Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Zafarali Sayadali vs Bharat Sanchal Nigam Limited on 2 December, 2019
t OA No.434/2016CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI BENCE, MUMBAT.
O.8. 2190 /434/2016 Date of decision : December 02°, 2019.
Coram: Dr.Bhagwan Sahai, Member (Administrative) R.N. Singh, Member (Tudicial).
ok oe te ftv iS
i) Ph os wom cy @ rd oh Zz ret ayn siding a ~9/3-4 MBC Colony Mithanegar, Near Dutta Mandir M.G. Roed, Goregaon (8} ~- 400 080. .. Applicant.
{ By Advecate Shri G. B. Kamdi }.
Versus mene - s vo " r
1. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. mm =o --~. yt = < = ot * _ Through Chairman € Managing Director } pA ot oy mee Tha Uy we ~ i Sharat Sanchar Bhawan H.c. Mathur my a rorns Ne rm Wwe 1a P ANG bans Janpath New Delhi - 1ibge:.
ho el 4 very . tad Fy wy de £ ea he 3
3. The Superintendent of Fost Offices Nanded Dn Nanded - :
ita % P31 6G2.
as ey WAS woos ary RESCoOneeanes.
{ By Advocate Shri V. §. Masurkar }.
ORDER {O RA ) Per : R. N. Singh, Member {d) Present.
4 3 . by q -- + AT yx. ~ « i Shri G. 5 Keri, ibearned counsel For tne @ Re} re cs wo ws bt C a x w fon) 3 © 53 Ad i a St OF Ae 44 Ra 3 A ot ad c ny a 44 os "s 4d iY 6 aN 43 a 6 ot t 6a nt @ ved . :
uy 5 rae Bs Bb te MO TN OO Det ow aM cd . g ma G Be G4 I Moet Sart wh Tp @ #} wD i ae ity i, 3 "> DA No.434/2016 o ~ ff Bheed 2S GY LP ao? MG Et HG Sew WD > 4 q . co be a Rm 4, ™ he ed a od "rd as a A oO, kyo AS i ry oF cS i gt rm a : "CS Ae Ae ke OF " arf oo a by hs a C v iy 4 ae eA Oy et oe D wy Opoad "ed a , ea " in OQ 7 & " "6 wood Oy By E 6 Ow he ei tt oo ° ia @ G eo g " A GS fod y oO € o cS rr. es G 5 i 74 BOG 4 2 oe es iy ee oS aa G a 3 Cy 0 GS ay EO 4g $y O "4 an Ss ;
"tS wa oa GE Goa oe. o no FO B Hg a3 y 4 a; ky fk AS 4 oa an 44 ved bed ~ 4d co mo So Ea a go Uy ne 5 £ Me nd ad oe °3 a HG cane , va u "4 « 7 te Py a Sta ae we ey Fa "
' 3 8 a 5 a ay ba o eo ba wd 63 wy wt aM Bs woe x £3 ol eet DB a OK 4s oe af ' > p " = "rd v4 a howd pi @ S a o 4 or : ag it t ge gy teh oe td it La re oh M oe 4 bed Met ha eT ea si Wa ar Mt oa 3 a ms «es ; @ Oo By OD a Ns ss , oe a . i ae " we a 4 a aa G2 ig 5 "el © sf tA a 44 a ' th bee SS > cd Be aH 63 J ved my ng red rod w @ 3 Bo st 4 ; s j = "4 4 3 ref . Se ¢ fe eo " . Ly G i HO Bo Ho fu iB 2 2 poe F Riel abe. Fe -_ _ ae : , 2 . £3 AR. tee o>. ret re & is os a es & wm © oh a Gig © mo Dg Sel 4 OQ : ee rs) oo g red 6 «G Ba ty 1 , pa BA O.4 nt i fy BRB oO : u IE ta OY og Oat . on ne O " G mA Qo 4a pm & 0 7 a3 Wh cel tw me my 2 Oe * oa 0 a ed oe ty 4) OM wy O 4 hop OG a I i m, 4 fs 4 ef oy te Ly 0 > ba A vcd MM a iS iG 2 a uo 7 fy rd ws ne bet 74 A eS ut a rt 8) a es 74 0] % eg Q wh rey a a gy wt - i cs 5. og orf M4 yg GB she OC g ZS @ wy a 4 nd x x »
-
a e c Bag 2 Nee Maoh YA OGY a) " rt 4d Baa cM Bo GO PO Rk . Sa ® & a4 oO ~ QB 45 ro - ny . 2 g & co 4 f: 3 Ad bE ie $5 ea p ~ wt Ne wre be o th he @ oS wo Bk 0 @ A {> ty rs ( S 3 ip re me te gt Cy Ne OG . oA ot O es Oy od $ 12 i 2 2 rp OD wm g % Re my 8 oy os] c Ch .
ver} ed t se§ mm ws Os Ad Fa 5) t een a 4 mR.
