Karnataka High Court
Sri Kempaiah S/O Kulleeraiah vs The Union Of India on 12 August, 2011
Author: N.Kumar
Bench: N.Kumar
EN '}.'Z=§§ HIGH SGEERT $33' 3.-.3; AT E&NG&LQRE
.Efi}a2£,e:i E'.h1':;3 {.§"i€ $21333 {fizzy ::i"z'%:42.gL:si';9 26% 1.
E3E§.I%'€)R§{Z _
mm Hm:*ELE MR. Jfisrxcg « V
Wrii. P&':¥;.i3;E<:::': Na. 2?84» _V j
§3EEZ'.E'WE3E§N: 4 V' ' ' 1. « ' .
Sri Eiexrzgiaizih
S/0 l}{uHeera1?a1i3 __
Agged 55 years; V J
No.';758_/10, ggm Cmsss
51" Blottk {W631}
Jalyanaggjzzr I , . ~
Ei~ar1g;>:.1{}:*r:w f:1§E@'{}1'_'E g f ...P:*.§;iE.§0:1€r
_{I3'y E"vi'{__:F'<f». .jS.s:--5.s_~'sh21€§2'.§, £'&€§'v€_>{::c1f"€}
mg): _
E 'f_.§_ni<}:*; ;?j}i'"'§«:':--a',':1:a
E§%_':p:°r*9'€.:j:i:<;éd by >:,.§".:€ S€{3i'€{.£-'i1."':€
' ' ca E'"§<>§}1&% j%.ff&%§.iT5
'r>:>é'<;
'~Ngs%;:;*:ifs;%::3::J : :0 ea 1
' . V 2 Séfie 0'5 ?§.a:4.:.":":223;'ia.E:;2?;
n T R€i§'}.§'f3f?':€ff§E§,{;',{£ E33;
' L" 4.. «C §:i&§° S€CE'€:?§'I£?§?jJ «
..*E"}:_"§;":<fii§3;,-ii E3S%::<::'a%§i.22;*jg ii} {}<,m::':":'m':€:§:é
§3E'}:"'xE{. %'i<.%§':2'a::'":z:: E=}:';va4':§iE.":;?:
Eifigzzyzggzzizkm » §Ei§ SSE
3 E?{'2'-:3':':a£z2§«:22: E.,<}§::g7:}":2.}§E.2z
§%:>:;3z°<%::[email protected](.% 1'3}; $3.53 R:=;2g§5£':"2.u'°
M S .B:.:i§£iiz1g2j
{Era ;7i.:z'1§3<i<£E.iaz" Efioaéi
E3az'2ga§{3:'e » 560 {I383
T'i::>. Addiii«:m'.2:} Ef);i:'a<':i.<)r Gm"ss;é:'2;.'£
of E-'901.E{:e
§'f§'u:'::%2u.2 9%' E:1.v€$1:%g3;z1i:é{)1': J _
E<Z_.:3zI'::;'-1.%2.€:k;.=L L€2§;;2z;;''z,:kE.a "
iv} 8 Bu;iidi:1g./gs; ~ _
§3£1§3g€il€3E'€3 - 569 08}. V 2.,;E%§31:>€)zf;.c;§.%_;rj2ii'Ss; "
Q.»
