Karnataka High Court
Union Of India Ors vs Dattappa S/O Ningappa Ghangapur on 17 June, 2011
Bench: Chief Justice, L.Narayana Swamy
3?? YTEEE }§E{}Ef {:1{}i§RT {)5 E<;é§R§'~;?P\.'?R§§fi CERCUIT
GELBARGA
ggygg 232:3 THE :'2*m am 0? §J:::\sE;'.;2:;=.éf:, V
PRESENT
mg HGWBLE MR, J. S. i<:1s.§;:L':_:_~m:Q "
AN 3
mg HONELE MR, ;;v's'§si?1CEi:,_ §a§i:§:9--5Y
B§"E'WE:EE\§:
E.
CM"
" C%§}LSé§RG:"i Bi'*Jf§Z{}?'=§ -- $85381
mxasm cs? .
Takaaéygsi sv5;C:"<E::'ARy';w ~
aEPA;::3;*r:v:E.;M:::e%> _
DAK 3;--:A.:irxN; %3}&::__.:e-:3. _~---- 3: ma 2 .
CREE? é:;sé':vy§$T§'§."G..E:'a:§§éé§3.,
§<;%RNAT;%K§3;..CfE<3C:,E;'--._ ' '
Bg~\.;»j=;;e;raL_§;}RE 4» 5_6<30m.
._ §>.:;%§'3'*§>¢i§2:g'.:§fE';;::%:._ agmggfiga
'i"%.G7:%=TPi'vE%Lé§<';€%€'§'£_E<¢% §a<:4:}§\§
=-§::;§i;»f:§*'w.Vég§_ 2 §'E:%§I%'Q€3 2 g
::>§:{-$$3fs;%§2.,}é:§a§%' ;*aA<:<:<im\??$ g?@:3%:;
Bi} age" .<;g§v1?;:ax,
- "-I%;:E'£:"}?:1;Ci§§; ~ 55;@QG 2;
'::e1R1;~«s:i;§J%:§'<m3'§',§§@€:x:? :3? €,1%§~??§CES,
?ET'E'§EG§'x§'E;RS¢
A
\
3
2, E: E3 ;<:£>I; 3 §E'1§i§;§€? <3? :i§:~;;:>"u'i,::* éizaé': {Em zésgpcxzderzi ;:;»;:r_::6 to
be inéucisé as an Extéa D:3§a:'i;::r3:ér2:3E Mai} {§ar:é:%°»V"駧'.T.%§j?:€
err:pi<>}?r1":€::w: <36 pegziaé auéhazééiss 3: Shahafsad Ea~i%ga"dV-<55
22l§1f?E,
'K:
3, The p63: of Extra D€pa.i"im'€n§:2;'!..:v§a1i._'<ZT;if*rié;f§--..s%i;s?;i%;s
subssquszziiy :e~d;esig::aEeé as Gzarzi Efigzk Sssiztak --: E=Ji2:i:_§E
4. '?h€ claim sf the §"€S§{}f1{i€:':i firias ~€30fiS§éf3~ET€§ 59:5 Séiecziozz
and appaéntmsné is {he Gmupséié _ca..§é:'<;:'_ ' §,:i"'i_¥'?§S; E-Eavizzg 59:11:37 him
SEEEEEEEEE; 3:16, having ssisctfid Eie ::r"9;:s* 'ézppeéniad E3 the
':%:"Oi2:§;}~§ azsfize ::{:e;'::a€jaI%1dL; :":3:._ "'<3'a1'§:'é"i Eé.E..E§95. The
respandeizi: «:Qn'ti::_§.1e;%_i_ §iVSC%z;3;":"§_<3 frii'sV§u'::£és in the Greup-B cadre
iii: he atiainzsd r:hé*;:g§ <f)i"3.'Si,1.};}é':f§/*.1'1I7§li--?J€iQI} an 3E.'?,€33g $9: havirig
f€EE§€f€(i u':14§,n§€§f1£:Q§Vé§;..j v.E3§':f?g'§{:€?"'. {mm 19371 :0 2Q{}3§ Ehfi
:'€s§;::<::r:d€:::.<:§a.i:::<9:€§ g}€gs.ia:':.ia;.:r;v'"béinsfézs ands? E1216 4% Q? fie CS8
{;?é1':"3.%.0r:}'R{3;i€,_$;{ E'§f?2a """
_ 4;%;§xi*:':§i1»,n}{..T_ ?en:gis;r1 §--- {E} 3:: {ha @338 sf 3
