Karnataka High Court
Sharada.R vs R Subbaiah Setty (Dead) on 29 May, 2012
Author: Anand Byrareddy
Bench: Anand Byrareddy
EN "§;%£E EVEQH CGEERT SF §{:§§€E'~E;%T;*%E<A AT LB5%£'~§GAL{)RE DATED THIS mg i2<;"' gm' SF afigy' L. H BEFORE mg :~1c3:\:* BLE; zviaé §UST1CE :g'>E%R:g%p%_E:§B:YV'VV_ REGULAR FIRST APPE:;;L 7 {)}?':§t3;!;"i::;§;Vé' BETWEEN: x ' V i L Smt, Sharadaii. _ --_ Wig. Sri. S. Renukacharya, Die, Sri. KIT. _I<;'a:_11aia;§/:"'Sé3iij;f, " _ . . Aged 38 ye2_i::s;% '€S%.:d2:*sEiini*',' ~ Yellamma"T£:«;1:§:.}v<3':'--_S'é::a§;{_,_V" " " » Vijinapufa; 7 " ' _ Bang3§1=:§1's:§'§G §iEfi.;ff:',-- Sri. Sic. ia:e:'~S:'i. KT, ':zgm:;;:a%;;% sag; gfigeté 34% _ :
R;'{a N324, Egéfifika A W A :§'€e::*5»-.:§A::éE§:sj%:2: '§'<:::i§E:; ' , "S;Vyag2:raij«2::§z;:g;j3:$ A H.A??EL1A?x:T$.
{E §i "E§ . Sad;2§E:i:s3.§_§2a§ fig wegaéfi Ami S':::i,':. §a:'§<::«:_§a:32ar:i3 2§{§:Is3s:a:@} * if Sr; 3 Szfiisaiaiz 332:;
iii M ' ~ 1"») SE30: by his §:%g::EV:a:p:*::s:::'1i:::%:?'::$:
22} 3232:, ?::s:1mamm2':, WES. §3}:»;;: R. Sufbbaiah S:'~:§§§,a Maggi'?
E3} Miss, Hernaiaiha, ._ D10. late R, Subbaiah Sstzy, It/iagbr,
2) Miss,Ka1pa:ia§ « 910% late R. Subbaiah Sexy, .
Majeg ' V' d': Miss, Lavanyafi ~ V V ' _-
D/'05 Eats R.._*Subbaiah"S&t:y, "
Majer, -.
5; Sri.LaE<;shfr:§§_Raf1:ai_::ih Se;§'iy';' S?zj;'E;::<:'E§: Si.§2£3ai'a§; 1'%f£ajQ1;_ ' ' ' Eézssfi ':15 E56) firs E*::'si..§é';:§: of V §\§e:::* K§i3E:né2,_ h€i;.:*::'ér'; . «.%.':Ba$~:waaVap§:a Raavzi, §{:~.E€. ?:s.:3n3, §é%iga§:}:*e"3é, ' .85; R; §é;g:;:a,::::a:é: ea}:
3 S §:£*;:1':s€..__'§.§a§-:.s,;':»§$&§ E33; Eéis Egg} :*§§r£:$$:::a1iiv:.::s:
AA .3} Séiii. Sgrasammafi £5 yeafs, a 355:3. his 3:: Eagaggzaéfsa Ssiijg F E3} Sina gifiiljiliég 25 323333? '§> RA») E513. Eats: S3'; Eagziniizzéiia, Séffijé, <3} Sm: Maxéaaiha, 23$ }!e:§:'s5 Q/Ci, Eats: Sgi Jaganzzaiha Sciéy, (22) {O {<2} 31% rfa NOs'3:7§, LKumbaz*pet, KR. PLIF§.i1"EL ._ Bangaiereafiéfi £336; 1 {M Szi KN, Viawaiiatha? 55 y:"%2i:--si_, S,/Q. Eats: Srik Narayaziappa, Cfsa Ncrfl Iii Pawn Brim'-3:3, .
