Karnataka High Court
Muthyalappa @ Venkatesh @ Chamcha vs The State Of Karnataka on 5 July, 2011
E IN THE HIGH CSURT £3? §<ZARF'~§ATfis.KA AT B§§"éGA§_QRE msrm "mg mg $7" my :3? 3:35;?' 2&3:
gamgg % V mg 2-iaswgg EVER, EEJSTICE ma §::;%.§';r}'i.'.jf~ T' T CRL,AP@EAL, gm. 2§2;{ééa§; '{5f§}{£;' ff: 4- EETWEEM:
MUTHYALA?PA @ VEE\iKATESH3._._ @ CHAMCHA, ' ' _ V gm, gugaawma, AGES ABOUT 3: YEARS, 00:: ASRICULTURE, R/Q.VALLUR;'"j _.'* NAGALAMA_§3»I'rC§ €iii_QB§;I,,_' 4' A PARiAGADA"§'A_s.-_U_,i<, 4 .5 mimic?%%:%{V?:;VM"K£;.g. " AWELLANT {sax SP;-3 E._.--. SIRv£\§"i7sfi?{§;5>,'BA§"E;!, }£'§DVQCATE} AW ._ .
TH§._:$§'ATE GF'":<;éfR5N,a."éAK;a, V - av '?Ti~¥§EE>;é3?~é;i%A§'vE 9@::f<'::1Elg .":*:,s«:xa:M;<L5§t,%.,% %_ RESm:'\§@EN?
{E'f? '§Q§'V\ff.§'g'%Y;§§V%§;}?\'§;&§€ ivzagagg, ;-;:@@,; ~;~:»;:s%{:m APPEAL. :3 931313 8/3 374. ssrwgcv BY «mg fi;I}'_'~é,?~"@CATE ME THE APPELLANT AGAINST "mg = --.Jij§3.;Cv_E:'\;€E?xE"£' 33?: 22' E LEGGS PASSEEE 8%' mg: I: krgzsgfg' 5.3" 'E'UfvIKEj'R, EN' gawa, 25mg W €Q§\mC*m2<; T;-ESE APPELL&?€TfACC{}SEE3 N93 mg THE SFFENCE .363'/S8. 30? {pa AMI} U/S, 25 0%' 'E'E§E §Nf}L%.N ARMS Ag? AME} SEE\l'E'EE'ér'CEE.\'G Bf}? T9 SNEEERGQ Em mg *5 « 'EEAEES Afiéiifi -"re PA?' A mazg 0%' RS, $<>{::@_;-- 1.3", "K? »:/2
2. SLFFFERS Si ?'{}:'?€; 4 MG,?;\T'"i"'E~§S mg? 'm§: {}E'§<"'EE\;fCE P/if/S, 33:? 9? we AN?) E'EjR'E'§~iE1R S€'i'€'i_'EN€ENCz HEM m %jNI}E;RSG 3.}. ma 3 YEARS .AN'E'} TO PAY §':.:*w.:._;E 0? RS. mm/~ §.Ef}., Ta 333333 8.3 mg GNE..E¥~'E~€3'f*£fI'H mg THE QFFENCE E?'/U/S, 2.5 013' THE :Ni);AI€"i2;§:%_M.S Am: THE SUBS'i'AN"i'EVE :SE21'xE'{'EE'*§fCE;S S:'§§AE;L;~ CONC§_}RREINT§,Y} TEEES CRL APPEAL C®MINé§ "E7 THES my, ma COUR'E'i._ ::3E:m*f€§2.§ET*:is ' FOI¢£,GVv'ENG : ~ I JUBfi*::s.f:Ef:a:1' _ Thig appeai £55 by'? étfiégiieggixag aha judgment daied 22. 1' }£__):f§; the Second Aééétionai *1':;§§{£ié;::V:.[.%:;€: SAC,N0.25;'2OGO <:tGr1viC'éii:1g€ E:.h:§'_».eip:35:;§}fi;§':'é.. ;f«;1::*V' me' Gffezace _p1;mis7nab1<5 ur1d€:f§_Se6_:{;o'.EiV ;S{)7Zf;"iE5(§._é§1d Section 25 0f Endiagn AEKIIES A9? and S€:__1*€€:1Ci11ghizszgiz) undegrgo R1 far 3. paréoci {:af 7 §:?€:ar%_afid_ to 1{§é:y.f§_:__;¢.<>f Rs,5,@@G/~ in dgafauii, tic} 51151561"
fog: far fhfi offenaéét Lmcissr Sf3i{,';f§.O'fE SGT? {PC a::d"fu:"{h::§-EffssAé:3%:;<:':3{timg him 230 :,ane:ie:§_*g€) R1 fax' 3. péififid f:>f 3 gm {(3 pay 21 {ms <31" E{$.E,GGG,!-- in <:§efa.u§%., iii} ~ "Lz:z§{i§3{':zf§;'<2 8,31 Eb? f'i}EE'§.',h%;'§°' ;3€=r:Z.{>{E (ff E m<;:1*é.h E233" i:_§";z'-:= 0§°f¢;%1'1{r:5 ':2:%:d@:* Sz'3{3::3'sm 25 hzdizziz Ar:mS Egzri; wiéih gs c§i_§':3<:i;,§{2:2 Efiaé Sé3E}iZ{*fi{f%iS $31313 mi': §:<>:1.:3z,:r:"e§1%:E:g1 5,1.) 2, "E'E':<:: {'.8;f:'~S€f {sf {hi-3 }3E"€}S£i?{iT?;.§E§.{}§'1 éihai; an _E;§.€i2° 199% 21%: "'xfaEh,:.:" Viiiage in H21rija;§'3 <:<>"£<my £3"; f}'Li}"E':'eU_E1I1{_Té? $3.0 file <7{}I1§pi:"22<ty <33" :;ig;§.1"ee§_:r1§%;%r:€:" . a(:{::,zsed, by recteivirag E35589/w 21§§é;€rr:§3}i::¥C§'i:1. _i:£z{;%"Vhe:ss;~::
Sf AL far {ha pm°p<.>ss€ £21' p:'ep£aré.:.i0aé: Tezwr §:iE:»._'-H3" f£V',i?ufl'".§¥§"Z§';§€: I}'N.£E"d€f§" af N£i1E°&3; 'a;r1a 22 :;md"'E..a.maf3'fi, whéicti '?5_a'.¥§:§:: 3: fire "
said Nelrayanappa fa}: :pr{3d;;Vci;§§§;.._hiz:1 "b :§f::3m.'i,1r:::<§-3 Caurig thereby, they gI'€;' DI.z1%.{éhed criminal C0:";.spi1*a{:§; pL1:::i:€Ij1'ab1;é" E3 532%' {PS Further, at; 8.26 22.2215, :31': by CW22 spy.
