Karnataka High Court
Shankara Naik vs The State Of Karnataka By Channagiri ... on 8 July, 2009
"E
E353 mg: £~i§{}§~§ {,'i{3E.E'E%'F CI?' §+2;i,%E<E NA'§';~§§{é':,
m*:£'E{3 'mg SE3 "£'E~§§: saw §§s§':f'*{}}§' :2{T%f}*§§«'.i'AV Vk
£;:e:§?{::12Ei'~%_% X'
'§'HE2 HQEBLET EVER :}USi?;7.' §{;E§E: ;§za;,:'N'gaL£:l§a,¥'R?AJ"M
ca1..A; :30. $®2*ALf:§'2.ge5 ' '
BEQWEEENI
1 SE%A§%KA,-RA" " j_ .. ~
Sjfié <:§-i;::M:%§<?f;2iA E>z;aVz§~ai;'*«."_A 'a '
<}€3€§;é;GjRii{;;..*vV
R gzarz-5 L2'-'gfis/££%:%l*€'{" £3?»
RA/T RE;-%R.AV;%N;¥l* 5f§~1«;.{5;35éi)A,
:':§;x:~;rx:g*s;:f,§:2*;:f:*<;a,2_ A
{;'éx;::%:9A N§§j%€,~- %%%%%
.4 «,S;'f}f:1EE'§;%¥'A PEAEK
!%;{3<E§E:3_ i:E«'_?"'~'{T'f%:$,
_ V{}QC;;§§REE%.,"'v..
*§3fA'F.§E~,§£¥§§£ANE HY {1';§;S"§'.E';9
§;;%;'::": }:»'}";';;Rz%,V&E§..,§Z '¥'.E-iél'€.§};'&3
CEi,sXE\§§;>EA€§IR£ Ti},
§~:E:«ERm Nzéfiéi
$3;{> YENKANAEK
9333 A0823? 56: ms,
" ${}{)LEEg
R/$3? ms THE: BCBEDEZR «:3? ExiiA§%iAVA§'=iJL
r..__~(*-.....--«--\,..-
2
4 :3: MA'L1,£;tS:~:A?pA MA'§_3,,A??;a
31¢"; §'~EAGA13i3A
AS153 ABGEET 623 ms,
Rjfifi' G::%9§:NA§~§ALL: "x?£.LLfa{§§f;,,
€1Hé.N§§A{%§RE '§'Q., ' A'
{By 3&1: RE:EjB§:~m;a{":<>§&, _
RS. PRASANEQAi{UB.!E.fi§13V§L"1f&.}:)Ef()(E;f;*£'§3Sv.}
é;E\$Q:
E THE: STME: G? K£a$:§A5€;§§;é,§'§g['% CE?ié§'%lfiGIRE PQLICE
§AVA2~zgGaRE,
RESP. ass LE:a:~e§:'§;D 23?? ~ » E<:«:g;><3N§:E::~éT
{By 3%: é§5~{5.RA;§é{;%i§'§.£§%VS§i_I€5;S~'Z§?';E'E:§PEJB£,E{:
€:§€L.£§ ;~':L§::;":;j':::€.;2'?"%».é§.;>.{::§ 8'? *:*§«:§§ A§¥J'if§£".;%TE F'€3E€;
THE 4%P"Pf;ELLEs;}'E«1"'}fSV _é:;GAiE~Ii§'i' mg sjuazmmmfr §;:~r:: ifiogsifié
_?ASSEE:i{: BY 'FHE=..S'J.,. fl.é§'~f§EN&GERE,EN S§{',;.§'%§.:3%'G} ~«
* C{§}£'€'sf§£?TIE5iLxi§ A. THE "" "APPEE;LAN'TSjA{3CUS§§T{} FQR THE
3{?:§8"E?EI3¥*$%C';1E?';,S ~«§?;{:}";f,S S53*§ 9? LE. ACT Aééfl U/S.3G%~«A 2/33 34
®i€"'..EP:§:': fi;N§}.._'S'Ef£*$§'E3NCING THEM 'TC! U§\E}i}ERG(} RI. FQR (mg:
YER'~5§:*E}3 'E'}~§*:*;§";fi:'RE ALSQ Sam'-Emm T0 PM 5 ms}; SF
"RS. iifiafiggm .§EZ%{iH 0?? ma TS LFEDERGG 3;: g ma 2 ESETHS
zviagg §'f7}LE=Z.f1'HE QFFENSE P/{E/33¢} 0? LE AC'? 1933 R/E? 34»
W §'§§RT}IEK SEEQTENCEKS Ti-EEM T8 U"§§§E§G{§ RE.
