Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Jogendra Singh Rathore vs M/O Defence on 11 January, 2021
1 G4 Ne glee seGgen CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCH. MUMBAI ORIGINAL APPLICATION No.210/439/2020 Pate of Decision: 11° January, 2021 CORAM: RAVINDER KAUR, MEMBER i) Proceeding conducted through videovonferencing with the cansent of counsel for the applicants feeek ogendra Singh Rathore, MTS (Chowkidar}, Group C, aged 38 years, working in India Naval Hospital Ship, Asvinn, Colaba, Mior a and residing at Room Wo.3105, Bide. No.2 19, Seetor-O1, CGS Cotony, Rane Nagar, Antop Hil, Mumbai ' ae O37.
Mobile No FS0d202750, Exrail [dS bet Ashok Kumar Sah, MTS ¢Chowkidar}, Grenip C, aged 33 years, working In Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvin, Colaba, Mumbatand test idling at Room No.258, Bide. No.7, Seator -03, co GS Colony, Rane Nagar, Antoo Hill, Mumbai 48) 037, Mobile No. 8433634378, Email td: SahSids34izeraticom.
kasd Halas Girdhari SAW, MO YS (howkidar), Groep C, aged 33 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvind, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room: No.2o01, Bide. No.21i, Seetor02, CGS Colony, Rane Nagar, Antop eon Mumbai HE} O37.
Mobile No. 8G80 797487, Email id: Hulssee] G8"
4, Auvl Sata Cauda, MTS (Chunwkidar}, Group C, aged 38 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Murnbal and residing at Room No. 144, Bide. No.d4, Sector-07, CGS Catony, 5.M. Plot, Antop Hill, Murnbai 4{i) 037, Mobile No 8861048658, Email id: Goudganili [email protected].
5. Sachin Aran Tambat, MTS (Chowknla}, Group C. aged 30 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbaland residing at Room No.20s, B Wing, Saraswati Apartment, K Cac, Aweda Uran, Raigad, Pin 400 702, Mobile No. 8160317400, Email id: Stambs Herre som.
&, Ganesh Gori Dhumak, MTS (Chowkidar), Group C, aged 33 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvind, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room No.29s2, Bide. No2i3. Sector-i2, COGS Ce fons, Bane Nagar, Anton Hil, Mumibar 400 O37, Mabil e NO. 383013 S339, Email id: Dhumakeanesh 1235ci8 Subhash Geeridhar Chavan, Mis (Chowkidar: :
aged 40 years, working in Indian Naval B spinal Shin,
10.
en eae heed bad > 2 Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Raom No. 1698, Bide. No.44, Sectar-07, CGS Colony, 8. Flot, Antop Hil, Mumbai 400 037.
Mobile No. 8967037048, Email Id: Sc2T 16emailcom.
Manjunath Keer Naik, MTS (Chowkidar}, Garoap C, aged 36 years, working i in Indian Navas Hospital Shin, Asvini, Colab va, Mumbai and residing af Room Noa? Bide. No.23, Sector -- O07 C8 Colony, S.MLPhR, Antop Hil, Mamtbas 400 037. Mobile No.970264696 Email [d: ManiunathmanvidS gemall com.
Sunil Kumar Pal, MTS (Chowkidar}, Group C, aged 31 years, working In Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumba! and residing at C'o Parasnath vo.74, Uttaranch! chawl, Anand Nagar, Mirmbar~ 400 103.
Subhn Singh Chiriar, MTS (Chowknlar}, Group (2, aged 40 vears, working in Indian Naval H rrepaal Ship, Asvin, € olaba, Mumbai and residing at Room No. 1020, Bide. No.ath Sector ~ OF, CGS Colony, SM Phat, Aniop Hil, Mumbai ~ 400 O87, Mobile No. 8320833837 Email id- Sabhansinshsurjar oso @email.com Antarvami Arhin Sahoo, MTS (Chowhidar), Graup C, aged 34 vears, working in tadian > Navel Hospital Shin. ASV Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room Nad f23, Amtop Hill, Munvhar-- 400-037.
