Mariyamma, vs The Special Land Acquisition Officer, on 5 September, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 5]

Karnataka High Court

Mariyamma, vs The Special Land Acquisition Officer, on 5 September, 2011

Bench: B.V.Nagarathna

 

I "1?! E HIGH COU'I;'{'E" OF KARNA'FAKJ«k AT IEBANGALORE
DATED '§'HIS THE. 05m DAY OF SE*Z'P'.l'i'3§\'EBER, 201 I

: BEFO RE :

':fm=; I--iO3\E*I3LE§ MRS. JI§S'I_"!C',f,Z I-'3.V.i\EAGA.R.zY§'}-{NA , V.  

W.P.NO$.3228OA3241.1./201i (mwag)  ' V

BETWEEN:

1.

MARIIYAMMA AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS w/0 {.2-x'r£+: SANNASE*iE'I"1'Y 2, {£1} NAGARATHNA ' AG ED ABOUT68 Y}3ARS".._ W / O RAM:'\SITTf_fL'E'fFY A (b] MANIKYAVMMA V V ' AG ED ABOUT: 22 _ ga} AQELD AS0331" ?;'3'j;~YE:;xRS _ _ S/G .:2A_:*:~zLrs,s1%=-IE:'1'*£*x«' '-.».J "(£3 V. J;%YAM1\zi;X "" " 'V .V .. >.:f%;E}§*2--IL>_ Agog"? *?0 ';f§+_:.;-jg-T23 V Z V ,__s.-;'{>T. _Ri_;faMAs:TT::«:'1":"{

4. ' ' e:_.';§;E-n-E.E;%i::!:;§5.:i::TT:g>;§\é::>§::;f~, ;:e::ia;;:; .Ag;:af'{>:;':' €36 VIEARS 3,/eggs.;zL;:c:;;a$§~;:::y:*:*g"

, ;'%§?g%.J§$E--§§€7E7"§":"

_§'z.{Z% §£E'} z%§?§{}U'§' £333 ".:"§€ZE'a.E§iE% S ,3 Q E RASETE EC-"ET?

Eb} 'JESERABTEAEJ RASH ETYY AGED ABOUT' 62 YEARS 3;' Q 'E<LRﬁ'xS}"iE£"§""FY .-"> =~.

, //' 3*;

l\J L») S / O BASEQZXRJXC HAR G . B . C I.-EANDRAS H EKAR AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS S/O BASKARz'i'xCHAR G. PU'1'i.'EG OWDA S / O G-OW'DAIAH DEAD BY HIS LRS G. P . SI-11%-ZQSHAN KARA S/C) G-PLETTEG OWDA AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS G P RAMESHA AGED 41 YEARS S / O PUTTEGOWDA EZSHWARA S. AGED 35 YEARS _S S /0 Gow'I)EGowpA V G c :vé:%iKK3€fGfo\%%§j:j;«_;'D§E:AD ié§$E"':!-ils ms i;A}:{'_'€§I--{Vi\xI;'l4I\?I1a'\'{££?s,GGX?'J[V{L'..iATE3 G C GOWDELG owmx AGE) -72 YEJARS. V " "_}:3<3LI1/~x1E2A,.r;;4§;' S £a£;1:::> 50 YE:"aRS S{€)_E;Af?F3, G <2 GOW'i')EZ-GOWBER §~£3'&E?§ &}f%£.3--.I S;5GS:E£§§Lz'§Ni}z-11% E)E;2'%.E.3 E337 EH3 LRS G ,. {;:;;e:_ V S2-{mm am: 'we 3;-a%J'%§;zU:.,:_,.r?a E§2--£.;ar~:

IVS» ESE} 38 YEARS '' En} S§52:§2;:5':.,m. §§z~»;;gx2' AGE!) 5&6 Y'E,57':RS S/'O §{£':L}':§NE}GR §{HAi'€ {C} NAZARULLA KHAN AGED 40 YEARS 8,! O KALANEEEZR K}-i.AN ﬁyfy :

I vi _td 33, S UFEYEXBI '.-'~.7'/ O KI"iAS§Ps/3 SAB, [DEAD BY HIS L-RS [213 PYAREI JAN S/0 SUFTLYAESE AGED 55 YEARS (33) MUNWAEE {)E"2AI') BY HIS LRS AZAGAR1 BEGAM W/O MUNWA}?

AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS

D/O SUFEYA ;, AGED ABOU'1'6O 'r'EIAIg2S "

F{A'V'E '-

AGED ABOU'? 35 YEAR-S' S/O DASAPPA SL-1E:":'1"'1'Y ' JAGANATHA T _ , 1, ;

AGED ABOUT 35 YEEARS" 2 S / C) I')ASA'§'PASIj{'E'FTY' :v3*HAA4§m;$:--NA_V@'JNAN EZNDRA A_(;1~:D AB om: 2:2,». _.YT§:A;j2s S/Q :>ANAPr>"A 's.r-1's%:.iI*:aY _ _DEv;itRg§;;zxS--I»iE;TI'&* AGEE) z%;2E3QU'.I' "£1 Y"}33.5\.RS " 5;.'Ow}AVARAS}*~!E,'§TY »§3§:£ga€§g:AM MA ' ;?;..E§i3U'§' 50 YEARS ' a,:a.f,,r'-<33§§;a;m';g<:r~a;x3qI>§2gx SH§"ZT'§"{ E91?'.?E"j3'x§4A§§S§-%i?vZ£%.§E'EE'v'§A ~~ }%S§%§§§,'} 2'--';§"3{}'{§"E"' 3?' "E '%""E?iZ":E2§ ¥»';'' G §{i%E!E£E{T§'£A.N§}§€§7'.«, S:E"§§*:'§f.§."'z.' R;a'£'§-§.NA'Exﬁ'MA AGED ABOUT 5%? YE:'-'xRS 'N/O LATE NARASI-IIMHASHEZTTY JA'{A.I's/I it/EA AGEZEE AEEOUT 55 'ETJAEES }§,§/ an

38.

39. -5- W/O LATE PU'I'TAS\VAMY SH§§'1"T'Y (21) MOIMIAMMEE) IPAYAZ AGED ABOUT 50 'x'§ZARS S/O §\/EOI'"I;'¥£'v'I?\/{E113 AYAT {:3} MOHAMNEEZD LIYAKAT @ sA:\a1ULmH.._ 7 Vi' AGED ABOU? 43 YEARS S /O MOHAM.M.ED AYAT {C} AKH-LAR HUS-EN @ .N£'gSAR. " V' "

AGED ABOUT 40 YE:,;§;Rs ..J j;

S/0 MOHAMMPZI) Ami? "

Ed} E\/{OPIAMED SI**1}iI+f:I'{'L§DI§'€A." V S/O M0:*1AMM_E:D=Ay"AT AGED ABQUT 33_.Y'1$£-\.I€S--. {£2} MOHAMEI) :%:\1.zxJ-Rt;11;m;"'-Siiw-~1AJAN AGED ABOUT V32'V'Y'}::M2.sV '- . _ S /0 :\z:or1;=;r»:'zsx::«:§3*~1;;g;;cx'1' v_ «V " - "

gm _ ,A::;'E:D'm3'a9.§J'1>__2'5-YH,ARs . 1)'/v0vr§s;Q1.ea1_.;w:i§:¢1?> LIYAKAT JAYAMMA ' ";;.C;I«:D A:3_<3m' 6'7 'ma:-as '§2'Jj{T} RAJ:'%'gS;E----§--E§ii'I"{ ' 40..

_ ;§,%s.*m:~,{i'z»crzx A "A§1E§D.;?:.fE'5'0'U"f $5 YE«:A_£2s w;EC;'j"E3JE:VAE{mA sH:«:"£"*§f¥ ' .. égsiiémzxxirvisx '£§i£;.§E3Z} AB§§.}'E"' 3% YEARS E555 £3 Em/3;'§xE?L SA?€'ﬁAi~}E3;'E SEE '§E3T"'§":' E} L--ALE'"i'§T*iAME§EA AGES 2'-?~.8GU'."E' 5% E"E€?r":E'~{§ 'N70 LATE PAPASH BETTY G K CHz'--i§dUVAS?§ET§Y ACQEB AEEQUT 50 '§:"E.iA}'{S S/' O KEQISE--ENA $HE°'§"TY 441

46. 48'

49.

50.

