Karnataka High Court
Smt H R Lalitha W/O Late Sri.Anil Kumar vs Sri Smt M R Malathi W/O C.V.Ramesh on 14 October, 2011
Bench: N.K.Patil, C.R.Kumaraswamy
M?
TEES;-3 ga.§f3§I>§e;3g.':., :53 E'*~'§L§%Z;§'f;> {ET€Ef}§.=;I:7€; 5:;:%:<:*:":<§?~s_....1_'£=é§;~ I's:'::>« V. §*'z%E;'E§E_J".:' €:@:3'§I€'§5; Am: K-§{§A.§NS'E' ':"%~»-:§T«: JU§I}{,§E3_€%r§i_iE%1i¥E"E*fj';'%jf§ ' . §I}E§€E'{§;I'E%: §i).€':'"E"E{ZEi} i2;5%.3;;3E€2G9 §.3£k$§E%L-{E IN 83 N{}935§j'$;f§}t3€§ {E3 ".§'Z'-E5 '§¥'EEJ'i GE?' Jiiiififiii. §?';?a?xf§§IEf:'* CQU§{'"E1.MM'{SOE€.E€}';'EZ?§$F'?a:fiSS'§_N{% 'V T§'"§.': 3%.??? §7'§LE?§§i} E3{}E'§ EEEZC-§.,AE{z°i'§'1{}E\E }§.f€ii§'E?€g}E§N{Z'§fEV{3?~§_. V * '1';-as ga.§>E>::;a.L {3G.E\f§'§'i\E{§ {EN §>-"Gr§1;x1§3gzéS$:é'::§%'W25 N K P'E2_T§§_( «E E_}EZ.§J"J§%ZE5§§¥ZEZ§ "§'Ei'E<Z E"§'i--_;E:¢§E«VE§3%G:
§§§§mG3V§_4:x1*:;;§:*:%VV_v "
'§f§:i.g é?i§%§3§i"3E1§ fig _§:h2:% :fi":".:§'::g:::2d gtzdgnzesrié. and €£§::::.:f¢c;é :E:i'Ez"é':Lh'*.»'§ ivfifzigseé in GS $335/2@s§ 1j:a§;%;.;%g}:':é:§; Judge, Fazmfly Czmri; { iz>'::ri Ems; dis=sm:iSsss:<:i {he Suit; §3;§:{£r ' "
2, "E' C2136 ems»:
§'§?_€'<"-*:§iV 'f§é&§2§:3§7é' iéiazifizg iii} E36 iériii Eaégzzfigz W:-";'~{§<£€{§ '$1-*§:%};é. {:é§=.E;7:'és::: ;%:':§§"E€.1:.:::2:r wE";s3 vgzzg zarwiiizzg 23$ §%<:§;;%:r E3: Sm ' Jélfiiéifl§§'§;?:.§'§":EFi§'£g;§%;%'§T§{§}'E'a C<:;§E<%g§é% :3? :;*r;s1g§::€.€rEng--;; 38$ 'E'€<t:%m§ca.T:
§;<: gEiE:a:'i:i5:s:'1:€~:e. €i2.2,:3":§:s':2$., .?§§§7S{}§'{?. 'E_"'E2@ §§"T:"cli'§'§&§i'i wag sé;aiéE_:3.:méiiés{:%€E ax"; §4Q§{ExE§§§ 25:': IE~§'has:«:Ir:€:::'é 821%:§1y2:.:§.23;§°2:3Ja:";2:: fi'é;3§"z'§§_}E£: kgizizéiéé §%»'£<7{§':2:E%.z2,e E':/E3'-§;%<3§"£;% 2:53: 'g}a>:' §'.§'§.{i' E~E§;="p:§:.: §'i§.i'f§:% ..'{;:"{és2::2:i_§é:'":§g E2: é".§:z:%§:" {f<i}}'1".§.§".£1'iE'£'§.:§§.'}?. {f}1.:,':'. z::.E';€ 22-*s5r{.*§§_{:%{:§£;.3 25: f5~;{}§'§ E33; §":&?s}i"E1%3: §€<::%§i'Eir: {§f}{}"W :'i:>t{i<;:23,:s:~><:E} wzzzsg; §::<:>:*§1. $336? ézas; ':{..'.'{3'.i7":§7£f:3 up ii} 2:,;}pe2?:.E. §3éé:i'1:m:% §;'E';£;s C:>m"é:.. Eigéiifiéfii. fie §:.::ig;;~;::2.