The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Smt.Annapoornamma Chandrashekar on 28 September, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 9]

Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Smt.Annapoornamma Chandrashekar on 28 September, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath

1;.., T_C%¥E'?:.'§V8é§'vK§{_C'%';$;

15%? ?%"§E Hiﬁﬁ QQBRT Q?" %<:§Rf'%;'~'C?£a§<§% ﬁx"? 8;K§'=é§§s,L;€}'_§E Q;i"?E§ E"%§E§ mg 28?" 53%;? SF gamgmBgggé-§'3;':'%I"VV;. $RESEN?

"I;":»~:& %~éG§\é"§i.,E {via 3u$f:€§5E :=.;;--V:<':;;:»1:i_§.@;._": '- £2.33 L A % mg §e@s\3-'gag MR§JijE<§;"E'~E§E éaaié §\§:?x£;E E§§2%f_%*%é.. :m.:x:§$.231s 9%' 2@§§..:;'v§ 23>'a**:A,»*%;2:;g55VT:

&&&& " J':%?¥s%Vﬁ§§:S'»VV23®4'$§'§Va 231s,:@§ :?;m~s§,233;M§g:@'$ " »- 4' V §§_;E:%i7:;s:i5§&~*§':é;

M§"E'%:?§_vAi:g§%7ii*§A.§'§':§vS§§{'§E"'éz'ﬁ.?:%' gf Encgme Tax _ ..;:«,_%\'§'€.%:,s_v:§__§;:;::h;;;

' .__Que;er:s'*--E£sa@,, 33 a §a:s":*e¥ _ iféza !i'x'§$§Si3E":€ ?::{§?12'i%'":€%§$$%@?"§8§"

'<3? E?E£%§'%'E§f3 Taxézﬁzwé, §§m%e~5{:j;

%i% {,T,R,8u§%éé:':g, Qiiééiéﬁ Rgaég Eagsgaésra AM:'fa;§§EL:;a_?éT§ {By Sr; E.R.§z'%ﬂs*'a§<u;':'§a§3 §r,€s:.:z':§e§ fair 33:1 Eﬁanmaizhé Enérakumar, Aéxzacaiéf;

QND:

§{?%iﬁAT'i§§&§3§§§"EE§mF?E§ ﬁﬁaaﬁiashakar $30541; §"' 3 éregg, ivéahaéakgézépuramg = 1f2ie5tefC%:<:sré Qgaé, w, «.

ﬁangaiera: g;E«"%_E$?G§ﬁT£}7sE';'':.%7§f_ ; {By Eﬁ A,S§3a§'§k§r & $3": ?«§.i'a::§":i%_V:.%%if _ Sr: 'v'§!':a::@:"as%':e¥<::a:; §«§§€)C§3'€'$§ "

'g&$x%} ms':"r;§"'sgééﬁ?a.;r§'§%é,i§;f"§s:5ﬁ-ziﬁgfg 25$-A af :i:".Ac*;,, 1%: as*§s%reg_.V._§:_si'?:=._'€;:€*-:;,_Qrde%"._£:ﬁé§:%§ .51:~«:€%»~2G04 pasgéé in £?{SS}A..?\§é;'.E¥.;'f,{8a%':g;":§»€§?' f@r_E%§e Agsesgmeni yearg Q83» 86 ¥:a1...:2~.~:}2.~:'}§-E;_;'~§é*2:<y§':°z.g ﬁg fwmuiate the szsbstaniéai quegtisfsﬁg :72? §§W'§§.§&i€'<'Z§._ %§"7%€'!'e§§E, aéiaw téza agwai am 5%': amde :%'i€:a__ ::v§fée';"_ vg3aSS§€f}'§ $3; the £"?A"'§} §a§"§§8EG§'€ in 1';"§{$ ;§}£x,?\§€:}"i%,2;§.a:*:gj';19Ei2'? éiaieé ::»~§§~2,§§& am céééﬁrm E§*:a.{g:; r§?:E%' af ':%1V::=AA§§és;$:an% {:§E'§"°;§?%EE«S§§§""3€§' $5 im€:§::2e{E:3v}g $E's'ci§5e~?:§»i"§,}"-,.$a:':§a'§'i;:é*ég agfxéggasxsg in "§'?::?~:__€::$mm§3$§§n&r S"? Erzéssme "'§"§>< ., -.§@s":i:"aE Cériia _éf;Rﬁ:si%£§:":g_, Quams R956;

?;a:":g§§9ra 3;

2, "me ﬁaggégéaysi iammégaiaaez £3? Encsmﬁ "E"a><~{E{:a;}F €Z§;'€:§e~5{:} C'R_i8ué£aj§:zg,r Quesns Raaé, Baikgaéarei ..(£:P?ELLﬁ.§'~§'?§§'<--._ (Ea; Sr? E,RgIndraE<uma§_, Sr,<:;'ea,2:":5e§ 59:"

Sr; E,.Sanr::ai:,%:% Enésakumarf ﬁévgaaia} g§;'§§_I _ §r: £,Raw§has'2E<ar §"*~$s.4i, $5' 3 {_:§"§}5§S:;

5»-%ah&Eg§~:§h§§:j;"a.r:2, aﬁ:'§$t 9;? Cheré Rsadf §ang&E@;*eg W-RE§é3{;%§'é_ﬁE§'ai"E"F ($3; gr: zasgsazskar & s':L;..%'§vf;'¢;a~'§a « _ am' Sr; vkﬁhanésashekarg gkéazacaiesgj.

?::;s..:m *:'"-:;a-5;'a,s,::'s;ws::r"-wctgan zégm 9% iigzacti 2%:

aréging V;ces.s%: 0-5 "a:*é_%'c%_é'r'-._ %§«a€e€§ 13~»1€3*2Q€%é Qasgeé in §"E"{SS}.éU%'a§"s:~,_;'§e;'},{§é2"§g§.Eﬁ};>9}'j~fag' the ﬁggégsmezéi: ';.f€§f"S i§8§- 86 {Q _V12mQ2'-.i'§9§.;- gjsfaying Etc: fsrmuéaia ihe §a;%$:a:r'a§§&§ §:ges:i:Ai@:2:;: 5"? %a'wV...$%;aie<§ i:he:*=:~3§r;, aféwz €238 gggeaé am 59%:

"V"«--..;a;-<,:§£::i.e" é,§**':;a"~§rz§er iziafsgeé E32 iﬁa EYAT; Baségaiam in ._ ,ZT"'§"{.§Sf;5j;.S'-§{:;M§é§jE5r2§§§.§9?' éazeé §;:?;~iﬁ-ZG§<% am mnférm _§:§é'r:T_é3';<r§_§::V_9?"E:.§f2§. §5;<;§§ia§':i {:G:'§":ETEiS§E%E"':8%" 9;?' E€2£:3;:'::'2a{Em;}, :.:.%_:::,e_«--§g' };;,;;§a;n'ga§em.

" --jB§"::,rvE§;'%::

2; "'§§é e %fZT$r2%:*§:é$§éz3§:&? as? §§':(:a?r":& "Em C€':"*§'§§'E"§§ Sjéniéa, " , . Ag":

"£32 ' if} C:§;»§z;§§€§é;'*;§;

Qfjﬁéﬂﬁ Rcsaﬁf Eaﬁgamre, 2? Tm ﬁxgsisiani Cemméagizrsnar Q'? Ensame "'?a><-{§:":a.:}, CEE'C§E%*é{1} Csﬁﬂgufiﬁing, Quaezzg Rgaé, Ba:/égaiarae ...;£§§3'%'?3i.jL§;_'g{3;bE§'§F?E,:"A {ﬂy Sr: §'R,§ndr"a§<uma:*_, Sr,C@un3§':E §Q§'7» } Sré E.Sanmath§ Egéésakumarf £§veca§é3$--} AWE:


Sré Cgﬁirésh
fxfgéé, §"' 8 Cmgsf

?»'§aE"2aEa§<$%:Em:rar:.:_,   
Wag? sf C§%G§"G_ §:s}avﬁ_,    j'
ﬁaﬂgaiéra H    j .L.F%E'§V§~?'QE'\§§EE\!T

{By Sré 'SMEmaniagéﬁj~S'T:*é'--£i§?;'L;~'%~'s;:a and $3 V£Zha§'z:§r§$§:$';i_a::. §'3§":'T§,?»«'%_,'?£a'E8$:) *>i<>%< :3?'-s.féEe§ agnéar gaﬁéarz 26 43:, Q? miﬁié, 3%} "'A%__;a'%éVg.%%ég:V '=§::€:"A..;a§.. G:"§E§'" aimed 21»§.§}»~ZGC%4 gagged? in 11% {'§.E~:«j:,£'*=»;,?H3'{:;v»,é<3j'§ang;'jA§§? fag? 32$ ﬁgazaggmena agearg $82» :Z:.~§";ii.4E§9§, wagging ':5; fcwmagiaié the SE,E§}$i8§'EE§§§ é$'%:§@;:«,§ $5 %a::«; aiaiaé fiégaremf aééasw {E26 aggéai am' wig éa "%j%:%: gréer msgeé by ?§"':€ £"§"§%"E"_; B5§:§a%{2:"a in 7Z3.S}si;?:£§.£§;'Bang,f:§§Z? §5i§{;§ 1E,--§$--~2C%{%«€ and aéﬁférm {K};-

