Jsw Steels Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 April, 2012

[Cites 0, Cited by 1]

Karnataka High Court

Jsw Steels Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 April, 2012

Bench: Chief Justice, B.V.Nagarathna

3 . SRE B. KU Mfi}? GGEVIJA, $2.50. I§.i3--5$B, L'Ei'nCQE,{}§"~§3'I SANEBU R '§'AL,UKg.

§%E2LL&RY 583 1 E9, SENCEE EDECAE} BY §,.§~?.S 3{ 1 EEE .§{2%.§.!§,z%§£3i'V1.?vii§.;

2%§EE} AEEGU'? E36 YRS, W' ,2' 0 ' B V §§U§»-"§i§Ré\. C:G'~ﬁ.?'§}i'§ 3{2}B.F€AGANNA 6333;? I313"

AGREE A302}? 3:6 YRS, S/'O.B,KUE'VfARA G:GE?3f'E}P%., ._ 3 {EEB K, B,é1SA§f:"%Rz'%J 9 §§GE:1f} 5333915'? 36 YRS, T. S/'©.B1KUi'v7§{AR§§ GQii%"E§.§':;'---.

3§4}B'RU§}§=Ez'%; GOWDA, gag-3:3 A}38'i3":."' 3:*§s:f:{.s, A S;'{}(E3a§§§5??;°£fxE%:E £:_§§~z§::-.;a. ; . "

3:35;z:§::m;:~:;@,r:3;:52;'? ~ zr~;G'E;::a; §,;;B@U¥f:§"' 45 'Y RSg EB ,/ £5: £3. E: j'%\.s:AE7€;z§ fciﬁsagfgygg 3'g=a:;§:SH'A§§":'§2;ég __ AGEX} 35 YRS; - V _ 1:) fG.'Jfg5.E{"{..§F'f.f-§E§iE€;;;L_ §'<:}w'i>z:M sj2';;,§§,!a§7é§EZ'; §z;A'é*;;~:£é_,1.;2;:~;;§i ' ' - L-SE3';C€?{;=£}'{§;E".?"ff SAN{}UR '£m_§}§ » §j3€?.,,VLé.}f?;"§ ::s.§$?;§ .$ E{ESE3'{}E's§§}E*ZF*€'.f§ .§§§*%j fs§;::'5"~..,:a.:§§'.:::;:>L.L§2:$ 5-K3:-E: §<'{}E%i Eié :33: 58$;-'=§*€E';SE%5 §r':3:z R;3;«:5v$:;§ §A§z:::§s§~§'::*;.;':'.:;'Fag SR3 K,?€$-SEZE?€E'i--?'"§aS§ 53:32: 2x322; §%::%§.:~4;} 5233:; $§~§'.%'---§'§,?%;'_f%'i.3"s£;%-"%;E'§€.: §;?{:f:GE§?\£SEZ.Lé mfg r:£;s,?a:g:g.§§§ 3: ésgaﬁi 2;;-32%»-" E<"'§'E€;§%;§ " '§:§:$ '25J*§_:'§ §»>E'§mm3 :3 FELEE.-D EEI'€E}E§§'{ AE€',E'§CLEf;S 225 3:

2:'-3:,'E'_;GF' 'E'Ei'E3 CQ§'~§S'E'ETi§§'EG?€ Q? ENEEEAE P§%§JE"'E§\§G TS §§..§E\SH N®'i'EE'§€A',€'EOE'€ £}'£'i2?,f2/£38055 'JEDTE: '§§.f§\3N-El, "FEE; ' 2 V I,/Q --: 3 :- NG"£'§E'ECA'E':§OF€ E}"fI2QX7.2GG§ \»'K3I:S ,5'-"aJ'€i'\E--G ANE} TEEEZ MZNENG I.;§€2z'%SE§ E}'.E§E§;.i} §3E§iAR§§'s§{}- N0K?a:'.'£..L..:25§.6 E}'E','E4.3.2@C}6 Viiﬁfji fi;"sZE\E#E?.

'E'E'§Z.S E3'Ei"I;'§.'I'"§'EG?'§f §3EZ§E'f'x?Cz- §93;.}EZSER'~§E1§) .E%,NE} CGMING GE'? E'-'QR PRGNG§§§*~5€3 §ZR:'iE§"§' S? Q§?;.{3'E3R "§HES §}§15f, f§§5§..G.&%Ti'§§NA J2, §!§j%.I{}E§- '1"§~*EEZ §3OLLO'§JE?\EC%:

S R D E R. N,z'3.G?ARATBNA $3:

in thig writ, p:3€.§ti0n., the §§fj'£i..f.,§i;{_}§}€'.§ .};i;??;§S"--..$z»5%§2';§§€¥ﬁ'"§.§'}€f'_ z}Gi§f§{:3£:;Lcm3 ﬁaited 2'?.G2, T '~a1ri:3¥;

€Am1<'iX:,:r€ss--E $3 C2} 'F85;§}€*:ZE'£i£r"£3lf§'-v..§1§1€§ *€:§:1,<3 m§::.§ing:_ Ei<:a§3é am-s:<;: §éﬁ§:§§2§8$ §A:11:€:>;a.:_r;é~F} iggzzééi-_ f2w't§%:2.:.,. 3?: ihﬁ {bird §"t3$p{;::§:€::2%.. 2% §§i:'&§:%?;£§§1T'~§.3' fsa',§::g§§:'ér.'V 32:} aéomsézier {he 2:pp§iC3;t§:éi'1=:f§§:i 84,€34.£99§ {A'§::';t:e:&;'u3f£z~« B}, TEE §;i€:'§aE€gis;;1"1.€=>_:2Eirhéezh i5 5: {3ff}E"ﬁp€:E?;:;J,, E1225; 36%: up an " V' "-§Z:§€,:ig,'§§'23;EV'»:3s:i 'gigs; p3E';£ij:1% 2:: §.§"1s:: S?:.a§€-- <3? §{2i:r:é2;i:a%;2:. ii E2215} _;2}i%;p§'§§fé:A<:%;:"§5:::"v gzigiijgi {:5 as §n§::'ir1g§ Eeaage, <}t..-1%? an arsa <2? i;'?'?6 a.<tA:2s'::s. in E%§f:ama;°2z5vJ;3§::j; Sz1§':{"}ia:':° 'E'2:E:2§g E3é::§E22z';"j; "~,§"}§$éi:'°i:€E'é:.,,_{:'::": ﬁééﬁéi E§%X ii i;$ €E:s.=:= {:s§é;E1€= §3:':%%:_2§.§::'*<3m'--r:'* *::§%:.22':. $*::é{§; a§::pi§§zE;§..%:§:é:': 2%-*z:.§; £:::§; {?=:}:':;=~;§{§{-é2°<-iéé dé:.;s=3§3§':.{*: mpeeziﬁii .,.§.é§>r5--$€:":i:21:§§3z2s. '7E'E1%3 p€=2f:1:.1?z>n@2' ieearﬁé, ihzzi the thizﬁ ree$psm&<:ni had 2333:} made an z2_§3§§§€a;"f{.§oa fa}? gran: sf 3;:

/J,/» W: 4 :~ gzxiniizg £82135 9;: 3}.@?.19§%Q ifm" 2'75 acras 1:: S,R§.Bi0iék. AccG:*<:§i;1g to {she §e%i¥:.i.<3:1e:x izhéz sgaiii 2:p§3§i<ta?,§;<}3:'; s§'i{><}{i éeenzeé ;'a;;?<::7i;€<:§ an 3§H.0i§.1981 am pm' Eziie 24$} 0? {he §v§§:§i:1g§ €0:1e::{--:ss:Z<:111 Rufiﬁé-3, E958 {h@r§3:'n21fi.:3r re§€:":§{:_:i to as 'me Zi:£C.§€uié2s;'; far the sake of 'm"evii.y}. Sn w31"§f:':f<€2:»%'§.;_'§':72;;f1?'*,., lihfi p€iit:.i<>§1€;:' Eearzxt. that this Sums Gav€'rnm.e:3ﬁ"':E'12:{%_ i é' ussiéi 332 :"a{:>E,;Z§E3i{:21'§'i.::§:: S2}.I}{',i",§{}§1iIE§§ mming 3-:::21"%r. Qve'{:r ;1_zi"';:5.;f{3:1»..:f;g.f j 2i{',Y'€S in fmzmzr Sf §"£'.$§}{}'£1§€;'*E1.?;', E'€{>,:E._ iéz:-:1 2'?.:i?;;.2%'}--f}'7i&Z.. a':;::i $2££§$e{;:2€:%r:.?i',Ey, ihe Eészzéééa ag§j:"3é3::mssm,~.. 2;a;--:«1;$*, é>;§%?i:%:i.€d 03:: E=~';,S3,2§€f}€§a E: :55 §,h.{%:"::;:§;£: ,a}"§ {.f1:€*; giagfsiéé;::{7:':*"é.'E:22;':. '§:'§'§{;'. €i§'€:'£i g:z*21:f;ii:€d iii} regpimiiérrii; E'~§s:§-;§3' '€¥§"}§_j§9:._;>: area aippﬁeﬁ 3%: by €hé;~:{ fu.1_E§; avszriaps. Thaéj, 9::

2QsG'?,2{,s*{}6', £1356'..?:,'$"{:::?ii$%"'«"'Gs.>V€r§§n3em. had Eszsuéid :1 C{>'r':"§g;"s:%a"':<i"::::'if: *mé:._§_<:§:1g*'L€.he ezrvea GE E€i'€1S€ §_§r3._::%:é3é ':9 reggéégzzéani: ?*§:i;;.'§..§r<::::31V E38 acres E18 E34 2191135-gm Assazﬁéng fa %;'*::.a::3_ :}_"".)i.';',':{':i'§,Ei'{3E'_E€-i':."._¢, iihé? gram? of E32236 313 ::*§;%$p<}z2{i<i§2§ Na_3 $3 an ;:=.xg?5t::j;f:~€s§€: sf §}{,'ﬁQi-7{'?§" :>22'i§h{;::€:, "§§:.::°i;s%<§.§.a":§:.§;{:t:: 3132:? %:.:V:é;i:js:f<}:';;a azzzééé, '.§"'%"2€:':*€§"<:i::°é~":,_ i§§:%si;';;§i:e: %;.%:m*a% bésiéég 2:3: z1§§4a%:'§1::2i'ii33: :*<:':::1s3{§j:; ms: §>§;%§;i%§:}'§:<:~:* "hag xfiied ﬂag-3, '%?§§'i'{. §€§l:i'§.i<m xS5€,'€:§§:i§"i§};N§,§f§€3 afmremenﬁoiéed reiiﬁfg, g\E4"\>"'"'~1«x\ "':§i'"

