Karnataka High Court
Abdulgani vs The State Of Karnataka on 25 March, 2011
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
I
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD
DATED: THIS THE 25Th DAY OF MARCH, 2011
BEFORE
THE HOWBLE MR. JUSTICE V. JAGANNATHAN
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.1657/2004
BETWEEN:
Abdulgani, S/o. Appasaheb Timmapur
Aged about 68 Years, Sheristedar
Tahsildar Office, Dharwad.
.APPELLANT
(By Sri. Shankar Hegde. Adv.)
AND:
The State of Karnataka
RESPONDENT
(By Sri. M. B. Gundawade, Adv. for Lokavukta)
CRL.A FILED U/S. 374(1) CR.P.C AGAINST
JUDGMENT DT. 10.11.2004 PASSED BY THE PRL.S.J.
& SPL. JUDGE, DHARWAD, IN SPL (SVC) CC NO.19/96
- CONVICTING THE APPELLANT-ACCUSED FOR THE
OFFENCES P/U/Ss 7 & 13(1) (d) R/W SEC. 13(2) OF
THE PREVENTION OF CORRUPTiON ACT AND
SENTENCING HIM TO UNDERGO R.I. FOR 1 YEAR AND
TO PAY A FINE OF RS.5000/- I.D. TO UNDERGO S.I.
FOR. 3 MONTHS FOR THE O].FENE P/U/S 7 OF RC.
ACT kND FURTH ER SENTENCING H .M TO UNDERGO
Ri. FOR 1
F AND TO PAY A FINE OF R S5,OOO/
TO UNDERGO Si FOR 3 MONT HS FOR THE OFFEN CE
P/U/Ss 13(1) (d) R/W SEC. 13(2) OP PC. ACT BOTH
THE SENTENCES OF Ri SHALL RUN CONCURRENTLY.
THIS APPE..AL COMING ON FOR HEARING THIS
DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
Thi.s criminal appeal is by the accused who has been convicted by the trial Couit in respect of the offences punishable under Section 7, 1.3(1) (d) read with Section 1.3(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act' for short) and being sentenced to undergo one year RI and to pay a fine of Rs5,OOO/ in respect of the conviction under Section .7 of the Act and for a similar period a..nd similar am ount of f.in..e in respect of the offences nder Section 13(1.) (d) I' S t C) b C) C) 0 WI WI m 0 e 0 0 CD CD 0 B ma ma bØ ma CD 0 0 0 13 ma z' , g:C) I a 0 CD 4 WI t Qa x ma 0 CD qqgCD a iii 0 CD ' e CD ma I-' 0 EQ t0 CD CD o 0 ' WI 0 B CD Z' ' WI m w C 0
--. C) m CD ; O be 0 ma 0 CD CD ii 1% ma. blat tIC ma CD B 0 ma lEil IC ja.
ma w 2 CD 0
BCD
%4 CD CD CD 0) Wa.
be
CD -- CD 'S 0
I-a p) C) 0)
EQ 0 CD ZCD
n
0 C) ma
CD E. • CD
CD
ma
ft . B CD
4
bring the challan to the Tahasildar's office for
completing the modalities.
3. It is the prosecution case that on 28.12.1995, the accused demanded and accepted bribe of Rs. 1,000/- from the complainant and in view of the complainant having approached the Lokayukta Police and the entrustment mahazer having been conducted, when the complainant accompanied by the shadow witness PW2 went to the office of the accused and gave the amount to the accused, the Lokayukta Police came inside and caught hold of the accused. The amount which was given by the complainant was taken by the accused in his hands and were put into his banion pocket. The Lokayukta Police seized the amount of Rs. 1,000/- and the hands of the accused tested positive when immersed in the chemical solution and the solution had turned into pink colour. The trap mahazer I o a pa a a a c a a , a a z a in n 3a 0 n I-' CD a a in o a 8 a W;.a B inc a ana 0 B a.
a 0 in a a a a a r Co C, X Ct ' ' a' a' 0 Ce & (p -4 C, a a a B a' a' a' a C. t j a' 0) flI 0 pg a' a CD 0 a z a a CD 0 pga pg a c.. Ct a'[3gC a i. a' a a' qq P1' • a (P a' a apg CtQ a a'pgo a Z. OCt a 0 &0 Z' 0 a a' -- 0 a' !LCo & - a a' a a' a' r - C) CD ) r CD CD -j .. 0 F' j - CD- CD CD CD CD- .-" 0 0 C 0 1 CD 0 CD j . CD CD < CD C) 0 (12 • . CD CD CD CD 2 UQ c C) CD CD -- !-0 CD 0 --- CD CD r - ,- CD rt CD 0 CD * CD r CD CD -• CD C) 0 0_ 0 CD CD CD CD . CD 2 c 0 0 CD CD CD -- 0 rt --+ j. rn -- r CD -j -- CD CD > CD ' -- --. CD - 2 CD- )< CD CD -- CD t CD -- 0 CD r i CD Z C) i - CD CD CD C CD $ K) 0 CD C) CD , CD CD CD -- CD -- 2 CD CD r C) CD CD (ID --, CD CD CD CD . r* -- ' ((1 C o CD- 0 CD ) CD CD CD C CD CD (1 C 2C) ((I C) -- C) CD -j -- CD CD 0 CD - rr i rn L ) V -- r* .. C) - CD CD CD 1 ) -- j C) CD CD r CD CD 0 (12 . . (12 CD (fJ 2 C:
CD •CD 2. CD
-- CD CD CD CD 0 CD C) < C r CD C CD C) 0 CD 0 P r CD j CDI CD - CD -
CD () - o P
CD CD CD CD r-
CD CD :r CD
CD C) H
CD -C C/2 CD
CD C) -- CD -j
CD CD Q2 CD - -i
(Ii. rt C) j. 0 CD i CD
CD 0
r± CD 0 CD) CD
C) CD- CD p. (12 CD CD
r CD
CD CD CD CD CD - --
.