54. H ON N EC} OVJWJA AGED ABOUT E32 YEARS S / O IN/iOG;'k}3PfXGO'£K-'If);°a PUTTIEGOVVIDA I)E£AjI.) BY HIS LRS C HAN DRAS HEKARA S/O PL'='i'I'I~3C§O'~}VI):'-\ AC. ED ABOUT' 47 YI%ZA.R-S C HAN D RAS H EKARA AGED ABOUT 47' YEARS-..__ S / O LATE PUTIEG-OW.IJA YASHODA ..

AGED A"!-3OU'.I' 4~£3..4_Y':9?AE%._S "

W/O pm*rI::GowI;A - -- ' KAMAL}'d\.§"1 MA.

AGED ,_4:Bc7;U-*5 47*._Y1i:m~is u W /o__ £;gA*ifEZ'IAT\£N'E2Q QW1_)z*y* V I,A_f§SI':{M'3'3ié%Q\A?li)_A "

:AGI£I')' A{30L31'3;' ' 3i£§1'1RS V V 53/Q *rI--1':1xv1MAI?[T::t;":;Q*<;a;':_)A S1~:i13L§2AI)AE%3M}"{ » "

_ __AGED~ ABOUVT 83 YEARS \.:Wc> GOEAXALASE-}E1'I"iY ('gm s%é;1_x.§1;>Ie;rx RAJ ' _ 5;-£}1é1I ?§~ 5;ETs(3u':* 5: YEARS A. Sv;'i{3,C»£)§%s>&LzXSE--EEEETITY <;"M<::'E--mm E{z-id ..E'&C}_'i§§.} 2"-%J3€f§?J'F EEG "§'§fZE';E%S a:<>§'a;a.:4;?;S;1TT§§a;T':'*z' {E ga';*xs;-x:~s*:'iT:g2 §:2;x;'a.; 51$}-E31") .,§&.B{}iJ'E' 46 'f§§Z1?\E?{S 3;' G €C§{}E3Zi?%.1.'-*3: SE€EZ'E'T'.'f E'xi[AI3A17ACHARI AGELI) ABUUT 68 YEARS S f O 531$.) ff.}z'7iCE~L1-KR?

§ 5%" /-

fz §,

55.

56. 58'

59. hi.

52. £33:

.2.

['21) APPANNACI-{AR S'UBRiX?»/EANYA CIVEAR AGED ABOUT 47' YEARS Sf O RUDACHAR {b} CI-iAN1T)RA CHAR AGEEZID ABOUT 45} YEARS S K O RU E)AC§~I.5%.R G S CE*fjXN'I3RASI--iIE£1€{ARA SHE§:'E'I"r' AGED AEEOUT 63 YEARS S/O SUNKASHETTY .

ARATH1 AGED ABOUT 21 YEARS_ D/O RU I)RAS}~iE1'E'1'Y Q ,';*--.~ KAVERAMMA --

AGED A.BO{}'"I' 50' ~yjI~:A1:;1s3 " _ xv/0 'n~11MMAsrH::'r':fy » ' RAMAC1'iANDE2AS%%I~.ﬁ1'fY'--.A _ 2 '- s/0 -SUVB--?§ASEHifI"FY I_§l£AD'~~E5Y VI-{IS-«LRS 3(a) ._ ~ NArmS;M'i=%1_A"81'--iETTY . :3/0*RANrAC~:_:1AN'DRAsm:':TY

- AG'*et:)~.z§:3,.Q'a:ir 50 YEARS ' " (1:3) §»*I§A§3AK;xIaA AG"{%3f}....ﬁ:{3OU'E' 48 YEARS " « ._ /' C} RA1\«'125XCMAI\ED RASEMI EZ'T'EY ' '§%;a;:§I}%;m§icg gx.{;--§%?;j;$3 ,%%.E-3OE£'§.' 43 "'fE£ZARS $3.: ;'Q_I=E<; EJMAR " 3:3 E32»§A§2;:'zH£ .«5X{)%E.?;E} ;'%§.3{}EJ'.i.' 40 "':f'§§;'-'a§?{$ SK} {E {Z E}U'§"E}'%.EE:'%<_§E§ G E3 €E*E.E%£'~.i BRA.

ERGED ABOUT 58 YEARS S /O PUTFEGOVK-'I)A 'E'HQ'§'E,U SFDDAEAH SK 0 SEDEf)AS}--*§E§TTY' DE.i53.§[) BY HIS LRS é ;f..r Hg, (21) SUBBAMMA 'W / O NIRV5M'\5AS H]':Z"I'§'Y AGEI) ABOUT 55 YFLEJQS (19) R.1&MASE*IET'E""{ AGED ABC) UT 45 YEARS S/O AJJAS}*iE'§TY {C} SIDDALIE\EGAS}*1ETTY AGED ABOUT 85 YEEARSV S/O TE~fOTLU' s1I>DA;A1»a ~ id} KALAMMA AGED ABOUT 13:0 "{_I£ARS- ._ W/O smvAN:~:As§:§I§?1f'rY V

64. LAKSHMAMMA -.

AGED ABOUT 7C:_Y"§::A§-gs , . V W/O LATE: 'I'}«11MM;A;,AE»i

65. VIJAYAKUMAR AGEEZD :%\£~3§«'1&I;"3' st». YIi§z~'x;f§s""' ~ /O es. ;3;4xVA.ia?A:vf1$x1A~ _ ..

AGEDA % ABOUT 5 5 YEARS _ _W'XO"NARAS;.IMiv~_iA' "

11111 «, 3 m;;12::3« ..ABC)U'T 52 YEZARS ~ _ "3/'e:>_ §>:g'§rA1m»1 " .::;%§'; ':A§§:3'?%1§viA.M3v1A .55 F ﬁ«--"¥1f€A.S§{E§'?iY ,. :%;§3E£D 25:;-3<3E;'§_' 85 &i''§mR.S » AA -sL:§T3§a:2$:rTz;;%'§*:*z? s axe ?\; 'z'£§%;%S§Fv§E-{£2 SE--{E€,'E'"§"":'"

;?§GE~:E'} A§*3OU'£' 85 "{§3A§~18 ' "?(}. §<AR:S1«i§::'I'"£*Y S/O NAMSIMHA S}-~I'E"£'I"Y AG 5:3 ABOU1' 50 YEZARS 7]' ?4'';.

N}.

--1§}~ KEMPAMMA W7 0 EREGOWDA AGED ABOUT 75 YEARS NAGARAJA SHE3'i*I*Y S / O ANJANASHETI'Y AGIi',ii) ABOUT 65 YEARS KALABOVE S/O VEINKATABOVI AGED AEBOUT 48 YEARS {£1} NARASAiAI**i V S/O WEN KA'I'AE?O1?.'{ .

AGED ABOUT 50 EARS

(b) NARASIMHA A S /0 \%Em:Af,rAB«0v;V . "

AGE!) ABOUT 52}-YEARS I'.


'I'}*£IMMAE3Q"v.'1  V    

;i.'dI'4:'1::s- §;;B0    V  V

    .-
W/'O PU'FI'EGOWD;5£.

_ AGE{3~.AE30{3T 7-5 YEARS

 L . .. ..... .. v

9:1; 0 iV:i{%§)U

~. _ A.:31::::f;%._s§.23oU"§' 53 YEARS 7 ' <;Q'°§%':1}e@Iié;a S E' O» ffsﬂﬁl} LJXEEREE 1' ,.A{1'¥_E?;§3 ,5"-'1BGU'E" 85 Yiis-'§E{S A' -' .EiRES§*%?€Ei{}{}§-%'?E.1i% :3 3-1;: ":3 :53? 53% E.,E%_;€% {a} G K PU'§'?E§§2A:EU SEQ LATE KR§S§~£N%ZGQ'@§E35%. AGEZD ABOUT 60 YEARS {b} Si} N EJARAJ 8;' Q I_,ATE*: §i§%iSE"'§N Bi} OE-"£'§}f'; AG RE} ABQUT 55 YE.-ARS ?

80"

84.

