Karnataka High Court
Shokin Ahammed S/O.Saleem Ahammed Khan vs The State Of Karnataka By Udyambhag ... on 1 August, 2011
EN "E.'E"§.E§ E-§{§E"§ Cf{§U'E-Z'§' 6}?" E£A§{N!a'_E':;%..KA
CIRC UH' §%Ei\E'C' FE AT §'}1*'i/3x..§€V¥'7r':'1§.:3
:3;m:.if;":':»«1_I§;':":~:%: .DA":" 09' A:,;e:;Us':" 22:; 3 ' '
PE¥€E€SE:N'E" -
';E'HE HGIWBLE MR,JUSTiCE?A1'§i§§iI;Z,AF}*€§Ex _
m\:':;>
THE HCIVFBLE: MR. g_»}'}E}STI t3E NAQARM
CRIMINAL A:P?EAL 'Kb-.;"§8:04 $13 19
S::':;,Si"1«:3ki:_"}. AE:21:112*:f;é:'2;,1'}__ _ V V --
S g' 0 , E3aE:'5:<:% I1': _f5:E'Eéi; ;r::;r;f:::;3(§ i%'<§*i7::'2'2 ':1; ~ ,
figifi 38 y€a:i:'~:, {_}{3{".Z §'--é.;<iv§.":§:*§r i;a»tf:}'i:*§s:, * '
E43/{} A1.'1;g<>L E§é::.§gzs,:.1m.. "
. . .A§}§){:?1.EEiE1'ii
{B}-~' Sri o {§&iE'1;1§)2£Ei'ib.4f»5§, 8}}, Q1-., J9.'-'%;"._£é?;;':
TE: :55 ';€§i:2:: 31. :E:_ {.'}§ §€'§;:4;*;:_L:."':':2§*§'i;.'¢;?aEé;;§-L
V V £3}; E} iijga£21:§;:«.§':éé;g'§?<}§§:;§::ie" §3'€:z.:é'%{::§.':g
"'§?%§'é>:ii%«-' E2€>;3,.__%}y §j§.,C;'§j-.9; 13.. mE?%c%s§g."::">:':{i<«':~z:£:
M .. _.§';~.",E."'=:.-="iF'=£?&§:§;1Ai:3':2E:E»i2i§.', éfigfé, $52 21%;
?
Tizisé %i'f:*§2::':§:':.;2:E A;§§:;s;z;:.s§ §§§e::<"E §.2§f§.,:§?<3§§2} {§Z2°',§~7'.{f:, _§5:"2:i}r§:':;;;
_ :?::{.} Em? :.:{:§;§s'§::T%§'3§.. 2'23"" {.Tf{fl}.§'E¥§{'.'i§.ii;'vL%".3 :az::<'E <::"{:i§:z:" zzvé" =::»;:;::":':":§;%:':{'%£:
3
N'
{%a1<;%<:i ,23§{}?;"i2,{}E{} pas:;a:<e{:<i ':33; 'v'--;'%,<i{i.i{:i<';z':a_§ E'§€§5=§Si€3r}'ES gfiucigge,
E?§c:%§;g2z:.z:11. :33: S.C?.N::s.i51;'20G8 §E::};:' %':h€:% <,:i'§}:?e::<::?:+; p:T:z1i;ss_haE3§s:%
2'x.m§e:° ;':}*><:?€;i::+;.f$:~E§e't,%{;'%,) 382 :3? EPC,
'jZ.'h§s {Tf:f:imi:.22-1% 2i;3§ié2:a.E <*::;3:1§iz':.g; <}i'} Em' §'}:'12is}; §:T?";"£:::: ~
(fizzy. BILL-APPA. J" <:i:=31i2-w::>.r<:>{E 1.11:6: fE:;1E<3w*_i:':g;
'§"h:'$ zappmzi iay the. 22<:m..z%-;::3:i" {E§";:%e;f£:#:{§' V-fa: <f§i:'3:ai: $19: "
JL:{ig§me:':_i:. zamd Or{i€:z°, {2;21t<:?;.§i 23 ;3§1$§;'::sé;%{§ .E;:;§,r the V
z»':{is:§i:::.§0:':33 Ses$.§e:ms~;; J'L::.r:ige, I?E3'céV};§:};2::;f:::g;}gig': 5 E /2098.