$_::2§';_' a:":{§' qiezéme §;>z--?ass§~;€:{i by iihesr E?21_m:iEy {j<>ui*i;. it is; 'E:Eji.zi:?:, _A;:::-;::s_ge;j:;§i_zf::e~ zipgieéiiaiiéé: s';,}.";a%;: sgha the §;.m;"fi;.E_ 223:3 E{"=.;.§2;:E§}* 4&2-='€-,%§:§A;::£:33;:33 --:a;:*§.;f§%A.gj3_§ ' {he €§€i€T'.€iE1S€(§ zmgi E:.'f:é2re:?§5'{;s:"€, V<%:'"s§E_4iE?:E<z3rs:,§"fgéi" 2-':EE;*é:"£és E>s::z:{:f§*:s a::<::'2_:§:<i 9:': :¢1c<:£>z;11";%:. {>5 aha': u:3:',i::":4é'§.'%£' ifiéaéiéz '{;§_ Eégzzgbzzanafig {§€C{fE?.,Er's§'3{i jilifséii Kumar, V'FE_1%:; r§*;s3:3{;=:§z5,&§:a€£, ciaimirlg is be 'i:.§'3€ 5;37.:'~s:é3z' af §2:"§'.é3 a13;:';iE §?<I;2;2:"§?§:§;§" *:--°=:§s::_is~3'i.é':;i zaikgeai righi :i%i&i:":':a%:CE bx? €:h,€§'--..21 i35%3§_3ia,~:z%,« fjiwzat _g}:::}e iifis: ieifafigr wedded .; _. _ _ __ ._ _ , :23 , wiiie G5 7,Az1§E-- E<;:;::j»:=:._:;£:<.M ;§"f1_€E"€f°{§Y€%§ the app€7.Ea:f2.'E:, was {?{}E'}$fF€i§iE€f{§§.{§ ffié»: ..;":g3?{:',;§i:"f<;a;*"«:%é*:<t§ar:;1%f.i{>11 ami §':2_j%,.m{:Ei{>r1 an §'m;*: {EEG «:>f 'é'}:£;:=L "ET Z-."'i;§"1:".¥.I5:}':\,,}" ._€{;:.:§:.. ~33 ?a€j;$:>:*:3:. figs: §;:::§{3§"--V:£:_;-;y;.§,:z;%E' E1;-:<.'% {f{}ET£'§E'f 22;} §{}'§' <:a:>msEr:§;é3z';1':.1?{:»:'; ~.{}§1i 2:%_,.§§,2§{;{%E}., "'~_E'§":€;*; §?'2m":§§j_; {i:>:.:2fé' aéési.' ::<:§'::s;%:i£3z*§:2g 'éhéi <:=§'2:§_ {E€?'§ii€:f1.'T:£? ~.§>"§ ?'i?*§7,§ $11!': 2:316: {i{§::::.::z:::%:3%.2§:j; ééviziatmftfi 22%: %Z';X:«L§iE éi.<:e_P;§--'?{§a--{:} :-migé §::{A§?}aE {:9 E33'? E23255; ziéfirzzsigsézié "€L§"£€f i§§<éi.§. '£35; §lVE'3{,': :2:§§g}:::'§_§a§_E':i. %:{f:§{%§:'1g;§ €.E":2;:aE: i:1:=s§§}§§.€ :3? $::§'§":::§£;%1:2i; V' i§g3,§:":.':;%'Li,;::r:i€'§ ;;;i§i:s:%:"2§, E.E':a*r. 2£§;pa%§§:z2.:':€' E: :"g::i§é:{§ ?;;s:,> 953%:-:§M"2§§§;Ez y' 5"' if , M é E§"s;:;-it .s+;E2:'3 E55; '£:§:":.<:% i<;%§._:_;"g2§§§; 12¢-x=%<i{%a%{fi£ xrgéib-é 01% {§€<":<?:::.,<..~".-;;;3-*;s:;§. ;'%I,;":i§ E'{:,::"_m=2:: E%;>;aE2':;g z:;g;};:"i€:v<:t{E E33-* €i§'.§.€f i§:1p:,:;;;:1s{i_;§;:{§'g§r§:£:_f§i.a:é:i* {§%;'.§TfE"{','& fights: 2;2p§::<-3:E§a:§1E.. is; in £i§_}§}€%&13 ?3'gf:i%;:"={;3:'£fE*;§§é:'.?C§:§;,:zi§I,'S§:::<3§%§.i§j;,a§f a;>§}:*<}§>ri2n:e rsiiefifié.