"

8% 4;", [{2} G K NARENDRA S / O LATE KRISHNEGOWDA AGEZI) AEEQUT 52 YEARS {6} G K VE',NKA'I'AR2"&.J S f O LATE KRESPiN}3ZQOWI);X AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS G A RAMESHA S/O A1\'EN£CGOVV'DA AGED ABOUT 40 YEZARS JAYAMMA W/O 1./-m«: G A ':\3'AGARAJU ' AGED ABOEET 44 YEARS-

KFZNGEGOWIDA S/O KALEGOVVDIX , . _ --

AGED ABOUT 824_Y'}'3AF§S E. V V' ~ 9YAVAM1\z1'A V W/O NARASABQVI " -

Adtij; .. Qﬁgxgoﬁéff' '":{E%:A£<S."V V V ;J1RAJU « V S /0 "1'I4[1M'2.,!£s$:acx}}'i"--- 4' V _ AGE33 A3013? :37 YEARS ' ..... .. 5 SK {,7 \?ENKATABOV § V' " _ ';;x§:E-in Mom'? 48 Y*'15'-aRS GC"§i!T_Rf%§vEP¢Zz% :V;'<,1~L;x':': G S N;a_:,:,.URE:<;0w':>A 1' .. A<;2'£:::3 z?'xE30'¥;E"E' 55 ':'E<351£%S E;;'3;E§S E"? ?v'E§F-'°a?s«§ EVL5:

EXJEG C: T'? §JAEiS§:"§F\ﬁ%:{§{}i3EE};% AGEE) ,:~'&BQ{3T 68 YELFKRS TE"iiMi\§,.I-XM§\I§A 'W/' O LATE AYYAN NASHETYY AGE?) ABQU'? 175 YEARS Jr X-7§%§¥;E£(}GE?\z'E)A 5,»;

90.

91.

92.

93. 94:.

'?}€~'é'

98. _;'>_ S/O §'*IANUMEGO\-MBA IJEJXI) BY L-RS [21} G J E)I€Vz'XI?J\JU S/ O .LAT§'£*? JAVAR.EGOV\?I)A AGED A¥3OU'I' 55 YEARS G J £\'1ANJUE\3;X'£'1--EA S / O LACI'EZ JAVARIiGOW"DA AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS PUTTASWAMYGOVv"I )A 8/ O M.U'DDEGO\?VDA z'--\G'I33D ABOUT 77' YEARS SANNEGOWDA S/O"1.'£-{I}\!1EV'EAI.A}'} D EZAEJ £3)' ms._1j_.1~:s MEFFFURAJUS/O sAN1\z§j(3(§\;'.I:)A * AGED ABOUT «sq 'YEARS------- _ "

KU MARE';

S/0 PU-'n'As\2vAMY _ . V AGED Aasm" 39"Y}s:A.f{S "

7MU1>z7 E::vC;a2s}I>;;"-V_ "~----_, ' ' 5-,/O «e3A\«*.A,I'<:?;:3»V:jsxz_}i3-A, AG'ECDAv}E3()U"17.?Ci VY-3s;:ARs , "G-.1vI :xs1"U:::_§1:§§ic30*-.2x.r1:)zz*-x $.130..M;<xL.§ac3ev;DA D£<:A§) BY ms LRS V' " _ ';v;;:x.1.\:;;.::j:*«s--...<y:'zr~:zx G M é _.é"€); mg; C} M ::v:U1::;>z_> mowm AG§{',7,Ei} K-'i§3QU'.§' 49 Y'E§i-ARS ,. vE}'E7}'~J':'%E.?;:3'xJ {E G E'é:E§J-§i3§i1§*2€}{}§§'I};'%. A' ' ;:<:z:::3 ;g::a<> 3-32 ':"EiAE§$ MU {FE} EELS-O's?v'E)z7§ 8;' E} KA§,§ZG-G§.R?I}A§ EEECRD E3'? LES HOMBALAMMA W,' G LATE I}D}3GG\5fE}A AGED ABOUT '?G YEEARS {EN GAE} E JJXVAEQEEG O'€*i?'E§);"%. 'aw' '

99. I83.

IBECAD BY I-HS LRS G J SVVAMYGOW'I)A S/' O LATE ANGAD1 JAVAR.EGO'WDA AGED AESOUT 70 YEARS G S CHANIJIUXSE-iEKARAIiX£-1 S/O SHANKARALIGASI~f}3'FFY*' "

DEAD BY HES LRS Vv KAMALAMMA '-

W/O LATE G S CE-LANDR%?gSvE*jII£KAR?§mH ' AGED ABGUT 65 YEARS ' " ' G c RAMESHA .. _ ..

s/0 cHANDRASI-n7:m§m1gg'r-ii. AGED ABOUT 57 YEAR;3 f G C D1-rfgmsiggajzu 3; .

S/O C1:1ANI3fRAS¥IE1{ARAIAE{i. AGEI3' A£;_©:3"1"' '54» YE;;'\E€€~., . 'C';i1zIA§~§;rU3$é:A3i§V *i*:w1}x » s.._/0 ._czA1A§€:>RAs}1:€KzaRn.m}1 Aeg;)1A3ou'mV5' YE;-'.RS G. C. 'Fa-.w1§<:,U MA:'--.?_A ' ; we C}1'ANr)'RAs}§TE:.:KARA:AH 3 ' .A§3:gI;;I'§_ ABOUT-.43« 'YEARS . <;--v..R;M;a:§f:;.r;ANA'mA 5:» g.'.{;s. ;;Ar'§E: V RAMASH E;';'£"§'Y 'AG;:«:;:3'ij 58> YEARS <;:g:<::x, Séz§;<;aN'r§-EA S ,/'5 RAMASH EETE'?

A' * 4_£§€%E§§E} .;%.E§(}E§'§7 $5' '?:"§:"iz":§2S Eii?

" :E<2Rs%.fvEE'~xL5%..

'ﬁg-"/Q S§iEX;?'€}?§j'§R2':LE§*§FCvAS§*§Z-§;Z"§"EY AGED ,é3s.BOU".I' 79 YEARS E\§AI\EJAP§'A S ,1' O S.§*iAN'P{A§€A'E,,lNGfiSHE'§"?Y §}E.£}'--§.E3 E3'? SE3 LRS JAYAEVI MEX. J, * *1?' I {'39.

' i'23i§*~.. ' ' W/O G.3.NANJUNDASI--1E.§I*"£:? -54- W"/ O I,,A'FE3 NANJAN 1.3143533 AG iii) ABOUT 80 YEARS I)I"TIA.FAN I*3S'I--§'X?WXEQ;¥\ 8/0 (3. SHANKARALI§\§GASI"}ETI'Y AGED AIBOUT 64 YEARS G.S.SHIVASI---1_ANKAIf2A1A1~1 E-3/O C.SHANKAIQAIMGASI»-»IE:'r"r*Y AG 131:) ABOUT 51 YEARS G.S.\?ES}~IWAE\EA'I'1-{A S/O S1~£ANKA}zm>iI>A AGIBD ABOUT 58 YEARS RA'FI---INAMMA '--

AGED ABOUT 6 3 .~Y}s:A:a:;- -. _; = '-» G.M.I~>A£zAM12sz»«1A4" 'A __ 3/0 M.AR1S_PIis3'l"FY.. , .. ' ' AGED ;----xI.3»;)L:itf E3C;_YI3AE'{S _ :.:§1A1,ACi;;-*;;~:§;~1pf§fE*Y- . ' v _' _ _-- S3./G S1--iAI\:"l{AI~Z}'aSI"i=1%§'1.'§'Y. 1.')EA[) BY ms G u :\m.Gsi;.R;i;;I':; _ 4' V sxo £18';E~{ALACi--AS%'i1.§iT1'Y' " 'mi: {:13 g'-X;'I3.QU'Z' 6:-":2 Yzaguas 3s;':>1>,zg:,zNG2xsH::'1"ry :5; 1:; .,J;;i»,--:.:mz;>gs;»§xzﬁy. E.)E'%ZA§"} 23'; 21:5; E;-RS " "s:.;§;;---§'a?x?;xm ._ ,.z<> §:1;>:;}_:x.m:cg-;xss§~J-3 '§:'1"':"~{ ;:{;§;:.;> A?-'%{}%,E'E" 55 '£32;-ms; ' .. ' §'--'3E-{E=i'i¥§5-'a 'Ev' ,5 {} §_A_'§.'EE"j E'}'E""§5'%§'?;f%£'~E EC D E-7~3,.f':' {E .523 .:*a{}EiE;} 5\.}E{ﬁ(}E.E'E"' 59 '1"EL:1'%_E%2S 'A (c3 SE--{WAS}-"IAN EAR E3 / 0 SH") I7}AL1N{}:'%SE"§ E?Z"E"'.i"Y A€:}E*ZE} AEﬁ(")T;.E'.E." $5 Y§§s5\§{S .117.

119. RAJ HG OWTBA S/O HAN UMEGOWTDA @ THAMMAIAH AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS G ORVD EEG OW'DA S/O SUREGOWDA AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS PUTTAMMA W / 0 LATE MU LEMAN 12: Mz\§'E£I€GOWI)A __ ' -..