2, E3}; iiifuzz _1%.rr:.;3;:_-;;,§;'1s€«;f;§ J1,:.:§gn1é':':fi;~.g;__::{§ {}z'{§er, the 'i':"ie1ET
C{}'£,,£§T"§'. has; <:€3:1%;7§:%§.<:t=7r .§v , 31325.'22{7.{3+aZ£:$;.€%d for '$16 :'>ff<?;'zi:<teé3« pz:;'1§5sE":ab§a%
1.z;:'1:E€z" ;S"~§:%<:?:s'i'$€3f2 "2t;:;.'2{f3_ zmd Esazasa E-f=3€'fE'1.i.€.I"i{?i{'*.{i é.E":€:
a.:ir<tus;s3s§ {in -":1 :'1.{ie*:f;.;;:3 1';i£7<;i§' _i.n:pris;§>m:r;m'1i: emci {.0 pa-#25; .22: fiE"iE'f <21"
§°j'§.,§'§'}£§§'Aé:é" {i::%§'Eu.:EE. <35 §_>e::;zm2z'1E_ 53%' iirzsx iii: E.m<§<"~:rg<i2 SE. 59;" 2:: '--§I§&-:v§_"§<'i::{§ éé ;?f;:.:.1;':'2§',E"2s3--s {<35 ::§'::3 <}f§:;:':':z':é:: p':.::'1.isaE':ab§%: :..:;21<E:3:* §:'§:}::r:'§§2 E'1§>{3 ,_g§2.:;:§«--""§'§.::" 3%:-3 <>;§";€'1s;*;.§':a%s:: g;m_,:;'::'s:E":;;z§3Es=% "z,3§'E{§§.?i" :~:s{>:<%f:°_:_>:': EEEZL éE":--é} 2.'i{ii{'T'%..1£~3é;'f{i§ is §f}:';éz;?<:§'f: §;e:%:':£::z:3:':<'ta%<.%; {Li} 1: §[:s:§<%§'§gi> 3? §E::' 7;: 'g?;w;._.=§*'§a;€,% 2}? :_}m;* };a::2~*:s* gmzé £3': {§&%§a'z:E%:_ <25 §.}§i§;"§'£]2.éji§1i51 {E5 %5"§E'.:<'-.5 fa ' _ :§%.§, fa}: 2.1 E.§€§'"§i}{'§ :5}? 3 z*:':{_;a':2§".}':s:;, § % /'"' -
3/ . V §73:%€.s"3':i>e.-<2;é{f§§___ A 33% 3 £3' f':f,§;,§E"§{?¥'IZ'?f{i by i..E':a£T., fix: z?£§')§}€'fI§£}..13"€'~»:E{{"?€2E.1;£'$€»S§ hz-as fiizéd i_h:s>:e a::;:}g;vé:;2:.L 4}, B§'}:€3fi:§,:" s:;i'.21?;',c%{§._ ihér <'r2.a:;;€ {sf Ejhi'? §f§§'éi}f-3(1?{Tf{,ii,i(}fl_.-is 21.3 {0} iiizwsis :
i} 'I'%1:2:E: {.§&%<'%<%a-:~:<?{'§ E"{2m1§2:2:. wa,s.;=, :":1:a:1'*':"i§=:{E 2:E3a::%js;:;i: .33 ' §3aa}<;. She W213; {IE{'?f-f§€':?1"€lfi?€f by 1'1<:r h 1[z.s.:E"32:2_VrV:'{li'; "PTi4'\f.'§{)_:3;5; %;.'