S & & ry () t a «@ ae; u & ¥ WD ~ oS et <f ry f @ va ft & "ARTICLE ~I weed rod us TH G ot Oo arf at ni om G ba ard r?
wo bd wD eyed be
5) Che @ Aa 4 ty cr ard od ej wo 4 2, ig ay ed HK 22.95.2008 Gh TA kyr Ci o of a 4 ve, N we ©3 ) Tose rm wy Xy i ny pe ed 4 aR xed in tH ed ws fs ui
3. 4 nae © 4A
5) "G rod rod ard 4.3 * iG {x2 L ¥ ay & ved bed ky ood 44 Ls LS 3 oo "f Re def oo Oy ee G4 g a by ms ig rh Md a a rey seh if} mK ty oy A nef oO ad ved eves on ¥ che Se aod 4s Ww ARTICLE-IT a € nod a 44 "
is ba Shei at x * 2a TT be
0) oa A ot fu sty et ee £ de 3 ved 4
4) Sh comm itt ted 2 :
> * god 4 ie V 3 i J9,07.26 wed srl geet omy oo gt + Boal + eo het ved te ay MM GS ae OB eg rok ved OO O my a Oo "rd ts th Bt sed oct is
a) FA ted é re} fel aed "et am eh a a oe © bebe us hs ed a ~ No. Tar O oc iG "et 42 43 ty lack ibited 5 Ber Med:
Ag ' fOMmL ert oS ig dure the ric aA ee it ha ~, ¢ gE aa oo eof @ ood D ord Ney yt O seed arf ard aieaed ef arf Aeot @ y SO pha "id 44 2016 i 4 3 2 i Ut ee o.4 3 Pp 2 iy vB 43. 44 @ he sed $4 Ow y O a> 44 O42 SG i &o OO Sa oO OD. : OD M3 og 3 nt Ch ted TBoerd 47 3 a th ad. EG) 43 : Aa 2s ae rt @ at wo 4) 'e , thE aw Bo wy kgs gt gerd 43 " ¥ up th ved 5 ct wy & Ps 4 mo wg, "HO OG o Ly ee td 4-4 at CY Pt cea et Oh ors bs ony, '4 P74) te 3 £ i : Bs 3} As eg mo i, ; ned 8 ° 8 & GEE OE ep ae A yea ih rag AY Beds Cz 4 aw pe ' nen Sep as wy a ¢ 4; 4 ig AA 300% wed ity pa y at eee GE ee gy a WY aged $A 5 eed Se es ka Bes an Ege Sa Be ey, Be ao mM O on th oy ved eset rye Ot cd Ss & ~ om 4 a i, 3 m a dl om et , 8 Ok 4) 2 fy oA oy :
LT ~ wef YU ca at * Sp fe ge fy TR i w oe Eh, 4 rf ES py tf os "ort om a re) a fe OD a G co ~ var 4 DB ot we Oe J Ly rd G eA 5 ta. om 6B oO Ey OW rd nd Ct 8 se ln ts Om Cort Eg 3 ERS ? . ts on TH "4 a Os, hk 7 3G a Boar 74 . fe a 'a rs ae OS Wg Bog " Roybal a a 6G gy OB ba ge Oy Q UD ops th 4 i) ° ay wed HS At a ted ape pa oe Es hee a ae ced ond gat 45 = 7 3) 4 ae mo oad ' Ue 44 C Os UD a ef) rdoved ei Ao Oe ge vn a og te Ma, B 3 Oe gD ry o *h ol ved oy Ae veh Po yy BOM gH et Bog mo Be mS wl BY kg wed AD ot ha Ty WD ® uy od a aie ch "rd ba TS He Ci, 4 ye GE ed ag ij cs D mie Cy iis Y 4 AS ft by 1 Oy Cp sed PS hy ce im © ao @B an Ged 5» am © - Bb ER a Ma ap aes rel fa Be og fd) in 4 S Deed GO GG rt mS cs fe c wy ye f a a
-
