Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Krishna Kant Mishra vs M/O Railways on 12 May, 2023
1
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI
O.A. No. 1436/2023
M.A. No. 1652/2023
In
M.A. No. 2749/2021
This the 12th day of May, 2023
Hon'ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A)
1. Krishna Kant Mishra
S/o Late Badri Narayan Mishra
OS/TMC
Qy.CE/TME/L/NDLS
Address: A-264, Gali No. 5
North West, Vinod Nagar,
Delhi- 110092
2. Bindo Kumar
S/o Amrit Lal Prasad
JE/P.WAY/NDLS
Address: 139/G, Railway Colony
Paharganj, New Delhi- 110055
3. Ganesh Mehta
S/o Basudeo Mehta
SSE/P-Way/GZB
Q. No. 427A, Arya Nagar,
Railway Colony, Ghaziabad
4. Dharmendra Kumar Singh
S/o Suresh Paswan
SSE/PwWay/NDLS
Address: V-258, Gandhi Colony,
Faridabad
5. Muksh Kumar
S/o RaghunandanPandit
Treckman under SSE/P.Way/JHL
Address: Quanter No.L-11
Railway Colony, JakhaolJhi,
Dist.-Fatehabad (Haryana)
6. Chandra Prakash Singh
S/o Sh. Ram Lakhan Singh
2
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Trackman under SSE/P-Way/Mansa
Address: Railway Quarter No.T-7,
Railway Colony, Budhlada,
Distt. Mansa (Pb)
7. Ravish Singh
S/o Late Chandrika Singh
JE/Hort./NDLS
Address: A-41, Shyam Park Extension
Sahibabad, Ghaziabad, U.P.
8. Saroj Singh
S/o Suggan Singh
Mate/P-Way/KKDE (DHLM)
Address: G-30, Quarter No.B,
Railway Colony (SHDM),
Sahabad, KKDE
9. Murli Kumar
S/o Ram Bahadur Singh
At:- Chakhusaihe, P.O. Mansi, Ward No. 4,
Distt:- Khajaria (Bihar),
Pin- 851214
Designation: Tech.-III/TMC
10. Santosh Kumar
S/o Sh. Shankar Kumar
Address: A-98/C, Raja Vihar,
Badli Industries Area,
SamaypurBadli, Delhi- 110042
Designation: Tech-III/TMC/NR
11. Sunil Kumar
S/o Shri Satya Deo Prasad
At+PO: Madhuraapur
Via-Barharawa, Distt.
Sitamarhi (Bihar), Pin- 843315
Designation- Tech-III/TMC
12. Rajiv Ranjan
S/o Sh. Arjun Kumar
House No. HR 21-A, 2nd Floor,
New Sharma Market,
PulPrahaladpur, Badarpur,
New Delhi- 110044
13. Pradeep Kumar
S/o Sh. Narendra Singh
3
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Moh:- BishnoiNagr
Tehsil Nagina, District Binjor (U.P.)
Pin 246762
14. Benktesh Kumar Pandey
S/o Shri Niwas Pandey
Village- Kaupa, Post-Sakla,
District-Rohtas (Bihar)
Desig.: Tech-III, M/C-UTR-
2001 NR
Pin- 802205
15. GopiBhagat
S/0 Late Sh. YogendraBhagat
Quarter No. 176, D1, Railway Colony,
Basant Lane, Paharganj, Nw
Delhi
Pine Code-110055
District-Central Delhi
Aadhar No.25161864418511
16. Sh. Ramakant Kumar
S/o Bishehwar Paswan
Quarter No.1318, Gandhi Colony,
Faridabad, NIT Faridabad (Haryana)
Pine Code-121001
Aadhar No.828475477872
17. Brij Kumar Singh
S/o Late Sh. Ram Kumar Singh
Quarter No.E/67A, Railway Colony Rohtak
Posting Place: Aden/Rohtak
Aadhar No.673533653837
18. Mukesh Kumar Singh
S/o Shaligram Singh
Village: Baniya, Post: Bhavanipur,
P.S. Gopal Pur, Distict:
Bhangapur
Aadhar No.751459946053
Headquarter: Varanasi
19. Sanjay Kumar Singh
S/o Sh. Mahavir Prasad Singh
Village: Amarpur, P.S.