%iu ,2: ;'5:2:*: of ?:.h€3. <,%€:<:e2is€:cE R2-m':_i.2;v:2':. :'Ezz'<):,:g,§h has E9? E":: a5:_;%32}2_;1c1. Ai;mE;:_»E. 2 'bz:{tE«; wi":€:_r} <:i:%<':::as:s:.i Eiianziza. hzg-ad g;§.g>'f;--€%: 3:3 Eiesxfiézsaéez é;.h€m<:,:*;.:}3»£e I in <:<>z'1é:21.<.:€. x,,v;?:'E"; {E13 32pp€E§ar;:"t\. 2;:4e::(:2.:aA:é;'é5§<7§' grief"::_:a1:°:"ietihifi1a After '::E":<:: marrizexgggeg i;'E";c~. €§ze:{::::e1:s€-tzi i:?l§'.'§_€§ 'E:§'2.7:*:":;¥.i?<%;.j-1§§§:ti:fisgzréi §'{fSi{iT§1E'E§_{ in 2:; :°<:2n:'.§-rs'? g.}i:*é:€:::2£;9_s;%§~;:,Vi.é*:jézffgéw§'::iw::éa:.._<;§" «$3 , *:§.2'-3:2" f'v'§E,3§§£-E, '"E'}i:s«::"= 2';§:;i::::':,:s::*{;§ VJ2'.1f:i va<}§'ki::_§,: m».AlEa:3j§: F;E:i5\:3:'§:.{.§ry1 'E'h€:":"':;': ?;,iEE3€{§ iii} be p<;*.f£:i:§; <;':.:;a:rm=%§$ _§§36§;'za%§:<;%:3 "i,'§<1_,e;5 5é€jf{i'E.£f%§€{§ zmzi me iiéiéféééifiéfii' {EB .§.5',52,:'f'féi?{f?§§'§¢ _Size:-. é::::'ius£;::i 221153 iiéw ::ie.<ts:::?a:-ws<:t<£_ Eééifi 5;§€}::€;=: 31;} "Z§."Efiée;% 2':E.{?{ji'%.,}:E€§{?{.§ ;*{%§'.:4::*:':&%<'§, 3,,-;'2'E:@:;<' aizng fizz: T:j::i9<:€»;;2;2:':a;:2s::E; :*'9%_'1.é*§f:':§3'{§ ;:_:'*s<§ 2-2:':-aiag-.=::{:i §'§'}§.' 2-.%;::*.z::2T2§;:=%z:£ as-"%':jg :»;;%:e wezzs i:3:'i"§: £3:
4. %.:§§l::: z'Zs--;x--.4_ Eii 'ZE";:§:é; iT'.{}§"li'};€'f{2§'§{f}f7§.; iZ§'2€;E§"i? wza-.s§ <§z2zI:':*':":=%E Ei§"§{.'§ ii: 4"::_;i:>;'.;.§:£.--z2'éégi iii} _'§';?;';' 31%': E??? 2;' i?1{}{,}§=:§.i E'E'";::3 Q;-i€,',{'f'%.§:'r»I=':§;T*.:i§ z::.:*'§=:.=:::% ',m.,.....-mwv :8 drive ihfi dazzesasfié aui 0f the EEQQSE. Thfi éeceased Efifid £23 re-523%: ii; A: mat tima iha €i{?."C'il$€{i geumé E:€r0Se:1€ 3Ji3_éi? $€€ firg 91': {Z36 éeceased gaying iha': 'yam dial 'Thfi §€C_€:é$G€..T}_; -.(_{a:;f:i_;e"« % 01:? Crying. Thereafifir, thfi aceugeé eXti§1gu.isE:&:i.-éififi axigi '» 2 {$9}; the daceaaéé $0 €315 hagfiiai. Tirsée 'E§1§ haspiiai 0:1 1 8 / 2 ,2' 2888.