{By ASG_§':;:~ R1; ._ -
81? K M SE1i1r3,y0§;'iswamyfi-§~£C--€3P f0:* '.§?§_3v21:1{§?E{3;
Sat: J; P;~asE121z:ij{vii}"Ac§:*€o(:é:;-fig: {or R4} "
"I'§:1§£=; Wrii. Pf3?;.iU€}2"i is.T_fiE€(-E.vi1:*1ci§?;'L['2'¥§V{i€:E¢s 226 and 22''? 0f
thus C{}E"iSEi'EZEEU.G'I}AQf 1:1di;1.g.p;'2¢y2:1g £0 itéiii fc;z7"t:h6: :"'€<::f>:*ds leading
E0 the imp1;.1g;;£:td« <i;-§"_1a.rg;je---s%1t_¥;f=:E, -,..7';E{:>?~. '_S§*L 34 ('if 28$?' as per
Ar1r1ex:2re~A " 1' V " "
Ti'éis_ Wrii, '§:?{:?;'§V€:.V§'::2;}."'*a:§§§'::§ng am {Cr E":€i'?;3.l'§EEg 'mis day, the
Cauri. ::':adi»:-:-. gin :1', 3Zi:).Elzmi* ~'
@RfiER
%,«:#;:1ez' is .22: s::1m":'2bs;":;" of an AH §:);:E:':.=z S€ffE{'1x"§{3€ :5-3*,
V V
E:':::§'E;_m E-?.c;§3'{_"%<;?.=Sfirviaée, am H/"S :)f§<7<:r cf E98} baeih E1E'"§{3i bs::x;;':":<;% sm
"wihe ;?<Zaé'v:<;_:-:!:.;1E£;;i: €C£:a:£%:r'<;*.. {>31 2f.'.E'2<3 t:§z;:*é"€ {Ef §"i§§::.g §3<:>éé:,§<}:3 he '£52353:
" T2-&"<ra:"%::£.;':<¥ E§'§:?;:3{:%{%'é.{21* {f»{%:'::%:"22E 9%" 3%':Ei<7::=--£3"z;,fi}§§<: §:}§'"'i€i1'&E.Z1('Z€E§ zmd
"E'I'1é= ;:}'re:.E.i1'1":i:':2:H"§; §,§<}i§T2%. is; £-':ZZ'":S%§E€€i§'fi?d 2:153 :3. {1c§.€::":~
" E :3. T§'?2:3z'<-,jf'oz'<: :.ifze> cg; }"f€)I'%.£':'%1i-<};:.E'{T'§_ '
<:»E3s<-3:":::zz'ion. Qf z"Iu;> fipex €.'.r}z.:.r£ Ezaéi ;"€..;:; " :_.
2.zi'1.{}é3:":.~:?.<'}<)d in 3.32.3 £7(}3'£.fT€X€" 22?': z,£:f':€c:%§'1. :3 zfiéjzazféf.
"E'h(3;; :.::z3m';>. g){)§I'1zi:2g; (mi. %f'.5t':c':%' *£{E'fj'§'3:i'E3F'2{)f€.A'"if: z'.}":sé',
Zarzgzmgge .<3m_pZog;e::i En Sr3é:4ia:3z'2:1"';T§?[?' igii £1¥:1<f}' C:';:is:..&
mm? 8e~:?z.io:'z. E9 Qf'§i'17*£.£V;':'«'K§;4{i'f,. fix ..S€?(.'il'f()2"E tgf" ffifiéj
C051:-'2. :.:?'2.e3 worcis z.sset£--,{;iz<s2 :;zq*§.?z'as.r§:?Z 55591;;
Qfflrzzzce czllegedf. in M119:-3...fiéeari"::Qm.mi'Z:'Ie<iA 32;; Enizrn
:,:2?2,z'Ee aczzhg o:«;::§fgM>z}:::1.;;V ~--:a;:;*vf: :":r~':A EIh(3 d§s«::h.arge
off his z:g1'}"icz'ai ciuiy v§'Ej:£%__'.wo;"ds "used
in Se¢I.£.b&fi-._l§3 fare '"~:::.--£¢geav £0 %1.ave:> been
::()21t%i'a:'f.;ie:§75;;--.;:"~pu..¥':5I£.g7 5;s3n;an!.. In cerzse qf
.See:£.i€)z1. E'§}"?Z v33:(;§j'L:2;f.ge--- 0z.:?c0rdi.r'1g sanc:£.'z'.{;2'z. {he
{£ii'§l§'Eéf§Z§}'§'1.€1S'_?.{5;_,§:f'?1d 03:3. z.z;?":ez'.i':er" Zfze aiigzged am:
...?.'2.a::s :::In.§_,; "%2e,1;:.:';i»; LUSELF7; 5.328 zii.z'.s{f§3ar§ge Qf c§z,::'z'e;=;.
1."L:i.T<3§V2::-:3r.:<;:€Eg,,z.' """ ":3-fz.z'E£? g;r::zz'z:z'r::g S€2i§'?C§,f.OF2 mzder "v..4S?e'§§:"é:";;*z.*--.;1' E3 egg" SE26 .:'-'mi, fifi} saw}: c3§3iiggc:€z'.«::s1 is casé; V«::;:f:i_"-f.}:.é:k:zz:i§z(3ri.:::e$ ::<.*<r<9:'a'iz'2g $z2.z'2.{::'£e?':.. $5': $35.55!; ..__'{:{;:2.ééx!. 2': was saizif. 351545.!" zméie.-;>z" S~3£fZ.§(}¥'?. E3? Qj' {he " _ z":{f€'. s;ri;:':<:zL:}'m is :3' ::z:,.si':3;*':*'za§"i::? s':a§.iz.sz"53. fr': €>EI'§'?.§£?"
