M/S Gouri Enterprises vs The General Manager on 9 February, 2010

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

M/S Gouri Enterprises vs The General Manager on 9 February, 2010

Bench: N.Kumar, B.V.Nagarathna

<§§€""

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA. CIRCEYK?

BENCH AT GULBARGA

DATED '}T'HES THE: 9?" .DAY GE' Fa:E3RUA;;s%f"T2'<;~':_:;-%f:   _

pRE$$§j_

THE HONBLE MR;;it;sfrICis   

THE HON'BLE MRS.ﬁ UST_I(3E ﬁ'.--ii.:§AGARATHNA
w.1§;3\:o. m'351:L'g:z:s09.L fa':-.«{'r'EN)

BET'\N'E1EN;__   5':f ...~;_ * 1'

M%.zs.TGO.IjRI1:;2§:N";*.E::2.PR'1:'3§:S . 
R§AHABA.§4ES;%IE?»?AR_ NAM

:}AMAK%iAF3:i}.{'E2i€§§;«i2§3*- ' %

§3:;;APL;R4585..V'3T.0'2 

R§:p.§*1'.-3Y .LE1%'1'E:1?2'j Q}?

"""'GE-§NE53'1'sE§RI  ,PA.'I'"§L  £~';?§3*EL1AF~ET

EL'! 1 ¢

A"  ~:':3'r' SV¥;?i'R.M..KU_E,KARNEEAEDVJ

:3. "~'rHE:-i;;§:3qERA2, :»f:;*am.£;£:%;;:
 ?'{}{;>Dj«~{ZGR?§§€:z%'§'EON 0? ENSEA
§§EQEGNAL C>F°§'ECE:,. C€f)N"_£'RAC'.E'
.A _ mvigmsxz, RE;G§.ON F\.:'O.L.
~ V ' "-.§~:AS'F Em} MA§N Ré3aé':{.>
'« ..:§AYN;%§E,s'§R EV' §3_LC}{iEi
E,%£§N€§AEJ{}E?:EZ--4% E g

'°' 2; mi ¥§{§§>«.':2%L;%f9eiE':/Ei €;;:{><}_:}$ "E'E{z'§.§%§E§E3{}E€'E' {iii}.

i*f%"'§}%'E'E (3 31% E.3:'?":.{','? K §€;{};'%§[} 

 

 ~  



BEJAP{§R~58E3 101. REP. BY
PAR'1'NEZR.

SR1 ARAVENE) "rAL11%s:<:)':':  §{EZSPOI\§"5Ii)::E1fjf§;i§   A'

[BY SR1 VEEREZSH B'PA'E'Ei;;; '}iE3V.A_§*OR' R§':.;_ .  F.

SM' '.F.A"F33~E?s. N.sHzx7AY0GI1vtA*;f%; --AI}£-r_"."~F_{)R" I'

<:AvEA'zj<:)R«R2)A   _ "

WRIT APPEAL IS Fmgiin Uf':E3 _  < 3vﬁ ""rHE
KARNATAKA HIGH COUR'ff___=ACj'_3C=,PRAYH'~3'§ fro SET
ASEDE THE ORUER. EEKETEE)_«'2OT8;2QQ9._PASSE§} IN VVP.
NO.82'?64/O9.  % - a  .A 

This appezﬂ :;0n1irigV'<;»ﬁ7j« E'_éj:*.:'fi_:1;21I  this day,
N.KUIV£.% J. ,2 'dafiﬁ/<3re£?«_ folliawirig 

 wNpQ:s.ww:_E T
"f'{%_éi&s _Aé3;'}':1;Lf2€;%;j;§.'nf i:T:'  '~§.3fi'€_"'?§"I"€& by éihgs p<:tié.i{>:3.t:~;r
cE1e1.§1e11ging,§Eghe v::_<'>'1V€¥<#:m;.4mgésahi' the order pa:-sggd by t.E1e

§<:':ar:"1s:.'a:':v :;i:':gi%::».J'{2:dg@ é';ii:»~,;1':":i::;e,~;£;:":g the writ pef;§ﬁe:H1. For

€"h.<~: §311r}f:%{;$éA~.::f <:<3:".w£3n;E€3:11<é(-3. part;i£3$ are reéferreai '£20 355

AE.-;?2€~:§:? Ei:iA"t:?-.4Ef;§u¥§~€»i3i"?.%f3f¥;"' $10 in i:E':_<:t writ. p€:*.§.ii:ion.