'._{§<:eé;<:::;§?:::%_::::. sém?a::': :*€:§,::"Ez::g 32:2 accardaizcs W:i?;h €338
;:*§r9s;§3ii:_3::;s«:..~_c>*:f fiisge méess besfarz: {:§:::{:£€:§::g s*;:;£s£i§j,/*%ng
Seavicéé =:3§":€:: yeais} fine a:'§l:<'>U3'€{ :3? service gra%:ui£};
._ SE23}? '%:;;% egaészgéaésd at fie ;"&§€ 3% 33,53? :::e:):"::%:'s
' ..€g::*:.€:a§;::'2*-:::€::i3 59: every ca::{:;oE€:::v;% six mG::i'::§jy* §€:":;G:i s>§
Q12'2£if}«*i:2g ssrvéca *
' {2} {a} it: the sage GE' .1 'C:{}Vi3§"I§,§"§";€:':'€ sfirvani
fsiigiiég in 8CCO'{§8;QC€ aayéih previsséorzg Céf %:§2.€S<E
5:22:33 afisr cazzzpiaiéng q1;aEi§m2g 3e:*VéC€ of 32:}: E833
fécéé '
V Eséizzefitg,
1'?
:':3f?E":€ E3278: €ar:%€z:':iG:1 by {he Eezizzrneé C<>:;:':s;§:§ {er
'ibe gsatéiissér befere ibis; {burr wag? éhat respancient $55}? 1. 31:3:
9.,
sntitisé E0 the §3€F§€f§?i of E3 €:2§:£r€ Ssrvéca frara E§'?1_-£9 ..f§ ::._'
éezérmizééag his Séigihéfizézy fer p€f:S§Oi"'2'3Ej,? begsfiisg E::'%i?'é:3-. ::f}:€§i:éé:*::§a3<%
fiat he Wag eantitied {G bsnsfiz ¥ _
2093 932%}; in so far 33 '$16 S:,2bmés$i[f3:é__. a§
the: psziiiensra is C€3I'}{1'€E'§1€3d} he desir5s:fi"L:':'§f;,Vi:$ §v#2d%i}'{hai the
petisjoaer was entiijed for '.i{;r_'L»g;_3 e::*°:%§i<:>:"1a:*3,r '§€:1efi.'gs,
aniy wiih €fft";'C'i {ram izhadats arhfifi Vfifiifiaépoénisd :23: zihs
{}ra:lP~§ Cafire 16.; V/?§:1"1A:;;j£V:'i/%'"?»q¢.tV:"§:'€?%?'i¢4,9s<L95'.§'"his the contention sf
éhs iearnfid c01ms€:§__fsi:§ Vihé ":haigsérvi<:s renééreé by :56
regpandem: fzjam 4I:27;'3..5 fig? 3,iQ§._G3_0%1E},7, can be CO1'1S§€i{i'?€§ as
quaéifying serviigé, 'Easéci '{'}§f£'[5§'i4f;'-.'.'E'.iLE"{>E'iEE~,'cE';§i"§ $e:'Vi<::€ rénderéé éj; ibe
res§3<;:r:逧::E_i2i: G§éuV§-§}.v"{:a,ér€; {he Eearzzsé Coégnsei for £326
pf:-'iitisvgzers«--.g€,:?:§::<zi%:s,. that éfifié §€iSpS§}é€?§1§ WE1<:: Eaaé' HQ': Camgéisted
ii} j,?é;gré:VT§V§«<;é;:::3_§f§i§gg_;.servise, was 15:31: észstiifisd is pf31'1S§O1'3a§'}?
_ {?.'\E\s'€ %3:z€g_%:s;%a:"d ':33: Sézbézzésséams advagzcsafi ai izanés 95 {has
'E€a*::é.é3.§ §:§'{§£E"';$§}, £81' éhe §}€§§:§;"§i,"21f1€E"» §§:2é::::': Q5 '§';r1d,2'a. W5: £3336
§§E'.'V:L§z"E§3':§'§%:E%;':'31§{}§'31? \:J%:a.€s@€iv€:§ E22 {E13 samfi 33:3 dissési 323$ aézrvéces
far' ?;he "i;~:: '
e~>««%
":
Q.