Kahalgoam,
District-Bhagalpur (Bihar)
Pin No.813204
4
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Designation: Tech-III (Varanasi H.Q.)
Aadhar No.459229071371
20. Manoj Kumar
S/o Shri Yugeshwar Sinha
Village: Sarika, Post: Lodipur,
Vaya+Dist.: Sheikhpura (Bihar),
Pin-811105
Designation: Trackman (USFD)
Aadhar No.440372932545
21. Hari Nivas Dubey,
S/o Ram Shiromani Dubey
Village: Baghapur, P.O.
Bankati,
District: Basti (U.P.)
Desig: JE/P Way/PNP, HQ- Panipat
Aadhar No.260469508469
22. Raghvendra Kumar Singh
S/o Ram Naresh Pd. Singh
Village: Braini, P.O. Nekpur
Via: Rajgir (Nalanda)
Designation: Tech-III, TMC
HQ-NDLS
Aadhar No.666036673628
23. Bhola Singh
S/o Sh. Harnke Singh
Address: Ward No.7, House No.56,
Near Pinglwara, Shiv Sunder
Puri Road, Budhlada, Distt.
Mansa
Trackman: Under SSE/P
Way/JHL
Aadhar No.518485090012
24. Vinit Kumar
S/o Amrit Singh
Trackman SSEPP Way/DL
Address: 56A, Krishan Vihar,
New Delhi
25. Anil Mumar
S/o Shri RamchandraMahto
Address: D-210, Nandgram,
Ghaziabad
Designation: OS/TMC,
5
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Under Dy.CE/TMC/L/NDSL
Aadhar No.931965134766
26. Yatendra Kumar Sharma
S/o Shri Prakash Chandra Sharma
Address: House No.313,
Kumharapada, Goverdhan
Gate, Vrindaran, Bangar,
Mathura-281121
Designation: JE/TMC under
DYCE/TMCIL/NDLS
Aadhar No.960457065208
27. Sunil Kumar
S/o Sh. Rohan Mahto
Designation: HD TTE/NDLS
New Delhi Rly Station
Address: 871 + Aram Bagit,
Paharganj, New Delhi- 110055
Aadhar No.644244233462
28. Ramesh Kumar,
S/o Raja Ram Mahto
Railway Station Golchwala,
Firozpur Division, N.R.
Village: RampurwaChapariaTola,
Post: Mainetang, Dist: West
Champaran, Bihar
AadhdarNo.303898511194
29. Sudhir Prasad
S/o Late Shri BindeshwariPrashad
Designation: Station Master
Station: Kandaghat
(UMB/Divn.)
T/5B, Railway Colony.
Kandaghat, Distt: Solan,
Himachal Pradesh
30. Jitendra Kumar Nirala
S/o Shri Ballan Singh
Designation: Tech.-III (TMC-
Track Machine N.R.)
Station: LKO (Division) H.Q.
BSB
MIC No.WST-49
Village: PritamBigha, P.O.
Jagirdari,
6
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Via: Bandhuganj, Distt:
Jehanabad,
Bihar-804432
Aadhar No.845508668438
31. Santosh Kumar
S/o Shri Chandra Mohan Prasad
Designation: Technician-III
(Track Machinerry), HoD-
Luckow (N.R.)
M/c No.09-3Y-3971
Vill: KoyariBigha, Post- Giriyak,
Distt: Nalanda, Bihar- 803109
Aadhar No.696116171833
32. Aman Kumar Akash
S/o Shri Dhaneshwar Prasad
Designation: Tech.III (TMC)
H.Q. NDLC, M/c: BCM702,
P.A. Village Banshipur, P.O.