',2. Ré::2p<>E1€k:::t. :."i{},§ ﬁg §'<}::)c§ C:>rp{3rr.a§£.i{>n af Inéia
~.LC.ei.2;:"is'z':.:f£:.z:::?~a'E z2:';»:ie:" S:?:<:?::§{>:."a :3 :3? €;§'1é;: §?'<.><:s{.§ C<>:'parati<}:'2
 Z§%{*3%. ii' §S;s=~:~1,:€:d 2;: €'.::%::T::i::::' :1<:>€;§§i<?:a§:§{}::3 iigzéistcé

 §E}ﬂE"3.:?;£"%{}§ €f22§.§.i§":§§ EEK i:s%m.'§€:;*s,=:: fmm cEégg;§'E3E€:

3:



Arﬁx

i;:'anspc::.»r*£ ctc::r1E:r21<:i'.<)rs for 1c)e1di:1g§/u_;11c::21<:ii:1g/Eéaiidiéﬁg
tm;:'1sp(>'rtai'.ioI1 <3!" g:;{>c1$. ,App€r1dix H of tbs:'F§j{)€.i£i§;égtiaﬂ'
pm:-3<::1*;i;b<3S iihaiz <:1i;§i¥3Ie: <?.<):1i4r23T'i7'fiA{}:':s« A_s'h<):;13:i "  ;e§1{:i<§:~;€:";

dOC1.1IT1€f1'1f.S 21$ :n<):*--;.1 in 11 ai<§';1g :_wif:I1  'téxxtief

app1i(:ati{;n in seabed e1'1x%4Le«E:.{T}Tpr:s V. c}r:3_é§.'t":1y .=  xthe:
SL3 pe':_*$e;ér£p€.i<):r: 'TEEC     V 

3. The petitigner  and had :*i<::.h
€Xpf2I"i€3'£'1Cé3    ézxecuiiing
the very s21;1}e  of 1% resspondent
which  in I'E3S§30'l'1S€: to the
110{ifi<:a1f.i%3:§1§' _it'   fulfiiiing ail 'thé

i;er:n.:s 'vzuad €:s>I1ACii'§§:>n-S 0'? t:he e::011t.'2"::1ct.. ReSpanCi€::":§:

 n:1;f}V[%»}5<'<i'é;§}£;§ _C:;§rp€)r21i:i<>.n sf inciia iizejreinazfiier résfé-zrreczi {,0

12:3; *ﬁ_1€:A €3{§'z<p{;2{§1vt.i{>§1. {er .€€;h0.:"'£:} <:a§i?--:d upon the p€:tiE:i0:1er

£0 2iiiT,€.:2..:_i 'e:,:s~p%:3§:;.1fi:":<2;;f 0§'§;1";§r::e 'aid {>11 3G.€:3a2@G§ ii: whicih the

 §§>eI:T.?Li:i{>'§:?<:%:° ;::«2:.1:*'é',i{.:.i;3»:;:7:.'{:{-xi; ;>r%;<>r' :0 ii, €,E3e _ps;:Ei§:i<:§":er
_  zi.;3; 3':":§::g<:}';@::i i:E:.E.s:s; :'::<m.rt  €'.h{5: g3:'§:f2§:.ip2:§ §}€j:§"§{T§'i ss;@:::}:i:";§,§§ fer

V' '§iI%::3 :"@§.i§:§:m <32?' §.§::t=a':E2:n"2?:%;4i<:2:': éhzzi. §'}"§é:" ;%"<"3 §*€i':E%§}{}E}{§€§§"£. is; gmzi.



aligibie £10 parIf:ieipz.1i:e in the Prim: Bid 21.5; it "1:'21:§f.;i<:;

r<«::q?.1.i$if:er «:';:,121Ei.f".icf:2'-::1t",§<};'1, whiairh. Writ: ;:}<~E.t£t:i<:r1i~.__iv:1::2,  E:».".1_i'.<i:?_f

wiizhdrawn ,

4: The CCv1'p(}I'2H;iOH 3'€€,'.€iV€d t'h'r§>eE--_21:3piiC::.t:i(;:n:?. ,br:£%H

of Em-3 pe'r.itione§: respond¢3§:i:~..:ﬁ"a3,2 
M/5,2 S;-mgam6shw.a:r 1'  he last
app1ic:ati0:': was revie(:i'.€;C1VM I.z:5A;":   they did
1101:: produce   EFF Code. On
£3. '7. 230$,    -:1 CO1fI1II}L"£I'3iCE1tiG.f1 t9

