The State Trading Corporation Of India ... vs B Lakshminarayana on 4 November, 2009

[Cites 1, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

The State Trading Corporation Of India ... vs B Lakshminarayana on 4 November, 2009

Bench: N.Kumar, C.R.Kumaraswamy

 

IN THE :~;:$;-: saga? 0? mgmraxa AT 5g;gG{;§;@3;E  %

§.&TE$ TE-§.7S 'THE $3 am' as m¥%;;?§":%!:£&E:---2,', 2s;{i§-  

PRESEET

T:-EE §-§QA£'5i..E MR, 3US3'"'§C'E. M. §<mAaf"%M A' %
"mg mmggg MR, 3;:§:1f{:cEAv<:,fR;guyi},§gAswAM'Y

Rgguma FIRST t»%§g;;w,é;;;% %i1£;,;.sf>ei3g_r3;:g;;§

QETWEEEJ:

*3";-«:5 S"§'A,TE "¥"§?;ADIE*3V;fG'iV§:€§i§RPC'§'RAT£v€}§*iA £3!"-' zérszwx gm

£-§AvZf¥\£G yrs régm §'31'?i~'FICli:?i =m:§3:5%, 3Aa:;x;»AT:~;

cHAa:aRALo§«:, NEW &ELa2;.%wz?%%%T.w§

gamma QFFESZE 31;? i%A§§{§AL§'.REA..,' " 

s2.2Pa§sEr«rrE9 12%;? mg ?a%A:%a;<Efr:s:acg MAFQAQER

9:: 'mg BA{*$GALGf?{.$ sazmcw; 

cHAmaAx:R,;m, 1; FmoR,§4a.m;x

%{A$'f%.ﬁRBA'5%?{Gﬁ;D, BANC9'-'%L§QRE «W 1.
  A      AP?ELLﬁ;2'%§T

{s*s'k$_a:A_£ :92: a;53_a:# zmvgcargg

 ~ -- §1i;' ~.__§§i§; 3 ggasésagzzaéaamgrga

 :~.:;:: 'L335 R $AL£:§<R§S§-£§*«é;%£.A%-Q
 sazgm $4853? 59 "'f'EA§:S
..;Rg::;m:§s;§ AT aggmejg

   %   _i._£-'x§*j€SF§*:'{§ Rﬁﬁﬁ, S%%AN"E"§~*fE?éﬁ$A?;
' ~  'w_§A!%£3§AL$RE 55$ @232.



lib}

S§§"é£E £}ECEA$ED 3'? H15 LRS

5 mpg;
sza R mmxazgaaxmzaa

:v:A3<:z!z

KE$:9:?~3SuAT s¥1:N,a.£AR HQUSE
$3.395, 5"' MAEN RGAQ V
KENGERI sA'rELLIT§ Tam:  %
EA¥\3GﬁxLQRE 55:3 3%

Ski: amgxag MQRTBF  '

55% R 8ALAi<RIsw~iA:.a§---§_  M 

gym: 5 QQPAL, 9/EAEQR      
RE§E$I:"*~i$ A'? §3R§.N;a§§'«gi%i-%iG*%.§SEA  ' "
%;Q;39§§5?";eA«3§;;%.:3;;g 'y   
KENGERE s,%f€":?;VLL§J%"E,":fV§'~%;*v'§.s.   
SA;ﬁ£Q&LQR:iE5E;'§¥ :;:<;'e:»?__,  "  

S§§:§CEVVé'1.?*_EE:E;f'=s_S¥§D1:'j'?.§:f'§:* :-?+;i§:f%g';kLif;;$z.:s:; %

$:'-s---*;."r; ';"§§-£;7%§*4"E';% '§'.,:«§-j§..%$%<iAR §V%L§R"E"E-§':r'
wfG"a._,s%¢,xSKAR '%«%::R."r§~§'sf
 EvEEE:3QR,;'§'?;Ev$;_£_iB;:?é§ AT §<ER&%'§s'%_ E-EQBSE
=.-.v'Eﬁi%.E<'f'SH%*€ﬁx%A 'v'%E3%'v?%?s§S SGCEE3T'v"
.:;«§vA$A§:§aA; §<R:SH%'§ARAJAPL3R£sM mg?

 --  f8e§?r;?"%£?4'£;?s.Ef.§T3R§ Séﬁ 33$.

3-%{E?¥}€.*i}

;{§}_{_2§ . §;§?lj:1='éA:«s:§52~4;§;-s&A§§~e;§;§',A
  Z 35:: 3 maagma %«::.s§.?:«s*§, wmaa

' 'j .j:s:;;;;§g;V"' gm g. magcagwggg

35$ 3, §§~ii3~:§KﬁR ?v'§i}§."§"§-ﬁi f'f§ﬁa.3GR

  %%:iib}{4) 3%; ;<E$H,&2;§QH&:%éaR_&

3;'? $ 8%~%§§Kﬁ§{ §'=*§{}R°E'"§~s"':i i'*v'§r'3%3§R

l{¥}{fS} 3%, 3 §%,§£!§C!"éAN§§,A
ﬁfﬁ E Eﬁﬁﬁkﬁﬁ %'%'%i3RT%~%"=;Z :"'v'Ei'5"a}GR

La//%



§EF§!\§QA§\iT§ ggigggg) "re mags ARE RES'f:E¢?;E>§h"«§-E'-S }'  '

Kiﬁﬁﬁiﬁ HGi}$Eg 3%.} '\:'§?~3§'<;5sT§f~~§3r'v';?3.§.ﬁ°e
'£\§G§'?1E?~é$ SQCZETE'; QE'X!A$£¥¥'*§§RA
KRES§*~E:*\a%i'3s§ﬁ.}ﬁa?~'*a.f§.4r'*-3x%'*'§ z%G$"f"
BQEQALQRE 5&3 935.

1:3; 32*; 3 ':j13A:Yﬁ¢S;&_R§J§"Ei§,.-.  
§fC3 3 EA§_A§<RESH%éﬁ£A§:i""«. 5
:v:A3<::R    
agszszgés AT Sagmgga ;~:g;;g:;:%% ; , u
3%, 6"" §v3A3f?~é R.Q:1*:_$, §<:'Es§GE§az_§§3f§ 3-_z<2j'.s
"irmqrxi, Bﬁsi'éGEs"LQ"?.E' 56:6 @:a::;;  _ 

swag: aE:§gs§:3 k$§?- §»-§::§§:57:;_§z :   '

zggggaju ':v2';:%:.:_, s§;,aA3vg.§,"m: M3 B3
 = x:'¢,r';'3'ws;'ﬁ;_f€'§.B**;::3'A'%%.$aR;aTH§
« '?éA:i'@;R;; .L};+:E$:.wss€;; A"? ?~s<:;u:59
 %2a2'*'?* <;:;:a~ss,. i.'=?""'* §'43AEé"=E
S;'%,§*&£sS%€A.?*éK25{R£ 1: smgg
$AN'§.£g§.QR.&? m

gm; .§jmf a%§<;§:;a;A:<;[e;
 Awia é'=e§§}f'?T.V_&%('E*«%i3%¢'zf_}§?5
:»%.ag3%:,§§§ «  
§:§Z:'%§§§.?'%?;% £3. 'gazmgga é-§Qi_§S§
. 3§§g"5m--A?é§g§§§ Rﬁéﬁ
V'-.§<Ef°éGERi"1~3ﬁ§?E§..LZ?"E mwras

H M'  xE'£';§"%..§ﬁs.§;QR§ 559 $29.

  'géig ":4; X; gA§A:.:ARA3

. _ EEQ EATE 5% \!EE§.ABHAQR;3;iAl~§
 "'.ﬁ7;GE§ ﬁsﬁﬁif?" $1? YEARS
V' ;§;E§EQE?éQ ﬁe"? ¥'\éQ'§.=4§;' %WA;?\é§§7§R.Q ?;QA§
$%*%§E'§"E"%~%Efa§AGﬁR, 8r'3.,F*«iQ;§;i.ﬁRE $66 §2"?,



 

Zia)

;{§)

 ::i§;%%2 %=

SEEECE QECERSEQ 8? H15 §.,R$

mg. 5 :--4 m:f*JAKAR   
rvaajaa, $§§"?ER 0:? SECMSEE  

re 2: BASAVARAE   T ~
MGSARAHALLI; 8%~§;5;E3RA's3ﬁ{'§"§-$3 _"£é.Lé,ii:=:A 
SE-§E%»«'EG$.€'« $ES"§'REC"€'. '    

mag: C cs-;Ar=:m;ma§T;-s: 9&2:  j  
MAJGR, SISTER cw :m'E=:e; as _3ASA'«.€;{s.RA:§
me? :«4a.3e3§ muss ;\:':.::s;§+9eM%:£::i.{5:£3   * M
sazswm AW~ﬁ;"'s"F'«?E:':i'?, gas-sxzjF§e;':asBa:~:%   _ 
H'{§§?ABAQ' -  ' 1 .. 