Arma,
Via: Kajra, Distt.: Lakhisarai,
Bihar-811309
Aadhara No.493668631489
33. Dharmendra Kumar
S/o Shri Jagat Pal
Designation: Tech-11
Village: Sitapur,
Post- Khajuha,
Distt: Fatehpur-212657, (U.P.)
Aadhar No.427830092034
34. Sanjay Kumar
S/o Late ChhavinathRajak
Designation: SSE/TMC,
PF No.503HQ000130
Village: Sunderpur,
P.O.+P.S. Pirpanti
Distt.: Bhagalpur-813209,
Bihar
Aadhar No.569469143398
35. Sunil Kumar Pandey
S/o Kesho Pandey,
Designation: Tech. III
Village: Bharkuria, P.O.
Sakla (Bazar),
7
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Distt: Rohtas-802205,
Bihar)
Mobile No.9812200159
36. ArbindRajak
S/o Late Shiv Baitha D
Designation: SSE/TMC
PF No.503HQ000124
Block No.133/C, Double Storey
Railway Colony, Kurukshetra,
Distt.: Kurukshetra-136118,
(Haryana)
Aadhar No.657707230882
37. Kuber Pal
S/o Shri Khushihal Pal
R. No.E9 A/c Rly. Colony
BGZ
Designation: Trackman
Aadhar No.906022978329
38. Munna Lal
S/o Sh. Bhullar Kushwaha
T.9-B, Railway Colony,
Kartarpur
Designation: Station Master
(FZR)
Aadhar No.729513852680
39. Murari Kumar
S/o Shri Gajendra Prasad
T-5B, Railway Colony,
Suridwan, Sant Ravi Das Nagar
Designation: Station Master
(N.R.) LKO
Aadhar No.873162291894
40. Md. Nesar Rehmat
S/o Md. Iftekhar
Designation.: Station Master
(LKO Div. NR), First Joining
Trackman under Aden
Rohtak
Address: Main Road, Old
Town, Ward No.9, Old Town,
Daudnagar, Distt.: Aurngabad, Bihar-824143
Correspondence Address:
Railway Colony, Parsipur
8
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
(PRF), Bhadohi
Aadhar No.596130391085
41. Jeetendra Kuma
S/o Si Socha Ram
Station Master
Vyasnagar (N.R.) LKO Div.
Village: Sripalpur, Post: Lalgang,
District: Ballia-277216 (U.P.)
Aadhar No.403888191158
42. Vinay Kumar Singh
S/o Shri Bhagwar Prasad Singh
Station Maser, PrayagGhat
(Pyg)/NR/LKO Div.
Address: 22 M, Prem Nagar,
Maini, Allahabad-211008
(U.P.)
Aadhar No.223868828324
43. Sanjeev Kumar
S/o Late Dinesh Singh
Tech-III, TMC NDLS
Address: In front of Electric Colony,
Sheikhpura-811105 (Bihar)
Aadhar No.422329767502
44. Sanjay Kumar
S/o Sh. Karu Ram,
Designation: Station Master
Station: Galudih (Gud)
Division.: Kharagpur,
South-Eastern Railway
Address: At-Abdulpur, Ward No.3,
P.O.+P.S.: Rafiganj,
District: Aurangabad- 824125, Bihar
Aadhar No.711087400306
45. RupeshRanjan
S/o Madan Baitha
Designation: Station Master
(Gill Station, UMB Division)
N. Rly.
Address T-78, Railway
Colony, Gill Railway Station,
Ludhiana, Punjab
Andhar No.964754725290
9
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
46. Sunil Kumar
S/o Sh. Muniram Singh
Designation: Guad/NR/BSB
Address: VPO-Dibhiya, P.S.
