Karnataka High Court
The State By Honavar Police vs Ashok S/O Maruti Karaguppi on 29 May, 2008
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit, L.Narayana Swamy
COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT GF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR Ee TES RiGd COouRT oF CATED THIS THE 29!°pAv oF MAy 2608. ey be ted Hei it =
ie tea ps ha ie ee Pilg NO i B43 (2061 , THE oT are BY FROUAY BR. POLTC 7 "aes APPELLANT BY Said TADHAY, STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR) BMD :
cay MARLPTT KRRAGUEFI YEARS, R/O.OLD HUBALI AB DA AAY TRNAHARIA L HONAVAR ICT UTTARAKANNADE «os RESPONDENT RIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED U/S. S378¢1) 4 BY THE SPP FOR THE STATE PRAYING THAT SGURT MAY BE PLEASED TO GRANT LEAVE a THE JODGMENT Of.
sSSED BY THE PRL. UMFC., HONAVAR IN " AGQUIPTING THR RESPONDERT~-ACCUSED PUNTESHABLE USE. 3232 B/e 34 IPC.
CRIMI uA APPEAL HAVING BEEN HEARD AND FOR JUDGMENT, THIS DAY SABHAHIT J., PORLOWTNG?~ "Oy o Ss Bf G Wo eo 4 4G » a o § uo: Ho goo Q op goo ee Bs e 8 Ou db 4 mo by Be ao 3 Pay iG i a 2 $0 4 G8 ed at Le ty i CG ib O * iy " ic bei Th a woe ne 4 be) oped a LS ee ea {3 te rd co boo 2 Se BG) OS 3 oom Hee a 3 u 2 og 4 ooo oF gs ai a so C es n a aha ha ri 43 4 aL a cp a a "ed r ff Et 43 . m =f uj fy ! eo 7 a te a ei a ee os ns oO wo 8 a cA vi ooo 8 ks 1 . o pF tm Ho os @ ye to @ ne ey a4 G D th eth aa i is A He 2 a g z a G ay a if a rs - j a: ae es in & o "a: r re 7 Go MM wo os | Og ago 3 a my ee eee: Ro u if 7;
i g . ed eA 4 2 il na hs Ae +4 th e Bs ma , in 7 mee ue ad bef {3 i he o in ; ah . oe ery i a i * sy .
" cA ane: oe upooord a er & ha ey feed si % eh Cpe Fa at @ i a hi a mye o a uh she BY ef of es a in be
i) ay "ei ey ; Seg ed end Sa ae x a w + Hh, x e cp e " '7 . i> in Por a 'S oy en a | a bo Ee Be ry OW o « « * ee . . -) ve oe F id Rd bal a ped ra "4 en: f pf ae Pe i oh ee ce Eu How Wo sO E er ee a og e 8 , te ots a an "i ao : a dee bd a ey at ep Beg od wh a a e Big q ote nw &S rie @ o Be ag cl a 4 vy 4 hd vy re g ce ms sa ts Ai a iG a iia] iy pug ong rey aa th re oe * be ha ey "ef , ay S a is a SoM 7 'ts a @ Hoy 2 3 i #8 e Bu #4 Fol if ei = ~ - E bu i ; & rd
- BD " i oo oe poo OE a ie ° Ras Ch a ms a a is : ~ -
bry fa a Gi - at mm rs ha a a a a * a o 3 a nd - pd cA #4 ae Li a ' a "| a 4 42 a 8 4 : ey i @ ' oe ic 43 a ed a 2 hd a kg 4 YNOD HOH WIVIWNaV 40 LINOD HOIH WIVIVNUVY 4 al © LINOD HOH WIVIVNAWN 4O LIND HOI. WIVIVNRYN Jc a 4VH JO LUNOD HOI WIVIWN AWNYWH dO Larco"
iad 3 CF aay an a ° see uF me fo ho 4 ' " ne ra) ' Goo oS 4 i 2 & 8» eo o* 4 @ 4a oe FF o Bo Ro @ om eo CG cd 4 Go 'R ® St a es ee | fel a 3 in v a vod et . ra BBS g 8g me @ Ho |. § 4g can . By sips hd oe OB es 4 re eel 4 ae uf be ht wi hay ih md gt hy try "pd ae i ® " -e4 c cy 74 | > ep | ; 'a a vat a4 a gp a doo. ad ra
- ce am m . m4 th a be a "rd g Y - g a cl i pow op yg OR ey u rr a er: = ne MoU ee oe GB OG ne ca ne) g 2 Soe ow © mG a 2 ~*~ m9 » 8 & a : " bye ' x ae mom FS oo RB om Tey gE ¢ ew § Wo 8 8 fy 44 bd nS af . vheg cat of 's and a : re rg a he a G ue de ti "4 ib ts, a 4 a oo . oped + age oe ey bea oi a Aa at ha Yi et) oa) a oy aa ay - oe | a thi o aed a G iG vd +3 . wow ek ia a or Et spd ry : ce fs, ge _ Lo wey ea be ne ae aro c es its ie ed es i oot ee ; ~ & bi ar es ee ee = oN Poo Y 3 eo Rete SB oo TT SD e Me kq ad a a "ef ~ : a : '4 a a -
ee ee tt my a ie 4 : Shy rs cpt) 1. My i a | "I 2) vi re ne oe bi ay p "s rig! Boom bse a 7c © . nr ee ri. q ot E 3 soot 4 eye ed Rea oo a | "ed nF ee ee GS at ib . my a or a a rs a an ved ce G if . Dee o a 4 Q 4 thy a d a : vs vad Ls | F : oe cht ea a mf te a Ao a "| oe BEG 4 S » Boe Me ay _ ved if os Ls fo has fr rae ly "py ne ee ee re e ad wea "3 Ae Ag ae eed en "4 ey _ ; wo 'k 3 ' ha ' a - ie 2 ' ° a oe] 28 cs ag 'e fal 3 Hs ! be 2 om ik ; .