Mabile ho 9768002 $37 a Bmariid ~sabilsdhootiemmLecen & Wa, MIS (Chowkid ar}, Gran C, al Hegpital Ship, and t resid Rn ing at Roam No. ta, sehind ¥ T Bakery, Hariyall Village, Chandrakant Baiku Nimbalkar, MTS (Chowkidar), Group C, aged S7 years, working in Indian Nawal Hospital Ship, Asvint, Colaba, Minbar and residing at Room Nal? hs Vijay Nagar, Salt Pen Road, Near vithal Mandir, Antop Full, Wadala {Bast}, Mumibai~ 400 037 Mobile No. Seis eres.
z votlein ain indian Nav at Hospital : .
38, Mumbai and residing-al Room No.1 G2, Floor, Mahaveer Darshan Co. Suclety, Near Secondary ¥ High School, Nalasopara OW), Mabile No. S450985 404, < x x y ' x ' s y :
:
t t t :3 4
s i $ g s i $ 3 y t g i 3 y 3 sfegetecs ects asagslsgae line tacit A AAPOALERIDOLTLLALDERIAED DILDO GED O LADO SES s Swe pril Ashok Shivankar, MES (Chowkidarl, Group C, ved 32 ee working iy Indian Nawal Hospital Ship, Asvini, "Colaba, Mumbas and residing at Room Noa.t937, Bide. No. 213, Seot Antop Fill, M& ube Mobile No.792 Emall id-Shiva oT ao C GF S. Col ony, Kane Nagnr, Jansairam Tirkey, MTS € howkidar}, Group C, 8, working! in agian N Nz val Hi spe tal Shi tp, Ashtays Anh ak C 9, Hise , Society, Plot No. "5h Seawoods SOW) Navi Mamibai -- 400 706. Mobile No B833 048042 Emaildd ~ ashokoeminigtg@ensilcam Pandurang Raka Jadhav, Ex-MTS (Chowkidar}, Group C, aged 60 years, working in indian Naval H ospital PShip, Asvinl, Colaba, Mumbal and residing at Room No-765, Bide. No.25, Sector-07, CGS Colony, SM, Plot, Antop HU, Mumbai ~ 408) 037 Mobile No.9 869801029 Email d-Pat qduranujadhay LOG) Gemail.com Parmar Sudhir Pravin Kumar, Ex-MTS, (CHOWRIDAR), fam INAS Asvini, presently LDC, Group 'C', aged 34 years, working in CABS, Mumbai and residing af 49/50, Building 02, First Fleor, Gram Shup, Aaram Nagar, Old Fisheries, University Road, Seven Beaglows, Versova, Andheri (West), Mumbai -- 400 061, Mobile Ne. TOT? 4 885 87 Email {d-Sudhir.com,in@email SOM won Appleants {By Advacate Shri Al. Bhatkar} rod hat Persus The Union of India, Through 7 we ecretary, Ministry of Defence, th Block, New Drethi-~ 110 008, The Chief ofthe Naval Stal, integrated Headquarters Ministry of Defence (Navy), Yalkatara Annexe Building, New Delhi ~ 110.001.
The Flag Officer Commarnding-in-Chief, Heacauarters, Western Naval Coromand, Ballar Pier, Near Tiger Gate, Mumbai -- 400 004 The Commanding OfReer, fadian Naval Hospital Ship Asvini, Colaba, Munvhai ~ 400 UGS, aes Respondents we ES ® £4 9 aa I yet A iG 2 nn:
o Se oe 4 ae ed a 3 fa Seaey send ry 4 yO ie ' G he $53] i ta fe Ba
a) ort 3 < x3 us ch cx weg 2 es a Bo "% So 4 Ra re 4 : of : L Epa $. wie 4c ay ® ug uy 5 t 2 iH eed 4 g o vas ches & .
