Karnataka High Court
Arvind Murjani Brands Pvt Ltd., vs Primus Retail Private Limited on 14 October, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
EEK TEE fiififi fifiilfifi' SF' E5"?
mgmn TE-{XS TEE mm gm' me' €:;$'§*(3fB?;z%:§,§.§: 12$.' fi 1'
BEFGRES
THE H$N"ELE MR, JUSTICE @§:?;§§ 'KEVQY 1
CQMFANY' yflrifi-9:53 ';x.._;'§_'g f2mQ;:;,;
EETWEEN: M Arvizxl Muxjemi E%s:_a:z--:1's:§:3 §;,i{i E§e;wé_:}g its :°<:%g§sf.s3f€-rd :9-4fE§é:§:.'%aé;: .' _r'.XI"§'§.3¥.{i Miiiss ?r£%ET£f:§:é'?<3sI' " J Narocia Roaci, R&1i1¥;x;ra.}§g:~L:ii: §7'a}$si;, ' ;Xhni:§{§21%)e?:{;i 3230 {iifiu V' _ ' ' E€€;pr9ss<:m£:<:3a:i hé';r;"§':§'é;'} E332' '§'i'..:%: ., ;%::t,E1<>:"£$e(§ S§gr"::é{k:}2*§".V V' "
17%/'§;",E?.~2w§ Rafi .. " * -
{X-7i;:s::é . §?:°£;=::s>§<E%/:j£":_ii; 3 §3'§:'1;m{%'e3} V H _____ H A . , .E3'E1'E'§"§'§C§N' ER. {E-3?'.$§:§;;a:_§{a;§*.ss%;§§;§'E»:":;f:v:,{z:,& £aE1}V§"}{i';%"§5Ei E'{}E?{ :22: j:§,§N§L}éES §.J£%E?%i g%g}<;zf{}:':;2gf:s%~:§:s§ Ijgsfifi:
§.3';;*§.§§:g_:,::4-.:; Eigfiééifé Efijizrvs.-:*£'.s;3 E4-i2_:{2.3i'§:<2::'§.
' "$25:
§ gwziv ; __ :"::5;g;;.§v.<+:~.:'ia1::*:¢2:§ s:§E"€§{':éé 315%:
{i:*{ss;s:s3$ 3?" E';-'§a§§L ;%3§2z>:?§.::§ E,.z;~:§'<}1.:%;:., ._§§L';%€_;é";T;:"'2;., §§:'-:_§=é;;:;§..Es>z°@ W E§E§{} iéfig?
__ ' .z'?§s:i':_{fé'sisg}:;§:$a:::':<i,a2{:§ E':§::z*s;>§.::": "$3; . V 21%;.%.._:1::2.:.;;{.§,§':: §}§'£."€?£'? €103"
, b R §~::% ?{f} is} 3;} 3%': ?*€"§' ?§§'AKA AT 3 % ./ "Ea :.2n{§:3.rV ::=;_;':§:"i vs§{a%;.E§.Eza.r§.:.i::§T:i. 2§§:{I'€ié;¥E}"ii'f§T§.fi 2:.:'é_d ass :e;:,:{:h '}":<E<§:%:1g§_um 'v:?%é%§i§:T§;§:E3};':f,:s:;*::'2*€"'*-..___£%g;::r<%'sz3f:vé;%2"§ii" wag %3§§'i'.em§E izééié {.333 2r:§.,{}3.2:{§E L ' %.