Yo CO 8 8 -m ¢ tC * 0 8 & @ ~ & &© ¢ & w&» @ Ww @ a aed wed So gt s & at a re Pe] i} ad uy q roi or Me A ti ay a a a a OR ie a: a ff Fs ep rd * 43 fd ih @ oo a Moy 9. Fe oo a Ee end ey a @ a i 4 ae €¢ OO & wm 6 'Oo «a ee 4 We @ . of Tose ih ot ty a * 'ns re) x gi Gea i o Ay fc 8 he <7 & & it Be] va, i ah eo an ep tra fed . - "O Abd "as a ; "a ti od igh uy 4 ry a . er a u ee a nt 'a B it o es ee es pom © 8 6 EF G@ 8 7 a ae ee 3 oie itt fy = i ra ig qd i ou BB Be » o " 4 o o © «ft ty, . a " ™ moa ~ rr A an , : i fea i> i ; @ oom sg Bg 7 es ee in ag rs er er ee er es) , # ti E as 4d 4a iwa) rd " 3 ' a? a ae 4 4g gy sy i a eo elgg aoa iY uw oO mR a wo Wow & & re a id i & Q a 4 rt ee me Gy , « Grd of LJ te) i hs So me ay Je) oy ty ay Coo ify . gs en: re rn re ae: nn ee "8 w & a go oo 9 eG fo ROM mg HF ¢« 8 « & 4 Gg By ee G8 oon Bo oo & a oe O a °7 . ae a ei # b4 =H i "a = £ "peo c em J a a 7 fo aH iP a, Spa MM. z cu wi ba rf u a? ee ot o eo ary .y 7 "a * 5 ie:
vie ih rs fi ' Loo Ay ae mm an w "4 nt Bu i haf A ® ie mp 7 ns | 2 = ed th a PbS bi a a eo + Ni m oe * a a a rd be] ro a "4 4 ms a th Bd we aed we : ch et Fr fh re a gt a} "4 ° My 4 a wr "4 ne in : a te . rhea a ae as i : ba 4a mE nS. wl La @ aa r e re at z . 5 en re ee ee 7 es Oy on ee Ry ed Ld cy uA th a a a a : i aa 2% c * Be " ay - Ww hd oy nt a i Lig ing . Es 7. i my moet Ma i "afl fe i i's wo : fs ch * bod © my Bhs hd im ar} i rea * ie "et * a oS aD 3 te -- a r bf Ld i i th a * "a mu Fe ay Aa ei tak oc YNOSD HOIH WIVIVNEV JO LINOD HOIH WIVIVNYVN 4O LINOD HOH WIVIVNAV JO LINOD HOH WIVIVNAYH JO a4no> HOIH VIVIVNAVH dO LenOD ' a ifs I 3 MM * re * 4 ie ty q ib 4a TH aH ea 4 ae a a a a rs : wed : Aa a > op i oh wood ts weed i i i 4 aa e A en te So Bet aD , oS a ba " , 8 2 4s @ BO fo &@ fp om & ' w per "bg 4 us a4 ad i = ort o ea Py ip oy A acre 4 gf nm «ft 4 Og cS 5 mn we a ORY fa ae . é i x in rn ; 4 @ a Woe iM ae x oi a od rd S : 'a te! 4 a o a 4 Bo oe wee a " " 4 # gq id a a ou a ke 4 gp ce aa 3 be ir} ° a @ B a o oes ee tH eran + cae : - rol " SO dd ay 8 a e . my a +4 ity a i ti ' a 4 "aa: - . a2 fey o eo] a 16 "ad © a g Be gy SB oy z xt a ® :
o a a & & eth a 2 ¢ = tl aj As w ay ved by 4 rr it a ha . Ost rd ia iy 4 a a r a i mo ee = eas e ry dd , "I "yee if we a « rf E ro mt 4 nbd be a o£ i 8 & og ef 4 _ 4 ° 4 4 {33 - Bd a _ B 3 fe © we i of . = a e # 4 es aa i 4 a A ae. a gay . S : i 2 re H ve cd a. ar ~ ' 4 he me Gag 4 cs) _ v= gm : ce Tay a 3 i ip a ow 12 tet ib cond ib i pel ay = | hd ie é 5 oo o- ¢ & n G : roy Te 4 i, q i a i AS a . B 4a rae " oo oa oD eR ' Crs) ; oS 3 hes ut is od ba 2y ed m4 4 *e ej fed _ uy ™ rm) a4 " pod v4 2 t hd FEE a ay oe hdl ae V3 a i ie es rt ey a Be ed = c 2 te wy yh oo ,) aa ' a Cf a : ee £ ' ip do vi a Q tas a3 "ed Sal gi iy af i i wi Eb INOD HOIH WIVLVNUY1 JO LINOD HOIH VIVLYNEY 4O LINO? HOIH VAVIVNAVH 40 LINOD HOIH WIVIVNUW! dO QINOD HOIH: WIVLYNEW 40 DINE COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR ted runing. They were chased by the 3 i a BY eveil of FW.2¢ and apprehended andthe. persone Sevegled Ris neme ae Ashok "fo, Maruti atatement about tha incident that teok place aE per the complaint. filed. by Pw.4. During che "gearch of accused no.i, it was ma eheo. he was in possession of currency metes Sf . Re.i2,088/- of different having & paper 88g containing 100 gms. of chilly powder.
- PELSS. peiged the said cash of Re.12,Q35/-, Lch accused noa.l was a duking the personal Ol SOTUSER mo.2, ii wae found that he was in possession of currency notes of aitiercent denomination totaling to Re.14, 000/-
tilt dao Tae omens "EP Eade fet G a: itt :
Ged apg oO. er @ eo @ ie i 2 @ Wt is os ee. * wee - a i Lh be hy ot 3 gs 4" oS a 'i 4 a © cid a . :
pee ee: eee, SY i 8 U i my ry a P. eS o td a 2 he Ho py a 8 nm hoa a - oH ~f i 8 fay Ely " a a ord oe ay ots a ir ci i a : S a so Hw o ua oO hy a = Pip ar | 8 By BY a © ci ap ee 4 a gh : a 4! #5 - o iy '4 a es a Hos Dg e 8 wy , of re a OU 6 ay 2 ood 4 v hy be He He E « ; . < 4 oy : wed a J i a Peo tds MoM Ao og Ug a es eo i dh w a"
eeu 5 S A ve Pers fy I hd a ;
Spy a if uw an 3 4 ej i 44 ab ft a . i vhs re se £ ri iw a . a] . b . oe Aad ved 3
a) ' pS a a f-. : it te yet za . & he vn 4 te a 4 ct And ; i 4 id : 5 rt ti a oh Ad KH aa i rr aye GS » id a i Bet my y 3 oes re S| PB oe ee ee es e + a 2 ® an: @ on 8&8 4 : ! wf e a 3 a Dp =F 4 a ft % b a is o hed . . : ., ad i Bet .
: oom oy om Fo Tf 8 moi ay t fi wD 2 4 MA ey a pee bd p oe ' 2 a 43 e g 'i ih a a aa E m4 4d fe .
wi ' co ih id es Pe a be 7 ae " 0 193 rf HOH WAVIVNAYH 40 JANOS HOIH WIVLYNYY JO LHNOD HOIW wivi_waADie am PAA oad Wowie LA sininin WAR ere eee ee ee TP ou Pye Be ee ee sey "8 oy 9 cn rn; are) co gt id ' nf ad + © a o 8 ~ad 2 a So ee of Be ae nt ae rd 8 H FON a oa 44 a ay "Ti ri we Ee 4 a a - 7 a at ip a So ea ce 5 ni ® Pr "4 ti ~~ ° me ; : aoe ne } P A. O ed Bs. ; aD 4 7] a o 8 woot ge BR wg fy 8 m8 g 3 a 4 9 a ne OH Og 4 , om fo os a en ee a » of 4 & . i re mM ood Oo 4 PL Fo hg D © y a 7 i ® G ; bet mi oe - eS ok a rs ae 45 rd oh ie om a og BO Ro i 8 ™ "4 a . = Pa Root ge a a we i oa ry Qn ° . a sot ae pr F : i el e um ps og Bo. a om « b 8 8 '. 3 LP co 7 Cl + it a) i. abe it hey ig 7m a cs ee ir ! "oor i OG z rn ae a a eS iD % ; he "4 il as, 2 er os th ab ey 8 ic 4 ae i ri § &h iG ML bp : an: ai p ° "4 i i Oe ee bd a ta as tO a 4 8 | 4 tb i it i ee ae R b a ; mp OO a a Soo oF ows t fi Ke 4s wi 4 i ty ig ref i re % ae a = i wl ah oi i z Et be fh zh ba od a i un "I o "ae a a :
Be US ee te ii a sed at ie ee Ai hd s om gp rf Te Us wo ti ; ' a a 4 7 i "a ae c ia tel id a vot ay ' fy ' o "
he "3 my pe " a 3 bi bed HOIH VIVIVNAVA JO LYNOD HOIH WHIVEIYNYYN AO 1NNOD HOH wwrwAD uA punjnn ad Wawra 1A sranlincn Baeeae se mee cee ee ee wo Pm "o ay ee) we ord cs _ xi td o 9 1 wi 8 wo OG 2 Meg 4 tl "4 a FY ai cB = pa a 4 ot nS ii g ey ed a a bed ig -
re Ray os "i ou
- ® XD mn om bl 43 a bd & a 4 ae 2 Dy rd | a id cat u a3 "i i a mPa ce : 4 a to Ped ap 44 th 'by the d at , Tass on a ek OTE * arg ae OT ek the JaDEive 2B:
has Lou secut a, Fae re HSIH WIVLYNAY dO LYNOD HOIH WIVLYNAYY 40 LHNOD HOM Ea se) 4a ef @ 4 i a oh : 4 fi a ne) te i is "ed 4 ah o a i bd ' a iy we g & my 4 5 ao oy a oS ef cr ib a as a eh 4 ee: 43 0 it bol iS .
