Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Nilanchal Sabat vs Defence on 28 June, 2023
Sac tersk S '<S 5 ae fo ta Central Administrative Tribunal, Maombal Bench, Mumbai.
ey Coram Justice MiG. SewSkar, Member (Judicial ponch * eee, e Dr. Bhagwan Sahai, Member (Administrative). Nuianchal Sahat, Working as Tradesmen-HSE-1, (Group "C" post}, in the office of C.No.62, MPM Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at :
Quarter No.273/13-A, Vikramaditya Building, Naval Civilian Housing Colony, Kanjurmare OV}, Mumbai ~ 400 O78.
Hemant Harischandra Birwadkar, Working as Tradesman-HSE-I, (Greup "C" post), in the office of C.No.14, MFAB Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at :
Quarter No.203, Unity Complex, Building No.05, Rajan Pada, Behind Kiran Tower, Malad (W), Mumbai ~ 400 064.
Sanjay Ravsaheb Chavan, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" past), in the office of C.No.62, MPM Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at: Quarter No.273/11-B, NCH Colony, Kanjurmarg QV}, Mumbai -- 400 078.
Santosh Kumar , Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" past), in the office of C.No.62, MPM Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at; Quarter No.302-D, Sita Apartment, Ayodhya Nagari CHS, 2 QA.82/2023 Tisgaon Naka, Kalyan (B), Dist. Thane -- 421 306. Anil Kumar Sahu, .
Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.63, MYAS Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : 774/23, Rambhajan Compound, Hariyall Village, Near Durgamata Mandir, Vikhroli (East), Mumbai ~ 400 083, Laxman Parmeshwar Survase, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group "C° post), in the office of C.No.24, Sawmill, MOUT Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 5.B.S. Marg, Mumbai ~ 400 023 and Residing at : P-41/09, Defence Civilian Colony (SPDC), Sion-Trombay, Mankhurd, Murnbai - 400 G88. Kalpesh Kumar Manubhai Jayswal, Working as Foreman (AR), (Group "B"" Gazetted post), in the office of Avionics Department, Naval Aircraft Yard, Goa, Dabolim, Goa -- 403 801 and Residing at : Flat No.107, First Floor, Devashri Darshan Society, Mangor Hill, Vasco-da-Gama, (oa State.
Maheswar Das, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.66, MYAS Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : Room No.272/5A, N.C.H. Colony, Kanjurmarg (W), Mumbai -- 400 078.
Sandeepkumar Sabhajit Pal, Working as Tradesman-HSK-], ( Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.56, MYAS Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, Mumbai --- 400 001 and Residing at: C/102, Yashwant Park, Opp. St. Xavier's High School, Unitech Road, Virar (West), Palghar ~ 401 303, State of Maharashtra. .
iQ, pera beeed, Fann, Love Nat Ipoh fn, fox ;
bad oO ie eat ed tS BS fos Siba Prasad Trip athy, ;
Working as Tradesman-HSK-T. (Group "C" past), in the office of ASD. (Mumbai) Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : Quarter No.273/2D, NCH, Colony, Kanj ucmare (W), Mumbai -- 406 078.
a Balakrishnan, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group "Cc post}, in the office of A.S.D. (Mumbat), Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S-B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : T23/4498, Sector-07, CGS. Colony, Antop Hill, Mumbai -406.097, --
Sanjay Kumar Ojha, Working as F. radesman-HSE-] (Group "C" post), in the office of A.S_D. (Mumbai), Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate,
5.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 O01 and Residing at -
Quarter No.273/ 8D. NICH. Colany, Kanjurmarg OW), Mumbai ~ 400 073.
P Sam Jeyaraj, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group "C" post), in the office of A.S.D. (Mumbai), Naval! Dockyard, Lion Gaie, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 409 OO and Residing at :
12B/273, NCH Colony, Kan} urmarg (West), Mumbai ~-- 400 078.
Padmalochan Rout, Working as Tradesman-HSK-, (Group °C" post), in the office of C.No. 66, MYAS. Naval Doekyard, Lion Gate, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at:
Room No.273/4-B, N.C. Colony, Ranjurmarg (W), Mumbai -- 400 078.