Pavagaééz the I:'§f0E'€S3.i(i itrimimal {:021$pir,:€acy,; CPE 1>é?e11.:E: :0 {EH3 E10115-is of A}; at Vafiur Rriiéafigfié' 2:-:'3;A:*i Vaf, that iime, the acctzasé were preparmg to '1{E.{3V§V"'£7.'i_'£'_3'i§'.;.~§%i"i'1i§f'L§€'37°_*f}f C'%/E122 Ravi Nalrayema zmé 'w%;1€:r"; Ehéiy ss':m%:'::%j;t:n:{__£i€,"A*sc'§.,.:'~" éihe accussé, the aciéussé .Ne,E '4"-.. i'i2f%,:':j§izj;22%E';€:§;>2: afierzrzpteé :10 {}p(i'£"£ f§i'€ am CW22 by the " j.§"e§é:>1_E';*a%r9 E:2:»_: p<:£ni;§::g* ELEM: gazid re%;<3§*m::* ii: CW.22 wi::Ir: am . u"'§z:§:E::1i'.ia):": {Er k'm}wie£Eg€ eizngi zméié.-'ir s9:4:{:§": {_?i.E'{?i§fBE%'§1E1§T§{fi*?S9 <3» thaé if by éhgzii zzziig E1? §'§é%;€§ {féiilfiéfd €..E.":<-2 <:§€=:e1£;§: <3?" {E33122 Rzwi Nau*ay21_I12L he Wi)ll§€§ 11::1v"e% §}€fté?3f§ ;g1.:§Ei;;; cf ni2,{::"{§e:"
?;§1€3:'e*b3;x he is <:ha.rg,gjeci {(2 have c:}mn:i%:§;@d 0.f3'_%;%;r}_g:,%§-3:":,z%';r:£€z* Sazttien 30'? EPC. R: is fzzrihaz" arheuggzggi""'ef§;fi{zs;i;§':~&§%, Vif}'::'9__» a.pp€E.ia;z:4;1 thai; 2117911865: N03 R:;i1naii§1;1'i'.E€.2é§'::;::;:i;ié§ {hie aforaegaid dexiéz "piggy 2-meti time, fix-<%1e_:_1. {,2-'W :°é€;id €<:i '< aflfi s2;;;°:munded the houge .§I<V"}';':".:VV::&.V'¥.i'?€i":E.Sf;"fVi§'-Vgfiégé ;::V2'e'%,-*e1:2i'. then} from <:€}n2mit.t.ifig..,. :<%<v) V:m"n§'i,'i:§:":g§ murder of was feund in the p<3Ss<3ssiC~:_§§ '{',i:i?:V1'c;Vo1i1;i*1:trj»f §.£§'é.a:Ei A ii': C01'1U'E£V€'I1'Ei{}I1 cf the: Act, zvithaut valid Eicencéfi' E3'-§;§§"§'}g £t;'i}f:i'{:pCt%i§l:®---_3}:,1#iI'10fit§7 'ih€:1"eby§ he has <:emzn1?tt:€d!'L;*;:: ,;€}ffE:;"';;€'fe2=; L:.;j1}:ier 85960:} 25 9%" Er1cE§e1r;; AFHES
3 fez} grave 3i:h_& {.':5;S€:?,_, €316 p::<}S€:<:'u.t.§<>m _E'ia.s eX3;:*r:.§:}e§:E 'in.-'a.§E 20 Wfizzstssesa and ggei: maiiied Exam? E. :10 E &"i§££E~§f{}§L1{E%S€§ fv'E€}::~LE W 2?, ii. '_§"§1é:% <i€:f£3:}':(':e sf ighe .22::<:u§6<i§ wag {X16 :3? £'.:}%.aE *.z:%s'5m?a.1, ?§€§§£-'€fi~"€.:?E", a_fE'.{-3:' Efzaéaréng ihéi ;3:"<:»8€:c::%:£:m gmd ihssr L'?
eiefézzite i;h_s3: iaivgmxéed Sssssicmsz fiucigéé a::£;a2§.i:§.'.<:%d A2 :9 A55:
0%' .213 the {3hé:E;iT'§;f3S lgéveiied ekgziizigii ihain, u;hfis;> aE<>:f:¥_§§é€..§:1§§ A} 2:3 af{3,w:t;:-:»2::.%.c£g '"}f'hs {i€}1'}.°%'i{3i',{'3d €i€i{fE3..$%'3f{iE appeai.