Near Ci\iI.C.5 KR, Paimrn, ' V' LBangai<:>re»-S68 G36, " '
4. 81:11:. Saraswa§:ha,;I1ma.;'55' _ <:/0, x Marathi " A 7 KamakshiV.P;é1}s'2;§ ' VBan.g:i1':3:f's3:.: '1; V' 5, S§2:§"{%éwr3:1:ma:;'L«.V 3 Wig» S:=%_L.' E'€aga:*aj;''?§/:ajVé§::, ' R53: Gazéégafa B€'£d§':i §{"z};§§a§::, ;€:,i§;2i'::::% §is§:*ié':--.. {;=%,R;: . §6 RES?{}N§ENT§; fi{..Si::§v.'Ekfizzgifxzzgaéhanagfi Adaascaés far R€:3§G'iEfi§§Tf£S 2{a to <3}? '--R£S§::§§;a<é§:1z:é & Rsggendsgt Nai S25: R&ai%sh::::V§<;:::, Agiééégaie :'é:j fiagsrs. Lax §\§%3;¥;'i.l§$ ébr Re$;§£}n§:e::i ?*E:3$3, Eézsé'---K. .f§E:%:2:}§ R39? gééyggaza ix' Raspggéerfi. K2: $3 2):
>2} '45' 4, 2 .3 é«¢%%
-- ' TEES liggaégz E733: Apgaai ii; féfiéé azgész' Sssiéégrz <96 9? @223 .. ._{_"f§§e {>5 Ciaié ?re<:eéz2re§ F938 agaizzgi £16 guégracsmi 322;}: ésatzias ",3 2:3 sjaiazd 2§.{}3'Z{}€}2 pagssé ii: €}.ElN<},f:3C:f$3 23:: i%%§: 53:: 3? aha':
KXEE ;'~':<;i':%§:i§>:::/2E Ciéy Civil $1: S€iSSi{'§f§S iudga, V8232;-g:§§:>:*§: éismiggéag éhé: 323%: $31' §3£Z%f'€§{§{}§"§ zmd p(}SSif:SE%i0I: V This Ritguiar Fiféii Appazah Ceming :}:_1; f£).:' :§ :p{;:':i{:1'§ seiilamenig this day; {he C:"2L::': (fi€§iV€*3If€;}€§H'1§iE f0_'§'i<n;?fii2g: " ;UDQEN?f '§h:3: maize: having baea :*e:fé%§';::cE -is méldiazieafi {E16 parties have arrivgzd at 3 geiileniéizfg xx.€hiCI":vi.;*§%aéi'§ z;3 'uE;&e:':« *1\giE::x:/§;:;1%:;:,NDLM--. 501:» SE'1f{f:,EiME,NT LENDER SE.CTI_QN.. 8§=5;f0__E <::§>j<':_ READ_«--1'}fETH RULES 2;: AND :25 fii? %*m_;s';=, "'K;xRN;<§;::é;':<.A_-- A{:mL PROCEDURE ggx/@E3:Afi§i<QE;a,'RU;,'Es? :::.:::'}{~:}.':);:.:'. ' ' Tifse §gVr:§é:;Aé§b§é?a._:2:3iz:e:§ 'bag is s;u§mii 2:25 f<>§E9w$:« E. T_%1a:?_.:j:§.é§e§E;a;z::s had, fiisé ihs: gérégérzzaj sad: Seazéng {}E;';§;N5.%3G§E%83 $33: 2: rsiéef 93" gjaziézéog zaié ssgaraisa :%:$;:§?é:: i»;fé{?: I'€.f§§§Z{:i 3:3 3 i::::m$ éescsiésfifi fzafijg ii': 3&2 . " §%:v§V<2w 332$ :3:%ir:§ 'i'6§€§S,' xaiiiécirg gamfi as E36 sfiiimésgeé ' }<i§{Ei s%<§:§é£i<}i:a§ 5&5: Civéé amé Ssieséans Euéga, Eagsgaéaye :31"; Eéié ;'%z'E:::'ch§ 2@§%?; zzggimi which 2&3}: §§'£§:f'§'%3§ ?