Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Akshay Rana vs Govt. Of Nctd on 16 April, 2019
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH: NEW DELHI
O.A. No.2799 of 2018
This the 16th day of April, 2019
Hon'ble Ms. Nita Chowdhury, Member (A)
Hon'ble Mr. S.N. Terdal, Member (J)
1. Akshay Rana
S/o Sh. Anoop Singh
R/o H. No. 179, Village - Mungeshpur, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
2. Pragya Manchanda
D/o Sh. Inderjeet Manchanda
R/o 2954, Sant Nagar, Rani Bagh, Delhi - 110034
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
3. Yazana Chuttani
D/o Sh. Pramod Kumar Chuttani
R/o A-155, Majlis Park, Adarsh Nagar,
1st Floor, Delhi - 110033
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
4. Geetika
D/o Sh. Rajesh Kalra
R/o 447, Mukherjee Nagar, Delhi - 110009
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
5. Shikha Bhatia
D/o Sh. Anil Bhatia
R/o B - 134, Pushpanjali Enclave,
Pitam Pura, Delhi - 110034
Aged about 24 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
2
6. Surbhi Jain
D/o Sh. Vipin Kumar Jain
R/o 3378-79, Arya Pura, Subzi Mandi,
Delhi - 110007
Aged about 23 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
7. Sheenu Sharma
D/o Sh. Mahesh Kumar
R/o H. No. 608/6, Near SBI, Mundka, Delhi - 110041
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
8. Sadhna
D/o Sh. Bijender Singh
R/o H. No. - 138, Tilangpur Kotla,
New Delhi - 110043
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
9. Anshu
D/o Sh. Paramjit Singh Rana
R/o H. No. 359 - A, Khasra No. 105,
VPO Khera Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
10. Mitanshi Dabas
D/o Sh. Vinod Dabas
R/o 122, Unity Apartment, Pocket - 23,
Sector - 24, New Delhi - 110085
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
11. Kunika
D/o Sh. Dinesh Kumar
R/o H. No. 44, Ganga Toli Road,
Pooth Khurd, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
12. Nidhi Dahiya
D/o Sh. Narender Dahiya
3
R/o Flat No - 66, Pocket - 6, Sector - 23,
Rohini, Delhi - 110085
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
13. Umang Khatri
D/o Sh. Dinesh Singh
R/o H. No. 162B, Chopal Ke Pass, Bankner,
North-West Delhi, Delhi - 110040
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
14. Ritu
D/o Sh. Suraj Bhan
R/o H. N. 338, Bankner, Narela, Delhi - 110040
Aged about 28 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
15. Parul
D/o Sh. Pardeep Kumar
R/o Plot No. 19, Khasra No. 130/8,
Gali No. 09, Block - A, Vijay Nagar,
Bawana, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
16. Aakshi
D/o Sh. Udaivir Singh
R/o Jhang Appartment, Sector - 13,
House No. 49 B, Rohini, New Delhi - 110085
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
17. Rajni
D/o Sh. Rakesh Solanki
R/o 565, Pooth Kalan, Delhi - 110086
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
18. Priyanka
D/o Sh. Rajesh Kumar
R/o H. No. 1231, Ramayan Gali,
Pooth Khurd, Delhi - 110039
4
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
19. Akshay Chhikara
S/o Sh. Rajesh Kumar
R/o H. No - 129, VPO Jaunti, Delhi - 110081
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
20. Komal Sharma
D/o Sh. Rajesh Vashishth
R/o H. No. 175, Ishwar Colony,
Bawana, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
21. Apoorva Dabas
D/o Sh. Satyapal Dabas
R/o H. No - 283, V.P.O Pooth Khurd,
Delhi - 110039
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
22. Himanshu Dabas
S/o Sh. Bijender Singh
R/o H. No - 283, V.P.O Pooth Khurd, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
23. Madhu
D/o Sh. Mahavir Singh
R/o H. No. - 915, Chabbu Pana,
V.P.O, Pooth Khurd, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
24. Kavita
D/o Sh. Pradeep
R/o H. No. 179, Village Mungeshpur, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
5
25. Atul Rana
S/o Sh. Arun Rana
R/o H. No. 162, Darwaja Pana,
Mungeshpur, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
26. Akanksha
D/o Sh. Vijay Pal
R/o D - 104, Raj Nagar - 2, Palam Colony
New Delhi - 110077
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
27. Deepa Mann
D/o Sh. Ashok Mann
R/o H. No. 368, VPO Pehladpur,
Bangar, Delhi - 110042
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