5. Efearii Sr: L.Sri:1ivasa B:1br.2:_,'éétéirrzsd'-.C'£3Lii':$%i?:}"£232"
the appfiliantt and Sri Vi§é1_jy':; E{L1;m:5ir VM;:jaig§§€v,«--v...§§%z::rn€d*V. HCGP {Gr the respandfzni S£'::;7;_§i,' '
6. Learned Counsei f0r' *iif1a:*3 submits that the charge :agai{1$?: A23 is Ah4:':"--:>;r;2_:§§A in pmasegsion of the revolvéi; 23_%i*1<_»i.'V'fifi;at: C§Jt'1ft. has acquitted him whe-1"€:as,__Ehéréq~~i$'<;1(2~._ t:1i;2x:'ge against A1 for having possessecigzifsy i:;re::;;§©ii"'é3nd éherefare. hi' stxbmita i.h::zi:? AE V, uerztétleei' "f{if an order of acqufiial of ihe e:)ff<:n{:e .u:':<d§:r __Se<:"§§;G:1;__ 25 of Indian Arms 1-kit. 36 furthér S'§I:§fi'§§'ES '€.}'"§3J€[i3f1 flhfi inciéerzt, :15: :n_§m*§ 1'3 iézrmgefi is any 'V of €59'. §§1;{i(.f:4'é1§S 0f the raiding gafiy 3.1152 €%1€r€:fe:,>r<«:g "€115 ..f'v:r3§£ég«:~3;f{,§@::$ $231: '$336 aeatmssd has p01'.:::£%<§ Gui: ihas: §é§s*0§:?€r 2:1'; CW,22 iiéiiiflifii '£36 b::t.£ié.=:x.--"€<"§ "i)e{:::§us§€g zzatitirréing $10 the p§.'{;s@2:'ui'i<}:L ':§"1«:*+ £"{;'.'i%'{}§'V€};" wags ::2._E:"é32::{§j~; 6 Eaazied 2-méi :;f;.<}?;:hing:,;; ;}r<=zVe§2'::eé A1 E10 ssE":<i><3: gig: "E.§'§€;'. ;*a.;?<§§r1§;:j p2:.r'i:y'., if at 2:3 "Em Ezass %11§_.€::_2d<:{i £1} {fie see, E§:zzf:E':7T é;h.«:"~: {7_i:'<:a.::nsE;211:{:e::+;., no <:rve32""{. acts; are zzliaaggefi zigfgé-xii':-:§'§t:--.T."t.v%1e a£:<iL2Se{i fer 27;.?;t€:"r1pting§ to <:<smm1?:: ariy c::g§i'€'m:§1:4'=.éi1'_ '§.;> Cause Siiiih. .§E1jLiI"jf is CW22 as wQL1Ed §'1'2iv'&3--.::j"::?$€;zE:§i§3.€i :,i;"§ ' fizz': death af CWIZSZK He eompiaizzané. PWQLO §*1a.5; £'}1}.e<:i éihe'campi2iim;'.A,.E:f:"'§§1iS*.{§éaa;<2'r. ané 3516 §'_1.in1s§:§f hzm §nva3sé.ég'a1jé:'ia§' the c--2;:§e.a;f1{£ >f:§iéi"ef0re, V ii: is net: pzreper thatPW.2C*--~.E}§a<:;°§nv€Stigated~'§h.§$ awn 33% argci }%'1enc€§ €iS"".E;ifpA0373fi;€'i;3f':V 'fiigh Ceuri; 0? §{a1"natak2?: in (21. }5':3':5i"Ifa."fie by Upparpei ?0iiC€ 1Si£%.E'jiOfi V7S';.."Sa,):i1p§:é3g'i and athers, the praCt.ir:,e 01' C9m§£ai11E>x1ftf himseif "ifl%l';estigaiTing {be case has {:0 be d<3*;3r*§{:a;f;:?:'§ ic1f§{§.,?gj§j;;€:;*@f0r€:: gresg inju$§'i€:€ has; been ':f:;éi:;:s€<:-§_ i~»:§'«.%;._5E"1:;>.,_ 3,CCuS}€:T{§. }§é:n€:@._ he Slibflliils 'ihzafi; the a'}';'.{E§£:'? GE {t'a:%jmz§"<7i.i(m ES Vi%:iz£'::%d in {E35 casfs. figs i:§2€:sz°€f<}r€, 8'ub:r:éjfé§'«:_§h2zt the Qrdei" {sf {E16 €:(31'1v%<::t.:§<:z1 ezgaiasit lithe ~ ";€pi§'€~E.ie:§1t far' ihe <::E'"fe:2c%: Lirzsissr Siizattiizn SQ? WC §$ " e:'§°{>:1€:m:s Eifid £13516 Sélié {>r{§££:' aim {E{}§"§i-'i{§§§(}Z1 E5; E1?a.'