.£:Cy.{.r (""1"

C} 9.3 :;§:'§§r 0% %:%':§ Aﬁaégiant iamméggissgs? <1}? E::€e:*;':§{::*a:}? %r§Eé-§{ij;a, §§=3§"2§&§{I3?"€.

s'/"M, E"?§J\§Q,23f;5_f2G§§:

§E"§"V".f§§§'=E:

Ea Téée Cgmmisgéansr G? Encama Ta}:

ijeratfai ﬁiraée, Cxﬁaﬁuéidmg, Quaemg Road;

Eangamrea 2, We ﬁgségéant Csmmésséersar Sf' Enmme ?axw{£rsv}, Céraée-égji} C,R:8:;E§é§:2g_, QE§E3€€§§ Read, gangaéarek ,,Aé$'*§?§§,fém%V§'>§"€S {$31 3:; E.mag:a§guma'r;«.é:"s._£::;;rgsgé"§:é§~ ._ Sri E,Sa_r:mat%':§ kzérakfumagn_ﬁaf:'sJG:a:-e'§_} A' $;~; €i,Ev!a5he$«%': 1% F'-'ﬁgﬁk-£3-<:§ 9*'"'=% ﬁrssgs, %%%ahaEa§<§§:%p5'::ra'm,,VI miesigjsf' Qﬁarﬁ ";?~":.s>_aé, """ Q,.RE§?{"}§'\§§E§'x§T L:s:§;'$V:; ';a_$:«:;3vr:_§«:a;& & Sr; ;€v§,Laxga 'assg-'3»: 'a;a'::%:g::Vg:;vg=las2mm#; siéazsiaia} A. T%ﬁéé'S ETEL: fiéaé ééfiﬁﬁé" geaéésrg 266% 3? E.""s"1&{:§, 33%: "«.§¢:<§g%;r'é'§2 $2.2: {:5 aréer daiaé :i;}~:§§»~Z3G:-fé gassaé E52 _ E*':T{§§}é,§*éag48;'8ang;§;'§§%? fey iha Asgeggﬁéent warg :%8T§» 8%} is 3,2-Q2m~:%%; §%'"a"g;i§':§ $3 fermuiaie éhg gzmgéarzéziaé gm ¢¢¢¢¢¢¢¢ gmgiéagrzg af Saw siaiaé éézérein, aéiew me agzvgaaé am; $9: agézée iféﬁ arses" gaaggeai by am §"?£a"E1 Bazrzgaiwa in §"?{S§}si%§«§§.é¢8f§saag,f2§§? ﬁaiﬁd i1~"';€3-2G€3é% gné CG§'E5§§'E'T§ $528 Gsﬁer sf am ﬁasgigianég *C§§"¥%%"'a"?§§S§Q§'%€E' 9? IncQme{Em:}, €ir:!&--5{:}; ﬁangaﬁsra Eihege ETAS gaming 52:": fer fmaf 32%réngigim§:'hééj'--..<jf2:i:%_,_V". §'m<U?'~%AR 33, éeiéazereé the f§E§aw:ng:~ }i.}BGfVIE?\é."§ A3 gamma: a;u€3sti£>:*:§~ a':"..é_s9 fém. €::"%'§§§€§L€'3 ?'§7i5€3_§féWVS53': ah _ > mesa fem? agpeaés, §r@fer:"&é Reéézfégjé against iéze eréer 9? the T%"§§E.i§Ea§, téiéiag _gr s t33V§<:@'%;V--.';%;v.%;;:"::§ge€h&r, ééspsged Q? by Ehég aamman sré;e;.ra~ _ jf ' 2;} -The pi':*~é,_4':~?i'z §':":;'.'--¢:__§"~{;%* "§:"é3§zLsE Erzzergrigag 833$ we $:*'% 15'.CE';3§i':i;':fé3F2§-E<a':'~_ azxééfa geﬁmzaﬁ 0:": :i2--~2~2@9§ ééﬁﬁﬁf' 'V'~..§e£Eéén:,_ -L..f_;§'2 9? %?':"é' 3:n§@m§5'{ax ﬁat, §%:{h§re%;';&§ier ,5a::%:," far ghari}. Z2': the =r;:::>:.s:~§e 9? $€§¥"{§"E :;ca'::;;§r%2&:€i*g'L'§~.:2ég%§::aE§r§g 'me aﬁegsaag herair: iﬁféfﬁ ssaémé. "ﬁn é?::»;2?;;_7~?:;a§%S §}E'G£S€§§§"E§§ wagers ésaiiéatm? aszﬁez Eaaiésa V.'-:§$:3'3':T',} $5 ihé ﬁlﬁﬁe %-§=:}:::;&:re:3 the naééw gerveaf iii'? ':%ée V' asieegseeg wag 5:365? i€~a::E':%23%: EESFS' Mia? $8%'1:'§{iE 9? E":§'£§£% am ........ --

35 we ieamezj gezzior €::}s.m:;_&% a;3§ear;:.:i:::§' Rﬁvemse aggaiémg iize émggugméé aréeé" ::@:':.%tér"s:§~e§'-Eéaéi' M iémugh me pmgeeéings iizétéateé .£Js,,;;_:f*:{§e:f"§e:::é§'_<:r*: '::§8§§ the saéé gmvigian 33 Such éid net}€ozf's_"i%r§f§§ETaEéA'a._ §'2:::*v%._;c;é{A:::.T>A' be éggazed ta the &S$$$$€€. "Hie s;.3'a=._§_é .g3rr,>::i$:V;:§wr:"»e>:;3'%:%§.§e.§}g'~_ pmazééeg ﬁzai ma §s*e<:ed:;re ;..'a:91e~§y::*i@éi{E V_:,:a*:d;Ve£=V_S:§Ci*%~:>n':58 " ' E3 is be feiéaaweﬁ. "E'here§<3re_, i_%_:__ié"-;}:;z;-:zVé§éQ%:'*s;«-aéf Ch§%pter~}£EV 8 aaméy am t%:€2'e?<§';jé'~..':h.;Vs :.$é€1:_§<i>f?'«.AE§86C vmécéi is a§§:}E§€&%§€?r wézéch éeaig 2.:=.%§':E'{'3.::ér%:§_:s§i'a%i_§.Qh ;_9f Lméé§<:§o$eé §nc0:¥3e3;"E§2€:~ :§§'Eie:f§%§ igéagié :,%z"ié'§d léé' §§:::'%:Een 1§8§C ég the rwiirca §€:--€f:§e:,;%§ Tizerefsre {ha ayder §a§$&é 33?' ﬁe' "?F5b%:3?"1V_3§V§fz":3§é%'v:':§"'°%?;aé the smtém :3 mm and {E19

---.,._@rz;7-éﬁ?' :;_;:'2;§se:;§ Es': §é_§";'g'u§n::e ef gash miisge ég gigs: wﬁiﬁf E3;

' _ §§'§'€3§ E 'and-'"':<.éaf:,;§:'§§ :9 W $9: Ezgiéa Gr: merzéa he <:@';':_'_%;é§i:'*:§§&f*af§ §;':Ej_aa¥V'%: 3 sum :3? §s,%':;E;2§,385,,:'3~ menérzg égaiame W,$§"'§@w§"s" @152 am Siﬁtﬁméﬁi 9% aacwgsizs §a:§s2§<s§':a°é by $919 "'-"_'3:~;;s5é'S1_;'§€e$ msaa mi: 8§§3§§§S§"?€i§ by §£CE§}§&§§8 €"«§§§§%"'%C8 3:33? i%?:§:°'&[email protected]*& by gériug 3%' gﬁiiéﬁﬁ §§ ii £5 éﬁﬁmﬁé $3 %& 5:":

%;~>\---»-- ..... -

Wig-

ag iF'§CC%E"§%€ §§:":v€§ fmm §vE,?§,$r%§:*§3za E:eaze%<:zg:§&:$ gs aanaegnaﬁ, the agme is aim ms: éégaégseé am t%2e_:%_§"e:'e the ﬁsgegséng authority bmugézt E: ii; iax, Es: ;r93§a¢::.': ::=s;"_"'e':é.f:e ﬁiary gaézeé am 9:": iézai: bagés agﬁsgment é:3'~----zI?§;édi§.{;'_.__§§tV.. méésiéiuteg a ﬁaczsment ﬁigcieséng ihe :3mdéﬁciéiéféﬁcii*%.§§VCa:%é"?':§: "

