Delhi District Court
Criminal Case/278/1989 on 21 June, 2007
! "# $ %"!&' $ )(* + , "- . / 0(1 2 / 3 4 657 , $ 859 % "- :& $;6 =<->?5 $ @ A=&=5CBED/F-GHF I &E 3& 5KJML ;EL NO =P QSR ETULVTW< < QYXZP X =L [ \4R]XZ^EL ;)_` ;
QU&
acbed fhg!ikjlbVmon
p/qrpts'uwvogyxzb+{WgO| o}Z~z:Z
a ZdyCvhgyVbru8g1pts x p!j{?{ jpVpts'uwvog prss$gVhx g | Z} q e~ q rV+ axrd vhg#+bVygyprs/uvhgyx pVVmb!j+bVKu4js b-r | f-uqeVij{ v-hbo bVKuj a!d+ vhg#+bVygyprs/uvhgbhx xoo{?g+hg!i {Wp!e bVhvVj{+b-igVru8b+ -gybVhi gZ{ jeg!hx gE| ¡ &C =L [ \3R]XZ^EL ;
/G:A¢JW^EL ;E£=P7 R;E¤=^ G8A9 ,¥§¦k¨ ¨-%©hJS<!<Vª1LC;« L QSNe© ¬< ^ R2& B§& =QLCNZL XZ^* ^EL ;E£ /G:A9 ¬<!< ®O ^EL ;E£ G8A ¯ ¥§¦kIC°+± ²h^ A/A E ,AEL/£C© ,TSTUL [ L/¤ L QY© ¬< ^ R2& ag-d+Cvhgyprss$gVhx gyx p!VmlbVj³hg+´pts | µ {%¶e¶ ~z ¶ Zz ¶ }Z· ¶ ~/?oeV¸*¹.º » a]sd+ vhg#VmgZb1prs/uvhgbhx xoo{?g+#bVhvVj{ gt¼ebVj³+brujp!´aCjs b-rVdk| º mgebh-g+ opou§ /-j½m¾u$´¿ xomlbVj³ygZ1uijb!m½q a !d+ vhgÀsHj³+bVm Á%i -g!i| §xzÃ'Vj¾u$uHbVm a vZd+ vhg1Vbtu:gyprs {·hxtvp!i -gViY| E q Z} q e+-~ J? ¬ (* 3 @5¦ q ¸ ikjgrs4ig+{ egprs uvhgs$b+xÄu8{ptsEuwvhgxzb+{Wgprs4-i pZ{WgZxtruwjpVj{ uwvhbtu,p!#pVi hgrs$pVig - q eÅ q tVh b+x xth{WgZ ÆVb- !j{·v+b-v+bh g!Ku8gVig+*jru8pp!i -hpV -i p!og!icu » p!Ku8 q]qÇq]q]qÇq]q j³«hp+{?{WgZ{W{ jpV7prs¬sHj³i {Èu j³zs$p!iH´b-ru x p!VmlbVj³+b-ru Vij{ v-hbo bVKuj º mptu hp'q§¶ j³ ¸ mp+xtÉ ¸ ÊbV+b-É º -ikj§Á m' hgeb-i Ë3j³m½mb+ -g ¸ jhVb---i8 ºoº«Ì bh{Èu¢µ!u uHb- n§bh Vb-iH º f Ê:b-+b-É º -ikj3j¾uwv`j³ru:g!ruÀu:p@x pVj¾u¢b-Íprss$gVhx g@prsÎxtijj³hb!mCuwi gZ{·+bh{?{*bVo pVi b--hptebVhx gÏu8p {ÄbVj hp+{?{WgZ{W{Wp!i)pts)-ipVhgVi2u$ bVh b!m{?p {Èu8bVicu8g+ -rÐb-ru8g+ x p!o{ÈuikhxÄuwjpVyuwvhgVig)jyuwvhgOVmptuÑbVo bh{¢i gZ{·hpVh{zjVmg s$pVi§uvhg {?b!j xovhbVh eg*j³ uwvog0eipVhgVi2u$ÒbrsÓs$gZxÄuwj³h Ôj¾uj³ÄÕ -ijp!o{zmÒbVoÖuwvog×{?bVjØx pVh{ÙuwiHhxÄujpVÚx pVVmÛhptu v+brÜZg9ogZgV9-h-pVhg juwvhpVru {·hg!oEj³h )bVyp!