§'}.Eé3 ':13 be :e2$Ed€, 7 1?, L€2%_rz%.€£§ ECG? s;L.:b§:1.i€:5:; §'}"ié?éi'. Eéaezr :;:=v§:§.:=%.:2c{z <2? ?W,2G iieupied Kg.-fiii the e~;r§{§€:11<:£«3~ of P"\E£5,9, E9? £10 £9 <:Eea:';E§;" e$€;21bE§si1€:s> Eihai. the a(i:<?:u::~;€:<:i E3;-:_..:§'f"giiifiimpé-ifiéi _ '£0 (tau:-;€~ the iiezaih cf fhfi CPE .i5y'v~§:{}§ri;€;§:n§;"V "
i'€;"V0§E-"'€iE° at him amd iihaii: if 2:;::1::§ A{>;1}'Ir;«€é§i<s if,>1;i~:}::
{§"J€i"" §_'){)W'€§'€3d 'é.h<:~ a<*:<:u$€d;"h<s3:_V svozéivri E1;12r€'v_§§{§VEI§'@;i HP-'=;: "}2C'e=. ' and t}i'3<=: rczpori sf "i.h;e fu-fiber sixes Ehaf; the avea§§<3'g;A";1.s%:>§ '4i'IIé'§..:'é}ppei1an§4 was; live Weapon and Wggs §%ap2§_E3§T€'.«:%:f Fzzrfilsrg it was 10&1fTiC;i of A1, He Subm:iisM'iT}1ai.':ifas 13:2 'higfiiifig repmté-rd in 2069 {2} Cr£me$'.8f}..(SC-3 ?.v.VEEias§};{&1;.-Ramappa Mada? azéé 0'ihez's Vs. jS;§aé:e 4 :sf_ £€=::2,:".nai:akéi ~ that i::h€re: 13$ as bar for "v--§¢EI"iC§{f&:1'3;£1'iiiiI3'g£}; inxreéiigémon by the ttoxnpiaimamfi. himseif »-§;)€5~:€;':Tx;§é';.§3 iihfi {:<:>mp£:;:.:.?n3.':2fé <:<:>::éu{:'{.€& this 111%-":.sé.igaé2_%;)L:4:' Aweruid 330?. be 3u§'§:'<:;'.€r1% {<2 {:21u§{3 dzmbi 0:1 "iijae pr€.;~S<%cut§<3:f: ver&:.§<m ix) hoid that Ssmgsz EIIEEKQS ii:
_ m§_:'§--;:s--:i°ab§€. Thé: mzztter ham "Si; bee dezéééeai azm grass to " = -»zf:.:-":38 Eaagia '§§z'§"?i§'2{}'E,;§"§T 'zinizrferazfi geziemiiszzfizm. Semis, he ff/) I 8 saubmiis 1i:ha¥;; Eiize <3rde:';:' af ::<}'nv:k::':§<fs§1 {E063 §'I{}i'. -E_§?L,3ffffE" from any £1}:-3§;;a§;:?.i:j;e,r"* GE" 1?m§)r<>bab;£_Ei'€:§J anzi E,§m'£' i:%":::*:.'é§z«§;a§3€:esE may 'be {§i8H}i-.':§S€d,
8. The pr05e<r2.zt1*o11 in this case <:<3:1':m:&%;:€:ed".wi€,h°' {fling (if the azompigufni. 13€1?c>?€§._ §;}?}3' ..'9£'}1.irLz'm;é2;:}i' : E3'--;)§:':ft.f€ Station, Pavagada on 19..C'*:2§'-E_}399:H §'.h€W said zriomplaint; that an ?£9.G2_._} 99S}»_;:1t a1b:3:1§A§,i1.nL, {E26 Circie Ensépeamz' sf P{§:Ei:§:€. f-s:C:§iV€§a;{T%::é{§;§bIe mf<)m'2atIi<>n {hat the naxaiiéfes b€§'dtigi1i:§§ *::c3.V:'13:s11{3£~;a"" group by 1121316 Muthyaia "'vff:fi;i'§z§2;:if:{é:~;':f1jiaa 'beC,r1 §:«:>nsp§2*ir1_g £10 zéamnaii Same g:>?ffé:':'cz:iif§n 'i?7;iiEL1'r»3}§£iageVV7by p0.€-ssessiizg arms. He went §'§:":, Vaiiuifl "v'fi__iage-.__ é3j.o;':_g mitih the siaff and {he}?