gmiimizlary 0bje{:t;:<>:":-:ae.T by imer aiia <:<>z1i:e::.d_i::§§ 't.hat the p€:§.it;1?:>:1e:r' has :10 {EEZEZSS {>5 agtmm 2zga.i:"::'-;"£: re:s;;}{m{§;em': I'€e:>&3 sizzii 312%; no ZE}{T?.:'.5§ ::'-siandi ':13 ma1in*5£',a.ir: '£,E'§.€', wrié: p€E1i'{.i{}EE. 1% ES e:*:{>n'[.é%:1d&d tha': the p€::ii:i0§1er had 22ppi.ié=:d far gggzgrzi, sf 2: mi':1iz1g §f;"£:1E3€ in Black 'Q' :11 E:£u.n1arasxa?a.m§; I%%a:§g§§:f"L:':»3;?'§sgr€in f€ES§f3I1d*8I?£' N<}'3 .13 gra.:1€:€d i£3é3;S€ an 2?'§2,-i2::{}G§'3'*.._ "H{;*a§%'e2?é3¥; i.h<s: 2:p;;i§<%ai:£«:>z: {sf the g3ei;iti@::€:rj2%:;£is:=;-i>;éiEj:{§1jz3's{ir';=v"s"35$;'--§'l2;:§°1'%:;21{%%£ AV 215:; :3': EQQQ ami a. 2%: nest was tzxraéﬁgf ":19. %rz3f:é:._:r:é:13:.:'éV-'i"Es::3£::f3 31:1 Eéamariaciuzigia Rangssg 1=Jhi<:?:*v--,L7§;%'2:s ss1;aE;$€<;i§:..:é':":*::1';~g g:*2:ni.€& {H1 2'?,§:§.2>%€§{':e {§:;:§1é%>:14:;»§3;~A<'.§§~»£;53;'W'§'Ei?§{;:%'z§§.1i:::;"e9 f%§..'§§:{Tf€?".§%'§E§_E'(?§'1.? §.9§§§;»: éiherﬁ 'carats :13 app§_§{':21i:.i{>r: ~15)? §fvi.'i;€§.¢ p§%€j§:fi§'§:i3€§'_. pending for §_,-,§E'3§Z'§ sf miﬁ§:zg_ 7;.é3:2§S<:--':._£3"K'2:'m'2:§;1:s*a,>a:ny' Range and {4here§ar<: théi p€t§"§.§{}ne:'=._Ef:2::é rm. §C31{?Vi;:S ..§?§§§£§f§di E19 :"::a§nt.ai§f: i:'§1:§$ Writ pei;.%f:.§£}::., ii %;~;:«:$ :3€:X:it4 ctgzlienésd izﬁgsf; 'E'E'§€i pg-3'5§i"i.i<m £5 bassd .a::..f;:f£$§i :§:.3,'§téi;:e:1i gang': '%{:i'1e§"*€ E5 ss:,:§§3:*'<::s:§i<m of ::;a":.€:*iaE f§i{i§'.S3, "§~1;:;ig ::4V?:€:"_"_v»§::E:}:i::§;,f §€:a§é3. ;;7r2é.::€;.a*5¥: ii: :'<::§§$:1§§§:=2'3: 'wéiié

-V §m2:E§g§z:::"2;§:é%{E Ezéjg :;,§{.'§"§§}§ §ErE2:::2.§;g§§:.':;§ §_§§:'e:<:"m§* 9? ihﬁ gzsg-:'§éiis::362' 'V'~..$::*-5§€§},{'%;'3'i»Ezé:%€3% ézéaiée _!3;§'§E'E§?X":l§"'§',w§{§ ?;:s;:»+ 339:3 ":sEr";.€}§,{}:¥:;'2: Es; zmiﬁ _ E é "'€jZ:1:f5ra-§%;»:°€:§ this pé:'{.i':i<:s::<«3:* {EEEEEEEGE §'e§:g:r;; §§.§.:':9§'EiE":{:€ zrariéih resfsreméa is the grawr. sf inizaing E62138 is R€*:S§E3Ei§§3E":'E E''§<>.8.' :

Mfg

-: ? :--

"E116 'p€5:':éti:m<3':* has aEs:»;2;:> smppregsed tézés: £13131: 'athai the Stats: Ggveyimzezzé. has gr2m€,£:%<£ miz'f:i:1§.§ Eaaezssusé in ;'s:$'p€<;::i: sf Rékﬂiéifiéiﬂikifgéi <i£:p<3s-321%. in Esietz 0i." B§<}{:E«:s 'A1 "IE zmdi 'E' cs? Eéitzniéirswaimg.-=' Railgcaz Ehaugh Ehif eippiigtzﬁiéﬁié maﬁg' by {ha p<:*;i'.£'{:i<§1':€s:~ was; far 21 mizmzg Eease in Sf §'§'é1f}'}£E}TEiE§".¥f"2i{E1}' Rzamge. That. i'.h::-3 §{»éi:t.<ér {§:2.'§;:%;=:£EV %3§E°§§i§i{§E'1 by {.3253 ;}<:i;iii{:§1se.:" ii} ihaé' "Si;a§a:% {'}§}*g:.--"ﬁg:§';?sé':";-if} <7{k'j2:r§§; A' incii.<ta.i'€€E %:.%12;f:: 5; recgzzesi. was rr§a%;<i§_€"--?;.<3¥ 'ihéz? ~§',§f§L'.*»§."t'.--_%é3.-.§;,';é;."§'~. g-5,11%-,f{:'i'. C{3:n5s€3<g2.:§:rzt,iij.,:g {he Sizzte C%<3v€-::f:§:§:e:1£. an 2'i?T,€%23'V:?V»GiG7'{}, ggramfséi ::':.§2':§;':':§;{ E5323:-:;€r e:7;'§T*'"'§'{§T::3? .:::;6;%é§.ii..%:<:::s;§:" Z4l39=.:::g-::'2.;:{§:s§";§2a; Rzmgs vvide A:1:1e.X::reI~.§'€s§ hewéévar' been §5u§3p}"é:%fE§E§€:_z:"i. A3-is{?~«.._:i§1e;::éti.E;,§{3:2_§.r has §_"}i£§.'{':§*i.8.S{i*.t'§ are fram the third :'@s§;{.}z1£'£e:':§.-- §'j«.}'. §;:=;s3"§:«:f';;*;g g§3{}1{"}g§{ifc"ﬂ pésrmiéi %}}_; }{3§?;=:-3:" daéeii §3=;;I.'§§i/:iai'%€%8, :%i:'Eﬁ:,_i§%§1 is. pr{;€§m:§%:§ 2: A§3::€::x2.z§°e--E%55 'E%:§<;§'<3<:*;€:1 .i:§;ff: $f;:é:§ i}%wi€:"§1::1€'::§: E3.:;1& §.$S'i§é;'€§ 2*: pzjbiéit ';;.::é',if§<:2:i'.§.ar; '%'\,?"§7{h %~%%§§a.:dV"'é:::§%."_~-ihgé"3g;f§az'};€T 3%" mégzinggg Eeazssé? 'ii? r::>.ssp{>::s:§e:f22'; E'\Ea:},3,

--V E}a3$§§§;§§€%'*A§;2z:'*§€§:;:§ E<;¥1{}'a>s,;3{:<ig;&*; :3? §E:s*. sazié §a<?:3:.%;§ §E"34'3 aazrié; peiééiészz f,E*::::<sg-._u'::a<::§5:1 §E§_€:{é :33} E523 E.,2@€f%'?, 2%: ggf §,'§';a:'€:§?'{::§°:: <:<3§§§<::1{§é,=ﬁ éffzaii whiszzg ziése :n§z::;z*:g 3621553 "has; Essay: §;§:'2m*€¢.%:a:§ ii} ifhs M'§€'{.i"ii€}I1€E° an 2?iG8.,:?4@%@ an Razmzagméaifga Eiemgée, Ehﬁ /var

-18% pefz:i'£.§.:mé:r <:a.:::1{:r£:: h21w-"6 am}; §§:"'§€3i--"23,E}C€§ with reggird 5:0 the grant sf 2:. mining iease $3 E"€S§(}E"§{3§€£"}'{'. ?=§e.,3 in Béaatk ':3' {}f E§UIf}€1'f£}S'§s-Téiiﬁjg' Eézzzzgs. E: is axis-G c<m'{:::}d&c§. {hat them hag béiﬁfi 23, €§E3§E1j£ in fiiirzg {he zwii. §<:§:'§'£m"; .si'nz::<3 {he £;:«:ii__§r deziizd 2'2'.02,20G@ and. the :~:ub$eq1,2«=:z11: £82136 ybéﬁfi asiaaihz-:{*§ f.3£":€f §,:°é:a:° nine months»; there:2a;f€.s'3_3f" 1,-vfi:}:':§t:i:Vz::1§,; €:Xp§a:r:a.'€éz:331 12$-*§'1.2a§::;<)em;ér €i«:%é's§;>i§s:"¥Ei';a;%;'=iz1g'..'k§":{:é::ié::'ig%:7«'@§'*"ihi: VL €':':'£i:'€ §.21<*:%.&-: and by faégely ::=;€a$i;'1§;;f pe€.:§ﬁ@nz::r biicamsé &§'£E:1E"§i' <3? g¥7_if;§"}?i€§:;':§iR€i1e;§V'V§f;$§;-p{)§'§{£§?;§"}'{ '§'%2.{%§{;%§'k§§{;%§ ii é%;,%:'§% §}€:§:.'%'é.%<.>:": Ezaéé we be d.isn1i$s;é>.:§ in €',{}T£Sid€§§"&§'§{}E§ the m{+ r§t,:=3_ in iii;-«.::§2aMtf'er§'v..___ --

?, " £?€%si {%G1'é§:f;*{,"§§2;:ée & Sarstzzier Ca'u§:$s31 €i§§€E'i{'i§"£§_:': f%:}§." Tihe 4;;}€'§;§§:i{}z3 €r'-»§;§:¥1?":¥::£::éé"§@d {hat {E163 £E}}§}§i:E€§.'iiGE'i {ﬂed %§.;-' 'EEK: :§3«&=:f{f§?:§<:»§:"a;%:" _§i:":._ §"€3E§«§€f{?§ sf §§umara$x%:am:; Razgzgge ES SEEEE; g3§V§-%_i§§§é'g:; {:.{;§";:~':§_i 2 "%:'§d2éi.i{;2':. "~;%?'E';21%;. 1%»-'gag g§;%*::£::"; up ¥¥2?;s§ $3121? £3: Ekgaiii Eiiriﬁ. §.§'§:=: ;:E§§§3§%{?2§"ié{}§": €35 iieii 'E°€E§§{§'§Eéi"§€'§"§f§, {'§:<'%.€:€c§ §E.;'G?§'E.§8€3 zérhéiééé haéé %;";:3:<":a>:::a= Eéfaééiaa .§"¥,;'§i,i7ﬁ'E"€C€€§ anﬁ the base had E3569 grazniedg 313$ €326 Eé'i3i:€ V '"G0'a?€z':'1m@:15: maid :10': E132,-'53 takezz zzp fa? aéansiéﬁraiien ﬁgs sé ,.«'""

-; 1% :~ §eE;3":i::sner heat} appiigci far grant; sf 2: miriing ieassés aver an area 3'? §,'.??'8 A<i:res £11 Kzzmzmzzgavgxmgr Rgmgaz Sagidmr' '§'2:.i'L3;I%§;, Beéhrgr E}is"§.. 0:": §%f@«f§fE985 whereas, fﬁspﬁndﬁﬁi. N013 haf: appiilaci in I'€;?Spf3{'f§. <3?" 2'35 2'-'~'a.C:;"€3.<_s 3.13 S.1'sé{7.:¥3_i§0<.:§«§ cf Sazzdur ' '21i.u.ix: mi: 31 ;'G'?/ E980. By 3%:>>::§f§::2afé:{)'§%i :'-_ﬁz¥:{.€d 2"?;'O2'-X2856, S€£I}£"iEi{}i"1 fag" ggrzini sf mining Eészzsiés far: 3 ﬁaeéfioé Q? 20 years 3:"; :°e$'p€{:'£;. (2? :":%s§p{:=:1£§;.:é:':%"?€«s:2f3. w;:~é§_:§;;:;fg::_f;%:§:i 5'39? T 2:12 22%;: :3? E98 A_<:;'<-:-:5; in 3%-*1B§<§<:k;'.fWE':_:_<:h wégsx s3a:E;:sé3=:;é;:~§:f1€§f; 3"{-;*£i'£§{fi'& Ea} E34 §:.{3§"€S E}-I z-1 C€§'r;95i'§e§1§u1';<z. ﬁza%.._§_:;§ SE' QGS5 agagai 2: E€;',°2iiE-:'=,i.'Z*. ,€[§;z_§',:-::€§ r'§¥§fif§;_'"§ s'€§§'i}_§§§§ 132:8 "%:::x:%3aé:(,2:{=:{§ ér: E21-'{>11r of mspimdszné: 539:3.' V L 2%. "E13.'%E§ie:'V'§3;i{:1~§§§rs§ia§:1<§ GE" i.?2£2 afaivszsaigi factsg what. hag is be Lsgma in, j%;;.:g§fa..§§QS§f;:i:i;:.1 is that the pe%,i'§i<3:1s::" haé ..v_:'€£;;{L,{:;€;€;<;%:;:'; éihe S§.2:€;s:--«€}<}z-*€?:1me3;i €91" gyami Q? rn;i':":m§§ §;sa;:;s: E'r:_}§';-v.9_é§g°§E'%'i}::'*--E{2m2e:::2:§2;:r§g2: §}%3'§3{}$§ii §:§;s-sﬁﬁziii {sf B}.e;":c§: 'EL?' gégﬁzé ¥.§:f:;;'{;%.i{E{EHEEE1§'£i.Si%?2¥;:iE'E}? E}$§}<:-::;é%3 Er: §"{f.§§§}€{3§ :3? iaﬁaéztéz '._:;2;j;;§3§§{:*;?;'%:._§é:::f: izaé §}i',§T*.§€'; i:"z§é§2:EZjj;' "§"I";;3.€.T§§;':' '.?M»s:s'£:.é:.s::' :'§&.§',%'3€;§ " _:.E2'é,;"{E3 §_§§3'£'é iii} §.§.'§i;"': z'-,*:f§%?:{':"?:'f. 5:-E" §;§m:':§.§2':g z:3§3z;_':i% Eesaééaéi in f:é;"%s€}::'§* 25"