-KuÝgt¼Zxzg+g+Ej³h ÞÆe{Kq ÅZ ß vVjxtv b+xÄu b+{{?p -pVhgOrb+x xth{WgZ juwvOjru8gVru,u:pxzbVo{?g pVi ÉKhphj³o uwv+bruÝj¾u j{m½jÉ·g!m¾´u8p xzbVo{?gàuwvogá{?b!j@mp+{W{pVi%-bVb+ -g7u8pàuwvog -i p!og!icu /q Â=x xth{WgZ º i:b-É bh{ v » vhbVh bVmpVh Zj¾uwv x p ß bhxzxth{Wg+ f+bVvVj f!jh /v a{ j³hx g go¼!-j³i gZ'd v+bh b!m³mg+ -g+Em¾ j³Ku8gVrujp!+bVm½m±b!j-gZ±uwvog±bhxzxth{Wg+âÆVb- !j{ v+b-Òb-h p!iOjh{Ùuj -btu:gZÏvVj u8p gVru8gViãj³Ku8p pViâ-hpV bVopoÜZg+{ÄbVj -i pVhg!icu b-h xzpVj¾u$u8g+ prss$gVhx g pts b-hgougVru§prs:tuwi g+{ +bh{W{ÐbVo j{WxtvVjgrskq q Â=x xth{WgZ gVig*b-iki gZ{Ùu8g+7b-h)gVVmlb-i -gZàp!)hb!j³mq6Á%Ox p!Vmgtujp!Oprs j³KÜZgZ{Ùuj VbtuwjpVxtv+b-i eg{·vhgZgtu§Ðbh{ sHj½mgZ q » pVVjg+{ %gVig´{·--Vm³jg+´u8p1uvhg#b+x xth{WgZ q fVj³hx gObhxzxth{Wg+7fZb-vVj fVj³h 'vgt¼!Vj³i g+'=eip+x gZg+Ej³o -{äb+ -b!jh{Èu vVj %g!i gOb-+btu:gZ Ü'jeg6pVi -g!i¬Vbtu:gZ E q e q eZZ} qÒn pouwjx g*s$pVi uwvhg9prss$gVhx gZ{ --Vj{ vhbVVmg -h-gVi fhgZxÄujp!o{à¶-¶ ~Ò¹.º » b-hÚ¶ V~Ò¹.º » bh{Os8ibVygZÚbh VbVj³h{Ùu1bhxzxth{Wg+ÛÆ-bV !j{ v+b- b-háv-j½mg9{Wg!hbVibtu:g@n ptujx g)s$p!i prss$gVhx g -o-g!i {?g+xÄujp!à¶-¶ ~ ¹.º » i rZå¹.º » b-h¶ -~ i tZO¹.º » b+{ s8ibVygZb+ -b!jh{Èu bhxzxth{Wg+ º ibVÉ·b+{·v » v+b-h'hu8py vVjxtv uwvogohptuwv´VmgZbh-gZhptu§ /Vj³m¾u$´b-h´xomlbVj³g+1uwikjlbVmq æ q /pyx p!-ogZxÄu uwvogb+x xth{WgZyj¾uväuvhgyprss$gVhx gbVm½mg+ -g+1uwvhgeip+{?g+xtrujp! » p!Ku8 q]qÇq]q]qÇq]q æ gt¼ebVj³hg+ {WgtÜZg! juwhg+{W{?g+{ j b!m³m¢+b-g!m¾ fVv!qtfVvVjÜ ZbVib- bh{ ºÄç f-v!q3n jlbh-gVi fVj³h 'v«b+{ ºÄç* fVv!q f+bru eb º ib-É bh{ v«bh{ ºÄç æ 4f-v!q,f!q3'q/Ë=gVikbábh{ ºÄç ¶' è » Ë4j³hp+7bh{ ºÄçàÅ ¹ h{·hg+xéu:p!i4Á% º i:b-É bh{·v bh{ ºÄç } bVo ¹ h{·hgZxÄu:p!i ÆVb- fVj³h /v1bh{ ºÄçà~ q ¶ q êépVi4Ðb-ru ptsÑj³oxoikj³j³+brujh «btu:g!ikjlbVmVhp'jrujh u8poÐb-ie{Àuvhg /Vj³m¾u pts uwvogÚb+x xth{WgZ! go¼eb-j+brujpVÍprs uwvhgÚbhx xth{?g+±-h-gViÎf+g+xÄujpV æ æ » iq º q » bh{ Ej{ hgVh{WgZyj¾uv!q Å q ¹ v+brÜZg