CD CD CD CD CD
. .
CD , 2) 0
-
C) CD 2 (1) CD ° 2
C CD CD 2- CD C 2 CD
CD CD -- .- -- -- CD
-- CD CD
CD r r
-- r
CD
0 -- CD- r (12 CD
cv CD (1) CD CD
V -- 2- 2
rf (/2 (ID r CD CD- --
o '-t 0
= 0
a a ace p a
CD a a z --
b Erg Cl,
- 0
CD
CD 0
CD a --
B a
ccCD
2CDce 0
CD 0
CDCDmB.
\a2CDt
°Q E ® CD
a
D 2
0 CD a a
CD a Z a 00
2 o CD CD a 0
CD Z 0 z a
-. 4'. CD
0 U) CD
zOO
CDe
CD 0
'
a CD CD
CD
o CD
3 &
a c CD a CD 0) CD CD CD
rt rt rt CD
p D p C) P P CT o 00
I
z
cn p 0)) CT CD CT 0 CT n CD p < p
QN CD CD (DON:
00 CT S CD
00 ON p
..
ft. C.
5
-. p CD CT h CD CD P
0 P CD i p CT H -- to p
CD CC rt CD CD
fr4• 0 A DC) ,, CI CD
ft 00
ft ft j (0
(0 °' CL 00
H CT P S è. L
C. 0 00
$Cl aCi p
9 p 9 9p p C
9;:) 00 S
ft p p P t
r p CT o P
0 CL C ii P CD Z CT CD CT P
CT 5
CD Cl CD 0 CT 5: CT
= CL ft P 00 CD '
(0 ft
00
CC CD CT Ci
11 CI CD CD 0 ii &t CD
5) 9
CL CC Cit CD
ft
CD p p D)
P P
P CT CT pi CC or 9
C CC ft P CD .
ft ft CC
ft ft CT CT C) CC
P CD --
0: CD 1
I ON <I CT p 5 CD
- it) Ci -"
-- ft
-- ft CD Cl.
''
9P
CT -t 00 CT n cc (0
--" 0 J) (0 p (0. (0 CC ...
t CC --. -- CL
CC J -- CC
$1) ft . 0 CT
P ft CD P P P CC CC CC
CD CLII 3) 5
r --
$ ft
CD
Cl r ))) p
atsCT CL
ft P P CL p CD CT
; 9 C
ft
ft CD CD 0
sCT
DC. l
p 5 CL CL 00 (0 O• p (0 or CD
ft P (0 p
p.
C') P CL
. ft . ft
ft pp
CD ) ) p
(0 p ) CL ft
C) 'DC CT ft CT < -- CT•
CL .' ft
ft ft -- (0 .
CC pp. CC CD CD
9 0 p 5
ft. NOp P p CT C) -
--j ft. . ft.
CT
ft (0 ft CC ft
ft ft P
CT CII (11 0 p CL CT P CD CT CC Cit CT
CD C: CL to C P CC CT CD ON P CD 0 CD CL CD
C 2 0.
C) CL C CQ
CD rt j j 0- r
CD
-"
.
cC 0 -" - 1
CD •
CT
.
-- C)
C)
E•-- CD
CL 0 0 Q
CD 01.. cr CL - CD
CD C 0 C 0 H 9
._
CD C)
£) (1)
1 j C . - C)
0 0 0 0
CL CC CT 2
t'l CD CT CD .
CD 1 CT 0 .
9
0 C CD C CD
Z.-o 0
C) 0-01 CL
J CC 0- CC CD
'---- CD C CD -- CD
.. .
.
. CD CD . CD 0- CT CL
-- . -- CD CC 0 CD t
CT CT CT CD) CL CL 7 CD
C) CL -- --.
CDiCD.0
CT C) CL C) C) CD C 0 0
P CD CD CT -- C) C) CD
CC CD r CD
0101 4 C) CT 9.- CC
C) -- C) CD
CD ... CD .
< CD m CT --
.. .
CD ,
.. r
p CL -- C CD
-
0
t (C0-
CD CT CC -- CD C)
9 CD CC CC CD CD C
C) CD
CL o C)
C C) C)CD 9
CL
CD CD çjq CD CD
C) C CT
CD 9 CT CL CC CL CD
CD
9CD CL '\ CC C) CL
C) CD CC C) CC
C) CD CD CD CT CT CC CT CT
CL CL CD CD CL. ... C
CL . C) C CD C) CC
-, H CD CT
-- o CD r
. C) CL CD 0- CD CD 01 0- 0. 0-
9 C) C CD CL 0- CL CD 9C) CC CD
CT CD CL CC C)
CD Ci CD rt CD rt rt rt rt -- rt
ci cx CD
CD o CD CL CD b ci ci ci
ci ci Cr ci ci CD CD CD
B CD rt 2 ci CD
rt CD CD CD ci .
