Delhi District Court
Criminal Case/931/1996 on 13 February, 2007
1 ! " # $ % &'( )*) &+ $ % , ,& "+ -
.&
/1032 4 57698 :9;9<>=?:A@
B76DC$618FE!G1HIG1JKB7LNMPO
C QRGSQUT V TWMPX+LYX EIZ[0I\ ] ^_Z`2
acb+d e1fhg bji $k!- kDl+mRnoe*p bjq er& s+s tvu?w
aUxod noe*y b mze*kol9pFk1{*{%g qFq g|k9}`kDlSmRnoe*kol~l3e9}opFeW& wso-zs!-S
a p d n
e} b {`e*kolSmRnoe*pFk9{* ib g} b }mWg l b }I& .GYMPOI\#O,XjjG!HC jG!
a y d noe} b {`e*kDl+mUn
e b pFpD q e+yoe1f q k9}j b }oyn+g q E1G1O9\ LYKGYM
b f3e1}Fm bS e b }oyf3e q g ySe1}
pFeW& C9=?5#!LYXSIG1H\ L GYM
21=5 5NLWXDTHI5N63 :W#
Z[ITS7J
GYMY 5N57H+W
O ¡ ¢G1XoG1HWI4 G£¤GA¥?¦!GYM¡
2 5WGS7I\ G1§IG9XjITWMRG96
a e d noe*kol~l3e1}
pFe*pFk1{* i|b g}
eSy*kDl& ¨D©Ar, 7
a l d n
e ie b kDlSmRn
e b pFpD q eSy b }oyn+g q
eDª b { g«} b mhg|k9} a gl b }F d & ie b ySe+y}okDm +g i m,`¬
p ib g{`eSy mRfhg bji -
ac+d noe lhg} bIi `f3ySe1f?& (k1}+g|pmhg|k1}
a n d noe*y b m3e*kDl q
pDn`k1f3ySe9f?& s
¨j-®w1-®w++9tI-
E ] ¯ ° ^*± 4.²³8,´
so- µ.fhg|eol f3e q +{`e¶kDlYmUn
e·l b pm q kDlmRnoe¸p bjq e kDl$+f3k q eSpDmRg k1}¹g q mRn b mºk9}»wYso-zs'!-S
b m b9x k1Fm¢so- ¨o9S{ b m¼ i kDm[}ok1-~½+I (g q mRfhg|pm¾ (e1}mUf¿e!$À b } b9Á .Sfhg $e i n+g b pFpD q eSy
y9g q n
k1}oe q m i f3e1{`kooeSy¹mUn+f3eSeÂySkSk9f%n b }oy ie q kDl bIi +{ g}+g«S{ { b ySeÃlRf3k1{ mRnoe
Sf3e1{ g q e qÄi k x+x b }oyÆÅ bjqÇbIiq kÈf3e1{`kD+g«} mUn
eÉlzk9Sf,mRn k1}oe b }oy g«} mUn b m
Sf3kSpFe qFq +noeÊÅ bjq¼b S+f3e1noe9}oySeSy x `pFk1{* i|b g} b }FmY b fhgDËNg q n b }% $n b nj-
