Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
B Patra vs Bharat Sanchal Nigam Limited on 26 May, 2020
Be ge get a wt ee £ Re Vanni ni, on 7 bet tan me , BOI cs E me ob BA Bow a eS ot 42 SP ad ae aA wn wae oe Li sy a gy af wo t ws me ue rt Oe 3 pa es st Bn Je we ee G bed Ee ort a ae bs hae ae be eee GQ "s o> "<4 & 5 rood he o e es a a ad rae ae "f vr ® WY ES te see) ae woes ev ad ea a wy oe Be * 3 A & ns 6h 'ef ra gk Ls aa we fh nt Bo re a OF ny * soe z at 4g G 5 oS 5 2 toed itis. vie c vet FS ed at 3 it ee hy res be, ne eet ven Pe "FS ted ti, ° * A fie tap ek f aes Oe cad nay fen Be Pts a Ft en] F gg & & oa Fee pest gd oan Ta x te Bo ws Bhs ott, Ce aon 43°73 es a3 Ay oe 2 Mere "8 Bo Fe "ft fer vs BE ee , ? we EX toes : ce bo © : ne x a ; ee, et , . eee ; z ned, wy pew, ge * pore "t ay < ee woe DR ves My ng Peairvan! * vi ot og i ten, ha Co " "A ke on ome OS ty he " ro a " ft bw " eo ed be v, ¥% be ws fh Mom 5. gooe need ga a we od by ee Lt FO ih Fa Ape Gb Here bot &, he My Lome) + ae Yh 25 £25 ke % a pear, ae Te NY ge oe set eg we * ba Go We oS area 43 So eed ae neg, fe} . Let we tied th Fasaiieaat bon OH a th OS o, A ed >» het yee 73 thes ort ry ede GS EA 0% wha 45, TS ee is N carn Oe we OR " teh x bes. fen thy ee, ee cee! ten Ott is * ~f ee * % % iad of Coy» om EE gs $ aa orn, iat Ex ae Fy ry Re who a a8 a. at fab ie wed gy cpp oe ae oe 4 Be wea oo ann ~ i eg BM i Pd OY, 4 ieee ts von SE oe ay ae MS et ke 164 9 a Cg tdaad a bt iy, Oe Ree rae er og Med ee Leo at OY pm me a age ws 9s Sei st ys 6 td (vt wf ye) 8% NA bee rs re nj tke ih rs te uS5 bey OS ree : ce gt = one Ba oe Be x od 3 8 oe S pane ; we mpi ~ ie il £ ot bes te nee i da UG jenna, A ee my ea fy wes eh iy ke Z mM ig Te ge hey jos. a Tema me Pat ed moe. pay ass ae wo ¥ey st te, Sede + ¥s shod gh ae Ys % : Py ia 2 OS qi te. ae bis } ioe ., x « be pe Re 5 feed mo es " ta 23 ee, poe 1" ee ie "SS ah am me Ee, det we one om are bang be ws oS ae bs xs ety mt Bae 2 ee SS rr £5 Bi fc eo oom DSi he Mies oy SS © aa, Lo om x fs & M4, sad 2S a wi #8, Du eR a hs ie vee, m soy ge j aE 25 mo pees pee el eS f aR LA pr we * rh a he eg res oe 3% 2 aa "fi Be cet teh ng an we i ee ws "at i a ie C5 ey is Se av me Ea CRs prt. heat gan hd '"z fa" Ow oe me a weg fea Sa ia ana 4 6G wy My re bee iy he = we ob bee fos Ao 6h a ey : Wet tod ee ss ie, 13 a om B Bo, :
each * capes st et oa we . > ey Ro sy Gt aS en j Fad a ot. 0d MAce es we, ty © bx re 2 er wey wt ee fe oy on, aw. ~ Ta hee Os as aA Fs 7 Nad SO pe oe Pe x aS 4 vy. 2 ¢ os a etl t eb Tab Maret ce vend pas ¢ ; A Se Tee Z BE om ys + Iam, tp 7 " 5 ' : ee, v a Vine ee" es Mae See mh tan eR cee Boe % oe os oe 4 Oo Ge & od, eh, St Ta GD weet weee The we 2% 03 eee tat . ' + Pe oR tb te ro ote aad go, EE ORD re te 5 ba ee wt a peewee YY Mant ot tyty £f5 Se ra = pons 08 qe Oy a: & ih es ae age ED % ; : Tet ee & pon "a? fate ae a ay a £8 ge OSE on a ae £3.