QR; 'arm m
ég
é
2*€::§{3:*5é 1:25; {ha f€S§"3{}ZFZi§€'1":§ £3342» two sempezzezais is, gmzzz
22";EeE§'?
ymx
zépiis E§;E¢19§E}, ané tharaaftazy {mm
31.7.2603. '§"§3€ firsé part: :35 asrvice :"¢:f6:;"ed :9 hersin.§V_é.'b:»':?§'---§*g*1&;fS___ Eendérsd as an Extra Qsgeaziméntai E\s'f2;1i Carrisr {S'.;'\§;3S~€;:;1.}€!fE~fl}"-Aféi-:_' fiesignatéd as {}:ra::1 Qak Sevak: Maéé C=ar§é§.zf;QT135'S1:bS's{:§;€:2§;-
service which was réadersei as E3€m%;z:_§ of 'ii?-§"'Greu;;>'§VI;V&: vzéé W636 gévsn {Em émpzesséon that E3526 a§%%'G2:.:%;:::;VV€n€V"G"f r€'$§;:»end€nVt :0 éthe €:r@1.:p-D Cadrs was E1216 no nexus £0 thé: €3.I'hJE?:§' s=<3z*V§C€. Vv'§_ irnpressien. $11 E6335, Elm: C§i::f:e€b{E" by a gracess sf sdsctian ta 31$ daied
16.},95§ «%'§_:'a:,VfVVVV_§;V»:§v'1€c1:io:": to the Grsupfi casfirefi is a¥a%§av5t3Ee" A2. A réisavani sxéracé:
sf éhe aferasaifi <3§;:§é§ 2}; 3ZCI'€U§C1{i*SF. A A fi2'E':;*2§g<*§:»x2g§\z*§ {>3 ?:;:>$:'s " ~ THE 33 $S?§'?Z G?' ?C2$'§' QFFIGESE .}§3'i;§LB&R{},s--'; :3:ss'?§§<:?;; g2g'c;:v;a;g:<, Saéad a: C:u§§:2a1:ga«}. £16} ' :€:z;:.:2.9=95 .».,«.;;w»V~NAM»)"nu;-»..¢~mwNw~~N»V»/~~w»v»¢~~N~N~N~~~»v~h,N»Jw»¢ A firm WW "3 an <%i:a:3?%w$:w'T't"'5£§i'{fl«x'€fC3«»*§§' 6' m*'§ 'Q 1?
TBS feéiowiag a_E§V{}::::€:::: <35 aggprevéé s::a:/2§:Z&3,:;_::ss 31:3? apgaénzmanz is graug "D" ansi zeqzgesi. érarzsfsrs as rzotsiii agéégsi Sac}: 3123 §1€f€b:f {>E'@€i"S§ :0 Ezavs: Wi';§"i immadéaie effesi. * 7 Q'3:'i"§':»-?::'f£'<:d: i:<'> ' A. TL E'~E{:x Nams 85 Deségrzatéorz 'aha ®{§'é<:r:j;=,..,. _ _ _ V 2, Sn fiflaflé Razz {SC} :3§>::r; ms-:' E~§}_3'1's.:E_? ._A'£€,1nCé Kawalga 80 aj/W z%Eur1<% $0 ' _ "3f_i?:$ u {figpmved Caaéidaié} 'TS;idra1rs.;:é;pp7a " "{§.I".E'\f'--..L HA1 E} and * '§ra.:":$.€s;:f2:%d 1:0.
{E3 2, Sri Dattappa {SC} E";Q§\sEC; * ""39 ""P«:3si:r:as'::€:; Kadr:£BO a;'wFarE:;3_Eéé:ba6. S3 " fl.Si*;:ahab-ad HS Efinit {£§§I'0'i7€'fd canflidaés} ' ' 7 ' ~9{g.ai::.fs{ '€8.C&Ht gogt.
3. Sri Sidd2a§p;3¢{;'E':--}_E<:'£§_AP§:,1f., _ 8&1 {P} Shahabad Chanda§L:_f V . °'€}:>:é: vica S36 Shakar {P1p§§"O'iijtf'éi'C«8;};i§§3§E"U:€-:t_n.__ _ ' CLRZ Shahabsfi ACC ' -T " ' 'E'ranssferred ':9 GB«
-------- ~ Bahamanipurfi S8 4% S:i1.Sh'a§<ar Sh"e;.E_:é3:>a:§ ACC T23 gs? arc, GB-H SQ '- ' Sub 3:: mg: agai:':st vacant pest {£335 requsst, ma T}:;"Z§"'?}.
