Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Customs vs M/S Next Fashion Creators Pvt Ltd on 11 August, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
- E-;Gi?'%?:3:W; E??;fQI:_D¢ ........»L EN "'§'E'"EE?§ E'§E{}}'¥ {'i{}{E WE' {E}? %§E%R;N£'E'}%.EizX Eaifi" Ei%.fi'x.§'~§{7}.?aE,€f} RE-3 Ei}A'§'§€§f} T1 TEES T§TEE%Z- 3 ET" Ei.};'7%.f¥" GE" Z%{{§{?: E§S§'§'Z 23 i ?.RESEE"£"§' "my: §~;®m%3L§«: Mzz.3:J$?£{:;§; N 2§::"a2_;§.§'§'j:'~., AME} . M u 'E"'§~§E'{; 2&0 .mm:: M§~mLES@'§§:5 mi:M12'/;:zaj§':%LL:% C 8 TA NQQ glqaaé' 8Ei1'E'W£§:E\5: "
CR. BUELI)2£'\Ef;%S,_"' QUEENS E{GAE3*{ ._ 2:
BANG;xL@2§f:..--«A-56é:é_Qf:f}:3 _:
. A§5'§'3'E2LL£XE'*§'E"' {B}; SEE S ;%§z;s;:g:'é:>:L:;;,:;g:>i;';; " A ANEE: A % V MKS ?~5§i}{{E*"'v«?f?3.SE--EEEZEIN"'CIr«":.;E§5§_}%?*;;'17;§RS Wig: 1333.? Na 2,/21, ::3z=:2=:':'§aN;;; jAG:2A1~~--:ARA E3E:c;;;§2' :»§;0£«3:,L"» 1/ s;x,?«;:;A:;{§§:T&:>'~.__ A . E%.§3;:S;i?'C*iF'~.§§}Z¥:'Z,f'~.E"§7 {E-332 3':azfi", §2°%;:.;:;§";r2s:a::es§ ?':/£E':ZE.'€OE:'€, gxzx-=*.; '?1'*j§E§-3 {3S'E¥%. ES §3ELE%3E} Ui'~§E}E§~€ SEZCT§{}Z's3 33?} SF yE'§"§§: v ,{Ei;'f3'>fE°{}F:.«§'::% :3.C""§1 mag EKRESENG em' 0? QREEEQEE {ya-':'§;:§ 23 "«.{;£s,--:2::::%:>§ {<2 _:2--1;2--:20§5 _z->;za_sS§e::} $323' E7E_?'\£'..:"~'%,,E';., ®E€§f}§?3;§% Ema _:;'2.:3";2;z'2@{s€§ <;§2.§:~::§;=:--_:z*<z--<>§z:Qimz, 'raga. 32;"?;Q@5, E1}§3%z%.':"'.EE\§{2 " ':'§--gm' TE--EE8 .. 1' ' " "E~"E'}E%M§,EE,£:'F§%:
3'm':"":-:§T> ':':T~T§§2§-2:%::?«.:§ $:e:':* ;%$EE7}E§ '§'E~iTE.§ .EZ--§.z5'%f'z' Efiiii .E3L§§E%.S§§E} TO:
Q1} EB;;;"3:"i'°§§?§ (3? L531?
E3§"f'£5%L {}E€§:}%%ZE'% EEK}.
E--§GE'é"E3§;E%: C®UE"€'.E"
'E"'§~§Ei Si§E3$'§'z'%?'3'2'E§:i , /.