SIRCE 1§ECE§-S:.§Q;::§ji8i¥_ msJ&%    T   '%

   

 3/Q 1;'-5?? §§<~:.,;ﬁ.re1§;§%.:=:¢v?a%."_€%~%z azwz
%%?4A3§e,§$ ;~;vr:§';A3£;::,; "3§"*? L@Q&
%i'f§%.§'E§E §'aés;f;.'§.::'s.%~iz:3;i_a'a:« 

SRELEKE-QR. ﬁa;9ﬁaj_R"?*§%f§.;F:T§s%"Z"S
_, ,§\=£E&R:" 8.;-iﬁ?1;%TI-1:-§'!A vzgm 8?~§A':?.A?'§
..  g;;§:%;: mu ;?e:.€3 Sag; _'-iY§§3§iﬁs.§1A§.

2§§}1¢

E

'V§»%~?;%;1;§:s:f?Qa
2 $';f§ ~:;-2€::€;E1j..CH;:%»s $Rﬁ.f'v%§CE"E-éi aw:
« ?*?§i'%;§'_af.§;:§;,;; '£:z@Cz°m
§E:§E'§§'f'~é$ $5?" m%<%§§:.:
E533?" gcégmgkazg £1?e§€;'3?;ﬁ& ?aA§§§§»;;

~  g ':?"'P: zﬁsma aaagmg
'=;?%é'E;%,,"§G§..; $E§"?ER SF mm w x2' §§;§§3C'%f§A.°§zi

 -_RE:T'£?;§§ E-§E;%§ E\'§£S"?°&ESS
 %i%%"*§§':";-gm? §'~§@§4§$E; ": g RQAD; £aLL&§ﬂE§$§x 9:35'?
T :»<z,;a:ss§aa m§*:am;. $J*é§§~€RA ?%A§ES%~§.



2(6) SRI. GOUTAM
MAJOR, BROTHERS SON OF DECEASED N B BASAVARA3

2929, GOKULAM MAIN ROAD
V V MOHALLA, MYSORE 570 002.

3. MRS. MEERA CHELLI W/O DR JACOB L CHELLI I   
NO.72, WILLINGTON STREET, RICHMOND TOWi\~,~~----._,'V~.____0' .:  I 
BANGALORE 560025.   

(R3 -- DEAD)   

4. DR. JACOB L CHELLI
No.72, WILLINGTON STREET; _ ._ =
RICHMOND TOWN, BANGALOR,VE"~5_6O 0;2s_. E

(R4 --- DEAD)  __-."fa..;«.,RES.RON.DENTS

(BY SRI. R1(a), FvL1(¢j'(;§j','3R1(id);IR2(.b.),"R2v(b)(I), R2(b)(2),
R2(C), R2(d) 5,_SERVEEf}1,;:.,_ -   * I

SRI. S.v. SRZINATH,,T;ADV(T)C.°L;f"EV.:'FORR3' R R4;
3. JANARDHANA R.AO',.ADVQCATE._ FOR R2(b)(1), 2(a) & 2(c);
RI(b)(1), R1(b)(3), R1V(iI)j_({t)v,..R1(b~)(5) - SERVED.

THISRFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 96 OF CPC AGAINST
'l:'.k€'E._v}U£)_i':"3'§'./lEEt_W'V_AND*D.E_CREE DATED 30.10.2002 PASSED IN
O.'S1.NO.VI.,049V/SA._ON_THE FILE OF THE II ADDITIONAL CITY
CIVIL.1U.iDG'E»,.V4:'E3ANCS-AEORE, RARTLY DECREEING THE SUIT FOR

0"A.._9PECIF'I'C_:?ERFOARAMANCE.

VRTHLIS REA COMING up FOR FINAL HEARING THIS DAY, N.

 '{'--'.V.KLlM'A_R. _J..,;DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING.

XI/A



{4} Tha Qafemazétg 1 am: 2 are the jam:  _
gcheauée grzsgggrzy; The :.%.;e§e:2:3ar2*it_g,..,aj;gg;§e§a:*;"%;:§_';V§§§:§ _*t%'2§':
smeéuié §§'"8Q;;F°;§""!:'=»{ is ting p%a%::t§ff :%§*:§3&;%_'_'a§2 
gaée datgd §.s:£}:i..§v:'§$E~.. €32' §{ _ _j"?:.:;_3i:;'3§"A"' j§;'e::g%;::%%:g;%;:»::*:;%;:;~sn  5* = "

F2;s*4;4§f§§£§;~ an téza terms g:*;:j ' --.s::':§»:*;é%%:%e"::g._.gizﬁuiateé

hargézm :P§aé§zt§§§ mm a 55:5: .33 aévaﬁse at

(""1"

she time at?' the ga§..::*.,.i«*a§Vg;-.;e.*;s=..az§;':":$;2:j;V..A: "§7%é's9:"_j%§§%'g%=§ca £s:"'£%da§'a§§{:s'§

:53? as.3,§£§,fS§§§;'i%~ V%§§;'*::"%.:*.?l.;i*§é"'--§&%ﬁ {Ema sf yggigtratéssn

9? %:?Eg gig Q§§£§; :   *;:;:;§~:?%:'g,;;'§:f:2§ ef the iermg 5? the

agreement, ziégfénaar:i:§"~é:;;":§'§"§«--..$13: the ;.!'.§E&§§'s§§;?:é€ ﬁg": passagaign
9*?€__*;;+:a f%":i':;'~J:3t'§§£:e;'::§~ é:;'2__ Q;" §§%?$¥'§ 3Q,%<§1§$1 awed tiée grazing

§'§é::*~§_3§'.%3';2« §3:1eV¥?;c;:%g~.3EéS&:§$E_. Ascaréééngéy, 52% aiéefgﬁdantg

,§..mw

 in §§.?":-"v'";.':*%':'"?é;"fVS"AT'é"1'%§%":'.*"""'?4é" 23? $25 §§§"§é§"'%"":§%"3E'€ Qifi 32% gégémiéff 

°»._;g$:;g§;§§§§':*%§_§'§:%é§ ffémi §%:3:2;- sf 'aha igagiiréézég. "§"%:%§! %:é$$'"§% grg

«:.'V:é;é§3%g%%§§L"«%;$ gm: Em ;:'§§§§::§%'? if: gzgggesgsém Q? me gsaasasi

 '.'jT~%?'§_§'t:.";%'s* Vgiissrtégrsé Yha gsiaéygiéff yggeatméy zeqaggzgé me

> '4j"A:§§;§%::afantg ta §§§'"§§§'%"Z!'§ 3592;? gay'; gf tha mrztrasi égézx ta

 ~3@b%a§:§ aéii maaeggaargs §:";§Ea§"§§%£% gaah §§ §;r2;m§*§*:e $32

M/A



C§&%§'§§"'%£$ iiértéfisassa atait. 3% aim mg: the 
ggsgeggéam €53? '3:?§% gmm ﬂag; gartém arzé is 
gaié Gfééﬂ, Eéafeyzéagztg 2#~;&§°':§ an §§e:a§;%.s*j:gg 
psgrfarm §§"§8§? part 5.2:? 2% <:::;s1t;"s3::f*.V  
Q{';iE'?;%s;E§§ was mt zgasaieé. V§~§.§f;a;gv&é*'V'  "
3.:':§,_1,1§§£;§ {ha giaéniéﬁ vzmsgg a? the
§m?;:%%%:"$ :2? :?%e 3?' §@fes%§§%;s%:$ a:;f4;'{ §"'§§§ féégﬁ &

sasét Es"; GE. E'éa,3?;§2;i€§3.  %*:«a§'%'v"i$;~i*2a§.§ffeif'i;:;> %sz;%%s§§": 'he :53

Qefanaéani  9.:'3té:V§és;':§V--%:_é"V:§§-.5'-§.::;§:i: farméégz pmpggrigg am we
s;'%;%§;*"§$%'E"%:E;'"%'§." 3%' ::V;;.§'-Ea éﬁ_%";5E':;" &€°§ §"€7§'€%i_,'is' .§§ 2-s'£:%§ 552$ ::2";s2;+:2;%*{3;'£aa?§.§=g,
E5: fag? §:*2V§:_%f;§ §:3'§:'§_ $V2.§.§'§: :%*2&:"é $5; E"ar33§*:3rassg Eajagagzéan far
§::'%e§%§€%::fg1%%?§:§,§:%:;ad:.:%é""§é4a§%?'t3s aggészgz §§"'§$ :35 §$§a:':§a;':€:,

 ﬁg ggéd §:.§:§%: ég °c23§%:_:2§a;§ age» Q3

7" _:%f*:a: §w=;%aé:<%: §€§"éé?f'jg:' %;?§§?§ azggééérzg :3: exgcazie ?1';%""z$ gaéé ﬁéﬁii

 {jT;?'3.:§ §& Fa%%'::"§§;=*2V=::$'=:;.'*i§:*;:"*';a% 4::-§§<g aﬁzgantgge {T}? tﬁaér defaagéé: 353%

 ..%:§§L1_;2&§*:"a:.trz:*: their gar: :3?' we {:'$?'s%E§'a€t§ ""§"'??:e gagéyziéff

"«.V.éi':':é;*4;r=>;f23_§*§--~é;~;a$ &".;=;%""2§?:r$%r';§§ :9 '§'§§% am am: fag' s§§::§§§z::