Aut Dattatray Taralkar, Working as T. radesman-HSK-1, ( Group "CO" post}, in the office of C.No.70, MER Department, Naval Dockyard, Gun Gate, $.B.8. Read, Munibail -- 400 001 and Residing at - 2s4/15-B, NCH Colony, LBS Road, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai ~ 400 078. .
16.
ive 18, fest "OO 4 OA.82/2023 Vijaykumar Sambhajirao Jadhav, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" post), in the office of A.S.D, (Mumbai), Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S, Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at:
Building No. A/8, Room No.103, Royal Park, Ambernath (E), District Thane, State of Maharashtra ~ 425561.
Channaveerappa Ranakappa Yaralakatti, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.56, MWEA Department, Nayal Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at:
C/o Raghunath D. Patil, Kharkhand, At Post-Kegaon, Taluka Uran, District : Raigad, State of Maharashtra-400702. Pradosh Chandrakant Shetye, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.73, MIS Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : A-301, Pimpleshwar CHS, Drakshabaug, Tank Road, Bhandup (W), Mumbai -- 400 078. State of Maharashtra. Chetan Shankar Bari, Working as Tradesman-HSK-L, (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.38, MWEA Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at: 1003, Mohak House No.3, Opp. Moraya Nagar, Manvelpada Road, Virar (E), District Palehar -- 401 305, State of Maharashtra.
Amita M. Mishra, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "°C" post), in the office of C.No.84, MWEA Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, §.B.S. Road, Mumbai--- 400 001 and Residing at : Jayraj Nagar CHS, 1-002, Manav Mandir Complex, Ambadi Road, Vasai (W), State of Maharashtra. Dipak Rouumar Mallick, ~ Rae al a boo Lod At O ge OD ht io ers BD $23 Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" post), in the office of T.No.12906T, C.No.11, Fabrication Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at: Room No,04, Building No. 132, Naval Civilian Housing Colony, LBS. Marg, Ranjurmare (W), Mumbai ~ 400 078. Ravindra Mitike Palo, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group " >" post), in the office of TNo.12O8ST, CLNo.10, Fabrication Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $5.8. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : Laxmi Darshan Apartment, Room No.304/176, Sector-21, Ramothe, Navi Mumbai, State of Maharashtra.
gree] amaswamy Venkiteshwaran yer, Working as Tradesman Mate (FGM), (Group "C" post}, at in the office of Garrison Engineer, Fort Saint George, Chennai -- 600 009, 'Tamil Nadu State and Residing at: A19/104, Saroiini Naidu Street, SSM Nagar, Alanakkam, New ; 4 & t Perungalathur, Chengalpattu, Kancheepuram, Tamil Nadu -- 600 063.
Dhanapal S., Working as Skilled ICE Fitter-NOMG, Clerk Indien Bank, Station Master ~ Indian Railways (Group "C" past), inthe office of Skilled ICE Fitter NBMB Ministry of Defence, Clerical at Indian Bank-Minisiry of Finance, Station Master southern Railway, Ministry of Railway and Residing at: 21, Bast Street, Opp. Vinayagar Kovil, Samiyarpatti post, Thoppampatti Village, Athoor Tk, Dindigul, State Tamil Nadu. Pratheesh P., Working as Rigger (SR), (Group "C" post), in the offic ce of NSRY KOCHI, C.No.68m Rigging SNGop, Naval Base, Kochi, Ernakulam, Kerala, - 682004 and Residing at Pratheesh P. Pozhath CH) Parakkad, Arinbur, Thrissur, cerala State ~ 680 620.
