Karnataka High Court
Vinay Kumar S S/O A V Shivakumar vs Kunjanna Gowda S/O Lingappa Gowda on 18 September, 2008
Bench: Deepak Verma, B. Sreenivase Gowda
-.m...m.,_.. »
q""§;?!
ism ".a§_<:>g1 &m»'s:<';>:~; n\;E.£ i__i:£;.Lf££Z"_'>}'&id S/W 'Q-~-W: Eivzifmi
%'cid"v'£j>NE'1'V-E'}'E¥'}x£ ">1: 151$ "*£3""H §:i:::x:{ _:T'_:.£'*w' 'E."~.E"d W; , "
i%;L:x{:i3:_<3':s::::%(§:£;%:é3?2:i 'E °~ir%.E%§iI"fJ"ET'%v"EI>N'%2'"%%'{..___ '» ' "
'aL:s'.>@fM« mé; % % %
{fix-2'e:;;>:»;¥ §'~£§ffr§.%§'.7"}e'\Z ';§'i.>.';.%1m';i.' * %
Xifimziwflkfl) '}'i1i'§§{";;'=?'I_ i--:;:§§.:;' EEE ._ _ '
:a::i}L,=~3:s:_i<':; :~m:§_::~:'§;f\1aij3. A. '
"(E2391'(1T::f)C£{:"f)[?~J'%ffi§1$;;§§§'§~»fI\;?f\{iT}'f',.§§,'v"'1E'~§V
221;;-£{3I3g":<m:*v; 12%-LL " ~ "fig;
{am « m';;;:--":t:;s~:' iEig%¥:§}*?Z_§f{:f}'.E~éiV%3j
51_:*1**:'m;A i:.*:%j.f%fi~-.i'vz~$x:%,s1':§'<;:
k:i.d%§€:.}{V§, ?rjj(1':{;'"2{Ei\§VE?\'£ 'S*§§?'.Z:'§:i€'fiE"?'§';§:;C}'.?§{;§f§ 'W
_
'k:?cicWN'¥-E'E;E2§:5:?f3:"§§'<F"g%'§:-if :;Tj'}/ M 3;s£:*e':2%:%%%.«2w:*'* 0
<;_ M %"%7.;L_§Ti_v€;f:$§V":%¢§§:'%9I_{iT§§?"E\f§7}§*~§'v'E1i
""" . _ j 1: " '"§I£'1?".i'wsf;.L §'¥,'"FE"sa"§~5£'\i'i'~I'€f&f§.§Ci
.%:;$s::<:'>(%¥ .3::;s=:<':§;:&Ji"%:*§rx:_%%_'i;>*>§ :"agi.'%m,c%>.2a. 1'" W 3&1
' ' ar:};"Wv
'€£;{c?{':x'E3-E-:'f)VE£\f:*§Ti'>€£E'--{C} :;:;> /"is
* _ {.W;;»§'xa':*.:1»-:i&;m":>wwv2:3: ms; -:2
" '~%:;::zi; - E;{{rii73"E'if{f} MW~<:'
A _ _ a:':2"'v<;}a mLvwV"Iva_
T " v*.;«;::e31:j};i,:'i'>¢§iss: (L:j§§~éT'1zX's=§%§';f 'c£i'.c¥:€f') '§;t<»*{>;a$ "gm
i%Ei)_%xEVZ>r1f"}f£~§N'I"WNf;1>§.'L'v"N
* iai:s;££>vMvw' iii}-igf, E3'
E: A ':e;;a{'>*1jv::>%W'w
TEVQ '.i"%-f'H"lf)'}§
'€7i';i;'1 :T}&"';i} W W
:»sm;'L:f}:e12a;ii1<i: {§=.f~EE-£'3¥fN.'V¥-A1 i§§HgE.- 3.
?i£.]'N"v"
{'.i\.('LEX? 'F{f£.{\€':.€f';>*tZfL' 'v::»§::;zz\3::'a;§_;:':::x2% 512%: A9') 5 Q
§§§.f;i\Ef'J"'l§",i.f".%§sc>Ec*,§"'9" ;§,<5;.:<;:x ":'v':+::":::§ :§§'2~>:<'>f"§\£:"3.%g;%ar§?«€ =
§§{71'3's;flh ,.xi'_:"HEM"vm:sm':;;:.g;1: %
ms::w-a :3}2z£:s:§.{:1):;i{<:"f%:i:mr;;a::z%'
'.»§f'"f'TI V?~'iEf?:iVMlL§}::{ <::/3: ::;:é;1£v"#:§*§'-V =
wg;§\s.y<:i:%§f%ar§»%L; 1%: <::::
%§VI~--i{3:.:3£\e'j.E;:'§§ J, .§.2,%i'*;~"45 L ':5:
':f<:i6}'_'i?"'§fi§ :%sI.":f?:>1:&'_,__i:'€ ji;:":;;'
s~-i'§:i§:'F<'§ C'.{:}§',fi PK? ' f3;':§§E§ "E93
_. - i.":~:~_:¢':i$*€::§fi"'i:»:>%"':':émv
% % "*xf'¢-iTg;€.'W--%1T§ji¢*"iWELL'.-§N mm
5. 'viz2%a:::rs21.z:*}'sxw%;'}.;;I :.mz~::;: *3
I:::.§;::v
' JE%{;:c}§"W'::.'&{;:*§;~§:;.:x:I":22%: W is; if),/5??