  V .T , p5$--%ff%:f;'§*?§"%af%£"$,

V



'*%:§§%:',:2S"'§t%f2@5g ?r*:;:*%.*;%& sizaﬁémaé 3% gagzigggés

{5} ﬁfta: gamae sf sagmmmsg tha ﬁ efe:":§a7'§:.§::§'§;T."«a:2

" "*5: ' ._
'-Qua. gt _ 'V

ergérergg 3QQE§§'&F'§£§; 39%;': ﬁ§§&:i{ §F'§§é§.}é'E*3§%?i%"':§Z_.:"%a5§i'i§'§f?£f§{§i'

Siﬂiﬁﬁﬁéféiﬁa

{6}  the 'fffiitéfé s€a§§.m%::*-*'"éd. 5";:5_%:'"?:§ "§;§'--.;*.%%a=v§'es:£a%°%:,

545$:
he did 5%: gésgasta tisa "e7::;e%::f'é;%§:é35":  agreemeaif

£%:";~§":$§G€§'§t§Q§"§ ag§'$';;e*2«e?3  mgagié a:é_{:a:= :.§;Al§"_j;'2§%i,?:'%f:;éz2i;c 6:2? agwaace

'"'" C£::;!"s%e:'§t§Q§*2 ?:§"§§?i:

Q *1"

L

Em

amsuﬁtg  " %§'§vg.;§;:$,z;a'é*:i§:.;  E:-:::aL:A 

agreaemené: %%s s':%'._~;.: 9'-,e;ﬁ.fé*,::'[K»:~".?c:«.*3a3§*_;'2.§f.:':~33T;,---., ' ﬁe am mag a €.":*""2%'§§ﬁ§";'t§Qﬁ

that haﬁgagse 231$'-g§*Q§é_§'f:.§ §_§<,37»:;:s'-rV was as: vacaéegg, i'§"'§§'§£ wem

:¢.§§'%?: aiEbv%&  saga? §ﬂ ¥?S¥§$ §§%Q£"E. "§"%*3@ §§gi§'2€:§;*'f azéiﬁi 53$: shszsg

égéfi

§r2zg"§s%g£E§;fé}§? §*a;€a4 ';Q;:'_§.%£%*2§s§ tifze Sif:§'§Qﬁ%.§§;é §§'e3§@%""§:*s; am iézexg

7. '$%;:;e3we€:.féégaég".-;;':§§j'§--:ég:§:sr3 :9 §§..§F£§"E§§§ gmgéiéeer pmgartgz am;

i

E

Thay a 3%

 u_%§§;%=é?e:§"%:%"3.é§r §§""%C§§E°':&%§§§'% ':5 pi§§"§§"?§$& ma? ggaﬁémé sf ﬁg 2"
 §é§%§'ﬁ€*§3?%€ w%':%;:.'§'*: accarﬁézzg 2% She E." ﬁefeséﬁami aégg

 ta abagééanmenézé Tﬁgn zhggg Ezayéé %'&'§&§'%"'%§§ is aha

La/*



 

11%

suit ﬂied $3: $229 'agéjagg Sarathy agaénst {ﬁg 3.5%  "

Sﬁﬁt E\£a;3?32,,i83 and the araergi-J;*§i'a3:sgs.§7."'@3525"; V'

beaaaggg af t;?'%£3 aaéd suit whea thé ._¢%:i;_é:* a§f_» §§*;j;.s':2£:%i'§k:;?.é:"'~

asgeratérzgf me gait agraamenz £a"§hg';{€%:V£-33% 5:5. a~~r:§a:~r?ié3atAV"2.v§s€é Ema
Q§!§§%i§£1§§S gegfsrmaéi "§"?:sa':;3..§A;a;;:_E§§§V_§%§§;.;:s§'§-..gdx,;é§'§Vf:a§'§ Q? the
fact that they are gutting 33% «ricer
psrtém, are rm: 'T<;:f:s;*j;'"¢:::§éiE'§r2:.;;;.:V.§9{§'*:a tsamactéan.
'me piaézstéff is ':1a:fi:*:d "§:é::2%?;%r2:.:ed aagzigansa
anal  zsasha "hag camméttas
éafazgéi in ;3eA§§§;f';?'2g§£_é$2?»}E'§é§§r'"@§§Ega:§$:'2s,§ "E"%"*;§ giaénééff

gas ;::§:g'§:..yAea§g;..: a:2}¢§' §?e;i§VE«§}.2g ta air: Er: éarmg ef aha
 i--."7V"'?:§s«'_iQ:ef';e5§*é§§f.%"2it mg as @E§";2§'s;" §§'§§%§'§';f 925%}:

his §%=':§:%§V§:*; é:§%§].g£§*:%d;:§% gzagertyﬁ if Eats éefgrzgamt

 :5  §s::az4:é§"i;;a sgéé mg ggzage Em Ema 323%: gaﬁeﬁuég

 g. 3%.. ﬁg vgigégtéfff ha %§g§§§'b§ pas? ta é:-*:*@§a;'a¥5§a% §§§g

 . ;a?§'2:§"'§?:iar'§§'%"i%% gag ma: be =:'ac*§';§»:.'?a?§ 5223 $3535? 5':/"am big mssgn

'  géssthmst §"2E§*s!§§""%§ gag ghgitar 9? mg awn {Q ééxza Ha ﬁg 5:

 X["~.r$§:§'§'§té§ amgiayae Q? the Qﬁee aggré and if at thégv



22

'""'f'

§geg:§§§£a§§g: aazemzg ﬁat 2% agweangsnaeaae §~:..%fa:%*§gaé=;;';-""iZ?§é* 

parézéeg £§%a§*§g; shsws the 23'? ﬁefa?'":é;-'24:""2"{"§**:._.31s'%j:*%a2:.§é~é': §{<s*2«:%.w%2«;

eager: at the time 9? the agreameniz, Q§'?§3e.§$ert%::;;%%aE'r. ;z:§g§§f:':3:;r:'~.

area was :2: aarémt mg 325$ a:.:ef§:f:aa:';%:'--~.%:§aVb%f'§2 '§a:3s9"'st§3erV

Qsﬁém, zine péggnzgﬁ gas-s;:%2;%i;;era1.%;fef%2'a,g%i%LA¢§§:a«::a§LV:e"%§ag théa
baanze saée §§§'§C@ egg get  fémr fmm
ibis deferzgégsétf :3A._g«:g:eLv§//3§i*%§%§':é'~%;s§§§%%zgA, in these
£§:*a;:_:§z*':s:a:*:c9;s,.  3? his §¥.«'*J§":
ashes,  .§§.%§é§§§ gamané arzd marge:
wig §ef~r;maa&:..§,: ééeai mx fiééfzg {ha swag
 g:éa;'%4;;7:§'f§.. afVbaé':2:;Si§%:e§: ftééa agreamesét em fagriéaag

aggaéiégiﬁﬁ §é:* .5:3.44§'ﬁ'%;?§érar2: grggartyg émggactgé the same am

 éaiay "::.:é"'--§fs.}rvV":§%%:.*:._ :g:*§:'£a§g§:2g 35435? §<§'§€3%*xf§'§ m 5: $5 mt mg: it

vVV"'§:V;*<:;:§§%,"."" z"§§a2* iﬁﬁﬁiiﬁi sf the pigéntéfﬁ, gartraged Qy
 we $§8§;%"'§?:§§: maﬁa i.-mg sefenéagéi Ea §€§§&'%£%
 me: enfarce Egg rigm: gags; the agraemaat aad
geggtéatéag far sthgr §:"Qp&;r'€c§8$. The géaintéff ggaéﬁ

 .;Ei_$&2§;§I§§§~ adxgagéaa ate this séefenﬂagzi: gsagarataégr 3:23



:3

R$§25,§$§/~ ta aha ﬁt éefemriant. The pﬁaérztéff %ﬁ54.f3f';3.:.ff#j'§'§'}{

aware that the first ﬁazss" pgrtésn Q? the guétf 

mésrzgeié m 3% wars 3%': the QWﬁ€{$hg.§"'G§.zﬁé'2Q%'§;?f'3:§%}d.3'ﬁ§"~'

anaé Fm-they the g!aérztEf:F"s afficars ¥*sax;*::2g<.5€§§::2;é":;%:*~

ta: Eangaiaye am bemg in zg§ge?r2i<.L'f2~2;ea §§~f..;a':::;cf':7;"€}:'2?:5é5§'éi?;a5t5%r:;:2
sgaupéed ma férst féasr an{ §.~ .?;_?':é ;2E'f§sT'%;"25:j§'*EfVV':'::.._§§ab££"t:3'"pay far
the ma am scsugatéan acm:9§§;s€g'gssét'§11;§.A.§';~gg%§é_'§§:2g :*a2:£-*;_§ far

$Ls{;t§": a§c2:r*:.r:2:3daé:§g2:2;.'_V'j--1:2e§:::a3;<:i.:'..'e*E«.Aé§§';:g___ §:'3, the @§3§:§t§ff

mnfarary ta '--._a§§._ ﬁtaried §Z3§"$SSL¥§"§Z%§"'%Q the
£§%§%ﬁ§ar§t§f Emﬁayérgg §:;s%§  hégfg réga £2 aha mézéigt far
$é;£_?"*; ba.:;';a;j(3;:3;'%%;:sv;$ a:'°§::§'~--.f:§a%$,. "'%'%'§a p§a§ni:%Ef'§ mggrga :2?'