$503: $33 gaimd matﬁyéai aaé me ?;:"»§§L::zaf é;§:a5 's*is£%I£:'§:§5.'i_§f%eEf, 2 in énzerfarégég with the saéé féz':é§s':g;._ "é"§_§'1&r:3f<'a\g:_;: :5s2E;e§:"%§.s: that bath 9;": mefétg 33 w€E%r as am"gag-2r2§€:§GT{f:v*"-%A:;}¥V'iéwef; '{'§?*z%=;--fa Tréburtaé was mt gugtéféed in seE:;%;g as§§e:1._:§'2'a:.é;r:"a?"5e;r ggagsieé by im asseggérsg azgiizmriftyn

-_ '?>@§*"":;:>V-%3A¥ﬁ%=a;, '*%i?%'e~._ieamaé <::r5:m§e% apgeariag fa: {ha a§3@§§@jaV+3u;o§'§,;§EiA:é:§* éaﬁsugnﬁé $§*<:§€?g P. ; _ "¥'5*§<é§::%si:a5':2%;§ E Q§..§€3§§E{";f'ES <2?' Eaw w?r'::§<:%': a:°i§€ my 'V"5;s::zé§é<"ﬁé':9';§:%<§:':.é_§r°: tmagg aggeaég §?'$ aa :;ndar:~ ~"§'}..:E-?%;f'.§é§:?r':efe:' 'aha §mﬁ§§:§ Q? iééé "€:*%§Lsz2aE iéwaé 3&9 . 3-_ mi:§£'e égsaeé §,::";§§:" EE3Ci§{}§"§ EESEC $52 5 reggeéi 6? $39: grmxégg ;;§':{é&r sastian 25338 is; vaééf ab~§n%':%5 am fE§"i€§'€if3?f{§<.' i::7.§§ Gfdﬁé" Q?' ;2$se§$meni: gasgeii in gz-;§z_s"s':é'2:..?f:* 'V' V gzsch ngiéce Es a§:~i;§ zzgégj big ii: c;:§%:"'£&3é%;'?,

2) Whethe: we @;*der ';f2as3:é_ eic:} 53 heéﬁéag zhai i%§e:Ee..V§g :.;__:'%dE_$é§-§§'a>;§""§:2a'éme " V ag féeéé by '::%2e:Va-éV¥;ie;c;siie*3;g aﬁé[email protected]§bg.'§c:aE§3 far :'nterfe;*e%i'<,%?*' "

ﬁg Vi>".. I':\;*.'-1» é:1?':ea.§ s gpeégéaé pmaeéu re fer as:;z3s§:_?_'27e*§;L'E:_.. E_§E 3v.;S€:'€i§;EZ§5: ::a$es, Segiiéon 1588 i5 the defénétégm " 4Se'::§€;~é:;"'«. .;::§f:?1.:=..'""E3__eC':§c2r2 EESBA :§@a§$ with a33e$sm£é€t;:'@f :.:'s<:éé":::§'§:§éé--::§"é%zm::'°:e 33 a remit {sf $ea:*ch.. 'ﬁne §;Qv;r's"m:,;4€*:aiE7<s:f:_',%f =;s§é€iE$€Ez,i%§eé magma far 338 béadez §s5e:"§»:.;~3%*:§; §sug:§:fc=v%:.:§§'e':f«:,§_:i:{E:3: Saaééwz £3858 am §f3§"Q€§ﬁ:,§€"Q fa:

.%3%::€:i_< £3 gmazéﬁaﬁ E_§:"'s§§?' ﬁaatiara :§§8§C: if in Y1 ;%.:£«:.T';:§%L_§'vr=.%;}&:«. '0T:,'.§:;=s:§;"€E2 am seézasre é? 35¢" §§%":£§%$€:§$S§§ éaaeme <*s?As%_. ;::~e§f3::é'éj'.,--'T§%§"2§;" E29 geggén zésmae g3rem§g&§ £3 gearahaé E3 zeercaazemdf Séaiéazs $838 gmvésfag 153:"

agsegsmerzi: af 3235?: i§§"%§§':Z4€§%:'sS§§ émcemg $3' gush _:<,.::s>:_jri';s;<>Ts:_s; Sectiage £5833 §"€'38@$ 53 zméern 'iES8BBx.{:} Tﬁe :;nd;'§ciaseQ',..,.i;f:§caaf*é"':2?f'_':%f%§:= bieck periaa' sﬁafi ﬁe €535 gg4:;:A:sg£3.::e:fj»G'f"-@593' 1"-Q4i'"&5 éacome $2' izaﬁa grevigagg,3/@ars7fa§f:'§?§ w:':;'f3;:¥f'% Si",-'e " ' éfsak ;rez';'a<:f gampwéeﬁ, ;;'--.§§§"~~3cc9:*é::'ai'ncsA w§é5~-téfée' previgisng sf :*f2:s__A<:*€, mf;___f§se__z§3;_sis bf'-ayfﬁgééae fsumﬁ as 5 ra3s:.:§'.§ ':%s<}f éééafﬁié "..Q';»',, %1:?ga;£§§t£sr% sf 59025 9?' acjcazmé gr 'é:f:'?é'r'::?§§£;3.§§§§§~f§_'.3:?a' 356?: other mg:+€§?'afs i}fA"W§%i?3{Q.§"!%"?§>AE'§f§_f?_3S "=.,»:§*§ $2/3533358 W5??? §:"f§ce:s%-- réiééabfe 59 saw:

evz"de}2.:;e§,'V:;3.§ }3es'a'z;'V:*e:§';:j éggregaie :13?' we @358 may be, ag ;?;%s:ré5$_se*:?: V§:{§;..%'§fse44V_VV'a.§§:;§e§ate :32' me iesgeg Q?' §:,zCf'f:-- L;:;*<:> 2/ééfzzéyiieg 0% iermineﬁ, ~ a;}' wf;e'?'e.§§£aL$s.r:7e;?€§ s;:s?§'e;' §e<:':s'§:% 24.3' 0: .:3*'::.?§;:":5*;? 244 0:" sesiﬁsn 34;?' have 52%;: 'z:%j,:s:.:=;ﬁisT:,:g§'€§ {ﬁrm is 5.5% :::?§§*§ :2? '7é;';*=E3"::r'2§:'?:",*§rrse;';§ §:' gm gegrsf? :35' 552$ 33% K52? re§?us'sii"§§;::}, an 5533 iragég sf gucf? § §s2:§§gmea§§; .

{'3} {5} (2% 2* 13 wfmra §'8E"£,§f'f?S $525595' $a<::E"s'::;;:

aaéica £535,333' gfecféaz?

gsgeggmenfs have 2'20: @§Ve;? :"2"z.2«:'a'%5:§"'z*-i§'E%;'9'2'e:,3. éaie 9? S€§i"{ff? Q2" reqaigiiéggﬁg :;s;é.§ﬁéA 'béﬁiss A f gf éfm :'nc@m@ 5'f53§i::2.§e§Er__.2 .%;':gs:ff: f"€§';_;;§ff?E§," '~ s";?r:'$;'2"?s5E £235 exgfrsﬁg-.,V&;z,: r2:: :'eé:;r:?}af zrzceme f2a:5A___b%:..e:z .;§'ie:af: 4' --« ' '- % 9;? #26 $3575 c:f.'e i?f;";°és;" .._;i;_§*<:%7:;;c7V%*:':f*_.g<§cf in She 5:203:57 Q2' §;'c'%fé':;;"s§7 ;3'r:.:§-.V_0:'i'§a{. é:}'GCUf'?'E€;'?fS znigiﬁéééneaf Er? 1 €578 _:":<f3--.~%$."é"2a§E "&'é::;*§e an gr Efgefrggfgé "zfhe $earci2 gr i'ii?:£:§}'.€g':;Si§§iV?§'? _é«wj'§?€r& .§}:é;ih gnériag raga}: in " }:air¥'?j§é§£a{fV:ssf§%"<:>f"£';:%s$ far 59;' grevimss year _5s;z;;:§;; gga .:z~;;»_e:'b_;s::< §8s';@§'; Q? ésg'-féksﬂ '3b§s§'§ sf srsirieg 35 re;:<s:'e:2*'eai' 5;'; 553a '---E§9:3§<.§ éé"""éC::'0:;:;:" arm' Gfﬁéf §€Z3€{§§?'?t§fE'§"§§ '_';«::3 3"§;:fg§z:Ea? En SE29 ;'E{}?{"?"f§§ <2:"2:s;'§s 3:': 3;"

' '_"_~.§&.g':'"f§'}'& :':"?za~.'«* £536 :3? 55% £95555 Q? ' ffagzgssézésﬂ wimre Siiif? inmme 338$ ;'"?$i"

ezcaea? we maxfmasm §.f'¥'?<Z+'i.f.f"?§" 5395 z:'§'s§s"gsa§f£ $43 332%' fbr gay §§"€'*»f§Q£f;§ 358$? fgiisrsg is: §T§?§ §.s'3z:i< §€z';'9§_;

Q?' :'ﬁm:':7»:.= sﬁgaxe 53$??? ffiea' .

