Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Sudam Pandurang Bhamare vs M/O Statistics on 14 July, 2022
2
&
mile 202
4
of 4
UrVvey
ors
3
TRIBUNAL
MUMBAT
day
AE
; Member={d}
RATIVE
3
a
o
a
CATION NO. 8605/7019
the |
as
t
Karande}
oa
N
*
aur Gpero
R
Re
MUMBAT . BENCEL.
ch
Phy
fy
See
ra
(TRAD ADMINIS
<
ow
CEN
LES
th
der kK
ete
ORIGINAL APPL
nee
arvin
eoRN
VERSUS
Dated
BR
(By Advocate. Sh
CORAM:
ed
f24
tuk
wise y
POSS
te
3
x
tf
KRos
P
ty and Shr
Shet
(By Advocates Shri RR.
ORDER
= iS 3 i oft : Rhy ved ap ec h = inks aes wat he i act Set SF ey if: e : 5 4 i A oe a 5 st a us 2 43 +e 4 eS os oD yy a3 Bes ie Utes io ky 3 i é ' £5 Pots i a is uy oe » Bo ie . : 4 4 it 7 € ag Fa "rAd o fog @ a 4 3 ne & on fy a is vie : I f 3 By wd 3 i a) vy cyt Let or 3 o, ; ; Cy we cot 4 . Bef ov nB a B 3 + o et $2 (4 yy bay het jo --
ef os ie we Py ran 43 4 @ 4 me wa , te 53 3 $84, (eh 4 cf gy nx: Sed foe wa ye $a iB % 43 :
vat 4 a > Yes 0 i a are * 5 o a 2 ts Wa 3 a nl Ee ca oa ; fglg it 6 fas
- wy C 4 Cy ig gS te "4 x4 2g &S i fay bet ws aa i os bred BTS oa a <4 3
-- pte a od 3 A Ay : eee nae ' ms ih hd a uy * Y ou 67 i A i a Bo, iq os i) i oo be Po ae : : % be nf 4 * bet , Shel Dp ds oa ved iS tng ay i) ey inet 43 33 4 +}.
+ i t t < x oC ct ah th} t bet ot am ae ! 4 : ; C ra Co whee Gt oo 5 oS b } : 3 Oi 1.3 he ath ay iD 03 mh at ie S S B98 Oe b A it oo Ss : $ : z ep -t3 t oe a ies oy go t j ty ce va we oa cod Ae he ° ap j : L4 a a iH a3 a ty ny Oy . 5 yy t *. f iy ; : : af } ; ; iS oe oo poe 3 Gy hed : Le te sot part ae 4 ) tel th od Be : ve $ el hed eo ' : t : x nee ¥ 2 oe: 44 et : Pos & : ty i) @ be ee ed w : 1 ee os ; "at 4 set (op ie : & ms cS €, 103 PA : 4 Cy : a) a ree foe " s B ig ee 2) 4 o 4 2a ou a ; 7 a a) $a od ef hes mad Sy bed eA c ay i fe 3 j ed : s At 3 goocs ' . fol Q us She 39 o. 1oUr % 2 pg fed * ; PR PT tte PROPS he : Ee : : ; . ts : : : : rd 2 i : : ay ' at i : 3 ao "
Lr « 4 : i a uD if) SY i : : te 6 ved ' i 3 x * 4 : .
3 i : ;
& : oh { ; & 4 rf Oe tae: i : a MM * hy ' t $ te ho : f ip © bet ~ boned © eed i ok: { vhs C 4d . Doge $ : uy :
e3 sts 2 $ : : oe nS G a ook i boo : ve mw 1 ay ' beg Say e co 1 ed { BE at : s ed oS ; be ' ee :
. vas i : ' : 49 ! } 3 : uy es ' Be gs " * ° "3 f vos if " sot 4 eth GA OE ye o e A gg or 2 ® * io 3 : foe gy 9 bE ag wd Bee its ved ; Pose ES he ey a ee wh * is ve : PEP OEY sced oe a a} pe Let . wack ' Pe pda AOE Dee ey i ; bgp sa Bao ah 3 a es om t ' ie Ly Mt ote nea : 4 hp sa "rd Q is iy ad ' : i : Lt Gy a Eby . B pe fs ™ bint i Ss sch Us $ -
ue Ce Bs ae : ' was < Be rey ed & aw 4 Let Es dd $ t wo gy > QO Sage ai 4 iS i = 2 f ryt A C: (6) : ate OR Ea 4) peg, & a 45 a Be sat Oa i os € £5 o oe 5 oe CGH va a ed '5 | i 58, ei ne s 3 cA raat 3.