Sey oe 8 u xX F a a 5 a 3 "4 oo, @ oa 4 rn are Weg oS ot Uy wi ved og wa a wm os es si a a re QS 5 4 ma % @ v is? bp cee 3 © 5 nm g 5 wn cf 'c 5 ea S tS Ss vies * , ot wd os tf tt i bed 4 By a od 3 a ent ES , wD arf cy bs a oe 6 5D ry me Sg eo Bay ao FR ga Ee oy ort 2 @ o hed ' 4 my na] ca ahd jaa] f apt o¥r ae 4 Boor a wha Ged GM oy get Oa u a en Moa et 3 4 ce ww. 62 43 A me ¢ "ny ee ep EE gt TT een GB Oe 8 ota - a Qvri Bay ms aa @ Zoe Ht pool gy U5 sp > 6D OR a NTR od WW gy Dae 2 iB fs ak 3 4 £3 ee a Cn CS ord ed ID Sg ed 4d 4 FA ory 4 rd a 6 ae C 4 bgp ert bb ER Ad oe OW a -- 0S "4 Q OOM «a i @ em DO OQ ort Ge Be ew We 6 nD oa a4 Gh OF Bc it Co wm & a wo mM 3s ao @ gb «<F gE 3 ws Bed SE ad Poet OG as Us a he how ch UE fe Se ae A - kt «4M OO Sto we : vet $4 GU O OG GO OO th ep ARTICRE-TII ARTICLE-IV 40 Chom & ed Oo @ is 2 fa bh Ou am ot to ooo Mt Go oT bt tH o-ed NE 2 uc OS a i n mq seed ux % iD G bt on} i> wd : " tg. i) WPOPLOOLPOPEPOPEEPEPEPEP EPID ED:
Af20L8 Fy e 3 .
ce gO ct ¢ 28 A BUG GE tes 1 4 Aed aa) bee En cl £8 oA o 1 B dB OG os @ gE Go wos o Go 4d © oi od a 6 Gm o oy 0 a " As > a mio Ea ® ye x a wd @ a po Es mt a i fs 44 : Sy Be fo oe stot F rob oy rt rt fas gS a fou et ot in oo 8 ie at 1? ge oa Ge ee ee So OS gt , wf ; CS OG oe Ce 2 Le Sx la §e my OO 8 fi oa ho § ot ts we 5 9 6 he © be ; wD oe ved bt be mm 2 O43 <p ', ce ~ ~ & a : uy @ 3 4 8 a Bos '"o enue 5 a oo me Gg mo FH c a aE 4 & gwen ao Bo og oe eo OS ~ @ Looe » ° a ai BE gr Bo 6 Hoy «6 ERO 43 See BS 8 yest @ Ds . . '3 ord cf @ Pe Et 44 Ky "cA cy uy TD Co oe a ome ~ od 4 q n * 43 bi in CG i wh +4 oy gS Wom % ts cos td tom 4 me ES © « eh ord op es mg ' s ® Ww. Aa " & , «fo Wh i Bo 2 ms <A oa By a > Q mi & im Ro Se oa BS wt mo Bag » BG Bg ma oo OG Gs & Go ee e a 6 # ~ 4 OF Bye Ss Ck gy es ef & ved "t wy wept 3 o "a fF wa rd ts Oy i a 3 od * BE ot a "p Pes mS ox 6° Pe OR 2 uv J . 1 Or mq ert & hn ~~ 4 Pep a C5 a, & oO @ oa > oe en OE yy s3 0 Sari ti G re YB Bs Mee ug Bay SD Ca Per os mp 2 BER ae ge SOR Seg Loe Mos Gp. ¥ it og Hed ug) tad 5, 6 2 So" ns we fj oed SP BU 49 "oS , ro Or G po j cone © 3 O74 i] 6 2 ; et oF Cy 10 4 2 Me te ~ fst , C3 to eo, . O fr 4 Sha cian Ls 5 "4 mS, r A Atty th, < Co ype" oe a tr ' ot as G & ea m3 Ge wp (o,f Sed eh alm= g Mt iad ad be RO gc Ra 4 oOo He Ho a rep yg NS gO ge © OO & @ £24 A ye 4 : 3 + QO 43 4 ws GOP ayo sek ol of 4 iy Gd yy > > °G wed fa * 54m Res a4 oO SG a «EL EB ty ty 4 The as r~ Ay GS j es eh 5 4 i Ct Ey ey hd oA ped 'i i gy OM 4 oO goo . Ob? oy GO geet Za « P & y N r 3 a aefH gweo U8 mm @ " Vy ty & . oO nent Bua hs Bese Ba Bg Og" ~ ee DR epo fuk wp 5 GO fae SESS, 8 8R s pb oo Oa Ys ga i poy & mg oR yy i 7H 4 ad e NO 4 Sea fae , {r~ 4 (epi % * y mp uy #) wD 3 {x} Oo 4a oS A » 43 3) , @ So 3 Ch Ep oy OS :