surrcyagvrgdafif' '§§1€. .'§10%:;se' of A1, at thafit Eifiifi, sings":
,...¢_gar::e ':I§c:a.;iy s§f:011é:é:£""'éhaf. pehce had came, a'@e:z€, 3 to 4 L.3;riV:v::a:t,a;>${'»-:;f" 31";-€;": §7;(}'i;.§E~§€i Cams: :"m1I11?z:g: {ELEEE-Eifiifj, when E16 E;:'*§ée:§_ f.@v_.:;::2%_{':<F.:hA {me Bf ilhfilfi, iihas azitctiseai Nazxi €13-:>k Elhii V':*§§%:{:s}.1f<:§'v...§%"<}§"§: big "@'&'iiSf f.«:::_;.£E piifililiilg iii} Ezim, he was 'a. b7e::»::.'::"f.<; Shiiéfi, him' EfiEI1.S%;'.§f gmcti EC 8?3 Y21:=;E2a>{§E':22.m§ = .§v:':£zm:€£ia_€3:€:*.Ey giamgghi heid him zzzfmi §:m3rp<}W€.r€:d him azfzd 9 §}r€$€=z":E'.€£i him {mm $h:}<):;§r:g., {}E:':;;€3* aiaifi' whe z1c€:<m:.;3e1::ic.d him iirieii {.6} a;_)g3z*€<1*:é31':::.': {E353 :>€:E:{':_:::_ 3 of ihém bu: <é<3':23;{i 319$ {:at.<:§':. '£.ii:€;:;1. '§'he rzaimé "'f.§:€ pgrsgan wha 'é3§:"¢-ES ifaiéigiéii, i§1f{)rn:1€::i izham tE*1a':,_ :Ef'".§;:Z'z':';'_°§">Z:.':'i.f§7§-€.'_.E55:a' % Muthyaziti @ '\/:2::":i<21i:e;&;h; 5301': sf Sub§:2e1}."1§1r'1;é1v_§"'éi§§§*=3--§' E_ii»'<§'5t%fT...VV ' 25 }>'&arS zmii --%ifc1i'.£::d that he is;'*9E.'r1e§"at«€:n:_::{3'a..§< :}fg:2;;;:1i;é5€i1* (if Ashoka gr<)up. Eixztept {he revoiiéezf ---i?1<:r'e '~ai;a?f;<-33%: 1:16 abjecta in {he person sf fire --g_15€:~::_used'. }i:€'.'§iEi SV"'§vf'€§§Ei:§"€(§ 21- V §am:ha::ama. at the gscene Q.§--r3}c'':c.u'2<'renCe''Eaeiwiezén "? arid ZPIQ5 and sinC€'uh'€_AWa£«:{_ inu"gag-§S~:§8$i0n of firfiarm without licence and 3.§;§é:*n.:pfified: *t.G"~k§iE[_E1_i:'~m iihe accuseé was p"2f<}c%:<:ed 'a;i'o.;igT»€i?'iiE*f1j'the compiaint and the revolver wiih 8 :i,0é}.§dé. of " :-;§1am'a131iti9n. Th§;I"'Ll.i§"!EU}§ Palice r::jg?§'ss,*€§:;_f¥e€i1v ihe"'S3§.:@__«Ca$e in crime §\k},'?/' 199$ far Qffamts ' ,:_:f;d;«'::*._S<i§:t§}i>'r:_ 25 of Indian £--':rms Aiét: and <:<:»mme:1c€d im_f%:s£:iga'i{i{>r::. Q1': <:01"§1p§<:§:i:m Efif H18 ir:vesi.iga.€i{>:2 and afEer~~ @7b;E§ai:";;_mg S2iI1CEi031 frizam the §:<>I1{:em€é é'3.,.'L£fi':{§Z"'§i§/' E5 {tha:'g€ -$33663. {tame ':10 be ;5'§£€:d.
2. {E Q' PE?2f'§;,i {<3 6? 8 2121:} E1. is 14 h£':i.'2-*'€f mrnsad %1<>s:ef::fi:3 H; f,§"i%;", {félfiif <3? E:"f*:<:: p;'<>se{:::€,i<>:L PE?%''.'? is: ifhst %_.za:;E<>2' Ei'€.TE12";5::
Iissuaizd .21 'E"E3{?f{'3'1'}3'tZ 215; per Ex.P,6 fm' ?;;he {>3;i;dx:-tiff».;§f-faiis: Gopaiayrfiddy :0 34;'.it,::h iwg} Shii-t»$t b' the conssiabk-2 Whe E12153 a§:<ta>mp:::1ieci}?iV',.2§_ ?<3z:"é.E;v(: €i§1;'€€§' af iha offenéte ':0 the §;<:ezf1:;--:<_ 0f <:?c:<::*:1%'3"3"€I1::€é*M- Aaicyézg:fiaf§"i.h', other Siaff. O1"; rfsaathimg t:hé' E:.e_1;_3e Gifirié E§§.1.bb&1fl§1EZ that is, izhfs 8;CCU:S€€§v§£I{j15[,h:fiP:E&?;T§L3.§2i.,_"35h€}? Sm*:*z)z_md.€c§ €;h<3: said house 2133.51 3:: that.f§;§;r::a;e,;s»;bi11e "E70dy 2-éheuieéd 21$ poiicfi and hie: ._furt'hé£_ate1te}c3V{hé;£i"3 {<3 4 peopie came gut af t_:_.];1Ve hQiz_sé3,,a,n:§. '.~3teifte::i:ru.:ining§. Himseif and R: vi Narayana-21tE€::1p%<3d'*?.5=.{;a1:.