AG ; ae geen at age "E, Soe Soe i 2 of ve t. ;
BEEPEE F ee Be % 3 "%, ena Bow, fo wa, as 'es oF, ag TE OE eee ¢ a A a a Ny yee ye ' , a i " ' ' 7 Geocoo £ . ts a :
wet mh oy ion mH ts, » ' 4 ees mt ot ae) he PiOe Se ok, ra we Ry Serb C&S:
i { Boa 07% Seance hed, ETR,
3.
c% Ck Fo El a WY the «th a pat , om fe rae 4 pene oe = wet ps ry ee want uf ia "3 i, oo etd we os oe fot ae re ae on 7 eh tr OOF} UTR ti OF m%
-
Se Bast, B se Ley arrad He wok, E 5 mat el w3Te is, West Berge, Tey DOG Ayhaar x aN wenhe Lsa¥art PenrnononncossnaS | Font OH Ly ES KT AAS AT Suds 1, B Sent On ete ¢
1.€ oy! + ok aR vy.
+ ORDE Per Mx.Qokul Chandra Pati, Member({Aj:
», OA No. ols A4O/ 9015 J i> FS i rye SON MA Na.
\3 ey Bat > art OF tak * >} met > Fy 2 4 '4 Fa 3 3 3 3 z 3 z 3 3 3 3 z z z Fa Fa tet ot + Frags Bs a ea be ge need, eB se mg Fass ee oe a nn See ep Me py RT Bem Ui J y % ¥ oe nel Ly a fr a ; Bowe Be es g Feet a A ae he ee OO "e te ee no fad They eS i tA ion sp 43 mE or ae 2 wed 5 es r te) « OF £55 ot "23 Be ay SS te Valens yer be bed cena * : a on a ve 45 'ted ES om co ae OS 4 ted ik a os Se A zo ve hl " ae ae ~ o , ben "3 : . i 4, ee 5 , 6 te & re @ 2 & & oh wm ne ee fe feet tae A bn & y ; F toot Bee a Fp ena a bead Sa s 'tha? a on Lae raat - x4. ap hep J C5 wn wm fF ae OM at oN Paes bee ros a %, weit EE tae by ~ 4 ; oS Be os we f. tf Me wg Pad are Pa ; yD sd m4 bebe MW . Ww at a fee oS wk yet A ie wee iy BA i ia fake ene th on . or meer oe eet : a wg Gee inact 5 "fi, Pe LY g ' A - 4 pa gh | ta q wa i OF ahs ke fet ng ar PG bee By ts ;
o a we ke : zo Bo ths pa a a ae oe »s ate AD oe & & y ; 4 5 ~ tha, . + a : . . "5 ar fee a GB pes 3 Fad re is he pets om ke we 5S) ms gy a rrr 45 4 ae 4 A ¢ pee. % 4 2 aed he gy ES Dn a nr Toe ee ad ns 74 ey dad it ay a we id poe "4 oe se te ae - = oP tee ot : med Wp td aft Snel * pees ond ho mS rs 4 is pres ' ye 2 f™. 'et a yes Sies £2 7 4 Di, et a 4 Ps , wh 4 Y 4 od #3 tes a ns ~ it bes i, ret be nn? nr ore) ? aad Uo "8 #2 ip. # tO Fe pot Bir apd owe wae be : z ty le ot & . jee? 2 ort ' ons oe ee Mas ie "& Gm BB @ a Sg B og & my OY BAO SE ie B_g@m Bb oe Go © . P / 7 eb $s sere a) a Fs 4 % ' é ced ef ' a ff 8 Be bh 3 os ae coe "a 4 Ss ee ae ees o 2 Oo f @ op & mm Skog aes Cee et SG wher we C3 mM & F As ae at & ge ne} SOS i og, «6 EE ae fa oe a mal . & oe Lage he 2 be pw Aa , me th & wg Me m SS US eas 7 4 oe a pe! : . mR i is ' 4 " oe % re io o tet og oie Bf # , & BCE a om fad os po oS Ee ™ & a a 6m & a 8 & ge oS gy mm gf a Oo 4s wg " eo 6 TO 4 TO 4 Re am me OG bee A de aon o G w tome BT 4 as a i y & & Bf oe oF Bod - cae «an Tce rene nye SA poe GG Ge 2 fe ae , jn ot nn ne + aia & 8 m Te