vmVw'wv¥~;'3. W" ms; '1
¥\7C%?EZ%1.2'?:'\'.L51 E?
met! .53 mg! m mm
'Mi}.§3;'t5*"$'sf%i:2€;£§'§k"i*iT§f) mt; ;:i.N':;iw_:a:vNv%';~-m:&§ £'I}NE'§i£§Ei?§.E%
::;:3W" :~§<:}1k1,*::$:x::§;~;%;.~§'i;«:'::;'>;%if> ::;<:">¢_a' N{_)E;Li}.};Xr1<%f w:W;L> :m.:.
m:;:gvs<;>51*1*v ;a."m::V<1 'Vki§"icHE:§¥;='2?:W'I\ZC£f"££i¥%-§ 'xzcrm QENV'
A 5'i'<_ih~':%v.".';§1%;>'%<::m:f~ '1m:':;f> 3E1'-%$,L .s%'{j) ;:"»m..r;{ tafm. N0 8661/Si?-I"
"«x:>j:s;~« ¢::m~:»; ffxiii <:::»{s;?~;s'm m:;>3:'w:» :r;._m;,v<i§ aggmwsgav
-- F. "-.<::..:s:'v ';L§~:55§11é%x-:f:<x::im"* :?1_2-LL mwzv'-53% Jgzv Aw 3151;) iflzm:
~,S'/ £1": ..'1"<:§3*';;£;si '"§Vi3§'<iEd';f ;i§§2-i'E&' Em€jff}i%§.f~§V'T}1i%i;}$Em
€31
"*%?§3;,_.
';i.'E,i}]}{I(}d$§2;;k[ .113'; '(}"E;?2=:{ 19{E'ZQ.I§3?"{§fl,Q§9$3'
'gig ..10g1 .}1'3¥;£I.{)'}{"'L §i.L§".1f;':&}".{-1 "':;::1'{.3 pm»; t7$"'*:'}.§'§§'. ._ . '4
~s;;;u:;;pz.I(:»ci{s;;;1 mg :;m;_g\§ 'gem' :3z.::::rg,}:.1oc{<s;>.1 .u;>_}'_ '":'2§j*s2:;§;*_j .
'gag "_1Ii'E3fi1Q(T£€i'E3 §}L{f§ mg §=:§>:w:.>§j_3 '£3..E§)'E,.E}}l1'r§ j' fj:§;i3 " . "
£E;7""fi?fi37s;'2{1""""'7".{1.""7"£*
:§5€..s:-gxygofi (fag?
rm: T§>a~Iaz&¥I%1> 'firv1A:'>15£AT:~>§'w_:i*:':a:i»::3f ':i?<3:f>"$i'£'i€ri;: E£'r::'.;rmmz E'€'?'"€37'i§-
gm; 1.10 fiL1§u;tc_>:> ':3§E?}';;)iT:{(f1'§;f '3+s;,1;¢{ <;:m.a}§;3;:1%eg,1:;:;:$;gps;;2>§;:;%:;.§LL
'E%é()I.i;'»?"--%:?'§£\li§'s§;i?'§fi;iv€L;'¥'«aé§'{f:A.;E,ixFi%7§Eé"\{'$£{2C§{\E\{HN'E7£
€§}i\i.E'}i5:Ii§IE§ flaw _:x$g:3T:;:;fg?ji$3.M:s§=¢w:t:>::: ;Sif;.Zi¢} ._.....Nf§.}I'.L§.L;':7£c§
}%'\EjW'i:1> 'Cr}§§~§.L sf}N11_.m§>*2--*"{v%':jg:,,%"<:J,z~;m;I ";2."*E:i;§l";;<§?§«'§'\7*'P:W£'~lS%E§'£{f}§<I
'.§iI.;;T}VE!"Q '$2 ('NEE ';~1'8)€ :;:i*."::<;:;%"w'<i:w::':§:v%rs;:~aL1.i--¢i'é;i} ;i:;'-me; :?;;£»:1;L _?:\Ti'(Z>
Ssasigm '<;>:~;: ";§}A_§!\i__ ;~;:'~§._ ._E'T!%;T)'£;;i:iz?§j}»{é%§.L\é"(i§ <:.i:'a«iV'mv
{i".};N'V .I,.A'~.E'C£1I»'\i§;}<§i"f1£"' .I§?.;3fé\£El"%f"i?)'_%' k££L}V AW. xiii} ('{}sI:g;'§
£+.';:':"1 c:;::im.:§ $5.. T%:':é1¢§.aW'» 'j;i,§::~_ET:.:§%v~J.§:.*:ia <.';}:2§T.:\ivTm:;>s:§1;A::
' ' . *i43x?«%*'-'1"~'!*
V §E%2?:_ff ;é's"s;?;¢1 ;>;mze=:::::~i IL 1;---LL:ae::s12»jd S/W '9~wa1 2>:.£<;;;>,:£
X-:'&§;=§§*'§i;:x :q1s%'iaz£>vN~. j:a£ .2. %'§€jTT):§ :":.:"-w 'm; t:-IE: .ifl}}