T§1<-3: $i,E.E:}3"£E?:;§§E§i{}§'1. 9? <t';<>€b;::;§.s}s}§:'~jE ££:v§:'§p€21f§.§E§§ far thé 21§.§p&-'siézsm. gait 'she: beizixg 32::
i'g§i'{era"£:<:é emii Egg";-a;-r;§;":E. :.i':¢2;é.'§g}-Vii": $155: kzmwiséggé aabaziéi $2": i::~;s;;:«1--§ "§tf§1'§I?:iV_i£fEi'Ei{}':_13S',._. izgidjé-3ngg1ged E13719 $€'K"u'§{3€S of {£16 {:am;*5§.ss35i '"":;:1'év}f_,5 5?;E;fs:""€.§.§§:a::'i.€§1§"7:i:§'1€ <:e:}u.'§";$é:'E hzifsz :23:
-1; <1? <:§°<}$:*3-€::x:21:11§:3e1%iia§1 Q3 :5s.§s§i.5:;€€%::£ %';*%;£;%" ;Ci<::';:;;'°"':i .'i§é'{}m '9 §'€::«:»§_}a'>::d€%:1%;. '§3':f:,::;>f"é':»s3 "E:/;3.<:§§ af as§s§.§;3:.2m{?:e by hear' a":<_>1mS€gi; 'ffifgfir C:>:..2;~2i,";:ft:§-3:" §:€3.2::fi':":g <:3:'2E§ £12135: Q/a:ms{;>.E '56?" this: '§:§s3§§5<>§::'a¥i?::§. $122.3; Vgééisésséégi am :;é;%<§;;::"'{.<% gz"d§;2r: ?E1E:»:'::%:§<2:'z;: ;"§Ef:é;:"'s;§:éé:§i$*~%3;f §2:;V {?2§:Eg:a§'":'::.;;:E'§,:; fizz: §:§"<}:2€ hs;-'52:" €722.88 ::m:: 5§§"§%3: _is~; '%;.h§;€' E€§§_;_:"}§':'i§§A:£' '€§*fE{§1{§{:?{i ":a:"%:§'§% {>5 i§€<?z:%21Se{§ f%.2':é§ Ei'a,:mz2.':: 'Eh .:%.'«:-,2:%:s5sE;2é;':'§§;§:%}:.::?'Eéaz' $%":€: Ems tzikiszé {§<:}:.2:f:Z, §;.§":m:,1g;§h {}ET'{'§€§'g_.;.%§§:';€iE€?'iT. ::'2.;i:§3':'é::;::%_*:'3éié. E3};--' Ehe €f<:n,.:§°€, E::--€:E<3:*e: 34:: $%::i>~2a-* %ii.Eié:;:§j .:~:s§§::. E"; :'::,>é;. §:}z2:¢§'::'z <'>§E'%:?:*%%::§ :"s:;%2-2.§;{';;¥':.2:2"%:§Ea& {}§}§}{}E"§Ii.§§1§.'§Ijs£ tar; K {if3'i}:'=§.f=f~} €3}<lE?iE"I1§'E'i{i'. 3:32? 2*?' §"if§§§;}<T:§'.3.{i€EI§iE'ii gm ;:.2?:<':a'f::'£,':':"g'I§§'~.T.5? m:m:*i::z.:.";i<t2:::iam ggazp bafiwas-.:: Egg,-32%:-:%§;{ zmii €:E";<:: €.:4':;%:.1'n.$§€*é§v:$:§§%:;--T * z*é:rg3:'€=ss<%;1':.2&£i Ewrzz a:_:";{.% fl:«:%:'e§'°:*.:»2%°'a"-3, SE36-...::§2;:£:i Eiéiii'"&>tf:§;§:é;g:é'.zh:: ss%rir§{:::%s; of gmfiiher ::::>z:m:<5{-':E zzmi '{:%1€r5é-.%§<:a;;*<:,'»3L':~§3fi::§fiéi '~%E"é:3§: '£.h:<: §H:g3:..1g:_1%3:§jzidgmésm: 21:36} }fi8fZ'.E'€{? 'p.:.;m:se<i %.s 5§.£:--:bEé *%i%f3 vi"§,ia':'.s,-Ed and 'éghaé: iiams SEE', .:°e21£§y"~.;1§'p:--§-I aakéléingg ii} <:<>mp€na3S£.s3 §:hz:% Ii'§Ifi§f£1'i'.i{}"fi..V_€tX§}iffiSEiS;: t<}"L~.';§.;e 2~'??":"'€'S§<)nden:; §3€r$a:aa.§§y €33' '£§1r<>'Lzgh her .T;<":?{;=z:.Lr1:;~§€:§, _;ij,§§.2:E....1*:';21y $6 fixéai 'By iélrisé C0ur€:.