CD CD CD rt CD CD ci
CD ci CD
CL C CD 4) 0 0 0 ci
0 CL o ci CD) CD ci CD ci
BCD . ci ci ci CD
rt ci ci (IC CD CD ci
CT CD
ci .ç rt
ci ci (IC CD ci
CD ci Ci r+ ci CD 0 ci
rt rt CD3 g
0 CD ci c CD ci
rt ci
CLCD ci
rt CD ci DC ci CL ci
- CD
CL o CD CL ci CL rt
ci
CD ci CL CD
CD CL ci CD
Ci CD
Bci
CD CD ci ci CD CD CL$LCD
0 ci CD -- CD CD cD CD ci ci CD CL
rt CD CL CD 2 CD
CD CD CD CD Ci CD
CD ci 2 ° 0
rt CL CD
rt CD ci CD 0
r CD CD CD
ci
ci ci ci --*
CD g
ç -- CD -t
CL
c-I CD 0. CD CD -- &+ cci.
-- rt Ci rt ci ci 0 o ci 0 C ci I CD CD ci ci CD C 3D CD -- rt B n (IC ci 0 CD CL CD -- CD ci 0 ÷ rt CD CD r ci CL ci CD CD CD 0 CD CD CD ci 0 CD ci ci CD CD CD 0 ci CD B CD. CD CD rt B 14) ci ci ci ci CD rt CD C) B CD ci CL ci CD 4 CD ci -
Ci CD CD
rt CD CD
ci CL CL CL• CD CD 2 ci ci
ci Q ci 4
cg ci CD --
ci
CD Ci CD
CD: ci ci CD CD
CD CD CD Q) ci ci
ci CD CD -- CL CD CD CD CD ci ci. ci ci
CD - CD CD ci Ci
CD 1
CL B CD 0 r 0 CD. CD 0
ci --t
.
ci ci CL 1 CD
B CD ci rt rt
Bci• CD
CD CD42 ci - CD cii 0 CD ci:
CD K) CD CD ci 0 CD ci.
ci CD
CL CD
ci rt ci ci- CD ci
CD CD CD 91) 2. o CD CD
CD
rt I-- p 14-- rt CL Cr 2 CD CD
0 CD ci 0 ci
ci CD CD ci Cr ci CD
ci CL CD cci CD
CL rt
ci CL S 4-I CL B ci
CD Ci ci
ci rt
BCL ci rt CD ci ci
-
rn
CD
Ci
ci CD ci ci ci ci ci ci CD
-r
ci
CD CD CD CL cci CD CL
-- DC ci
Cr
ci ((Q CL CL CD CD
fl 0 Q
° Z o
r c ? - (
H Q 0
-; C -1
H
1 iQ C
C a.
t cr
) c cc
t (J1 I CD
r H
:c H
cc
H E cc cc
H --
g i ccc
C
- 0
C
ccE;•-
$ 2 $ 0 r
a
Q
cc cc - cc
cc C) ç
Q C- cc)
;: (2 cc
0 0
- ' -a C
. --
C a ?Th C C. --
ci. C) )
j -- C- v CC
C- C cc C a ci C Q C
(2 0 C- C
C) C/)
cc -- , . --.
0 (2
ci C- C a a
C ci ci cc )
C) ci a cc
ci cc C. C C- C
r C- C-
C - C
C < C ccc C
C) a (2 C a
(2 -a a ç
cc -- 0 -- --
>< i ccl cc C C ci C-
C C-
cc ci cc ci cc C
C- C- C- C
a rt r r r+
C- a
C- C) C C- C C- C- C-
cc cc cc ci ci cc -i ci cc cic cc cc cc
rt rt rt Do ) CD H CD CL
- CL
CL () Do Do CL CD CL CD Do
CD CD CD CD CD fl CD CD
-i &_ A• (J):
2I CD Do
CD c- CD H <4 C Do CD H CD CD
H :
CL 0
e 2 CD CL H
CDCDCL
-
CL CD CD H Do H CL CL CD CD 2
r* CD Do Do Do gi p-- Do.
CL CD -- CD
H -- CD
CL H '-t CL CL CD
Do Do H H CL
4 CL H CD H m < CL
H ° CL co 0 rt
CIQ: CD
.
H CD -- CD rt CD - CL CD
H CL H H H Do 0 CD
H CL 0 H j r Do CD
H CD H CL H CD CD CL
CD - CL CL
CL CD CL Do <- <. CD
H-- CD
CD -- < Do:
Do Do Ci HI
CL 5
Z CL CD 4 CD Do CL h
5 H Do CD <-rj --t CD
H Do CD CD H H
CL C CL Do CD a
CL Do "
CD Do (ID Do
5 Do Do
CD CD.: Do rt CD
CLDo2CLCLH &Do9CLaN)
< CD CD
cc cc cc H CL CD H
CD Do CL CL Do CD CL Do cc H
CD cc Do CD CL. CD CD H
--t CL CD CL Do H CL
CL 4- CL Do CL 5
CD CD Do rt CL <
5CD CD CD CD
CD CL 5 S
CL CD
H CD CL CD S CL
CD r CD Do CD H cc 4 CD Do CD 5: CL
CD Do CD
CD H CL CD CL CL -- H CD CD
CD -- CD Do cc CL CD -- Do
H < CD CL CL H
Do c H CD CD Do Do
Do CL 4-
$HHCDC
CD 4- CD CD CD Do Do Do CL cc H
Do
<CiDo 2-- Do CL CL
cc 4 H c-I CD CL
Do CD Do < cc CL CD CD
H Do H Do CD
H CD CL cc Do H CD CL CL c --
cc CD <
5 CD 5) Do -- H Do H
Do CL CD H CL CD Do
CLDo Do CD
CL 5
. F H p CD -- CL 4 H
CL 5 Do 4- CL CL CL
CD
5Do Do
RDo 4-
-- CL Do CD 4 H
H 4- cc
2. CL ES ES S. cc -- ES
F CL CD H cc CD H CL CL H CD CL CD CL
CD
c<
H
c CD Do cc CD CL (3D CD CD cc < H) CD -- CD
CD CD CD Cr CD rt
CD rt cr rr. CD CD CD Cr
c
ci: T p c< 4 CD ci CD CD Cr
><CD CD o Cr ci CDSCD.EiCDS P ciLCD*2 aZ<IECD ci.N ag CD Cr CD CD CD .