Kargahar, Distt.: Rohtas-821107,
Bihar
Aadhar No.8897 4562 4343
47. Avinash Kumar
Sh. Sh. Nagina Prasad
Designation: Guard/ER/SDAH
Address: MO-Beltal, PO-
Digha, PS-Danapur, Distt.-
Patna-800012, Bihar
Aadhar No.6383 8378 4669
48. Binay Kumar Tiwary
S/o Sh. KanhaiyaTiwary
Designation: SSE/TMC/NR
Address: C/o Krishna (..illegible),
Opp. Power House, At-Askamni Nagar,
P.O. Bikramganj, Dist.-
Rohtas-802212
Bihar
Aadhar No.3811 86009356
49. Lal Babu Mehta
S/o Ramdeo Mehta
Designation: Tech/TMC/NR
Address: VIII: KeshuBigha
P.O. + P.S. Akorhi Gola District: Rohtas-821301,
Bihar
Aadhar No.7731 7827 8340
50. Ram Babu Kumar Chaudhary
S/o Sri Achhe Lal Chaudhary
Designation: Goods Guard (SRE)
Address: House No.121/A,
Bhatyari Bag, Railway Colony,
Saharanpur, U.P.
Aadhar No.9715 6594 1500
51. Brij Kumar
S/o Shri Shailesh Kumar Thakur
Designation: Goods Guard
(Gzb.)
Address: HoouseNo.III F- 108, 1st Floor,
Sector-3, Vaishali, Near
10
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Chhaya Public School,
Ghaziabad-201010, U.P.
Aadhar No.2258 8056 1552
52. Dharmender
S/o Sh. Ramlagan
Designation: Trackman
Address: House No.1006,
Gali No.Bl. Nathu Pura
More, Shastri Park, Burari
Delhi-110084
53. Sanjeev Kumar Chaudhary
S/0 DwarkaNath Chaudhary
Designation: Station Mastr
(ARP)
Village: Harpur Pusa, PO:
Harpur Pusa
District: Samastipur- 848125, Bihar
Aadhar No.5898 9949 1254
54. Akhilesh Kumar Gupta
S/o Late Shyam Sunder Gupta
Desig.: Station Master
Lucknow (BHA)
Address: 119, Hundal Khel,
Shahgahanpur-242001
(U.P.)
Aadhar No.4398 4067 6526
55. Sanjay Kumar
S/o Shri Bihari Ram
Designation: JE/TMC
Address: Village: Narayanpur,
P.O. Narayanpur, P.S.: Piro,
District: Bhojpur-802004,
Bihar
56. Anil Kumar Mahto
S/o Late BiloMahto
Designation: Ch.OS/TMC/L/NDLS
Address: Village: LakhanchanMarhu Tola,
P.O.: MokamaGhat,P.S.:
Patna-803303, (Bihar)
Aadha No.8321 4791 8423
57. Mahesh Kumar
S/o Shri Deonandan Prasad Yadav
11
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Present working place:
JE/TMC/TMC-396 @ UBC
HQ-NDLS,
Employee No.803 HQ 600131
Village: Kailudh, Post:
Tankpura,\
Distt.: Gaya-824232, BIha
Aadhar No.9257 9629 1098
58. Sanjay Kumar Mandal
S/o Ramchandra Singh
Village: Katharain, Post: Kaler,
P.S.: Mahendiya, Distt.:
Arawal-824127, Bihar
Present working place:
SM/UBC Dir-Ambala
59. Umesh Prasad Singh
S/o Sri Bhardwaj Singh
Permanent Address: Village:
Sara, P.O. Maniya, Distt.:
Buxar-802125, Bihar
Temporary Address: Moti
Tola, Near Peer Baba,
Sheoganj, Ara-802301,
Bihar
Present working place: WST
8083 M/C
Under
DY/CE/TMC/L/NDLS
Designation: Tech-III at West 8083
60. Sitesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Yogendra Singh
Aadhar No.7588 2273 7563
Address: AT/PO.: Gonahi,
Via: Pachpakari, Distt.: East
Champaran, Bihar-845427
61. Tehal Singh,
S/o Sh. Hardial Singh
Address: Village: Phulu Wala
Dod.