the peiiEi{§.r"1£:.tf'._{p;;%;;&:I._Cf:?sgi' a2.s_3§.:é:1ex1:rewE {G the writ

§Jf:Ti,i'§i.i{}I'1j*. }1'1*:--fc3:r1"rav;'151;;§;Lj~._ﬁh--:3¥f."»».'f:}1e application of the 211$

respgzfgdem %,i¥:i;S ::§::%€:31=<3C1 and the e:::0nt.z'aci'. was awarcied

"H33 ii;  '";E?1*:.<=:* '}':%§:'i:ii:.i<3§":é':*"s0L1gE:%. far irzformatiarz under Right,

V' %i,{:§ .Z;;1iE:;r§:1.;1f1iséV2aEiatii as-='i_E',E: regard "to §3r<:»<:€::3<iings befsre

E1316'"-..C{}1fp€}fé;3€.i{}I'i., EFF' Grgexnizzaiéam, G'uEba;*g2":§. Vijezyez

  '\i':§3E};Iif3;I€, E3.:'§é1§}1:2" B:*2%:r2<:§2, and Fvig/s 'E:"::i3ia Fazrzzaerg E?{'*:"€:§!;i;zE:r
 _ '&iA;';v{iw;:s§:z5i:;*.:°2';s£:ix-*9; E4-_:;:':'2_ii:%;":<§ {§§?'§?'{f{}}¢ ta §'§E'E€}'§,¥ ii? éhéé 233$

' = .»:<£:~$g§<}:':{§&7:%2§. §'§é'§éf. §z4'2E§2?_E§é;-°:{'i ?;:E':&:,=. §I€;'ii'E"ET§:'% ,2'§,.:':{,i :::)§2:i:Zf{.é<'m:%

ix

 

3%,»?

2 v§  A

J
KR.



5

<«::":'r..1.r1:1(:*>:'2:i:<:*<:i 1:1 é\}3}'§E?31diX {E of t:h<:*; térrzcier r2.<:ut':ii:ic:21-$11023.

  

The: C<;mn1itt.ee. c<)z1:§$,i.f.1zt',ed 15231' ﬁche pur"p(Js3<: exggraég 

the visw i:ha€. ﬁx: p<:iiti0m=,r' was; prima fzxcie"q9{12%,.iif1é:'<:§' Ea? --

iiake up the C0a'1i;raci;, on 'i:11e:'b21Sis _G--f _i;t3 'f§n.211*1£iia1."p

aspecis and the fact iiilat, »i{  
<:c:311t,z"2.ct<>r. 'xvhen $316539   ' i:hs2:
noiice of the C0rp01*a1t.i{:):<:?_  ;§§1c3r¢ 11«:'}f.VVé0?f1%sid€reci,
arid therefore, vthe   writ, pe¥;,i;€ii;0r:

"-3=--.f .' »::e:r:éi'i()r;€u=:E: fizz e:jfs;:Va_s_}ffi:7g A11I}€XL11'€E-E,

Seeksing a writ]
C:«:31::1mu:1aEcé;§;:iz>?€;s."fs%1:é£'i,e3e:"i'"5'.' "i/3:Z?..2G'€3§ an& a writ. Q5
mandaV:Vr;1111S ' i=:*;Tf'rZ',:fe.<:"£;:§~;.;1'}_§___»)f."':'i§<7.s._'€: C€31"p()1"8.fTiC>I1 to award the

t:c>:":.'i',:'=2i<:':'§,' 5; .

- 5,  }v3;<é:ap0n<:i§<>3:3L§::§ Latxci 2 hzxvt: rmi; ﬂied staiemerat 05

r

  i"i<3;_<§: 2%"? 'I'€iE§§){}f},(i€fE'ﬁ'. €a::'::€§"ié€% {:2"we:9JE., 'a}'v'h{3':':

fzhéj: '=:nai:ie?z;j . {:1-ameé up far' p':"<:'.§§mEna:'§,r' hE38§E'iI1g4 elftifr

j i'}£fE1§'§I§T§;§1' ﬁéiiaéé §;e:a:'m'td {if{}'L'E£'ii§:§€2E :f°=:3r {the p€'£;i'E::*r;1t:1<-:1'; '£1329
..ﬂEa*:A2?s.'T:*:":.¢<=:s;"§ s§§.:a:1§,§§€: =§'iE.i§§giE7 hetiai iilzaiz ii, <':21.:f:m3*§. be $21.i::i ihzat ihaé

'  :2??? z"e:s:s§}{}'n<i:9m. :§j:§£::§ @152: <::§§:':§3§y azzéﬁi. E'.%Es;?: <:m";{§§::.i::I:. :3?