<;Eh '$16 said parser: and at. that iimzffi, "ihézS2:i;§§,'péf's._§§i:: 'i"<i:11{,w(5d the E°€~:~v0h-'6'? {mm his v9a.iséi axzflmadfi' _35t'£§3rn--pt to fins' p{n'ntir1g iievardsg the tiifygzegt'3ii;":<1,§_,___E};iI1'1se}f and CPE camghi imii': 8%" him 2x,r§f:'iEe "oj§ih.;ei*$ §'£1'Ei. away: '£'h:'=: gaéé parser: w%1<": zafziés aaéitugezi biifzigre the Caari, ""316 said fgésfiééiivfiég" :':;éi__C:hi:1a made 38% reveaixffig" anai w2:,s:=; §{)&'逧€{§. "{E;é":°E: ':%.I»3§'{-; 'mT:a§ 5 buiiflg in 'Eh:-2 Z'€'3V{}§V{;'E1 CPE méiéfi a m€:h2i2:;}:.::é° far Whi{%§1 he "E2213 s;§;g;'::.<::Ew H55': bass :Eds:'r:i:if'i@d X' BE 'E"'€?'V{}§'v'€3E' as §\»fE{},2, PWI9 Ems bé-3<?§E ¢:é}:i;.e:§1ss§_x«'e=:§jg <:1"{}ss-:~ exzmzimzézi by {ha excriruaaesii améi ii; 3122.2: ';3i3e:'3. su;g;g;ess§'ee:§ ihafc', they harm faiaeiy :'<-3:p{>r€;ed {hat Tc1Cf{'lE-.'€%?3{i *€€.?:i1;'3 the mszzoivexx remd that. :19 sue}: iI}{?id€;'.§'fi. has; h;;g};§€iz':§£i":3$ zgiiagad by ihem. ?'x?£7,7iG Th§'p§eswamy '12.55 aiexistabie wha ha-'Se c<;rr0b<}I.'at€_d...i.§f1€: {-3$Jit§{§:':éiE*r:: ':':§ 'EE';§2\:7.(Q'A" regardézig {ha appwzhensiara 9fV=.A:icc:2:'-3:3'%d7x:3i':., the'u€12;%:@,.of ghe affense ami at the i:iis°:;e of €:.§fe':1e:t€:. g §-E:°: mask; 2§._E*::30', stated that. the a<:{:L1$ee:E xAr'aS':.1é1:, in pbsséss-:~§i0f§¢3f China made 380 revmlxrefg §»xr1::§311 they 'ei:ppfe.E:endéd'Ah§fi§, PW.1Q has aéso beer} €Xi;.€:§§'S_i'£r'€E}{CFOéi§5}€I.?§EiII}}l§3€3§ but ma e*»..-*idei1=::<::~'- '1'emai':T1§é:i»T, éiméhaiiegiged, in S8 far as the seizure 55.._:*€;v<;1%,i§:z°7.f:i:~.{:i the passessigm of {ha aetcused w._§":é':.n:ifi¢: jams '§:fa.1§_;s,§fE>:vi.. PW.§5 Rangezswzzmy is flag: SRO ' raéf "CB6..T§?:§'iTE:§E£?.afi.i ?oiice Siatien whi) hag .:*é:§.§i5--;€;&:*<;%ci the 5:15:56 a::;df'V'%§:f$§;;$'::1§£ted i:E::e FER 'is fhff Camra Pie EMS afiazk :'e:":€5i'::f§:{i the sspcst mgihazar pr€pa.z*ed 23}-Y CPE amd 21§.s§<> fix: ':°§§*§',»?'5<'::§*tJa>::° 332% § Tm2E§::>'€.s geizsd 533: She €_ZP§- FEE? .16 'fizz:-is __%s'E,23.'{€d iihzii; an :°€%<:€i§3E. cf '::E'§s: i§:§E>rma::§é.};1 raégzxrdizzg ihg p<}$:'~3c:<a$i<:2n <25 fiTf{'3°Ei1'§"§}E§ he Ems; aisgai} a<:::<:sm;32:;1i@d FE?v'.2€}, $2 Q amgi ES Ea €316 scram? af €}{fCiiI"E°€;'1'T1{,'f€ ami xaras p?e:~%;€§'1€ 21:: that. mm-§. £3"? zzppmhasnsisn cf iihif a.{:€:1:s<:*«:i with %.h€: 2%;'§Tmss. PW.E? is a:1«:>the§ Péfiiite Cmgsstabie? Wm: hz;1s;*a;Eé:a;_j;.§;i:é;é1;¢e§' in t,§".:e ggexma '{,€=:*'r12.ss 21$ t;hai'. 0:" ?W5s.9. 2G_zznéi"'w}.:v6:;A./Z"PW 1E3, is-5. aisga an 5-:ys:w'it::'1e$$ 1510 "$16 if1{TiC§.€I1f, 4';~.-3:)" .,ai*s<§v. P179120 is the §I1V€S{.i§§ELi'.iI1§':i}.i:fi{f¢3F"Ai'{1 'Ffi1T1§S:(i'2k$=ET'_.Eifi€§g§ aE£~;£:{'. the {:amp3a§_nzmL Hg has :é:<>n1piEa_i:3i.
gifi;-'€"{1 by him? FSLV __markeé ihreugh PW120. is.~"é,E§éiioffiggg§gE".é.'1:;;V:§%f3L5;"a11d:1m under which izhgmw ~vf;§{1f¢):;g€gif§,;'ara;-:iejA;, §'{1'£:*iV§{ur hag accorded Sa::Ct§V@mVtidV._§I: under {he Arms Ad in Cfime hir'un1a:1_i Poiicst Statiozz.