{.VF.'%,N<>.?§?EZEi}§E, "fhs afaregaéfi agpaai 1?v'E'§.'% i'°£}C€é"f€{§ H zg maééaiésn fa: :'s:~:@ixi§§g i§'1£ éésgaizi §€i'év'€€§'S {ha paztéaia E33 :5 %i"::: <::2::§*se:--: ifs? :11<:::E%2,::i<>§";§ :%ze::j«; Elms: :"e;~;r:3§v::d ihcér §§f§§}:i{€3 E21356 2:;'r::s£i {:12 $326: éhééamiéizfg %:3r§':1.<~; and <:<mdé:§(:ms;: E. Baih the §>2';::i<;2:§ p2:r¥:icip2::eé $2 $23 :*aae:i.:'--::"1_:§<}:é" 3' $§§'i§i';I"{:3d izmj ibis sz-iiiierrxegzi. zippeiizmt :29'? E333 appeiiagzi no.2? her younger' brQiherV':§AA%::'2£'::§ $271.9 s<::iic:n:::iVV<}fV 9 the abews: d.iS§}l2i€. Sims: ms E" z'<3§'§2<}:}c;i';%::i~ :":§_n5<;r<:§ E36 :*ep§es;6rs:ed by his Eegzfi r::§;*é;s€:1:ai§'¥:$'." Tbs':"é;23§d.__ic::ge:§§ reprgssntaiix/es are not p:*e:~:e:zé;'a,E§é3p<>n<ier::.§<:§;'3 £5; £E1.é_t$VPHA hoider sf R:::~;§<>nd€n;§.:20.:'~§~ 2;n§-- zszici-~..§j:€: sz3§$3'vi.h;2.:v h:% is signing {his _f:3f;_ i?j:e%§f 31350. Lessgaé Rapresenliaiivc no'2c: is shs: is 22130 signing this .ag%c-emefi:{A 9:; b§:}1a§f Rfqéreseniatéves 23 and 2%; w.h§3 312:: :11:r:!?:_er':;.nd sgisziés respcsciixieiy. """ s;{;u<4i=e;i b'y~.:h':: §;sar%:§éé:'"fiVr:a: £16 appeiiaiiis and IE1: is'€';:;p@z';éf¢:;:§ :§:>;3"%:;:V:?QL,2:'g';1;:éd té fssmat {heir £§i:§;::3i::s in reggae: €21? §fi=:m Haifa? {>:§iE}"€3A:.'$"'L'3f1i.':-{E-ESEE msirsiioned 'aeiew fssr an amezmi Es;,§,'i¥§:§ {;€}'f<:Gnc: iakh §s:':§: Theusani eiziy} is"; *Z§'z,1§E_ gsté fiszai $f's::E_s3_:.3ii$:":§ Sf aié [hair Ciaémg §i1}W&f€§.'§ {hair 23%»: ' v. 3 5% tbs: :;:§é'--:§3;2§s%l§s2'2:2%0§ §3a};a%1e :3 £23 aggeifagig. ~ 313 '§'€:'~f;§?:{}%!:§€EE§ 123.3 E338 agraeé :0 gay R§;.'?i"}§§§:'~« {éfiagges §€'%f§E':§}/ ?§Ei3E}i§{/Iziifl szsijg} is each :3? aha ;%§§:€§:iB"{f4; absizég :%':si:%r §'iii§§§$C§'§i'f:'; §«,:§12::*$ E33; cézsagas r:§,§2§€§§§ dgzzaw. 63:': Szé Cfiaran 331:3: in fa%;<§a::* <53?" ihs ,5s.p;3&§§aE:: R. Shaméa 221$ sisqag §"e;{>.