;)r€$fcfI;"£i= H V  '~'.'E' *



te{:}:mi.c21} €;'>~aZ;)€I"'[.iSiZ? or work <:xper§e:1<%c=: as rec;L1:;ré>§i
the 'E,€)'i.aI '$211116 of ihff (':<:»:'1t:rz-3.c::ti under ihe  fl§%I11:ij{3~fVV:'§$£i5é.': V'
Rs.50<'§~ iéikhﬁ. anti '¥;'Ii1€f p€tiE,i£)11e1";'hé.d"net, pr<zd{1(:<2d"2i:1y"'A

f31'1d€)I'S€I}:1€}f1f. f1"(3n3 EFF' O1"gaz1izati0:1;".E%ijapL;_:.A"and e:.4f'é;«er 

relying an the decis-310:1 of  2,%]:>ex
C€}'L1E°'{.§ it was held  '£13-9  :.1:;L2ft 35i<-EAVV shew
that. iihﬁf W  mazmer or
with obliquiz I;_:'1<4:§':f;é' -.;%V.   r'é:sq:;_.:ﬁ'<;§i*1V:i.c1;§AtVhaving felt: that
in Vi€:'W of  supra, it was
z:r;de.3%,%;§ﬁkéi:é  Of 'aha pei:ii:1?<mer: The
Same is-3 ":1_<:>i. :j'e;::§i'ia:'i}21§ review in the absence of

('*3

_.m  ,_ -Ni .4' .  :7 -an-.-- ,_._"1_, V 17:' "1   an-S...  4.: . __._ ,.. 1_:.-._,_. _,n. -HVNH ,2 .:,i, ."..T,_;;'.. _,,m 4.1..
E." 5.}U'?.' "'x'5§i U.1(,§.l(i. §iL§C§3 <Ci.I.£§,i ii I.C1.E,iL}£iCi3.l Ey (ii iii £.£3LCI CEUI {/1 iii

 w:;ji{"§)ei:§:.i<>Vi';.«_<:21m€ {:0 be dismisseéd. Agggrieve-3d by the

"s.:;a§¢:i_ {;§3"{*§.é3;?.,x{}f.'fj'é;§i":é% Eezzrzmgi 5.-"sizigies. Jlldgéi {E19 p€i:§t,§<m€'r' ifé;

§:}ef{i<:f':::>: 3:25. .:;=;i}3;.:r't:.

 3:3»: j faiﬁaér §'1{)'£,§£?:i?, :'@$§3{}:.1c§e::t;s §":.2wa: e.:'}.t.53.-rg-(E
 _ 'géspgééézérziiiaisi. Th4:  :°€:.s;p<;':':{i<::2%i. i;§"2we:'sén§::j §;§rze:

" = ...:;:;iTE::=:§;2'3_'£é:.>:':_s§ zfzzazziaf Es": 'aha '*.§§f'E'"§i. §:*«{:é%;:§§.:Z{:~';L <:{>:<:§.éiz":::§é;%<§ éhai. §;.%":z:':

g2



' ?:,: 

21'"? :.*€spcm{£<::';;'3;I:: E}.a.ci _pr<;w:iu<:«2<:i :%c3.ri..ificéz1t.es £$$=;{%<i"%:"._§'3z
EFFCQ M/5: Naincii S211".1akaI'_i S21kkara'F._ Ka1*k1*1éi.I3.%3¥_f "

Niyezmifez. (M,/:5 Naxidi S'L;g2a:" f<t"1*»AA':£sh:3rji:}-, {}};I'§)$iiL'¥.§Zf€3€fi' }EiS I

Am1eXur<:s R1 and R-2), to_prove7it'i1ad dO11§:"i:vh?: x.'»*.»-;*<5rk 

of handiinv' and tra,n.s <>rt,'i1=1.i"'~.(H 8:. '1"'}T_Vdu§vii11 I the
p1*evie:2u:~; 2: yﬁrars to  e;$it'e3:1:i*:;~- }i:V1;:'ii.Q.21t,€3£i; 'éipéirt. fmm

bank sta.t4er11:311ts for tkie ;5a.~:~;:f:: s:-«giéiv-'.:'v;I1éni:h$. It ES

  

