Karnataka High Court
State By Ashok Nagar Police Station vs Ashok on 7 February, 2011
Author: K.Bhakthavatsala
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala
s»&
' Vif;:I';g:3_g2;g:::;-;x';--.% '
II? THE HIGH COURT SF KARXATAIKA
exxzcurr BENCH AT GULBARGA % _
Ij}A";E'E:E.fi> im:£~3 ":";«:§: 22% :_;>;¥:=' <35' Ee':~:E§§2{,z;x_mi__.i§'é§:. .
PR'£€SEiN'I"
THE HQN'ELE ax. JUSTICE K E'HAK'w::§vgai%S;a:,5fi«'V%
EKNEE
THE I'iGN'BLE MR$JUSTI'(§.§-
C§a:1xzm€AL A§?PE:,.s%§_g Ni}; f2:f2;'2f{;<:=i§% % '
{EREMENAL §<z_.'?4:§%; /--2::':€i--'f;?%:v
CR§,.A,N0,§£22{2{}f§'» a':jf ._;*. ' '
BETWEEN
S"§1i{{'E?: E%Y 1-'?'aSE1'§{3§<;__ :x;;5%;c};;:a.,;1:.__§::f>:T;,s.e:?:i§;__ -- I
S'i1?YE'EGN.,GUL£§A?¥=?:{;f%... - .
£135.»? SM'E"15¥\lUE3?,AI§§9-EgfaI'Zé'f%;$;1:£, L:-'s.:i'>'i:';::_,=$:§§'>;
523;,-.~.:@§< S Ks:§~'%;;i§j§Ti:J:a,';J, E§§N§€;%:ET';- ..... .. -
;a§::a_ 2§*:'i§§;&:£S"'- f ' '_
€3C€?fE§E'€§,3§'iJ' .§3§z.rv;.3%::2:':ai;<%;§3'
Rgi} ;'%E§~Eé{,}_§€ 3~;;i:;€;;;¢;§-'%
:j'§=;f§ 5~:~z%: :2:za_:€':4>gx:><§'$:?4'ééi';§4:§a §=§<.>z::;§i:: ;:?:32.a §~*<f3'§:e; fa:*~$E":"{T>%§
" ~ ..z.:%?'.'::2;2":iE_:_,.§ iiaifii', ~z«*'<3:-'2 E%i§iE§§3'{§§'~E§.i}E§E'€'§'}
?\§53E-'§§£,E,£%.?*§'§7
§%E§;S.E53{"§é'€ E} §€§;§\E T
M
TI-{ES CRL,,z"s. ES E*"ILEfZZ3 UZS 3?'8E1f: AN'§} {3} GE? CR_E'}.C'. E351' '§'f"II:Z
S'T}~'¥'§EI Pi}. FOR THES S"§'zK"FI?Z F}¥€A':'1:"*«§G "'E"'E-i;'~'x'i'T '§'I*i'1S E'EOi\§"E53i,»I?3~._QOUHE'
?'~.r"§AY BE PLEIEXSEZEE TO C'§E73;AN'§ L-EEZA'§:'" 131 ".F£l'z §7'EE,,rE€ iii-"E3'EZA.E;§&{NS'E"
'THEE JUDGEMENT §)z'&TE.§£L} ESYGEVZOG? .§N S.C.NGa7,.--/2G€"}5*-£?E}§ TI_'E-{Ii
FILE GE" THE 9.9. E7" 518'? '§'R:%CK C{}'i3'§7€"£'~V, gf:§'L?L;E$2*'%_,_f{{3=.Vi3;" é ~
r'XCQL§I'.£'E"I§'€{3 THE: RESS§3ONE}£€ZN'§',/2"iC{iUSE§I} FOR ".."_§°"§'uE E?}A,E{}F'
E3,/U,/S.3G? Q1?' ZPC, .
CFLR E' E*€Gff94;'20€3?
BETWEEN
S£~:ARANABAsAP§>,»=a
S ,1 0 M'ALiAPE«7A
AGE A3013'? 2: YEARS
§«:AN'rA COLOE'§"f'
GULBEXRGAA -- V g ~ _
« " 1 §3:~:';':'r:eN§e":R
gm' SR: 8 S §§AL.A',L: 'Azs,:f>_'2?.g §§{}§%_': §?E«:'P:fr§:€:,%:%::§:T{}
Al?!)
2' TEIE 3*"§A";f;3:%':;33T. ;éigx§2r&;';€i;:~:A'm"--
"E"'}iE€Q{}G;?f§ AS;§»::3;<§€Vz3£;«A§-2« -
POLICE "§A'1"§;0:x§ ' ' " *
GL'£.BAE»?_GA} ' _
2, E';S§~i€)K.=» _ '
» 53,20 VE'§i§~L%kLL %;:~zG§4~r£::. ..... .. .~
, 58:3, ;sg:;3Q:;?T 2?}YE<:A§%;S
'{ECG§:§"E<.';{}2f§'°'£%E3S§'1'*§.£§$E$
E€_,f.,C33 _:3S§i'QE§~V.N;::(j;g:>:
§zj':,«Esma:Q;a; ..
