Smt Ranee Govindram Hassanand vs The Chief Secretary Of Karnataka on 25 July, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 4]

Karnataka High Court

Smt Ranee Govindram Hassanand vs The Chief Secretary Of Karnataka on 25 July, 2011

«§¥§§§E%IEf§T 'E'E":é:*3€e E?;§)p€3él§S &§'€: p:'@:5;e<3:":i:<-:%{§ €ig;&1§E"£SE, fix: k:a:':2:é<i S'i:i;gE.e ;¥'::sci§g<:%'S {::rde§", «:i::~:€£:{i i7§3V2GE..1 EEEESE-3£':{§ in .. 655Qf2§E I {Lz%»?{§;'--'s§')B}.

24. '"§'hé: §'a~::i',s ef Ehe Céiiééif in 'iyriei 21z"e_ t.§;a1'i:_[t4§*:As5 Vgipggsaiéééggit. {}'W'1"i€{§ Ehﬁ iamsis s;€'.21r:d£r2g,§ 21% Syvfﬁéfatnaéél :-:,%:.1<'iV--»'f3;5 :;:s:%;:;s§;::mg;; 3'? acres 3'? g§um.a$ af Pui:Ei<:na.h21E§ii' *~;>i?i:;§2s.g:;£;§ VEV-iebiig B3.£'1§§Ei§{>§'€ North 'F21Euk. e:%%§An'§§11§s0riEy zzcqazired and the c9mp€31S3g§i£)n:.ﬁzzég..V%§T"=;>F';f'z1.%5h%§f:VV--§.»;:;r'31% tipfﬁﬁﬁélfii, Wﬁh §;r;€--3 £m:ard--':;f§::éi§L§'z;§%:%.'_§._ §ii':;(:%1a$€§ éize iaxxai §Ii€aSU.f}}Z"i§.§ ggunias af kharab Eami .21: vﬁiag._§;::3: {>11 5.8.};QE§5, E§€2w€v€:: E:»:,;;1d':ra: is 5%? 3;<:§§uir'€:d Vida §1"§_%§;i§§3i;";.aé:j_g '2=1{}i":Z;E°i<f21?:_§«:1§ Vda%:e{:§ 25,3 L1988 and {$3331}; n{§:'.§f 3{s9g€§»:'e_:f:§ .,{§:.:::s2<_§£.»E98? far the g::~:.1:'§3<3s~3§-3 :3? mzizirtﬁgaizrzingg {:p:::.:"é"§pa{:::--".";§.:":}§§Vgrsﬁexzazy ta'; <ts:}:1€.§<}§ {E163 %:3i'ff€:{'ffS <2? n{§i$<5 §:;{}E§'z,:':§=:}:'"; .2i;;7:{§"':=<=;z§':{}E<:@ €"Z'E':.':iSi%§€}:"i zmd 3351:} {(2 §":Tié',€f§'. §l2é*. $§a::<ia:'€i$ {E2«:i}t:i§ %§'.:--:i: ?<:sEE:.2?i,§s:>:"2 {I<}:";'s,:*@§ B<>2?::"«:i "§'§":€ £i('.€§ﬁ§§;':%i§'.i.{3E"§ asazzg %}}>' $135225: E-'§§')§&',§§§;3;§'"i§". E}; Eiiigzgg '%¥.P.?€<}, E ,1 E-ir'!E"Za§{§.§'E ' "i%?;§§§V€§§:$§E?E§E€%:'%§f;"f:f§ E3}; '%;:E';§:*: §z'-:2-3;":*:e{§ :'%§:':;g§et Jz.':_<.§§,{§::, K23? i':":§:'-ti. <::*ds;=:::