§?;i}i'§§2 §L:'awn am 3% Baéaii if} fzwiéig: 5 6 9%' this 2"'? /?:;3;::::§i:é:2{ R. ¥:2::§<;ai<::~;}3a E/E::z*t%:§; %5&f:.:s:*e: {fig Hisnfiéie High €935': GE} 1%: of fé':?=i}f§§§}:;f Séiififilfifiiii. apgséiagriig ggggretj is C€_'?s£_'§p€§";'iE$ miik E"€:'°§§}{};?§{i€§§§ :";<:a3 fix' V' (hi: éeeé :f<::g§:s:e:*;s(i in rsspaci sf §'{t'i§"§§ 3&0} sf' '7' Scheiizzie describtsd %:::3E<:«w 22$ the :05: 0f {ha R::s§Q:1V;§<;:;;£ is 4%. Dispuii: regardE:1g Egan": ':«3,§.f.-._ m<:n:i:§:":::d" ii: 2 iii; * scheiiuist beiam! is peniéing §€;f8;3~b§:fo.r¢ §'Eé.¢A15'%f_§;"Ci3:i§: iudga S3, §:}§'J§SiOE§, B2::2ga§0réR'§§L:r;2§_ sand"{he'§é§ftiesVV¥;2gree {hai {$222 dés;pL:{e: reg2{§€§.§:1g :h§é"'§ir::éé' b}§'.:'i6€§i§€ E§'"i:§ié said Cmzri, ' ' " '4 V'
5. inA.respecig3f7.,.:E:s: i£em fi:é':;:§oned in the sxzhedule }:>5i':'s§z{;':h€:;=.par:i€;:;'; Vvshazéé: {he amauni of Gnéjg} 121:: deposit in Bangaiore in Savings Ejéank a3Qfi'g_w§§h the acgrueéi énteraai as per {ha s:>:9€*3,_é:r {if tE2e_H@«§§'bE¢'fifgE3_Cs9a::'€ §£%};€3€§ {}3.€é§,2{§Q9 §'céSS€{§ $3 ihis 2i:§;;:§::§§,.V E2} Tiéé' {:9 ::¥3im:; zzgaéénsi 3235?; Qtiiér, ssifiszazj ;32':§;:., grsssm $3' Euiara £}£:i.'.ii§% aigreazsi abexrs Er:
" §é:<:;é'§ :::;a:=':i:><:f:; E 33$ 3 33 §s::s,«;»:§%'§a€sé ii: {$263. V S£h¢E§{?§'t§. ;L'?~?f;1C$K3?, 'ii %: azéexsz at? £235 ;§§03*§§;ai§ agffifimfiiif £i5?7€'x;'3§'€i§ iiém ':b~2~2:2*sa:$"::: {Ens ggziéisig iizr: gariées 9321;' %§{:.r:'§§§<3 €8i§E'E :23 § §f§§i:%?§€ f iii: zébgws zgppazzé in %:+:::'m:'~;; sf as 2:§0:'€%»;;:§:i ::gz'e$ms?:€, é E33 3:": vimsx £2? fizz': ;:§%3:'::s«;;:§<i .::g;*s:<:;2":i::":{, {$19 e2§2§>::§§a:1é.~; p:*::j,2 $91" :':i§':m<i of 81$ £332 ::oL::*t E/"es/;': gaééa EX?) Parties: wééé ;:p§>a':.:;:r 0:3 28.{}5;2€:i§;2 §:}<§§?:;?:%"Vv':h;é 4 H0:27%:s§:3 Eiégh Cami {sf Karzrafakzg Bangafaém §;;s:V;:nLg »:%€€z':-:s:>§0r<ie:rs in {fifmfé Gfihe '<').gFi;if3£"'Q?3§§~§,._ ...«.g.g...--r-