H . , zz_:s:s9<>N§:3::rx?'§'S
~ '::;zm'. £33: :;;~5;;'a§;:-'13; iv: $1'-::sA;§ ATEEEL, 3 :53 six gage K1,}
'..'_'V{:€»_25'~éi$ ;;§:«:§§=é;«'a:*E<M:§}§ E375'? E5N~E<%§iE9§?iEiZS§%:E'§'EEE'}}
ws9»mm»wmmwmqu.mmMmmWmmm.w . ..
T§"£ES {L'R'L.RE3 ZS f~"E§;Ei§.} U;/8 43%. OF {>/'»E:{W}'),€:5 ?'Rflfi"EN'G TD
i*€}?Z'£I'S§?, T§'£E§ QREJEEQ £3§%.'£'E§f) .i8.€}3.$?,{3€}'? ¥¥3:f:§;'E§E?ZE} BY 'E'%"EE E5313? E*"'E."C«
V, {;L§§£:3fi§%{;f%a EN S¢CxN{}.?/2€}C¥E's;
'§"§~iIS .:m>£«:A:, gmis §z:m5:0:~s §??E§'E'§'I'§{}E'~.? CG:5v'IE'€%~T{:.._"G?§--VV FGEE
§~fi«;;sg22NG $1.13 53%;', £32m» E13E--E£Ei'F§'~ir"x';?z9:7ET'Sgkijs J, :13 E%1';«§~,--§'7§fE*Z§~'<'E?§f,3* " 'SEE
FGL-£,QWEN'G:
JUDGMENT
Criminal Appfiai ET\E:3.§ 123 Z O'? §Ti.1ed[i}}r "§.h;é j.S€'I2T;ié::._' '?z..K'£"'i£.§Vé1f~§f' :E§:s;%g:'*i.i<>:i' .1 3178€§} am? {3} {>5 C:r'..P.{2., is; s.:i:':*§cif:§i 21§éw;§;2:§i €:21:§':ir::f§ .E$v3n26@Y made 2:; S.C,N<>.?_;'2GO8 c;:¥:%»..§,§:».;: fiie 'g3;?.§%fi.:asgi. **:;ac:g cmm~v' at GuEb23.rga, a{:qL2ii?i.i:1gf %,.}f1£=;:23?;*€L:a::3'éV<.:E_i%{)r 1E51.£§'~-Q§fen::ré:'A aizédéi' Sectéan 3%'? am' {he E::d'ia'n Pe.z1:;;:§ ems. 1€:¥,1'.'§<:':>..1-~:%i;»;§--'?j~:35§'--;'2Ga? :3 23:65 by PJ¥7V". E/° 8har2;_:1a1.ba_sé:§.;%p.a.,_ f:'.h:3 'i:f;j"::z.,:f€:cé. 3;-=is::'E«§m in E">lC.§'§0.7 5 28061. ziilcéeg:
S€{':t:ie:}r"s 4-GE (>5 1i§:€:VVC<}<i:2 <';;£f'{3bj:4§1<:1_i:':§::§ ?"£'{}<3fi?{'§L1E"€f, pra§;§:}.;g; is: Sfii. as--;§id€ ':.h€.}:1::€gm€;':i'. :::a<;%£= in S.i§'i,N<:z.Z7f2QG5 9:": iihsié fiifif 3%"
E'V23;.$i,'"'-§.'r;§{fi<; C:»é'uri;'.~A7xf .223 Guibaggzgfi amt: {3{}EEVi{','€_ the ;::(Ea::'a:;<:seé*{§ fag' 'me {}fi~E§§%;'.&VVL?;Z1{§f::f'?f_:'§§§:{3"s§;§{éE§.v ft:i{}?" 95} E? Q ?l;AS§~E'?.Cf3 '£.§*13¢s-=;§%1= izw {EE:S%3'.$ am-:3 fi§:"e{:=';;s;2{§ EE.§.§Ei§i'1Si, ifiiéfif zmzi sszmae '7'[_;'::{§g:§::'m3z2E.§ \':£%'{%5' E2é:v:::= %':€'§E'iI"'{§ <:(;;'z::n<}:'2 22:";;;f:,:23':€::T:.és; 22:':{.§ §>2*<><':€:€:{§§::':g;: €45} , .;:§;%i:<»;;§:_2.s2?;g%' {}f§:I""'£.l§'E§?féis{f ?.':.r;:} r,22%;5~:a%-s:a %:«:J '%.h.i.:a {'.{"3§'£"::':E{':IE }*'§,§{"§j::{§"iZ{?E*§§' 3, Tiifi' C.f£1SE'. <3? ihi? p§"i'}Sfi'.{7ii§.,.i.