é;%?::¥é'%;? <>:z.i:'i2g:%:;?:" '§.'{;?E£«--'g}:{Z>:'E{f€ii§§IL z3:<:E§:':<}:xs'i€{%;g§sé§i ééis-3 {::,:€.5;i4;az.:':{§ia;__§ iifibit in §:.§:'§:~'~;~»v.e:E%<2E;3i ii" 3'33;-1;-::.:s'a,::::s{:§ §}€}fi§"€1£%{§ s:E::%i::':{§ {?§jE.${§§.§{ii%&=; £02" 21: {$122.2 V,éf§j;:§.<:§:.:_§'2§:. <3? %:%,:§i§é%5§~,{}?Z:i,"§§ £132.31' :12?' s;;:%{,% {.-.'k-.}-'"E{?f{§E..§§::-:-§;§(_« éwzé "is: .'£.'€i?',".~';§}€:':".t1'.'§". {>5 {7}f§'ic<% é>1'.33§e<:.*i§=:m E.'sE<>.5 §}(}§§¥f. E3e§(::re {if<::z1.:.r:' {fir (Keri, 3, E~Z:':*r2.7m:i E~3ri«.Am:2 §3rik13m;:::". §ag1.:':":e{i _.€T€}vf;!l"E1SV€:?3g.:V' f_{::.af :pa%t:.ié:i.{>:1<é.r. ii: is iha a7<>z1£"em:§{t::1 0? Iig€§1§«'3:fL.::j:a "%ié.:;jn2;1:"~.i;;h21i,__ f 2*€ésgps:>11§i:*rs1'£. <t:on"zpa:'2y {}v£€:§ the: ;3_ei.iii<§';'x_er', z2_.::3{32;:mé',:-'s $3.3; ' Sp€:<:i§ie:d in thfé ps:%'z:§'t:i0.:T1 2-113:}; :"£%'::;_§é:3:'1cEe:':i..'-- '_ isagm bfiiifl :;:<.é':",as_~:»}'.:-_§'::e:":.€E}~.-' in {:§i{f'E-EC-};€_..iE£L\/'V Va-§1<§§;_ 21$ .:2§:_.;<:«h " .:é:'ffi:::f_f:'1eg0€;ia§,i_s:3:1s% 2:. s;€:t:?t:iem€.nfr. 2?aggr{-:m'i9;£;s:':_.€I"V_<§::ir:<;e »:=,iz"?.;§<';':':"{ir<:§ _:;m:<; E3<3éwe<:n p::.é.ii§c>m3':* :_u:V:V:§ V?'sr:§;§;;§:':d1'§:::iE:_ {}*'§;'E 2fi;}39.2@1G 'ii7§1€fZ.'Ei'i;.EE£§t%F :*e;ésspa:::d;&m'. a;;;es:: {:2 the ;3.§}"i{3*£."§.3'}'§l szjué sand kl ii: 31;»: <?:{2::i:.€:":<§€.§E ,4 2~:_{:§«::2<>wE:3<i;3;<:»:%.V de'z:%%j. ._{;1?"' V. é,§;:%fi.j<;2,:"27éAe:::~ ':3:-§s§:£»:3';:<:E'é3.;;:f':: (iii: §'_:éE, fmiféii £111.:-7*»; {2b1§§;;2i:1':.i<>:'3_:a; ass; §:l§.§§"€'€:rC§ ' $z,::;-is :3§"%?i3.;'§%E'%£.%§%%?@'{}3;;~ 23% an 22%*{}3.2€"§E"é zmé in {§::2s§<?E'::i.:'g€ %€W,-,.