2
Ì1Í Î ÏFÏDÐAÑ'ÒSÓÕÔ¼ÖjÑ×Ö9ØRØ3ÒjÑÚÙzÒ+Ó Ö9Û
Ó Ò9Û+ÜÖIØzÝ+ÒSÓ Þ9Û ßDÖjà«Ü®Í á`Û ÏFÞ9â*ã+Ü|ÒoÙRà Þ1Û Þoä
àÛFåoÒjÑÚÙRà|ÝSÖoÙhà Þ1Û ÏDæDÖ9ØzÝAÒ Ñ
æoÒ+ÒDÙ¶ÔçÖjÑèähà«Ü ÒSÓ!Íêé(Þ1ãAà|ÒIѾÔ_Ò1Ø3Ò Ñ
Ð+ãSã+Üëà|ÒSÓ Ù3ÞìÙUæ
Ò
Ö+ÏFÏDÐAÑ'Ò+Ó!Ííé æDÖIØzÝ+Òîä3Þ1ØKÞDä,ä3Ò1ÛoÏFÒIÑ ã+ÐSÛ+àÑ
æDÖ9ß+Ü Ò ÐSÛoÓSÒ9Ø ï Ò+ÏÙhà|Þ1ÛAÑ ðDñAòÃó ô7é
Ô¼ÖjÑ*äUØzÖIâ`ÒSÓÇÖSÝ+ÖIàÛAÑÚÙKÙRæoÒ¹ÖAÏFÏDÐAÑ'ÒSÓ1õÙ3ÞíÔÊæAà|ÏDæ æoÒ ã+Ü|ÒSÖ+ÓSÒ+ÓöÛoÞDÙ`Ý9ÐAà«Ü Ù,÷ ÖIÛoÓ
ÏoÜÖIà«â`ÒSÓ ÙRØhàÖjÜ®Í
ðjÍ óÛøÞ1Ø3ÓSÒ1ØÙ3Þ¾ã+Ø3ÞDåoÒùà ÙcÑúÏ ÖjÑ'ÒûÖSÝ+ÖIàÛDÑÚÙºÙRæoÒÇÖ+ÏFÏDÐAÑ'Ò+Ó!õ1ã+Ø3ÞIÑ'ÒSÏDÐÙRà Þ1ÛÈÒDüDÖIâ àÛoÒ+Ó
ÙRæSØ3ÒSÒýÔ[à ÙUÛ
ÒIÑFÑýÛDÖ9â`Ò9Ü ÷þô!ÿ ×é$ÙUÍ (à«ÛoÞSÓ!õ[ô!ÿ
Ì $Ö9Øhà àÑ
æDÖ9Û ï$æDÖIæjõ(ô!ÿ ðûÎ(ï ó
àëÑ
æoÖ9â*ßoÒ1Ø
$Öo÷DÖIÜ®Í
Í
æoÒ1Ø3ÒjÖ
ä,ÙzÒ9ØUõ ÑÚÙzÖoÙ3Ò1â`Ò1ÛFÙøÞDä ÙRæoÒ ÖAÏFÏDÐAÑ'ÒSÓ
PÑÇð
ðþé ØUÍ,ô Í é ÔçÖjѾØ3Ò+ÏFÞ1Ø3ÓSÒSÓ
ÔÊæoÒ9Ø3Ò9àÛøæoÒ æDÖjÑãAÜ|ÒjÖAÓSÒSÓ¶æ+àëѺäzÖIÜëÑ'Ò¶àâ*ã+Üëà|Ï ÖoÙhà Þ1Û Ö9ÛoÓ·àÛSÛ
ÞSÏFÒ1ÛoÏFÒ1õ!ß+ÐFÙ%Ó+Ò1Û+à ÒSÓ
Ù3ÞÜ|ÒjÖAÓ*ÓSÒDä3Ò1ÛoÏFÒ*Òoå+à|ÓSÒ9ÛoÏFÒ!Í
Í ó æDÖ
åoÒÕæoÒjÖIØ3Ó ÙRæoÒÂÑ
ÐSßSâ àÑFÑ à|Þ1ÛAÑÈÞDä ÙRæoÒ
Ó!Í Î ô ô×Ö9ÛoÓèÙRæoÒÄÏFÞ9ÐSÛAÑ'ÒIÜ ä3Þ1Ø
Ö+ÏFÏDÐAÑ'Ò+Ó Ö9ÛoÓæoÖoåoÒãoÒ1ØRÐDÑ'ÒSÓ ÙRæoÒ*Ï ÖjÑ'Ò ähàëÜ|Ò!Í !Í æoÒÂÏ ÖjÑ'Ò ÞDä³ãSØ3ÞIÑ'Ò+ÏDÐFÙhà|Þ1Û æ+àÛoÝ+ÒIÑ Þ9ÛþÙRæoÒ â ÖoÙ3Ò1Øhà|ÖIÜ Ù3ÒIÑÚÙhà«â`Þ1ÛF÷ Þoä ô!ÿ Ì Ö9Ø àÑ æDÖ9Û%Ñ æoÖ9æjÍSó|ÙWàëÑ Ù3ÞßoÒKÑ'ÏDØRÐÙRà«Û+à FÒ+Ó`Ô[à ÙRæ*ã+Ø3Þ1ãoÒ1ØIÏ Ö9Ø¿Ò Ö9ÛoÓ*Ï Ö9ÐÙRà Þ1ÛjÍ+ô!ÿ Ì àëѳÙRæoÒ ÔçÖoÙ3ÏDæSâ Ö9ÛÄÔ[à ÙRæ Î Ö9Û Ó¾ÖoÙ ÙRæoÒ¾Ùhàâ`Ò»ÞDä_Þ+ÏFÏDÐSØRØ3Ò1Û ÏFÒ!