oy rd onl gi i neg red "} ved ri ar ay "ey gj ;
wy ey b ha i LI te a tt G "rd od a - i Med aH z in mat ord red ae a us * hd Fits a E a - "" #4 a ' red ~ i @ © ie g Moog 8 oy a lat gol ct Cay \ oa M4 , 'a a8 'A a 7 i o A * oo '4 "4 © oe 4a a fd ye) a " ved a0 85 oh whe ry td fat oe Fe fal "4 3 4a ty yd ay s a © ; ; = x 'i o i. be Lis at Ay ood od :
ab at ae us Ad m vd od hy WY IVAINYY IO AO Gat Hwan GA PUAN Pea Un ns \guk ee ee ee) a, a fe rt » ned * hed e - od: Me or a ve] a 3 a fa Tj ci & . At re ' rl a o fa pot QO oh MF. het wt hd pou : ae re; aed ew 3 im i 4 mo] ey ae 4 Ci ord i x rs 4. ed - " red ci bey -- het Ly hd ih ra 1 bq ey be gs ht ai ry hed t t ee t Fa a Fl 3 4 7 ae es re | e & 4 G F 7 3 a 4 bs, bed 0 ed 6 rn 13 4 ne wo 43 s hi 4 - @, ry Fi : he eg a ip ed a {3 r c o Boe te EY "alCU eo 8 € OF . Boor ra sae * elt i a nu nu Le reg 4 re a ei hud ra an os he" che | a "she ig hf ge td it a hes ay "rd 4d - : apd ong Q a ad iu i a Ty id ey o g a . i tad "fey a CG ut b4 uf Ey Aa 7 ae La ie em) "3 im M4 i ns 14 ay a Mg od a i we i "y i Poe G , ay 4 : Ad yoo 4 43 rw) 4a ii = * iD f ee ie o Bo Ag 2 4 # S a G 8 oe es '" ee ee ee Soo. G # # A ry + 0 OB i abet hd . : Bea oe. doz . ie yet gy a : ge oboe ea gag og 8 Beat - : " . . . 2 # . 4
- -- #4 4 eg Fe eT |G EE o og Boag fi oe) g aie Et iw dd a i 5 . j ch ae rf ay ae 4a aan ' ep ry T Hi _ to i) i bg ae * hd . - i . a tad wa FA a Fe ded ong ey g ud # a ix; of ri it ng de + aa a a nay wha i ° is Hog Mey ge 4 RoR Ue Be od . g mn a as : C ey v L of ce moo : a a . ha kd "i a e vied . 4 By in a "4 it if e ct fi fa 'si 1 i oy ae a : a © i 4 . " q : f 6 Sg be o a a oo «a £3 ff © am B Lt a Ky 2 og "ey > 5 oY ce 7 " « 3 s Mt er ee ee ee ee a ae: . a 4 i ts o a Va my - a : be te Li 4 i3 4 in ' a es ee ge j ved Gg ™ fy rf a % "gt fa mm wed i cp it "4 ut ; 'a ea ed ey o Ae aE et ¢ ie , "4 bd pd ey ad ' ees et x rd wind we {hs ' ; is ' fe at. aan sed sia 3 P 13 4 4 red ee ee ee ee es 4 a @ + £4 i fe a a i 3 : is 4a pond th i - ih. eb aa i: cS ae w rt is sped ond td oe fi 4 i aa dt id fa : By it ar ty oo vt gy a ae ne . ag io og a » 8 & 'i go ooF " Lomo eB ' Me : me By od : ogy 4d Vs ae ht a ee ey i oy : a Ue id # Ks ies i. : a x : it ei red Sof : # , "3 a) esd i is 4 cs et im F wt a oy es th G = tt a ved ad ig Ba wes ci ae 4 ie 7 Cy LISLE WAIHI ir sete ame aocusedd now.l.
Hear ST AS ed Sh de need oh sods Ey aad ' ld ind | di a ay ; OE ge es, ro 5 5 '4 oe 4 ibd wy a Ete ih * a 43 nt Gi CO © Q end os ee ee ee | H "ef u a 4 oo oR ee >» » & © es ee, eee ee o fe u 2 n i a ao By a" ra =) a a led ee e sl eo oom GO oH my 'ed Ei a © GD Ro @ os og a 0 7 a ou. 4 "4 706 6@ o al A? G ae) mart w ied 4a ai Pa ue wv wi ie Ot ee i _ oh it " a 4 ef tw i ee! wg 7 by, "a bef ct 3 Oo mo a an ie a io is " a rl ur mo bbe OH @ oR qa vi 6 Qf w Q st ri Sop wd oe) "ey Ea fi "4 bet "eS hd ir sad eS rr re: ie oe o 2 wf cl Mo oop oo oo Be @ og » ho ti ip a ha ed ed a ae er ae ES on m hq kot ond ae nu as " he * ha ey oft, a e 8 & a a rer > : i 2 a a. othe ae ie m te F vl . ne Se eo og . wo feo "
rnd tl re a 43 ee 2 " 13 ey a cp fe) ra 4d © ey ope we Bay ro ig He . ii x a eae so mB 4 ri re cs . oe. Sho : a ty ae ' S uy 4 5 er iG aba i ify " ae © S| * x Hal 4 Gg ic a 7 i aa a a ay ed 4 ' o Smt 1 eed a ke "al ; <3 ; Ho Fe ig an ee ae w ee tt : ' ae ct io ry r Pte goof codes i % ni DS og Bog bo Sin oy eyed % iT $i Th a ip ip 4 ey " ~ ed . oe rd a © to" as b :
. Q] be wt i} ep fay ap fas di ~ ni a 1 at) va a e i ee ce al -- Lg be ii ae fi aE LA . ue be ed et ify = # Ch ey © "wt a vt ul ¢ a © z ay a HOIH ;
VAVIVNAYY dO LUNOD HOIH WIVIVNYV dO LENOD HOIH Wivivno sy do pings ued wrerwanie aA sun aeenane i, my TS i i a : saosn 5 S & BF 28 fo § 8 8 9 2 ¢ BB 8 BS 2 Bh fF BB 8g eh. a, te = a 4 4 " wm 4 end im at ¢ 8 a + | "tt @ oon ed 4a : as ~t ° te eb Ee «pd "i aad <i Pa Be yy a a a em OM i a G a B as * a ort me on e pe HD ra we 44 Hi as G a Ss 4d :. A pp, oo. i : od =) D fe : @ md tt et ag : eer: : ved 43 .S, te | a aa 4 th iz Soe, age "4 ra a a a, & a 'ha red Ks " Be ie me py ne i 2 oH a ° & ou =f niet my my Qo ce es m 8 y Nog om fF . && 1 6 oo Be aR in 8 4 oc g m H 9 eg iw " rd eo a i ib a ay H i"
Bee 8 3 3 8 g Pepa ge a ® fog 8 8 p Soe 'os E re . = . po & ci « ee 5 re a = eS . yy fon 4 it nO mR ee me v4 a. ee r es cf hd "ef as ee, i) zh 4a F