:m'§as:%:j':.%§'z_;'azg:;:h::'£;:€~--gartrgyg §§'$ szargé the: trgéa gefeadggzt

I §%¥'&$ reTgi;}7§s:f§%§iéA--".'f:.$;'t:Ezéza first fimy am ha axgg-"tea iéaég

?.f§$1?&;§:d§Ta:"%'; é::.§1;;SA;%§€:*&%3%§m2 is 32% ﬁrgt ffeasr am far azxseaagtégﬁ

 s;'?7V.§4§*:§]}§§Aa;§¥e£"»§§:e§;; mg gﬁaéatiff agaséieé Ema €."*;i&?§:Wﬁ5§;r°§% ta Q92

Z Egarsq £§&&§"aE'E£$ m;"t§f%£at§: 3% ﬁg: {ﬁat gzsigrpsgef me

VVV[f}g:2--§.;3§§*é*:':§ff' ga-ya 3 izragg cggy Q'? tag draft saga éaeﬁ gégagg? $3,; it

 éa:§;:§£'§ was gives 2:2: 2% Enmme Tax ﬁaparézmergi am



'LLV':_;'a:;:.r_§'a;2":ez*;€: axeaateﬁ ':23: him :3 gm: max-zg ugm tfzam

s:§§ara:':s:e gstaéneég Ex; azérme 3? gig ;',>§s;$g's$§:%s*§V«- 

the agreesmergt anﬁ the agave s%i::,;a:i;.:n .c:§rc:;'_§w9é?;:};7a1'T%€.;éé,. _£;=§*:s§., V'

gaéaérgiiff is eetaped fmm éaéméag 

the: agreemeyzt :9 Egg it is tlzza  éééétg §**s--as§'v_jc§:--§§*2%§':§€¥:9§
bread: 3? the ta:-mg 3? the £t:3§':ts*a;t';'  .'_'?4'Ei§';«_«t,._{.;¥ef9;?2'§ant§ has me
athsag' prsgarty af mg ca=«22m  am
if 333 Es faraeg ta  Efiasg grad he wig

mt be having 5-5';iy.-'1,:1¥b,§:'§c~3--. §:5'*5f§é;:'é Vém::%&x.sen 'ca gagycbage

stag? grspeétéag  mg? 559% is: gpéng $€E':e'€§"§§
§a%»<?:s sf :*m§a$$"'--:=:=:4_;'21:§   i:::%§"'_§§rceg étzi': gaffer ;*rret;*%a:sa§£';A
__..._{8} é':§:§.::f%;'*;g zhe?"'£sgL__;_§fs£% af iféwa tréaig the £5' dafenéasat

am-!?§,_ '

 "§*-€23~._§§s§ai "yagragsantatizzag 943; am ms}; ﬁéeﬁ 5

 '%..x,a;;*%:i:§:':"§t§%{é:*:*:§%%f%:_ ééségésegt §"&§§§¥'aE§§"':§ ma aéiggatéms ysgéaée Ea
_ §,=§*;';e;44és{?%t:e$*; ~.s€a;t%§°s**:e:":z sf '?;§'%% 3;." §%§%§'%§&E'%E§ 'E'%:a§; £§§%é"'?"%%$
 ':i;4_"§§3;: ggégi gmgertxg is 5 gain: famééy grgmrty. it ﬁéé mt

V' §é':2:-§:%§és§%%:e§§: §@éa§*:§ea§ as $339 3" dafenaant and therefare éiéza

ta/J



{9} Lagaé iapregemtatévg !\:a§1{::} alga f%Ea?§:.§'" g§T;§§a?%l§t€%_¢'T 

wrétterz stgtamanég €Q!"§§i§?$?:%§'%g tita ciasiéé '3§":«r: 7%"%§§§:1§.§' 3§.'.§;".2§"%f?§§'1
3§§§§%'{%§¥°E§ maﬁa $5: aka wr%t:er2.s::§:é';Vné'a-*:.t §%§e>:%r_é==g "§:§§é';+§'«..
and aim $Q{'!§:$!§C?%€.§ ma ag:'é*e.;:i:9:*::=-t3=:*':§ '§§_ ég mi:

&§'°'§§QE"£&8§§§E,

(1%? 2"  §=-éés Eegaé
regzegentaétéagag    ' mm rﬁa Leggé
%'€§%"e$%:"%%a§%*e£é'"'  :3'?  aﬁéézianaé w:'E€:%:€§'§
§ta:§:°:':$§'::  a%§agat§§a§ maﬁa 5:: tree
Qrégéﬁﬁé %.sg;*::_ie:%' g%:g:tsas:"%.&%é%;_:s:1§ gaugﬁz far éégmésggé Q? 33%

Sizéétg"

{..§3L:e= ?§§  :§i§;~§§a§ yegrasemaatéasag Q? éiescéagaé LE;

_ €?§§;§.V{§} §éf..§g§e%$g§d ééféﬁéféﬁt gig': ﬁgvg fééag 3 §"ti"?&¥'?"§§

'._'_'a§a§:%L_'::::;r;:;§"'-':.;?§§ zﬁsréértegz s€:gt'a:z*:§;*;é; fééeﬁ ﬁg L,;%;, §§§,§..{E§} :35

"  i::9;}'=:éa§ :%§ §§§€§"§§§§"'%§: ;f§{3,fM

V.



1%

{:2} ﬁn aha afgyggaéé péeaaéngsf tag fa%§§2:;:%%:2:g:

are §z*ar"§2e$:   ._

"iggaes ﬂamed §%''': 15*' 5.'.1"$&£€f"§?":§?é§*»; };§8~f:§: 

1, Eﬁihemar 523%: ﬂied $5.23; t§2é'*;%{:';s.;n4:Ef§ ;:=:.7§:<?:3:§;";§eVV;3'*--@g4§§"" 
maéztiaénaééa? . V    

23 zfghgzhar [email protected]:1;§ ai':~1;§:"s;., 7.w§:':féu"= ]:§e.;§e:,£ Qr
exaaggizeé agreeme;}2:.£é§:--s:3'§véf§._  'V  V

{ta be  r5e;.azf' 'ég"' the
§ef{si;r':§dT§a'2*:£§i:4;._v s§§§ég%e:"'~r§§:§r§é;'"<31""E9 exemte an
ag {ﬁe mfg} at :V}'$a::§le»'?v ,V':5   " 
¥%;he:h'ia§ s;g§i'_;ié§reé§ ;$ mt gugpmtaa by

LA}-

V ;;;>r*s'$§:f.§e:*$t§-;:_2f#§H'§* "
.   ﬁe 't;3;§<ar: ":*é a3:§§ as -~ Whether ﬁne suit
'  was ma: gupmrézad by
V " . .fL'Q«{%§v§;§éV?"$*:f§:§E1':9*:}
--V 4, '%§?2;!;?}é!::§f§é';4"V gm: agreemagzé: ig zgséﬁ as"
  .. Vjggrzezzfieraeagéa?
T: '§V,"«.%3§.é1a:h9;r Qtaéntéﬁ $5 wééiéng ans"; ready ta
  gerfarm its gar: sf cantrast?
  iﬁgnethsr suit: agreement has been abagzaenaa

by giainiéff?

1?, waetmr time was agsezzsa fag" Qentragt'? 



$3' Wﬁeihar the sefenéangg gzmlae; that; if;"t'%§§fj_ . . : 5 
sag': is Qacregaﬂ, they wééé be $13": :§__' f'g%*:«ge;a?'j%j '~  %

hagﬁghig?

ziixdééiégaréaé $31,293 frgmeé Q{"'$j__-i_3.§?;Q{}.2; i"

"':A§§:ei;her iha §a.{_;a§ r§g:.:és:éa§:':g;1tiy;%s«.§;§ 
gamnsj défﬁﬁiiaﬁt §rfs*;zé't_?f:a?é,tL itjigééy-w.g;ré'~gn:§t%ea ta
tag damages far a=:::.1;.{3§£_';£:,;r1.v .{::2f:»  avg zha
géaérztéff, as Q;;'lef$§E:~id tha--:.%gr'§t':Ta%§"a§:'§§§efnen:?"

(13) '§'§':e"g*§;§§»a§t§f§'§ én_"zzagféar éﬁvégtabiégh éts agssse has
examéneé a?r2;e* %§a%.V "§}%;:f§T?3%*%._é'%%..rag ?'%!a*~1§ gsrséagscsa 43
dacumani-;--v:&g%z:c?é g§*e~sf:'2aé*-§<éé as EXMB1 is $45, an gehaéf

éﬁééfge_§ss:=fé:%§§V§';~%§§ Sr? ""  §epa§, Eagaé ragraganiaziva Q?

éafe::r;§3§_:.J* %~.3§;..f§;_  axaméneé a3 §xe*§--: am me 332:?