2339 (:3? 5;? rgsgarzge §"§§1 _ "1 Uﬂﬂéf' .s:.:£3~§e:::z'::m {Q5}. ' " ' V' V' .3432 as gacésan 248-}:

wfmre She {Liege a'a§§"~f;j:" fifzgég §.Vré-§a:%f:"":zf~ % g'1:a,Z1 M2355 5%» ﬁgs $333 fa: ﬁfing at szgagrg': :3?"

irzsame hag a3;~:§;"svs§, bar? as §"»Ef:'i'£§£'f? <2? inggzﬁa fzaﬁ bear: ﬁigé, §3 :35, in 53393 rm? faffirzg :;sr;§»s:f=._ 'T._ :::s'§usé{::},j,.?

(5) smarg 5&8 greazisasg year' has <3: éﬁe ifgfa sf" fs'i?:?g 5&5, .;f&:;;;s'r; _t<§?"§%§'::~.%éj;?%éé"

anger gzgbvsesiécrn (:5) :53?' 5z;*~:§§}3;é:,§3$"?§3':,+: -.-,,__ AA 539:' §><§§r€a', §f? v§"f?€ 523353 af_§:=.:3;;*2é;§ s'ef3:::'r:g is such i;:r;§;3§@ 9% n2?g**a«:<:;s:§:2;cf;":;2;92:?5"' ' as racgrﬁeﬁ 5;: :*f?eAV_.5<§?Ai3!<s"':3Lf 5%C:"{3;;,zi; § $23' €}€"f?€§" €3;QCf{§f§;§,??{?§'.{§_ in {ﬁe nsrmai a:"as;.::<§Q 'T':':z_:j§ :5ef;9.fé daze 9%' éize; S?i§§§'TC?E iqﬁr ;f@§;q}sz,;i;<;§i1§§ii§:~-_féiéjzznég Se 39:??? A' (' """ 'akﬁéésfa Qgééifiemené ﬂag ﬁééf?

1 " §;?'2<:2r.fc¢'f§>'d:;':«;?${"Twsékiffgécfiorz {4} 9f s;&<:E";":};2 L34 :35 §:;»--e.EE;»3$§§ 3;' 5255!? orﬁér;

;{'f}_ g«§9f:${"€ "'1&f?V'8$S€sS:*?'f@:'"?i" sf azndigazfegeqf V§:3c:2:?:%é"'*?§'§:j 388?? maﬁa eariéer unéer 'aféase {5} cf ;':3§&€Z§fQ;"? EESSC, an {be éggfg ' " géf-,§:;:;{:*:?z agsessmargzp §:~.v;;!3;é.3§§@z§§ ~ £73.!" fire §€.1f';3C%§$S gf §§1§§éi:rm:':':§§3{;:? af §jf?fji§£§QS§§ irsmmei ~ x .{a} iﬁs €353! iﬁﬁéfﬁf gr Q53 3;' 555?: grewkssggs yaaés" ghgff, 2%? $56 gasgpasge as' «._,« ....:§.m g2gg;'sg5$§0;"§,i»e §:§f<er: £3 mg 5935:} gamma . gr 5533:: m:?;§g2:'s::z' 5;"; a::c:s.:2:'§§:2€§ 5:555: :*f:;€'T.__' 'T ;%:§s"ow'$s':>:";:«;* 9:' {€h;'§ £55} wiiﬁsazé g_§.az_:;f;;;{'--§"»j. effea' as 3%? eff 3?' §?"Q5J§§?§ far;/mrag--.§§?$;<;e;§§' "

wager Cfmgtséar W __§:__ z2;:5."éT§s:';"é§}%i*%é1:fV a'€preci3z'?§;": aadar s;;§«$e%<,9£*§:3}:[_ S€t:'Z"§0f? 32 :

Frevfafad mat gr: §em§p:;.:fE;m§ a'&*;§a,;.;fii;*aé{:.§~,;£?2§'é;r* Chagzfer §z'§"~/4 fa; we §_;i?;:i2§ss§ 35? "$255 séééd §ggrega€i0r:, ez':'e;=:;::_2'f"'j.:&.*~a"%:§.%f}' Se: $2' ﬁraughi" forward 22:55:35"j:2}?:§'e;<.._T€;"}&;2;i§:_;:3r V3 9:"

:sr2ab5or$e;a]f';§§prg§&f;§f;i§§z $u£,.:%;=§&:f£0n {2} [{5} Z:_§}fi:_;E?;_%f:;f';"?', ;f!?éG??'?€ arm' iota; i{% é§?T?5?'?£:' Av§'§§5SS@§§i€'£5 !;?£Vf"€8C2".?."Vé'é'§i?e we viaug yearg fa3£g'fr:?g'_ Qerisﬁ gfmif be ifza Incaémée * :3'ef§?{§%;i%§e:3§"..»L.§i9f§re aifawing a'e@'z25§;'§z§ ;:;:s;f _ §3§$2:*;:; "'§ééé"e.%%e;<5€, aamméssﬁgnf banagg as '";"e.;*:?s;;;<:2§:'3§ic:2é'é"'§;%;?Vméaéever rsame? aaiim' {S9 333}; V' " §é?_§*§$T§£:';f '§*:$_£" being a wﬁréciﬁg ;:}§r:";':@;j_?.: sﬁrﬁviﬁeﬁ iﬁgzé :sr§a's'§€i{:3€z:f sirmame :2? 5:39 ﬁrm . $0 ::.f?:**§5s'sn§z?€§ gfsaff rsaé' 52$ £"j?E'§E"§8§§?€* 5:3 §"§x{§ré._ V €536 fzanﬁg sf me ;%§:*::r';e:"5, %'?Js'?'?€§E';'3€;f'....._ i'}»f§:"'.. n.V affscazffarz :::r art: aciaaxni sf e:?§?3r"§r:e:zf2e:"z€-_;:'_;?"

{5} assagsfmané £2f?Q'§f' §,3€C€f{2{? :4,.?"';f2::f£'_.z:fé'::

ﬁeéermmaéian Qf _s'n<;:Q'm§._ ?' z;5r2£:£s}"._' '5.::§l.£3.a V geaéfen {3} 9: s:,;b;~sec€;'é;f: '(;-E8} €??CL;E¥. :"*:fi';'§";é'8'f? * «' 2'43.

{2} fr? Cas;2;§:;:i;":"3g;;:_«i":'?&":;%§3':§§é::'§;$g§:',s* méémé 92' 53:9 bfack ' ";,I%e;:'s'0::2;Vg-§;§L%%I%,i%i:.?§5!ar2;<3 9? $§<::€":'3s3V5 68;,"':f>L,:f«:3?§A,;»§§:é'v_a§%if'§9C Sim', 525;? fsigyi 1;b%éV é§p§y'--"§::5§.:ref@rez'2ce za pféagf-f"fA'E2-:.._§§EG:s:-2&5» séciims sﬁéaiz' ﬁe """ 'a;é;'*réféfer:~£é§ $9 the refevané V --. ';:rrié%:;}':'<:2f':-ﬂaé*;;ié;2.{ ;£%£§;';ég £3? ffze biack Qeariaa' " 5s3C§:;d§:é§ 'tf§é«--._:i=':5:/535:3 year eﬁﬁfzsg wééfﬁ i";f':e_ 533.543 Q':'i"$é'$:':i'z as" 32? {EM s"eqe:;s'5:'és'm, "'''"x , _..§_N ' ':~',_W,. , __?'"f:r€"5;:».<:f2'e;'; 9:' ,3I"G'zz'§:"?§ {"63 the saZ";$f§§§;*@:*§ $578 ,%s5@s:~::i'::§ affégar 5:523: gay V4'w._ _:.g,%§';%§c§a$§a' :;r2::s:me 55$ §§r9§s';-/ gsgars . _"%:;f;';é'£§s3€@' 5:"; gay rasfzgrzz :3?' éaaasrze f}*"§eQ' is}:

$25 §S:'-§€S:'§£*s.-'3 Sﬁfﬁfé 5&5 Cammeagemarsé 3? 5e§r::?; :13?' £3? 552% féégéﬁfﬁfiiﬁﬁ, 3g 56% 5:339 E'?§3_';f éé, S§"3&§! 53% $53 23% 5§§@:::§a&i ?