28. Manni
D/o Sh. Pushpender
R/o H. No. 904, Mozan Pana, Bawana, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
29. Ritika
D/o Sh. Vikas Kumar
R/o H - 19, H. No. 154, Sector - 7,
Rohini, Delhi - 110085
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
30. Anshu
D/o Sh. Ravinder Singh
R/o H. No. 258, Daryapur Kalan, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
31. Neha
D/o Sh. Anil Kumar Sehrawat
R/o H. No. A - 72, Gali No. 4, Vijay Nagar,
Bawana, Delhi - 110039
6
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
32. Shweta
D/o Sh. Hari Om
R/o H. No. 09, Auchandi Road,
Bawana, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
33. Jyotsna Nagpal
D/o Sh. D. V. Nagpal
R/o Pocket A1, 119-120, Sector - 4,
Rohini, Delhi - 110085
Aged about 23 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
34. Priyanka
D/o Sh. Prem Malik
R/o E - 113A, Yadav Nagar, Delhi - 110042
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
35. Shivam Mathur
S/o Sh. Krishan Kumar
R/o 84, F Floor, Pocket - II, Sector 24,
Rohini, Delhi - 110085
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
36. Pradeep
S/o Sh. Jagdish
R/o H. No. 1006/26, Dahiya Colony,
Main Kakroi Road, Sonepat, Haryana
(Ex-servicemen)
Aged about 33 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
37. Manju
W/o Sh. Amit Kumar
R/o H. No. 242, VPO Nizampur, Delhi - 110081
Aged about 29 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
7
38. Mayank Rana
S/o Sh. Karamvir Rana
R/o H. No. 345/9-D, VPO Mungeshpur
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
39. Hinasti Rana
D/o Sh. Anand Parkash
R/o H. No. 74, Near MCD Girls Primary School,
VPO Qutubgarh, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
40. Nikita
D/o Sh. Jai Kanwar
R/o B - 5/75, Sector - 4, Rohini, Delhi - 110085
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
41. Shweta Gemini
D/o Sh. Ajay Kumar Sharma
R/o H. No. 103, Gali No. 7, Prem Nagar,
Najafgarh, New Delhi - 110043
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
42. Kriti Sharma
D/o Sh. Raju Sharma
R/o H. No. 722, Sector - 6, Bahadurgarh, Haryana
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
43. Deepanshi Gupta
D/o Sh. Narinder Gupta
R/o C - 33, Budhvihar, Phase - I,
Sultanpuri, C Block, North West Delhi
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
44. Ria Jain
D/o Sh. Pavan Kumar Jain
R/o RZA 24/1, A Block, Mahavir Vihar, Palam
Aged about 21 years
8
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
45. Charu Verma
D/o Sh. Raju Kumar Verma
R/o 2576, Street No. 15, Kailash Nagar, Delhi - 110031
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
46. Kritika Khosla
D/o Sh. Vijay Khosla
R/o 1573, Outram Line, Kingsway Camp,
New Delhi - 110009
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
47. Vaishali Sikka
D/o Sh. Ashwani Sikka
R/o D - 19, Manohar Park, East Punjabi Bagh,
New Delhi - 110026
Aged about 23 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
48. Yogender
S/o Sh. Mahtab Singh
R/o VPO Matan (Bichla Pana) Teh. Bahadurgarh,
Dist. Jhajjar, Haryana - 124501
(Ex-Servicemen)
Aged about 35 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
49. Sonia
D/o Sh. Samunder Singh
R/o H. No. 492, Village Garhibala, PO - Bindhrolli,
Sonipat, Haryana
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
50. Ritika Panghal
D/o Sh. Gordhan Singh
R/o H. No. 953/7, Jain Bagh Colony,
Near S.M. Hindu School, Sonipat, Haryana
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
9
51. Priyanka Bhardwaj
D/o Sh. Parshotam
R/o H. No. - 337A, Barwala, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
52. Rakhi Vats
D/o Sh. Anil Kumar
R/o H. No. 455, Barwala, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
53. Dimpey Tehlan
D/o Sh. Raghbir Singh Tehlan
R/o H. No. 74, Nangli Sakrawati, Najafgarh,
New Delhi - 110043
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
54. Nupur Bhardwaj
D/o Sh. Yash Pal Bhardwaj
R/o H. No. 349 350, Ward No. 4, Ready Made
Garments Lane, Mehrauli, New Delhi - 110030
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
55. Geeta Kumari
D/o Sh. Anirudh Prasad Mandal
R/o A - 204, G. No.- 1, Keshav Nagar,