Shifu Jose, W orking as ICE FITTER CAND vo (Group "C" post), in the office of URG, | SHS 31, MCXK}, Naval Base, Roochi, Kerala and Residin bed od 28, 3 ie 6 OA.82/2023 Mannukunnel House, Lakkatoor P.O, Kottayam, Kerala-686502. Vipin Vargheese, Working as Plater (SMW)-SKL (Group "C" post), in the office of SNC. Kochi, INS Garuda, Naval Base, Kochi-Kerala -- 682 004 and Residing at : Mullakkara House, Near St, Sebastian Church, Valachira, Kaduthuruthy, KTYM, Kerala -- 686604, Sooraj K., Working as Tradesman (Skilled) (Group "C" post), in the office of MWIJC Department, Indian Naval Academy, Ezhimala, Kannur, Kerala ~ 670 310 and Residing at : Nalini Nivas, Subhash Road, Onden Paramp. Civil Station FO, Jivan Narayan Kolhe, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group "C" post), in the office of C-17, MDDHP Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.BLS. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 601 and Residing at: Room No.611, B- Wing, Thanekar Parkland CHS, Near Katrap School, Katrap, Badlapur East, Tahsil-Ambarnath, Dist. Thane ~ 421 503, State of Maharashtra. Nilanchal Biswal, Working as Rigger (HSK-D, (Group "C" post}, in the office of C-17, DDHP Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : 1O1/B, Prathamesh Vrundavan, Katrap, Near Kirti Uday society, Badlapur (East), District Thane -- 421 903. sandeep Kumar C.K, Working as Tradesman-HSK-L (Group "C" post), in the office of C-17, MDDHP Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai - 400 001 and Residing at - 129/02, N.CLH. Colony, Kanjurmare (W), Mumbai ~ 400 078.
Rajesh Talagareddy, Working as Tradesman CHSK-D (Rigger), (Group "C™ post), tad tt OPA "y in the office of C.Na.61, Manager Civil Maintenance, Tiger Gate, Naval Dockyard, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at: QNo.273/14-A, Vikramadity a Tower, NCH Colony, Kanpurmare (W), Mumbai -- 400 078. Satvendra Kurnar, Working as Rigger CHSE-D, CGroup "C" post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~4§0 00) and Residing at; 265/14, NCH. Colony, Kanjarmare CW}, Mumbai -- 400 078.
Bhausaheb Devidas Yendhe, Working as Tradesrnan-HSK-L (Group "C* post), in the offices of [No.1 2954H, C_No.10, Fabrication Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 GOT and Residing at ; Shree Krupa Building, R.No.414/4, Dr Ambedkar Read, Kalachowki, Chinchpokali (East), Mumbai ~ 400 033. M_ Ganesan, Working as Tradesman-HS&-I, (Group "C™ post}, in the office of C._No, 65, YU Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.8.8. Road, Mumbai -- 400 QO1 and Residing at 208/09, NCH Colony, Kanturmarg (West), Mumbai ~ 400 O78.
Parag N. Shende, Working as Technician (SK) (Group °C" pest), in the office of Sr Quality Assurance Estt. (Arms), Ministry of Defence (DGOA) Ordnance Factory, Ambajhari, Nagpur -- 440 O21 and Residing at: Cio Mohan Gadpayle, Plot No.231, Balaji Nagar Ext, Manewada Road, Nagpur ~ 440 027, State of Maharashtra. Abhay Kumar Tiwari, Working as Power Electrician Electrical Fitter (HS-D (Group "C"' post), in the office of DGQA, Senior Quality Assuranee Officer, Senior Quality Assurance Estt. (Armts). 85 84 GCE balpu 2 O11, and Residing a Je CP Jabalpur -- 482 O11, and Residing at 135, Kasturi Cry, Reaawa, Kachnari, Patan Road, OA.S2/2023 8 OA.83/2023 Jabalpur, Madhya Pradesh State,
38. Biswajit Barik, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group °C" post), in the office of TNo.13088M, C.No.68, MBEF Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, §.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 601 and Residing at:
Quarter No.273/3A, N.C Colony, LBS. Marg, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai ~ $00 078, State of Maharashtra.