$.:i,1t«r:;a;[<;;i[z-f'c:i2::§_:a::sM W: - i%:E2%§{T}'"§"\é"{§}§\§\fE§{
. " * 'a;<;";<Tm;'i M;
T' % :;mf:a" szwvw um éffl 31,1
f>{CEi'EcE.W€I);i} iwxw": 1%: m
~- i"€i:§I.3Esi¢f{I'> :x{<j3§_'E§.§A}{E
m;: '€jj)'€;j} i%>E:;iI3E\E":f1>:H"'§_$i\i}; r*1v:a:m:.W
z»ma:>2zN:Vw :?,?§E"'{L£: <2;
52%;" "" H\1.J"i.ff)$ E§'?:%§(IIf}'*E'§*'§3TN'VE7i
H
smmx :,19g1s;:.;n'E} my '§§E"E(_"{ ;;¥g\; *p:;r§'0;j; :;;:.m"tzm1sg1.:.} {'@II()§".}*E7:Z'b,§
;;z:.:{.1 --- 9 "mpg 3,'EK2}§}t.l{)£"IE¥$9.E Ej..{L1§.M §I}';3,IY"%';é§';I§§ ptm gr {mm 5-wo;«x§--
T},{uI9§;3§L,£()£IEE§'é-)3 'gm hzstywg zsgm xiii; g:7z:.:mm(> ptm :,§::m3;;z*;.:> L7£EZM'.§;:'a.1".i{i},V ' "
"mg §II;fi{$.A¥~§JT;§ ::;1;;m. 'p;;x1:u§"1.:1"§ gtmrs: p*;>s.*:r;v";*;::>:;}:.«;;x§;&:-<\.:;w't';';M':;--- {fig ' g{g3,{l','§;
»~;»~m"_ jg; gt» '}Q'3'§f{'i;p'§EZ{I. ;"z7E,j'j}. 'EEC: :;;s::>%2§::'I A.'g:19§:5'g;.'i;>'§;:'.
'~3;:;>;:1T;%§t.Ig' ;{{gp<)cg e";":":uA9g..12:% ';}$:'s;_1;ms11*s ';fe::_@.§'£t*i?ej 5+:§{{:1 ;j5"e"f>'.:*s23;:g'i:,r:
x§§2u"g;\ 11$ '1I;m{1j:}<:i€:§'¥.«a :;"£A1a:;;*s;?:.zn«:iE' gfaipm <~'e;:m;§';j";::§:.§;'.;'i1_.Eazgrxg :;1_t<.i$;*;:;:z;:E
:;?mg;' ',3{<_:_:«;;:;:;:w{¢',§; 'V31 '%{',?_§-g :;,1<;)§'.;.ve:9;r.1:;j:§%:§.i .E"::;{Vg';zia:2v;§>::; S_§§%i§ gggwg
«;y\{~gj(}-g;"}§ "£334 ¥§£i7}'§"}'E¥_IT},§3{§:i1[':1 ' 3{!g§;&2:§a<:;.g 'u:;;9;m:;;:';
.:;:;)*e1§::':§ u:;;§{m 31.:1;iA?a:1',g':ufi:;'§;3;iii3§%__ §)1i'¥3e:§;£x;i'c:a'§_§}11_i~--;;1M;;::' go ::.':_.m.<):}::>'e-3
:10 19:41 2412:1011 ,i'::.m (31? "3;:é'L_£r;:3_AV;;;;:V:[):3:;§:i~x:;;g;: :;L§.:0;; s§2£.§' 17;;
"fi'§:3:xE"*ia:>at»<?£sm 85€'f«:;«~;":~.4-_v1 % 3&3 'E 'SZEL 'am 'gm 'mm
:E:u}s;'e';}..--,»1;a; 'pm: £33'?-E A"'i;};~g.....;_;$:';=3«;j; Aw mg; '.11'ae:*%'"g.s;r2,,::::I.1;::'{('>}g
'§Hui'1q;,gL V' " ' "_1i;£:§~§'3§i:l)';3§g" N:c>1(>_§;q xiq ;j>;:£»;.s&?cE
.3:'é;'f,';"g;i;_f»-g;« *;1{_*,:: 'g;:+§£wg§"Ea' 7 jt;}c'§"{x::I1€:;) ;:;r;§§j gs} tmw agw;-2 $1'E:a<1s:£¥3
:1 E279 "~s::{};:>2?:Vf<;2<:s:1'<>zx1 Vega: 9% '2?:<;>{:»3t/wg.:2:§'€>N
45%'; . S§(=i§€'i)Z7/{€;?%ET';'<79_f'$ '\.%1:'{Iz'%§ aim: '€~?iT%€i}£f?/*E?'3§f{'<">{'~«E
;;'¥--;s0eii$:'g3 {..L§;;}A{}3 g{§31;;§; .fi;%§7}..I.(11 s;g*z_.§'g'1 'gi
:33
..-.»s
'''*''~_.