 §~%e.ma§afé%':g iéiééaaééas aégga gxaméﬁéé 35 §2é§1~«2a Em fact ag the

,  }§ié§'3;;;'§:."§::g«;:_€:g 3'; am: 2. aéiagrgataé gm grsgexy, the guraézgggrg

 ?%*:;a§é gariéeg, 5:', Eamb Em Qhetay wag axamérzed ag

%%'k++§aa;é3g may gmégsiaé éﬁ aéi 33 agagmentg whim are

  fma;*i<a§ 3% gm ta 533$ 



2%

gm; Sr: €::,€v'%. Saga, the éeamas £:::;.;n3e§  
i:2':& agzgaééantg aaaaééézzg tha éavégaggséad  
Q§§'§§&§'3§§ %'k§E"%&F% agreemawi sf gaaa $2 
aéazamge unégr the agmeman: af s a.§g %gV'":::ﬁ'§§1%:tewr:§;'  

géaémaéff wag ream: am w§§_§mg %::,';_.§§=~:r§_?a--»e':_;':r% éimggartfi Q? tha

mnmcz, whee :2: ii; the de'§%:é:§as;§*t;:s?§--.g%g§°£{2 ':$':'zf§;¥:étt§§ gram:
3% the temzg a? :%2e_::s:{§*;vé:g"ac;g:; §$':'  Qéé mt hand

was vagagzt §Q$§é§§§j5§:§"'§ff §'§E§}§é§§Q  ggmrtém as agmesj ta

sage; téﬁei:e§'§:4éé7..~vs3§_7.:§:--s$ *~«§g:&ame::tg iﬁa ma: Cgurt
aamméﬁed a~§;és"%:::;:§.. §:{:*::_§*'"*«..§§":'*"ﬁésmégsérzg zéze 32.55:, s? the
g§.;ai§:2§é§f§'E'Enufa¢§ £:'§':§':pf§g§é':t%§*§ madera as attamgt tg émsieaﬁ

?'zém_s§§f«.§g  $§.3:f:*:_ﬁ féiea. .&§*;=as:' a éasrag wag gaggeﬁg ha

 Q:'@§a:';3e9':§..a:*%§§;::@;;§§';  Tug 35$ aggeaé agmg 3:'; be é%§m%s§ed

M;%"TT.&§y%.:§:s mgégzg ma: iha §§§':§§ﬁ§ raﬁazéaﬁ an tise ggéé

9_"$::%izff»%§§a.;f3;:':g ihé naimyg at? $29: g§*@§i;+;e:'%:§ yasgagiﬁ mi ﬁg

' '~'jT~%%:::'s:§%:%'=gg 23$: him gang am mm Ea at :§;e:~2:y ta gs mtg ms gag

 "'=€.§_:'.4:}.I«~2$'4:.%§<.:*.m avg: and agaésa. 'Sim:-2 aayiéeagaa gr; %'&m:*:% aiaawg

" aszaﬁéégéégs ma gag 5:55;: £3 3 :§%§:_:g§aze am: am 32% §'§"$§%§§'"§';"

'K/%%



H}
w-

QX£§£.§S%¥'§§3? saéarsgaé ta the 3g' Sefgsséagét aﬁﬂ it was mi:_

jam: ?am%i*=; Qregerty aizﬁ therefare ﬁe gubmézs =?;§*2.ie '::'_é':g3§

Qmrt. mmmétieﬁ a seréazgg array :5:  1_;%%%;ai*;V'_~
agraarsaené: :5 vaéé, gragartag '?;r*:*:§:*;2;:'2g$ %'.*;E *;?2E js;%;':§:'v§.;§§'z';%'§"s;: s.2sf:§:_   '
{i''§$:§'&§Q§''% 6:; gaéa Ezgzigmant and %§§§"-3% :;'r:*:§;L2§:*e;'s--.i:%:': 3-;;,%§§:{%'

aaéaie am ééiifﬁﬁ far :-zaggeszéféa §ar?%;é_§'§s-'.§af'2£&%'~%$; -1:':  %

{1"?} Fa?" cmtrag tag éélaémeﬂf'.{:§é~é.;vn§:§Vf_aégaggréag 'Ear tﬁa

2?" :"§'§§%n§%e--sv;°:%:._§§%V;9'*§;':%£:%._»':;ut'«€*f:%*'%§'5.___:':'?':§€e:*§a% 5.32:': :'*eca;'€.% i§§f§£§®S%S
when iiée $3 §§§es"2§aé":té:%%;§"'%--§  é.'}§£§.§§?%'§Z%€.".%§E Q5 2% Gfsamaé
fE::~.:f::::" a:3§i.«ré§g3§~:;:2;§§.é:a2..:s agggsaié £§§"'E.§ §s.a;*:§ ave: geggaggéazné

:§'%é<«j£3;'"'~?5":iQfP~..:f§§§§**:.:*£a:*:*':a f&§"a»*a§?£"%»=%.$ axacaia a wig céew 

 '».._zfié§§;e;:.ﬁfﬁéég ;i?é.'}%'§iZ,§§§'§k Ha L£':§$§ Ea %£¥';%é§§:E*;§£:é;"'E 5% $22

1%

 %:j§§':§E§$;:" g.ﬁ%§«:_$:;m;§:t§z§§y ha §%§§'a;'%§"§é '=£é'§€:§§"§{ ggggeggégn S?

':..'_'%t%':.;e"«%?;S'§.Vfémr Ea Ema §%a§§"r:f:§§. ﬁe 2.?-{sag :"@§§*xg am '§'2i'§§§%§"';§ %:§:;

 ma gaéa ﬁgaa'  ?§$§§.ﬁ :3? hig am? §:'.::ré.§m'"2*

 '§""§.%5'43:T'§="*-»s'§.;*¥§%' %.:§':§ §%a§§*:%:%§é' gazga mt :?%'§§§%§'E§ fa: gar? garfarmazsca 3%

'":%":§ a§§'é%§"%"E§;f"%§'; :3»? 35% '%"'%°*:g*~g érzgégtm 3:? £225 ;}@?§§%"§""?§§§"z§§,

xx/A



22

Yhé $2.5? §;§:§"§%%'%'%"%E§%"E€Z§ 2:s;§§ gm: mggéigéa %:}e:s;._z--:.:.§é 
iétégaiésa ans tééa érsiarém mag? gagaafil  
géyazgmszaaaes ygéaaa *Z§"%§. §§§§§*%%:%;*'*r§"*  §*9:2?s;éTgad'--_ ?f3v%"«. 

m°?:--s3ar:~§; :23 £353? 6&2; fa-.§37::ig.s= gm

$""'§'"

$%:¥1';§"%:%%':'°{%§§"§€§ sf iiwg: asﬁizaaig §

wéééézzg Ea gmarfarm Esig §}%§'%:'*'§§ %?§:a;é""g;*::§L_§°;t;r%s.':f* gg '?%'§?..:§{':é.  mi E223

age}: £332": 33%' %':§"§€¥"EfQ€"§ :%":%_ gztéigéaé 

Sagas far $§$g%?'::~ 35; mt ragéy am

zasiiémg ta §$2*f:3:*§%f':  -:,t§r;:2?:;*a<e:*ta "'?%:§:;g%: the trig:

mags': mg ﬁg: ;:sréVis:'§ai:g::%gi=a;*:% ::3é~..::;ai::2r§a§ gr; §'§C%!"§ fmm ihég

aﬁgéa am :.s§§§%"?:g_%:&  réggrgag ﬁg: 2:§w;e.::ea: Qam; ég gag:

39:3 as:~iM%:,sé.?:';§:)i%g§%§:~ am 53$ :';as& far észiéréarsangg 23%???

%;§'*gé.gg§V§«.§§§§§§§g?%éﬂ:,,/-§__ﬁ§ iééfifﬁé Ea maﬁa zgzgtﬁ

gig'-'1': Z§:%v":§§.i%;--=: §%:;'3?:%:, 3? iﬁa §§$¥"§;'<'=';§§§ faﬁa gaﬁ ma?

H"§}§%2--%:é':":.:%§§:2§;V%:§§§ gmgzig §':§"%&§Z' éfisﬁ 13%: 5:21;? $Q§"§;'~'f§§§%§"£*?;*§§%§§'§ at

 3;? £5 agrgaégw: 132



23

1) Whether the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform
his part of the contract ? 
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitied to specific 

of the agreement of sale ?

Point No.1:

(19) The materiai on  kcieanriyV>j'i_:eVs'ta'b'iishes 9'
defendants 1 and 2 are i;13,~gg_join't"'V_g}gqnVersA.oftthe"scheduie
property. They entered into:_;(j_f..sa|e agreeing
to set! the schedt.='__!;e4'ﬁ;prop:érti{  for a sum of

Rs.4,40,000/-.  reduced into writing on

1.

