Karnataka High Court
Bhimappa S/O Siddappa Madigar vs Mr Srinivas R Ghanti on 24 August, 2010
Author: A.S.Bopanna
Bench: A.S.Bopanna
"\ «»\~<m«»4v«»3nw.\i\'v¥v>$.'(».'V«%»'e'4.sk~)r}§o.\;»};§ Efi *§'§§E» Efifiii CQURE' Q? KARXQATAKA QERCEEET BEEESE fig'? §§'§.&RX§ZA§ aymg THIS THE 24%: 3.5;? $12' A!.}'fi~E3S'£_'f;,' é§§:';'3i[j= A. BEFQRE TEE £~£®N'BLE MR J§3ST§c§:,A;$;~;§ém.';%:§§gg"
E!LF.,A. §Ia§65§3.,f§'§%éA€'fs%V;§' BETWEEN; V' M Bhimappa S/0' Sglddappa Masiigar . .
figs: 30 years, Qc<,t.:a£:u':e3§:"iE<$E§gm*-_éi:*i%;5::" "
Rfzké Navaigatti,3.fI'q;3B_<::;l§.Ef£<:2;:3l;§:aE V B1's%=B6::Ega1,1:'1': " V " ;'£§'?ELLAF\§'E' {By Sm, '{~¥._j;1-.'<m<;E, Ad.vs._} AND:
3. 1a<§:_i; Srgmgvas §, {@m:m Fazgzé: Maggy, G<:::i"Bus§:r:esS . j':§%ga'.,%i_...%:~x:'g:~4_:49 " §{a_:':g:''a,E {%'.?aE_E2"_;,.'E'<:;. Eaiiharzgaé r §'i$'{, 8a:%E'g5;L¥;if:':
Iiéarzagar A 'U:r2i"ée;:§"§:zéia inauramce SQ. Lié. V. A E%:3;.;d,h§<righr:a Cgmjiiex E.§'?€a §_ETs'?E, ' " ES?-.A';*3'Eee{::", Efiaruié Gafiié, Baigaum V' 4 RESPQNQENYTS ' 'jj '{~B:J----§§°§» Laxmaa B. Ea/la;/sziaéaz' 5;: ?vEah€S§':§ Mars. 59; §:?,j; vs.~Aw«w«\«~£t/IAX mmmmmmmmvw\m\mw;mem§§;\gg: TEE!-S §vEFz% ES §'E'§fg€3§ 'Uf$ 2?3{E} G? E\zEE-T' £3? ;%{}A§NST THE JE}§GMEN'T' ANS fi,WARB BATED @E,%»'~%;2{¥®é Pz%SSES EN EVEVC E'%EO,,2En€'s5j2®@3 Sf? 'FE£E FELE i:m:, J%;Ji9<;;_E. (_SR.Bf?'€.} 85 Mamam, AB.D§2;._4'_&»E%§\g£;3'F§ BAELHQNGAL, P§;R'E"L":' A};LGW§f\1G ma cmiigi:--.PEf€:iE"--:{>T:;-_ ma CGMPENSATEGN £§N'D SEE}<.E.E\lG EmAzf~;;c ;::;:s'§:":,frx:*:f :">;:_+'%« SGZf\/'£PE§'s§SA'FI®E\E. TEES APPEAL CO?x»€ING- 0N°=%'C>§"'T'%{é:;a§%:--2§:a}V% Qfifi, 'TEE CGURE' §EL£\.fEREI} §<*f}§;§30E?v?V1:\§§'::V'_v_ &UBGM:'E%'E€;§ % A V "Q16 ciaimam H Seeking enhancemem of the Ehfi sum awarded in :';E"E4;§:e 'E'r'§%uz:a1 hafi awardeé {$33 <::§:*::gi%:§:.nsa3§i't>:"é'--57E
2. §~{*§a.1*d' :hi€.. §6a%::;§VVé33 Cémmsei for the payiébs 352$ gerused the 2ap_ps,a1 p3p:;??g.=._ __ '§'E*z e fa:j€§E'1.2%:.i:vthe céaimam hafi guffersd :1':j:,::*i.e3 €§*2é'v~%e::'a;':.1ééV$v*::;~%; ~--WEf:i§:§f24 sccurrasé an €;.§»2€}Q3 £3 31:33: in ' §é3;sé:';;é§ fiaiuzs sf izsjaszisss Sézffszéd E35; Zzhe ciaimam is '..,a'§30 e$ta'§:>Ei$h.$d béfarre ififi Triéuaai, Er: regpeci 0.1? "thé Said V' 4--.:?:3:;3Vé_;;::*é;beé"A_« 122$ d%sa'é3§§:j: Qsrtificatfi 3.: .z'~'~Jme:%<:':;r€ RES ax;-'gs x vxfizefi 3 2 § ,3 § § § 2* '.,v.5 preduced amii the giastar 23213 exam'§.3z$d as ?'%}J=f;:'. Cerisiésfiag {has iiééiiiffi 6%" the :"»*3{:€>ver3»-* 3'}::ad_c34.§:;};~*'.'4"éiZ%:;:3 cigimaz/it aftfir the §.n;?L2:j;' wivzicéa wag s'uf§€r§d,_.--%§§:é"