:5'://,.... " ' {:3} Sat" 11% gurgagg m' {Em §$'S€:€€SF2'§€f'§f wissfss 557:3 Sfmgégz, {@553 braugﬁé §'G?:f¢'§r§7 . ' fram €525 pzevssus gxgar :,::"2a"e.r £'?:a;2é$;i_'4:/.§f':' -. 0;' anabgariéeﬁ <jeE§f€C!§§"§Gf? :s;2§e---*.f::'$a;£%} secffm {2} 9;' gagééari 3'2 9sf;5§!i 3&5' off aggirasi" €253 s.:{?;fs'i3;Z:§S&Q*"._> &'e€§;'m:'r;e§ in $538 bVfa_ci€*.V_.§§s@i$_:-;§3'?«:>n~§ V' asﬂﬁef ibis Cf§3pféﬁ;"~é7_;1§ ::b.<_f«:1 {:§?§§é&§" fagware?' fer aging §_§¢7E=. a;'*if_;':": é'i?e _§f'egz;}?3;° a§58g§m@n'§§;_§"'~.. 'A ' A H fhug by ?ina::¢$ Asst \:§'§ﬁV?:%é ::j:afE'¥"%AA;&:V. %§'§'f§':G effect from :»6~2§Q2 the:w~'}§fd:-.":,ss'i§_def_Sieci%A?t3'»%£_j_'~3,VS8E%C%" ﬁg mtreéuzed, Prégfsr i<:;«'VVt%§s:"$s§?§ as'*§°f:ie";e§;*n:en: %f_é%"i3z assessment has is be made $2-f_ %;,:4s'/'s$7vis§<:'§'a:%$e;péi~,;%':'<::§é*;'":_§hsf am; mixer geraars Em §rev§$§:3n$*-5;?*€i,fiwé§g.':té:¥,>:§%E--.:.S was maﬁa apgéicaﬁa, Ag £3 séaaﬁérsﬁm Stétéat-.AA2;%:'<3'f§%r€'{;S.'$f the mm Sectisn {hat if '$518 *a3sé:é*sE:2:.§.. <;f§é::ar 7§'fs'%;»:'eé ﬂee boakg sf assaum; 3%' may €.§%;'sV<::::r:?%E~:v:'j:}i's::M ';3_:' G.E am? eéhar §e€ss;:'; sine? §§°':§'§% the jgargas': "'§§"~?§§§.$%3 ::"ré'm&_§se:;§"Vé§ gaarcieaﬁ he aéaaéé grsaaeé againgi smjéé {%§?':{~;*fF_ ;:::e:*~<;::.'a.sf2.i'.»':::'*;§ﬁa*:* "gm gmzsigisrgg sf C%3a§%,§: X::i»~E« "§%:€r'€ gwag n@V§'3':€::v%§éa:': in 32% gag"; ﬁeaiégzz ea: gash 2%? same sf % %%%% E./' any nazéce Es:-= f£=i§C?? garage, §:'§C§f§%{§§'2 33335:: p§'§*~z§§&§ {Gs §§'§£€'{§éi§"€ far %3%e£§< aggégsment ::=-méizéé reaés &$ :s§éd§$r'} fT. "z§85{I.L Wfzers &:'z:«' Searcft: 5:233 éegrs 5:}r:a3'é'5%17;5§f??""*««L:"~Vj. éiﬂﬁﬁf S€'{iE°iG!? :32 as' bsaks 92' §CC$é2f§ff--l<fJff3é,%" daiumentg 9;" &?S§€€£ are reQ;;i>5;'€:a;"::é§";§?;v:ffér. §e£'tz':';ﬁ .E;%§'2A, in she C§SE:' cf ;3n;z;::;e7:f;§é;i2,': f 553} {ﬁe ,/iégseggirég Gffﬂcgr §i'z§fE: V' DV _ A {,5} in rggpeaé 3;" éniziigsijggif.§;': £3'c.§;'i{5~V cf' 3{TCQ£,ii?E" G?" $§fj?§:?'..:€EG.§,f.éj???£L'§?E€S%:§f gfrry gsgetg reé_;a:;':g.é5§§;;E2;?§¥;$"'«f"f?e 385' Vﬁay 0;' June, 29%, ':f;:}:":'Vbefié';<é.:'.:"if?_§ .235 gay 'V015: £35': ugzfé} '£*:ﬁ§*:3.§*';~«./: J:r.gr*y9e iéoéfzie is P§~v"$r;;:9;< _:5c1j_a::'§ff;':';l§r is fumigf: %%%% s:mé:é3- éeiﬁg £5542' man {ii} 4' . 5:?"z'é*s%§§€;*{f§"«<§f;:%fé§r::*§3 s}r2§§;'§§?ed as émiirg a£:::£:;§é;:r2VE."';:2r Sifter dggwmwés 9;" any a;é'$a::§..re;:u;'5:'tisnea? 9;"? 0: aféer $3 355 '~-:2f'3;.z Qfjamsasjy 2'§§?,. same 5 :"?Q§"§€I€ :f@ gergan s':.€<g§;§;'i;"§§ fgzlm is fzgmigé;

é;;'i%2%r: 3:55??? fffffé rsaé' gﬁesing 5933 55:3; fifzeeré afagrss' 535;? 52$: mare Effsagé Ears?» ﬁve 55 gag,

-'ﬁg may be 3§§::s';%e§' 5;: 53:9 ;:azi::'::@ g raaassrg :32 ms gﬁréggsféﬁezf farm gas? azerzﬁezi 55: 5% 5§,r:2§ Ag; ,,,,,,, Wig"

§T?&{3f?€i" 33* a :'e:"z:..»*:';: :.::m"ez' gfagsgg {5} Qf sags- . s&t::°:'a:": {E} of gecéém N2, geésféng faréfz €335; sgrzaamg fﬁéfifdfﬁg {ﬁe :,;ng'§§;<:°§:::se§ £:?:ia:ri§3é :'~;. far mg bfacxéi geriaa':

Prmriafea' fhaé ma :":05;'::te undazi. $€CZs'c_v€§'E'-458. #3:» reguémé {*0 E9 §S§::I€ﬂ' f?::};':_ £f2:e. ;;:}::;§::2é34;§Le----. prazjeéﬁfng amﬁer 352:5 Cf3a;3i:e};:V__ V' » _ Qrcsvéﬁaa' furéher éhaé» -.,§'v~.._%1£rs,e*"A;é":.:.:»*:!__ 'v«g§§'a'}; furaiﬁhed 3 raturf? :;r:a'e:f___L:é?r.§;§ -:_{3:.;5.é «gfégéif {£95 55 e:'2€;'€§ea' éﬁ fffe §"zfev§:.;jvéa':;,?_ (2%) the Agsesgéﬁg -T.'7:)f,%';{::'t5é:<' s_§f_;é'e'EA_'.:v,::t'§':2ceeo' £0 a'e§e;;f.{?2§;§@ §ié:ef ';;;'§;cg'3s;flc£é::§cf 92' {he .§f5:=s::£< ..}?3f;§$§:':V ¢':*"'§a:'9' 0% W5'? in 1:§5t£5C--?:g':Cg.£} 3:242?' 257799 jaroz/s's;"o:35 of i'sf:::%éfaf§o;'2 :'f.1:V%;."»:f';*s€;i2wsé§:?£*f::n§ (2) and {3} 0;' " :f;§e'e;"€_§ér% "~«.'€}<f; ;._ E;jgé:":?:£m 34% am)' 59550;?

,_§éfiSM,? 34$ {my be; apgfyg {'::i}_ 53%» .;{5iS§'e3.§s'ng; ﬁfﬁcesj, 0:? {:i8:°3;'_r?:;';2§i"E:,m §f?é'%'.;??'§§'§35Ea.§e:3' éwsgme as' we éfﬁﬁk :.§3ﬁ&f%:'asf sir: §€€$Fi?8f?£'§ yariif? 55353 Cf?c3§§€i} gags 5:; <};~a'er $5" §;§'§€§fZ§:"2'"?§:'?i' gm! ' ~.:%'ez'ermm6 we 53>: §§}f§:§§E by f"?§}'?"§ 53:7 329 fﬁagég as' f3§§.5i"f? agggggmmf,' "'~.g'"{:§j§ 55% :§S§E§"§ §a§2e:*§ wafer Sﬁiifﬁf? :32 gr 'X reg;§s'§§§"§ar"seQ' anger ségizész: 232% gm; 5:: gfgaéé wizﬁ Er': §::§Q:"c;fa;3§e :,-a;'§ff2 $56 §f'$%:'§§§:iﬁs"E3T 0:' ._ ggcfiaz? 3325} V "