}¥'(_}R YEAR AERFB '.'e;f'HEY §E~€E ALSQ §}£RECi'?EE¥ 'K? PA'? 1%
" CIF' E§S.2$QGf~ E§%.CE~'§ QR E.§,,. TQ IJNQERGG Si §?€}§€ 2
' MC)E*75f'§'HS MORE FQR THE QFFEEISE ?jUjS.3$éI-«A Rfifii 35% OF
T _ £'}'77"'.:i.~T§T ES §'{§R'E'E~EER GRBEREB TBA'? BQTH '?E"£E SEE'§T'EE,?€€§E§§
S§£.s'3:LL REE CC31'§'€3§§REE*éTLY 'JVFFH Efiiifffi {f)'§'HER.
TEES AFFEAL €3€}E'e'fi7é'€f§§ {E53 98% I§sEz%.E%EE'€{} '§'E§§S E}:%'{,
THE €i€3'€jE'i" ZQEAEEEZ TEE F{}LL{'}WiE{}:
£..'_("\.-----\/--4
2.5.}
flméamnr
3*:-as accused Exam 1 $3 4 in S€ss;i€§1'}.':§4;{L?a--f3& ,N¢;,%V::,<2;A2§::{)'F'_;.« 33:;
aha fik: fif the 1e:«2z*:1&& SfiSSiO§"iS ;}:1{E§£3,__
f*efsrz"e& is as Trialfiourt fer §§aE;e_ sjg3:'eséi~iéE
appeai aggievad by {he j;:c¥.gme;1§"'a:f§:§ 'firsfizer 'C@m£%%ci.i@§2 dated
36/63] 2305 §}3;SS€€§ in s;x:{:21sed-
appeiiani Nag. E #70 $531' {$6 §§§i7€'iI1€;*e S»v §;:;§; {'§r3%{' éaztiiezz 3&4 Ex af {PC
and Sactimr}. 39 £2?' 'E:":§cfE~i;:5:T:. v§E%;}£:*;éi:fiCi€§r 94:2: ham': 2* es: ésectiazi 34 Qf
YE){l
W
in a§§§'i*".'§f._§§1!3 $336 if the prssa-irutiofi ¥éé*ai§€g€é
.%V.f:._tE:.é'é;:§%::i:v;}i2;§§::f, ElX» PE filad by the Cafizpéairzazit. zzameéfg, PW}
$ha§:§§§a§pfi §";'j_%'§?'§;a:;:11ap§aT is 33. ':::';{§&:*:
" H "€L?{I1. 13/877' 2%? 3: abam 8.38 $2»: the
AA {7*'.'§EZ1§.} i'8;:iI£aflt'8 father, the deceaseé Laxmapga? S;'C%
'Ra§:gap@3 %2'é?€f§i ta E3313 iané. At abaut }«@${}fi IEGGE1
}¥'Jh8i1 the eftsmpiaizaazgt 'éifiiiii is $33.6 }and {er givifig
§"!}.I1€:I§ :9 his fathar he fmmfi him missizzzg in thee
f_____(-'-9/"-\.a-"~"
5%
E3116, 1%; 33%} PM ha saw his; fathear iying {ieadj
the fefica 0%' 5.11% {and 3%" {>123 Evigaki
Ths camplairsmzt, §1{}fiC€£§ ma? his §'a'§;he§;f_3::a{u:f:":V<;;o7;f%:1}{{%'$3.;3
c:0::u:a€:%: wifsh the barbed '%%»'iE'€ ' §$:9;t; "£9
{he {and aria-::7'? the Said r»§o9;::.g4;}a;:=:3. :%4:a;1<,a {.P§é%é3;jj:%VTiJ~i
which was &§_e<;i::*ifisd bfyfiaiging' A':3:1§:f;'i{ii%€§s};"s:1§§;i§; A
uzxatitherizafiiy fmm the Eigm "1i:'a$f}$i_{"1g Viffzaarbjg
$116 $335: land fer 1;hé::4_§}:.Irp_:§§a:_ :l::;:'§' 1. ._V;§'";*%x,%<5nti:"§.§ the wiici
anémaixs entering " Eazzci anti
C0§1S€qij€§1§£.y4.:$L1$t8;§i;}gé§if§ V. 'amci died 5:?