z.z,=z3r{§s;. She? {.;:.:.e$§"§srm off' {i.E.:.§?'T£.{)?'£iE;i4,€ <:<:»:'s:s°i5§a>r2':':§; ¥."'?1§% ne;s:z§:-s a.:::':§:. {fie d.z'.:;<:§'1{:rg;as 2:35' a'.:sz.fa%:e% $3 :7.<;~: §.§'2z3§'e. if 5: pzzE'2§£.:f .<~;g,>r:.;a:'E§': is (".駧€;'§jé?€§ £0 3'35/2:29 £?(}?'FE.§?'2§§{€€i. $2.325; {3]f'}'€}z'z:?ar g..ma'€.»?r' 3.3%? ,»=<"§:?z'., {f {fie (:z.g2""E'2:;cj§.;';fE_':z§'§,§ : ~ .f5§(1i.§§.§f§€C§ sgfgauz. ifze a5.Z€§;a£.i<;;ns§ :4:.:.€.2""?2<}z.:.£, g:gi<5}':'2§g,:f§é.§.§§ {.5753 5guc5;z.'z'<m. z,:,:i'2ce£}'z€3'" 5:;.{g:>§'z {§£i%f'}'z'EfE:¢;{ > iiidg' _ <:0rnmf§:.ee:'f w}"zz'£e €iCIfi1'"£_:';i or ;:::.z§2';3(3'_f{"§::Vg'go 'E5§{I'iv._.:fP:E 'V di5;'{?f'zai'§;<:% (Lff Qfjfiariczé d:\z.z':';;.u';$£;--2°:.éz'i.z3:'z '§:.<}:.zE:"i «. Sitar' ae;'mr"(2'€€E. In (jzher Z,.-£.?{L"°V?f'{.1:=L{?.,.. sc:m.€?i.'iQr'z .23; ;CL--i.Iv.£.'§i§?f%7ééZ£~§ff).":
if is {his _pl2rase 'S(1f'IC£'Ii(,;}'T?"~'lf;'§ (1:.z1'é;(')':<:'"zfi:.'z':f rzafizzre' E3 s;0ugf[z£. :0 E3215'..V_«;::<:>r'zss'§:fi';z<i>d 52$"-.§j:0 sczvz;i1€i§'i%§r2 is 1°s3cgz.zi:°e>€i under ff 3330?': an iz'::r3rfJr"e{a{:ioz1 53-€4::>c:5f3ie55aAA\'€:5 }':.£I?»3:xt§r§:'i.z2Z'er :0 E5153 prevfs;§::=§é§§;;.E}ei>z2f;{i§«i;'26{.€"$2 Qf {he ACE. ii.
is z?;:2éliV.s.<3!5t:€ie3:;'_ t.f1'c{:'--..g:"g:£§ai:iSi«:f)nis an a:zihoriE:;;_fi9r V _z_..z;_§j:(,I.i"'V._{{I "1;';gf{:z1(zZE§;,'.__ <1;?3c?§(ig{§s'. R(::f}3?"::"?'EC€ :0 at ;Jczrz_izji2{:'ar..__se:2t.a3{1&faV__ in j fzhe amaze/I' Qf' j70;z:z':'z.:.aE :~:.:reflari:> Vc?.5zrAf_m.()'i"-bé~z'e'aci om. Qf ConI'6>:!:.. if she cg:}"}:}:*<;*§:(,az":<3 :.a;g:')z4c§;;9 53.213 read in rim {:0me:x:E. in zwzizrfa 'V 3:". is E,lS;i1'6,.4_V £2' £3 dear fins" ;<.;az'a(:z.:'0z'z is z'z?z;)05;£d. on 3-,i:"a{«3 €'ffm.sr:. §.a.§ci::g cogn.2"2:an::€ of $52.6 :g{}"e:?::g3 V _ 'V{.'i{)??T:r'f2if:fI£E{£ z.:z'zof.e;r" {E29 Ad by 52 pzzbizt? S631'-{I?T.f, Q3"
i;i':{"é.~:',3'.V.V '5T{{:3?°°%Z'$CZ§f€? z.v0§'<i '&:azE,€>rnaz§.ég7' 51$ mezgi 05:3. of .g.*.'<>'2"g.-:?'«:%<a 55 :.zsc>:zEcif €z'}:j,1":;>az:' z.}":a>. zsfggjacz. zv§.:.E'2, s::,>f2.i{;?Ez.