7. ze SMe Ho. Bom OR p 4 &@ pod oy Ls. : gy «6 : _ G gi be e '4 So % 4 ns eos ope Et & 2: Y ae & 8 4 od oy ies) o oe ge a 2 a a pod ifs ra = re it fp ogres : ru o Ud ce ci t a - fy ' et eI 4a be ny o a "nt wa al : _ & » youl ha 4 AS Ny: ° a ad 3d i ae id i a7 ab x md ii id ay Beg oo OS . a a b3 re > ah wd cE a and pan - be {xh . ey ue gt itt Py . I re f i ped ox 4a 2 ied vk ES a : a i r © "f . E3 io ah nf : m , 4d rf ' ° res fq ba ai uw en fey o ji or: a iy a i ve} ae $3 ne x a Hy he ay, a oe ; . Te as md 4 tt a eo 8 ~e gi # es. ee ee: a og = wd ef op] - Ae ia bd 2 af a a 1 ig : 4a ' ay : eB Loe a a ' yoo 4 Og a »§ 8 oc o F mo Geet gM rn ae o ooo 8 a Rg dd Bo os te 0 a fy i ced a ie Led a bb Aut a "
ai . x ; a 4 ms i ro * ty! = 4+ et _ iy a ti ng mB 5 Booed a _ * Fel eg : oe Ray at i oF p ape " Et a} Ae a 42 aed e "4: a Cy Ad i ay bea e Ue a * vee Yel go a y Ms e a M4 a 4 be i a Re a i) ad <p iu ms : ° hed ra ri io) if} {3 a i a te a ia uy a wa ey oy oe] 4 od ra pod o ile ie {3 a oo . i - o bd ae 7" ; do ot i' a - ae Ld i : ig) me £y ad be a 7 HI oa 3 | : a > 2 4a Et a a ped ed oe ci ve Ae 8 ria ke a ae ry : ce aS Li i a nd os he an . = Q 4 i ci ° 8 a phe yy HOIH WIVLIVNY WA 4O LYNOD HOIH WIVIVNEY dO LHNOD HOIK Wide AD An Ena an Wwowinwannen An ;
vy ay tt ct thd i OG bea if ra TS i o 3 4 ay © c ae aa DF a if 45 a c. it A) a ie, A -rd bai at ao. b ® 4d oy So Pog 4 : ot OB
- ka ' oO Mio o re de = . & oH moO ie Ei i py BN 4 Ge & o 8 iy A a ij 4a "3 ' 2 a a i ad Si
- i eh ca , ;
4 a "rd i vi Bd i | oh =f m3 aa. * if a a m a a "ed ip Lt mn 4 ° " 'es i "ed Ch 4 - tt if 'i o 3 ew mam Fog Go & en j 4 0 i a : w a hd '4 ; o fa faa aed a Ni oped 4 ta ot ne i a 6 9 t mE "4 ae cn . a wp a et es 4 44 hy oe, "di a 4 a - » A BO gs rs gq a ® = e 4 ha ie ved i " i ad aa ui x Ym ag ad "Fy a * ag 4 . "4 -s 4 i i . ' ' : id on : a + . my ee ni ou - a cf : By ' i Sf att al ef , _ , er | oh at duit k4 oe is eo et aged Se ; 5, . wy ad t) + Pa o a Chop a = 2 8 - Boe 8 e --§ 0 » HH goo 3 8, ary me oye AS md Bef " ro OG a @ ¢ hd eae a a : a a "rf s ® 4 OY & a od & at . hud sae carey + "st a bel je Se . a 4 4a a is Ly 2 Bag et eo, oR he eed i] . 3 > a shed Le Ng Pa rd " iE op eb Me be a be te ey ct io c aa aa i Og Hog hug ; Sy oR Ok ns er is, si ry oa ie da . ; : - 7 whe iv . And at hed . a . a Bed ri Mee a La a , Saya " reed " 3 ea) ' td sh a ; wy ce "ey om] my whet : a a rd a 4 La a oH. at a et ff BS. a ta 4d ef P q wf 1 ay a fi) ah 2 ify ao Sa hd a = a ks ey a B as nm oe aa ba HSIH WIVIVNYW JO LINOD HOIH WIVLWNYVA JO LINOD HOIH WIVIWAE AO DINAT WAI Wien GA EAA inde Cann be cee TOT ETS PAGE MEME ST RARIEMARA FIG UUUKE UF KAKNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH i¢ Caalatace ec came on two wheeler and purchased cigarettes arid were amioka ney perletltes when he wes handing over Rye.8,000/~.
ee ga, RT pe a ret oe meter oy og Soe eet Praer nem : el b = To AE. Bo 2 Towa ree he wae Py BUD? 2 BS ef him amd the said two persons 'had geen hin, handing over Ba,8,000/= "ke PW2.d and 3. On receiyire the anOUnt PWe.d. and 5 went on the ececter. The parsons who were smoking in the 'Liowed PWe.< and § on their motor 2 cpele. He hes furbhes submitted that he _-- _ 2 em de ily wale te me ; CAMneh.iGentify. whe hed come to purchagze Sigerettes in-his. ahop and those twe persons neo Beer hemaing over the ameunt to PWse.4 SY 8 arc accused no.2 who was hefore the . ene of these two persone who had come fo his ¢heop., At this etege, the ete Baek BOE tee beee be ae | LB considered as hostile with regard and 2 purchasing cigarettes Ereom that shop and on seeing them handing over "oh gmoumk fo PWe.4 and 5. However, nothing RAS been elicited from tha eoross-sxaemination cf Chie witness by the Assistant Public © TE erin see Seen SENSE NIMEMERE MAT DARINEATARA TIROTE OUUKT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH 15 Prosecutor to support the case of | the PECBeCUCLOnN amd therefore the evidence or. Pale L@ met helpful te the prosecution to prove cnet accused mnos.1 and 2. obgerving Pw,8.
g over the amount to PWe.d amd &§. Ba g=_ ced Macnuker 12 aleo a trader at Karki. ~ Hs has ceposen in hie emamination in chief that on 2.3.36 @& ghout 8.090 p.m. Pes.4-6 5 came on ninetic honda to cellect the amount from him Gat riervied over Bel 9,000/-- to Pwe.4 and amc [end the amount see kept in a leather bag am obhev. want towarde Honavar. Later he _ L@aryr that nhe =mount was Looted YY Same "persons. Rt this stage, this witness FW.9 was asG6 Treated as hostile es he did not support tha cage of the prosecution and nothing has "been elicited in this crogss-examination ts Suppert the case of the prasecution that the 2CCUSeG wee glec present in the shop when he hendect oatTar the amount and deniad the Siggsetion that two unknown Customers TT TTT cee sew CEN EME OE RAR NO GWU UP RAKNAIAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH ifs Widence of PW.9 is ales net te ih i rd be} _ bk rt o ref ee 1g ee ry ae Le ity ry mo ep fo ms i fat i ' roving thar.