ﬁg siizziégisii 22.?;,EE3E§{}, "i'E2a=?:'*::E23;i'*{.{-rrg. §:?2e ;::.;>§;€:£i22.:'1§', ;;«:33g§§'<}e:<_%'i::%{'E éiées iﬁévisaiqara iiemaith by .f_i§ﬁ':§_g; 'E-'sZ,;:~'a,'E'*~Ei>. if EQQK 'imé. 2.-vé€;.§1<i>:V.:g§"'*-gm}; 2"a1,€: :31? EE=§L§{Tf{?;€f$§:">2 %--i<3Ws3v::~':*, i;E'm3: §fi>ivi.:'~:;§<f,>::*; igﬁifiiéfh? 'E33/i,..§?'_s;'--;» .;:%:§§i§é;9; 3 {§a€c=:d 29.'?,1Q9§. i"<{ifS3€i'"V€',{§ i;E3<;*. Ei%3e:*§.y is %hg%M__;§%pg}:é'§:§.§1*:é.§: '§c:} E3;§)§E'€§§1(','.}'} {fE3;<? ':}€}"§s"€F}'iH§€3,§1'§. zmgi sgeek i'.ij:§;% {Egi:1§3"é§';E£f"§.:§é1f€,i{}.:':-- .v<}V§"V%:§g§:A' :§:':"i§3{'§§L "ﬁle; G<:wre:"m§::e:1i. haw ':15: a:::;:e:{ied" fi_a'i".%1_t: :ja::;'a,2.{:V$i{ oi :.?1%:e:

a§3peEiz:11'{ Eb: {he v2;*1?£',1*1dr2m-*a'i ef '{}"1€ }im1{E:%fraéyfz'21§é:};i:§5:<i*:§{}r:.

On :10t,i<:i:1g that §LE'€3€fS Siailding 0:"; Eihﬁ 3;§.:':s§éV5t: _'§§§ (Ema azzd £131.63 ezirih Eevsiiiiigg <§;::§§1--ip{3'z3.:2<Wi Wag §:Jeing €:0:1sf,1'%VEC'?£€d::' "'£§*:€ %%%Lg:pp;é%;;:n§ggea .'_W';\_i?J.Na$.§E*;49#§55G /20; L Th<3 mam Ei§1;:§« «'ap§3@:'§E21m's (ream: bﬁfbfé? {E16 '§é321rz1€::i Si;3.;{§¢; Jélgééiggééai wizis ﬁr1a%€ ﬁ1 view-' 5;? éihe: 2'1<;z1~'a.:é:§EE:r:aa§§s::»'n if EEEE" ¥l7§§u£VE3F';§i{}E€ 'i7€3'1§*'«v"¥i,}.';;€ pé.1:_'§:3{>s:: €02" WEEECE i§1<:j§-7 2-v€:'<3 £i{3{§§i§'?§?£*§_;- "«...€§';'§:§:f¢.:~~ z1_<?q:1§$§E:.§z}:1 §3§°{}€':8€{§iZ'E§_.3,,§§¥§ hzzwé §}€CE}§33€i' §5v:ri'£":":3;<t§::;s:§'2._i£=:$: v_v"£:§:2:§~V' 2i{T?{§1,£§S§?ji€:I."E §>:°<}{:{:€<§i;1g$§ E'223;ve €i'"§{§€'.{§ £21 §:'%.:;§iiifE§,-L ''E'E'?a':::=--- : ii-::;%..:*:':§?{§ Sizfxgié Jzﬁigaé, by §'3€':" <}:°{§::-31:: gizztﬁd '?_;Z§_.E{}5§_"§--*:"£:§<é;t:?;.@:§ ii/is wriii §f}&':?§'§.§€}'E'":S=j-Ea by E2{>E{§§'§§;§ !;§";z,':E; E';§":z:::"«.:*. . _ :'":<::a_ {i'i::'€:",%3a§§'é<é.2f::::.:.>§': if 31315": izzmais:-; fi'{§§":E Shea? §:z':z"§?a:§s§'.':*§g:.§. §}¥.§I};"§I}{.'3f7%{?