EX,P.17V E'SLv. r§§p_()Vr';'_V that {he Iievelver in zzrticie '=£\E=i§s;'?.. i5~'-_3_é;:g_woriiizzg...s::z:m_d:;ti01': and ?;'h€' cariridges marked V T; E;-.§i¥:)= We=:r°€ 1;'.v€.% ES, ' {mm {he ea:-'iflem:€ sf téfifige wfizzasges, E.ha.E; fihe leéfiaed S€3;E%S§{}Ii£~E (judge hag f{>ur:c§ this acatugsd ig'a:§E:1y fcmd :::*<}§1v§<:i€s:i him amd s;€:1E,:3n{t{:c% hizn as _ ..::§<}§€=§2ai{£, E3 EL {>11 2;: {:a.:°€f1.;E €??{'§I}E¥§€§.€fF&Tii1i{)§1 {if fgéae €E1?;',Ef€f maf,eria§5,:. am r<:<:a:'€E, '{.%1e &;u§:::r1is§§;i<}z1 madefr %3§.»f ijhé', aagpéiianiig Cm::z1$€L §§1&E1i i§we:;i2ig.jat.i<)11 in i:h_§:s_ ::i>1é3>s.::Ti?:a1$s been V;ii:i3$é;ed Sifiiiifi the C(§I§§pI'c3;iI1&iI1'£. §:im§$<§i§' . imres;tiga:é,ing,>; afficez' cam:1<>i: be accedeci_.£i:>,'*¢'fE'iés§é' pe;,e.i§::':<:a_ ' efficer Whe ham itgndmtied the; ;'a1.i_£i§'§:f§z-fies '1a(:t§3ic-3' rgié' f{}1€'; in§0rmai:i{2':3 reef-:ivee:§ by him aitxd '--.t_:h.'aJi; he £53 agggievfid persan in this; {i;;2;._;_'~=..'%t';n, ".FhA5e~ Eaw_fL:q1;;i1j:€--sVV.that: azfl' person Cannot be the judge »<':>'f. his: 0ax%:':.c:§_::Se. E A police: officezr 01' £1 dete:::t.i12.g'f--officesgr 'W3i1'Q "+:;>:f: recteipti af ihfi hlformaiicri, getss to the 'L€:'poi{':é,fid .-f;.h'e,~:2*jr:. géama Vi£}13.fiOI1 ES f0ur1& by' hVivn:1V'fiffi'1':,T(fiVfé'p0'1't's the incident, it wiii net became GWn"".{éa.s7€--«,_éG 218 {<3 digqzzaiify him {ram c0nAr;¥_:,1Ci;i:1§'i;§1€.i.r;vé':sf,igati0n. A gxoiéce Qffécéér in such 21 :éz;§rg~ ¢f_:2}I1I_10'£i %§{3'~---5,-*;isia'b3;€6. by sayizzg {hat he iés éiaithezz' ' V1?fiifjI7tEvS!i9:3;Gf'<._{§'1'._E16 is ihe Campiaineani. 91' the agggrievfifi .p§?'.;'§.rvfE§f{V'E '};:;,.gf;vé§'géizé €'.§"m:>ugh fighéz jL1<ig1':3€:::i'. af ihs Efiixsison E%é';<:cEfa--._"€>§7.§h§s €»;";a2;:*E., 2:55 saiaisgi by §,i':é:e <:<3L:::§§€E for ihe n2app€.§§:<;__.i"':E and {ha mlizggg éjiteé is §2.{;>t. apgflicgable ta {fine f:«i2;§:'{:§ «::a1?.":'.E1éé3 <:as55: Héizsa améi {::s:§":z1<>'¥i: _§?§1::<:§ fauéé. Er: Ehe E4?
:i:1ve55t.§g§a£.i<>§3 <:ond:.£<:"t.:"3d by PW.2G= EE is 'il{} be :*z<}'£,€:::§ i.h2';:§ IRS is Elie §'IE{}S§ {ii$i;:t€:'e:s:§{.e:<i p€i'§'SOE'l. 530 far 27:5; i;h<3_..:'fesu'§E 05 ihe case is <:{mc§3rm:d €'fX{"f€E§i. ihaii 1% is; }1e:'f':>:*i9i'ii:r§§:€§'"z§s d'2,:tée:$ .213 21 pehce-3 ~:3ffi::e:2 The Suprem:".{ "Cv:;>:.§:'£. '"'i";é,_%S gbservefi in the {"::i18€ reported é:i2"§»9"'{'2}_ {:'Y§1'.1E'f§S:' {SC}:
Efihzxssfiiar Ramappa Mada}? 21z1d¥__{:%i.§}er$ S?7§;'~ S*é:3.*%:é:'--~, <5§.u §{arm1't.a§<:a -- that meraiy "'-fQé3'eaus€"* .fii§1'€, f.=<:<:¥'§'f:1pV1Va§1rzzm€,V canduétieél the: n:<>:§ ?btE'VLguffizziezat :3 cause doubfion Eh; to hoid i:'E":a's;
the same §}r'%3fsé:;:§;§. ti§311.jgérsion vminergxble. The matier {tags to case baséa wiihzggt =;*:_::j§ V"'g€:1'era£i-sation. I am of the <t0:":$§def€~3:"i2::vpf§:i$f:; t;hi$ case the inwésiigatiiara Cgrisiigéted b§f"'PW.v2Q Camila? be ztimsiéared to be ' .Vx%uin€':V;:'b}:§:v~. :>:<i vitiateé just: because he hims£:§;_f hg:-is étt:{:*':é:.1{j:t,é§i§i__"s§1€ raid,' E1: E3 very 0i3*»--':io'::e3 that": P§?«J}2G :3 Eéassi': §§:;*':€'z"::§€.ed 33;} ihe i'es:3::'£%. Q? the {E386 exzzepé fifzasi. E36 sisgndsggémé EEK: i:1vs:aef:.i;g9.'£.§_::3':1 :3:f'{:€'§* £:{>§1€fE1:::E,§1':g; the __ --§E'£i3§{i.