fl i:':;«'2b§§1?.'i2y iii} §:)a§;=-' i.E':e a{f§;:z":i'%,€I:€3<§ <fE€=§3{: xx;-"<.3:.§§{§ :1-:é=><%1§§.::.§*E'. iiifié §;::<?§:<i'««.:;$§7w.v s:;{}}§»-*€:T2c':}; aami 22:5 s:;r;:<"§1 ii: is; <i€::2i=:1r:éé{i éhzai; E'€E§},){'}Y2€f§€}'I'£'E'."{?(}E1:Ti:E3&§_EE'?;}f :5; mm?t3§é:~. {:23 E333; iisis a<§.z';'z£t.i.c§§ dé3E;>é: :;1.'I'l(i c._<7:.::1é<_:§§':{§s:«;_" i§'§é;'i:»§;w:r%i§€:_£{§A:'j:
§E§fj?{§ u';':d:?.r $<;%<i:i';.i:'m. 433 {ff} zmd {f} be z1<5%'::e;';fi§:§%§:i igy.<§Vs:2':*;°;;§v§§1§gVTA7A :}§'E'i{:.s::*: {}E:§:3(it .§<>§1. V é' V _ -V 4, En {).E"{§é?I' {<3 {:<:;1Si{§é3'r E.E"::"«2 p§:erai*;;);1:':" _fE}rw:i;;rg§TE}§r Es;~g.2s_rné3{i (.'(7'§.Ei'3S€:§ §'<>1' pe:E,§i'.i<>:'1§~:1,' §.:fi:L:V1'"a:<>1:.£}<§ fig'; {-::x%.2'a{:E; éhss ':"t;:E.::%v22.1":t pr<>*%:i:-5;.i<3:': Ea} af $'L2;b~sss:=3ci;§.<3:1 {E3 af S€{3i1i(}§'3 é#=V:V:%;V»V4.§§5§ wi':i<:E: :"'&2,1d::; as E.3ETE€i§3E'Z ' I V "z£34%{1.}--{a§ ~ ai;{:*e:§.i*é,<);x E:}y a5ss;i;g':a'z:;3_<%:t3§: <32? . ..::a'Ehé>:"2,:.z?§5se;'* ii} W§'2':'m.:1V_€'.hr: érenapaxzy 3&3 .i.:':.{i€§3i:.é%e;i in 2::
S'g:.*;:'1"'L<2*>:<;':%t%'::{:fi':?:.g;§ §j<>n<;%W'EaE<§;.T:"2. :'u;::€:'::<=;} i.%1s:::1 (E129, E2-}.i':% '.¥;§§<:E:'"fi.?€'i'{§ {E12 ':.'§§'1€E3..§f{3§E'E§}£%E"E:§7§ by <:,g::,:ss:'.:1g; ii €10 ha': giséivéérézci Em: ' zf;:fé§;:§f:;+s:'2;a%}:T=:%;f:i;~ :>f§E::te,; $33; :"2:;g;ji:=;;E';&:z"er:i. §,>:::s&s:*, <32" <:s€.E:eTr=;véss=:§ éa: j€§€'f1':2i§.'E{§ z.m<:.i::ér Eng h:a2:1_€§ :'€q1,:§;;":.:1g §'h€f {:<}§:"2g3g:._j:";:g; _ 1:; g:>}la:.; iihét :=;~um f.=3{} :C"§'%,'E!ff :§_.:':<§ 'i'.§'2é? <:<}m§}.2:n:; A '?%::a:~; §%_>::* .;i:Eé.:::%&% "é?§'3(°3§<;Ss 'éT.%:T<%'rs:%21£?::::;* 2':aé§g.E<;%<:é';c%d 'is: pay #336 '. <:=.:°*..--{<é ::~:€{%é.,§:*<--: $1' <:$§::;3::su:'1::E Eb? it is Eihéii ' E~":§€',''iT€ij§{}§:'E';§§.:i}ji.E? 3;;-';:é::+:zi'2,-":.«;.*':'::.§<>:'"2 :3? fig? <:':"s;zséié'{:s;:".
.4 :36-»v7§*':T2<2 s%é;.:»:é;:.2.é{;:':"}f §'T§£f2ET.§{"fiT'. w.'§'1§::%: ;}s%:Ei.%<}:;e::;:' §"éiT'§if:{§ :sg;e{:::;:'3 2:-gm'?
" §:::; %32;*s..vi;:% Ex-'::¢:=,§: ;s;a?:"az{:<<E :,::__:;g<§§': :"s::$;:2<E;:":::T§:;2m; §%aT>§:":§::2'::2;r Essa 'ii? E:}a:~::
égw as?/.