V' as. §:'§*$ Ex-3':i'¥{.i<§:":e:" in E?;a§:221:":ad;m"g§a Ragga 2:e§e:*;"€:§ iii: 2:? Aiiiiaxura "R~4" by E'€iSpOE1{'iE3I'i'E. .§§<:s.3ﬁ 'E'E":£: Efﬂiiﬁéiqléﬁﬁi <;z"é€'§:' dzzteﬁ 2?XG3/2008 étiegiriy staééas €;§;:a'§; rim: State {}<>verz1me'n1: recammezzdegi E0? ;:g;rem.'z. {if iram. (3:23 m§.m':::g E63186 in Rgzmzzrzzadurgzz i}€:§{ss§'; in §a<;<3:1r «:3? 'é:h<~": pei:;ii:%{m{":z* %:f: E§£:%.: 0%' the 11:13:: are mir1i'§1g Eésasgﬁt <?x:}mmii§:€d {G be in Blgzztk <:§'E£:2mara§:;'xv21niy Eﬁepaisai-

31. The grezmi 0? m£nir;g"'E&;1s<=:-'_4inV Ei;::4n2i:1gd-ziifga ;

Rarzge ii} éhe pfﬁiiiﬁiéilef is ;}ri{:¥:' £1237 "the"*r}p::*::::':§; °:;§>'V.95 §~§2;:rr:2:rg1s§v;ar:2y Raagge "Em Thﬁ' ;;1.3.ﬁ;%'§i<: "<3-?';m'..;:::Ef': -§1:i§}§::§i9:€%€§'V{:a§2§3i in 'aha jgezu' 2993, "E'i:r:a:§:"::2aff:;@':?;-A _§;h%é'-n_:::;§p§i:é'a"é.i€%':§ ﬂied $332' §'§'E;'§§3{}E'i{§€32"3.§', E?*€<§,3 f:,E":m3.g'h.T_:§:1"::};jé::"}?§::»:'15'_»§§E%{§ 253355 praaﬁggaﬁ and an;V'é:§i"&a_ §f.?f7;.??"E§ .§*«'~»,;:::§'é3s3 §i1'?§i3"'g?;;§f&§I}i.€(i :0 r€s§<>:1d€ni: §'--Ie,3 in KL': mi'z3raswa2fﬂy"« ,E%f...2m n ' " _\ E5":'s.~*i4'/'>;'V:*,: ﬂfivé é¥z'§3éi;;'-ks: f8.{2{8$ E: bsssééérrzésge Ciéaf zihai. as 3:; V' 7{i2*:_f;»s% {T0§1S'§!:§"€%"i"'Z-;3.Eiir{}i1 sf éhe aéppiiiéaztiisiz 53:" 2*€$§3$fm§;€m, ?IE'E%3"'2Lé§§"}_§§§'é§27£5£§{}EE {iii-Ed by $139 §3€:éi::Z<:~'§"is3_'§ 1%'-*§;€E2 regjaré 13:3:

K::z;'z2:ra1:€x,§r:3;::*;j§ Rezzzgs (1:52 2:533. $:;§,:2s§32;<-3.1:, Em" <:{}§:$'§{§€m§§:§;:x ii '§S E§é3ié';'::E"§_.V__§}'E"{}17§': _z*§:::':cX2;.:E°9: *:.ha.§. %;h<}u§;?%; 22;: 2:§2§Ei<';aéi§:}:*: '$3; A' -.§.}'*';:-*%- peiiiigzzer 2-mg fééeé in ihe yeaz' E.9§§ in ::':5$pe::*;%; {>5 I%J?'?5 V. .,._.!?':'::"€$ at Kumaraswamjz R3_z1gs3 E"E}"' Béacéﬁ, gubssquent 59% .2'

-»: 12 :w £et.i:e3,:f ciaiiegﬁ 23;/$3} §'§{§E}§ ::f{3c;m3s;t.i;1gg f«::>r ggremi. sf izeazse Em R2m121.:1_;1du'r§;j::=: Eﬁepasit, in iézizg st}? the irmr; are E32139 to be g;a.ni.€=:{i K1 B§e:5{:k:~} 'B' eméi Sf Eiu.n':£i.:"21sw21m3; E€;a.::g§€;':

Eﬁepm'-,a§t.s §e:31§4:2we{i by aha Cs<3:*e:rn::m:%ni. Qz°cie::..__ ﬁaized 2'?/%.i§;'20G§ 'V-"§{§€'? 2'3§{1§1€XLEE'€'. Filéikéf it <:E.£:a;'= far as iﬁiettk 'E? in Kuzfnzarzxgwzzmy Rzzzage E3 =;?L}:.>!':1§:~:;:*:r:3-%§=,1s:;§,.""i.h;s3 ;:1ei:.if;,i<}m%r hagi §_g§ia->=:":r:: up ﬁis; F§f{;§,£é?i§{."3313:"!_}.{;T*£§E£~€'f'~iI'%. V»;:E'f§ii?3 E~:.ai:')§j Eiack and haii Si}i';'%E%1f3{§E1,€i3'"i§'§j;?§ .2:<:<:€~§3i.{--:--§§i:h€ é€:a.:~=;é;2 ;;r'a1§:~€;§:¥'<;§.in §§E:I§3é1ﬂ£1€§11i'°§;a Eﬁepgissit E%€::{:':«:i{"':.%§1§: 3;i:}E3:.i':::7'i.%..%f:}Ei.':fiévéﬁg by the '§3s§;?§i'§.?§Z§{EE":=?.'§' in §.7:':§-? :;é:~t:;';2§°*"?§§§§§;{€%;:§§_%;_::'.:.:£é§;:§: §j§';e":3§'s§%~::f s:§a:é,€{.§ 2?/01%/2806 §}asS€{i $3}; '§R:i¥f.E§E.{:~..f*:§§'§x?:§E:":§}'1€::§:1: ins;0§a:' 21:4.-3 E3E@ek7f{}9 _;{}§" E{':*V:'*.a"s*:.§§"-(13:Sisz;%{f,::;jg Raiagié ES c9:3:;':e3:°';:1€ci, Siﬂifﬁ ii: 31$ in %;:h€ 'ssaiié BE:.3;_::Es:.. <3'é$§{:::'ﬁi€m. 3\3<3.3 zarzig g:*21::£'.€:d Tiilfifiilig' 1§3£ES_~}§3. bjg §\§{3?1",i§_f§i{§7:%:'{.,'§{}§A§V_ééééilﬁd 2"?"fG2,f2%§§bL '£33? '{§'1€ §,§§'§}{3' ah:-2 s3;ai':§;:'«:s:;}pii:{;aiiazé"e.::§..€t§i§_e I"€§~:a"§;)€}E':e:ié%I"":ii N{}.3 :%:a$ ctzénsideréiai, izhé: ' E7iéf;:§iéiE?i by §;'E.";;:_=,~ g,":=s:é'{i€;i0:":a=.§ E02' g;§:*&:i:§. sf minizzggg §é'?§:§.E§€ E32 " §§§1{§.{.i§:£Z"'~§§ﬁ'u.'{2}? J§§i§§§TE&?§3:S%%?&EETi3;"}?' §§{t§}(§E:§§§,., mi: §{§'§T3;§_._§€;?§" :%2_:'?.;s»;i%€.',€:{§ §;§§.é;'s:f=.€: :;g:':' §.§?&3=. $2.2§<§ ;?a§}§}'§§<t%2:§.i<>1m :::::':%§:::" {"§22:ai,:3:{§; i2';?;' 1:?! 2{}{}%} ha? §3{i€E§"é :5:'~3_f§"§3.€i'.{i E3}: %;E2a=: S?:.aE:£.-3.; G{",%'i;'€if§'1EE1{%§"§{1 2-mg: E32136 in é'€':=":§§3§{E¥;T. sf EK_'rl§§1Ei§1£iC§EE§§§Ei {}Eﬁ§{};'"3i'E' had baa: ax:-3-;£::.':i':2€i iv: faveur af 5, NJ »' t --: 13 :- the p€'t::?2:.iG:::«3:". 'Fhe:re§G:'é:., 'ha.1.rmg given. mp 113:: ciaim in Féiﬁpﬁiit €35 Black 'B' sf K'umaraswa.m.§2° E}e»p{>$i.'{, ané aceepiing {he Eease in Ramaﬁadurga Eﬁepasit, iha peii'{im'1er had :19 :::Gmp€t;ing interesst when the appiicaiion :31? the ':'E:s';3_§r;d&§:i §'§'9.3 was being {:Gns§.d;eEr€d. Thé areaa § e a;*3aé€E-'L:'€{§'v..t%2e petitianésr arzﬁ rézspandani $30.3 bairig mu§\;2;:Ei§;=Veﬁiéiuééivéﬁ {£116 p€i§ti:3'§:€;* cauéd 320?; have a:n:%; gf"i'e%{3ﬁC€:' '%2s;iih régggariﬁ. '$97. the area gramieé :0 regpanjdené E'"*§Q:3_: 'E'§:1%3_:;';é§"0:*:e, 'xéfs firzé ihai tbs petiiismzr hag RE} {0éf:a,.;§"=.;«:§ancE§ .'{;~;3'z-,:s€=$ai'Z {E36 mining E6359 g:=2:§:':i&%é Ea i"€5;§§'§3i§;:§";§{,7<i'{?§EJ{"VA'?€{}L3'.: E.:1:'§:~r:i;€?§'E-g it iri§2'{;V:;;;'§id be i"@§.€'%!a§1{ is {£31}; an fhﬁ éecisién 9:375 the A§§e.xV;i.:': éhe case asf gasbfmi fﬁeiibhai Eesaji an 'I' %I's:&s§tas;: _§§:::}m*i%', Rafi §as!1ir Ahmed smﬁ whers SSS v?6¥§"§--§:." in the Saéé gage? it has bﬁﬁﬁ heéd ﬁriai '£236'§:;i"{>s§:"§éi:{§'r' .<:;{ a sénema E:h€a¥;:"e ?.:@§§;§;::§g 2:; iécence far é3,*;~;E:}?fB§1:jir;2g§';'§ti:é&::'1a?§>g:"z2§}§'2. éﬁmg wag Emisi '€15; he :26': €:':':,§§Eeé E8 Emir ﬁzezz {:é:'§°§;.i€>:°.:«3;:'§ §:s§"~;s;di{:E,§<}2": $2: ::§€:'§.§:i{3 :;1iS§§§i3.€ ii? fggeéf. " ._;;:.,_'E§%'@--<;§}€::.?é,§z:"::: C€:z"i,%§E{*a£,i3'; §;:°f.:":3;%:s:§§{§ %i§1§%;'E' 5 G? 533%? __Eamba§ Cinerna Eéuéss, §§54§ by ihe Bigtréitt, 1'*£Eag'isE;:a%€ in faifaur Of a rissrai in fhﬁ trades breughi mp aﬁéi qzzaaheﬁt ;* 22:» 1%' in §.%.1e gszziéi €»§{.%(.:%\$..§{.}£'-£3 me: Siipféfﬁﬁ Cisurt a:":;3;*£.:-:g_§{:az"i:s;e€E $.16 ap§3Ei.s:?:21;1§ S.-"s<§ii'.kiI"1§.§ 2: writ. {}§ if€§"{.i{§'E'21§'"'i mtg} ihffﬁéf <:21t<»:;.;§G:°ie§: E} persxm gaggrieareé ii} :~3%.r£a.'r:g€5§°1 :i¥1{E iii} busgy b<3d§; as" 1':"I€{1{H€5E;{):"£1£~'. §z.1i€:'i@p&r. '\?i§h.§.§£: :7?;*E~ss€..i_::§>;';:;;--€ 'pers30r: ag§g:':e2;<:{§' fmm "$€.re112ga'3r:s' aé. "aEi:;e f<>§E<>wi:1g_;: "?£.e=3:s;i',s hm-*<-3 been Lezidzw To di3iérzg2:s::s-?.?._ §i£i'?"{_'€k,pf}§ii?{L§'%§;f§ﬂj§'8§%3, 3 ';a:£s*a:'zge3".:«;'. amsrzg fj§1€??'i;'-. §':>rr:€ §3é'{,:§;7aiATi?3;<s£t$_ r?z ay be deﬁasced hf"2°0vn--*:...§.§z8 ':{T{}?Z;'€T§?€?é§'i{S gfbave. '§'§':€5;e §;€'S§:§ are z':;:;i:~ a33$;--§§;3{:.i:}.? . i§:£f:'§;?:a£z:>. 'E'§'%.a>i§' €Jf}Ee.::'a{.':_:; ::a;?f:°€.;<s :::;?a::$§° a*:5z':§3--.:;§ i§*';{é..::?éf§2§:,;:§::"z,.§Emzgtzzs Q?" {he ca.%*; 'é%"%:t5i:.<€i:3%--g ifE"2€ ${::L§:1§:£t»:§:*g;_.<:r§:»3"::é3.:ci" in wizicfz {ﬁe éarfcsiaiered. 7E'?zs2se &;?'£E'Z 2%/'?T2§giE':<:r 'iizéé' :--§zp§i:é<gi?;:1::: is a parser: zzafzase fézgaé :jig;§2.§' "§=:r,:;<;r .§:;:j.e§z'--._§:1§;'é;{:2gse&f? E::'a,s;: E26 szgjfered a ;:2%é%':g..._.ﬁ.¥f.» éffgfwgg, is': {$28 SGEESQ. ﬁzcai 52,35 €2f%£$%{e?$:*;.,_ rgaagrzzigeﬁ by ism}; 52,95; E3863 aizci &£2'€<:§E§,: {§;:!§e'{7§€é 23;; éhiz 515:. 52?"