39. Prashant S, Desai, Working as Tradesman CHSK-D, (Group "Cc" post), in the office of T.No, 13 O99A, C.No.68, MBEF Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 5.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~400 001 and Residing at -
E-504, Vighnaharta Park Complexx CHS Ltd,, Anmol Nagri, Garibacha Wada, M.P Road, Dombivall (West), Thane District ~ 42] 202, State of Meaharashira,
40. Sibram R. Muni, Working as T radesman-HSK-[, (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.35, MBER Department, Naval Dackyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at - Room No. 106, Siddhivinayak CHS, Sambhaji Nagar, Sahar Road, Andheri (East), Mumbai -- 460 969. 4}. Ganeswar Soren, Working as Foreman (&) (Group "B™ post), in the office of F3 S85 W, C.No.6 8, BEF Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at - 12B/271, Talwar Tower, NCH Colony (East) Camp, x Kanjurmarg CW), Mumbai ~ 400 O78.
42. Manas Ranjan Mohanty, Working as Tradesman-HSK-L, (Group "C* past), in the office of C.No.3 9, MBEF Department, Naval Dookyard, Lion Gate, $.BS, Road, Mumbai -- 400 601 and Residing at - Room No.203, "A" Wing, Ganga Apartment, Ram Nagari Fiswall, Hajimalang Road, Kalyan (E), District Thane, State of Maharashtra. vhs tay Jagdish S. Panigrahi, Working as Tradesman (HSK-D, (Group "Cc" post), in the office of C.No.23, MOUT Department, Gun Gate, §.B.5. Road, Naval Dockyard, Mumbai -- 400 00] and Residing at : Bide No.265/] 0, L.B.S. Mare, N.C.H. Colony, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai -- 400 O78, KK. Ranganathan, Working as Tradesman CHSE-D, (Group "c" post), in the office of C.No.9] » MCM Department, | Naval Dockyard, Lica Gate, SBS. Road, Mumbai --400 001 and Residing at:
Bldg No.267/9A, NCH. Colony, L.B.S, Marg, Kanfurmarg CW), Mumbai -- 400 O78, State of Maharashtra, Md. Habibullah, Working as Tradesman-HSK-L (Group "C" post}, in the office of C.No.22, MOUT Department, Nayal Dockyard, Gun Gate, SBS, Road, Mumbai -- 400001 and Residing at:
Bidg No.128/05, NCH Colony, L.B.S, Mare, Kanjurmare (W), Mumbai -- $00 078, State of Maharashtra. Nageswararao Jana pareddy, Working as Chargeman (Boiler Maker), (Group "C" past), in the office of C.No.39, MBEF Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 5.5.8. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : A.No.271/LA, Talwar Tower, East Camp, No. Colony, LBS, Mare, Powai, Kanjurmarg, Mumbai ~ 400 078. Swapnil S. Jadhav, .
Working as Tradesman-HSK-1, (Group "C" post}, in the office of T -No.13109-W, C.No.68, MBEF Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion. Gate, S.B:S, Road, Mumbai ~400 001 and Residing at : 1/8, Jamadar Chawl, Near Satya Sai Mandir, Mahakali Caves Road, Andheri (East), Mumbai ~ 400 993, in the office of C.No.J 6, DDHP Department, 49, UR ms Gs tos 10 QA 82/2023 Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at; Flat No.706/D10, Sapthagiri Tower, Lokdhara, Kalyan (East), District Thane ~- 421 306, State of Maharashtra. Rajnish Kumar Pandey, Working as Rigger (HSK-D, (Group *C" posi}, in the office of C.-16, DDMP Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S, Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at - Quarter No.273/6-B, Vikramaditya Tower, Naval Civilian Housing Colony, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai -- 400 078, State of Maharashtra. Prashant Gajananrao Shrirao, Working as Rigger (HSK-1), (Group "C" post), in the office of C-16, DDHP Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.8. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at: A-204, Santosh Darshan Building, Near Jarimari Mandir, Tisgaon, Kalvan (East), District - Thane ~ 421 306. Mukesh Madhukear Armrute, Working as Rigger (HSK-1), (Group °C" post), in the office of C-16, DDHP Denartment, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai - 400 001 and Residing at; Saikupa, "C" Wing, Room No.59, Umarkhadi, Mumbai -- 400 009, State of Maharashtra. Mahesh Dagadu Padekar, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I, (Group "C" post), in the office of T.No. 12926K, C.No.10, Fabrication Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, §.B.8. Road, Mumbai ~-- 400 001 and Residing at : Chavan Bhosale Chaw! No.1, Raom No.20, | Bhatwadi Hill, Ghatkopar (West), Mumbai --~ 400 684, Niranjan Swain, Working as Foreman (Group "B" Gazetted post), in the office of C.No.7, INCOD Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : Quarter No.27 L/2A, Naval Civillan Housing Colony, x kere) tas CPs ned at oo il OABL/2025 Kanjurmarg (W), Mumbai -- 400 078 Karishna VIM. Saripilll, Working as Fitter Gener! Mechanic Skilled) (Group "C" post}, in the office of Military Engineer Services, GE(P) Navy, Railway Station Road, Visakhapatnam -- S30 004 and Residing at: Door No.S5-7-44, Sanjay Gandhi Colony, Old Venkojipalem, HB. Colony, Visakhapatnam 530022.