PAS.¢ and F whe collectad emount from ais Shep. PW.l0-Hari is a treder at Haldipur and he Nes cepocmed in, ig suemination in chief creat of 1.9.89 4f suout 8.30 p.m. when he Was me, -- a oc a, re -- 4 :
2 TRS En, WE. BI 2 came on Eimetic Ho handed oven Ba.d,0od/< to PWe.4 and S are to. WRB DLesent in the shop when he eves LHe amount ancl Later he Learnt B that the amount collected by PWe.4 and 5 were 4 aoe a ae a : 1 ' L Gy Teh Deracns. © 18 Cigar from the ayidence aces gcd m Looting of the amount from the possession of PW.5 as he does not epeak anything about tng ~Drezence of the accused when he handed ower the amount te PWs.4 and &. PW.LL-
Ganepeti 18 a trader at Karki. He has deposed La @Meutinationm in chief that PWse.4 and 5 bs oy Bf ort om Oy Og om oo mM TH wu «a cd < es mo omg ag nS as | o iG a G =r a iw rs 38 Moo i} 44 iS xs 44 43 a B du » ap BR 3g a rs 4 ty go oo ey ue as vet f a 4 a uy iS " a gO od. ab » -£ a fy ;
i . al a : wet ; a ar i ra | ie i i a a . ly oe Oe & 8 & 6 fa a Hog MH 2 oe y. &B ba a A 7 rn ; Sg re en co 8 a 8 GC GS & ° 7 : " ~ef ' ; co rae Sn ee Ae zs) res:
ch a 4 i AR gh a) a 4a * . "
et 4 @ ood a qi we f Gf op 2 a es a o @ + ™ mt ne as a "tt 5 ed fi ca ip i " "Eby me bry fl er a 4d 43 a '4 es a S ej bes Fh ra] ed 'pa hg ia 4b sei a4 Ad Fe : ded Aa Pa o A i a4 'e oh oy & 2 5 vs Sr ap Ba gs # fe © oO gt wand ¥ ; cans et ur} i) ; a 34 S wot woo Boom oe 8 ae Po M4 bed iG a "= ops HR. ifs wes * <
3 es is ct. . i cb ua i on Gy et he . o Em egg aya ; ra * eg So od a i # e aa a a rat ae) 4 = | a .! i se ne oe oo oe BF oa 4 he, a oot a coe 7 a 4 a i ey a . a a is 7 ee 24 i : a Bo Som ow a «4 7a a uM yo. os in Lae a rs] , aia) ip " ¥g Mead Py va ran pind el "ed a es hal eh we ae f fm ie] cd wm be Le ® ' Ss me ; * oe = if ce Bee ee: re BOO we ga a Ue rr es ee 4 : » A : o a h - a if 5 pag B = re i u an pha we Bs ¥ es an ao a es ee Ss a rs ' ; p 6 © Go ca fi Apr fs a. no a w a 4 4 x = oy '| en) tT 43 a ~ FOF wD " ks 44 ds as Si @ i ad ti o "rs be & in Be be aa ie ed ga 4 aw Lt ; ae ap *y fa ved a Aa 3 ry my ro a xl = i} . G Hi i Ep Ag aa ny 2 ogi we rf 8 he #4 Ae 4a a a oa a HSIH VWAVLIVNYY 30 LINOD HSIH WIVLIVNYYY dO LINO HOI wiwiwapn an nan en Unni TA A a eee cme ee o bo og a3 mo 4d ted gp * ' aon § £ Sf &g 3 ¢ # H fF! th a Cake i ed Gi o "4 M "ef Mi m7 3 t. Ber geet ; e 7 4 ; , dl ; poe He oy a " op ct 8 q oo og xg 4 8 i = a fe ne a> i cfd G om eG 5 oa he By mm i ; al ; : lye om iY fae 7 Fes oe eh '4 bd 4 o weed . ao of 7 A oe 8 BS aa 4 si a ed ug ae oT ee ne & Ae a a = a et wo eo ne a 7. 5 tri f£ & A a Bt Hi it - oo. a 5 4 Bow . b a . ei kd ns fog > . * a gs v hed ot + 4 ie due He] ot ct ry int o hel ie a 7 sng co « in e Mi . - hd Woo. ie . ns vet ah Lt af ral ah a 3 4 ot ni me oy i 4a ct Q :
ag Sad ; te ee, fl i ra] @ et ° . re nj i aye & bg it . G iy Qo + . $A gow oe U = g§ g¢ 8 a? 4 a" Bead * o mt a os a oa es EL ay i i Ay 0 mR eR yy UR a ar} ; Coby ' a ee ou Sob yw rs : co ff hy a o a " < i " 2 in Oo tt oe aS Be ; i 4H G 4 g 8 4 "8 B 2 8) oe S Fou 8 nd Hoof 2 8 & u a a + m - (3 _ rood od 4d a 1 Wi } & a i iP oop foo e om 3 oS ous ed m0 i re @ oon a te . eo ie] aah on mH a ua -] i Pet tb an abo i ; x ai CS a shed fs ; ur b 4 a 44 of, o a a es & vt nn i op us 3 ty 7 hl el c ns 2 ke y th re " vt ed aye yh :
on fa a i " a i 4 be $9 "et or oon a u Be EE 4.4 wt : &. "4 : , ie st im gi 5 ae 4a i _ gy HOH WIVIVNAY 40 JUNOD HOH WIVLVNAYY JO INNO Hom ww}wrwannn on | PMA DIA Unnuia ene ea seen ie. .
HOIH a ify ae oe Ss mM @ w® @ a4 " a "4 3 wy i a | ei co A moe a en cn a 7 J got ow. Bw 8 a ee sand Ae oe EP. Sp, 7 er 7 et ed 3 bs kp co nn: | ; a ; -- abl 4 Bo Fai] vf # oa oad 4 eos Bd "4 Good is ba Mt To rc | oC Pa gg i o mn ne ren ee Me a en | ee 2) "ed ba a ort ey : ad Fy y o : cy a veh pa in ou EI i ii i a a ® . a | " Hi Ob = ed vn :# B vy 44 Gy a Re Sof 43 "ed a ke BO ge G8 Ve oo # at re gt ip ve OR ne a tp . 'e iD 8 RR a:
hy ved . oy he ¥ sal Oo UM on oo ue ad a on a de a OP ape tog wd ti "3! ze ms ' ae] ri i " ity a apd 7 vi m4 4d ca) be a "et a a 4 " a oped 5 am ci "ef a = A ;
ht ae ord vb be i" = gly x Seg et q 2 4 id a 4 mt we : 2 a a ae a Pu & mn is Bey "4 a a fret ahd ae at . a we cea va] o eegt mS ny ri } '| we te ® a 8 . x ft a ea s hd iy ° be hi ed a . a iP ai zy! ed 4 om om aa id ch de i A me aye WIVLIVNAUY dO 1LanoS HSIH WAViYNYD 4OUMNOY BA Weir GA ames cre Cine ee wee "ee ia M4 ip kd Le bh Las c ® 4a Hood .
ed ns a) ade * 'i 44 cg ne i bo th o "fa fa! ti : ey a Q y c G a al ny wend us t ig . . ; . . . ' . 4 Ce why {E ci fd as: 4 a ae "4 = 4 es ad Cy i: ni a . © | ss oa 4 4 " a ah o a 42 va 43 By a he wy ig ad By r g ip i "a ged ae 3 od ao ui we : "3 E} ts ai ood od Wd a "a us mG. iB : Wa Bee dH i ood a Hed wed ai bs a "eS 5] pa a "D Te OL rs 4 z+ Q 43 a v4 4 ce . 34 plo BY iy on Fi ® a OG Wi oa a "a i] x Ia a : gt mas i a is ud fi 44 v eR, gt - O mp fp Bog goB 8 oe g & 4 8 goo. gt fel - ' 4 2 ae doen, : ' & SG 4 = 4 8 Boy bh Ff oa co oa 8 a eae) ey ee . Hi ; e é : iS oy ee ee eee ee 4 . 8 " a '. fe ; ro OR a er oy hep ord as "4 ao 9 f 98 GoM ggg oR TOR 4 go 2 g "
ea . i) ey i Ge ey Le a ae in oe re ad = mre Pe es ye re : a b rr in a rr 7 ree ee mo 8 a «GB ' ae . . ka . "ay rm aa a mB eg oa eed ib $ whos "4 es 2 ek Rad | 4 Hag ood Og BB a a og nO oe F ry ee H wpe a: " oe i: 2 a ee a moe oe a a 2 Ff 6 6 ob» «a & a ef et ee ne Ri # ifs fe) faye 7 x 5 &8 a <4 es "4 = t oy et o i. ve 7 x , rs 8 uy dee 7 OE a:
o qo at. oo Aa err ie - * 4 or € ao « ee 4 4 Ld "s apf ach . an .