the 3991:. _
3. G:*:'~j£he ':§;a$"i':% Said Camgfiaigxi, €333 1301166 {)5
_i'3?18I1§1{£¥..§_i§13§"V'i}'.?.S. é:f.._§}ava :§:agere Disméct ragisterad 2: 23.56 ':33;
Eitizzié: ._3'=%9¢ _1:":3.5-,5Vz};**9f'9? far '(:16 0if€fiC€S undfir Sfiflfifiififi 173?} azzei 43;
V $5 fizaégxg Act mg rjw Ruiaa :35 am: }.38{_%3} of she
1::cz:a::é.';¢:::;i<;iiy Ruiaa 195% and ugs: 39% A mi: agaskigé. the
AA Eiaiogké' Rama Eéaika. {ha swam' Sf 'She $315 Eami and fig
be against fairy; accaréimgijy. Buiéxlg the
st-
_ Qéimvéstigaéisiz ii wag faunii that E136 accrued E03. 3%; {:3 4{
§"€$§€€ii%?€i}='" appailani Neg. 1 E0 5?; wmfiz regpansffiis far ééiegailjg
afid I1§g}ig€::a€}§: eiecméfyiizg 'aha 3&3 wire femte far {ha pLE§'}T}O$€
e'-----(f"__""""
S
thereibre ztharge shim: came ':0 be fi}€i€Z'a"3'g8;Z'fi1Ef§Z théiai ffbi' .{:i}e 'L:3a,i{iL. '
<;~§'§'€1';{:€$. ?}"}€ "E"*:'iaE {:QE1{"i §:*amé":<i"'.§$§}:.£%i1'g€:$"gggéigggi: :€é;.§;"T--.%;h€
amused 3103. E to % fer {E33 {2f§7e::<:j§i€e_%»::f&;V' 3{3éi{$,}'~.;of'..EV§'{"3~ sifié £355»
3% af Eniiiaa EEe:";E3'"f:::i?:§2* 321:2: 'aajih ;--g!_};v u:E':'a¢c. 34" 'v£?§§i'4 and E3}; $.23
irzggmgnfii jazdgarnani. 3:151 {21_"{*i€:'--- {3i£' q5<:%§:f;e*E{:'3:Es:}:"; 3:16: S€3E'Y€£§1'1C€
cm1vici:€:<i and seggtaizgczeii fiizmxa ~f;é}"I~' '_§__"2s_3;:h Elie: SE-lid @fi'c:«::z<::":&:¢
3%. Aiéamfir, heé?;:*{i "{'i~":§E- a:'g%;::::é:';i;s ai' §:*'~§z*§E*.E%»'§a}:'::::«a§?:3 {the
iearfitiié C':::m3.sé:£-- V ap;3@§§a_nt$~»a<:{:':2$€:fi émd SE1
1%,'! .§€a111a}<?is1é;:'::3_; €;7%:€::= Eééggrifaéé éiigh {§{>1:§'{ C}G'¥§'€'3E"§"§IE§.@§'i§, Pfiézaiizisr
I-faiiéé ";::a'5:*::;.:";&{§;~~ fiiiff iifigfiégfiééi jiziigzisni ans: 35$ {he emtira
2:1%;z:§é:f§_a§ 1'?}:i%-3{§(§uiiiE_ 331:: ayigixzaé. racgrdg €}h'§3iI}€~f}; frem the 'E'ri.a}
2 ''{';{;u::*':. $9 Sxzbstazéiiaie the :':h33:g{~';s Eaafafiiéii againgfi. {ha
" iyj:3¢:;:.:,:$a€£~é;§;jg駧1a:3:s far {.3353 sari; afimigcasg $36 §m$ecz.::i@:1 has
A '§'§:% €}:3}§%.f§i§}€d fez' ii, PWS 1 ta 3% and gcst markad *a_i":<~: gimumarzig
'}1:§M_§§.}:}f1ibi:$ P1 ta 9% am}. MS 1% 1 t0 3, 'E'h€ defense {éfilfm
VA -fizircused being Esta} dfiniai, §}.'§€§=' havfi 219%: chgsan '£9 get 331};
%¥§'{fZ&SS axggrsémad may fiié §§1e:§? sham 2% file an}: {i{;Cu:11€:1': £92"
t.§§€1n., ,___r-.....\_,..