Tééa méé §:'§\2'ES%{3%'1; maszéatee tize gewége G? r2a:§;é;:% i:Q. f3€%?S0§'"§ reguérégzg him to furnish w§tf":é:': gush.?:§.r"é_éV.ﬁ<3--f'be§;'%:{}"

$855 than 15 éayg 3 reiasm ﬁg: iéfga gjgizrgs;-$.::%i.T;§a§=4<:§"--f$'r*n":».__ aA:§@' verify in ihe $§:":"ee manner aV:"--;: ﬁihe ream: g§v:?;»;1 u.Ef{d5er :3;:s,s'§'}%- Cfaugeii} 3% sub»§&::i:§ars(é} s3*f 3S;a?:_Tzi¥;§{:§n £42 :§e§t§n§ am; his tsiaé érémme E{E€E%£ﬁ§é'%§ '{::E'} €«.E..£f"B£§A§§§i§é)9E.»%'£*:§§§v.§i?"§'£jj@E"ﬁ€ fﬁfthe ﬁ§a€E< perégd. Thergfﬁre §'\ih€§f_e 1*£§*3_&. 3S;§8§:S§.§f;g5§'éV%"§f;. "£$ is M $0:/'se under SeC'i:%0r_:" :§§};fT§$§E§" 0;f"£L'VS$'E':§"-V.Es::--u;% Q? a nsftéie Es mamafiéryq 'aT::§E :hé1"f:§§é3s§:§"nﬁzécg iéaigo pregcréwé améer ihe ﬁat, E!'§"'.§F"{f'E3£*E"'?Q ai":§V&§.Ef§§;';f_{Z'§'l%.§ '{3_@$§'€§0%'I by $%na:'z{:€ ﬁg; ESSZ, ihe 2%:@r$S5"--L'f_'g;:%n;§e:'é" .§<5»%%f.";é:%§%':;»L. §;58$C" $3 E><§F'&SS§'y' gmsgéﬁedg Tm :ja1%'°::? _§§"{"s€r':'§";§§f3f4:l€3E:"'§"§ ié ciar%f%a:a%;@2*3; is: rzatura, Eases"; thaugh §s;§ _§'=:aa%:-%@ «ﬁat %E2?é""g:%m:Es::;mg 9% this Shag-:8? ghaéé apgiy 353$" £5'; £:v%§ $':;':?,7%§;:--5;':er; ﬁetiéaszs E3835 whéséz ég the graazégéezz %Q:;§*:E{:.E"3; _;ﬁ2%'é;¥é_';::fE@;é§ 'ithe §¥€}£§i;"§%_§¥'§ 'Em 7§%e§§< 5SS&3§§"§'E§E'i§ 23:8 aS§a%$m__s3:'*r%iéméer ﬁgciésrs 38%} $233 :3 332$ gr: §",€§"§"§'"§8 sf ', §€€§¥ﬁ2'~éE§fE?8§C. ¥2;'%2€m §j:2E'§€§§<:§Eé'¥§3 we énéiéﬁiezﬁ in iermg :3?' .5 ia/M1,,"

M31...

Eeciém i§8$£ agaémga 3 gzsargam 233:5 is cszzeraé é£s"%ﬁ:'~':%"

Semen 3;58§E> ané Em name :9 ba égaueﬁ $3 pregcrémé mag? téze As: am in téza wgenie 0%' any §§"€SC§"§Qf§,§..§ E?z.!{Zif_§ raeiége in a grescribeé manner urséer §acEie:"2__§'_17'S8«»§';'Z'<.:

Qnégz mziga that reguéres is; $5 Esgzggé' 'set?-'"s"':gv::§s:%:f"§€::.ffzia;::§' 1532 and 1;S€§£§$_és the mtéeze w§":§é:,§'2 :s%A:;~§§j:%gg':;Jré§gc%--.L t%f':; e meme §%'€${i§"§§€€§ Léﬁdéi" Se..c'%:§:&_§2 :§8_$€ ""§T'E*é%:%%j}:.,=>f§_V:*e),_:§ :?':§_ *. aanieniézm ma? the a§gagsme%i%~.,:§:$ggndéé' .§%em m B880 w§1@:*'€a$ miéaﬁ égguaé ;:_%%*;§er"__§£:§EfL§:.a"n_'VEESBC am tmrefare $33 emtére p§"@£€:é?§%£"1g31§v%*3~--.,§}§;:£"Su3§§C€}E3? é-:}_<:%'é miéce ES amid ans? :5 L,;:'*:t@%':'_a:?:--'}§&.;5'"' ":51 ""§"E'»"efie:-3., a§V7$;@:;sé::é._';'§%:a'3$ $5': iéée Eziﬁgmerﬁt is? we §ambas§%'«§%§'g§% {gage of £©MM1$SEG§*~£ER G? §§x:<::3:>»:-sg ?;é'>< ,s;;s;?:f"zmA,é'v;>,2'%;'W";'T:§-s: 9:2. €ii:f%§3:?GR%?§G?2§ repmea '§,Q%. :,.§'§"§;~vV.{;/';:1;Ez}'V;i'é%. "in the a§'0:'e$a§§ Euégmaﬁi 32$ ma? _%éfa;f5%3;é':§_A£'%;é:':séjj..£2 tééai a awrah QE3:?i§"§§:E{Z3§E 2%-'gs carzéusizeé ériféze: §§'GT'§'*é§f}§;§§ gt}? 3 §f;§§"§C§"E§%'. ;'2f§e:* éihs gaéé S£§§?"€:?"s 3 name Wggm ma E: wag ézgéﬁ mat E? Em: aggegﬁmem $3'? 32% agge:~;sae--§§:m ES %a be ﬂame, mg a$g<s$s:§§':§ sfféce? £3 zegaséaed ﬁg %m@§<_e S%Ct§Of'§ $833 w§3%::§"§ has mi: $225.35»-:;'z:;::'_2& ":3 the saga Thefefaref ihg bésck aasegsmgrzi r:"éV_fa:d9«__ét§1%-53: _ firm wéthazsi faiésvvéézg 5&6 p:'aC€§ur1eHMur:::'e:'-- wag mzi in law, in iize afar€33a§d':..3:2d_§mf1as"éé.fsaéés-%z%§':'é:-LL.__§§"=33;A giateé that a mrgtéae m@n%éé:":_é_ng V§3x::":éV'?;i%:V:2 éagased ﬁr: §:*':3§.'ee::"iE§§'*:§3 :;r:§e: 'aiéé nsi:§::e wguE€i ha wéék 'E"§3erefVa':f;e :T'itEfgé._}as;;E'§E?f':'»z%'§*:.é:L2ha§ r'z<:: awiéaatéem.

8. Rekignce is gig:-é ;§¥aij:.:'#:¢§§ €13-F3_i§3>£~.3?§§§§§'"§§E3§'§{{ 9? the §@i§'iE ':sa;g;j:-- gage Q? CQ¥'v'§E'«4§SSE§§x§ER SF ::x:£@?v2E'~}"s2.>< vs,"-§2'::§':r:%§>;£::a:mxsE regmea mggaazs) 3:55 "mxmm 52%? ;::a,g;:j~;;};~.% 3:-2' gm af<::z"eSa§{§ Eaéﬁgmeni if: wag E zzeévrj'-3~:i:%:3a%' e_:§2%$;<;§"-V;%.V_§:§ee~r<:E: Wa§'§'&E'1'€ :3 éggagesﬁ €333 agsaggéng .%:3f§é:f:%$ _éu Ef:::4;ék';=..V§::a:@§<§ Em gresasigmng sf Sﬁiéééﬁ :;%8§€ $3?