2:; 9;: E'?/:2;'2Q§8,"}'£'1,_'W.tfigvéfaiémfifii 0:"
izhe deésaamd as pg? E:§.P~16--.$ CRSQ in Crime F'€§,18/'ZGG8 Wag ;~'ré:£§§%i§{€r&;,'+§ gp3i.§é.i:1V:;§:tib'}' §;%f:§:faééeusad for the affences punishggfifié_~:;%::E§?:::.:s'ég;駀;r;_' a:;%gg,gA:% and 30:? 9? {PC} iii} fife? éifirge sheet has been {£166 agairggi {if}: 9.V§éU.s:ée:%; vf<3Af*V_: affances puzziahafie :,;n&er gsgwgggéiééi :;;zV:m'Evu:3;§2 55 '" -._ §§€ %i'_:':§; ihfi §§°i3$€¢E1'£§;G2': has fififiiiiiiififi £2: aéé .;§§i:;'g§g;.§gv----.§Ag';gifiiififg, E m 3.8% EX$.§»E is FMEQ 332$ ?si§.Q3i.i grgarigaé;
'?
{:£{:§€':£VEE,},E!:-:€:\'{-E 1552155: <;*;.2r:§}2£bi{% <3f:1'1_2':_K_§:1;:; .s;Ea'£e12'::2:'1£ 22:16 t._E':a::_:'::%§."0rc:: ther §§."E"1;}¥..1.§.{I"E&?{§ a}ud;__§f_11':a3':.'1i" £:'i.E'"£{§ :>r::i<?3" dz_:::;3:~;e: :'1<:>%_ {ire-2E2 £1133' in'%;m"fsr<:%z1{:<:~.. ii}. We §'12:x-Ye <:21':'e_£3;:__I.Ef,; c<3;'}s;i{i<:%1't%:'i '£.E'2é% ss;L,:E3_;"m_§;§:%g:T{;.::'15$ n12:d::7 by $119 Ee2;z:';'}e::ci {'?{.'}i.EI'}S%$€1 for 13:16 appé:£i21z'1i; ;;,«;':_(i ~ E€,=g2.rm::<i Ad=::E'1. 5.-EPPW _ E 3.5 The peim': Ehai: 2;:.:'.is€:§; far 0t:.{»::f <7ifgzfzcsiT{*3€;é':'?3{:'i<3i?*: i$.-§:: "---._ 1;' E»--ir'E"g(3E'?'2e?I' zhx-,> Triad <:7?£:_25u¢jf:' 3.142513 .2}; :':0;'m:':3i.z':':g {mé S€'F'Z§"{3I'ECiI'i§}' : ?'zVa? aca1a.:.5;é'5. .fb:' §'}'i€ :;§[)'£:22zce.;<s: g9::z':is§m§3£e :.::'5:é:€§3?* Ség?{.§"o;-is 4§8Z2§} a.: :fdV3€}2 QHPC?
E2, §::;*:__a:-2»-:;_é:m*E:'1£:§'§ in 21%? 15% '~,.*a,:"1?.';".:";é%s.;;<.s§é;*:»; ixx, $313-'i7$.iE. 'm * 113.3 "E"§1§£ WE: ;:2:*:~:=. .§3.W'se;-,2? E10 am?