?%a§% %&W%mmm%w-.s-%<'::
ffigzid §'E{§§",§.€T,'€? :"<":{§a--:i3;j;?e%§<ii ii} Ext: is-312%;-é{i {ii-'i§iE'?;g§ :.:§>:s:': § §§€;'5 {§»E:§3'i.<;:" €19; ;j::<::.jj; E;_E_'2,a:j: ;z::m,>':.;':j:éf' *"~2'i?§§§':§E"i 22:1; {'}%..§§'€E§"' limit' :1}? %..E'21°{és:*: :a?2:%€:§{;=:s is %:z'3a»:E}§:'3:
'3i'§'§{?:« :{,'éaf%b"'E,<32' Ezra ;\::»:'»:}-I' 3:'; €:."E'2:'% <?r::{3§§§;;<.é:° 5:-;232.§i§ &;:::m $2.? :;;m: 3;:.":'3;<";u_:.:€; E:-:5 ~._":;:eiEm;.__%fi:"E:§%<§ '1;'{f; %i:2<3 séautz. '§'§'1<i% §€;'%;_;§&:Zg:.%§.:.:r=:;% 1?_";;,':.s.+> a'%<i;:2s<%é:;:,.:sa§.§; §Exé:é:§ i%'E'::'-r téj'*:::.:i.§é:;'iizézér §2'.§f:*:§é' :3? §.,%'::*=:'~%{.% "'Qi»"'é".""{f§<if-;E§;, :=:e® €23 :%z'2..2:§'§f}Ea:: 'i"§"EéT'. :%§:%3é_§;r ii;
fi:':~:';£i a1i.§i§.1."%&',éT.'i'}'}€f'£'}Ef. <'i2:1'é%<i §5L{}€3,2{}};=€E, z,m':<.'::.m'a. z;§,§:'ém:=:{i Ea x.-ms~:; ?:'§.G2.é'i9§{}{}§%~3;'~ 2::";a:'§ £13 iT.h:;% z%{.§::ié:3;T:d:,::"n. E§é7£i§',i«:éma%::":'£: €?fI"E'{I{'EE"'{?{i i_:'"m:: w§1"m:': :':;.£:x:. £E'E{}§'Ei§§§&§ %:h<2::"¢%:;:1§'é 6:' _1?.:'-1% -1- am{§:::.:":'é'. ezgrééttii E62 E36: pziaifi 3:3}; 'ilhif r£:s:;;'}{3;'1=;':iie§»zV'1f'é. $50 u u.-va.s ?2,4gZ3',,84g{}2§§/«~ Ei<f£?{)1'€§.§i'1§§ €10 ma'-§rg__;;i:'"2 {if Six n:<:«:1t:}1:'~s there is; 3 $:;."b'S-§.§§:}fi%1Ev.
{:£a;§n2 i}":E:1{§(f by iiE§.i';', peE.E£:§:3n:-:jz* {§':&"3 §'36_~':*:;i%,i0:": fiseéf <:9:'i.zi:§m a1.m<3§1':*z.§;§g _ :*<:»';é_§t{%Ev{3:§ fmm .§"€;%S.;}{}I1€ii*::1Ei 22:25? 215; s_~:-1,;:_.':§: z'5:¢Z1£§'iVE'3V1"VE€.{L~?.,:'i'§'1'£"ASf¥{f§E€':.E'§7§.é?§§. ?3's,§.};§'f:%€EI§€i"£'iL came E10 baa? €;3I1'§:. §E"€ff{I§'§FE7{'}. "
Be Ehzaf. ":2;g;"i€j:V mg-1.3:' :;§:«s:"'_.':;$§§u<3 in {;ue:*,:=;"i;'.i<'::n :'<:};22;t:es $9 9§aE;;1§j:>;'"3,-* :'3:f;:§:i<i:z:%' 31$ '~E1;'g§-%§:¢.be&%:': ii~::;:3%L:e<E by p€:i;'.ii:'§.<>:':<3:° Eifhififh is; g;<V3*<::;.;<:T1;e*:i{--E.§,1s§:_e;.:E;s:::,:§§€ _ éaé zjgaf 5511?)»-$;¢:<:§:.§<:>:s {E} :3?' Ss€3€,?§1§{}§'§ 435%,.
§ ~~""'" '' I