E3, 451$ 2:s,;§,>;'é:.§§'"»:_::~§:l.%;V';?:i§§;'vv%:_§1'¢":~E£:a:":2@d <:{3:_ms_§<:§ zzappezmlrzg; far fiche 9*'-*= 'iefg-'<s§p<2;'i:<%.é:§'sf:.' i.fi'§i€-§v;':i§i&1 <7:<m%:.€:':;":dsc§ i;¥r:33?:, ic1.f%s::~::' 5§E.":€'E ::<>:1,;e3§<f2§;=;'§'z;é.iaiér: {>15§'.héé 'r€EtL'-1?2:::'E. zzzziixéiiizfi 22:;-*:1i§21%3E€ an 'flies? SE16 'V'=:C'g::»:.::v-'€:__'E;}<3::§:*m:»E':2:§; 3; $.13: zznaé :"€=g1§as:::;1;{b§€--t :':sr{E<%:: E? iyf %'fs'tT:_:% E:%g_T}§E*§§E}.§1?;3f"3 €*a'2.2.:::§£:E wag IEEQE. zwzzilgzbés £0 §":--§_:-:1' p::«:9:;;:'_ Elf.-iI%, 3*. "§{}'§'. 2:3 §2m§%;: a_:m:§ '§%é«:'»é:°é;*e§'<:z*€:., ',§E"'§§'.€f§'f:Ef§'€E'i€':€* aé.
-- f$E":e:== §"§:*:E"2<ié'&; e::"§é:.%";%;:~;; {'3{:>z.:z'E. is gmi. éfzifiifii ?2:isz: §§{:z»:a?'a=%:r<;é12 zkféaés g";jé:f}:.2'1§;§ i."§'::?x::>é:;;§E: Eiffifi <>:"::§%?.:' :3:;E?:.s%é;':?:'. n2;::i:'§§';a..§§:§>{§ by *f.§'.':€-If §'é§.§E§i'§y " T.%ifir:>a*:.V::*i:,--.*' §€E2?.§'§'Ei;".'.€§ z':<>?;,:;'":.%+;s:€§ i°:»:§'§:;' §;2.:Ei>s'::é§;m{i %"i?':;:§:. 3131:: :':2e::.€:€:€:-#2" y Wéi 21¢"
éfi :"s*&{;2:§:*€:éss;- a:<:>':1&;§<1<;:*:r:a.§:§{:e:': i'§:"<_}2":: the em-.:Tg,;:;s:§ GE £§."I.'{}§¥§$ %E,'X£%.§};.§€ffiZ£z-?:§'f}f1V. sf 3* ;ré:%ss§_3{>'n£i:%z':%..