4.1981 wh.ich:_is' in the case. There is a recital to the effecit th-atA'~F§'s...§'O,00O/- was paid as advance, theiﬁtieerendant, Rs.25,000- to the 2nd :_"-._fi"hfe.::d:efendants agreed to hand over vacant V7.vVf:""-ipossession oV.~.°.'t'_h§;-'f:;15" floor on or before 30.4.1981 and the '"*'f.--Tg'rou»nAdgfioorion or before 31.5.1981. The balance sale con_si..de»ra.tion of Rs.3,90,000/~ is to be paid at the time of regi.s.t--ration of the saie deed. The said amount is to be 34 gaétﬁ is': iczagg gagargia iéemand ﬁraftg :12? _ Then tﬁay ghaéé gamer aaazant gssgsgsgégzz 5:15 gragzerty sémzgézanemgaiy aefsra gariiéés as as: digpzgte tésgw %:a§*%fs_f:f;a;~*:._ sf terma $2" the gtégmégtéans ;_:an:a§VA:;.égdf~ ;::~.._.:?zé'é§§%gg;§e::: af saéeg mg 2"" éafersdant a«*;%;%'::: "§s;a:';:__v324;} :2? we 15' §%as.:z:* gariéan gf sage? vacant §Q$3%$S§%§""%. "E"%*--;é __:a %a$._: is' ;':%%'SS@S§§%%"§ sf tﬁe gmmédﬁ féaaég ._ is sgacata afizar gemgring giiarnatiaga 3r;£'z:2L;3':r::aair:a¥:%§':::«r "*--._ééé wag amabig :5; hand? may §Q.§$$§3§:3%}§ i§s:::?z~* %;e;a§#§:V..§'f a§%j:e::?2a%*,éa:& aacﬁmmgéaiségn' Bag: 3? :;:§&%V;:~gg:2%s;;::; §a:%%;:§I§%%;m:%:e;» mag a 323%: GS. §=;g.3*;32,zg3 23::

:' <._§a§"§§i%€:5'§.éﬁé ;a;é'§;v3aéA%::=§§& pagsaggém gf §":%$ §%§§?.:§3"%"'%%5:€ gﬁarg én _ '_T'T~%:_§§¢§e'V§j%§§§ §§;=§é;§:zé §§ 5% §s::%:@§:.:%§ §§'ﬁ§§?"§':i; w%z§a?: gégaég $52 '._'_€'?%.& am 35*' éafamsni. %%e %%m astaéaad as": §%''ﬁ§s' ' 7;3§_"fE*'&rﬁ%p@?arg .?és':3i;.s§'°:ct%s;r2 ?"'é$E§'"a%€E§?'%§' the E" €§%?@f":§§§"'%5: frag? ' 'a.§,§4é':'2a':§ng aha gmgzzgg-%:%g, T§"§§§"ﬁ?2'3%'% %:§*;§ agﬁtgasé améﬁ mi "$9 §é?"§{§§"3"'§':%§ $2; §€§§i.§§§t§d. "Egg 3.3?' §%§'%?E§§&%"%§ wen: gr:

R/.

taéaéaeg gxégggéga cf iiiéme 2:9 parfaarm mg part 9? *:§'":;gV~::--3:':f2;é:,%f§%;*:%;*.:; 323% m Em 2"rs@&:°:vv§":%ée the 2" éefaadaﬁi w%";fs;__':%é<aé5§'?{p :;2%f:e:%s§*-.T with §§gge$:~;§a§: Q? the ﬁrgi fiaar =;:s?2%:%§"%,%%aI§« E5: 7?7;%$_:§2§S'3§:~z§.§iz;3:'*:x'v~, amt'; wag reaﬁgs @523 wéééing £33, §*:g§g:;?::;*g"«i:%é;e §;'=.e;%.é; rggpégt 3? ha? gsriégn, wmta 3 3%; gag: ;'E::s:;'%i'?:?""'r;i%§fit%"2$ m,?z3~§§.:i ag §.:%"':€3§&§': h' i "ii"? ms*:*t%s":z.s$€%m G? <*:r4.a's';*_AE§§*:€:a:g;;"vv &§V;a1L%:»§§€c§%__8§' Emzé ":§83;,, my §f§§ﬁ££ Mr; 5, §,a:<:*§.§:z'éf:§r;'avr§'g%:'§s%*' Wm 35 §'§S%§§%'f'éf§ '3;V§'V?'z'3§7";%EL?"; 5;"-§'§i%::':';§'§i:§~»'fF"§:3s:;€_7:.*§§'""%§'2§: Q£"&£§"'§§$sE-';§ mg ga fag-'=._ §"'s§4:;§i '%:§é;;._ s:s§'e3_ "§:§' geszsre &§§é§'"§E§%§*:.,«*& :::s:.§:"* bag: affsgrigg "ﬁe V a%5§;§§*:*:§L%;ga:§i'€a;e7;__V_V"%%é $%S§ are ﬁiffarergt. . """§T%f:é'*séf::'§=e2§"".:g::§gé?"%:§9iés@ sirzsgmsianaeg E wmgéa geé: ?"$;.§§;;'?;?é§'§ﬁ 23%? my ghg-3% 5:3?

%?*;§";§:':..:§éVé%*%:*;:.'T1'2*g:%€:%*2 2£5§§§E"%i §§S$€s$$§®§'3 g? 31% ﬁygi fims b*g<'v§?a;§g;ém;g ifzg méaszaé ammmt :3 ma; 5% h $3 :r%é:a?;L"

{E33} ':*'%*:§ gem %&t%ze;r° wag ﬁagbg gassgaﬁ am ﬁéé Qiaégéiéfi, V '"'~._ i'§3%a§.;%:%§§ §°"£%§§§$€Z'§ 3% 9%: E24398 sagéignaéﬁg €323? ma §'.E§"§§§?"i'§ émgégg?'-2% is $5; seési ég ﬁwfééﬁ jaégziiag gag bath {ha ﬁefegzagnisé 'A/.

2% Tﬁerg ES 529 ggecéféc am sagsrata dézségém cs? tag pj_ri3g'§9;§i;[:~«.tj:;¢~-..__"" _ tgxsféégh gas'; EEQE sf tﬁam has t::t?;vj%-am..." .'§§§éf§"'ei?; t?'s§g&-._ zzéraumgtaszcagf it 25:: mi: gsgsébie fez gQ%§*;2g° ',?§':44 :"é%;J;§t:.r1a%i«fgV:;v§§i*---@591i the 3.5' ﬂaw anéy as §€J'§§$§t*2:;';gT~..__f?}%5{ %%'€av..2*7§ 'v§j;%é§é'?2<'§a%%t. "§h$3e§are am; reguegigﬁ .£';;:?'<;':::;%*: g§"'%?:=¢%?2VVi::':. ga§?{;:~g-..ga§e dam registergd as agreed and géﬁs AV_::'1'&'§9:°%'V 2§a;;é*;ta%_i:.=:.*:" 'gasgaggisg 9% :5? reg: Q? the Q:-s§;;*x:?;%;;§*f%:-is ts: a:x;:*§%d4V§:::%?f£?:e%1;fV:VVisembarrasgmeat. Giza mare mtg?,§s«s:3_§;,'_§@::r:9¢é§$-«r;'§':'agg :§.g:' E><,?% an 1?..&3;§'5:é $3; the 2% d';%f%:%d:éé€v*3:Vi;s7%:%:e,ﬁi§m€:%%?? 25:'? r mg ihem that we :5' def@rzéa?:§: é§ ﬁr: is Séiiiéfé a%?;e:'s*:&%:%2;% g:v§§;':"::'r:§:3%?§s¥%:§x:";:*L .. _ ':%~%& er;c§Q$e@ a mama: agreemegét b§e'-:%é;}e<% E5' Séefamant dataé 24s3ai§8ﬁ whécﬁ §*;%::.32n;$<'§"-§é:*§:'V'f%§::~:"'§%;ag iésg exaéugéaze gagsegsém 352$ _ T.. §ﬁ};:symé%:%.. §§'?:%2¥é 2"; dafendarst ﬁﬁ 2&3: ﬁg $3235 iransfér ﬁég '1._'_"'§24}iaé%fLj"s§:é%-e gm gxsiugéase $$$§%$§§§§'§ sf iﬁg 11$' féasrk Gaga " iT"%s.*:*j%§:*é'§e€;t%:* was 2;%;:'=%%%e:'3 W Em 2% §%%$%§"§$§E"§'E ag ﬁg? Exﬁii * fA.:§_§v22,$9,1§83_ briagmg ta wait ngtége that ha hm fixes :,:g 55 gyagarty at Mygara aria he ig mééy £5: 339$ em? mamy ti} 2"?

gggychage ma gamas '§';?:& @395 <3? the §;'Z*:%;.§%Eé§%"§g he had;x§i_:f<{§§ :3 R$'l§?§i@QQ,?-3 me :9 urgeagy in tag agggé'-:*a§e§ :9 the géaéniéff {:0 gfgzaa mm_a.,V§;.:r:§2€es*"'g--;.<:§'$séé':~§e--_Q§ ' Rs§§,,?§,,@QQ;'-~ ta grgcaéd with the prggeﬁy giangéng vasatém 53;?

grageytxg beébra ,;'§§t.}?;m1§§'*.::E__ ar';:3~~~ u§r€1g."'a§$a é':<§_§a%.§§e§ 923$ Qéfféczgéties in mtg ragaré. smménﬁfsgé mi?