35:2 Guibarga SS uni:
_ V-.35: :3-:a3ramg§pg';""::;:v Aéusé 39 V. , agaénai zracani §>a>;3%:
€335: f€Q%.}€i'S'i E"~€r:3 Ts%;'E?}¢ * '§"h€ 3:3 ""ei:1'{i:: {£3953 sgncsrrzacé may §S:31fis'3 5." Qigérsézzés 3 . . I/' E'? :' ''-«¢:%f;:a::":._$:'::r3 £3rd€r§;" {E5 1:326 ahave appfazaed Qanéédaésg afzer ebgémzirzg ; 31E':;?};a,1L33:;:;a§ fermaiéies ifzatlzgéing 'aha: vsrifiscaiien Q? saga of 38/ S'? V 'é:a2,"--:::i::?a:€_ Q: pariicuéar 4'v3@;>§§mi;;:€:::;"E'§3<n3§er csrdesr .:«:§<:::g with charge rsgsorts gszay pisase ';::t::'~--e:f:cEe§s¢§ ":3 this s§€§£§."
xafézhén a §0:"£:::ig%:':. Tins <:si:sp3; sf $26 abmvés saié afiiésiézd €$AS §j;;<:eués3. 3101: bss r<;er::<3'::;a:%.__§§ an}? Vigiiatsceigfliiisc, f:Qi:§a:>§: i$ cithsr psrtsdéng 02* cantempiaésfi agéiénsi ihfim azzd repefl; 8621: 58 {E113 <>f'§iC5i f<3r::%::2si:E:.
8. Fmm psrézsaai of €238 aforesaid exiraci} E:
the f€3$}Z>{}1'}d€I";{ was £pI'G:f}'1Gi€é" fr<}::jz:H,__3';h5 _--'CééL1'<é_'xa fV Z3xi:a"
ifiégartmeziiai Ezfaii Cafzéfif to ihfi Gr<)L1_§3,-3:1'¢:¢u'iE€§».F::r_"2;;EEu iéztgzéiéis and purpeasg, {E16 ampéajgmarzi wai :;:",-_r;:§n,2\:::>us in :i_ai:;2::%,a:n.§ no':--_"
as if it was from 312$ semis: 'LG 3.5. {E36 a§;:s0:£:1%::"1*:$z:'2f: {sf tbs respéfigiéni uziéxif 'aha gmplojgerf 'W6 {ind n0gust§fi§;2a:i;;>_r;. éhe pstiiieners herein fie: bifurcgtfi regpgndeni énzec:
{EKZO Separazsi of tha regponfiem is tréatsfi a3 §%:$;i§:§:€Ey 'B6 fguné :0 have rerzéersd "pt':3s<:r3Lb€§ fez' entiiégméni E0 p€I'}SiQ3'i€i'§{ .3.}€z:,:3f§!i5s; exifacied '::e:*€é::gS13m*€. '{i;§VéV§§é'f;i%ion€: in assafiirzg {E16 Grésr pagsed. by ':§':S"=i:1€:1:§fé;2. §;'a<£::1,é%fi$ti;1Eéve E'§i'§u:§8f;, Bgzigaéers Bszich, Ba:r::gaL3:"€ 'AA....a13i0::ishfs:ssV us: §::ié_s:i:§:*::,ic%: as; 132% émgugzzéfi Ofdfif paaeeé 33:; {he '~€7f,_;a:n::jaE g%é:n§zi':sEra::éV€ T':€?3u,::aE d2:%::':d 23.433} rczréaégg 81$': er:
' _'é'é.$:":i:e:3% é';:\::%:mV$:*Sj; §!Ei§"iE:§§Z§f§§;f is am}%:'n€2" a:m;:5iC:j§;<:s: eff {E253 gssaszaé :'§:gaI'::is;;a,t§G::,? $15 Qariiifaé Aérzziizésérazéve 'E'rEs:,:2:1a,1 E'xz'%a,d:'a3 Sezzcéa