " * . ' S'E'AFFNO.1243_1_,'*.._V j 3. R/O D 196, NOP\'1'I~I:3'iT*_.LA,1\$E,
1.T.1.coLONY."
BANGALc)REg56p'016. " A _ ' GURU C}IANNAI3ASAPf'A. G s/0 LATE MALLli{AE?.JU'NA1AHI'.... ~ AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, "
STAFF No«.11'580,' ' --
NO.86, CHINNAPPA LAYO.UT,_ RA1\r£AMUR'I'HY-.NAGAI"§-, '-- BANGALORE M 580016.
s.z\/1U1§i1 REDDY, "'STP;FFT NO, 15708.',' V A O' 'I4:
R/.O"NO.6 10,--'MuNNE KODALA. HALL} _{£§r:)ST), BANGALORE '- 560037'.
'A...s1VAL1NGAM S/O LATE GANJUNAN, .. f EAGEDGABOUT 59 YEARS. ' $TA_FE.--'N0.7405 R,
415.
R./O NO.1l.
NANDAVANAN 'G' STREET, I: -ULSOGR, BANGALORE » 560 008.
P.M.ARUI\/IUGAM S/ O LATE MUNISWAMY, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO.15333,
16. E7.
18.
19. 20,
22. R/O NO.103, 47'" CROSS. NAGAPPA BLOCK. SRIRAMPURAM. BANGALORE - 560021.
MUNI KEZVIPANNA, S/O LATE PILLAPPA. AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO2953 R. R/O NOE 397, NORTH RING ROAIB. I.T.I.COLONY.
BANGALORE ~ 560 016.
BYLALAPI S/O LATE JAVARAIAH, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STAFF No.5440 R, G R/O N0.416, 14"'"MA1NM.C.LAYOUT.~-- ' VIJAYANAGAR.
BANGALORE -- 560 040.
B.S.P ARAO, V S/O PSRENIVASA MURTHY' (LATE; AGED ABOUT 59 Y§}Al?.S, r STAFF NO.1093§3_, ._ . « NO.I535, 28"?" CROSS;
B.S.K.2ND STA(;E;i__ , ' ' BANGALORE-5800-76--; :;,_ ,_ FERUMALC . --
S/O CHINNAFPA RE1)D{YAR, AGED ABOUT' 59 YEARS, v "
STAFF NO.1"7'S978,V _ .
R/O No.31/1,"4'F-I'cRoSs,"». SAIBABA NAGAR," . _ " « ..... V4 9 G -BANc;ALo'1»'Lr«: L 560021. _ S';'::1§iS1a':\:;A_;5FA "F1$:D.DY. 'S/0 LATE SHAMAIAFI REDDY. AGEDFABOUTSQ.
STAFF NQ..'54.Q4'.
R/O DDDDA NIE)KKUNDi POST, V x_BANGALf_)RtE ~ 560037. {;*SYED«--ABDUL, KHADAR, S ' S/O.LA'I'E3 SYED ABDUL REHMAN,
- AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 1564 R, " -R/0 NO. 181. Sm CROSS.
RAHAMATHNAGAR, R.'I'.NAGAR POST. BANGALORE ~ 560032.
KRISHNASWAMY P. 5/0 LAE PERUMAL AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 1 1492.
R/O I BLOCK, III CROSS.
ALSHAYANAGAR, DOORAVANiNAGAR POST.
BANGALORE -- 560016.
23. KRAJU.
S/ O LATE KANNAPPAN.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.188817.
R/O NO.6/1. C CROSS, ' NORTH STREET. NEELASANDRA, BANGALORE ~ 560047.
24. B.K.KR1SHNA RAD, . ' < 5/0 LATE BNARAYANA RAG. _ I AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS. A ' STAFF NO.13693, V _ R/O NO.5'75. 163" moss, , - 16?" PHASE. J.P,.~NAGA1?<. g ' BANGALORE --4_5'+300?A8. ' .
25.B.R.SESI~iAD}~"'.1, --:fi_ ' ' ._ S/O LATE? ,B,,RA1\I,GAs-WAMK _IY'E?,NGAR.., . A AGED ABOU'I"5.905YEARS. * ' . s'rAFF1'xIo.12614; A - . R/O No.255'3, 11'sfrA@}a:,..1 11:: 1v.AIN.. 13: BLOCK,' SUBRAMANYA NAGAR,' ' BANGALO,'RE:_ 500 010. ' " *
26. N.VENKA"£ESAN, ..
. é_ S/0_"N;ARASiMNLALU 'N,zu..D.U;
"AGED A1§soAUTA'.*59 YEARS. A STAI*'_F £'JO.8.596 R, § SR'/0 No.22, REGEETSIDE. '0jm"C_Ros'3,"MA0.AaI ROAD. BANGAL0RIs:»a;_560023.
27. T.L.1\/iUN1S?APii~A, n_S/O LINGAIAH.
' V AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS, M'3j\1\3JUNA'f'i~iA NAGAR, " BANGALORE M 560010.
A ' ' « A » G28. VADIVEL KRISHNAN. v.,S"S'I'AF'F.NO.I719l, R/0_1\1o.171, 11W MAIN, S/O VADIVEL.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO. 6420 R. R/O NO.10/54.
29.
30.
31. M27"
ASHOKNAGAR, KADUGONDANA HALLI (POST), BANGAIJORE -560045.
SYED AHMAD.
S/O SYED MASTHNA.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STAFF NO. 16894, R/O NO.932, OPPOSITE MOHAMMED, ALI LINE. 4T" CROSS, PERIYAR NAGAR.