:'1{:§ :'E_::a:§:. §Z§."§2i" »E%§.a2;E;é: {:2<:s2?a:é1*§'z§z2<%§':§', {?E?£;EE.E"."§{'§§. Esaz {§::'e,:<%E:z:%{.% EX: é:§<..= 2:p'§3<:§Ez::'1_E. Eaaii §E_E_£:d E35 .?.E€<fn £f§EéE%.i:'§ /' E €388 ;::z:{§ Ei?a_:5;E'€<:>, .'}.éi%§§%;" "§E}E%.E... ass i.E':é3: <.>§"<i:-"£55; <;2'f1:.h:*:-: éiissmiiggséié §;22§5+;::%§i_ in 'E':1_:@ss:':? <:as<-5:-?$ h2a.'ve.:*: 21¥i;i:2:im<=3ﬁ fizmiiiigz E1319 ezppééigézmé. * H {>212 ;":"1<}:"€ EXEFEE ;}<::§'.:i£:i<>1':a HE: S1EbE}1§'{.§§:'§IIi:iV§i'£'<.t.§"§é;?§ :+jza;>::fT<;>*15:_e;§ VE%--'§*ii §}€'iE'£,i<}n 3&2; Eéii; ':33! {ha c:i0£t':z'§.11é:: Q? ms;-a:§'L::d§{f:=:._:2:i';_V

5. Sr: V€z:*:§'21ppaT 3::bm§'%,_.s; §h::3;i.f20E E imgjghi: 314:): havr:':-- been :"eje€:t@d am? Eachiisg <:>z1E_3;, as; the }3f;"i'?;.iT._'§€)§'}.';'?3:"«':?§§"{f §'@e1.2"$ Q? the i.S£-'isL§3.I"i.{i€f (if 'ghés :1:§§:?.§;§::.;31_.t:i£;';;fs%%§5 " V '?5 'Fh;:%.. V..E,e:aui*':.1_§<.::?:i'1*1:;$§A ;'j§§i3i*::':g.;;jW_:,1?:: the Ayex C0u:"i:'$ _§udg:1":e:':'3{. in *:3hé;*:'~ Asp Aﬁg ANQTRER Vs $333 :4:--§}g:§'§;:i€:§ .m1,é;m:4' 299% 3a 492 s3'§.2a.§3n.":it.:=;9 that s}r:{;'£%. ﬁiéil' ?_.'s2é;i2faé; is }7€3;'?§Eié€f'{§'.§.§}__E:fi€ {}(}::§:%':":3.'r§:€::2';:'.§ 31': <32"s.11.1';{>€, E36 '§°:~3--

{:§1>m*t?_?£%:;'.%'?<;':% _§z';%.;:§:T';3ig§§':s:{% €10 §;§";.«:3 €:"&;§:w;':§§<:e <:>2>m{::'r, <;:vz:.z1 if 2;: _g::2::"é:

7s:::__§f_i:: f€E§E'";'?1}: §'1S a.m';;:'j_'*:.A:"T§§:»::2<§;K "E-E63 a.§3<> bfiiigﬁ ta': 013:' n<>$;.i{:s2, {E39 .§f'g--ps:}e;'.__{3{éu:"E,3§ ;§'a.:{ig§::1s::*2::'E: :21 t.h§-,*. +.:%as:»;<% (if §&§§§iL§RE 'f§3§:«:?sf§~ﬁL:i;§*f3:§}*3¥5:*9a:.fE§§*§ g§I§"i"§§@R§"§"Y mg ﬁﬁiﬁﬁs in ' §;f';§~¥ ;ﬁg§E; 4 §s.§§§ @"§'E§ER$ :*€r;§é:;:'¥:,s*:£§ Er: §§;R 293$ §;¥%§, mz §§33, 'E"Efs:% §"€§€"'i,---"§.i§"£'§. ;>2;.:"2a;;;§:"2;:§:.'g': GE" iém s:<s;>.:_§.=:i jE.".i€§§§§;E':€i¥;T§§1 €:<€;;:"2ic€;aéd E:@z°e:'s'1b{-3§m%.?:

"351 Z5"f'2g>,:"é> 53 no pr:';v:':9:'.o:: 2'31. §.3?.<;> 5-kfi" éméi ff V j'}"<:s;'2'2e€i' :F':e:'<3:,a:'z£Ee:' er'z<:zb€z':'2§g 5.32.53 E3522': E0 z'£3(;:3V:3;:::4::§§_;;._ Eamf a<:{g:,:.i?'e€i :3 €m;3Eesnez7:zi' 5; :s:{:}'zsj;?z»2;£éb';f"<:?t ~}'£}?"r:r:iré§ .sgfT "

sséém; and §:'E"a.z3f:" -::E£(;E.mer'2.£: as yer mia-,>.:§:. E ~'? é§4' %~:.:.§é;>s _;a'z;* '$15.33. "

gyrzkzaide _;"7c;r° r"e'3~::?<}r'n;@g;ane::'e3, §i%.e '£2-§:;s':<::::?a%

f)?'GE,3§.S§ef)?7: fr: me Ac: or (Sis: 2%Zz.zfé§::_xj'3';:rr:eii'-§}fié:ég.::§§§.ez' aaz'i§mrEz£.:':.g Size BEA £23" ~:je3--co:%é}éé;; --£g:an.ci £Ea':*'e::"§E':V'.<;:':

Carmof. be issmecé {(2 Eigw £~3'f32'§T:0Ezggjifzfivégg:;§£;%*f:'~»:>j' {he Earaci :37: {he grotmd z.haIi'_ ii" E2ad._;;~:~*frr1f':€se--<§.& 52:2 :f.E§l.,Z'f'§1e mie Qf przmtisééargg r:cii._zn.::¥:L, 'V perzyzif. or C{}ETC§,OI"é€' :3: gb'f¢;Q;c?i"" §§;_ "'§j£:§?.::'z<>;I.' be irmaicecz', {,0 cfornpei V2fJ§2,€TV{§bv:3é:'f§.':<:}§jz::f étm._:r;;;_?{.:Dr0}1ib§§:ed by {aim If uiozgigji Ex: géiéégs _g§§a:;:'r':"'~:?f ':',§'V:_;£-' 3£'_e::£:u.€:e;: 'E"E2€2 p:"z".n»:é:ipEé: 33'"

_prm?1£$s;}:'7;;' éeséopggéél» {The ctfrczgg-ns§.e:2?1£*es be no: &}:3£{}§ZiCtZér;.V?}5é1f E.{i §:'E;;£3 ;:a:~;g> ':{§ff'za?2C§,' ..«.§E:1L'::h€ <:§'a}.':"s€ 5}? z"a;*}0§:':d€:r_ the §€i£¥.§"§}€"t{§ Ss3:":i€;:r C{§i:.g15;s;%§;*» $333..&;2§,r2";}%:u'§fr:8;r $.,Paé;.i3; :=;ui:rmi'i,§; Eihzﬁ: §i.i*":.e d€.}{T??.E'i§1€f af ' 'L._:"és:%~j:;§{i§<:9;'E,éi £3' ﬁsgééi::;1._'i:*{:1"a<:'t::é=:{§ ii} i;E1i$ {37c1S{?,, as tiésé zxzrii §3€Eii:i:>::

ﬁésii SEE ..;§j..:%;€g>fc'2.:'2iE.€;"% sagas»: <5? ;;::::;é§{m, ax-*h§<:E2 ha.:e~; 3,:"§sg=.:2

5.SmE)€.§§'qué§'2.%Ey 2-imi hag azf:€:ms3éE_ iii} €338 Zigﬁgﬁﬁﬁéiiﬁil. E-kl: ss:i;?:m1§'{:Ie

-é;E:.;éii'é% ég 3.32%: §%:%§E;'§1_;; 4:}? <;":fz.2:if21.E§§_":>*:.:;;s.s+; ::§":3:§,:;% 222$ EEK": :";2:%;§§:2g at}? éihs:+ §§ arivié <::5;:SirI;:cf.§<;;:'r': :x:<>§'%i 9:': §'E"i.€E i.2;2:T:;.d;s; in {§£i€é€~3§i.i€}.t'3, v«;'.ni{::%1 E';;-M.-E give::1 3: freak {','.EiU:S%3 sf E-'£{fi'.i{}§'} $55: the z3.§3§3:1:§§2:;r:%1.