ay 7 gee B Bo OG mB wovclag & O Aas wt rp BOS oa 2 3 ge @ So ws Hod be 4 wb ed Cy bed at <4 ee oO v 4 4a * 43 ta fy (O48 ct oy UM gh FR ay i . s . 2 oY i> o em thy Se a BO dg Eee t~ ALS Ad p ; Pa ;
he Ne 2 Ds ras] oe a ka a 97 rege card sol 43 £> "
' ie i m+ 4 43 <> : ss ~ yet BIO w+ a » t> . ~ t got OR : Le eS a oy : iS: im @ - ee + Saat OC Oin HOw | i¢ thm 0o GO Ob oo . $ . Q ee g tt POD CR ed ed et st oy a +3 Go £3 mo c 4 cite eh oO Me ay Bi ha a es *. 300 bet TO re OG 43 8% ai * Fs tO O WW et ri 0D Che ra id Sach Kap ONS ye Ao Ons Np Oe 4 Uh od WD wd Oo eM eas is 2 as Q 4 3 4 CP ok Sy i C2 oC « Seocnnnetnetee cd, @ fo art
3. hed ws 3 {3 4.4 ae @ ged ser} reek at co i tye} abd wt Pu n ~s O ?
a) a i oot 2 Cy ee CHLEY ey £ Se NA ae ~ a "4 By Cy us Ba ka $4 3 3 Oy ' w3 a ed, yer ay C2 ad nerd he nt Le F ed 3 ng Bu vd M4 ay .
eon oR opel be, aa 0 ® Tal Ww 43 ow] ch & Ch red.
?
on "4 iy ' ~y re An é BOLE STEELS & z 5 Oy cond ® hed 16 si ms Ai cry x OA No. and ped ye & defence i key a3 vd ta $4 @ v4 om weed "
rca Sy od asd io.
co pi y oy 2 << a we
19) 34 vt ae a £ BR a a hd "3 a wit ¥ ho fe vee eG, ¥ } Ne! 4 os iN rn of york os mS ™N NE Ww Cr oS rt o oy od eS Gi QO oO 44 mS aes ne 44 & "
ip 4d 4 si5) ved & ra we @ red M4 Py §2y £3, wi ved cm wa on ba & ner + fy weed hd bs a @ "$3 {Xy ug 3 4.3 3 ae ob ira) bey & fet set ® red Yd Qs @ Qy £4 1S?
ged m> sd » ee od gd fy o = o> a wy ry =~ G woe <G oO "4 omc 3 eo ' oh AG © td ved Sa 7 aS > . Q owt bee nD vt my rek eo bp w "4 ont Bo Bd 4 & w £5 Dm ved ip i334 " athentene inna rre ses an 3 Li.
MW vt i3.
y a $3 art &} @ @ Ave hk rel Naat cnn att 3 {3 q
5. whe ee $3 gy 44 ard go ver voor ot ved se tt uf i,
4. kA ce & i 43 ca "se reed 3 ww Ke Ot Ad need eed a OA No 4434/2016 tS o 44 2, ard u | 43 ERS ed YaCeLy y sot only + +
3) ay ned cea wo 4 aforesaid ba urthe £ sed G @ harg icies ofc art "4 asd tb $ ao 3.3 As et D wet SA ae mg fa ted o
(i) gh gy m 6 ce ver} spf iss qt i4.
orf Boh SE oA ty kd mm by Bown Usd conc) 1232 AIR 1596 SC ae State of Tamil Nadu V/S SS. Subramaniam.
15. oF 1988 (1) arn Ramamurthy reported N. Tamil Nadu V/S KR.