CD ci ci CD CD --*
-t CC
C j CD
ci ci N CD
n.
ci CD t Cr n
r±
-- --
j CD ci C) --
CD ci CD CD
ci ci
Cr B CD a
P3 a 2CD
$ci Ci
..
rt N CD
ci g ci CD: CD ci
2 CD --. CD rt -- CD ej H CD rt•
CD ): CD CD r+ --r CD C)
n
- - n --
p -- .-- -- C)
-- ci Z CD CD CD Cr --
CD rt CD r-t
rt
.
Ci ci Cr CD N CD ct• CD
CD, 0- CD N Cr CD c N N
YC) o N
a ci i: N
N CD CD
) CD CD
$.CD Cr
CD
CD *C CD $L ci o ci o ÷
w rt -- --a ci CD CD CD C)
C CD N ci tp - ci 2
C CD ci
CD c Cci -- 2 ci Ci $ N t
CD CD - P Cr CD Cr
2 -3 CD i
Cr ,
ci N ci ci CD
CD
-r CD
--.
.
ç CD CD -- CD
CD
CD CD CD -- -- Cr N CD
(Th r CD N , ci CD ci Cr
. CD -r 0 Cr CcQ 1
N CD r*
CD 0-
2 . QN -- CD CD ci. CD ci
CD N <C. CD CD CD Ci ci
ci ic -- 2
rt
--
ci - CD CD ci CD <CD
rt CD
rt
ci g c- S CD
rt
C
<
rt Cr Cci
2N 5
N Cr
E5 CD CC --5
cC) --. CD
pCD CD CD
CCD cCD$Cr5gpCCr. $
ci CD CD N -r i CD
CD CD CD CD
CD CD <t CD <Cl Cr CD
CD cD Cr - CD ci CD ci CD Cr
CD CD CD CD . ci
CD
CD H Ci CD CD <ci N CD
$. rt Ci CD
rt'
$ .
<ci <C Cr N•
CD Cci Cr Cr Cr CD Cr Cr CD --CD Cr P
CD
, CD
CD ci N
SCD ci
CD N CD CD H CD N CD ci
CD r r -
- H () H 0 03
Ci C) 0 C -a C C
c C 0
3D r 03. CD 3D
CC C) Ci- CL C C)
C i E CD C)
-a =
03 C)
*
3D CD 3D 03 03 CD 3D
r C) -- 3D 3D Ci- C) -ó
r
C
to C) C) 03 03 C 3D
C) 0 3D Ci = 03 CD Ci CD
r
H 0 CD 03
) CD CD CD 7.
r CD 1 .7 1 C) CD Ci -
= 0 -i C
7. 03 CR
CD - Ci
CD 03 Ci 3D
C) CD < -- 3D
C (0 H 03 C)
CD CD CD Ci CO
= 7.
CD 03 CD CD
CL = -
CD 3D o CD L C 03 C)
CD 0 0 C Ci 3D
< = rt a - (JR - r C)
0 rt
CD
CD 03 03 -" 03
-
-- CD CD rt r* CD --
3D CD CL
CD 0 (0 Ci Ci CD CD
03 (0 CD CD CD 3D 3D C)
03 03
-- 3D C) Ci
CD C)
CD 03 3D CD C) rt Ci CD
C CD 03 Ci - CD CD 03
CD CD rt
1 03 =
--
C
03 03 C -" 03
0 C r
03*
3D - - r 0 03
CD Ci CD -
--" 3D
03 C) 0 ci Ci CD 03 Ci- C) 0
Ci CD CC 0 0 CD h CD
CD
0
-- - CD Ci
C3 CD CL CD H H
3 CD C)
C) 3D 0 CD Ci
3D. Ci 03
03 3D -" C) - C)
03 CD 3D C 3D
03o 7 0 -a -a
-- -- rt -a
CR CC
CD CD CD -a 03 CD 03 03
C) CD ) C) C CD C)
** C)
.,
7- 3D
0_ Ci Ci
C H 3D < 03 3D
C 0 Ci
CD CD r C CD
CC cr 03 C) C
CD
03 -i C 0 03
C) 03 -- Ci 03 Ci 03 03
CD CD --
C) rt .7 _=
0
Ci (0 03 CD
3D CD C H H CD C CD CD Ci H CD
16
issued and ill that is requirc d on th part of the
complainant was to takc thc c hallan and pa th
imount in the bank md threafterards produc the
hallan receipt either before the Tahasildar or before the Deputy Commissioner Keeping the aforesaid evidence in iew me will have to find out as to whether there was in fact any dc mand made by the accused from the complain ant 19 PW1 Anand Kalawad is the complainant and though it is stated in his examinmtion in chif that th r11capri 1nq1qri irn en flS\ Rs 1 000 and a c rdn I In m sca ciemanded thc a d mmcun c A n 1 ffF ci h p1 1 mn M )I Tf c e to em t I t CD ci ci ci -' CD ci CL ci CD CD cr ci i ci o CO ci CD fr*. ci * CO ,-
CD S ,
J rt *4
9 9 CD CD -- Dci
ci rt
CO • fr*
CO rt ci ci em CD ci rt
CD ci Ni ci em en CO CO
. ci
ci L CD
]: 9. o z< CD CD CL
CO CO CO CD rt
SCD ci 03
ci CD CD CD CD ci CL
CO ci
ci ES' 9 CL C CD
ci CO H fr*
?*w ci fl
CD rP (_4
5CD
CL CD CL Q
CO L 9' 9 t4 rt cs ci ci ci
CO CO CO cci CO ci ci
H CD
rt
4CD CD ci 5
cci en rt CL 9 9'
ilL CD r+
ci re '
fr* CD
--
9. frj
ci
fr*
CD CL r
ci ci CL CD i ,
CD CO ci CD CO ci CD
CDóa rt )ci CD
CO ' CD CD CD CO
rt
ci ci- ' CD
ci CD -
CD .. CO .