33. ("if the Said :5 ¥¥'i"§Ilff3S€S§ $163 p1":>F3;:%:<:'*::?:"i%f)r:3 ;;i;aicé>;.«;i' ~--.
raiiarxcfi -an the evi<i;.er1<:::=: of P1553 2 {:3 3:3: §_~'£T?,.}3Ti ézgirzi. fé-3 'i2;f:'-LL;<;>;:*'?';,::%1' :0»
{3€}I"1}f1€fCf. the aacused. Naa. 1 t:: _f=§~..j;§:'i*;E:£ '~iI'§:&
aiestxicitfifi frag; the main igme to fézfice t11at was
put 13:) {he lanci cf PW3 fer the puztpase of
hunting pigs. '{§';3.f§rt13iii.;¢i;t:;2.1§}1§ §§i§é:'é%:11ti<31"1, afi these
wit1'1eS$es I;a«v€«~'?§1:;'Ii{:%§'i3'. hcésfgikirz; $:G:va:1«§;W'£7£':€y have cianictd tha
s11gge$ti0::1s §31:i:'*fi;: §,%ila::I:;.4 §:;§§ the iearneéi pubiic prosecutax' in
their €rQ$54e§{a::1ir1a:i0§1. ai~"t:;c5':< {beg Carzjae it; '£36: 'iraateé hssifiej,
that '{1}€y_Sif:1i€:$fi"{);;€fE¥V1"{Z 3:6 respectiveiy as per exhibits P2 :0
I- 'P5v,,. }3a.sa2:9jar2gja; Naika has Statéifi in his s:XamiI1ati0n~s?.n~
ffhiifif' 1:§vr_i'i;§ie3;.::ti;3r:te 0f the iiacifieng ha saw the aecussd N0. 1
' ~.ru§::€§:1gM?:a1rii:';'g{; empty bag axzd, an thee max": flay ha saw SE16:
fiagd 'e;3ai.§,; +:§f the: zieceasfifi iakshiizappa. in a Fsiaia. '"§§1::3:::;gh he
:k:;=:$ Astiatgé in his ::r<>ss---sxazninatiozz $131 ha was ksizewimg that
f;§;.é"'._?d;é:c:i2$6<i *&;&:'re Fainting pigs arzrfi {ha}; aged :6: gfii the
é:i€':{i¥:i'i€if§? Suppifg fmm the main fame ETC} E316; bayfiazi wins: fsfiacé,
VA ie has éieniad that "E16: has aimed befere ihta ffiéfliétfi as per é:§e:E1ibi7t
(.......f"""*---""'
'?
as P2. Similar is the fiviéemce cf PW3 Rama @1133
deniad the suggastian sf {ha ieamied' 'P1;:b£i¢' ?ri}.s§éi§i%?i€§;*--.i?héMt; 0:";
12/13?} 199? {I16 accugaii 1':r:::»:::kV ei€cAi§f§é;--{§' :~:L£?{:;i;§§ .1;.::s " 'A
fencing wira fmm the main £3316 iF'7ii?Ef;"*:}:"i€ §§Ei1"1Q§€}'Si€3:"'§}f }:f}:ini3.'§i§IE§§ gigs.
PW4 Sim. Kariggmzxza, i.r:,:::...\§,:=s,?ife,A:}f i:.'"g5:: dfe<:eas€fi"<ha?s @111}? siatsé
in her eXan1ina{i0n~§.:1-chiéf.' 'éhatf' ::1€;3:' "Ei;..§ éi§_ar1(i éiieé «sine K3
eiecizic Shfifiii. ~S::_»a alga. §i;;*:s §'E'3€3 suggssiion ef {he
4,.../'
9rf:_I=c'_ -, -_ v.