P.O. Datewas, Sub Divn.
Budhlad, Distt: Mansa-
151502, Punjab
62. Jaswinder Singh,
S/o Sh. Ajit Singh
12
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Address: V+P.O. Saidewala,
Teh: Budhlda, Dist: Mansa-
151503, Punjab
Aadhar No.9628 4990 6309
63. Sanjeev Kumar Singh,
S/o Shri Murlidhar Singh
Address: Village: Chandpura
P.O. Nawgai, Distt: Munger-
813221, Punjab
Aadhar No.2695 4130 8696
64. Om Prakash Kumar
S/o Shri Ram Bilas Pandit
Post: SM/Kartarpur,
Divn.Fzr,
Aadhar No.2804 5590 6996
65. Hukam Chand Gurjar
S/o Sh. Sonya Ram Gurjar
Post: Tech-II/CSM-942
Address: Village: Padili,
Post: Tehtra,
Tehsil: Rajgarh, District:
Alwar,
Rajasthan-301406
66. Anil Kumar Mandal
S/o Sunder Prasad Mandal
Address: Village: Tapua,
Post: Budhuchak, Thana:
Pirpainti, District:
Bhagalpur-813222, Bihar
Aadhar No.3569 1052 7704
67. Sudarshan Yadav
S/o Baleshwar Yadav
Address: Village: Mourkahi,
Post: Sihma, Via: Bithan,
District: Samastipur-
848207, Bihar
Aadhar No.6543 9939 5410
68. Kundan Kumar
S/o Late PashupatiSaha
Address: At+PO: (..illegible),
Via: Behaigang, District:
Madhepura-852101
13
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Aadhar No.9029 2862 9726
69. MangalSain
S/o Late Kitab Singh
Address: Village: Mohammadpur, Post:
Alipur Kheri, District:
Muzaffar Nagar-251301,
Uttar Pradesh
Aadhar No.6201 7987 3834
70. Punit Kumar Shukla
S/o Shri PremNarain Shukla
Address: 127/628, Block-S,
Shobha Nagar, Kanpur- 208014
Aadhar No.2737 3500 9223
71. Sunil Kumar Singh
S/o Krishna Murari Singh
Village: Jatubgha, Post:
Chokhara,
Via-War, District:
Aurangabad-824103, Bihar
Aadhar No.9982 2251 3213
72. Dinsh Kumar Sah
S/o Shri Ram Chandar Sah
Address: Railway Colony,
Budhlada, Quarter No.T-
9/A, Post: Budhlada,
District Mansa, Punjab
Aadhar No.3369 7810 2638
73. Komal Prakash
S/o Shri Telu Ram
Village: Bhalaswalsapur,
Post: BaliaKheri, District:
Saharanpur-247001, Uttar Pradesh
Mobile No.9996436042
Aadhar No.6713 8822 2682
74. Mani Ram
S/o Sh. Harphool Singh
Village: Bhalaswalsapur,
Post: BaliaKheri, District:
Saharanpur-247001, Uttar Pradesh
Aahar No.5131 0377 7654.