2313;; file r{';§fg1;::gHg'g pm? 'p;?gf'§"<::;} '£3-J'£f)[E'¥}".E'{"ESE',1§ {%;'3I..I(}§'.'§'E7§_N 'firaz an
2§I}?..1"(<?.E..§'1'.§UE f§)Y.Ifl3'S' Z».lJE_}"l§ 'g,3Zw3xI1'"'i':'-'»'{..'{f". €§}£iE§;'&t*g §.)E.H:3' 1l}f;_€;)€".{'E%?
{..}.""§'€§LI2=)E,{ ;;};:au:}§t:;t.mu1 mica :M:';A;..::;3 :m§3:;}:9de::;.Mr :.:..;t._n xiq :;:;.A'g.T;§§§: L-
p%:::?§2 p3tC{;'.A0 amm $;:1:§:m{;m ;r{,;"1 IJ{f§€i}€7§ ';;m1g'.; gm 3;2:';mi:i :m:;ss§;xi7;%Ej.:+;&.E
;::e'Q:;_ ya 11mg'; am :;m>_3_::::;g §};2¥},E'iET{':§§§;} E'..}".;.§2)('§ V;:)1{§§;13a§_ ;§ iv '1
%::>%3 =:%? '
g;'z;9=:-::§as?:s;;?@ *EE'7.;«);¥£j{ '3§'Ei%E,;'?_ ;;:::>;_,§;::;f§*g§8:;3I..:*: A:."£€}1?t"i€Z{:§;Ifi:I:i3;Z} I§.:;§:;:g._§_ Eitasé <_>j;;:§
"erg :,{:3'@;.> r;<;;,(_)g;; ":12: §3'§}E3§S11)S$§"i?§ I..§2}Q_fIf""S"§93Y;§.'vA'£§i}{;;)'§'E,L§£358. §§'E.fI; L'§_1uq 5;}
;;n:}z.1:;3§[3;>¢u ;;{{\§;' m::§g:g;{g0:;:)~ um g,::r2;:;;;1.;' z%'2;¢+;*:§$z*g1;_f;; "'gI:;~s',41*zi2$~~§T+;;§";{:1.;::s:;»1::';L:t
;;1;s<><7I:_i'm men; :?§"£,I%§::3;:;:;3:_§ :;i;'i':>z2x ;':t:i3'{~§_f*A '£35: ','.i;'§§.{'I§T13'i?5?1?£E""3.112-fifi1:{§:7}¥CI
mm 1:§:s11a_: E? my zmzam E§;T1}§i}H{'£-JA
mg'; :;_i1_<;s=t:; i1¥a2q"; "{tf2t.i1'j';q h-';m::>§;;:se:; ;1:::;§,{@g{c;¥:'1$;:=
{yam 21::.A>:;::1 $732; 1: uj't;3t:::§.z€E" V1@§.g-Iii.-E pm: §_1£(?if;Z3:).1'.
um ;;*2.1g;'};; :§;%'}§'1'v-;;5> "L}T;§¥_1;;},fj},'i§' :31.{'7£ HQ 'g;
' é}If{E'I3'££
1;§'z..§j.} $: &;:;{:;.:{.1:;z2. ;:ni'{'t:- j§§"1;.€)<1 _;.Q2 "Q3 :;»:;;)ma:m_v.-W",-1.;:{ '21>"!.",{di1 ';3'1;'"§*m;;_j;
_;3:}:..1"_t«m'1s;1..ig {t3I..I:)::::g;~g -~-- §§*£:zN 'fi,1i'ii;3:*{_}I;,i*C)€T§€st;1§«.I z{;gA<s. {)iL§;!¥§.E~§U§ mm
"fffigs;.__'m':,.§;;:t.£.{}::Z{::;;).V: ;aI<..§ §m'u,;xm *§;*<3;\;j '_';.Eu'£ié)})iWT{}f§'é3~§£§3J 4-{Q V£._::;m;:§:>
'*?<:iM
3'u'§}@a:1I "§I..:g.§:;3;;fi""zs; §;sm2: m;s:«2s:;I :~.";g.:;giz5,w.0"; -- fgj}(__';{j,~'(;;x<;:'°sg_{; gm {£31113
:3 p..m2m.42 MA .='{[i1'3E§'{ gum ;§;;}i.37%"3:{.i;k.:kE_If3;) §_i:>{.m m3;'.u:a*_.;..I:{3c:'};s:;1.1:mi1 T
$'§:a.mm::>i1 »« j{){;;qj'}*§.3'3}§ °;>_'m'm'; LI; <;}fi,I:m:.1§:": 01 §,):;.1"g1i'§.%}i;x.1 4' ' 3"
;:;»::1 .;{m::':£. mpg :g:3;:_.;..»n .-{g:;%*1':;Mzs; .;tz";; »- /("}{}{}'(}Eff'."_§%{t:{ .39 '