S
12. 8:) far: 212% tfiéis meriiisg e.:)ft:%1e:_-6 gftafge: 21%;? {:€}§'?;{?€':I'?§€{L (J1 ii: £8 s€€'r:a that; the acztuseazi ha-s £3113}; p0i:1::a%dVT'{>':zt at PWQG ?c1§i€§ that w§';é:r1_ they wesnt, faif raid, 3..<'é+:;' Came oumiclsz the h(':LES€ and the ac;tr::z:5s_<:%:fiV_%'*€3:z:*~2§§*ed t.E":e_ ' revelvez' fram hi8 waisi: emd was pQ.irit;§f1L;;, éii *PVv'.. TAL:
ihafi. f{.im6;~ he was caught Vb}*. §9Vv7i9. £'1'§'E€]L 2§3;'V'M~ principle 0%? Law that. a perS<;fi'V.;§;:ar;V beg eifiy for the act dame by mm. 1-_f:3'(%:t--._ _»}»:10I0g<:§; has been injured and iihff,E1CCL1§':*3€9l.:.}L'§ié1€;.V§%1£§;%§ trigger sf {.116 ravoiverg Esomébedy and iherefgggfig the finding of the Sessi§::2s'--Jz%.{i§§€':':-ti@'a§ v"a*;§:'L1Se{i has attempted to Commit murder 1Cef_P'.?§7.;2€}<V€;é;.1*:;f::_€if£ be ssusiained. In thfi facfgss of "£;i"1_€5'.:;::a$S€:> vvh€.'i'S~'en_€,_};fied far an Grder of acquitfiai of $16 ' ;jffe§1<:eV":.§:2d%:':_ Section 30'? IPC. Hzm-'eve:r, Eram éhe €:'.%i &"é:1§::£:".§§§ %P"\f\f$.§s :0? 169 1'? ané 2@, it E5 «:::ea:« ihaé. iha a<tcu;§:e<:%;_w21s in §3{}SS€SSi(}fi 0f the arm M82 and that :::§::§€c§.ré§z1§g 555} EX.P.E:7 Ehffi said ezrm was in 3. w<}::"§_»;:c1b§e gigzzaiéfécié am'? ii itgmiained kiwi i7:;z§i.r£:£g§;éss. z3\;.<t:€:us<:& EMS fiiéii {tame féC}§."15JEiE'd W§'£I%1 any p£'..E'fEEiE%E31§{}§1 er §i{';:';'3Z1€3:T.:'i* fess' h.<>E.«:§§z1g the 3&5}; w:::a,p~:3:1» The priisszéutiém Ema §m*E,§1€~:r ifibfaliiiéd fiat: §;a::<:§i<}I1 $63 p'r<}:<_§<3*.z:ut:e A; f::'>r {he .@ff°e-":§:<:€: z1::_d§':r Ehfi Exiéiizm Anus Ash €;§>ir:.i::>i.1 far the ()ff!3£EC€ under Sacéiém 25 of Elbe En{i'§'%3,r1v_zf&:f:i1:§ ;;";e:::%4 V' an the evidencts an §"€£':.{f}1".d_E11191?'d{}§€?'E:§=._'§1{)'{"{j.Eifi E-232" inierferez1c€3, Howfiwsrg {he is:-3:fy:;<:1'1<;c: Vefi' t?:_:1r'(:<; gfgars he based impased E6 021 the appefianéi is an *:E<3V<: "§.--1:gh<;:ré~:.id<3,€.hé;iéf:3§":3.,_ I 132153 the fellewing order: ' 1,
2.
The appeal is a1].0v€ué::3V:..inA pzilf.
The Grderi '"<~:«;f (2(}'E'"'i"*'»¢'7'1(T"='£i3"4(Z'}f'§ '.'g_3¢'{1é §§éI:s:£;'€r1<:€ thfifimvappeiiant. far the . 0ffén<t:e'é::11de«1T_T;§£i<:::.i0n 30'? EPC is 86': aside vvé;::§Vdv.isV' 21c(§,iii§f {éd 9f {ha Gff€IE"?;C€3S Eevefled aga_:%."z€~£tA 311111».
A f}§I'{i_@;' esf c0:2v;§€i:.i0'n far the @§§?er1{:e undar 25 0f the. Inéigzn Armsg A9': is Lip Eieweverg that $e'§1:em':e E3 reduétad m éfi-Y0 ycarS RI. flag' {he Said <}ffem:€§ whiie keeping fiibe flfiffi anfi ée.f:;mE§: Sfifiiifiilfifé iE1§".»I:1{':i. 3 it is -$:3:£:%:1 {hat "éhfié €i_CCLESé',£fi was in <7ussi.{}d§J far 4 };"€fi:}E'S 8 mamhs am? 3 éajgs smezi.
W' Th Ef§'€fff(§E'f;?, E £%_.£'§".: .V {he tizaf. iiize fi:1ci:i:1g of the iss~:a;":1@{i I7 E;,E3s3r§3:E':)'r€i, E36: Eiasfiai mat. SEKf'1T€:§E€"§€;'E1° iii} $€i'2f"*z.:"é'. om: gmy §}€:E"'§. Q? the 5-:;m1é.a3:1<:€ 2:29 hem§:*;__ befwre :"z1{>d§§'i€:(E, Bani b(m::L<_-2 GE' aC<:uS<:d is ctazgcreéisd, P-'£116: 2zn1{3§{:f1i,-« :-
Ei*XCé3;'}§E*§ 0f "ax-*%1e>.t is irzapcnsed $1ere§.:1,af£E:s.{>xf<:1;"if d{;*.pOE:'sit§3'&, aha}? béé ref:7gi1§fi€§§§ .€;;_{) .h3;I§I:,_z "
av;