ae & wy BY y ie ee Boa Bo as & Be 6 8 Boe f Be ose $% rt c oe a4 3 on ¥ % ke Ft OT gee hey z % Pa % io ft oe ' Spee Cy he woe "S hg ai ad 53 ae anit "ea Bes ee a veg Ae bg td ¥e roe & SS hak wT oe x, Ch os rs " nal as Boo hot a YS +e CG ea me oe ad & of ke ee ; ap be od he 5 aa oo we aS Sz $a 4 vA ; ard % - GK n we ten Oe vee OF op TF £&é 7 % od oo wet Ue Aeot ee a5 aA are, eh a i Se 4 tee at ¢ wo * en ay, oy, 'nat "n, 5 z ays ag 3 pot Son : en «EE Bog m4 fy oO é ts Tt aed 4 pa ot a, OS senda ra a a 3) 3 ee fon ed " a 43 ie LA 45 i a3 ones: on ooo 4 a, ti hy a * » 4, a pnt of me ob «4 oy OF Th 40 Be OTD Bcd ene pe he Be a Boog fe as oy hoe ee % pel pe: % a . Pac a . : Hoe " Koa aoe tees ek , sos ie v pond 2 4) a ES Te oe ee a af rate vy te and aE Roc pad * % oo a ce ' ree4 ey yew a. tn ; eed ped, Fon' ure o, raga ~~ Gf eH & ws £& Bg A ® a "3 YB g ss & me GOT me we BB Oe re 4 fg G ae BS OR og yer 4 te te a3 on we bad ee a ao <r "ss . we «WD & £e an bee eee bee "4 Pao ma re NES Ae FS ri ey AS yo Ed Ls Oo ere * Ch pemeeed 7 a net ae a dog, . 5 tee eee Gd y a ad ie oe: a oe Oh ne We weed oa iS x3 gs AK nt 5 WG oy fa oC Ss @ & Bw & un 2 oS eo Bg S @€ 2 & 8 ¢ S mars a gf BB e me oo OES onl wwe a wy os «4 ite es = bee De a a re fm fF OG BP:
§ 4 ae a ss 4 H phen : ¥ Ve iG ay * % Be # oe. 7 5 ed a mw yea 7) as ue 4 ay ews teed Darl a Seay 2 Peer ues pees oe Sts, Fi o % 4 q 3 f ot :. get A rie "ao oa au 4 % t Z ~ eee Z a 'f 2 g dy g 2 nes fee % 6 » wh my Ed a "ad n Eomey See aS 6s on ind fed ae os fy et Oo oaet :
w& © © 7 8 fen fk oh HS we tt on? os % Fs ay 4 2 & Gs ea . & : ; bee oes Re & 'eat rad £2 Gow tt 43 "en wy FO OE Pr & "an B35 awd deat od i - es ", Eh td ms: be om wt a se ied Es 6 pe ee fi tae! gs % os we ORE tp EEE By oe & # #F & Gs re. a a en et Seo "f Fae x vem ye OE go SP 6 &E m <2 & : Pow eB fe 8 OB oe @ 2 s E & & Sg bo BE ne 28g" ¢ 2 & Fos! 4b 4 ae "o : - " aed $ ghee we ee w Pend re ws Fess) ai oe Ly See "4 " . * 'ph Oe A oy me, om me BO oe OS 3 & Lan SS gy eee, go ie ALS vod a, @ ah BO Ets ee aA Gh be go we BS i he Ee mS w gh ve 4 ars! Phe Sod a $5 oe oe Mm & & a a sees 4 . fe ' aed. my ante # ve ' oe a «po Z 4 " ge ft aad ie oe 3 i AS et wr 'Es * . "owe i ne a3 Cad id % se ee Sh tree a waa ot we 6S > ge Se ee Bee te rd ot Et OS ete AX th Pe ie ae ae RD he oS Ph a Om te hee we Es ai Ee "OS wo GE Kwa ow "4 eo «& ke we tt ws a me a ae wm ore OE Ee oe 43 eras, ' fie Se gh HOG te ise . : ° , So "ge go BR ee os EE om om OB a Bae Bg FT & ws ome Y om OG fi me OS om ; a . i on ae poeese iS 'o bs * ge * noe 4S yee I Bh et BG pa ye BS OG oa Pe we «sf "ake ea es me Sh he tt wom Us pes "st PA B mb we i ' . a pod the cet " 4 £ ea ere. Ped Ye tee OY : Beye i ie Boy & & ® @ & mere GB wm 2 so oe oe a me Me Oe hd. Sonn ees ee %, oe wer os + g Bae et "ib eres od ston, ay ph ay peek bab Ke re a as ba sri a a ae a ee 2 got ahaa b. b Se 5 ors " Q . ee ks hy pers ay ead vant be i & aac te am st Sa & CS oka 3 "Fg tw 2 ba OF hie %, rt bet mak, rae, Ae _-- fa yt noe roy a £O% 'rine o. raed we boat + ihe i aoa s ES Ww. oe fe mo OU w Bet toe ee 3 fy tee hp ane wt oy $ Ks wn th EO w fy dR ert sn ond on af ed AER MM A 't + yi gs Fad i A Rw Be oh tes OT ven ' regs oy Fo ne $0 > et oA xt ai wo et ; LOG teed ro wa MS re aka 4 coat © tot . ae ip oe ye Be Dal ot Or a is ve veg ry AE ee 4 4 a "2 wo oe 2 Oe ' a Sow ee ish me a by ~ ee S o is BSF et a be ye eS re} 3 a: on tt ~ $e a mo wee , oe o wy keg Poo re *. EE s Het ea Ro Ly baie we. ne iy ' Me Ag 4 g " . wee vt Bf 5 os Sew a 5 whe Eo 'se GF rn a nn & G m bo 2 A Ee boop 3 eB te oa rr; rns ane ' fs te "e8 x 3 5, é _ & pre : ed s eg 4 ae 2 4 nn oy OO as nn en oe &E BE ¢ 13 @ a nt en nn on gr oS a Se. 4y eg. ra oy Meee ee es we bey a5 7 wy 5, ne Oey a yeod RS oe fee te ot we, am c me ae) wo wg io ee OS v wd we Oe 4 w d Pm & 6 © # b "R ree . ose gt we OP & rs 2 oo, « - 6 mem B Land a ee ae ms OY gp OS te, Sg OB wee re ug ne) wh EE rans tA ae te Sa a Or me Oe CR tes 'at <M ye % et raid x 15 ; : yt ' " 2 4 at Be : a % tae pons os . ent ae it Me : Se an a ar Gob e GE SF ors wa db a OE z pies mo fe &B Mow ot ea tee ted é ori a. * but oS ot oe me 'ot Se se * (a ann ae tt ong pee 2 eae Pon vo os vai > ree eb peed et we ro ES een gn a wen 6 cod a ne 23 oy v Ga ME on ae ve een a (Oe og MS by ort bd ; a a | a of .
Be eh EG oe weg we EE bs a ss Be a MB Be bag a @ & EB Y & tog ott fe mw 57 F) ay an a %. of : Pa ret Le, a oe ee oo . we yn 4 ewes, + ; os Sod te, a abs qe pe S [ai ro oe 4 Ls, Ot ben < nyee Weer a cae z. wd yet o g 4 we wm . % 5 , mn . oh * eee re aes Lat at yh ee 4 ss ee tty « 4 + yes, re . ; < a wy Ke GR £ @ eS 8 » & G Bro O Hm im eg oe ~ 5S 4 o @ DD & [en mH 8 8 "3 beg @ Be gh Ds na EG mR ip bp A hee &S ako Co "ye So eee a »# ae me & be og Om G a Bw FT "8 oo Be me 4 Poa bared aE fete, po 'we von a 3 va i Loaad ea SF o a se rar' a 74 gee o oe ag A oe ae a yet a rag der 43 la a Ls Kom ay pe ay Moor ae P= be we aet need 4 Th OD 5 Be Le & adc a sa ga he mt cae ee wm " 2 ie) : fs ce os wm mb th oo o% sO ot nr ofr ns ar? 2 :
a net ne | QB Ba ke eo ae oe & Fn BR me Gc FF [ie pm he SG oat Ky Tm Pan EP OF i pote! Boe "