Ibrahimpur, Delhi - 110036
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
56. Kirti Kumari
D/o Sh. Satish Kumar
R/o Lekhapatti Mohalla, Near Allahabad Bank,
Khaira Village, South - West Delhi,
Delhi - 110043
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
10
57. Divya Anand
D/o Sh. Narender Anand
R/o H. No. 533, LIG Flats, Sanjay Enclave,
Opp. G.T.K. Depot, Near Jahangirpuri,
Delhi - 110033
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
58. Lipika Sharma
D/o Sh. Dinesh Kumar Sharma
R/o H. No. 308/A - 69/7, Main Bawana Road,
Pooth Khurd, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
59. Sudha
D/o Sh. Rajkumar
R/o VPO Kheri Asra, Dist. Jhajjar,
Teh. Jhajjar, Haryana - 124104
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
60. Himani
D/o Sh. Anil Kumar
R/o 779/27, Gali No. 04, Adarsh Nagar,
Bahadurgarh, Jhajjar, Haryana - 124507
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
61. Monika
D/o Sh. Anil Kumar
R/o H. No. 531/13, Gali No. 03,
Balour Road, Vijay Nagar, Bahadurgarh,
Jhajjar, Haryana - 124507
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
62. Himanshu
S/o Sh. Narender Kumar
R/o 537/29, Shyam Nagar, Upkar Clinic,
Mehlana Chowk, Sonepat
Aged about 25 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
11
63. Priyanka
D/o Sh. Daljeet Singh
R/o Flat No. 130, Harsukh Apartment,
Plot No. 4, Sec 7, Dwarka, New Delhi
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
64. Nitin
S/o Sh. Ravinder Kumar
R/o 1063/E, Lohiya Gali - 5, Barbarpur,
Shahdara, Delhi - 110032
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
65. Rajinder Sharma
S/o Sh. Govind Sharma
R/o Y - 1451/11W, Adarsh Enclave,
Prem Nagar - 2, Kiradi
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
66. Ashish Malik
S/o Sh. Virender Malik
R/o H. No. 60, Gram Sabha Pooth Kalam Extn.
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
67. Harsha Yadav
D/o Sh. Surender Singh Yadav
R/o RZ - 54, Ph - 4, Prem Nagar,
Najafgarh, New Delhi - 110043
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
68. Chanchal
D/o Sh. Suresh Chander
R/o WZ - 194, Palam Village, New Delhi - 110045
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
69. Sheetal Arya
D/o Sh. Ramesh Chandra
R/o S - 162, D - Block, Phase - I,
Qutub Vihar, New Delhi - 110071
12
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
70. Parvinder
S/o Sh. Ranbir Singh
R/o H. No. 793, Sector - 23, Sonipat, Haryana
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
71. Jyoti Bazard
D/o Sh. Lehana Singh
R/o V.P.O Panchi Jattan, Sonipat, Haryana
Aged about 24 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
72. Mansi Hudda
D/o Sh. Rahul
R/o C - 33, West Jyoti Nagar,
Shahdara, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
73. Vandana Baghel
D/o Sh. Agyaram
R/o B - 45/46, Gali No. 13, Phase - 10,
Shiv Vihar, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
74. Himanshu Yadav
S/o Sh. Satish Kumar Yadav
R/o 1405, Bazar Sita Ram, Delhi - 110006
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
75. Sanjana
D/o Sh. Sanjay Rana
R/o H. No. 179, Vill, Mungeshpur, Delhi-39
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
13
76. Sonakshi
D/o Sh. Anil Kaushik
R/o W - 126, Chander Shekar Gali No. 4,
Babarpur, Shahdara, Delhi - 110032
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
77. Udit Rana
S/o Sh. Ram Kishan Rana
R/o H. No. 252, Khera Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
78. Abhilasha
D/o Sh. Rajesh Kumar
R/o 1064, Hanuman Gali, Bawana,
Darya Pur Kalan, Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
79. Manmeet Rana
S/o Sh. Ram Kishan Rana
R/o H. No. 252, Khera Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 23 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
80. Renu
D/o Sh. Gyanender Rana
R/o H. No. 85, Near VPO Khera Kalan, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 25 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
81. Sushant Kumar
S/o Sh. Sunil Kumar
R/o 482, Chirag Delhi, New Delhi - 110017
Aged about 23 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
82. Pooja
D/o Sh. Dinesh Kumar
R/o Plot No. 1305, VPO Tikri Kalan, New Delhi