V Q,;""::§za-,> {.:.:2E"§":a§'i::;;§ <:e:2::2;3§{::':T::€c§ Q5"? Es ﬁg? 5: §3%é§'_?§§§'E :,::§':0 §:::2S égzgfﬁénégé. 5;, Ezagggsi §:'is3;n::;:'?::?a 52, A §ér;<§e:m; '3:z;g::::'z:s: 2.525292%: 5,: é§€{f€;'%iG§"si 525:3 beer: ;§m:z0u2'%e',?£& :;::§'z2ic§'?: ET:.{2.§} zzérgrzgfiziégg §£3§§"§§f€f€§ 535:2? sf :'§C?f??8E§?;i§°£§3 9:" d}fG?7igf§i,£§,§§; :"°s§fi:..§ed §Ei??"?£ sameifzirag, at w:'0:é:gf%,aEE§; qﬁgéaéégé Ezié; zgiiie £0

-: E5 :-

san"ze:%:ing?' Has he a sgaeciai and s::@;~;E'an§::'.aE §;§?"f€UcC£3'E£'€ of his 013:: beggogzd swme grievrmce 8?"

§?i{i'Cﬁ§'ZU€T1i{3'§1{f£:' szgfféered by him; in mmmora with {he res: 0f the pabiic? was iii? enéiiied ta abjezsf;

and be heard by ifze {zuthoriégg bejbre if iask {ﬁg impugrzéd actioni? 5?" so? az,}:::,.<; fie pn"2jL:d21<:é(:i£g;'~._ g;f;'fé3c€'ed in {he e.:<'erc£se cf :'f:a:' rigfzi 53;; §'z7%'}%§;".'.'{Z«~."#"';VVEg:i :_. A' aasurpaitian sf _§:,:rz'sd:'€€i9r2 are {he _§§}' {'~-.V.C§§iA_V.V'§§T§€ 0;:,:i'%10ri§g;'? is ifzé siaiuée, :':1:"§?ié";:fonze,x:ij}'.{;}":z;?1£::%i,V ﬂag gztape of £518 wards ";§'{:rs3§:2'*'ag§ri:2:.;é».§" ~7 being C83'7é..f§?id€?"'£3§§_ £.3, S£§{C'i&§ ";:;é§f'§:'£;' %:%:2;e.{3§:,arje deségrzed is 555;; daam '"e2i§?*::CaE 5?. §=r:;,,}'Tes;gia::a,€ 5szi.5:z2§§5é;°s:§§ aj"éfariéigati.&f%:§%7é2?';g%1z:{§}:fs:?'::z:':éirgg?' E}? :5; ii a siaiaaie deaéing :£:i_;«f'§';. ':%:g%:V:_s §j° pa}*§ic:,:Ea:r= é:"'aﬁTis;% i::i§§j;:Es'?57:

A? .[g2:rag2221§h_L' I393; :23 ..--;3§i:1{~':d 213 fe::Ei0vs,=s;: «~ V .,§fV?€§§€V§fi:1E5?"ﬂ%€:FEiS§€3Ci?"é approagfz shauid g;_z_:aide7r;%.»......:,::;T:2;' Q mée, {he Cami; $§"a$:,:,£d 330:" :T:'m;?{f%;§'?:: _::;£' {he i:*:3£'a:"a€e ajf ca 'giranger' wsiess . §:'§zé':*{: e.:%.%s3""excep:§0:z€aE CifCi£fZL§f'G;?"E§'.?€S {rim-aivéng a, §:12::é'f..-iééigsarfiaga Qfhjiiﬁiiéfé ?'::";;::€§":§; as: ask;-%€;":;€ "§.:°:?:;;:§$:?§. an gmgbiic §3'"£§l'€3§"QSf'S, E§;§?E§E§.¥??;§.?EQ :"§2Q'£: 5%? A .::;;:s;9€§£:i::z§. £5; 5,; 1':§§.3"{£?"§;§{;'?"',, .«:z:':<:§ ass: 2:; Emggg ﬁaﬁgg, Eizera gigs Ezherg are :15; €25/rgfegsiierzgai {"f§.?"€§é§3L§§'{3f3C€$ in {fie present' cage whiafe: 2;{:0§,£§O3jE,iSi§;:§; she {$3359 of Q z;;:ri:' Qf Ceriiamri Q: $2.213 insgémzcss. Sn aha é w,/W, » 1?', E}€35:§'p§{1€ ﬁxes £1b€)"§»-"ff {Ending waé maxi: C:€>:':s§.dé3z' as is a>%:'h:--:iher §',§3;€3' 'W§.'§'{. pé3i?;,i«:m E12155 ilé} be giiz-_=,.m.is;ss&d an the gmaznd 0? {$632132 a.:".ut§ E21i.<:%1£::-3' ii is; ﬁiﬁiiiiiﬁd film. the E}E§E1i'EE§§. §£':r;;S€_ 'WES Qxﬁiiiﬁléii in §'21's;{2:.1:° 01" reapanéezzi N33 cm 'Er;

the s§.a1§.me':3E. (sf <ﬁ3»_j€:{:~tiony 1%. E1213 bgaégi av'.::%':":'aa:%:§:j'4:VE:ié:i, 2173:: ._Ri?§"1§/'i. p¢3tiE:i{:>.:1 has b:3:=:':n {ﬂed £32.'; 3::/'E E. ,}*._2§§;}'?..-;:'::I;._n'eai'1~1§ §t5:f;§I*ii;;2f€21r " § rnanizhza :<1f£.:3:" £.i'1:>. §\3{}€1E{EC&i'{,§_{:¥3:}_V ciaéeé 2(T?!2€}§§3..,W§?;ra1::i,§n§§ miziirzg; E€:e1S€: was isssuﬁci i'i:____§2;sy%<3'ag;r <3? %§es3f_§{§:%§éé5:":i. ?{'sE'0,3. i,h{}z:§;j%§ "Sm: p€Eiii?:i.<3'§";.€r '*=;;2,*a:~:;. .'¥§¢*f3§§';:}EE:.'s?s;";§Li'I%€3.AEEK? faﬁ: ihat right. fmm Elfiif je;'{3';':'ﬁ" 'éa§3§é€<f:';:§I'i.<::2 €:s§..é.E':é5 :'€:s=3'§:»<2:2_{,';€:t:'2.E: §*£<5.3 was ;':':':{i€::'t : A' éhe pet.i':,§s:me:: being 21 naighﬁésafiﬁg .w<5§}; azaxrgzm sf 'ihssa facts paﬁ.§:Q:;Ea1EE§;'<..'g,v:g':'1V€,;%r::_ A§"%3p;§V§3'§§:1de':3%, E'€s:;.f3 <':{}:m:3::*§1c{:d Zﬁiﬁiﬁg .. .. _A€3;§<;%::;}'3:23;€:,§;;;§2:}:;<3Q1: '§'<:--::g,<§e& Eand. 3 iéiasi 21$ <5:a;:'§§; 213 an {3?I@8§.2i§@3$ gfazbiiit :":'{}i'__%:%i§: :§,é:a:é;;::€:§é5f;%%:as%{§ *'=2i;.§i,E: rﬁgard ii} 230:: 21%": E'E'.'z§§E€fS 3%: SE:'xe*EB£e{:E<;§ V*§?.'i§.§'I"£Zi:'?§:3_i%5?&3;§E":}7 Szizagiaz 'E"2';1%z:§n:3 E-§€E§2f:':"j;;-' §'}§.5-_>;§',:s'%<:'?§', zmzi an 1%£1 *:é_~% g_j,>f;:°2:.:1"'§: sf €z:2r'§:°a:1m€::::§a.E £f§€3§:§§"£EE1{':€': far {he Saaiii .. .,V_§_?':§§':": {Era mmeg wggs r2€;'zif§ede Q2: §E,G9.2i§G5, C:a_;>:e§*£;{3 fa 9%. W A, w: 18 :~ m>'céfi<:2':t.i<}n :'e§§arding§ §;§:°a:1?é: sf azppravzzl amaze? the Faregi {C<3::1;~s:e§*x:ai'.:i{:ez1} Ae::i; 1§8<3 for mining; §>p€r:a1?:.i{:sné; in f.a5;{}1;r 9?

respezzzienii 3*«§<?;.:3 was; i:=:=;s:§:,1€d, whéaith wztzss f<}1E.<>i,W.{1 by a::{:~'z.§/19:"