5 CD CO 2 CD
S 15 -ci CO em cC CD 0
ci j ci CD o CL CO em CD CD 0 ci
ci rfr CL -i - 9 .. ci o
CD 5' 9
CO Ci CD CD ?1 CO
ci CD CL ci 9' CO rt ci
ci 0*4 9 CO
CL CL or E cC ci
:
ci CD 'ci 5 -e - ci
CD It ci ci CO
rt ci: S 9' rt CD (ci
CO CO
cci
r*
cci
--.
ci CL CD en CD cci
CO 2 rt ci . CO ci
rt ,
CO S CL .ci CO CO
rt ci CD CD CD CD
.
°' CO CD 9* CO CD
o CD CL ci CD CD CO
CD o CD 9*
9 CO em ci CD . CD
r+ CD
ci CD 2 rt
o ci
5CD
('C 9' ilL CL a: ci
rt -i ci g 9 a
cci e: CD & rt 'C
CD ci -e ci
CD ci ci. ci rt CE
*
ciD
ci CO ci CD CD ci
.
CD CD CD -
9 ci CO
-e CD CD CD
CL frj
S ci X ci CD
ci CD ci CD ci CD CD .. ci 2
- CD CD ci
rt ci ci 5 9,
r* CL ci ci ci cii.
CD
aH cci
ci ci CD CD CL <
cci ci ci ci ci CL ci CD
S CD CD CD CD rt CD CL CD CO CD CL CD
E 93 93 9 P 93
rz --3 4- 0
.• 4- 4- .
ç) 0 L)
..
..
r+ r± 0 Co 0 IN) 0
Co 0 c 2
0 Z j 0 Z rt
ct .
(4 rt
t ..
-4 Ct) -- --
3, RD 0 RD -, rt (t) (1
.
33" 0 3) Q Ct) Ct)
0 RD 0 r d 33
"1 CD RD RD Cl 33
23,
-- )
93 96
CD 4-
CD -- 37 0 0 0 0
o 0 cc --
0 RD 1
RD 33" cc CL 03 0 RD
C ' t C) Q
37 RD o 37 RD 3, 0
Y 90 3,
\\,%&j "
90 RD 37;
I rt
0 CL 0 Cl 0 0
rt . 4-
)4 RD Z
4- RD
C) Ci o 3, RD CD o 3, Co
"4- 4- "1
rt9$ 3",)
Cl 3, CC 0 0
g rt rt 4- - -- 4- CC 0 " 33"
0 CD 0 0 © CD 0
Di 0 0 0 0 RD
0 3" C) Cl
3, 0 Co C Z o 3,) . 2 Cl
0 CL rt
9 9 0 0 0
0 0 37 rt
CL .. rt "4-
ç" 0 0 "1 0 --
r 0 "4- 0
0 4 0 RD 0 *
4- Q 7 """ 0
< H RD < 0 CD --, 0 CD
-- 33 RD ..
..
'1 1 0 0 0 Cl 0
(7 0 3, 0 0
RD '
0 0 0 Di CD 3,.
93 RD RD 9. RD 0 CC CD 0 RD 9 $CDCL0rtC3930 CC 0 0 37 2 0 4-
3, " rt
rt 0 RD C) --
33" 33" 0 37 ( j 3, RD RD 93 CD" 37 CD"
0 0 0
3,r+
0 0 , CT 0 $. 0 rt 0 CO
C) DO . C) C) C) C)
C) p
CD DO 2.
L
C) CD C) DO
i ) < C) Ci i CD CD
CT) DO
CD C) C) r
ClOT r ç C CD
DO ClOT - cc
r* CD 4 C) ... C) C) i) cn
CD C) C) )
1 C) CD CD C) C):
) DO CD C) <-
CD C)
C) CD DO DO c
DO DO CD CD
E C) C) C) C)_
CD
• 6- C) c Z C)
C): C) ..
C) C) C) ) ) C) CI, C cC 4
). C)
6-. < : . rt C) C) C)
C) -- CD l DO DO
CD Q C)
,42 .