$3,138 is; '€.E'";::3 f21§;§':<?:". ?f'iF§.§} €55; %:%1€é z";*;.{:}i':§'§é:':.'_,"'E?3§«'V;':§.§}-v.,iS '3:£'E'":?:§: E.%§{}'§.'} :::»§" zihéé <;§€<_:=<;%;j:s;e<"-ad :<'?3§3{§ £3.35. 2 3%; {E29 %3;":3:.E:é:%§"--§;":"«T§z:s;%;' {.;'_§'. <£e::é{:m:§<%{'%. .?*E§§m'~% «::s§' §.E:.a"::":": §';i.::v::% ::§&*:§3{>sse{§
4. _;:§*:j,F'£4_;;zg§.§%é§:'::~§E. éiiaa"-6 22:.<%<:':T,zs§{;=:{E. §2:3€fi.., §'§'§.€f§"{i' .2?'s'£'{';'f mi; 8 :7:E2eg_;;2T:i;.§<T}:':s; ii}? 33% %,:'€:%;;1'::"m:22':': zmgi Ehe:*'<:= m} €i?3"Ji.d{fi"1{f€2? (:23: §':i%<':<>rd fin' £3223 <:}%*i"e:z1.<:%{: ;3:,.::T1§:'.<,E3;r:E:.»1e uzzaier f%:é<'t,4€§é-':~§{;'%} sf EPCL 14;. in s-rm fax' 2153 *é:E:e:;'. <_>it'f»:%z'1<":.€;% §')i.lI'EiS§1£:i.bE€ :13'"2{£:,%;* $a:<.*;.302 of EPC is :;:ar'1<?<::"ne{i, Ex'?-E6 is the ci§,ri:'";§_;{ <i€s<:§ar;~:i':i<3;1~;--.__'E"h€:
gififiiiégg {i€<ii2:1"21E,3Z<:}:': 1/7:21:-'~; b::?:=z:'1 :"e<:'<;;r{£€r<§ an 'f:?;':»3,f2:€3¥Q§_-§_} » if :i?)<;> ::-E, 8 pxzx E_><;'P~I'? is thx:-7 }"f3(i§i.l§S§ii{}§'1 .2m<'i E§2:,P-'};"?'.§é1}v 1:15:53 V' a:>;')é:':i{>:'}. «::;;E" flhé? <.i<><:m:: 'E"'h<;% ::i<>:*;:':<>:" h21s:f{2p§:i'e;:<_i £:}::2;:'§ %:;§:e;:;::;:m1;;:
£59; m»:-3z'11'i2-ziéy éliféd §3hy$§c%aE}y {E3 ix} 'Vggiiksi i:§1€:§i."_; AS§taf.€n"*:e'f;§flB. "§'h<«:*::*e272fi',::;%1'1,. ;2m9§§1<::" :*a=tq:,2i:~3ii",£{>:': §§§%%»%1x..P¥'aE. bécfrs §,§ive;::"15 E1: 2§b(}i§.'f.i 9.25 p;{1':.,, {>11 §q'?.v;2.'2;«f€)Qé_=§,V i4§f:€:~- 5;;.z>_€?"'z::3i§:° E1213 €}§ii:":€:d ihai. 331%? p2::§:T_é:%1'";§: 1'-3%.-'£;:.5; -:1§:;~".::°:.s;§§%§§:r:::i?;,E3}"';v--~ .§E1%.,=~'.'e_'1i.2:':EfE§,.-Y' zmzi §:§'1.yssei<:-'1§§§; fiéi. in ggivssé am}; 8'i:a*;:€§'1:?s,c_:2'é'.. 2-*i';:E"1--é;'é"' -23. s:~:«pa..n <35 éfiéij 2191.1? the d<':»<::%,<}:" 212:5 {};'3§.:";.;»'~%§§ é.%:;:;,i', i.E'§é':' e:'§.§;%;;:§%23::;;<_*;d WE;1.S 21:71:: :11{%':';£"a:E§§; anii ;3E*2§;se;§<:.'--fi§j,f §'Etf=§_,{3 E%'5é'£'§'.iff§'1fi\€£5"Ez'.1iii. 'E'h:'r {i{:§{_%'s.:3;;' xx;-*%'3<3 E1215; ggia-'<%'1;: ::>p.§.:':.i{m 2:3 g>:'-22* E:x--,?:«..§'?E:1§'.";::£2{E="§§";;xa?~é§{22.} is»; E}:E§£:*a%:':E§:2::f:;7:.:"* zimfi E323: §'1££.E:?s 7,_§':{;i"E3éé%§':m §{:r;a;2:{':f;2§;i::£5{'§_ ;a;.r*;<.§ §"1{1§§' <'.2?é'r:{.§ 2,a=?§i.z':{I%:*~s;:-2:; ii': £555 <t2§'{{E<:::.;Ei. is: .1 §'°§:;:_§;.é: 'E.E2:'-2 {Z§C{,,'€f£é${?€§ 'v£2:::+; 5%: $11} 2":1;I:}«;'a*. 2: s:7:§.2;:'é4zamz3,nE, as; gm-:'° E E {Q / 9 Ef-xi}! E 6. '§"'E":€: 'E"r*i.21Z C<;;'m°t' E2215; (?{}.{iE'»'§{"fI';€',.{j§ €:.E'§<:*' a<7<:z.::~s~:.:;:e:.% §)aSt:':{§ an E3x.}53'-- E 8.
