Karnataka High Court
Oriental Insurance Company Limited vs Sri Muni Thammanna S/O Sri Muni Kempanna on 28 January, 2011
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
$§' 33% my S? g £§§"?E'.£§ E;§§€;E§§§:§s§;'$§§ W §é,§§.. $3 2 :§§s;f:;;%igi§§*;? %[%g§x::%§§$;:% %%%% J % mg, §§$:%§§§ §E?§§'§E§§§'*§§%;:§ ' mg §:.'%i?§§§1,i§ '%i€é§%-{§'§§'€E§§§§E§§§if€' E %§.»§;;%;§:?§§§?
. % :;§:§ .»..uwwm'-.-. ..
?:%"fi.,,;é%§%§:§§§ mm 23% :%?§:§§ §%§VV%j%i:g€;%y§;§?M§% » T §§§%§%§%'=-§;'aZ%§Tf'*?Z*§§$;:é€-Efiiégfififi? fig ' 'r V' figs; a;%;%;;:*:¢:*':'§§ §§::$ §"§§?§%:.3::§.§3§ fizfijg gm "T §E"§' 3%: K __ ggéggggéga mg §§®'I§"E€'.?*;§,'§fi§i§%§§§§§§§ %?§§§§ ' §a3*§s;':§ %& § %€§-s,%%%§§§§g fiié?
iigfiéiéffi s,§"§§§§E & § ,
-- ggfiggeiézfiiéa T. mgygag yafi i::3;;1§§§ g :3 _ §§§%§§ 2; 35 Egg?-
a::%;:**?§§§ ;
§'§'.. Mfiffifi $5?-*€§;f ~ -
**§:~§§§:: g§§*"*gQ..§g-- mg; figs ' zégig §§%%: Z§§§f?§§§:iif£i§§vf% §3§Eé§i§E§§i§%"§f§§§?__§%§;E§§ as fizéaa afiggzgfigéfig "§2*;;é%*e& %§§fi §:%§é;":%%§.?§ Q?' ifi gg "gag?
n 'T §§§ 13% fifiiflfl 5.}? Q3232?-;::§§§;§§;_; fiifi gaféaag am
- _. fiééiiiéafiil '4 Essa ?::':é:'% 332$ '§'%§% Emégf fafizg 5.22:?' 233% iifififii "
gag isfigg igggfisgég $§' $2; §§%§:§€? §;%;;g;§§§:;v§§%'% ¢ 3;€;§_§;:§2§%%? g %% A $1': Efififisé %s§°%:§;a*2 iiééé as §?§€3§ . ,_ :
' 9:: ':::;
a gfififiifif £5 a. ggiifiémz fififii" gjiééiééggj vw%%;«'%§:§:;--. _ fig was §§:§;§§;&§z§§§j@'°a::--":§; " §*a:§§,§;,*%;;"":':§«;*:§:§ V " ' §§&'§$€%£§;%§&.. §i'2%§E§ E: §§3%:§%:*§,§;Z%:*:=r5a%§;*?§_; * "5; if féfgigiifiiifiii §§§s, &.
ms}: fifié gag?
13:2. fi;§§_§§1§§' A §$$§%s:§§'2 :*§$;:,:§%;§ gig ;_::§.fi§ '-*§,;§s,§:._.«§';::§§ Eiézzggfi :3: _' § §:%§§;j€_;:§§:": flf'i£§fi§Q§'§ %§%§Q§;%§m gaaiagya Egg-$;,'§""§ '9~::s;%%lfi?%:§:*%§:;;*%§§§vi§.§:'V* Q?' *7§'E:§ " Va $§%§§§°§$§.}§§:'E Q?
§§,g§§%;:g~§{;;s; ea: fis% $.35 _ €$§%.;é%§§ fig §§ 524;. §:'*' %§."fi%ff:
£33?
V' ziégigfaaisfiifi fifi $3; %;§3§ £5?
fig fififiiififiififi fig fififiififi-3&3 :1 ' 'a%§§31$:§§_ $233; @§:"§;§*"§'3§Q1§s.f"§i":é':i§f 'V ffif mfg fifififiiéfiamfi 31$ E235.
mg ézfézs"
%§" iiififi '§:"§%;§*;:$§ fig zrgj $5:
ii €233: féi" §::*vL§§:§§%;§§::§:.%§Ka§fi%:?§ é§é§'? §§::?fé$ E gfifigafigfigfifia §;iéa:;*g§%3;:%Eaei:f§%§ {Egg '"?§f°§§ fiiéfi ggggfi ii égééi. A' ; 5;%;'§:::3§.§'§.%§§ fif $3 §%§§J?_§ ggigafiggéi $353; §c§;g%~%§ zéfigaf gzgé. §§§;3%% §§§§?w§§§ %§.§:E:£~ ' ' iétrg? %:§§;§':s:%:f";§s:;%:§:§e:§a3§;; Q? a 7p%§*i{§::;;§ éé «:3 fifigg 31::
3 gag Q fig .
ifi figs zéigéwfi: @%¥f§§* ifi .