€}£} i5; ihaé {Em 21:r.::::s5€,e:E h2::i'»TiEi~2¥iI1 ziigziizzsi P'.':2E? 1 ,/'ihef: §::§u:"e;%=::§. an {.118 g;:'»::»L1:':€i "aim: §3},'27s;' E Of {he e::;:::::§z$€{i¢ it is sft.;:1';€d £323: 911 i2,4,2{"}G5 zii. Ei%Jif}Z§7{I:VA'§§~,3Q' Em: £:<>mpEain21§1:.fSu}<%1':13.:':jPWIi «z§J'§.i;§"1 5' .E3}'Jv' T ZfSha.remabe"-mappa and §3'fEAz" 2 / I'«.:'£21EEVi§§21rj:£:":__ a£»*i:_::e 116.3; mes, at Gilibéifgéix Théi 23.{TCL1S«f:'d jawed i.}:1€£.'§"}.. '€~.1bE?{§ eismcézi'i§f£§::Ii;E,($Vfsraviés #3. cup af tea. 'E.'%'2§ zzcztzssstéd £::3§;k s3&p'§*i§4s:* §<%€§::~.E d:*in1¥:};~ 'ax:-*}3e;'€21s FREE? 1: ;' €:0E.'I1p}8.i3'13.2"i'{, and P."\?s§ §fiI'1}"ti§f{':C§/S7f§Ei:;"211';§§}é:SE§;}}§)E3. had Rea. 'Whfle retumingfi, the a£?{%:;:%ee:I%Q<;>w:%_:':1€ is §;h¥»:-:'*E:«:::~z.:f=:1A's;'i'.a_V_1r;.gE' é,«r::;« aénsaver :2;=:?c;:_:'re'$ {'3E'§L RW Ifinjured '--«i_ir:f;e». the a<:cu:se::(i aszsauéied P.W 3%. GI} h.;:€1?ei.._g'§§;E1'g ggée "'c¥?f""*»:%§1e:é§i;'fright. siéifi {if 21bd0me:1 with Ja.m%3j;a E3.i1§.v7ij&1"§,";Sf:-"5. E§é§i'::§i.i;:;§ 'i§g§é,}*a"3--":Ec:?:sv";'. P.W "E iiried is Sgettztzpcé and mm ?;0wa:°dS Sy::":.{%£'<;:V.2z£€;. E3-am«;';" 'é3§;i.i'=._::}ié a<te:tuss%(i ifhéifififi him. Due £0 injmsiag Su;Si.;:i§;':€C§ by E?V{\3:?" L 7I"1éE: ié:}E,i21pS€{£ 216211;' Sy.z1e:i§.<:a€,€é Biéflk, The ifiztiéérzzi. a2s:i:3;;?~; . avii4né;§.<;%'é§é£i by EKW E.3_f4E'§EI§%3'ET&E§,'ET1 zmé E"1'€%f 2;§:z.:::;§§g;:::;gm'._':":::e ._§2".;=<:*i{'§€*ir':E' <>{'{:::::'me:§ §}€:'{',i&='€;*:é?§'} 8.30 ;:> 22': mag? {,2 :21. 83:': E;?§<3 zi:*:£'»:§':'--§:1%::i'.i<}:: §§§i="€:'E,": by {KW E 3.; §i}:"{::E,h<-_*;1' Q? £.3":j'u:"e3£§/P.'=¢7*§" 2 a-*§;?::--, E3';-E? ;'i§'fS'§1'§;3.§:"{7r"1::i Eiiifi §2:E}1¢'-er £15 §}.'=§%! 2 gmté §3.'x3'§ Efgfgerii S§1z2,fié.;::i{i§:?: ""<§%::':;-:§;§" €;{:»_iE'::3 ":i«*,=-gé{>§': and £3? §'I§EE§'§'1 1.53%: ';1:i7: §§Ek§i.3§"é:"?{§ as Cv:.";~'%J€3E"§'§§E1€':'£E.'?z. "«.§*%Z::s«;;§§§::;VE_._::§:; {E:.:§E3:?;:";;"z": §:':>:* €;if€;'f2'i'§'ii"§1iZ%§E§., fsizm. §.§":s3':"t*: Em as,»-2,-252% &3E<1.§§E.a2%{§ E15: Yasheziha H«::»S;}it.aE at E:£yd:%:'z';1':":2i{1 5:131" Eliggizer i.:':;éat.mm'1é. PR3? £1 Ieszigétci 2-2 ixmzpiaim 21$ §3{=.%2* Ex. E3 11:. "I'%::: P'<:=ii<f€ f"{;'fgE:'~,§-'E'€?3'E':+:i a c%aSe3 zagaiilzgi. the 2i{*.{Tiu:'5€C§, L1:1{".i€;%I§" E-*5m:Ei<>:': 30? :3? E E") C. "file 23i{f=:'f.:{'.i'i-?