iearned p£zb1i<:€.g}:'<::%f;£§€%¥%fi.fi{'a:'~ éésiiéed vs>'€:r5 :r€Sp<::3sib}€ £31"
cé%1¢<:f.:'i%'},;i11;,"%:»fé"*£:%'3%c5: {A?._ :g"{}_ 1 E have alga siataé the
Sfitlilfi. filf ..Vf'£L}y::s§"': H} 3216. 1} fiavfi cieniad that
$::ggesi;'i«:3~';':3.p:«;é ._;_£'/4N§:€3;'}7t.'V'bf%,r.'.'..¥Z§'1€ iéarrifizi P'1:§3li{§ Presacutay that
rsspectfigeiy as per aX§1ibi"§s; P3, P4,
95;" 93-$3 Subsiazisa {sf Whixtiza is éaama as axhibii
[W
.. AA ?'§*¥13 ?@6:§»::::. Naikg, has; gtafged 33"; his €3X8fiii§1a'Ei0iTE---i1'1--»
<::hiéi'§§}fiéE ha £19458 :10: Emew haw the acauged wera :'6:sp8:1sibi€
. ' ':'%;€V:"7£l?:e daafh sf {ha ziaaaagsdg He has danéeé {ha gzxggéaiizm :33:
"aha iaamxéég Pubiizr Prase hat E3333 Rama
8
Péaiiza used :9 iafi the aacusssci *é".hat 3:62}? 3E1@:z}:"§..~~--.':*_:;:§:1ij._'_ .é;}:{*:
@1&{:E:ri<:§t§; {':QE"§E1€{":ti@Z"1 is the fezaairzg fmm fiié: 'gmié 'E3'?;(f3f;x!'"'__
gram 332:3: i;é$?esr:2_§;:{1g E0 Efigm. He hiafs ;aA{§1:_?.%'{.1£;&:Vi "§§3'-.z;§.fS§"g:r§sg;..__
fixéiffliiéfiiififi xszmde "by the I€aE'i'Ii€{i Ptibiié: ¥rcx:;s::9*<;°:f;§z;+:}£* iggégz: 'EL-5
dscfiased Efifiii 251$ 3 :*@s1;}'£i {sf €}@C'ilfi'{3_ SE1{}€}i iszifitafiérafaéfi, 3:23;" him E332
Ciéfiigiilg $33.0 camiaci with sgééci-Vf€:1:3_:i:'ia?%E:§ch was $§6€t§'§..f.€§.,
Thig adméssign €3€}f;?'i'$ mfi gay' -.gx:a§;' ""i::_@'Ia5';:$l f§§'*1& §£'i3Sfi£Z?;.13fi@E"?.«. ta
Qanzxaci the acg2E,s@:§i'"%;;;£E:' .1338.' i.E1_e;§a§"3§e'c'£.rifi€a§ien sf $363: said
fence: éisjhas ¥::?§':é;":.:*i_j;'VAia3:a:1:é%;i Eizés further avééerzca $3323.: he dgéd
:"_;.<::Ei 38%? a1T1};@:3f '€316: §,a<:{fu;§::>{%§["a:§&:*€:*i€}?iz1g ihé: gaié ffifififii.
Y?' é"§:;s<:§fsm thus: fiirisiarxaa sf PWS :2 :0 5, 1%, Ti .1 grid
§h"§<~;i :~'£{3r:SifieF§é gpéniefi iiifiai; $16 Trig} £39123':
V C{)IE§§%fi§*ii€€C§V.__'$%i%5§.§}%j$ €I"{"1§}E" in mzzzriciégzg £316: a€§:u$€<i«ap;p$Ba:"::s
§&:a:f""£E::§ affiezécas aiiegegé againsi them géiasing :*&},i::sz";ce 9;: {ha
fs*a§{i _é%;i:i€::{:€. As Siiith the impugzéezi judgnent 322$ ardar 9?
.¢:::<wi€{,i:;2z1 arid Séflififiiffi éiagéwézg 'E0 E36: 36%: aside.
r""'\""""""'
9
8. F93' the reagons af{:resa§.<i the p:'e$§?:.:"_s i:. §;:.§;,;ga£u is
aiiawefi' Tirie irrxgzvugried juégrimrzi anfl <):*<.iezf}:>f"'::£m§;§;::ii<:i1~
S€'i'§,'€iiEf1Cfi dated 16/€}3f2€3G5 §3QSS€ff§; 'r;-$5' E;§f::3._
Lhzzige, Bavaraagera in S€$sic>:"1s G,a;se E"€:)L :'§9;2§fi€;§? it is Sgt,
aside. The appeliani; N03. 1 to aré' gczitiéfitd
N93. 1 "£0 4 ii': the Saifi ;" %€;?€?g};1iiL'§,é:tVf:'Af}Vf: €316 ééfffizmzcés
Eiilfifii' secticm 3134 0%' Ekzcizriciijg Act,
91%}. The baii éfiécigtéci {fie-----ai;ppé:fia11tS Shali stazzci
C8J:1Ce§}.€,:{}.: If i§fi€:v",:§fiI1E3:Vit1E€L§§4"£'if,§f€:I} péid by {he &{"2C5'L1S(:3{i, the 391116
Shel} "be ref~;::;d~5a tc:éZ'z f€:x£;"~
.....