:1Gi:§.f;i<t21i£{';n §§a:2:€:E€;.ed 03:: 27.32.2906 rega:°*di:2g §h§;:-~.__gra.n.t, sf m_§11i:ng 1<3as§£: which 133.2153 e:>;é:<::1'{'.ed am }.4:.Q3.2G§§;, xSE.21.t€<:i that', §es3p{>r3.{1é3::i. 1'\E{},3 {f{}HH§}€E3.iT:<fd :1':i:":i.ng.'§__"{};:2€.:é};ii0ﬁ'§; "ix; ?'ss"§Ei1"'{fE'i.} 2@§§ i'{.*s:'::if $15; i:.1:fe$€.:§:1§,§ §i§:ii§§<:5':M:.a.;:::s; .{3§_ §§1ig;ﬁ€:§-'5.«' Fir0z":T: VL {he a1.f{;:'<«:*;<_§::1_i<i féléfixfig ii. b@c{3::"§§3$ (','§€;§1;§' Eeassﬁ €10 :*s3sspa'r:d€:':i ?~Za.3 sf §<3§{;*::;%;z3.§: "§"§€}'{iC€fr£=§ zmgi . 2 €§E:§§ V{%X:%%§4:.:§:i:}:2 ezyf" :",_'rf:éé §€3'&7i$ﬁ was; in pgbiiat vAA.;;;;:f:%f_t§§.:.i<}:*:e:* <':<§uEci Ezave 2ara1ii<:%€iV Sf :52 Si:::3f.'s.:E.§}3"}?'<réE:21¢;i§,% under Rule 5% 9f ihe Miizeml €:>ne::€=.ss:i:)§"§' VR:g}.§5S;:."-EV§€>fG'« "by filing a E"€3V§Si{}f§ b€§1:::"e théz G-ia-*e:°1::1r:§.6;_'%;%». (E? Egg;-iizé'-.;a%§'§.hi:: Ehe §{:~'rf:::§ p3£"€*E5{:i"i33€i'C§. 'i'§::e saiafi '_ :"€§%:'€ia.djg;_}":§:Vs m<>%."'%;2;€::;€;é:_:3;vaﬁazsiiezi by '§§'§€': p€3;:.i'i§{>:1€::":, i§1.::--:ei@aé., afiei' .2:;v§a_p:»2g= 52:5_{ii::§:1$§:"§€§mb'§€ the p§"é:'E3@'§§¥i. zrazrﬁi: §3a*"§',§f:'.§:;::n has; '~%j3§:é;*._::. :%7i}§%'a€ <;§'§f§-=:%::EE:%j;7 2a$--ss:a£E§rEg;: {E26 ;,§r2:.;2€; <3? :5; §E}§§EIi§"i§§ §€%:5:S*i'i 52;} :'§%:=§§{:=:'2/€.§~;;*.s"_:£1}.-Eiii}.,3 '§"E:i: '§;%_::i:%;, §,E";;2::%':, §§§.£i§.é§.EZ{'§§'§:"' remegigg Ema-'5 §':{:%;:

$66.3 arleziké 31:: E219 izzaizmti. {',.E"i.;<:%é3 212% $1335 22:32: §3e'é,§":'.i<:r§": haying; ., ' §<:?€::--:§ fi§{'-{E z1ft:m"' 01963:' 21 :3?-.".E"i{'§{£ sf *:.1:a.-*3 §;<i:»2r$ "E-E-"{}3}j€f atiéiayijq imp}? 9/'w

--~: 39 :2 that i,here. is; {$9222}: zmgi Ea:::§1.€S an ﬁii-3 paré: of the §3et.1?E.i<>r}.e§" in S€{f§§iE'i§§ q_ua1$hi'r:g sf {he m§.m?'n§g; }f3ZiS{f' granized in fa'i----'OE.,1§7 ef 2:"€:s§{mdant: N03, The peE',i'{:;<3ne,r being; 21 P:"i*a;23::;e Ssaier Camparzy in the :~321.z:w 3.11:6 of bus;§ne:«;s§ czmici :10: hérifﬁﬂ ig:r*:<3:*an':: with rsigzird ':10 %':h€ ggrzzm. of n1§r:i§7sg.{"-.§j:=_:;1§'sa.£3 £0 reSp<3';:1d€'::%: N03. Thfs aE3ssé3::<:t€ af zivaiiiingig 21 s3€f.é,u:fé;~:}:.*§r 'reﬁieéy in '?t,u:m3 czmki 11:}? haw: been {tir<:;'iii%}*i£§:4:*";i.é;::A:i 7jb;f'?::i<':g§:V §é«§ii"{i{3r;€3;:f L 73}? fiiiilg 22 "av:'i'é: p:"5"€,ii:i<>'n madgjﬁAr€€{;§.§%::':2é5 {@221 sf inziléa. 'We 21;":-': Eli}? fééif 2i st.'§1,€ Qyii §}{%i4§§.§<>:3 <22-.'§2_.::;.<§';. E353: 52¢?' H{:§?§ "Ev/i3v'¥2'i§§=§?;f§3*°3:§;§§;_:€¢.,>' 9% an :a&£erna%.§w3 r<:fm$dj§,_r What 2336 .f:ir;:§ is;

ihat. {ms ._§3£3%;1§V*{.i;:::*;§:§'~%f{§.:: %,:§<f2£~ Eféia-:s:=;>z1S begt E«:r:eW:': {<3 3%,; has faﬁé-Ed is 39,-faéﬁ é;'t;::_.:.;é:e:§,z:g f'{-Efiiﬁiiff £31 '{.13;.'E.1E€ zmci énsiead, has ﬁEe;%,_§;j§§:és3 xx,rr§§.V"p»:é_7§.:i%.§<§:1: Em ihssé gféiar 2$G8 aiier a mpsii 037 ::§a':'§}7 .%4%.%m_V§'§*;;1:'s3 --$§7"~-éihe sxecuiicm of the mining Eﬁgigéi in fazzazzr GE §§:sé§a§::£§e.%?z:'._ W§1§{i§': '%ﬁE<i': ﬁmé is %{'3§E1§:.@{§§ Er: §3;{f:"{..3 'iéhgs-: ﬁ.p:<-:::>«: {§{:a::r§é',,, $2.3"; %%;é3:"2:§ {i,e:{iis:;é<3::::+; has ',§i;:~é§5{§~.é;'.E*:2:i. éfiaé-*. ::§:_;:§3:s9;'§.§:'3~3:':: {if {§L€'f,'§Ei§;" azzéﬁ §z?«;':;:;i:§:s=,a E55; {}'§":{f *4-*§"::%§":§§ E32223 3:8 W3 {"i{E§"§S§.€§€E"€é 23:: ?;.'m3 €:E'1a"s:SE";<:E{E b€EfG§'€: €X€E"{f§Si§2g {EiS€:}f€f;.§{>1';. L2':":=:3€~r Aﬁicéa 225 225 {ha C€§E?;.€E;'§§§":l§§{}1¥': <35 Endia, ya ww W: 21 :-

b} in the C£iE3€;§ cf Shankar Caﬂp gauging Sacietg Ltd3 »- V3 M.Pz*abhakar 82, Grs regretted in 2911 AIR SSW 3ﬁ33, {ha Apex Cour'? 22$. pare} $3 has; given "éhe r£%'Eev2;.'r:t {:0::si:.:§:<:rai:i:3s::s, in <§e*;er::1§:1in.§g; §¥h_5:i.h€:r fisizzy G2' iagthéais; in appr°<}a(:hi:1g;§ ths writ, £20m": zzgzder Qf thé-3 C<'>:':sii.'{L:"££@zz 0? Endiai The? Same §ff3&"i§S as is "S3, The rgievam c0r1.§§§d£3r:::.:ﬁé?:':';§, &i§§':€Ef§?;€?" defagg or Zacifzeg s§1§:;£.a?._A_*b££TV pig'; i'7 pe::;<;a:'2 what appma{:%:l£s:_..V €?3e"'-:;}%'£§;V €@?§§:ri€j v.:;;§d%3r V z'§§"iI.°C§€ 225 cf {he Ca:13i;i§iz£;{0';': is §'7:v $':~,£.?':£§;%{?:§E $;:f§":"£e&. '§'§:55§; are: 5 S E §.§':.g%;2;_>. is .=2V'::"} "§V§'zj:,?:§§:';_E;§{> %%,;:€'$e Q5' Saw zE':a:' :,v?:ez:£:ver ::"E'{€%°g"é';s§L. {ream msasgfi sfaVe1¢:'é;:v:&§~;§%:jiii;:;A:':i?;;§iz,£é§¢:§fa? e}éi{'3'm,'0:€:z {fine g3e§iééa:2: ii' is a :;:;Ee= of. V on saunﬁ anﬂ §I'Op€I' €§§é::{:§s£é g3'? and each stage :"::a£3€' be _ .;:EeaE€ :'L=i$.V§1'9,?'e 23%;: 9:%;a:'i3L;'fa{?€s. E42} ?§"ié3 priizatipie an E§:e>V"V<f::r::;A'£'V 2°'eji:se§ rgéieejf an {$253 gmzznd Qf §::z;;*§2..»3;:: §:§f_ ﬁeéagg :8 am: {he rigfﬁs acemed £9 ';V'ﬁf§'§;'V..€§":e &eEa§; €:":__;'E2:i:":g $18 §e£'§f:':'a?z Shazaéd ::;__:2:' &i:»;i:,§§"E::eé, ssziéess: 5525233'; £3 Q regsgagzabée "a?§§§=§:z§":€z§£[email protected]%,é? {E26 éissiaggg §3e{?::z::;<;a? e:i'§E£E"'§. ;<;§'s.§z:§5§. :"::;E'. Ezzzrzra '£.?7é=F"EQ{i'€§'?;§ §ar:"sTes {,5 ;:'f':é§:" €":Z§;§":§L§ Esau? A s3m£2:fg€::1E E332; {$2.5 éeiagg an {$29 §3m'§' Q?' {he peiiiisrzérs. {3} Tfée 2;a:£':'sj'a€E9r§; uzagg agfeﬁcgiaizzirag deiay in :f:10;§<:i,z's,g am; appiicgiiﬁn mzder firéiesée 225 :5 X 1' ~«: 23 :~ d} Refﬁ-E°€3'TI§1{tf;'. 921:: 21.33:; be ma{i€ {E} 21:1<:>'{.h{-3:." d.ee::§si::m cf the Apex Cimrf; in she: ::8;::;»::t 0? (1 996} 6 SSS 44$ STATE $15"

§;4JA$TH$N £2; &'l"HERS «FS» .B.}R.L&Ii°SIiZ9ﬁ Si, §E'fmRS}¢ xafhsreirz ii. h_a:~3 <?:1::t,:Z{}z1e:€i {he High Caizuri. 3.10: 12.5; aszriirsrfzain 'aim Writ peEii:§.<::1$ whszrsi i,her€: is; :ir:<:rc1_i:f1ate éiﬁiél}? jur:$d§c::':.i{:r': unsier z%.r§:i<t:i£3 2128 {Elf éhfs C{§z1st.§%%::'€:if§§r: ' 2:2} Rsiiamtc may be piazted i Apésrx C(}1li"§ :'§tp<}:'"'z.&d in iihéé {Emse Sifters :2. Efzﬁerzfa 9f fnéia aﬁi§C;:€}§?té?"$ §§': @339} 353}:

w%2é3§:€3i§: ihﬁt ;:%€%f.i3:§<3E::'5¥$ '?:';7ﬁ:€a§":j:~£i:: :<:3{}1:g§ﬁ: §"€~:?f{f§é§'° ii"; 'i:é~3§"m£~§ 8? the Q'r::§_'?e:*':*" §?.?*£§g§1 Casuri: of Judi<::at'.:.:§fé3 21$ Bambzéy, far ':S$§¥'t¥'S:ﬁ!C<3 §"3§{éé};'*§£°€3}3§T§Efi§.€ wrifg iga €h<~: 21u%.h{3:'§ti@$ ii} §°{3x72}E'if:.§_a'ie. '§:i*..'Af1}?€§.'£-'--§ mEéééffiﬁﬁ, bzzsed <33: €a:"E§€z' {§I"§:€'E' $8.-$s.é§--'.:'§: by 'é;v_ }€z1%t;::e:i. ??:::2gE€ Jaziiga ef the £3Gmbr:.»::§:* Eéigh "'._V_€:@:j §*i.§ gﬁkiiivph '$5; 'she Eﬁzizfésgégm B€:*::;:§: :3? {he %1'<_f;%,s.::":.--.;aé;=;§§h §:"§§${"% 'Q3? EEK: Agmx {i<§:.::*é:= E': 'wag a:?z§r;'{.:";%§':{i:;i{§ ""i',}":'a"_é. E5339T"§:§*:§;§7{:':;:=§:{%r§ §T.§:::%:'{=.i:: §5;'&:'€ E%§§"E"§§§£§E'§§ pE;2.£::.':<;%::.'5; 3:351 §'.§"§.&§ E. '§§}:*:é.§:i<2_:'{'g'§3§9-:<§ 'ééze {'.'§i§'3:§€.'.3"' ::%2?a§§é:%:<g :z;§:r':"é3: ;;'.__-§E°'é3;'I}§€{§; ':*%§§a:§' 3:35;"

iﬁhe §:?«{}E'£§bé%.§' Eiigh C:<:v:.:r"{: arzd é.'§:€r€§:§r:39 Sis: ssaid rééﬁef S;§*:I~;:s.';_:§§; 'E363 gévésn {.0 'thésm gist}. Théj p€€,ii.i:::s:f1§srs €her<<3§1:: had E ﬁg.