tag ﬁiffészgétéeg ex§§;%.~:§:§'-s":caf§ :ﬁV§é%&'~'VV%E¥éVb§%$ﬁE$a "fhazg stagk ta :%*2;.§ S§§§§V{:'v_'v?:?%f&A§I '§Z".§'7%é"~«;;»"?'f;§§'f§ﬂ§'"%"E&%""§'§ is me am améesg égiéxggs-x; 95 xs5::;aé*a%: §£;V;€:,§e$:=.':%:_{§:.*.:_ 'i:s'2?"the gmzsné fieer $3 §*'§§%"'E;£'§&{;'1; {wiser Ea :§i%fg%*¢.a§°:é '§~,>.:;§t%: §:;§'t?:em exscuta tifwa gaéé §§€dPa {ma §§z3::+§:;i:.,:£g3:§A;é:,§: b§ mmpéateék {)3 $553: rgfasgai, 'hm': i';§"':% «f§§§%?§%:i§$.§'E--i§ s¢;ééf'{¥§§;;."§§§& mare Eater ea :2§2.:@i82 agaézt ,_§:§§g:gé§ng "§§§' ,§é§m§mt af §;%s.1§,§§§§fQ§z»~ 352$ agrgaéng is ' '§"'§§§73}i{i§ Aiaﬂgkagf téza remaémmg wrtéasz Q? Em aaééaauia grime??? ' .'ij-:a_g1'§€?::s§';txééa mmttza Siiié the; ;z¥§§s';*E§ff gig mt regganaé aéggugtaa asgiiéw the aiétmée ef §;§"'§% §§ﬁ§E'§§%§§, Eéw 2%' Wﬁefassdagzi wrgte a éatter gs: Eéﬁhiggz ag gar ﬁxﬁéi? 28 afferéng is Féfégﬁﬁ 2:313 maraaey w§'2§<.:%'; he has r§3£.§%i:${;%L'a%n'g2..'T_A V' :'§q:;e§t§d the ;::s§§§:"2?.:§ff ts M95 eye: éiéacsé':::;é2_p§:$:$¢;§s;§gf2' g}fi~ $318 :3: ﬂwr 93 that ha €§%..§§$ %§v$;: 3:? pé2:,c:;é=at é:'z;§% 3f ms ééfa. "§'§'2.& giaéntéff Qéd 3.2;':

295.3332 as ﬁe? .._}{.P21 ifjti%"f:e3,»rt;*%e 2"

aafanaaat ca!§E_::g agspggz r*%'§§§*§§é.'1§%§mar£ateé fgr sgegéfég gamer; ' a*n:ﬁ céaaar gaeabia €§§8§'i3§":£§: "Vééﬂai '3.'?";% mrgaratéan {° 5».-

:4'?

£35': §§:'2$§§Le%%__;?2§z=;_; --:3§§&;~'.'::"§xé%{ﬁi;;§é_a*::-'as? 3 gaée mm is res sf éméf ms'::§as'2';__ * vT;*:a%A.3%§;:§ é:a§'¥eé awn him is abéraén Egzmma C:~§s2aran:*:'£é Cgrééficatas \ﬁ;'%%::n she gasgagé af :§n§;e°:§§ »%:?§1e--» aw: '::f'«%§*§;v:§f3:§s;ab§e prarzgerty §§'"%€§'"&§§$§i, Tﬁéfafﬂfa éé%'£%§'é.£:*:3a'*§%'5.%%f:--§;°i:é=.éga%:'*§ §"$Qi.2%S€§5 téééwz 2% rééaéva mag v_V ":.?:'_§§4'g:§a%a{;:& 4 V%"2a§'z§ imgér gzaaarzi ggsgaggégma %-§a%;§§az$?° %: %;§& reagagégé aaf %?:;r=;'g:f':«§a§§2§:%§fi ha aagsme a iattgr §E§;.?,'§;§8;E 2g2.:§'2§:;*': £5 markeg as E.><,§23 raqasagtigzg t§":e:*'r: iészsrzw in $323: farm am memes shag é§X§é§$ 333$ }:§'ama:*°£a%§a:'2 3?' mg réghtg 352:1: siagrgzzcg Q? ?'%§$ §;;%§§§§§§:§ K/% téig §'§§§"'§ :3 Ha gag braasgézt ta tézeig" mtéag aaiy Efiéf f:s*:%§*2%:%;§'%:--§§g_g a graft sa:$ éaaﬁ by 3% pégirztsfff ha wmgd 5% far g ?:'*e$§°%; cégarsgrzgg aartiféaates %;@::2%;m ;~;~s§Ts:*:; gag M éézé.

pmgméazg ggigght §-52:; %~%':aig ;*&§>§é:?:__?é§:§é{§ £{;.??§%%?';$°§Q§'E, "??:§raaf:e: man 3? VV§é;:ts:'_a;* as gar Ex,P2§ pasttézzg are. is régfzszzzi tha amaami: reaeévgai: }'.§f§':"}gV'v§_2§--»;é§,tVv'%s§{.; __%.§:em is mm ave?' mageaséaa aver 2:: the ggégiméff. igéabéééiy ta retgzrrz t§'E§ gragertya §':§';z=;aa$' mtiae ag gar E}(;;92:?; Thai: :?ia__§z;:€;*&:senta '*5z§§}§ '§§A :?E§&§£ gstfg {Ewe parégéeg have a§:i--:,:§§é:_§V.§$s§::{é::;:& E:3 gzggparéz Q? their :-asggatéve cantantiaﬁs ipairzd téée'Q.zf:t§§§' §:€2:*;:é$§:§r2:§%::££ E3 merkaaé wfgéﬁz giaaiegeg <:r:§§*;a :gV§a§*egé;.:§ "§gc*:'$g }:;3::1'}. §§*Lm;'ir: 32$ afgseggéﬁ facts, %: ég séggg" becausa sf §.%:§.ga1%;§m 352:3 the irgizgrém mﬁgr gramtaa by 2:29 Qgzgm msgr zgagant ggegggggéan arm sxgsauténg a gag sggé xv 3% 3*; $213 3.5' défﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁi '*€*£%$ rm: mssiwé. We sffazed ta égggagia 3 xaie ﬁaeaé §n;';*5e'§g;:*:a_c:..: iimrtéan. as ES 32% 2" §@§éf':$§s""§'?':.: ;é¢§:a;A1"»a%;%';§V_A.%'r% the first ﬂaw', ﬁareééd aver tim 2,f$'a::a:;'r:£ §e:$1sg§$§§i$':3 13' ' fimr gazes': aafasa the a§' %;:5§s*?;f:¥.:a as? a cmgrt eréer the 332$ Pariéas ghmsélﬁ haxzs fQ:;:":sj§_ 5 geyfasm the:

523;": Q? 1:229 as£2:§;§;§ﬁ_"_":%§%§izsgg» :5g§E§§§_§t&§'§? iféém wag 53$ [£é%;a§ émgeééméﬁt Q5 aha §%&§§"':'{%f"? 2s%<%% g«. _Ea $§'§--%;:: 3% 2" ﬁ§f§%"'%€§3é'E€ §?? raggggt a:Lt*f_§ ;;?§§ug gaxgémg me bgéarzgg sgéa mirtgéiééigratiaré' VAa§44v%§:.3,95,&5%§~, Em ﬁafaaﬁﬁaﬁt wag $53 'xxj,_§%$§§§$éé:f:ré§' *:V%%_§. :?'"*§%:";§s" =<sz?%2%£%% %'%% has ﬁeéévezad' $9 aﬁgga §j'_'$§f§3g2 E5 fgéég 2%; $555 rem? wiﬁé tag magma $52: £§§§§"'a§"*;{i§ {.£v;:§*,;; ?'%:'§E..§?§VfTeAA3t§';.. East it ég S22 §§§§;'::E?'§ iégﬁﬁ '§%$E{"§'% 9:2 Qaigsgémg :53 ' .;i';§§"§"é«.f§§e5'?;;£ téﬁé 333% trangagtéans E: gémws théy géra 52$: V: "-vf'9;V;éé:§?g gm wiiéészg ig gerfazsa t§"é§§;*" gag :3? zﬁa mnizraaé; §'§&§:':i§§-3' :5 5 State ";¥";raémg Carggmgiémf %:%3e §$'2,!$§'§'%§'"E'%:§§§§ Q'??? \/% Eﬁﬁia angeﬁakéngi E: is as: that thgy 5&3 mt ?2:i%§é'z§Vr:§V$%é§i;%",_"'*T Eu: thaxr were 33%; raadtg 1:3 ;3erfa;:*:éi'*«:%2aé7:' ;:3é*é:'._r§§*'«.é:.%wé'--w« cmtragt. Théy' sgﬁgere gm': raacgy 9;§ %:_s§;:.é :§'z§_..gAa§»aA.de:ééz:§:;'= Tnay wera :23: wéiiimg :23 pay at""vi;eVi§;¢;%: t§'1a%:_Vg::~::::"'*?:§é¢%';*f%; 5% she <.".§ﬁ€'?$§§@i'§§%Q{E whésﬁ Egg§%§:§*%%:.a%é%«ég¥'W_sfé*:€};:$'€i-._gs %?a*°i:he 2??"