Aged about 27 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
14
83. Anupriya
D/o Sh. Suresh Kumar
R/o Flat No. 1427 SF, Sector - 7,
Gokuldham Society, Bahadurgarh, Jhajjar,
Haryana - 124507
Aged about 22 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
84. Urvashi
D/o Sh. Rajesh Kumar
R/o H. No. 334, Village Daryapur Kalan,
Delhi - 110039
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
85. Nancy Solanki
D/o Sh. Narender Solanki
R/o H. No. 14, Pooth Kalan,
New Delhi - 110086 (North-West Delhi)
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
86. Shweta Solanki
D/o Sh. Joginder Singh Solanki
R/o H. No. 144, Pooth Kalan,
New Delhi - 110086 (North-West Delhi)
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
87. Rashi Jain
D/o Sh. Ravinder Kumar Jain
R/o S - 90, Sunder Block, Shakarpur,
Delhi - 110092
Aged about 23 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
88. Anu
D/o Sh. Dharmender Singh
R/o Village Dariyapur Khurd, PO Ujwa,
New Delhi - 110073
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
15
89. Akhil Deswal
S/o Sh. Jai Singh Deswal
R/o D - 93, Raj Nagar - II, Palam Colony,
New Delhi - 110077
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
90. Priyanka Beniwal
D/o Sh. Ranjeet Singh Beniwal
R/o 345/1, Pitampura Village, Delhi - 110034
Aged about 27 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
91. Meenu Beniwal
D/o Sh. Ranjeet Singh
R/o 345/1, Pitampura Village, Delhi - 110034
(Contract)
Aged about 33 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
92. Sonia Gahlot
D/o Sh. Jagbir Singh
R/o H. No. 169, Village Kakrola, New Delhi - 110078
Aged about 28 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
93. Yogesh Attari
S/o Sh. Amar Singh Attri
R/o B - 60/1, Ram Vihar Johripur Extn.,
Gokalpuri, Delhi - 110094
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
94. Kapil Sandwal
S/o Sh. Surender Kumar
R/o H. No. 93, Rajendra Park Extn.,
Nangloi, New Delhi - 110041
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
95. Aditi Singh
D/o Sh. Dalip Kumar
R/o B - 1088/89, Mangol Puri, New Delhi - 110083
16
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
96. Ekta
D/o Sh. Surender Kumar
R/o H. No. 303, Khera Khurd, Delhi - 110082
Aged about 20 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
97. Nidhi Malik
W/o Sh. Nikhil Malik
R/o 142/124, Karala Road, Kanjhawala,
Behind NDPL Office
Aged about 21 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
98. Nikhil Malik
S/o Sh. Ramkumar Malik
R/o 142/124, Karala Road, Kanjhawala,
Behind NDPL Office
Aged about 26 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
99. Jiya Chaudhary
D/o Sh. Nirdesh Kumar
R/o 494, Devika Apartment, Opposite Handa School,
Bhola Nath Nagar, Shahdra, Delhi
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
100. Subham Gupta
S/o Sh. Desh Raj Gupta
R/o H.No. 168, Block B, Shiv Vihar,
Karawal Nagar, East Delhi - 110094
Aged about 19 years
(Group „B‟)
(Appointment for the post of Teacher (Primary) in MCD)
...Applicants
(By Advocate : Mr. Jatin Parashar for Mr. Ajesh Luthra)
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi
Through its Chief Secretary,
A-Wing, 5th Floor, Delhi Secretariat,
17
I.P. Estate, New Delhi
2. Lieutenant Governor of Delhi,
Raj Niwas, Rajpur Road,
Delhi
3. South Delhi Municipal Corporation
Through its Commissioner,
9th Floor, Civic Centre, New Delhi
4. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board (DSSSB)
Through its Chairman,
FC-18, Karkardooma Institutional Area,
Delhi- 92
5. Central Board of Secondary Education
Through its Chairperson,
„Shiksha Kendra‟, 2, Community Centre,
PreetVihar, New Delhi - 110092
6. Union of India
Through its Secretary
Ministry of Human Resource Development,
Shastri Bhawan, New Delhi
...Respondents
(By Advocate : Ms. Neetu Mishra for Ms. Harvinder Oberoi
O R D E R (Oral)
Ms. Nita Chowdhury, Member (A):
By filing this OA, the applicants are seeking direction to the respondents to relax the qualification of Central Teacher Eligibility Test (CTET) in the context of appointment to the post Code No.1/18 (Primary Teacher) applied for by them in pursuance to advertisement No.1/18 dated 26.6.2018 issued by the respondents.