AGED ABOUT 7} YEARS    j

NARAYANA   A.
55/0 KRISHNA _  I
AGED ABOUT 3?' YEARS '-

(21)

§2AVi
s/0 KRISV£*i;\E_A . ._ _ "

AGEI) A3019? 32..1Y§:;e,¥~2s3._'L[ AA _ ib} M,D;§_RAMES--}xEA:". ' .A 5/0a_r)-I£v'E:;GQw;'aA_V V' :

_AB.O'UT,3O '\_'EAR;"3 Kz}'=..L}\MMA: "

W/0.jXf1E\&y-iE::QG'(;j"i'?I€ﬁ}'h~ 4' V V _z_\cr13',:j" ~A§3oui=? 6:3 WARS (:93.(f:§~:;r*~;1,€jwg~~'~§{1a:'I'E'3' SEQ 1,zaf;iE: KR1sHNAsm:'1*rY TAA':;1E;:)'-AT£soU'r .37 Y§iARS ':.:::'_';

G. M';?a'.$§k§€ATvEU 3_,>'£; .3-..:'=(:'}i~; G..:v1.:\z:L:r};:>E«:G®w£5A " ,.A<:§_E::> £23053' 5? YE€;z"aRS ' Sf{'1?§'§'§€;EE¥E?:-sizl i5;';G i%;A'.E'§%; <:«i:z€5.§xz§:;:}:}§?.@<>:§:§}z2 AGEE3 AER} UT 75 YE:1'3'*;RS . "\fANAJAi'§SHi W/O LATE CI'IANDRASHE§§AR£X AGED ABGUT' 55 YEARS E'€ANJA.M MA '{V/ O MAYE EGO\N'E}A

-- {€34 AGE'-IE) ABOUT 70 YE'-LJXRS

125. E3§"iA{)RA.¥\J1TS/'IA W/ O LATE CHiKKEGOVVDA AGEII) ABOUT 70 YEARS E36. {:1} G.3\!§.NAR/XYANA 8/ O M'AYEE§GO'WI3A AG-ED ABOUT' 56 YEARS {b} G.M.CE-IANDRA -

s/0 MAYEEGOW'[)A AGEI3 ABOUT 53 YEJARS *

127. (a) MARIYAMMA .. ~ V ._ ..

W/O LATE', C}--iAI';UV?1.§COW'[)ix~._ "

AGED ABQUT 70 '§_{_EARS=.._V Eb} S'EiIV'E3GOW'IiA.A _ AA 'A S/O LATE? JAVARE;GOW_E)_A . AGED A_i3QLJ':*.6'Q YEARS «V " - "

128. ,egJ;"I:5»:;:[;" _ _/ 0 ._31~m'eV: ;AR2\,PP._+3 ' ~«-- ._ - AGED. A}:3QU'T_ 5 8 x:'E;--,rx.R.3 I 29 SHAB/1BTMI1.IE%EGE3GQ3?§gfLDA _-S/0 s':~v1E'";;'1'x'230'-Mvzx 3 Aa3.£«:D ABC>_U'l' 48 YEARS . 'I V~ . . - . . . . . .. ' " ~ _ SEO, §'€«§A¥EE1GOWi)A >,:§,_:3.§;£3 ;?;E3§}U'£' 33 \5z«:;sx_R:§ '-:3 ' §'»~:;:*£i.;z3;:3' 3:3:

Q 'E'%:§{}E~~1A?srEE2-E) A'és'sm~§ V ' g-Eiéﬁiif) .g:5{:»:_:':§ {$5 Y§§A§'{S AA 2 31 €;,_::a ,AKS1TT§k4ga§2A ' S50 ?U'E'?EG<}E?v'£}A AGEZD ABOUT 63 YEARS ALL A.R§3 R,!'A'f' GQIRURLE VELLAGE K.!':'?"£'AYA HOBLL HASSAN 'i'ALi§'K 8;: §}ES'E'RL£C'§' 33 E ., . PEETEWONESEQS ax {By Sri: P.MA}~I'f3S}*I,A. AIDVJ AND:

L THE SPECIAL I,AND ACQUISETION OI*"FICI*3R HECMAVATHE IRRIGATION PROJ EC'?

1'-IEMAVATHI LEFT BANK CANAL D.C.OFF1CE BUILDENG HASSAN yd! THE) {DEPUTY COMMISSIONER HASSAN DISTRICT -

mxssaw I

3. THE STATE OF KARNA'IfAKA 133/ rrs SI£CR}EY1'ARY ' "

VIIMANA soumm E~3AN{}ALORE~560__O0 1.

T}-EB EXECUTIVE CAUVERY NE-EEEZRAVARI L~ItGAMA._L*7;:

HIEJMAVAT} :1 VRfGf<iT'B_f§;§\JK' QANAL. D'YJIS1ON VTALUK & INSTRICT

5. THE' £)IV£SEO&;xL vc_{}za/ﬁqzssromxaa MYr3.o}szIs: :3'1'v1;~:2.:'o.;\:"--«--

_MYSO*RE" _ "

= :3. ..f mV§<; S"£'AC: 15:; A @..'e?.. §"{AI{T\éA'E'AKA " E3':f':'§s~.§ECRm*ARY " --- Tm,,N13'«ACQU1s£T:0N I.)§«:E>A12':*:\«:§«:;"x1"§ "w*5.,;*~;..;3U:'LVz>1rx:€; " ~ §3g'aN€'i;;i%l3(3§{Eiw58G 0:"; 2 _ R§%1S?ON'{}E';l\;'TS nifigz' ii-7'E§fN E{§xfZ'§ZSE-LE.--E,§.){}E}§3EZIE{§, 53.81% §3Q§% E31 "$9 R3. E?.i'"3; » R§;._§'aiE§?SS°§~?:'§.?zs§Y2X'E--E, 5%?-7'E-3§f3A§§iEZ§f} §3{}E?< ?v'§'}7?i.?»"§£%Z.{T.E~3§:'s;?'E3 ;'§E3'i,?C ' '1'*€..???i 3%} THESE: WPS; ARE FILED PRAYENG TO BERECT THEE R1, R2, Si R5 TO CONSIDER TEIE: REPRESENEIQTION :}T.27a5,'i0, 29x£0.E8§ 2G,i2.i8 & 17133:: & To PASS THEE AWARE} AS §€§3QE_5'Ee:$'§'£<:I'} BY THE:', PE3'§'E"i'E€}NE:':RS 'V-':§3E:: A.NN~ E; F, G &. M, ~£;;;~ * ~ §.E'€--

'.I'I:"IESE 'NR1'? PETITIONS COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING ".17f"£IS DAY. TH E COURT MADE 'i'E"1E FD LLO'WING:

GREEK 'I'h0L:gh 'mesa Wm. p€:i.it§{)n$ are p(}$t.ed {C31'_.;?r_1'c!i.ii.:aii:21fj§ I'1<i'é-:1'i1"1g. with the C€)13S€*I11. of Eeaxmed COL1.i'1E3€'.1 <51-"1_ bijtﬁn LSidE3.§ £hey are hcaarci finally.

2. In 1,1165%? writ, petitions, the §:%§:t:i:i'jA1':()§1:eI'5§*}3:1\:c s<3ti gl?1{\:.,/21 di1*eC'i'.i0:1 H) the 1'eSp011r:ie'n.1. E?T(_)'--§3*...;i to an£i. 8"<ij.t}'"-Qazisider'VV V {ht-:13: mp1'esen%:a.ti.():1s3 and 13z1$_$}:1T1_ *21}.va1fd."'-Copjvés of the ;"ep1'eseI1i,aJ.i011s are pr<)'Cln{*.ed'~_:;i 1;/;'i1V1.1'1":*uxjt,:,1"c3éA::.,--£E7, to 1"}.

3. ' §h€3" pe'i;itidr{€ats >1<1fa§\e>=£-1 éétated ihat, £h<»)§_.I are the owners of their 1*es;5é:«c:f{ix»*x:? I"1(;_iiSyE_isp«1j€§p€1'ii€'S and x-'a:7ani: sites Gamr LA'Ke1i.ia§-'é1'--vItigbéi, I~*iass3a'1': '§'21E:.ak :«1r1:i {)i8'tr;'<:£.. '"§.'11;-u.