§;?'{§ 'W213 armgifid an 3394,2005 zmii he 1:921:33 exalzirggeai {rm baii e:}:f_:-"E. f£'.f2:'G'i,_'}-Efi, 'Q*«'a;:fi.'i.r:~:* the i.nv6si.igai'.i0:1 xvag cmsz", Iihé-3; Ir12*:%5;i.ig;21t.§:;gg tC}{i.§.<:zjé*"£z'1ésfi'_'«:fi%:'.z1rg:3 s::v},1.é::'%:t against" the acctuszed §}::::r° aha? <>ff"€;'1<:e. :.m,d:%'»:f Sei:':":;.i.@;1 '$0'? 55 ¥ ':1f§.'h{3 2u;:<:L1se{i was ct-m:1mi't€,e2{i to trizii ?;?€f1r__>re: t.h4:_ E-3es;;.si1:3V:*:éi.;v£f,§}'L1€i3§,, 'E'§_1g.¢z 21510233626 gfleexded nei gufliy and <?Ea§n:%§¥é 1.e.x%3e% é:7'i1<::%i.' wig} Cam'? fm.m.€d crharge a§.§ai:1si: me: :::t_2:§%;§s:%d_ L1§:vfT§;€'f£'~«._i:§}§%i'f%,i{}§'§ 38?' :3! I E3 C. In gagggeyi, Of {he 93% £1»?p:":>se{:::_£;Vi§§:a,V "gg§:<*;'<'V%;:%§»f<;;e¥.;sj':'1§.:"m€§ as :11:2m.y as E4 'W§{,I1E3SS€S and iii} *E{r?t{i::E',.>;£sL.:?"2. {cf} E' 5:?' g':-sad Mai:e'::"£z1E Q§3§e<;:E1i0':2s E to 331 I}u:'1§.::zf;_§,"i:h§:v.':»:'2i":::::f{:::§s~<:§§§:*1:':':.'i:;1.z':'£,i:31': Gf §;}_,'W:;-;.<3_r and 3, {I36 §Bf€3E"1Cf;' has "?[}%Q3.r::<§_ 31%. ,sT':f?;.~:=::r ?i.7E:e- eviderzcre af prG3ec::;'f;.i(31"1 iX.?E1§'(':.{%f1é:i§;%;:f§ffte%§A;~.v§'EE§:%¥3fi'1€'§EE 95" me £;'£{'.{,'.§.iE%€€§ 1..mde:r Si-3=::::§<m five? {%zé§;3«.zi§:§:{:r€%€é{i. '§"'§1€~ ae;%<::;s;e<.i Ezag c:£€3:3§£-(3 21%} i,.h.s3 inC:.'§1:}E.;5:2zi§;:g;€I:=.:€a2;i1§%§¢£z:'1<:::;5; 2:p§:>[email protected].*;n;_,_§ in §é';<% a=%i;i<:§e:1:%<: 4:25 pr<>s-;%3c::§,'i:";r2 L» 'i»'J§"'i.£1«ifé=3és~%'§§3L'~.~'f§%§':€ 2%'a?:.::é;;;:s:é:§ Emg rm?" E":d€§E,:{,'.€'ttIi 21:2}-Y c:Ee.§1:;%;':i%{:> é;%v§ds:§1<té%. "E7136 5 i:'fiy--§ Cezmfig ""Ei.f§1.€3$' §.'}.€?2?z§".§fi§;»f a;:.z§_;»§m:'1€:'1'%.s;, pé:i*E"i.E$E=§'§;§;§ E218 (32253 zznii _3cVii;=<:7:'?t;;r;r:a"::'¢=.';2?;:°;-E" é?:=:%t§a%:2{:s:% {(23.1 r€;%m;*{L {rams-:: ii} :3. e:i:0:1<:Z1.:gi:s:': mzagi: me ;3;_"i?A5?9¥3:é"z.1;E..§'€'}'1'§ faiiéfzi :15} '§r>':*£:':§;'f %:€;r:":s: Q35: 'gguééié: :0 gm»: ;§§i.(7€f,*E£§5:i'E{§ £21}? §:%:<>. V {>§'%1i;%%":«:'%&" S€<'f':'i{>:'i iii}? <2? E 3:7' {E zzmi "£",§"§.~£}§'::i*§¥i§;%"{-? 3'"<"%e"%m"{.%,e::%:.§ :;s_:".; {}E'{§i'%3" <33' E § §
5./w.\' (3 acqm'*£:1,aL Tizis Es; c7:§":21§§§:>:r}.gge€i by 2111:? SE.ai'€% €13 'w'{--:E§ as: {Em i:"g§u1'@€§ ~ E3 W E. ,3' Shara': :1s§b2a:'~3a.pp21.