Awé:§§:_%-;a?;%':;2.§f%"~::';§ éSS§S§%"§'s$s*':§ grsaaaééagg zmdar €ha§%;%:* XE'-a='T__€S. S.§a;~*:E";"a.:':é gaézum :;r:ﬁ§:* §aCi%@z: 132 s'? 't%":% ﬁat %§ g & ::<'»":*'::;,§%'%:§§:"é ;;:*§c&é&r2% is: énéiiaiécsrg Q'? pmceeéérsgg :_;r:§s2r 3 >-o¢ooE:3»¢~un ﬁhagzer X323 3 "é"ha;z zjxsam mi ﬁﬁﬁﬁiég w'E§?: a aefiaé ;§;h%£§'é ghsaéé be éseueé Léﬁ€§E3§' the grexxigéams' ??:ere.f:3.%f§é3'4.._3t§*2v;e Euégmmic hag rm appéégatigm $22, {mg 5553 "§?2@§&fGre in {he Eight Q? what is S§§?Q§v:4':"§Vf§V§§A.%§¥§_;_ {€929 "kééunai wag mg: jugiéﬁeé :5: ;é:a%é:ééf'%§. ":h';3;t'fa'-.;:;§§'*:é.;;g'f §"F?&é"'%§§C}E'EE§"§§ §'a;§";§{3'>?'{€§ ﬁg» %'2a$s;T:}.4bese:'"é".§_s:$--::§<3? §:~:9éA~:§~r=2:r* ;§@i;:%;§é>;:"? 1588C in a grgceeﬁéngg §r*e§tf§até3<§:L::*;der'";";i.&;§i:.§é§": ::§8B§} ég 'méé abwésééiégx ?Q£§*£"'{ N352:

§.°, " 65:: r%:é:;'E:%:.s7'Ttv§*2é'*a$:%;&.s§%ng autézariiy hag heié that {he ap§rzér:§"'::ia';2§i:Va;%V--_g?:'::»vé;;=:':bgx the asgegma ag an :~é-1§8E ' >._ég iv-Eiié::;»§ﬁ:3§::§a§s3§i;*;'$§;:*:*se 53:" {ﬁe %:zE:";£E< p§r§::2é, if: is mi in b§€3=iZ§< ganseé ig far we gsmésé farm : ~="%,'_§"§L:'?£r8'§é{§I.V_i%.Aﬁ«12~§§%$, the éay an an.:%:§c:%: ma Sﬁafﬁfi wag;

",_:9::§a;:':§:€€::§ any énaiéme acatrzsgé is me §$§€3$€€ ﬂaring '~If"::%:;ss'~«_.§e::aaf if ii %$ 52¢: éégaésgeﬁ wouia ::@5':3%ém%a :,;;r;éé§;::§@§e:§ magma ag éefmegﬂ urgéez" ﬁéatian E5888 2:?' ighe _g§"..

ﬁat' If 3?;§'"%€ gaéé amaaseét Ea; 2%:<3:;x;;: ag 5 waning %a§m::e is'; aéi tha asgsagaeg ézéégt is ma éncméa whégés ﬁag aafgiéazad grim' {G :~é;+:@8§§ T§"i8E"8E§%:'"&, éhe Eﬁiﬁmé w?:§%::h"'--«%:;i:2$ accmeé tag iha aggegsee 3:39;" ti} tha aammeaagmani; :3? the bégaéz gerisé wauédH:f:é::..,.C€:.fé'§t'é:;sia-- gméigciaseé éammﬁ under C%:a;';ie§*"§{E\;'~E:_ égf %::%:%.%i '§f'%A.g.:'§; -.5%'7hé-- cgntaniém cf the Revenue ig ihaé. %:'::'_"r%23;péa:jE %':%"ife "'-5«:.a"é?;I?j amazmi ihe §SS§SS€€ w.»:e're._ ;"s@':A.V_ a%'>iea'%::;";_A.__g2'£':§§:.2fi& satésfacmréégg ihe mamréaé Ea é:'%:§,?<2:i the 's<:§;:r::é.= ef*".}:E":Vé saw iacgmex Tfeerefare aq:.s:@ré§ré§:-----~--%:é-. {hem S&:.%:%<;.:é 5% ég attgacmd 5:26 i:%':@§"@f§z9e---.§§5' £3'.de;3:;":fzé"£5_'L'%?a§V%:»e the éaieme <3? §§":& a:;§e§s;éé7I[_.:3fV'¥;us.:%j;"-.§i;':ar:~:f:éaE year and mrégiétuteg :.,sr3ax§§ai_:f2éd_ é§:xéé$%§*:*:e%";%:iV"'--35Vtaaémaii 9? {mi zszziemééers we Eaammé €a§'L,%§?€§3§ éeéiég. Euégmﬁéi sf 'aha ;3k§3§K Cam': {E16 4;{:;&£i,e 0%» .,§ﬁ<:%i9«zsx/§§"S£"s§<";§\§§R G? §§'x§€S€*«*'§E Tax 353, %<,§}?§~é;fa.--:v-~-:3' regzsrzaé E9 {m::s?} 2% W: 433 .---s '{S€3j>-.. "§'v;*i§,;2ééi:A 'é;:aa§'§ a; cage :3? sjeezmé séaziéemi magma azzaragmg aéméiéediy aizsrérég 33$ biﬁﬁié gaséaﬁ.

§H?§§';%'-§T_E§':Gv_"'=4",Z*'{_..vA'E7,f§"Eé gaéé 3Liﬁ§E":'"2€E"i§Z mg as agpéécaiésﬁ iii: i§"§€E E

--V §%:*'e§:m:'_*:,%AA$é§":<::%:§§;r: améea 'chat $e&::§, €&€t§ sf tfﬁés 5:836» Ezﬁaci, the "méumaé gm gang ':%::j_5:;;;2§%: the racarég iwag Lateggsriciaééy giateeié that we r:'2a%?:':::':.sf:é:i=32«E_'e§: raaaré éﬁgarégr d§§2'::3:°:$t:"ata§ ihat rm agsaggajs-3:55 anaugéz regsurgea £23 gubsianééate Qg3,<~f2;f}éng _{:'a";fr;'§ié§§': .aVs"'we ";: 4«1§§§f the asgegsees have M)': $;aEé;'_i:%:£é tazg 'ﬂags ﬁpenérzg aaggéiaik Thig is eufséée ¥:?:§'=.ambit' _§f3{.%;v§<:§>:m%t:%§€§< --. ' garésség ii gamma: be 'aa_f~,<a~§ asV__;§V%é-ssésaéklegeéé' *;§°2_<:: :>s"s':§§? far {he bieck geréeé $33 i:%2e:'e:.§€}r.e;§{f--:§é'i*§:'és':_ cf eméésaéased §l"'%€,ZGF'{Eé unées the af;:.a:*1es:a:§'d "21eTa,@ .'x%9a;'§".v"crdereﬁ :6: b3 ﬁaieiteé,

-. En. V'§§ fV§é'%:"-§§IE43f§"'%§:4€TQi.'§:.i§7'%§ afaregaéé fazitg m:& are sf the 'ﬂéifsf tha%f",§13_%;Ei':3_ a::faE"<.i. "'_.s<;§e€':£:1g aagéiai agcme EC: the §§E3€«§.;;S§ﬁ"§ ail' " §<iaé:":';£ 3*? time antgriaf ﬁg aha »r:::§':r2fz;f»:':a;Vs'§a:s?sT;*:f:Vé*':@i_ cf Ema ﬁiacéez ggrésé, it iannéé ée trgaias ag :,g~:<'*sA§%-§::"§§'s:<é_?<_i~__%:;%:§:"2*':a at aié, we ?:E§;:$§i wgg gugiéféeé in 3 E .

5 4, '4 .

§-?;éL,~'-av "" /' W2?"

:2. Rem zha aferesaéé faéiig ii §$ ﬂea? Eha: the amauni ::':2m§:;:e§ mr {he aggeggmg afﬁcar éa §F's§§i a--";<t§:e:"e aggamgiégn. it $3 mt barna Gut {rem 'aha mai&;;f§;3i §é'é'3é':j ﬂaring 583:??? when {E29 aggeggéng Qﬁcar °=a*»:a"::_ :;:*2E£:;:V§:~;fE§a$f ihe gmgs aaée §°e::eé§i::s at ihg :'a'%Vf'éA'5:3'?"E?T§5';7?'§?,/f;%« $§T'2;'art'e*:

feet, ﬁe _?@§°g9i: ié {am into {0E:i:§'§_£§:é:i*.§f:§"{§SE"'s. j§T§f§&v formatéerz af Eayeait, _:*aad.<::,"'-vL.d:T'*§--%r,7§<E:";gw;:.?a§;§%f: évrfzénmeizééei"

