Karnataka High Court
Sri Ashok Kumar S/O Late Halappa vs The Managing Director Ksrtc on 26 August, 2011
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy
Bench: Ram Mohan Reddy
ZI7l.L'R.E?~3€} "I"E"L»"{E" §3'E%ZE€.E{'3'§I} .5%?*éLi§ :"k.i.JL {f'{'}?\§E5§?LQ'L§'§%2E\3'E.'E.A.L E§§*ZE'*~£E%Z§?§.'i'§:§§ Tfj} x~:§::i' ':*:»~:':$ '%fbi4:}n £255; {':{')M.IN<} {EN §r<:>§z P§e:LE---::a:a§%:?'é<;2...iii".Ej;:'é<;:s{:1<I>:
mas.-1; ::>;'s,*:-1 "ii'H'£%: {:::11}'{.:§-2'? wxm: 'ET-ii}: §><Tj>i.,i.<>w;:'\:<Tj;: '~ ' ' '_E"%1e {E<3:'1{,i':.:<.:€.<::§° in iize R{)é"£€3«'Ti1?§f:.f'i§§§}:§1'§i._ ¥::{i§I'§}{'§'E%§i §%1.2:::§ {?a.E_Ie:d in q1.:e3s;i'ir:>:: i:E':€-tr -g_ii.;"j:r(i éfiii, 3{}£:}.._2'ETi€:if§»»<;§' Q16"
i§"zCi1.:S'£.1"'i21.§ 'I'§§bL1r12:L °»._é;r: E:II},.E}§.6/2989 {R«:3f.'1'\§<>, E 33; 9/' ZEEGG} raj é%<Et' R:
2, Pg:%é:i%t',i<-->:1e:j"VV'?§§?E:§§€: <§ui;.y as 21 <:oI1dL.:<:ii.::s:if' "§;z%_'«. §..E'i'(i'3'.V_.b{L§§.'/., Vb*e1_e;€'::;_;1'h;3 '€,c::: i:i*f:¢:;>: :"a::%s.;;g3<:}'r:<.:?';<:%:':.*:'.-- {3<}:';3<§3i*é7:'?é;'i'c'3':i:.,:3, w."E."V.'_fé';":; "~:';E*;;.a»"«:»::%:€;_§é.:'§""V 'EVE-XS famsétri {ii} héii-'€*? <:<§m.;3iii'.i'.€--{E' :;:<:%:méf3};§1fi41v%E:1:'i'£.Ees f:>E'§<:nx,s.rin;g wE":E<:h 'iihzzé d§&~:.<%§g}§i:1a::"y»;}'r:i:=::e%5di::2g'-«wézfi i;z'_;2i?c'.§:.--:1"i::<;":cL Ci€)§E'E€fE3i'i{.E é::2q:1::'}z E"z{«:§_:i 3:15}. :1 %<3._§}<.>?;:i:7'§;:,:§::::i§tt;e{i Emiéinggg' §§'1::: szhzarggess p;"<}::'e{§: Ef}ivS__{ii:§§3§iL:f:a:f3r 2:1,:iE*:'{;:3i"éi.§; 03": an i::<i<:_pe:1€E€-:§1i', 2i:se3;<_"§<;*::'.~".~:..%::*;m.::-*:m'. gf"
' Vf:'§;:-<:§é[:::;% "i'f§f'{"':§§E"§"§§E:?§'LE3..§"§*;?€EES zzzmé <-:2aT'r'i::'§::-;?.:'*:{':~.e {:52 :*€:<::>r<£ hszizi J:E.'E.2€;';"' §}€;?€§'i,§g§§f'i€;--i" ;__§u£E€.}g wf i':1':a»: §:%%:az_r§§€:s§ z3_.:.'§{7§ E33-* i)§"{§§*fE" (is. i§..€:'39EE' " %_::'2§3<i;s;:{:'r<§ ::§'2:5;*; ;:s1.::':§Shme:::'::'T mi" E%£'§§1§":?}€j§§(§§E'"i;§
-'§§C'F£E:Tf§E ';»::;:é IE :2 21$ i§'i{,'?§'%.i"ZE"'E{i"§'E 51$ Er: iiéééf E:>::5:;ie:'- _§32.»3;§; E""§,.'E.E"§'Z£E_3§.§.i?;I§":--'f;E§}§; I / <1»-
'....a 'I"'hat: {}.'zfz:§m' w%1e:': <:2;1§1e{.i in <;1.:s3s+;':i<3:'1 ii": 21. :::<:;:*:c:d.E2i*£.i<;:1 p2'c.):7«5:e{%i.r1§;: miaier Effie i':zdL::~3'{.ri2.i§ ii);-sghzxiiets A{'_T"§i., EQQ7, fix"
:e;h:3:*'€, 'HIE? A{t:t'.I :~:u'i:.g§t::7.':: grzazfézer off 3'é;?.t%;":t's;%=:1<:zf::V j':i:i:??€_i1%::
L2;:':}{7;z.z2' €",'e:mriT by 2:1": e:>r{.it';%:* of £',§1<:;* S'{'.£1?;'.é;*r {}:5:a:*s:¥§":'1__::'zé::i, Pa:'"\:,§c%::; having e:'12;'<:::'::&<,i apps3,a1"2'1:'1.<:&:g fiéed '£,E1.e:5i.<:i;;* Fé;é;spé3{'ffi'v:;§ V' §31€2£d§I1§_-_§S. the 11'1£i1,1ss*£,z'§a.£ 'i.'riE)z,:r:2"21.4inzmcésgi'--{gss1.i<:5s;_ 61:1"