,§*=,f*::.@:" ggcaizag §:E_'2:'<}u;;h §'§¥;':=:
am {§z::<::*€s;? §3ase;s@<3; '$3? £:§":€: C:;:'a::%{,__ "::>ei<i2:;;"<*2?a:°€:'f1::Ej;::.:::'1.:$§}:§ if me: ci<><:L1§z'1{:&::§i'.s,; 22.14-*e2.§§a§3§;é;3 in me :».:,1";{£ é*:'%;r2?::E::.é11::§<§I§ 9%' {ha ::<;r:i;€m'.;i:>:":;<s G? ilhéf? p2£rE..i.<i;%%,:":t. Eggs r1;:;aI::*ir7s-' 'otgz iiisi fa:::{:% {Bf file gamzi that €:E';.e F:":m.i_Ej«; ::f.Z*Z'a;sL.:.:fi3 h':--::..s~;:»__<€<éi;::;é1%§'§,%:d grzgxm €<:°r<2:' :rm;<:h less: m':;2.€.§:;f'i2LE§:"i:"<:g§:E;a;z*ifi:j§.:,_ -;:iif;«3.u§§:.§%§:g in ::1isc.;1rriagf<-t of "§i_,i;"%§i{E€':'., f§'"Eé'§c% <:;§:}i~:m-. !5?if{%§:>i:r~,§§5<:£:2g §3;)i'§ij §?fi.?€.FE1§'€ of i:.hé:é fact ihai €:.h€:*é3: zxsaéu mar: 2125:;--%sV§;<;';'é;fs:i:::%'e:.__fi3:'}:?;§ §.h<-i iTi(}'i.E:}Sii'§. ::1§_pe:az"§:1g; fer €¢:£':{: ap§>€:'ik3.né::'"':E"2;f{":mi:_VH.'-é,'E§{:. §iLé:.g:j€-3: 5:2? {?r{}se:%;--4:%xa::r:§:":a%:.i{;1%i :3'? E8? :*?::*;;§s§3{é;a?;--":L::'§.:3ti*:*:a "V'<}:.2g:;>;§"t;%;: V§:é:':%' '§":aa:-'e %E=i=E:§U%?{§ Smzré: §f:<>%.i<:€ 331:} §:E":{-'3 a9ag3§V3::E_§-i2*z;¥":?i,. "«._a%;é§':ei";V:3;.22.1%}; :¢u'2{§ ;2%'€'.<-'fig' 22§§<}§*€§%mg_g§ r:%21s:';<3:*::c':?Q§§: :é§3§:3:'?E_;:.:::;%*'é§31.VS%;h:31,:i{:§. §32¥J{:~ pr>:><:~<'-sta-:*:i:'::{§ Ea {isztidéj 82:6 r§:2:€:E:e:°. .4 §"1§;§&;T;is§';>::§:::¥i: {ii §§';:=% §";":;'2%iJ:',<-;*::" E73225:-5 féifi. "§:z€:s':'::': §{}{)%§<.i*:{§ §_§"§E {3 bf; {ha " {i{:a;.§§":'.-V":;i%§{§:a=2 "§';*";:=.*. 21 "%?.}{?§§.€1E'1§. <':E;2.im§ Ex-,=: %'l':é% 3:?-fizziév' __ _ , 2 El "ax-,«*s:::%'e';éi::§,a';~":§% :%:'i§%: :33" 'E;hs:%% {'§€i{7Ef2':E."%%';"?{§ 2'i.E"§{§ 332*: :"€:s~;;§>e:':<§€:::'3.§: €f§Zi'§E§"iE-E .9 3'-2 fit: bi,-2 §I§'.3:€;f'. €55 s--E-24:: {i§€E€L?§?%2Ef*E%1?éi§. aha: W 2":-;'i$§;:::;*':=:i:€:':'£: 7 9 m2::'i.€.€r E°é':{§Ei§E'§3ffé% ::.2?a:"~e{:;1.§ &%v::;Ez,:ai:,E{:2:':;» of é*;gr1?駧:':<:.e::é%--..§3_§:f€:?f§%f zirrizzing 2:: 21 <?{.}§'3{3§?;.§E=.§§€}§'3; *x?£'}'3§€§3§T§ .§é"1€: §"2;=;m'§.%y {'v:}i:':j'?'_' §:2:s";E<§§'2.: sgigghi <:>f. K€?€;?p§Z"§§§ 222.1} *i.§":€s3s--: §'e3%s::{;%::isE§:'i:*1Vvn*:§*:':fi;%_VV:$.%E=: 0? ihs <:{;a:":5:;§d<-:>ra':*.{§ View i:h;2:'i'. A2.=,:/V*:::i i§€3{EE'€-'E6 §}a$:--?;€cE iéy file C:3.z=.,2z"t: and fig Eiabie. '£0 E36: $1236 :2'1£§:ri{..s_% csf the (E2185.