%::=;1;{:mi"g; '8 ";;).,t"va22zm2° €}S§{'n§.? 233$ ':;:;:.>::;s;;1"2§'g(> Spu:-2; 23%;} L;§_;:;§T1z. g§§g%'z£}:g~§,
5;;;;st:1;><:'i1%<::3 {?v3';}fi§}i§£{.{ mm §;;3'g~m'ém'1£e: s;:p.;f§é;éfi{1'; 9;'ij)QE':¥§'I}V£;.f$:';;§""
_g<i> 'I1I'.IFi0"EiI"Y:3 EH9: £1wE{}§"LI§.'d{} §:a;>.:z;;:sp.r'.§1;<.::);).tu<;).--%:z}_":s:_1't1.;%'!'gg *1"zi~ség--§_:?Er:§
:;t:.[.°g gm {{'«3.:'§§)'{lf.E£§..'E .1:{:;; g33::x.1<<>g.1:;»:_E ;_»>£:';'k«:;2'.1.~=:g;>_.{:s;j§; ;;»§'§<;*:»V§C:_T:::zVV::m) gzma:
p:sm.:Q;::;<i§ m:;:mtg_ sip;a:m":a ;:;;xmg;'$:;Q:;z.§%.,:;i_i«:ff*:::g;isM_J -i;<~:.z.::?;»jA:;:::=<;«;t:
:;1,2_1":s>..:a_;;1;g_:; .«"{€'J{ g3:;s'1¥:--:;;1j;"'9;13._;§{gfsifié «s;;V{;g'3_§.r_i'.§;e:$;:A;f~«,_?1M:1;m;)K;;g;> :;2:;m.;"i;.
1;; §')'1;§l}';§i§'£1E§)'iE3 '.~?;E2',»§a'x" Vazrq, _"3,.":a':'§éT!'£:$:1:L:§:"i§".l3'13:f's* ":«>.':;M;1. _§€_} :1)*g;';3?g:: ;;*I,,"{'f§ ;};)E1TfJ:'s'e xasxzgz
"gram Lanna at :11; ir_.§n:.:~;:: ?%;§iaa::';r:':gQ;z§ g"'z'~':'C}'§p;9U.E ;f)1_m m.m.;>«::sp
rm »~ /g;;{;;.{;'(j;g:;*::;a '?;1;.3s5;l<f£$§ ';:«31ai.,;f«. :;;r.,;- " -~f:;i.:.."'<§§§Ag':;<?3;::f£'§2 ()1 '§%En.gp,.:{>:):w
";s§1g:)t3<iv3:> 3u;'y£;r§:a;; £§~}.%§i;tE'13;1§'VE§'§E.§.;;T{) ?.«:;s,:z:2g $§3.;£"e:Mx<);1 "1I,1"!L*3{§£3(T§(§T§3
'J:3'§{.fi§, «'{3i"~§,._V «X gt} '5i',¥;EE;i'1*§:«"Ee §;x1"z%:g-x112? ;'mx ';*;jf€i{,I§§§).i€}£}£3V
"mi €§{}iif«.'_h':1?V:f'm'§=7{fV -~-/<;m'§;*:*$s::£ d:";)'"I':%;.;"}'I;:)1"{l§4 'imiir
,:;;z;§_f.; get) 3;:§:j;I;;1t:_-;:"g~i~;?1:::fi';;3,ig::f'ggzméi S'1;)1:%{j 2311;; mtg .1:9::I<a.i<i'3': Qq gf;{t'1€}.r~g2
;g;}~;=;{3 _I';§§";:iI_';§{:':.{1.:. 'Q'i7EI,;F_'L§;' "IEI?-:}{}E;2)iI}'i'3 3:1: :mm ;i3%"€j{3 H»:
'gggj. 'f3111II§*i§§%'*? §f}:'}13%'é3 amgzx ;}§~_{ w /gj;g'_}{}g.:'§§;g; 011; ;?a;3:)<"t1'p:u'_;:.;%
("-3
V"-3
§i13~a.".-~_
gitatitgg p:.5).1:1§7:;1<§ gm £}Q'£¥':T) ::;1;§".: :1; {j}'é)E..£§}_;§';T~3¥3 :;3,?W3I.f{ :..mA '(.§':}§L§A*&
§é2¥_I€}SE'"é).I. QELEQS i§?;{}, .I{3!¢_%f' Ciélfifii - /('}(_) "IE3 "£§}U;E{)Z}¥..§'_I .I{'€)Ef_},
{}iQS'.7;'é€~)SSl~'73 {"€<3{'i1"1(}i'§'..I'L 231$}, 'f.§&I}1.Ef~Q>3'§Q7§C$'!.i;-Q1 %'E_f§3iIE__"AF..I€}2"_} ECBIIXC3 'V