a nr ne roe ts oe oe ai (ay a iis : an ye a se i od aha oth equeh 6 oe , wd ee Qi red rs wi "2 oR. a a ce dy age hes jut ne "4-4 wy it Le - it " ved Parad a ue a 6 oon Oy toy 4 4 j "
fd wee es wd 43 bd hs bs uM th es es a } HOH WIVLYNUYy dO 1a#no> HOH WIWLUNAYY 10 INNO edi WiiWiwannn oA Pn nn cia CAs nnd san ciiatin a ee ee ee ow tO ot * Len te a, 4 me thy yt we oo a abo © ot rhs uo of co . 4 OB fg og Mo tb a @ oo ss D cook m gay cg . : - _ : Le ee] be, a - Woop og Bont oe ee be MA re sh . th a re 4a iz rt cy e 5 4 0 Do EQ as) v4 a a iS G aa a Wi (} on a so oo <p mal rn cb i ce a Be 7c oa mn a Hy Shoo. Hi fel ity 4 et a rd a 'bd GF me Al " "rf wey a a i ot Af 4 ', » a rr th te a 3 | 4 O i} p san rs Fy a an iy a ct id Fed g af th "4 : i a ae ao a io ba 4 Ae a a Bg © aoa 8 you go " Gg ow 8 BS 4 (2 oe LO 1G . "ED. at i . - ; is = of he wv goth ik " ° e J u a 3 , re Hi o plied 7 a 8 i ae - iy 43 bag of. bd on ra os A 4 L2 Z - i o a Ad ad : ke Beg eo ry mi 4 eh } oe) aye 4 jd a oer (a x4 ee] ie er e gc re) iio «6 ane . . . : foe ae ia rl a , posed if x ow fs : . - ee re apd > 4 he : :
cy ~t es Pro: . con ig ott . : 4 ad i "i g 8 7 fos oR Bg ap ra rd ot A og fal es cel ' - aw rt ey a ded ad at 3 4 vo rr Sepa ER. a, it 4 x ad ue e ; i 43 a ti th : i oF x di KG i os Meo hE LY abe hs Na Aa rr . "ol ty cm 2 wt a ne - wo g ~, url ts "3 agit of me pe ah id iw i 4d od i ip 4 ; 43 ved a ee wn =) it 9 ny Bh " in 7 a ii ip ae a th Ti iy ri ra) fat oy nol ca af 1 i oh Dae : Oy hy mj ee * ra Ay 'mn i a) ; ae po td AS res ort mm ct ao lO ep oy "4 ly rs "ef So x @, SE ch Ee a! a i a itt ci eh ai ved it ry m '4 a vey ia 2 wee we oa : 4 ni he 'f ise ae a Oy eo _ mB Ms un i iis " od a ty on had a h : a F re ' ve a rf ¢ a fi "al ony a - ry ~ enh by, ing
- » oS a a ai Ls rd uy 'ha 4 "4 a aU oh diva ' HOIH WIVIVNAY) 4O L¥NOD HSIH VHWLYNYYY 40 INNO B}e Weawiwanr GA NAA Adis Grune LA sanelied in elt oo aw eos et ah a u i ay a ° : ba "
rf - po. fia: a vd =| 5 | @ G nec og st wo vi 4a ory "8 ao Bo Re OR + 3s 6o0CUR OR hr Q ate OBB at : 4 a iG on i ay T iu "EY ae mh at fee, 44 Q eg = 4a a ey in ao. . 8 my OA Fi f% i" : iG Pa i 3 bel e go 5 ey ha ond ie a tn ii aa a ti Cy on m '4 py PF Gi - fa wont mT He BS i eh ges "pg ' oa be 'he © et tht bh ke eI tT a BO ag ne o poe x «(OM rh 2 ts 0 a wed . RO ced @ med ; os MA ra ad ay S a ed, . oh sd AG 4 4 £3 vet Qo ed & n 3 : ae , S os "a J a qa "4 i « a y g 2 @ gq 8 a es a e 8 8 a gi o Ob - ed at ved a ot oe 4 : Et a: ' ie © " : os 8 a its ey By md : ya " : re wt ay i ed 4d ts ' : o ee ' eyed = CW a ' G , a. aa i ' 7. , a te * # i 4 os ™ ey ba fg _ oe red " of oe a gf eB ci uy i 3g 5 re 4 @ oo @ A rf ee ee a6 F ao 8 i cg 14 a a ee "4 a 3 Es as bu zi iy a ne "ci pes ne "et Qh a ei 2 gy eed cyt hl a a ay Wi bat ai G ob om ft os og 8 a on: » os a ® on oo 2 HOR Sn nt See Boo Me B e BH qo Go a of 8 oo Bm a ne: " mom ; 4 iy je wo Boa a mn Po gt ved ay q fa i a a Gi pled , tt it of AJ ie Ps a 4 a go PO & wo Boo a , hp 4 43 aa ia wo & : a : - te os qi = «OOO & bm oH geo : 7 4 Boog oF Ou By vd TSE vol a ~ 7 - 4a my : : i 5 vn ; ts oe * oy oe a et . : ae ope 1s Sap a my Thee mn i on "a ' ms i . oe iH go US rr ae ? » oo pa " es a jo i end . x dal ad ah oy ¥] Be fod rho - i . : & aa hq re ® ui a rt He wt a oF at } ba i' dy eal a a "4 ; a Tota ; a Eo eed Fy (hy i "Lal fa ' e Gon is i * LA fp why by " | Ant a a i iB va spd m3 sr r 4 ib a py * 2c 68 4 g {xd ot 'HOI WIVly NYWN dO 1a NOD H SIH WIVIYNAYN AO LINO? HO r. : Om WvhWitfaAbDWy 4a IVAN Lae wae.
RE, ef eh at o oh ao oof @ Se eit ey BOS wk y oe og § S&S Ge a. a er i ip be a oO o mo "3 Ge eb a ye MH gt " i oe rn ae Bey my ch i £3 nt y ro eee a . g. a] ic a od b a 0 ay <i et WG ] BD Gd o 4 Sire : id = sel fe cera? HE. . 'tt bi whe 'a = os pas re nan gi C a a G ay is a , vd og a § BO i rt ou o 8 & F Ay oy es ae | a4 or} bef tt oped a i apd 3 Sang ay # 4 Ac ae Ct D ; a . ai tat ped a ha hd By - t a £4 i rr a o> Ad oo . y © ' $e JS ey , «wy i%8® & boost 0 fy "rf ee ee Pes Seg ie E. te aa 'et a pa 44 a vty ol a a j i A) Bie ge bay eH Cc re o in mh Oo a a 4d : bo i. 6 & . ru og ii oh i eg rs ty u ad 44 mom of oe me e £ © & ce a & " a ; eh : kd : - - :
3 mr , ss ce : 4 rf ie ri 6 m «=~ a ti A er ts Dp k " 5 eh rey ° . 4a ef : _ he Be o Foo ee ee . 4 m @ ow 4 # & ?
; , rl é a | "4 yi ha ahead aa] " a E--t S ons o ui a 81 a . ° be 5 by oo ha : a > ooo - @ fa oo wae 0 a goo OD Sg Mood 7 a & ve Ae" 8° & S af cn a oS v4 rm e ad wed ar ar i = 4 vf ig OM OU we Od + "a » a) ® bs 5 g3 hed on i aon | i ong ua e qo mk eo of. a a. aq HH & ei foo & OG ss ge mt 2) en th 4 co aa aoe ee ra Le Pa Fie wang 3 ja #1 * s 4 a ~ed hen pot ip ed red 4 y gS Poy 8 og EOE dk goa & r sh go Ae un oy Mos 6 f ££ a nw 8 mtb 4 . Ws hy nw ch noe Poot tH & it r ch A * a3 aye oe Bd iv! god 3 : fe Ad a t or a as td et 3 vi a Ph ae Cs nt . oy iP ha Hi a 8 fe Py l ; a es 4B fe * a 'D « : a : a ae e oo -
; ej se 7 a ay vet ao ri Ad A & Se th te pe i a ' i ty vis a ee Hb ow . a ee 38 ry be = ord et ag 4 vy iy re By by! : i F H hd ae ae : A wd a ad . ep, ve ' v4 £3 ; s en ee fe ; ca a we ah ad 2 WO é aa y _ Se . : j et, - be] Oy i a} ie ta Mad rar ed 2 iy ¥ a ae 7 ; is ee | i? a i © es Ao _ ;
" " "a we AG G x ° ren) fe 'a a * for i (HOI WIVLIVNYYH JO LYNOD HOIH WHAVIVNAYY 40 LINO HOM wirereapy an . MAAN ans wanwiwannnd LA nna Om ae , a bes ak . . .