'?1 Fkiér éiiééf '§:{T;.§f€i§;§€3§V§:Z.§;'E:"§'?Eé.S{}I}St§§ $1315: §n5;t.a'm.'. appaai :13 ;§EZ<>:a»*e{i :1: ';;--:1_:°z;, '"_?T%1'€::_V :§£':{}*§}L;ig§1'i€;'.{§ ju{§;;r:':é:<:'z§; amé {§E3C§°'%73.€ " §§".:é1s:"a$.:-:u..,ri%'i:"; GS i§E*%;'§§ by é;E::: Famiéy C{}u:"?::§ §;:a=éE;--z1:~.;§d§:. "§"Ezé;% 2's::e2.E','Ese::r :-*:~:t:;'m<Es~; §"'Efi'§§E'§'.é'E{§ §}2%{'§<>; ififé 'Q13 '{Z:€.;:;:'%"é E3e:*§{';%: Em?' :*a<:<}2:§§{§€r§mg 23_{1:'%3s43§"': {mm £;%:i€: «:}§":"::'"i:::ss$ <=:>:;';u":2i§':23E'.§<m sf §"{:?E~',=§}{}§'E{,§EE§."i§.Z azmi m {i€i*{f§{§§;'f . in Ei£"f{f{}§"{§2':i§Ei§i€E 2ar§:T}z E21321!' :e2§*£:€.:' ;z§"§'{§z*<§,i:2§;§ E:'€':é.i:'$§{.}I§'EE§.$E}f§€i? €."}§'}§3e£f}i'i,'=;,sE.§'Eii? éita'; '§}<:si:E'2 $1219 §}:§:':§"§.i€.'.8. ,5 E ,.,-» Ea, ,...
9' E?z,::."§:E'1<;r:_, "azhzé .:::ppeE§;;:'1':. E"§<=rr<-gain <§i:'£;%:~,";«':2-z;*::i§j 2:2 sa-;'um (>5 'g3 by wa;1y ifif d.e:z1a'm<§ §Eraf?I'.., E'§i;§;§g4:§:i:'::";5' <;':X§3€;%fis;<:ét~; E19 €.E";<:z W :°e:%ss;3<>::{§m::E: §;)€f.LfE~:§€')E1_£3.§'lj§.' }:';r:* '5:}f1§?;:3§::;§.§E%3 Ir2,,:;5rf ::.<>:;§_n sssi *»§éE:.§":§:": as pégsréiszi Q?" §%f°;':.2;_" 1.-E2.-*<;%E%3i:;3g§"%fr<}::r;»' '{fé:s§'_«':ia1;::* 4:3? I'f3.Cé'*.i§f§ {.25 9;. a%<::§};..2 9%" 'L'§2:5:=; j:.:{§gn*;€;:é'£, gm {i'*:',<3 §}"_§€:': Ea meme befam ?:'E*:é3: FE"-imiiy C{m:'i,;.._é§'*§0.r1*g z?;?i%' §1" ~~.2_é=:.:§§':~§ {m,?1e%€1g&ms3:2%. €92" haavmg paiiei the .%a:i_d 2>:a';':<f22;:»:?:Ei:g'= Q, V ;;5~§;<§'$53:.<;Ee1ri.if;jj--%.%ia:'§ the saifl amm.mi;:
Ea zizfzt p:/;j:.£fi §}_§z'A.?' ?;fi§% a{§§f;a*i§é:3j"£:% %%:_eW§3;:mi§y €Z'0ur'2:, is-; {'§§;E'€{',"§l€'.€§ 11:23: £162: §>:"{§a%{:€d f:.:::°::§:e§féi§';i§E:§3£ (mica? §}2}_$§5€{i ixy éihsz §'2a.m£1§?' €«:}L.:;'%:. é'}_E%§i€{§ 35/G5 wézuéigé E35: £°<fS'§1€}§"€3d.
$5.?/N §§§%i§1%§ gfigi"
§;'%"i§'§€.§§ " '.?;.?*.':'3'.":