has Stated the di$ab1?E§t3; E9 {Em hmbg4:4@%;"'*§':z5~5E*:=;Vb:;::a3 after neticing the same and 3159 ta§~:i:*:g n:;§:e':;i"~t§ie'éé;1+:'§§%:*' cieaésézjn 32? this Cam": has §€c:E?i.§';~:.$d ':§*fi%: = L Eiencs, in that regard ihars is n{;..:%:i:*:<z:;;:*';--.__ 4, Wiih regard "{£;2' i{§*2€ Aflf1'5: '§"r§buna:E has mckeried the: $a.r::;}é at E'-?;'§s1V',V'§.V'i;%=Ci,-»'-_:' aiajgj in 221% ingiané a_u2:0:"§kshaw._iir;v';3:«V._3;1-mg"fig-....§;;c"1*':§ sfiighfijg Erégher incems {ham :":c%r::1a7'E__'<;z;Z?;i<§§3. 'Est; »--:'ié1':;:LE<§r2s§ far 'aha eihez' pssrserzs _."%a;e;he:'6..«.{:':@§i:mal"mmmss is iaiiarzj WEE} hairs {:3 be "<:_V@:":Sj:'<:-E§r'€.fi,'«.M '§«~§_é:"2§@§ ii is éakan 9;: Eg:E2%3;'w» per éaj; azié ms'-ap§r>:"€,>p:"i%fi;%A'?;;;}i1afitégiiez' is E'? The camgezzgaiéarz {gr 2:288 a:>fff§,3§tL::é ea:°::é::g 0:2 caiczflaéiszz basaé GET': the saié I pg;rs,:«:::e:a;~ $2-*s;::;.Ea' ha E"~is,?3,€w4%{}j'a Séncs {E16 Téébaiaiai hag .__"&;%;2.:-"aéifisd §s,i§?_,éQC%;'1 {ha céaimani 12$ aniiiéeé :9 gum of 3,;
;¥s«.'E.:'§}8<3;@§-- 12352555? the 332:? heagé. F'u2:i%:§:r it fig Sifiéffé iihrai the ameuni azararéed Linda? {he head {£1333 cf amsnifies fig an the Zewer side and as sueh a Eartha"
Rs.];€1QGCi;~» is awarded; Furtheix is sézsrécfafl umcier 53% siher heaés a :3u1<:::s._@f fig 'V awa:'éeé.
E5, Eencey {he €iai:rié£:§{~V..V_§n ta €1":haE'E.C€d compensatioig RST;3'5V;V:.8j:%<G;;-5'. v»»?§_.iibE1v.§.s..v;:0unded 9%' ':6 Rs,36,€%Q{}/» with rajie and manner ag 95$-'\;'é§.E7€: €€§_ 'bf é}5i€..:*§7ri'b§?i:1f1a§,";« Thfi enhanced amount 'Lt;-'i'5E*_;_ ér;{t§r3;f:i:asé::"s§1a.,_E§"'~':;;e .§j::p0sé:eQ by {he mgurance Campanjg x,X:§fi*a_ér: ':3; §§:'_%.{"::%:¥._ L:d?«six wfieks from {he daze of mfifiigt Q5 3. éapjy' %,§;*::;.f;S"~~z3r&e3: Q3: éepasitg {he erzfairfi:
..-v3_;f1':9*:,1§"':"%;4,sifr:?a:ES51 'fie §3iEfé§}V1_._,§i3_"$«:',*é. is ihéf séaimanta .4, i ,6, T' afiava abservaiéezfzss 'aha aggaaé siands :13"? ' ~= ~...._..._(,._ V:
M. *5 €i§S§z3:E$ :§4.
$ed,:f':T's?:é'~"{;r逧 33 :3 étfigfgs 'aw;
ww §'"';f§ Q-5;" ' 2;
W3