'3,::I;;803 firm ;<:.» :3::'€~1:;s<.;g§3 :;{.g'.:; 1.1: Liiilfi "$$~31§'{}I§.'E§I'i€I; ;{.1'E:E{{§;§Ei?;3 '
.x:;;1{1{.:s [31:13 SI..IgpL1;:m. }{g:'tI1 €)1i;{1T§ 313% EILEQER ':;:i)""§*e« .";;:;;.1;:;;2§:§¢$g:;
911;; 0:; $IVI§p,I{};)ZII§V' *<;;8'E:«'; 'gm s.:.1'e%3;;r§ {V5 cs}§:__ 1;"5:_ u..;»:;Ar§g§
p:;;a3'é: zmgzm E:-:;§;'w::a::);;a§:) 91:5"; '§:;:=;:§:z:> ;}$:3*£§'L;;VL.':§""g=:9§ L31"
'$:;>s¥3;) I.;m2:;'g3 :;>q: {fm ;1»:~g#§3*;g...,Aft_;{
'§"8?"{,{"!"lC§"§i.I'L .é:'t::L{ an
i}{{'}§3.1£f){§LO.I(i <;;1::re;,>s: gm"; gifiég ':§f';-a£:§§>tV1a)tis;a%:
mg; ...»i'<:; gggesgi He'::)3;; ;:--gr;as:;;;.I<3fia
219%,}, '{;)3:$xiE :{§{w:.;§3'§:"§§V 1:'; "Lzam gm a'.3,r~.3§_:x :91}: Exiting}
%g gm ;;>:m.: ;>:t;{';g. jg: :£;¥;'qT1;T)30'§ - ;'.:_';(j;{j;'gf;gj;'z*€s;~5§
gm "'}§{fe~§;3"fi:§Véé""p}L1'@ ;{g"_.m:ga::»§s:i3,{1::)§;3¥;1<7>:"1$:;>»_: $11.11
_m;0..1f_.; gq pgxegsx 3:.I§€3LI;}I;{ '.§,[EE3{{1.i;€iCE'£3
'vs;1;;_:tL'§'*;{' .§I1I_g':;<:;z.i{ f'§;>;;*§g"gi':;';:€:~t:iI: pmmte gi><.;»I.I%%t":e:'iE.§;§ "1,.1":%:d
'¥étE"'*e'2i?3A*f¥V¢E"*;BT%'S§ s<:%*;;>"/%3§£:': 'QM ww 'tmtm, '~f{>::':(;'{;€f:'z~"&:2+"z.
231;'; 01;. zgsgqa-i;§t:3<":1 "_}i.§I'i"10{1£E' gage'; 915:3.
t."'"i
P1
01. fiimq ${..I:m:.z"ta::: fitzrio-2; E} mg. ;:;(:E{::;:;*s gm mg 2:1 ::u':;§Agi; ;::..1;«rmg_m
':;}:qE::3§;ciid'I§ {.E;9£)Q ';~)fa;E3'£'_'{ §ilI§'E"i.i'.iL-'SA *am.:.'i3..:Q; gfsgmz ;.:>£..;1 'zaagraza ';.t>12t,{"1_m~.
:1"; u:;):{;: "$'?e.1r..1§mW 'Wz:%:'1;1't'1a{'%2g*;") '11ig§a(:g '.--»'i'Qq_KI!i1€)§§ ':;.1'(2g*a%Iw¥:§§§:1jf' ' "
:;2§{s_:§ :s7?;§;:': Ltlfifg'{0{§{IL).£'_};31T£"i' "8 go $1L::;;;»'gs::;.: :z:;:;:,2€:; . ~ V'
pxgntym g3:;a<.-::"§3:;::::9g3 :;w:.;{"1. 3,}, 'Af{§I.15?i;Ifl3._I{_} "g{:}r:Q§;:jj:;ai£;;;§g3' 7;1"i"s:} é>{§:m§"
(L31 --~,1{";(:}{_}'§'_)g".~."%}§ 'gm 1Ii.Em>:.2;zse: {3)'§j1.£4§*é-?é}_3.U;§i'£Vr§:32$; 3.' ZX'%T'}f,1;}'-- g»:>:9*g:3+;:":~';}:>;?-..g;ia' "
aq g;){t"1c>1,§s; 1_m"1.c>u'.§¥% ;;Lgj1 50 'T§££'}!;)§_3 '§Y33I..{".1'}.)I:iL§;¥1'f§€):) é;:~'.;.V;;::;"2§:.?.::..I;>@:a:»
{)'.1U§ gyms-;aw1c;§ {fit-i~';{"Q Qm§QL'fi S¥.I€)f}.¥:3T}§Z.3 ;;z::<§<5._ gaggaé :;::='::;L:£.§:1,':