* Q he "4, o £3 ta itt a baa as ie eo) a tog oD ; 44 win, r ee 4 ne pod sod o ra fg 4 ba 4 feos o . ' rs) 8 eon ie ied & ot 8g B38 o, S . Hs 2 sd ee nd eh. bea aa mort , poe a. NO © fe cn i 43 wd BS Oy tea ra e id % a . ot ge Go. Ry % ot od aed ad #4, " 2 'i . baw ret St + ay As C5 Cd a fe) rz £3 ie t hy we Fe) a o 3 oy ey on Cc vA ei Fret as a " : Sg +3 a3 ved '3 Ma Os ue io . 83 ft, op vee$ bed i} wt ih ue ' ; a i wy i a he w OH OB ne Bs toed ' . " ik nh ¢ rans Cp ° ¢ noe Oy * i G ea ; ee ' % @ {3 et ¢t Oo Qo ad ba " ed cs - i 2 - 8 sad $i in oy . ot Ag 43 vet 42 ef ea rs 3 aed uy is ga sae ay Sa oe £3 m3 £3 ef 5 vel ae 3 i? Wy g a oe a og Y x Dh eS 4.2 o ae ot da ' * Os ved . ' > Be w Bai is oy try is a) . & $2, " £2 Y hha 43 iy at 4h a ' ts 2 3 e oe ry "3 ith % ' ae a oo wy Ad ye "ih @ BH ma 4 4 Ch oy 3} te v4 mn bt FR ore ra ts 3 ies a owt tat a 7 we 5 43 A * Ba $4 ef on on . wee yey 43 my a ved we 4 sy ¢ ai tH th £€ 5 24 wgh te 5 f+ 43 "4 Pa o : ah a 4 ne = S 9 aS , yey be 43 a * re 0G © 2 £3 es rt 5 re ze & o 6 g b gt % , : 4 % Be , oe as ee : 3 o i * uk i ved oy 3 23 cm wo m3 ida vel 4 4 by a wrk : Ta bo ty $f ed os B "5% es i . ~ a aed + 544 et va " C oh ' te 2 eG : a Bo as 6G ns a cst * et " 43 ere] 73 1 O os - od % os voce n s . ; eS se Pe yet go wen ee we om fe ' " a i bas A = 05 al a3 43 ay Me in ied "ot SS on he wt 43 , £1 aed o gS wa a " iS : 1s 6g ot } Jy 49 a 3 OEE - om fe 8 ei oS fa 3 if . et 13 43% 4 x ee is 43 Ly * 2 g ~ ah a iy wa os '
4. ¥en fot ¢ ' if ne oo . : ES a ws 1% ui t ee :
5 es ee Re my at vt ag y ~ % fe a : oo ge es M4 "et : ia bet % ny S Eo st aay " on a A Gi . 3 ie) 2 g a .. 4 ree. yt % fra $3 uf Pu me cs vag £24, é TS 2 6 % anh ab ws ae 33 zo ae my ae ie a " a5 Y i " 4 3 he ss ort :
ep) ord in vt x A, ie 5s ° fhe & rel a S aay ot ey! o 3 4 2 vA ' oh oy ne vE re aes 2 G eh, ged . cok : O of "4 oo ' oS . "A $4 Ys rc eB bet re a ' s KS & iv oe EN @ srt s 3 Goa i os eo a a we io ard et w rt we 5 ie sti AS s is 3 12 oo . os 2 +A ri "4 AS ' xed be 3 vet 4 $3 C5 C3 he at . a oy beh Xs ee 2 - uy > fh wed eh fe Rey cn cy ta nd Qy ee a" my Ls E Fa {6 ba iy = G 45 ® bt "CF mt tad ay
6 @ 42 veh ES cod gt oO oO hed aw w aw te % « "cd « Ba Bee ae . am 3 bt , £3 ay oo oo id CS 4 be be :
2 g * "a fied tee i 3 "4 @ $s % iz cf cs ty is Es © fon it 43 go o Cy a + 3 and ay 4 4 rs : ' i AG Ry td, wx uh A ad ty vo on?
a Abt or me 4 o a ie h o59] ics syd y Pe Se et , a " ' oh bee Y 4 bet th hoo ty 3 ity ' S4 o teh e o ee or v4 ft sy 3] a Bi 2 Bs S » £ a rie rhe gt $3 ed us + ved cect * 3 Oh On a 4 Cy, iF ded :
+ : beta : ean Ah, ae iB $4 14 his #5 god ted wD 5 a 5 .
4 a 2 * a i es Ww a o 1h . & Son AG {7 cot ood ¥ * A "4 "| 4 oh hi 4a a3 eo @ ty ary n " ce: o oe ¢ vet " ny 4 et wy w "
16 "4 4h "gh "3 & w : i a wo t i a on ie a th a e + ith on oo ea mi 54 43 te +3 go 63 op 42 . i " wD 3 ¥ :
ud Wg a ih Ld ¢ : go .
Mh * 4 ao so Sa ue dt ing 43 i ag ee ot ad @ Pi or) its if a eed a
4. es es wD ted ot 6 £ / £4 ot a 3 a4 itt rd go ods an bed £2 4 hs eh ted vot Be i a Ae a ts S wy 3 6 .
ma ih ie * ps a e% i oy iw 5