_w W

--: 24 :~ if: £12122: dire-é€:t.E_'§2* 'f§;i€3d 5: writ: §3s::i;it:i<>z1 §i'}_¥'{}}~1§}'.'i§ Ar£:i::?:Ee 32 0f {ha C<3ns3i;.i.t;ui::Qn b€f{}'I'E': the rkpex Coazi. '_E'i'1:: $aid writ p€§£'£i{>fE$ were £"€3j€*{f'.?;€3{§ ami {ha Agxéx Cami d€:::'§.i:1@{i {<3 in?é;.€:'{er§: in the 1":12:'v':.€%:' by Si.21€.§2'1g§ tihai: 'ilhif p€=%ti:ii:i{3';1€::":=s were :"€:~.:ig§if{:3£,i.r1gj aéiaimss Whiith éhésy harai m3': p::§'sLz<;:=.ci far searera.i§._jgc;z2%.C:"3;;~ °'"fTh€ peii':.i<m{:r:~; 'wz-32% 273:3: vig:i1:m§: bu: wa=.r£:V__ %:E«::x;1;*é:.ai::'§_i:':»'%:' tié'- 'E_;<é €§{}r:1*:22n§ azxi {:h<:sa% 'E0 53%': an 'aha fe:§_<:'<:% ~%:'i§«'; E§{§E"17?g%€3'V§Z3§}§;_'f'V§i'§S§ii3?$'~ cage: <:21.m<:~ is be? deiiideci, 2%;L§:{:<:%'::E--§:§_:é§;§-- $.19 'iheir {E21863 <':<§u.E{§ "mist; 'W <:{:n§'§é%:e{§ :;:§ af €}3;"i{i' x,:s,:'h<%§°€: 21 §§§."%£"»J hgzzi ;%;:';«:E aﬁisé by 21 e:*:<>m°§:s 3:0 21;; £0 I1'¥.{}I1§f3S paié :_:§'1€§er7:he fféﬂi-'£3fi«.3.V_§S§Gﬁ'..s;§V§-..23f E.2>;¥s; §:;:'€:&:' Si'; €§€"{?E{:'aE"€{§ zzeida 'E'he A§::=:§:: C{:'u::f'§: §s;€1{i"-t§'i':iEl §T.E§'é>.r€ zvag an e.me:z;§3;2":i:1<3£§, '§'§"z0r5:i1':a?£.€ géaéaagr £3 ;:>m%.f::,rrin:§§ E3"-.a_z'3 ¥a.;2:§%. pﬁiiiiékn xvézigth aazasg bmaghi, 21 V' °i3.2,_:t*,-§f%z'1~» n'E'ha%r€éf*<;:*é3 'ﬁgs @6121}? in §:"§E_§.ngg Ehé: '%.i?"E"i{. pﬁiﬁiaga '§;é':*$s:;22s;::§i§;€;'iziﬁéz---,A;§aéX C{>m"é:. €15; §ie:~:{:§i:"z€* Ea %.:":i:%:2"f§:%§'<: 172-*é'iE': fhﬁ %::.--::2,§,§?;3,:*::§'."_':*:;=:§%;:{i'§;9&3 §'.Im:=. Wréi: g:»§:"§§€é::::L Ewzzz é.h{;2;.:g§h iiﬁﬁééiii ;3@:*'$3<::"si5'é&r~::=:%. gg:°21:':'%.é5d E"€§€§:'€§ iii: £1325: :":':;z€.'g,s32' Sf émparé §:'2:.{t§§'i£;:;; :3. -7:§ém§E~:§_.:' réziégaf w'225§ :":<}"é: gg"ra:2.é',§:{§ ii} $;%";_:'3. g§€%,§.ii,i{:m3::"::e Ehereézz b}; A JV"

:» --: 25 :- tha Apex C(}E1§°'€. §"1&?UJ§'§":§;§ z'e;§ar<:i £10 the {$6121}? arzd iaficthes in ;1ppr@zzch.§:1g§ the C{}E_.1§'f,., if} Sinaiizizﬁy, 1:": *$:.i1<:=: <:a.§:;€*. 0%" The Municipal Cauncii-, ziihmednagar $2; Anr. an SI1a§1 Hyde? ﬁég £2. §z;f$fV"»;"§%':'.'?;_Vf6*@2} 2 SEC 48}, it Twas beer: iapinssd ih1;.s:-- ' H' "The reai 583:' jbr saamci :33}?

éwcreiiarz by "£2153 ffigh C9:/ar:\"si%%; :'?z:fs ;%.gggr°;d?':',s: rf:{:{T; A iize pizggsiaéai mrming 53;" €'im;s;=',5:153":..¥§::§T.§'f"::3V"':.§és§': fig if ;;;:E'2eE'},1er by :*ea;<;0:'z 0f C§€§5:__;g,"'.§?2ere' _---2:3' ». .<;~z,:cE"{'--~ ' n€g:}{z'g€r2.C 5' 0:2. 2,316 pazfqf-'..:E2€ p<:%:'.ii-5935;? 'slekusrzgég {:5 irgjér €§?;:2fE" he Ezasg giver": ﬁg); Fais; <3§§z:mo;:;':_%?1é1:fe ihe peiiiianez" §":s:zs ?'?EG¥ﬁ€d {fie} ?:';i_: :7"Lfour:.;' :1-3:9 rigﬁzfs Sf €528 ihimi par:'ie.:§ r§;aaL%£e' z::52;<s£: Vilnis beézég "::>§:i£%1 gizaagisi :23: E353 5:§§&s:a:%a%;£'--§:jo ?{:§.§V:<.;.%i":;::.::':2xéizgizigsg €§':€ra> 51%; E'€£E:§&?Té{Z§3§{£" €)€pi{Z§2&§§{}§?.w§E}'f° :,§";g_ﬁ~._dé;%§I{:e§;, "'f __ .f:é"'f;Ejm::__'{:as§'»:3 '{>.{__ Retimana Qayaram Shetty an £nterna'iie7:::9za£' ﬁi;iV:*;<§§2z*§t;""'---e§§;:: t?w:°itgs Qf India anﬁ Stizerg (1 3? SCC {he S'L:p:'§:§:":e €€3'§};E'€, Eieéé Ehgu Ehe writ. 31.11:;-§._V135E§{3IE "$';?;'$;%._Vﬁiﬁd mare %;.E':an fives :'§::{>::.ﬁ1$s aafiier iihs "§:E::i?:{"EE;7}3?:«T::E:j§'E*;':5f%;E._. §§1%;"', ii'.e:':<ia=::: éizzﬁzag ¥JE':_§€%: §é3'i"'§;*;'}¥§ EEES §;z;::::fi=5 &:;ss1§1.:'§"?i"€r2<%;a%:"§:tr hggé §:2£é:.:§§*a<i ::i@:":$§{i€::";:«:z§'}E£% €?X§€iﬂ{§_§§L§F€ .,22j;;"::E,_ "aaéi 3"§'iEi{§€'f 2zr.:'2:.3:;;€::':€::::§s am? :'E";.6:%:r§%;§':"<%, it 'ii-'{}§;E§.{§ ngaési £:':i{g:z§E<2:,:s5; ":9 gigéde éhéi §t:€2§i§.€:raa:%;:.ss: ii $5313 551335} W{'fEa§"ifi€& Etfixaé. E336 pagéiiozl w'<>z:E»s:§ hays b{'3€iE differsznt. if {he ,5,"

/ w W: 2.6 :~ {':§.'i&}_H€"3§1§§€3 to the 'ierzciar had be/6:1 maﬁa Emmediaéeiy. '§'hez'ef9r§x the Supreme: Caurig. C§€:<?Ei:3e3{i E8 izmzrfézre anﬁ gram miiei" ii'? §.§'1€i 1z;€'é'§: petiiian by ncsiz. ::§Xer:":L<si.:2.§g diSCI°€E.§GE7§ Elﬁ{§f3'E' Aréﬁrie 22% 9f this COI}S§iﬁLﬁl.§{}i1 "<3? Isidizax. hi Si.mi.iar1§a in '§,E'3;€3 {:a${3 sf State af Gtherg 3. filaﬁdiai Jaiswal and Gthers 566}; 131%: S'u§}z'€:m€ Cgmaf. héié €.h9:E:~£:E.:,§;§ '§%:';§i.i%§§:§}_;§ 2.%%eff§t:§:' . rﬁgarii iii} Ehs grant. of §i€"§€1'}£':E3 59:" %é:::I1:;§€ﬁ1'L::<>'{§€9;:' sf fer ma1n2:i%::.ct.1:r:@ if C<>:;:.§";.i::fj;;<.V_ §IQ'éi£i§1§"' :79-*.;3Js§".. "t€a;§<:%é':2 @521:

"13 FE J} 5 E2; lééééi $.'§"2s."§ ithéz _ §;e§§%:§$z§s}ﬂ:*:' §'E':s3{§ 6:: 28; E 1/ E985 eabezst E E :l.a.§':_:t:?:::'{ f:'»,f¥::1§«:':--.§r;{1p:,2gn&:i paiicy deﬁzisaiézééfa f{}3§{};§§--~*"<j£§-.._u§Z?:g?"'v{};ﬁ'§§§i' ﬁirit. ?€€:it.i.o:3$: Under ihe €:£rcu;mst';§,:1'{:§-:$,' %:;§:€;..jVS::[:}§3}ri€3>f:'x;% Cmzrt hséid Elhaii: thai. ichere was §?;E°'GSS_ _{%;€:E23§f'~V iii: .{i§V-Lag-._ fix szzrié: §3{3i;_i'£:31@'::s.$ €i§T1{§. {hat ii; W225; E§§1§3?\-"§§ié3:'sf'ié1§i§}€ t.Eié::.._:}if1¢.: §ei:§;tie:}n€r.€:3 did 219%: kgieais that 1361*; ,§~§.3'§.§E{1Tf£?3»§§~7a7';?§:§'§L' basing £::=:}:1$:r:§<:i.:5{i 233 {ha E'3€'%§£ aiiéig by $223 *%§2'<?{t€§T§$.§%;:.E'V f%;.;r;r:§%::r{%:°§;§ zzzzrméijg §*{=:;%§<3§:<:§€:*:?;',&§ 3:} E} r E7§'2§:§f€§§3,. §'Z%";%:,-'$4;s§}§'€::":"::3 €E{}zf::"'ié'. 3.§s;i> ssgsémzté $6335 if 37:19 g::@Ei:::§ é€5e§.3§a': §g_{§éi€:€£E 3{};"£2f19§%é§« was is he 36%'. agida at i:}':€ ._§:':i3?,_aH{€%é if {he §}€"{§U{§f1€E'S. ii: 'i?i?'G?.';§.§ is,-?{::"§; immense 5;

yr ~: 28 :--« §eti{§.or1 W215; {E651 {)}'Ti€.;', yezzr i:E2er€aI'iz.5%r by t.§f1a=:rn. Ths a£§<:E:i::3:€: Ezaci Z"£{}§'. a>n1§,; i,&1k€':E":. _'§3{)S8€SE§i{}E1 «:3? 'ilhﬁt lzmd hm; 31:30 5:121:16: szzzfﬁstiezzi. §.'fi'£€S'{§11f;',IE€.. Ac»:3<}rc§'ing§ is "aha $u'p'r<:m§: C€}3;}I""{' cieizijs' sf this n.21i'.u:*€: -shisuizi §".'i'€£¥€3'. i'):i€}'rs {Tf{}E"i§*3§{§tffE'%;'§§.-._H:b"f?v'y {hes Ca>urE4 to be €)f'€£i'3Z.£iE imp<}ri.;m<:€:.