" ¢V»$éJ»:'::'.z".{>n IE} 53;" 552.9 Aaff is <32rz(,:.::3§i'é%d;. :::::2{i :"{3r[z0§e3:<-'; fhrze 'E gzsafzzérz. {>35 S8. %/ ':3 2?', 5%. zxzfzzi sa.r2e::§,'i=r.}:"z 2'5; 5: ;3m--recgzsfsife :0 {.325 z"a§<°z'r2§; égf <?<2gr'2i;»:5:::'2(:e qf {:'2.e m'z.zL.:mer(z;£{%»:"f <3,f}%3:2<.'es czifegegi {"1} I'z5::..»c;> ba>er2. {?omz'nz°?5'e:fZ "Q pzzbéz'-::* 3a=rz'::(mz; 1"'?2e> bar is; :0 2.22.9 ia}g§f2§;-
{f(}§j?'EfZC£§'I{f8 Qf q{7&>r':.{>£> by 332.6 Cs:3z.:rz'.
z,z,=h€ar'2 5325;' {fo:.:.rz', is zisziied 2.:_g}(3z2 to f,a§_c.<.-:>.. QfSE.£.{?3'E, (g[f}"2-fizcss, if mus! ea>:7'%.{§'Ai::ife'V«r.;;}z€i:}§:3f £*f'z35:;V5%"V :2 z:a,Zz',d :«;cgrz<:§--gz}I'2 Ila _pr<}se><é§1z.{e ggzizéslffim _,;,§V;;>:jz}<:;%f:.'5:._Q?' __]E;»;' §"i':e> Qf}*'7e:rz.ce 5zileg~éaT.,__I0 fTive£1'L'-,%€ '§5'éj8i'z* :é{}Z}*E!3f.Ei1f'{€?:i1? 59;; him as gatzblric s>er::;z'ii;*?z.Vz:§f* The cV:C:f_Lz'.é§c;::¢vi? :7?:i;;sE' be :2 pubficr $er2.:C:I3e', :4z,rZ:s'n' uz';é~;?._.c:££eg:;£2'{;i"'{.5} Etizve c:0nzmz'£:'E:ed' ifzé i_é.fc>'..és accused. If
55. is; «::0r1E'c2=m_;3Za(;:fcE. {G V _g3;°g}5;::>'i?':;:,I'<§'"fzzgibiic semamf. 55,221.53" '3'i:_c2s_ V<:<3;7[2r7g€'zL£'1e;'%cZ. SEILT}? (,yf]Ef~3rz€€:§. when {fire ,Co:;.::"£: is 3:;:iE£e3tf'«.;:}i:<>gr:," {'0 ziafce c7ogn£25m.C(3 Q3" fi'?'Z€ c>5"L<:r':e:e?. '$3, .';<ir:«r::'f'£.(m 0:55 51:. £0 be-3 a:,=az'Ecz.E3ie2 1 _V . V J L.{;E:'§":er'zi2a's;e,, ('fig Cozzri :g>z3z.:,£{/i §'E.fl£fi(;" no j£.i3"§S€ff£?§§.O¥'E 3-f"zl;«7 §i'a§€c f_'.'{}§?7i§Z€€?'EC€f Qff E338 erg,{}'éz'z{75, A érziaf :,:::':i20z.:.i. ~.4é§4'Z.'Z?;$Z?f.{?'1"S£E?"E.CfE§€}?'Z., a:.:§2z,>:"<3 (am: 55; I/E{3;('f€}4S)\S'{2{*;z/ffé :.mc§z<3r E3:ér::§z":'§;2:" if} is as €"r°€{z§ w:'iE':{}z.z£, ~f:z.ri;s;a'§:?§.:'z2r'z Egg; ifzg \._"{:"f£}-f.i'z*;{", A :Lr:'.aE :£2fz.§z:3:,z§:' a s<z.z':<:?iz'0r'z .r{:z':€:'€:'s fizz} " _ gfmgreéaédiziggig aft: ins' 5.221 zéaéfai E55'. ' '§'¢':.e-? {er2"";'::'z'z:zs9 €§Z.£«:') Rib?" 2:2 zxziigi :~';{g,r'z.é,f§':1:};*'2 {Em 3§:'2':.9 :.v§":s;?:'2 if;/:3 cIff{;2z:r*f <:={z§fg%(§ ii///,.... .