4* L:::*a.r:";&d fxddé. PuF::1i{: Pr<§s%e(:u£:m" SE1;-'€}Z'£_1::i3'§«3 _'§~';«'£-"5
2 ,/ E'eTa§1ik21rju.;;1 is friesxzci af PEEK-" E 21I1€.'§ 21:1» ::3:t%..X%§"if;V:é£::3§ E'{}'-.§':i§€"fTV"~i.;'1C'iV:i"3'{1i,. ' P,W 3/Syed $h.EifiLECi{§i§3; ;°§:a=::h<:*.€i égmi, §z:§ft:§% r-- r:3c:£§;.i£i*.§ of the iH€',§fi€3'£1§ ihmzzgh PW .§.1fSL;i§§f§3%§'; 'E73. "§~g}'?*;§V#%'/&"VVE3;:5xs'sa1.'z V*;:;";;"a#VVis pzmch witnesg £113}: s€::£.:»:uz'€:: of C} f\§':§';E3~j_:L}a1§:':V5E3H);f_a§ :§:{:j§£§'v"»vE:e~§A§;>€3<:i ciosih%:es {sf ibis: :T:':j:,u'ed. 'E'h€j; have? §tI1E'Hf3€§ 'P,'W'.§3, E8 and E3, the Meaigtak ®ffi{)s5j~¥ig'_§ z1aiure3 0? :'nju2'ie3 $uSiair:€d éifid 's..Ei§§ '::§3§° P'i7i?i~1i.E1€ Enjzzrsrj. It is .3E;::2t.ed mat Enid {?0E'I1€ :9 {ha Cum"? :0 gii-"E e"a;'ic§er:{: é*';_&?; ;t1%e '§E'2r€:£.%':': to .E3,W.4»,fS§":21n'§',u and b:*a'z:E':er {sf Eiifiz' _;%.m§ 2: corixpiaini k----Vz';?;,€~3 mdgésrd with the P§;vE.i.:;:ex E""§*f:"'.%'3Z;;{g"f€3'f, "£§"'£f€E €.ré;%i'«£i_Q_:::v*t' €38;E1C§€fi€{i 1,225? baii gm 5I§*'.QGG6,. The 2E{3{'L?,_;V1S{f§Vfiiéfiigiv§Z%€1'i§ i;5i':»::_i,.i.§E<}':: zmcfi ms: same {f§i'I§'§€if {.0 b6 :'e§ez::.c%c§. 'E"h;.u5, size: £i{3{Z.~*»,;Sé'i€§ V$'2'?a:.?s.V.V'ki--{iiq.%§iVi2.E%%€.{){§}»' {ram} 6.'?m28G{*% EEEE ihe {i:;:';,é:é sf ju<:ig§mc=r::.%'. *1_§&.;-- E£§a3¢2f's\'Zée:"}",?9,& Eé is :::Es;<> s¢,»mb:':;i:;£,:::a§ i:h:«;a:, .§{"z«"%f E L zxzha §£}{§§§€i'€§ a
4. _;E{';':'zig;§a*£n';.,' Wgééé <:xa.:'i::E::e=§§ fig": 25f'f,2€}€36., he-is :'-:;':4z;};3:2:"E;%{% {he £23188 9:"
g"2:'{}$j:_*<:":;2E";%:'{>:';; E322: 2211. :1E:€ ;'<::{§:,:<;%.§5'%. 5}? PFEJ E 2.; {7:*:'::zs~.z§a-=;--a:-2:rg:m§;'2azéan a? E}, W 2 'f; 'a}€'E%;f%;"'{§€:'f§i%3'ET"§'{?{§. 53;': :2. §:2.2E{}{%§:%, *s;}:%::5§': .§?',1?J E E. E?2:';&',§fé% ~:'T-.:"::2sea;*es~2%x'21::'2:i3':a%::§ E3}-* % 1 \ \.
--J t:he Cmzzxgel fcgzr' thié ;::<'?{7u:~2<3{§, E1:-3 §':a:'~s ::iep<>s.-2ae3{:i i,Em"£. he ggjzwe the:
('.';{3I'£1§}i€iiIi§'¥Z v.>hé:;1.1 ha? was; Lm{i€;%:° ihti i.11fE:.:€:';{te :13?" :;%..E:;.:0hs:)§ 2z:1§,§..VE_*z';3_A{ii_ci EEGE knew "§s.--'h{} 21:-35;;3.uEi.ed w'%1{;m. §3é.:E,. Ehéi w:'i',:'1s%:ass wa:'~;;_.§§2<'3'?; " :1vss h<>:"-si,:fie:*. as i;;h.s& €<}m:'i wzizuid 2:;:~pr€(:i22J;€--: the ::%<:ic§§%;i;--{?«£~:..:'z:.ii "i?§%f"--EA L Bvidfifiiifi. plziceii on :'e{:{:z:*ci by the §31"<>se:§g1i.§{:>3.'1. s3:;i"f":;.;§i€-:*:éj=i%@_'_<7:a§:':vi€:*;. ' thrii €1C{3ZZS%€d unészr S<:>:{:'i.§=::sr1 30'? Q? IFS' V'"i'Ti:::<ir:" E€ar:'~:£%dVA Figbééig: ?;ras€CuE0z° Subn'1:£ES %ha£. {he in1p'z,:gr1é%i,0 rde;" :112é.'y ?I'}Af3'?"i"€?'«.:"€v';§.'&'s€E€§K 5, 'Fhe C{)I1tf3'£'£EiO}:"£ {sf '£1116 1e21é'r:ed.§ 'C<%L1;:'s:€%i':'2;;°__E.§3€ agtatzzsed 2355 that P, W E. E has 226%: ;<5*éa§i~<:{i§'phi8*_:::<"{;:1-;S5<3:=:'a.:::i--:ii2;'£i_::::5: as-3 f;'.<:2 wha zassszzzzéiiéd sgivezig "M1611 he xxsais ?.E'i'£d€¥§' $336 Wham anti Ehai éfhzst _,.i:s:?;1fEi§é§2:ifi§*f};*:,2i'ss~..L §I1fiE,E€1'3.Cf3 {sf .::;E{E{3fl?10§_é:i;1:i §"§"3:€I"€f{;=3"£é' £13253 éx}*'iV{i§:::1c:% 0%' E3796} § {'.if :19 z::v'ai.Z. is {he €3.86 {ifgarage£::.:.f;§{:>:'1'}"~.E-§.:2._;i%£sG' s,:bmi'z,ss iézafé. E3W' E} and §"Q%"2 are friemig sf PWL zhsfzy "Eur-%1e'c:fL-- "L}1.0:3'iiie E0 §;r:}s<:%{:u§..§.{>;2 ;21r;«:§ £.h<e am; €§:»:_:.:ii; :}r:_";i»r<:{g3<?:z' ;:i§p§:a=:§'{"§g;f€'in«:; a}f'e;3<:icie:1{?ee 3122.59 :*€<':{}rd§":d an <}:"::Eer 9? as "s;3_i*:',':§1EV:3,§1{E €h€:1:i€=,'" :29 rfaaii zggramzd ii}? 2'.i'E'§,{%§"f€fT§Z'i '3" v«;'§%i.%: $16 .. 7 _ AV . 3:1':