9. '.E'h€;-t ssubmiissiaéns 9'? iiée ieazrrzcii _<:_:}i:~-::;2S€:§ '~ E3.':i§9'€'3"

E'€'I{?€3§;'€€{§ Gm' éh_<}:.:g_;fhﬁ°u_E c%«:>'n§séc§&°:ra§:ic>:1 ":s;:'1é£:';3:é1£§.'i.;3:5; ,i_&3f 'Ei§€€i an 21 causys {>f21<':t§e:31L Whiifh Eriag é'i{'§E?sf:i?."'§'L1E}S€§f§i,§€§I'£ﬂy; We':

z>v£3:':°LzE€ i:§';:::é §3I'€:':§£Eﬂ§I1fc3l'}7 ab}§%<:€,§0§1§;€;% :*9§««§'2:§{i£:r%ﬁ.2§;:, gégiaig? amt? Eezathesig raistieé by 81% Veere1g3%a¥é£,'- 'A -- ' K KG. it Wm:Ed._::0§i ugsaén the Gavernmsnét ':0 €{:I;C}C"i and every 'bié; (3? the Ego. {:2 taking 'sﬁriisi view; 2%: 13}; '§5i0I2."5Ee Suprenze Cemfs jzzdgmenéz in 43:? 321%. mm §*'mERs v.

L sH§:;§;§m§m*§ 'éc3<3:'9§::I:§§f12;}§ r$p®ri:ed in ($393; 1 SSS 256;

'E"%iéi,_<:»:a§%fi§::g ..:>§"«.:4§*§i%'*--éguasaéyptus {mes zmd §°a.§$i.:'1g :22! 'she {',§"sE}:§ 77,_<3;):1§€.3*'as{:t;fi23:3 'éE'{£;E'}§$,;1 ?sz;'€r": if €,me:, ﬁe §':<>?: §:::>:z:;'§:§%E.L:'{:<-3 2£.d€£§:;a_%;e "v§gE"€,§:;':.;f:{i :9 :.§:i:?2;u§ Eh??? :':E,{1{§i§i$E§f.i{}}L Tim éaarrzaéci Sing;-iiie zfiiiigfff i'%:22.E. ii. is»; 2%}? €.§":<;>. £72136: sf :;ha-E .:«:;3§§é:iE:1:'1':

iéi§f:_;iE:'é'é1§: iémdg g§<':<§.:i:'<3{§ 'far i§*:e:%2us:;?:.:°ia,E §::u1';3<>:%£-, Eifif 33:?-zizzggg z.zs;<3£§ '- '=§'s:g:~ ma: 2E:§f_§Z"§€;fi;.E§§Iii§E{§ §?E3;f"§}{}:%?{?. :3}: :z"£;éS;Z::§<t:3.E:%21E. §}z.:§"§>{;§:?;{=:, 23~£'i 3;

"~ i.1é§:'v.f:E_<:§1'T%§<3 SEE§)I'€.*E1'E€;"': €f{}m"'a in {E39 (T121556? GE' Siiigﬁﬁ §:%'z.e E:'g§':£' 535"' 2":'E2s2 {,T§¥;€ZE"EQ€-3 53,?" she user zgf §':E'::;> izmzi 525:; per {Em ?'€;%§fEE«s'€{2§, {§f;}f)I"{}i?€{'§ picgn. 2': 2'3 §1;*°z.£.e ££*"ar:zE, :2": {E29 0:3',g£:3a§_ :~.::7§'2@ms-5 §;§?:{% ;'es;:'i€e:":iz'a§ :;:;arz.a=3"sj?<};* {$32.8 szagjffi' z.::c::°E>ci::§;;é?§: S€a.::ag{3 P:,zr§;E<>5zi€(3r2 §7'Ea:u', aware :'32:.e'3m:i.<3d. Egég e:?{;:z$f:mcied. (2:35: 3,316 $€Z??"i{3 ;:>:.:.rpo$e is 3{}z:g?'2i"'._:*:{; .§;g. ' servgcé. by Ema as:qm'sEf,i.ar1 53;' {he farm'; b§;..:.g8z".2"'é.g;2 Z; 432%'.