C) CD C) ciQ: cC)
. CD DO C) cc
CD S C) DO
C) C),
ClOT CD DO C)
CD C)
C,, CD
ri --
r CD r CD
fl CD DO
CD --j CD CD
rt CD
--
C) ._ C) DO CD
CD -- -- l .
< 1
- cc < CD CD 1
CD C) CD CD C)
C) - C) cc DO (101
C)
DO .
<C CD
I) DO CD C)
CD DO --
C)
X C)
CD IC) _
C) . r±
C) CD C) C)) C)) C) C) C)
Cl) C)
-- t) DO
. .
(C)) C)) DO lO
6 DO C)
C) C) C) DO 2 CD CD
CD CD r
DO C) CD
CD Q DO C) CD
C) C) CD :
. 4 r± . j r*
j
l,4 C) C)) r C) DO CD L
4 DO 4 CD
b C) C)
CD . C) - 4
CD CD C) 4 \ C) C) 4 C)
l,
CD + r* CD 6$
1 C) CD CD CD N
N o CD
N 9 CL CD N 0° -i
.. CD
N CD CL) CL CD
9-
cC) C)
R B CD CD
-" K)
CD N -
t N
0°
2ci 8=
CD ••. r C CL CL CL C
C)% N CD
CD N -- CD
N C) CD CL 9CL ' CD
C/C) CL 0° N
?. 9t .a 1 0° gO
2 -
rt
r rt Nc CD 2D -'
1j 9 CL L. N S
f rt CD 0' N 0° <C CD
CD CT C/t
0° 0 N'
N CD
ç C/)
CD +-- --#
c/C +. , N N
n <C rt 0° N
:.
C) -- -.
0° CD '. -- 0°
V0° CL CD C DL
) --
2CD 9 9 N . , -- 9 9 C)) C)
C)) .
9. C 9 CD
9 N 0° CD cC) 9 0° 9 rj N
CL0°CLN
0° N cc9dcj Nj 0' 0° N)
CL 99CD N 011 CD N
C/) : Ni
N rm -- CL 0° CD CD N -i 0
c N 00 C) CD N
'
© N 0°
CL Cj) CD CT '> rt N C --
0°R9-9-N99% 0°
JO
N .
N N N N CD N' N CT
rt CD CD /*W 9
CC) < CD 0° N
N' JO CC N' C') N DL -
N
CD -c N cb P+
9 N 0°
p.
'-'
CD Cl) N *
CD '
S CL
N Dl N 0° N C0• N
rt 0° CT CL 0° N rt
S N "
C): N Dl N 0°
CD j N N N r*' 5 CL 0°
N 0° N CD CL CL -- 0° 0- H
$ -' 9C"
rt N CD t CL CD N
CD N
cz$. 099° J- N CD: rF 0°
<C N' N CL CD N CL
80°
CD CD JO 9
CD N . CD (C) rt
9 "-'
CL
CD CD CD
CD CD CD i 49 N i 90° N N' N' 0°
N CL N N CD CD CD rt N 0
rp. CD n . CL CD CD CD
CD
N. N N. 0° ' 0° C..,
CD N CD CT 0° 0° N C)
CD CD N 0°
0N
CL CL CL CD C)j <. CL N
0° CD = Ht 0° CD
rt rt i (/2 1) CD
C: C: CL C: Ci CL Ci
CL £1 C: CD CL C: CD © C: C) L. ©
CD Co 0 CD CD Cia
hi CL
- Co C: tit CD C: CL -i ' C: CD
CD (:
C: C) CD 9 CL CL C:
- CD CL Ci CL CL CD t CL C:
© 1
S C: r* CL
C: C: Co C: 0) C:
CD " -i CD
C) © CD -i
CL Ct j CL CD CL CL
a• CD < tit n C) CD © C: ©
r © rcn• C) C:
CD •' --. C) © -- k:J tin CL
CD
93 C: 9 C: C: : Ct
C) tin C: 02 C:
CL C: CD
CD CD
CLC) 5 CD CLC: tin
I CD 'i .e in
CD CL -- CD CL
C: CD CL CL CD
93 0 C: CD
C: C)
93 5 5 " rt --
CD © C: C: _ CL C:
CL CD
C: CD
tin C) ra C: C: C: CL
CD
9 in ti n CD
© CL -- CD tin
9 CL C: q C:
9 (10 CL CL (1Q © CD
C: CD x: _ . C)
-- C: CD CD C) Co CD
C) rt CD C) rin -- CL "
rt fl fit -- C:
CL CD CL -- - C: CD hO CD
CD CL CL © CD
< Co
t 93 C: CL CD
CD tin 9
C: CD C: CL 93 CD
. C: CD in t
C: tin CL © .q C:
CL CD . CD -in C)
C: 93 CL -' CL
CL N) CD CL tin
CL CD CD
93 S 9 CL
C: CD < © tin CD m CL rin
C) C) (22 CL CD CD in
in
CL
CD• -- CD C:
C: C: CL CD
C: C: 5
CL t CD 2 9 CD 93: C: CL
© in CD
CL C: C:
(9 CD C: CD CL CL 9. rt a. rt CL
93
a
5 S 93:
CD C: tin tin tin CL
o$
CL CL CL
-- CL C: C CL CL 93: CD CL CL CL 93
in c- CL CO CD C: C) CD CD CD CD CL
2 $ 2 3 (3 SD) C) C)
c< CD cC
C) SD
1 5 C CO
C) C) C) SD) CD
C) 3 .