in':§}':.'z§'n€§§ ';a~@i€f§§ZV.§"£'E.';';'f§°.§?i.,A.,:'§'"§€::' _§§:"a§;:-3 :.E"2ai': bsiiz i.§':{;: <7.i3;5&a€:$ 'vi-:é:.€ iéée £:g}§>s?2:E '7 §E.E.e<i'V *§§»* Efihegfi E'-::§g;§é% Eiiid E::F'§§'§"iiI1E'i§; §%<:~2z'§:'~,;§m'3 E%t1:iié.<3:': §Eii§{":{§ £23? £326 , ::.;;r;~:§;v:;;::;;z;;:. EEEEEEJ Em ::iz'.$§:':§:§s;:%{,i;
5 I irz "\._h M s_=;p::§%;. a_i:'im' r€cei.vi.r1gg ini1:}3"r2'12-":i:..£0:'1 abimi. H16: i:"2.ci<:ie:1t4 iihmugh E3 W iii. §31W'4 £55 aha b:*«:}ih:.-.*;: of? W 1, P W 5fE§§*:;"i:3;3zm't.E%1 film umsrie sf P W" E? wha cams: :0 {he :a;;;:2<::I'. af¥;.er £'E?{"1€iViE1§_§ i:1§{:rzI221§':i<iy:é-.._:.1';:"<}'ug.h P.W 3 zmd actciirrzparziéeszi ihe: §:":gu:c*e::£ £0 '£:.E2r;t E-"I<}s§>:i.?:.21§., "'3. 2"1E,"€ pariah w§.'{:1ess3€s" P W 9 31:2; tin: §3()Ii€:e {:"(}.{§5.§E£}.E}E§3s v_.'§3'c',: acgtxzsed zmci apprehe;:1c;§c?d and pr{>:iz:{:<3:cE.A_§':é::=2-T n{}=.i'.1"E3,'é1;20*3S';..__P"*§§5 M . is the canwizainant. P 1%? :6 is iihe' i,r;1jure::CE in the Q{3V€§"I"11'§'1€'ii3i E-iospiizzzi.' 4§é.A%?9' $3 wh.:3 treaieé ihr: in} Lzreé in izhe P' W 1:: is Ehéf E><:>Ei€:{-3 §.:'1sp:%::'§<3r, v:ViE'::;3 'z*e€§§:' $§.r;:*':";::§i fiiezfi ziharga sheet. agaiimz. $13 23.{:€:L1s@£§;;' 4i'§1.2._i,' of iheiséiid 'i;'~.:§V'£j[1£{€::a:5e:2;.<sx P,W$';?;,3 emzti 4 have :.u.z"'n«3::% h0S§i:i'}éM3fi.§ 'H"1'je_:H:*é i.s rm impséiiznem is base atenviciimz S£?Lf§z?ji}; Q3': gs? 'E3 W "E /Sha;"21nabas~3apg321 if his tesi.1?mG;'1y 3#;:f::%.;>"€s2va.?r:Eg;a'v._ g§:~3féi"~.:¥'§aii;%§31:%' in me izlséanti saga E' W is 'E"AfV§'é%'1:5_...@§° P W E2 §<;cige:§ 2: ::e:}mpEai.m. agaémsgi {ha a{::<i1;,3,S<':(,§.' " --V.Z?§::'v.__V§?22:»s-. '"Eé;--:_E§.§-" $'m.p§><::§"Eé.*.{i {his «:?as.~;e {if :;}§°{)SEi€iii"E.i03'1 in '.Aféizsxgéi:i27_€:i{:':i--i%:¥{!:.§é;;§_%é§;'V §'5u'£., wEm:'2 EW .2 {'::°0::%$--£%:«;.::z1'2i:}€:fi aiies' <3?' §§2:$§§:%i:%;$, §:1e;=: Ems iiepasiiéi in 1?}? =i.',Ii'{}S§:§~€§i3H§?§§T?;£,'i§i.€}E": fixai &<%<%§::;3};>:§;::i. w'§*":€:': §E€-3 wass; urzgim" E,E1€:? i:":fEué2:3{:&% {}.{;1E<::;h<}1 ami .§j_;e:§--E§""§'%%§:, §§.::{2zz* R-'§"§{?1 ;::::-T:»s;;1:z:E.s::€é<§ w§;{;:':1. in E":£5~; exam:§§§;:'£.§:}§:--§n~:7:?';§aE", Ezeé-.V§2éi.%§ i:i§s:3§":é,é{i&(§ éééa-'t E::';:;{>{i :»is'%::Is.sZ:1s":{§ ::Ee:}?Z."§'1é:2~; 0? i,E'm .§:':jz::"&é{§ amfi M S, 3 , i J;~:'e:~;_ec_:¥__::;,;~ aw fijdexmbyzi. \X£"i1j}'E which ihe a:*:«:?u5@d as$21:.:iE.<:%<;§ P W' 1 1 {I16 i:I1j'L'1r<3C'L grmm (gm ggzjgiegzgjfi gt' ;>>xm_, ii. is {::"j._rs;t:aZ :':iea:* §'l'1é3.'{ he E':as""de;}c)s:«:6<% fa}:-a€I*:G9<:§ zmd ii W213 fa €::2:s:3€3 Uf p<:=1j;7*;::"j.g-".