zi te me @ <-- SS fo ive a 4 wos c O "oe £4 4 ° oe} i Sy rl Ch ret 43 B & J S s eg ay 1 % 23 Che a £3 in i , AS tf y "xf a s ; ie ng be ce ge us Le oO s atically condoned th 2S ey ed Co ed le ed & ie) we Bea ee a" 8 Weg 2 3 " nen is) $., Es} ' S 4 ee » oy a 4 ra % i Ce Dy ; we 43 x "ch bE ed 1G i Sh ny oi U 2 Bs a vd « ah ' "a Nas 4 :
B a ou & uo 8 oe : th Dy ved G, Tg o 'ae rg sf % Be ae a ues yas = B ea @ i os ay eh a i oe "
set tye wy " ie : ny ay OE ae ee ne i he cas ed, £35 ih te "a ey £4 Ai we et 4 ba u > anh i) as o 4 4) D me ed ee Pa 2d 6h i a tes q i ie 4 rs Ma ay 1s 2 ca fad a ao Oy id ed be Ae i wed o Os u rd : bby ba ey Sh4 sf 94 Gia : eo 5 a5 . e oi : ea 4 ced 4 ee: "4 a us f im : £4 Si ord A 7 Fe ed 2 et a : : be o "3 oo m4 rs ore 4 fn ka ing wh sy : 5 oe : is) " Op * Ba $3 = * . ee . b in od bP At 2 eter ve @ 4 vot aS ord a ty 2 aid en 43 $4 ct we ie cp A 3 nerf wee 1s yet ie : "5 > he ; es ae i © eeeh ee Eu ot er eng cat co on % } by yee he reef ei a ack bea ork tt i ' a pa ¢ C4 %G i ik 3 gS aa 8. Me at os td oa hee ae ne bey Dy i iD Es} org tit fy od ir 3 : ky £E On Eas : A aa a tae by a , i g eh : : 1 ees ' a a " 5 os a 43 t & a "4 i ed gE aw 8 Oo a wt ha 2 sed & : Bs wey "
: * osed CO oy 'Ss : a2 i het 3 aD. $3 neat. Sy f © ' af ©, . a ay 4 es qe os deb we ¥ 3 $n oc a oa 2 0 ab u3 itt a a ! 8 a we 4 age ce G £3 ¥ " 33 > > a bt €hy 5 . eee , a ve ". at $54 os a ne im wi uy £ ae ae Oo eq ge i Bw g a A ah pd ue eh & * eth é pd sf? y3 ' C uw 2 » - % Oo apy 44 8, ve ts wo '3 B 3 a S of Qi 2 A ae rg z ie a Mo * nA 3 set 3 % ed food at ¢ ae m2 ip ' a3 QO; vo 10} 5 a ry * or Ea 5 } 3 mi gy oO Bey ord ; fi BD " ey ie : _ i : © A Seok oA tft :
wm be s . s wr pe zi o 3 i a be ey a os Ry i -
4 ra ws 13 a bh 43 t 1 el Oy Sy 5 42 13 oO a a , te ta s wh a a v Wy oe ope $a a C4 thy <2 £4 g3 ae 4G. i me i) 3 rye a. Kh % id beg z a Mi o a o we Cs 4 ; w @ set a wh ry e gt i <p e i ' a gy Ky
1) 2 ea o =f om 24 Ba Lc oe Oo 7 a
a) Cy rt ag ' : od oa a 5 2 a . i cn & i ei s 1% 1 x 37 * ccd ° oO 5 ' , .