{:2 E37E<:><?§<: 'xiii N{}:ze:§'w§ess {he a{:5;:,§fr;ef€§f~--§§i}':.d i<'ré:;_.{§E:f... Egg? ' {riS'€?{f 5;; 2'.?1.e €Z1:)rp<>ra:':'i{mi {bf ré.é_§.Cé<::2£'§aZ¥C:m2- €3§}5Ef3€£3:f%{?i€{i. pazrpasse j'::er iés ez'rzp§<:gees c){:Eze3r'VL'f:E:.§ §;Q _§?2{}5%5'--:g§ﬁ}?§%{f2§'§ in: {he Sewage E"3z.gr;'fi;C:3.€:z'an. "§?'5;a;m.. :;y.§§:c,:i1é§"-:;0§., §f'E:€f'?;€;ff2}§"€§, be rE€fC8$S5£I"_£; §:'ha§: the §}f"s;g;f::r:{E, ;§_::ﬁp€}5e sf's.s:>z,g£d COF?;f.Z}"'££,£€ Ego €Xi:s3'_ {iii . :c::u}(:zf€;i_ lgiiﬁzde and p{}sseags:'or2 f:'a,§:;*'é§:j';,. ..'g'J0iﬁ 31$ £,}'*:;3 :f§'z',si:§;....;;j" {he §,.a:%r;i Acqwlsiiéasz. ' pubiic purpose c0r2§:inu. es~ié V.£{:_ 'ifsgé ,:;::::<':z'c¥..Vq{tﬁ§f parssession £:'aken 5350 no: :£3ec<_3?§z1é £z*:.:.:r;gEVzA";:§ M o'2*._:£.§j;f<:; .:2§.;"€5§ {W2 §:}Ow-es' Qf' Laizd Acq:,:is::£::n_ {};,f;f':'»ce%;i' ':_jQ§*:'".iﬁ;Eci;2§ possession 2'3: b{f£'Z{Ef3'?§3 vesied in E321/f C -frészé j§fQ%:':« .:;*:££ 5:1zr:z;nf:;rans?.:25; ;'.z*1:cEu.d§ng :;€§:a;:'§:§*§; r".f.{;:f1£§ V':aiE{§{:jea' by heizii by 552$-2 z°e;<;p«:J:3de:2?.s6 '§'3{2sé:'a)$5;ii%§'n_. {ind iiéﬁe zraiidigg :2es5.'ir:g in 5228 Stairs, £0{,>cc2r?2::

Lgzﬁéaéé;,z.E:z'§-.;;::2:§€3:i v§"'§«s'?{"4':.E7.{}?3 H}: Qf {he £55 and :§2er{acg,i"E:'e:* She _;;}'€3%:aedi%2g$t"*:_:?é;r£é3§' 5525 £575'. 522:: :2<:2§:' b€<%:'>:::£;> iiiegztgi £2;/ad my E,5mef£"-<:r{2s':_;fé{:E:=.3325 5* >z:e:€»;:.ec% in ghee 0:.:§2zerx.u T " ii. 215:; 3.1%} §3£'{Efi§ifc'i§3§€. $19 §€?§€Ef éé} %'1§hf3 §;1'é.{;%ss§:j1:::§g§:€:'2é3:::i, 2:}?

I %§ Qgmxgﬁ $2 wﬁg EaiE§¥E€§?$£ §

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court