opg3<>r'z.z:r'2§£.;; 50 new if hfkyr' <:°<'m"§.z;>€ mgyrizsgsg, '§':"2er¢jf<3re, Lfw »::ormpI" {?€)f'E.d{.iCff. 2'29? {iE'E"§3€.'f.1'i:i;"
ai'z,z'£%}z:.§.aE:>ie sf/sniff.j?oz,:::-;j%'<>?':'2 Effie ;:2au2er £703"; an {Fm Qjf1'c«<.>.. 'F'i'u's Ems;,>:'re?Z(1i.i<j:#:__ '€;:v.*:':.fg:€.. -1- 2'mer:i5;?pe>r1{£a3z'z<:*e .be§,weer:. i:zdi:,r€.€i:.aa§.., v_{i':=3e:i.V égfifizie fie fmédg :15; s'z4:E3s;::ar1.:.§£zE 52:32:'? '_:'2.;:);:'. 3a?z_J¢>':'r;Z:aE&>;-- < .f.£'a<:I"z Qf Em: £:'h.ree e::Z<;:u$e:>s (Eff$z.£?3¥:3é;>e:?::'ic;§'2 {3.} <3)' 39 uses me £f,¥§'}F{2SSi»7§'?'fQ}:}{\f{?£.é'-VCfi:1{"iVi.?'E¢:*"1bif}:;:}g';' Effiél ggrané. s:zmi?i.i.(;z'2 is §?<3:;;}'i%Effe:fi <'2r{' ~.:_'_}'?§é~,?T {t»:z.s§};0ri§.g; c<3r?1}3<3:.er':.:. {.9 rfe=';irj;c:av<3 :i.?':"é p {..{I:2Ziz:.5s3z"z2fzfi.:$j"r9:T§'1. his tgfifice and S. I §?:5":"A:>aq{:V:ié"r3s5i§f':,i§§%:--,,%)q' bra' iLakz'n,g «cognézcmzgre <gf'AA..(gjfcr1ce.é; :g;:<;3'i*{::'1f'i;iégfE5' by pubiic serzag;:T:E.§'«{.Zf§#.e Qjfiférzcaz»;3;itc=.L£2'd[_:'::e3_ct§m:I'ziE::ecE 10;; £"i'§'£.fi V p:zbii'£C;§;é::'1;:&;zF"a.é,,_éiéggn 'z':V2.i.s%:,:sz'%ig or c:2§3*i£S2',?'iQ i:E'1(3 poamsr .oj:f7i:?§V cV.¥_f2d% :i?Q_T?I. zhczf, Qjficez zihe azzzfzoriiy riézgs E39'£j<2%:izp;>§:é;j2€. Ea ?"{'3§"$'"£{}U&? hi 2'21. 5:} as; :0 E9 _e:'z:::'.t;£er£A 5'32' '§;r':::%'?.i sa;r:cZ:'imf:' T328 e:<pr"e3:'s"s€0r'z 'Q1}F'E:7es fr': {E253 1 V. "&'§}%*e;~;%'s2.:;:b~-{:Za.:.g.ses {;2fS§3cE.z'.o?'1 39 {E ,3 :2.><}ui(é <:EearEgg _:f§:é~,?r9:;:{§:> zffzcx Q;f}'z'<:<3 :,a.»E':;i.(:E1 £:he:>. ;3z.:E3E:'c .<§a>r°aso::'z§:' " ,m.§Sz.:;s:e§i7 G?' z:2}3zz.sedj§i3:' <'70r:'up£:' z?20:,izée>sj3:;r :.::f'z:'.:;*§2 he :15; :10 E38 §3f"€};'§€:i?{.£€.E;?(§. aims' in re?s;z2ea>:'." Q?" :.::§'f::'{:?: 5:; 5;a:':{r§:':'<};'2 is} ;}:*{.2:s~.::e{:::.:{g §"sim. is; 3"E€3{3€3f§fS{E§"§ Egg; éfzggz {f§}§7":g3§3E1£;'3'Ef' {TE.§.£.§'f'2.{33'f§f§_j ez'2§'§.§'§es§ {(3 re2';2'2{3::e ?'l§£"i': jmm 2 ég ¥/ i§'za§' <2;f}"'E{3er a;;:E:§c?'2 he-? Ems a.%;su.s9{f. '§'§zz':=; €r'2?m*r°s:%£€1§.i0z': EJe3§.:.ueen §:'ff:.e Q,§'}*'%'cc> «:/mzti ziis aE3z.:$e.g}z:;T'~.T :§{:>a:€re>ci, i.L*{}§.»fi{{ rc12.{"ig:%:" 535 3:9 ciemici Q? "
I:rts:az'"z:'2'zgr,. 'f."'?'2.z';<,: §.E'ZE.é'TI'€I€LI.'f(}I'} cEa>a.:°Zg; _;3rfg:-Q$._i£'E§if:i;>"V--. '7' 65213 :5; :':2'1{;? z,:r2d€r;s:i<:z:zdir1§; 63]" 31:2? ;2ro:;i,«:ioz'é_:':53'; pr0::fd.£ng '£702' s:r:z.:'2.<:E.ian fag; £3 <':(}?1?*zp:2:_E.<;=«n§. gr;:.:fi':!'u:;;"iVi.§;* * z.L.>?":1o :.5:a:)z.:E{i be able fie} _fz.zaZi;€ :£:.F1}é:c;:::£'i0_f: Q!" TA gjzibfic serusmi. E}e:3fbz'éf '4-.Ijer:1o'i§é.:1gjv the }}z§.r.,.__F3g;§ grz:2r'zz'i:'zg 3az':€:.f<>7'2. 31:: z1E1;é*é.;i.i<ir2_.g <;jV°2':ffs..e"t::§grfi};;Q;2ce Qf Qflerzces Ffigg" ~,§,3<a.e ¢{f:E)73az%i ' rigegirzsz, '§'.?z'.e5 g§i.zbiic 5::-':r::an2'.; f[7"Z4€-;'F°é;p¢}flIf€., V§,ii.4cjiié:$?£,i.§:}nq:bly fallcmjs ihaij {W3 s_<:aI1cZ1'Qzi%,...i.r§._'z;?f<3;'sez§:é,:E.£:'.f>::zIi giver": by an cmihori£§;y:'§:-'r?2,r)Eé_lien: =55 z'e:>ni{:--ije3. pubiz'<;? semarzi; j}'orr§."é;*1{:3 e:3j§?7r°.ce .:1,§?2.xi a'2 he hast misused. or cabused ,,,,§:3éc:_::u.:::££V£43331."::zz;.E'}1§2%*§_€;;.; a£<>n.e> wouid. be able Ira §€§":r_3_»;i: 2.;:§2é:{%2%3.r' §.§1'£':§§"Ei hstas been er; m.i.sa::~;s-3 or €zf:2:.£se? _:3;" i.?1e"»Q;fjf'%':*£é 29;; $1326 pu?2i:'<: sz-,>:*z;:a:'"z.i'. anci r?a{;~£. some z1:z?':.3§; (31; Esz'{"€"éf; ' X Z?'?1e granf. of :<::a:2.{:iz°{;2f: 2'3 f"£(}§.' an V.§;§,Eé .jE:rr?za.§izg;. fhe soiszmn amgi :~,:a<:2"<)san.<:z. ac:
" ':.z,:%%icEz r:>??":<}:,>e5§ 335:9 z,:mb:°e2ZEr::. 9,?" ;:?!'"€}E€fC§.f0?E (gf €§0::a>?"r2.n'2,e2'2§ sss-,>r;::2:: is agafns if '_f:'z'.v-afikzgs ;3m;«;e?<7:.s.£.€<;z'2§ eimsf. {Em <:;_,f'1<:r<3;<§z2.:':§ rg;;:.;2':"<3:2':s3z:§§; mz.£:~;zi :"'E'ze:*ef§1::):"s;% E39 ;~'--sz'.r:'{>:E§; <:{:~m.p€ie(E w2'§.E':. E35: "Ema ::2:2.;; p:'s:>$e<?z.::.i<}::. zrgmici. We §{ZZ.é?Z{i'§'i:'3f§. ag5:£.z2s;:. pagbiaizf .sc:'var':.:":'~;. '?'§z.{zf. :5; E.£.?§'Z§j {E28 §3'cz.rZ:'€mze§'?;§:' ::*£e'-aezrfgg §.m:}::ide{i §"E'2.a£ z"'?2.z& 1:351 €,'?':.cm':j;; aicme ::2<>:;?.€2--..§ be <:c}zn;::e!.z2r1:': {'9 g:'an.: s;ancz:ior2. :.:,>?'z:cf2. is 5.->z":?1«:_I{3Tz'V::.>:§_'é':--«_ "-- {<2 rerrzgove £:'?'2.e g'}::§;:£'f:;=: .;%}r:sz:m£:' C£g€£E'2"'Ef§?1 :'_j£.::; -1- s(;z'2{:£.:<):z is s;c,>s.:gsE':§j"mm {.f'E£'i zgfffirgi 221 'I'F'3;erej 5c2rej}*'Q:":"s §,?z.<31.:{:§]'%:3z"e§§§i:i:'::'=,;£i:;C::z.:3§i.é§i'::_ A' :35'; is Ciea!' iizazl {sci $Ci$'"é€?fI'§{}{1' is requ----§z'°éd i:'0fz'£g,>f'={?!R' Gr {E2 . raagésfger 03: HR. Ric: '::gjf;.{;:.i0:'2 is ' --:f€(§::.i%a3aE'"''':.{§ :'.r"s.:;>e5I:igai;e qflier zfeg:;is*f.s3rir1g;z 'a:1.'V~.E}'R §:z'r::."£_ alsgé no sarlcféan is require-:§_. jfie ;:?}1 c:';';.{_1£>,_ $312365. béf bra iihe j:.:4:"isdfcrziorzaE Coufla, E5'-cz:_1<:i;'it}Vn.':s before the Cézifz. :'i::=:{gz:i"z:zg:rf:::,e Egg"-~{ii.ie (;{]E2r1C£»'2 aiiegs-Bci 3.0 fziavssn 93:39:92' '«"f:{3'.f}:2V2'"f1i§l:_,'IVLtC?,7{§iby {T318 pz.:bEz';c sen:a,r2.z': under §,§';eQ<%.ci ;;czr<:::1'.w.I%>q§5'§}1ief§i:;:;é:1é Qf pmce-ass. if ail 532.51: point _ Q2" £.f.m£:>'; vibe €;;:<?:'i§«;L><;E Caz1§,z':1;.:.e:3 {:3 be (2. pubizic '"'"«:.s§?:f:>cr;2E: amt?' g' §7...§i}1.s:vre is :20 sar2czIi»:::r'2 unzsier Secfzkm 3 :13 :;§*:?1<% 2=':;:%§1 313:6 C<3:.;r"§ 525:5 I20 jur§s<t£.i.c£:'z"0n is éa§<:e .2;5:<:;:?i'1;:-':a§T>.~~' <3)" She <g}ff§'2'3:faCe .::{>rz'm'z.i§.z'.<-55$ i.::;=2oi'e:" me 53631; if' gs; E.s:j;§»:és {r<)g:1i;»:e:2:§'2.€e {ff s;z,:<:f': zig;fj}%2':c:e arzgfi. issmzs ;;:%:3.,»::<->$°s. if. <>ng> z:.%z'.:.%?;{;ez1i, Mfi.£§°E';§§£§§.£?§.i€3I'L z:::»:'.{22 9:33 i.n£z'.:'Q {z%*:'€§. 520:: 95;: in fire eggs 5.3;' Saw. 5?: 2.9653 hmze :10 iseggczi §§'§%:tz., '§'?2.s: {iggzm is ::»:}:%;:'.<3<.f. 2.:.>:'£'E"z {Eye §2zm:a?r sis: i.52,§<:'<-3. <:0;;::2§2:{:2'2:7e 5:5?" «:32 Qf'§'%,>z'":<:eé :,.m€E.8:' §.?'w ;§<;'§. 52325;; i.é3§":é3f";. as 3.3;} } I?'E£??'8 is s{m:?s'2T<>:'2. (,:r.t§?<:rn'.ie.>;ii Ejgg z".f":<,> ap;3§'(3§}rz'5::.s-,> {}:}z,><a:*z':me2'2i O?' srz;)_pr£3}m'a§:e;> €i££{?"i(i}F'§E.§_;. £2": spize zigf z'§:'.""zL'f7» 5': €X€??'{?i$GS pr:3wa>r, :}"z.a;* §.EI€ga£:'§";; is €f€)I'I'EI?I?if€€»E7":éi§E;§' She E}>z';'I"§j afiitgfecf, ieefzizzai {his pr'c,>z:z'5:::'€}:':r; ::r1cgI<%{r":;{';;"'z'.§P:'e: 5' s{z:'2:r£,'z'.0r2; mar2.e:E{::::3rj;; 4:0:.«:.§e:2Z E352 {£<.jf%é(:;t§a';,x V ff:c2ms:§me:'t: 3:0 z:h<3 puE*;Ez}~:r Q['{f§é:fE:Z:j;"§:¢_ ':;§,is§.:?t§i.:§g_e;* iqjfl {heir <g{}"Ec7i£:£ :7E.uiiz'<3;.«;, .'§"fz.€:1 ii'. %3<e§%':<;z?1e;§_§é*[ if E2:§_f:'§;_§gj' A :Z§'c)r_.a:"'E.' 2'9 sijegs in {'70 mzde: : :,i1¢ é.z'g.,§V::§z.:«,:V_§.'ii':;> Va'.»:;;v"2éé '§fQ :3;.z<??§§ g::u§;£§c 5;«r2r:2arz£..
23, A Cmzré' _£.Tt',§£_F'£?'Zf:}'i uz.'::!.i<:(£ ":fiy:>gz2izan.ce Qf Q[fL'?'1C€f pz.:n:'sf"e.abZeH:;:j;'ci,er° ;'3e{j{.i<;--;*z~..?; If I I, .38 and 2'5 aiEeg{=a>c:;'~,._::(:. E14126 Z.béénv_{'5C'f_j'&?'IIff.I'é(,i by C; public sgerzsarii:":é.:¢i§,f10'E;;£ :13f;é';:2_fe:>ic):,:s s.::n.cf;z;'(m Qf {F753 Cenztraf G7@,vs3z*:: mien f:,:".S: am < (}:t::.5%§rfr1 memf, ,-1' A::4£.i2c:»3'i£,§.; cor"ng:2e 5.5512"
:15; re;5':z:_<;::><3 ?1i::r:'é?«:)?e':,{§§§?i<:e¢ "En £2122: £::s£'.;1z1i:.::z:$€:. 9:: i;.h.e day "ms: <;§§'e:1C:z=,:; under 1.1%':
;:iE %:::s __§121*~J€ béffiié {3G§T1I"§1§'é,"{.€f£§ by ?;.E*":e ;;:s{«:%§.i'1.'§amt:'1 he:-7: WELS .2:z--'§>'::.b§§<?V s~:%3';~*2g21.:';;[iI; {En {ha {fa}; Ehe C{::m'%, ¥;e:;<:%«: «:3<}§_§11§;c2m<:€: sf $316 aE"§7a":§é¢:';<3S~-- ;4;:'i:§{%tr iléle ;%:::%;. anci %s;;s;z,:«:%a;'E pr<:»::§*:§ss§::,$ E36 '@2255 wéarigizzg as; :1 " V§§;.:v§:2§:i2: .;',~%€§'.i'i'é'?;I1%.., 2%; mi; S%§2iE'?.§i2';.§{}7£E ':fs'é'-ESE :I;z<:{::;:f<.i€:«:§ :,m<,E:;%;° :':'"%é*.<t:%i'.i0n E9 ¥:;.§ 'if'E"i%: 555:: E33; %.E1<~? SE;:?;&.€: {E-§:s2rer::::'1:;%:'1i%,, 32%;? {Z€m.:"£ érmzki 1293. Egeweé Ezeakmz {:$§_§1'1iza:'1<.rr:% zzmsci s:t<.}:.1§d 11:}: hzzvs <31'<§m'€c:.% s§:..:n::':1:::»'i'T:&z;.
"E;1s:aa"e§%>:'<:g am: <>r{i<%:' §)a§I~3S€€Z§ by £.f::£'~% €;',:>'u::"'a; is; "~f{T}i{i ab i;17E._f;:'i%:;. azsai :'&%q:2i1:'€s&; {.0 be: &;<-3E: aside: ;X(3<t<3i"<:§i§;g;§§:,?'. I pass-3 i'E'x::~:«.f§@:,§E<3 __"' en"? es": ¢ Writ petittian is aiiowed.
"§'}1;@ :'mp:..ggz2e:2' (,>?*d.<:>r f}CiS5}'i'§i. $33: :f1<'3 'E~42arr'z5?r:£_'--V.S;:}e<§iaE°'J:'ic:fg%3L m 3;}; (jg: ;§;g_34;"{}7 an i}_iV§:}':é"}§X}}§5 City Cizzié Ses3zi0r':.s; Jzxdge c::': _&'*.-Speziiial _»j:;'a:ig<:,L"§3angal5}%"~éA Ciiyz ialcing cogm':»:ance and zszssue fQf_;):'éCa>Ss .--a.rév.?§<;?té.f3g; quczsizecf, Na "C¥:};~"gI;:§ .'