S r CD C
CA) A)) CO AA CD SD)
C) C) ) 3 C C) C) --
C) CD CD
3 C) r C) C
C9 3 C (3 SD) CD
CO . C 3.
3 Q 9 CD 3 3 (3 CO CD CO
r CD CD
3. 3 * C) CD
C) L C) CO 31 C).
C) C (3 5
CO CO
C C) CD C)
C) CO
-- C 2 -) C) C C)
C) CD
C / CO
j C 3 (3 CD
C) CO
.
rt 31 A CD (3
C DC ; C) C
-,'
•c 3 C ..
C) SD) CO r -
C) 3. C) C) SC)
. CD -
C C) C --,
(3 r* C) C - C C CD
C CD D 3 C C SD)
CD 3 C) C)
C
C C
-- l -"
31 3 ,- C) C) C) 5:
3 CO C CD C) CO
SD) (3 3 CD C cr r r
31 cC 53 CD
. C - CO
(3 C - C
çi -
-- CD C C)
+ D C) n C) CD AA --. *
C CD
3 ; C)
CD CD SD) Al -
. 9
CO 2 C CD C) 31 C C)
r *A A**
c_ . 5 C CD
9 CD ) 3
, 3 CO CO r 2 CO
: C) --
C) SD)
rA
C
C) C) C) CO (3
C) C) $5
-- 3 C r+
C) SD) 2 C)
CD C) r 31
-
C -C) C) CD SD) C C) C
C) CD (3 AC)
S cC - AC) CD 2
C) -- C)
S C) C
C) C) C) (3 9
s C) C) 2CA 5*:
C) 3$ r* CO
z
CD
CO r A -
AC) r r SD) C)
rA
C C CD C) C CD CD r
C) C C) CD C
(3 (3 CD CO Q. C C)
r
00 0) - 0) 0) 00 00 0) 0)
CD 00 00 00 CD 0) 00
CD 02
9.j CD 0)
0 00 CD 0) CD Cl 0)
r*
0) 0) -
i 0 CD
z 0)) CL CD 00
- 0 CL - 00
CD 9 CD
02
0 (0 CD CL 01)
--
- 0 --"
- 010 0
00 0) 00) 9
0) 00 -- --
02 CD
00 CD CL CD
r CD 02 CD 0) 0
.
Cl) CD CD
00 - 0) 1
CD CD Di CD
00 Di CD
Cl 00 0) a .
CD lTh 0 52 CD CD j 0)
\4
-- CD CL o
CD 0 CD 0 00 CD 0)
ODD CD Di Di 01) 9 0) CL•
0) 0) 0) 00 CL
j >1 0 1 00 C) (0
r± CD 00
00 Di - CL 0
ODD CD 2 0
9
-- 0) 00 o 0) CD 00
0) COD 0
02 0) 00
r+ Di
0) 02 0 0 0 00 Di 0),
0) 00 0 r CD
ODD 00 CD
C) 2 0 (0 C CL
r CD
0) CD 0) 9 0) CD 01) CD <
0 COD
00 CD CD 00 0) CL 0) CD 0)
b 0 CD CL co
0) 00 9 00 Ci) Di
C) C 0 Di ' 01) CD 9. 0 010 F3 CD C 0) Di CD 0 CD . CD
0)) 1 -' CL 0 , Di CD 'r' 01) 00 --, C)
0) --
0 -'-'i '' rt 010 CL (0 --
0) CD 0) 0 0), Cl CD 00 (0 CD CD COD 00 CC) , 0 CD .
.
CD 00 COD 0). 00 CD CD 00
0) 00 00 CL i 01) CCC CD 01) CD .
CD
ON , C) 0 + 01) 0)
0 CD 9 0) 0) 9 CD
r+ C) --
00 0 r 0) C) 00 0
00 0) 00 0) 00 CD C)
0). CD
CD 0) D 02 6 01 CD CD
CD CD CD '0) 0 CL 0 CC)) Cl
r - CD (Th rt
\4 03 1111 >3 3D 313 3D CD CD
iT 03 3D H' CD CD -'
3D
3D 'CD CD 31 3D >3 --
3D &t 0 Q .
3D ci rin P 3D 03 fr**** 3D:
03 2 CD 3D 0- 0 ci C-- CD CD (3
rt cci 3D c Ct 3D CD >3
1.: Ct 03 ci >3* ci
Ct
>0 CiT Ct ci CD Si ci 0- ci
ci 0- i 3 = 0 3D 3D 59,
>< CD fr* ne
3D CD 33 nt CD CD
3D CD >0 32* Tin 03
r± 3D 03 5
>3 03 --
>30303 CD Si 03 3D
(3 cC) CD 31 CD ci 3D ni 3D
2 0 - ci- Tin >3
rt CD 03 32
CD 03 03 3D 03 ci 3D .
3D 5 c
rt 3D US
rt
59 59' CD rt 03
CD CD 3D ID
>3 cC) 3D59*Et59Et? 31 03
-
- 313 3D 3D hCD CD 3D D
CD. CD 31
3D 3D - 22* 59
>3>3 CD i3 3D rt CD 3D 03
59 59
,'t ci- Si ci
cci r 3D rt -
,
- US --j --
Cd -- >3- n ,
-- 0 t rt 3D
- --
o CD 0 35
53 31 0 3D 03 3D nt ci) (59, 59
E CD 3D
((3: >3 >3 ci
59ci.
ni 0- O 3D 0 C:
(3D 935 3D Si 3D 3D CD
> Tin T
3D 03 3D
3D - CD
__'
-- cJ 3D Ii. CD
Tn 03
CL ci --, 3D >3
3D 3D ci CD .