:r0rmf3nded,,, 0r_;éi3%"j;:§f§::'.  pmduced
2111:! €iS(?€f1"§k.',-EV1.iY}:_41%.'1' %.  the c<>nt::'a<:'{: was
a1m%?ardt%§   {Isf {hrs C€tZ'"iifi{Ea'{€ of
Sue Eﬁiigérzeéé  mSpO.ndent,S Charmmd

ff'xC)(§{)?;1i'1.'=;§{1'}i( 7§'E';{:' '5ct;%rViLi§<.:aé,e:&5 izsasaami as pm" ;5'3;mt%2a:,z:'t::s~

,1"auzﬁﬁ:}§E5§irg:0':.§§Eeé with bank Eséziiezmerii {Anne:x;ure--§{~

C; '¥'g"§£S<.7§€§:i:xﬁ:{E f'"EEK: vzziusé af w<>rk =:i<mét by' this: 2%

:'€:S§§s.::':§§'€2:2:: ix-?'ii'.E": {:s€i:hé3:' f°éZ'1,§:Sk

» "'?A;  $1;,:,§3s.~:<;%:i;;,:€3:1':.E},r, E91316 Ce::rp<>ra§'.§<};2 filed <tieE:a.ﬂé:::i

';¢s€i;::?ai:€=,::1:.-3z':§: of «:>bj<?<:€:i.c>:::a_ :°€:3?E.:3.mE:.i:'1;g i.E";21'§. <}z':_E§; {H3

$Ei'E§E%§§E§£YE1i<}'§"i 9? 32.1.2 *::'§"":e3 <:§{:ss;.%:.:::":1:%'§'::%.sss §_':r:::hz_{:e::<i E3}-' i:ha*: EM'?
*2

. .K 

 

rm «3 °@?\?&«§%?§"\§§%é?§\% i W%&§r'& 'V¢



 ~i.%a:':'2€ :'222'?s;.?,é;: A:l%;.*'=.,a,*;;';2.':*{:§e;*:~<§. Era': ::.%":€~::  :'é?rss;§;*zs::w::'.%;<1Er;:*::'a E,

be <é€>z"1s:i<ie:'eci by izhe  1"c:spc::1d<3:'1t:. Se:::§>;:_é'dI§1>'*.:'heV
Cc:);1{.€:nds3,£L the 2u1th0:"i2:2H.i{:r1 Ietmr is 110$: in' E1Vj(f(i{}1*dé1I'ECs3.  '

with Thaw, the 1et.t:c3r from i:}1.e:v"b.21iék..{3f :3'm§1;iég'.1i:11'ii_s '«

erxjoyed and ihe iazmk S1Z€3IZ€1'f}f3I'"1t  1'"r3:r  »f:_h%;§ I21S'é:_vééi:s;v ::10fiEV.}11's--..

which were exjpectterd to }:';£i:_ ':a,:1r1<3:§<:€<i a1io'ng'{w1'-1?.b'the =

tender appiicaiien was not eii:;:_IC;'<.€€i 21:";-d_At,'fi<3{éf0r€ 1138
tsncier app1_iC:ai:.icm it,s€%Ef xva§s'"i"1'(;t <é;§mpiet.e. "'i"'hL1s, his

tendezr d0<:11me:1i: :t0u1d'f:€;i: h_.21{zs:}béc.ﬁ1~.,¢<;;:1.Sider<:d at 21113
Vfhen the appe1Ean'['s e:}a_S'é>_Vw':~1S;i;h--'é~.Z'*"9'jTespondﬁnt did

not s21t:i8f}; _1;.};f:'«:?_ "_'€1igEbii.i.é:;§i' c:9§z"?::'<'»:f:ii.;«:. ézrzd his ?;en{ier

appliczatioﬁ ES_.--i'";<i§f '{E§eil,1}34§fiiTf}i'T'{:€ECi decL12'11€'r11E.s whicth

 

{;'ugg§}_1i:'i'.L:   ' ' :'ir;;{:'V1s=,-:§ E_':'.£Ev':iVi§V?tt::£'i.E'11¢;'<,1£ Sitigie Jucige:

pr:>(:g2<:dT3 {En €,h§:é'éigsigtififyiiiéirfa tihe _ju.<;'§;i<:3§a1 'review' z?a1'1r1<>£::

'ix: re-3:3:"t<:d<--t._o,vvi:<3 i'§€:1{Z_vé2azé?'{:h€ {",{)§'§'€§','€.§1€3SS £32" Eihezé positiari

 emd__§ :¥<*:;j:._i%<:%:.s~§ $2.9 wréi: ;'3i;'.i§'é::ie:3r": <:::":':3§T:t:<3ussi§r w:§*:.E:z>:2t

 §}i"i}§}€:'1.}é"&1§}.§}i'€3{Ti§Zi€i§'ig ijim mai <::3::Eem.i{1i:s; issgue in {his

?<é;;z.§~?3';_ §.:;v:i"".i;:h<:§%e3:§?:3:'t2 31%;? $'L:%3:12i'E.$ i:.E';a:§: the: €)Y'{§€'3§' {)5 {E15

 

§e%:5:f..:f_:is;*:{§ Sizigg ;éV@§:2si;'g<:  §§é'.ib§{f iii: ':33 $:%%:' 2E$§{§%;'; 555$ z3;§.:§<7; ﬁ'1€'"3

    

?é<  & ./ma». xﬁgxi» §§i%& §@$%%3§ "



1}

"i.'f.i) 'I'ec?'mz'c;r.:fz£ EXf.7€?f"i'i.S~3'£?

{I} A) 'WORK EXPERIENCIE: fer ]3;"e::":£::ii?':g;f  _

years;

{El'rz.cZ3s€ (3Xp€i"i(3i'2.Cé3 c:erf"i/'ii?zfz€:'é;:'_'j'%}r ;*1:?_.k'e:>_ '}:ci:;{é£--E.i:}§z.:

and £"2"cL:'1spor1ai'ioz't:»'  duly, " :3bt.;.zi'r'z{g;vi ﬁom: 

.Man{J;f?.C£c:?iur{3r/HaI'1dZir1§* 'ager1é"y.,f   Dept". /
PSU,/Public  {T{}'i'?:£:§}E;}"'E§/JV" *--J}'8?'}'1'  '%c£eé4lz'r:g in
ferr.iiz;izers. jE30dg}'f'<:i ﬁf:s if % simiiar" prod ucts
during the pregéedirigg Vz--.»'1&r=:3_(2"  fqj" which the
uaiuﬂ :1-:§O2?§l.?"&c:zr;%'£:"$}ﬁfi'L:E:i...:fz9i be less man
50%   "e£>;<§v_?Li:r£t:é1',}:%«:'i' '  (5,? presezrzt contract' (for
{1~?T13L£?Iif.;'f}Z%§'%;?/LS'_€  «'£.o----vJr3r(,{_<;s C!,CiU€3"§'iS(3IT1€T1fi with
:':j_espec :- '£':.:~«:jéﬂjé'$,g§Ovz:df2ig *°cert§re} in arty Gf {hose

£i':1"{;cé' g,V;ec:r*.3,V {§iE1é;,¢;}Es;é. mark experience will not be

_ _<;?0nséii;€;«'3:'(~3e<:zi}

  T3163 hf%:::z<7£..6.:f:.>r sizouid have-'3 t'3X€:"(f{£{é'-,'d. in the

:'Vz3'z:.m~?diaE€E;; precedirlg ﬁzz:-0 g;er:Lz"s; Eraszspert

 {:r::is%"e«f.;9a:f?z;33;"' 5.32.5 Eoiaf zicﬂue Qf" :42:-?2:'z::*?'z is :':c>¥'. 283$ z'f'Tea:":

5{}%_ "<4f)j'":'.§'z(»3r .:;z:zE:,ge Qf' :'§":.e <>{;s::£.:'::/1:754 25:: be {£55-(1¥"£1§£'f€§'

GI"

7§'§w Ei':3f':C§€i"O§" :;;E'20:,:.Z€i izavsg exe<.%;.z:)ed in 5.318
:'z:'::'z2g%::§iz2z.§3£§; _;}%'"E?{fé?::ii.i1§; mtg gears»; (mg; singie
{.i'{3_?'EE?"ti§{?f. §.§'Eé? E.}£2E.:.£{? 5:3,?" a..z.:§'z€<:?§'2 is; ;:.{>':''.' Eesfs §.'§':m':  {ff

E:'?':a% :ﬁ{2§i_.§.€? <33" ??'fi:e:% e:.?{:>z3.§:22:%f: is 3%,? s2.z.§.:n:::°€f§:?z:€, 



vaitm. of the <:<3};'3;irz1c?t'... 'i'13€r::f<3ré3, ;}r.irr13 "fi};::.i'6:,
resp<:a'r1ci<::'1t; N432 is quaEifiie_-"ecé 21$ per 'the w(:«1*}:. é%;s<;g3€;%:'i:3:{1f1<:é' ' H
at CE21:,1se TB, In me <2nt:.ire ss?'_:'¢1ifé3t£1£:5'r}.i.. of'. {i1::j.::::i.ic§:<1s}'."VA

il.I'1€1'f3: is; no re-:f€:re1'1ce t::3V {I516  :w_._.vé;*3ﬁk €xpe1*;£&:1V'1(:E;_ 

C0r.1taiI1ec1 in s:€I211.:s-:.<: IA' 'I'}1er<§fQ:*c._ it is'~<71_€5ai* C'1ga'2:1se 1A
provides fer WC}'I;'}i €x§::é';=icé:'}'c<:,<:{f "~'&;'é¥.1f1'é3 of 50% of the

value of the pre;.s:,_e11t: <é:mi:_fa;<:i:' 5.-:h,<;m'I'c'E 'h'2:iy-2%' been done in

 

21 3i:1g§Ee cc)_:13€;:'21r;"._. . 'TI'1"};;eeuVi,:)j£'§;1?IFgéiiitié of {he present
<::0r11;r'aCt. 153  L;1'kﬁ':%:I.,«-- fof it: is RS.252 lakhs.
'E'h<=:re§e;?}1"e,_ -'Ki 'Vse1i;;:;§Mi_ii>.1v§3__ --2m<:i to saiisfy the wcxrk

expe:*'i€'n{:'e 2:3 <E=<):ii..>3;it.1<§%:i in Ciaus-e 1A in (me ssingie

c:<3:1§::§?211::i*,. tzhe "a~.;:r;jii{:21:'_z€. .sh0t2Ic£ hax.-Tc a. work <-3x;3e:3*rie::1.::<=:

 :§;i1%::f:..vE{s.,252= Eaiahs. Aziiniimdiy, in the Eight: of

ga;§::EI'..&'E:_fV,"'EE%'VE§%Tg$:fi1{3:£:%::.'E-£1:){}\'7§3»§ in E1329: :~si':3ai.s::me:r1t: of <>'i33§z~_%.:az*,€;',i<:s:"::-:3, it 325

r:£:>§: é'h<=:4;~A <:é'11éé;e £3? ti'f§?.'lh€:f3' t:E";s*; W :°é;>s:;p<>ne.:i€:n':: or ihé 21*-E

:j».,:fi€;%s:%p;}§1.{i e3':t ihai; 2"" £"{'3f:3}}{)-'{1{§€£'§§' Saiisﬁes éjhér

2";:{;:.g§_:*:'&:21@:':is; }}r%?:s{:.:*iE3€%:§ £23 f;.h:% {iEa:.:ssé, €Z'ia.Lis;<»:: E53

::::.a._E<:<:%:i-; iii: wig":/" :%E£~:a2_:°, i:E":z'-3 °'=;'%""{}E"§i {?--x§:>st=r:*§:*:"%:&::§;*: viii} :":{>¥;: 'ix?

:i:<i2?:':s~sE£:§2%r$€.§,  if '{§T§{i' ;?s.;}g:;Ei:::2T:'§'2§ {E0 323?:  s:?.E2;a.:ss's:.=-:> Efi
3;:

    

 xx <'<? '§§a<?<s "



I')'i}1'ge::1::e Ce3:"€.§f'i{:e1t.e" issued by Es;1w:a.1' E{.ing--1g§f':€a*T :f:i3.4xA'
Cha1riie.reci1 Ac:c<>1.mi.am",s. {$16 is pmdu  V'
that thi-3 zxforesaid -.amt>ur:t: of <>i"~.  
21 smgie Com.ra<:E; wIqi(:h reacig 21$  ' 'H V'  
THE NANDI SAHAKARI  §i§11};xn4IT
KRISHNANAGAB,  l:J":F-SC:'"_; ﬂ}'F3IJAPUR~