:1. Naxv, we §3r:3c:;'-€:d if} ztfisaéuag abcmt. €39 r:1<;*;i*i.:5+:%. '2f'E:éj"§?r1;i$'z--:%.v<3.b atiributefi by the accusee:I :13 {ha fghést }?>'Vsf_:.1,:s's¢(1 1:7,! :§§ss:.€r iii" » _ {he 5-3.C{E?d8€i'd, ?§"he d€f€11<?§: $1215; HOE ;)12x{te§4'21:';.fgffiéziierélzii '£9 why 9 E13' 1 §fSL:i5:112a1'1 Shiléifld §{)':iTV_§,.§§1c;°-.3": §'21§Sa*'V§é<}§:;p'§§fizA;.§.'v;:_g.:§zzi%:&3iV€;i3:{§"
accuaseé' P 17%' 3 had s:;2s;ia:i:1€fd four V_i_1;ufL$%V;"}§r?~s:.;é.4f:."-'E.,_j52<:%:.f§":dé_:;%:":dw ?he W'£3;S :10:
in a §>a$i?;i.m1 is talk. E3 11? 1' .}§§§:'é';?fig;%.§:§Ss€«fg:i ihe initident, hag; iaciged {ha cmiipiaini. AF?' W 1 Av;:2.vE%_ 25% iii'i}é§%;£;é';-'éameysé, HG-S§}i'EaI at Guibarga aI:':dY"' "£h:*{"lj:f'ii'E;1':§§'E:i§:;i'£"" "z;r,i miiié&"*'~é:{§ 'z';-2.s~;.'£':a0€§h21 E--iegpiiai as E-Eyderabaé {€126 iriiggizrésg':,§§*:;?§i§'L:':f:€é'i:fi_;"whétre hf: was i.r&z2i.€£E E33.-* P W IE3. Later an, s¥';at.;e:31'E€33é;.v €353" §3". ":2'9.--7 I'€(f<i)1'{it'5d by the Pfiice. 'E"'E"z<: {:G§1i€nTii{3n; 'C-;§'_ ?t.§:5 §§3;::'r1é,d C<3¥_.z£3";s=.:<:%§ i}:>2" {he sieil"-::§":C€ ihai éiiy-'Z§d€3?:7§{'iff GE"
i?i??' fa .._:§'i«'.§_E. ss1:§§>s;;--:fi%';€d {ha {',E3;:'-R3: Q? pr<§s--3:3<:u€',.i<2§: c.2m.::ai be 2ifi{:.§;}'"i'i€i€§;' _'$31 v{§T'1€',%E§'{}§§S~i%X23.I"§"iii1.E'i§'§{}§3. E3 W LL £38 33213 éfisiziiiiiéid ihéf 'ya-'€a§3é£2. V'1i.'é.S§f:f{§ §'f;§"'v.'?§E"§¥3,:.{§€}E';¥"EE¥E§SS'i{}E"i GE <::s£f§%3E":<7€:é amgi Ehe '§§{}:>{E §i,a_§::€-,d V€§%.:€;E":<-:29; @'§74._£;.E:a%_v'§:;jju.é.'<2:d E} 'ii?' '3. '°E?:e: deikéncéz E1215; 11:34:. §§r'{:cE:2<:<;':{i zzzajm' «ft;-s'2féié<s:::i:;:";s3 22%?' {t<§'mz2<§§:::£:§{;ns 53$ 35 ':9 :§§:e;E3c%§§s::2---<:;'~: E335: {':E'§E='€33 9? <1 i 'V§;'§E%{.:§$%{?-§w;§.E:r§L€.;'E,}3. Er; gm' ?'§§%1i»-', 'Sim ::%z:i{E€:':":{:<*: :33? E' %,-7i-'' :::e:";m;'35:%::E wééifg €i¥if§.iE'EZ{'Zi."":
f, :,s,\R E3" This;« :55 {the {age of me? yé?az° :2§O5¢ 'fie 21:6: in tin: y:*;11* 281 I, 3*}/18 Eirizzi Cc:-;:..:1"i. :'@<:%o'r«:i:=2; :*<3'e;e21E that, fizz: alercfussed was zirzeatezi an §3¢f?g.,2§05 and szaiaxrgézi am éaii 9:1 §.'?.5.2iZ?GEZ E-&g.;a:*m €136 S.'Zf£YE.ES€3C3 W233 £1£'§'€;%S§€C§ dzzrixzgj iizsr pfiiidfiiiify 9:" the Trizzi <31': {hrs §.',§.r«:fs1;=;§:, C1*' he:
gaxre ?;hre21€. ta aha u.-*i'z.m%,~:~:s:~:i::'n<*s mzd Vi.OI2'ii€3€§ the c<>miiiii.:r3:--; ézjé". ba..i..i" smci '{.h€::"e.f{;re E125: wasa t.a}<:en '£9 iiussmdy on 8.'??L2{}05i:§« ;'_:'H f€_Ci ;*<::zj.é«>.«:'.r_;<:%v<Vi"'i":f: J31} 7 and since then he was; in <?us§0dy €321 i.'E77;<: %_:i21%;e G'f_= i,h<:='~irizp&g;19i<:=§ juégrfieaiii, W's gm: csf §;.h<> vicar that s1<~::ji§::;1;{:e 5):"i;f1*:g>.3i;Zfés_s:>:i';:f:fzé1*§it. far izhé ggeried GE' i3:§1p:'§s@m:1er1': azndmgezze aititugésd I:*;'aj,;~'Eée érzxpasesi K65 £216 £3. vigw ithai, P1's3'~f E h§,:isrQ':§u:sfi:§§aiu&{1"é_z1<t7.iS;€d Wétsund amfi the av ._ . _ . _ E}2;1=~:'z.0r: Of Gm,re::rr:memf,.E-9£:§sg3éi§:€L 'G:;;f¥;baf§§§:;:,_ha_$1réfer:'*ed "ii; Yaséizadhzi Sagas: SpeCi§¥§i':.§;' ' E1E' '}T:§'Ei€31"駧2i§V far '£'.r{;*a§.r1:1€ni.a W6 award <:0m§€a»:1$ai§{>§§;. '€}§v"%4§{}§§:€V?i:.\i}"':7' 14' in "£326 ré':;3uE*; 335;: 13124.;-55~s=V,a'*~;}V1.e i'<>31§{3w'i§1g mséézrz .°-.C'riV::1§fi:é:.E:;'§§};)e2>{i N{§V;§ '§A22 ,3 288'? zmzi CE"§§E'i§§7:£§ 'E~€€:v§53§{):: Pe~§§'£'.iG§": Na.'?'§;;:{?2S€)'?_ a.;f:=:~ £§;,§EE1Fi?e-"'{':C§ 2131:? Effitae §m;i3ug§:<"ie{E _§::{§gm€::':€. s:'Ea.':'.€d L'-~3§:'i.%.;'3a.2§~%'C3'?.%'f'_' VI'EEa€§?'.:'f S.C.?%E«::.'?;'2GG6 3:22 23°15: flit {E5 '§%"'afs*:L ",.'2'a:;?é<; C<:::,;.:'i3%f _ 4;G'2;2Eharg;fa," is A 536? a_é::§£§a=%._ \..\*g gar ".i."he: f€?$3§}£§E'1{iéf§Ei.f€i{?C*a:S{'fiZ1 is «::{311vi.:?.i.<::{i jéiér Cm": 0f§.'e:':<ts;% :m<:1@:* S€3::*;.i<>3": 3214- {sf E 33' C ;{m»:.§ .:=§e3.~n.'§..t3§?;<::3t=:i for {he pm°i{.}d <1}? Emp1fiis<>::,%1=1§:rn'€ ah":-:a{i§; L:':1:i::t:'§jg<}§':z: bf; 'iE'1€: 5"s{',(f{iS:§f;':{§ 2-mii §:":';§3£::5::* {Erie {sf ?5Qj,.{3?i'%Q'g'--{;,%;:";. giefazzéé: in pz~1:;':11e:1i. <3?' §'i'mt, 131%: a:;n::z..':ss<:{i s;%:21iE Lm<:Eé::j§g:3 '=$iii:i"§:>§;€:1 1:z:§:ri$<)§1.mem. it}? 51:; :1':<3:'1'th$.
sagms Shali be paid to P.'§x?1 21:»: <:<m2;}e.ns21i.i{>:£1__ 538 if 'she: fine. :.5:'m.<:>"s;.i:;":'£.,'_ r;:i%{}§~%i_:'z'é(.é;~.:'i.11é~.,