» €:€C;"'£f1,1:'.,viS'.'St;;;f'-iﬁfjandﬁfd by CE1ag;a.1'av21.1i Casneli &1'1C} §T*i£::11a»zv21ihi 'Ex%'£'%i,~'E3e:: {ii.s§¥.,I'ib':.2E,i¢;*.:'s--3 =:?2;mai, 'E;'E':z.'g€ '%.h€t §E€)1.."zS{;'.E§i» aréz :-::§.%;u§.:;.i.e'i:§ 2%? §<3W:?'z° Ears': as {'?{}iI%§}271§'f;Ed E0 fhi'. Eeaxﬂ ii}? {.216 $3613 " 17%;' aF;E"i€? §':::m:::E. 2'31?-S 2% K-?&s1.:Eé {J}? iééez? €?si"}E'1f3§E'E"1;.3{T'i'.E{}§'E {:2§' 'L121:-'~. sszéiii "V.<:T*2."::1"22';.<.-1:». f'.§:€§'é3: .":';a;5:s §3€3t?T£E 2-2 és:*:<:=gj}2zg3;s: <3? "WE3ie1'.§" 5:23:53 {.?<}§'I¥.S€'2C§1if3IEi,§§-2 "the HCRESE' p:*Gps§,rt.ieS3 have? basil {§aT}"i£¥.§.§€€§ {£11613 '£0 {Eamp;1<?S5i and S{}:fT[EE'? 91' the h!£}LIS(3S of the peE:iE'.i{>1'1€;11$3 E3;a.ve 21130 C<)§L2?:§3$€{i,. '.Fh€: g3<>.Eé§i<,>:1e:*$ E':£.w@ éﬁizlied {E1211 ii. is; hia,:"'z}'2f'uE €61' A %/

-;g:;_ t§.'}.€I1",l £0 reside in ihc SE-Lid i':0L1.&s<--:s. Ulldéfl' 11116 c§1*<:'L1r11ss'{'.an(:<:~s. tht: Siaie G:)\,~'c~:'r11m€m app(>i'n1.ed a }'Ii§,-$1 Lave} Conznliﬁee 10 :'r1ak€: an inspszciion with regard to 'the eXt:<3n'i of <:aL1sec1 to the house pmperiiess in V€l£"i{)L1S aiffecrted. >i*1-Iifagévs. The said committetz géoznprised of the V' Cc)nm1.1sSi0n<3r, Mysore Distr'1(:'1'. 'WhCJ"'E3.CE,f3d as V1.f1EV..Cha1r};12i;1 and six 01.he::' officers as n1e1n¥:3erss."';'1"1*;_e:TSaid';%g3i;'m":§it.eé~wéis. <30'r1sE:ittzted by mder dat€C§ 1998' v..<_h_d Go1"L11"W V Village an 22.10.1997' and a icieféxi1ed.._rep<j1-is .W_;j;1sVA_§u':3n1itEeci si;.a1.ir1g that about k5O""h{')L1.sé$ :,iT,}4i'e ﬁ~'i.'l>'I2e.,g_§_t3 s3:i1.L:aEed in the lower level 0£'t}1<:--IQed t.he_'sL1i:>;e;f1i;é{1'rib11t:()ry canal and that (Q11 21r;*.'t:T'<';*I,.TV:'»3.'_;1;'. and Céarxlpness. there had been dar11ag%:&<t:}:s.uS€.d.' {)';.<.1 tT}1:;'Ti3:;,é;s of the said report G<>v€:rnn1en{ Order wau;9.pé1ss€€:i _013..}."5,EZj: 1999 and c0z1seq11entEy'. éhe State G0v§§z'1:I:1e,nt: <ir:éitiVéd {.0 acquire the damageai §3rape1"£.§'.€£«3 by A iSé§'L'1éz:ri»z.§£':' €>l'VE'..:3etif§{:a§§f.i€);1s Ui'EdE3E' SE'fCT;§{}I1€-3 5§{1} emd 66?.) of the V v§§...(2i:":é_ .§*:.§?'{"1'{.v1<}I;'F§'§v'§{.3I"1 389:? §§"1E'£'£3EL:";E?.E'§.€:%"£" :'<:?fe:*r&{§ E5} 2:55 'Q36 H ViT2:.§v2.E§99 amci 122.29% :"€se;'><:*<:i,;%v€:E.:;. T339 g.;:"i9eé:*a:?:é::.€ '52'? {E33 p€é.,ii.2f{::.§.e":%§' i..:e; iémz. aiiiér é.E2€: E§3§;'u.2§:1:it€: 03" §'.E"';{;*:

Asam' :1€;"§'.§£E€z:i§{>:1S, {here ézzis bﬁfftil E16 d€E§,£;'.f¥7£}iI1&£'£,}Z€}2fE 0? ;<':Gii";§3eI1Sa%.1'0:: anti as 21 reszzii, ihéifﬁ has been no payrzxezzf

--gLiS(é. The p€"{ifi{)1'1€§"S have aiss<:» s::{>:1E.€:::;ded tha': c:e:*'i,am .--s§.m.iE2>x.r§}*--§3§a(:£%<i §)€Z"S{)}'1S in mher xziﬁzzges 3/3z1"v€ ap§}r<;a<*:h{ed %'/_.* .Ij»/ ~2()~ thisa Cmxri, in W.P.Nos. I 4~5'7é1~853/201 I and W.P'.N0.22299/201} for i-E-3SLi.':1I}{.'E'. of :1ec:€s3s21;r:,-' di1'e(:1,i0I.1.<5 wiih mgard 1.0 éhﬁs ;3as&sin.g of the awzxrd and }}£1}.;'}I11€'.I 1'{i of C0rnpen.s:;1€.i0:1 ami the said Wrii 1.)ei,i.1.i.{>I3s3 hm-'€:

of on 4.7.2011. The peiitioners have also "

regard to Iaeighbouring v'i11agcs"' Néeijzﬁai;~:a%1a_h.a1Eé,. Garlgzmaihaiii. KaHa.r1akez'e and. <>£'.i3;Qr'1ViE'§ageS--, _ ém.-t:a1j:i.i~: '11§i:'--2§ been passed and <f?()?I}p{:'.2"£S8.'{i(}E} i1;}.S :;1i5.3'oVb€r:_nV ¢3Ii:~:§'i3_ii'r:~3Ved, but V ir1S0far as {he pc--:§.it'.ior1§:z's \--'x-'h(),..:1I'_é"{GS-§[email protected]"O[. .QQI{'3.1E' Viﬁaxge are co11ce3'r1eC1, 1.}:1e1'<2 }12is "i3€:ei;_ 211;-Elf?'séi'§3{i;.i:i21t:ion, I--lance, they I'12:u»-'6 smxghi. a cii.=.feCt,iQ1i"t'e:)' ~:1:i:'ﬂ€"ZTé53p{§'fidéT3ii7i'S3 to pass awarcis and ;:fay {.116'{>T§;~:11péj:f3s;":_1.'i03§i to the pet.i{..i.0:1r:rs.

4. I ha *6. hezxrci" 1j1I,.e.""l§§é1é"11ed coxxnsei for the pe£'.itie:2ers and; £€<23TL:f;1ec:1. {;'vi}xQ'e'rhr11é11i. Adv-'0<:a1e fer z'e:;p<::1<?é<:~:':'i. N055} ':10 3, ' dad 2:n}:i,_iea1rz1e<"§ 0011:1563 fer ;"espGnden'%. 30.4.

25." it; €352.__<:i«::g:':%i.z:::":{£E{i an beizzzéi' aéf {ﬁe ;>§;%"%;i'{§<:::'1z'33":=ss éhaé IE1:-;-*. S%.é§€€;% 'é'f§<>*a;*=;%'r;1::1:a1':{, has; *;.a%3<;m": .21 <§.c2:':is§é{::'§': 2:} ETﬁE}'}.€E,§:)iEi'E;.&1"§.£% ¥;.'§::>, " §_:::>._:':é%.é<i%:*:s:*s:§ <31'; a<":<'t<::.::?:%::. :31' zhi.-i-: :,i;=2:1':2'»:;§{% {i'£%é.E$§?<f§ ii} ihsrjtig" §:{.é*;,1:%€ fpé"e¥§:>er'::§es; due is» EEK: {?<3z:s»;f;'r:u{i:'ii@:: <>§ "éhﬁ §€z:::':av2:§,i':.i. 1,«sif':". ' BaI1i«: C2-ma}. begged an {he i§1Sp€C'§'.§()I3 mgyori s3ubmi_'t.i:€C§ by a jainf. ins;;3€3ct;'.on <:omn1im-::€ 'i-'sZhiC§§. has baen 21cCe§)t.e:d by ihe High Pswsir €i:::§m'mE."i,:i<€:=. A<.:€f{):'{§§§:g_§E3L .21iEqu:is'£.i.i:31'1 :1c}?;.ii.%ICa*{.§{m:-5 C-«.