Pothala Jagadeeswara Rao, Working as Foremars (S24 }, (Group "B" post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, Weapon Department, Visakhapatnam 530014 and Residing at: 361, D.No. 38-19. 24, Sri Srinivasa Sai Se adan Jfyothinagar, "Marripalem, Visakhapatnam (District), Andhra Pradesh 530 017.
Uma Maheshwarrao &., Working as Utlity-U, (Group "C™ post}, inthe office of Garrison Engineer (Utility-X1) Military Engineer Services, 104 Area, Industrial Estate, Visakhapatnam 530007 and Residing at:
S. Umamaheswara Rac, Door No.8-140, Nallaquarry Colony, Pendurthi, Andhra Pradesh State -- 531173, Dileswara Rac Kaniti, Working as Foreman (FP y.) Gazetted, (Group "B" post}, in the office of The Chief General Manager, Naval Armament Depot (V), NAD (Post), Visakhapatnam (Dist), Andhra Pradesh {State} 550008 and Residing at :
Door Wo.19-27-36/12, MiG:70, Heritage Enclave, Third Floor, Gandhinagar, Vuda Colony Phase-Il, Pedagantyada (Post), Visakhapatnam (Dist), Andhra Pradesh 2 (State) ~ 530 044. NVON. Murthyraju, Working as Tradesman-HSK-H, (Group "°C post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, C.No.127, Gearing Shafting, Visakhapatnam -- 530 014 and Residing at: Do, 19-25-7, Nellimukku R.H. Colony, Pedaganiyada (PO), Visakhapatnam (Dist), Andhra Pradesh (State). AN. Satvanarayana A.,
62.
co tas - QA.82/2023 Working as Tradesman (SK), (Group *C" post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, PGS Department, C.No. 122, Chalukya Gate Near, Visakhapatnam and Residing at - 32-10-26/2, Road No.B-3, Venkateswara Colony, Sheela Nagar, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh State. Eshwar Kumar Thokala, Working as Skilled (Group "C" post}, in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, C.No.11, FAB Department, ND(V), Visakhapatnam -- 530 014 and Residing at:
D.No.10-113/23/60, Kishore Layout, Near Sun Agriculture College, Sujathanagar, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh State. Biswanath Panda, Working as Foreman (Gazetted Group "B" post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, Electrical Department, C.No.77, Visakhapatnam 530 014 and Residing at :
Bharant-03, Defence Civilian Colony, Meghadipeta, Visakhapatnam (District), Andhra Pradesh State, Bhogapurapu Suryanarayana, Working as Tradesman (Skilled) (Gazetted Group "C? post), in the office of The Chief General Manager, Naval Armament Depot, NAD (Post), Visakhapatnam 530 609, and Residing at : Door No.7-42-162/124, Voolapeta, Chiltttivala sa post, Bheemill, Mandalam, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh Staite. Ravikrishna Manapuram, Working as LDC (Lower Division Clerk), (Group "C" post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, MCE Department, C._Na.G1CE, Visakhapatnam 530 014 and Residing at ; » 38-25-21/1/9, Second Floor, Jabili Residency, Butchirajupalem, Gopalapatnam (Post), Visakhapatnam (District), Andhra Pradesh State, PV.S.KJ. Sivakumar, Working as Storekeeper (HSK-1), (Group "C™ post}, in the office of Material Superintendent, (FOR CPA), Material Organization, Visakhapatnam -- 08 Andhra Pradesh, oP CF & Pin "35 §, OP fs 13 OA.82/2 Residing at 1 39-22-26/7, Kalinga Nagar, Madhavadhara, Yisakhapainam S30007, Andhra Pradesh State. Medisetti Apparag, Working as Tradesman CHSB-ID (Group "C" posi), in the office of Garrison Engineer (Naval Depot}, MLE.S. Department, 