\O ted , 5 x v °C w 4 sn eg a << 43 as 3} C = on be MA Yo 4 1 i) m aged oa wD a g ge § " oe Jo € ££ £ 6 2 gs °
- a7 bed "ey wt " heh et tt as ei a w& YS 4 ; > oy oO 'ad hed 44 43 sy 3-4 rs roc w th er a . Md we ed hd As os (2 23 ~ a oa eet % «ied c ' : a red 2 gq ng Og OM 43 ri Gort 8 } 4 {. > ui. ¢ pee or om - ti t ; ft he £ ) vee be ae ot uy st CF t i iu gy Oo, "4 ws @ a . 3 be . ¥ eS G bed os i os a a He 2 vA My tr , mo ta @ 93 Q f CG a 4 0 wn , eet @ iG es ed oF A . ms 4 i ie * " C4 ts v4 aot on ts re ++ _ ys a e we SB Oe ~~ @ © wo m4 we « ar + a A & q wn S xk "e 4 i es a i D w if art 3 4 * q @ oe Q i or a ® 2 we 4 4 ' 44 & B bt ' ard de 33 ad wn % M4 O 6 sO i 4 oye) & ee 54 ao 45 Os c ved w ' R iF) t Md f a - - 4 " Ma "3 O 3 5 . SS o o 5 oy rat 8 " ra 3 a) 3 (3 ty \ wD o i : 4 ved w ot n be eo. & oa cea "C4 ro GC *e ' i ard re ' fe i i ss ua - ne ord cS wD é 4} vt ~ ee £ fa iy ra Xe 4 43 a | Qa wD rod ee Ci on : oo aged 4.3 £4 j.3 saeany ey bet at 5 ve a ne om, oe 4 wy +4 o veh , i 0 os Cy ws 4.3 Ae 7 Sh, , c 4 Pas Bt " "
4 5 bel ; a QO a oa a. ° . rt oP ted ry ad DB . ha 4 me w in +h a vt a ni GG vod a A <3 Go a hoy 5 2 00OCO eB GO ee o 'a os 5 Pon Boe & iy ot aS a eo ve "F3 ued Gh 43 a a "C5 $4 ood 44a go ® a ored i & " 4 ay C & u q y big b , ay G3 QB be B is ct a Se is 4 ~ @ iG th oy eA ws my i oY 0 & 7 § @ wy 8 OM om Oo 8 6 & a 43 4 G * 4 iw 4 "5, M4 a '. a 13 Ba O & sg Go fo. a en » MO ° OM a 7 C: cA ns GB 8 oH 8 6 8 Gt Fa @ . 4 ra a @ cs ay a Gh g 0 he ; 4 a3 as © 4g O oO ar in es $4 as a ire) "eh edt Ae Cc x te "
fy ' 4 de cs cc s @ 1 1 ay 4 3 re on "
c SC @ OM wR oOo fo @ got 5 oe ftp 7 J th 4 et a srt ty ES "v4 © ; Oo sei od 1 ved ce : i : ca : 0 i 44 " « oot rf x ts it my Be Ko a m4 vf 6 a rey A - ey Pow a a ot i a 2 Q wy 4 so a / to OQ aD Oo a a rE Ad 0 a a4 wy > hea 4 ; Ss aod 4 OQ oo é 3 ar ot o a "4 arf ¥ 5 3 be 4 i " Lh 1 it5} Bel Ct Ci ord a4 ej 2 4 ha sed is) bet of 4 Q re 5 $4 : ee a ) ' ' tf a a, ° he "5 ay t hi ay &4 4 G3 Th, a 5 u ae) a rod tc - "4 oy 5 a i Ba 74 "5 ct hg i £S at te srt o (G @ : f ty by er gy af whey ~ 'g * a oe a a e a a ot " uy O i $4 , , a 2) c 44 "t ty rd od t . had - apt . hed, So si ua 'i b a g hs od 6 ed a a . , $3 ve} 0 An 7 % 4 . 7 5 7 C3} gt a a) fd * a3 is) py b a uy on § be 4 43 of , Med 4 o e vcd Py owt @ od G Y a oO o Sot S wt 'j ' A te @ au a * mn as @ ° " ee ' i iJ 4 <a rs .
4a OF ; 2 me 0 a a GF oS ke val ved $4 ved mt 3 43 ty, . B i iD i tn vd ay ae Po 8 wD oA Bel Cy oO » UO B a oe e 23 28 oe 2 & 8 . & 8 "8 HOH @ OE a ® 4m ad 4 Ry it rt 0 a at tm is na a io 3 "s v3 4 B "4 Es a a an a " (1 rc hi ¢ Pee a ev oo w iM s & §& 6 & © o & 6 So & 8 g 8 © ~ ; " € 7 > a oy Jd rei . eg i xed bed «v4 ' oS oA 4.3 ws rn ' 3 4 rs} he mn oe a a3 rt 16 oo 4 =i ty Noe Zz LP OA Vy be annot a ecw G4 i ci} 2o.
be nnot ey wk Q iy a8) bed ve hy 2i.
STS .
ee Net order as to Bhagwan Sahai) Member {A} {Dr "Singh) Member {J} + (R. M. a