ﬁaﬁs«2:*2§asw,':, ZI'"§':a~g ansgara me:'7a§'§§§'§::V:i'v i:}.:T *:§é.i3%.;éf'.'.-333% ﬁagié ragga: 9? §':a£§ pm_:';§a':'§;;.;%;§ 22:: wmgh the 2" iiﬁfﬁﬁiiaﬁt 2&3 ii': ﬁgs aarstaxig ézhé 5&3§*rzad £o_§3'%€$évE*'wig;.'%:b?:«é'_':":.5_".déééfzdaat Ezramgﬁt is $23?' Féﬂtiﬁﬁ }mQgm'§n§ Er: :53 way; sf S%,§%_iE:'§' Kggg .:z§g;[«:M§é;&:;§Q;;$s:;:kA$:%§xg§%;-s éeggarsea ma mm as 392:2 %¢%§*;%_;"é --i:7::;~~:g_;*: hag égaég 53 asrzéarz €;'§3;'%§§§E§ téat tézég ijaagrz ég {mt _ ._;§g3:§§*%g $923: §"§":$%'&§§: baggage hr: Qﬁffaﬁﬁﬁﬁéﬁﬁﬁﬁ 3:"

_ §H§a:*é:~g has éagigteﬁ an gaegfgrmagzaé sf tﬁg «' élg§é':s3%lé§ gmirgsi he zamzgz §f%'%§?'é§;§'?:&!" gigs: its " waégcagt gazfafmaﬁta :3 ;2a:*%, ﬁx; §'T%$§'E aggartéarz V' 2%: $§*:"':§:;"&£?; mug: ﬁe §:!§%"§QE'§'§"'é$§ in fzgzi Q? 2s3a;&z"3 a fiéérag 3%'; a gm: fm' ggzagsfés garéfsrmansg Q? the 32 whaéa £f::;*"'%§%"§{:'§ aéséthaagz axgarrémg 2:25: aha is wééééﬁg :3 gmagz §%€"'§Q?"§"§'"%%%"%£§ $3 $33': r;:::; azmuat :9 Qiﬁifiiéﬁg mm: is §c£&g£;...g::e_rfa:f;*:':!al:'ga5§a§.§;?':-

gszaﬁ. it £5 mi? E52. ﬁaﬁﬁﬁ w§'é=§:'é-..a fp é:,z§%§g: aaiegmrécaééy Fﬁfiiﬁéﬁ ta §:':s:_£§t §;3;@%'?~é3r;*:':a;.:i'::;sé§:"2 gag': Lg, $29 $55 as;?§az*::§%g:;l£2va,%§;§rxg e§és:?;§§;:;§.T%'::a€* %:§' S gscagt $232": §9;r§sr::":a:*2{';a.V-«~~--i§§a.t"~-._?'2& 'éa;%v§«§. greaéuéaﬁ fmm §a;b$é;€:;z;§:a:':%'§§g :.i;:§:§":';é[§.:é::3a;rsd §§%§ aﬁagtégzg ta amag}: garfarﬁéeagzhﬁég ﬁhathar 3 mm; E233" é'§§:?:§ea"§.....é:¥§* mat WEE?

daganﬁ '*£é§*§ *f;s;:-ﬁg '§:a'":§:f€as;é';"""' 2 3%: .§§g' % a§é:s::§'-«.":=:éi:i:_i%é'"i"'. Ems 4% 9 z;m:'"?'""i:* _ ' , A .7, ,>...§..x $5: mes. $g%.w§;aM gérfﬁsffﬁagziél; ,éa:3sz€~m2:'.§§.%" §§*'»«3;":ia;%§ is a g::sa;rt:; whg 'W.-'ﬁg§:2l_j§':§§;.,[ :m§§: %éav$;:-«~:a::§¥ aagéééémg at 35% gtageg ta §?§éf§"§%i?'§"§'f%jV"~§T;§'§§ vf:@?§§£¥"3€'§.L Q? masrseg 2&3 gﬁt aﬁ-

E'%§é;.§i}«?§{§V§%§'_§%i'%"#§§" §"'§§ﬂ§*°g' §§"E»:§ %;:;%%§%n:§ 5:3 gerfgrm ﬁg £$r:'§ra::%:"§r§'.i'~"%%§ &s2:§:'&t%g& T5: iﬁat Qxiﬁﬁt iééaré ~<._ '-»';aﬁ§§§;§§' zgagfézzggg am :£.3§%§%§?:§ﬁ§S§ 3938 gas":

_ 5_''::.%§ %;7:"2«§ :33 féﬁﬁgﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁik $3.52 is': £a$§$ 'f§§'%8%"'% § ﬁé3ﬁ%%§C€ $3 52-9: sagafﬁg 3? Qaérsg parfarmeﬁ. in ' " -'=ggé§:>§& tézsam 2% §§3§§aa§§ gm w§§§§;:g§u:~:$§,, at as:

V gtggagg ig iha reaﬁénagg 552$ sxgééééngmeaa $9 asgagé: giaﬁ geyfgrmaﬁaé, if a mmiragi ég ;r"::::t aagaﬁe Q? Z533 ﬁazzzg gerfarrnagf Er: szzgééaéa am 3 Qaftgz aéearéy ézzaéaatgs $25: he Es gm: zasiiiésag :5 acgegz g§;'fan:*;*::a;'§<:a§ than '£§"%&%"§ ig as §'aa§é§'§£$$:*a--§"'§§ '_ _ ' ? wééémgnesg, at 3?; gtageg, étm a££sa§§;""-. §pg:rj:%:w ' perfsrnrzagzceg {:3 tag: sage :%"2é'.%"&--.;a7§1 ggécéféc garfgrmsrzae Q? a gay': €55?' '~:;fi§:*::.:'§'-if a éatgr gtagef' {E23 3;: the Eighi Q? t%"aaafar£%,*§g3:.é*;,§. Eémz éaéé' azgagrié mg irha I ﬁgax £053"; ms 1;§§"%é.§% sf ifrgé J$;:'§t"§E::?aé3 --?:*.;.r§%:?2er 3*? ma W §@§e?*;da:;'é%éz'za:.%§f€:_§:§'7f§%%';é§'%§ §:"':z;*fé';=* g:'a€éte~*.:¥ by iha e;.."':§:.;a*t :*est:'a%:%%?:§ {fag 121$? :§g;€:'I:jf°z$§a'a,%"»%ram %§§%§"s§%%"':§ me gregariagf the aoniraﬁ gs é'g:éa§§v"ta"'-héiwgan {me gayzégg masiﬁ $253: ﬁe :"::%::"2$é;%Eé1:%. :%*:a%'é%s§$ ma §®§%?.%®s':; we 3"" ééfeﬁdarzt :w?z:t:"§g =$;_3f::7 ":'§:"'-§Eg§*§;§g.»:'§Q tha guéi wag 2333 mi? ghare in am §%'21f"§&;'?*:%?""--~a§§*é&::°%7' 5:; ﬁg §Q§§§§ game fawgarﬁ :3 exaasgté a gaéé Qaaé if'; ragga? ﬁr? mg mi? gﬁarg E5: aim ' ."v.._Vpr:;%'§é:*:*;:"* Saésaﬁzgia §§'%$&%"ty' azsmgégzg sf gssmé fies? gag ﬁ'*:=:~:i%'"§%€:G:': %?$% 'fézim? wag if: the £'2€€i§§"'§E§®E"'% ﬁf ﬁg 2" V _ :3 V_':j%§§§:éas%?:.§ Qmuzzﬁ Sam' was in 25% si?é£§%.i$a€§§T%'§ :95 %:%":e 3% §/ 35 Point No.2:

(23) It is aEso held in the suit the undisputed*..fac'ts point out 15' and 2"" defendants were living said portion. Both were aged retired"'peil-<sorasA.::"«.'V:vTh'ey:

wanted to seli this property anbd_forv"aA:s.gle conys'ide'rai:4io'~nv,"3 they wanted to purchase a prope'rtyi live peacefuliy rest of their 2"i'v'AA defendant identified the property inA....i\/liysoreg :foi*";aV'l':V~C'ci'i'1sideration of Rs.1,'/5,000/--. of that money to value was raising everyday. requests by the 2""

defendant, the lp'Ea.iVntifi"' didlinot pay either Rs.1,'/5,000/-- or jthge algreed price in so far as half share is l V 2 l process he could not purchase the conciernedj vV'.*--hpVreperty':~-- But-.A':unfortunately during the pendency of the he also died. Plaintiff, a governmental agency Hheasrtiess in this transaction. By paying paitry 36 amount of Rs.50,000/~ they occupied the first floor. ___They did not pay any rent to the said portion. Beca«u's.ef--«b.tn.e ground floor was not handed over, they occupy the 1" floor, do not p,a'y'"'the7._ if consideration, sale is not concludedifanid._Aeveryf--v_:.a'ttem.ipt-tits:._ made to find fault with the defe'Viii:d'ants."fo*r_V_n"ot'.= their part of the contract--:_'."':Wh_e'n;_ came forward to perform his pa,rt_v:ofthe::cc5nt'rié';%fpartially, they were not willing, The property in Bangalore.

Even on the for sale, it was worth of Rs.50,000/~, which was 1,'.1A_V()'§' o.f.{th:e~amoVunVt:a_g_reed, the plaintiff was en}oying half in these circumstances, the trial Court into the facts and circumstances of the .?'_,~_i«.ca'se, of the parties, the conduct of the parties the fact the way in which the plaintiff dealt with the defendants who are helpless, rightly declined to '2' 37 grant specific performance. Though the reasoning of the trial Court is not proper, ultimate conclusion reacherj"is'f'jiis.t and equitable and we have supplemented the --!5:€:."aS{DlflS"' "

the said final conclusion. Therefore s'eei'ng é_fE'T'{)i'tfl. ahy ari--g.leV;; we do not see any merit in this _appea'i__a'nd appeal is dismissed.

Gss/ -

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

The State Trading Corporation Of India ... vs B Lakshminarayana on 4 November, 2009

Bench: N.Kumar, C.R.Kumaraswamy