X \;<..'v>" "'»'¢t.'».» were issued. housci pmpﬁriies of the p€.£.iti0n€z's have bfiffz} acqL1.i.r<:d b5; the Siate GOV€:1'£1I11€;',Zﬂ for the purpose of paym.em', of c0mpeI1sa{i0r1. The p;'eIin1inary and £1393'-. fina1 r1c>1,ifiC,ai,i(3ns are of the yézar 1999 and 2001. but §;fs%2:i.21 1211336 0'!" a decade, no e:ffeI'1.s have br3<3:r1 'put, tot.;§21:s£3,2iwé1r!'f$ ' and pay Corn;_:zensaE.i0n to '£116 pe1'4it§<0'ne::?..". '--E'hat;; in. ';*é3s3}3=::k;?i, bf sevetmi su1*r0Lmdir1;3; V-*i1i£1§._{€S. th<3°'.S1::?.1.é Gt)'-33:1:1I:::>n€;':"A.hé3.s. i'n.it.iatc:d acq'ui.s1'.1..i0n p1"0£:eedi.11g;=2:.V c:o'r1S£d€z'=i1_"1gV-1.Ht3 EXVt;<~5i"1t of' damage ciaused to t11os__e villa-';g<:3.eii's(3':m.c! hg1's--pgsg.éd awards and paid c.<>n2per:s211.i(3fi; * j£*3.:z*£', i1f1é3§")I"2:i1"LTV'as t;.11e peE:iii.0neri~3 are Concrerrled, t}1em*is disci'i:1'1-i.ri3,1i0ﬁ;_ HE, .t:h'ez'€f()3'e, SL1bn1il.'é.ed thaét. a.'(i'i'r@_<;1'i'¢31*1 =is;$n1Gd 1,o""i;'h9"i*esp0nd€:3i:s to d€i.<--:r'1'11ine the C?Of31]Q€'I1S&E1,iC3;}:'E1§{'}Lt1» the same 1.0 H16 pe*ti1.i0I1e1's.

6. __Per {i'c>:zi,1'2:,V'le£1§*11é{i. Gr()V"€3§'I'1I'I}.f31'11. ,Adv()Ca1.e has» $tdteCi 'i4h£1'f'ir;~,.% 1Z11si:a1i':""t;-zaiseg {I16 acqL:§sii§<m r:{)t§;{"ic:ra3;,.i011s are of vEh:e"}:fe:zIj "ami ZOOE. S§1':<:é:* 31:3 zmrard Ems §}€':€I"3 ,:~:>21._<:e;-:_a€:<:§ 'évit.§?é.§12'3. 21 ;::»;*:"1;j;i{}3:'i of §w<'; yeeéri'-3 as»; 53§,§.pz:ia1'éé*.{§ ziéziiez' Sa>.<:7t.i{3:3, E EA 0? Eliza V_z5i{,'§..3 E329: z1<'.q1.:issm'::>3": :":<}§.§fi<3z1%;.i<)§'}s,=; h2:z.vi: E2-:§.>s€:€§. 'E"':h«':_%?:<%§"{i;r:%.§ rm {§i'§"€?{3E.§§'}'2'E é;.<i> §.'}Z.1S:§--.'"r3 an 2;wv'2;1:'§2 £72121: $539 in ré3s-,~:»p{é{:i: sf' 'Ehessa §}('i':iE'§£}E'1€f1"§5. Bic 2"3i:=:'~;{) :;i21t;.e<f'i §§."12':§.'E 22 deirisicm was takeiz is COE}.SIIi§L1i.€? 21 new COIz1.m.it£,€?8 far Ca:"1°§;ing out fréish m:~3p8<11;.i<:m {if the dE.':§IE&1_§§ci'.d pr9§.)e1r"*;.i&s and §EE1.er€21§£,e:2' '£10 d€&?idE as is "\R7h€T.h€'.1' £7-:16 sziid pf§)p€':E'§i€3S have £0 be? &3.{,'C{U.iE'"€j€§ § 3:» and c{:>rz'1pe11sat.,i<3n be paid. That tfhr-5 e:arlie1' r<ip<>1't su.b1r;iU;'.e:d by the jczsiné: §11spec1.ion c7c>r:r11né.'£.i.<:«:>. which has been acceptecé by the High Power Cc)mI11.ius<: has baen rczzjected bysrdel' dated 11.12.2008. T1'1.e:ref<:)3"€. ths petmiozlers {:z1I1:Ii01"'._""':f:é};»{ upon the said report. He, t,herei'()re. subrniﬁed .iY':2a.1.j:he:"'w1f§'i'~s ' petitions have L9 be disxnissed as 1':h_ey'...:1':fe v..-*'i_tZhd:ii:=:imzV'n1¢ri1..:-_ V

7. Learned Ceunsel 11:31' retspV011de:é'i. h&1S :§_~€'.;:ii'Cf_i3 tﬁ--ai.'=iI' V' is for the Stair: Govemmem is an §1v.<;,§:x_:w..aw"Q5525:-:}a:;;.e the C0mpes1sai.i{m amdv 017113? ﬁres£§<§'r1('ie'f1;E has to deposit. the 2,m1«:)u.nis f;,"v:'r:";_';*.1f,'*":s:.'f:11aez1t and the same would V' by the Stats G<_w'er1i:j1e1f_1.1,- é1:'ie.i-~.._v14he1f€fo.i*s,_ 'app1"0p:"ial.E: orders may be passed Hi ihese xxrrit "pé Li.t.it;--ns.

8. E:rz<rep1§,;z "v!.t:'a,I'I1€'Ci {:c»uns€.1 for the pe%;it.im1e:*s has :101::ics order dated 1Cé.9§2iC%C%Q passed in ems zxanng-:<7ts::E m2ii.¥;e:'s '$.13 <%s:}';,s:":€§ ihaé, 'zlhﬁf T§%?j€if;€2ﬁ€}"§§ Gf iizg: :"sp<>:"'£, by <;:'d.s:° ::%s:".s{E E i.§.2.2G§8 has _ Egzétsiz s€;€"'22.si.€§€ E3}; éhés {?G'{,1I"'€. ami. a €§§:*e{:€.§<m. 'imszz issusﬁ %;;QV 'g>3.§£ {I36 <:r:'}z:':;*;<-3:;2s:c?».':',§sz2 £2': ':1s:"ms of césmssm. gzweayai = wpassed. 7§'heref0:'e., the G<>vs1'nm6nE. Advscziés {:21;'msi; gﬂace reliance an tbs proceedings dazed IT/I.EE.2G€}8 as the said §3m(:a>.sz:hng;s 'n2_1vs beer: (gus.s§":&c:;§ by this cs:1:':'., %§f:.'f§ E:h€E'€f{§.F€k a/~ ./ #34 recommended, f'-'urlller, irnprolsecl. drainage system for the other" porlfion of the village abeve the Clmngravalli Canaljrom the new canal to the old canal is also ree(m1mertd.e»:l. The grm.lr1cl level j will permli. such drairzs. There are totally .' lwuses. Tllé' average ground. level Qfz':'h.e 1;ill;?,fl§e;- ' 862.530 mlrs. and the bed level and'jlol;;»lle--pel.:Q;{" L. the sub~dz'sl'rib1.:iorg; is 86OI;'32£? :')1lrs..f'-c:n.d'A 861.220 mrirs. The 1.l:az':'er level 2;-:;"'a;:a.::;> e_j3ex'z* :l5ell$..\_ in the cy'['ec::;ed. porli.c>r1.*q._{ l.l1el'l:;ill'age below the ground level. ""ve.lf5ar£'ial sh;"_]Yi.r1g'.=Qjllvillze village and provision of _A."in1';}z:ovec:l. ﬁ'cZ;r.c1izfuiqe system in the ol:'he}*' pGIfll(_?+,;!lv Gf?_Vl4l'1e'll>i.llages are recommended.