Ea} §';";{a{':?. in S,$,BaZ:: and aihers* _:i:,.

Kamatazm 552mg; 2 gas 4?§f}';" iE:'«?;a§--$ %;ia.ai;

déséay {i£:':'f-"*:&i'.$ {3.::§ui{.§; :':'i§"§{§ t',§';a_E', 'r<:'E§k:>_f €:.:~_m bev_'v_€ié:1é,%:d»_<§:*: €.E?g<3 g;2f<>:§.:":_ii <2?" §i::>:Ee:j: éﬁﬁiilif 63%;: :;E:':3.;igh ré3'_iié:§'_ is-5-%>j:*21§;:i:éé::§ '5i{} <}:h6:' :'~i;ir::§§21;°§y $i':.:.:a§;:::{E_ pe:"é:<£:::<:§; :a5%':V<§ £§§§§3;:"{};£§;':Tff§'E :i'E':e_~*: iiiéiiris in ¥::§r:rs.€£ 2.0.. E-Eav':;:1§g«..:fég§21:"»:iﬁzz}ihe aiarageaid ééattza, we are Of the vies-is §;ha??;: 3".§'3<;% "E51-§"--P5eE.:3i§.<:':*; has; in be {§iS:*;z:1:i$-Seci 0:1 $33.5 g:>;:*s:>1m€§ <>f%;i..e§2:§z a.:"::5;~.Vi;23:i;€:§':::=.ss, having; fsigfzirai is ﬁn'-3 §a{3'?{.:2.;2.E m2%_'E,:9§.X:g§f iiizis $f§:"i$€?*,.._._2§E'1{§ €;.E":€ :";;1'é:a':1"€~ {if :"e'i%<3§§; $:>u.g§::Ei by the p~*;%$_.»*;§;4i€:»:'£a%:'. _ ~ A .__ i£E {:=:§:'2i;{:--::%;§<3:': 0:? :*é;*:.:~:*;g3{§:f:{£é:é':":';'. :3 :x:§fc.1%: ':;;\§$:c7;:*{E :§;;s{:::Eé§<";z":€::* ?i§<:-:».11:é;§.;"{4; §;:;éE%i§; <2? 3z2:§§:f@s;=?;§::;:§ :55 §::a%<3r::;:§ i~fa<?*:?;4s whiitiz pa_:"%;i{:'a:Ea:°E:; {§ii%€EEE§ii§E€f*$ 'ihii patééiienei"

1, /. "3§'i°79;_>:":iA.' anj; ?<-éiésf. /' £1 «: 2% 2»

22. in this; c:a>r1i'.:i::»:tg wilzat Ems; b€*,€:'.fi saeizzisgé by z"e5p<;:1<i§'§:£ N33 is ﬁléif. Ehfi pei.§ii(;::e:z* having; ﬂied the writ pe*£.i{i<::"2 beiaztesiiy has 'z:ak€'::: 31 fzxise pies; ﬁxai v<':r3I r€{:€:'nﬁj; iii: <:am<;3: ii} imam: abimtz "£1315: §.;;;'ram*. of mmiygg Ease in §2?:%{{3*ur Sf r€>$p{3~1':d<::x';i: N33? The samgs i;'=§ iiiiiiiﬁefﬁféi by f§i":E§Li°;§§::£§',>; "'£§'12%s£ «ﬁaizii. Rfféiiiiigiiig E}i:'€=:?:i'<3r' Sm B.?\§.Singgh £11-2f:_*;:_;;g?gg.;ff;1'é;éé2'§§.khé» '_ :ni:1:_:3§; §7L'*Z}S€$ 'i5:E';.iz:%: is :1-*:%{2.e2:.1:{_é{%{i"'¥<>';? ":'E1._:*; §ﬁC;r}%c:--;§T:"2aVL§;:s.E3:s' j A:1::e3:xm"£:$ is wh'.i{;§1f"--_ s:/2.3%: .' ET:{}'ij.. '§'§:<3§'€:f0:':3, me é:i:§."£i<';n:3r {:21.ZEI*:'£?2i §7€:i'4-ff: i:€nG;<2:i';:<:é":i}§Vﬁgs Gfdéﬁ' V' as .. . :

§32;:s~;3::%<§ in §§'.E.§ff :£=i';E§,§" <':i}':"a'::{%::<§fé:::% §..E:_:a€, ':'E":<% p€3i:,§;'é:'i0§1€§ haﬁ Szzggprﬁasezéi f;'$;f;:':é.7{h.::§V"C;;:s,1:::€', ms: faati. %,Z"12:i. it had gi¥:ji3:;__ a:;g .§::':.~3:-~'r:féqu¥:«s'5;}TfQ§-- graiat af mining §€38..S€ in Bieark *Ai 'D' z:.g<::d if "E§2:::*;'a:;*'é1&§xx;a§21j; §§}epni}$ﬁ; B§:i§21r'y' Bisirict gmgé Vizfgsz-§<3£z7{2': iv;£E3:'I§V.."'§"€i{;1E !&';f;.3~{€3€§L mézzizzgg Eﬁzzaéé far %.r:}n 33%: in E?;21:':i;%;§1:e?L.é21V:"gzz E}<«3:p§};;<«2it3 whiith §'€'3{§U;€;'fSE. '$5218 .%:2m{:€;,i{m£3d by f}i':*£?i<i«:fV 7£§:%.;i.@&. 2?;'{E3,?2§éC%i'} "«.'iif1:€: &.::;;§';_s--::X:.m:= 1': £3 %;7z':€.= §}§'f'€1i?;.§{}§73f.-'fiE" E33252 21{§§2:?Ei',i::e;é{§_ E:§;':a"ié éézegfg §."§E":{§ §;s:.§';-*.z;:§':»2253s::*:i.§v f%;§°<>:: {gm 1%{;m :':3$§}w:}§':§i:::é::% EKEEEVE §;a':r ﬁa::"s:::é:%x':2:"<é 1§%'i:.:',€:'r {§83;{i'{§ {33fE€3;'2L{}€3&£ w§';':':.%:,{-32;; {}E'."3 E;2<':}12:§f Q? _é;:,§*:j§:_t;3€%3.§té<:%:";a;%:<' H} 3136 §}ir<~3<:€:.Cs::', E}epa:"i',rné3:*1i: 5%" ';\z§?:n§3:.5 and 5»;

M, W: 30 :w Geeiagfy, C§€)'V€I"I1i"'1'E€E?;'E Qf Ka:*::21i;22E<3% seekizng ESSEIBJSEEE Gf Geelogicai Permiﬁ; far iiféénggg '(hrs lrcm. {we fram Ga'/t'.»:>'§€:' 2888 emssardg. it is aim {fQf§'E,£-Efiﬁﬁéii {hat public €§1'§fifG§H§:€3?{1E2:§ hearing rssggzrdirzg $16 gggffcxgzi cf <:n2ri'mr:mer:€a.E é;f§ii'f:1E'§:1f1C€§5 at S§M.Bi0ck§ E{1'::3*;é1:.9$~s;%X3;zny Rzmgﬁ was heid am. Q9/QQXQGQS 211163 pubiic Fi{'}§§{'f€ éiafisd 23i@§f2®€:'5"'£::< Eg>a.:;§i:;«;§_ATV'§{.<:xx;$'--7?2'§§::€:ré'é AV regarding? ihti'. gram: Gf »E§12zi:"A:{§:1%$*2é:§:t,a'i.y .'%:§W1ra%:;%§é~ 'igggs I%SE§1i€ﬁ, which xazas f{}§{}V3J€d Ciaﬁéd {"}'§;'§%§,»'2§%:3 §.'@g:2:§'si'E.%::§§~~..§::"a*:f=':V¥§ %§§ :é:§§:*{}fs22§. ibis E"i}§<3$':; §C0m:~ser::aiii::1} ;%e::i:,§ E'£':ini'ng§L Qysratisga in §<.;}:.¥i'%"§,_§.3.%§éZA§¢Vfi §z?Z,V...V_ §'t:;?LE1if§é{i".;Z;"iE§;'iEa1'§T1§' Rzmge, WE:-S gyaniﬁé. Thereafféiﬂ {Z~az.e§:.é*e.E'£§€.i-§§é€;it:i<}::: de1E:,<:é 2'?f€%2;'2§G5 grantimg E38?-?§}€Z'" {<3 r€$%;;«:;:4§den€i: N833 fa}: am area <3?" 198 Acrea in , E:"3.j¥§.;¥r3§é:=¢;§i:,A£*Z:zm.ara$wam§ Rgagzgég 1-'£38 issuéci. Suppregging " Vviimélviffifﬁ ':;j:':£ p:*fet'.e:':d§:i§ {:3 Em: igzzaremi. Gf §.§"'i€"3 gram G? ::z:%:%;:":§;§AEe'2:S€ :5; :'€3p0§:.€£§%:":i'. thﬁ §€E,é'%:::e:"::T3:' @223 :'sa:;::§h'£.

" 'i,<::L--.§':E2a1é€2:3;;;@ 3.212% ssaziié gr;/1:13 "i7E2e:f%3:§'c}ré:, iiééi <':<:z"§'é:%:§:":.§::a:2 sf 'fEf€':'E§§G§}.§€':§ﬁ. I'€{:=,3 £3 Ehaé fhéi peﬁ's.§{>::{-3:' guéizjg 9;? guggesﬁie m: 32 :-

m£sfea.c€iI':§; f:'E:e C'<2:i§':"_. §2:'5~: ;)»3§.ii.'€€}z'z r'n€§,g.; E39 {i:'smi$s,:ec£ 5;: {E16 :§m3s?1<§£.5i 2.0-ii.}':0a,§.§.

{:(;2;'2.s»;:z§.e.:"2'.z:5;; {.§":Q me:°z':,s 43,?' {fig {:§.5z§m¢ 3!: $5 iii #4' :25, A 3/2r:;>.r0§;a€:'i:x:? E'é?¥F'Z(?€C§gj is? 229:. 2:: m::z:,:,e2* cgf" c0a.gr5;»:3, Z.-Vhiie e:<€e~r<:%isii'zgv 5-:%:<z.z'(1::>:*{§ :':'zc:3*;.; p{3a,a:e§' :1 3/i='rzi{'. Cam', :z,:'z:;;:4l£'E'{;§' <;r@:"£"{iz'§'zEg; bear in m:'n;{£ {E29 <:<:::'2<:€::<nfMgf-._§§":.a%f_:'w. _{}{i?'f.§g z,:.:§'2:> §m,2{2§s:é?$ §':'§':e>. jag;'i4E:;?'{23'{s:':{'€e;>:'§ {fi{>z.zr§,a if/K {:§'z.{3 a;:2pZi.m:n:. ;";:;':{:§§%;:ia<§ 'V S§.{;£i.:3?§?E:';?¥"E§. 6*?' :»'=;zzg2;';:*{-3::§e;;.; :':':i{}z'::<;;?f:'.::E: f§§§€,'¥?"3,§}§,S 5:} z':<'::"sEea£§ "{fff<2:,:r'i.. 's:i'Ej:é' T $593933' §':2:i:§,; {§2's:z':.§:»;;$ a:e:%§::'f<§:é* §g%*:§:;,s_.:§éf €};§{?EE£f' {,:;':;{§ :':':{2.y ' $5230 5525» §§'if:j:"*s?:;::?;',§?'- 'E§'§{z'zL§V:;T:§; "E:§»'e> :,a::"EE 339:. Vi:jsE€§5: Z'.{}V'V;g;'tj::3é4£.%*;' €i§§;?§:ii.'f£EiO31 Eﬁecazzse Q3" :.:.:}'2a{ ggésgjégswi 9:-§o§'1ni,§",. mée §'2.a::«; §'38{3§'"2 ezsaiaﬁséai 5' »i:g '4§§'2;*.'§g:;%s'"' ;'§:.:E*3§E;:'{: §:':E:re.resz :5: gieissr :_;=::;5a?.;f;;pu§b:i'5""Eizéggazziﬁ j%*o:':'*: €T§§'}i.é;%T§?1§§ sffze §:?;_?if;:€gI;;<;$':"§f{1;:z.a.:"E ?}§; {§.53{7s3:f:'e:'§'s;c; :1"