"4 ap a : ia ay 4a re ae vad a an fe] t . ded 1° Be, ie) ey as a : Ai at a it a a wee Ce BP eet # & n G 3 Es a3 an ou , m A rs) 5 a Ps" if a : Voor - ' ; iG i 4 be . oh ui oe Oe, am o o 6 a goon a O& 2 so a " 2 aos . ew : Lg Ps ye te 4 cy ne ay 25 " a) a . a a fac ia a vied Sy " as sed mo oO woe aOR Us _ © 8 & . a vend iG al es 1] a rt 4 vf = Ua - a Li ae STi a ui mo oe4 a 4 co i 4 OO go too oo cou SG BS Pal a ce 3, a £4 ra. ib % a is 4 hi '1 wv . - =a ah eG Bs a i cc _ 44 i 4d aM a ea " "«s : b- fe 4 A B4 o a rf of ae hea ae : Me a da ra s e a a $ a rt rd : we A pone 0 mn fs oy a ys t ci go , i. hi ue . Ss 8 aw ae ee wv e BB "4 Soom UU a a a fC en. a i : Ee .
Go. § boa | 8 Beg eo 8 tt f 3 ma Soe" i a ee mot ao Gg F a i = i re bh om ' i. ' Boy 6 ORs eo SG 8 ct rr a my OMe ; Db ys mn oh i re he ot ah eo Ma S on ' 2 a ts i fond e Ad is ; "4 i & a % 7 ae wv "4 aa my By ci a Pl (3 ma ra:
"ed ts be ve Aq "5 he ng a e & ks Q Py eed 4a e fg * #8 3 ; & o = x Le . 3 AC Pt hs a, Hoy) Mo & HM pe Le i fal 'a i ak o es oo et, re ay va uh . AS = "4
- a on, * .
a 's _-- re af . - a i 4a a o Le a ype at 7 a pt ped Fe ad a \ a ip od sy el 4 if . i 4 : Pet ae he a ded ty 4 vi ua oe a m a ui . ve a a me G a i to ~t ed "ak i re . i ha i te os n ci 2 1G FHOIH WAVLV Navy JO 14n OD HOIH VAY EYNAYN AO INNO HO wie f RINWY JS Pm. EF Ai tiwiwarual 1A an wr ee RE WE FRED WER ESREDR OF EERE FE SME WE WARINAEARA MRP CVU Wer RAAKNAIAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH i 25 aemage to the ececoter and he eecaped LRIUnLesé.
Lo, 4 fqid cue in fea ob Soe a TiS. ¥PEEE Ca Tay Tie Molar -OYOo.e. Bec.
geen the accuged in the street Light. He has STILT are, Mids Ls at OnGS wRre pelzed from the noone 'of dEfnee. O-8L9.96 they were called rar arci Teheildar was also present at pelle Station and 12 parsons wers made
-- bye ween and +i . - ered #- ky hot kb a 7 Lh Cae Were as £60 oo + identify othe accuged and they identified .Leether beg, which contained cash. MO.3- EnLfe with which the accused threatened his father. 0.4 is the terkin worn by accuged ue mo.l and MO.5 is the terkin worn by accused mo.d. MO.6 ts the Aelmet which accused nol Kes TENSE NEEM OMS FU A? OE RAR, PHO WUE UP NAKINALARA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH ¢ i 4 on 4 4 WAS WGSring While riding tne moter cycle. He ' = tee ded Oe pad te 7 z S@E S.So identified the motor cycle selzea. by thea welice and the cash MO.7. He has deposed. im ble further e@xemination in chief that the.
Leatien number of the vehicle driven by.
regis et am " Se ag . : ; " oe OF Lhe accused Ls KAeZ5 ae per MO.G..° It ie elicited in his cross-emermination that he tell the amount of gitogeries supplied me ious tiadere on 1.9.86 and the account chem. The moter. cycle was driven in high the hag containing cash held by his father, gillion rider of the vehicle was a. They followed the ropberyvy and when thev . STONE. The incident was published in the TWEE BOY. On the next day of the incident, LE wee published in thse newspaper that the bergoms who have committed robbery had bean nrestecd by the police. He had met gone te \ah * t & ag" : i , bal @ 4 af vay Met iL. - , 4 ® ® a Oe 8 o ¢ 2 £ Uy wv So Bo ce 4 i is) . as 4 ib ' # 2g # eg 2% eee EB S282 8 8 se ae a é re ts oom i f 8 foo . 3 » ® © 2 8 : 9 4 4 rs ee ee ee: 2 ret Ps fog Fe po 43 a coef ae. ' cal uy a pont nt wi G 4 es i a oP Os é at he rd 4 O} ci a @ 4 4 - Bf Bo ae S fh ~ pp os ® woos o Ff 2 & gq " £ 8 og &. @ 4 cd oo. a # a @ & ed ot , sed £3 : : ct HOOF it iH SS ; > Medd ae et "t a * o : "S "3 a) 7 O o ty ; ~ ord 7 ye ci "4 ee 4 a " th my Pu a Le ri a aad mo a " _ ot ah He 4a - Ei et o a eh rf Is. bo St iP hd ¥ cy a ci bd , J a ree ey i orf "4 S es ep iy if 5 ce ' -- k4 . A § na am i a | it id ih a be ca tf - . w 7 3 a 4 wh} 44 wi rs ed afb i Gog 8 oR a Be © 2 ow Ho oS @ & : ii: 3 ho ay bs 3 44 fo i ef bn at OF we os OH : i oF = wo th @oop ng & of & 8 8 7 OM ae | rm rd a *¢ a " AM : 3 "3 ) ae OAL : ; b a a be o bed me I Gq rf . ing :
e @e@ BE Sos wR. a " SE ag "OU ye ty cs os ow ; 4 ey eG ced . ° a ba td ti Ae oe doe Ye 3 ° pn oH 4 i " B wi . wing o bmn, v1 7 4 be Ae : % ct ve ai wi 5 't : ms Ea ri M ct fe om "| ved ca "4 os a e a o nF be ; OH o m be wt iy Go " ao Os a f
5 4 | " :
bo Baa bh ay : cr a m be x M4 + bd te 1s fe x G el Bey HSIN WOIVIVNAY dO LENOD HO! H WIVLYNYW 4O LYNOD HOIH YWiyNWY In Innes wevin wut: a WAN BA EA" UO Vianna Cas MONTINI PUNT SME UT RARIVALARA PHM COUKI OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH.
tb ca PeS.2, 2, G apd 7 and in the procesding sce pane ee sort ne ol 2 ce ee -- "4 ofa fo ee ur prepares Sy him as per Ex.F.i2 it is elicited ih the crege-examination that he had not given = ais request to the police "ho. produce. the ae that of the aacugec. He has further es ee pe . _ aepored thal' he does tot. Bnew as ¢co whether Jb. ap.to whether all the persone were wearing Simllan ¢regs. The parsons were ko. wear iJerkines, He denied t awe cnat he hes nek at all cormducted & 4 ep _ bee Py fF sGentiflcation parade.