Em 3t:£:pL:ads3 'E.{';):~)Q ::m¥31.;{ 1'sm':;;:_A 'g3:;s2;_t>§:;:3;;.1§'v~ AA 'ism %3;m1;1
$;::§;'L:;}cIx:;; £;;p.z"§--;?.as:s<;)'.1, ;3:>';;,:::r11:_:1:>§> ;1>(:§._V§[3§:1<M;2;:-:1,» *3:ii"x0ViTi:'§g*--- "i.§9z:11;n:
,m.0I;{ <3': Em g::3:>z::¥2A;';.;¥-3?s:;e.s:{:?=;i;:_r;:;i1z1fi%,1e ""'i;::>t%§; mi; * gg
'EI1E11I1Af'é§'.}2}€¥. -;fv{f}{}.{_}%'fJ;§ffE§;a:£VA'§3:3,Ifig'i3(} :»g.:{:w. gamem 9933
1.'{(}{~'l1;») LI§ *s.1:i1m'_,:._rg%§§;;) §€.:%;-- x§T;§'2j1:3;'5i..E:;>a"isang; ';}'i.f1. '82§A§i$:E§££IL)'§.}f'3g. rm :.V:8u'vK:;1'fi)1'K§9VC:..§-Q?' i,.:;-:g;;a;;rc;;_ :;;.m§I.3' """ '1;*a«::"t 1:11 ;{;§1:;.g"; 'gvseabtggé ':3,m1mm»:a 51.18'/("i '§§§II;§:'_}?;}I;!.V§A§5%*E}>.L{{§#;L}€;:¥!;' . 'ew';'E «« j{;g'_j;§;'{)g;*Q;¢§ <31, @::m.£0:.> :v:;g;§?gx;'{'m I'1;:;£;:}>::;;. .z.:§(;E .«:;'g;;{}g;';jj*s;t,gg§ g;:»m92 f{'E:?f;} .:1:;)d « f (j;{j;1 "$931; 17{i%{.:{'i; '-.-V;s::",~*=:§§-v":':§.;>V'i';. fiII"§{,LfEi:3§§§ A*u:1;;;rq %Ll}!';E3'i..{ i1:~?.1:1m: "g_:§:;a1a:;:>3g..1 2:51;; 29:13. 'gm ""-. '3T§_":t;3;;: "'»:1:.t;#1;'s,Ig.<c1<;2_A;1.1:'m" "go 49.153 gmx '$35;/gg;;g'§ 'om' ';:7'L§_{F§ Lt; .1'.r«mmi;~§ fig W SE. X «-f{j}{f;{':'§;g"sf;;g§ ':::;;:...§L§4 "fig; W ;;_:;<ig i;_;:n'::>m mwg.gs:§§'1gIxz:J, '~"'bu?V'44 13%.} ""'é3VZE.%§~§' "'13,}';}1.)¥C}CJ"E? ff} i§;}I."£.ii:E,), 2§}3§_{'L§ $93 HE £}{ii"E§ "§;,Z};'}fi¥% _ V' :;;q_ 0:1. z:mc:3Iigj:§; s;Emx .m1;;f:;t;3m £4;";},{ *5-;..:"%:«2<:;>3{ 3: '.§.z"1<::q W ;):;>%*a §§i§%;<§:' 'A '~- .1g;:3Mm3;,iu.;n,; §)i;¥*i~7».i'E'(--T9;");?§:s§;.} 'gm; ,1' giggygj "E '€)}j\§ vg;;rg{H pm:
"W ;':}s::-fiiis.' €43 £:'f":s:.7'é§:~§"%i¥.% "$1.3? V' wgimm L'{_:Z}§"{.§.!Y& ';;:s<)q_M£a* p;:;%:,:«:)§m;::m *s'§a'j_s;*gs}§a:;1..; 'g"e::e1:;.{.;§;j3;§::;é.,;§z1i};_=;. ${L*:~i"5'r'x'a<T%"--% */{}ff}€.Z}'€;')§r2"r7~?eTi:i' Smsiii «i:}tI:::~é:">~:<::a<;E=e:%w ;:<i>« ...'%3f'3%¥§.§ mg; - f(f;g){}'(i;g;g'g:'*;g;g{ (:21: §f);;¥§',};§'}{V§¥.3""€}:T;1§€%_§$.'§¢iE"%3fV{:i+E§7E'{ZL1f .f€1r:»3:fe :;~sm:_> $31.1 LI: 'fifiiiiggi {:_}t;* Agaq (311 ;;;;;;:.;ige:}':.::...;;§i;g;; }':~:;> 293%:
::.}s;.{'), 'e:)»&;{":?2 ":;.E;:}H "s.2*€:.:;a§s2. 45;;if ;11_'1(}(i};§3__ §_:+;;3 ,-{;t§':;$.:'ma::zf:£»3m'..;2;§'.1'}§"j~{ Swzm in ':32?