St Rea opm oh a OD Lhe Ta <3) oo wei wee hed Re toe OOS ye" apt Rpee; es aye. AY pa et ae 7 pee. . 2 wi ew Te ew Ba Mo RO hes ao 2 F BB oF he pik ee oF 2 @ cy ong, ces ern ae Be hea. eA B Bleoc on ws +s pectinases pa Pe seca 954 > ee wa " v4. omy z Sat 4 para g oo a 3 eed D : a uo © & 3 fas4 oR s ye ws pms - 5 * wee Fe tee o os ia 43 mo FOR © 'we of ted a4 se ' a' 14 Dear' 3 ce by : Saeed m nat a SS x sed aod be 5 = ne 1 3 os ei & 2 a ge 5 Fadl wh eee e 2s ty ge es acd woe uy eet pee ua iC is ed Pi be mG i a Ds fe id a ty ae " os 4 ae af be oe ae 1 ea a 4 rsa Pad pet at Sab, 2 , iy A Toa, oe) a & - ie Ok * : pe :
we its eg a es af :
ot ae poo Fs ced ¢ % oe a yA ay £5 a f Sh. Sets ae "rt he he tut ede z eet a 4 "3 sos { 2 i e a . a ann t oe ad AA x he be ge :
2 % & Be i x: 4 os oe ;
~ 7 % ; , me rt Ns a kG $5 he 5 a vz y et m 4 4 . ve 2 ot om io G pn peo t om ™s S woot Cat '5 z 3 fas £ 4 : ? oe ae on we a 8 re oh Pe my OG Deetd o ses 4 & . 7 ron G :
oe a, pees % ot fe ti? ie o a Gg = 4% sn, veape eh Rags ors yew oa 2 wre, rt . tard 45 fe we x es me ORS , et OK oe Fe ah at
- mB Of Ja aq Oe od he ba ey wes on Eva o spot fen < of an cd 7A home Soa 4, qi z * 43 A pon ya Ks ; te . v ead wer m6 ¥, Cy $) a oy "4 ~ . pei pos con ae Pal oF a aren, Re os wr é , eo Yaad 45 on rans an % ft "4 4 £5 np tA cy ° Re ce) ot bas ye "GE ie fe "et Oy 4 o eS yes he 'rs von - os SRO J se x i te ES px zw eal Pod i ESS Pa Spa 'at ee NG co ee Pas me" mm a is ih fs '4 oe y oy is & 2 ws a & % dda "3 ng *e 4 a7 fsa ka rat G Pyar' sy Bad ret ws 4 Sead py thy. be #2 G a od se ty ae od ae fa z ben bor 4 s "ast fe) net net 57 3 pm he booed kat ra
4 oe f th ty mom fea aa a oo Fehes ; a oy PA "fA G2 he OOS ke 2 4 cs rs , % of be gt vere 45 mae ead a nr G S 53. % a 8 g By ® ry rae, net when he +04 wee > sk 43 re cae $ hors hed od nad 2S # a pt 5 Heh fs, iA no t iat Qe Pa wees ». are Hi MS ort id i : ce " Ly ae tae eet t z : s is 8 Fe, ® ones Sh bog at we tk ' " pe we ued SS mi vos a vane ae we im we vel pe Pa neal WS Oe Ses oe os ba Me ve es ph tals. oy ed Pros ae ba wn peek 23 "od 'we Sie ee nba w os 25 owl a Sw, oy YE nae 3 A ae ry shod, ot re a rn rs m OTS 1B "ek wen tt Saat LB oe fa wb we ° part pe oe x ¢ Ss ~~ 3 Re the ws . x eas ad an er bes ed oe a hanes Lag . : vet ot a ae ot o weg ee « ye a Fae ae ot wk ages wok hah i) me < * es ee: ca 5 43 DQ en ne 4 3 , a pes fags at : af % « aS mo» kb & vent we i ie ane be ae ts rte % ray pees bg Hoot i ves pea nee te ay tS Be ay on St OG rs a "Bw a ea Kea rs a sis 2 were th Bey fy et weg bee wee as oO beg oy 4) al pa i ne " sh | 6 Seen feed av 4 a r% ot A eaet " poy od . ans uy ved 4 4 SG ow. thy veer ty ret age] - ped ann st ay a se Wt 'hoot ya os £3 weed ne Lg 3 4 wen Pan tex 5 Sat ecg $y ae ral wa & San we wk ve mee os b ee f et oboe the pas cx be Cod