104, Area, Industrial Estate, ner Visakhapatnam 563007 and Residing at: DINo3-74/2, Vikalangula Colony, Pulagalipalem, Pendurthy, Visakhapatnam, A Andhra Pradesh State. Yalabill Srinivasa Rao, Working as Tradesman (Skilled) (Group "C* post}, in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, C._No.20, MOUT Department, Visakhapatnam 330 014 and Residing at: D.No. 38-4-72, Marripalem, Maharani Street, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh State- 530 O18. Dharmaraju Shavukary, Working as Tradesman Skilled (Group "C° post), in the office of The Admiral Superintendent, CUNG.27C, MDS Denartment, Naval Dockyard, Visakhapatnam 530 O14 and Residing at : S. Dharamaraju, D.No.A7-28-1/8, B-Block, G-2, Sri Bhacavanniketan, Bhavani Gardens, Old TTT Junction, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh State 537007, ~Avam Achiyya Naidh, We rking a ve farpenter CHS-ID) (Group "C" post), in the office of Garrison Engineer (Naval Base}, Military Engineer Services, Gandhigram Post, O op. Malkapuram Police Station, Visakhapatnam 330 005, and Residing at : D.No.24-05-8/H, HIG-132, Sri Vatsa Bhavan, Vinaytaka Nagar, Vada Colony, Pedagatvada Post, Visakhapatnam-S30044, Andhra Pradesh State... Jeeru Bangaru Reddy, Working as Carpenter (HS-ID} (Greup "C" post), in the office of GE (P) Navy Ralinga, INS Kalinga Compiles, INS Kalinga, Bheemunipatnam and Residing at: .No3-61-191/2, } NSar Sarada Public School, Chitivelasa (Village), Sheemunipatnam (MLO), 70, 71, wed tL) ~y On 14 GOA B2/2023 Visakhapatnam - 531162, Andhra Pradesh State, Desari Sreenu, Working as Carpenter (HS-ID, (Group "C" post), in the office of Military Engineer Service, GE (ND, AGE B/R, BR-IL Naval Depot, Visakhapatnam $30 608 and Residing at : D.No.7-36, Narava, Ward No.88, Gopalapatnam, Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh State-53992 oD a aoe x Satyanarayan D. Padhi, Working as Tradesman-HSK-] (Group "C" post), in the office of C_No,32, DAG Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 406 001 and Residing at : A206, Lords CHS, Bhandup Vilace Road, Nahur (West), Mumbai -- 400 O78, State of Maharashtra, Lingam Viswanath, .
Working as Tradesman-HSK-T (Group "C™ post), in the office of C.No.32, DAG Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.B.S, Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at: 15A/273, Vikramaditya Building, N.C.HL Colony, Kanjurmarg (W), Powal, Mumbai -- 400 07 8, State of Maharashtra, Panchanana Roy, | Working as Tradesman-HSK-1 ( Group "C™ post), in the office of C_No.32, DAG Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.8. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : Room No, 12, 3° Floor, Shah House, Opp. Hotel Vienna, Dr.C.H. Street. Marine Lines (East), Mumbai - 400 004, State of Maharashtra, Sanatan Soy, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.32, DAG Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.8.8. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at ; 199/14, NCH Colony, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai ~ 406 078, State of Maharashtra. Pradip Pandurang Nikam, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I (Group "C" post}, in the office of C.No.32, DAG Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.8.8. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : B-303, Supriya CHS Lid, Plot -33 » ~need "4
--
iS.