vogeb-iuvhg{·--j{W{zjp!o{ prsCuwvhg ë?Eqy ºoº b-huvhgx pV-h{Wg'mzs2p!i º ibVÉ·b+{·v » v+bVoÒb-h×bhxzxth{Wg+ÛÆ-bV !j{ v+b-ÖvVj³y{?g!msÀb-h±v+brÜZgÒhgVikh{Wg+`uvhg xzb+{WgäsHj³mg'q } q ºÄç6 f-vVj¾ÜØZbVib-åeg!hp+{WgZÖprsähg!j³h `j¾uwogZ{W{ u8påì º Â Ì ¼/q ºÄç Ä Â gt¼ZgZxtru:gZÒKåb+x xth{WgZ×f+bVvVj fVj³h /vÍbVh º q » q4ì -KuHbÚj³ís brÜZp!-i prs b+x xth{WgZ ÆVb- !j{·v+b-yb-h#bh /ig+gVgVru u8py{Wg!m½m Ì ¼/q ºÄç9ĸ q ~ q ºÄç* n jlbh-gVi fVj³h /v -g!opZ{WgZ9prsÝhg!j³h 9gt¼ZgZxtru8bVKuÝprs¬{?bVmg)-g+g+ Ì ¼/q ºÄç*z  q q ºÄç æ f-v!q f+btu$eb º ib-É bh{ v -g!opZ{WgZ uv+bru vVj{ ptuwvhgVi fV¢uYq Vij{ ve+bo b-rujî3xzpV-mlbVj³+b-ru¢v+bh@gt¼!Vj³i g+ÚbVoÖvhgÍbVm{WpÞ-gVhp+{?g+Þuv+bruÎ'-ijh j³KÜZgZ{Ùuj VbtuwjpV*vogO b+{ j¾uhg+{?{u:p*{Wg'jðïzeigàyg!yp Ì ¼/q ºÄç æ ÂÍprs=uvhg*{?bVmg -g+gZ b-hig+x g'jru§{?g!jï?g+ K ¹ ÁÐq » p!Ku8 q]qÇq]q]qÇq]q ¶ q ºÄç ¶Øj{uwvogÖµ§ñ » s8i pV prssHjx g@prs f-- ß ÆegZ Ej{Èui:b-i8 vhpå-i p!o /vru uvhg pVij Ej³+bVm {?b!mgá-g+g+' x pVr Ì ¼/q ºÄç K ÂÚs8ipV uvhgáprssHjxzg«ptsÝuvhgíf-- ß ÆegZ Ej{Èui:b-i8 Zb+{·v-j³ikj ìÑbru8g-!ñ,g!m³vVj½q t q ºÄçàÅ è » Ë4j³hp+òV-bVi1bhx xzpVhbVVjgZ ¹Á j³Øj³rÜZg+{Ùuj -btuwjpVÖb-hòj{ j¾uwogZ{W{ u:p uwvogåb-iki g+{ÈuäbVh±hgVi {?pV+bVm,{Wgeb-ixtv@prs b+x xth{WgZåxzpVh/oxéu:gZ×b-h`prs pVruHbVj³Vjh ´pts {·hg+xhjgV{zj /+bruw-i gZ{%pts'uwvogb+x xth{WgZr ¹ ÁÐq
- q ºÄç*} -g!opZ{WgZ´prs§v+btÜ'jh ´x p'm³mg+xéu:gZ1uvhgê·fVëi g+{ VmuYq o q ºÄçà~ j{ jrÜZg+{Èuwj Vbrujh prssHjxzgVi8ovopOjru8gVi bVm½jb#-i g!+b-i gZ{zju8gVmbV Ì ¼/q ºÄçà~ ÂØb-h«xzpVh/oxéu:gZÍhgVi{Wp!hb!m!{Wgeb-i xov)pts b+x xth{WgZábVoá{Wg'jðïÄg+9-pZxt-yg!Ku8{ hg+{zj-g+{·Vi g+xzpVi Ej³h 1uvhgy{ÙuHbru8gVgVru§pts/j¾uhgZ{W{WgZ{zq æ q êKi pV gVrujigÖgtÜ'j-gVhx g`pVØi gZx pViÛhpÍs bhxÄuvhb+{«ogZgVØ-i pVh /vruyp! i gZx pVip!i -i poÜZg+prs§bhx xth{?g+*Æ-bV !j{·v+b-g!j¾uwvog!i v+brÜ'j³h x p!j¾u$u8g+ xtijj³hb!m uwi g+{ +bh{W{âp!i j{?xtvVjgtsÞb-h bhx xoo{?g+ º i:b-É bh{ v » v+bVo-g!iÞg'juwvhgViÍx p!ju u8g+ b-hgougVru,ptsCptss2g!hx g´prs xtikj³j³+bVm uig+{·+b+{W{ p!i j{Wxov-jgrskq´fZbVmg1-gZg+ Ì ¼/q ºÄç K  sHjh-{ yg!KujpV6prs btÜZgVikyg!Ku pts eipVhgVi2u$Í{Wp'm`j³6Ã/hg+{ÙujpV6prs ¸ mp+xoÉ ß8¸ ÊbVhbVÉrj º -ikj !vhb+{·i:b hp'q ¶ vhbtÜ'jh -g+{?xtikj³ruwjpV#pts§uwvhgO-i p!hgVicu hpV-h-g+Ob+{ n§pVicuwv º mptu¬hp'qZ¶ !f+pVruwv ß Æ-pZb+' Ì bh{Èu ß Æepebh e êWuYqebVo ç g+{Èu ß Æepebh æ êWuYq]qä vhgì º Â Ì ¼/q ºÄç Ä Â sHj³he{gVrujp!ypts'uvhg-i p!og!icu OjÃ/hg+{ÈuwjpVuwvog!i g'jÀu8phg¢uvhgVmpou pVru pts Vv+bh{·i:b)hp'q ¶ ¶ VÅ/ b-h VÅe b-h9j{hpV-h-g+ bh{ Ì b+{Ùu=óÆ-pZb+! n p!icuwv º bh{?{?b+ eg Æepebh'Efhp!ruvÁ3uvhgViô{mlb-h*brsu8gVi t ô+ì b!m³jeb-h ç g+{Èu ßѺ mptu hp'q » p!Ku8 q]qÇq]q]qÇq]q Å ¶ q7 vhgà-gZ{Wxtijrujp!*prs4uwvhg«-mptu j³9hptuwvàbVopoÜZg)epZxt-yg!ru:{j{1Ejss2g!i g!Ku Ã/+b uwvog egZ{Wxtijrujp!ypts'uwvog-i p!hgVicujg+{ { j¾u+btu:gZp!#ju8{@s$pV-iC{ j-g+{Ðb-h -ikj³h -{j³ru:p m½j /vru«uwvhg s bhxéuÞpts)uwvhg -i p!hgVicu j³ Ã/hg+{ÈuwjpV j³ uvhg+{?g -p+xoegVru8{±u8p hg Ejõss$gVigVruYqäCvhg!i ghg!j³h Ohp´pZxtVmbVi§gtÜ'j-gVhx gpVi gZx pVipts=prss$gVhx g´ptsEuwi gZ{·+bh{?{ pVi6j{WxtvVjgrs6v+brÜ'j³h hgZgV x p!ju u8g+ rÏuwvhg b+x xth{WgZ p!iáj¾u8{×b-hgtuwgVru v+brÜ'j³h ×hgZgVáxzpVj¾u$u8g+ÒrÞuwvogåbhx xoo{?g+' j³«uwvhgÚ-i gZ{Wg!Kuä{Wgou prs s bhxéu:{·4uwvog -i pZ{Wg+xoKujpV v+b+{×s$b!j³mg+ u:p -iptÜZg j¾u:{0xzb+{Wg b+ -b!jh{Èuàuwvhg bhx xoo{?g+ ogoZpVh i gebh{?pV+b-VmgÏ-p!eruYq Â=x xth{?g+ bVi g vhg!m hptu* /Vj³m¾u$ bVo bhx Ã/Vju u8g+òs$pViuwvhg prss$gVhx gZ{`xtv+b-i -gZEq ¸ b!j³mÎhpVh-{`prs#uwvhgãbhx xth{?g+ãb-igÏxKb-hx g!m½mg+ bVoâuvhg!j³i {·-igtujgZ{%Ej{Wxtv+bVi -g+ q êKj½mghgyx pVh{zj /hg+1u8p¢uvhgi gZx pVii pZpV q ö P QH÷§R;E£ < Q% LC/ RÓ; ¤=^ ø £ £=c&O ^ Rù<e>Ð(<eTéQAC®'A R³TUL ;6(LE¤=R]X TéQLVTU<'© ,AC^§RÓ;§R]© ¬< ^ R2& =QwA ;EA P ; ²K<'£6R;T·^E< A ®'< ;*²rA P QHTÐA ;
T·^ R]X B ¡+ú]û ¬LVüàAV>CJUP§;E<'©íB'ý/ý D & » p!Ku8 q]qÇq]q]qÇq]q