BANGALORE - 560 005.
LJOSEPH ROZAREO.
S/O GLIGOURI, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, . ' STAFF NO. 1 1800.
R/O-NO.5/106, JOSEPH CONDOS; = . ' NEW POST OFFICEROAD, LINGARAJPURAM,' ' "
BANGALORE --w 5.ScOSg;.- ' RONSID LEWIS. '_ S/O BERNARD LEWIS ._ " A AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF I%IO.1;'5«;55. _ R/O NO,.92,_4-T"MA1N..R()AD;._ AUSTIN T_OWN LA.YOUf1*... _ BANGALORE 4 560G.47.=.. = "--- ANDREWS P43:
32. _ V _ .--
S/O 4£?.V.JAQSEPH',' .. ' AG};O.AB_O'u'r 58 * 2 33.
"STAFF N'O$329?T1, ; . R/'O _NO,v35,.%L1im:.E FIDWER. _ 1;"1'.1_. LAYO«UT,~B.NARAYANAPURA, "BA1~I_OA1;OR13._-- 550016. GANOA1AH~.'1fl A S /O THIMMAIAH, ' x_AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
' . STAFF' NO'. 3964 R, "R/0310.60, mm CROSS, V1SHWESI~IWARA1AH EXTN. KALKSRE ROAD.
R1?xI'v'EAMUR'1HY NAGAR. O"-~34.
O " "'BANGALORE'..
M.ESi-FWARAICI-IARE.
S/O MALIGACHARE , AGED ABOUT 59' YEARS.
STAFF NOE 1078 R,
35.
36.
37.
38. _28E R/O VARMAU AGARA MAIN ROAD. VARAMAU POST, BANGALORE - 560043.
VENKATAPPA, S / O GIDDAPPA, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.1'7167, R/O CHELLAGATTA, YAMALUR POST, BANGALORE -- 560 037.
JVICTOR, S/O A.JAcOB.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STAFF NO.13930, R/O No.44, CHAITHANYA, ' 121%: CROSS, JAGADEESH NAGAR;--_ 3 5' BANGALORE ~ 560075.
BCHENNAIAH, S 5' S/O CHINNAlAH~v(LA«TE}, _ AGED ABOUT .. 1 STAFF No.14-"284 P, '-
R/O No.52, NOR1é_'H,AvENUE,"'O~'iS'O_' A' ' :.'1'.1.cOLONY, BANGALORE '---- 5ij50_O 16.1;
D.NARASIMHAN, _ __ S/O N.G.DAIViODARAN {Lz~'.'I'I3i}---,.___ "
AGED ABOU'1f 58 YEARS; "
STAFF_NO.12258,V R/O No'. 12/2, Sm CROSS, ~ . é_ K.P_.AGRA_HARA. MARIYAPFANAPAIYA, ' 'BANGAIJORE 4 560023.
' §1J:_AO;_JAYASEE»I;AN, "
"S/O_AROI£EYASV'JA}vIY {LATE}, AGED ABOUT. 59 STAFF NQ;1.'2_935, R/O NO.1'42, '1.T.c,cOLONY. ' u_COX 'FOWNL, J EEVANAHALLI, '£0;
« S,--{O MUNESWAMAPPA {LATE}, ' 3:EAN(}AI.G'RE -- 560 005. THEMIEARAYAPPA, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, " '"S'i'AFF' NO.1068 R, R/O KITHAGANOOR, KRISHNARAJAPURAM POST, BANGALORE -- 560036.
41.
42.
43.
44.
-BANGALORE 4 550044.
GPANEER SELVAM, S/O A GURUPATHAN, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.18021, R/O NOB, 1ST CROSS.
MUNI NANJAPPA GARDEN.
R.T.NAGAR POST, KAVAL BYRASANDRA.
BANGAIJORE ~ 560032.
NGANESHAN, S/O NAKSAN.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF N01 1967.
R/O NO.17. 1ST CROSS, SARASWATHIPURAM, . ' < ULSOOR, BANGALORE -- 560008.' I C.R.S'I'ANLEY, V S/O D.R.CHAMBERPA_1N, AGED ABOUT 59 'YEARS, .
R/O No.88. 80193' ROAD, . I MICHEAL PALYA, NEW 'THIPPASAND A BANGALORE-3569 O75. ' ' T.RAMACHANDRA, , _ * S/O LATE G.TH1M3;-.1A1AH, ' ._ AGED ABOUT 59 STAFf<'NO;_1494 R, R/O NO.180',;8'"i r_:ROSS,g "
Sm PHASE, 181' "STAG-133." ' WEST OF CHORD' ROAD, RAJA;_;'INAGA,R, "
T',;}.TI'fiLIi,P.SINLCPEiA:§E PILLAI, "S/'O _fF.R.JAGANE=IAT'I~1AN PILLAI (LATE). AGEDAABOUT.'59S'¥EARS, STAFF NQ;63.73 R, R/O 90/1',_<::HARIES CAMPLE ROAD, *.,cOX TO:m_\Ii; BANGALORE A 560005. "'¢fENKATCHALAPA1'HY SETTY. S/'O.?3;'V.SATTiYANARAYANA SEITY {LATE},
-- AC-ED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STAFF NOJ2727.
" "R/O DEVASAMDRA MAIN ROAD. VINAYAKA NAGAR, Am CROSS, DEVASANDRA, BANGALORE -- 560036.
47.
48.
49.