. fig $3 §":*§'%§ 5§§'§;"*'§.f§fi §§m%§§s£i§:§1§ g%;;
=; gfié; Eéifigfi ix EEQ 飧§;$§ szzfimaisfg zsfififif fizég Egg ' iififififié £3 §'§.f§§§,,'ii§E':i fa': & _ Eiagg
5.' §Z::::; Eiégmgi flag? ' § fifififig flag égra . --. A " 3%? ?§Z'$fi§%§fi'§g mawzzfig '§2*:s:::%.§§:'§£&§ 33 E;'%$AA»;§.§m'%%§:g*"§¥i'%i§£;«v ?i?%;;'i;$:§, 'V _% " Em gifiségé am: gm fig §%e€§?'§%1j §§*§§§§ ; . mggmfifii EE§"§i§&§* ' _ .£;I§§§ 'fig §;§:%'§§ iéiwafigs fig 5$§§:?;g%§ §$: :% « L V 21:5;-».§§::;g%::T.T§§g=::§$%§ gag:
3. §§§"§:QE§ V%:a§ 5; VV' y !LV $2335 §m:%§§§:§2 & V' igié '3 §:%§:1f'§T.§§*
-' ' . $3; éfha éfifiifif afié; fifi ~ Eififififiééi $3' ' 33$ $3 Eiiifiisfifgié :f'§,L%,§ faiimfi ' ' 'Www aw ifi ?%%$%§% '€%f
-gfi Em? 2&3 33% fig fii ' iimfi $3' Sgfifiéfififiig -:2: ' §:%§ m§é§;:§;é§>;--§.§§:* ia $3? $2.5 L13 _"'.f:.§% Q éifiéfifig §:§§%':§ « £5:
£3 <§§§i§;'§§§§§Zj§féis:_ 2% T *:*§:g% 333% :::zzE§§'é:;i.aE2§a;:£.;§§{s§..'=$§ 253% Egg $3' A' "'§§§¢%§..,;§%§§§%§éEE§§ éigaéfiégg gs:
1 .,é'€*§ 5'? ', '::;%:§:% =.§§?$%§s $§ faiiafig §;2'$$m§ 34%? 5%: -33% af fiééigr :1 'fig aégimawi $3 E'§§§§i§§*§€§; fig :;§:§§};g$ §§@§'*%§;§I§$§fi far _ ifi Sfii 'V «V ffif fi1§. 'Ei'§é'.é§i§§: %:§%§$§$&'€:§§§2 Q § §"'e§§'T§$'%§'§§ isf ' %§:$r§f§§*§,, a Efig ?%§:g§g :§§ ' 2':'*:§%§%;¥§fis"'.:r§i:== ;$ QE §§§::'§i§&:':;§§§ é} ififi Q?
éasiafifg 11$ §§$§"§;§§ ._ % E: ' $3 Q? fliiiiifi Eafizigfigifififi E} ifififi 3:' fgizéffi §3a**:»:%.:<*fié5?$"'v V " V' ' "
gg §?':2:::?§:: mfiqéigaé & ' ' a £3;
§§£i§5&f§1é§ éiéifsé' :§§f&§.:i §:§::E§E§%:::?:.. §f%§§"'~ Z iééfi K V' w . V. %'E?fi§:§f'§ $§3i§§§%E'§ $3 I ' A " 'V ' = .,%f; 2 " "%':%a:%§g§%2*:*§~,:§ Ea iiiééfi §":§%§§:é&§ fag ii?
Egfié §$$;»~ ?i}%§_§E§i§§ afi' 2% Sf 5.:
gsfiézéiéfigrz iii: $15: fifiéfi $2?' . 7 3? 'Egg Eigfiégragggg fifimgégigg Eéfiéi K V' §%§§$3:'§ fikfi iféfififfifii Effiggégz gf 3. gagzg $5' fisia 3% E3: fiégi if gm fiiifiaiffififi .§é§$2:E?§f$?§$&'i§§fE ;§§% fig Ea flag amfizzfié: WE??? £3 ffifi "zfisfiégggzfégiig é:}§':§ .
$332' §%?§§§.§:";3§§$a%§§"
fig: %A.§'§~§E'§$§§ V§;3§§ géagéfs, féizgagafia gma £917: 3 ya éfiififigi §::§:*:§§sfi§$§£§§§ §::~:§:°z§;lé:w§=£s§._" H3 §7'%§ rééafigfi £2: §&%§'§*£§ £2? fiza : fig fifigfifiii ' §.fi@. fiafi §.%§"£§§§ éfii fig fiifiéffiii '33:: %§ "' %2 gr: in * 5}? éégfi @:%%*§:*§g Ezfififi g§;§§§£i:§§§§ §m§1§§§%£§Ei'3§E._ ; V§£§i;,f§:f§§§§§:§ %§%§;ffi %;§%:L%:av§§1$;:a§9'; fif