FY, iS "4 © a Cees fod po oS RO had seo-1§, Kamothe, Panvel, District Ralead ~ 410 200 2, State of f Maharashtra.
Debaraj Patra, Working a as Tradesman- ae I (Group °C" p »St}, in the office of C.No, 32, DAG Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Ga ate, S.B.S. Road, Mambai -- 400 001 and Residing at < CY Vaishn avi Park-1, B-203, ARNandi well Talaa, Malang Read, Kalyan (£ ast}, Maharashtra -- 42} 306, Prabhat Kumar, Working as Tradesman-t ISK-I (Group "Cc" post}, in the office of C.No.33, DAG Department, Naval mockyard, Lion Gate, SBS. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 90) and Residing at: mane Vikramaditya NCH. Colony, Ranjurmare (Wes }), Mumbai ~ 400 078, State of Mahar rashtra. Radbe Shyam, Working as Tradesman-HS® 1 (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No, 32, DAG Dep varbment, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, SB, $ Road, Mumbai -- 400 00] and Residing at: C-1, Room No.106, Tulshi Building, Saneliwadi, L okudyan, Kalyan i (West) 421 SOT, State of Maharashtra, Umakant Singha, Working a as Tradesman-HSK-] (Group "C" post), in the affice of C.No. 70, MER =e ses Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.8.8, Road, Mumbai -- 400 O01 and Residing at > 273, 'SD, Viraat NCH Colony, Ranjurmarg (West), Mumbai -- 400 078, State of Maharashtra Yogesh S. Wadkar, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1 ¢ (Group "C" post), in the office af C.No. 70, MER Department, Naval Dockyard, Gun Gate, SBS. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at: Room No. 303, Jayshree Krupa Aperiment, Plot No.163/166, Seo-9, New Pany el (East) ~ 410 206, State of Maharashtra.
Santosh Kumar Sahu, Workine ig as Tradesman-HSK KG (Group "C" post), in the office of C\No.70, MER Ss. Department, Lo) Sad C4 tay 86, 16 QA.82/2023 Naval Dockyard, Gun Gate, $.B.S. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 601 and Residing at : B-402, Shiv Ashish Apartment, Plot No.S6, Sec-3 4, Near Hotel Tawa, Kamothe, Mansarovar, Navi Mumbai 410 290 State of Maharashtra. Ritesh Kumar Bharti, Working as Tradesman-HSK-1 (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.70, MER Department, Navai Dockyard, Gun Gate, SBS. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 001 and Residing at : 273/6A, Vikramaditya N.C.H. Colony, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai ~ 400 O78, State of Maharashtra, Vinay Bhushan, Working as Tradesman-HSK-T (Group °C" post}, in the office of C.No.65, MY Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, §.BS. Road, Mumbai ~ 409 O01 and Residing at- A52/03, Ameya CHS, Sector-15, , irol, Navi Mumbai ~ 400 708.
Aswint Bikram Swain, Working as Tradesman-HSk-] (Group *C" post}, in the office of C.No.65, YU Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, $.B.S, Road, Mumbai -- 400 00] and Residing at : 263/1 4, Naval Civilian Housing Colony, Kanjurmarg (West), Mumbai -- 409 O78, State of Maharashtra.
Vijay R. Gite, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.67, YAS Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.6. Road, Mumbai ~ 400 00] and Residing at : Flat No.A-401, Anjani Paradise, Manpada Road, Chera Nagar, Behind Unj on Bank, Sagaon, Dombivali (East) ~ 421 201 , State of Maharashtra. | Deepak Sadanand Dalvi, Working as Tradesman-H8K 1 (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.67, YAS Department, Naval Doekvard, Lion Gate, SBS. Road, Mumbai -- 400 og) and Residing at : Deonar Municipal Colony, Block B-15, Room No.03, Go yvandi, Mumbai ~ 400 O43. oh CK OO, i7 OASI2083 Ranjit Singh, W 'orking as Tradesman-HSK-I (Group "C" post), in the office of C.No.67, YAS Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 5.8.8. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at: Flat No.8, Vaitarna Building , Shiv Shakti Nagar NR. B-Cabin Road, Ambernath (East), District ~ Thane, Maharasistra. Sanjay K. Udange, Working as Tradesman-NS&-1 (Group °C" post}, in the office of C.\Na.67, YAS Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, S.B.S. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : Netrasanjiva Apartment, 403, 4° Floor, Rood No.27, Shanti Nagar Wagale Estate, 'Thane, Maharashtra.