õ ÙRæoÒ (àÑÚÙUØcà|ÏÙ ÏFÒ1ÛFÙ3Ò1Ø oÖ9ÛDÖ ýô.ÐSØhà`àÛ³÷oÒjÖ9Ø ! ÔçÖjÑÐSÛ ÓSÒ1Ø ÏFÞ9ÛAÑÚÙRØRÐoÏÙhà|Þ1ÛSÍÎ(ÑKãoÒ9Ø ô!ÿ Ì1õ7æoÒ æDÖ+Ó Ï Ö9ÐoÝ9æFÙÊæoÞ9Ü ÓöÞoä!Ö+ÏFÏDÐDÑ'ÒSÓ¼Ø3ÒSÓ¸æDÖIÛoÓSÒ+ÓíÖoÙ#ÙUæ Ò¸Ñ ãoÞDÙÙRØ,÷+àÛDÝÂÙ3Þ ÙzÖ " vÒ·Þ1ÐÙ(ÙRæoÒ ä3Þ1ÐSØ,ÙRæ æDÖIÛoÓ9Ü|ÒÈÖ9ÛoÓêæDÖoå+à«ÛDÝìÖIÜ«Ø3ÒjÖ+Óo÷ ÙzÖ" vÒ9Û Þ1ÐÙrÖ9ÛoÓ # vÒ1ãÙÙRæSØ3ÒSÒÕÖIÜÐ+â àÛ+à«ÐSâ æDÖ9Û Ó9Ü|ÒjÑìÔ[æoÒ1Û ô!ÿ Ì Ñ ãoÞoÙ,ÙzÒ+Ó ÙRæoÒ Ö+ÏFÏDÐDÑ'ÒSÓ!ÍÊô!ÿ Ì Ï ÖIÜ«Ü ÒSÓ ÙUæ Ò +Ð+Û+à|Þ9Ø $ % &% ÛDÝIà«ÛoÒSÒ9Øûï$æjÍ Í çÍ æÐAÙ>Ö9Û1Ö à Ù ÙRæoÒ·Ñ ã ÞDÙ7Ô[æoÞºäRÐSØ,ÙRæoÒ1Ø Ï ÖIÜ«Ü ÒSÓ³ÙRæoÒÃã Þ9Ü«à ÏFÒ!Í ô!ÿ Ì ÝSÖoåoÒýÑÚÙzÖoÙ3Ò1â`Ò1ÛÙ $ üjÍ,ô!ÿ Ì cÎ Ù3ÞúÙRæoÒÂãoÞIÜ«à|ÏFÒ1Í ' $ÒøæDÖSÑÃÖIÜÑ'Þþà|Ó+Ò1ÛFÙhà ähà|Ò+Ó Ï ÖjÑ'Ò ãSØ3Þ1ã Ò1Ø,Ù,÷ ãSØ¿ÞSÓ1ÐoÏFÒ+ÓèßoÒDä3Þ1Ø3Òþâ¢÷ ( Ó!Í ô.Ø3ÒSÓ+ÒSÏFÒIÑFÑ'Þ9ØUõNÏFÞIÜ«Ü|Ò+ÏÙRà åoÒ9Ü ÷ ÖjÑ $ üjÍ,ô oÍ 3 +) *-,"./. 021 354"687:9 ;8<>=@?BA!68724!C ,EDGFH. A IKJ 6 JLA!I 4!CNM"O21QP RTSU)+*-, .L. 021 3'VW; J XE;YVZ<\[&< C <"J ]B< 7 ^ J 7!<_I`<"I`,NM"O21QP R acbdFe1 f 1 g ,\6hC < J ]EA![&<i,ED"9 ;8<@C XE[&<8V ,\[jC XE[&<kVl7"[+J ^8<\[jmB0`9 ;8<nJ 6B^8<2Co9 J p!489+JL6Ep 4!p <\6kXq0r4k9 9 ;8<'Cks8,E9utv,\[ J 9dCW68,\6ws [&,!7\A8Xq9+J ,\6KJ 6`XB,"A![Q9 mk<"J 68p'.x4"sEC < Ccby.x489&XE;8<2Cz,"6r9u;k<_sE4"[Q9 ,ED 9 ;8< J 6B^8<2Co9 J p!489+J 68p 4!p{<\68Xq0 Xv4"6!6k,E9|m8<}9&<\[ IW<!7 D~489~4 .9&, 9 ;8< Xv42C <,ED s![&, C < XEAB9+J ,\6CvJL68XB<9u;8489 JL6YJ 9+C < . DV,\A . 