V A A < '4''-:.}.:;'k'€i''§C}€.)'€}1'€'$E::§ 9% PE?-"i0&'-
W}; fig gm' "(W v,;--{ :;:{:fg';&3?;§~z'..{§§:;Eiii%)Q gm :m§2.<;:»m'"::;* m.g:g_ '£§'i'E"i{.k§$ §»§%gJ:;'i"'z1'}%§ '1§{'§fi,é%§3f§;§t}<f§$;vim}. ':;1¥~:1s::;.;'; ;;t__{; :37; se:2:;c:g' _'I10g*1:3V:§g;_.;%e'V':_:+'£i*{3* 'em 2;;-:"::'1-5; sap%e3;;>':.;" gwzam::>§";z:;)m.m::: :A':»_3;f§}i'z3§;rE2A 3§J::=%;.m(}:§,.~ éf}{;g}'{f;gj'§;;;»§ go mm; '24; 'g}'§f)E?§ <3": :.;::;';$t>2z;{_ ':>i~;<v§7i"%»3,T'E:I1' 93¢ ?;*£;;§%:><.::"{';§:'z';'*:Azs;a éétii E-3'{1"'tW¥-'s €23: >4 -/:j"><i%><:>'é;i:zt'ss"2;.;; '~ «. , "=. -*:;:i.:::3p'§;:2:f:e:§ " :f;m'§:1 ";§'i'.;T,'§ we :=;;m::3.J§ if} 1;-,« '§,tE<I)(j§'Ei p;;f§1;2 ésrazxx. '9;1L1'9§m0€££;:;.z §;}L{'I1 {E/1(:§W.§k':£ '€s.§¥§3;;M:'£':€i'eMI: ;3:_;',g 35:: §{;'m:; :;_s;~1§.mE%'e3 "£%:mm;s: ma :::;:.1;:1<i;'s.£rE% £)i'_jf;};, ;mg:2s;::s::;z:, «.633 g3a;::q*},g'1L:;:;;» ;;;q g3§:V:.{;.rs;:' 'V ' 'éi§il{l"8{{T{}f,E{5h?3 i.~.}L§L§ '?'S:§i}E§'E?;I} §I'}§"€€§'é§i;}£C{:§7i3 ';~)1'..{"L} EH9.' éi-§'{U,.{\§J °-« f§:>.<j§Q'<':¥:3"é.fi$2€' = 01 s:;;m;:€;;3 '".S~}'{31?3i.i)'€WE '{m_:<:.)g:';g1:_r;;sm_m:> £;V::e_:,_"£§:m(;x3, ._~« f{:}{"}g}"{)§§j"'$A§5§"' SI1E<i1 -/1:){>e;:'(;<fzi'$a mm 21;: "E X mV§"a::1j§:1";'{:E%'*=é'a5~ V.{'I%§~§"E\WE/'#5 ; 1;: "E % 2.3»-:1 gjmzzma .%1;:"§;§:§I_:;a.§:"1:1_: :n;§f.1 ':;>>_,_3:i;<;gri;«»; ~;_'j§{'.£i;}§f}'*i£.}§7_$:E'T3jigie.'$;}E}{'i'§T1 -M153 um a;.%I1c:3;:wfZ gay pgfiteé s§;%;43m .:::;v;;g%3;:")":%«£ '£.=§§.:¥.~:£ _ "'»f:",<:;s;*'sr?_22;,.%'§L g;%3'.i;V%:i:1;€2?g;;1i*; p;:s%'B mm @?9J"5@'¥?N :39»:-m:s::':%é2>p 'jjf'z~;*€'::*;'.:;§?:r%: '1<%:~§ 4.'*5i';:?!i'%'\i ":1 '"/€'}(_){}'{:I ac)'; ~;;~:;m1r:?2:;s "'*;;;31:%?;;.1.gj " .{Emz1a"§j:ffi§:§§;\:i<:;:;§"- ».f:"%§j}.1{%;"¥X{§',§ M /gj;{}gjj}'gf;<g;'s§;>;§ 9111*'-31 ~f<.)a'><':'V€;¢s;W%'E%%:%§ ~=-/€:(";(i}'(.>$"i3'2&§f. I--I:?ML1, W'; fgzfczg. ;;;§m:»_.{S2% .'i_x%§A"§d°§l'1A.f¥"l'1'.I.Ti %:;:.1'§";:_"'*';';.1M:;p'§V' ';;:.1:;;>§3g::::1z:; gm :m:I'§.?g ;;}i...{'§ H2 $§.£*E%2f$;>'§§ {;§,_§"sa»'?}jf:4:* ._Q§:'2?.;%£x=T.._:;§§;..§1n>:x: :»:_:';§;;T '$;J"&3'w{ 1' 3; :m::x:;:g_e ;;:s:;§§::~2 %?éz*£%»¥%tfiIBm?%i.-M; '2:z:>m;::2:: '*'~1?N 'm1:z\: mi "ax z '~.,.g';{:){}{j}'{'_}{§';"f'$31 ya mrg; 55;-_3{..:<:>m. L;':>'g"zi,{m §;:gf>'e:;a':§ ' 4".AI*'3§I01'.i£I';?'3'*'1i'33~:3E3-Wr¥'if3l- "/{}€"j§{"1§(f§'EJ 'SE1 '8¥I'1{€3- W/€::'::()'::;€A;;a'g:**:%i