exgenges and Qtimf aVr:'m:V_néE%evs,:';"";3;3:'ESEgégar ?a9ofa*?: his §E"§@§", he hag taken mg 533% af'A§a't::é:'a%§__.A;§'a*:s§.E$:%_:;:se§ and than made thig :a:§..r::o%.;a:':Qn ::'E3E-'ii .é:'iecj-:.5eLfea.%}(;§V~.uiéﬁéjcos? sf Eanﬁ aaé ac§:::rdE'::g.'f:e. '%;s:f s'2 "E.héx, ba§anc:e is me incame which §"E$§&S§§'¥f§;__'§§"E€ {.§E'i@§S'C§'éf§.?'3€§ gmtamés, Fherefaréf the Trm:;j;n §%L'~a»;ae '§::v§iéVf§eGfv En géttiag &$%ﬁ$ me aaié fiﬁéﬁiﬁg, '§%§«a: €:3§'é'«:fEa:>f§ "§:>»§:f {he msés am it :3 aasisiﬁe iha gasaséew sf ihé a;:3gé§é*':_':*"z.e':'f;%:"g:"c:=£&&dEngg, §§f§v'E§'?'} :f§§' 3% $23 tramsaaéém witéﬁ §'*"'é;5§;.QaE"%"%5%"§§S§':§"%€ ""=._"*::§3sfr:?%%%:»§"%$ i';Gi'%CS€"'§"E§2'§ 3%? me §S$T§£S€%§ hgé éiégé ézéégér mggw Téiiifﬁ grim is the ﬁaéte :32? Size E!§&§"s:'."§'§ in wmcéz 'Sag i:"an$a=::*3¢n wag reféazctaﬁ, Yhe ?€&S€3§% agaégzéeé by the aggesaing sffécg? net 221:: étake mate :3? ma game ;'éV_:§<:.% is mciégde it %n the b%G::§< agsaagmarzi ég rm: Ea §he:.~r:s?:_:;%¢ ' mi gmcifigaééy meﬁtieneég Ii wag agar; €:_<:§..i_§F%e_'a:éé.§g;e"»3:$;§%%"a:gT auiﬁegrity is ﬁﬁii man im 3SS§E'; S€€i' A':ii§3;'?§'¥§§':f'$AE'eE.E%E§'E»i§i§ Eiﬁéi' samé am §"'§§€E§ {war %:h;e_sa§2"é';::% ;:s;ré.a:i:.;f:<':if{":<g°': dscasmentg. in fact the éataﬁéanig *¢ix3:5eTAT3:EE .'%.:?'g"<:}é§j{:€{:3'x was E5 2% awe: %:ran§a.;:_:§en" :a»;§4§:£:%j._ éV§x;=:.:":€:Ei'eé §:V"éV':G by the §§S€$S8€ ag feazzzé %:;y' €338 §§S1§%:'::~35'SV§;f:bg ..5.:;9:§é'{§rE__i_gx, Under these sir£L:mgi:anm3" éésggf.-:>é$: :25'; i.i;:*:'Vg§r"a':su§n--<ﬁ' ~~%f.1:%ft Er: the retum it £3 met exigraséiyi§:.s=;>.a;§i.%sc3§'4i%:_E9ia%:_Eha saéé iz"a::§a€EE£;§*: geriaéng :9 E*«'§,z'§,§\a:"f:'a;n'a s:%§:*&§;" ;9§*§v'a*ce imiéw ihg a§s@$§Eng aa3'::§"§<::_s"%§:y §"§?:;€§ 'r:::.aj';--::"§s:._d%'<:~:'%@:": i"{;% §F'i{:§U€§€ 'zh;at mwme wééiih ig sﬁéégafaéﬁé %%":'?;'§--'?:=§____§f§g';zJ%§;r zeiagmg as unéésﬁeseé Ensstzme :%"2éL:":?r§%'%";:._na§ wag gasgiiféiezﬁ in gaiégéng ggéée me ﬁ:2<:éér:§ L...r3.:.':.Tr;sV:*£§:~::je;::;»..V_«§*»;;*é'E":éi..as§&§gé:2§ a§§§§?':C2§"§§'fy'. Enfact 322% aggessees %'é_;»;'::s§: :;f§@%?é~:'%:é.?'t§':e 3&5' Cagéiai gaéfsg fa: éhe agggggmeré: wggm 'wags i'E¥§@~9Z%", :.§§§«~§Z?'; ?,9§?--§S. That hag éaan aaaegmé $3,» tﬁé Qegartmerst in the regufar' a§saSsme§§é, _T'~._ 131 in 3% far ag the trangacéian wéih §§€'f3§Sri_¢§kié;f_éw~. ?m.rr:<>ter§. is €@:":<:€:r:'°:e§ échaé: wag a cage Q?E.3rf§§vV.§;;V§?}{:§"2asé:§" ' bﬁare 31--3--~f.§9§ amé digciogeé ir1}>E:§:€:..¥;jé?;;.:§E":2$':grzﬁ'§+:.ev.r:é§_§::' wag affecieﬁ Emmediaméy §§'%::r__§<> :%'é'e:._$ie:3r£ir2_3§*:;'?; :S:}'ar9i'géE;; they $1355 atiemmeé E0 d§s{;%eé'i€V.:_%§'>,ei §a%':"g@:7a':V':t§*2'é=:§ 'iéme cf fééérgg {he reizsm far wéécix ihfé. Eé;$*:::.._Vg:'.,'é:i:3M?3ad ":'A'%§§tx e><§§re§. iréfact ism a§§d§i:§<>nH_V_ ' ca§@ 0?

Sri -'¥ﬂ«SE$§"3a{§3'{:§%:.€§f§~%é'§<a%//;:'. érg "':3'e$15§pé ::€ "»::':.f..fA the 'very gamﬁ ifaﬁﬁéifiiﬁfs.§;r'§}é'§jV<7§é§?:;?~'%t&C§ ?;?25g7'_ the Tfibzsrzai. it has atiaéngd férzaiéiyx W§i€&~§é:"?;.§é€f§$§E3.€iE:*§L:";<'%"2~£{a§'iCe§ ﬁne Trébunai $6: aséée time gaéci Vs§.;d§:%a.%<:s;2-__aé';é.=.,-7'Es: $3 far ag téze aédéiéssn <:§%"

§.s=14$;3S;3?§;'* '%;%:€ saga as?" ;%'-¥'E,,{"'$A:r:,:*:a;§o:>:*:**;~:%; ."--§fjé:s%;£;'ra§.-z:;t§se':*%.$ ég £:"}%*é%:'?e5:*23§§ 'me $353 adéitéasz wag made 5::

'?;§f:€" %}a::%_s;'~::':"«..§"':§%a:°3; W?":§C§'E sizmé $5': the name :3? Ezéggézdra, Er?:§§§§V§§éVéa§ §_3;--__és*'s',%§%& ﬁéaryg i:§*:€ zéamé :3? Sm§.A:"*n*:a§99r::mma ﬁg r'%v:.}: :2 ES way §5{F§§"%§€ 'iiﬁai ifrse gazéé ézzcama E5 """"""

ireateﬁ 552 a2rz§Eg::£<>§e§ §§'t£{E§'2"':& 3% 32% han§5 ::;:f ééza agsesgw §?E"'§%C,,§F1i'?§g'}$€'2§'§'%mm& am Size Ea ia>:e&._§.:2_ '¥::_%€<3_$€ qérmmgtanceg me Trébunaé wag gasgtéieé _d%V_{é'C?:E%:1§---. f::-gs".

éeéeiiﬁrs $5" the Saié addétém' ii"; giamhfgr as'.'ihé.§§i'_s:3§V§'::%<";'nV§ we cage :3? the asgegsee Ravésha:<2}<a:f"&3*['£G':1:er%:'€é" 'Ea-.é*f§5*:_e? figure @§fe2"eé by %;%':e asse53'i~*éj@"~-;*}ad :*':é::2.%:'%:;»§3&ri' :é'€§:§«;3.i:§{§3 and. L adéétiarz hag Sam f3"%§§€§ '~;':.r_§:aVJ*._§rA1£IV5AvVV5%.:i*'zai: the exggéanaéim Qffereé bVy"-- §:é':eA 'massséabia and We saéé amsugaéﬁjad E:>t3°e:;§- :fi:%fE'e.c ;;,;e;'§.«..E'nVé:j§éé".a3se§sm€nt by the &S§€$_SEgf ms': Canaiémte '§:?E<::f§§}VfQ;{~é E: dérecteé ﬁeééﬁen, sgndéscéggeé"'~.§;'%'::c!-:f::?:_a a é=:iV_' i}n§e:~'I_:he;-sev::s.ra:,éé*'r3§%s2_:jit:+2s', -'me Qréer giiagseeé by the Trébzmaé ém r::.e;*§'%;=f+; §'$ :;»--a§S?e.a" 9:'? iggaé evéﬁeaéa wiﬁch is; 3:33:

am;._§§@;:§.:abE§';;:mV§ {EEESS :29: gzgffar fmm am; Eegaé §E':fEE'§'%"EEi§! .é5.;'«;F2_§c§; ;.g;g%%s«: Ea":%:erfe:*e_:s£a= '§" ;_'.'§ .g Eight a? what 2% ?E3V§ giaieé, 'aha ?§?.;%?£ :=sa,;E:%:3%§::€:i%1aE.'*"' Qi.£€§§E§E": sf éaw $3 a§'22wes*aé ér: faizrszsg' <3?

--_ ??e,:;f_e:":s.:'s:§ ané agamgi" 23$ ﬁﬁﬁﬁﬁiﬁﬁ a'°':€§ 33:9 ﬁﬁiifﬁféﬁ "a:::;:z'&sé:E<>ra my Eaw is; § r2$we:'"€G? m favms: <:2f we aggeggee and agaéngi gm Rezzssmia. E5: the §M$gE.42§t'5 $1328 aggeaéa $58 ;_Q&?i:§'g; aéimrared Rﬁiﬁgf"

Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court

The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Smt.Annapoornamma Chandrashekar on 28 September, 2011

Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath