Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Raj Kumar vs Central Board Of Indirect Taxes A& ... on 2 May, 2023
i OA No, 302/202 CENTRALADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH, MUMBA! ORIGINAL APPLICATION No. 302/2023 Date of Decl sion: 62°° May, 2023. RAM ; JUSTICE M.G.SEWLIKR, MEMBER () DR. BHAGWAN SAHAIL MEMBER (4) rs, Presently Posted at: CGST, Th hane, "Mt , A LOL, Rendriva GST Parish Navi | Mum ibai- 4 1 0210 Mob, 8104558359 . Email- suptaraid | [email protected] 3. Vijay Singh Age 39 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai East, Residing At: 52/2133, CGS Colony, Sector 7 Antop Hill, , Mumbai- 400 037 Mot. 7506220334 . Emall- viiaysisodbiva@emall com 3, Amit Anand Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: PCCO, Mumpbat. Residing At: 52/2125, UGS Colony, Seetor 7 Antop Hill, , Mumbai- 400 037 Mob. 7903609936 : Email- amit 281290 @emailcom 4, Upendra Kamar Chaudhary Age 'y 39 ¥E ears, | Presenitly Posted at: COST, Andn-I, Residing at: 32/2005, CGS Co o olony, Sector 7 Antop Hill, , Mumibai- 400 037 Afob, FA03835983 th §, Jatin Kamar Age 37 years, Presently Posted at: PCCO, Mumbai zone Residing at: 52/2115, Sectar 7.CGS Colony Antop Hil, , Mumbai- 400 037 Mo- 9R060R6e44 , Email- [email protected] Se Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit-Ti Residing At: 56/2368, Sector 7 CGS Colony, Antop Hil, , 400 037 Mo- 8955052021 Ematl- sirpawanpatelemil oom "saat" Nee s 7. Akash Singh Age 32. years, Presently Posted at: CGS, Audit Raigad Residing At: 36/2353, Sector 7,.CGS Colony Antop] Hill, , Mumbar 460 037 Mo- 8108052157 Email- akashsingh4490q@iemail. com Sn & Vikash Kumar Bhagat Age 38 years, Presemily Posted at: CGST, Mumbai South: Residing Ab 32/2140, Sector 7,CGS Colony _Amtop Hill, , Mumbai- 400 037 Mob. 7488746474 9. Neeraj Kumar Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: POCO, Mumbai, Residing At: Sector 7,CGS Colony, Antop H aun 5 Maumbai- 460 0 03 Mob. 98903706002 A NM, ¥ ip SOL 2023 Antop Hill, , Mumbai- 400 037 Mo- 9769461209 Emvail- top 1 Odhirajé @gmail, com it, Rabul 'Singh Chauhan Residing At 2/03 7 "Sector 7 CGS Colony Antop Ha, , Mumbai 400 037 Mob. 7014694859 iz, DYnarmender Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit Raigad, Residing At: B-1302, Kendriya GST Parishar Kharghar, Navi Mumbai- 410210 Mob. 9729833791 13. Oinesh Kaira Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit Raigad Residing At: 1102, Vivant.A, Lodha, G B Road Bhayander, Thane West 400 618 Mo- 9013465483 id. Anand Pratap Singh Age 32 years, Present! iy Posted at? CGST, Audit Raigad Residing At: D- 103, SMIT CHS. Plot No. 9 Sector 33/H, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai 410 210 Mo- 9082863749 Email- [email protected] . iS. Amit Ranjan Age 32 years, 'Presently Posted at: CGST, Appeals-ITf Residuig Aty $2/2098, Sector CGS Coluny > > Antep Hil, , Mumbai- 400 037 Mo- 9122616225, O4 Ne - FO2°2023 4 Od No. 302/2023 Residing At: 32/2149, Seetar 7,CGS Colony Antop Hill, , Mumbai- 400 037 . Mob. 9907908837 Email- [email protected] Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai Central Residing At: 52/2144, Sector 7OGS Colony Antop Hill , Mumbai- 400 037 18. Mayank Gupta Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: CGST. Audit Thane, Residing At 47/1826, Sector 7.CGS Colony Antop Hill, Mumber 400 037, 18, Govind Kumar Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: COST, Mumbai Central Residing At: 56/2466, Sector 7,CGS Colony Antop Hill, Mumbai- 400 037. 20. Sandeep Kumar Tomar Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Bhiwandi Residing At: CGS Colony, Antop Hill, 2. Sundeep Chokkapu Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Bhiwandi Residing At COS Colony, Antop Ell, 22. Ajay Kumar Sharma Age 32 years, Presenily Posted at: COST, Bhiwandi Residin ie At CGS Col ony, mee ye Antop Hill, TR Toews. 3 ed aby COST, Bhavand woN ad Me Moe ke eres Is Antop Hill, Mumbai. 24, Madhur Tivari Age 34 years, Presen tly Posted at: DGGI, Bhopal Zone Residing At: Flat No.512 , Block A . Bhagwan Parisar, Near ANP College MISROAD, Bhopal- 462047 25.Archana Singk Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: DGGI, Bhopal Zone Residing At: Flat No. S12, Block A Bhagwan Parisar, Near RNP College MISROAD, Bhopal- 462047 26. Mehak Bhargava Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audil-IT], Mumbai Residing At: Thane, Basant Vihar 27. Rebit Shikara Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit-ll, Mumbai Residing At etendar Singh Negi Age 35 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai South Residing At: 49/1950, Sector 7 CGS, Colony, Antop Hill, Munmbai- 400 037, 29. Keshav Kumar Meena Age 29 vears, Presently Posted at. CGST, Mumbai South Residing At 49/1947, Sector 7 CGS, Colony, Antop Ail, Mumbai 400 037, - REALE, SO.Rajuesh Meena Od No sb? Prarie) Piety & Oo No 3Gen0s3 Mumbai- 400 037, 31. Rajanikanta Sahoo Age 31 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit, Nashik Residing At Flat No, 18, OME-AR Apartment, Parab Nagar, Indiranagar, Nashik, Maharashtra- 422 009 32. Harmeet Singh Age 35 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit Nashik, Residing At: Nashik. . 33.Sant Kumar Age 29 years, Presently Posted at: CGST Audit Nash i, Residing At: Nashik S34. Arpit Shrivastava Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Thane Residing At: Thane 35. Sanject oe 32. years ny 'Pe sted at: CGST Thane Age 3Ly years, Presently Posted at: CGST , Belpaur, Residing at: 1201, Tower A. Kendriya GST Parisar Khargar, Navi Mumbai. 37, Himanushs Vijayvargiya Age 35 years, Presently Posted at: CGST , Raigad Residing at: H-S02, Ashoka Geomatrin Sec- 25 , Ramothe Navi Mumbai w=} Vallabh Nagar, POMC, Pume- 411 O18. §, Binay Kumar Pandit Age a8 years, - Presently Posted at: CGST, Pune-Il, Residing At: Flat no.408, Dreams Savera Lohegaan, Pune- 411 047 48. Suject Kumar Age 32. years, Presently Po sted at: CGST, ae Pune-Il, R Residing Atv Ganesh Park iokegaon, Pane, 411047 S 4, Rakshit Shekeen Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST , Pune-Il, Residing Ab C-45, GST Bhavan, 'Residential Complex, Sasoon Road, Pume- 411 001 42, Manish Sumar yaday Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, ' Pune-H, Residing At: fat No. A605 » Aeronest Society, UDDAN- 411 060. 43. Geeta Gupta Age Si years, Presently Posted at: CGST Pune-l Residing At C-45, GST Bhavan, residential Complex, Sasoon Road, Pune- 411 G01. 44. Harshit Saini Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: DGGI, Pune Zone, Residing At Cé/24, Pleasant Park, Society Phase-2 Fattrna Nagar, Wanwadl, Pune- 411.013 $ Od No. 3022023 Residing At: 2" Floor, Jalgaon Niwas, Nigade Nagar, Kawade Road Pin 411 036. 46, Siddhartha Rawat Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: C GST Audit-Il, Pune, Residing At: C1/10, Pleasant Park Society Phase-2 Fatima Nagar, Wanwadl, Paone- 411 015 47. Vishant Kumar Nivala Age 31 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Audit-If, Pune Residing At GST Bhavan, Residential Complex, H/15, Sasoon Road, Pune- 411 001 48, Abhishek Leel Ape 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST , Audit- 1, Pune, Residing At 56/201, Future Tower, Amshore Park Town, Pune- 411 028. Fey 49, Asinvani Age 35 years, Presently Posted at: CGST , Pune-[, Residing At: Flat no, 20, H Building, GST Bhavan, Residential Complex. 4 oe Sascon Road, Pune- 411 001 56, Uday Kumar Yadav Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: Pune Customs, Residing At: Flat no. 05/ H building, GST Bhavan orb) Residential Complex, 414A, Sascon Road, Pune- 41] O01, Abhishek Annragise aS sted at: Pune Customs, ATI Fist mo, [4/4 x building, TOOK , ERY ees * Reside ial Camples &2. Anchal Arora Age 31 years, Presently Posted at: CGST Pune Residing At: G- S01, Annex Society, Pune- a: toe x > 3 one at 'years, a 4 2 Ee Mac eG -o ts we, <p o > + © --* ae) wy S4. Vivek Kumar Age 345 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Pune-Il. Residing At: Flat No.03, Gajnath Apartmer Hatgi Road, Solapur, Maharashtra- 413 003 Residing At 56 OGS, Colony, Ant Mumbai- 400 037. a 2 t% tA oD naw .s Right ~ md ¢ [eo bts pre ras oe os rs to . °F Ss cy i GO oa or ue po & rt a 2 iA 2 Presently Posted ab CGST, Navi Mumbai, Residing At: Kharghar, Navi Mumbai 458. Vikram Singh Age 35 years, Presently Posted a. CGST Navi Mumbai Residing At: Uhve, Navi Mumbai 59, Hari Mohan Meena Age _ years, siding At: -- nX ~ fy a" Si ' =a See SIO iQ O4 No 3022023 6&0. INnesh Chand Saini Age 29 years, Prese atly Posted at: CGST, Navi Mumbai, Residing At: Ube, Navi Mumbai asted at: poae Nav i Mi fumbal, Presently Po Po sted at: C GST, Appeals ~i .Maembei Residing At: 49/1954, Sector 7, COS Colony, Antop Hil, , Murnbai 400 037. §3. Pardeep Kumar Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai Central Residing At: New Panvel. tendra Kr. Mittal Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Appeals- 111, Residing / i: CGS, Anton Hill, , Mumbai A008 O37. Presently } Posted at: OGST, Appeals Raigad, Residing at: House No.08, Mona lisa Housing Society Lid. Secter 803 CBD Belapur 86, Ajay Singh Age 34 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Appeals Raigad Residing at: Plot no. 85, Flat No. 405, Aastha Avenue, See- 5, Ub ve, Navi Mumbai bey i O4 No Je 2023 Pre sently Posted at: CGST, Belapur IMD archid, Plot Na. 209 Flat no.203, Sector 23, Ulve Navi Mumbai. 59, Anu Agarwal Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Belapur, Residing at: The Springs CHS Ltd, 1202, A wing , 12" Floor,Roadpali, Panvel 70. Vishwas Tiwari Age 32 vears, Presently Posted at: DGGT, Mumbai, Residing At CGS, Colony, Antop Hill. 71. Rahul Bairwa Age 31 years, Presently Posted at: PCCO, Mumbai Residing At: 56/2336, CGS Colony, Antop Hill, 72, Rikesh Kuma Age 29 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Plaghar Residing At: 49/1974, Sector 7 CGS, Colony, Antop Hill. . Mumbai 400 037 Age 30 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Palghar Residing At-Fiat No, 302, A Wing, Bldg No. Vinay Raj Regency, Boisar 401501 we be 74, Satish Pandey Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Palghar, + Residing At: 56/2359, Sector 7, CGS, Colony, og OLR py rig ey BS yoo' Residing At: J 404, Old Sumit Regency, Green Dale Society, Virar- $07 303 78. Ved Prakash Meena Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: » COST, Palghar, Society, Vira 401 303 77, Preety Kumari Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Thane Rural Residing Ai: Ambernath 78. Ranvyince Kumar Age 35 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Thane Rural Residing At: ASO1, Vinavak Kondilkar Ar cade Badlapur, West, Thane- 421 501 79, Ankita Jain Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST Thane Rural Residing At: S01, 33 Imperial Heights, Opp. Dadoji Kondev Stadium, Thane (W)- 400 40} Age 33° years, Presently Posted at: COST, Mumbai West, Residing At: 47/1822, Sector 7,CGS Colony Antop Hill, Mumbai- 400 037. 81. Kuldeep Singh Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai West Residing At CGS, Antop Hu, 82, Manish Ker. Prajapati Age 34 years, Presently Posted at. RA: On Joan basis, Od No 02/2023 Residing At: COGS, Colony, Antop Hil, Mumbai 400 037, Presently Posted at: COST .Mumbat West Residing At: CGS Colony, Antop Hil, Mumbai 400 037. 84, Naveen Kumar Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: CGST Mumbai East Residing At 56/23 60, sector 7,CGS Colony Anton Hill, , Mumbai- 400 037, 85, Prashant Kumar Age 30 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai East Residing At: D-119, Ashwatha, Sector 4, CHS, Sonpada, Navi Mumbai- 400705. 86. Rika Backhuwan Age years, Presently Posted at: Residing At 87. Akash Parashar Age 31 years, Presently Posted at: CGST, Mumbai Central Residing At: CGS Colony, Antop Hill, Mumbai 406 037. 88. Nagendra Nr. Sharma Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: POCO, Mumbai, Residing At: 32/2147, Sector 7, CGS, Colony, Antop Hil, Mumbai- 400 037 89, Subha Sankar Chakraborty Age 50 years, Presently Posted at: POCO, Mumbai Residing At: Thane- 401 107 30. Pratyush Kumar Age 33 years, Presently Posted at: > CGST, Aurangabad, , G4 No S02) 2023 14 O4 Ne 3G22 $1. Shatlendra Singh Tomar ose 32 years, nily Posted at: : CGS im Aura nuabad Residing At Qtr Na, 32, Bldg Na. 6 GST and custom staff Colony N-T CIDCO) Colom, Aurangabad. 431 O03. a 92. Krishna Kumar Verma Age 34 vears, Presently Posted at: CGST, Aurangabad, Residing At: Qir No. 05, Bldg No. 1, COST and custom staff Colony, 6-1 CYOCO, Colony, Aurangabad- 431 003 ~ Piyush Singh Age 35 years, Presently Posted at: COST, Aurangabad Residing At: Otr No. 33, Bldg No. 6, ST and custom steff Colony, N-? CIDCO, Colony, Aurangebad- 434 003, $4, Lokesh Agrawal Age 32 years, Presently Posted at: DGTS, New Delhi, Residing At: flat- S-2, plot 743.4, Sectar 3 Vaishali, Gavtyabad 201 O10 98. Prateek kumar Age 30 years, Presently Posted at: DGTS, New Delhi, Residing At C-3/47 | Black- C, Sector 85, BPTP, Faridabad, Haryana 121 002 86. Ritesh Kumar Age 33 years, Presently Posted ati CGST, Audit-I Mumbai Residing At 52/2148, Sector 7, CGS Colony Antop Hill, , Mumbai- 400037. - Applicants Sy Adveeate Mr. Viciy Negrasn QA No. 3002/2023 Me ta i. Union of India through The Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Sauth Block, New Delhi ~ 110 001. rD . The Chairman, Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs, New Delhi --- 110 001. 3. The Chief Commissioner CGST. & Central Excise, Pune Zone, Pome ~ 411 O01. - Respondents ORDER(Orald)
Per : Justice M.G.Sewlikar, Member (J) ) MA Ne.402/2023 bas been filed by the applicant seeking permission to file the OA jointly. For the reasons sisted therein in the MA, the same is allowed. a Learned counsel for the applicants submits that the applicants have made the representations in respect of seniority. The representations are not yet decided by the respondents.
3. The applicants have contended that the respondents ms st + ayers bhew (Herexore, EAey 16> Od NO. 3022023 yet, three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order and communicate it to the applicants within a period of 8 5, it is made clear that we have not made any observation on the merits of the matter. &. With these directions, the Original Application is (Dn Bhagwan Saifad" (Justice M.G.SewKkar) Member (A) Member G3) qalte Ma.