7 6k,E97 <\I`,"./J/Ck; 9u;k<CVZ,"[ 6>Co9~489&<\IW<\6B9 ,ED P RTSK<"J 9 ;8<"[ JL6r9~,89&,w,\[ J 6wsE4 [Q9 J XEA .x4 [u1 =\1 P RTS 6!A![dC <!7 6k, p"[ A872p{< ,"[s [&<E^ J ,"A{C <"6!IKJ 9Q0 VJ 9u; 4 XBXEA{C <!7\1w;8<"[&< ;E4"s s8<\68< 7 9&,>m8<68, ,!XBXv4!CvJ ,\6zD&,\[5P RTS@9&,D~4 .xC <". 0J Iws{.LJ Xv4k9~< 9 ;8<Y4 XBXEAEC <!7 1 P RTSY;E4 7 m8<!<\6NXv489&<2p ,\[dJ Xv4 .'JL66E4"[ [~4k9 JL6Ep ;848^ J 68pC < <\64 XBXEA{C <!79 [Q0 J 6Ep 9&, 9~4"?< ,\AB954 . A IKJ 6 JLA!I ;E4"687 . <4899 ;8< Cks8,89ZVW; J/. <9u; [&<!<4 . A IKJ 6 JLA!I ;E4"687 . < C VZ<\[&<T?<\sB9Km8<2CvJ 7!< C4 XBXEAEC <!7HVW;8<"6P RTS[&<!4 XE;8< 7489 9 ;8<Cksk,E9u1j sk,E9J/Cw9 ;8< JxCo9u[+J Xq9 *-<\69~<"[utj4s{.x4 XB<J 69~<"[~ 4 .LJ 4 D&,\[XEAECo9~, 7E0,EDs![&,"s8<\[Q9Q0 D [&,\I V;8<\[&< 4 XBXEA{C < 7 ;E4 7@[&<\I`,E^8< 742. A!IKJL6 J A I ;E4 687". <2C'VJ 9u;k,\AB9 4"60<8O!s![&< CBCZ,\[ JLIws .LJ <!7 XB,\6{C <"6B9",8D!9 ;8<w,kVW68<"[ b¡sk, CBC < CBC ,\[ 9 ;8<"[&<!,EDu1 ¢ 1 £¤6UIr0nXB,\6{CvJ 7!<\[&<!7@,\s JL6 J ,\6!tKJL6:^ J <8V|,ED¥4"mk,E^8<'7"J/C XEAECBCvJ ,\6!t s![&, C < XEAB9+J ,\6U;E42C m8<!<"6j4"m{. <9&, m![dJ 6Ep ;k,\I`<n9 ;8<p"A J/. 9,EDZ9 ;8<4 XBXEA{C <!7hmk<E08,\6k7l[&<242C ,\684"m . < 7!,\A mB9\4 6874 XBXEAEC <!7J/CW;8< . 7p"A{JL. 9Q0 4"687JxCZXB,\6B^ J Xq9&<!7Aob¦C`§8= ¨©£ªPG*1 a ¨\1 «k<E9 ;8<_m8<_;k<24"[&7w,\6z9u;k<_s8,"JL6B9",8D C <\69~<"68XB< 1 ¬ `®G¯~° ±³² ´ µ ¯¶ ·\¸E¹ ±º² »G¼2½ ´¾ ´¿¸³À`ÁZ¼ ±Âµ{åĵ ÅƯuÇGÈ Ç¿¸³±ÉÅ ·\²ÊÄr·2»¿±QË8ÅƯ+·!Åuµ"Ì Í ÇG¼ ±³² ±QÌÎ¥µ ¸º¼ ±QÀ ¶¯uÇG² Ç¿® ²"Ï µ!´Ê±º²Åм µwÇGÈ"µ"²Ï!Ç¿®¿¯ Å ÇG² Åм ±QËÑ8ÒkÓ/Ô ´ ·{ÕÇ\ÃjÖ2µ"×دy® · ¯dÕ Ì Ù!Ú!Ú2Û2À