.10. l1'e;es:be€z1._Wél{iﬁ:e;3t.ed in the paroceedings held 0aéx'.?..I'.5.1998«ljyVl}l1f:_li*iig';--1 Power C<:mmi.El,<::e chaired by the Divisi.<):'m/1 CQm_n1i::si.t;;1e1', Mysore. '§'hereaﬁ;er {he S{:E§.E,€ Go1§fé':fn;13Ve;'1.§;: }_'1&?.S":CIl*3'eE?E;;;.'f.V'.'.d lie zzztqzlire the clazrzzzgggséd pm§3erlies '.:=:.hc'i=a<:'e::;§:'ed:£:2§§§y_ has isszzed r1<3tEfi:*al.%.{3ns_; cialied 29.} $3999 z%;':é.d""§l2;'2ll:}'.5'}QE5' zzmlez" if}? pr{_>\.:"i$'§e»ns sf 'lhe Earl.' Sazbseégllezzé, f is i.hs::~ }s§'e§,2221'ac:e of lhﬁ' :1e'£'.if:1{:e1i..i0ne, EEG :~i-stéspe ?121'~Je, Eaeen 'laken is air: :;l22:;r:z°{i and {§Zl§°3lf}l.3;.E°-E%§?:'f me {:<)l*:':;3e.2':s.e;aééim ;2z:2:>:.:;¥:E.. 3:'; 52:5': 53:2 .EZ?Z§E.2Q€}E.%,, 21 €l(f'{f§53Tl£}§} la-'23l.:~s %:a§§.en by me: Slale w'GC3'»J€3"{'I11'i1€I1'l'l iheil if the €f(}"§TiI'§1il,l.€€ zziready eon$I.i.é,L1l.ec§ haiei not vi$§;l.e<:§ emf; village in respeel. {>17 which z:e<;ui§;i.l.ie;":

;:>:"€;eeed'i11;;§e ﬁeld been iI1EEé21E'.ec§, {l1e:": 2; 1'1ﬁ'V£--"' {:e:}m1:::1§.E'£,e€: Caulcl /1 recommermiecé the aequi5;iIion of {he lanci, and if is only thereqffer' the 661} r1oI{.ft'ca1.i<)1'z is issued. Nothing is breughi on record before this Comm .:;0. Show Iihai" any fraud or misrepreseniaimiﬁ'Q"{sf--- ccammiited by the pemiorxers herein in c:Q.;1_z}.iL:a:1ee». I with some Qf the Qfficrials and :.'.ha{."z';he C'.pp"r_'C>L:'nCé3'¢Qf;V V the Gouerrmqenr for {1Cq1.iiSi{IiOf?.'(gj5; i3'ié Iiouseé iri the village was the resuﬁi. Qf the ésgnie. Tfzefejkare, merely becmzse the I)£:>€si€::f{0;i Com!'nissAir>%.1ef"ig:iidV not persorlally vi3f~f;x l'!1e,L*-'i'iiaQe Corzferldedvjby the ieamed. G-ovef2':fneIi'{,e. { cannot" be said. thai. (he erltire..:Egzcquisiibiori'~pﬁ;§iee~$iings and the awrjirﬂ get..ﬁ§iiiai.ecij_'0.I1§lEiltzi. the whole proc;-:>§;sv,.F'1{1S"I'f.<;__ be._V:=eb'penedfyeieagain. AI. team, _i3§v.:fz'i}i"1:i1e ;21,_Lr;2_c§'1*'f. "cx.r_1d cf Armexure K' pr*oc%eeedi1'1gse3Qf I:he"~«£}oLfernmeni" presideci over by iiae = Prizieiﬁal ~..S'e.,<:é'g::{az*g.; of the Revenue .Dep'0f£'7neﬁL'.._ Kl::7.VV"§:§Q:L>€U€%:.mG?'1 .£2--.f2--&8. a meei'.ing;; e%1air'ec2 by e. :"?.._}':'ie.. ".{{e:,:em.Le Minisiier Ems .I:.ake:'z a deeieiarz £0» :7a?£.%f;:7e€::ViI'?:e emsard sand a:.:é&€i, ';'"ur£?1ez" szieps is be zjjcziceﬁ ix": {I318 §?1£éiIi'£;"?° zmég ggjfjer G. :*e;3{:2?"i: is . v,__é';z.:§';mi':f:£.e(§ by 5: %'~fi§;§'z éleeeé {f<:amm.2'.§.i':ee e.<>ns:,i§:s..:i"eai in SEES; .?"s3§;€:.r{£ by 'SE2:-3.' {§+<,sz.:ser;'"::*:ze?@£ {}:2:§er :7 E. E .E« E 2» C38. E11 is Seen. zizsraéi E§'z€;<; {}<::semme:2 :1 {}3"{E.e:" §§§:'. E E2438 eGrzs:'i.§.za§':'.n§; she Higglz ilezjei C<3mmi::"iee :73 {he result" Q3" the proeeedingg Qf the G<:;eemmen::

(iii. I 7-} L08 .5'-irmexure Ar1ne,2:ure 'KI as airecaoigg zejerred. {"0 §:.e:"ei§'2 aiemze. cizées: 22$: reopen S1.é.C'?1 eases; :.:2Ez.ere fnspeeixm £.?_§CiSS aéreacﬁg /' * / ﬂ3g_ C:{)IZ1p€I1SE"it.€', flhff petiixicrmezérss 21:35} ailtlel" sim;'iaz'1§,s'-sii:uaE.€rd pe:*.r:scms as on aCC{)u.I1t: of the a<:1i<}n cf}? State §,)r0per':':§e.s have ltseaarm. c:i:;1I.naged and for third p'L'11fp(>se U716 ;1<:q1';.i_5ii'.i011 z1<3t.ii3c:21i:i():3s ha-we bee-11 issued, I do 3201. t;§71e no11»~passiI1g Sf an award within. 21 p<§1"i{>d of (E5) 3:-e>£;ié'&:'"i"1¢rj'i":1 " the ciiaieé GT iss-suar1C<3. of firm} 110i.i.ficai~,im1 v}fo:.214cE'"0r):*a1év3:1 the way of £1€'t.€I'1'11iI1iI1§._,_§ the c<>11'3.pe::1::~é°:3.'{.iC11 A}'.:'i;1d>"Cii\S~bLfLEfSiffig._.{file same (:0 the pe1.iE.i0I1ez*s. 'f'I1€._1,E3<:hr3ic2i'} V1":.r.E(-.=_. of ;5'21$'SirV1g'0f arr award Within a p<31'ic)__d of two yca1:*.5_s as Si-i.p';1}V;7ied 1311361' Section I 12?: of the Ac:t.."'i*_i 13:13}. \.$?c3i§i1d'Aa11f'ise zmiy VV1"i{:'.'Z1 the powers of cmirlent V51'o1':1:§g§31 exCr§:i'séd by the Staff: G0v€;V'i111'3Té1*zt; ,j'Si:1<:1-9}: ix1_i',i':..r:" iz"3ss€';_1:'1H'€§ case the: Siate Gm--'er'r1met1t. iI1te11d;e: in c:3121;)'e::ﬁ ':;2_iie..__'é1:Qs:'<> perseneé whose pr'0per'{i€s5 33:6 damaged (31% £i(;<:Q£,.=.z:£:".:)f féie said 23lCU(}IE, the st.i;i>'L1_Ea1t§<::r1 u.I1d.er S$é3;€'i;i€};f:L 1 Va. :3»? 1 Vh'<:*'*';":.<§'a, c2m1:{::t' ctaalze in *;ihs=; K7é'"21}f' mi i;.h.<é Siam :{}'{)V§?:'V17:4r>ﬁ€'.VI4'1'{AVVi"1é*fI1C§€rEE1g 5_~:0€,ia.} jusmti-3 E0 the {:i'i,izé:::S by {:a:§:g3<%z1se;a§§31§§ {hem {ms :az<:{7<:r:,2:'11 0%." 'aha ifiéiiélfigiif cazzsseai *;:<> %h<~:i:: §}'::<>§:s:%:':.2'{%5:3e 'E'E3€=:°e:*fe:»r@. r:i&:::a";§:»i'i.€ "£'.§2e§"é:% bijzmgg mi; 2i'=3z'éi1'{E A§?3::'.';a:.;:%s::r:§ 3:: Q}:-3 5j~.%§E."i<f?;. ?;:er:":'1s:: cf ;%::%<'%ii::}:'; €11.53 5}? §':%;é:. ;"a{7:i,, Ehaé. "jarmuid nei: {',{>E"£':€:'; irt. abs: 1x~*a':; {sf $i.2':sf;e {.§<;%;.2€:°z*;:":2<;%;';i. de:.ermi:1§H§; {he C0mg}€s::s;at:iG:;. and dis%mr$§:':g the 5-221316 to the p<:*ti¥;,i(:»ne::1"s gg hsreiri. / ' '13. Z11 fact, iT}.1r:% Siraic: G<::Ve:rI:zme:.1t ctar1r10§. take advantage of its <>wr1 iapse in not passing an :a:wa1'd wiih3'__.r.1 iihe st',ipL11ated periad and "LE1:-:r1. carltend that. no ;'eEi€i"_4}1?_1}s._<be¢11. grzxmed {:0 the p€i.i'E'iOI1E3]'£~3 within the date si.ip'a;:§1_aiE:t'1.' . Seczion 1 IA of ihe Act. As E§lI'€&1d§,fHSi'[email protected]"Eli'i{§::iSgS;L1~?1E1:jEt __()f ' the r1ot,ii'icaiions in the i_n.<_~:tar;€'. Céliié Afar' 2:C€:;r,1£§'Vi;r;;g 'E336 pmperties for ariy pubiic }3iiITg,§{3S§¥ as é;A:.:_cr},:_ thr:.;i:gh.xy1'1icV}1 i.he::_ V F Cempensation has to be paid t4<:V¥ 't;}_1 <':~ f}v€?'(i}:'{.i(i.}§"1*E,?f"'E5'.. Ir1:}ihe1t', View of ma mattelz I do nt,?t_ 't"hiz11f§;. E1i};1{. "T.'_i'i13j 1'§jSU'§CtiOI1 stated in Section '1 1A of 1:116 Act. }A.7_{5i1V1VC£ i:_()1"}j1e..£ir2.2y of the Stale Government. git} "a;1"e'i.ez":i%_in::% 'the°<:Q1:§;f3e:1.s3ati011 and pay 'ﬁne same jib (E26 TA;3f¢i._it.i0V§'§é;'S. " ' »