1' ~a duijgf5?:.£'<>;f¢ggr>j::e3 {§fi'v.§§;".i.€*«' ggfiedés €i€$i§'I'{}jJ€€.'§ by fire wag RS, ""'E'E_":@: S§.§§}€3Z'§'§'§§.€§'i{§€jf§E§, SE €:;&=;§,<};::1$ €iii.3"§;%:.:'{:e3{§ éhe f ;?a§::§}i§e:::'-}ii'e;:a;*: $3: €3~§}~2C}¥:?='¥§ w§%,h aha': §}€§3z,::.y Cs:mi1"§:is35§Ee:2:";€3:' <3? ..:'Zf2;,:'é:;<::_:f:1:ss;; B2:':':;§.21';a:°<a <:Ea.£.:2':§.§:g §"'€f§}"£§;'§§$i(}%f"é aéf {£u:'E::§,.-* ':.§E"§{§éf':"
- S;f:<?.f:§<:::": 233 <1? 'i§E{': €i:,2st.<}m5:s f%.<'%'£. E.€%€32l {§%}:* .s--§a§2r;):*é: "£é":z:é giigiéf} in é*§--:=s+;§::%s:'f§. {if i§":€ g;:9@<§s;; £§€:S¥;,rs>§;&?{i in She §'i:*s3 ;1<%<:§{§s::2§., E13 égiéié fig-
:':@?",;:2{:9£~; z}9;:"z«:,-ET} 2:§A0£3--2<><>5 :'>;2,s§$§«::} £32' mza: {:E%:;§'::&£_ 5;{;s§5':"§«§ Z{§N;-"xi E:3i£%i11\§{fE~£ E351" E:§f§N{}j%.Em{§§%E§, 'JEEEEEZ ANN EZ.;;}{UR§%Z ~22": REiE§'.E'{}E%E§ ':*'§~§%: G§€§_}Ej=ZE.{--EN-{}Ei?;E'{}§NAL N5}, 32;--:z;@{}5 :;>;y:'§>::> .13 £2--:2Q{}5 PASS$Ei'.'Ei} £333? "Ema: C£}1':v§P2;§'§SS§{'si'éE%§.._'§ 'fT}§*' CU;:'§TG1VES, Ef§Ea_E'€GA,E,.{)E'{E; 1.-11.325: A?~£'rx:':%:;'x:Ja;'R:4:#:e3, m€:':':§ Jwiii} CIE'{CUMS"E'Ai\ECE§S GE?' ":_'m:": CASE; ~ ;.
mis AE53E5'E?;-AL {EOMENG ON" mzag ;~§a:A;z::%:'»::-- f?:jj:»:£é':3 :;>;xé;.,' K'U1'y'§;7§_R J" :3§>:L:'s,->';§;R§:::; *m§_2: :%'a:,:;Q§:;f§T:'Vs{;: "
.3 {J D N '.'f%':.is appezzi §"3};': VV{ui{f';::7;i§<3fi§'§§vEi;;§ c;>:"d:-3:"
pasgsaéé by "aha 'E'rEbuna§' {he a:Ea1%:":": sf r<:m§:~;si<;:1 {sf ' a_s$&3:'ssss:§3, The asasessee .i::~a=i' .E" Vt.-;:'::;i:y 'I7h€<y i:":1p0r":e{i '<;5~;:"*é<::1.zs§*{'i{':'?:'3:* ' §#§=:::'k«'i%"é'.<:;"%.£":<;% §§1"€f £&§.'f{2idé;',i'EE. an "F-4- ZGS4 E:i_'£:i"zr;;: S§,{}3"V€3§%""--.{§§""i§"iE'£;i{?§S€$S£%€f'f'5§ m":i£._. the? <;*,;1'£,i.:'e f'£:';FJ m9JiLe:é21Es:= hzézfi been -b1,a';::%1«.;i2.5E€3:2g w.i..!iE'1 <é€::'?;ai:1 €§€}€?:LIFI1€'ii'1EEE;( Th6:
g:%s%§<'és;é;a%<§% é,<:¥j--j:3§:}r Eléia 5-szziéi a§::':<2:,:::";*;.. '§'§';{:: féieé 211:'; V2//.. .