15. P.W.§} ths:-2 3"§'}€}§§1£*::" <35 {$1.9 :iee:ez;:s<:%ci. S'§"§§ "»§:2.1s 3fi42:a%;.&{i :;ha£:. %3s%§ws3%=e:'1 §'l.I.1}.. 2'::.m.i 5 afizé Size {§e:<§w:;:2::';;_§:::*:%..=;:é:;j:és~~.
{i'{}I}8{?§{"}§.N€:% gzzmfi 't:a1§k.§:'f:g;; 2-maii {hat ::.%=:~:-mass-.:€d "'§.<>i€i..."§f_2§;>;w:fu é;%:§:ai._ ':'.hé:
a<':m.2se{.§ pi{ftk+::a:i 1.: p qz.:121.rz*e*:.E in {?()E".1§'1€(;,:fii{'}i'}...'gJ:£'ivij}'§-,>7€,'§'iA§E"-§T§{3éi;§___ E3.<;s¥..' zmci pimzw-.~*:ci; }:i€?3'{}S€E}.€E zmd fire.-.__ '"E'hi$«.;'_;<é" §.:1<:<::§ssiV::ifV,§:_r1i. _§;>a.2*i*;.%£L; _ EXPM E8.
1%, PW ziihzzz f21:,%1:£:_r<_ :;f 'ii-éés ;:i=:;i'<A:«:3_2;;.zi§%:'-s:,%M E333; si:a§:s3;d ?é',h.:5:'£:
E:E":e £ie::§323;s;e5;§9;>fs%?T2':s3;.§i:,<3E: iii:Jfff"<:f?.§§E:.di§ii€§iT $0 znake am; si;a£:t:é:13ss:§}:,, '"§'}":<~: a<:c§.1s&;€3i*.'i. §":._2:s ' «crziiiii;gg:.zT:3§":Ta%;t§" jthfir fire: zmci E12155 :§s.,:s3:.3.§:1e{§ §;t";.ju:'i€se;. T§'§i"E ;:'2:si:'<:1;:a:<=:éi' Ezéigzjé; €;g:'§i%;é'r: :.h::*t tZi€',{.*€;'fEi.S:§€:£'§ :15} ":'§*:::*; b<>:i»;p§ta;'E zamgi h;?:$ ;é:?:§%;=':*',s'1'?;::%<%-. _::§'§ '§':§.";€:- §'£':','Eé¥.1i'.§'e;-"{"?§=:=§. "E'hz:':: atiéiédzgzéii 9:7 ii:Ei2{-3: a%§_€.f'€J.iTi1v<S:€:%€i §;§i}f{7<}§1-1%?§S§.€'E'E'§E--~--~~E'a?"iii': his; ggzzfiii. '§"E";<-322%-'3,*§?:3;"':-x iézae "§'ri2':E iiééaigi; éséza Ei".§{.§"iI, _§:;§:é .%.;¥;"E§'éd in :it:>z';vic§.'£:1§§ E:.'%":_§:% a:{:<?é1.:$€é{%_ §3.2a;;%€%<§ {Ha E:><,§7-- ';%i:g"'_~+:E_ea:§:g;:§"*:2aé;E023, '$1.22: %§§2g3'z:;;,§.:';aé{§ LE1; <§g::"z:*:;':€. agmi I%'§z*<is:2:* <':2;§.r':«.:.j':{3€'..V_ix:g'=:,.:s%'::..:?2";Z:":e:<:§ in E.;':a.z~:,;. ___m»..W..m,...-o