E37:.§§;§'§:? f%$€i{f}?£E{§ <;%a.%sa%. $1322 gf':§:{?2; {:{}i.E§"§ :>%.§§;:%:°:*{%{§ as; ' 3 J 9 % in;

\.».»I 1 E5. :§'z:g.s; :.?Eg%c3_;' §§'":{,:;§.' §:'§'a{}a,s:§g§: 5&3? €Z§}§)€3?§.§.( :35 <:*e::'a§:{:zz:§.; Ezgzgi {:;:;aV;s2'35z{f§'2.{-faﬁ 55:9 Efgiggfs {1":;»z,mi zazzgiszzr .;f§?"f,§={:'E€ 226 05;' 532.9 ai:cs;2.:~;:',z'3i":,:§"€<3z'2. E: §'a{:;::"§ :29: a?c:z:'":d.i§§iE.§_g §.%E€£§€d 0:55; £}'zé3_§§€;:<:=§.§ {.52 :.§':g-3 {'.'Qi};:"'§f, 2

-: 34 :~« d0€:u'n";s:n%:..ss has-"£5 b€:e:%:1 z«§;<:ive:rIE.eai ta a.b{:e*a,--"e, which would c:1<3a:*Ey bmzg (mt: E}'§.€£' fair: that tbs: p€:"z.ii:,§.0::a:-3:' E12135 HG Eacus; ;<;i:a:'zdi is zmsazii the mizxing ieasiz g:'2s;:1t,§.-'iii in fézafozzr 3:7"

:'%::sp{3§.1{ie2':i, 7:'\E{§a3§ ihaé §e':.;i£i<}:1€::"*s:; app};%Cz1%:§::>:1 %;a:,§g*e heezx i'f1d€p€§1§EfE'1?.§}g" c:<>n.ssic§e=:zfed czximinaiiizzgg in éhe %i:%{>'*:f§';«,[ C>.:'der skated 2'?,fS3/'RSS9, Fm"i;.h@:3 She pe'{.iti{>m3r :;w;{2%§§é gjrawi; (sf the mi;1.::1;;§ Eéféiﬁif right fri:,s1f§::"":;?::e:: '3».-'€f1'_'.°§§§1{i}€i'§}?;i*i§§3;Vbiiij A' €?h{};'3}€ '11:}: iii} '3{1.f:'a§{€f any aéﬁoga Eﬁi v%:}_;é'--};:3a§ :T%1é37;5i;EH{?§fff; ihﬁ ::<)m.{-:::*§i{}:": mi' the 3.€21:"E'"':€'i:§_ 'V€,2'{}iLi§"£E§=€:'.'§'~ .:f:{3".{V*.T%'s?:<$V§";=::sré'&s*3z1§: 'E's§§.3 iihaé; §E*g:::§"€: %:*:$§*: ::'§;.;j_3§:=;.°€%.~3éé§ié';':.'§:»f %:<:_:?:§:ié§i;i§"§2*:'£t%'§.$ EEEES :19 be:

aa::::<:pt,.eﬁ(

218." At: ?f}7ﬁi£§'v"€:§§':21§}§é'€'%¢7€):i1§.€§ bf: 'r€E@2?a::€. H} aéveiri. :19 E336 Qrésr dazﬁzié @f31_fiZ}E;'1.?§{}€i;s'é3§ paagésd by §~£<}::*b'E€ ﬁbéﬁzzi Eazeaf J,.j 'éig._Ej'a,N§x2'f"=--£%€%?i égseéging :4-*'2>;{:a§.i:3n of a.<f§~§'::E",s3:;"§:"§i $13.21;?

{:ﬁd€: éhig Cmzri, {H1 2;3;"®°?"g'2®§3?, '§"%:€3 §'e§£;*:2z*ar::§;. §§(}§"{iGEE_ ;=:.5~.2 E"{}§.'§{}'%sa%;:~ _ E Q, $526 zsmri é3~;§}::§,s3z;§ j2:z:f:"':«;; 52:22 ::§"sc;:' £318 :'a?s.:§3@:2§a%§'z£ E2521/E :TsT:{:,d€ 5,53: $531235 :}:?5=_§':"{>:"2 K;'%3';* ggrazzi 23;' s":'z€2':é:1g§ §.8€2$€ {:2 resgpezri of "£3253 mag :22. €g:2,s;?S:§Za:': 9::

BE T?';' Z 983, The said. &§pE.:ca3i:j@:: agsas carsséderssci by 3.316: -Siauze {Egg-€rz1:":1;e§'zi; azzd G, 2/, ' :20§ii;'f'i::a:Tior': as pg?' f1z2z:exm°e»E' dated 232.2005 1:503 isgued azfafordirzg s2:mc?{'iQr:_;"7Gr gram' Of'E»:3'c.--'--i>S-6 ft)?" 52; pgrigd eff 28 yean; in Lfézvazgr sf -i_'}""a€_._"'--35i'>".,u resp0nden:'_f70r from are ever an «sire;/z.--:%§f"i"9?§».{§£?'.._ ' actres in S.f§%._£3Z9<:k, Sandw' 3"'a.i.:z§-;:;*~._ fﬁgiiiargg §3isi'rir:ié.. ﬁzis ::2a3kj'"oi£@zz/mi; '2§V§;"i}3{3"e:{£e:7zzﬁ::%::.Qéfa rnizzing Zecme deed or: }4:'3,233é?5. '§-f}éu2€s.:e:; 'Q"= €.'G§"2"ig€?"Edi£?}"1 wag §Ss':.§§>'a?.V.Q:'1 {E153 z:':§n§:';g area :9 E34'v%€z::7'%'esf ?'§"e{3' g3:¢'§f$,£i9§ize§' has appraagrhgd :'?1i;§ ' ~%:L_'az,z:f§ :§g::'z:g 331% Majxbregaid n9£§'iE£:52,'§iorf: and § 43, E §,2Q§Z7;, ?'?:er:2 £.5; 1:::_deisiiﬁV{§§7:£3bC«:§.L§i.V.§ ';;,ss;g:>5;'r 8 ??"EQE"'§Ef§"LS in s:'2§g3;";;§é§g:§':§" ::§:'i;<; ..{}a:;:f:§ ' §%§°::iE€2:'€€:§ as"; §°€"?{.'®§°€§.

.:?E€gis'_£;; ggzisciéssés';.?j':.{:€;""{fie §:)é§'i§:'i@:153:" is a.§,:;sar€ sf ~:'F:lé' gz';5m£" 5f}7'I:%1izi:z.:§ Eea,:§:{§é"?£:*5: respmi Qf 53252 area in 'queszéari";i§?;-~j2:«;J§&: {he SW' resparzderzég As a rz€,a.?:ﬁ§er »-- pe€T:'£"iar2e;";9 Jami ﬁafanaging * -vféireciogf gags Eiimgegf gresezzzhjbr §3EO.E,égEif'&§'§Q§?, sf :,}-35:' :<z3.i:2ir1g £T«:,5:':fSe 3}" ¥f}":€:' 3?" re§;pa:";aier:£; '?§2,§5; E2.a:.§ '_£;reé;--'s, dispmed by {$36 peiiizmzzer, E3' is £559 fmm 3:326 nzaieriaii <93": reﬁaré £T§z.aE"

;.<§é?EiEf€§fE€? 2:-5&5-3 his §€§'§.s3r dgzzleﬁ :23;3¢E§Q§ Ems:

" rgségzsesigégi. §':'§":a> S§'<2E{,> {§a:;%€:"::.:32;3;%:.§: }%}?; §r»::.2'2§: 5:3?' ::¥::i:':§3"zg;;' §€{II.f§£3: 9:5 .§%€g:::{:{§a.:r;<_"g<:z {§a?;;§:<;§§T ;f:':$§':€:2§ Q? §€zg.:2z{g:"gzsw&:22§; éfepasii {md {§a:9emz:r":8§'zE §s"éer E1523 been gaassssaé as per ;'i:':r:e:<:;§:'e mfézé an 217,3,2Q@§ ?"€C0?3'2;3'?E€§Tc§i?Ig grazzi of {mm 5%:

51. ,,»<'"'¢--

m:'r:ing Zeczsajbr 70 MZ?:ifT in §€ama££z,zrga ciepaséi"

in favésaar of {The pe:'££:'0r:er' in Ezieu sf {he ::"0z'z;i;x:f€ mi,m':'zg {eases C0.E'"§'?;§?Ziii€d is be granéred e::s:r'_f1iz:%:%f"--€:9:"*._ Bisdcéz A; E) E of Kz,:rnar:;:sa1:azrn;;.--lﬁégkiéiﬁ-ii; 'V' Pe§z'E;i0ner has sazppressed {Ems jt:e;%i'V."-z;z)a::%Z§. T§'L€?"'€.f bra, ii CC{?7é¥"£0Z be s§:aid '£?';_a§*Z. £~:?:::>;fé'-_Vi:s 'i0". subgziﬁiérzg app£z'ca:jio:'2; A' 30 , j?r3zr «. "

f{££¥'?1ﬂ?'ﬂ:'~§E§3ﬂI'.Q§; E1353 pcé' 'ii;-~ .V x 2% 5:? $5; 3.16%' V' ;::.£:"§G agpiied for grmzii Q? gééaéfagigai ' §i;'::z_z%§f?1§Z€' 5:25 per .f~"§rfanex::r€ -~ }€5§?c:2'§e& mzfzergéifén if hag admizied gm: £21 §"ié;:;§' g::g:'52eme;:°'2_:' far' suppfg Vqf izfb%'é"<;:%je:* _,§%":;t:}€""1"ir;?;'.;sx§{La;2':ara &f§=$§§ §2':€:%:r£a:* :[arz;2;3§: _-géfsélsfHv:%i:2.r2§j§iJ£'.':V'L_~ £535 eviéem 'j%'a_m. {E26 ;:éiEiég~. fg::§§é:«:ed' Eécard am: pe:'iz'iaz';e:"

'beéfzff ' iron 9:» frasm; {he re3p0:1der€:'. "';'7-'jé&--§?;€7{;»:?:{5z' has suppressed aii these ' z3?5azi€r£a,§.Kf:::::s, SE" is {hug eséew" ifzaii §8§fi{'€8¥7i€?" Ems ;2,i=9'~§ cz.:"?§?ie £'0E?':;éCG::.r§. ::;zi:'?a cieasz Ezarsds, 2"'§":0ugf"z Sssverai deaisimzs; Emva 3356?:

<?:'.§§3s:'§" 53:6 £s3{z:*:i'a§-3:-i {?{§§,éfE§€§§;§:Q?° 532.8 pafiiesa ii' is ~.r29E;.. ??,€{?€.E§,E§iZ§'§§ :5: afsrzgiéézr 5:326 :s*&:?":§2 as éizis aiiaga ' E5 is .§€§:E'.§€{:§ fftai §@:.:.:s3s'° Q? 55:9 f:%'ig§": {,.13u;:*Ejb§"

A £55535: ;:fg:pg33"@pz"£:;a:'.£ ayrii Eifidzi-3?" £%.r":':°{?§e 2:25 Qf' 3&6: Co::s::'€'::;:"i0n is dz13€re{'ia§:a;§:;. E%f"Eze€?1e:' 5:318 Szaiie Govemmersi Ems mzésidezred :2 dew appiicaiiaa 5?:

f-" 3/»

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

Jsw Steels Ltd vs The State Of Karnataka on 13 April, 2012

Bench: Chief Justice, B.V.Nagarathna