Loemce of PWe.d, 5 and LS that the evidence of EWe.d and 5 would only prove that while Pe.$ waR riding scooter and PW.5 was the pullin rider holding 4 leather bag containing TRE cf gccused persone have committed TT MME ME ORAM THE MAUR VT RARNAIARA FHOM CUOUKI OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA HIGH ( 30 rebbery ivy threatening them. However, the LGgntiiication of the persons who have QommitTied robbery has mot been proved beyond.5
Rete be da yo ay sage, % 3 ey awe, oe ma LeSRCUIEDLS USP &S anh is elear from the avicearnce oF PW.4 that he wes called toe the.
after ¢ deys of the inelident amc Taheildac wap alec .present.and test identificstion parade. was -cemductsd and according to him 12 pereone were made to stand Atk & Tow and ali. the persone were wearing PR.o, .Kainmselitoahd PW.4 were ealled to the and Tahsildar was alec present _ Sb) Barsens were meade toa stand in 4a row ae ama. he identified the accused. The persens whe were meade 'fo stand were wearing pant and _ @hirc. Purther, the evidences of BW.19 would PW.19 himecli ifs moet aware of the Lon of the accused amd persons whe were Nace ta stand. According te Pw.d, both cougar wera made toa steari in 4a rew and o ee, 44 bs "a a ie ra o 7 AE a et gin hd us . a, Aa: ; wi 18 cn = a ifs ee ee ed D Ta a i ee Pow ono" : £ ob se Pee. ae 'D : an: t a bet a > os thd a ay - at a 2: ° xy: ' & * pd i yr 3 a a a a he é is s ng po go ot. er a rd be & "4 i H eo id ies = Bs Bop Fg gO ao" @ fo oa 8 om @ ey a oo US A » & Og. og OF a on &@ #7" on a doo. "= 2» eo ti rr ay : . ; hd Le a * tj i 4 ei & "et U et ee 8 me mn | yy Me i. fa mw 7 a e , &t re G om it 4 a rel ia aa hed bt 4 Mer & a ne ud >» @ 8 gq 8 8 mm OR m a 4 Se ie hy 4 oe Ny & Ey 9 oh i a 4 ey, a ip . mG FR afooek . Oo a 4 = 6 8 i 4 don et 4 © » 2. RO do 2 & ne a 5 § * al ky pe 7 a m4 a _ Paes a Po re : ae et fae, " ith a ia oad dt S a 7 i a Hy a i ie du 5 ey 7 oO & ae e rv i tn tw 50 os ear ot nr rt 4 no i how Gd avy Faf x ie rr mn a iy : fy er hi be : Ee ; i al it fd et 5 a : be can : * ae we a re at wed i Pe Le bd Pa et a . ty ad | tl ne a a 8 og 8 re er ee ao Bd ; € 8 Gu * Mo WwW OOD @ ee a re) i Uy ny a Se a Md vet a He ool td " ext Tey i peg i) de & a) &, xi bo es 4 o ad wdc! a 7 hi 4d +4 . i a a : A ae i Cy Oh m 2 Lb x a , v 3 ae : i. oa ib Je . "4 wt o ;
we mY " 4 va cr fr 3 . 4 kg he 4 » oo a ct "f - i ol op UTE Soop ot oe GG ag ee os hs a ey A ted i a "es i = © o 8 i pa Fs om iB wd o> oy et Bu he cS a " ie wed, 4 o uy} Le ; ie f 7 S "% . rr i Led Te a2: oe is . ee . "rg mm eel 0 : b ed 5 Li : bt ch 5 ue ag a i _ 8 i wi ' fa et hd as a a . et iE oot B in : Te hey % a ay be et @ "a 4 ie i h 44 a ns an 4) oy ae a mo ed "eS i i te cl Fl Pw ie tj ts C id ci Li rio w hut oat s se 4 rd in| . cs th a ey "k 'i mv ab "7 a"
a 4 et Cs a 4 ts ft a ved ; a es, ei ; ae) ys Hel AG a ed ya ; ae Ban Ms i 5.5 a iG oe oral gs ih Oh Led iM : on ve a . ey he hy Wi as ; 4-4 at ct vl "et wy eed a Lb peda 7 4 = at ii ie ae a i cH a cE i i ake rt t3 mg ay ne a eed x eG 4
a) ed Py he a rol " ig a a iu Le oo a of 8 ni a © peo Mae ts i roo O SG : = ied bed 'HOIH WHVLVN 4VyH JO LYNOD HOH WIViy Nave JO LYNOD HOH UWIWAINYY 40 1 AOA YA wwiywai _--
WW A PAN Giada wr et ae, é > eo ue gh ue pe th a Aa Mm oe nh: a a oa mo a4 8 S 8 @ & @ ww & 2 ee faq 48 9 8 $38 4 8 & & 8 : or rn in | di hd a Bp ie <3
7) Be a | cs : rnd a 5 " zu : a et abecd a é | ce a *, "rs a, : end orf 4 BR ee eo ¥ 8 8 ee " eR & 8 Ba es Se eS a og g SP 4 Hog op od 8 OM 8 Oo ft ee 2 ; . Ad. : _ bt i S| a iv ow Tt bd RE 44 ged bp a va ooeed eps « : a a cy fe pa mie ® i a = Li iM "rt ee He in al ap 4G a mre a + a cS "T he or. . B on i or} ved "4 "4 fas af & i & Se ys Fy "ay 'r po a "4 red a we oe Oo Ay A a a of a a 1 oo we a cs ig ° a 44 -- iu ib .
"g is oe A) . nr: & be : a a4 ~ Fest kd ral : . a ~ i a ot @ a rf eB ae Ae en a ve vee mate a 4 Pi G C3 a 4 nn a, ee OP * " e oo 8 xy oe BH 8 @ og US Be GB a | S| ry G oh a by a ge bs a Be EDS at us He "4 ra % sy «4 aos _ ate Oo. ® Oo MW wed 4a ty id ee aP Rd . is) " . i ' Gi a we . : lt ed is u} oa hoo) Oy UU | wo og 5 i "
D a & a nl i He a ee a D fal oe Sad m OD ey A ' ey dc ba a rs tl ea o gf © 5 go Be oo. 43 fe a eo 6g OD rn | ; 4 Bo ~ D a UU a ® oy, oy tl he +4 et ky i <6 ae ic wha ~ pound ne ord « ie a fh a Ho ago Ae wt cs a . bey Bt bd ah F Oo gy ee {a & 4d Pet ot ww = "
\ i ey a wi n eo et Let Mod a3 in : bo ; a set 1 ds ts ot 5 a rd lb j Ae i et hers Re. 7 " ze ae ad as bs m 8 ae = a $2 7 4 a £ a ed Ae n ;
4 el ia ved ; - a on o Bt a AA i ory 5 'a HG ce uous Hoo OH gy a ; S a a a od held i t re M3 he Bs @ou 4 4 its 4d )HOIH WIVIVN ¥VA FO LINOD HOIH WIVLYNAYN JO LYNOD HOI Wiwiryho aa minnan uan wii cn "yp hyo oY ~ od SC Ha q m9 on ae rod rd &i EG go «ged a g a s 4d fs " "ee foe . La aed 44 beg "# t ® a! oO 2 = a owe ga a v h4 e by a oY 3S 4S oo ® ig hi re ah a : . ved : td i G is} Ki pd A om wo crs _ eS 4 a ed a ;
a od og om hy ~ 8 mom food | 5 ~ 8 qo. ze a mg ~ . e cf ae kd. a _ 4 ia it g a" a. ae ie : ee - r a in «| i © fd Hd es fs e ty oo ae uo * os ir et re 4 2 uw Us in sod ia Gd jai | Pe oe beg By bod tvd , *) Yt a ape 5 iy * ts a om Sty a i cl. f ery ie B rs » had oa e , "i 9 8 MF ow 4 Boo PO He Pa 4 2 i : aes ee os bs yy i 4 ey : : re ; < ht ihe a E "4 y 1 4 we ae ae te red ae, ih a " ai a a whe o . = = Ad ips a ug 44 ia Pi a 7 oo», sf oe & Bo Qe. a Gg oe & & 5 fog 8 j m ~ed Soy Cy Pe " : i os . 4 rd rd bd aa aa "
ns a a i ed fa « Hae uh b 4 ved ae w 7 fe oO an reo ne Tad By = itd M4 3 i th a cl i o 3 'a ws Hd iG ky ga Gy ts ty £4 re Ha ud ai we tp ius By By i '. fy ts fm) a rai oe fe as "i £4 bop }HOIH YAVIVNYEY AO LYNOD HOIN VIVIYNAYY 40 ENNOD HOW) wires an InAs ued Wowiwaniwu GA Gunn An Unnuiuennal CA mR An a