|--«<--
"z-2:t%z.m'3:2 of §:%.:*:'-% ;2-z:::::i{%:3'z£. 'i,i-'"éi13i$ <':m';<":;.1':r.':=..::3i::2-tied {<72 %;?:%3 E:}%£f}}£}L§":'.E"11€;?I'1;L E,§'§<:5':.,-' :::':c§e:é*;i,.€}<>E<§ i:':v<;%$%.i§§§:%.i:3:'§$ ' ---:;;:£.":{i Em;e3'€',§gzzi::i{m:«s §"€"i-Wfféii 1E:§z;9.%. {he v;:z.Eu€: :33" {he g<><3c:§_$ {he fiféf E':{'?{'.'i{§€fiE'}';. as ctlaigllaézi in the i§"":S§L1§'2-.':..EV"':'¢1','.'€i'::§' R.s;4._2£),';?'E%,539/~,, h<>u..?e,v€:1", ihe. '»:2?:EjI1;<;»* V(3'i" 'aj.':'"?;'Q"..4£;(}'1;){'§;fi§::V§;%£f£"%?:iSt§%§':€i%§"' 'E40 ihe Ce..1s.=:':.{::rn.e3 I}:%par::'11€1'1;§ 2,-wT1;:~3 Was; h.L2ge v2>.1"'iaE.i<}:: E3<=;é§.w€<~3n E:}T};'.'§'i4;3:'%:5c'i?"1€"i§.3 has-3 'V been s;i.ai,€rcE i>€:£.2:>3."<-3: Th?' ~.§§1:5?/'§::'1*%'i.e:;A..'v/.:QT§%%%€:. _i.£;E.2:L}« a'2'a§z;:;€;: 9? rezzaz ::1za;:.€:°§.a§$ 2111:? a{?C€'i=?,aS{}I.'i%3':€~3J aa:01'P:s {mi is Rs; .3. ,89;.b7@.€39_§ "'-§.'§":€ iduigy fifl E'..E?:€§ ;:?}{}'§:'C'5':§§{){)C§S (TGEEEEES :0 E-{SK V;'..fE:+:_ 'paid 'ihe 21,mGu:ni.."'0n va.rE0u,é; €ia{<§:2=,--.,j _ EA-E%fi§Wevé3::,«" whileW<:{>:1s:der§:'1g {his :é.':a;1n1 far 1'€3E'QiE-',»Si{;'§"i, 331:3 Qiyzzzfgrgiés:=:§:*:§::j.~ztozzfirgéaed t§3<-3 dsimand 0i' {£21.13-* of §{§§E%O.,43;€%.V.Gi';':"?V/~'._ a;::d*...-*::.E1.€: 21n"1<}:,:_.n£ 21Er€:::_-w:.<:i§§,: paifl werrs-3 23_'f:3'g?;'€3aVif"'§lE:{1%xI';€'E€} é.<§'v;:,::°ds_ 21b{)V€': §§3v'is:.s3. The C<3m§1:;1$s§<};1er ' =;j€:}--e;::§.<c.§iT 'iE_':23.VM{%="::-3:11 fa}? z°€:=,m§s3s:;is_3:'1 0:1 ifihts ggrszazmi ':.%:22E'. 2% dssiés i1:31-..:§§;§E39."_'§.::: "i;§,i*;%% :?.as€: {sf faiizmir Ea '¢1CC{}L3:E'1i'. €35' 13"».-*£i§"€E§";{"§uS€€§ §_;§<:>:>%i';§sa "'§-:-E€;%';'i;E::;§3 {}§}:'~?5€3§""sJ€{§ %;h2':"£'. S<::;:EE{}:2 23 2:21? 'aha :1'X{:§' 13213 EEG " V. :*s§::i:a;3:}:% 2:; 3,11%? §§;><':€Z:'~;; §§E'E§'3{3§°§.€{§ ;:2:3{i atiatziréiié azéiiaé :3{}%.%éE<::a'§..i<>:2 ' .~'.§£:i:E,€fA{§ :'32i;'2i3QZ§: 'E.'.7:':£;*. ssaési <}:*{E:iz' was; <:E"zg-fflééziggéié by 3&3: " %3a:%E'{>'re:*: t..§":§% "%f;"'§%3z.;:':;':.E. 'E"§§£% "i.'z°iE3:>:z:21£, <32"; :;%<::z:s;§{'Es~3:§°:»:i.§:>;3.