sCHEDULE. < Rem Nai: V' She bezzréng N<}.& '§fE€iél駧lfiZ3§; Egg: :9 32 fl; and Nani: ie SC?3.E{Z§E Zfé '§_.."::.I"£C§ :_;§:ua_t$d Puram 2/'i§E::1§/.26, §<.R: Pura.m Eéobii, Ba:1gaf§€3I'c'S0i:i:§: T_a:ii:"§: anV& '%}§2Lmded an; E35: 133%; .' ' Site Naif}-V 5' Wé;+;3,_ Vb}<:v-
NQEEE33' ': R0¢;{{% V Ssgh§y;Su¢NQA2, ;:egg;§¢@2:"
%*£:.ag}e;&'..b¢a:*§i:g "K%22:n$s§*:uma§% E\?<>£i7€§, aétazsieé' :2:
Si:"%;':;:v,__.K,«i~Z. ifiarain Vfiage, ?':::':m'; Eisbié, ' 2 _, ;'%_zmg;1Ea:>§'é:V..S:3::{}3 ?;£:.:%< zmé zfisasgréfig is Was: éégfi icmé {:5 ?§'f:. g30i'*;%::3:': :3? ii}:-:: Eggs; bfiéifi cgngiraciaé V 2::2é_ :fé:s€.::::'§*; éé; 2: sift: zmd §§1i§3§€C§ 3:2:
Efiaeéi ivy: 32%: ?€{:ai%EeZ Wag: figs: :}fK::;:1I:>::r2: Féagapgggs ?~E<;:'§%3 '*£§E{2:g:: Eviarin Raaé 253:1 Séis E0, 355., Eségégsgizég is Sm: Cémégarama 23:26:
Saszfih by : {,:{}§Ef£i*§E'%':i§'§£}; E2136.
" 133233;' 53 item [email protected]:
:»:g.:é:,§{}::z- képi in Sjgz3<§§<:a::': gm, Erangh, Eza:3§;al£}r:3 $3253}; Tzgzzk fizz Sa¥§:;g, A€g:Qi:'§:i M N<:s.2{}2?."
in terms of the fietilementf ihévkagned f:f3»:' '{%n;--:J9'~.. gespancieizi seeks is ham N05.
@2909: and E20092 a:_"% .§§gé2V%%A'A.1vé:;§(Rs.%%é,C%é0;« 63021 {Rs,E,-$3,000!» in__3fi)5 ,mj :§e%V':i§§,$;;1i'::;§§::ij;7~%'wish is raceived subjectto h 3 . 'V K 915 Seitiemanz is iaken an r::c9:'é ":f§<:' 3%' {ha trig} £93223 siagég r:";e:><:1i%§'i::;;%é:': :&.§§reg§3f'ih€§' afiavfi séitiemsgzi. TEES sear? fesg mid '§9=§:fé;:§'é¢d :9 3:6. apggsziéams. Furihsrg ii: {@5333 0? {Es 1's:é"::§§%:§§:§i:::: "_§EE:_e'~§:j;5;;'§a§Ea;n§$ 33:: mtgzzireai $3 €X€C¥..§§£ 21 3&3 éfififié ég fgvsééf :3? éézé ivézéraf 3BS§{}§'§£§£I"?£i. Sims» 3&3 3 §§«3§E;:§i$ 33% Saéfi :9 '. w§':§%: 'arxafiegfees 9? fizz': Siiélfi Ge:>x?@:'::::'1er::§ i%'i€<}*' are féégiéffiéé is ' éfigiaia §}§§G2€ psrmiggim £9 iifiééfiiéifi fig: ggig @6336 312$ thsiafeysg % 9 {he 2':§:sp::§§2:n§s; giéifiiiifii éimai as gééjiaén sszsgh §:3::'m%$s§{>V:z ;*:.%j:{i :9 :h$:'e3§:c:° sxssuis {E3 3221:: ziecé, withir: 23:21 gum' Eirgggé --<1:!1*"~ msrzths from isisciajyx