14. 0'17?'4U§.}1(é1'a.Ei5§Er££_i '"IQ"'I56 <:0:1sidered is t.hat the State {::1(}\;'€fE7}}'I1€?I'1J{i]'l§1d.V ieikeri §I3i'{'.i.a1,i0;1 :0 pass €O?1S€3I1'L awards and di$b1,i:"Sl'€A '§L1'Vi;€:3'{?{}I}1p(":ﬁ'&3&1'£§{)I1 in 1':';'.Sp{3'C'i of C€:I'{1E1i'.f} vi'lia;__§jes viz'.

f'°é;:_<§é1:3;§;'E2.;31i., u1'E_§i.os;1E121}E.i and {}*L'E'1€1" s'w:tth vi§ia;;__{<;*.-3, '§"§:a'£ being; Ehéj §3{}&5iiE,§€§Ef';. E§"i{i* Sizaie C:{}':?€*,§'1T?x}'i'1E3I1E, gramme? diss::::"'§mi3:aai.e §33s5<}{r.;£:iV;>:i:s E:he*: E§.§§I3iEé1E"Ej£ giizzaéifzgi ;3a";é:"s=s<>n:<,«: if: <>i,§';€:" "viE3:»:%.§;;E:s 213%:

{3iT§E'E{?§="E'E":€?i.§ 3:' w§:.E2 r°€:g22.2°{.§ £0 'E'.§";€.%:;': §:}€:§§:é{.:z':<;=:5's~3 '2>;§*":i} 9 ":3 f3'"3S§d€'f1'E.S 95 C%{>::'u.r '~.=-Eﬁezge. in éiacég am: qzzegfééaia {gf discrimination has also been <:0r1sidr3z"ed in the ewe? dated 19,9,2GG9 :*e§.%3:f:'€ci 'ma afzaave amd 133:3 §'€'§€'£~'£§.§T£E. p0:'ﬁ<}:§. reads as foﬁbws: "

-34-

".21 . Coming to the ﬂex!" question. z'egarding dz'seriminaI'0r;; treaimemf to {he _pefZi:'i(>I1ers Has COf?f(3fEd.€d. by the learned Courtsei ifie V pei:i::i.cmers, if: is not in dispurle thaf: ::r.:;;;!---- Conmmiee which visited Yamasandi balsa';

visited several ether villages f.¥fae£.L4d£;ag H Kodanahalii and N;.I~fasaI1aiI.i pilblages. .1":_zj\'c»1.f:i: if:-:. ' the rejoinder filed by'>:?:}ie~..pefi£io:"1er;;._ L3'§.Veg;«:._:f'x'a:re*': speciﬁieaiig; ::'c>m'7er1cieci ir1. p.aragraphs- T QV}iha{i' the Joint Ir1.speci'ior}. C(2z":'1'.}}/1i:i'£:?a:'e V'iI:~!1'ic*h m;;'ize:§z the peI.iti0ners' uillage'al_5o 'I:{o}_1'::1fta.f1alii village on the same day-.wiFza:iV is :v,2E§--2--O6 and likewise,' 'same Uisiireci N. E-fosahaili village it-,sei£_, 1'n;':fe"Spe"ejIf Lj'bat}1 these villages, b_a,sVeCiV._a:'z:'1.:mg «qffVVV':¥}1e Jaimie Inspection C<;>m_n1i'zI V" « . Vacqzki-s_i:'i01fz proceedings were i':-1.if.ia..ted,-- V "'3'}h.§: 'Gaz;ez:rm1en€' gave appmzsai for aCq'zaa--f3i1.ior1. ._CCnSeg'i1en{Iy, final deeiaraﬁoa was 'issued and awards came :0 be passed. 3'2: is alga }~.ii(3f; "€23. dfspafe {hair {:2 respeezi Qf' these use 3 _ based on she eonsenég award, eO;'3?'_g:*e%§T:§af,zTOze:. €55 »:§:'s%}s.z:"see§, 'F§2.i.S fgeirzg Effie 3:,_2Osa'?z"€;rz., {here is ai:2soiz,:ie£y :29 jz:s§§}"i<?az.€a:": ',f"er " fjr_eaE:z'.n_a size pez:'f:'.i{mez°s3 33:33:; are zihe z:z'£ia§;ez:<; 53;' E/2::::::a:;§;n{§§ :;%2'EEa§;e 53;; :_2z;::g3§§;§32§ 5: 53553:»:-em ggarae :i:'e§~:.

22, Tizouigh Governmem Advocaile canrencis that {here u;:ez'e F10 eemp£a.:ni:s wz".Z"?1 regard :0 {he s;ai.a'. E,w:i) gsiéiages and {he e<;:mpEa:'n:,.§ were z'e:re>:'a2ez:§ azzig; z.e:'.§;¥": regareé {a me viiiage Yamasarzéif. in the es fr' ..

_ a , A, .»(_g E F. < #35, Goz;ernr71eni Order -- Armexurea 'M (The main basis: for rescinding the award is the aiieged report qf the De_puZy CC}ITlfI"i"fSSi(3?1£3T'. There is no sspecgfic reg érertce in any Compia:'mf:s in this regard. aga:.r3.S'1,*--.»j any villagers allegingfraud or misrepresen1'arib:if~. 1% is also not the came of Ehsz responderit.§mS'i'a:.¢..: ~1- Goverrlment': that any action is §r1i£ia§e_a""aga:if£s2?{ any qf'I.i1e au1':h0ri.i':'es an (aim grm:r1.d*'_'I:ha.I;"

and cc:ancoct.ed report was ::;ub;j'?1ir.f'ed.»af"ter"&jo%1zi.a'~--.¢ izispecﬁiarz.

'I'hersg]"bre, the ConI.erIIai.oﬂ».aa}:athe peE;i.:for2e}':s I'f:a!.W;']' the action. now sought; I:Q..bé"§.r_ti'1'ia£ed iS'p<é:frn.€iI:ed, it will CUI10l.LI'1i.v£':'O_:31iSC{'iI?'§£_i:'1C£'i,i'9f'y.'1"f€?CL§.T?1€I1I, also merits acceptance. V_I«i'.:$;f1'.cé, _§i*:Q¥5f'1{i:_'vN(V).2 is also arlsweredi' acC{_§rdxjrig;'.:y.._ fa;;::,¥ur Qf {he pe£i{'foaé3'ﬁs...T_' " 2 E:{Jf'V.r1.x:":V¢2" i;.§é"C:rs?u.msEa11{:es 1*es§30ncie:1'é. N059, E E0 3. 6 am » _ €.c:> dei.ermi};1e me <30rn§3:i:;"zs21i;.;L{)r1 and €§1'SbL1E'S€;' p€E'éi',i0z2e:1's §}€i'.E"€'i§1 32:51 oiiheg' $m51ii21:'E3,-* $;T?;,:1a§.&:é. g}é§'~'..53{?iE?_$ . *s,«"53lf{E'::%§": ea peréad <3? fem' r:1<3nt5:"§S f1"{}:1'1 {"2362 giaﬁéi =::~{' AAI"§":{,'.€§;§}'3';,,_. {T€§'E§§ié;"'{§ {:{>:gt;j;; £3?' thég airéiﬁgd '2%?'§é.i": 11%.-6 ;'iE}(,"2Zr'€? '_ Vrii:°é:_:§:§{>:1, t'.E::£3se: writ p@€.iE.§{22HS 3:6: disp::::%;€:c% 0?. This 113: also "'zf:o'.'t £,he3:r' Asiaz1d.";

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court