ced hed nd Pex' nee ye yh et ag Be B & eo e «"~ 2 2 8 SS ep Ee Bh 2 EB ee os GD too' an) be ay cee cS ov at as ne rs Be hy tok pees Mm co 4 gg ay a5 ber oe vet +A be + 'Angi a the ed ee tn ben Se an bat pers 4 DKS Se ke Aree grt ns wee vere: oad nt and & he deo ae aiid 4 ' g pm i i pO. a 4 or fave 4 yes wen Pat 4p pea ad Bose 5 ~ ' ao hs ant ye va ed cf re nah, , & FE he Lp £3 ee Cy Ste as x be ee . ao s 2b ah ve) Ly A he me a iis oo oy be ors iad % % t Bee ue " Me a aa: te om, HE vet fag fast Aa ee wy 43 &, ¢6 pat x4 on Gy E> oo +o ao Go we i «m 4S ne nt:
bse aed Seay ee) eed 43 5 Bw tm A * be ' At Pe % 8 Loe, Foy) Pad) eS, ye he oa a3 * bo 4 a Me A acess be, oe fae fa oben Pat Re m in, * yet trey s ifs eh fied a Re od ay mol &y Ppees jos) é ood rey & "fs Sy OM OD es rors te fot oe [sot ears ma ot te OR Bw LS 2 oc se Oe a ts ee th ow OE ere ee ee ey ; ae . A nese 4 ~ as Ge SOUS os es weg SEO BS beg ee tS ee ee a ne a mS ah x cy 3 iw ea m ated ne o ry, Dect % BS pets ie by « , ya we he a> CMS ar oe 2 a © Po tt ome gh So me RM of GS 2 6 8 & eK mg & £ 9g & B oe OT me Re bee $a ot preach airs ' fe aay " Eko ped c sand eos : ae eee 7. sen 4 rm brat taf ta . ; i of ' Ba fee OF & ES OL a op 8 uw ok oy Og ry te Eyed i; wih oS + a pon of . a ea a oh 7 vad nae ti a spr " wa 4 A . ot (ry ional a ee sd % ae [4 os par oe bo gd eat ; ca ~ 'i bea va oA 'ed 43 se & es bs 4 a qi f « me bes 'a WH: as 43 o4 he ioe i? Gy £2 & & oO : 5 3 r os ' oot . Seka wee vt , iy 5 ME ae a fe ee ee ee % @ 4 "ho ap tA EO, fas m © & Bie "OF ds . Hw : gj eho ag * 3; one ote : te cba? 2] ° i, ie vet % 6 ES os vate an Of me & GS be ae oe Ee bm & Ff £ os 2 On beck , a OE ' be we mm th Hm ©, rriry % ee a veg Een EE ers i z OS bee er: ee nad wee, = oe & a zn = "™ &» & & BG th 2 & bt wm et es Ce er a oa A? a eT > AS re * $y ne, ga J ry ee whee ca Se doa G bee 4g 3 aod oe mo SY BA CG es eR v3 ahs ts sl as ret, Pies ee ein Pa gst 7 piee ie ; Fal oF i 2, #e Be pow oot a WES te Se ee OER wi ki oe Meas fa ar ro : & ~ & 2 &¢ YB RS he ed vy ake p A%. ped 2 5 a, % > ce awe f ets a ey. eg mm Zo oe Sm os ee OF & od " ay ou he Po a cag ES wi . ie os ee en ¥ Pad a:
ee me ee : nes : ee a OD tg EO ; , 2 * g . oe es he si - pees ge ee A "es oad Stel r¢ a ge ~ or =z bow Se os . a es ow 86 te ' ote OG * OA a om aed a od 'at le wh $4 Paci as pas », L g a 0 SS % aces! hot wed 7 Packt roa a tat srt is ba eat a ; "SOs. 4 ot ins Yo eee is ween eo ee + is Ss a vets % teen es E est mera been Be et Ape i, a 'vs "Ms, one Be! rm ge Seem Sa we se oS. he hae G wy Peace Pa ain m2 se Bo oe G oe & neh ay 6) oH & "a3 faxd eK ge wi a - me es ae as a ae ane "4 iB A : 4 5 ny .