Ct CD 3D
Ct ci CD 0- 03 ci
359. 52. 3D CD 03 CD
3D cci 3D C, 3- (3
-- nt 03
3D 0 >D 0 52* N 03
3D 3D CD 3D 3D 3D
>1 03 53t 503 959
ci 59 03 9.
CD -- 0 3D 3D rt CD IN 35.
CD 1> 3D Si. 03
CD ci C::. Ci CD ci ci 5
13; 33 03 CD C 3D
CD 03 0 3D 3D 3D r*
nt ci INC 3D 0 .
3D P Ct 3D CD ci 5
3D 935990359 3D 3D ci ci 0 2 3D ci
- CL ID n CD p (CC)
CD 0 CD >3
nt 59
3D S Pin
Cr S 0 -- CD .,
5903 3D >3 3D -- 3D
59ci DD 31 >3
03 59 59 59? o'CD = ci ci 3D 36 59
2 3D 0 rt CD 5j 59
5359
1* L cC) rt 0 nt
[ en '
- n Tin rin --*
CD
>3 (3- ci CD >1. CC >ci 935° >3
ci Si 3D CD CD -
03 3D CD ci 0 ci 3D
CD
25
on the part of the accused and the Apex Court has relied on the very same position of law in the judgment in the case of T. Subramartian Vs. The State of Tamil Nadu reported in MR 2006 SC 836 and in the case of Punjabrao Vs. State of Maharashtra j2002)10 SCC 371).
29. Apart from the aforesaid decisions, in the case of Duraisami Vs. State of T.N. reported in scc (Cri) 1508, the Apex Court has held that even though the appellant had admitted having received the amount, but has taken the contention that said amount was received as balance payment towards Indira Vikasa Patras and in this regard, the appellant had relied on communication sent to him by his immediate superior, on these facts, the Apex Court held that the case set up by the defence has to be accepted. In another decision of the Apex Court reported in AIR 2004 SC 1728 in the case of State of Andhra Pradesh Vs. T. Venkateswara k C ci. C )) r r ) Oi -i ci ci ci H CD ci ii CD ci C) ci• CD CD CD CD ri CD Hi Hi CD c Hi ci CO H- ci ci CD ci g. CD • C) ci CD. r CD . - ci CD 0 CD 0) ci o r+ CD Hi CD C CD SD- ci ci 0 0 H rt r Hi ci r* Hi ci 0 CO r CD SI. j ci CD Hr CO ci- ci ci CD CD CO 5 CD .5 -- ci ci ci- Hi ci CO - CD CD ( 0 '-- 0 Hi ci ci rt CO CD H ci ci CO CO ci CD CD CD CD 0 CD ci CD CD CD D5 S - CD ci 0 ci ci Hi 0 rt L
-- Hi ci .
C) ..
ci ci- CD
CD ci ci ci
ci. )1 ci Hi 0 ci CD
CD -i ci Hi CO ci CD
CD Hi CD Cl)
ci ci ci Hirn, ci 0 ci
-i CD ci: ci 0 Hi --
CD C Cl) CO ci CD 0 r
ci ci ci CD 0 cci ci c ci Hi
ci ci 0 CO
C ci --
Hi: C ci CD ci
r CD Hi CO HHi
CD ci ci ci
--- ) Hi Hi C >< CO C
Hi C)
CD CD ci H CD D
Cr0 -
ci C) CD C) j CD
C -- ci CD CD ct Hi
C C r ci Hi CD ci CD:.
Hi Hi CD D ci ci ci ci 'H
CDci C ci ci CD CD
CD 0 ci.
ci:cici -+
- ci CD CD ci
r+ CD c_i >< ci ci CD
00 Hi H ci
ci- ci ci ci CO CD
CD CD CD CO E)
CD Hi CD
0) C ci C)
CO H)
CD SD CD ci ci Hi ci
ci 00 Hi CO ci CO
H" Hi ci Hi CD
$ CD CD ci CD CD r
0 Hi c55 ci o ci -- ci
CD 0 0 CD CD
CD ci C CD CO ci ci
Hi Hi CD ci CO C CD
ci ci CD
ci ci 0 0 ci r
ci ci ci ci C) 0
rv CD ci ci ci
ci 00 0 -- ci
ci CD ci r
ci CD ci CO CD H" CO 0 ci ci r* ci
CD ( CD ci
CD CD CD Hi ci ci ci- ci r r+ 0C CO
CD CD :i) -- CD C
C
ci: :s
CD c
CD CD
CD 1Q a CD
a CD C
-- r
CD C
CD C ;i
-- CD
CD
-3 CD cC
CD
i2 CD r CC
CD PC
a
CD CD C)
a CD -- CD
a CC
CD CC
C a
o -
CD
-- CD
CD CD C)
C .
a 0 CD
CD
CD
a
CD CD -3 t
CD D CD r
C c CD
C CD
-- C D
- fr-- a CD 1
C CD
C C CC
r CD
'-3
CD
'-- rn CC CD a CD
CD CD o a
o
C)
4_ CD ii CD
Li. CD o
tzJ r- CD
CD
CC
c7 tr CD
CD Q CD CD L