Karnataka High Court
Shree Durga Constructions (P) Ltd vs The Chief Engineer National Highways on 31 May, 2010
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy
Bench: Ram Mohan Reddy
M
WW
N-wt
w
§fi?§§ ?E§$ ?HE §E§§¥ G? fifi? Efiifi
EEFQEE
'Ea EE§§ fifififi? Q? §EE§R?&K%§ §§§§&Lfi§E
?§g §@§*§;§ xg. 3¥$?EC§ gag xfifiag e$$§¥'"CFf'
§.?,§G.Eé%§§ 3? 2%fi§E§§~§$$E""'
EE?§EE§
$3233 §§R§é fi§§3?RQ$?§$§§ :
?a@? §§k$»3%; fififié §$,:3§¢§,
a:s§§&?3 c@;a§¥, agagm §3§§§E
T&%I&fiA§¥ . Nm_=.'a
RE??§, §¥':?s §A§&§:§$'§:gg:?§é,
?*EE§%?fi§&§ "=5. ' 1"v " "
W3
1 ?EEV£§E§F akggxg §.§£t:$§%a §:$a%a?§
E "
§g§ ggggg gazuazaaa
K,R.$Z%£L§, EA§$Ea§RE
?"§ §Xa:§?E¥$ §§§:%E$R
.?$§&E§,¥3RK3'§£?fiX?%EN?
.&§&?:§&ga.fi§$fi§&¥3 azvzgxfig
."§E%fi.$%fiR?E?%? ?E§?&E
{%EfiSK§éQ§R¢ wag; $%$a$
".§§§Q§$$R§?S?§§§5
3 '?a$_§$fi£g?Aa¥
ififigfiffifik ?§E§E$ fifiéfifi §EE%§.%E??
§$;a§:;§:§a; EA§Q§LG£E $2
,.. RES?$§§$§?S
gum}
H3
,Wq
wfm
, SE? $%?.%,3?§$§$3§REE,§$??§i¥¥$C%TE ?fiR §1~R3§
ifdx
Vmginagfia
2
TKIQ fix? ?E$§E §§§§R §fi?Z$LE§ 22% fififi $2? Q?
?fi§ £ §$?E?§?Zfi§ fif Efifififi. ?$ §E§§$T ?¥§
§ES?$§§E§?$ ?Q ;$fi$§§£R. TEE
?ui$ pgtiiign Qamiag @§'.f3: §:a2igx§a§§ *
fiearifig in 3 Qrsmg tfigg £33, tag agar? mgfig tag
R%$§$a£aat»§§i:$fiai& '§i§iga§C}_ amtficsitieg
fiaatafi as tsadaf
"?erie§:-ai .§z;$§a; ~§§\a§%§i$fi%l Eigxay; $3 fer
ma <32:
Esaqgigzg W fééfigfilfifié "$g£:i@m", 331%: :2 ha is:
I'
gh ?§& §a:¢:;¢§ar 5 §:§ aging tfia
iswggfig'Vga3",V¢$fi5i§§:&§ Ey th% re5§$§fi&§t~
'§:aa§ta%§@§ tfie §atit$Gn%$ fi§§f%§E%fi § iatt
fiaizfig tha iasarzagaamg bfifflfifi
§ut%®é:ti&§ @;1'
W
E
V
$3.3
" :2= . i ~ -. «
§&agfia.3§ ' ggaa 2«$% zgvitznq ifia zasgsafiaai
. . - -
-jgttgfiéian is tha iikfiiihfifié sf fxzthaz fismggag
",£§é 2; aaiufiai agigxitigg Efifi 322$ aafi 2%
siarify 'tha a:3¢$3$e§t:§§ selatiég :3 the 3$¢§$
$5 Zanfigx cfivaring bituminfigg $v§:;ay witfi maaiag
mg aha ghauifiérag §§%E§?§f hécafigary; gné ifig
$%&%%£ net Qfifitifig § Eeagfiaazbzizty an Vthe
§s:ii:§nez in §fil§ii§§ ia aha
mgintgaaafia af tfig ziéifig aurfacé
;$§::a£t. gfirisfig mfiifi a$§rs§r:§:%?ér figs 'i?' gi;h
9 _ g & ygé , 9 "fie
1§:$a$;ty' bf§$¢$fi $3 Efiial
:§%§3 fimtfiifié tfie gaaga ¢f*
ia tfia zzgaz cf' Fara§;$§h ~53: 4'V
gmfi ifig bi§¥ Lfudiiifiéfi" ?e§@V"with pa§agx§§h
§%Eg8.?,1 3f :53 §i§§§%fi§"vfiifi§i§§ fiafiumentg E
fifififi? ,3 '§,fl fig? _'§§ihi; §é¥§f€§%E%$E zhe
fiazgaaéafitg',wi%h$§t "su"££grific§:i2n, é?' i%t:§f
fiataé E%.?;E'§§;1_£fifiéiuE@~E caiieg ugam tfig
*§§ti::%n§: :3 afiafiiwintg ax agseemafia as xia 33$
vé£%3_"a:c§§:%fi,Zi¢: %3g3§??£§é%§§wg witfiig EE daya
$§T the igttggg faiiigg whiamg
gatiafi yéalfi ix; iaztiatafi E; iazms afi? garsgragh
*.§§,3,¢f :?g.
2, ?ha 23 :§$§'méa:t. fig' Qffiéf fistgé
'"§§12*2$%% ififiéfififié L £a§a§;;§§ tfia tgnfiéz gag
farfgitefi thg bifi fiéfimfiiiy sfifaréé by 25%
;§:i$i$§ar, sinse tag geiitianaz aid fifit acmfi
M
§. §%a:5%§ Cauaaei fa: 3&2 §&rti%3 aévasaefi
argumaafig La $§§Q§§i mf fifieix :§3§$:tiv$ §ia&s 53
5%? sat in the mg§$$an§m& Qf wfiit ygziiiaa géfi
gtaiémaat sf afijaatiamfig
.: = 3., -1 ,-, ....-1 ~ .
$2 having fieaié iufi Lfifififififi Cfiafifitzuififziné
§gr:i%£¥ §&zu5afi tha §ieadi§§§_ 33$ }$$g$i§9£ 5t§ax,f
ar&&'.fi&fiex§§% Q; thgra Qgfi §§*;nc~ £i§§u:% :§$t'
tha §ati:ianer %3¥ia§ g£fery§*a §ié lfi--§%S§§E3%
1..
is the i§¥iia§i$fi fiafiazuraéfi géifii wuss éfiéagtad gy 33$ f%$§§fl§$fit; gas-lfigmfiéf :$ R%mtgr inta as . vi $§fi{} 'i' '«'= aftge » , agzaamaat gzafigg figfi agaa $u$%fi4&§$fie 1* A, fix _§§vé§g *&$§§r£" ta fiiamga Ea fif ififi §$i§iti$a3 sf hi§W%hé fiéiitifinar £3 invsatefi with év §iG%iYWt§.'§iVé a §$§§i§§; éfi tfié aaziigga £§§§:§§n::§;"¥r§:2t:ag is §§&aifi$ lik$i§' fmtura C1" ' gvafits §fHfii€fiQ§3€§fi$§§ tfiat may gfivefsaly affect & quality sfi the waikg é§sr%&3i§§ 2&9 :a§tr%$t 'v: gsigég at éfiiayg :3 tfia fixacuziafi $5 :;% wcik. ?. it éfi ma §$ub: traa tiat $i§u3% §%Zfi$ $5 ' :§e staafiing 51$ éasumaai. fififigf & E; aging a cafifiitiaa :3: aha igvizsiiaa fax Emgi £fié§Kfiré~§; gravifias fax mgggaring §é§§§&t§ly far §&§fi§§i ia M é figmare m%t%:3 ffif éfifi wsrk $5 Eiilifig §fl§h$i%fi gig.
83 ;fia gatitimfier fiaving ifiVGRE@ iha Ciaaéagr in tie hifi figammagz £3 3%: amt a$§§a=::$"*fi%a"t 3 ifivitgiimfi :2 gig; fflrégééifii $§m3§§§~}- aazurai caiamitiaa afifi zsim §§,§%;33a£»i$%a:fii;~»T W:
sf zraffza gi mxgag $313-,v%%;$;%5 flux' m§§i5§ fif Kara? §fifire33é§_' g iéifiaz jfiatefi £3;
3§.$§,2%%§ agiiifig ,. .a am' , "-rsfifi - 2: ' 3 _hfi% ;.,--:a3§$2mant t 2 cfifigzder the maitér fif isagtima fl%émit%%£ af w$r* f§:a§e§ mf'a:§§._t§&é$r and aa 33 auisifié fihéa ¥m§i§E;Q§§; §§§v.$B%§%%§%fif 'ta§$ & aaczaxma yg assay: as :§j%§:"t§€'§é%;ti%n%$?$ t%fifi&:.
:?he_ 2"'"r§§§%§§a§t.:gi2h$a2 aévfirtifig ta 7ih§VC§%xQ*?§_t§% §§:it:eaa§ am termg 3f the filfig algag l~..£'» .§g aha: ihfi §fi§;ti§fi€£ xafi f&;i%§ is fifitfif
--i§t§ " 3§ 'ggr§ama§: gmrfiuaai in iha lafiiar 'fi§§%KQ§Q9E égtafi :§$?.2§$§; figacgiléfi ifia iééder afi§ Ifsrfeitafi tée fiifi assmrity fig fifififif fiatafi ';;12§2$Efi fianexmrami, Efi. Having ragayé ta t%§ §a:e§: mifitgié Cfififiiitflfi fly ifie Ewfi Eefiganfiagt :3 :33 mattar cf M ?
a§€ Efififiififififig tfia §a:i§i$&%r*3 aiaim gnday aigaga 32 $5 tha fiifi fifiaumgmi 35$ $i£§§§ $@§,$.?,: sf tég fifisfi? & H; gugxg, i&§ éiéiai, misfiixfistien aad gggsaasagtiaa 3f vifi§;"a§§§%_ reiavagt. factag jfifiiifififi iat$:f§:ea:§~~%ifi§* t§% fiE§%E im§%§§$fi$ M:
w .3'.
3 £2 %%a z&3u§t,V"ih$ wrgi gghztgag £3 :23.
§£i$g$'. Tag a§fi%zT %fi§&x§$%»; §;, tiéi 3 §e$§$§de§t :3 gmagfiégg é §i$§¢&:$§»i$ iasaaé ta 2 .
ihg Ewg reggfifiésat :§w;fia§fii£§r ":§éC;§&t :i$&&£'§ ,4.
zs§ra£e&tatiaa5 f; éaia§i "x3§,é;;€fl§g ?,9.ESQ8§ '"w§*Aa§eXare3~§, ?, FE 32$ 3 raagaativaiyM§né'§§3§.flFfi m ix thg light gf tbs" §@3e§$3:i§&$' §m§£a aafi a§c§:é&n£% with Sd/-
JUDGE figfi