" aed nt & te we ay Fas ae vg ox ay ae aera Boe Sat wm 8 £2 BS mt " a x its * tes gee Sat Sey. jas es 5 eer bee 24 oa B a G se a SA Rb ge F xo feet a © o te Bo wm OS 4 ae ied 3 KE tee pe os gS aM 4 pe ' a) po ios] hee i) ' tt © We i yw lU™! bee + fe : "gt fee RS we te pe) ". ; Theses Cs. es 7s Fa £3 L, A + ones Paced ao "eat ef as *~ ental: bad "a on g os 4 Lb pe pes fs ts, = Samad ra M7 tty leecd y oh . a eke a ge wm te an a & ow * Gt 06s "Sad Go iS wee Le = Scie oe -. ai 3 oe Cf poet vue tere EE : bea ws pars : AS a Bas = P4 pa bed os, "as > eA * hed. Ls he pe; Ge ae w 7 aa cc a sos oa, wot x we Oh Sk 4 hoe ten we Soe Ce in oe vee "est ert Veg ard et 1% et se > 4 an few, fogs' oS ay os 4 os ay xt _ ? on a3 [on ; ft " ys uy i ee th ety =I lint ras) ee Bes Lo es 4 ae oe ww 504 xe $3 5 Oe xe 4 pn a oe ia ' ee Rod pve re oe aes] Ly t. ke wees, ig ' Saat 2 vane > d £ r% yon) fo kat on) fh, fo wy Parl we , ona eat te ay cS . ge : on ' rine.
g G ™ fee at, é Bow 2 a aa a eE "eh Eg we Som "a oo na hE pee wy ed xs rasa ny Eaae GR ated pe eee las ae pos Tee og & ue ae a ww SO tw Gy wpa a4 pie aa ed hy % we shad 3 eS Py a4 % rent ah Lory ret ro a ed. bas ~ io om = a a , ae ee se At s ery & at i wees ied oe ony $3 bow. one We . $x a4 Sal i BP aw mth od ty sng et * wi ye, ' aa ee macs ~~ . aoe fe ay ax as io a a va oC mo ws gy oe - % Bsc! rat . a *: * - en rand q i om a Ry ; ' ee ee ge © & oS rae a ob ,, >? IN ' nr een A ones B eo tt <4) Pg ay pig * Hf ~~ ed. on Ps pane on LH bee ne fone, be %, roy res, F Ae ae 4 "4 shed. om ee! "5 et itt Ss Se ' EE ba ce + 4 ta Gs a it ; a e ¥ ' . rn Cnr ea $e a '
-- y Some & Bw ¢ 8B Be we OG a ao # me oe OS ce V &@ Hh w& 2 wo BO ee ee ae ao pas wy G , af aah a Se " ves so " ia , new te fk te OR oa aero Ba Ba OO es RE Coes hea, " ' & +504, : haw ver. £% ws Pree 'a i. ee " _ es ee bee. fom cs & <t 'oak! ora oe wn 2 ' vies ead a) Fy z g a7 5 we " Ch wee ES OMY Be ae) oy bene Be ee AG isd ps o% - on . Z ie r¢ he " oo, m 9 a= & § Mh fo. Boe Be OF Bow OB Pan io Ct O. 0 t Gow 4 2 we. Y of @ Se eet we so ts na Fe ba She by wd wos e 6 Bo wm % fe ee we Ef . ; fa Ft a re ; a Bowe MG Sa co tee rag Bi By ke oe : Gass, - hd es oy ao co "beet saad bee 4 Ch wee ed > a3 oo te att 4 By] Oe ~ 3 egy ti Se AE "tn - Sosed we Pac) Sad " we & ee bes brs Sos e ee : oy raat S on %® Cy Beek fy be "I OG 7 o Betts tea bead * we acl S a Pos' & respondents.
ned by th BS ribeuir fant will be nes oo 5 ph ~ } in respect of the ar the OA the OA Nos, 485, 485, 611, G12 and G13 ef 2018 in these Bi 3.2018 ne re pHa ets ened $ Rs pas inp the wher tred eh ~ me if Ose 3 & 2m af ie L8 was resuct é Of 2 OA No. 44 3 bi 3 335 pension of £ ALS Were retired by Pa rod < SPs . ime aes CRE and Per rs ey 5 SSR fy SARE we Ne athet th S are & Jor2ois as the <4 By oe . ol ee FAY OA f Pto dr t PQSPred ay bee reormoning the fo Be MA the a8 4 ce donned, ~ t 2 DA No. delay cor g ihecd i A f Sd f