2. We heard learned counsel for parties. During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the respondents has submitted that similar matter has already been decided by 18 this Bench and other Benches of this Tribunal. While deciding the OA No.1916/2018 vide Order dated 26.3.2019, this Bench held as follows:-
2. We heard learned counsel for parties. During the course of hearing, learned counsel for the respondents has produced a copy of the Order dated 14.3.2019 passed in OA Nos.300, 320, 335,345, 1710, 1904, 2741, 2770 and 3084 of 2018 and 770 and 686 of 2019 and also of the Hon‟ble Delhi High Court in Writ Petition (Civil) No.11328/2017 (Annu and Others vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi and others) dated 11.1.2018 and submitted that the issue involved in this case is squarely covered by the said Judgments.
3. We perused the aforesaid Judgment of this Tribunal dated 14.3.2019 and found that in the said batch of O.As., i.e., O.A. No.300/2018, through a detailed judgment, the Coordinate Bench dismissed the similar issue as raised in this case, holding that the qualification of CTET cannot be exempted.
4. Learned counsel for applicants submits that the qualification cannot be insisted, particularly when there are no qualified candidates for the said posts and the posts have been remaining vacant for the past several years. We find that the qualification prescribed is in compliance with Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 and hence, the same cannot be exempted/relaxed. Further, Article 309 of the Constitution of India gives the power exclusively to the State to prescribe qualifications for posts as held by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the case of P.U.Joshi vs. Accountant General (2003)2 SCC 632, the relevant portion of the same reads as under:
"10. We have carefully considered the submissions made on behalf of both parties. Questions relating to the constitution, pattern, nomenclature of posts, cadres, categories, their creation/abolition, prescription of qualifications and other conditions of service including avenues of promotions and criteria to be fulfilled for such promotions pertain to the field of Policy and within the exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of the State, subject, of course, to the limitations or restrictions envisaged in the Constitution of India and it is not for the Statutory Tribunals, at any rate, to direct 19 the Government to have a particular method of recruitment or eligibility criteria or avenues of promotion or impose itself by substituting its views for that of the State. Similarly, it is well open and within the competency of the State to change the rules relating to a service and alter or amend and vary by addition/substruction the qualifications, eligibility criteria and other conditions of service including avenues of promotion, from time to time, as the administrative exigencies may need or necessitate. Likewise, the State by appropriate rules is entitled to amalgamate departments or bifurcate departments into more and constitute different categories of posts or cadres by undertaking further classification, bifurcation or amalgamation as well as reconstitute and restructure the pattern and cadres/categories of service, as may be required from time to time by abolishing existing cadres/posts and creating new cadres/posts. There is no right in any employee of the State to claim that rules governing conditions of his service should be forever the same as the one when he entered service for all purposes and except for ensuring or safeguarding rights or benefits already earned, acquired or accrued at a particular point of time, a Government servant has no right to challenge the authority of the State to amend, alter and bring into force new rules relating to even an existing service."
5. It is further relevant to mention that in the case of Annu and others vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi (supra), the Hon‟ble Delhi High Court held "that advertisement pursuant where to petitioners had applied for post of TGT, had not only laid down eligibility qualifications, but had also stated in no uncertain terms that educational qualifications shall be determined as on closing date of receipt of application. In advertisement, it had clearly stated that, it was for candidates to ensure that they fulfill all eligibility conditions and if upon verification at any subsequent stage, it was found that they did not fulfill any eligibility qualifications, his/her candidature for post would be cancelled by respondent no.3/DSSB. Perusal of conditions clearly show that at time of applying for posts of TGT, candidates should have clear CTET examination and petitioners were well aware of fact that they did not fulfill said mandatory eligibility condition of CTET, as prescribed in advertisement, but they still chose to 20 apply for subject post. As a result, Court find no infirmity in impugned order passed by Tribunal."
6. Following the aforesaid Judgments of the Coordinate Bench in O.A. No.300/2018 & batch and also of the Hon‟ble Delhi High Court in Annu's case supra, we do not find any merit in this case and the same is accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs."
3. In view of the above, we are also of the considered opinion that this case is squarely covered by the aforesaid Order of this Bench and as such the present OA is liable to be dismissed. Accordingly, the same is dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
(S.N. Terdal) (Nita Chowdhury)
Member (J) Member (A)
/ravi/