50. 51;
AvEr§I1~:AT,i2."iAI--I," ~ . A 6/0 VEI\.?KP»TL'SHv(LATE). ~30 NAGA REDDY.
S/O NARASIIVEMAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO. 13109.
R/O 1300, 1ST MAIN. VINAYAPURA, DOORAVANI NAGAR POST, BANGALORE -- 560016.
SUNDAR SINGH.
S/O LAKSHMAN SINGH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STAFF NO.14023.
R/O OLD PUMP HOUSE ROAD, KADUGODI, BANGALORE -- 560067.
M.vENKATswAMY, --.
S/O LATE MUNISWAMAPPA.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NCL12355, j ' :
R/O KHAJI SONNENAI,LI, KANNAMANGALA PC¥;ST_.; VIA KADUGUDU. 1"
BANGALORE -7569067. ' U _ S/O c.n»1A11ALwEvA:zB<1{LATE;, = AGED ABOUT 59 _ --
STAFF NO;1l964 R,»._ . "
R/O NO.2862..__ 15355! . , E BLOCK, SUBBAMANYA NAGAR, BANG'A:.O.RE --- 560931. _ AG-ED' ABOUT 56,.Y'E;ARS. "STA? 'F. NO .. 15,1 47,,' A A "
R'/O NO.24, '19f"171\/J.A.iN, 13?" CROSS, NAGAR, N EW THIPPASANDRA[POST}, BANGALORE 4 560015.
KALYANA SUNDARAM, /O 'LATE SEAMASWAMY PILLA1. AGED. 'ABOUT 59 YEARS.
-- STAFF NO.13326.
RXO D.NO.10, HANUMALAI-I REDDY ROAD O V' ""L}LSOOR, BANGALORE -- 560008.
" . KEMPANNA.
W/ O MUNIYAPPA (LATE), AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.1051 R.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.'
-31 R/O GARUDACHAR PALYA.
BANGALORE --- 560088.
SKONDAIAH, S/O LATE SUBBAEAH, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.3156 R. R/O N03. 89.NOR'1'I~i 4'1" LANE. £.T.E.COLONY.
BANGALORE --~ 5600} 1.
DHANAMAIH.
S/O LATE ROSAIAH.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF No.3S17.
R/O NO.867, M.S.ROAD, . ' MUTHIYALAMMA NAGAR.
MATHEGERE POST.
BANGALORE --» 560054. H CHIKKANNA T.T,- ' S/O LATE .
AGED ABOUTSS _ STAFF No.193e3~;,__ ' ' ._ R/O N0,1S.9. 1'2:ItH MAT_N,.R0_ MANJUNATHNAGAR. = BANGALORE ~ 56@"0:Q. T.LAKSHiv:AIAH. ._ * S/O LATE ".['}H_lVIIMAIAii, AGED ABOUT59 STAFF NO.,l3849," .. _ R/Q I'-$0.564; T 71'" CROSS; T1 STAGE. . -§NT)1;2ANA(:AR.~ _ A SANQALQRE '~-.V5(:'»0__()38.
"3.SR1NiVASA,N_AiK;""
S'/.0 LATE B;xrgNKoBA NAIK. AGE-D A80 UT 59 YEARS, STAFF N0..l1669, HR/O D.§\IO..'E»77. EAST 57" IANE. ' E.T.,'..COLCINY.
» . _ "BANGALORE --» 560016. \"2';cI«~1" ANDRAN, S/0 VADIVELU.
" "AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF No.13147.
R/O NO.487. SOUTH 3R1?' ROAD. 'B'AREA, E.'I'.£.COLONY, BANGALORE -- 560016.
V 6Q£.".'\.K2XSf . '
60. s.sRiN1vAsA REDDY.
S/O LATE SUBBA REDDY.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF NO.1066.
' R/O SINGAIYANA PALYA.
NEAR GANESHA TEMPLE.
MAHADEVAPURA. V BANGALORE M 560048. " "
61. D.RAI\/IAN.
S/O LATE DURAI SWAMY.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF N0.13095, R/O NO.36/1,R.MAN'I'HA NIEAYAM, VIJINAPURA, _ BANGALORE »« 560016.
62. RALAVANDAR, S/O RAMAKRISHNAN {LATE}... AGED ABOUT59 ' ' sTAFFNO.12843,"~.__.-- 2: g R/O No.48,RA..1\;:AsWAMY~zAYO:1JT, ' BYRAPPANAHALLY vEX"l'ENSIOI'I. - BANGALORE +_5600;_38.
63.M.D.YASIN, " ;
S/O M.D.BA6HA,' H AGED ABOUT 58 _ STAFF N0;.:3694. '-
R/O No.68, 'M._.s.EéALYA. ' VIDYARANYAPURA. ~ _ BANGALORE --w 560097.
_ » S/O AR1.IMLIGA1vr.q,ATE), _ AG ED' ABOUT SBXEARS, "s.TAF_-F. NO..1'2.,162.j ' A "
R'/0 3410.181.' BEHIND TXN FACTORY. DOORAVANI NAGAR POST.
BANGALCJRE M 560016.
A " 'V ."65.,"sH£vAsH:ANKARAN .A.
-- STAFF N012231, " "NAGAPPA BLOCK, SRERAMPURA POST. BANGALORE A 560021.
66. RAMA KUTTYP.
96.00 LATE NAGAPPA, AGED. ABOUT 59 YEARS.
R/EO NO.36/I, III CROSS. S/ O K.RA.MAN NAIR.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
67.
68.
69.