Cy (rs ty wad 3 tet £4 co 4 if ' Col of ad Mey j as) w ; 43 x eas 4 rd
2) m3 ie g } 7 +, Qs, wen i - oe fy > The thy > ad Eh od / : Ss wot ee ty 2 4 re on i . 9 E "4 : " te 4 ug a 3 ; ne oO Q é 3 fg a & & ~ ae ey.
= a me Rak Ae aS €.
og '3 ty 2 a 3 9 i 2 rey a i 6 Paes oe ry ' uy % AS £ a = ke poets NN ae ok, t = fe Gees gee * 2 LARS SEeYh SSk5 = wh} py sere choo x A = BE Sea yen Ww @ opal opr AN SS Nake Bae Net de OS Cte, 4 to ee Nt z x N beaten soe FESS ca x Set 4 y : ' ao ak. a cect [a af seat wort ea Ss 2 es a ® Go gq 4 "ps e ted rea © ff} 2 "74 "yA 5 a Ld Ae fi ' ay . au vl 3 32 wy gy ba et ; : eo @ D us sc) we " 5 a @ te . ot So 6 "4 hed ¢ 3 23 4:4 iB Le qi QD 3 be th Bs net "
3 A ia fl Li na "4 be vy oh o Boy * ts on Le . g " at 2 4 0 43 wed ; oy i at re ne ort Mp 4 a Be ra aan iS ope ¢ ihe eo red os ves oh cs Boo Be BE gs ee Sty Ba 5 . «© a «as Be as 3 2:
OG oA us D Ae og o a a - wre - en, ee #8, oO ee ve : d fs © oe oH i * , ge @ ra wo ma a ih 3 fhe B kt XS + aS Mel ' ub 'i os Bg is a fa 2, 4 2 Pg a G ng =) a "ay 5 ha ih weed 43 of . Hy ca 0 4a sa is n o Bera o ry e e Ce w i) ie v4 fi a ee 43 td oD 29 #5 3 4a ~ ' oD o> a Fed th 23 is
2. 4 3 0 o . e tes set " CG a prt iF e :
4h sy l why < ¢ SS a > 3 2 44 ie i * Sel . 58h $f
6 be wy x OF Es ty ria € 43 Ly if * 4 "eS a td ay . ny reg 3 a ; i o og MA a M in ot 3 ve Be f 49 A re) © od 1 v 482 +3 4 $34 bee "
: ;
: we j A? i) 2 2 A fs in i im . at a " Fed tt ; ret x en Poa t 3 3 + _ Se AL ee AVS, any oe CAS & Ke = eS 3.7.2
Pad Se eb Sa x at tht + os £ Ak b, £ 3 >.5
Se aa ek.
ROO, & ae Le et Seta miss:
LTS.
Me & ye < a5 SO iS
38.
on
8. % 1 Vo ve 4 bef a ay NA?
r aS ee SEs coe "as as Ne?
io ited a gt Be ' ts A o wt mt wet ot "
Le > oh aa 03 uy Ly tet 'f } "rh ers " bs tae ft ot Me oO O hes ref ty iS fh 3 fre cae a4 te yg ee oy uo cD : $5 ~ vel td 3 Pe 3 ays qt :
4 £2 0 DB ae :
3 i & i 4 os : es oe ay : 4 ae st Be a (ch & be a ee ci oS ; ae sp eS i 44 " n te fe os 14 ot ay Cx a wy 85 mie v a ta et ot reed "2 wnt to hen ue vt a} :
Si aed yp.
oA ved B 8 ad % i ia oh oe tg .