75. Bijendra Prasad
14
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
S/o Sh. Someshwar Prasad
Village: DhanpatBigha, Post:
Suhawanpur, District:
Nalanda-803116, Bihar
Aadhar No.2423 7832 6715
76. ShivrajJat
S/o Sh. LalaramJat
Village & Post: Tiloniya,
Tehsil: Kishangarh, District:
Ajmer-305816, Rajasthan
Aadhar No.8672 6560 7209
77. Beer Singh Meena
S/o Sh. RamgopalMeena
Village + Post Khanpur
(Meena), Tehsil: Bari,
District: Dholpur, Rajasthan
Aadhar No.9378 7253 5454
78. Shyam Narayan Prasad
S/o Shri SuajDeo Prasad
Mohalla: Jai Prakash Nagar,
Near ITIT Bettzah, District:
West Champaran-845438,
Bihar
Aadhar No.9685 128 0029
79. Rajesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Mansukh
V.P.O. Niyana, District,
Hirar (Haryana)
Aadhar No.8541 9076 9058
80. Mohan Lal Parasher
S/o Sh. Om ParkashPrasher
Address: D-152,
MadhuVihar, Delhi
Designation: Helper/TMC/TKD
Aadhar No.5032 0040 695
81. Vijay Kumar
S/o Sh. Ganesh Roy
Designation: Tech-III
Address: MahmapurPohiyari, P.O.
Mamsai, Via: Jhandaha :
District: Vaishali-844505,
Bihar
15
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Aadhar No.6179 2111 8539
82. Nardev Singh
S/o Jagdish Prasad
Address: Village
GarhmalpurJazibabad,
Bijnor-246763, U.P.
Mobile No.7906213893
Aadhar No.9876 1908 1379
83. Yogendra Kumar Singh
S/o Sh. Rameshwar Prasad
Quarter No.DT 57, Post
Dhurwa, District: Ranchi-
834004, Jharkhand
Aadhar No.3057 6793 8699
84. Kamlesh Kumar
S/o Sh. Nandkishor Prasad
Village: Govindpur, Post:
Sonsa, District: Nalanda-
803119, Bihar
Aadhar No.5774 4224 0414
85. Om Prakash
S/o Ram Pravesh Narayan
Uhl
Village RaghuniChak, P.O.
Noawon, District:
Jehanabad-804429, Bihar
Aadhar No.9049 5077 5186
86. Shamsad Ali
S/o Late Md. Munsaf
Village Bagahi, P.O.: Banahi,
P.S.: Bihiya, District
Bhojpur-802783, Bihar
Aadhar No.3537 6741 2878
87. Dhemendra Kumar
S/o Brajnendran Singh
Address: LaljecTola, P.O:
G.P.O., P.S. Gandhi Maidan,
District Patna, Bihar
Aadhar No.8424 4656 3493
88. Gajraj Singh
S/o Sh. Ram Kanwar
16
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
Designation: Helper/TMC
HQ:NDLS
Village Post: Tatarpur-
Istmurar, District: Rewari-
122502, Haryana
Aadhar No.6468 4921 5401
89. Raj Shree Meena
S/o Anil Kumar Meena
Designation: SSE/Works,
HQ-Kasheri Gate
Address: Flat No.359, Sector
18-B, Shree Awas Society,
Dwarka-110078, New Delhi
...Applicants
(By Advocates : Mr. Hemant Kumar for
Mr. Sumit Kumar)
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA,
THROUGH SECRETARY,
MINISTRY OF RAILWAY
256-A, RAISINA ROAD,
RAJPATH AREA, CENTRAL
SECRETARIAT
NEW DELHI, DELHI 110001
... RESPONDENT NO.1
2. SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF FINANCE
RAJPATH MARG, E BLOCK, CENTRAL
SECRETARIAT
NEW DELHI, DELHI 110011
.. RESPONDENT NO.2
3. GENERAL MANAGER, NORTHERN
RAILWAY, BARODA HOUSE,
NEW DELHI, DELHI 110001
...RESPONDENT NO.3
(By Advocates: Ms. Nidhi Jain for
Mr. R K Jain)
17
OA No. 1436/2023
Item No. 14
O R D E R (ORAL)
Hon'ble Dr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A) Learned proxy counsel for the applicants states that he has been instructed by the applicants to withdraw the present OA. They have also filed M.A. No. 1652/2023 in that respect.
2. In view of this, MA is allowed. The OA is dismissed as withdrawn.
3. No order as to costs.
(Chhabilendra Roul) Member (A) /aks/