w%1§z;:h *é,TE1.<;'e firsst i.s;s1,:::-2 :*<3:}?21"t.ed "A1.c>:;'£7§:.t:;§ v:_;:_E§c.?%i'i"j; (.§';£7--..&ii*§i.§:c ci<)mesiic. <3r:qz,:ir:g: §\J§:cr i'.E';x;§_ §)£?U('V'€'.if_i'.S3V'€3I'{i1r'3fi'f.i§!;§.,}EZI"i£i}'§Zif1C§ d0CL1n1s3:1é;s :}:1::s:*k.é3:€i, §::1c§L4::sEi':"é:a..'E"V.'E'r.i'm.::*:a%:.=1:;i%Lje::":%ci ihfi Eirsi. isssue in the Va::ffi:':':::1:2."€.:1€;i€*:_ 'E.':駧;{£§ng i§"'n:: 'A"<i{31m3s;£;i<:
e:1q11i1"yM'é;':s- Tféiir 21$-::i-- }3%<.3§§c':. . 1C}:': iheé I."I'§€;'ffi'{; {3'f'i1h¢:": szlzziiizeiz 'She §§§x(§'{1E::.Ei§"'i::3& "§'.'V1?"i"§V)E'Lf':vE*1é":'%;'1: , '1Vj:3:':.€>z'ci<;:«:§ 21 §"i:1:§.£:1g; i:E':ra?. {he €",§}EiE"§§£3S-E w'€,~;rar" pgfi-:'2«-'<55: Vzizééii that Efihfizm W'E:1:?§ rm Iiéjiiiéii E0 m1~:?;%:.£*:f?c"-::g'--é: zetifégh §4E}€§"'€,§i'{i€1" af §}:;m'isi1::1::*:':1":: s_ea_i1:1<:e:;é ii; wa?::<.-3- :'1{3'E:
if,§S_§§'§'€§f}':}V§;?.'§€§E73§:?{§}Eff {<3 étize §._§rav§€£.;--' <1}? §":'EfiS{",T{)E'§(§1)§{fiE*E' a.:'3e:"E 22{::<:4<>r{i1?::g7:E§;*'-'V.{iii Ef{f'i'.%:?€§ itiésé E'€'i§é?§'f;?E':{?vé'E, w E': :1 {ts ziéimégii '£",m.€: ijémit §::.E::é.*; :'<7:5;;:<3:':{Em'2E:~ '~<:;:-{H§:»€';:"z;.E:§::m fiiéi 33:}: §:?np¢:::a-=:e;<T;'. %:'.§'";.:s §;«':_.::':is;§f:.:::<:=.§':'E <53? ciigmiissesg-:1. btiii. i'.:>s:>k 21 §<::%:':£.i@m?: 'wk-"§L€i:'.';§--=' i:h<31;g}1 I'm: g32:::is'i m«::<:s1"::i ::3E' "{..i'}€% '€253"{}I'.}iI'i}.fcZ§;}E'"£ <:iis~:<":1<::+s~:;é:?rc:i 3121:: he V";-s§§§€:{§ With. p-:.1.:'1i;<:;h:n<-3:':t: <31: Em': <.':<"i<":e;1ss;i<_2x152; fax' _ ~.::3i' LL 3"£"EL§S{?()I1{i"£.'1{IE'., E~Iaa:'i:':g§; :"»:*:g.a3'd to "{.hf3f fa{;_:_i;""'i.'%é£:i*E--._: "<:.fr.€;'--i' ;}eti's.i<>':'1:a2" is; aim: in :'::>¥:ér€: in ZGIS am} E[>;:3i:'ig;i..i::.A_:i:hc: ii':-1;; _A fiflfi Of 2-:<3':'vi€;*;ex éientizzfi <3? :--3ev<;é'r"; :i3'"I:A{':I'5é';'.I",E"I't';T'£";i'.'j§_:«§'£_'i"§.§E€Tf 'E'3'Afif駧.4i1*.' gézay beirzg 23. major p:.::':is.:h:I1<3:':i':§ éazzaigs' ofj1,i5f:Ec:t:%"t>e;€;é:.i§;d rmzét in the pcc*.r.,:iiar f2u*:i.s 2z:*:§§'~--::iz"<:Lams;1;.ar1<:é;é;§Q?v':,§i:§s5.>«:'::::§;£:--. L 21.11:} ;"1<>".: m.:a;§s:,i_::g '§',hi-S as; .21 pf€:a?§%{§<::3:'., '(.i.i:'a::é?:;:1;:<3d %;%1aE:
'é.§1c=2 oreiier :3? §}L§E§iS}"§f§%{3§'iii§ s3E§é1§'E-.1:':r3%f=;s.ii€<:*i. Viihévv é',é:rmin21E b<;%'nefiis"'"§,;*é1jgf3;:ft3§&§ :f1A:';:'e:> "'£t§1€':- p<:f1i'i;E'e:*,»3é£%r an z"r€:ii2°:€:3":":€m;. EB €.:E,h.e:rV'.._W{2riciéa. V' '{¥fi'<.=?,4£:2:"E§effi""-.sf--;§.:.afi :'}§.§f', hzavee the a'~:}';':fe--:c:f;, {if d;in1§:3i:~5;'E:;':i';,g;j_ {he:>::_ 'a.e3..i"migr;_gaE*E?%€:z€§°Ei;.:s; 6:}? {Em W€)§'k£Z3EiE'1 zémzi in 21.E§_ c>'i:E§.é%::*' ~:€"a*:é1:ag3<::<'V.:_E'.§:sA':fa%:2'aiz§$ :.::'.121Eé;,<::z'::é<i;. §f€*.i.i§;zT.<;n ES é§{*ia:;=':i;'é°dEnggijg' {>1:'«:i:'~:m<i,