383 ma he " ert y ey beady re bd {3 in iz 2B :
o : $ veh : ne That aad Hea} vo a py Sy ' ws ah t ved 2 enh eo AI AG ay? eve err ga vn pk Say: $ Es he yh ay ' at es i 4S oy : SoA : a 4 us s ee x ey re Ad 4 bog a4 =e oh 5 By cy s wi ee ra IS. aad he ity es aa ws Ms 2 SE ASSENSA SEEN SSN SESSNSEDSESESROVG or yt nt etter entree "REESE ey % wy 5 on Aah a : = An 5h ba Rad oy 6 "4 oP ion t if "se @ fe a an de i 7. jet "5 ' t be qa "a xt) i & i : a 42 ba io i * ify © on oe % 2 tt mo Bs bs M4 3 5 ped Wy F Re @ ie oo Ay a " ": 7 ra , 74 ef 423 4 te wy wes a Sa ry : he w a a £ eo} ay & wl Ba a u ' ih 03 La py aD a ie : 14 a Cs oy eed «s wg ag gs we :
Wye Bed ye ree £3 ; irom % :
My. : ae he L7 uy a eo : : G ts } i a wat a ta. iH OS ren "et 1 x y : 4 5 iy Mt : eal ven :
re 9 " 4 83 ty Ae } " acad 's rel fey het ; a :
on +t a3 '5 teed ss i te ; Pe . Eh ey : teh ne e 3 if : 5 iy on : w By eg aS '3 ai cs "a a wf " fs 3 S "4 ' bs) + " 5] it ; 1 $4 oo Ss "4 Bs "2 i. a fi oy 3 ht 31 aS xg ¢ oo ys nt is ros a 3 a ha "2 et :
oh 3 cy xt on roof Bd : ¥4 :
i} £3 " 3 o Ohi @ ty a) : i F me : i ref o m ALG 44 wed i it Hl 4 aon Ls : 3 4 ber ps oy a ao " bed 8 ' ty ee ' 2 o a a 2 be * a ws of o oye i 3 v4 "3 2 :
a Ae i vo 2 a i i es go : Ow OS ep BBG 2 ct hat i fy 44 a it 2 rot ee :
ood , oy . : i o, Ww iw WY j as i oa w i ' eB WO ug = : 2 n 1 4 i . :
a a wn A 4 G , :
iB : w 5 Fy } '4 % 12 Oo © oon : me by 4 - fhy cs ait w ay es af wef SA a < , ve st
s) is a we ye z x a wy * rd "4 a es ohh : ds 4 a G u oe Hes a oo oy ' us Ch Pe ' " & he mt aS ey C G ari Cs $ to bs oO & Cy @ wef 3 w re Ea be RERREEREEREEEEERRR en} ow Se Sar wh bet wy o} a £N it he ess A AGAR ay x aS oS rod Aas ¢ Me et ey weak ory poi a Sohem leony BAe 8 Ma + a 4 2 ib 3 of het age = AR:
:
EPR oN x wR 2 No Na AO se te Amy ee SARA M3 ee! Ae Aarpvoas Boh he te NE oe eres Sk eves hoe yebca ke Se ER.
se Yad hey U3) 4 cane q pay Qe g i ae SY Sak Boe Sette, nm AIR 19812 8 136 aported 4 ay Loos aA trae SSSE ARS Pa Gy on Fl 2 Orn Vey etc., Cotton Millis ste, Swadeshi ox Myo Be wee ¢ sc S8i AIR 2 22 etc., reported india ete. , of Uniden Ba 3 oes.
CaS oS a wt.
uy Pat ay = 3 = os 2 ¥ a en ey, we wyoty a8 x Ne egad act Ww Wk Ry oy thet ih eed Son, et Dek yy wt Nees SA os te bone pe oren 4 ag 2 3 2 ot 'en oe 3 we.
a 4 eh ee is @ iD ed a 4 i) of £ Ls a fs : ha wee be a { :
BS 8 * vod a a f eh Suey < Go oS in ff 4 etna, ry { Member 4S f{Harvinder Kaur Ob ed :
oops Ss fn ved Le co o : Sth ect ent ie x opt at . 4h ted &: ae De, og bony A, a a a! "a4 ge rg % pene < \ Oey