The sza:em<<m.£" Show-:?_f": " ' L~S}'1;'e::: LT"§»{";z?'T.z:1"x'-sxia./1cr7"::' Goods
9 V  i_; J__
Transport' Co.,B§japLu" fiikgttrﬁ-E7,§é;3:§}r:V of Qyf.§*° F'acZ'ory during

the sea,s<::z'1 

 ,1' 20{3":?i«TE§"§§'"'" %

 vé:a«::9}ﬁ::€}:?:%§}:éé _ 
 2:72 } I;:..2{}€}'?*  AV '  '24€s4<} 2950 2:3§€)E§880e{>i}

' '-»D§,d. E a;=.:';: ..29%-..;§; 2£}{)5:}:{} 2%; . 50 L_s2a4 E ?34{:;.<,>{_:

..  §33:1?C.i::%zs::& g 4.j:«'§_3
T ':Zi{:':zﬁ::%3.:E.é.e€:=.
*  '~%1-'JWE-€>--%%.2€%€%?% 5G<'2:'><> ?2-':.:3<',2 :32-*:¢?*z?;,<2@{:s.{><;e

Work {)rdef' _V  Iﬂxpoﬁ     'Rate? Amount
N0.  _   
1331.6 A T  "

 ' - 29.50 "E4.5L:"E5"Z§ToG

6-4-2007

'. .

= ':25<3.o<3--.,LV :;»:s15<) 137,500.00 4E»).88€)" 29.50 E4,71,4~80.GO ' '>s>ﬁ«:: :%5,=-E9,:3:~36.®{} 9% II} 6,9'?,£§E38g{)C3 \ ik-.2 Ca'?

G'.

4%» Q N?

\.J"E 2384i} f;3?;€?§'§{} 'f.32§78{§ {)0 n ~§;LiEf§;.:

€T0mm':L%€:<3"' . V E3{}¢{§(} 12; £2': 1. éﬁi}. {K} ;,....4 ?f}{}{}{% Z?§}§. 58 :'§§'%4é?}2 2 :3{}{?.{§{} iZ.'3€[}{}i3 17$}. 73%} E 3.8? « ?3{}{}.€}f} <.3?W\'?3? §"'é'1*"'i'¥*sé s;a:5:§:5§§;;>§:;%%'?; ;?3£%€.}.2'}.3:¥%%.iEf'§ 3

-$1

- e.,.»»-' 241 and he is the <>:1Ey 21pp3.ic:zm1':: z"ema.i.:1i1'1g in 3 €()I}'€.i'£3.Ci' ttammt be directeci 1:0 be given €10j(,_1i'e%..uap}peE13.n$£-- ' also. This exercise which is to bef'A d,~:m_e 1'€3SpGI1d€I'1i'. over" 3.gz.1i;1 amid i:1_21<:c::>td2iﬁ(:e wi3.{?;,1:1\,£I. ';"'I0"W it is pointed out that: Clause }~»:x:s:. Ciause EB is ir2t.z*<3d11'eie_'{§i«-- 3.5%-'_ﬁVe1}ﬁés§:j1je;{.i<>1j of IA. The quesikm. cf iVg;1.'ppeilar1t in the light, 0? the 21150 would not ;'r.1I'j%,<T~f,f'f:J We deem it p1"<>pe1':g_§;<3._ 'e.:_1t'§I?e Eléfidtfﬁ' pr<><:es::-3 and 'the <:ea'ztract'.« §;»;i%fer:V'ﬁ':e .-é:;:Ii'1't-gee"4:"esp0r1u:ient. and direet: the 131 res§;§§;'r:_der1€. :0? ".";v~f¥T7i'{':{)I'1C}FTJ'{°£1i,(Z' the amendmem. pmperiy in _Vi;e::1<i<-3;'..vVé:§ec:1ment and eaii 'fez' freak tendere and. §;;r;g3;~.s3;~§V_f§;g3;:"_'g_§~e';:Vé:>pp<>:f%'17mi€;§ {'5} 21.11 Ehe: pers{>:1ss e<;~:1eem.ecE, f§I12ﬁi:§€ E.§1{f Eeneier .<:::1{i iihai; w<m.1cE meet: the ends; sf V. if ~32: S.-:;1",3;.::ee.

N 5?

P21r"£.i_e3.s in bear %::E1§?ir cm-'11 C.OS'§',S« A11 tha {Asa are'? mrciered it} be .fi1<;::e:i.

5%' vgh*/tn:/2*-*

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

M/S Gouri Enterprises vs The General Manager on 9 February, 2010

Bench: N.Kumar, B.V.Nagarathna