Nitin Vishnu Karande, Working as Senior Section Engineer (Group "C" past), in the office of Carri lage Wor ksh hop, Matunga, Mumbai -- 400 019 and Residing at : Building No.8 ; lat No.103, Mohan Palm's Phase-IYI CHS Ltd.., Shirga: on, Badia apur (East), District Thane -- 421 503, ate of Maharashtra.
Anil Kumar Sharma, Working as Fitter (Group "C° post), i" the office of $08, Army Base Workshop, Qethi Cant ~ 110 G10 and Residing at : C-15, Sector-36, AY Pari Chowk, Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh -- 201 370. Anam Charan Swain, Working as Boiler Maker (SHK-I (Group "C" post), in the affice of C.No.68, BEF Department, Naval Dockyard, Lion Gate, 8.5.8. Road, Mumbai -- 400 001 and Residing at : Flat No. VG-05/06, Tower-C, Dreamz Home Society, Ghitorini, New Delhi - 110 030. Rachunath Santara, Working as Foreman (Mechanical) (Group "B" post), inihe office of The Director General af Naval Armament _Anspecton, Directorate of Naval Armament Inspection, Integrated Headquarters, MOD (Navy), West Block-¥, Wing-T (FF), ROR. Purarn, New Delhi - 110 066 18 DOA.82/2023 and Residing at : At Gandarda ,Post-Palsia, Via Gadodeulia, District Balasore, Odisha State.
93. Prasant Kumar Sahu, Working as Tradesman-HSK-I (Group "C" post), in the office of Garrison Engineer (2), Gopalpur-on-Sea, Army Au Defence College, Golabandha Ganjam (Odisha} 761 052 and Residing at : Prashant Kumar Sahu, Bhapur Telli Street, Near Mukteswar at Temple, Bramhapur, Ganjam, Odisha 760 001. . Applicants { By Advocate Shri R.G. Walia ). Versus i. Union of India, through The Chief of Personnel, Integrated Headquarter of MoD (Navy), 109, D-IT Wing, Sena Bhawan, New Delhi--- 110 O11.
2. The Flat Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Hrs. Western Naval Command, Tiger Gate, Naval Dockyard Mumba, Mumbai -- 400 001,
3. The Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard Mumbai, Lion Gate, Mumbai ~400 001. .. Respondents. ( By Advocate Shri Rishi Ashok, for Shri B.K. Ashok ). Order (Oral) Per : Justice M.G. Sewlikar, Member (J). This Original Application is filed by the applicants for the relief of bringing them under the cover of Old Pension Scheme. a ihe learned counsel for the applicants has SPF oduced across bof Se kt ain. fades Akio M dated 3 March, 2023, Where the C entr al Government civil ee es 19 GA B22023 employees whoa have heen appointed against the post or vacancy which was advertised/notified for recruitment/appointment, prior to the date of notification for National Pension System i.e. 22° December, 2003 and is cavered under the National ¥y $ * i Pension System on joining service on or after Oi" January, 2004, may be given a one time option to be covered under the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 (mow 2021), The learned counsel for the applicanis subnits that the applicants have given the option. He submits that this OLA. can be disposed of by giving directions to the respondents to take the decision in accordance with O.M. dated 3° March, 2023. as in view of this, the respondents are directed to take decision in respect of the option exercised by the applicants vide OM dated 3° March, 2023 expeditiously.
$. With these directions, the Original Application stands disposed of, (Ur BhacWin Nanay {Justic :dBAG, Sewlikar) Member (A) Member (J).
SH.