Karnataka High Court
Smt. Padmavathamma vs M/S Burmah Shell Oil Storage & ... on 28 September, 2011
Author: H.G.Ramesh
Bench: H.G.Ramesh
E';/E_..§'.;5§.E"~§<).£5E3 E. O,/2{3E .1 =::_&T A-5'? BAEQGALGRE EN THE KIGH CQEERT OF §;%:§'Efi Tfiifi THE 23% may 03' §EP"'£"EMBER 231 1 BE}3§RE THE §£§E'%§'BLE Z'§;£R§ J{.§S'i'E€iE :s::,:<*Nms:e.6919;3c{:;; 1;
EETWEEN:
E . SFWET §3Px1fl}?xf§S¥'%f£'§'§E"'§AMTIVKEE'; 217;' (I? LAf§'§*3 E3}. §'€A§T%{z'x':':'3;E\iA if{A(} 1'-3;{"%§?3E3 §\.E3€T)i}"'£" £32 YE?21~'s.RE§. J
2. E5-ERE. §",§'J=E%?;'x.§'v'?.£"a F€A{§ E3;'0 §.J'a"§'i§ E? §\EA§*ZA.§":%Nfi E'€.%7'.x.{'§_ A{7}E*II.} ABOUT £384'rfE%;fiS§{S :' ' av ""3 ;-:m we flue W-M >1 M"
3??
W' a £1}? {E 1,5-'{§"§3I ?3. 4 . _ s%{f§E§Ef) Ps,E-EGU 4 EEMQ'. §,}'i:.3»E"-{A_ . « 11> ,.»='<f: m;:"§e:. E?§'~éA§3fz'X'¥'AE'~§.{% é=i:sx<':;:__ " __ A€.':§:ZE.} gag-;<;>.;_;£' :39 '§"E§;X§1€E§ --- " "
;'-}§'.?af§'iI Ear«:.:Ja:-<:«:e;§--i'rv§: _ ' , Efkféi} :;s1'.:'§§:i1P.NA§is; "'::~;,§§--:_:*¥g.:'-is;:,:§a'§';--$5 «_ 5%.}EfZiIZi;%E3{i}E.F'i§ :3'? E-';:;a.E'<s:;. CH ..m'l . iii, ?{§I§E§§E"I}'§.iZ§\E"EI'f*§ {I}? ?*«E{I>\ E123 'E:4=?;{""};"*%:'*"€ $VS:§E§fi L. ?\5L§*".5E«N<3.€3E3 1{)f2{}'§ E in is:-1:2; in z'£:%v§E?+w'§:'1;,§; i';'.:=':e <;:"§'E::.>.1i. are; iE1€':"<% xrwzs; ma} éjrzm"
a§:»§}z?z:f:;2:%:€ an §i§'E€E" §'ea<'é&* <'i2'§' t'E':<% :"<:<%<T;*:"££'
3. 'The: L-<::2z.-*@;* §';§}§}€?§§2%.?§.{'.* {fiamfi ':1 E"e;%V'§<;é1é-Téii' ' i.~ <::E°<i€;,*.:' dafaéii 2i6,{'}8,,.C»E{}'1€} :1'1as:i€: 3113. £32': Ehfi gmi.,:z'1{i thzii ii; s:i§{§ mizi. {><:}:'§':%;§<1a§':'*$16».¢f*§?;§{':5: 41'%'::EI'~--._ TH xi-3€<:E§<H'1:*«; 33(2) and '?{3} <*;f '1§"i:".1,;e B£F.%"E7£? Qii; AA'i§;'i€.z£"; gflcqufisitian af fIndertaZcing$.--£;§§"fridfiaf .A'ic5€.,._A1VQ§?§, it ii-3 ':"s3;EeVa;'1'i: £10 mféz' {lei} i,E:':;%M _£3::»£§'<%§;{¥*'%:f:g :'::iV;:s§é:)%':":_i:1gg; 0%" the L-{}"%}'J"€§' §'x§>;;>€:'§;Eat':%. .-- ;C3@_':.1r"{.; e1t.'§3a:?"z:Lf{-E3 '0}? I £12122? <>rd€:"
in':p:_.: gr: eat} E1mi"<:¥.'§:";*-- . "' " ' "
f1_'{<2i§'E-i,".?€e:;{f§»:."7§f?:{* _€.'):éL;i.?_VI'E.(;?~f7Sf3ff} sgf' §§'a:° 1z3%§.::£.r':i'.§'_,§:?Z<s? :f>z.:€%' _s§:..:§.§ S§:f':;2%i§2.g?{-9'---gfJ§"::;gi>€s"§§; 2'5 3:0: 5:? (LEE {E.i5g):.:!¢-55.5 }<:.i:é:€>=_ :.:§'2distp.::.f"e:'i '_;'Ef§.<?z. §.§%{2§:
~ '-i::;zE;"e>€z:i;; Z5:':z'E;5. i_2§._'-'_3£"_%J w«:g;r:';'e{§ 5:': {E26 ;:;a>a:' f:':%:?%:}§ {zzéfé E5'?_€%'Q_§%)E'"£' ?"§'2e §.g%:z.r:'2s3(E. e:.7<";:.m;-:2:-BE <f2g?§;}é?€E?'§§'Z§§ M, T. " _;.:;f"e%_;..2:E5;:'2 EH25; :":3?'Z§'§1:'::§ am 5%;-?<:'§'i<>:': :T:¥{;:3} ".4 é'f2.?'§.€'§ ";.'g'_;'§f}; Q)" Bz.§:'m::3 $§'z{e§§{mi{g:,.;,zs;5:25:25': Q5"
Ha"::.2'Eé':§g%rS':.é§~:i2z§; 5.2': E:":{§£5a§ ,->'4"1{fi.? ';';'-E75 €§?'E€§ A {£{f€:'{;}2;"'{§i?'E§§§j 5: is €_f{§E'?.§€i§'E{§£:?{f. E"%2.(z.§' €95,235? .$5.3£.§.:'}§'E"E:2{§§{I*{§§§§; P1'-.?§'Eé'.'i.a§.?{,:"{;§Lf'§f}f"}(§Z.é?'§§§.éf?" :36} ;,;e;:z:':~»:, §:E?:§'z" 2".?':2'::; :'is}:.:..:*:' 39.533 s{:%§'«'{:§;§::§g:% Eézga {éféiiéff gycgsgwzjf $55.; Sim §{3:.:.'.><.>;" 2f'."£'l?£.i§°§ =f§?"E.§§.; am. Efae ;;r"z:>2i.:::E Eézaeii §§€§§€&'%§¥§? &%\ \ §ifI.E5'.A,N:3.{§E§§{) 28'! E §§'2.«:,=z'a% is no :i;£e:}pe 2::'z=:';Z.e%:* 3:533 £{:m..> :0 gizfs-;.mz"s;::~: i,"2z;.% :=;mT§i 53;; £r'z:,><.;-§€in§; ;2rz:>z:i.$i{}.r": (Jgf s><;.><'£.'i:;>z': EXEEZ €.IT§3C? as; gjsar Zia? {f::?<>z':-';i.<:vz'z. r'a?;;>:>:"f{:*££ in. §{{L'C1?'"€ i2€?{)8{2} .3 §'?§. Efizsi" I..3'2i::~§ {7{}U!'f Ems §'E.{,'}f (:5. £23 {sans§.{iée*:'ef_af:§'""
53.2' §;fi.s;:?:,::;3¢:<i :<:.E3»::}:s§' :~§<'><:»z;>g.> <9?' .;}mz::'.ss2'm'z :s:s;%:?i'i.m': 5{:Z} am}? 753] :3?" .--f='§1;»::"ma S?§'} »;='3E§ {;*a:?::gz.:.i5;f:::€c>=r2. <23" £.£i'3Cf{,?fZ€1?{€F'2€L] 2.2}. .{'rz;i:{§:':,2 a£§<:=i:. ' ' . . . . . , , . . . ' . , . . . . . ; . . y . . , . , $ . .
{U f;':{i£:>rE_§1'1i:1 g
4. E E'i;:1_(%; 21:3 §._§;*<):42..%.<'} i,:i%:f'ViV°§:4:r<3§::;2<:§:
E~i0w€-:ver., E <%.i'r*a';é<3'§: 'éhé? E0 (3is§}<}s:;€ ("sf €i;:*§ /2008 in £§<:{*c;3§'da:.'1<*:&i aariijfi. *%.$Q'§'%4E'$;t§'é1'w:'..E§i%':i:f:g§ §.:'2iE1[i«:i=:j1C€%:t§ by 't'h<:< <')§i§s?s€::"s.?z.':.§:ié';--':'1S' E153" "§}.§f;. {1%* @:€<3t1:'sesf¢? if EEK: {3r~:§:*::' %}:"}'1;:=s;:g§';€3{.% h€§':'*:=§*i:':v. ii»? _ "g_%::§*~: zziét -------- é'.h<i% :~;'f3§:iZ' i}';.-{}€}Z3§g. §f._E':s': E{i2w{=::"
a:§':p:i%§E;f2fé§.:;:: - ¥a:';E.§:§°é3§':'€i'.::2{.'i {£62 <i§s.%;§s'}s;=_§=€. <2? §;§'2::% {-1-§§"}§3':'.2?i ' s:%>;§}€é€§§_§i:é<:>:.:s:§§? " '~;:r:.::::'§ 1:2': 23..§':_j.,,-Y :';é¥<;t~z'?:1§,. §;:e::a§'a:>:'a=-7: €;':§":<=i :=é:'§§§ £3}? " ' -T 1 ' "E%%{,}'i')>€%§'E'E§}€.é:r. V_:.}'§{} E E 3