70. W33- STAFF N09 1 / 5. CHINNAPPA LAYOUT. KAMMANAHALLY, BANGAIJORE -- 560084.
GOVINDAPPA.
S/O MUNIVENKATAPPA {LATE}, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, V b STAFF NO.5883 R, " ' RIO NO293, TANK ROAD.
KRIS!-INARAJAPURAM.
BANGALORE -- 560036.
JANAKANF, s/0 P.KANDU {LATE}, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO. 12673.
R/O NO.20, 4TH CROSS, .
RAGHAVENDRA EXTENSION. _ BANGALORE - 560016.
J.J0aNwEsLE\:,' A ' S/O JAQULES_;LATE;; D. .- STAFF NO.iC250_'=, ' R/O NIRMAL£._.NILA'a5A. .. 5. OLD EXIENSKON, KR:§HNARmJAPI.JRA...... BANGADORE +=5;;o036v';V * . DKRISHNA 1v;UR'rm'~.. 2 . .. s/0 LATED[JRGOJi..RA'-0;' AGED ABOUE58 YE'.ARS,3 STAF'F'_NO.137'G.')V. _ ' R/O 4E3AN"I?OSH NIVAS.
sHARAvAfrmi STREEi';~ ..... '=R,M.'NAG'AR, V' '71 »BANGALQRE 4 4.560016.
."'s.m-*3.--i:Lr Mk;
s/0 LATE M'.R;_m'JRtJGApPAN. AGED AB_OI;fT 58 YEARS.
STAFF' NOI9493, HR/O NO.18}'I. " "AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO.I3220.
1. KRI$HNAPPA.
' MA.vR,§'-\PPA"ROAD CROSS, ULSOOR. ~ . § "ISANGALORE -- 560008. S /O LATE MUNISHEITAPPA. R/O NOA86. NEAR POST OFFICE, K..R.PURAM.
BANGALORE M 560036.
73.
74.
75.
76. R77.
R. SURYANARAYANAN, S/O LATE V.K.RANGASWAMY NAIDU, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO12871.
R/O NO.25A, CHICK BAZAR STREET. 2"?' CROSS TASKER TOWN.
SHIVAJINAGAR.
BANGALORE - 560051.
MUNIYAPPA K.V, S/ O LATE VENKATARAYAPPA, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, 1 STAFF' NO.16083, 0' R/O NO.101/1, KADUGODi ExTENs10N_,':' _ WHITE FIELD RAILWAY STATION, BANGALORE - 560067. 7 M. .
s/0 LATE MUNISWAMY, AGED ABOUT 59 w;A_Rs, ' ' STAFF No.9183;R,' * R/O GARUDACHAR §f'AL_YA, « MICO RA1\«Las1AH'5gaoUs;L;, ' MAHADEvAp'u0RA._P0_sT, ' BANGALORE g 550045,
0.JAYARAM_. -- V AGEDAEOUT59 ._ 0 STAFF' NOJO694, R/O No.80, 3:?) CROSS. ' HUTCP_II_N'S TOWN.
ST.'I'Iji~jOIV1'AS TOWN. . ~ 5. BAr;G;u,§);;.=; :7; 560084;v-- ..... .. = M.NA_RAYm5A;« . "~ _ s70_ LATE'«MUNi'£AP;?A,
79. 'AGED AB'OU1T_58.Y'fi1ARS, STAFF No.1 1132. (Q), R/0--DODDA DLINNASANDRA I)EVAI'-IAGUDI POST, HOSAPOTE.
K.BANGAL()k3'E -- 5600672 'i%;vSV;M<JAND .
_ 3/OIATE SONNAPPA,
-- AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO288, HODDI ROAD " "1's/LAHADEVAPURA POST. BANGALORE M 560048.
T SRIRAMAN .
S/O LATE THIRUMMAISWAAAYNAIDU. AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, V _90."r~1.s,S}§1I5'§iiARA;,
86. BNARAYANAPPA.
S/O LATE BUCHAPPA.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO. 13818, R/O NO.230, LAKSI-{MI NELAYA, KRISHNARAJAPURAM.
BANGALORE --~ 560036. 7 p
87. BKARIYAPPA, S/O LATE BORAIAH, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF No.4564 R. R/O No.22, 41% CROSS.
5TH MAIN ROAD.
MAGADI ROAD. DASARAHALLZ. BANGALORE -» 560079. _
88. GRAMESH CHANDER. H 2 s/0 LATE GOVINDJEE MORARJEE, ' ~ AGEDABOUT58 YEARS, ' _ S'I'AFFNO.l2612', x R/O No.J.1.J.cr2os:%g}'V A PIPE LINE. MAL1,B_::=3HVvARAN1-,.j,"*-.,, BANGALORE _,5600;::)3. ' ' '
89. ANTHONI _ .0 _ w/0 LATE c.s}LAN'M~U;;AM,' AGED ABQUI 59 YEARS, ..
STAFF No;:2806. . "
R/O NO.148",NEE3.U PLJRAM,"
THIMMALAH ROAD caoss; ' BANC;§AL(}R}?, »_ 5600_0 1. _ S/0 Ei.'v'..SI{IN'IVASA RAO. ._AC+ED';~..B0.UT 59,.y£;ARs. :3TAEF.N0.«1"4324..., R/0 D.No.434;_ 91% MMN, PADMANA.'BiLA..NAGAR, A B.S.K. I1 STAGE.
'-.,BANGAL!.}F:E _ 560070. CL££ELLAP1'->AN.
-- AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
" "R"/O NO.236, VINAYAKANAGAR. DEVASANDRA,K.R.PURA, S/VG--T..K.GANESHA EYER. STAFF NO.13141.
BANGALORE »-- 560036.
92. A.S.PADMANABHAN.
S/O LATE SUNDARA WNAYAKAN.
93.
94.
95. gs.
* S/O A..IRAé'II'-HNAM, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, STAFF' NO.9. I CROSS, A STREET, N.K. PALYA, SHIVAJINAGAR.
BANGALORE -- 560051.
AKARUNAKARAN.
s/0 LATE ANJANEYAN, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
R/O NO.520, 3.2922, R/O NO.520, 181' MAIN. 4'"-I CROSS. NEW EXTENSION, * KRISHNARAJAPURAM, BANGALORE --- 560036.
PARAMESWARLA. I w/o LATE JAGADEESAN.
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS, ._ STAFF NO.9005, I R/O NO.322, Sm CROSS, "
RAMCHANDRA MUDAIFIAR ROAD; I' MURPHY _ if' ~. « BANGAbOREg'~ 5230008'; A.MUNIRE'.DD_YG,W,_ S/O LATE ABB:AH_REF;D'a',_ 'I AGED ABOUT 58'YF,ARS;I STAFF NO_.7843K._ .
R/ONO.261/2,I ' VIJINAFURA' }3_RIl'JDAVAN LAYOUT, 77% CROSS, * V '
- 56G0.__i6.
KDHIAAIDAPIWI.
G _ Ac.-ED' AI3D.U'I 58.YE:ARS. 'L3'_I'AFF.1\Io.I11.74~3.,.V,' ' I ' Rm 897, B mock, 3.3'? I'vLAIN._ A3"). CROSS. BEHIND AMBEDKAR HIGH SCHOOL, 0 '-,D.J.HALLI,_ BANGALORE -~ 580045.
98. }!SW}\5.'}{AIAH.
S/O. IATE NARASIMMAIAH.
-- AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF' NO.7261 R. " "R/O NO.5£, RAJAMAHAL GUTTAHALLE, 61" CROSS. MALLESHWARAM, BANGALORE ~» 580003.
F. SEENAP}3A, S / O LATE PERIANNA.
99. I00.
101.
102. AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO6962 Q, R/O VARAMAU POST.
BANGALORE -- 560043, J.I3.NAGARAJA, S/O LATE JBHIMA RAO, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO. 10875.
R/O H--26. L.N.PURAM.
SRIRAMPURAM, BANGALORE -- 560021.
RKRISHNAPPA.
s/0 LATE PILLALAH, AGED ABOUT 58 STAFF NO.18270, " _ R/O KAKKADASAPURA.
C.V.RAMAN NAGAR. A BANGALORE -- 569093.
C1-{IKI{AMU§--_1VIS\?:f25;i\/IY,~. ' s/0 IATE Ym_;zxGAPEA, ' ,j AGED ABQU'F_59'_YEARS,_ STAFFNO. 16923';-1:;.._ , . R/OGVNEAR TI:fIRU1\/EAIA CTa.bLILTR'§f" V MALUR TOWN?' 56.3 130, ' ' KOLARDIS'l'R1_C'I';.fi. = B.N.G0ViNDA,VRED_DY',. " ' . S/O' LATE NADUPPANA:REi) DY. AGED ABOUTEQ; YEARS, .S'f£AFfFj 1\:o_.15933; ' ««««« --« * A R/() DEVAPA BISINALLI. * BILLANDUR POST, V :3A.N(:zu.;,0:2:«;.0$t;.uTH.
103."
. c;ANNANLA:_.Aj', '3/0 LATE .C,'HINNASWAI\/IY. AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF No. 15876, .. ,R/o NO.D140, NORTH 3&0 LANE. I.'TaI COLONY.
0' " BANGALORE -- 560016. A. THYAGARAJU.
S/O LATE YAJAMAN ADAVIYAPPA. AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.1 1431.
R/O NO.3l4l. HAL II STAGE. ESI HOSPITAL ROAD.
INDIRANAGAR. BANGALORE ~ 560008.
105. E06.
107.
108. KARIYAPPA.
S / O LATE PUTTE GOWDA.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS, STAFF NO. 18469, R/O NO.4l, 399 BLOCK, 5'1"" LANE, DASAPPA LAYOUT, RAMAMURTHY NAGAR, V p BANGALORE - 5800 I6.
VENKATAIAH.
S/O LATE SANJEEVAIAH, AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF I\§O.3844.
R/O No.18. Sm CROSS.
KALKERE ROAD, RAMAMURTHY NAGAR,' BANGALORE~ 560016. _ I VJAGANNATHAN, S /O LATE R.VETi\Ik{.l?gTAC7"r~IALA{v15 AGED ABOUT STAFF NO.3241~5, . . ' R/O NO.L§'9/9¢_"RIGH§j_SiDE;--5TH--Cf€§)S$, ' MAGADI O ..
BAN_GALO_RE..g 660053. T.E.VARGH}3:Sia:~;'.V--~.__ « - S /O GGEEVARGHESE 'EASOW. AGED ABOUT 59~.y1~:ARS. " " ' STAFF NO.__136.73, . . " . .. R/0310.180, SHAJIVILLA, 873$ CROSS, ST'.A_NNE'S COLLEGE ROAD, :<IARAYAN,AREDDY LAEYOUT. RAMAMUptmmAGAR.
» :f6A1\:'GALOm§:1» 560016. 109, '1i§.i_.__ NAN'JUNDATSvi}AMY. S/O LATEJOGY SIDDAIAH. AGEDAISOUT 58 YEARS.
STA:rF'NO.16449 R, R/O 'No.69, EAST 411+ LANE. = A .¥.T.I.C0"I.DNY.
" V BANGAEDRE» 560016.
-1310a.
SAYINATSA TC.
S/O LATE CHINNASWAMY.
" AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
STAFF N052 10 R. R/() NO.1030, 6'1" CROSS. SREERAMPURAM.
BANGALORE - 560031,
111.
112.
113.
114. KSUBRAMANI.
S / O LATE KANNI.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO.15412 R. R/O NO.E3~793. EAST 4"" RAIDAI ROAD. I.T.I COLONY.
BANGALORE -- 5600 16.
RAMASVVAMY.
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS.
STAFF NO. 18293M R/ O KADUBISANAHALLI, PANATHUR POST.
VARTHUR HOBLI, BANGALORE -- 560087. _ IVLGOWRAMMA, ;
w/0 LATE NMARIYAPPA, _. "
AGED ABOUT 59 "YEARS. ' STAFF NO.19()1«-'+.' . 'A R/O 7/9 9TH caass... am . ADARsHANAGA1%..'SCHAMARAJPET... = BANGALORE "--.56e0--1_Vs. R.NARASIMimLU;--1 S/OZLATE 'K£mL1Nr"gAM, ' AGED ABOUT 519: --':'TI_:'.ARS.'-._ sTAFF_NO4.10466.~.V"A... R/O NQ415, EAST v.1w\11\'.._ " ' 1:111 COLONY. _ . " V. BANGALORE 5 560016.';
rs/iEt1~:1;s_\'Af.¢\1yIy. ' . ..... _. . s",'o ROSAIAH {mm}, A '.4 can Al3OU'1"v.5_9 YEARS.
" STAFF"NO';],1693'7... ._ "R/'Q No.'192,w LANE. AVIVEKANANIDA STREET.
')3; PURA.
BA1'{GALORE -- 560016. APPELLANTS 1' '(By M.C.1\§arasimhan, Senior Counsel)
-,1". CEAIRMAN CUM MANAGING DIRECTOR . * 13:1 LTD. CORPORATE OFFICE, No.45/1, MAGRATH ROAD, BANGALORE - 25.
_.56m company and the Volume of production not inereaysing substantially in the areas where manual labour is :1*elei(a.n't}' the report suggested encouraging the work force to for :iI:tV)'}1,1'I'1l(.l':l'I"_"','.iVV retirement which had become an 1;essentia1"«_pfeature, growth of the company. Concern _Voioed....the Co-iLn1l:n'itltee'i':iri'its'= >' report stating that, 'ITI which hasturned Veijylrlecently will be hit Very hard finanoiaily of' Crores towards VRS is not reimbursed of the Committee also, of the financial position of the tovigorously pursue the matter relief; to the company for its sustenance. ' C
16. LearnedluSenioir.7'Colt1nsel Sri M.C.Narasimhan appearing for thelliemployees whlowhave preferred the connected appeal, 'theWo}utset, that the Apps-llant-Cornpany is the C instrurrientality:--.y.ol'f the State falling under Article 12 and the . status of"the~ employees of the Company vis--a--vis the employees th:el""'A_«Goverriment is totally different and therefore the .._lAlpple%1lant--Company cannot at its sweet wfll roll back the age of dfetirement pleading financial difficulties. He submits that the essential difference between a Government servant and an tr
-57..
employee of the Public Sector Undertaking whichitsatgthe instrumentality of the State under Article 12 gis Government can unilaterally choose the age_of'v_'i'etireI1:1e_ntl' by. u framing a rule, whereas in the gcasefof "the '(}o1rernInen':
company, it is not so. He has addressed'elaborate. arguinentsh on the aspects as to how of' in an Organisation depends upon'&vari.e'tjI factors clting"number of case laws on this aspect, 60 years as age of retirernentasvl. Catena of cases wherein the a reasonable age is referred the following cases may be usefully l
1) Guns': LTD. vs. P.J. STERLING & . _ oTHI«:_RsV(xa1R"I959 SC 1279).
,I1\aa={ERIAI;V"""'cIIE2vncAL INDUSTRIES LTD. VS. I _ WQRKMEN (AIR 1961 Sc 1175). ._ 'ifi_1}.1 8: OTHERS vs. SHAW WALLACE 3: co. . ' 1964 SC 1886).
iv} .. Iyt/VS.BRIrISH PAHVTS VS. WORKMEN (AIR 1966 SC
-..732).
V' --V}_.u*' I-IINBUSTAN ANTIBIOTICS LTD. VS. WORKMEN (AIR ' 1967 SC 948}.
The other important aspect he has pointed out is that flxation of age of retirement depends upon important factors fir _ 60 _ Standing Orders in Rule 1"/{7} to urge that since the increase in the age of superannuation impliedly became 1.)Eii:':tV."~:.(:)"f.yVi1'_l€ Standing Orders, the same could only be amendment or exemption under Section~1.0 of
20. in so far as the alleged loss suffei:-'ed:' Company. learned Senior Couns'el.___for tlie 'pet:a;.;n'.g; .pg1nfi}s that the annual statement shoWued.1:eneouragi_ng signs of the industry and when the 1"ol1I"back was taken on 25.01.2001, the company wuirhich factor has been ignored. us? "report of the Standing Committeelandi' Disin=zestn1ent Commission, he submits that they couldunot Vhaye"vbeen--~._rr1»ad'e the basis for the roll back. Replying to the asse.rtionv.oi""the company that roll back was a itVpolicyicdecisionr he Qonamgds that the argument based on policy deeie:-ionisvtinéacceptable. Even if it is a policy decision. if it 0 by infringes the the company cannot take shelter under the same. this background. learned Senior Counsel has contelndred that the order passed by the learned Single Judge 0" __ " 'deserves interference. 0" Having heard the learned Senior Counsel for the parties and on careful perusal of the entire pleadings and the legal 9%?' A.-ll 51 W contentions urged the points that arise for our consideration are,
(i) Whether the order passed by the leamedft. Single Judge directing reconsr'Lieration_';oj"' 'th_e--- " ;. question regarding roll back of the*._a'ge-.oft- retirement from 60 years to 58 yeaJ"s.legai . and valid? : V =
(ii) Whether the action of the "Appellantfionaqany it in rolling back the a_qe_of retirenient from .60 to "; 58 years deserves interference" by this {_3o'u_ri?~~ {iii} Whether the decision to..roi!,bar:kfron1-- 6.0 to 58 years can run A_c'o.nnte'r to the certified Standing Orders without p..carrying"'~t_oiitt necessary amendment to the Standing "Orders as per
22. Point Nos; athe has persuaded the learned Si11gle"V;Jfe..dgeb'éinilcorning to the conclusion that all the relevant 1naterial*s ifivereV.not taken into consideration by the _v board xvijhile.takingialdecision on roll back from 60 to 58 years, had not properly appreciated the various options gi\»e'i'1.ivytV'for.:'the purpose of cost reduction option in the report"'sub:fniite:dby the PWC. M/s.Price Whaterhouse Coopers was engaged by the Appellant--Company to suggest élrecolniniendations and various options. The Board of Directors of_t.he Appellant--C0rnpany at their 2328"? meeting held on 21.05.2001 discussed in detail the recommendations of the consultant M/s.Price Whaterhouse Coopers. The report of PWC Bf sun; 6 2 M makes it very clear that the manpower cost of ITIS was at 2.0% of the revenues in the year 1999«~2000 which was as high"
in proportion to its fixed costs, and thereforereduction 0 ' manpower cost was a 'strategic irr3.per_ative;". "One the it important options suggested by this Cemniittee reduction in retirement age to"t38'-..years'v.by andfl' thereafter to 55 years by option suggested was to provide attractive during 2000\ 01, transfer of about pepartment of Telecommunication'tiuriiq ll-gdeployment of 200 people in :Tota1 fifsolutions and Teiecom Softwaren,' by PWC are cumulative options .
can be seenvvfropm the recommendations of the }?WC, the :1neas_ureps,/voptions cumulatively if implemented, could reduee.--.theV'1nanpower strength to around 7,600 by 2004-O5 and V the manpowerv cost by Rs.81 Crores in 2004-05. The learned W H 0' Singles Judlgeiiwas not right and justified in holding at paragraph the judgment that various options given for the purpose of fiiinimizing the manpower cost were not considered based on it ' ei merits and demerits and only reduction in retirement age s} W ..
by deploying these employees to the Department of Telecommunication Services has been turned down. f"'i'1a circumstances, the observation made by the 1ca}me.d:l'S'i11gle V' Judge holding that the options suggestedby h"a-Jena: by been considered and therefore reletran}+yfactors"' .haVe».:'beeri omitted from consideration, is agaiiist the "factuall.pAositien.*" The * V L' roll back of the age of retirementpyfroVm__6€)_Vto yearsvihas been one of the important and suggested by the PWC. Acceptance theA.e5atd:"&0V}fiti§;»I_1_ 'board and the Government on the that the other options have-been considered and exhausted.
24. Another by the learned Single Judge in paragraphV'24h of the that the terms of the binding setflementi_betyveenl"the.._parties valid for a period of 10 years llhaveclnot l:1elen'«referred to when the decision to roll back was takent' It is not the case of the writ petitioners the settlement had anything to do with the iijic,reas--en of the age of retirement and the subsequent roll back. It -As as the settlement did not stipulate any term or condition "regard to the roll back of the age of retirement, reference to hlfiysame by the learned Single Judge While holding that relevant materials have not been considered is not sustainable. The other observations of the learned Single Judge seniority and experience are the assets of proper ~ company and experienced persons can...perforrn""thie: jobfin a K"
more efficient manner compared toV_otl_i'er1e'ss '-e_xfperiénpce1':i' persons and that maturity and e:»€perience'we1*e vfaetor for . * a suffering/sinking' company have been forgotten and that some and some more attention would have sayed..:.th.e roll back and therefore it wa_s?_: ll'l.reeo'hsideration of the matter, in ourleoriisidered 'vieW,' are"'noVt matters that can impel exercise ofypowerpofjuriicia1*reV§ew to examine the validity of the decision takeninr the'*matter: pertaining to roll back of retirement age. lrightlylecntendelcl. by the learned Senior Counsel Sri "matters, which are essentially impelled by rnultifafrious:"factors--"'incl:1ding economic and financial strength and \riabilit_y'af«:l*'"the company are well left to the wisdom and if":7.4A"discretion. the Board of Directors of the Company and the "'"EJ.n1on-..f}overnment as these decisions are essentiaily a policy ll ':"d.ecisi0ns spelt out after taking into consideration all the "'--relevant factors. It is held by the Apex Court in the case of %fiN RAILWAY COMPANY LTD. VS AJAY KUMAR ~ AIR 2003 SC M 6 7' M back as it was one of the compelling options and choices--which the Board of Directors had and which has been cho'se1::;'«.£The Government of India has approved the same. It "
Court to sit in judgment over such a decision as .JV[V1ivf$':'.'S8.vlJZl V decision is not arrived at in an arbitrary, teepricieeis or manner. The relevant factors'r.e'quiredA"to be [considered are-V factors that are placed before thep__(:3Vo:*r1n;i.tte\~«m,. options in the report of PWC. t)11ce.tlie is clear and categorical in suggesting are cumulative to save the companjt have chosen one or more the others for valid reasons the decision cannot be interfered with__on_th"c_ one of many options alone is _ vacceptped'. it It is openior the authority to decide upon the options to the exclusion of the others. Therefore, the Judge erred in holding that though the V rnaterials in thvelforrn of several options were available, the same it not considered. In the case of ITI L'rn.. NAINI OFFICERS "Assoc1a;TIoN 81'. ANOTHER VS UNION ore' INDIA AND OTHER - Vh ff 2oo:~§m LLN 32, the High Court of Judicature at -Allahabad dealt vvith the same question pertaining to the same company but of a different unit in Uttar Pradesh, Where also the age of w 'J aggm, different class of employees such as below board level employees and above board level employees for the purpose of rollback cannot be termed as arbitrary or discriminatory violating 14 of the Constitution. We have no reason tj._o';--. ~ contention as the classification is fou.n.d_ed on"ai1:'_intel1igible if differential between the class grouped togetlieric»andl"thos'e._left out of the group for the purpose'<--of roll-..back :Vr§:ia;pisoVyyr¢ S8 years.
25. Although several decisions fare';-,cf1te'dlclVbylthe learned Senior Counsel Sri M.C.Na'rasimha:t'n-- to s:.;'ostar'1tiiat'»e his contention that havii'1g"l'r"e,;-is-'rd generallfl health conditions and longevity and life the age of superannuation of 60 years is fair and "reasonable and the same is held to be so "in_vnur:ib«erEopi' dVecisionsv--.o..fi;he Apex Court, we cannot proceed to llinterfeie.tlfieidecision taken by the Board of Directors of the up Company Union Government on the basis of this p generaipzjinciple. The action of the authority in taking a policy V ' decision.uforrolling back of retirement age based on the report of the hP§WCband its financial position, its viability coupled with the "reports of the Disinvestment Commission, can be a subject 'matter of judicial review only to a limited extent of finding out as $6?
V???' __ to Whether there is any contravention of the constitutional or statutory provisions or there is any arbitrary or malafide exercise of power, which also falls within the ambit of of the Constitution. The correctness of the de_ci'sionf_' cannot be scrutinized or examined by this Court..onu_:the of the general principles such as the :prevailing._gen'er:a1. life expectancy and longevity which may*--_justjfy7. ag'e"ofl retirement at 60. We may very usefully refer~.to'the decision of the Apex Court in BALCO (nsoijfirs UNION or INDIA & ormms (2oo2(2) soc C333), wi1'eArein.'..the Apex Court has held that the relative merits of different econom.ic'upclicie's''ie.ririd ' cannot strike down a policy merely on the'g_rou_nd' another policy would have been fairer and better and that': unless the decision in contrary to any "'~staltutoi'y pr:o.visAio.n or the Constitution Court cannot interfere of Judicial Review cannot be exercised. p 2.6. Fo1*..the aforementioned reasons, we answer point nos. 1 & fijbagaiiist the writ petitioners. We also hold that the learned '~Siri"g'l§exJudge was not right and justified in recording a Finding " relevant factors were not taken into consideration While resorting to roll back the age of retirement from 80 to 58 years. A/' __.71_
27. Point No.3:-- The next point that requires consideration is with regard to the provisions contained under the Irid'L1_S:EIjlal Employment (Standing Orders], Act, 1946 and the__e'iTi'elot'. certified Standing Orders applicable to the Clause 17(7) of the Standing Ordersgwhicyh eariier, the age of superannuatiorrof theyhempioyeei years. The employee may also airai.E:.l'Volunta1'y lretirefnent after attaining the age of 55 yeai"s'V.by months' notice and the employee who attains the age of be continued in service upto the' ':tge--of 60 ye-ars"subj_ect__to medical fitness at the end t"éaeh]'. certified Standing Orders has become theeclonditionrfofg_seryice,of the empioyees to Whom the Standing Orders aregapplicabfle. Merely because the company has the xa"c------o«f ' superannuation from 60 to 58 years. plcannot the effect of negating the operation of the Standing No doubt, the age of superannuation even in the Standing Orders is fixed at 58 years. To this extent the the company in rolling back may be said to be with the Standing Orders in existence. But the Orders provide an opportunity in favour of the employee attaining the age of 58 years to be continued in service fir
-73"
from 60 to 58 years is subject to the certified Standing Qrders applicable to the {T1, Bangalore Unit. Accord-ingly, W.A.N0.2024/2004 is disposed of.
30. As there was an interim order ofstayé of'_4opVe'raV;ionV ofj.th'e order passed by the learned Single of these appeals, we do not fiild:"'tl,1_at this win": anys' manner fasten financial burden 0n..an3r._o'f..the employees as they have not been continued in"-service a.fler"'attainjang the age of 58 years by Virtue of the direction: ljy.Vtl1e learned Single Judge. Therefore, ilneasiires in the form of necessary un11e:(:essa;ryV§' V
31. Partiesto bearV.their costs.